Loading...
Agenda 08-28-12 CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING AGENDA DATE: Tuesday, August 28, 2012 TIME: 6:30 P.M. PLACE:Commission Chambers, 100 E. Boynton Beach Boulevard, Boynton Beach, Florida ___________________________________________ __________________________ ___________ 1. Pledge of Allegiance 2. Introduction of the Board 3. Agenda Approval 4. Approval of Minutes from July 24, 2012, meeting 5. Communications and Announcements: Report from Staff, Sept. meeting 6. New Business: LDR Amendments to Nonconforming Regulations, Landscaping Standards, A.1. Community Design Standards, and Historic Preservation Requirements (CDRV 12- 005) – Approve proposed amendments to the Land Development Regulations (LDR) intended to update and enhance development and design standards to promote business/economic development and increase user-friendliness. The proposed amendments include incentives to the development of industrial lots, promote more urban development through clarification of build-to-line regulations, reduce landscape requirements for non-conforming lots, update historic preservation processes, and are intended to enhance project appearance through various changes in community design regulations. 7. Other 8. Comments by members 9. Adjournment The Board (Committee) may only conduct public business after a quorum has been established. If no quorum is established within twenty minutes of the noticed start time of the meeting the City Clerk or her designee will so note the failure to establish a quorum and the meeting shall be concluded. Board members may not participate further even when purportedly acting in an informal capacity. NOTICE ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION OF THE PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. (F.S. 286.0105) THE CITY SHALL FURNISH APPROPRIATE AUXILIARY AIDS AND SERVICES WHERE NECESSARY TO AFFORD AN INDIVIDUAL WITH A DISABILITY AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN AND ENJOY THE BENEFITS OF A SERVICE, PROGRAM, OR ACTIVITY CONDUCTED BY THE CITY. PLEASE CONTACT THE CITY CLERK’S OFFICE, (561) 742-6060 AT LEAST TWENTY (24) HOURS PRIOR TO THE PROGRAM OR ACTIVITY IN ORDER FOR THE CITY TO REASONABLY ACCOMMODATE YOUR REQUEST. øÍÙÇÏ×ÎÈ NEW BUSINESS 6.A.1 LDR Amendments to Nonconforming Regulations, Landscaping Standards, Community Design Standards, and Historic Preservation Requirements (CDRV 12-005) NATURE OF REQUEST Approve proposed amendments to the Land Development Regulations (LDR) intended to update and enhance development and design standards to promote business/economic development and increase user-friendliness. The proposed amendments include incentives to the development of industrial lots, promote more urban development through clarification of build-to line regulations, reduce landscape requirements for non- conforming lots, update historic preservation processes, and are intended to enhance project appearance through various changes in community design regulations. ANALYSIS Preparation of these documents has involved the comprehensive and detailed review of the associated land development processes, the applicable standards, and the city department responsible for the administration of such regulations and standards. The following list summarizes the proposed amendments to the land development regulations: Part II (Code of Ordinances), Chapter 13, Article IV Live Entertainment Permits Update the live entertainment permit submittal requirements to require a signed affidavit that affirms the application will not violate the Noise Control Ordinance. Update/remove the requirement for all conditional uses to have a sound analysis, and only require this analysis from operators who are reapplying following revocation. The sound impact analysis must demonstrate mitigating solutions aimed at reducing or eliminating the potential for violating the Noise Control Ordinance and preventing off-site nuisance conditions which led to the original revocation. Part III (LDR), Chapter 1, Article II Definitions Update the definitions of Auto/Car Wash; Restaurant; and Bar and Nightclub to emphasize that business activities are to be mainly conducted indoors, but that such establishment may have an outdoor component to the operation to accommodate such unique businesses (e.g., Cuthill’s Backyard) that operate primarily outdoors. Part III (LDR), Chapter 2, Article I Overview Update the article to include the newly created Historic Resources Preservation Board as a reviewing agency for those applications involving historic preservation. Enhance article to include asterisks next to the types of development applications requiring quasi-judicial hearings. - 2- Part III (LDR), Chapter 2, Article II Planning and Zoning Division Services Update the scope of Community Design Appeal application to include deviations from build-to line requirements (i.e., setbacks) in certain zoning districts and areas of the City. Insert into the article, a new section for the applications established as part of the new historic preservation program to include: 1) Certificate of Appropriateness; 2) Historic District or Properties Designation; and 3) Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption Application. Amend the paragraph order in the “Eligible Applicants” section to improve consistency and clarity. The two paragraphs regarding voting rights when designating a district are now next to each other rather than being separated by other wording. Simplify the public notification process for individual site designations by only requiring the notification of abutting or adjacent properties rather than those within a 400 foot radius. The 400 foot requirement is still in place for the designation of a district. Remove unnecessary (repeated) wording from the “Board Approval” section regarding Certificates of Economic Hardship. Simplify the application process for “Certificate of Economic Hardship” by requiring only a written statement rather than a formal application similar to the appeal process currently established in the LDR. Expand the submittal requirements to provide additional documentation of hardship consistent with procedures of other cities and beneficial for the determination of economic hardship. Part III (LDR), Chapter 2, Article IV Building Division Services Update article by reinserting wording required by Code Compliance to ensure that sites are maintained in accordance with the approved site plan of record. Part III (LDR), Chapter 3, Article III Zoning District and Overlay Zones Revise site regulations table for SMU and Urban Mixed-Use zoning districts, and the Urban Commercial District Overlay Zone to emphasize “urban” design standards, with minimal setbacks and a mandatory build-to line, and include exceptions when accommodating pedestrian amenities and sidewalk areas or to maintain compliance with safe-sight and visibility requirements. - 3- Enhance the site and development regulations for the Urban Mixed Use zoning districts and Urban Commercial District Overlay Zone by allowing minor deviations of up to 15 feet from build-to line requirements to optimize a project’s landscape design; maximize drainage solutions; accommodate architectural enhancements; or to otherwise enhance public spaces in front of buildings along rights-of-way. Exceptions would be eligible for the more appropriate relief process, the option of a Community Design Appeal instead of the traditional variance. Update the M-1 district regulations to encourage development on non-conforming lots that do not meet the minimum lot size by amending the development standards, including minimum landscaping requirements. Part III (LDR), Chapter 3, Article IV Use Regulations Amend the Noise standard of the City’s operational performance standards to include a cross-reference to the Live Entertainment Permit process established subsequent to the update of the LDR. Update the conditional use application’s evaluation criteria by removing the requirement that bars/nightclubs be subject to sophisticated “sound study” certified by an acoustical engineer, and allow the submittal of a less technical non-certified sound impact analysis. The new Live Entertainment Permit process was established to provide a simple, more user-friendly system for permitting such activity and which emphasizes the City’s noise ordinance. Part III (LDR), Chapter 3, Article V Supplemental Regulations Enhance the general design standards of all fences by requiring the finished sides to face adjacent properties. Update the nonconforming regulations by exempting the M-1 zoning district from complying with the 85% lot frontage requirement. Part III (LDR), Chapter 4, Article I Environmental Protection Standards Update the methodology that is used when calculating the number of replacement trees required for mitigating purposes. The new methodology differentiates between canopy trees, small and medium sized palm trees, and large palm trees. The new provisions aim to discourage the replacement of large mature canopy trees with small and medium palm trees. Part III (LDR), Chapter 4, Article II Landscape Design and Buffering Standards - 4- Amend the design standards by restricting palm species to no more than 50% of the required trees on any given site within commercial or mixed-use zoning with the intent of increasing tree canopy area and decreasing the heat island effect. Update the Alternate Landscape Plan (ALP) provisions by creating new landscape regulations intended to support the development and redevelopment of smaller urban industrial lots. Part III (LDR), Chapter 4, Article III Exterior Building and Site Design Standards Organize article by separating major topics under section headings rather than subsection headings, thereby making it easier for the general public to locate specific standards in the code (e.g., Design Standards for Multi-Family and Non- Residential Uses Adjacent to Single-Family Residential Zoning Districts; Design Standards for Development in Urban Areas; Design Standards for Large Non- Residential Development (Big Box) in Suburban Areas). Part III (LDR), Chapter 4, Article V Minimum Off-Street Parking Requirements Clarify the existing provision that limits the maximum allowable number of parking spaces for non-residential uses. The existing provision was originally created to further sustainability initiatives (e.g., prevent over paving sites with impervious surfaces), to reflect staff’s original intent that it be applicable only to new projects and major modifications to existing development. Part III (LDR), Chapter 4, Article IX Building, Construction, and Historic Preservation Requirements Reorganize entire article for consistency with all applications administered by the Planning and Zoning Division by relocating all “process” related language into Chapter 2, Article II. Relocate all Historic Preservation “process” provisions to Chapter 2, Article II, to appropriately be combined with all other Planning and Zoning Division Services. Amend the “Guidelines for Historic Designation” section by adding the word “feeling” to the list of aspects necessary to assess the integrity of a site. The list now includes seven aspects of “integrity” and is consistent with those listed in the National Register guidelines. Enhance the “Authority to Initiate Designation” section by adding site recording and architectural