Minutes 02-02-93 #INUTES OF THE REGULAR CITY COH14ISSIOH #EETING HELD IN
C01414ISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
ON TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 1993, AT 6: 30 P. 14.
PRESENT
Arline Weiner, Mayor
Jose Aguila, Con~nissioner
Edward Harmening, Commissioner
Robert Walshak, Commissioner
J. Scott Miller, City Manager
James Cherof, City Attorney
Sue Kruse, City Clerk
I, OPENINGS
A, Call to Order - I~a~or Arltne Welner
B, Invocation - 14oment of Silent Pra~yer
C, Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag led by Commissioner Robert Walshak
Mayor Weiner called the meeting to order at 6:33 P. M. and announced that Vice
Mayor Matson is ill and unable to attend the meeting. Following a moment of
silent prayer, the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag was led by Commissioner
Walshak.
D, Agenda Approval
1, Additions, Deletions, Corrections
Commissioner Harmening requested that Item 'XI.AA.1 be moved up on the agenda.
This item was inserted after V, Bids.
Commissioner Walshak respectfully requested that Item XI.A.1 be postponed until
the February 16, 1993 meeting, since he had not received all the backup informa-
tion he requested.
Mayor Weiner added Item IV.A.3, Four Chaplains Sunday - February 7, 1993, and
Item XI.A, Title XX - Children of the Working Poor.
14orlon
Commissioner Aguila moved to approve the agenda as amended. Commissioner
Harmening seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Mr. Cherof requested that he be allowed to add two items to the agenda. The
motion to approve the agenda was rescinded.
Mr. Cherof added IX.C.8, Proposed Resolution Opposing Southern Bell's Message
units. The resolution which the City Commission had previously passed on this
matter had a clause in it which is no longer applicable.
Under IX.D.2, Mr. Cherof added "Direction with Respect to the lawsuit between
Bethesda Ambulance and Palm Beach County."
-1-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Adoption
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve the agenda as amended. Commissioner
Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
II, ADMINISTRATIVE
A, Accept Resignation fr~mRoger Kirk, Alternate, Education Advisory
Board
Mr. Kirk's resignation from the Education Advisory Board was accepted by the
City Commission.
B. Board Appointments
Appointment Reg/
To Be Made Board Alt
Length of Term
Expiration Datn
Matson Community Relations Board Alt 4/93 TABLED
Harmening Children and Youth Advisory Board Alt 4/93 TABLED
Matson Code Enforcement Board Alt 9/93 TABLED
Weiner Library Board Alt 4/93 TABLED
Weiner Advisory Board on the Elderly Alt 6/93 TABLED
Commission Education Advisory Board Student 6/93 TABLED
Matson Education Advisory Board Alt 6/93
Aguila Education Advisory Board Alt 6/93
Motion
Commissioner Aguila moved to remove Mayor Weiner's appointment to the Library
Board from the table. Commissioner Harmening seconded the motion which carried
4-0.
Mayor Weiner appointed Robert Goldber~ as an alternate to the Library Board,
without objection.
Commissioner Aguila appointed ~lll Shaw as an alternate to the Education
Advisory Board, without objection.
All other appointments were left on the table.
Write-off of Accounts Receivable i Utility (Water/Sewer) and
Sanitation Services for the Months of August and September, 1992 (End
of FY 91192)
Per Finance Memorandum No. 93-004, Grady Swann, Finance Director, recommended
writing off certain water, sewer and refuse accounts totalling $8,080.10. These
accounts are finalized accounts with uncollectible balances. Bills have been
issued each month with no response.
-2-
NINUTES- REGULAR CITY CONNISSION NEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Mr. Miller stated that these accounts will be turned over to the collection
agency.
Motion
Commissioner Harmening moved to authorize the writing off of these accounts.
Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
RequeSt Authorization to Trade the Surplus 1986 Ford 1-ton 'Squad'
and the Surplus 'Squad' Body for a 1988 Chevrolet 1-ton 'Cab &
Chassis" to Replace the 1976 Chevrolet 1-ton 'Road Service" Vehicle
Mr. Miller stated that the City is not using the surplus vehicles and has an
opportunity to obtain a 1988 Chevrolet 1-ton Cab and Chassis to replace the 1976
Chevrolet that the City is no longer using.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve this request.
siderably more than the City would get at an auction.
seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
He believed this is con-
Commissioner Aguila
E. Ftnal Change Order to Nllne Nlcholls for Construction of the
Recreation Activity Center
Bill DeBeck, Project Manager, stated that this is the one and only change order
for this job. The contract sum was $590,250. The changes total $6,047.
Revision of the FP&L service entry cables to underground was not an additional
expense. Money was funded for FP&L; however, the contractor did the work
instead of FP&L, saving approximately $2,400. Therefore, this total change cost
only about $3,000 for the total project, which is less than one half of 1 per
cent.
Notion
Commissioner Aguila comrnended Milne Nicholls for a job well done and moved to
approve this change order. Commissioner Harmening agreed with Commissioner
Aguila and seconded the motion, which carried 4-0.
In response to MaYor Weiner, Mr. Miller stated he will set up the ribbon cutting
ceremony soon.
Acceptance of a Proposal for Engineering/Architectural Services
Regarding the Review and Inspection of the HVAC System in the City
Hall Complex and Preparation of Specifications Denoting Necessary
Work to Correct Present Humidity Problems
Mr. Miller explained that there have been some changes since the original pro-
posal and referred to Memorandum CM93.015 regarding indoor air quality con-
sultants. The original proposal was to bring in a HVAC consulting engineer to
-3-
NINUTES - REGULAR CITY COI~ISSION NEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
test the air quality and report any problems with the HVAC system. Mr. DeBeck
and Mr. Miller have since discussed bringing in an environmental consultant to
handle the air quality and bulk samplings throughout City Hall and then bring in
an architectural engineer to handle the HVAC system separately. Five proposals
have been received. With regard to the original proposal, the low bid was
$22,700 from Ralph Hahn and Associates, and the high bid was $32,000 from CH2M
Hill. It is now being proposed to retain Dr. Phil Morey and Doug Shadick of
Clayton Environmental Consultants. They have been involved with the air quality
problems in Polk and Martin counties. In addition, they have recently been
contracted with in Broward County for some of their buildings. The proposal
before the City Commission is to contract with Clayton Environmental Consultants
to perform air quality tests, as well as bulk samplings throughout the City and
then work in conjunction with Ralph Hahn and Associates on the HVAC system.
Commissioner Harmening asked if Ralph Hahn and Associates has a mechanical
engineer, if the City is in possession of a resume on his background, and if the
City is satisfied with his background. Mr. DeBeck answered all three questions
affirmatively.
In response to Mayor Weiner, Mr. Miller advised that Mr. Morey was not able to
look at the building; however, he quoted a top cost of $18,500 over the
telephone. Ralph Hahn and Associates' proposal would cost approximately $7,400
to provide the mechanical work on the HVAC.
