Minutes 01-25-10
MINUTES OF THE RECREATION AND PARKS ADVISORY BOARD
MEETING HELD ON JANUARY 25, 2010, 6:30 P.M., AT THE
SENIOR CENTER CENTER, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
PRESENT:
Betty Pierce-Roe, Chair Wally Majors, Recreation and Parks Director
William Orlove, Vice Chair Jody Rivers, Parks Superintendent
Robert Lapin
Janelle Sloan
ABSENT:
Corey Cook, Alternate
Thomas Gresh, Alternate
John McVey
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Pierce-Roe called the meeting to order at 6:27 p.m.
II. ATTENDANCE
Chair Pierce-Roe called the roll.
III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM: November 23, 2009
Motion
Vice Chair Orlove moved to approve the minutes. Mr. Lapin seconded the motion that
passed unanimously.
IV. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
None
V. NEW BUSINESS
A. Support Letter for Grant from Florida Department of Agriculture and
th
Consumer Services for Reforestation Grant for Pence Park and 4 Street
Jody Rivers, Parks Supervisor, noted the City would be applying for a grant in
th
conjunction with Public Works for Pence Park and SW 4 Street. The State grant is
1
Meeting Minutes
Recreation and Parks Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
January 25, 2010
fully funded and would require no match by the City. Board approval was required.
Motion
Vice Chair Orlove moved to approve. Mr. Lapin seconded the motion that passed
unanimously.
B. Public Feedback regarding Pence Park
Wally Majors, Recreation and Parks Director, noted that Commissioner Rodriguez had
received several telephone calls regarding the homicide that had occurred at Pence
Park, and he requested the community have an opportunity to provide feedback on the
issue.
Jose Rodriguez, Commissioner, noted he resided across from Pence Park and believed
parks should be a safe place for families to visit. After the incident, the Park was shut
down after hours as a temporary measure. He remarked on the merits of the Park and
invited comments as to the manner in which the Park should be used.
Mr. Majors explained to the attendees the Recreation and Parks Board was advisory in
nature and provided recommendations to the City Commission. The Board would be
listening to the views of the attendees at this meeting and at some point, would be
making a recommendation to the City Commission.
Commissioner Rodriguez also invited the citizens to contact him or Board members with
further comments or suggestions in order to keep the lines of communication open.
Ms. Rivers provided an overview of the City's accomplishments with respect to Pence
Park, the oldest park in the City. Improvements included replacing the playground and
park equipment, revitalizing the basketball court and converting the softball field into a
multi-purpose use. She wanted to ensure everyone in attendance was heard from and
comments were invited.
Doug Brueggermann, SE 4th Street, had utilized the Park. He observed that the
street behind the park and near the railroad tracks contributed to "elements" cruising
and parking. He suggested the road be blocked off or used for parking, and he did not
favor turning the lights off in the evenings. He suggested opportunities be available for
those people interested in playing soccer.
Lisa Adams, SE 9th St., felt recreation leagues and walking paths should be
incorporated into the Park.
2
Meeting Minutes
Recreation and Parks Board
Boynton Beach, Florida January 25, 2010
th
Candy Bruerggermann, SE 4 Street, learned of drug activity in the Park and was
advised that neighbors had seen condoms in the playground. She believed shutting
down the Park at night would help to avoid this kind of activity.
Mario Tomei suggested the Park be reconfigured, adding gates for parking and
sidewalks and paths. He suggested the use of cameras, patrolling on a regular basis
and establishing a neighborhood watch group. He requested areas be added for
hopscotch, volleyball, picnic tables, bocce ball, shuffleboard, tennis and possibly a
community pool.
th
Kristin Hardy, SE 9 St., suggested, in addition to all of the comments made, renting
the field on a Saturday in order to generate revenue.
Rick Katz felt there was a drawback to late-night basketball. If the basketball court
remained open until 10:00 p.m., people would be encouraged to "hang out" in the Park.
He suggested the hours be limited, and the lights left on. He felt the response time by
police officers should be quicker. He had no objection to the soccer activities or to the
multi-uses of the Park.