salvaging requirements for undesignated sites. This requirement was only in place for the demolition of a designated structure; however, if the Historic Preservation Board delays the demolition of an undesignated structure to determine if it is eligible for designation but the designation process is not - 5- completed, the owner is required to record the structures and attempt to salvage materials prior to demolition. Relocate definitions to Chapter 1, Article II of the land development regulations for overall consistency. Clarify the description of works eligible for tax exemption by adding the word “appropriate” in describing the “renovation,” “restoration,” or “rehabilitation” to reinforce the requirement to follow widely accepted historic preservation best practices. Amend the process for submitting an appeal if a Preconstruction Application is denied by the Board in the “Appeals to the Historic Resources Preservation Board” section. Appeals will now be submitted in writing rather than by application form. The notification requirements have also been enhanced by the addition of “adjacent property” for consistency with the notification requirements for designating an individual site. CONCLUSION / RECOMENDATION Staff is recommending approval of the proposed code amendments. Overall, this amendment would help promote business/economic development, make the code more user-friendly, and provide the necessary updates based on lessons learned and processes established subsequent to the 2010 LDR update. S:\Development\Planning & Zoning\P&D Board\Agenda & Packet\2012\8-28-12 meeting\CDRV 12-005 Staff Report.doc - 6- To: Planning & Development Board From: Eric Lee Johnson RE: Proposed Changes in Attached Document To assist you with your review of the attached revisions, all of the proposed changes to the LDR are highlighted (in yellow). You will find that much of the highlighted text is 1) minor updates to cross-references that are located throughout the code; or 2) deleted provisions, shown as stricken through. Should you have any questions regarding any of these changes, please feel free to contact me anytime in advance of the meeting. I can be reached at 561-742-6256. PROPOSED LANGUAGE 1 2 PART II (CODE OF ORDINANCES), CHAPTER 13 LICENSES 3 4 ARTICLE I BUSINESS TAX RECEIPTS… 5 ARTICLE II GARAGE SALES… 6 ARTICLE III ADULT ENTERTAINMENT… 7 8 ARTICLE IV LIVE ENTERTAINMENT PERMITS 9 10 11Sec. 13-80. Live entertainment permit. 12 13 (a) Definition. 14 15(1) Live entertainment defined. Live entertainment 16means a use in connection conjunction with a restaurant, 17bar/nightclub, cocktail lounge or other similar 18establishment, wherein floorshows or other forms of 19entertainment consisting of one (1) or more persons, 20amplified or non-amplified music or the like sound, are 21provided indoors or outdoors, including but not limited to 22entertainment provided by disc jockey (DJ), master of 23ceremonies (MC), or karaoke. 24 25 (b) Time limits. Any live entertainment permit (herein referred 26to as “permit”) granted by the city shall expire twelve (12) months after 27the date of approval of such live entertainment permit and must be 28renewed in accordance with subsection (h) of this section. 29 30 (c) Method of approval. A live entertainment permit may be 31approved by the city after an application, as provided herein, has been 32processed by city staff. 33 34 (d) Review and approval procedure. 35 36(1)Permit Live entertainment permit applications shall 37be obtained from and filed with the Development 38Department, and may be initiated by the owner of the 39subject property or the owner's designated representative. 40All applications must be signed by the property owner. A 41complete application will be processed by the Development 42Department, which also consists of the required fee and 43necessary supportive materials, including the following: 44 45a.. 46b.. - 1- 1c.. 2 3d. A signed affidavit affirming the application 4will not violate the Noise Control Ordinance. 5 6 (e) Non-transferable permit. A live entertainment permit is valid 7only for a specific establishment at a specific location and is 8nontransferable to another establishment. If an establishment with a valid 9live entertainment permit ceases operation at a specific location and 10another establishment begins operation at this location, the live 11entertainment permit is nontransferable to the new establishment at the 12same location. In addition, if an establishment with a valid live 13entertainment permit relocates, the permit is nontransferable to the new 14location. In both instances, a new live entertainment permit application 15must be submitted for City Commission consideration. 16 17 (f) Standard conditions of approval for all permits. The 18following are standard conditions for approval of all live entertainment 19permits which are incorporated into the City Commission's approval of a 20live entertainment permit application and made a part of the terms under 21which the live entertainment permit is granted: 22 23(1)… 24(2)… 25(3)… 26 27 (g) Standards for review… 28 29(1)… 30(2)… 31(3)… 32 33(4)… 34 35(5) Screening, buffering or separation of any nuisance or 36hazardous feature, with reference to type, dimensions and 37character, shall be fully and clearly represented on the 38submitted plans and shall be adequate to protect adjacent 39properties. This shall should include proposed strategies to 40mitigate sound levels at adjacent property lines and 41distances from the noise source(s) as enumerated in the 42city's Noise Control Ordinance. 43 44 (6)… 45(7)… 46 - 2- 1 (h) Permit renewal procedure. Permits Live entertainment 2permits shall renew on an annual basis in conjunction with the Business 3Tax Receipt renewal effective October 1 of each year. Establishments 4with complaints that have been the subject of an Order issued by the City's 5Code Compliance Board finding the establishment in violation of City 6Code, and/or findings by a civil or criminal court of a violation of City 7Code or other applicable law(s) shall require annual City Commission 8approval prior to the renewal of the live entertainment permit. Permits 9Live entertainment permits not approved for renewal by City Commission 10will be prohibited from re-applying for a period of one (1) year. 11 12 (i) Revocation of permits. The City Commission may revoke a 13previously approved live entertainment permit upon making the following 14findings in a public hearing: 15 16(1) The operation of the live entertainment has resulted 17in the violation of a city ordinance, or any of the conditions 18of approval outlined in the approving resolution, including 19the standard conditions outlined in subsection (h) of this 20section, and that the City's Code Compliance Board has 21found that a violation has occurred, and entered an order 22finding that such a violation has occurred pursuant to 23Chapter 2, Article V, of the City's Code of Ordinances. 24 25In the event the City Commission revokes a live 26entertainment permit, the City Commission shall not issue a 27new live entertainment permit for the same location for a 28period of twelve (12) months from the date of revocation. 29In order to submit an application for a new live 30entertainment permit, the location must not have been 31found in violation of any City Code provisions within the 32twelve (12) month time period just prior to the date the 33application for a live entertainment permit is submitted. 34 35(2) After the time period specified above has elapsed, a 36new permit application may be submitted to the 37Development Department. However, unlike the original 38application, the applicant shall now be required to submit 39an impact analysis which demonstrates mitigating solutions 40aimed at reducing or eliminating the potential for violating 41the Noise Control Ordinance or otherwise creating off-site 42nuisance conditions. 43 44 (j) The City Commission hereby establishes the following live 45entertainment permit application fee, a live entertainment permit fee which 46is computed based upon the date of the Commission's action approving the - 3- 1application, and an annual live entertainment permit renewal fee: 2 3(1)… 4 5(2) Annual live entertainment permit renewal fee 6$50.00 7 8 (k) Live entertainment without a city live entertainment permit 9is prohibited and violations of these regulations may be enforced by the 10city as follows: 11 12(1)… 13(2)… 14(3)… 15(4)… 16 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 1, ARTICLE II DEFINITIONS 17 18 AUTO / CAR WASH (POLISHING, WAXING, DETAILING) – 19 20Establishments providing for the cleaning of private automobiles, recreational 21vehicles (personal watercraft), or other light duty equipment through manual 22detailing and / or mechanical resources. Business activity is to be conducted 23indoors, but the establishment may have an outdoor component if approved 24through the site plan process. RESTAURANT – 25An establishment engaged in preparing, selling, and / or 26serving food and beverage items. Food and drink may be consumed on premises, 27delivered, and taken out (via pick-up or carry-out). Alcoholic beverages may be 28sold in combination with selling food but ultimately, the sale of food constitutes 29more than 51% of its monthly gross revenue. Business activity is to be conducted 30indoors, but the establishment may have an outdoor component if approved 31through the site plan process. BAR AND NIGHTCLUB – 32Any licensed premises that is devoted 33predominately or totally, to the serving of alcoholic and / or intoxicating 34beverages or any combination thereof, for consumption at the licensed 35establishment. Leisurely dancing may occur or patrons may be entertained by 36live or recorded performers who dance, sing, play instruments, or perform other 37acts of entertainment (excluding adult entertainment). The service of food may be 38incidental to the service of the aforementioned beverages, activities, and 39entertainment. These establishments are known as but are not limited to the 40following: bars, cigar bars, cabarets, cocktail lounges, comedy clubs, dance 41clubs, discothèques, night clubs, piano bars, pubs, and saloons.Business activity 42is to be conducted indoors, but the establishment may have an outdoor component 43if approved through the site plan process. - 4- PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 2, ARTICLE I OVERVIEW 1 2 Section 1. General. 3 Section 2. Types of Land Development Applications. 4 5 A. Table 2-1. Applications by City Departments. 