In response to Mayor Weiner, Mr. Miller advised that Clayton Environmental
Consultants would be able to begin testing on February 15, 1993, and Ralph Hahn
and Associates would be able to start on February 8, 1993.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve the City Manager's recommendation with
regard to Clayton Environmental Consultants and Ralph Hahn and Associates.
Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Acceptance of a Proposal from Gee & Jenson for Professional Services
in Connection with Preparation of Bid Documents for the Second Phase
of the Community Development Block Grant in Subarea 1 of the City of
Boynton Beach
Mr. Miller advised that this involves the continuation and completion of the
public improvement project. A split in the engineering services is being pro-
posed, whereby Gee & Jenson would be contracted to revise construction drawings,
prepare bid documents, evaluate construction bids, and prepare right-of-way
drawings. Construction inspection services and the monthly progress/evaluation
reports to Housing Community Development would be handled by the Utility
Engineer. Costs will be lessened by doing some of this work in-house.
Notion
Commissioner Aguila moved to approve the proposal from Gee & Jenson for pro-
fessional services regarding the CDBG in Subarea 1. Commissioner Harmening
seconded the motion, which carried 4-0.
-4-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
H. Fact Sheet Infomtng Residents of Upcoming Referendum Issue Regardlng
Hlgh School on Congress Avenue, North of Old Boynton Road
Mr. Miller stated that the fact sheet will be mailed out to all registered
voters in the City. The cost of the mailing would be slightly less than $5,000.
Commissioner Aguila pointed out that this referendum issue affects all the citi-
zens, not just the voting citizens, and questioned whether the fact sheet should
be mailed to all citizens.
To lower the cost, Mayor Weiner suggested running a one-time ad in the Sunday
and weekly editions of the Sun-Sentinel, the Post, and the Boynton Beach Times.
A few thousand fact sheets can then be placed in the Library, City Hall, and in
the schools. This was the consensus of the Commission and the City Manager
received his directions.
Motion
I, Reduction of Retalnage to Poole and Kent Company - Contract II, West
Water Treatment Plant Construction Project
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve the reduction of retainage to Poole and
Kent Company in accordance with the contract documents from 10 per cent to 5 per
cent. Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
III, CONSENT AGENDA
A. Ntnutes
1. Regular City Commission Neetlng Ninutes of January 19, 1993
Bids - Recommend Approval - All Expenditures are Approved in the
1922/93 Adopted Budget
None.
C, Approval of Bills
A list of these bills is attached to these original minutes on file in the City
Clerk's Office.
O. Budget Transfer - Contingency Account - Personnel Department
Per Personnel Memorandum 92-133, just prior to the 1992/93 budget adoption, two
unanticipated projects were approved. The first was the Drug Free Workplace,
which mandates a training program. The second project which was recommended in
the Murphy/Mayo report was to utilize a non-city employee to administer'poly-
graph tests to police applicants. This was not budgeted for. The PerSonnel
Director recommended that a transfer of funds be made from Contingency to
001-135-5-482.00, Employee Assistance Program, in the amount of'$2,500, and
001-135-5-470.16, Recruitment 40 x $75, in the amount of $3,000.
- 5'-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY CONNISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
E. Budget Transfer - Utility Department
According to the Budget Transfer Request, dated January 15, 1993, from the
Utilities Pumping Stations, upon retirement of the Utility Pumping Station
Supervisor, only a licensed operator of the Oceanfront Park Wastewater Treatment
Plant is in Public Water Maintenance and would be an additional responsibility,
which was not funded. The amount requested to be transfered from
401-352-5-499.0, Contractual Services, to 401-336-5-123.0, Overtime (PWM) is
$3,1oo.
F, Constder Request for Refund on Cemete~ Lot 279, Block M, Boynton
Beach Memorial Park
Per City Clerk Sue Kruse's Memorandum 93-013 to the City Manager, Edna McDougall
requested a refund of the purchase price, less 20%, which amounts to $100.
Notion
Commissioner Aguila moved to approve the consent agenda. Commissioner Harmening
seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
MAYOR WEINER DECLARED A RECESS AT 6:53 P. M. THE MEETING RESUMED AT 7:02 P. M.
IV, ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS
A, Proclamations
1, Cm~fflunltyCartng Week - February 21 through February 28, 1993
Mayor Weiner read a proclamation declaring February 21 through February 28, 1993
Community Caring Week. She thanked the members of the Community Caring Center,
Pastor Ackermann, and the Rev. Robinson, saying the City is fortunate to have
them helping.
2, American History Month - February, 1993
Mayor Weiner read a proclamation declaring February, 1993 American History
Month.
3, Four Chaplains Sunday - February 7, 1993
Mayor Weiner read a proclamation declaring February 7, 1993 as Four Chaplains
Sunday.
B. Presentations
1. Employee of the Month
Mr. Miller and Mayor Weiner recognized Jim Ness, E.M.S. Coordinator, as Employee
of the Month for January, 1993 for invaluable service in assisting the City in
-6-
NINUTES - REGULAR CITY CONNISSION NEETING
BOYNTON BEACH,, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
obtaining A.L.S. transport licensing. Mr. Ness said it was a long battle and he
was glad to be back. He thanked the staff of the EMS office, particularly
Lillian Cripps, and his wife.
2, Presentation to Bryan Croft for Wlnnlng his Third World Title In
the World Am Wrestltng Cha~lonshtps at Chtba, ~apan
This item was deferred since Firefighter Croft was out on a call.
V, BIDS
A, Purchase of One (1) New/Unused, Rear Loading Solid Waste (Garbage)
Compaction and Transportation Unit for Sanitation Division
Per Agenda Memorandum from the Purchasing Department, the Tabulation Committee
recommended awarding the bid to Southland Equipment Company, Bartow, Florida,
the overall most responsible, responsive bidder meeting all required specifica-
tions, in the amount of $87,466.
Carel Fisher, Deputy Public Works Director, stated that three bids have been
received for this replacement unit. The mid bid was recommended since the body
offered by the low bidder is a short lived, municipal quality body.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to award the bid for the new rear loading solid
waste compaction and transportation unit to Southland Equipment Company of
Bartow, Florida, in the amount of $87,466. Commissioner Aguila seconded the
motion which carried 4-0.
XI, NEW BUSINESS
AA, Items for Discussion Requested by Commissioner E~ard Harmenlng
1, Diane Drive Neighborhood Association Petition to the State of
Florida Department of Transportation
Commissioner Harmening referred to a Petition to the State of Florida Department
of Transportation signed by 180 residents of Diane Drive. He stated that some
of the residents requested permission to speak to the City Commission tonight
about their most recent problems with the Department of Transportation, and to
beseech the help of the City Commission.
