Walmart at Gulfstream ZNCV 10-002
DEVELOPMENT ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
APPLICANT'S AGENT:
Lucas Anthony- Kimley Horn & Associates, Inc.
li)';veloplft8l\t
paz
Building
Engineering
Oct. L\c....C\tfk
Oeputy Cl"
1--
PROJECT NAME:
Walmart at Gulfstream
APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 601 2151 Street, Suite 300, Vero Beach, FL 32960
DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: February 16, 2010
TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Request for relief from the City of Boynton Beach Land Development
Regulations, Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 8.5 B. 4. a., Urban Commercial
District Overlay Zone for front and side property build-to lines, on a 9.36
acre parcel located at the northwest corner of South Federal Highway
and Gulfstream Boulevard.
LOCATION OF PROPERTY: 3629 and 3675 South Federal Highway
DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO.
X THIS MATTER came before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida
appearing on the Consent Agenda on the date above. The City Commission hereby adopts the
findings and recommendation of the Planning and Development Board, which Board found as follows:
OR
THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton
Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the
relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative
staff and the public finds as follows:
1. Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with
the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations.
2. The Applic;ant
X HAS
HAS NOT
established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested.
3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or
suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set
forth on Exhibit "C" with notation "Included".
4. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby
1 GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof.
DENIED
5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk.
6. All further development on the property shall be made in accord
and conditions of this order.
7 . Other
DATED: :f-,1/1-~ .1 Il) ;k:/ {;
S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJEC rS\WaIMart\Walmart @ Gulfstream\ZNCV 10-001, 10-002 & 10-
003\DO New 11-09.ooc
EXHIBIT "D"
Conditions of Approval
Project name: Wal-Mart @ Gulfstream
File number: ZNCV 10-001, ZNCV 10-002, ZNCV 10-003
Reference:
DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS- Forestry
Comments: None X
FIRE
Comments: None X
POLICE
Comments: None X
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: None X
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments: None X
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: None X
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST
Comments: None X
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments:
1. Staff recommends certain architectural enhancements (as detailed in the
COA's for the concurrent NWSP staff report) in exchange for the greater X
setbacks, so as to contribute to the implementation of the redevelopment
plan designs for Federal Highway.
ADDITIONAL PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS
Comments:
Conditions of Approval
2
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE ~I-' 11-<1 I
2. Provide a continuous trellis (pergola) and plantings along the front of the
property extending east from the south driveway to the south side of the X
central driveway on the east side.
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS
Comments:
3. Revise # 2 to provide a continuous trellis (pergola) and plantings along the X
southeast corner of the site in conjunction with the art feature and welcome
sign, as depicted on the renderings presented at the hearing on 2-16-10.
S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Wal Mart\Walmart@ Gulfstream\ZNCV COA's (l,2,3).doc
. EXHIBIT "A.. - SITE LOCATION MAP
WALMART AT GULFSTREAM BLVD
,,' , ;,.
, " ,,;-
REC
, " I
....
t)
o
Z
N
w
R-1A II)
PUD
..-. .-..-..-..- ..-..-..-..- ..-..
CITY LIMITS
:; ,
~
J:
w
S(
is
o
-J
o
>
~
-J
~
t)
tt!
';"".."i ,~..."~: ;' ,~ll~'.,ll:":~.,i;.l,";~
ti"",,,~, ';c"":; :'{,'....~ "C",'.::~t.'r.l u:,,,,~~s\~()~r' r.J',. P'''''''~'J i.-:\"~:' i.I' :"l"." :;,(" :l.'~'" .' "'I"~ ~< ""..",.nll'.~.U~~
EXHIBIT HBH
. ... .... i;'~- ~ "'1
I,;.... -~"'. I
I "
'.
~ :.~ i
.., .'''''''> ...'. ,.."..~ ..........., ...~, ~'.' .,,,...,,, .' ......" .. ,"..~..... ,"" ,... '~"'"'; ,...... .., ..~..~, ...".. ~.. .,,..,,.., .,~..-.~ '.'" ".I"'<'~ ."",.",~ ,,'.. .~"..,,,, .~".". ~""" _"".,,,,..' ..._ ,~",,,,,,,,.... '....".,....,,- ,., .....'....