6 7 8Legend: 9 10HRPB: Historic Resources Preservation Board 11P&Z: Planning and Zoning Division 12P&D: Planning and Development Board 13CRA: Community Redevelopment Agency 14CC: City Commission 15 REVIEWING PUBLIC CODE APPROVING APPLICATION TYPE AUTHORITY HEARING SECTION AUTHORITY (STAFF) REQUIRED? ARTICLE II. PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION SERVICES Standard Applications Art II, Director of Annexation CCYes Section 2.A P&Z Comprehensive Plan Amendment Art II, TextCity Initiated Only Section 2.B.2 Future Land Use Map Art II, Director of CCYes (FLUM) Section 2.B.3 P&Z Art II, Conditional Use Section 2.C Director of CCYes* P&Z Conditional Use Time Art II, Extension Section 2.C.6 Art II, Rezoning Section 2.D Article II, Master Plan (New) Section CCYes* 2.D.6 Director of P&Z Article II, Master Plan Section Modification (Major) 2.D.6.g Article II, Master Plan Director of Section No Modification (Minor) P&Z 2.D.6.h Art II, Director of Director of Sign Program No Section 2.E P&ZP&Z Art II, Director of Site Plan Review Section 2.F P&Z CCYes* Site Plan Time Art II, Extension Section 2.F.6 Art II, Site Plan Modification - 5- (M ajor) Section 2.F.7 Site Plan Modification Director of No (Minor) P&Z Vacation and Art II, Director of Yes* CC Abandonment Section 2.G P&Z Planned Industrial Development (PIDApplications ) Master Site Plan (New) Art II, PID Zoning District Only Section 3.A CCYes Master Site Plan Director of Art II, Modification, Major P&Z Section Master Site Plan Director of 3.A.6 No Modification, Minor P&Z Technical Site Plan (New) Art II, PID Zoning District Only Section 3.B Director of Director of Technical Site Plan No P&ZP&Z Modification, Major Art II, Section 3.B.6 Technical Site Plan Modification, Minor ARTICLE II. PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION SERVICES continued Art II, Director of Waiver CCYes Section 3.C. P&Z Relief Applications Administrative Art II, Director of Director of No Adjustment Section 4.A P&ZP&Z Community Design Art II, Director of CCYes Appeal Section 4.B P&Z Art II, Director of Height Exception CCYes Section 4.C P&Z Variance to Land Art II, Director of Yes* CC Development Regulations Section 4.D P&Z Art II, Director of See Site Plan See Site Plan Waiver Section 4.E P&ZReview Review Permit Applications Art II, Director of Director of Sign Permit No Section 5.A P&ZP&Z Art II, Director of Director of Zoning Permit No Section 5.B P&ZP&Z Historic Preservation Certificate of Art II,Director of HRPBYes Appropriateness Section 6.A.P&Z Historic District or Art II,Director of CCYes Properties Designation Section 6.B.P&Z Historic Preservation Art II, Director of Property Tax Exemption CCYes Section 6.C.P&Z Application Other Applications Art II, Director of Director of Certificate of Conformity No Section 7 6.A P&ZP&Z - 6- Art II, Director of Director of Lot Line Modification No Section 7 6.BP&ZP&Z MobileVendor VenderArt II, Director of Yes P&D Approval Section 7 6.CP&ZNo Modification to Art II, Director of CCYes Development Order Section 7 6.D P&Z Art II, Director of Sidewalk Café Approval CCNo Section 7 6.EP&Z Zoning Verification Art II, Director of Director of No LetterSection 7 6.G P&ZP&Z ARTICLE III. ENGINEERING DIVISION SERVICES Art III, Preliminary Plat City Engineer City Engineer No Section 2.B Art III, Final Plat City Engineer CC Yes Section 2.C Land Development Art III, City Engineer City Engineer No Permit (LDP) Section 3 Art III, Right-of-Way Permits City Engineer City Engineer No Section 4 Engineering Division Art III, City Engineer City Engineer No Waiver Section 5 REVIEWING PUBLIC CODE APPROVING APPLICATION TYPEAUTHORITY HEARING SECTION AUTHORITY (STAFF) REQUIRED? ARTICLE IV. BUILDING DIVISION SERVICES Art IV, Building Building Building Permit No Section 2 OfficialOfficial Art IV, Building Building Sign Permit No Section 3 OfficialOfficial Building Board Art IV, Building of Adjustment Yes Variance Section 4 Official and Appeals ARTICLE V. BUSINESS TAX SERVICES Seasonal Sales Event Art V, Business Tax Business Tax No Approval Section 3 Manager Manager Special Temporary Sales Art V, Business Tax Business Tax No Event Approval Section 4 Manager Manager 1 2* Quasi-judicial proceedings are required pursuant to Part II (City Code of 3Ordinances), Chapter 2, Article I, Section 2-20. 4 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 2, ARTICLE II PLANNING & ZONING DIVISION 5 SERVICES 6 7 Section 1. General… 8 Section 2. Standard Applications… 9 Section 3. Planned Industrial Development (PID) Applications… 10 Section 4. Relief Applications… 11 12 - 7- Section 4. Relief Applications. 1 2 3Each application for relief shall be considered unique and not set 4precedent for subsequent requests. 5 A. Administrative Adjustments… 6 B. Community Design Appeal. 7 8 1. General. 9 10 a. Purpose and Intent. 11The purpose of this s 12subsection is to provide a relief process that allow 13for deviations from specific build-to line 14requirements of Chapter 3, Article III and any 15community design standard of Chapter 4 of these 16Land Development Regulations. The intent of this 17application process is not to provide a means of 18circumventing such standards but to allow for 19flexibility, and alternative ways to meet the intent of 20the code to yield high quality design, architectural 21detail, and visual interest without negative impacts 22to the subject site or surrounding properties. 23 b. Applicability. 24This application shall 25be applicable to any requested deviation from 26specific build-to line requirements of the Mixed- 27Use Urban Building and Site Regulations (Table 3- 284); Urban Commercial District Overlay Zone (Table 293-26); or any of a community design standard of 30Chapter 4 of these Land Development Regulations. 31The requested appeal shall be processed concurrent 32with a site plan unless otherwise determined by the 33Director of Planning and Zoning or designee. 34 c. Rules… 35 36 2. Submittal Requirements… 37 3. Review Criteria… 38 4. Approval Process… 39 5. Expiration… 40 41 C. Height Exception… 42 D. Variance to Land Development Regulations… 43 E. Waiver (Ocean Avenue Overlay Zone)… 44 45 Section 5. Permit Applications… 46 - 8- Section 6. Historic Preservation Applications. 1 2 A. Certificate of Appropriateness. 3 4 1. General…. 5 2. Submittal Requirements…. 6 3. Review Criteria… 7 4. Approval Process… 8 9 5. Certificate of Economic Hardship. 10 Prior to taking 11an appeal of a decision to the City Commission on an 12application for a Certificate of Appropriateness, an 13applicant may file an application request in writing for a 14Certificate of Economic Hardship. Utilizing information 15supplied by the applicant, the Board reviews requests for 16Certificates of Economic Hardship to determine if a 17decision regarding a Certificate of Appropriateness 18application has caused or will cause an unreasonable 19economic hardship. 20 a. Application. 21 A request for a Certificate of 22Economic Hardship application must be submitted 23in writing within 30 days of the date of the hearing 24at which the Board’s decision on the Certificate of 25Appropriateness application is announced. 26 b. Board Agenda and Notice… 27 c. Negotiations Prior to Certificate of 28 Economic Hardship Hearing… 29 30 d. Determination of Economic Hardship. 31 32 The applicant has the burden of proving by 33competent substantial evidence that the Board’s 34decision regarding the Certificate of 35Appropriateness application has caused or will 36cause an unreasonable economic hardship. To 37determine economic hardship, the Board may 38request the followingapplicant shall submit the 39following with the request for a Certificate of 40Economic Hardship: 41 42(1) Proposed construction, alteration, 43demolition and removal costs; 44 - 9- 1(2) Structural and condition reports from 2a licensed professional with experience in 3assessing historic buildings; 4 5(3) Estimates as to the economic 6feasibility of rehabilitation or reuse; 7 8(4) The purchase price of the property, 9details of annual debt service or mortgage 10payments, recent appraisals, assessments, 11and real estate taxes; 12 13(5) Details of any income obtained from 14the property and cash flows for the previous 15two (2) years; 16 17(6) The status of any leases or rentals; 18and 19 20(7)all other information considered 21necessary by the Board to determine 22whether the property does or may yield a 23reasonable return to the owner. 24 25(7) Details of any listings of the property 26for sale or rent for the previous two (2) 27years. 28 29The applicant may submit or the Board may 30request any further additional information 31relevant to the determination of economic 32hardship. 33 34The effect of denial of the application for 35Certificate of Economic Hardship is that the 36decision regarding the Certificate of 37Appropriateness is upheld. If the 38application for Certificate of Economic 39Hardship is granted, the Board may issue the 40Certificate of Economic Hardship without 41conditions. Alternatively, the Board may 42issue the Certificate with conditions that will 43avoid the economic hardship and have the 44least adverse effect to the Property and the 45District. 46 - 10 - 1Such conditions may include, but are not 2limited to: ad valorem tax relief, loans or 3grants, requiring the owner to market and 4offer the Property for sale for a fair market 5price with appropriate preservation 6protections for a period of time not to 7exceed six (6) months, acquisition by a third 8party for a fair market value, Building and 9Zoning Code modifications, relaxation of 10the provisions of this ordinance, 11recommendation by the City Manager some 12or all of the applicable Board fees be 13waived, or such other relief as appropriate. 14 6. Appeal of Certificate of Appropriateness and 15 Certificate of Economic Hardship Decisions… 16 17 B. Historic District or Properties Designation. 18 19 1. General. 20 21 a. Purpose and Intent… 22 23 b. Applicability. 24 This application shall be 25applicable to all improved property that meets the 26criteria of Chapter 4, Article IX, Section 6.C. 27Applications for historic designation may be 28initiated by only the following: 29 30(1) Historic Resources Preservation 31Board, herein referred to as “Board” (see 32Chapter 1, Article VII, Section 4). 33 34(2) City Commission. 35 36(3) A property owner for designation of 37a Site. 38 39(4) A simple majority of property 40owners within the proposed District under 41consideration for designation. 42 43For District designations, each Property 44shall be allotted one (1) vote. The identity 45of the property owners shall be determined - 11 - 1 2Rolls. 3 4Only the Board or the City Commission may initiate 5designation of a property or district owned by the 6City, County, State, or by an entity created by state 7law. For District designations, each Property shall 8be allotted one vote. The identity of the property 9owners shall be determined by the most current 10Palm Beach County Property Tax Rolls. 11 c. Terms and Definitions… 12 13 2. Submittal Requirements… 14 3. Review Criteria… 15 16 4. Approval Process. 17 18 a. Board Agenda… 19 20 b. Board Public Hearing Notice. 21The 22Board shall advertise and hold a public hearing in 23accordance with the following public noticing 24requirements: 25 26(1) For the proposed designation of an 27individual site, the applicant, at least ten 28(10) calendar days prior to the date set for 29the public hearing, shall: 30 31(a) Mail a notice of the time, 32place and subject matter of the public 33hearing to any owner of abutting or 34adjacent property as determined by 35the Historic Preservation Planner. 36 37(b) Post one (1) sign for each 38street frontage of the property in a 39prominent location. 