Loading...
Minutes 01-19-82MINUTES OF ~HE REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL HELD AT CITY HALL, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, TUESDAY, JANUARY 19, 1982 PRES ENT Edward F. Harmening, Mayor Walter "Marry" Trauger, Vice Mayor Joe deLong, Councilman Patricia Woolley, Councilmember Samuel Lamar Wright, Councilman Peter L. Cheney, City Manager Tereesa Padgett, City Clerk James Vance, City Attorney Mayor Harmening called the meeting to order at 7:30 P. M. He said the invocation would be given by-Rev, Barney Kitzmiller, Pastor, Crossroad Baptist Church, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag, to be led by Councilman Joe deLong. AGENDA APPROVAL City Manager Cheney asked to delete under "II. MINUTES" the Special City Council Meeting Minutes of January 18, 1982 (last night), as they were not prepared. Under "IV. BIDS", City Manager Cheney added "G. Proposal to Accept the proposal from Financial Service Agency for giving financial services on the beach bond issue. Under "X.. ADMINISTRATIVE", City Manager'Cheney added "K. Approval of Consent Agreement relative to Lawson Industrial Park and Southern Bell on the City Easement." Co~nci~nn~'~r'igh't.'.~te~'.~-hat. . a~:~st was . ..~knze Human. ., Resources to consider research and development priorities they are aspiring to receive through the State Community Service Trust Fund. In communicating with staff, Councilman Wright felt that the applica- tion was not thoroughly prepared, so at this time he did not add it to the agenda. Councilman Wright said that in the future, perhaps they could submit a better application that the City could probably consider. Councilman deLong moved, seconded by Councilmember Woolley, to adopt the Agenda with corrections. Motion carried 5-0. ANNOUNCEMENTS Mayor Harmening announced that there would be an auction of City trucks, cars, tractors, sold on an "as is" basis at the Public Works Department, 222 N. E. 9th Avenue, at 10:00 A. M. on January 23, 1982. Mayor Harmening also called attention to a parade which would be held on Black Awareness Day, which will be on February 6, 1982, mainly at the Civi~ Center. MINUTES Regular City Council Meeting Minutes of January 5, 1982 MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Councilman deLong moved, seconded by Vice Mayor Trauger, to accept the minutes as submitted. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. PUBLIC AUDIENCE Mayor Harmening announced that if anyone in the audience would like to address the Council on any item not on the Agenda, they may do so at this time. He added that if anyone would like to speak on any item on the Agenda, they will be called upon when that item becomes the regular order of business. BIDS One (1) Emergency Rescue Vehicle - Fire Department City-~aqer~2~heney~saidi~evehicle is sometimes referred to as the "paramedic" vehicle. City Manager Cheney called attention to an error in the bid sheet. It should have been $28,386.00 instead of $28,585.00. CoUncilman deLong moved to accePt the recommendation of the Tabulation Committee and award the bid to E.V.F., Inc., Riviera Beach, FlOrida, in the amount of $28,386.00. The motion was seconded by .Councilmember Woolley and carried 5-0. Toro Sprinkler Units and Controller Units or Equal - Recreation & Parks Councilman deLong moved to accept the recommendation of the Tabulation .Committee and award the bid to Boynton Pump & Supply, Inc,, Boynton Beach, in ~he amount of $4,806.10. Councilmember Woolley Seconded the motion, and the motion carried 5-0. One (1) Excell Hustler 261 Tractor or Equal and One (1) Fayette - Haulette 15055 Trailer or Equal - Recreation & Parks ~CoUneilma~.i'~TeLo~ng.~OV~tO~cep ~.th~re~~tfor~-~ of the Tabulation Committee and award the bid to DeBra Turf & Equipment' Co., Holly- wood, Florida, in the amount of $9,790.00. Councilmember Woolley seconded the motion, and the motion carried 5-0. Utility Lines Serving Santaluces High School City Manager Cheney explained that this was the only time that the City provided utility services outside of the utility service area. It is being done at the request of the Palm Beach County School Board because after two years of negotia~Cns, they found it impossible to get utility services from the utility company in that particular servmce area. City Manager Cheney informed the Council that it was just outside of the City's area. The City's area goes ~to Hypoluxo and this is just north of Hypoluxo. City Manager Cheney recommended that the bid be awarded to Woodruff & Sons, Inc., Bradenton, Florida, in the amount of $679,856.00. City Manager Cheney further advised that the City had arranged with Woodruff, although their original bid was for - 2 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19~, 1982 150 days, for them to reduce it to 120 days at the same price. This would mean that the utillity system for the school would be in-by the end of May, within one month earlier than originally agreed upon when the City first met with the School Board last June. At least, the City has done all they could to prevent any delay in opening the high school. Councilman deLong moved to accept the recommendation of the TabUla- tion Committee and include the remar, ks of City Manager Cheney, and award the bid to~oodruff & Sons, Inc., Bradenton, Florida, in the amount of $679,856.00, with completion within 120 days, in accordance with the recommendation of Russell & Axon; Perry Cessna, City Utility Director; and City Manager Cheney. Councilmember Woolley seconded the motion. City Manager Cheney added that the cost of the utility line would be paid for proportionately by the School Board and by ~he other developers and land owners on Lawrence Road that would benefit from the line. It would not be a capital cost attributed to the City's Utility Fund. Motion carried 5-0. 4000 Series Cleaning Systems - Fire Department City Manager Cheney informed the Council that the City took bids and then discovered that they had a spare of cleaning equipment that could be used. Therefore, it was recommended that the bid be rejected. Vice Mayor Trauger moved that the bid be rejected, seconded by Councilman deLong~ Motion carried 5-0. Preliminary Recommendation - Twenty-seven (27) Hole Golf .Course City Manager Cheney passed out documents that summarized bids received last week for the golf course. Once the golf course was designed, it was agreed that the City would go out 'to bid and get a relatively firm bid price so the City would know what the cost of the golf course would be. The City would then proceed to the next action, one of which would be to attempt to sell the bond issue; City Manager Cheney informed the Council. City Manager Chene~ told the Council that bids were received last week on the construction of the course, mostly pertaining to the buildings, such as the maintenance building, the three shelters, the club- house and the storage building, plus the parking lot. City Manager Cheney noted that all of those itemswere indicated on the page by an asterisk. Some contingencies and estimates on some other items, which the City does not have bids on yet, are also included, and Mr. Cheney said they were confident the prices fall within the prices referred to. A year or so ago, it was estimated that the construction cost of the golf course would be about Three Million Dollars. It is now estimated that the course will be approximately $80,000.00 less than originally bid, City Manager Cheney advised. City Manager - 3 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JkNUARY 19, 1982 Cheney said final approval of the contracts was being suggested tonight. There would have to be more discussions with the architects and the individual bidding firms, but City Manager Cheney wanted the Council to know where the City stood on total costs. City Manager Cheney said the base course contractor is Myer Construction. They are the contractors who are just finishing the Boca Raton Club, Mr. Cheney informed the Council, and there have'been some very positive recommendations concerning the work Myer Construction has done there. The building contract was bid by a local Boynton Beach contractor, and the parking lot was bid by Hardrives, and most of the subcontractors are on electrical and plumbing in the various buildings of the local bidder. The car storage and the maintenance building are both metal type buildings, and were bid by a local bidder, City Manager Cheney continued. City Manager Cheney .further said that the plan is to continue to work with the contractors and be prepared to make a final award two weeks from tonight (February 2, 1982). Mr. Cheney told the Council that they had talked with all of the contractors to make sure they understood everything about the bid specifications, which were quite complicated. City Manager Cheney advised the Council that they had received in their material a letter from~George T, Bland, Senior Vice President, Florida Municipal Securities, Inc. One of the things they recommended in connection with the sale of the bond issue was that the~City operate an independent feasibility study, Mr. Cheney further advised, and read from the letter as follows: "Independent Feasibility 'S~/dy Since this project is to be secured by revenues frc~ the operations of the Golf Course, such revenue projections must be impartially determined and unassailable. To a large extent, the credibility of the proposed project will depend on the information presented and the professional reputation and ability of the firm making the independent feasibility study, AttaChed is the last letter pro- posal that we received from Economics Research Associates regard- ing the cost of updating their previous study. I suggest that the City consider giving ERA the signal to go on this. If the revenue projections as attested by ERA hold up and .the local golfers, banks, etc. are Willing to invest in the Series 'B' Bonds, we will be in a position to make offerings to others on the 'AT Bonds." City Manager Cheney asked the Council to consider the above recommendation with the proposal. City Manager Cheney informed the Council that the City began sell- ing annual permits for the golf course yesterday (January 18). Forty permits were sold in two days. As the City did not want to be swamped the first day and wanted time to get uSed to the permits, there was not a lot of publicity. Also, Mr. Cheney continued, there ~was no rush as the sale would continue through February and March. There will be a drawing on the lottery system the 1st day of April; forty have been sold, with $50.00 d~O~its - 4 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 on each one. City Manager Chene.y asked the Council to approve the independent feasibility study. He hoped to have the final figures at the next meeting (February 2, 1982). Councilman deLong Moved to approve the preliminary recommendation for the 27 hole golf course, as submitted by City Manager Cheney in his memorandum of January 19, 1982; and that the memorandum of City Manager Cheney and the letter from George T. Bland, Senior Vice President, Florida Municipal Securities, Inc., of December 9, 1981, be made a part of the record; and also to authorize the updated feasibility study. Councilmember Woolley seconded the motion. Councilman Wright asked if the Golf Course Advisory Committee had been able to take a look at the proposal and what their recommendation was. City Manager Cheney answered that a meeting would be set up with them on the bids that have been received. Now that the City has talked to the contractors, the City will have something to talk to the Committee about. Mr. Cheney did not want to hold up the Economics Research Associates. Mr. Cheney said if ERA needed to update the figures by an independent source, he would prefer not to wait two more weeks. City Manager Cheney was confident the Golf Course Advisory Committee would support that. A vote was taken on Councilman deLong~s motion, and the motion carried 5-0. Proposal to Enter Into Agreement With Florida MuniciPal Securities, Inc. - Provide Financial Services For the Proposed $.1,750,000 Beach Bond Issue City Manager explained that t'his was a case where, if the bond is not approved by the City or the C~ty does not sell the bond, the City has no obligation. If the City does successfully sell the bond issue, the obligation of the City (.as indicated in the report') for all costs would be $23,000.00~ which is slightly over 1% of the amount of the bond issue. Arrangements for rating services from New York to visit Boynton Beach and review the condition the City is in is also. included, and City Manager Cheney felt thils wa's the appropriate time to do it because of this bond issue and also probably the utility bond issue and the golf bond issue. Mr. Cheney thought it was important t~ get the rating service here in Boynton Beach so they could see what is happening to the community an~ review the bond issues. Mr. qheney pointed out that the rating the City has on its bond issues would ha~e a lot tO d° with the interest rates the City pays. He reiterated that a part of this cost would include that special added service. MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Councilman deLong moved to accept City Manager Cheney's recommenda- tion and approve the agreement with Florida Municipal Securities, Inc. Vice Mayor Trauger seconded the motion, and the motion carried 5-0. PUBLIC AUDIENCE Mayor Harmening announced that during the Public Audience portion of the meeting, he did not see a woman who wished to speak and, therefore, apparently ignored her. He asked her to come forward at this time if she still wished to speak. Mrs. Ralph C. Collins, 757 First Street West, Riviera Beach, asked for the City's help, as she is undertaking a major job in the City. Mrs. Collins said she was trying to turn a negative neighborhood into a positive neighborhood by purchasing a piece of property on the corner of Tenth Avenue and Seacrest Boulevard. At first, Mrs. Collins thought the building was not fit for animals, but BOynton Beach is rated very high. Mrs. Collins said she has been in Palm Beach County for 54 years and watched Boynton Beach grow and progress, and felt Boynton Beach was one of the most progressive communities along the East coast. Mrs. Collins announced that she w~ll become a permanent part of the community, as she is in the process of totally renovating the entire complex at the corner of Tenth Avenue and Seacrest Boule- vard. In one of the business fronts, Mrs. Collins informed the audience, there will be a family restaurant. She said she had not-seen a family restaurant in Boynton Beach. Mrs. Collins stated her company is known as "Mag's Enterprises" and is composed of Mrs. Collins, as President, four daughters, four sons, and her husband. They feel they will be able to give employment to fifteen or twenty individual's within the community. Mrs. Collins further informed everyone that their second business would be an upholstery and drapery shop. She felt there-was a need for that trade. Mrs. Collins advised she will not only ~serve the community, she will train .individuals who are desirous in going into any of these trades. Mrs. Collins said the ~hird business will be a women's boutique, catering to the full figure. The fourth will be a complete unisex beauty shop, with some of the finest recently graduated cosmetologists, who will develop the whole person. Mrs. Collins advised that someone will be on the premises all day, every day, and hopefully, the first phase will be opened by February 15, 1982, Mrs. Collins stated that she had been in Riviera Beach for 32 years and in West Palm Beach for 22 years. - 6 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Councilman Wright commented that Mrs. Collins was investing her money at N. E. 10th Avenue, right off of Seacrest,%hich.has been clubs and bars for a long time. Councilman Wright noted Mrs. Collins was requesting the City's support in terms of supporting what she wants to do. Councilman Wright pointed out that Mrs. Collins needs support from the Police Department and the City's administration to make sure t~he laws are being enforced so that Mrs. Collins will not be wasting her money investing it on 10th Avenue. Councilman Wright remarked that he would like to take his hat off to Mrs. Collins because it was a big job to do something like that and told her he would do what he could to give her assistance. Council- man Wright felt she could count on the other members of the Council also. PUBLIC HEARING - 8:00 P. M. Request: Land Use Amendment: Location: Proposed Use: Applicant: REZONE from R-1AA to PU From Moderate Density Residential to Public and Private Institutional, Governmental Bounded on the north by Mango Court, east by $. W. 2nd Street and south by Bethesda Memorial Hospital Provide additional parking for Bethesda Memorial Hospital Agent Southeastern Palm Beach County Hospital District d/b/a Bethesda Memorial Hospital/Robert B. Hill, Assistant Administrator, Operations Mr. Annunziato informed the Council that this was a request to amend the future land use element of the Comprehensive Plan and to rezone a parcel of land to accommodate parking, as stated by the applicant, Bethesda Memorial Hospital. Mr. Annunziato stated the property was bordered on the north by S. W. 25th Avenue,' on the east by S. W. 2nd Street, on the west by Ridgewood Estates, and on the south by Bethesda Memorial Hospital property. Mr. Annunziato said that basically, this was a single family area, but there were mitigating factors. Based on a meeting Mr. Annunziato had with the hospital officials, it was determined that the hospital will grow in a vertical manner as opposed to a horizontal manner. The concern on the part of the Planning Department was that the uses in a Public Usage zone are not just. limited to parking in support of the hospital. Their concern was whether the hospital could have plans to develop more buildings in connection with the hospital property. Based on what the hospital authorities told them, ~hich was that when the hospital grows, there would probably be 90 more beds, which would bring it to a peak of 444 beds, Mr. Annunziato said it would grow vertically at the south wing and on the north wing with all of the ancillary facilities being located below the north wing. Mr. Annunziato stated that the hospital plans indicated that there would be no more horizontal development for the hospital property. Mr. Annunziato advised that the above reflected heavily on the Planning Department's recommendation because had the potential existed for physical structures to be constructed on the property - 7 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 requested to be rezoned, the impact on single families to the west, east and north wOuld have been greater and perhaps would have resulted in a contradiction to the Comprehensive Plan Laws. The third thing concerned public costs, Mr. Annunzlato informed the Council. The application is somewhat different than a shopping~ center. It is a publiC body coming before a public body. Mr. Annunziato read the recommendation of the Planning Department as follows: "Recommendation: Considering the proposed~use for this property and the fact that applicant's long 'range plans for expansion do not include building on this property, rezoning would not significantly affect property values or the living environment in nearby residential neighbor- hoods. Thus, rezoning this property would not conflict with the Comprehensive Plan, and in this light, should be approved. However, approval of this rezoning should be based on confidence that the applicant will not eventually construct buildings on the property." ~. Annunziato said the recommendation went to the Planning and Zoning Board and, after conducting a public hearing, the Planning and Zoning Board recommended the_application"be denied, noting that a similarly sized parcel of land exists and is vacant approximately 300 feet from the hospital, and it is properly zoned. Mr. Annunziato advised that the motion to deny was made by Mr. Linkous, seconded by Mr. Wandelt, and the vote was 4-3 with Chairman Ryder, Mr. Hester, and Mr. Winter dissenting. Councilmember Woolley asked Mr. Annunziato to.point oUt the property that was available. Mr. Annunziato informed the CoUncil that the property lies between S. W. 23rd and S. W. 25th Avenue on the west side of Seacrest, separated from the hospital proper, or about 150 feet from the northern most building. Mayor Harmening-announced that he had received several letters from residents regarding'the request for rezoning. The following were in favor of granting the request: 1. Robert S. Herman, 130 N. E. 26th Avenue, Apt. 401, Boynton Beach 2. Marion Z. Peirano, 120 $. W. 8th Place, Boynton Beach 3. Mr. and Mrs. M. Tabak, 5397-C Lakefront Blvd.