1--.
OmiJDDOD l~
iililfll;
! ' 1 I ' . j Z
I f, i ! ! ! \ 10
d ' ~ j \ \
I I ! · ' J !
, ~ .
~
.! ~ I~
" · \ . ; I~
I "
Hql~.ll~
P ! L \! ,0
. ! \ [ I ~~
Ii Hl
'c
.
F
i
,
,..,~..~ '."'1"
~t~~:: ~~1'~
,~ I,' !~~
h ~ if-
~; i!' EU,
~.~ ~~
I .1
~ n
r,;..
F
~.l
H
F
~'J~
H
H
.oF
; ~
#~.
~_ L-:-~
~~~
\;1(..
I .\/ i
I '\'
, Ii: '\
'Iii:'. I
Mf;"~\
: ~. \
, I
'IIi \ . ..~
gJ
,1-
I,
1 ~..,
, , -:, - , --:: ~ Jr: 31 ![ ::1
,.,,'.'.....r,~1\. I, ,.s._ ",..
, -.. \ ".J.." ./~. ~i ~ ~~~:,
'. f:,~~" ?~..
~': (.
..~; ~.,~~,..'.t:.:....;.
(. '. ~,:; ~'i..
~i
"
il
!~
i"
r!~: r':
1:7
'"
c
\;
;;:
G1"'~
g~ ~
""~;:; -
?~m~ 3
;~8~ ~
<'l~~ "'
fL"
B~ i\-
.~
'"
."
"
I
/,~ '....; /
Wl~
,i-,f-!I
~~~ii.-'
.!~
p~
.li\;
I~
I
I
~ "i '''r;]l -,,,. j' . , " '" 'I
"" ,;,. 'e' " "',' . '.'"
'" ";;' 1s.:1i r.' ~"'~_ 1 a ~.? "
'. . ,. ~,'..' ij.' · , if .
~:;;: ~~e~' ~.. ~.. i" 2
u; ,,~... t. IE ~ ,.~ l
.""g I't, ~i~ . . ,., Ii
~~~~ F~I t" ~:::h ~ ~ ~I
mr H f! ~ ::~: ~ n
~; e i ;~," t; ~" I
,1':;;~, ~ ~ :
I. I
i
r. .;, 'H~ ~t : ~i:.li' '.1 ".,;. 'j.'."; ..; '.i ~."1:: ~ ....!..'f . ,. I"_i ..: ..;. :- .:: ". 1\",.
f F till ~~ i;i . l~ !lld;H Ii !;'~m,i!itij~ ~~ lK, II !i.1 ~ll ~
i ui ;:!F,' ~r !:~ <* II ~~!h ii h ;'il, j :~h;l!' ~,!, If l " , ~
, ;~ "l' :;, I: ! \'i~! m~' ., !1 "!:~!' t !i'-'~i '1. f~ I. , ',I ' ~.
!. ;::~ 1~~.I.r.:, ::: g ::. J. ~~ ~~ ,'-i;.' ~tl. ;-J' '~.~fl~ F ;l:.~~t,. i..; ~.~ ~~ ~..~. '.;: I' I~
" ...,! ... .!.,., ." ~ ,! .g ""~k.. "I'd;:.! "" r" ,., . -<
, /~ "". ". "iI Fi" "'I, ~f Ie 'Ii!.!. 'IP" ~.~ I~ '.' . ~ -j'; j "'
,.~... 2' I"~"P .,!.' ....,...,.. ,'....,. '." ,.. ,.'"
" '{ ij'iP : i ~ r'l"'! 'folt~~ :f. .'. t.~r='i i ~.'...'I.~A:;! ~~ ~l !.l i. .! l
z ~t =:~~'ol ~. ~ ~ l ;i: ~:S~H~ ~:. f.~ i~t/~r.', ~r'.!~..x ~~ r.:i,;~ ~ f '., .
i ,iii~ I i I U ..:; ,'II' E!. ~r i~'ij r ,~,r;";i ~" tEi: ., g
, ! 'io> ,., ! i 1" .lm;, I; I!f!,! s:e'!: k II',. i "
~ ,;; x~~~ t ~ ; i ~ ~~' ~r~9i:'t :'i "~..!~i 'I l';~'~~r;: j !;'t ; f ~ f. t
~ ~ ~F i ~';;; ~ ilK&.lii ~r. ~'~ ~~:Jp~'~' ~f~:~J;~ ~ ~f [ ! if ~ r.