40 41(2) For the proposed designation of a 42historic district, the applicant(s), at least ten 43(10) calendar days prior to the date set for 44the public hearing, shall: 45 - 12 - 1(a) Mail a notice of the time, 2place and subject matter of the 3hearing to any owner of real property 4within 400 feet of district subject to 5potential designation, 6 7(b) Post signs in prominent 8locations along public streets at the 9outer boundaries of the proposed 10district in such a manner as will 11assure that the signs will be seen by 12as many affected property owners as 13possible 14 15Signs shall be legible from a distance of 100 feet 16and shall contain a description of the approval being 17sought, the date, time and location of the hearing, 18and a statement that the application being 19considered is available for inspection in the 20Development Department of the City of Boynton 21Beach. Minimum sign size shall be 24” wide by 2218” high. 23 24Notice of the time, place and subject matter of the 25hearing shall be mailed to the applicant and mailed 26to any owner of real property within 400 feet of the 27property or district subject to potential designation, 28at least 30 10 calendar days prior to the date set for 29the public hearing. 30 31For the proposed designation of an individual site, 32one (1) sign for each street frontage of the property 33shall be posted in a prominent location no less than 3410 calendar days prior to the hearing. In the case of 35a proposed historic district, signs will be placed in 36prominent locations along public streets at the outer 37boundaries of the proposed district in such a manner 38as will assure that the signs will be seen by as many 39affected property owners as possible. Signs shall be 40legible from a distance of 100 feet and shall contain 41a description of the approval being sought, the date, 42time and location of the hearing, and a statement 43that the application being considered is available for 44inspection in the Development Department of the 45City of Boynton Beach. Minimum sign size shall be 4624” wide by 18” high. - 13 - 1 c. No Action Permitted During Pendency… 2 d. Board Recommendations… 3 e. City Commission Decision… 4 f. Boynton Beach Register of Historic 5 Places. 6 .. g. Designation Recorded… 7 h. Historic District Street Signs… 8 9 C. Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption 10 Application… 11 12 Section7. Other Applications. 13 14 A. Certificate of Conformity… 15 B. Lot Line Modification… 16 C. Mobile Vendor Approval… 17 D. Modification to Development Order… 18 E. Sidewalk Café Approval… 19 F. Wireless Communication Facilities (WCF)… 20 G. Zoning Verification… 21 22 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 2, ARTICLE IV BUILDING DIVISION SERVICES 23 24 Section 1. General… 25 Section 2. Building Permit. 26 27 A. General… 28 B. Submittal Requirements… 29 C. Review Criteria… 30 D. Approval Process… 31 E. State of Florida Fees… 32 33 F. Miscellaneous. 34 35 1. Revocation of Permits… 36 37 2. Certificate of Occupancy. 38No building or 39structure hereafter erected or structurally altered shall be 40issued a certificate of occupancy until the Building Official 41makes a finding that the building or structure has been 42erected or structurally altered in conformance with the 43provisions of this ordinance, and of all other applicable 44ordinances.Upon the issuance of a certificate of 45occupancy, an improved site must be maintained in 46compliance with the approved site plan. - 14 - 1 Part III (LDR), Chapter 3, Article III ZONING DISTRICT AND OVERLAY 2 ZONES 3 4 Section 1. Overview. 5 6 A. General… 7 B. Residential Building and Site Regulations (Table 3-1). 8 9 10 - 15 - 1 2 C. Non-Residential Building and Site Regulations (Table 3- 3 2)… 4 D. Mixed-Use Suburban Building and Site Regulations 5 (Table 3-3)… 6 7 8 - 16 - 1 2 E. Mixed-Use Urban Building Site and Site Regulations 3 (Table 3-4). 4 - 17 - MIXED USE, URBAN MU-L1 MU-L2 MU-L3 MU-H Lot Area, Minimum (acres): Public park: N/AN/AN/AN/A All other uses: 0.50 0.75 11 12 Lot Frontage, Minimum (feet): 100100150200 Structure Height, Minimum 303030 30 (feet): Maximum Building / Structure Height (HT), Density (DU), and Floor-Area-Ratio (FAR): Classification of project frontage on type of roadway: 53355, 6 HTDUFAR HTDUFARHTDUFARHTDUFAR 65 / 75 / 3.0/ 150/ Arterial: 45201.0 30/402.0/2.5 40804.0 333 1001003.5125 Collector: 45201.0 6530/402.0/2.5 75403.0/3.5 125804.0 Local collector: 45201.0 4530/402.0/2.5 55403.0 55603.5 4 Local:45201.0 4530/402.0/2.5 45201.0 45201.0 Building Setbacks Build-to-line 11 (feet): 1010101010101010 Front abutting a public right-of-way 0 to 100 to 100 to 100 to 15 10101010 Rear:0000 10101010 Interior side:0000 Building Setbacks, Minimum 11 (feet): 1213 Rear abutting: 78777 Residential single family: 25/ 0252525 99 Intracoastal waterway: 25250 0 12121212 All other uses:10101010 1213 Side abutting: 77, 8777 Residential single family: 25/ 0252525 12121212 All other uses:10101010 Usable Open Space, Minimum 13 14 2% (square feet): 1 2 3 1.May be reduced if frontage extends from right-of-way to right-of-way line. 4 2.Minimum of 50 feet, if frontage is on a collector/local collector roadway. 5 3.For property abutting the MU-H district located west of US 1, the area of increases in height, density and FAR shall extend a distance of 6 100 feet from the MU-H zoning district line and shall require conditional use approval. For properties abutting the MU-H district located 7 east of US 1, the area of increase for height shall extend a distance of 100 feet from the MU-H zoning district line and shall require 8 conditional use approval; however, no increases in density and FAR are allowed. Must also have principal frontage on Arterial roadway. 9 4.Must also have frontage on local collector or higher roadway classification. 10 5.Maximum height on any street frontage is 40 feet. Maximum height on Intracoastal Waterway is 35 feet. Heights may require reduction 11 where adjacent to a single-family zoning district where necessary to achieve the compatibility requirements of these regulations. 12 6.Maximum height reduced to 125 feet for the entire project where property abuts any MU-Lor residential zoning district not separated by a 13 right-of-way. 14 7.Plus one additional foot for each foot of height over 35 feet. 15 8.Where there is an intervening right-of-ay of at least 40 feet. w 16 9.Subject to permitting agency approval. 17 10.Sidewalk of at least 10 feet required. Setback may be greater if public plaza/gathering space is provided.Buildings and structures shall be 18 located no farther than zero (0) feet from the property line, excluding those instances where strict adherence hereto would cause visual 19 obstructions to vehicular traffic, particularly within the triangular-shaped area of property formed by the intersection of two (2) rights-of- 20 way. See Section 5.C.2 below for additional relief provisions from build-t line requirements.o 21 11.Listed eligible Historic structures are not required to meet these standards. 22 12.The ultimate setback is also a factor of height and application of the Sky Exposure Plane in accordance with Section 5.C.3 below. 23 13.Usable open space shall be required for all developments two (2) acres in size or larger. A minimum of two percent (2%) of the site shall 24 be devoted to usable open space, consisting of plazas or public open space, excluding private recreation. See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 25 8 for additional regulations. 26 12.Reduction in setback may be allowed if void of negative impacts on adjacent use or on development potential of adjacent propert.y 27 13.The ultimate setback is also a factor of height and application of the Sky Exposure Plane in accordance with Section 5.C.2 below. - 18 - 1 14.Usable open space shall be required for all developments two (2) acres in size or larger. A minimum of two percent (2%) of the site shall 2 be devoted to usable open space, consisting of plazas or public open space, excluding private recreation. See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3 3.B. for additional regulations. 4 Section 2. Residential Districts. 5 6 A. R-1-AAB SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 7 DISTRICT… 8 B. R-1-AA SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 9 DISTRICT… 10 C. R-1-A. SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 11 DISTRICT… 12 D. R-1 SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 13 DISTRICT… 14 E. R-2 SINGLE AND TWO-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 15 DISTRICT... 16 F. R-3 MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 17 DISTRICT… 18 G. IPUD INFILL PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT 19 DISTRICT 20. 21 1.General… 22 2. Use(s) Allowed… 23 3. Building and Site Regulations (Table 3-11)… 24 4. Review and Approval Process… 25 5. Parking… 26 6. Modifications… 27 7. Miscellaneous. 28 29 a… 30 b. 31 See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 43.J for 32additionalcommunity design standards regarding 33required site design in instances where the subject 34IPUD project is adjacent to single-family residential 35zoning districts. 36 c… 37 d… 38 e… 39 f… 40 g… 41 h… 42 43 Section 3. Commercial Districts… 44 Section 4. SMU MIXED-USE SUBURBAN DISTRICT. 45 A. General… 46 B.Use(s) Allowed… 47 - 19 - C. Additional Use Regulations… 1 D. Building and Site Regulations. 2 3 1. Building and Site Regulation (Table 3-20). 4 5 6 - 20 - 1 2. Building Height Measurement… 2 3. Height Setback Envelope… 3 4 E. Review and Approval Process… 5 6 F. Parking. 7Required off-street parking is regulated in 8accordance with Chapter 4, Article V Minimum Off-Street Parking 9Requirements. See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 6.F.4 for 10additional community design standards pertaining to off-street 11parking. 12 1.Freestanding Parking Garages. 13As required by 14Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.C.4.b. 15 2.Building Integrated Garages 16.As required by 17Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.C.4.c. 18 3.Off-Street Parking Facilities. 19The SMU 20district contains additional standards relative to location 21and appearance of off-street parking facilities. Refer to 22Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.C.4 for these additional 23development standards. - 21 - 1 G. Modifications… 2 H. Miscellaneous… 3 4 Section 5. Mixed-Use (Urban) Districts… 5 6 A. General… 7 B. Use(s) Allowed… 8 C. Building and Site Regulations. 9 10 1. Building and Site Regulation (Table 3-21). 11 12 - 22 - MIXED USE, URBAN MU-L1 MU-L2 MU-L3 MU-H Lot Area, Minimum (acres): Public park: N/AN/AN/AN/A All other uses: 0.50 0.75 11 12 Lot Frontage, Minimum (feet): 100150200 100 Structure Height, Minimum 303030 30 (feet): Maximum Building / Structure Height (HT), Density (DU), and Floor-Area-Ratio (FAR): Classification of project frontage on type of roadway: 53355, 6 HTDUFAR HTDUFARHTDUFARHTDUFAR 65 / 75 / 3.0/ 150/ Arterial: 45201.0 30/402.0/2.5 40804.0 333 1001003.5125 Collector: 45201.0 6530/402.0/2.5 75403.0/3.5 125804.0 Local collector: 45201.0 4530/402.0/2.5 55403.0 55603.5 4 Local:45201.0 4530/402.0/2.5 45201.0 45201.0 Building Setbacks Build-to-line 11 (feet): 1010101010101010 Front abutting a public right-of-way 0 to 100 to 100 to 100 to 15 10101010 Rear:0000 10101010 Interior side:0000 Building Setbacks, Minimum 11 (feet): 1213 Rear abutting: 78777 Residential single family: 25/ 0252525 99 Intracoastal waterway: 25250 0 12121212 All other uses:10101010 1213 Side abutting: 77, 8777 Residential single family: 25/ 0252525 12121212 All other uses:10101010 Usable Open Space, Minimum 13 14 2% (square feet): 1 2 - 23 - 2.Minor and Major Variations to Build-to 1 Line Requirements. 