-, Delray Beach 33445 4. Sarah and Marie Abbondandolo, 311-D Pine Point Drive, Boynton Beach 33435 5. Mr. and Mrs. Henry Wulbers, 614 S, W. 21 Circle, Boynton Beach 33435 6. Abe and Tillie Schiff, Flanders M, 583 Kings Point, Delray Beach, 33445 7. Mildred and Abraham I. Silverglate, 2615 N. E. 3rd Court, Apt, 201, Boynton Beach 33435 8. S. Goldman, Tuscany F-329, Delray Beach 33446 9. Rose Schafer and Henry G. $chafer, 4520A Ficus Tree Rd,, Boynton Beach 33436 10. Anne (Mrs. John D.) Moore, 1409 Lake Drive, P. O. Box 2346, Delray BeaCh 33444 - 8 - J MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 The following letters were against granting the request: 1. Richard Engetland, 141 S. W. 25th Avenue, Boynton Beach 2. Mr. Carl Shuki, 150 S. W. 25th Ave., Boynton Beach 3. William H. Humphreys, 143 SW 24th Ave., Boynton Beach 33435 Mayor Harmsning gave the letters to the City Clerk. Mrs. Padgett pointed out' that all of the Councilmembe~s had received copies of the letters. Mayor Harmening asked that the letters be noted ~in the record. Vice Mayor Trauger asked Mr. Annunziato what the price was that was presented to the Planning and Zoning Board for the lots to the north and what was the hospital's objection to them. Mr. Annunziato replied that as a part of their review, they surveyed vacant properties in close proximity ~to the property, The realtor for the owner of the property was contacted, and he said the p~ice for 1,68 acres was $475,000.00. Mr. Annunziato thought %he hospital did, at one time, attempt to purchase the property. Mayor Harmening asked if anyone wished-to speak in'favor of'~the pro- posed request, Mr. Robert B. Hill, Assistant Administrator for Operations, Bethesda Memorial Hospital~, representing the Board of Hospital Commissioners, Southeastern Palm Beach County Hospital District, doing business as Bethesda Memorial Hospital, appeared before the Council. Mr. Hill submitted petitions containing 753 signatures in favor of the hospital's request for rezoning. Those added to the signatures already forwarded to tha Council would total 2,824 signatures of the residents of the area supporting the applica- tion. Mr. Hill thought the need for parking was evident to anyone that has been to the hospital lately. At times there are no spaces available at the hospital. In another four or five days, the hospital will be opening an additional fifty beds, which will take the bed count from 300 to 350 beds. Along with the beds will come additional patients, additional staff and'visitors visiting the people, Mr. Hill advised. Mr. Hill advised that the hospital only had two alternatives available to it to accommodate the parking n~eds. One is additional surface parking, and on the property in question tonight, Mr. HiII said that cost would be $300,000.00. If t~a~ is not available, Mr. Hill advised that the only other alternative is a parking garage. The estimated cost of the parking garage is $5,500,000.00. If the hospital is permitted to utilize t~e proposed area, they plan to insure that this area will remain ~ positive part of the neighbor- These items have been state, publicly in the letters to the hood. Planning and Zoning Board and also Mr. Hill continued. Mr. Hill stated that the hospital with a very dense, mature hedge th between the parking surface and th intend to start with mature trees to the neighborhood residents, ~ully intends to landscape the area ~t will insure proper screening ~ adjoining n~ighborhood. They also mnd other vegetation in the - 9 - · MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JkNUARY 19, 1982 landscape areas of t~e parking area. As stated, Mr~ Hill said they would provide the parking lot with iow altitude light~ standards w~th directional light heads So the glare will be prevented as much as humanly possible and directed onto the parking area in question and not scattered throughout the neighborhood. Mr. Hill asked Mr. Annunziato to show his map again, so Mr. Hill could explain the hospital's proposal better. Mr. Hill showed where the property was contiguous to the northern property line of the hospital. That would mean access to and from the property could be from the property and not through the-neighboorhood, Mr. Hill explained. Mr. Hill stated that access to the property would be to and from the hospital. There would be no benefit to the hospital to'have an access into the neighborhood. Secondly, Mr. Hill noted there was come concern that .the parking lot would increase the traffic through the neighborhood. Whether the parking facility is in this location or in another location, it will not .affect the traffic~ through the neighborhood, Mr. Hill advised. What will affect the traffic through the neighborhood w~ll be the fifty additional beds and the people that go along with the beds. Those people and their automobiles will create traffic and will have to be accommodated, Mr. Hill continued. In speaking to several neighbors personally and from the reaction of the neighbors at the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting last week, Mr. Hill expressed that it was the hospital's feeling that the primary concern of the neighbors appears to be the traffic through their neighborhood, The hospital intends to ~be a good neighbor, as they stated many, many times before. The hospital will provide a well landscaped facility and are willing to stand by their commitments to support the neighbors in their desire to have S. W. 2nd Street closed to prevent access to the hospital and see if that will alleviate the traffic problem. In an effort to demonstrate their good faith, Mr. Hill said the hospital submitted today (January 19, 1982) an applica- tion to the City requesting the abandonment and closure of S. W. 2nd Street, and they are willing to proceed hand in hand with the area residents to accomplish that fact. To that end, Mr. Hill asked Mayer Harmening if he could request representatives from the Westchester Heights neighborhood to verbalty reflect their feelings regarding the matter and state whether they would support the hospital's request of record. Mayor Harmening r.eplied that the Chair had no objection to conducting the poll, so to speak, but he did not know what the result would be. Vice Mayor Trauge~ had no objection, but wished to ask a question of City Attorney Vance. Vice Mayor Trauger asked City Attorney vance if the City had the authority, sitting as the City Council, to direct that a street like that be closed while the abandonment procedure is going forward. If so, would the abandonment procedure even be required, if the City enforced its own closure of the street, Vice Mayor Trauger ask'ed. - 10 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 City~ Attorney Vance replied that in order to close a street, it would have to be abandoned. However, it could be accomplished, assuming the factual situation supports it. Looking at the street, City Attorney Vance observed that it lOoked like it goes nowhere. Mr. Hill informed thel Council that the application concerned'that,.portion of S. W. 2nd Street that runs in its northernmost point parallel to the property of Lot 5 of Pine CreSt Ridge (S. 63.56 feet, according to the City Engineer),~bounded on the west by the hospital property. City Attorney Vance asked Mr. Hill if the hospital proposed to erect a substantial fence along the Small portion of the street that would not be abandoned so.that no one could get through. Mr. Hill replied the hospital would handle not only just a fence but would remove some asphalt and do some fencing and landscaping, It appeared to City Attorney Vance that the only party who would have an interest in retaining .the street would be 'the applicant for the abondonment. Under those circumstances, if no one else isserved, by the street, and that these are the correct· facts, City Attorney Vance advised that that portion of the street could be abandoned by the City. The lot referred to was pointed out, and Councilman deLong asked if it was the 5ouse Dr. Kucera lives in. Mr. Hill said that was correct, and Dr. Kucera is a party to the application. It was Mr. Hill's understanding that all contiguous property owners had to be a party to the application. Mayor Harmening said if there were any property~owners from Westchester who wished to say they might or might not favor this, they may speak now., Robert L, Foot, 2400 S. W. 1st Street, Boynton Beach, said many people were concerned about the effect the parking lot will homes. He did not think the Council could ask for a consensus tonight (January 19). Someone else asked-to speak, Mayor Harmening said it was a public hearing and people could speak pro or con, as soon as Mr. Hill finished. Mr, Hill added that the offer, from the hospital's standpoin~ is viable. The hospital would, obviously, like to have the feeling of the area residents. For the record, Mr. Hill submitted a copy of the application that was.signed by the hospital and Dr. Kucera, as a contiguous property owner. Mr. Hill advised it was an application for the closure of 2nd Street for the parcel so described. Councilmember Woolley ~asked Mr. Hill to comment on something concern- ing the homeowners. She referred to the last line of City Planner Carmen Annunziato's recommendatiOn, which says: "However, approval of this rezoning should be based on confidence that the applicant will not eventually construct buildings on the property." Councilmember Woolley told Mr. Hill she knew he bent over backwards to try to make the best situation for the hospital and the homeowners and that everybody appreciated that, but the Word, "confidence", confused her, - 11- ~INUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Councilmember Woolley knew the intentions of the hospital now, but was concerned about the future or ten years from now. Mr. Hill said that would be in the next portion of his presentation. Mr. Hill introduced William F. Koch, Chairman of the Board of Commissioners at Bethesda Hospital. Mr. Koch said he had been on the Hospital Board ever since it started. Mr. Koch stated that the hospital was only interested in doing what is best for the community. Mr. Koch had been a member of the City Council for twenty years and knew the problems the Council faces, As far as Mr. Koch was concerned, he would recommend to the Council that they deed restrict the property for parking use. A deed restriction was something that would have to be enforced by the property owner, Mr. Koch explained. When the hospital takes title, the deed would contain a restriction, "For parking use only". Mr. Koch thought, with the deed restriction, everybody would be protected. As one of the staff's recommendations was the fact that, '~If the property was developed as a parking lot with access from' the south and adequate landscaping, then the impact on nearby residential properties would be minimal." As stated earlier, Mr. Hill said~they fully intend to do that. There would be no advantage to the hospital to do otherwise. Mr. Hill read again from the City Planner's "Discussion and Conclusions": "It is also entirely possible that the applicant, or scme future property owner could build a s ...t~uCture up to 45 feet high, and up to the 25 ft. front setback required by the PU District. Development of this type could have a severe negative impact on property values and the residential environment." First of all, Mr. Hill pointed out, the primary need of the hOspital is parking, and that is why they are here tonight. Secondly, it is not efficient for the hospital to expand its facility horizontally. The travel distances for the employees to service patients would be all stretched out, and the employees and operations would be spending a lot of time in travel distances, which would make them a lot less efficient. The hospital does not want to expand horizontally anymore. Mr. Hill further said, as stated by Mr. AnnunizatO, the building is designed to go verticall~ and their long range plans call for the future services of the hospital to be expanded in the vertical spaces. Mr. Hill presented a diagram of the hospital. Mr. Hill pointed out the southeast wing, which is now only two levels above'grade, and said it can go to four levels above grade. That is where they will be adding the additional beds that will bring Bethesda Memorial Hospital to its maximum acute care bed total, which is around 450 beds. In a couple days, the hospital will open more beds, making 350 beds. The additional 100 beds can be installed in those two wings that are extended further to the east. The other two wings to the north can also be expanded to four levels above-grade and are now one level above grade. Mr. Hill informed the Council that vertical expansion will take place in those areas. - 12 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Furthermore, Mr. Hill continued, the long range plan that they just had completed by the±r planning consultant demonstrates that they have no new hospital alternatives. Mr. Hill passed out a page from the plan. He refer~ed to the bid projections for 1990. The only time in 1990 that Bethesd~ Memorial Hospital's bid projection exceeds the 450 bed limit is in the no new hospital alternative. That alternative is dead and buried because~Delray General Community Hospital is noway.under construction, Mr. Hill advised. In no case can Bethesda Memorial Hospital exceed the 450 bed limit, and they can accommodate that by expanding that one southeast wing. All of the construction programs that the hospital has undergone in the past six years have been remodeling and expanding all of the support functions of the hospital, Mr. Hill continued. Mr. Hill informed the Council that the functions have been designed and built to support 450 beds and no more, so the support areas are designed out to that degree. Mrs. Hill referred to another staff comment Mr. Annunziato discussed. That was the strip of seven lots of comparable size and dimensions along the west side of Seacrest Boulevard between S. W. 23rd and S. W. 25th Avenue. The parking lot should be located there, Mr. Hill continued. However, the cost of this property would be $475,000.00 compared to $125,000.00. Mr. Hill stated that the hospital did not want to discuss this publiCly because it would alert the property owner as to how ±nterest.ed the hospital was in that piece of property. It put the hospital in a terrible dis- advantage in negotiating their agreement. However, Mr. Hill said, since the issue had been raised at the Planning and Zoning BOard Meeting and-made public, the hospital can respond publicly. Mr. Hill said it was the hospital's feeling that the Planning and Zoning Board member who moved and denied the hospital's request did so with the thought that this property was an available alternative to the requested site and was already zoned for park- ing use, which it is. Mr. Hill stated that the hospital did attempt to purchase the property three or four months ago, and their efforts failed. Mr. Hill informed the Council that although both pieces of property have approximately the same square footage, they w%ll not provide the same amount of parking spaces, The parking on 23rd and Sea- crest will only provide approximately 117 spaces, while the property being rezoned will provide approximately 186 spaces. What makes that possible is the fact that the Seacrest property is very long and narrow and, to meet the parking requirements of the City, the design shown on the paper handed out by Mr. Hill would be the best way to utilize the area. Mr. Hill continued by saying that the hospital presently has 643 parking spaces. Several years ago, they had a professional engineering firm do a traffic and parking lot study for the hospital and project the needs for the hospital up through its 450 bed capacity. He handed out a cover sheet and the conclusions drawn by that firm. He called attention to the fact that when the hospital reached 350 beds, it would have a need for 780 parking~ spaces. When the hospital reaches its ultimate capacity of 450 - 13 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 beds, they will need approximately 895 parking spaces. Mr. HiLl said, that being the case, it leaves the hospital with an immediate need of 163 parking spaces. Therefore, Mr. Hill informed the Council, neither one of the pieces of property (the Benson property nor the Seacrest property) standing alone will meet the needs of Bethesda Memorial Hosp±%al. In fact, Mr. Hill continued, the Sea- crest property will not even meet the present needs of-the hospital for they can only provide approximately 117 spaces on the Seacrest and 23rd property, and their projections show they need 163~ spaces, Mr. Hill said the hospital needs both pieces of property. Mr. Hill read from the "Discussion and Conclusions" ,of the Planning Department: "(3) In this case, the general public would be better served by rezon~g the property since doing so would save the hospital a great deal of money and theoretically save the hospital patients money. It would be private property owners in the adjacent Residential Districts who would stand to lose the most." Mr. Hill said there was no doubt that the public would be better served by rezoning the property in question~ and permitting it to be used for parking. The hospital presented two solutions in order to accommodate the parking needs. One was to rezone and obtai~n the 186 additional parking spaces~.at a cost to the community of Three Hundred Thousand Dollars ($300,000.00) or reject the request~ and force the hoSpital to construct a parking garage, which, will provide 274 additional spaces at not only a cost to the community of $5,500,000.00 but will cause an even more acute parking problem than the hospital has now. Very frankly, Mr. Hill questioned, where do you park the existing 446 automobiles for a period of eighteen months to two years while you construct a parking garage. Mr. Hill concluded by saying the hospital stated the landscaping in the parking facility would be second to none and.would be donewell enough to shield it as much as~possible from~the neighborhood. Also, the low altitude lighting standards will be utilized. There will be no access from the parking area to the neighborhood, pro- viding the parking area willy,nOt increase the traffic through the neighborhood. The expansion of fifty beds and the cars that will have to be accommodated will increase the traffic'through the neighborhood, Mr. Hill stated. This being the case, the hospital has submitted the alternative to that traffic solution, which is the closure of 2nd Street. As stated in the recommendations of the City Planner, and Mr. Hill quoted: "Thus, rezoning this property would not conflict with the Cc~Prehensive Plan, and in this light, should be approved," Finally, Mr. Hill advised, ~he containment of health care costs is of vital interest to all citizens of this country' and of particular interest to the residents of Boynton Beach, which is heavily populated w±th citizens who are retired, and many of those are on - 14 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 fixed incomes. Mr. Hill told the Council they had a rare opportunity sitting there tonight, and that is they had within their power the ability to make a dec~slon t at will directly affect the cost of health care to the residents of the City to which they were elected to represent. Mr. Hill told the CoUncil they could join with the Board of Commissioners of Bethesda Memorial Hospital and assist them in their effort~ ~o keep the c~st of health care to the community as low. as possible by acting favorably on the request which will cost the community approximately $300,000.00-, or they could deny the reques~ and force the community to accommodate the parking needs by c°ns%ructing a parking garage for apprOximately $5,500,000.