Minutes 05-12-04 MINUTES OF THE COMHUNITY RELATIONS BOARD HEETING
HELD I~N COHHISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL,
BOYNTON BEACH, FLOR/DA, ON WEDNESDAY, HAY 12, 2004 at 7:00 P.M.
Present
Blanche Girtman Dan DeCarlo, Board Liaison
.layne Kupperman
Brian Miller
Eddie Mitchell
.loyce Mura
Phyllis Stern
Brenda Lee Williams
Joseph Bartley, Alternate
Absent
Robert Harper, Alternate
Prior to having an election of officers, Mr. Dan DeCarlo called the meeting to order at
7:00 p.m.
Election of Officers
Mr. DeCarlo called for nominations for Board Chair.
Mr. Mitchell nominated Mr. Miller for Chair. Ms. Stern seconded the nomination.
Hotion
Ms. Williams moved that the nomination of Brian Miller for Chair be approved. Ms.
Kupperman seconded the motion that carried unanimously.
Chair Miller thanked everyone for his election.
Chair Miller asked for nominations for Vice Chair. Mr. Mitchell and Ms. Williams
expressed their disinclination to accept nomination.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida May 12, 2004
NS. Williams nominated Ns. Kupperman as Vice Chair. Ms. Stern seconded the
nomination.
The Board voted unanimously to elect Hs..layne Kupperman as Vice Chair.
Chair Hiller introduced the Board members and each Board member gave some
historical information about themselves for the benefit of the new Board members and
the audience.
Recognition of Visitors
Chair Hiller recognized the presence in the audience of former Board Chair Ron
Washam, Brian Edwards, Sister Lorraine Ryan of the Community Caring Center and
PATCH, and Susan Beidler, R.N. and Assistant Professor of Nursing at Florida Atlantic
University, a member of the PATCH Board of Directors. Chair Hiller welcomed the
visitors to the meeting.
Pledge of Allegiance
At the request of Chair Hiller, former Board Chair Ron Washam led the Board in the
Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
Remarks of Ron Washam
Hr. Washam reflected on his service on the Community Relations Board (CRB) where he
was Chair for 14 years. He recalled his first year as Board Chair and was honored and
humbled by the confidence the Board accorded him in 13 successive re-elections as
Board Chair. Over the years, Hr. Washam was urged to serve on higher-profile Boards,
but continued to choose the CRB. He recalled that this Board had instituted the Youth in
Government Day back in 1972 and it had been successfully presented annually since
that time. Hr. Washam credited his attitude towards public service to the principles and
inspiration instilled in him by Hr. Hitchell, his junior high school teacher.
Hr. Washam impressed upon the Board that the CRB was "the conscience of the
community" and as such, performed a valuable service, acting as a bridge between the
residents and the City Commission. Over the years, when trouble and strife appeared,
the Commission had called on the CRB for assistance. Hr. Washam was proud to have
been a part of the Board and its projects and expressed his willingness to serve as a
resource for the Board on a continuing basis. He spoke of many ongoing projects and
expressed his individual thanks to each member of the Board.
2
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida May 12, 2004
Various Board members expressed dismay and regret over the loss of Mr. Washam on
the CRB, as well as best wishes for his happiness and success in the future. The Board
was glad to hear that Mr. Washam was willing to serve as a resource to the Board.
The Board also expressed gratitude to the exiting Vice Chair Anna Noe, who expressed
appreciation for the opportunity to serve on the Board.
Chair Miller expressed the belief that the energy and ideas of past leaders would not be
lost, but would add to the strength of the Board as it continued to build on the
foundation past leaders had supplied.
III. Roll Call
The Recording Secretary called the roll and declared that a quorum was present.
IV. March 10, 2004 Minutes Approval
Motion
Vice Chair Kupperman moved to approve the minutes of the March :[0, 2004 meeting.
Mr. Mitchell seconded the motion that carried unanimously.
V. Agenda Approval
Chair Miller asked to add under New Business a discussion of a possible co-venture with
the Recreation & Park Department to take the area youth to some Marlin and Dolphin
games.
Ms. Girtman asked to add a discussion of the multiple problems of the Haitian people in
the north end. Chair Miller suggested that this be included in the Literacy discussion.