~ 7 ..ti-~ ,. ~;I I r. rh,;ll. "'I ..r ~!~"l!!. t1r.~<'~l ., ii :r r" /l'
r .: i'1)'\1: ~ ~ '" " l:; ~1~,"" I r.~ ... ~l);:! ;:::'1;:;1; (: t,\.- ~ :: r ~ ~
, ! II!! !l i I IIIII 'PI illl! !llllllll ; I! II
!!!~; 1$1.'....
i:i!l: ' V,
<~ Po ~~.
.. ~ ,l
: ~ !! i
't j p
e ,.Ii
I..".~
k II
i
O~880~~e00ooro80000088000000000080000008~
l;"'" t: ~ " ,. ': 'l ~ t r. ~ r' 1-'"
,- \ 1 ii, I !f f l q n j ~; I., ~.' !;!:~
~...'; I~.'.': " " ~ . :,- ..... ~ ~ {l i ::;; I"
, "r.~i ~!:>;:.~m
II: ~ - ~ '. ~ p" l_, f ~~! Irs
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~f,
~ ~ ~ ;' .. ; i~
Imart~:~,BOYNTON BEACH
STORE #5911-00
GULF STREAM MAll
"'~.lV. (:[:,1:.., ,~\)l.1'J" I'L:-Jl\ll_','
SITE PLAN
;~~':;;',: ;~!:~~~~'~~~~;:" 5l~~~~~~~,c'
d~.
"
~f
,
!
I :r
] :'
I:!
· i,l i~
J! ~"
~~
"
\i
jl
"
H@ ~'.... I
,,~ii,.' <, ~ -, ;r:
"""'~I~!
.....-,.,~::;~'~H.;. '1
II
IH
,<
f 1 r
i
....._~.
..~.:.;;.....~....~:\M:,::\=";::....-.!-..." ,.....,..u _.-_
I
1~,
~)>
tN
t,
g;1II
<Ii
......
g~
~
EXHIBIT "B"
'HiHH nn
l,," ." f ~ ~~, " . !<',l, q",!
,: 11; , : ,II ~ ~ 'h~ ~,! .
': ,I, i A ~I ' ,. i l~;; ~f ;
'. 't! " ! "\ 'i l, I · i<
it ~ .' ,'.. ~! ~,
;;;!r q !~~ i ~
h r1~., f ~;:t(: ~
; ~ ~ ~ f,'
S~ii~ii;;i;
~ H H ~ ~~l ~ ;~ ~ ~i i~ ~ ~
! ~I ~g k j:"" ',' · h !II ~
~ I II! <: ~ !~ ;"~ ! ; i:\
1 . l~! S ~ . ~ i I: ' ! g
I i ~ A! ! i ~; I h: i\1
; I i f P ~~ r '"
~~_ t ~ t~J~
, "
HI HB HHHn
5 ~: ~ 4: ~ ~i ip f: l~ ~ ; : ~ ~.
I. ; $, r,! ~\,' II"! I
, ~: .. '. ~'. . I I, I !
" n'", I I...." I i:i
i 1 f~ p ,l,' \ I ; t h ~
, " !.,' ,. ,\ ~, , 0
. \ !;I q '- ~ I ;;f
'i [; '! III
:~~8;~ ~~~~@ ~~UU
l! H P P p ~ ~ lUiH iri
. I , . ,~ 1 t , t! l6 ,1 ,'I, '1
~ 1 g - . ~ ~- t. f ~ ~ t~ 1. a ;;
~ 1 ~ , .. . , , , 'I ~ 1,1 : ','; \
, < l . , . 1 ! 1> e ,.. .1 .
. · , , i , ti 'ii,: it I;! I
ll!l ,J b
~ ~ '"
~.....r.. <:oUt?
W\!IlUII u IIlUl \l. t?oO::l
BOYNTON BEACH. 1'1.