~00, There was a lot of applause. Mr. Russell T, Claytol Memorial Hospital, p~ 2,800 signatures, and Mayor Harmening wante~ of the request. Mrs. Grace Pruitt, Boynton Beach, said he~ the hospital. Mrs. Pi and has been in the m ],.~Board of Hospital Commissioners, B'ethesda ~sented petitions'to the'Council~containing asked the Mayor to have a recess. to hear comments from anyone else in favor [Stewed Nurse, 4434 Round Table Court, remarks were voluntary and not solicited by ~uitt has lived in Boynton Beach for'15 years ~dical f~eld in various capacities. She was Assistant Director of Nurses at Boulevard Manor, on staff at Boca Hospita~ in most of the~hospitals in Palm Beach County. A Ih Mrs. Pruitt enjoys going to Bethesda Hospital bsc~use of the way it is administered and the Staff there, she refused to take a private duty case there because of the parking. Mrs. Pruitt said a correction of the park- ing was long overdue, at least by six years. Even thoughi-~Mrs. Pruitt lives only. fifteen minutes away from Bethesda, she had to allow one hour maximum driving around looking for a place to park. Mrs. Pruitt felt it~w~s a dangerous situation~ Mrs. Pruitt pointed out that the more the hospital expands, the more additional staff they will need to tak care of the extra .patients. Mrs. Pruitt also felt hospital Was-dangerou parking spaces. Mrs. would do to the peopl consider people worki 7:00 A. M. shift, who got to the lights of the parking situation in the rear of the ~. She heard aboUt the cost of the additional Pruitt did not hear a thing about what it ~ coming to work. She asked the Council to ~g on the 3 to 11:00 P. M. or 11:00 P. M. to would have to walk up a dark street until they ~he hospital. Mrs. Pruitt was also ~oncerned about the landscaping that would be going into the parking lot. She expressed the hope that there would be some security too, as someone may be hiding in the bushes, ready to attack a nurse with a gun or knife, to perhaps get into the hospital to obtain drugs. Mrs. Pruitt saw people snickering and laughing. She told them it has happened. Mrs. Pruitt said the hospital needed parking close to the hospital. She informed the Council that she was married to an engineer, had - 15 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 moved 28 times in five different states, so she told the adjacent neighbors she knew what it was~to buy and sell real estate. Mrs. Pruitt told the neighbors when you buy and live near a facility such as a hospital, you have to take into consideration that there will be changes and things happening that will affect your prOperty values. The patients axe the important thing here, the people who service-them, and the people who want to visit them, Mrs. Pru±tt commented. THERE WAS A TEN MINUTE RECESS AT 8:45 P. M. Mayor Harmening again called the meeting to order and advised that there were some vacant seats in the front of the Chambers. He announced that he would continue the public hearing on the rezoning request and told everyone that wished to speak in opposition to the request, they could do so at this time. Robert L. Foot, 2400 $. W. 1st Street, Boynton Beach, asked Carmen Annunziato, City Planner, to present his map again. He pointed to his lot and.informed the Council that he bought the property in the last 14 months. When they bought the p~oper-ty, they understood the zoning was there, and they have lived with its limitations. Mr. Foot said he knew the piece on Seacrest could have a four story building on it if the developer complies with City Codes or appropriate parking~and the other things that the good City of Boynton Beach does require. Mrs. Foot further stated-that they knew across the street, there Could be rental duplexes in that R-2 zoning, Mr. Foot said they bought that piece of property as opposed~.to a piece Of property'~on White Feather Lane off of Military Trail, which was a very private area and on a dead end street. Mr. Foot informed the Council that his job makes it advantageous to be close in, and he wan'ted to be in the City. Mr. Foot said he was proud of.Boynton Beach and he had come to know the City for some eight months before he chose his piece of property. Mr. Foot told the Council that the residents of Westchester Heights and the people from Ridgewood Estates were scattered through the audience. They did not try to caucus;, as the hOspital wanted them to do, because the hospital knew there were different points of view represented tonight (January 19). Mr.. Foot said they did not try to cross stream the vote, as they couldn't. Although they had different views, Mr. Foot thought it might be appropriate to ask the people of Westchester Heights and Ridgewood Estates to stand, so that the Council would be aware of how many. people are concerned about it. The people stood, and Mr, Foot informed the Council that most of the people lived between him and the hospital. They bought property in an area zoned R-1AA. Mr. Foot continued that the people bought with the understanding that the Council of this good city would protect their property rights. - 16 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Tonight, Mr, Foot infOrmed the Council, they were being asked to violate the trust~that the people placed in them - the trust that was Placed in them by voters in the past., Aside from the traffic question which had an affect on Mr. Foot but which Mr. Foot thought everyone would agree would be offset by having a parking'lot next to-him, and which he Would have to accept, the people~s~property. rights were being jeopardized. Mr. Foot told the Council they had the responSibility to recognize that. As individuals, Mr. Foot advised the Council that they had their integrities at stake. Mr. Foot noted the Council had a large system speaking on behalf of the proposal. ~The hospital has an association i~ind..it~and can pay for radio advertising time. The time WKAO committed to Mr. Foot's statement~was a contribution by WKAO, Mr, Foot informed the Council, but the association behind the hospital has money to spend for all the announcements of the hospital heard over WKAO and WDBF for the last several days. Mr. Foot continued by saying the small man in this community.needs respect, along with the hospital. Mr. Foot did not believe this one issue would affect the voters.in March, 1982 or the voters in March, 1983, bu~ifi~,theCouncil, as individual Council persons, allow~ this, they~may well be tempted to allow spot zoning or violations of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan in other areas, Mr. Foot remarked that then the Council would be tainted at the poles. Mr, Foot urged the Council, as astute politicians, as well as leaders in the community, to say, "No, we are not going to violate the trust placed in us." Mr. Foot thought it was time for the Council to defer the issue tonight (January 19) until the hospital has shown not only its application (~hich Mr. Foot understood was conditional since he had heard 'from Bob Dillon on the phone yesterday that the hospital would make application subject to the rezoning of the property) that~ Mr. Foot hoped was an application, until the street is closed and the hospital shows in definite terms plans that show. fencing, foliage, and lighting. Then the people in the property located immediately around the parking lot would be satisfied that their values would not be hurt and that the Council has respected their interests, as well as the hospital's needs, Mr. Foot concluded. There was loud applause. Mr. Tom L. Plummer, 1314 S. W. 25th PIace, Boynton Beach, knew the people at the hospital could put on a "bleeding hearts spill"when they wanted to, as he had an occasion to listen to them. Mr. Plummer was amazed at the hospital, knowing that the master planning and the meetings at the City were so large some time backtwhen the City tried to firm up its zoning, Mr. Plummer did not recall any- one from the hospital coming and saying they were planning to expand or rezone. Tonight, Mr. Plummet continued, the hospital is coming up here, .asking for rezoning, and taking some of the residential area away from the residents. It is up to the Planning and Zoning Board and the Council as to whether they want to do it or not, but Mr. ~Plummer said he would say, "No, you don't give any more~' You're going back to spot zoning and you are changing the zoning that you voted on and submitted, and it was approved." - 17 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Mr. Plummer emphasized that Mr. Hill said he would haue fifty more beds and parking for them. Mr. Plumm~r doubted that the patients were going to drive up to the hospital and stay parked there all that time. Mr, Plummet observed that the hospital is a monQpolY. 'It is the only one in town. They get all of the business in the City plus business from ~o.ther pla~es, Mr. Plummer thought ~he hospital was getting ~ big. A ~h0spital is being built in West Delray, so Mr..Plummer thought some of the patients should be shared with them. Mr~ Plummer felt the hospital should maintain w.~at they have here and improve that through medical technology. Mr. Plummer asked who would be paying the $300,000.00 ~ost for the parking. Mr. Plummer informed 'everyone that the patiei~ts would, because the consumer always pays in the end. The hospital gets tax money, other monies, and makes a profit, so Mr. Pl~nmer told the Council to let the hospital build a $5,500,000.00 parking garage if that is what they want, but do not take away residential properties to make a profit for the hospital. Mr. Pl~nmer did not think the majority of the people would want that either, so. he urged the Council to think clearly before they took residential properties and made t~commercial. Mr. plUmmer added ~hat the Council Should do what's right for the people. There w~s applause. ceasare Morari, 150 S. W..24th Avenue, referred the Co the map, and stated he lived on 'the corner of 2nd and Mr. Morari listened to Mr. Hill at the Planning and Zc Meeting and again tonight. What amazed Mr. Morari was with an expenditure of that amount. Mr. Morari had a expenditures that he obtained fromthe Building Departm July 15, 1974 to May 26, 1981, Mr-. Morari said there w expenditure of $13,724,000.00 by the hospital on renov extensions and modernizing. Mr. Morari said it did no cost of the original bu~ldlng. Mr. Morari knew, as a builder and investor in la~d, ~b~ kind of money, he would certainly look into every aspe traffic and feasibility of enlarging the roads to and projects. It Was only recently that Seacrest was enl Morari pointed out. ~ncil ~o 4th Avenue.- ing Board an institution list~of ~nt. From ~s a total ~ting, t include the ~ore"inves~i~q~hat ~t of growth, from his ~rged, Mr. Mr. Morari was sorry to hear that. the change in the hospital did not conform with the master plan~on two specific items. In 1978, as a member of the Planning and Zoning Board, Mr. Morari said they had the Boynton Beach Comprehensive Plan and the technical report. The report was made up by well versed engineers and people well versed in land planning. Mr.. Morari said the plan.was.178 pa~es long. ~rc~page9, paragraph 2 of that report, Mr. Morari read the goals and objectives, which were to provide a decent and safe range of housing and a~suitable living environment. The objective was to preserve the present stock of sound dwellings and neighborhoods. Mr. Morari pointed out that a parking lot is not such a thing. Mr. Morari further advised that it said to upgrade the present neighbor- hood and environment. Mr. Morari did not believe a parking lot was upgrading, nor was a commercial use in a residential area upgrading. - 18 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Mr. Morari thought it would deteriorate the immediate vicinity of the area, such as Westchester Heights and Benson Heights (which has only two houses on it). Mr. Mora~i asked, "How about the new people that move here, that purchase brand new homes immediately west of the property?" Mr. Morari certainly felt they should object to having a parking tot~in someone'~s backyard. He did not believe that was progress, nor did he believe that would enhance the environment. The one major factor Mr. Morari thought the Council was confronted with was that either they abide by the rules, or they throw them out the window. Mr. Morari again referred to the' repOrt-, and said it showed the g~ow~h of ~the City on page 6 of said report. In 1978, the report showed-that the City had 35,000 residents, and in 1990, it will be 57,000~ ~ ~t projected that in the year 2000, there will be o~er and above 75,000 residents. Mr. Mor~ri asked how many more parking spaces will the hospital need by 1990. They do not ha~e enough now. Even if t~hey purchase this property, they will be short close to 100 parking spaces, so'where will they go, Mr. -Mora~i asked. Mr. Morari ad¥ised the Council the hospital will have to have a parking-garage in front of the hospital Mr. Morari continued by saying maybe the hospital will go horizontally and take over the Benson property, as it is available. 'Under the guidelines of the Master Plan, if you go into a residential area and purchase property as a residential piece of property, and use it as coImmercial property, Mr. Morari said it. would be a dramatic windfall. As a builder, Mr. Morari s~ated that was exactly what they would call it, As one of the residents of'Westchester Heights, Mr.~Morari advised he was affected mostly, as his home was built on a piece of property 100x150 deep. At the time he pur.chased his lot, Mr. Morari said the zoning was R1A, or he could build'on 75x100, which meant he could put two houses on the lot. Mr. Morari found his neighbor built on the total piece, so he built to conform to the neighborhood, and built one house on the total piece. Since then, the zoning has been changed to R1AA. The investments of the neighborhood are there-and stationary. Mr. Morari said there was ~.nowhere they could move, and they have invested their hard earned money, pay their taxes, and certainly do not want to lo'se the 12% increase of value rise per year. Mr. Morari believed a parking lot would tend to lessen the value of the property in the neighborhood. There was apPlause. Jay C. Kaye, 2400 N. E. 1st Lane, Village Royale on the Green, who lived about three miles away from the hospital; remarked that he was not for either party. He pointed out that Bethesda Hospital was very strict about.people visiting friends and relatives. Mr. Kaye said progress must be made in Boynton Beach, and he firmly believed the City should go ahead with the Parking. Bethesda needs the parking with the addition of the fifty beds. Mayor Harmening requested Mr. Kaye to sit down, as he was out of order. He explained that the original part of the meeting was for - 19 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 those who were in favor Of the hospital's proposal. The people at this time are speaking in opposition to the hospital's proposal, not in favor. Mr. Kaye apologized. Edward Townsend, 2616 S. W. 4th Street, a resident of Boynton Beach for just four months, said he w~s very much affected by the proposed rezoning. He showed where he l~ved on the map, his back fence, and also wh~re the parking lot w°ul~ be. Before he purchased his home, MX. Townsend very carefully checked with his builder and t'he City, inquiring about the vacant property. He was informed it was. zoned ~esidential and t~here should be no problem. Obviously, there is a problem, Mr. Townsend observed. Mr. Townsend's main concern was factor but the hospital, itself, ing area and the other will stil Mr. Townsend questioned where th suspected the hospital would ove Townsend noticed the hospital wi but they said nothing about ~hei that not only will %here be a noise admitted tonight that this park- 1 not be enough to meet their needs. e hospital would go next. He rwhelm the neighborhood. Mr. 11 be going up with their building, parking. Mr. Townsend remarked that maybe he was selfish, but he did object to the hospital's proposal, and he felt most of the people would be in the same boat he was i~ if they bought property in good faith, thinking it was in'a ~esi~ential neighborhood andwould be a nice quiet place, and then suddenly find a parking/'lot is to appear right in your backyar~. Mr. Townsend appreciated the fact there would be screening. Even now, Mr. Townsend informed the Council, there is noise in the middle of the night with sh±fts ghanging. There are people talking and car doors sla~aming. Obviously, Mr. Townsend observed, it will not enhance the value of the property and Will be objectionable to have a commercial parking lot right in his backyard. There was loud applause. Jo Anne Fultz, Registered Nurse, 147 S. W, 24th Avenue, Boynton Beach, stated the neighborhood w~s all for progress but against the downgrading of others' for the adVanCement °f another. Mrs, Fultz said there was a moral duty to the city's children and to its elders that llve in that neighborhood. The people have the right to Protect the value of their property. Mrs. Fultz said they ~ere there tonight because they believe in the local government. and felt protected by the Zoning Code. If. the rezoning is approved, Mrs. Fultz said the neighborhood will feel that their rights have been violated. Mrs. Fultz further informed the .Council that a man in town, who signed the petition preSented by the hospital, came to her and said he signed the petition but he did not know the petition had any- thing to do with rezon±ng. He felt it was simply "a~thing of more parking space for the hospital", Mrs. Fultz adwised. Mrs. Fultz expressed that she w.ouid sign that the hospital needs more parking - 20 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 space. There was loud applause. Victor Ko, 2618 S. W, 4th Street, Boynton Beach, stated that some- times he hears arguments, which are very bothersc~e, Mr. Ko said the hospital can build a wall and landscape, but he d~d not think they could do anything about the noise. Mr. Ko said it would be very bothersome to be living there and have strange people coming and leaving from the parking lot. Mr. Ko was living in another ~area and just moved to this address a couple of months ago. When Mr. Ko's family drove through the n~eighborhood, they loved it, as' they felt it was a ~very nice.neighborhood;, the house he was buying was very nice, and they felt it was B g°od-place to. settle down. Right now, if the hospital builds a~pa~king l°t, Mr. Ko stated he would have to move Out. His problem/will be, who will want to buy his house? Mr. Ko did not think the hospital had any right to build a parking lot there. Mr. Ko said he was told it was a residentia think it could be changed to a commercial z rights would be violated if the hospital ge parking lot in that area. Mr. Ko said some through the landscape and go into his backy. whether the hospital would provide security neighborhood. Mr. Ko also thought the ~alue of the proper- and would go down having the parking lot in did not think the Council should allow it. applause. J~.~.Frederick Banting, 2414 S. W, 1st Street he lived right off of S. W. 23rd, on the sh~ It appeared to Mr. Banting that the people li~e on S. W, 1st Street, S. W. 24th Avenue against'the hospital. Mr. Banting noted th~ since'the petition for rezoning, it appeare~ became angry about'it, -but. he pointed out ti hood attempted to have the section of S, W~ 26th Avenue abandoned. Mr. Ban%ing informe~ gentleman who helped was Dr. RObert Raborn. Rab°rn helped to compose a letter to the Ci% people who had property adjacent to S. W. 2r time were Mr. and Mrs. Fr.ed Benson and Mr. f if that property were abandoned, they would Mr. Banting recalled that it was turned dowr Seacrest Boulevard was being widened. Mayo~ zone, and he did not Dne. He thought his ~s its way to build a )ne could just climb ~rd. He questioned to protect the 2y would.go very low his backyard. Mr. Ko There was a lot of Boynton Beach, said ~rt cut to the hospital. .n the neighborhood that and"25th Avenue are ~t it appeared that just [that the neighborhood ~at in 1977 the neighbor- !