Motion
Vice Chair Kupperman moved to approve the agenda as amended. Ms. Williams
seconded the motion that carried unanimously.
VI. Correspondence and Announcements
Mr. DeCarlo announced that the recent Youth in Government Day had been a big
success. The turnout was good and the students did a great job during the mock City
Commission meeting in the evening.
The Great American Cleanup drew some 200 volunteers this year.
3
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida IVlay 12, 2004
VII. Old Business
A) PATCH Update
.Sr. Lorraine Ryan of the Women's Circle and Vice President of the Boynton Beach
PATCH organization gave an update on the PATCH project. She distributed a list of the
PATCH Board of Directors with their credentials, a PATCH Monthly Report dated May 3,
2004, a May 11, 2004 letter to the Community Relations Board, and a letter from Brian
Edwards containing Historical Information and Activity Sheets pertaining to PATCH. All
of these documents are on file with the minutes in the City Clerk's office.
Sr. Ryan commented that many of the people on the Board and in the audience had
been working towards a common goal for the last twenty to thirty years: the
establishment of a community health center~ preferably in the Heart of
Boynton area.
Sr. Ryan pointed to the high immigrant population in Boynton Beach, estimating that
approximately 1/5 of the population in Boynton Beach was without health insurance.
The affected people cannot afford to go to the Emergency Room at Bethesda Hospital
or to private physicians when they are ill. The primary area to be served is on the
north side of Boynton Beach Boulevard. This area, zip code 33435, has citizens at high
risk for hypertension, diabetes, and HIV/AIDS. It was to serve the pressing needs of
these uninsured citizens that the PATCH organization was formed.
Sr. Ryan gave Mr. DeCarlo a petition in favor of the community health center that was
now being circulated in the community.
PATCH has been 43 months in the making and is currently awaiting its 501.1(c)(3)
classification. In support of the free services being offered by PATCH, $10,000 has been
received from the Medical Mission Sisters, Sr. Ryan's home religious order. When the
501 (C)(3) status is achieved, PATCH will apply to The Blue Foundation for a Health
Florida (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida) for a total over two years of $100K, for
the purpose of establishing a free-standing wellness center in the city limits to promote
full-time health care services to the residents of Boynton Beach.
The next PATCH meeting will be held at the Treasure Chest Learning Center on
Seacrest Boulevard on May 19 at 7:00 p.m. and Sr. Ryan invited the Board to attend.
She stressed the importance of arranging a workshop between the City Commission,
the CRA, the CRB, and PATCH to discuss a temporary site for use of the donated
doublewide trailer (from Bethesda Memorial Hospital), and eventually a community
health center in the Heart of Boynton.
4
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida May 12, 2004
PATCH would like to be able to provide the services for longer than the two hours now
occurring on Saturdays. Also, they would like to be able to use the donated services of
doctors and nurses that stand ready to do so, including health assessments and
prescriptions.
The sense of the Board was that if Bethesda Hospital recognized the need and was
willing to donate the trailer to support it, that the City and PATCH should work together
to make this happen.
Susan Beidler, R.N. Family Practitioner, Nurse Ethicist, Assistant Professor of
Nursing at Florida Atlantic University and on the PATCH Board of Directors,
addressed the Board. Ms. Beidler became involved in PATCH in October of 2003 and
was new to Florida, having come from the area of Reading, Pennsylvania. Her most
recent clinical experience was in a public housing based, federally qualified health
center, staffed entirely by Nurse Practitioners. These health centers receive special
funding from the federal government because services are being provided that go
beyond what is provided by traditional health care services. This is the type of effort
that she envisioned the PATCH program supporting. She felt that this was a necessary
step in the development of a community health center that was all-inclusive.
Ms. Beidler has spent every Saturday since January of this year at the Wellness Center,
on a volunteer basis. She pointed out that Sr. Ryan had extensive experience as a
medical missionary in India and that she was familiar with the notion of training people
to go out into the community to promote health. She had adapted the model from India
to Boynton Beach, and Ms. Beidler thought that this was a wonderful model of
community health, and unique in this area. People come in on a Saturday and learn
about a particular disease and go out and help to educate their friends and neighbors
about it.
