Minutes 02-11-04MINUTES OF THE COMMUNITY RELATIONS BOARD MEETING HELD IN
COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, ON
WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 2004 AT 7:00 P.M.
Present
Ron Washam, Chairperson
Anna Marie Noe, Vice Chair
Blanche Girtman
Brian Miller
Howard Solomon
Brenda Lee Williams
Sarah Dye, Alternate
Robert Harper, Alternate
Absent
Jayne Kupperman
Eddie Mitchell
Jose Rodriguez
I. Pledge of Allegiance
Dan DeCarlo, Board Liaison
Chair Washam called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. Mr. Miller led the recitation of
the Pledge of Allegiance.
IT. Roll Call of Regular Members and Alternates
The Recording Secretary called the roll and declared that a quorum was present.
III. Recognition of Visitors
Chair Washam welcomed Assistant City Manager Wilfred Hawkins.
IV. .lanuary :t4, 2004 Minutes Approval
Iqotion
Mr. Miller moved to approve, seconded by Mr. Solomon and carried unanimously.
V. Agenda Approval
There were no changes to the agenda.
Motion
Mr. Solomon moved to approve, seconded by Vice Chair Noe, and carried unanimously.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February l:[, 2004
VI. Correspondence and Announcements
Mr. DeCarlo distributed a calendar to the Board members of Heritagefest
activities for the month of February.
Msi Girtman stated that a streetlight was out, and had been out for some
time, on the corner of N.W. 6th Avenue and N. Seacrest Boulevard. She
asked how the repair could be accomplished.
Mr. DeCarlo and others stated that Florida Power & Light would take care of this
directly, and if it were not taken care of, it could be brought to the attention of the
Public Works Department at the City. Mr. Miller noted that in Village Royale on the
Green, the Secretary posts the affected pole number on the FP &L Website and it is
usually taken care of in two weeks' time. Vice Chair Noe lives behind Bethesda Hospital
and whenever she has called FP &L to fix a light, it is usually taken care of in 48 hours.
Ms. Girtman stated that the lighting through her neighborhood was poor, including the
area of Ridgewood Hills from Seacrest Boulevard west to 1-95 and Boynton Beach
Boulevard to the canal.
The Board's consensus was that the City should work with Ms. Girtman on the lighting
problems in her neighborhood.
Ms. Girtman also mentioned a problem in the vicinity of N.W. 3rd Street, N.W. 6th
Avenue and N.W. 10th Avenue, where so many cars were parked alongside the
roads that it was difficult to get a vehicle through them safely.
Chair Washam announced that volunteers were needed to work on a Habitat for
Humanity home west of Seacrest Boulevard on MLK Boulevard on Saturday,
February ::[4 from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Ms. Girtman announced that Miss Black America had attended the activities at the
Catalina Centre on the previous Sunday as part of the Heritagefest event. Miss Black
America is an attractive young lady, a college graduate, and is doing very well.
General Obliqation (GO) Bond - Assistant City Manager Wilfred Hawkins
Chair Washam introduced Assistant City Manager Hawkins, who spoke to the Board
about the recent GO Bond referendum and the decisions the City made about the
capital improvement projects when the referendum measure failed. Chair Washam
thanked Assistant City Manager Hawkins for taking the time to come to address the
Board.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February :11, 2004
Mr. Hawkins stated that the current Commission determined that the capital
improvement projects had to be completed one way or another, if not through the GO
bonds, then through Revenue Bonds. Revenue Bonds do not require voter approval and
do not cause any tax increases to the citizens. The Revenue Bond option was always on
the table and had been discussed in many public meetings. The City has pledged to pay
back the Revenue Bonds through the public service tax. Mr. Hawkins explained the
origin of the public service taxes the citizens pay to such entities as FP & L, the
telephone company, and the cable television stations. This money eventually goes to
the State, the County, and the municipalities for use in upgrading facilities and
infrastructure. The City has pledged to use this money to pay back the Revenue Bonds
over the next ten years.
Mr. Miller inquired where the money from the public service tax goes. Mr.
Hawkins stated that it goes into the General Fund, where it is normally used for road
repairs, capital improvement projects, and upgrades.
Mr. Solomon asked if pledging the public service tax money to repay the
Revenue Bonds would take away from projects that had already been
planned. Mr. Hawkins stated that it would hinder the City from using the money for
anything else, since it was earmarked to repay the Revenue Bonds for the next 10
years. The City had wanted to do the GO Bond option since it would not have tied up
this funding source. As a result, there is no more "wiggle" room in the City's budget and
the City is tightening its belt. However, there will not be a tax increase to the citizens
as there would have been with the GO Bonds.
Mr. Miller inquired when the Revenue Bonds would be issued. Mr. Hawkins
stated that the City was bringing in bond counsel, negotiating the provisions of a
contract, and would probably go out "on the street" to buy the bonds in the next three
to four months. ]:n the meantime, many of the projects are being planned.