~dAvenue between25th and the Council that the At ~ha~ time, Dr. y, and they had two d Avenue ~which at that arl Shuey) agree that purchase the property. by the Council because Harmening added that they were told at the time if they would co~ back in about a year, the Council would probably look with favor on their request. Mr. Banting admitted that they did not come back. He further stated that stop signs were put on the street and some police officers were there for a ~emporary period of time, One p~tice officer told him it was an unusual circumstance because nothing happened on their street. When Mr. Banting asked what would have to happen to get - 21 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 the street patrolled, he was told somebody would have to get hit. Mr~ Banting said the ambulance service had been contacted. The hospital and the police department had also been contacted since the 1977 meeting' to ask the hospital to please tell their employees to go into-the designated entrance, which is 26th Avenue (the entrance to the hospital}, not S. W, 1st Street, in front of his house. Nothing happened, There was not too much cooperation from the City and no cooperation from the hosPital. The hospital told them they could request their employees to go out the entrance On 26th Avenue but they could not make them do it. Obviously, the shorter route is out his street, Mr. Banting observed, because many of them live west of Boynton Beach. Mr. Banting further sai. d there is a stop sign at the S. W. corner of S. W.' 25th and 2nd Avenue, which they do not obe~ an'd also a stop sign at the corner of S. W. 2nd Street and 24th Avenue, which they do not obey. Now the hospital wants to make an additional 180 spaces, and there is a traffic problem already, which should have been alleviated a long time ago, Mr. Banting continued. A_~eal estate appraiser told Mr. Banting that the land values will go down and will not appreciate because of the parking lot. Also, when Mr. Banting. talked to Mr. Hill, Mr. Hill could not assure him that add±tional property would not be purchased and that medical support buildings would not go back there. Everybody is quite upset, Mr. Banting told the Council, because of their land values and their property values. He asked the Council to give his comments due consideration. There was loud applause. Lucien Samyn, 151 S. W. 25th Avenue, Boynton Beach, has lived next to the hospital for 18 years, and has seen it grow, Mr, Samyn saw the hospital take a whole wing that was 16 years old and tear it down because it did~not conform with %heir building program. Mr. Samyn said the hospital talks about $5,50Q~000~00 but~ they spent $13,000,000.00 in the past two years. They just completed a $2,000,000.00 cafeteria. Mr. Samyn remarked that the hospital talks about $5,500,000.00 for a parking garage. The costs seemed extraordinarily high to Mr. Samyn, but the hospital never seemed to.be concerned about money before; they tear down wings that are only 15 or 16 years old. There was a lot of laughter and applause. Mayor Harmening asked if the Council should presume that Mr. Samyn was in opposition. There was more laughter, and Mr. Samyn replied, "Yes." Noreen Engelland, 141 S. W. 25th Avenue, Boynton Beach, said they renewe~-~eir~bus~s l~a~ for ten years, so they plan to live, work, pay taxes, vote, and spend their money in Boynton. Mrs. Engelland was not trying to be unreasonable. She said they had a neighbor- hood of some retired people and young people just starting their families and some with children in college. Mrs. Engelland drove - 22 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 around the hospital and was overwhelmed at how much land has been consumed by the hospital for parking, The south side of 26th Avenue has been added to the main parking lot, and also, a large, lot west and north of the out patient building was turned into parking about a year ago. Now the hospital is asking for more land, Mrs. Engelland noted, which is tax producing and which will become tax exempt. The hospital said they will plant shrubs and trees, but Mrs. Engelland observed that they would not hide the emergency room expansion nor the heliport. Mrs. Engelland pointed out that plant- ing is one thing but taking care of the plants is another. The hospital does not have a very good history in regard to care, Mrs. Engelland continued. She informed the Council that the hospital has let trees and shrubs die because they were not watered or replaced. Mrs. Engelland told the~Council they bought their home from Wilson about fiv~ years ago for a very good price'because the realtors who handled it over a two year period were unable to sell it due to the hospital being on the next street~ Both of Mrs. Engelland's children have spent much time in hospitals, so she wa~ used to hospitals, and it is a comfort to her to have an emergency room n~ar, However, since the remodeling, Mrs. Engelland can now see the ~mergency room entrance from her front door. She stated it was no a pleasant view. If the hospital is allowed to put in-a parking lot, it will be only 200 feet from her yard, and she Will have a petter view of the emergency room and the heliport. It took Mrs.- Eng~lland some~time to get used to the helicopter's light at night ai~d to realize that it~was not looking for fugitives. She used to live near Margate, where police used helicopters to look for fugitiw~s. Realizing how important the helicopter is to the hospital .~nd'to the lives of people, Mrs. Engelland did not complain. She o~ty mentioned it because it is one of the situations they ~ust tolerate by living near the hospital. The speeding ambulan~es with their sirens blaring through the neighbor- hood is another .~ituation they must tolerate because it is important that. tl~e ambulances get to the hospital as fast a-s possible. Also, they must keep their windows closed because of the dirt and the noi:~e f~om the hosPital construCtion during the last four years. Livi~ng through the vibrations caused' by the pilings being driven for the new wing was no fun for Mrs. En~elland. Those were some ~)f the things Mrs, Engelland said they had to live wit~ but they' do not have to live with employees and doctors not obeying the spee~ limits or the stop signs and should not h~ve to tolerate the increase in crime such as mugging, which the parking lot would genera~ Mrs. Engelland told the Council they should not be asked to sacrifice the value of their homes for a park±ng lot when there are other alternatives. The request of the hospital was the final insult to their area, Mrs. Engelland said, which has united the neighbors "fighting mad" - 23 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING January 19, 1982 Mrs. Engelland also expressed the feeling of the neighborhood that it was very unfair of the hospital to suggest through the ads in the newspaper and the radio that the neighbors and the Council would cost the taxpayers an extra. S5,500,000.00 if this change in zoning for a parking lot is not approved. Mrs. Engelland and her husband requested that the Council deny the request for ~ezoning. There was a lot of applause. Mayor Harmening asked if anyone else wished to speak in opposition to ~e rezoning request and received no reply. Mayor Harmening announced that THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. Mr. Hill, Bethesda Memorial Hospital., asked for an opportunity to · rebut. There were boos from the audience. Mayor Harmening replied that this was not a cross-examination, There was very loud applause, Mayor Harmening cont±nued by saying that those in favor of the proposal are normally given time to speak and those in opposition are given time. Once in awhile there have been questions that the Council has. Mr. Hill said there were some misstatements and allegations which should be clarified. Mayor Harmening asked the Council what their feelings were about it. Vice Mayor Trauger had a question. Vice Mayor Trauger figured the hospital woUld still be short 110 parking spaces to the new wing, He asked where they would be a~commodated if they expand the other Part shown on the sketch. Mr. Hill answered that he gave the Council the projections from the Planning Engineers that stated when the hospital grows to 350 beds, they would need 780 spaces, nd when they go to their alternate stated capacity of 450 beds, the ultimate they would need would be 895. Mr. Hill advised that the property requested tonight would provide 1.68 spaceS. The prope~ty'~on Seacrest and 23rd will provide 117 spaces, so between the two parcels (if permitted for hospital parking), they will satisfy the ultimate parking needs of the hospital, if the hospital goes to 450 beds. They have 64'3 parking spaces now, Mr, Hill advised. Vice Mayor Trauger asked if that meant they would have to use the expensive lot they talked about on Seacrest. Mr. Hill said that was correct if they go to 450 beds. They are now at 350 beds. The mango grove (the property in question tonightl will satisfy the existing need. Mr. Hill said they were not assured they would be going to 450 beds. They were just saying that was what they had planned was their maximum capacity. Mr. Hill advised that both parcels would satisfy their ultimate.need. Councilman Wright asked if Mr. Hill said it would be $5,500,000,00 to erect a parking garage, and if it would b.e in front of the hospital. Mr. Hill replied that was correct; it was the estimate he had from their architectural firm. Councilman Wr. ight questioned over what period of time the hospital would have to pay for some- thing like that. Mr. Hill coulld not answer and said the financial arrangements would have to be ~or~ed out. Councilman 'Wright felt the opinions expressed by the c~izenswere valid and.~legitimate, although he hated to see the siltuation happen this way. Council- man wright realized crime was blad and a lot of homes are MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 burglarized in that area. He felt the hospital~'s proposal may cause some problems. Councilman Wright told Mr. Hill he heard many of the people who were opposed to the rezoning, and asked him what he would suggest. Mr. Hill replied that the parking area would be totally lit and would obviously be very beautiful. Secondly, Mr. Hill informed the Council that the hospital had a hospital~wide and surface parking area~wide surveillance system that is monitored by one of their security guards. They have inside and outside guards patrolling the area, so he felt the lighting and surveilance camera itself would enhance the security of the area and add to the security, not detract from it. With the hedging and fencing the hospital is willing to provide to separate 'it from %he neighbor- hood, it would add even more security to the neighborhood, Mr. Hill advised. Julie Brierly, 146 25th Avenue, told~about a hospital in Winston Salem that put in parking meters. She asked why Bethesda Hospital didn't put in parking meters. Councilman deLong was concerned and interested in the safety and welfare of the ~people in the neighborhood. Therefore, Councilman deLong moved to uphold the recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Board a~d deny the request. There was applause.. Council- member Woolley seconded the mOt±on~ There was more applause, and Mayor Harmening told the audience it was not necessary to.applaud. Councilman deLong said there was no guarantee that that land proposed for parking now would not be utilized in the future for a building because there was no legal agreement the Council could sign that would guarantee it. Councilman Wright aSked Mr. Annunziato if he ~said staff recommended it. He asked Mr. AnnunziatO for what reason. Mr. Annunziato replied there were several reasons, one based on whether there was .a contradiction to the Comprehensive Plan. There was some evidence that there may be some diminution of value on the existing Single family residential area. However, Mr.. -Annunziato po~[nted out it is not an area that is going to become a slum under any circum- stances. It will continue to prosper. Therefore, the question becomes one of public benefit. Mr. Annunziato said the issue had been addressed with.the hospital administration concerning what their plans for the future were. They told the Planning Department their plans were to use it for parking and they had no short term or long term plans to use it for anything other than parking. Mr. Annunziato agreed that Councilman deLong was correct in that there would be nothing to prevent the hospital from changing that policy at some point in the future. That brought them to the discussion of how the hospital would grow and the public's needs and costs. - 25- MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Vice Mayor Trauger heard earlier a proposal for a deed restriction. He asked City Attorney Vance how binding the deed restriction would be. City Attorney Vance advised that you can always get a quit claim deed from a deed restriction. City Attorney Vance pointed out that he was not saying the hospital had any such intention. It was a matter of practical±ty. Irregardless of the voteS, it appeared to Vice Mayor Trauger that one of the great concerns of the people he listened to was in the safety of the street. He noted there was a proposal for the closure of the street. Vice Mayor Trauger believed the street should be closed by the City Council and the procedure should go forward irrespective of what,else happens. ~ice Mayor Trauger was hoping that would be a part of the settlement, but the motion is now facing the Council and the recommendation. Vice Mayor Trauger felt very vitally that the Council should take action to close the street for the ~safety of the citizens who live in that area. At the request of Councilman deLong; Mrs. Padgett took a roll call vote on his motion to deny the request of Southeastern Palm Beach County Hospital District d/b/a Bethesda Memorial Hospital to rezone from R-1AA to PU, as follows: Vice Mayor Trauger - Aye Councilman deLong - Aye Councilman Wright - Aye Councilmember Woolley - Aye Mayor Harmening - Aye The motion to deny the request carr±ed 5-0. Vice Mayor Trauger moved that City Attorney Vance, through the City Manager and the affected departments, take the most expeditious route they know of to complete action on the abandon- ment process that has been filed. Councilmember Woolley seconded the motion, and the motion carried 5-0. There was very loud applause, and Mayor Harmening warned that if there was more applause, he would clear the Chambers. Vice Mayor Trauger asked if the City could barricade the street while the abandonment procedure is under way. City Attorney Vance wanted to check it out. Vice Mayor Trauger asked him to please check on it. THERE WAS A TEN MINUTE RECESS AT 9:50 P. M. The meeting resumed at 10:00 P. M. DEVELOPMENT PLANS Preliminary Plat of the Replat of Driveways 2, 3, 5 and 6, Municipal Cemetery, providing for 440 additional lots. Located at the southwest corner of Seacrest Boulevard and Woolbright Road. - 26 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Carmen Annunziato, 'City Planner, said he did not have an overlay. He informed the Council that several months ago~ the City Council abandoned the driveways of that cemetery plat. 'They are now coming back with a request to replat those driveways into cemetery lots. Mr. Annunziato said ±t was. reviewed by the Technical Review Board and went to the Planning and Zoning Board with an unanimous recommendation. It comes to the C±ty Council with an unanimous recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Board. Mr. Annunziato~ also added that it was reviewed by the Cemetery Board and it was found to be acceptable. Vice Mayor Trauger moved to accept the preliminary plat of the re- plat of Driveways 2, 3, 5 and 6, Municipal Cemetery, seconded by Councilman deLong. No discuSsion. Motion carried 5-0. LEGAL Ordinances - 2nd Reading - PUBLIC HEARING Proposed Ordinance No. 82-1 Re: Height Limitations for Referendum Prior to reading the proposed Ordinance, City Attorney Vance informed the Council .that at the request of Councilman deLong, he had incorporated on page 1 the same language that was placed in Ordinance 82-5 regarding electrical and mechanical support systems. City Attorney Vance said he had passed a copy of it to the Council. Mayor Harmening asked City Attorney Vance to read it into the record. City Attorney Vance advised that:on page 1, Section 1, paragraph 2~ the words, "electrical and mechanical support systems" should be added. On page 1, Section i, paragraph 2, line 7, City Attor~ey Vance said the words, "within a structure or on top of the structure" should be added. City Attorney Vance said that when the ordinance was drafted, 4 F was incorporated in its entirety. On page 3 of 4 F, there was one page relating to television towers which City Attorney Vance said did not appropriately apply to this ordinance. He suggested that that entire page be deleted and the pages be'-renumbered. City Attorney Vance read proposed Ordinance No. 82-1 on second reading, by title only: "AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BOYNRC~ BEACH, FLORIDA, PROPOSING THE ADOPTION BY REFERENDUM VOTE OF THE ELECTORS OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH BY ORDINANCE OF APPENDIX A "ZONING", SECTION 4, "GENERAL PROVISIONS" (F) 'HEIGHT LIMITATIONS AND EXCEPTIONS' OF THE ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES." Mayor Harmening asked if anyone in the audience wished to speak in favor of the proposed ordinance. Derle Bailey, 644 Las Palmas Way, Boynton Beach, said he has lived around Boynton Beach for 22 years and has lived in Boynton Beach since 1968. Mr. Bailey expressed his love for Boynton Beach, its atmosphere, and the fact that it is a small community. - 27 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Mr. Bailey liked the idea of Boynton Beach not being overrun by the monstrosities of some of its neighboring cities, such as West Palm Beach and Fort Lauderdale. Last night there was a proposal for referendum to designate two districts of the city that would not be limited to the 45 foot height. Mr. Bailey did not see what good a 45 foot height did anyway. Back in December, Mr. Bailey said this was proposed. The~e was an ordinance for referendum, and it carried a majority' of the Council. At the January 5th meeting, it carried a majority of the vote. Mr. Bailey said he would like to see it carry a majority of the vote tonight. He told the Council a majority of them brought it up; they put it before the publ±c and made an issue out of it, so let the people settle it. Nick Cassandra, 2554 S. W. i£ 18) and again tonight and ad~ concerned about the statemen~ one was a poli{ical issue bul it was brought up' before a pt to verify an article he read conduct a publi.c hearing toni Mr. Cassandra asked the Coun( to vote that either they wan~ if they do not want it, give Mr. Cassandra thought both r~ Cassandra said tonight's vot~ on its own merits. The 29th merits. Mr. Cassandra asked decide. Ruth Morsch, 120'4 S. W. 22nd everything on her mind last any commercial business wantJ come and do business within done it for years, and B0Ynt( Neither has any other bUsines Mrs. Morsch said she cs_me he~ live. She left other places traffic and came to Boynton ~ of the things they could depE her that when she wrote~to t~ The Chamber of Commerce said there was a 45 foot height hE it would be a nice place to ¢ th Court, was here last night (January itted he was confused. He was very s some people made. He thought . regardless of whether it was or not, .blOc audience. Mr. Cassandra wanted where Mayor Harmening said he would ght. ~il to give the people the chance ~ the 4~5 foot height throughout or, them the choi'ce of modification, but ~ferendums should be on there. Mr. should decide Ordinance A (82-1) it should'also be decided 'on its own the Council to let the people Avenue, Boynton Beach., said almost ~vening. She could see no reason why ng to come to Boynton could not .he 45 foot height limit. They have ~n Beach has not gone broke. ses in Boynton Beach gone broke. e so they would h~ave a nice place to with high rises, congestion, and each. They were told it was one nd on. ~The Chamber of Commerce ~told .em and asked about Boynton Beach. it was a lovely place to live, that re, and it would be continued, and ome.