Brian Edwards, 629 N.E. 9th Avenue, Boynton Beach, spoke in support of the
PATCH organization's efforts to establish a community health center. He distributed
letters and reports to the Board and solicited the Board's support to help draw the
decision makers together so that the dream of a community health center in Boynton
Beach could move forward. Mr. Edwards spoke of the work of the volunteers to bring
the organization to the point it was today and the need of the support and partnership
of the City.
Board members discussed various locations for the trailer donated by Bethesda
Hospital, but no conclusion was reached. The Board realized that there were some in
the City who did not believe a community health center was necessary and that it
duplicated services provided now by the Senior Center. The problem was that most of
the citizens in need are black and the citizens who use the Senior Center are 99%
white.
5
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida May 12, 2004
Chair Miller suggested contacting major pharmaceutical companies, who had money
and would be interested in this program.
Ms. Girtman, a long-time member and former Chair of the CRB and life-long resident of
Boynton Beach, expressed her feelings on the matter. :in 1972, she stood at the
podium and begged for a health center for the citizens of Bo~ynton Beach, for the older
people who were confined to the vicinity of N.E. and N.W. 9L'' Avenue to the canal and
over to the Florida East Coast railroad. They did not have cars and did not have taxi
service. They still do not have taxi service in that area. She felt that it had been very
hard to get the City of Boynton Beach to go beyond Boynton Beach Boulevard to come
over to the area to help anybody. She was still asking for the health center, more than
thirty years later, and was very concerned about its future. She said that many of the
residents of that area were uninsured, without financial assistance, but that they had
pride. Ms. Girtman felt that it was time for the City to step up and help. She expressed
love for the Boynton Beach that she had lived in since 1946 and taught in for so many
years. She had worked with the City in every way that a citizen could. Now, she felt it
was time for the City to support PATCH. When Sr. Ryan asked if PATCH could use her
building, she gladly agreed, l~f she could install the trailer in the parking lot of her day
care building, she would do so gladly, but she knew that the Code would not allow it.
Ms. Girtman's remarks met with considerable agreement and sympathy on the part of
the Board.
Chair Miller stated that health care was a number one priority locally and nationally and
that people were living longer. For many, finances had all but disappeared. He felt it
would behoove everyone to realize the importance of this issue.
Motion
Vice Chair Kupperman moved that the CRB takes a strong interest in the PATCH
program and believes it is important to the community. :in its advisory capacity, the
CRB recommends to the City Commission that the City do what it can to support
PATCH. The Board believes that PATCH addresses a group of City residents that really
needs this kind of help. Ms. Girtman seconded the motion that carried unanimously.
After further discussion, the Board passed an additional motion.
Motion
Ms. Girtman moved to recommend that the City Commission, the Community
Redevelopment Agency, and the Community Relations Board meet with PATCH in a
workshop as soon as possible, possibly in 3une, to find ways the various entities can
work together to make PATCH into what it needs to be in order to best serve the needs
of the community. Ms. Stern seconded the motion that carried unanimously.
6
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida May 12, 2004
The PATCH organization will work with Mr. DeCarlo to arrange an appropriate date for a
joint workshop.
VIII. New Business
A) Marlins and Dolphin Game Trips
Chair Hiller suggested that the CRB consider becoming co-sponsors with the Recreation
Department to offer trips for area youth to the Marlins and Dolphin games. The tickets
are inexpensive and the youth would pay for the ticket and the City would provide the
transportation. The CRB could participate as chaperones on the bus, for example. Ns.
Stern suggested that the Advisory Board on Children and Youth might wish to
participate in this as well, and Mr. DeCarlo will contact them. The Board thought this
was a good idea.
B) Literacy
With the consent of the Board, this item will be postponed until the next meeting.
IX. Next Meeting
Chair Miller asked that the .lune 9 CRB meeting be changed to June 16. ( The Chambers
is not ava//ab/e and Mr. DeCar/o's office w/// find a room and not/fy the Board members.)
X, Adjournment
The meeting was duly adjourned at 9:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Susan Collins
Recording Secretary
(os~3o4)
7