Mark Daly agreed with Mr. Katz's comments regarding late-night basketball. He also
rd
remarked about the speeding on SE 3 Street and suggested speed bumps be installed.
rd
Warner Rother, SE 3 St., agreed with most of the comments offered and would
favor the installation of speed bumps, especially since a large number of children
resided in the area.
st
JW Rowland, 1 St., noted he had to travel to Delray Beach to find a dog park. He
suggested something be done for people who walked their dogs.
rd
Mark Haskell, SE 3 St., had observed "No Dogs Allowed" signs in Pence Park.
However, the City had previously held an event which allowed dogs in the Park.
Perhaps dogs should be allowed in the Park or provisions should be made for people to
walk their dogs. He felt 9:00 p.m. would be a good time to shut the lights off at the
basketball court.
th
Allan Hendricks, SE 4 Ave., did not use the Park but rode his bicycle around the
Park. He had no objection to the basketball activities. He commended the Recreation
and Parks Department. He agreed with many of the comments made to keep crime at
bay, including lighting, programming, neighborhood watch groups, closing off streets
putting in parking areas, installing speed bumps and reconfiguring the Park. As
neighbors on the other side of Seacrest had organized, he proposed that neighbors on
this side of Seacrest do the same.
3
Meeting Minutes
Recreation and Parks Board
Boynton Beach, Florida January 25, 2010
rd
Shari Tellman, SE 3 St., suggested speed bumps be installed to prevent speeding
before another tragedy occurred.
Commissioner Rodriguez pointed out a fatal traffic accident had occurred on the
other side of Seacrest. The residents had organized a homeowner's group that met
th
regularly at the church on 6. Jeff Livergood, Public Works Director, had evaluated the
roads and discussed at a meeting the installation of speed bumps and closing of roads.
Mr. Livergood would be conducting an analysis and would report his recommendations
to the homeowner's group. A separate session could be held with regard to comments
made at this meeting.
Frank Call, noted he owned a house and apartment buildings in the area. He advised
the noise level had dropped tremendously since the lights had been shut off at Pence
Park. The youngsters playing basketball on the court were not the cause of the
problems, but rather the individuals in cars drinking and smoking "dope." The recent
incident was the second murder to have occurred in the Park. Gunshots could be heard
on numerous occasions at the Park. He disagreed with closing the road but favored
designated parking in the area. He suggested the neighborhood be patrolled more
often and felt speed bumps would help.
rd
Brenda Haskell, 3 Street, agreed with many of the comments made, including the
use of lights and speed bumps. She inquired whether anyone knew if the occupants of
the new condominiums and apartment buildings on Woolbright would be bringing their
children to the Park. Ms. Rivers responded it was possible as the City attempted to
provide neighborhood parks within a half-mile walking distance, and the new structures
rd
would fall into that radius. She inquired whether there were any plans to beautify 3
Street from Las Ventanas to the Park to make it more inviting and family friendly. She
suggested sidewalks and post lights be installed and parking be added. She had no
objection to closing the road.
Mr. Katz commented that his wife worked at the Library and on nights and afternoons
when there was a good deal of activity occurring at the basketball court, she opted to
take the longer route to get home rather than drive by Pence Park.
It was questioned whether the bathrooms remained open all night at the Park. Ms.
Rivers responded the bathrooms were locked after the arrival of the custodians
(between 7:00 p.m. and 10:00 p.m.). She also noted the doors to the bathrooms faced
the street.
th
Gerald, a resident for 58 years, remarked that SE 7 Street used to be very safe but
th
was now dangerous. People would cut through SE 7 Avenue and drink and use drugs
4
Meeting Minutes
Recreation and Parks Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
January 25, 2010
in their cars as well as in the Park. A fence should be installed at the railroad tracks
and a parking area should be created. Dogs should be kept on leashes. Sidewalks
should be installed on 5th and a green market or yard sale should be held regularly at
the Park. He questioned the merits of a neighborhood crime watch as many of the
homes on his block had been burglarized. Additionally, crime watch could result in
retaliation. The lights should be switched off when the Park was not in use. He did not
believe the police should relocate to the west side of the City and felt Dispatch asked
too many questions.
Mr. Katz felt the neighborhood was a "gem," as it was close to the beach, shopping,
restaurants and downtown. At the time he purchased his home, there was no grass at
all. Now, everything from Macadamia to Tapioca was growing. He would not wish to
live anywhere else.