~to~ Now that they have come and invested money in their homes, they want to change the height. Mrs. Morsch thought that was very un- fair. She thought many things said .about the parking lot at Bethesda applied to the rest of the people living with the 45 foot height limit. She felt the privacy of the people was being invaded when they want to pu~ high rises around them. - 28 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Mrs. Morsch hoped the Council would consider that most of the people in Boynton Beach would like to see Boynton Beach stay the way it is, with the 45 foot height limitf so that they could continue to live here. Ben Ul-eck, Vice President of Boynton Beach Leisureville Association, said they were also for the 45 foot height limitation. Mr. Uleck kneW that 75% of the people are retired or semi-retired and when the Council took office, they took office and took an oath to work for the people. Mr. Uleck as the taxes, and said the 75% w work for them,, not for the co estate people or the politici people. Councilman Wright th people. Lyn Huckle, 656 Castilla Lane comments and concerns. What they may be overlooking some understood ~t, tonight the Co proposed Ordinance 82'1 (Vice to limit all building heights it to referendum), Ms. Huckl almost six years on the City on some of the City CouncilS. always been a strong advocate with the zoning codes. She h 1974 and 1975.. Ms. Huckle suggested that the She called attention to the D present, this tract is in the DeBartolo was seriously consi ked who was paying the majority of ere, ~so the Council is supposed to ntractors or the developers or real ~ns. Mr. Uleck said they were the ~ught he had been working for the , Boynton Beach, wished to share some ~oncerned Ms. Huckle most was that very'basic factors. As Ms. Huckle unc±l was having' a second reading on Mayor Trauger's original proposition in the City to 45 feet and to put ~ has lived here 24 years and served Planning and Zoning Board and five Ms. Huckle expressed that she has of 'low density~ancl~ict~~nn~_c~ elped to rewrite the zoning ~ode in Council concentrate on some issues,. eBartolo Shopping Center area. At County, Ms. Huckle understood that ~ering requesting annexation. She also understood this would be very beneficial to the City of Boynton Beach and would provide a very profitable tax base. Ms. Huckle wondered if annexation.would be requested if all height limitations are frozen at 45 feet. Ms. Huckle also pointed out that the City would undoubtedly be called upon to supply water and sewer services whether they annex to the City or not, There will also be a great increase of traffic on all streets leading to that area. Ms. Huckle said now the City is looking to a much needed beach restoration and more property taxation to pay off the bonds. .She questioned whether the City would hurt itself more by po~ssibly losing the DeBartolo tax base than by exempting the area from the height limitation. Ms. Huckle heard at last night's hearing on proposed Ordinance 82-5 that some investors are already in the planning stages of developing parcels of the DeBa~tolo tract that are not included in the shopping mall. They indicated that they would require heights - 29 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 in excess of 45 feet, and Ms, Huckle ~aid that would surely influence DeBartolo's decision to request annexation. If the Council should decide to exempt the western Commercial area, Ms. HuCkle wondered if-they should alSo'have a height cap there too because of the need fo~ fire protection. Ms. Huckle offered those points for everyone's consideration as the City tries to do what is best to achieve a unification of purpose for the City. Councilman deLong informed the Counci% that he had a meeting with the DeBartolo outfit in the mid-~0s and they knew the.height limitation was 45 feet. Just r~cently, CoUncilman deLong said they came in with a plan for ~a three ~tory building, which would be sixty feet high. If DeBarto~o wants to come into Boynton Beach, Councilman deLong thought he should meet Boynton Beach's~ Code, not what he wants. If you tailOr the C~ty to su~t all the people who would like to come in, you will have an ugly loOking City. Councilman deLong said Mr. DeBartolo was not interested in any more than two stories in West Palm Beach. Councilman deLong said they were there to give the people the opportunity to make the choice 6f one or t~e other. He thought that was the fair way. Mayor Harmening did not think Mr. DeB~rtolo had any particular interest other than the fact that' they stay within his group. There are five major department stores coming out there, and they are the ones that requested the three stories or approximately sixty feet. Don Balmer, President of the Board of Directors of Sterling Village, spoke last night on 82+~, He said at 'that time he presented, a petition with 700 s~gnatu~es of people requesting the Council vote'for 82'1 (alsoiknown~as Ordinance A-). Mr. Balmer stated that sterling Village s~ill felt that way. that Bob Foot, 2400 S. W. 1st Street, Boyn~on Beach, spoke for the Chamber of Commerce of Greater Boynto~ Beach on Ordinance 82-1. Mr. Foot said many of the electors had position on saving the use of referend commitments to future tax dollars. Mz previously to speak in oppositign to ~ some issues they feel Councils Of the Foot told the Council they have been e people tonight are a sample of that im concerned citizenry. If the Council K ments to the City, Mr. Foot said they of the difficult issues along with the ones. Mr. Foot thought if the citizen the Council who are equally commit~d, potatoes" as well as they will handle that may be a little less controversi~ heard the Chamber's ums for issues involving . Foot said they appeared he use of referendums for future can handle. Mr. lected by the public. The terested public or ants to fulfil its commit- would have to act on some administrative and easy ry elected successors to they will handle the "hot the cemetery problems 1. - 30 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 If this issue goes to referendUm and is passed, Mr. Foot said the successors of the Council will be bound by that action, whatever the circumstances might be in the futur~. The Council will not be able to take except±on. The Council will be bound by the voters' acts. No matter how worthy the circumstances may be in the future, Mr. Foot told the Council they will not be able to take exception as they will be bound by the voters' act, No matter how worthy the private building might be that is proposed in excess of .four stories or 45 feet, there will be nothing they can do about it. Only with the great expense of another referendum where the citizens themselves vote for approval of an economically feasible building in downtown Boynton Beach where th~ City's pride maybe limited this time or where they wOuld like to increase their pride, or like the DeBartolo Mall area that they do want and will agree at that time would be a help to the community, can anything be done. Mr. Foot told the Council they should not and must not commit this issue to a cumbersome referendum process 'Which will discourage organizations that might enhance the City's image under a concerned government or ~future Councils. Councilman deLong interjected that the Council listened %o ~.he people when they came in with their problem about the zoning for the hospital, and he felt the CounCil would be lax if they did not listen to the people who signed the petitions. Councilman deLong said all the people were doing, was asking that the Council put it on referendum and give them the chance to vote on it. Councilman deLong said the'Council did not neglect the people in Mr. F~ot'~.~ihst~a~ce and he did not want to neglect the people in this instance. Mr. Foot was delighted that Councilman deLong,'himself, made the motion. Mr. Foot noted there was a pause before Councilman deLong made the decision to take a position on a controvers±at ~issue. He told Councilman deLong he was looking at two pretty heavy forces, and the Chamber of Commerce did appreciate Councilman deLong, in partiCular, taking a poSition that they felt he (Councilman deLong), as their representative, could handle and should handle. Mr. Foot was very glad Councilman deLong was n.ot referring the hospital issue to the general public because he would be the first to say, "Let's go back to Amendment 10." Councilman deLong said he was giving the people who signed the petition the same consideration that the Chamber of Commerce were giving. Councilman deLong told Mr. Foot to look at his record. He said he sits and judges the health, safety, and welfare of the people in every issue where rezoning comes before the City Council. Mr. Foot retorted to Councilman deLong, "I'm sorry sir, you are saying you do not want to do this next year or the year beyond." Mayor Harmening interrupted to say the discussion was going a little beyond and asked if anyone else wished to speak. - 31 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Mr, Dan Garnsey, 316 S. W. 1st Street, Boynton Beach,~. said he was a businessman and felt he was in the minority at the meeting. He read in the paper about the hospital and their problems, and it seemed only logical for'the Council to issue a variance to them. Mr. Garnsey said he sat at the meeting and watched another minority explain their problems to the Council very ably, and he was afraid the Council would put it to a referendum. Hr. Garnsey saw the Council make a decision but, as Mr. Foot said~, had the Council put it to referendum.,~those people would have los{. Mr. Garnsey told' the Council they made the right decision. There w.ould have been a lot of expense gone to unnecessarily. Mr. Garnsey continued by saying last night everyone attended a political rally right here in City Hall. They saw three Council- men make a campaign speech. They saw a 14 story and 27 story building planned for .just outside of Boynton Beach. .Mr. Garnsey remarked that he would like to see those plans. Mr. Garnsey stated that' his eight year old could tell the Council that if they put a 27 foot story building here in Boynton Beach, it would be like the Inca pyramids. Everyone Would go and look at it, Councilman deLong interrupted to say he did not tkink anyone said anything about plans. They .said they heard. Mr. Garnsey laughingly commented that they were dealing in rumors, and asked'the Council to pardon him. Mr, Garnsey did not think a Councilman should sit and be called a crook because he did not agree eye to eye with someone in the audience. Mr. Garnsey thought they were doing much better tonight, 'because he thought they were going to be fairly heard. Mrs. Garnsey stated that two unneeded ordinances have been proposed for referendum. One ordinance will leave a little bit of leeway for the future planning of Boynton Beach, Mr.' Garnsey requested the Council to eliminate what has been called proposed Ordinance 82-1 (also known as Ordinance A) from the ballot and go forth with the referendum which will allow future Councils some leeway in two small areas of town. Boynton Beach is a nice little.town, Mr. Garnsey conlmented. He did not think Leisureville and Sterling Village were beautiful. He agreed they were funct±onal but not beautiful. There were loud boos from the audience. Mr. Garnsey knew he would be unpopular when he finished. He advised that the business area in the City would never box in or overshadow all of the residential areas in Boynton Beach. They just would .not have it. Mr. Garnsey further advised that density is not controlled by a 45' foot height limit. As Mr. Garnsey saw it, this was a political ploy of some sort, He informed the Council that density is controlled by the zoning laws. The zoning laws show square footage and green areas. Mr. Garnsey told the Council they could envision quite easily building a beautiful structure that would be more than 45 feet high and still leave far more green area and traffic surroundings than the present code allows. Mr. Garnsey reiterated that density is not controlled by 45 foot height limits. - 32 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Boynton Beach will never look like downtown Fort Lauderdale, Mr. Garnsey predicted. He pointed out that everyone knows the economy needs more than the retired people and residents here, or they would be back to the old days when Boynton Beach and Delray Beach shut up in the summer and went to the Carolinas. People in the audience shouted, "Oh, come one" Mr. Garnsey said the business community represented a mi~nority of the City voters and he felt it was the duty of the Council to repre- sent all of the economic and poli. tical interests, not just the voting block that they feel has the most power at this time. Last night., Mr. Garnsey felt the business community was well repre- sented. A large percentage of the audience were business people. Mr. Garnsey reiterated that density is the real issue here, and the zoning laws can control that. Mr. Garnsey did no't think that anyone wanted a residential area with seven or ten stories in Boynton Beach. Mr. Garnsey told everyone to be assured that if no referendum were held, the Planning Department would not be undated with buildings of over 45 feet. Mr. Garnsey asked that the majority of the Council would decide to diffuse an unnecessary confrontation here between the business communit~ as opposed to the rest of the community, and eliminate one of the propoSals from the referendum. Wendell Hall, 700 N. E. let Avenue, Boynton Beach; ~said his address was in the downtown area. Mr. Hall stated..he'was one of the 25% here in the City that has not yet retired. Mr. Hall ~hoped the City would do all it could for those in busin~ess here. Mr. Hall Started a fishing business in Boynton Beach when the City was young. When they caught a great many fish, everybody came to Boynton Beach, and it was noted for fish~ng~ Now, "Mr. Hall was asking that the City would do all it could for the .original part of the City. Mr. Hall noted that it needs all of the help it can get. MAYOR HARMENING ANNOUNCED THAT THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. Councilman deLong thought the people had every right to make a choice and moved to gi've those people the opportunity of a referendum on proposed Ordinance No. 82-1 (also known as Ordinance A). City Attorney Vance added, "with the changes on pages l and 2." Vice Mayor Trauger seconded the motion, Councilman deLong said he would support proposed Ordinance 82-5 (.also known as Ordinance C) when it comes up at the Special Meeting on January 29, 1982 at 7:30 P. M., but he wanted to give the people the choice. Vice Mayor Trauger wondered if this proposal was voted on tonight and it was.voted down, would that eliminate it from any chance beyond that for the peoPle's con~iderati©n on referendum. Mayor Harmening advised him that was correct. 'ViCe Mayor Trauger concluded that the only issue facling thelpeople on January 29th would then be the referendum question again for 45 feet with the - 33 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 exception of the downtown area and the Congress Avenue plots. Councilman deLong added..the hospital. Mayor Harmening informed them that the hospital was included in both proposed ordinances. City Attorney Vance added 'that it was not in the actual designated commercial area, but~City Attorney Vance believed the ~inclUsion of the language on page 1 would adequately handle the situation. Vice Mayor Trauger asked if the Council interposed any objection to the suggestions of several of the people who were'present last night to give the people the choice. Vice Mayor Trauger did not think it shoUld cost more than 10¢ printing costs for either or of those two to express their own viewpoints rather than shutting them off with what some would consider the worst of two evils or the best of two evils, 'from~whichever way you~are looking at it. vice Mayor Trauger asked what was the difference in print- ing costs with respect'to the people who are voting in Boynton Beach. Vice Mayor Trauger did not feel individual Councilmen had made this a political issue. It was to give the opportunity to the people to continue what they came here for, so they could have a choice of either direction. Before it is locked into cement one way or the other, ViCe Mayor Trauger asked what the basic alternative to this would be. Councilman Wright personallY felt it was a political issue and was politically motivated. He felt there were other more important things that the Council should be' conCerned about ±n the City than addressing something like this. Councilman Wright did not think it should be taken to ~ferendu~n. Councilman Wright expressed he Would like to see proposed Ordinance 82-1 (Ordinance A) denied tonight and also see proposed~Ord~inance 82-5 (Ordinance C) denied sO they would'not have any Of them go to referendum. That was how Councilman Wright personally felt. Councilman Wright was ashamed to know that some citizens felt he was not'representing the interests of Boynton Beach. Councilman Wright informed everyone that he does come to City Hall and tries to do his duties as a Council person~and take into consideration all of the needs of the people in the community. Councilman Wright felt he would be deny- ing a~lDt~.of people.-iopportunities'..%o put .somethihg like this on referendu~ - ..... C6uncilman deLong asked Vice Mayor Trauger if he would withdraw his second to the motion made by Councilman deLong to give the people the opportunity of a referendum on proposed Ordinance No. 82-1 (also known as Ordinance A). Vice Mayor Trauger consented. Councilman deLong then made a motion to continue the vote on proposed Ordinance No. 82-1 (.also known as Ordinance A) until January 29, 1982 at 7:30 P. M. Vice Mayor Trauger seconded the motion. No discussion. The motion carried 3=2, with Councilmember Woolley and Councilman Wright voting against the motion to continue. - 34 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Proposed Ordinance No. 82-2 Re: Beverages for Referendum Hours for Sale of Alcoholic City Attorney Vance read proposed Ordinance NO. 82-2 on second and final reading, by title only: "AN ORD/AIANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, PROPOSING THE ADOPTION BY REFERENDUM VOTE OF THE 'RT.