Mr. Hawkins stated that the majority of the projects fell under the purview of the
Recreation & Parks Department, which is a department that reports to him.
The projects include upgrades at the Wilson Center for the park and pool areas and a
new Community Center at Intracoastal Park to replace the old Royal Palm Clubhouse.
They would also be purchasing property at Jaycee Park. In response to a question from
the Board, Mr. Hawkins indicated that the new Community Center at Intracoastal Park
would be larger than the old Royal Palm Clubhouse, probably in the vicinity of 10K
square feet and comparable in size to the current Civic Center.
Ms. Girtman asked if there were any plans to improve the Civic Center. Hr.
Hawkins replied that this was on the list, but the old Commission and the new one had
deemed it to be of a lower priority than the projects he had just mentioned.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February 11, 2004
Mr. Solomon asked if there were any plans to develop the piece of vacant
land in the Meadows, and Mr. Hawkins responded that there were not.
Mr. Hawkins stated that the Senior Center would be finished out and the new Library
building would be built. The new front entrance to the Senior Center will be what is now
the parking lot to the north of the Center. The other entrance will be accessible, but will
no longer serve as the main entrance to the facility.
Mr. Hawkins commented that the City Commission believed that finishing these projects
was important in the redevelopment of the entire City. The City is also spending
millions of dollars putting the residents' stormwater fees to work making major utility
upgrades of stormwater drainage and new sewer and water lines. It is also spending for
major infrastructure improvements, work on East Ocean Avenue, and in the north end
of town.
Vice Chair Noe thanked Mr. Hawkins for attending this meeting to
about the GO Bond issue. She stated that she had felt misled,
acquaintance, about the GO Bond issue and the lack of mention
option in the literature that was sent to the residents' homes
address the concerns
as had others of her
of the Revenue Bond
prior to the vote.
appeared as if the City had asked the citizens about increasing their taxes to do the
projects and when the citizens turned it down, the City said, "We don't care what you
think/say. We are going to do what we want anyway." She said that if there were an
alternative to raising taxes in the form of Revenue Bonds, the citizens should have been
informed about this up front.
Mr. Hawkins responded that the City had spoken about the Revenue Bond option when
it spoke about the GO Bonds and that the Revenue Bond alternative had always been in
the public record. The previous Commission was not trying to mislead the voters. Both
alternatives had been discussed. The press, however, did not write about the Revenue
Bond option, possibly because the City was focusing on the preferred method of
accomplishing the improvements, the GO Bonds.
Vice Chair Noe stated that she did not rely on the press for her information. She read
information on utility bills and came to meetings when possible. She reiterated that
there had been no mention of the Revenue Bond option in the literature the City sent
out to the citizens before the vote took place. She strongly felt that the Revenue Bond
option should have been mentioned in this literature since many people used it as their
sole source of information on which to make a decision about the GO Bonds. ]:f the
literature had said that the City was going to do it one way or another but preferred the
GO Bonds, which would call for a slight increase, many more people would have
probably voted in favor of it.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February ll, 2004
Mr. Hawkins stated that it was never the City's intent to be deceptive. He could
understand what Vice Chair Noe was saying about the pre-vote literature, but stated
that hindsight was 20-20. He hoped that the people did not criticize the current
Commission for pulling a fast one because that was not the case. He felt that there had
always been total disclosure on both options.
Chair Washam thanked Mr. Hawkins for his visit to the Board. He commented that there
were many different feelings on this topic and a lot of passion involved, but he did not
believe there was any deception involved. He thought it was time to come together
and follow the path the legislators had chosen. He stated that in the final analysis, the
buildings that needed to get done will get done and the projects that they all tried to
get done will be done and this was good news. He expressed the sentiment that in the
long run, everyone would win.
VII. Old Business
1) PATCH Activities Update
Mr. DeCarlo said that staff was reviewing the possibility of having a trailer at Bethesda
Hospital for PATCH. They were also looking at the cost analysis for the trailer to be
located at the Hester Center as a temporary site for PATCH activities. There was a staff
meeting today talking about the process and engineering and architectural work that
would be required to do this. It will ultimately need to go before the Commission for
approval. PATCH will have the responsibility of maintaining the trailer once it is in place.
A lot more information should be available at the Board's next meeting.
Iris. Girtman asked what was being done towards preventing the trailer from becoming
permanent. They had always wanted a permanent building instead of a trailer. The
community felt quite let down about this. Mr. DeCarlo said that the sentiment of the
City was that it did not see the trailer as a permanent site for PATCH. They see it as a
temporary trailer. Even getting a permit for the trailer with the new wind load
requirements will be a challenge, although they think that it will be possible. They were
hoping to use this as a springboard to develop and build PATCH activities so at some
point it could move to a permanent location. The trailer will provide a way to gather the
PATCH activities under one roof instead of having them scattered throughout the
community.