Christine Noeller of 3519 Diane Drive thanked the City Commission for the
resolution which was sent to all the legislators and expressed her appreciation
of the City Commission's support. She explained that the day before
Thanksgiving the brush behind one empty lot on Diane Drive had been completely
removed, exposing the street. Earl Jacobs came to review the situation and
promised not to do any further trimming until December 23, 1992 in order to give
the residents time to petition legislators, protect their backyards, etc. On
NZNUTE$ - REGULAR CITY COI~t$$~ON #EETING
BOYNTOH BEACH,, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
December 17, 1992, Mr. Jacobs' crew used herbicide to kill the trees behind
Ns. Moeller's house. She contacted Don Henderson of the District Office in Ft.
Lauderdale. He is conducting an investigation as to why Mr. Jacobs did this.
Furthermore, on December 15, 1992, State Legislator Carol Hanson visited Diane
Drive to evaluate the situation, On that same day, Ms. Hanson received word
from Rick Chesser, the head of the Department of Transportation at the District
Office in Ft, Lauderdale, that there would be no further trimming until July 1
1993. '
Ms. Moeller expressed concern about possible damage to the children in the area
from this herbicide. She would like to see more action taken against the
Department of Transportation. She heard environmentalists say that if this
herbicide ls used anywhere near water, it will immediately kill the fish in the
water. Ms. Moeller pointed out that there is a canal across the street from her
house, and that the residents were unaware the herbicide was used when they
discovered a major fish kill in the canals and in Lake Ida. She was informed by
the Fresh Water Game and Fish Commission that excessive rain at that time could
have caused the fish to die. However, they also said that when fish are
poisoned, their eyes bulge out. Various neighbors who swept many fish off their
docks noted that the eyes of the fish were bulging tremendously. Ms. Moeller
implored the City Commission's further support,
Mayor Weiner stated that she also was assured by Ms. Hanson that the City would
be given a six month grace period.
Mr. Miller advised that he too was assured by Rick Chesser that Mr. Jacobs' crew
would not be back in that area for at least six months. Mr. Miller will contact
Mr. Chesser and Mr. Henderson with regard to this matter.
Mayor Weiner would like Mr. Cherof involved in this matter. She would like to
obtain the records of the Department of Transporation to see if the major fish
kill can be linked to the herbicide.
Tim Budnarz, 3708 Diane Drive, stated that he has lived on this canal for nine
years. He believes there is a connection between the herbicide and the fish
kill. He said he removed at least forty fish from his dock that day.
Mayor Weiner felt the City should pursue this matter with all the authority it
possesses. Commissioner Harmening suggested that the behavior of FDOT and the
necessity for a wall in this area be impressed uPon Ed Healey, Chairman of the
House Transportation Committee. He felt there were probably some discretionary
funds in the State that can be reallocated for a wall.
Mayor Weiner instructed Mr. Miller to copy all correspondence to the Legislative
Delegation and to send another letter to Ed Healey, written by Mr. Miller and
Mr. Cherof. Ms. Moeller agreed to act as liaison between the residents and the
City. Mayor Weiner assured the residents that the City will be on top of this
matter as much as possible and will keep Ms. Moeller informed.
-8-
#INUTES - REGULAR CITY COt~ISSION #EETiNG
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
IV. ANNOUNCE#ENTSAND PRESENTATIONS
B. Presentations
Presentation to Bryan Croft for Wtnnlng bls Third World Title In
the World Arm Wrestllng Championships at Chlba, ~apan
Mr. Miller stated that Bryan Croft, Firefigher II/Engineer, recently traveled to
Chiba, Japan to compete in the World Arm Wrestling Championships. In stiff com-
petition against world class competitors from fifteen nations, Bryan went unde-
feated to win the Gold and emerge as World Champion. Mr. Miller added that
Bryan is an excellent, dedicated firefighter. Both he and Mayor Weiner honored
Bryan for his extraordinary accomplishment.
Captain Robert Brown of the Fire Department was proud of all the members of his
shift and congratulated Bryan for becoming World Champion.
Mr. Croft thanked Captain Brown for the recognition. He thanked everyone,
including the men on his shift, the men at the station, Lt. Tom Shemwick, Chief
Allen, his wife, Denise, and his daughter, Brittany.
Fire Chief Ed Allen spoke highly of Bryan, who is a native of the area and whose
grandfather was the Chief of Police in Delray Beach for many years before
retiring.
PUBLIC HEARING
None,
VII. PUBLIC AUDIENCE
Wtlda Searcy, 402 N. E. 13th Avenue, asked if Ezell Hester's and King Tut's pic-
tures have been restored to the library. Mayor Weiner advised her that
Mr. Hester's picture will be placed in the library for the month of February for
Black History Month. Ms. Searcy suggested that Martin Luther King, Jr.'s pic-
ture be placed alongside Mr. Hester's and King Tut's picture so the young people
will know a little more history and start researching themselves.
Other concerns of Ms. Searcy's included upgrading the community, a bridge on
Boynton Beach Boulevard, an amphitheater, a supermarket within walking distance
and HRS. '
Dee Ztbellt, 440 Ocean Parkway, noticed that all 300 of the Indian Hawthorne
hedges around the City Hall building were being pulled out and taken away
because of the sick building syndrome. Instead of using them for landfill, she
suggested planting them in medians, parks, or giving them away to someone who
could use them, since they are very drought and disease resistant hedges.
George Culver, owner of the Two Georges Marina, stated that Casa Loma Boulevard
was put in over twenty years ago and has never been resurfaced. He counted
thirty-eight potholes and asked the City Commission to resurface this street.
-9-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COMMIS$IOH MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
In response to Mayor Weiner, Mr. Miller advised that Casa Loma Boulevard is not
on the resurfacing list this year. He, Public Works Director Robert Eichorst,
and City Engineer W. Richard Staudinger, explained that Casa Loma Boulevard has
not been resurfaced because of two pending projects.
Mr. Culver stated that the City has been waiting for six or seven years for
these developments to be constructed. He believes Mr. Garcia, who owns Water's
Edge, is going to sell his land. He said he keeps asking for permits, but never
breaks ground. Mr. Culver suggested that the City refuse to renew permits
unless someone puts on the money to show good faith that they are going to do
something. Commissioner Aguila pointed out that the Phase I extension for one
of these projects expired February 1, 1993. He stated that at the time the
extension was granted, it was made very clear that another extension would not
be considered under any conditions. Mayor Weiner stated that since that project
does not seem to be going forward that perhaps the City Commission can look
again at Casa Loma Boulevard.
Marie Shepard, 140 West Ocean Avenue, stated that the FEC site downtown has been
an eye sore for a long time. She wrote to Mr. Bagley, who retired as Vice
President of the FEC. Mr. Bagley referred the matter to the manager of real
estate. Ms. Shepard read the following portion of Mr. Bagley's reply bo her:
"Our Management may consider allowing your organization to beautify the perime-
ters of this property, provided such beautification does not interfere with the
access and operation of the railway." Ms. Shepard advised that Mr. Bagley would
be willing to recommend that the area be leased for $100 a year. Ms. Shepard
requested that the City Commission review this matter. After a plan has been
worked out with the FEC, Ms. Shepard suggested enlisting help from the Kiwanis,
the Rotary, and the downtown businesses to take some of the Indian Hawthornes
the City is removing from City Hall and plant them on the FEC site to improve
this area.