~CTORS OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH OF AN ORDINA~tlE GOVERNING THE HOURS OF SAT.R OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES WITHIN THE CITY OF BO~ BEACH; PROPOSING TO ADOPT SECTION 3-4 'HOURS OF SALE' .BY REFE~UM VOTE; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURI~SES." Mayor Harmening asked if anyone in~ the audience wished to speak in favor of the proposed ordinance. Harry B. Stein, 760 East Ocean Avenue, BoYnton Beach, spoke in behalf of the residents of Coastal Towers Condominium, or-which he was the Director. Mr. Stein believed he was also speaking for the Overall majority of the citizens of Boynton Beach, who believe in good government. Mr. Stein's remarks were directed not so much to'the merits of the 2:00 A. M. closing, on which opposition is fairly well ~known, but rather to the question of why the proposed ordinance referring it to a referendum should be passed.by this Council, The past history surrounding the enact, ment of the present ordinance in June of 1980 and the subsequent events indicated that the issue is not dead, Mr. Stein commented. As one Council candidate (a legal counsel for the bar owners) recently claime~ "Whenever an issue involves big money and~huge profits, it is never de~d," Mr. Stein recalled. Proponents for a change back to the 5:00 A. M. closing have indicated publicly that the only way the ordinance would be amended would be by the election of new Councilmen favorably disposed to their position, ~Mr. Stein continued. In support of that statement, Mr. Stein read from a Boynton Times dated July 17, 1980, which was a day or two before the present ordinance went into effect. Mr. Stein did not mention the names but said they were two leading owners of establishments in Boynton Beach. Mr. Stein advised that one of them said, "If we can't get this thing turned around between now and November, we'll be backing new people for election who are more business oriented." Mr. Stein further advised that another one said he thought the ordinance could be reversed sometime in the future, but likely, through the election of new Councilmembers, Mr. Stein noted that therewas a prevalent feeling around that no matter what the issue is, if enough money and political muscle is applied, it will be put through regardless of the will of the majority. Mr. Stein did say, however, that the'Council tonight, in acting on the hospital's petition had certainly acted to dispose that belief. - 35 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 At last night's meeting of the Council, Mr. Stein recalled that a representative of the Chamber of Commerce stated that the Council's action in proposing a referendum on this issue is "an exercise in politics." Mr. Stein said that Coastal Towers Condominium says just the reverse is true. By passing the ordinance for a referendum, the Council would be removing it as a political issue to be decided once and for all by the voters of the citizens of Boynton Beach. Mr. Stein stated that they had seen in the last Council election, after an enactment of the present ordinance, that a substantial contribution of $500.00 was made by a local bar owner to one of the candidates favorably disposed to the 5:00 A. M. closing. This party was not elected, but if she had been, Mr. Stein asked if any- one there could believe that she could have impartially and objectively considered this issue. As Vice Mayor Trauger-had charged during that' sa~e election campaign, it was also a matter of public record that a threat had been made to him by two representatives of bar owners that $10,000.00 would be put into the campaign funds of candidates sympathetic to them on the bar closing issue if he did not-change his position. That is why Coastal .Towers Condominium believed it was not politics but rather a keen understanding of the realities of politics which motivated the members on the Council who wisely decided to propose the ordinance for a referendum. Mr. Stein warned that if this issue was not settled~Once and for all by referendum, it can come up for amendment after each election of the Council and, depending on its political makeup, with predictable results. By voting to submit the ordinance to referendum, Mr. Stein told the members of the Council that they would be. taking a g±ant step £orward'in maintaining the people's respect, confidence and trust, which the Council deserves. Mr. Stein read recently a statement by a leading spokesman for proponents for the 5:00 A. M. closing that in submitting this *~%ould be ordinance for a referendum, the Council will be advocating*its a ..cating responsibility. Mr. Stein'quoted him as addit~ionally saying ~/82 he referendum election is a traditional tool of the spineless Minutes politician who seeks to evade personal involvement in tough issues." Mr. Stein noted they were very strong words but said, "Let's see if they measure up." Should be *advocation of responsibility. abdication See 2/2/82Minutes. Immediately after the Council voted on June 3, 1980 for the present ordinance, Mr. Stein observed that the same individual called the action of the Council "the most raw political act I have ever seen." He further referred to one of the present Councilmembers who voted for it as a "gutter politician", Mr. Stein recalled. Mr. Stein commented that it was a piece of, "Damned if you do, and damned if you don't." Mr. Stein remarked, "Is it any wonder that you have decided to put a halt to this type of abuse and propose to turn this highly charged issue to the voters for this determinationS" Mr. Stein did not call it He called it assumption of - 36 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 responsibility in the highest and finest tradition of democratic government. Under the circumstances and facts as they exist, Mr. Stein thought this was an issue which should rightfully be brought before the voters of Boynton Beach for their decision. He felt it was true democratic ~procedure to do this. There will be a finality to the issue and no future attempts to change the ordinance except, perhaps, by another referendum, Mr. Stein advised. Mr. Stein further pointed out that one would have to be politically naive to believe that without a referendum, the present ordinance will remain in effect, very long. In deciding an issue such as this, Mr. Ste±n stated the present and future character of Boynton Beach, in a sense, will be determined. He asked if it would be a wide open city or a peaceful progressive community, largely residential in character. In seeking to ascertain the wishes of the majority of the citizens on an important question such as this, Mr, Stein said Coastal Towers believed that a vote of-~upwards of 10,000 people is preferable to a vote by five people or one deciding vote, subject to intense economic and political pressures. Mr. Stein, representing Coastal Towers Condominium, urged the Council to.vote for'the ordinance, submitting the issue to referendum for a better Boynton Beach. There was applause. Ben Uleck, Vice President, Boynton Leisureville Community Associa- tion, read the following petition: "We, the undersigned voters of Boynton Beach, respectfully request that the Council do not have a ballot and just close the bars at 2:00 A. M." Mr. Uteck informed the Council that he had a lot of signatures, Mayor Harmening asked if anyone w~shed to speak in opposition to the proposed ordinance. There was no response, Vice Mayor Trauger moved .the adoption of proposed Ordinance No. 82-2 on second and final reading. The motion was seconded by Councilman deLong. No discussion. Mrs. Padgett took a roll call vote on the motion as follows: Councilman Wright - No Councilmember Woolley - Aye Mayor Harmening - Aye Vice Mayor Trauger - Aye Councilman deLong - Aye Motion carried 4-1. Proposed Ordinance No. 82-3 Bond Issue for Referendum Re: Approve General Obligation Beach - 37 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNC] City Attorney Vance read pro entirety. Said proposed ord "AN OPaD~CE OF THE CITY C~ FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE ISS! PBOVIDED FOR, OF NOT EXCR~D~ BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, FOR ] OTHER AVAILABLE FUNDS, FOR P~ TIC,AL AND MUNICIPAL BEACH Fi BEACH CONSISTING OF THE CONS~ AND PARKING AREAS AT THE SI~ TION OF IMPROVEMENTS TO PRE~ IN CONNECTION THEREWITH; AND TAKE EFFECT ~/ATELY UPON Mayor Harmening asked if anyc proposed ordinance. L MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 ~osed Ordinance NO. 82-3 in its ~nance was entitled: ~CIL OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, JANCE, SUBJECT TO THE ~.FCTION HEREIN ~G $1,750,000 BONDS OF THE CITY OF ~BOVIDING FUNDS, TOGETHER WITH ANY hYING THE COST OF DEVELOPING P~CREA- ~CILITIES IN THE CITY OF BOYNTON .~UCTION OF A P~CREATIONAL BUILDING OF 'THE MUNICIPAL BEACH, THE CONSTRUC- ~ THE DUNES AND THE BEACH, ~D LANDSCAPING NECESSARY OR DESIRABLE D~CLARING THAT THIS ORDINANCE SHAT.T. ITS ADOPTION." ne wished to speak in favor of the Nathaniel Weinshel, 2601 N. a petition with close to 800 the improvement of Boynton B Weinshel is proud of Boynton the beach. Mr. Weinshel tho' asset and they were letting that the City did not have tl according to plans, Therefo~ E. 3rd Court, Boynton Beach, presented names in favor of this bond issue for ach last night. Although Mr. Beach, he said he was not proud of ght the beach was the City's ~1 t be dep.leted. Mr. Weinshel understood e capital funds to improve the beach e, there has to be a bond issue. Mr. Weinshel stated he did n, would be for a period of ove~ the cost would be approximat~ and a home of $40,000.00 woul for the year. Mr. Weinshel s a ~1 asset. The Council and Weinshel was sure the feeling to have a beach they could be Stormet C. Norem, 436 N. W. 7 and also on behalf of the Norem said the Greater BoyntO~ the issue to go to referendum Mayor Harmening asked if anyo~ the proposed ordinance. Councilman deLong moved to adz and final reading. No discussion. Mrs~ padgett~ Mayor Harmening ~ice Mayor_~Tra~ger Councilmember Wooll, Councilman deLong Councilman Wright h like taxation but the bond issue thirty years. Mr. Weinshel understood ly 33¢ per 1,000 for the bond issue, ~ cost approximately $13.O0 in change ~id that would be the cost of improving 2ity wants a beautiful beach. Mr. of the people of Boynton Beach was proud of. Motion carried 5-0. zh St., Boynton Beach, spoke personally ~ton Beach Chamber of Commerce. Mr. Beach Chamber of Commerce was for and he was personally behind it. ~e wished to speak in oppOsition to )pt proposed Ordinance 82-3 on second w~ s~'~n~ed~ by ~ce~ayor.~auge~. rook a roll call vote on the motion: ~y - 38 - Aye Aye Aye Aye Aye MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Proposed Ordinance No. 82-4 Re: Amending Section 5-16 of Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances Adopting National Electrical Code, 1981 Edition City Attorney Vance read proposed Ordinance No. 82-4 on second and final reading, by title only: "AN ORDI~AANCE OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLOR/DA, AMENDING S~CTION 5-16 OF THE CODIFIED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, BY ADOPTING THE UNIFORM, MIN~ COUNTYWIDE AMENDMENT TO THE 1981 EDITION OF THE NkTIOXIAL ELECTRICAL CODE; PRDVIDING A REPEALER CLAUSE; PROVIDING A SAVINGS CLAUSE; PRO- VIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES." Mayor Harmening asked if anyone in the audience wished to speak in favor of the proposed Ordinance. He received no response. Mayor Harmening asked if anyone in the audience wished to speak in opposition to the proposed ordinance. He received no response. Councilman deLong moved to adopt proposed Ordinance No. 82-4 on second and final reading. The motion'was seconded by Councilmember Woolley. A roll call' vote on the motion was taken by Mrs. Padgett, as follows: Vice Mayor Trauger - Aye Councilman deLong - Aye Councilman Wright - Aye Councilmember Woolley - Aye Mayor Harmening - Aye Motion carried 5~0. Ordinances - 1st Reading None. Resolutions Proposed Resolution No. 82-F Re: Accepting Supplemental Agree- ment - Metric Engineering, Inc. - Co!mnunity Development City Attorney Vance read proposed Resolution No. 82-F by title only: "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BOYNTC~ BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE M~YOR AND CITY CT.~JK TO EXECITi~ ON BEHALF OF THE SAID CITY AN AGREY~ENT WITH METRIC ENG~G, INCORPORATED, SUPPLEMENTAL TO THAT CERTAIN AGREE- MENT ADOPTED BY RESOLUTION NO, 81-BBB." Councilman deLong moved the adoption of proposed Resolution No. 82-F, seconded by COuncilmember Woolley, - 39 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 Councilman deLong referred to a paragraph at the bottom of a Memorandum dated December 21, 1981 from Tom Clark., City Engineer, to Peter L. Cheney, City Manager, which ~ead: "Th ' ere. ms a cc~mltment of $20,000 by the lClty toward dralnage improve~nts for the target area includ~g ~he drainage area east of Seacrest now being studied by 'Metric Engineering, Inc." City Manager Cheney was sure that was program but was not sure whether they year or next year but stated that the Councilman deLong then asked about a ps letter from Victor Benitez, P.E., Presi Inc., to Mr. Peter Cheney, City Manages which read as follows: "We understand that the City shall re~ for soil survey work and percolation tes~ approved soils laboratory, as mutually designing the project." Councilman deLong noted there was no a~ it was included in the $'20,000.00. Cit dollars to do that and the dollars for County Community Development funds. T~ but they will get the.money back. M~. Community Development funding of $400, area. Mrs. Padgett took a roll call vote on Councilman deLong - Councilman Wrigh~ - Councilmember Woolley - Mayor Harmening - Vice Mayor Trauger - Motion carried 5-0. In lieu of. the lateness of the hour, V~ that the Mayor and City Manager scan t~ all items with the exception of the pay the Agenda of the next Regular CounCil ~ part of the drainage would have payments this funds are available. ragraph contained in the dent of Metric Engineering, · dated December 10, 1981, ~se Metric Engineering ~s performed by an reed to be necessary in )unt_on that and asked if y Manager Cheney said the the contract came from the e City agreed to pay it, Cheney said it was entirely 00.00 they have in this he motion, as follows: Aye Aye Aye Aye Aye ce Mayor Trauger requested e Agenda, and he moved that ment of bills be moved to Meeting. Mayor Harmening thought that meeting would be as long ss this meeting. Council- man deLong suggested the Council move the items along, as they may have a heavy calendar at the next ~eeting. OLD BUSINESS Preliminary 'Report - Phase I of Annexation Study Councilman deLong moved to accept the ~eport and pl.ace it on file. City Manager Cheney said he had a hand(ut for the Council that - 40 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 also included a discussion on the tremendous amount of mapping that the City had been doing. City Manager Cheney said it may be one issue the Council may want to postpone. Vice Mayor Trauger moved to table the item. The motion was seconded by Councilman deLong. No discussion. The'motion carried 5-0. Designation of Terms of Office - Civil Service Board Appointments Councilman Wright moved that Albert Furia serve two years on the Civil Service Board, seconded by Councilman deLong. No d~scussion. Motion carried 5-0. Vice Mayor Trauger moved that Dorothy Detweiler serve two years on the Civil Service Board, seconded by Councilman deLong. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. Consider Paper Recycling Proposal Councilman deLong moved to'accept the recommendation of City Manager Cheney in his memorandum of January 19, 1982 and asked that safd memorandum be made a part of the record, and authorize its implementation. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Trauger. No discussion. Motion carried 5~0. NEW BUSINESS Review of Proposed Parking Ordinance Changes for Referral to Planning and Zoning Board Councilman deLong moved, seconded by Vice Mayor Trauger, to refer the item to the Planning and Zoning Board. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. Consider Little Leaque Park Field Addition Councilman deLong moved to approve the reconLmendation, seconded by Councilmember Woolley. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. ADMINISTRATIVE Consider Change Order for Lift Stations 316 & 319 - Odophos Councilman deLong moved to accept the recommendat±on of City Manager Cheney, seconded by Councilmember Woolley. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. Streetlight Conversion - U. S. ~1 Councilman Wright moved to accept the report, seconded by Councilman deLong. - 41 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING There was no discussion, and the motion carried 5.-0. JANUARY 19, 1982 Accept Resignation from Community Redevelopment Agency Councilman deLong moved, seconded'-by Vice Mayor Trauger, to accept the resignation of Ann. Barrett from the Community Redevelopment Agency. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0, Request for Refund on Cemetery Lots 462 A & B, Block N Request for Disinterment from Lot 507 B, Block $ 1. Request for Refund on Cemetery Lot 507 B, Block S Councilman deLong moved, seconded by Vice Mayor Trauger, to approve all of the above requests. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. Consider Recommendations from Community Relations Board Councilman Wright moved to accept the recommendations of the Community Relations Board, seconded byCouncilman deLong.. Councilman deLong said'it was advisable to give the money as pro- posed by the Community Relations Board. The motion carried 5-0. Report on Black Awareness Day Activities - Requested by Councilman Samuel Lamar Wright Councilman Wright announced that he would place a copy of his report in the boxes of theCounc±lmembers and on file. He urged the people to talk to their legislators, as they need more support. Councilman Wright said he would make sure with the City Manager that all expenses are paid. Councilman deLong moved to accept the report and place it on file, seconded by Councilmember Woolley, No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. List of Payments - Month of December, 1981 Councilman deLong moved to accept the list .of payments and place them on file. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Trauger and carried 5-0. Approval of Bills City Manager Cheney read the following bills for approval: - 42 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 1982 l. e 0 10. Air Ail Air Conditioning, Inc. Installation of Air Condition'& ducts at Per sonnel/Puscchasing Pay frcm Fed. Revenue Sharing 320-132-513.60-73 Per bid 12/2/81, Council approved 12/15/81 Allied Chlorine& Chamical Prod. Chlorine for Water Treatment Plant Pay frcm Water & Sewer Revenue 401-332~533-30-63 Atlantic Scale & Equipment Co. 1 SS Refrigerator & C~mpressor for same Pay from GeneralFund 001-221-522-60-42 Council approved 12/15/81 City of Boca Raton Operational costs for South Pa'Lin Beach County Dispatch Center for first quarter of 81-82 Budget Pay frc~ General Fund 001-211-521-40-79 Ernst &Whinney Interim billing for professional services through November, 1981 for year ended 9/30/81 Pay from GeneralFund 3,840.00 Pay from Water & Sewer Revenue 3,405.00 Halsey & Griffith Supplies for Central Office Supply & Various Departments Pay frc~ General Fund IBM Corporation Monthly charge for IBM Copier III Pay from GeneralFund 001-194-519-40-22 Metric Engineering Co., Inv. ~3 N. E. 10th~venue Project Pay frcmGeneral Fund 001-000-115-87-00 Funds reimbursible'CommunityDevelopmentFunds Pierce Tire Co., Inc. Tires & Tubes for EquipmentMaintenance for various departments Pay from General Fund 001-193-519-30-22 001-193-519-30-93 4,654.39 20.00 Russell &Axon Professional Services rendered on various projects: 403-000-169-01-00 $ 8,646.90 403-000-169-11-00 22,7i4[13 403-000-220-67-00 4,559.75 403-000-220-68-00 1,324.78 Sc~e funds reimbursible escrowed account P.B. County School Board & Burger King Some funds 75% reimbursible by EP~. 1,7845.00 4,093.04 1,050.00 63,963.75 7,245.00 1,531.41 1,270.00 2,520.00 4,674.39 37,245.56 ~INUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 19, 1982 11. State of Florida Dept. of He~t~ & Rehabilitative Serv. Contract 09A-1889 Florence Fuller Child Develp. Center Payment 1 of'4 November 1, 1981 1,050.00 Payment 2 of 4 February 1, 1982 t,650.00 Pay frc~n Federal Revenue Sharing 320'641-564-40-5A Per Council Action 9/1/81 $ 2,100.00 12. R. J. Sullivan Corp. Est. ~2 For City of B.B. Chemical Feed System Pay fr~m Utility General Fund 403-000-169~-01-00 11,110.71 13. Isiah Andrews Driver for Senior Citizens Club - 1WK k. Pay frc~ Federal Revenue Sharing 320-641-564-40-5A Ordinance #73-15, passed 5/15/73 70.20 14. Willie Ruth McGrady Server for Senior Citizens Club - 1 wk. Pay from Federal Revenue Sharing 320-641-564-40-5A Ordinance #73-15, passed 5/15/73 67.20 Councilman deLong moved that the bills, having been found to be in order, be paid. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Trauger and carried 5-0. Consent Agreement Re: Southern Bell ROger Saberson/LawSon Industrial Park,/ City Manager Cheney asked the Council to approve a consent agreement where Lawson Industrial Park and Southern Bell will use an easement that is in ~e City's name in order ~o put a Southern Bell line in. Mr. Cheney informed the Council the~e would be no problem in it because the water and sewer will no{ go there anyway. Vice Mayor Trauger moved to approve the agreement, seconded by Councilman deLong. No discussion. Motion carried 5-0. ADJOURNMENT Councilman deLong moved, seconded b~ Vice Mayor Trauger, to adjourn. The motion carried 5-0, and the meeting was properly adjourned at 11:10 P. M. - 44 - MINUTES - REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING ATTEST: JANUARY 19. 1982 CoSncil~e~m~r- -~ City Clerk ReC~vi~gT~sS~arY - 45- 12/S1/~l 2ITY OF BOYNTON BEACH CHECK ~ VE~D3~ t~ VE~DO~ NA~E 636 190615- SAX ARTS PAGE I X. ADMINISTRATIVE: I cc: Finance "~EC< DATE TOTAL' AMOUNT CRAFTS l 1/36/81 15.54CR 455.26 ..................... 