2Notwithstanding the required 3build-to line requirement of Note #10 above, 4portions of buildings and structures may be 5constructed in excess of the distance specified in the 6above table, but not to exceed 15 feet in order to 1) 7optimize landscape design; 2) maximize on-site 8drainage solutions; 3) accommodate architectural 9features and building enhancements; or 4) to 10otherwise enhance public spaces such as sidewalks, 11plazas, fountains, or outdoor seating areas in order 12to further the purpose and intent of the Overlay 13Zone. Major deviations from the build-to line 14requirement above (in excess of 15 feet) may be 15allowed, but only with sufficient justification and 16contingent upon the approval of a Community 17Design Appeal application (see Chapter 2, Article 18II, Section 4.B). 19 3. Sky Exposure Plane… 202. 21 D. Review and Approval Process… 22 23 E. Parking 24. 25 1. General Requirements… 26 2. Reduced Parking Requirements in MU-H 27 district 28… 29 3. Off-Street Parking Facilities. 30 The Mixed 31Use (Urban) districts contain additional standards relative 32to location and appearance of off-street parking facilities. 33Refer to Chapter 4, Article III, Section 6.F 3.C.3 for these 34additional development standards. 35 F. Miscellaneous. 36 37 1. Access… 38 2. Building Location. 39See Chapter 4, Article III, 40Section 6 3.H.2. 3.Location of Dumpsters and Trash Receptacles… 41 4. Shade and Shelter. 42 See Chapter 4, Article III, 43Section 6 3.H.3. 44 - 24 - 5.Sidewalks in MU-H District. 1See Chapter 4, 2Article III, Section 6 for community design standards 3related to sidewalks VIII, Section D. 4 6.Landscape and Streetscape Design… 5 6 Section 6. Industrial Districts. 7 8 A. M-1 INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT. 9 10 1.General… 11 2. Use(s) Allowed… 12 13 3. Building and Site Regulations (Table 3-22) 14. 15 BUILDING / SITE REGULATIONS M-1 District 1 Minimum lot area: 10,000 s.f. Minimum lot frontage: 0 feet Minimum yard setbacks: Front:15feet 2 1 Rear:20 feet Abutting:Residential district(s) 30 feet 3 2 Interior side: 15 feet Abutting:Residential district(s) 30 feet Corner side: 15 feet Maximum lot coverage: 60% 43 Maximum Floor Area Ratio (FAR) 0.50 5 4 Maximum structure height: 45 feet 16 1 17A property that does not meet this 18minimum size shall be considered 19conforming only if it contains a whole 20platted lot and was not in combination with 21other lots under the same ownership at the 22time of the effective date of this ordinance 23(October 2, 2012), in which the cumulative 24size would have met the minimum required 25by code. Any such undersized lots that are 26further subdivided and reduced in size shall 27be considered non-conforming pursuant to 28Chapter 3, Article V, Section 11. 29 30 - 25 - 2 1 1Where rear yard abuts a 2railroad right-of-way or any paved alley, the 3rear yard may be reduced to 10 feet. 4 3 2 5Where rear yard abuts a 6paved alley or street, then no side setback 7shall be required. 8 4 3 9A Floor Area Ratio (FAR) up 10to 0.50 may be considered for industrial uses 11allowed within the M-1 district (see “Use 12Matrix” – Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 133.D), pursuant to the Industrial Future Land 14Use classification of the Comprehensive 15Plan. 16 5 4 17Not to exceed four (4) stories. 18 Section 7. Miscellaneous Districts. 19 20 Section 8. Overlay Zones 21 22 A. URBAN CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT 23 OVERLAY ZONE… 24 B. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. BOULEVARD 25 OVERLAY ZONE 26… 27 C. URBAN COMMERCIAL DISTRICT OVERLAY 28 ZONE 29. 30 1. Intent… 31 2. Objectives… 32 3. Defined. 33The Urban Commercial District Overlay 34Zone (UCDOZ0 is established in the city redevelopment 35plans as the geographical area defined by the following 36boundaries: 37 a. Federal Highway Corridor Community 38 Redevelopment Plan 39… 40 b. The Ocean District Community 41 Redevelopment Plan 42… 43 c. Boynton Beach Boulevard Corridor 44Plan. 45The boundary is the commercially-zoned parcels - 26 - 1located along west Boynton Beach Boulevard, east 2of Interstate 95, and west of Seacrest Boulevard. 3 4. Conflict… 4 5. Building and Site Regulations (Table 3-26). 5 6Development within this Overlay Zone shall be in 7accordance with building and site regulations applicable to 8the underlying zoning district except as follows: 9 BUILDING SITE REGULATIONS Urban Commercial District Overlay Zone Build-to line: 1 Front (abutting any public right-of-way):0 ft 1 Rear: 0 ft 1 Interior side: 0 ft Minimum yard setbacks: Rear (abutting residential district):30 feet Interior side (abutting residential district):15 feet 2 Maximum structure height:Zoning 10 1 11Buildings and structures shall be located no farther 12than zero (0) feet from the property line, excluding those 13instances where strict adherence hereto would cause visual 14obstructions to vehicular traffic, particularly within the 15triangular-shaped area of property formed by the 16intersection of two (2) rights-of-way. Notwithstanding the 17required build-to line requirement, portions of buildings 18and structures may be constructed in excess of the distance 19specified above, but not to exceed 15 feet when necessary 20to 1) optimize landscape design; 2) maximize on-site 21drainage solutions; 3) accommodate architectural features 22and building enhancements; and/or 4) to otherwise enhance 23public spaces such as sidewalks, plazas, fountains, or 24outdoor seating areas in order to further the purpose and 25intent of the Overlay Zone. Major deviations from the 26build-to line requirement above (in excess of 15 feet) may 27be allowed, but only with sufficient justification and 28contingent upon the approval of a Community Design 29Appeal application (see Chapter 2, Article II, Section 4.B). 30 2 31 Shall be defined by the applicable zoning district. 32 33 BUILDING / SITE REGULATIONS Urban Commercial District Overlay Zone - 27 - Minimum yard setbacks: Front:5 ft – 15 ft 1 Rear:Zoning Interior side:0 ft – 15 ft Abutting:Residential district:15 feet Corner side: 10 ft – 15 ft Maximum lot coverage:40% 1 Maximum structure height: Zoning 1 1 2Shall be defined by the applicable zoning 3district. 4 6. Parking… 5 7. Miscellaneous. 6 7 a.Landscape and Streetscape Design… 8 9 b. Building Location. 10See Chapter 4, Article 11III, Section 6 3.H.2. c. Shade and Shelter. 12 See Chapter 4, Article 13III, Section 6 3.H.3. 14 D. OCEAN AVENUE OVERLAY ZONE (OAOZ)… 15 16 1. Purpose and Intent… 17 2. Defined… 18 3. Conflict… 19 4. Uses Allowed. .. 20 5. Building and Site Regulations (Table 3-27). 21 22Development within this Overlay Zone, including 23proposed expansions and additions to existing structures 24shall be in accordance with the building and site regulations 25as follows: 26 BUILDING / SITE REGULATIONS 1 Ocean Avenue Overlay Zone (Single Lot Depth) Minimum lot area: 5,000 s.f. Minimum lot frontage: 50 feet Build-to-line Maximum build-to line: 2 Front:5 ft – 15 ft 2 Corner side: 5 ft – 15 ft Minimum yard setbacks: Rear:10feet - 28 - 3 Abutting:Residential district: 20 feet 4 Interior side: 7.5 feet Abutting:Historic structures: 10 feet Maximum lot coverage: 65% 5 Maximum structure height: 35 feet (Double Lot Depth) All new developments with double lot depth shall be constructed in accordance with the Mixed-Use Low Intensity (MU-L1) zoning district building and site regulation Table 3-21 in Section 5.C above, except as contained herein. See “Single-Lot Depth” above for all proposed expansions or additions to existing structures. 5 Maximum structure height: 35 feet 1 2 6.Accessory Structures… 3 7. Parking… 4 8.Landscape and Streetscape Design… 5 9. Building Design. 6 10. Signage and Exterior Lighting Standards… 7 8 Section 9. Penalties… 9 10 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 3, ARTICLE IV USE REGULATIONS 11 12 Section 1. Operational Performance Standards… 13 14 A.Noise 15. No use shall be carried out in any zoning district so 16as to create sound which is in violation of Part II, Section 15-8 of 17the City of Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances. Any use wherein 18floorshows or other forms of entertainment consisting of one (1) or 19more persons, amplified or non-amplified sound, are provided 20indoors or outdoors, including but not limited to entertainment 21provided by a disc jockey (DJ), master of ceremonies (MC), 22karaoke, or the like shall be subject to the Live Entertainment 23Permit requirement of Part II (City Code of Ordinances), Chapter 2413, Article IV, Section 13-80. 25 Section 2. Hazardous / Toxic Waste and Substances… 26 Section 3. Use Regulations… 27 28 Section 4. Conditional Uses. 29 - 29 - 1 A. Applicability... 2 B. Definition… 3 4 C.Standards for Evaluating Conditional Uses… 5 6 1… 7 2… 8 3… 9 4 10… 5… 11 6… 12 7… 13 8… 14 9… 15 10… 16 17 11. 18 Where applicable, the proposed use furthers the 19purpose and intent of a corresponding mixed use zoning 20district or redevelopment plan; and 21 12. 22 Compliance with, and abatement of nuisances and 23hazards in accordance with the Operational Performance 24Standards as indicated in Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 1 25and the Noise Control Ordinance, Part II, Chapter 15, 26Section 15.8 of the Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances.; 27and 28 29A sound impact analysis shall be required for new or 30expanding bar, nightclub or similar uses when involving 31property within 300 feet of a residential district. The 32analysis shall include mitigating solutions that would 33reduce or eliminate any potential for off-site nuisance 34conditions. Depending on the size of the proposed use, the 35distances to and level of compatibility with adjacent land 36uses, the sound analysis may be required to include 37information, diagrams and sketches indicating the types and 38locations of proposed sound emitting equipment, speaker 39orientations, maximum output, building or site design 40intended to mitigate sound impacts, and any operational 41standards including an affidavit documenting maximum 42sound limits to be maintained based on the findings of the 43analysis. 44 45A live entertainment permit shall be required if a 46bar/nightclub proposes live entertainment as defined in Part - 30 - 1II (Code of Ordinances), Chapter 13, Article IV, Section 213-80. 3 13. 4Required sound study and analysis. All conditional 5use applications for bars, nightclubs and similar 6establishments shall include the following analysis 7performed by a certified acoustic engineer, unless a Live 8Entertainment Permit is applied for and received in 9accordance with Chapter 13, Article III “Live 10Entertainment Permit” (13-80): 11 a. 12Data on the sound emitting 13devices/equipment and the methods and materials to 14be used to assure that the acoustic level of the City 15Code will be met; 16 b. 17Theanalysis shall specify the authority 18and/or basis for determination of the acoustic level 19of the sound emitting devices/ equipment; 20 c. 21The analysis of any sound retention, 22reduction or reflection shall include information 23such as the nature, types and coefficients of sound 24absorbent and sound-reflecting materials to be used, 25coatings of the surfaces of ceilings, walls, windows, 26and floors and insulation to be used; and / or 27 d. 28It shall also verify that sound standards shall 29be met during the normal opening of doors for 30people entering and exiting the establishment. 