NO ONE ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK, MAYOR WEINER DECLARED PUBLIC AUDIENCE CLOSED.
VIII, DEVELOPMENT PLANS
None.
IX, LEGAL
A, Ordinances - 2nd Reading - PUBLIC HEARING
None.
B, Ordinances - 1st Reading
None.
C, Resolutions
1- PropOsed Resolution No. R93-12 Re: Opposition to Proposed
Legislation Expanding the Authority of the Public Service
- 10-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY ~NIS$ION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Comntsston (PSC) Over Water, Wastewater.and Reclaimed Water
Utilities
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93-12 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
OBJECTING TO A PROPOSED STATE-WIDE RATE STRUCTURE AND TERRITORIAL DISPUTE
JURISDICTION OF THE FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OVER GOVERNMENTAL
WATER AND SEWER UTILITY SYSTEMS; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-12.
Con~nissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Proposed Resolution No, R93-13 Re: Authorize Execution of an
Agreement with Gee & Oenson for Additional Services (Work
Assignment 2) for Meadows II Park and Boynton Lakes Park
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93-13 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
ACCEPTING THE PROPOSAL OF GEE & JENSON FOR FINAL DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF
MEADOWS II AND BOYNTON LAKES PARKS DATED JANUARY 25, 1993; AND FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-13.
Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Proposed Resolution No, R93-14 Re: Adopt Job Descriptions and
Pay Scale - Assistant Golf Course Superintendent and Supervisor
of Utility Pumping Stations
Mr. Cherof' read Proposed Resolution No. R93-14 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
ADOPTING THE JOB DESCRIPTION OF ASSISTANT GOLF COURSE SUPERINTENDENT AND
THE JOB DESCRIPTION OF SUPERVISOR OF UTILITY PUMPING STATIONS; MAKING THESE
POSITIONS PART OF THE PAY PLAN; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Notion
Commissioner Aguila moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-14.
Commissioner Harmening seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Proposed ReSolution No. R93-15 Re: Authorize Execution of
Standard State and Local Task Force Agreement Between the United
States Department of Oustlce, Drug Enforcement Administration and
- 11-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
the City of Boynton Beach Police Department for Drug/Narcotics
Trafficking
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93-15 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND POLICE CHIEF TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, DRUG ENFORCEMENT ADMINISTRATION AND
THE BOYNTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Metlon
Con)nissioner Harmening moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-15.
Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Proposed Resolution No, R93-15 Re: Partial Bond Release -
Meadows Park (a/kla Tract E, Meadows 300) - South of Hypoluxo,
West of Congress Avenue, Along the West Rights-of-way of Meadows
Boulevard
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93-16 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
APPROVING THE PARTIAL RELEASE OF A PERFORMANCE BOND IN THE AMOUNT OF
$47,625.00 TO WILSHIRE CORPORATION, AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Motion
Commissioner Aguila moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-16.
Commissioner Harmening seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Proposed Resolution No, R93- Re: Authorize Execution of an
Agreement Between the City of Boynton Beach and Gee & ~enson for
Professional Services (Inspection, Preparation of Bid Documents,
and Construction Inspection) in Connection with Necessary Repairs
to 10 FOOT Off System Bridges
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93- by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE MAYOR ANDCITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH AND GEE & JENSON FOR PROFESSIONAL
SERVICES IN CONNECTION WITH NECESSARY REPAIRS TO 10 FDOT OFF SYSTEM
BRIDGES, SAID AGREEMENT BEING ATTACHED HERETO AS EXHIBIT "A";.AND PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Mr. Miller advised that this project does not have to be done immediately;
however, the City should set forth a program in the next three to five years to
effect the necessary repairs to the bridges. Therefore, he foresees no problem
if the City Commission feels more comfortable going out forbid on this project.
- 12 -
MINUTES - REGULAR CXTY COMMISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH,, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Commissioner Aguila felt there is no reason why a particular firm should auto-
matically be given this project since there is no emergency, and the City should
go out for competitive bids. Commissioner Harmening added that a good deal of
the work can be done initially in-house. Furthermore, the City Engineer can be
employed to do several of the repairs.
This resolution was not voted on.
Proposed Resolution No, R93-17 Re: Accepting a Letter of Credit
fremNtnco Properties, Inc, Reference Securing Sidewalks and
S~ales in the Blum Plat Subdtvlston (Northeast Intersection of
Old Boynton Road at NWSth Court)
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93-17 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
APPROVING AND ACCEPTING A SUBSTITUTE LETTER OF CREDIT IN THE AMOUNT OF
$20,000.00 FROM MINCO PROPERTIES, INC., AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Morton
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-17.
Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
8, Proposed Resolution No, R93-18 Re: Opposing Southern Bell's
leessage Units
Mr. Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R93-18 by title only:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA,
URGING PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION DENIAL OF SOUTHERN BELL'S PROPOSAL FOR
MEASURED MESSAGE UNITS AND FORTY MILE PLAN REPLACING IT WITH THE CITY'S 40
MILE PLAN; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Motion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R93-18.
Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
D, Other
1, Lten Reduction - Code Enforcement Case No, 92-20004135 - Howard
Ta~lor, 927 Ntsston H111 Road
Scott Blasie, Code Enforcement Administrator, explained that this case was
turned over to the City by County inspectors. A dock and boat lift were
constructed by Detray Marine without the benefit of a permit. Code Enforcement
cited the property owner and sent a copy of the notice to Palm Beach County
Contractor's Certification to handle the contractor. Compliance did not take
place until twenty-three days after the time allotted by the Code Enforcement
- 13 -
#INUTES - REGULAR CITY COI,4HZ,~$ION NEETING
BOYNTOH BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Board. Mr. Blasie understood that there was a lack of communication and that
the homeowner was under the impression the contractor was going to handle the
inspections and pemits. Upon hearing testimony, the Code Enforcement Board
voted 4 to I to rescind the fine, in the amount of $2,327.47, in its entirety.
Commissioner Harmening stated that Delray Marine is relatively reputable. He
wished to hear from Mr. Taylor.
Mr. Taylor gave a chronology of the events that occurred. Early in the year he
hired Delray Marine to obtain a permit and build the dock. In response to
Commissioner Harmening, Mr. Taylor was not aware of any permits required other
than the permit from the City.
Mr. Taylor said he was on vacation when the construction of the dock was com-
menced, which was late June/early July. The dock was completed sometime in
early August. When Mr. Taylor received a letter indicating that a permit was
not obtained, he contacted Delray Marine. Mr. Taylor stated that Delray Marine
basically dragged it on and on. He has had contact with them and with Joan
Mormelo, Code and License Inspector, several times. He was working and, there-
fore, was unable to attend the October Code Enforcement Board meeting. He was
given forty-five days to come into compliance. He advised Delray Marine that
they had until December 6, 1992 in which to apply for the permits. The permits
were applied for before December 6, 1992. However, there was a problem with the
electrical work and it had to be redone.
