Minutes 04-13-05 MINUTES OF THE COMMUNITY RELATIONS BOARD MEETING
HELD IN THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, BOYNTON BEACH,
FLORIDA, ON WEDNESDAY, APRIL 13, 2005 AT 7:00 P.M
Present:
Brian Miller, Chair
Blanche Girtman, Vice Chair
Eddie Mitchell
Joyce Mura
Gregg Ornstein
Phyllis Stern
Brenda Lee Williams (left at 7:15 p.m.)
Kurt Godfrey, Voting Alternate
Thelma Lyons, Administrative Assistant
Neighborhood Specialist
Absent:
Stanley Sorgman
I. Pledge of Allegiance
Chairman Miller called the meeting to order at 7:04 p.m. Members recited the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag led by Vice Chair Girtman.
I1. Roll Call - Regular Members and Alternates
The Recording Secretary called the roll and declared a quorum was present.
III. Recognition of Visitors
Chairman Miller recognized Ms. Diane Pacheco who has re-applied for appointment to
the Board. Chairman Miller introduced Thelma Lyons, the Administrative Assistant to
the Board's Liaison, Dan DeCarlo, who could not be present tonight.
Chairman Miller distributed the Certificates of Appreciation that Board members
received at the Annual Board Dinner.
IV. March 9, 2005 Minutes Approval
Motion
Ms. Girtman moved to approve the minutes. Motion seconded by Ms. Stern and
unanimously carried.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
April 13, 2005
V. Agenda Approval
Ms. Mura requested to add under New Business, as item (a), a discussion on the
Florida Commission of Ethics fining volunteer members of government boards that fail
to file annual Financial Disclosure Forms. Ms. Mura noted that volunteer members of
local boards could be fined $1,500 if they do not file the annual Financial Disclosure
Forms, and she would like this addressed. There was a recent newspaper article
regarding the filing of the form and she would like a ruling from the City whether this
Board is subject to filing an annual Financial Disclosure Form.
Motion
Ms. Stern moved to approve the agenda, as amended. Motion seconded by Vice Chair
Girtman and unanimously carried.
VI. Correspondence and Announcements
Chairman Miller read a letter he received from Sherri Claude, Assistant to the Director
of Recreation and Parks. Ms. Claude thanked this Board on behalf of the Advisory
Board on Children and Youth for its donation to and support of the Youth Tennis
Carnival at Hunter's Run that took place on April 9th.
Chairman Miller asked Ms. Stern to give a brief summary on what took place at the
Youth Tennis Carnival. Ms. Stern reported that some people on the Board felt there was
not enough publicity about the event so that more children could have participated.
Also, they would like to have been informed on how to sign up for the event. Ms. Stern
noted that it had been advertised in the City's Funfare Magazine, as well as in the
newspapers.
Ms. Stern reported that the event was a great success, but she would like to have a
greater outreach next year so that more children could participate. She noted that 39
children participated and this Board contributed drinks. Many members from the
Advisory Board on Children and Youth were present, but no one from this Board
attended. The children that did not have tennis rackets were given free ones to keep.
Everyone had a wonderful time, but next year she would like to have more outreach to
children in other areas of the City.
Chairman Miller noted that Saturday was the Great American Clean-up Day that he,
along with several residents of his condominium complex, participated in. Chairman
Miller distributed pictures of the clean up to members. This year their clean-up efforts
were concentrated in the Rosemary Scrub area at the north end of Seacrest Boulevard.
Even though the County owns this Scrub, it is located in the City and no one is
designated to pick up the litter that accumulates along the area. There is a convenience
store in the area that generates a great deal of litter.
Ms. Stern noted there was an article in the newspaper regarding the Great American
Clean-up and there were no places listed within the City. Ms. Mura stated that there was
2
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
April 13, 2005
a poster on the bulletin board at her community that contained telephone numbers for
people who wanted to volunteer and Boynton Beach was listed on the clean up list.
Chairman Miller reported that Mr. DeCarlo sent out two announcements regarding the
clean-up and one of the announcements stated that the Community Relations Board
would be participating. Ms. Lyons confirmed that a notice was sent to all communities
within the City. Chairman Miller read a copy of the notice that Mr. DeCarlo sent out
along with a copy of the new City's Guide to Services.
Chairman Miller introduced Gregg Ornstein, the Board's new member and asked Mr.
Ornstein to tell the Board about himself. Mr. Ornstein provided the Board with a brief
background and stated he was glad that he was appointed to serve on the Board.
Members welcomed Mr. Ornstein.
VII. Old Business
(a) PATCH Update
Ms. Lyons reported that the next PATCH Board Meeting would take place on April 21,
2005 at 7:00 p.m. at the Treasure Chest. PATCH continues to work in joint partnership
with FAU. The activities for the month of April will focus on HIV and blood pressure
checks.