31 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 3, ARTICLE V SUPPLEMENTAL REGULATIONS 32 33 Section 1. General… 34 35 Section 2. Walls and Fences. 36 37 38Walls and fences are allowed in all zoning districts within all required 39yards and shall be regulated as follows: 40 A. Location and Height… 41 B. Cross-Visibility and Safe Sight… 42 43 C. Design. 44 Walls and fences shall be symmetrical in 45appearance with columns and posts conforming to a definite 46pattern and size of uniform design and separation. The wall or - 31 - 1fence shall be kept in good repair and be continuously maintained 2in its original appearance. All walls and fences shall be erected 3with the finished side facing adjacent properties. The face of any 4fence or wall visible to the public shall also be finished. 5 6 7 8The exterior surface of a wall shall be finished with paint, stucco, 9or other commonly accepted material. See Chapter 4, Article III, 10Section 3.E for additional standards regarding the appearance of 11walls and fences. 12 D. Dangerous Materials… 13 E. Attachments… 14 F. Construction Sites… 15 G. Easements… 16 H. Buffer Walls… 17 I. Low Voltage Security Fencing… 18 19 Section 3. Common Building Appurtenances, Freestanding 20 Structures, and Site Amenities, Excluding Walls and Fences. 21 22 A. Building Appurtenances… 23 24 B. Decks, Patios, Steps, Stoops, and Terraces (Unenclosed 25 and Uncovered). 26Unless otherwise regulated by a master plan or 27site plan for a planned development, unenclosed and uncovered 28decks, patios, steps, stoops, and terraces less than or equal to one 29(1)-foot in height shall be setback at least two (2) feet from any 30property line. Those with heights betweengreater than one (1) 31foot but less than or equal to and three (3) feet shall be setback at 32least three (3) feet from any property line.In both instances, they 33shall be maintained and drained so as to prevent nuisance 34conditions to the public and/or abutting property owners. Decks, 35patios, steps, stoops, and terraces greater than three (3) feet in - 32 - 1height shall comply with the minimum setbacks required for the 2principal building. Driveways for residential off-street parking 3areas shall be regulated in accordance with Chapter 4, Article V, 4Section 2.B. 5 C. Screened-Roof Enclosures… 6 D. Swimming Pools and Spas… 7 8 Section 4. Sale of Used Merchandise… 9 Section 5. Exterior Display of Merchandise… 10 Section 6. Special Sales Event… 11 Section 7. Seasonal Sales Event… 12 Section 8. Permanent Exterior Storage of Merchandise and 13 Equipment. 14 15 A. Purpose and Intent… 16 B. Districts… 17 C. Site Plan Required… 18 19 D. Type of Merchandise / Equipment. 20 The 21permanent exterior storage of retail merchandise or equipment is 22allowed, provided that said merchandise / equipment is owned by 23the operator of the respective business occupying the 24establishment, and is of the same type of merchandise or 25equipment typically sold or stored within the principal building. 26No exterior storage of building or construction materials shall be 27allowed anywhere, except for that which is stored in connection 28with a lawfully operating business (e.g., C) as provided ONTRACTOR 29for in Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3. 30 E. On-Site Location… 31 FSize… 32. G. Screening... 33 34 Section 9. Sidewalk Cafés… 35 Section 10. Mobile Vendor Regulations… 36 Section 11. Nonconforming Regulations. 37 38 A. Lots and Parcels. 39 40 1. R-1 district, R-1A district, R-2 district, and R-3 41 district... 42 2.R-2 district 43… 3.R-1AA district… 44 4. R-1AAB district… 45 5. Densities 46… - 33 - 6.Minimum Development Regulations 1. 2 Nonconforming lots which may be developed 3without requiring the approval of a variance, and which lie 4in residential districts, shall meet the minimum property 5development regulations that are generally applicable in the 6district; except, however, that the minimum setbacks shall 7be as follows: 8 … 9 10 7. Nonresidential Districts. 11 12 a. Generally. 13 In nonresidential districts, 14additional floor area and / or expansions to 15nonconforming buildings and structures are 16allowed, provided that the development meets all 17district setbacks. In nonresidential zoning districts, 18excluding M-1 Light Industrial, if both the lot area 19and lot frontage are not less than 85% of that 20required for the particular district, then structures 21and floor area may be added and the use may be 22changed from a residential to a nonresidential use 23on a nonconforming lot, without requiring the 24approval of a variance for the lot area or lot 25frontage. If either the lot area or lot frontage is less 26than 85% of that required for the particular district, 27then approval of a variance would be shall be 28required in order to add structures or add floor area 29to existing buildings or to change the use from a 30residential to a nonresidential use. Improvements 31which do not add structures or floor area or change 32the use of the property shall be permitted, regardless 33of lot size or frontage. For nonconforming lots 34which are vacant or are proposed to be cleared and 35redeveloped, approval of a variance shall be 36required prior to the construction of any structures 37or establishment of any use on the lot or parcel. 38 39The value of buildings shall be determined from the 40latest tax rolls on file at the Palm Beach County 41Property Appraiser's Office. 42 b. M-1 District. 43 A property that does not meet 44the minimum lot size required by Chapter 3, Article 45III, Section 6.A.3 shall be considered conforming 46only if it contained a whole platted lot prior to the - 34 - 1effective date of this ordinance (October 2, 2012), 2and was not in combination with other in which the 3cumulative size would have met the minimum 4required by code. 5 c. Landscaping. 6 All developed or redeveloped lots 7zoned M-1 or C-4 and determined to be valid 8nonconforming lots relative to minimum lot area standards 9shall provide landscaping on-site that meets the intent of 10the urban landscape code of to the maximum extent 11feasible (see Chapter 4, Article II, Section 4.B). 12 B. Buildings and Structures… 13. 14 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE I ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 15 STANDARDS 16 17 ARTICLE I ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION STANDARDS 18 19 Section 1. General… 20 Section 2. City Approval Required… 21 Section 3. Preservation Principals… 22 Section 4. Standards… 23 24 A. General… 25 B. Preservation Efforts… 26 27 C. Mitigation of Existing Trees (Table 4-1 Mitigation of 28 Existing Trees). 29All existing trees that are not preserved in 30place or relocated on-site shall be mitigated in connection with a 31land development permit. The equivalent replacement for existing 32trees shall be based on caliper dimension or type of tree as 33indicated in the table below: 34 Type of Replacement Tree Type of Existing Canopy TreeCanopy TreeLarge PalmSmall & 1 Tree (< 24” Caliper)(> 24” Caliper)TreeMedium Size Palm Trees Canopy Tree 223 1 tree 1 tree 2 trees3 trees (< 24” Caliper) Canopy Tree 223 1 tree 1 tree 4 trees3 trees ( 24” Caliper) Large Palm Tree1 tree1 tree1 tree3 trees Small & Medium 1 tree1 tree1 tree1 tree Size Palm Trees - 35 - 1 1 2Large palm trees are those species, such as Florida Royal, 3Canary Island Date, or any other palm species determined by staff 4to provide similar or greater shading compared to a canopy tree. 5 2 6 The cumulative caliper inches of existing trees to be 7removed shall be replaced on-site with an equal or greater number 8of caliper inches of a replacement canopy tree or trees. 9 3 10 A cluster of three (3) small or medium size palm trees shall 11be the equivalent replacement of one (1) canopy tree. Additional 12clusters of palm trees shall be required for each increment of four 13(4) caliper inches. For canopy trees having a trunk size equal to or 14greater than 24 caliper inches, no more than 50% of the caliper 15inches of the replaced canopy tree shall be substituted with s palm 16species. 17 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE II LANDSCAPE DESIGN AND 18 BUFFERING STANDARDS 19 20 ARTICLE II LANDSCAPE DESIGN AND BUFFERING STANDARDS 21 22 Section 1. General… 23 Section 2. City Approval Required… 24 Section 3. Landscape Design Principles… 25 26 Section 4. Standards. 27 28 A. City-Wide Standards… 29 30 1. Native and Drought Tolerant Species… 31 2.Prohibited Species… 32. 33 3.Plant Material… 34 35 a.Trees… 36 37 38(1) Signature Tree… 39 40(2) Species. The minimum number 41of different species of trees provided shall 42be as follows: 43 44(i) Table 4-2 1 Tree Species… 45(ii) Signature trees… - 36 - 1(iii)Small and medium palm 2Palm species, in a cluster of three (3) 3trees with varying heights, shall 4represent the equivalent of one (1) 5canopy tree or large palm tree. For 6the purposes of this subsection, large 7palm trees are those species, such as 8Florida Royal, Canary Island Date, 9or any other palm species determined 10by staff that has the same 11visual/shading effect as that of a 12canopy tree. 13 14(iv) No more than 50% of 15required trees on a lot within 16commercial or mixed-use zoning 17districts shall be comprised of palm 18species. 19 b. Shrubs and Hedges… 20 c. Vines… 21 d. Lawn… 22 23 4. Existing Plant Material… 24 5.Water Source… 25 6. Irrigation… 26 7.Installation… 27 8. Mulch (Non-living Plantings)… 28 9.Upland Buffer / Littoral Plantings… 29 10. Landscaping within Easements… 30 11. Landscaping within Rights-of-Way… 31 32 12.Landscaping within Off-Street Parking Lots… 33 34 a. Required Landscaping… 35 b. Tree Size and Type… 36 c. Large Islands… 37 d. Small Islands… 38 e. Plantings… 39 f. Cross Visibility… 40 g. Lighting… 41 42 h. Entrances/Exits. 43 Design emphasis shall 44be given to the entrances and exits to parking areas 45through the use of landscaping unless otherwise 46determined by staff to be contrary to the design - 37 - 1objectives and principles of this article and/or 2Chapter 4, Article III. 3 13.Maintenance... 4 14. Cross-Visibility and Safe-Sight… 5 15. Raised Planters… 6 16. Maximum Height of Hedges… 7 17. Soils… 8 18. Pesticides… 9 19. Crime Prevention Through Environmental 10 Design (CPTED)… 11 12 20. Non-Conforming Lots. 13 All developed or 14redeveloped lots zoned M-1 or C-4 and determined to be 15valid nonconforming lots relative to minimum lot area 16standards shall provide landscaping on-site that meets the 17intent of the urban landscape code of Section 4.B below to 18the maximum extent feasible. 19 B. Urban Landscape Code. 20 21 1. General. 22 23 a. Applicability. 24 The “urban landscape 25code” shall apply to all properties currently zoned 26Central Business District (CBD), any properties 27located within the Mixed Use (urban) districts (see 28Chapter 3, Article III, Section 5), the Infill Planned 29Unit Development (IPUD) district (see Chapter 3, 30Article III, Section 2.G.), or any commercially- 31zoned properties located within the Urban 32Commercial District Overlay Zone (see Chapter 3, 33Article III, Section 8). All developed or 34redeveloped lots zoned M-1 or C-4 and determined 35to be valid nonconforming lots relative to minimum 36lot area standards shall provide landscaping on-site 37that meets the intent of the urban landscape code to 38the maximum extent feasible. 