Commissioner Aguila inquired if an assessment was made for four times the permit
fee for doing work without benefit of a permit. Mr. Blasie answered in the
affirmative.
Commissioner Harmening asked what action the Palm Beach County Contractor's
Certification took. Mr. Blasie advised that he did not receive a response from
them yet.
Commissioner Harmening was not sure Mr. Taylor followed up or made any effort to
push this matter.to fruition.
Mr. Taylor said he was in constant contact with Mr. Blasie, Inspector Mormelo
and the contractor. The contractor thought that once he applied for the per-
mits, the matter was closed. Mr. Taylor said he had no way of knowing that this
was not true until he received a letter in late December saying that a fine was
running since December 6, 1992. The permits had been ready for four or five
days before the contractor picked them up. He did not pick them up until
Mr. Taylor called him and told him to pick them up.
Commissioner Harmening inquired how the Code Enforcement Board determined that
Mr. Taylor should comply within forty-five days. Mr. Blasie stated that
Mr. Taylor sent a letter to the Code Enforcement Board, requested forty-five
days in which to come into compliance. Mr. Taylor added that he did so after
conversing with Inspector Mormelo.
- 14 -
NXNUTE$ - REGULAR CITY COI~I$$IONNEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Notion
Commissioner Aguila moved to reduce the lien to $1,000. The motion died for
lack of a second,
Mayor Weiner did not like second guessing the Code Enforcement Board, since they
have heard the case and made a recommendation. Commissioner Aguila suggested
reducing the lien to cover the City's administrative costs.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to reduce the Code Enforcement lien of $2,327.47 to
$200. Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Commissioner Harmening advised Mr. Taylor that if he does not pay the $200, a
lien will be placed on his property and foreclosure can take place. In response
to Mr. Taylor, Mr. Blasie stated that he will be in contact with him by mail.
Direction with Respect to the Lawsuit Between Bethesda Ambulance
and Palm Beach County
Mr. Cherof advised that a lawsuit has been filed by Bethesda Ambulance over the
A.L.S. matter. The County was the defendant in that case. The first part of
the case was for an injunction to prohibit Boynton Beach from exercising its
powers under the award of the A.L.S. grant to the City. The County prevailed in
that action; however, the matter still continues and is subject to amendment.
He would like the City Commission to consider whether the City should intervene
in this matter to {1) monitor its progress and make sure the County is fighting
for our contract~ and {2) participate in the case more aggressively if the
County is not pursuing it in that manner. Mr. Cherof requested authorization to
intervene.
Notion
Commissioner Harmening moved to authorize the City Attorney to intervene in the
lawsuit between Bethesda Ambulance and Palm Beach County with regard to the
A.L.S. matter and, if possible, to consult with the CitY Attorney of Green
Acres to see if they would like to join Boynton Beach in this intervention and
share the costs. Commissioner Walshak seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Mr. Cherof advised that Jim Ness testified on behalf of the County and he heard
from the County Attorney that he did an excellent job. Mr. Cherof stated that
in addition to being Employee of the Month, Mr. Ness should probably be nomina-
ted for Witness of the Month.
X, OLD BUSINESS
A, Consider Renewal of Occupational License for Club Nautico Powerboat
Rentals Located at Water's Edge Nartna
Kyle McPhall, owner of Club Nautico, requested that his license be renewed. He
is a tenant at Water's Edge Marina and has been doing business in BoyntOn Beach
- 15 -
#INUTE$ - REGULAR CITY COt~ISSION #EETiNG
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
for seven years. Renewal of his license has been tied into renovations being
made at the marina, which Mr. McPhail said he has no control over.
Mayor Weiner referred to Agenda Memorandum No. 93-117, which states that at the
September 19, 1991 meeting, the City Commission approved the request for an
occupational license for boat rentals at Water's Edge Marina for a period of one
year, with the condition that within that one year, if the Lighthouse Square
Marina was not constructed, the parking lot would have to be brought up to code
in order for the business license to be renewed.
Commissioner Aguila asked if other businesses along the marina and waterway are
operating without adequate parking and if so, if the same conditions imposed on
Mr. McPhail are imposed on them.
Chris Cutro, Planning and Zoning Director, advised that at the present time, the
three businesses that are of major concern are Seamist Marina, Two Georges
Marina, and the Water's Edge Marina. Two Georges historically seems to have had
about four or five licensed commercial boats that do not have parking. The
parking is either on the street or at the lot at the end of Orange Avenue.
Seamist has about three licensed boats without parking. Water's Edge has two
active commercial licenses, as well as the Club Nautico license, which is a ren-
tal situation wherein the parking does not meet code. There is plenty of area
to park; however, it is not paved or landscaped, and it is not drained properly.
It was expected that a lot of that would be absorbed when the marina project
went into place.
In response to Commissioner Aguila, Mr. Cutro advised that all businesses are
required to renew their occupational licenses once a year, at the beginning of
September.
Commissioner Aguila was willing to put the existing businesses on notice that in
a year when they go to renew their licenses, if their parking is not adequate to
support their businesses, their licenses will not be renewed. In response to
Commissioner Aguila, Mr. Cherof advised that this is legally binding; however,
the longer the City grants conditional occupational licenses, the weaker the
City's position becomes with respect to issuing them in the future.
Mr. Cutro stated that a determination has to be made as to what is legally non-
conforming in the downtown area. Based on review of the marina and the
surrounding land uses, and working with Mr. Blasie and the Building Department,
Mr. Cutro believed such a determination could be made within the next six to
eight weeks.
In response to Commissioner Harmening, Mr. Cutro advised that the Janet Hall
project was highly dependent upon the infrastructure being put in by the origi-
nal Water's Edge project. He said he informed the architect of the project,
Craig Livingston~ that they could put in the utilities on their own. Mr. Cutro
will contact Mr. Livingston to find out the status of this project and report
back to the City Commission at their February 16, 1993 meeting.
- 16 -
14INUTE$ - REGULAR CITY COI414I$$IDN NEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
In response to Commissioner Aguila, Mr. McPhail was not sure what needs to be
done to the parking lot; however, he waswilling to cooperate. Commissioner
Aguila was willing to meet with the Planning Department to see what Mr. McPhail
can do to improve the situation.
Commissioner Harmening suggested issuing a temporary occupational license for
ninety days in order to resolve this matter. Mr. Cherof preferred that
Administration be directed not to cite Mr. McPhail for not having an occupa-
tional license for the ninety day time period, which was the consenus of the
Commission.
XI, NEW BUSINES$
A, Items for Discussion Requested by Commissioner Robert Walshak
1. Human Rights Ordinance (City of #teml Beach, Florida)
This item was deferred until the February 16, 1993 City Commission meeting.