53.79 ...... 108.59 227.58 --, ' -.63.23 343.55 397.99 ................ 451.73 88.75 .......... 88.56 451.39 155.61 131U 283034 WILLIE BAGLEY 12/01/81 1319 322435 ..... C2NSTANCE-BAISH ..................... 12/01/81 1020 021540 FRANK AD BEDNARICK 12/01/61 1321 325483 DBE BJTLER 12/01/81 1022 .... 03353t-- --RENA-.C. ARRIER 12/01/81 1023 333600 CALLIE CLANTON 12/01/81 1324 340432 J2HN HARRINGTON '12/01/81 1025 ..... 222794 ..... JOHN-Vt£KI ......................... 12/0t/81 1325 394653 MJRIEL HDLZMAN 12/01/81 1327 134538 FRANK JOHNSON 12/01/81 1028 ......... 10450~ ...... GEORGE--A,--JOHNSON- -~-12/01/81 1029 13451~ J]H~ 4DHNSTDN 12/01/81 1333 373313 VIRGINIA E, KEISTER 12/01/81 1031 .380006 ...... GRETCHEN-LU6Y ................... 12/01/81 .............. 410,77 ....... 1032 156303 ELEANOR PUFFER 12/01/81 : .'?.~::: 91.28 1033 190945 JOHN SCHNEIDER 12/31/81 . 133.20 133~ ......... 190940 .t2/Ol./8t_~u_...~'J!i -2-53,66 1335 192592 ADA SHOOK 12/01/81 202.21 1036 450024 ~IANK SMITH 12/01/81 ~1,21 2~2553 JA"ES 233452 OLIVE WALLACE. 490018 .... 1038 1039 1041 1342 1043 - 1044 1345 1045 1047 1348 1049 1353 1051 1052 .... t~55 1143 .... 1144 1209 I213 12Ii 1212 121~ 121~ 1215 1216 1217 1218 121~ 231583 W,T, WELCH 12/01/81 82,55 256~20 ~ILDRED A, ZWART 12/~1/81 77.13 3212t~ ---BRAD~DRD--BAXL-EY ........ = .... 12/01/81 .... : ....~--8-75,15 106450 GEORGE JUNNIER ' 12/31/81 ";'.!. ::.::::"': 945.98' 194593 THEODORE SORG: 12/01/81 "':] t,112.80 ' 1~5361- -~RS.--FL.ORENCE~-~dLLtVAN ........ 12/01/81 194.10 091552 H~RDLD HERRIN~ 1Z/al/B1 33.34 12~59~ NORMAN LDLATTE 12/91/81 42.46 t94290- -KEN-SNOW .......................... 22633~ J]HN Z. TUITE " t2/01/81 ']'.: 9!.50 222792 JOHN VICKI - 12/31/81 ii.~: 820o89 235495 CUR[LS- Eo--~RIGHT ........ ~ ......12/01/81-- :-~ .1,~74.79 ...... 324725 B]YNTDN CITY FEDERAL CRED 31~24] ISIAH ANDRE~S 130950 ........ WILLTE -RUTH-MCGRADY 270015 HENRY ALBERS i51705 PETTY CASH POLICE' t61TZD ...... PETT~- CASH-NA~ER.-~-~SEWER ........... 1533~3 PALM BEACH JR. COLLEGE 15038g PALM BEAC~ JR, COLLEGE 153383 ---~ALM-EEACq-gRo-COLLEGE 153353 PALM BEACH JR, COLLEGE 394291 INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE 33289-~----G.ITYDF-.~OYNTON BEACH 032895 CITY 3F BEYNTON BEACH 663018 VERNITA TJRNQUIST 423324 .... JAuES -R, -PATTERSON .... ' 12/31/81 273.00 11/25/81 42,12 11/25/81 .................. 40,32 ............................ 12/~1/81 722,00 12/32/81 :~ 91.49 '? '~'. ' 12/02/81 ................. 44,42 12/$2/81 30.00 12/32/8i 39o00 12/33/8t .................... BO.DO ................................ 12/0318l 15.00 12/32/81 193.~6 12/33/'81~ ......... 163,-t79.06 ..................... ~-' '.--~ .... 12/93/81 25~644.57 12/34/81 178.39 12/34/81 .... 561,86 .............................. CHEEK,." VE~DO~ " CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH VEN)oR NAME PAGE 2 CHECK DATE TOTAl_ AMOUNT ADVANCE AIR C3NDITIONIN$ 12/32~/81 498. O0 12E1 ;312773 AIR C3MPRESSOR WORKS INC 12134181 401.93 - 1222 31~723 ...... ~LLEN INS'JRANCE.--AGENCY .............. 12/3~/Bi.__£ ............. 5~,20~.00 ................................... ,. ~ . 1223 313783 ALEIED CHLORINE ~ 12/0~/B1 ~ 2~0~6.52 122~ 21~2~0 ISIAH ANDREWS 12/D~/81 73.20 1225 315703-~- ASS~D-W- OF. F~-DR-I9~ ................. 12/3~/.B-1 50~.g3 ~-~']' 1225 315315 A~LAN~IC NIGH SCH3OL BAND 12/0~/81 375.90 _~ 1227 315313 ~T3 STEREO~INC. 12/3~/81 ~2~ 3~3,00 1228 ......... 323235- F' 3"~- F-'~'ER T't F'IC AT I ON- B DA ........ 12t3~/81 ..................... 25.00 ., 1229 020~3g Td5 B~KER ~ TAYLOR CO. 12/3~/81 7.20 ~s. 12~3 OZO~D TNE BAKER ~ TAYLOR CO. 12/3~/8i 292.22 . ~';~'~ 1232 O21231 BO. OF, CO. COMMISSIONERS 12/3~/81 11~68~.00 .... 123~ 3215~D BE~NE EXTERMINATING CO. 12/0fi/81 50.00 ~ ,r,~' 1235 321595 JAN BERTH~OFF 12/0fi/81 1235 32~718 ~ETTER BJSINESS F3RMS~IN2 12/3q/81 ..... 1237 .- 02~37.9. B3CA- RATON-ACADEMY-=6AND-..-~._~!2/3~/8[~= ....... 225.00 ~-.r~ 1238 D2~383 BOCA RAT3N MIDDLE SCHOOL 12/Oq/81 225.30 ~z~ 1239 ~2~59D Tfl3MAS BOJREGY ~ CO. 12/D~/81 21.30 .... 12~0 .... 02~651 ....... R. ~---BOwKER ~-.:~ 12~1 D2~725 B3YNTON ~ITY FE3ER~L CRED 12/0~/81 :~ 1242 D2~753 B3YNTON BEACH RETIREMENT 12/3q/81 ]~]]'" 12~ 025370 ..... DR.--JANES E. BUFFAN .................... 12/0~/8t ................... 203.01 ~ :::. 12~ 333298 JJ3Y "ALANDRA 12/3~/81 15.00 ~ I2~5 330303 CAL DWELL~ PACETTI ~8ARROW ~ 12/0~/81 .... 12~6 33057D JIU CATLEDGE ........................... 12/04/8~ .................. 25.30 12~7 331553 CERTIFIED LABORATORIES 12/04/81 10~.30 ':' "- ' ~' ~:- I2~8 032~0D C~ASE MANHATTAN BANK [Z/D~/81 10~175.00 -'-':' 125312~ D3~553332~13 ..... CflEMI2AL.c3CA COLA:ONCEPTS"BOTTLING ..................... CO. 12/D~/8112/0~/81 151.5215~'00 .......................... ~.~ ~ 125[ 3~6582 C3L~NsIA UNIVERSITY PRESS 12/S~/81 :~:$" 1252 3~3535 .... D~IS WATER ~-~AS~E. INDUS ...... 12/D4/81 ........ 1.5~663.00 1253 ~052~ OLLYCE DAVIS 12/0fi/81 25.00 ~,.~' 125~ D~l~05 DEALERS COST 20~P. 13.00 1255 D~IB ....... DE-BRA TJRF ~ [NDJSTRI~L ....... :;-.= 12/3~/8~ ................ ~1.~0 ~-.,~:, 1255 D~5~13 EDMOND DU~Y 12/3~/81 25 O0 1257 3~6~5D JDq~ ~. DUNKLE 12/0~/81 15.B0 '~'F 125~ -3532~7 ...... D~At~E EARNH~RT _ ~j, 052297 D~NE EARNHART 12/D~/8[ 25.90 1259 353331 EAST LAKE MIDDLE SCHOOL 12/D~/B1 225.30 -Z~"~' 1251 1260 356gOg253900 ---EMERGENCY-~MEDICALENI~G INDJSTRIES [ SAFET ..... 12/D~/8112/0~/81 ...... 1*72D.20~9.G8 ~'J'/, 1252 2527B] FINANCIAL GRAPHIC ARTS.I~ 12/04/81 195.72 1253 35278g ---GIRE CONTROL. DIGEST ............... 12/0~/81 .............. 62.00. . _ .~. 125~ 262823 FIREMEN'S RELIEF [ 12/0~/8i 3~193.7~ ....... 1255 D55752 FL2R[DA NATIONAL BANK 12/D4/8i - - 1266 363793. FLORIDA---.RECREATION 6 PARK 12/3~tB1 ............... 171.00 .. . ....... ]~ ...... ;~ 1257 25379~ ~L]&IDA STA,TE U~IVERSITY 12/34/81 37.00 ~s~, 1268 36~555 F3REST HILL HIGH SCHOOL ~ 121;34181 375.00 ~ ~j · t25~ 36~591 ..... K ATH~--.-~S SELMAN ................ 12/D~/81 ............... 18.00 .... . ....................... 7 12/31/81 CITY OF BOYNTON BE~CH PAGE CHECK # VENDOR # VENDOR NAWE CHECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 1273 373355 GaLE RESEARCH CD. 12/34/81 182.30 1271 3?3525 GLADES CENTRAL HIGH SCHO3 12/3A/81 402,00 1272 . D76635 DAVIO-GD£~ENOUR .................... 12/G6/.81 ........ !98o57 .......... 1273 383339 HALSEY'S t2/34/81 1274 383313 HALSEY & GRIFFITH, INCo 12/3~I81 1275 .... 38~425__~AND~5 151.85 ~223~28I~___~267,65___ 1275 38~532 HDLMA' INTERNATIONAL CORP 12/36/8Z 179.41 1277 38658~ HDUSE OF GOLD 12/3~/81 1~763o00 '- 127a _ 28q6~5 ..... HD~IZON,Z~E?~A~AZiNE .................. 12/2~/81 ............ 1279 2~6331 INTERNATIONAL CITY 12/3~/81 1283 D9~312 INTERNATIONAL MFOA CAREER ..' I2/0~/8~: 1282 130313 JACK'S CAMERA CENTER 12/0~/8i 795.23 1283 131595 LEE J~FFERS 12/D~/81 t2~5 LlO~O0 JEAN KARR& CO, .' 't2/3~'8i--~T~-~TM 1285 1288 11~503 KDP? KING PRINTING CENTER 12/~4/81 18.95 -- 125~ 11~5~1 ELEAN3R KRUSELL 12/24/81 1292 I , 52 LANTANA'JR, HIGN SCHOOL B: 12/~/8t':~':?:~ ..... 1293 ...... 1265D~ L~NGVt~ LIMF ' · - - 225o90" : r: 129~ 13O~D~ RARB~a MANESS 12/3~/81 25.00 1295 133950 WILLIE R~TH MCGRADY 12/24/81 67 20 1297 132715 MI<E MICHAELS ---12/9~/81 ....... 1S2~ 15335) PAHDKEE HIGH S~HOOL BAND 12/34/81 ~CO.O0 1301 150383 PALM BEACH JR. COLLEGE 12/3~/81 68.00 13~2 152~13 ...... B&L~ ~.EAC~-N.E~SPaRERS_ _. 1333 152753 PICARD CHEMICAL CO. -12/0~/8i 58.75 I3~5 182771 JA~ES RHDaEN SR. - 12/3~/8i 300.30 1327 18~516 BOB RDBERTS l]Og ~9~5:97 S. CENT. NASTEWATER TREAT 12/0~/8l ~0~788,00 1513 195qg~ LD~IE ST, LDRENT 12/0~/81 25.00 I~I11~12 .... 2325~]19599~-'- S[ANDARD-SA~IIARY.SURPL~BELLE THOMPSON ........ 12/0~/8112/0~/81 ................ 215.00 39.90 .............................. 1~I~ 23~6.77 TDMN OECDR~TOR SERVISE 12/04/81 ~55.10 131~ 235970 T~I~ LAKES HIGH SCHO]L..BA !2/3~/81 .... 375.00SR 131~ 2~5970 ~IN LAKES HIGH SCHOOL BA 12/3~/81 ~75.30 ..... 1]15 ~15~ ~NI~E~SITY PReSsEs OF FLO 12/3~/81 15,00 1315 .... 2216ZD~LENC.I~oMMUNiTY_.COLLEG__~ ..... 12/3418~ .................. 150.00 ........................ .-_ 1~1~ 222799 VIDEO C SE~LING,INS. 12/04/81 5,055.00 1~18 233~51 ~ALL&CE g TIERNAN 12/0~/81 ':7 12131/91 ~BA507 STTY OF BDYNTON BEACH PAGE CHECK g VENDOR # ~E~3oR NAME CHECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 1320 232550 T3M WILLIAMS I2/24/8I 572.00 132I 232T9] EJNICE ~ILSON 12/2~/8I 625.50 1322 232798---~[LS~N R~AN LOCKSMI.TH.CO ......... I2/34/8! ............. 442.52 1323 2q1602 XEROX CORPORATION i2/~4/8i 492.75 1324 212152 J.S. POSTMASTER 12/24/81 5.00 1326 150382 PALM BEACH JR. COLLEGE 12/24/81 1327 2320Di CITY 3F 5AYNTON BEACH 12/~7/8i 20.00 1329 296427 HJNTERS RJN GOLF & RACOdE 12/08/8i : . . 603.00 1332 332B95 CIT~ OF B3YNTON BEACH I2/11/81 143,483.53 1332133] ....... 343004330S07 ..... DAVIO--~-GALEOwA.YwiLLIAM HILLIARD ...... .... IC/II/SiIZ/i1/8! I52.1324Z'93 .......................... ._ 1333 490021 TH~MA, S' WILLIAMS 12/11/51 159.00 1335 211353 AAqINISTRATIVE CHAR~ES 12/11/81 31,666.67 1335 213753 RCBERT K-ALSOFRDM,pH.D. 12Zll/81 1338 252313 HALSEY & ~RI~FITH, INC. 12/11/81 388.865R 1338 215000 ATLANTIC H~RD~ARE 12/11/81 1339 ...... 216333 -.~JT3~-{~DU[IS, iNr 29.00 .... ~ ................... 12/11/81 ............. 252.15 ....... 13~2 222131 B&L FEED SUPPLY,INC. 1341 323179 12/I1/81 83.86 B.B. AUTO PARTS~ INC. ' 12/11/B1 ' :: 121.13 ii' 13621343 '' 22aASg323~S~---T~E'-BAKE~'-[-~AYLO~BAKER 8 TAYLOR COMPANIESCD'-'-]]L ...... 12/i1/Bll2/I1/Bi ...... : ....... ~5'0&9.29 ............... -- ' 134~ 221537 BEA~E EXTERMINATIN~ 1345 12/11/51 277.20 ~2~522 .... BETTY.~BORON.L .................. 12%11/8 13~6 224598 BDYNTONeS GoA.L.A. ...... i ................... 12/11/BI BOD.O0 ........... 1347 324~13 BCYNTDN AUTO SUPPLY 12/11/81 654.44 . . 1348 _ 22~725 ..... BCYNTDN-.CI.~_FEDEEA~_CREO ....... 12/11/51 .............. i0,915.49 ............... 1349 32~7:2:8 BDYNTON BCH.NENS JOURNAL 12/11/81 t3:.20 ' . .~-:' 135~ 224733 82YNTON BEACH RETIREMENT 12/i1/81 6,137'.87 1351 ~2~735..B]YNTON GJN_.~ LOCK, .INC ............. 12/11/81 ...... 13531352 225580 024785 BR~DARTBAY~TDN TRAVEL ,INC. AGENCY IN: 12/11/81 547~20 ................. :'--~--: .... 12/II/8I I7.09 I354 226422 .8~RgJGHS COR~Q~A%!ON 1355 330185 C.K.'S LD:KSHDP, INC.' ............ I2/i1/B[ ........ ~I5.53 1356 030298 JJ~Y CALANDRA 12/ii/BI I6.50 ....................... ' ........ 1357 332405 J.N. CHEATHA~_iNC' 12/ll/B1 i~O0 ' 1358 33~599 CAMMERCE :LEARING~'~US~ ........ 1Z/il/Bi 1,423~B0 12/ii/B1 ........ 2iS&SC 1359 234604 CCMME~[IAL HYDRAULICS ~ i2/11/8i Ii8~20 1351 242625 ...... DIAZIT CD., TNC. - ...... - ............ ~1~75 12/11/81 11210T 1362 35133~ ECWARCS ELECTRIC CORP. 12/11/81 33~58 1363 3539S0 __EME~SENCY ........... MEDICAL & ~A~.T ............ 12/11/81 ............... l~.lO 1364 25282S FIREMEN,S RELIEF g 12/11/81 1,635.60 1365 362900 mIRST BANK ~ TRUST 12/11/81 52,20 135~ . O$CgD! ...... EIRST._.BAN< ~ TRDST_OE PAL ...... 12/II/81 -!54.~70 ...... 1357 063712 FL]RIDA LEAGUE OF CITIEs IC/I1/Bi lO~.,O0 1368 263752 FL]RICA NATIONAL BANK 12/11/8I 24,213.56 1359 253782 FL~RIDA.P3~ER. & LIGHT CD. 12/tl/8i 62~082.49 MBA5~7 [.HECK,," VENDOR ~.~ ~ENOOR NAME CHECK DATE '-ITY OF BDYNTDN BEACH PAGE 5 TOTAL. AMOUNT 1373 365533 FRaNKqDUSE ELECTRIC 12/11/81 47.56 1371 355590 CHARLES FREDERICK 12/11/81 23.56 1372 3555G~_ _FJTURA_RRi. NTI.~G ................ 12/11/81 .............. B.OD 1373 371553 GENERAL GMC TRUCK 12/11/81 43,91 i374 DT5480 G~IFFIN E2UIPMENT i2/Z1/8I I52.50 1375 .... 280309 _HALSEYO_S- iZ/ll/81 .......... 3.L3.28.]-- 1375 333313 HALSEY & GRIFFITH, INC. 12/11/81 1376 DBO310 qALSEY & SRIFFITH~ INC. 12/11/31 1377 ...... 33342~ .... ~A~DRIVES.._O.E.DE.LRAY,~.INC ......... 12/11/81 1378 283~25 HAND'S 12/11/8I 1379 381723 HE~LETT PACKARD 12/11/81 1332 ........ 232~25 HI~LIG~LIS_..ED~_~I.LDRESL~J'' ]_12/11./.8~"..' .. - 1381 284509 WENDY WOLLIEN 12/11/81 1382 334523 H]LLY 'ACRJMUL~TDR ~ 12/11/8i 1383 ...... 39~Ig~_!~DJ.SIB. I6_L_~_M[~N!.2.!R~_ 12KllA~i ...... 19D.O~ 1384 09~209 ~DUSTRIAL-WELDING,'INC~'. 12/11/81'". : 1385 29~253 INSTITUTE DF TR~NSPORTATI't:t::'::?::': 12/11,/81 ~:i:':~ 51,50: .':' 1385 ....... i.~SQ~ J.~E~ E~I~PM~NI_.~ --±~.'::', IZ/12/~l ..... ' · - 1387 135~51 JJND INDJSTRIES 12/11/81 1~487.57 1385 11155Z J~MES KEEL 12/11/81 13~9 __ _ 112315 ..... 5]R~_~TTERI.AL5~__I~C~ ..... 12/11/81 ....... ~9,0~__ 1393 123299 LEE LABRDTT .- . . 12/11/81 153,00 1391 123323 LAFRANCE EQUIPMENT CORP. !2/11/81 '" 742.83 13g2 123492 tASK LIoHTINo. g..E~ECT.,..._] 12/11/81'.~.· ~ _ 35.10 1393 ..... I21525 P&JL DAVIS LE2LAIR 12/i1/8I B.75 1394 121555 LES-RAY BDBCAT~ INC. I2/II/8I 223.20 I395 .. I~4595 _.~DNG-L~AE_~_U~LICAT!ONS_ _ I2/II/Si I3~5 1332~D M.T.A. E3JIP~ENT CORP. I2/ll/81 28~,52' I397 133403 MANHATTAN TROPHIES I2/ii/81 388.60 1398 I33565 ...... MAJ~.¥'S..!DDL.SHES~ ................... 12/i1/BL_.] .............. 73.75 1399 13395~ WILLIE RJTH MCGRADY I2/ii/81 57.20 1403 133~58 M~GRAW HILL COST INFO.SYS 12/11/81 32.90 1431 133950 _ .~2$Ra~_._r. 5IL.L 300~...23 ............ 12/11/81 ............ ~.29 .............. 1432 131755 MIAMI ELEVATOR CO* 12/11/81 63.30 1433 132723 ~IAMI HERALD ,~ 12/11/81 g 59.81 ' 1434 ..... 132~15~ ~iKEMICH~ELS£~ ~-:' .i'.-~]1:.'~'S_]___12/11/.81 155.DQ_ ........... t405 132771 ~ILLER DODGE 12/11/81 83.84 1435 134595 ~3NEY 12/11/81 2~o00 1~37 135423 ~JNICIPAL POLICE ................... 12/11/81 ........ 1,994.97 1~08 135423 MJNICIPAL SUPPLY & SIGN 12/11/81 335.00 1~9 137535 LEE ~YLES TRANSMISSION ~2/11/81 225.00 1~13 1~1731 ..... NEPIU~E METER--CD ...................... 12~11/81 .......... 1~19~.39 ..................................... 1411 15~135 PSG PJBLISHING CO,~ INC, 12/21/81 77,35 i412 15238I D~LM BCd. JR. COLLEGE 12/1I/8i 1S.O0 1413 ~59~13 DALM-BEAEH-.NE~SPAPERS ............... i2/11/8i ................ 2~5.25 141~ 151511 PEACOCK'S RADIATOR SERVIC 12/11/81 282.35 1415 152753 PI£ARD CHEMICAL CO. 12/11/31 527.47 1416 - ,152793~- .PiERCETtRE £O..~--INC. ......... 12/11/81 .......... 3~171.~8 ........................... 1~17 165339 P~E~TICE-HALL, INC. 12/11/81 85.87 1413 155233 eJBLIX MARKET 12/11/81 24.85 1~19 18049~ RANSELINE FEED.-&--SUPPLY ......... 12/11/81 ................ 228.50 MBAS07 12/31/B1 ~HECK # VE~DO~ 3ITY OF BDYNTDN BEACH PAGE 6 U_R R E N L.__M..ON~L_H ..... C.-H_E_..~.JC_S fl CE~DOR NAME CHECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 1422 1421 1422 1423 1424 1425 1425 1427 1428 1429 I430 i431 1432 1433 1434 1435 1435 1437 1438 1439 1443 1441 1442 1444 1445 1445 1447 1448 1453 I45~ 1455 1456 1459 1452 183496 RANGER CONSTRUCTION INDUS 12/11/81 192833 RINKER M~TERIALS CORP. 12/11/B1 19~822 _~2YAL.PAL~_DINNER~THEATER ......... 12/1LZB1 193515 SATTELLITE PRODUCTS, INC. 12/11/81 19052~ SATUROAY EVENING POST I2/Ii/BI ... 19095R .... DLYVE__E~C~OOLEY ........... 12/l-i/B1 193990 S~ITT¥'S SERVICE SHOP 12/11/81 19~594 S]JIH FLgRIDA MACK TRUCKS 12/11/81 _ _ 194725 .... S]ULHERN_.~USI~_£O .................. ~_2/ll/,B1 196013 ST~TF DF FLORIDA.DEPT. OF 12/11/81 195015 STATE OF FLOR:IDA 12/11/81"::::i'"' ._~195178_ DSCAR.-B. 5II-S~I..N ....... - 12/L1/81 ....... 200100 TAB P~ODUSTS ~O. 12/11/81 293383 TALLAHASSEE HILTON 12/11/81 28.56 135.20 _75..00 ........................... 85.51 19.95~ .15~00 13.55 107.02 __209.53 ...... 235,95 226.78 ' 312.0~ ..... ' .............. · ::.~-- 174.48 280.00 23253~ . l~qMP-SON~-~AYWARD~CHE-~ICAL ....... 12/11/8.1 ............ 238.25.-~- ................ 21015~: ~J.S. POST~4ASTER . .': .i 12/11/8I .' '"~ ]~! 34.50 ::-.i= / .:".! . 215415 U~IVE~$AL BEACH $ERvic'E'."i:~:'::~... 12/11/81 '~"7~"::!.:;?' ~ 311,00 ' 2334~ __EA.~L_.~ALLACE-MDTD~S,.-I~S. ' '.12/t.1/81. "3':~:::.5:'.~-8.7-2,90 ' ' 233453 EARL NALLACE FORD, INC. 12/11/8i 21.84 232545 WATER HYDRANT SERVICE 12/11/81 ff~833.33 23~625, J.J.A. W3LF FRESH DIST. ~ · 12/1t/81 :'~ 7/::~::~:;~· :6'50 ..'~':." ":~'~.::: '~ 2~1603 XEROX CORPORATIDN . 12/11/81 .'::.]:'~:/:::":}~.'.'. '569.O5.: :'~ ' : ' . .~':.:~' .' B9~O~5_ CARDL .MGARDLE_--._]__~_ ~-:.~ .... 12/11/81 ]_ ...::'- :--_:.55.~8 ~ ........... ~1]:_]~: ' : ' ' 5B0~3~ AD3COR CDRP. 12/11/B1 9~.55 533035 ~LEX ~LBEqT 12/11/81 23.53 5339~5 ...... E~PiE_ ALI~ANN ........................ 12/ll/81 ........... ~.50 ........... 540021 DE,EL Bo BAILEY 12/11/81 540138 LEDNA BAKER 12/11/81 54~I4~ qELEN J. SOND I2/II/81 54314I BDYNTON LODGE I2/II/BI 54~i42 ....... VEgNA _BLY~HER$ ................................. i2/IIlBI 540143 ~JSSELL M. BROWN 12/tl/81 540144 JANE S. BjRNETTA 12/11/81 2.80/ 4.70 1~.90 ............... 26.55 23.80 .................. 9.90 ................................... 12.20 27.20 540145 .... otis _NIXON BROWN ............... 12/11/81 ........................ 2.20 ............................ -_ 553031 CASTLE BLDRS, INC. 12/11/81 39.00 5533~8 CARTIER CDNSTRIJCTION CD. 12/11/81 12.42 552095 . GA~Y ~4L.LAWAY ............................. 12/11/81 .......... 553095 PAJLI~E ~qISH3LM 1_2/11/81 11.90 550997 ROBERT E. COOK;':-. :J.:" :: :"' ' 1'2/11/81 43.00 553Q~ .... ~HER.5.C~EL_~RDU~_'_i.~]:' .~. i~..~2 12/-11./81 ~_~--_ ~ ..... 5.15 ~ .................. :: : ' :~__ 550025 DREXEL PROP. INC 12/11/81 263.64 550095 CAROL DODLEY IZ/11/81 55.50 1454 590353 12/11281_ _ ~22.2Q ................................ 1455 590072 GIGLIDTTI COMP OF FLA. 12/11/81 433.26 1455 59008I SELVA GANESH i2/iI/BI 37.30 1467 590082 ..... ~tRIS _GEMSMIN ........................... 12/11/81 ................. ~.30 ........... 145B 500075 HD~A~D HA~BESON 12/11/81 4=70 .......... 1459 b33377 HASKELL SD. 12/11/81 152.94 1473 533079 MARY HOCHSTEI~ ........... 1Z/il/B1 ............... 12.20 ................ 12/31/81 ~TTY DF BDYNTON BEACH PAGE 7 2 J q R E._N T_._M. ~.__I_H. __C_H_.E_.F~_~_S C~ECK # VENDOR ~ VEWDOR NAME CHECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 147~"- 5DOD?9 ~AVERICK HDLLIN 12/11/81 1472 530083 JOHN HDMDNEY 1473 523281 __SJNQ&~ M~EBNER 1474 532082 HARDY CONTR~CTORS~:INC, 1475 530091 HJNTERS RJN 1475 ._ 613027 ..... J.OE.IZZ.I._ _ I~77 520035 EDWARD JASIEC~! 1~78 522335 LDJISA JONES 1~79 .... 532~51 5E~_K~ ....................... 12/11Z8i ......... 1480 530052 H~GH J, KENNEDY . 12/i1/8i'/ 9,40 1481 542053 ~A~L LIPPERT : . 12/11/8t: 1~82 ...... 54235~ ~ED[GE_G, I~GAN__ ::; 1Z/I! 1483 550037 MILNOR CORP, 12/11/8i 27,20 1484 552149 ~ILO~] DEV, CORP, 12/1]/81 155,90 1~85 ........ 55215~_ ..BA~i~E]L~iLL_Er~_.DF].,B ........ 12/11/_8~ ........ 60,00 1~86 550155 JAMES MILLER. . ':i~.': 12/I1/81 i . '/ii.:' 1~87 552157 R]BERTA MILL$1:~ i~i. '!:=;.::.~. 1~88 ...... 552158 ~.OLAINYA_~U~ _ ' · 12/II/8~i"'~ '--"i~';''':- 1489 550159 ARTHUR MATTHEWS 12/11/81 2.50 1~92 553173 ELMER Do MCARTHUR 12/11/81 15,30 15.20 t 14~1 1~92 1493 1494 1495 1496 1497 12/11/81 27,20 ...... i2/11/81 .... 9.~0 . ~ 12/11/81 :~' ~.': 42,10 12/11/81 593,70 ..... 12/11%81 ' ]' :~i:j: --]-1,50__~ 12/11/81 26,15 12/11/8I 22,20 1498 1499 153~ 1531 1 5 3 z 1533 1535 1536 1507 !53~ 1510 1511 1512 1512 151~ t 515 1516 1517 1519 732098 R4]OES CONS%RUCTION INC,. 12/11/81 , : 33.75 733099 DON RAAEN ' ' 12/11/81 .: 17,40 -__ ~201'0.~--~ [_~ARD__R_AA.S[~--_~£]._._..: .1..2/11./81:' ~:?i]~ 733131 DR. aNTHONy RASCATI 12/11/81 9.15 700132 ESTHER REARDON I2/I1/Bi 25.80 73012~ .... ~3~G~._~. RILEY ........................... 12/11/81 ..................... ~.70 ...... 712151 LAJRE~£E SELESNICK 12/11/81 ~.20 050019 .... _GEORSE__H .NEiSS ...................... 12/11/81 .............. 4.70 ................................... 670932 T~OMAS O'~DYLE 12/11/81 ~,70 : 570933 gZEAN PLAZ~ 12/11/81 39.00 5TO03~. ONONIARIQ. OE_ P&LMBEA£H ............. ]2/11/81 ..... :_._%~ ..... 90.20 ............................... .--. _. 580073 JOAN PATTERSO~ 12/11/81 4.70 580076 LEON PERRY 12/11/81 27.20 .. 7330Z~ .... ~.I~G~OQD ~UILDEB& ......... 12/[1/8Z ................ 66.70 ..................... 713152 HERMAN SILVERMAN 712153--_~AJL_SMIL~ ........... 713154 SDJTHERN ORNAMENTALS 720053 E~MIE TAMBER 123051 ..... MA~¥_ E~ICE ............ 720052 MIGUEL TORRES 122058 DAVID TUBBS 12/11/81 ': ' 30.00 ...... 7~001~ ._RICHA~L~ ~A~II~LE". ~ ................ 12/11/81 .................. 56.50CR ...................................... 740014 RICHARD V~STINE 12/11/81 56,50 7~3015 PIERRE N. VALCENA 12/11/81 27.20 . 7~0.01~ M,,~BEI E.~/.AUGH~L_ ................. 12./I1/81 ............... . ....... 4.70 ................................ 740018 MIGOEL A. VAS~UEZ - 12/11/81 52.13 7G~2~ GEORGE VESCIO 12/II/Si 2~.40 ..... 