39 b. General Rules… 40 41 2. Landscape Strip Abutting Rights-of-Way… 42 3. Perimeter Landscape Buffers. 43 44 a. General… 45 b. Performance Standards… 46 - 38 - 1 c. Design Standards. 2 Perimeter landscape 3buffers shall be applied and designed as follows: 4 5(1) Table 4-3 2. Urban Landscape 6Buffer (Type 1). 7 8(2) Table 4-4 3. Urban Landscape 9Buffer (Type 2). 10 11(3) Table 4- 5 4. Urban Landscape 12Barrier. 13 14(4) Notes… 15 d. Exceptions (Cross Access)… 16 17 e. Along Florida East Coast Railroad… 18 f. Miscellaneous… 19 20 4. Interior Open Space. 21 See usable open space 22requirements of the Infill Planned Unit Development 23(IPUD) zoning district in Chapter 3, Article III, Section 2.G 244, Article III, Section 3.B. 25 5. Streetscape Design… 26 27 C. Suburban Landscape Code. 28 29 1. General… 30 2. Landscape Strip Abutting Rights-of-Way… 31 32 3. Perimeter Landscape Buffers. 33 34 a. General… 35 36 b. Standards. 37 Perimeter landscape buffers 38shall be applied and designed as follows: 39 40(1) Table 4-6 5. Suburban Landscape 41Buffer (Type 1). 42 43(2) Table 4-7 6. Suburban Landscape 44Buffer (Type 2). 45 - 39 - 1(3) Table 4-8 7. Suburban Landscape 2Buffer (Type 3). 3 4(4) Table 4-9 8. Suburban Landscape 5Barrier 6 7(5) Notes… 8 c. Exceptions (Cross Access)… 9 d. Along Florida East Coast Railroad… 10. e. Miscellaneous… 11 12 4. Interior Open Space… 13 14 a. Multi-family and Planned 15 Developments… 16 17 b.SMU Suburban Mixed Use District. 18 19 See usable open space requirements of the 20Suburban Mixed Use (SMU) district in Chapter 3, 21Article III, Section 4 Chapter 4, Article III, Section 223.B. 23 c. PID Planned Industrial District… 24 25 Section 5. Alternate Compliance. 26 27 A. General… 28 29 1. Purpose and Intent… 30 2. Administration… 31 3.Applicability... 32 33 4. Nonconforming Lots. 34All developed or 35redeveloped lots zoned M-1 or C-4 and determined to be 36valid nonconforming lots relative to minimum lot area 37standards shall provide landscaping on-site that meets the 38intent of the urban landscape code of Section 4.B above to 39the maximum extent feasible. An Alternative Landscape 40Plan (ALP)may be utilized to consider spatial limitations, 41limited visibility by the general public, and use 42characteristics of the subject and adjacent properties. 43Landscape design should emphasize canopy trees along the 44perimeter of the site with hedge and groundcover plantings 45only required between the building and any street right-of- 46way. However, lots with a side corner yard abutting an - 40 - 1improved right-of-way and those abutting residentially 2zoned property will be required to screen off-street parking 3and storage areas with understory plantings in addition to 4the canopy trees. On lots abutting the Florida East Coast 5(FEC) Railroad right-of-way, landscaping in accordance 6with the provisions of Chapter 4, Article II, Section 4.B.3.c 7shall be provided. Where deficiencies occur due to site 8constraints, other methods of landscaping (e.g., landscape 9cut-outs, planter pots, hanging baskets, etc.) may also be 10incorporated into the design to achieve site buffering as 11intended by City standards. 12 B. Alternative Landscape Plan (ALP)… 13 14 Section 6. Community Design. 15 16 A. General. 17 18 1. Purpose and Intent… 19 2. Administration… 20 3. Applicability… 21 22 4. Relief from Standards. 23 Any deviation from these 24landscape standards shall require a Community Design 25Plan Appeal (CDPA), which is subject to review and 26approval by the City Commission. A request for a CDPA 27shall be reviewed in accordance with Chapter 2, Article II, 28Section 4.B. 29 B. Foundation Landscaping Areas… 30 C.Plazas. 31 Plazas shall contain paved, open, and 32landscaped areas. At least one (1) tree shall be planted for each 33900 square feet of plaza area. Shade trees shall be planted within 34the plaza area or along the periphery. See Chapter 4, Article III, 35Section 7 3.B for additional regulations regarding plazas and open 36space. 37 D. Drive-through Facilities. 38 Pursuant to Chapter 4, Article 39III, Section 3.J Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.A.10, drive- 40through facilities shall not be allowed on any building facade that 41directly faces a public or private right-of-way. Landscape material 42may be used to provide additional screening to ensure that said 43facilities, located on eligible building facades, are not visible from 44abutting properties or rights-of-way (pubic and private). This 45landscape screen shall consist of trees, shrubs, a berm, or a - 41 - 1combination thereof, necessary to achieve the desired buffering 2effect. 3 E. Service Areas… 4 5 F. Mechanical Equipment. 6If feasible, all above ground 7mechanical equipment such as exterior utility boxes, meters, and 8transformers shall be visually screened. Back-flow preventers 9shall be painted to match the principal structure. See Chapter 4, 10Article III, Section 3.I A.9 for additional regulations regarding the 11screening of mechanical equipment. 12 G.Dumpster Enclosure… 13 H. Lift Stations… 14 I. Base of Signs… 15 J. Landscape Standards for Specific Uses… 16 17 Section 7. Penalties…. 18 19 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE III EXTERIOR BUILDING AND SITE 20 DESIGN STANDARDS 21 22 ARTICLE III. EXTERIOR BUILDING AND SITE DESIGN 23 STANDARDS 24 25 Section 1. General… 26 Section 2. Design Principles… 27 Section 3. General Design Standards for Exterior Buildings… 28 Section 4. Design Standards for Multi-family and Non-Residential 29 Uses Adjacent to Single-Family Residential Zoning Districts… 30 Section 5.Design Standards for Specific Uses in the Use Matrix 31 (Table 3-28)... 32 Section 6. Design Standards for Development in Urban Areas. 33 34 A. General. 35 36 1. Purpose and Intent. 37The location of 38buildings/structures and off-street parking areas proposed 39for a development can directly impact the aesthetic fabric 40and quality of life for surrounding properties and the 41community as a whole. It is the purpose of this section to 42provide design standards that are tailored to distinct 43geographic areas of the City to ensure that the location, 44type, and appearance of buildings/structures and off-street 45parking areas are is appropriate with the type, intensity, 46scale, and location of redevelopment and new development. - 42 - 1The intent of this section is to promote standards that are 2functional, practical, equitable, and creative. 3 2.Applicability. 4 Unless otherwise specified, 5these standards shall apply to new projects and major 6modifications to existing developments located in the 7following: 8 a. 9 All properties currently zoned: 10 11(1) Central Business District (CBD); or 12 13(2) Any “Mixed-Use (Urban)” district. 14For the purpose of this section, Mixed-Use 15(Urban) districts shall include the Mixed 16Use-Low Intensity 1 (MU-L1), Mixed Use- 17Low Intensity 2 (MU-L2), Mixed Use-Low 18Intensity 3 (MU-L3), and Mixed Use-High 19Intensity (MU-H) district. 20 b. 21 Any commercially zoned property located: 22 23(1) Along Boynton Beach Boulevard, 24east of Interstate 95 and west of the Florida 25East Coast (FEC) Railroad right-of-way; 26 27(2) Within the Urban Commercial 28District Overlay Zone (UCDOZ); and 29 30(3) Within the Martin Luther King 31Junior Boulevard Overlay Zone 32(MLKBOZ). 33 34c.General Rules 35 36(1)All parking facilities may contain 37small, permanent structures, such as shade 38structures and booths used by parking 39attendants. 40 41(2)For the purpose of this section, 42“Mixed-Use (Urban)” districts include the 43Mixed Use-Low Intensity 1 (MU-L1), 44Mixed Use-Low Intensity 2 (MU-L2), 45Mixed Use-Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3), and 46Mixed Use-High Intensity (MU-H) district. - 43 - 1See Chapter 3, Article III, Section 5 for 2additional regulations pertaining to each 3zoning district. 4 5(3)“Overlay Zones” include the Urban 6Commercial District Overlay Zone 7(UCDOZ) and the Martin Luther King Jr. 8Boulevard Overlay Zone (MLKJBOZ). See 9Chapter 3, Article III, Section 8 for 10additional regulations pertaining to each 11overlay zone. 12 B.Building Location Standards. 13The revitalization of 14urban places depends on safety and security, with building/street 15design having a symbiotic relationship. The location of a building 16and its proximity/interaction with the public realm is paramount 17when trying to create urban areas that have a “sense of place” that 18is consistent with smart growth principles and neo-traditional 19planning efforts. Development must adequately accommodate 20automobiles, but in ways that respect pedestrians and the forms of 21public space and gathering areas. 22 23Each building shall meet the build-to line and reduced setback 24areas of the respective zoning district or Overlay Zone, whichever 25is applicable. The location of off-street parking areas is strongly 26discouraged between buildings and rights-of-way. However, in 27certain instances, this type of design may be impractical, and strict 28adherence may deter incremental improvements or upgrades to 29individual properties, which therefore, perpetuates the blighted 30conditions of the redevelopment areas. In these circumstances, 31deviations from the build-to line and reduced setback area 32requirements may be allowed, but only contingent the submittal of 33a Community Design Appeal application that satisfactorily 34addresses the evaluation criteria and when such application is 35approved by the City Commission. 36 37Within mixed-use and non-residential developments, structures 38proposed along arterial roadways shall be required to occupy the 39entire length of the street frontage, notwithstanding areas set aside 40for side corner yard setbacks and driveways needed to access the 41rear of the property. This building location requirement along the 42arterial roadway only applies to new construction or major site 43plan modifications to existing developments. Also see Chapter 4, 44Article II, Section 4.B.5 for additional streetscape design 45requirements. 46 - 44 - C. Shade and Shelter Standards… 1 D. Standards for Windows… 2 E. Compatibility Standards… 3 4 F.Off-Street Parking Area Standards. 5 6 1. Types of Off-Street Parking Facilities… 7 8 2. Standards for Mixed Use (Urban) Districts and 9 Central Business District (CBD). 10This subsection shall 11be applicable to all new projects and major modifications to 12existing developments. Within “Urban Mixed-Use” 13districts, off-street parking areas shall be located to the rear 14or side of the structure they are intended to serve and 15screened from view from public streets, notwithstanding 16other provisions of these regulations that require a specific 17setback for a garage for a residential dwelling unit. The 18intent of these regulations is to emphasize buildings and 19pedestrian features within the streetscape and minimize the 20visual impacts of parking facilities. Where possible, 21parking areas should be located to the rear of a project. 22Also where possible, access to parking areas shall be from 23side streets, in order to minimize driveways and vehicular / 24pedestrian conflicts. The following standards shall apply to 25all properties located within Urban Mixed-Use districts as 26described in Section 6.B.2.a.(2) A3.b above: 27 a. Surface Parking… 28 b. Understory Parking Garage… 29 30 c. Freestanding Parking Garages. 