SlcRt NO. 7\l1 J9
EXHIBIT "e"
EXlliBIT A
to
City of Boynton Beach Planning & Zoning Division's Code Variance Application
Statement of Special Conditions, Hardships or Reasons Justifying: the Requested Variance:
A. That special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure
or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands. structures or buildings in the
same zoning district.
Response:
We have attempted to accommodate to the extent possible the design requirements of the
Urban Commercial District Overlay Zone to have buildings as close as possible to Federal
Highway. The shape oftrus parcel of land, however, does not allow for an efficient commercial
building because to keep the building along the street would require the building to have angled
walls, This configuration would cause the interior layout of the store and operation of the store
to become unacceptable. for efficient operation.
It is our understanding that this design preference was intended for a mixed use
development, including residential, on an individual site. This particular parcel will have an
exclusive commercial use. Placing the building closer to Federal Highway creates a problem for
access to the truck dock which is an integral part of the successful operation of a retail store.
Trucks entering the site at the northern entrance would not have enough space to maneuver and
to use the truck dock efficiently. Putting the building on or near the Federal Highway property
line would mean that the truck dock, the compactor, and the recycling storage areas would be in
close proximity to customer parking which could create an unsafe condition for customers as
well as truck deliveries. The reason for this is that if the store were placed closer to Federal
Highway, a larger amount of the customer parking would have to be in the rear and side of the
store.
Another reason is that on the Federal Highway side of the parcel, existing water and
sewer mains run the entire length of the parcel. To accorrunodate the overlay design, these water
and sewer mains would have to be relocated or removed. This would vastly increase the cost for
off-site improvements and would cause substantial disruption of service to other areas of the City
because the water and sewer lines serve other areas.
B. That the special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the
Applicant.
Response: The special conditions and circumstances are not the result of actions by WaImart.
The shape of the parcel and the conditions and circumstances set forth in response to Subsection
A. are not the result of actions by Waimart.
RM:7107800:1
C. That granting the variance requested will not confer on the apo!icant any special
lJrivilege that is denied bv this Ordinance to other lands. buildings or structures in the same
zoninJ! district:
Response: The granting of this variance request will not confer on Walmart any special
pnvllege. It 1S the result of the special conditions and circumstances set forth to the responses
above.
D. That literal interoretation of the provisions of this Chapter would deorive the alJlJlicant of
ri'lhts commonlv en;oved by other lJroperties in the same zoning district under the terms of the
Ordinance and would work unnecessarily an undue hardship on the Aoplicant:
Response: The enforcement of the overlay design requirements to place the proposed
Walmart store closer to Federal Highway will result in the inability of Walmart to construct a
commercial building on the property. This building will serve the community as well as any new
residential development in the area. In other areas with the same zoning commercial zoning, a
property owner may place a building anywhere on the site so long as the site plan meets the
setback and open space requirements of the City Code.
E. 'That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the
reasonable use of the land. building or structures:
Response: In recognition of the overlay design requirements, the store has been located as
close to Federal Highway as is possible recognizing the unique shape of the parcel and the
proposed ultimate commercial use of the building.
F. That the grantinf! of the variance will be in harmonv with the general intent and puroose
of this Chapter and that such variance will not be iniurious to the area involved or otherwise
detrimental to the lJublic welfare.
Response: This variance request is not a request for a use variance. The proposed use is
consistent with the property's commercial land use designation and commercial zoning. The
granting of this variance will actually benefit the area involved and the public welfare by
bringing new commercial development to the eRA district and the City.
G. Variances to minimum lot area or lot frontage requirements, that property is not
available from adiacent properties in order to meet these requirements or that the acquisition of
such property would cause the ad;acent orooerty or structures to become non-conformin~.
Applicant shall orovide an affidavit with the application for variance statinR that the above-
mentioned conditions exist with respect to the acquisition of additional oroperty.
Response:
This provision is not applicable to this variance request.
In conclusion, we respectfully request the granting of this variance because it will permit the
construction of a new full service grocery and general merchandise Walmart store for the
RM:7107800:1
2
Boy.nton Beach community. This should provide synergy for additional eRA District
development. We respectfully request that due to all of the reasons stated above, particularly
recognizing the limitations of the configuration of the parcel and other issues such as the existing
water and sewer mains, the City grant this variance request.
RM:7J{)7800:1
3