1. Title XX - Children of the Working Poor
Mayor Weiner introduced Angela Girtman, Chairperson of the Children and Youth
Advisory Board. Ms. Girtman advised that the children of the working poor are
currently receiving subsidized child care through Title XX. The child care for
those children is in jeopardy of being terminated on February 19, 1993, unless
additional funding is found. On behalf of the Children and Youth Advisory
Board, Ms. Girtman asked the City Commission to consider a contribution of up to
$41,795.58, which would pay for the care of thirty-seven Boynton Beach children
through the ending of.this funding year, which ends June 30, 1993. Ms. Girtman
advised that the City of Boynton Beach will be affected by this termination by
losing those slots for the thirty-seven children. The contribution would allow
these children to remain in safe, subsidized care and for their parents to con-
tinue to work through the end of the Title XX funding year. She stated that
other agencies are contributing to this shortfall, including the School Board,
the Children's Services Council, and Headstart. The City of West Palm Beach is
considering contributing towards the cost of day. care for the children of resi-
dents of the City of West Palm Beach to allow those residents to continue to
work. Ms. Girtman advised that the child care is not totally funded through
Title XX; the parents also contribute towards the cost of this child
cake.
In response to Mayor Weiner, Ms. Girtman advised that even with the $11,000 that
the City has already earmarked for Title XX, there is still a $41,795.58 short-
fall.
Mayor Weiner was very sympathetic; however, she said the City has a considerable
shortfall itself. Mr. Miller explained that the City was advised from the
Property Appraiser's Office that its assessed valuation is decreased some
$31,000,000, which equates to $247,000 in tax dollars which the City will not be
receiving this year. This revenue has to be balanced in the budget by either
- 17 -
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY CONNISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
reduction on the expenditure side or hopes that the revenue generated from other
sources is going to be higher.
In response to Mayor Weiner, Mr. Miller advised that there are funds in the con-
tingency fund, but those funds are very limited.
Motion
Mayor Weiner passed the gavel and moved to contribute $5,000 to Title XX and to
direct Mr. Miller to write to HRS, the Children's Services Council, and the
School Board, asking them to consider increasing their contribution to Title XX.
Commissioner Harmening seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
~, Items for Discussion Requested by Commissioner Edward Harmentng
1. Diane Drive Neighborhood Association Petition to the State of
Florida Department of Transportation
This item was discussed earlier in the meeting.
B. Municipal League Report
Commissioner Aguila had nothing to report at this time.
C, Consider Approval of Request by Boynton Ale House to Hold a
St, Patrick's Day Celebration to Benefit a Local Charity
Motion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve the request by Boynton Ale House to hold
a St. Patrick's Day celebration to benefit a local charity, subject to all
staff comments. Commissioner Aguila seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
Consider Request from St. ~oseph's Episcopal School to hold a
Festival on February 20, 1993 and to Hold a lOK Run and SK Walk on
Narch 27, 1993
Motion
Commissioner Harmening moved to approve this request. He pointed out that St.
Joseph's Episcopal School has held these type of festivals before and it seemed
to him that the City has gone overboard this time in attempting to make it very
difficult for them. He was not certain they need to jump through as many hoops
as are layed out for them. Mr. Miller was only interested in the recommenda-
tions of the Fire and Police Departments. If the school uses a tent,
Commissioner Harmening said it should be fireproof, and if they do any temporary
electrical work, it should be permitted and inspected. Other than that,
Commissioner Harmening felt no need for them to comply with the rest of staff's
comments and recommendations. Commissioner Aguila agreed and seconded the
motion which carried 4-0.
- 18-
#INUTES - REGULAR CITY COHHISSION #EETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
E, Request for Spectal Neetlng Date Reference the Ctty of Boynton Beach
General Electton
It was the consensus of the City Commission to hold this meeting on Tuesday,
February 9, 1993, at 5:00 P. M.
City Nanager Annual Performance
Mayor Weiner advised that this item has been tabled at the request of Vice Mayor
Matson. In light of her absence, Mayor Weiner requested that this item remain
on the table.
CITY NANAGER'S REPORT
A. Update on Captain Frank's Seafood, 435 West Boynton Beach Boulevard
Mr. Miller explained that a site improvement permit was issued by the Building
Department in April of 1991. That site improvement permit was to include the
construction of paving, drainage, landscaping, and irrigation improvements. To
date, the site improvements are not complete and have not been finaled by the
City. A permit for an addition to the rear of the main building was issued in
July of 1991. There is still outstanding work that needs to be completed before
this addition is signed off by the Building Department. A sealcoating and
restriping permit was issued on January 11, 1993 for maintenance only. Until
the site improvement permit {issued in April of 1991) is finaled, which would
include the deletion of two landscaping islands and closing off the driveway, a
certificate of occupancy for the expansion will not be approved and issued.
Commissioner Aguila inquired if the addition is being used at all. Mr. Miller
answered in the negative.
Commissioner Harmening inquired if construction is progressing or if it is at a
complete standstill. Mr. Miller believed the addition is at a standstill. He
stated that the permit has expired, therefore, Captain Frank's Seafood needs to
reapply for a permit.
In response to Commissioner Harmening, Mr. Miller indicated there has been no
action whatsoever for six months. A1Newbold, Deputy Building Official,
explained that this project has lingered on considerably. The owner plays one
department against the other. When it comes to items he does not want to put
in, he asks for variances.
Mr. Cutro stated that he sent a letter to Captain Frank's Seafood on January 25,
1993, telling them that the plan is due in his office by next Monday.
Commissioner Aguila requested that the City Comrrmission be kept informed of this
project.
Richard Parsons, representing Captain Frank's Seafood, stated that his site plan
was approved by the Police Department, the City Engineer, the Fire Department,
and Public Works before any changes in landscaping islands were made. Two days
- 19 -
NINUTE$ - REGULAR CITY CONNISSIOH NEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
after approval, Mike Haag from the Building Department, added the landscape
islands. Mr. Parsons said there was a misunderstanding as to whether or not
this had to be done.
Mr. Miller stated that according to City records, what Mr. Parsons said is
incorrect. He advised that two months ago Mr. Parsons was given a directive
from the City Commission to put in those islands. Mr. Miller would like to know
when they are going to go in and when the building is going to be approved.
Mr. Parsons stated that the Department of Transportation issued a violation and
informed him that the landscape islands should not be constructed. Mr. Parsons
was in possession of a letter from them, supporting this statement, along with a
letter from his architect and engineer saying it is unsafe. Mr. Miller advised
that he has a copy of that letter, has had contact with FDOT, and that it is a
matter of interpretation.
Mr. Cutro explained that the landscaping on the corner has to be removed in
order to create the sight triangle.
Commissioner Aguila asked Mr. Miller to keep the City Commission apprised and
suggested Mr. Parsons meet with Mr. Miller and Mr. Cutro to resolve this matter.
Mr. Miller advised Mr. Parsons that his building permit has expired and that he
should see the Building Department about getting a new permit.