(b) Pride In Boynton Beach
Chairman Miller reported that no sub-committee meeting took place this past month. He
met with Doug Hutchinson, the CRA Director, last week. The CRA is interested in
participating with this Board to assist with financing, such as signs, litter receptacles,
etc. He will invite the CRA staff to attend the next sub-committee meeting. There are
grant funds available for youth programs, painting and repairing houses and this could
help the Board get into the community to reach and help people in need.
Ms. Stern reported that Keep America Beautiful has a program called Clean Community
Systems that provides litter receptacles with their logo on it.
(c) Youth Tennis Carnival
Previously addressed.
(d) Literacy Program (Read Boynton Program)
Chairman Miller announced that this program takes place on the second and fourth
Thursdays of the month in the Library Program Room from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. There
are only two more dates remaining because school would be adjourning for the
summer. This is a joint program between the High School and the Library and the
Community Relations Board has since become involved as well.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
April 13, 2005
(e) Heart of Boynton Redevelopment Program
Chairman Miller reported that the Boynton Terrace Apartments would be demolished in
the near future that will be financed through the CRA. This will be a tremendous
improvement in the community and the land could then become available for new
development. Vice Chair Girtman commended the CRA in doing a wonderful job to
relocate the residents of those apartments that were greatly damaged from the
hurricanes.
Going back to the Great American Clean-up, Chairman Miller reported that over 100
people participated from 10 different organizations and the main focus was in District 2.
In addition to the clean up at Rosemary Scrub, clean ups took place at Golfview Harbor,
Ocean Avenue and Martin Luther King Boulevard.
Vice Chair Girtman announced that the Pastor and a group of young and adult men who
are members of St. Paul's AME Church participated in the clean up along Martin Luther
King Boulevard and commended them for their participation.
Ms. Stern would like the Board to consider assisting the Advisory Board on Children and
Youth next year with their project to bring a teen center to the City similar to the one in
Delray Beach. Ms. Stern felt that the youth of the City are in great need of a facility of
this type.
Vice Chair Girtman noted the wealth of teen activities that take place at the Hester
Center and there is great involvement with the Police Department in various programs.
She did not think there was a need for another teen center in the City since the Hester
Center is available to everyone.
Vice Chair Girtman was pleased that the Old High School was being saved and
renovated and was pleased that the CRA took this project over. She felt that a
refurbished Old High School, along with the Children's Schoolhouse Museum, would
become great attractions for the City.
VIII. New Business
(a) Financial Disclosure Forms
Ms. Mura noted there was an article in The Palm Beach Post on Monday, March 21,
2004, entitled "Panel Okays Financial Report Fines." She read from the article that
stated it was common knowledge that elected officials are required to file Annual
Financial Disclosure Forms. The article then addresses volunteers that sit on boards. In
March, the Florida Commission on Ethics approved 70 fines in the amount of $1,500
against volunteers who did not file Financial Disclosure Forms they were required to file.
Under State law, people who did not file the Report by September 1st of each year are
fined $25 for each day they are late, up to a maximum fine of $1,500.
Meeting Minutes
Community Relations Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
April 13, 2005
Many people that serve on boards are not aware of this requirement. The State's Ethics
Commission is considering backing a law that would reduce the fine, but would not
eliminate it entirely. However, the article indicated that reducing the fines was unlikely to
happen.
Motion
Ms. Mura moved that this Board receive an interpretation from the City Manager's Office
or the Legal Department if members of the Community Relations Board and other City
Boards are required to file Financial Disclosure Forms with the State. Motion seconded
by Ms. Stern.
Mr. Mitchell noted when he served on the City's Civil Service Board he was fined $250
by the State because he did not file a Disclosure Form. However, someone on the
State's Ethics Commission reviewed his case and the fine was waived. He reported that
members of that Board were required to file the Form annually, but when he left that
Board to serve on the Education Advisory Board he was not required to do so.
Ms. Pacheco stated when people are appointed to a Board they receive a Guide to the
Sunshine Laws and Code of Ethics for Public Officers and Employees. In reading
through the pamphlet it mentions that appointed members of certain boards of political
subdivisions, including governing bodies, such as code enforcement, planning and
zoning and pension boards are required to file Disclosure Forms. She did not think that
this Board fell into any of those categories since it is only an advisory board.
Vote
Chairman Miller called the roll and the motion carried unanimously.
Chairman Miller requested that Mr. DeCaflo's Office prepare and send out the
necessary letter to the City Manager for a response prior to the May meeting.
Mr. Mura amended her motion to include that Mr. DeCarlo prepare a letter on behalf of
the Board to the City Manager and Ms. Stern amended her second of the motion.
IX. Adjournment
There being no further business, the meeting properly adjourned at 8:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Barbara M. Madden
Recording Secretary
(April 18, 2005)