Minutes 03-07-05 Mt'NUTES OF THE SENt'OR ADV:ISORY BOARD MEET:ING
HELD AT THE SENt'OR CENTER, 1021 SOUTH FEDERAL HTGHWAY,
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORI'DA,
ON MONDAY, MARCH 7, 2005 AT 3:00 P.M.
Present
Denise Chamberlain, Chair Steve Lulkin, Recreation Supervisor
Lillian Bruzzese
Elizabeth .]enkins
Christine Wilson
Rose Love, Vice Chair
Betty Spinelli
Robert L..]ames, Sr., Alternate
:i. Call to Order
Chairperson Chamberlain called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
:i:i. Roll Call
The Recording Secretary called the roll and declared a quorum was present.
TT:I. Pledge of Allegiance
Members recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
:iV. Approval of Agenda
There were no changes to the agenda, which was accepted as presented.
V. Approval of Minutes
Mr. Lulkin requested an amendment be made to the minutes of .]anuary 10, 2005 on
page 2 under Old Business to show that the generator was not "pending," as stated in
the minutes. Senior Center staff was merely looking into the cost of getting a generator
and did not have concrete plans to purchase one.
A motion to approve the minutes as amended was made and duly seconded.
Meeting Minutes
Senior Advisory Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
March 7, 2005
VI. Chairperson's Remarks
Chair Chamberlain reminded the members whose terms were expiring they must re-
apply by April 15, 2005 on forms that were available in the City Clerk's office.
Chair Chamberlin introduced three guests: Fire Chief Bill Bingham of the City of Boynton
Beach, ]oyce Edelson of the Retired Senior Volunteer Program (R.S.V.P.), and Brian
Miller, Chairman of the Community Relations Board.
VII. Old Business
A. Letter to Mayor on Emergency Services
Chair Chamberlain read a letter she had written to the Mayor as follows: "The Sen/or
Adv/son/ Board met on 3anuary lO, 200S and discussed the prob/em that sen/ors,
espec/a#y those in the north end, had during the hurricanes. A vote was taken to have
a special meeting to address emergency services pr/or to the upcoming hurricane
season and to invite the Rlayor, the Commissioners, and the City klanager. We would
like to meet w/th you at your convenience some t/me in April, 2005. I would like to
inform the Board at our March 7 meeting of your date preference. Thank you for your
consideration."
Fire Chief Bingham advised Chair Chamberlain of the Mayor's suggestion to have Fire
Chief Bill Bingham address this issue with the Board. If the Board was not satisfied after
this, the Mayor offered to come to the Board's April or May meeting for further
discussion.
The Board talked in recent meetings about having an educational forum for the City
residents on this topic, but was concerned about possible overlap with other community
agencies, especially the Community Caring Center (CCC). The Board wanted to discuss
this with them at this meeting, but the CCC was not able to attend.
Ms. Lillian Bruzzese had previously been directed to investigate the Community
Emergency Response Team (CERT) program also. This is a team trained by the
Boynton Beach Fire Rescue Department to care for the community until professional
help arrives during emergencies. They are trained to administer basic first aid, set up a
triage area, fight small fires, and search for and rescue disaster victims. They stay in
contact with Boynton Beach Fire Rescue, giving them medical reports and damage
assessments from the scene. Fire Chief Bingham later commented that in the past three
years. 140 people had received certification in the federally funded CERT program. He
urged the Board members to spread the word in the community to get more people to
sign up for this training. Ms. Jenkins offered to sign up for this training.
Meeting Minutes
Senior Advisory Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
March 7, 2005
The CERTS team is very active in Palm Beach Leisureville and helped the citizens of that
development all throughout the recent hurricane emergencies.
Chief Bingham advised the Board that the training classes were offered from 6:30 p.m.
to 9:30 p.m. The telephone number to call to get an application is 561-742-6332. The
training takes eight weeks and involves emergency first aid, CPR, and the use of the
Automatic Electronic Defibrillator (AED). Additional training drills are offered two or
three times a year.
Since the Citizens on Patrol (COPs) were already deployed throughout the community, it
was thought that extending their training to include certification in CERTS could be very
useful. The restriction on COPS getting out of the car to speak to people might make
this idea impractical, but the Board still wished to pursue the idea.
Mr. Lulkin commented that during the last hurricane, the Senior Center received a
number of telephone calls from seniors who were without food and/or water. The staff
of the Senior Center purchased water and food and delivered it to the individuals who
called the Center. The consensus was that people had to be educated about where to
go for help before the next hurricane emergency.
Ms. Jenkins was given an opportunity to speak about her concerns that citizens of the
north end had not been treated appropriately during the hurricane. Ms. Jenkins stated
that when Hurricane Frances struck, she had no lights, could not cook, and was afraid
to use the water. Due to her medical condition, she had to eat and she went over to
her grandfather's house to do so. She returned to her home after 8 p.m., the
established time of the citywide curfew. The vehicle she was traveling in was stopped
by a police officer, who said: "! don't care if you're the Pope, no one can be out during
the curfew." She felt that this was abusive, under the circumstances. She understood
that the reason for the curfew was for the protection of the residents, but believed the
treatment they received was unnecessarily cruel. She telephoned the Police station after
the incident and reported it, but had not yet heard back from the Police about her call.
l~n response to Ms. Jenkins' concerns, Chief Bingham did not wish to comment, criticiize,
or judge another department's actions. However, he did feel that what happened to Ms.