B. U~ate on Nurphy I&~jto Report
Edward Hillery, Chief of Police, was available to answer any questions the City
Commission may have regarding his update on implementation of the recommenda-
tions of the Murphy/Mayo report {Police Memorandum No. g3-018}.
Mr. Miller stated that all the recommendations in Police Memorandum No. 93-018
have been covered and the City is moving ahead on the hiring of qualified black
officers. The complaint process has been changed whereby all complaints are now
reviewed by the Police Chief and sent to Internal Affairs for a thorough inves-
tigation, regardless of how minor the complaint. The City is expanding the
community policing program. The Department has re-opened the vertical staff
meeting concept. A career path incentive has been put in place. One black
police officer is now on staff and two, possibly three, will be entering the
Academy next Monday. When they complete the Academy, they will be brought into
the Police Department. One applicant still needs to pass the tape test, which
is a junior college requirement in order to get into the Academy. If he passes
this test, he can enter the Academy next week. There is an active black pool.
Some individuals need to retake parts of the test; however, the City is working
with them.
Mayor Weiner was not happy, with the progress made thus far. She stated that
since September 17, 1992, the City has hired only one Afro-American officer.
Chief Hillery pointed out that some Afro-Americans will be entering the Academy
for training before being put on the street. Mayor Weiner wondered how long it
20-
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COMHISSIONMEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2., 1993
would take to have our population represented in the Police Department. Chief
Hillery believed the work done to date by members of the Police Department with
regard to recruitment is admirable. He pointed out that Murphy and Mayo recom-
mended getting qualified officers without lowering standards. Chief Hillery
advised that it takes time to get qualified officers. Mayor Weiner stated that
other cities have hired Afro-Americans. Chief Hillery disagreed and advised
Mayor Weiner that even though the Police Department is short staffed, positions
are being held open strictly for the purpose of hiring minority officers.
Mayor Weiner stated that according to Murphy and Mayo, testimony during the
Demearest arbitration hearing by superiors and police officers indicated a con-
tinuing pattern of racial slurs by some sworn personnel and that Management's
response was not strong enough to convince personnel that such misconduct would
result in serious discipline if warranted. She asked Mr. Miller if Management
has since developed a stronger response. Mr. Miller advised that the Police
Department has become stronger on this issue and that their standard operating
procedure is more comprehensive. In addition, Mr. Miller has almost completed
one for City employees.
Mayor Weiner referred to Murphy and Mayo's recommendation for a better civilian
complaint process. She said Chief Hillery's report indicates that the Police
Department is working with a software company in developing a program to com-
puterize the Internal Affairs records system to allow for the recognition of any
trends and complaints and to identify officers who are frequently complained
about to determine if officers need training in specific areas. She wanted to
know the name of the software company and when the program will be in place.
Mr. Miller advised that this has been done in the past by hand and is still
being done by hand while the computerized program is being developed. He will
obtain a report from Mike Munro, the Director of Data Processing, and present it
at the February 16, 1993 City Commission meeting. Chief Hillery added that this
software program is going to serve many purposes and has many facets, which
takes time to implement. He stated that the Police Department has adopted every
aspect of Mr. Mayo's recommendations relating to citizen complaints. The Police
Department investigates anonymous telephone calls if there is enough to follow
up on. Complaints are turned over to Internal Affairs and a full investigation
is conducted in a timely manner.
Mayor Weiner felt that recommendation number three of Chief Hillery's Police
Memorandum No. 93-018 does not address the substance of the recommendations made
by Murphy and Mayo on page 20 of their report, with regard to assignment of com-
munity police officers. Chief Hillery explained that he agrees philosophically
with Mr. Murphy on this point; however, he has a logistical problem with this
recommendation. He explained the difficulty in totally converting a police
department into community policing in a short period of time. He stated that
Mr. Murphy's study was based on a study done in England thirty years ago, where
the towns are small and are not spread out over seventeen or eighteen square
miles. However, the City of Boynton Beach does not have the topography, the
funds, or the wherewithal to assign a police officer to every thousand people.
Chief Hillery advised that the Police Department is moving in that direction.
Community policing is being implemented at the Hester Center and in the Cherry
- 21 -
MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORZDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
Hill area. However, it is very difficult to have officers walking throughout
the entire City. Mayor Weiner understood that it was not possible to have offi-
cers walking throughout the entire City; however, she wondered why patrol cars
cannot be assigned to sections of the City. Chief Hillery explained that you
have to put your resources in the areas of the City where there are major
problems. It would be a waste of manpower to give equal coverage to areas of
the City not having problems. Furthermore, more patrol cars and officers would
be needed to accomplish this task. Chief Hillery added that the HUD grant will
enable police officers to be assigned to the Federal housing areas.
Mayor Weiner asked if Chief Hillery's recommendation four, which is that senior
staff members are to get out on the street with officers as they perform their
patrol duties, has gone into effect yet. Chief Hillery said he started doing
this about a month ago. He gets out once or twice a week himself. His other
staff officers are getting ready to go out. Mayor Weiner asked how often the
senior staff members will get out on the street. Chief Hillery advised that
when they can find spare time from their other duties, they will get out on the
street. Mr. Miller added that this recommendation and the vertical staff
meeting concept are both ongoing.
In response to Mayor Weiner, Mr. Miller advised that the drug free workplace
policy has been in effect since the end of December. Everyone has gone through
or will be going through a training session. The City will do everything it
possibly can to assist any employee. Employees will be given as much time as it
takes for them to go through a treatment process. Once they are certified to
return to work, they are expected to remain drug free. If they do not, they can
be fired. Chief Hillery added that the entire Police Department has gone
through ethnic awareness training.
Mayor Weiner assumed the police officers were no longer meeting across the
street after work to drink. Chief Hillery advised that this happened two and a
half years ago and was taken care of as soon.as the Police Department found out
about it. It was not a continuing situation at all.
In response to.Mayor Weiner, Mr. Miller advised that all department heads and
the Police Department have gone through sensitivity training. He is attempting
to have this training done in-house on a continuous basis because he does not
feel it is cost effective for the City to bring in a consultant on an annual
basis. In addition, this training will not only deal with sensitivity, but with
how to treat the public, personal habits in front of the public, etc. The
Personnel Department has embarked on another training program through South Tech
through a contractual basis. Mr. Miller advised it would cost $10,000 to
$20,000 to bring someone into do it. The Personnel Director should be close to
having a proposal to the City Commission for this training. Chief Hillery
advised that the State of Florida also recognized the need, and standards in
training is mandated that officers statewide receive a certain number of hours
training on that particular subject annually. Classes will also be available to
police officers at the community college.
Elizabeth 4enklns, 711N. W. 1st Street, stated that in the 1940s there were
three black police officers in Boynton Beach and she wondered why there are
still only three black police officers in Boynton Beach today.
- 22 -
#INUTES - REGULAR CITY CO#ttlSSION #EETING
BOYNTOH BEACH, FLORIDA
FEBRUARY 2, 1993
llII, OTHER
None.