Mr. Hawkins stated that when the package was put together, they clearly intend to
have a written document outlining such things as the length of time the trailer can be
there and the services that can be provided in it. There are some parking concerns at
the Hester Center. It is not the City's intent nor would staff recommend to the
Commission that the City do anything other than a temporary site.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February 11, 2004
Hr. DeCarlo said that the challenge for PATCH would be to come up with the money for
utilities, phone, and maintenance that would be involved with occupying the trailer,
since this would not be underwritten by the City. There are some serious discussions to
be held even within PATCH about where they will have to look for funding. There have
been a number of resource organizations and individuals who have expressed an
interest in helping, but they have been waiting for the site to be acquired first. A
proposal will have to be made showing funding sources and so forth to actually operate
the trailer once it is in place.
Mr. Hiller inquired when the Heritagefest event would be held where PATCH would
have a booth. Hr. DeCarlo responded that it was on Saturday, February 28. Mr. Hiller
volunteered to serve in the booth during this event.
2) CRB Brochure
Mr. DeCarlo thought that everyone had seen the brochure and that it was ready to go.
With Heritagefest coming up, PATCH will have a booth at the Hester Center and the
brochures will be available at this event. Ms. Girtman asked that Mr. DeCarlo send her a
copy of the proposed brochure before actually sending it out for printing.
3) CRB Meeting in Different Neighborhoods
Hr. DeCarlo was hoping to use the brochure as a promotion, particular in some of the
different neighborhoods. They talked about having some of the Community Relation
Board meetings in some of the different neighborhoods. A lot of them meet monthly
and have nice community rooms. He had spoken to some who would be glad to invite
the CRB to one of their meetings to find out more about what the Board does and how
this Board impacts the City. Staff is continuing to follow up on this.
VIII. New Business
l) Youth-in-Government Day
The Board discussed this event and came to a decision to hold the event on April 28.
Chair Washam explained the event for the benefit of the new Board members.
Representatives of area schools spend the day in the City, touring the City, having
lunch with City officials, and participating in a mock City Commission meeting in the
evening. More details will be available at the Board's next meeting.
Ns. Girtman thought that a tour of the West Water Treatment Plant would be very good
for the youth. Mr. DeCarlo will look into this, but he thought that the time available
during this event was already filled with other activities. It would also depend on how
6
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February 11, 2004
many students would be participating since the previous year the event had to be split
up and held on two different days.
2) Great American Cleanup
Mr. DeCarlo stated that this was a community event held on Saturdays. The City
encourages the Board members to work in the neighborhood in which they live and
enlist the participation of the residents in the effort. He thought that this was a great
way for the Board members to get involved with a neighborhood project. It did not
have to be in a person's own area, but it was hoped that the Board members would all
help out on this day.
Mr. Miller mentioned a conversation he had with George Mantell, the Streets
Maintenance Supervisor in Public Works, where Mr. Miller had suggested that Mr.
Mantell make a list of the areas that were in need of attention, so that the Board
members could try to enlist the aid of community residents in the areas that Mr. Mantell
identifies. Mr. Miller felt that obtaining the participation of the neighborhood residents
was key to the success of an area getting clean and staying that way. Vice Chair Noe
asked that this item be put on the agenda for next month's meeting of the CRB.
3) Fire Station #4
Vice Chair Noe had a question about why the City had chosen the site it had for this
facility. She mentioned that the island would have to be opened up and she wondered
why Bakers' Furniture was not chosen instead. Mr. Hawkins stated that the Baker
Furniture site would have been nice, but it was not possible to arrive at a mutually
satisfying agreement with them. The current location was the next best one. There will
be an activated light and a restrictive turn-around (''emergency vehicle use only"), and
when the fire trucks come out the light will be red, and when they leave, it will return
to green. Vice Chair Noe thanked him for this information.
4) Literacy Program
Mr. Miller asked about the status of this program that the Board had discussed the
previous month.
Mr. DeCarlo stated that this project was still in the research phase and that Youth in
Government Day and the Great American Cleanup were still the main focus. Chair
Washam stated that the Board was working with the Library Director to put together a
comprehensive book festival for Boynton Beach where literacy for everyone would play
an important role.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
February ll, 2004
Ms. Girtman mentioned the very successful book event held at the Library recently in
conjunction with the Heritagefest activities. Also, once a month the African American
Book Club meets at the Library.
Ms. Girtman also mentioned that Mr. DeCarlo had completed a wonderful Chinese
pavilion at his home and congratulated him on it. She commented on the very
interesting article in the Palm Beach Post and expressed interest in seeing it.
Adjournment
Since there was no further business before the Board, the meeting was duly adjourned
at 8:07 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Susan Collins
Recording Secretary
(021203)