Jenkins was unfortunate. He went on to say that during the last hurricane, the Fire
Department had received over 150 emergency calls. When sustained winds are over 55
miles per hour, the emergency response vehicles and personnel (Police and Fire) are
confined to base until weather conditions permit safe operation of their vehicles. Once
they were able to get out in the City, it took several hours to reach all the people who
had called for help. During this time, they relied on the CERT volunteers to help people
and keep the Police and Fire up-to-date on conditions in the community. Chief Bingham
spoke of his department's efforts during the hurricanes to distribute food and ice to
areas where the help seemed most needed;
3
Meeting Minutes
Senior Advisory Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
March 7, 2005
however, they were trying to provide services to a community having 70K people and
their resources were limited. When the Fire Department got an urgent call from the
Boynton Bay area, for example, they pulled trucks off the street and convoyed ice and
food to them. Chief Bingham also commented on the breakdown in communications
that occurred for people using cell phones as their primary means of communication.
Hurricane shelters were discussed, including the closest one in Boynton Beach, the
Boynton Beach High School. Chief Bingham emphasized that this shelter was primarily
intended for use by those living in evacuation areas, which normally means the
individuals living east of the railroad tracks near Federal Highway. Ms. Jenkins
commented that she lived in a flood zone, and Chief Bingham said that was a factor
also.
Chief Bingham stated that there was a list on which people could put their names
ahead of time if they had special needs. The phone number to do this is well
advertised in pamphlets that can be obtained at such locations as Publix Supermarkets.
The Fire Department will pick up or arrange to have picked up the individuals on this list
and take them to the special needs hurricane shelters in the event of a hurricane
emergency. Since some people with special needs went to the Boynton Beach High
School shelter instead of going to the Fairgrounds (the location of the special needs
shelter during the last hurricane), it was necessary to divert paramedics from normal
service to set up a clinic in the shelter. This deprived the other citizens of the services
of ten paramedics, who could not be out on the street helping others.
Chief Bingham spoke of the upcoming hurricane season and emphasized the urgency of
preparation including flashlights, batteries, non-electrical can openers, non-perishable
food and water. Having an adequate supply of non-perishable food on hand was
especially important for people with medical conditions.
A Board member asked Chief Bingham about generators. He commented that the
generators could not be set up inside a home due to carbon monoxide. Also, the
generator will only power appliances that are actually hooked up to it.
Chief Bingham asked the Board if they knew of any local social service agencies that
might assist during hurricanes. Chair Chamberlain said that was why they had an
R.S.V.P. volunteer present at this meeting.
Chair Chamberlain commented that the Board had many discussions about the
problems of seniors in individual homes in terms of getting to doctor's appointments
and so forth. They would be especially vulnerable during hurricanes also. Some of the
larger communities seem to have more resources for coping with emergencies. The
Board wanted to see if something could be put in place to remedy the problem of
isolated seniors, at least in part.
4
Meeting Minutes
Senior Advisory Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
March 7, 2005
.loyce Edelson, representing the RSVP organization, expressed her belief that the Area
Agency on Aging was working on a program that would identify homebound seniors in
individual homes. After the hurricane, RSVP staff of 45 went door-to-door to find out
where the vulnerable seniors resided, but this effort covered five counties and fell short
of the actual need. They delivered meals, flashlights, and batteries. Ms. Edelson will
get a status report from the Area Agency on Aging and report back to the Board. She
will also contact the Leadership Volunteer Director to see if anyone wants to work with
Boynton Beach to get some kind of volunteer organization started.
Ms. Edelson commented that in the Palm Beach County Sheriff's office, some of the
COPS had CERT training also. She believed that prior to a time a Sheriff's deputy
arrived at a scene, the COPS/CERT representative could go to the house and ascertain
the needs of the homeowner. This made her believe that a dual role was possible.
Chief Bingham stated that if there were enough CERT members in the communities, it
would not be necessary to discuss COPS participation. A comment was made that
during the summer, the COPS population dropped dramatically when the "snowbirds"
went up north and this was also the time period for hurricanes. Mr. Lulkin felt it was
important to find out which areas already had CERTS volunteers and which did not, to
help the Board focus their efforts to solicit new volunteers.
Chief Bingham noted that the City's Emergency Operations Center was manned 24/7
during the hurricanes and that the telephone number had been broadcasted on the
radios and was on the City's answering machine as well.
Several people commented that the hurricane had brought people closer together on a
personal basis and agreed that this was a good thing. Also, it was agreed that it was
important to get the word out to the people before the hurricane. Mr. Lulkin suggested
the Senior Center offer a seminar two or three times before the hurricane season,
inviting the Police and Fire Departments, and all the communities in the City. This
would go a long way towards increasing public awareness. Chief Bingham suggested
having one in April, May, and .lune. The seminars could be advertised on the City's
marquee and in the Boynton Times. The people who come to the seminars could take
the information back to their communities to spread the word.
Chief Bingham offered the services of the Fire Department to speak at community
organizations on the topic of hurricane preparedness. He also recommended churches
as an alternate means of disseminating information to a large number of individuals.
VIII. Adjournment
Since there was no further business before the Board, the meeting was duly adjourned
at 4:20 p.m.
Meeting Minutes
Senior Advisory Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
March 7, 2005
Susan Collins
Recording Secretary
(O3O8O5)