It was suggested security lights be installed in the Park when the lights were off. The
lights should be kept on while the "good kids" played on the courts. It was remarked
that since the shooting, the individuals at the basketball court who had caused most of
the problems had not returned after the lights had been turned off.
It was suggested a water fountain be considered as an additional element and that
more money be put into the Park. It was also suggested recreation leagues and sports
activities be promoted.
One of the attendees heard gunshots on the night of the incident and called 911. He
was asked approximately 30 questions by Dispatch. Rather than having so many
questions asked, he felt an officer should have been deployed to the scene. Ms. Rivers
ensured this information would be passed on to the Police Chief.
Lt. Paul Deale, Boynton Beach Police Department, nightshift officer, explained
Dispatch was a function of the Police Department and in defense of Dispatch, Boynton's
response time on average was less than three minutes for a typical call. Any calls
receiving a response time of 40 minutes would be an anomaly, with the exception of
delayed calls. In the case of a home robbery which occurred while no one was at home
and where the perpetrator was no longer in the home, response time could be 20 or 30
minutes, and a report would be made and evidence collected. If an assault were taking
place, the police would respond immediately. When the shots were fired in October,
the pOlice responded in less than 30 seconds.
Lori LaVerriere, Assistant City Manager, noted the protocol for a 911 call involved
questions asked by the dispatcher to collect information to protect the publiC as well as
the responding police officers. Lt. Deale advised that in addition to the 911 emergency
calls, there were 911 calls received of a non-emergency nature, and it was the
5
Meeting Minutes
Recreation and Parks Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
January 25, 2010
dispatcher's job to elicit the nature of the call. Dispatch was "on the public's side" and
while it might seem as though intrusive questions were asked, the dispatchers were
attempting to assist the police officers.
In response to comments made regarding the Police Department's relocation to the
west side, Lt. Deale pointed out that regardless of the location of the police station, the
officers would still be out patrolling the City.
Commissioner Rodriguez noted he was the only Commissioner voting to retain the
Police Department on the east side. While police officers were on the road patrolling,
there was still traffic to and from the police station on a regular basis. If the police
station were to be relocated, this activity would be eliminated. He did feel the pOlice
officers should be provided with new quarters on the east side rather than the third
floor of a retail building across town.
Vice Chair Orlove inquired whether police activity in Pence Park was any more or less
than in other parks within the Boynton system. Lt. Deale responded more calls had
been received for the Ezell Hester Community Center in terms of calls for services.
Fewer calls had been received for Pence Park. In fact fewer calls had been received
regarding Pence Park than for Jaycee Park until the gates had been installed at Jaycee
Park. Calls received, other than the October homicide, included animal complaints,
open container arrests, auto vandalism and a domestic dispute in the Park. Sgt.
DeGiuilio was a member of the CRA Police and a number of sting operations had been
successful over the past year in ridding the area of those involved in illegal activities.
Chair Pierce-Roe noted she resided next to Boat Club Park. She remarked that the area
on Federal Highway just between Boat Club and Intracoastal Parks and the Parks
themselves had become very safe over the last 13 years as a result of police patrolling.
She expressed gratitude to the Police Department.
Lt. Deale appreciated feedback from the public and he would pass on suggestions to
the Department. Enforcement tools, such as requiring the lights to be shut off at a
certain time, were helpful.
Mr. Hendricks believed the Park was not necessarily the problem. Safety could be built
into a community by its citizens becoming active and communicating with each other.
Commissioner Rodriguez invited anyone interested in becoming involved in a crime
watch program to contact him. A meeting could be organized, and officers specializing
in crime watch would be invited.
6
Meeting Minutes
Recreation and Parks Board
Boynton Beach, Florida
January 25, 2010
C. Items for the City Manager's Attention
None
VI. NEXT MEETING: February 22, 2010
It was agreed the meeting would be held at the Intracoastal Clubhouse unless the
facility was unavailable.
VII. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to discuss, the meeting properly adjourned at 7:28
p.m.
r
(. {)
.,
,-k?;j7~~" . L,..__
Stephanie D. Kahn
Recording Secretary
100216
7