XIVo ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before this Commission, Commissioner
Harmening moved to adjourn the meeting at 9:18 P. M. Commissioner Aguila
seconded the motion which carried 4-0.
THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
ATTEST:
Ci t'yL~C 1 erk '
Recording Secrel~arY
(Three Tapes)
Mayor
~ /~/ ' Vi ce Mayor
,~/ornmi ssi oner
x/x Commi ss i oner
- 23 -
AGENDA
Feb~aa~y 2, 1993
III.
CONSENT AGENDA
C
cc: Rec, Fin, Util
10.
CENTER FOR FAMILY SERVICES
Employee Assistance Program - February 1993.
Pay from General Fund---001-135-5-482-00
1,344.80
ELECTRIC MOTOR AND PUMP
P.O. 3719. Replacement Parts for L/S 316-319.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-352-5-345-O0
1,001.25
FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT
Installation of 1-35/5 Pole, 1-span#6 Dpx, 1-50,000L
Directional and 2-5/16 Guys at Pioneer Canal Park.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fua~d---301-192-5-629-05
1,040.00
GEE & JENSON ENGINEERS
Professional Services for Task #200 - #212 for
the period ending 1/1/93.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-392-5-463-00
3,234.39
GEE & JENSON ENGINEERS
Final Billing for P.O. 86324 for the Art and Activity
Center.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fund---301-721-5-463-05
1,000.00
GEE & JENSON ENGINEERS
Monthly Retainer Fee for City Engineering Services.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-392-5-463-00
2,040.00
HALMARROBICON GROUP
P.O. 3674. Replacement Parts for VFD Controls at
Master Lift Stations.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-352-5-345-00
1,696.51
HECTOR TURF
P.O. 2877. Various Tee and Green Supplies for the
Golf Course.
Pay from Golf Course Fund---411-726-5-318-00 1,936.50
" " 411-726-5-433-00 1,408.30
" " 411-726-5-345-00 20.65
3,365.45
HOWARD FERTILIZER
P.O. 3502. 20 Tons ~of Bulk Fertilizer for the Golf Course.
Pay from Golf Course Fund---411-726-5-366-00
5,982.01
HUGHES SUPPLY, INC.
P.O. 3206. 500 Water Meters.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-333-5-387-00
11,000.00
COMMISSION
FEB 2 19~'~
APPROVAL
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
ICZMMINS RECYCLING
P.O. 2889. Recycling Bill for December 1992.
Pay from Sanitation Fund---431-341-5-490-01
MARK TOMBERG IRRIGATION AND LANDSCAPING
Payment ~1 - Congress Avenue Berm Project.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fund---301-721-5-635-01
MILNE & NICHOLLS, INC.
P.O. 1374 - Final Payment for the Recreation Activity
Center.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fund---301-721-5-634-03
MINOLTA
P.O. 3447. Microfiche Reader/Printer Plus Accessories
for the Library.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fund---301-711-5-672-00
MOTOROLA
P.O. 3604. Ten Smartnet Portable Radios and Ten Public
Saftey Speaker Microphones with Clips.
Pay from General Fund---001-211-5-690-05
MUNICIPAL CODE CORPORATION
100 Copies of Supplement 52 to the Boynton Beach Code
of Ordinances.
Pay from General Fund---001-122-5-477-00
NATIONAL WASTE TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
P.O. 3455. Seven Picnic Tables for Oceanfront Park.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fund---301-722-5-634-04
NORTHERN PALM BEACH COUNTY WATER CONTROL DISTRICT
NPDES Program Part II - Invoice #8.
Pay from Stormwater Utilities Fund---425-000-0-692-10
P.R.I.D.E.
P.0.2942. Tires for Vehicle Service.
Pay from Vehicle Service Fund---501-193-5-322-00
PEROXIDATION SYSTEMS
P.O. 3002. Hydrogen Peroxide for Odor Control at the
Utility Pumping Stations.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-352-5-366-00
POOLE AND KENT COMPANY
P.O. 2216. Payment #4 - Process Improvements for the
Boynton Beach East Water Treatment.
Pay from 1990 Construction Fund---409-000-O-690-10
2
7,989.17
2,250.00
35,560.00
5,855.00
19,750.00
1,317.67
2,625.00
3,000.00
1,984.87
10,015.20
816,445.60
COMMISSION
~t!B ~ 1993
A~eROYAL
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
SOUTHERN MECHANICAL SEALS, INC.
P.O. 3659. Reconditioned Seals for 14HP Pumps.
Pay from Water and Sewer Fund---401-352-5-433-00
1,185.00
STANLEY CONSULTANTS, INC. 59,160.00
Professional Services through December 26, 1992 in
Connection with WWTP - Construction Management.
Pay from Utility Capital Improvement---404-000-0-690-10 4,715.00
Pay from 1990 Construction Fund---409-O00-0-691-10 $6,147.50
Pay from 1990 Construction Fund---409-O00-0-690-10 $48,297.50
TRW-REDI PROPERTY DATA
Annual Contract for Maps and Redi Realty Reports.
Pay from General Fund---00t-122-5-499-00
1,362.20
TARE LANDSCAPING
P.O.2976. Landscape Maintenance Service for Period
Ending 1/27/93.
Pay from General Fund---001-722-5-430-15
1,440.00
THOMPSON PUMP & MANUFACTURING CO.
P.O. 2947. 12" Wellpoint System Rental to Pump Wells
and Lines Clear to Pass Bacteriological Testing to
Comply with Health Dept. Raw Water Supply for the West
Water Plant.
Pay from 1990 Construction Fund---409-O00-0-690-10
6,770.00
TREE PRO
P.O. 3721. Topping Eight Designated Trees at the
City Golf Course.
Pay from Golf Course Revenue Fund---411-726-5-635-00
2,286.00
UNITED STATES PIPE AND FOUNDRY
P.O. 3380. 1801 Ft. of Slip Joint Water Pipe to
Complete 16" Watermain at North Military Trail.
Pay from 1990 Construction Fund---409-000-0-690-10
31,985.76
VIRCO
P.O. 3022. Folding Tables, Folding Chairs, Chair Racks,
and Table Carts for the Activity Center.
Pay from Public Service Tax Fund---301-721-5-642-05
2,774.00
JEANETTE P. WILSON
Transcription of Trial Testimony of Witnesses for use in
City's Defense - Curt Blom vs City of Boyllton Beach.
Pay from Self Insurance Fund---622-195-5-468-00
2,400.00
XEROX CORP. 1,128.20
Rental Payment and Meter Usage for Copier Located at
the Library.
Pay from General Fund---001-711-5-426-O0 cO~M~Ss~0N
FEB 2, '1993
APPROVAL
These bills have been approved and verified by the deparment heads involved,
checked and approved for payment.
Diane Reese, Asst. Finance Director
I therefore recommend payment of these bills.
J/Scott Miller, City
Manager
COMMISSION
FEB ,~ ]99~
APPROVAL