74002~ F-OJ~AE,O~J~_~AN~EIOUGHION .......... 12/11/81 ......... 12,20- 753075 DAVID WHITMORE 12/11/81 13,50 753377 DAVID WAG~ER 12/11/81 21.70 750078. GLADYS ~ALKE~ ............. 12/11/81 .................. 23.80 ....................... 12/11/81 15.00 ___' .... 12/11/81 ........ ~.70 .................................... 12/11/81 10,00 12/11/81 4.85 _.12/11~81 ............ 1,90 ....... 12/11/81 25.15 12/312B1 GI/Y OF B~YNTON B~ACH PAGE 8 CHECK ~ VE~]2~ t~ CENDOR NAME CHEC< DATE TOTAL AMOUNT I521 1528 I524 1525 I526 1527 1528 1529 i530 I53i ff'-' 44 752S79 LD2 WEINSTEIN 12/11/B1 56,50 770005 DENNIS YESKEY 12/11/81 g,50 79DODO .... £IT~.]F.B]~NTON...BE~.£~ ............. 12/11/81 1,812,65 323802 BLOE CROSS OF FLORIDA 12/11/8i 25~855,52 150413 PALM BEACH NENSPAPERS 12/14/81 254,36 21019.2_ U,S, ~OS.TMAS!.E~ .... 12/~$/81 162376 P~LM BEACH COUNTY HEALTH 12/15/81 2D.DO I86025 STATE OF FLORIDA - DEPT. I2/ZE/8I 20.00 _ D16DZD_. ~ILANTIC.__NATIDNAL_BAN~ ............ 12/15/81 ........... t~1,4~7,60 .................................. 21215D ~,S, POSTMASTER 12/16/81 280021 BETTY BODONI 12/16/81 lgT.62 ' 1532 ......... 450019=_ HARDLD.__.H,_~MULL 12/16/81 4SO,DO ................ 153] 1~b015 J~CDULINE STAPLES,DIRESTO 12/17/81 125,00 1534 2BDO14 JOE G,' BLANCO 12/18/81 529,98 1535 2~00~4 __ TERE.SA~ISARS~I ................ 12/18/B~ .......... 158o29. 1535 BI]DO4 ROBERT EISHDRST ..: 12/18/81 ,00 ..:.. 1537 340032 CHAkLE$ HETTEL 12/18/81 611,70 1538 ........... 3700I~ JJOI~-L,-KI~C~EN 12/18/81- 143.,13 .......... ] ..... -- 1539 390022 MD]DY JR., WILLIE 12/18/81 367.33 1542 ~g0026 F~ANCES WOLF I2/IB/Bi IET.I4 1541 1542 1543 1544 1545 1546 1547 1548 1549 1550 232895 ...... SITY--3~-BDYNTDN-BEAC.N ...... 12/18/81 ........... 157.,287,7l S80413 WILLIAM R, HAMILTON 12/18/81 503,00 211432 ADVANCE AIR CONDITIONING 12/18/81 11To52 213723--- ~LLEN-INSJ~ANCE.AGENCY ............. 12/18/8I .......... 6,063°00 013783 ALLIED CHLORINE & 12/18/81 199,32 214067 A~E~ICAN SCIENTIFIC PRgDU 12/I~/~1 773.0I 214242 ISIAH._AND~E~S ............. 12/18/8I ............... 79.20 215561 AZTIC AIR CONDITIONING 12/19/81 : .' .: 449.85 21589~ ATLANT~ COAST FIRE C0, I2/IB/BI 68.20 21bOD3 ..... ATLANTI~_~A~DWARE ........... 12/18Z81 .................... liD,g8 1551 1552 1553 1554 1555 1556 1557 1558 1559 1562 1561 1562 1563 1564 1565 1566 1567 1568 1569 1573 1571 315313 AJTD STE&EO,INC, 12/lB/B1 45.00 32344S THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO, 12/1B/B1 759,7b 2205S4. BA% VALLE¥_ENT .................... 12/1B/Bi 22120] BO. DF CB, COMMISSIONERS 12/18/81 143.18 222930 BISHOP'S 1Z/lB/B1 38.50 32~5§7 __ BLA£K..~ DECKER IU, So)I'NC ......... 12/18/81 .................. 2~,26.._ 324653 T.J,BDWLES ELECTRIC C0, 12/18/81 453.35 22~695 BDYLE CDNSTRU2T[ON CD. 12/18/81 87~969.68 32~598 RDYNTDN'S GoAeL.A,___ 12/18{9[ ........... 702,00 ~24725 BDYNTON CITY FEDERAL c~E~ 1Z/lB/B1 10,231,49 g24732 BDYNTDN BEACH RETIREMENT 12/18/81 024763 BDYNTDN SL~SS. SERVI~E, ._. IZ/IB/$1 ....... 5.90 324773 B]YNTDN MEDICAL OXYGEN 12/18/81 113.00 22478~ BDYNTON PUMP & SUPPLY 12/I8/81 79.99 22%785 ...B]¥~TDN TqAVEL ASENCY. INS ..... 12/18/81 ........ 283,00 3~5583 BRDDA~T ,INC, 12/18/81 15,80 025609 BRD~ARD PUMP & SUPPLY CD, 12/18/81 '332,82 225380 BJLLDDG_INDJSTRIES ,INC, 12/18/81 .......... 1,605.79 226394 BJREaJ OF ELEVATOR INSP, 12/i8/81 23,00 239165 C,<.'S LDDKSHDP, INC, 12/18/81 23029~ JJDY ~ALANDRA .. 12/18/81 .... 15,00 ~B~537 CITY OF 80YNTON BEACH PAGE 'J CENDOR NAME CHECK DATE TOTAL A~OUNT 1572 331553 CENTURY PSOL SERVICES 12/18/81 25.35 1573 1574 1575 1575 1577 1578 27 :W 1573 .1531 _ . 1503 t535 1~37 ..... 1511 1612 1615 1518 1519 15~0 1521 332473 CHILDREN'S BOOK COUNCIL 12/18/81 332801 ..... THE.~ILREN_.£Q~PAN~ .................. iZ/1B/B1 ~32906 CITY OF DELRAY BEACH 12/18/81 034950 COVE SHOE REPAIR 12/18/81 D35355 .... £JSTD~_TO.S- 12/18/8.1 ~j~G9 DANISH FJRNITURE CENTER 12/18/81 7.75 ..... 453.30 ................................... - .... 88.15 28.00 269.00 1579 G~1588 DEPT.DF ENVIRONMENTAL REG 12/18/81 53.00 1582 ...... 3~2525 .... Qi~ZII _CO..-.IN.~ .......................... lZ/1B/81 .......... 113.57 1581 2~4752 DDUBLEDAY 5 CO. 12/18/81 15'88' : '.. 41~.90 . 1582 D50333 EAST :OAST FIRE E~UIP. 12/18/81 :.': I583 ......... 352BIR. __EASY, AY I.I~E~STDRE i2/IS/SL:;L '.= 1,658.52 " 1584 351323 EDWARDS ELECTRIC CORP. IZ/IS/SI i585 354370 ENGINEERING MACHINE 20. I2/18/81 i5.03 I586 ...... 2543?3 _~E~NGi~EE~_&ERVIC£.~ORP~ ....... I2/iB/8%-~ _~5,~.iD.-Q~ 1587 0~5910 KENT EWING ENTERPRISES, ! 12/18/BI ;' . i~ 8,521.92 1588 2~59~3 EXPOSITIDN PRESS,INC. ]::i 12/18/81~]" ' I~.75 I590 268723 FLORIDA EAST COAST 12/i8/8i I~950.~0 159I 25~?B7 FLORIDA I~DJSTRIAL SERVIC I2/i8/8i i,IO0.O0 159~ ...... 2537~Z ELD~DA_.ENGINEERING-S~CIE ........ ig/1B/BL? ........... 50.0~ -~'- 2~2--- FLORIDA NATIONAL BANK ' -'~ I2/1B/Bi 1593 85.00 · ] .... :~.' i59~ 25~B3 FL]RIDA ~ATER'~ POLLUTION IZ/i8/Si 7 i595 .._ DTD'~55 ..... ~ALE__RESEARCH'..CO ................... I2/i~ZSt ............... :51.90 1596 27~54~ GOLDCDAST PLUMBING I2/i8/8I 125.~6 I597 07~58~ R]BERT F. GODDING, INC- 12/i8/81 77:5.00 1598 ._ 075~D~_ GRIEFIN_PDLLUTIDN ...... IO/iB/81 ............ ~2:5.D~ .......... iSgg 275582 GJLF ]IL %ORPORATIDN I2/I8/Bi . ~ . .:. 08031~ HALSEY & GRIFFITH~ INC. 12/18/81 1,271.86 280355 ....... ~K ~_..~ALL~SO.OF....N,Y. ............ 12/18/81 ............. 192.00 08J42~ HA~DRIVES OF DELRAY~ INC. 12/18/81 D~5553 HJCKLEBUCI MUSIC 12/I8/81 385351 ~3~. qUDDLE:STON ........................ 12/18/81 ......... 292125 I=~,M. CORPORATION 12/18/81 39~215 INFORMATION RESOURCES PRE 12/18/81 13031~ JACK'S CAMERA CENTER 12/18/81 1115i0 KE~TTS TRUCKING SERVICE 12/18/81 i11545_ 239.32 103.00 ._325.00 ............................. 2~772.57 32.80 15.80 521.85 515.90 <E!ER,INC, ......................... 12/la/81 ........... 32.75 K]PY ~ING PRINTING CENTER 12/18/8l 2~5.40 1156~1 ELEAN3R KRUSELL ~2/18/81 12031~ _. LADIES HDME JOURNAL ...... 12/1B/B1 120401 LAKE NORTH FIRE E~UIPMENT ..... 12/18/81 122939 LITTLE,BROWN g CO. 12/18/81 i2290~ .. LITTLE,BROWN &.._.CD, ................... 12/18/81 125299 CHARLES LOCAS 12/1~/81 1BD31D W~ITT MACDOWELL 12/18/81 i~06~3_ _MAN~ATIAN TROPHIES ............... 12/18/81 130940 MZSAIN SALES I2/18/81 139950 WILLIE ROTH MCGRADY 12/18/81 130970 ESTHE~ MCCARTHY 12/18/81 34.00 ................... 9.97 33.00 45.~6CR ............. 45.46 B.30 682..80 ............. 181~90 ..................... 884.50 67.20 35.00 12/31/81 MBASD? CNECK # VENODq CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH PAGE 10 R F N T.- M O.~ I H ...... C-H.,-E- C...K.-S VENDOR NA~E ,"' " ~tE~K DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 1522 1523 1524 1525 1525 1527 1528 1529 1533 1531 1532 1533 1534 1535 1535 1537 1538 1639 1543 1541 1542 1543 1544 1545 1545 1547 1548 1549 1653 155I. 1552 1553 1554 1555 1555 1557 i558 1559 1552 155I i552 1553 1554 i554 i555 i555 ibC5 I557 1558 1559 I573 142444 143453 15131~ 153803 153365 153374 131584 ~ETRIC ENGINEERING~INC. 12/1B/B1 6,300.00 132733 ~IAMI HERALD 12/18/81 22.75 132754 .... MILEO~ PHOTQ .SUPPLY,INC ....... 12/18/81-- ~L ......... 77,50 135423 MR, ICE MACHINES ~O. 12/18/81 1~7.20 135492 MJNISIPAL FINANCE OFFICER 12/18/81 185.90 135429- MjNICI~AL POLICE ............ 12/1.8/81 -1~.932o47, 143394 NRPA 12/18/81 195.90 143~23 NATIONAL ASSOC.D~ COUNTIE 12/18/81 5.90 NATIgNAL=-.£ASH,-REGISTER ......... 12/18/81 ........ 1,306.26 NATIONAL LIBRARY RESOURCE 12/18/81 58.31 NATIONAL ~ELDING PRODUCTS 12/18/81 25.50 .ODOR ~ON~ROL SYSTEMS ............... 12/18/81 ............ 124,10 OLYMPIA SPORT SHOP, INS. 12/18/81 6.00 PAINT CENTER 12/18/81 199.16 PALM BEACh,COMMUNICATIONS ......... I2/1B/Bi .......... 24.~0 ..................................... 152391 PALM BEASt COdNTY HIGHWAY 12/18/81 159.00 i52425 PALM BEACH POST-TIMES I2/i8/8i 4~.20 162531 PqYSIO-CO~TROL ................ 12/18/81 .................. 93,30 .................. 16523? PJBLIX MARKET 12/18/81 109.90 '175333 QJALITY BOOKS, INC. 12/18/81 10.28 183496- RAN~E~-CONSTRUCTIDN INDUS .... 12/18/81 ................... 97.44 ............................. 181588 REEVES HARDWARE INC. 12/18/81 51.g8 192772 RDNAL2 RqYM JR. 12/18~81 153.00 ' : 184729 .... ROWLAND._T~UCK EQUIP.., INS ....... 12/1B/BI ............. 185509 R~SSELL & AXON 12/18/8i ~3,224.51 190399 SAL'S SPORT SHOP I2/19/81 95.00 .19395~ __]LYVE E, _SCHOOLE~ ................ 12/18/.81 ................. 15.00 191109 S23TT¥'S 12/18/81 63.00 191515 SE~ORES/ PHARMACY 12/18/81 335.37 19152~ . SEACREST..~ETERINARY .............. 12/1B/Bi ............. 128.00 lg4697 S. CENT. ~ASTEWATER TREAT 12/18/81 8,811,91 19~721 SJUTHERN BELL TELEPH0NE 12/18/8I 4,575.48 195427 SJPERIOR SURGICAL MFG.CO 12/i8/8I ..... 633.80 232537 CHARLES THOMAS, PUBLISHER IO/IB/Bi i55.IT 2~2550 TqDRNDIKE PRESS 12/1B/BI 12].56 215352 JNDERGRO~ND SdPPLY .......... i2/iB/B1 ............... 998.20 233539 WATER RESOURCES CORP. 12/IS/BI 4,847.00 Z31783 ~ESTE~N AJTD ST0RE 12/18/81 71.06 23470~ W]RTH CHEMICAL.& PAINT CO 12/18/81 81.30 241633 XEROX CORPORATION 12/18/81 1,284.30 251522 ZEE MEDICAL SUPPLIES 12/18/81 114.38 490033 ...... CHARLIE ~= ~ASHINGTON .... 12Z18/B1 ...... 223.56 593085 ~M. GOULET 12/18/8I 10.00~ 590085 WM. GOULET 12/18/81 lD.O0 740912 --~ILLAS OF..R.I.NE_TREE INS ......... 12/19/8i ................. 55.50 ........ 793039 CITY OF BOYNTDN BEACH 12/18/81 2O.OOCR 790003 CITY OF BDYNTDN BEACH 12/18/81 20.00 194422 SOCIAL SECURITY CONTRIBUT 12/18/8I 80,244.52 1~155t GEORGE A AND DORIS MEARNS 12/22/81 109.00 340~2 JAMES HAJ~H 12/23/B1 229.81 2~DDq A~T~U~ BLACK . 12/23/81 ..... 249.80 12/31/81 MB~517 ~ J R ?] ~HECK # VENgOR ~ 1672 370O32 CITY OF BOYNrON BEACH PAGE 11 RE ..N T _ M.3 N T._~ - C_H E_ C_-~_~ ................. CENDOR NAME CHECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT MINNIE L KING 12/23/81 18~.77 1673 .:- 157~ 1575 1576 1677 ~ 1578 1580 :_ 1581 1682 420011 CHAqLES PROSSER 12/23/91 225°26 ~SOOD9 ..... RDBERT_.J._SHAW ................ 12/23/Bl ......... 203.~5 S73321 ELEANOR J. KRJSSELL 12/23/81 58D.17 ................................ 31~2~ ISIAH ANDREWS 12/23/51 42.12 13396D .-~ILLI~_~JTH~_HCG~ADY 12/23/91 332995 CITY DF BOYNTON BEACH 12/29/81 151,268.29 32~725 90YNTDN CITY FEDERAL CRED 12/23/81 10,32).~2 ~5301~ .... VE~SIT.A_T~RNQU.!ST ....................... 12/2~/81 ...... ~21..65 32~725 BDYNTDN CITY FEDERAL CRED 12/23/81 2~7o27 1593 : ............ 158~ 1585 t72~ 1725 1725 !727 1728 1729 1753 1731 1732 173~ 17~5 t735 1737 17~8 1759 17~1 17~2 17~ 174~ 17~5 17~5 11~7 17~8 17~9 1753 1751 1752 1751 175~ 1755 1756 1757 17~8 1759 353752 FLORIDA NATIONAL BANK ........ ~733 B3Y~TQN BEAEH 1685 12/23/81 25,~12.1~ 12/23/81__.. : .~,55.~.5~__ __' 135423 MJNICiPAL POLICE 12/23/81 1,952.1~ 052823 FIREME'N'S RELIEF & 12/23/81 1~616.96 7!DD3~ ...... Y. SCAL~p~ .......... !2/28/81 ........... 27,20 ............................... DlOgDO A2R SJPPLY 12/28/81 35,90 311~D3 A)VANSE AIR ~'ONDITIONING 12/29/81 ~45o00 311~02 AOVAN2ED ~ARDIAC SYSTEM~ ' 12/28/81 297,70_._ 313723 ALLEM INSJRANSE AGENCY 12/28/81 5~20~o00 Dl~3D3 S~2MEN ANNdNZIATD 12/29/81 IOD,O0 D1599~ .... 6TL&~IC..._;D~${..._FIR~_~O .......... ~2/28/~Z .................... lO6oOQ ................................... D16OD~ ATLANTIC ~ARD~ARE 12/28/81 .~ 15.78 . ...~ . :. ~153D~ AJT~PqDDJ2TSj INC, 12/28/81 2671o5~ 323173 ..... BoB,_.AUTO PARTS! INC, ........ 12/28/8~ ................ 5~31°35 32~503 BETTY BOqONI 12/28/91 1~.00 ..................... D2~553 T,JoB]WLES ELECTRIC CO, 12/29/81 233,00 ~2~789 .... ~YNTQN AdT~.:SERVI.CE .......... 12/29/9~ 3~3185 S,K,'S LOSKSHDPj INC, 12/28/91 ............. : ...................... ~0 :"?-~':i~':: .":: ::. 0322gB JJDY CALANDRA 12/25/81 15~00 23033~ .... CALDNELL~£ET.TI~BAR~OW.~_. 12/28/81 ............. ~.~D03~O0 ..................... 332~15 PETER Lo CHENEY 12/28/81 12~06 ~)3531 T~OM~S A. CLARK 12/28/81 75,00 3~5415 74~ CqEATID~ TOOL CO ............... 12/29/8~ ...... 109o76 D~1581 J]E 9ELONG 12/29/81 205,00 2~6567 WILLIAM P. DDNEY 12/25/81 llD~DO 2503D1 ._.EASI_LAKE MIDDLE S~HOOL ...... 12/28/81 ................. 75.00 350371 PAJL ECKERT 12/28/81 2OO~O0 ]5358~ FLORIDA ATLANTIC UNIVERSI 12/29/81 lOO~OO 053692 FL]RIDA..BOLT. E NUT ................... 12/28/81 .......... 85~55 353791 ~LDRIDA SOLAR ENERGY CTR. 12/28/81 33,00 ~55593 CqA~LES FREDERICK 12/28/81 13D~00 ~5650] _. FJTJRA. PRINTING .............. 12/28/81 ]7~5~ GOLOCO~ST PLUMBING 12/2~/81 37~ 275288 ~EWNIS C. GRABEEL 12/28/81 39~g0 275~G9 GRAYARC. COMPANY,_INC ............. 12/28/81 075533 ~.L. GRUMMDNS PRINTING 12/29/B1 ~68,60 375581 GJLF ]IL ~DRP~RATIDN 12/2~/81 16,795,96 390~28 -E~ARD-.HARMENING ................... 12/28/81 D9~593 E]SA~ HOWELL 12/28/81 29G593 RDPERT H2~ELL 12/28/81 395GD7 ~JMAN DEVELOPMENT.SEMINAR 12/29/8l 225.00 ............................... " 20DiO0 112.50 607,50 I 12131/81 r C~E£K # VE~33R 'ITY OF BOYNTON BEACH PAGE I2 U E R E N T_. M O .N T H .... C__H_.E C-K.S ....... 5- ..................................... ¢~' ~/E'~DDR NA~E CHECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 1760 ~ ' 1751 1762 1763 ~' 1754 1755 1755 ~ 2757 - 1759 ~ 1773 1772 1174 1775 - 1775 : I777 1778 1779 1783 1791 1782 1783 _. l?q4 ' 1785 -_ 1785 1TB7 1788 l?B9 17~2 1793 179~ 1795 1795 1797 : 1798 ~_. 1799 1831 18~2 183~ 18~5 -' 1835 1837 1838 18D9 390131 I.B." CORPORATION 12/28/81 879.75 ICOZ31 J. g J CHEMICAL 12/28/B1 694.25 131527 ..... DeE o. JE~HERS ......................... 2/2B/81 ......... 203.0C ............................... CL_~ .... 111553 BERT KEEHR 12/28/81 209.00 I1460] K]PY ~ING PRINTING CENTER I2/28/81 55.85 1205~- BDB_LATHAM 12/28/81 _200.00 ~-,. 122909 LITTLE,BRDNN & CO. 12/28/81 45.56 13043~ M&Nq&TTAN TROPHIES 12/29/B1 3.50 131752 ...... MEYE~ SOD ...................... 12/28/.81 ................. 120.00 ....................... 13~625 MOODY'S INVESTORS SERVICE 12/28/81 1,345.00 136392 MJLTIPLEX 12/28/81 997.79 1~2453 ....... NATIDAAL--LINEN--SE~VICE ....... 12/28/81 337.91 i5035~ TEREESA PADGETT 12/29/81 50.00 163423 ~ALM BEACH OFFICE SUPPLY 12/28/81 45,90 15165~ .... CqA~LES-PERSING ................ 12/28/81 i62~?~ PITNEY B]~ES 12/28/81 97.75 164503 ROBERT POSSIK 12/28/81 156175 .... RjBLIO_$AFETY.-DEVICES-INC .......... 12/28/81 .................. 127.~0 ........................ 155233 ~JBLIX M&AKET 12/28/81 29.47 192353 SAFETY KLEEN CORP. 12/28/81 ~1.75 190399 .SAL'~. SP02T SHOP .................. 12/28/81 ............... 225.90 ................................ 190959 191525 191725 194731 195172 195435 195899 2J1722 225532 3LYVE E. SCHOgLEY 12/28/81 15.00 SE&RS, RDEBUC< & CD. 12/28/81 84.55 SEYFA~TH,SMAW,FAIRWEATHER ...... 12/28/81 .......... 874.15 SDJTHEASTERN LIBRARY ASS] 12/28/81 15o00 STEVEN'S DRUGS 12/28/B1 5.16 SJNO0, INS ........................... 12/28/81 ..... 19.80 G~DY W. SWAN~ 12/29/81 300.00 TESTING LAB OF THE 12/28/81 95.00 ~ALTER M. TRAJGER ................... 12/28/81 .......... 205.00 213153 U.S. POSTMASTER 12/28/81 40.00 224584 MAqI~N5 V]LK 12/28/81 35.D0 231533 TtOMAS E. WENGLER ...... 12/28/81 . . 200.00 232838 EDWIN W. NINCH 12/28/B1 ZOO.DO 234651 PATRI:IA L. WDOLLEY 12/28/8'1 205.00 235~95 SAMUEL L. WRIGHT ..... 12/28/81 ............. 205.00 241633 XEROX CORPORATION 12/29/81 124.14 264553 BETTY ZOBEL 12/28/8i 5D.00 ~70~07 ?~L. VALERIQ ....................... 12/28/81 ......... 28.00 590085 WM. GDULET 12/28/81 23.00 790000 CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 12/28/81 lO.O0 193447 RAMADA /NN_.EAST ................ 12/29/81 ....... 243.00 333658 CLERK OF 2DURTS 12/29/81 37.00 314243 ISIAH ANDRE~S 12/39/81 73.20 i33953 .NILLI. E.AUIH.MgGAADY ........ I2/33/81 ...... ~7.20 553084 VE~A LEE 2RAWF~RD 12/30/8i 2D.IO 232895 CITY OF BDYNTDN BEACH 12/31/81 172~98~.95 310031 E~NEST L. ELLIS _ . 12/31/81 ...... 309.92 420027 CECILIA PARSELS 12/31/81 ~69.56 324725 BDYNTON CITY FEDERAL CREO 12/31/81 10,158.89 063752 F.LD~IDA. NATIONAL BANK 12/31/81 _33,634.30 12/31/81 ~IIY OF BOYNTON BEACH PAGE 13 CHECK J _VENDOr._ ,V CE~DoR NAME CHEC( DATE TOTAL AMOUNT 1812 224733 BDYNTDN BEACH RETIREMENT 12/31/B1 4,575.74 1813 135423 ~JNI;IPAL POLICE 12/31/81 2,972.12 1815181~ .~. 333658052~22 ......CLERKEIREMEN'S-'"RELIEE-'~'OF 'OURTS ~--.12/31/8L_12/31/81 2.,272.72 1815 011233 ADAMS CHEVROLET 37.00 181~ ....... 01~t5~ ...... A~ERICA.N_.~AIER_~.DR~ AS$Q 12/31/B1 36.59 i2/31ZBi .... 1818 315990 ATLANTIC ZOAST FIRE CO. 12/31/81 13.55 1819 020150 B.B. ASSOC. FIREFIGHTERS 12/3~/81 1823 ........ ~20~3~ ...... ~I~HAEL BA~BD 805.~0 1821 221512 BELKIN MILLS PUBLISHIN~ 12/31/B1 1822 02~T13 BOYNTON A~TO SUPPLY 20.86 1823 32~72 12/31/81 · 325,~9 182~ 32~75~ B3YNTDN BE~H [HAMBER 12%31/8~ BEYNTON GLASS SERVICE, 12/31/81 45.57 1825 325599 BRg~A~D CqIEF'S ASSOC. 1825 225391 B q : 12/31/91 zo~ 326459 · BJS ......... :~ .......... 1~31~81 INE$$ MA£HIN S ....... -- 39.50 u283 ' CADILLAC E > 890.00' 1832 12/31/81 .... 2~0525 ...... D~.TIME~_S_~ ......... 70?.?9 1834 3~2595 3IAZIT C3., I~C. 12/31/81 ~7.53 ' - · , 18351835 ........ 353930353~52 ...... ELLIS_.BAN.K..&EMERSENCY MEDICAL-['RUS~CO'sAmET ...... I2/31/8112/31/8i -~ ............ 299.90 500.00 .......................: 1837 352703 FIELD,S ~RMY & NaVY 12/31/8~ 55.00 -- 1838 ..... 2527~ EIRE-.2.HIEE.~GAZINE 1839 353582 FLA.ASSDS.DF .......... 1Z/31/BI ......... GOVERNMENTAL 12/31/81 13.00 1842 35~5~9 GE3. FO~LER WELDING CO. 12/31/81 ' :?i 71.60 ..... 18~1 ...... 35550~ .... E-~A,-NJ<~OUSE_.ELE~TRiC .... -- ....... 1223I/8Z _ 18~2 355553 F~TE~NAL ORDER DF P3LICE 12/31/81 ~551.55 ~8~3 371553 GENERAL GMC TRUCK 12/31/8i 225.93 - 18~ 37553~ R,L. 5RU~.MQNS PRINTING__ 375610 GJLFSTREAM LUMBER ~O, "? .: 12/31 ...:- 18~9 DBD~25 HAND'S 127~.50 1851 381552 HES T~ANSPDRTtINC, ............. 12/~1/81 ~Og~gO 1852 39~62~ H]LLY ACCUMULATOR ~ - 185~1853 ....... 38535138~'57~--' ~DD~S-M~I-N~-HA~BW.~REJ~N3AM ~UDDLESTON ............ 12/31/81 12/31/81.' ......LZ ....... 315.55 99,99 ........ ~"'-'~ .................. - 1855 _. 990%03 .... I-B-M,---CD.~PORAIID~ ......... 12/31/81 83,00 I857 ~9~1~5 I-B,M, cDRPORATION 12/31/91 1~55~,25 1858 DBOlJ~ . ICMA RETIREMENT C3RP. ..... 12/31/81 '335.95 1852 191659 JERRY'S CONCRETE, INC. 12/31/81 75.00 1851 120492 LASER LIGHTING & ELECT. 1862 12/31/81 .... ' .......... 12/31/8i ....... T -88.20 12/31/81 SITY MBA59? C J ~ R E N T 1863 1~2911 OF BDYNTON BEACH PAGE NAME CAECK DATE TOTAL AMOUNT LLD¥DS AUTO ELECTRIC 12/31/81 1854 133555 MAJR¥'S TOOL CHEST 12/31/8i 153.30 1855 131571 ..... MEI~E,KE DISCOdNT_M~£ELERS ...... 1'2/31Z8i. 1865 232771 ~ILLER DODGE 12/31/81 264.85 1857 l~4723 ~DTDRDLA, INC. 12/31/81 2,252.00 1858 135428_ MJNICIPAL.SUPPL~_K_.SIGN ........ 12/~1/81 737.00 1859 I8544~ MICHAEL MJNRO 12/3I/8I IB7D 153102 P & G DISTRIBJTDRS I2/3I/8I 18TI ...... 152372 ..... PALM_BEASH AU~O PA~S 1872 L50373 PALM BEACH BRAKE & WHEEL 12/31/81 ~09.25 1873 I51512 PEACOCK'S RADIATOR t2/31/~1 206.79 1874 .... 162o521 ..... P~YSID~£DNTR]]L 12/31/81 ........... 1875 180496 RAN~Eq CONSTRUCTION INDUS 12/31/81 481.32 1875 I82803 RINKE~ MATERIALS CORP. 12/31/81 741.22 1877 18652~ ........ ROBERTS SEPTI~.[ANKS .............. 12/31/8i .......... 1878 192195 S. 2. So 12/31/8i 382.30 1879 190353 ~AFET¥ KLEEN :ORP. 12/31/81 1882 1881 1882 1883 1884 1885 1885 1687 1888 1889 1890 1891 1892 1893 1895 1895 1897 1898 1899 32970 37548 3~238 190951 ..... S~HNUPP. MEG..,%O, .................... 12/31/81 ....... 255.5~ 190959 3LYVE E. SCHO3LEY 12/31/81 15.90 191525 SEARS, RDEBUC~ & CO. 12/31/81 13.50 191703 SEWELL HARDWARE CO.,-INC.. . 12/31/81 192755 A.L. SILVERMAN 12/31/81 78.00 i94513 SDME'S UNIFORMS I2/31/81 23.00 194705 --- SDJT~ERN BUILDING-CODE .- 12/31/81 ................ 12.00 196~05 SJNCO, INC. 12/31/81 135.60 230~8~ T~ULMAN SALES CD. 12/31/81 23349~ 2.-C...TAYLO~.-~OTO~S.-INS 12/31/81 ................... 150.30 231732 TESTING LAB OF THE 12/31/81 40.00 210153 U.S. POST~ASTER 12/31/81 603.00 215390- -UNIJA~ ............................. 12/31/8i ................ 867,19 21541~ UNITED WAY OF PALM BCH. 12/31/81 525.99 233450 EARL WALLACE FORD, INC. 12/31/81 155.18 233457___ NALP]LE. NJRSERY ........................ 12/31/81 ........... 289.00 233543 WATER DEPARTMENT 12/31/81 2,991.75 231531 WENGE~ CORPORATION 12/31/81 11~.'21 2~1503 .... XERO×.CDRPORATIDN ................ 12/31/8Z ........... 213.50 ~5~22G TEAMSTERS LOCAL UNION NO. 12/31/81 1,108.58 71303~ V.S. CALAMNDRE 2/~1/81 27.20CR 153360. PALM BF6CH JR. CQLLEGE-__ 8/31/81 33.30CR 550084 VERA LEE CRAWFDRD 9/i8/81 23.10CR 1,932,033.75 ***