31 32Freestanding parking garages are allowed within the 33“Mixed-Use (Urban)” districts provided that they do 34not have frontage on any arterial or collector 35roadway. The height of the freestanding parking 36garage may not exceed 75 feet in the MU-H district. 37 38All parking garages that front on arterial or collector 39roadways must be integrated into the development 40and designed as provided for in subparagraph “d” 41Section 6.C.4 below. 42 d. Integrated Garages… 43 44 3. Standards for the “Overlay Zones” and Boynton 45 Beach Boulevard. 46 a.Purpose and Intent.One of - 45 - 1the objectives of the Urban Commercial District Overlay 2Zone and the Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard Overlay 3Zone overlay zone is to preventThe purpose and intent of 4this subsection isto prevent the placement of off-street 5parking areas between the front of the building and the 6rights-of-way, particularly in areas where build-to line and 7reduced setback areas are applicable. 8 9c.Terms and Definitions.“Overlay Zones” 10include the cUrban Commercial District Overlay Zone 11(UCDOZ) and the Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard 12Overlay Zone (MLKJBOZ). See Chapter 3, Article III, 13Section 8 for additional regulations pertaining to each 14overlay zone. 15 16Within redevelopment areas, the location of off-street 17parking areas is strongly discouraged between building and 18rights-of-way. However, when a project is proposed in 19such a manner that building location(s) would deviate from 20respective build-to line and reduced setback area 21requirements, resulting in a design that is contrary to the 22purpose and intent of Section 6.B above and this 23subsection, then that project shall be required to make 24upgrades to public realm and streetscape with simple but 25innovative urban design enhancements such as additional 26landscaping; pergolas/trellis-work/decorative structures; 27surface improvements to the pavement across driveways; 28short walls designed with benches and/or seating areas; 29public art; and the like, particularly in areas along the right- 30of-way where such deviations occur. 31 4. Standards for the Suburban Mixed-Use (SMU) 32 District. 33 34 a. Understory Garages. 35.. 36 b. Freestanding Garages. 37Freestanding 38parking garages are not allowed within the SMU 39district. All parking structures, excluding 40understory garages, shall be designed as an 41integrated garage as provided for in subparagraph 42“c” Section 6.D.3 below. 43 c. Integrated Garages… 44 45 5. Miscellaneous Standards. 46 - 46 - 1 a. Number of Required Parking Spaces… 2 b. Off-Site Parking… 3 c. Interconnectivity… 4 d. Off-Street Parking for Large Non- 5 Residential Development (Big Box). 6 See 7Section7.J below 5.C.10 above for additional 8regulations regarding off-street parking lot locations 9for large non-residential (big box) developments. 10 e. Trash Collection Points… 11 12 G. Sidewalks. 13 The following regulations shall apply to 14sidewalks: 15 1. “Urban Mixed Use” Districts. 16The following 17regulations shall apply to sidewalks in all Urban Mixed Use 18zoning districts as described in Section 6.A.2.a(2) above: 19 a.Materials. 20 Sidewalks shall, where 21practical, be Holland-Stone pavers, red/charcoal 22color mix 2 by Paver Systems, Inc., or equal, laid in 23a 4 S herringbone pattern to continue the consistent 24with the current design elements in place along 25Federal Highway. 26 b.Design. 27 Pedestrian circulation should 28be carefully planned to prevent pedestrian use of 29vehicular ways and parking spaces. 30 31In all cases, pedestrian access shall be provided to 32public walkways. 33 2.Mixed Use-High Intensity (MU-H) District. 34 35 Sidewalks constructed along arterial roadways shall 36be a minimum of ten (10) feet wide, measured from the 37back of the curb. 38 3. Mixed Use Developments 39. Sidewalk accents via 40pavers or stamped colored concrete shall be utilized in all 41central pedestrian ways of mixed-use development areas. 42 Section 7.Design Standards for Large Non-Residential 43 Development (Big Box) in Suburban Areas. 44 45 A. Purpose and Intent… 46 - 47 - 1 B. Applicability. 2 The following standards are 3applicable to any commercial structure in excess of 15,000 square 4feet, unless stated otherwise herein, excluding those properties 5located in urban areas as described in Section 6 above. The term 6“commercial,” as used in these regulations, shall also include 7structures utilized for office uses and those industrial uses that 8front on arterial or collector roadways. 9 C. Façades… 10 D. Roofline… 11 E. Windows… 12 F. Public Entrances… 13 G. Covered Walkways… 14 H. Landscaping… 15 I. Site Amenities. 16 J. Off-Street Parking Lot Orientation… 17 K. Miscellaneous. 18 19 Section 8. Open Space and Plaza Requirements… 20 Section 9.Standards for Pedestrian and Bicyclist Amenities… 21 Section 10. Design Standards for Walls, Fences, and Miscellaneous 22 Outdoor Structures. 23 Section 11. Maintenance of Buildings, Structures, and Site… 24 Section 12. Exterior Building and Site Design Guidelines… 25 26 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE IV SIGN STANDARDS 27 28 ARTICLE IV. SIGN STANDARDS 29 30 Section 1. General… 31 Section 2. City Approval Required… 32 Section 3.Prohibited Signs… 33 34 Section 4. Standards. 35 36 A. General. 37 The following general standards shall apply 38to all signs city-wide: 39 1. Sign Content… 40 2. Computation of Sign Area… 41 3. Cross Visibility and Safe-Sight… 42 4.Traffic Hazards… 43 5.Wind Load… 44 6.Unlawful or Unsafe Signs… 45 7.Maintenance… 46 - 48 - 8. Overhead Clearance… 1 9.Property Address… 2 10. Illuminated Signs… 3 4 11. Crime Prevention Through Environmental 5 Design (CPTED). 6 See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 12 75.B for additional regulations regarding signs and CPTED 8guidelines. 9 B. Temporary Signs. 10 It shall be unlawful to affix, erect, 11locate, or maintain any temporary sign off-premises unless 12otherwise authorized under this subsection. Temporary signs shall 13be allowed in accordance with the following provisions: 14 1. Real Estate Sign. 15A temporary real estate sign 16is allowed on private property for the purpose of 17advertising the sale or lease of such property. The sign(s) 18shall comply with the following standards: 19 a. Maximum Number, Size and Height 20 (Table 4- 11 10)… 21 22 b. Setbacks… 23 c. Exemptions… 24 d. Duration… 25 e. Prohibited in Required Landscape 26 Strip… 27 28 2. Project Development Sign. 29 30 a. General… 31 32 b. Maximum Number, Size and Height 33 (Table 4- 12 11)… 34. 35 c. Duration… 36 37 3. Construction Sign… 38 4. Banner… 39 40 5. Political Sign. 41 With consent of the property 42owner, a temporary political sign is allowed on private 43property during the period preceding any local, state, or 44national election. No political sign is allowed within 45rights-of-way or on City-owned property. In addition, 46political signs shall meet the following standards: - 49 - 1 a. Maximum Number, Size and Height 2 (Table 4- 13 12)… 3 4 6. Special Sales Event Sign… 5 7. Seasonal Sales Event Sign… 6 8. Vehicle Display Sign… 7 9. Recreation and Parks Department Special Event 8 Sign… 9 10. Feather Banners… 10 11 C. Permanent Signs. 12It shall be unlawful to affix, erect, 13locate, or maintain any permanent sign off-premises unless 14otherwise authorized under this subsection. Permanent signs shall 15be allowed in accordance with the following provisions: 16 1. Wall Sign (Affixed to Building). 17 18 a. General… 19 20 b. Maximum Sign Area (Table 4-14 13)… 21 22 c. Signs on Multiple-Story Buildings… 23 d. Community Design Standards… 24 25 2. Monument Sign. 26 27 a. Purpose and Intent… 28 b.Computation of Height… 29 30 c. Maximum Height, Size and Number 31 (Table 4-15 14)… 32 33 d. Setbacks… 34 e. Cross Visibility and Safe-Sight… 35 f. Property Address… 36 g. Project Name… 37 h. Changeable Copy Signs… 38 i. Miscellaneous… 39 j. Community Design Standards… 40 41 3.Directory Sign… 42 4.Directional Sign… 43 5. Menu Board Sign… 44 6. Awning Valance Sign. 45One (1) sign, located 46on the valance of an awning hung over each public entrance - 50 - 1is allowed within multi-family residential (10 units or 2more) and nonresidential developments, provided the 3signage area does not exceed 80% of the valance area. An 4awning valance sign shall count toward the aggregate wall 5signage area. The sign shall not be internally-illuminated. 6See Section 5.C.5 below for additional community design 7standards regarding awning valance signs. 8 9See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.E A.5 for additional 10design standards regarding awnings and canopies. 11 7. Covered Walkway / Arcade Sign… 12 8. Blade Sign… 13 9. Window Sign… 14 10. Rear Door Business Identification Plaque… 15 11. Mixed-Use Development Identification Sign… 16 12. Neighborhood Identification Sign… 17 13.Nameplate or Identification Plaque… 18 19 D. Special Signs. 20The following special signs shall be allowed 21in accordance with the following provisions: 22 1. Civic and Not-for-Profit Directional Sign… 23 24 2. Transit Shelter Sign. 25 Signs on city transit stop 26shelters may be allowed when authorized by written 27agreement approved by action of the City Commission 28pursuant to the provisions of Florida Statutes. When so 29authorized by the City Commission, the following 30standards shall apply: 31 a. Location. 32 Signs placed on city transit stop 33shelters shall only be allowed at city transit stops 34designated or approved by the City. A transit 35shelter, proposed on private property or within the 36right-of-way, shall be located and designed in 37accordance with Chapter 4, Article III, Section 10.B 383.F.1. 39 b. Number… 40 c.Elevation… 41 d. Exemption… 42 43 3. Newracks… 44 4.Murals… 45 5. Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station Sign… 46 - 51 - 1 Section 5. Community Design. 2 3 A. General… 4 B.Community Design Standards for All Signs… 5 C. Community Design Standards for Specific Types of 6 Signs… 7 D. Community Design Standards for Logos and Icons. 8 9 1. General… 10 2. Maximum Percentage and Size (Table 4-16 15)… 11 12 Section 6. Sign Program… 13 14 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE V MINIMUM OFF-STREET 15 PARKING REQUIREMENTS 16 17 ARTICLE V. MINIMUM OFF-STREET PARKING 18 REQUIREMENTS 19 20 Section 1. General… 21 Section 2. Standards. 22 23 A. General… 24 25 B. Table 4-17. Residential and Lodging Uses… 262 27 C. Table 4-18. Commercial and Health Care / Office 283 Uses… 29 30 D. Table 4-19. Arts, Entertainment, and Recreational 314 Uses… 32 33 E. Table 4-20 Industrial Uses… 345 35 F. Table 4-21 Educational Uses… 366 37 G. Table 4-22 Public and Civic Uses… 387 39 Section 3. Special Reductions in Required Off-Street Parking… 40 Section 4.Exceptions to Providing Required Off-Street Parking… 41 42 Section 5.Other Parking Regulations. 43 44 A. Maximum Number of Provided Parking. 45 For all new 46and major modifications to existing non-residential uses, the total - 52 - 1number of provided off-street parking spaces shall not exceed the 2thresholds as established below: 3 1. Thresholds… 4 2. Methodology... 5 3. Exemption… 6 7 B. Handicap Accessible Off-Street Parking. 8 9 1.Applicability… 10 11 2.Table 4-23. Handicap Accessible Parking 127 Requirements… 13 14 C.Permanent Reservation of Off-Street Parking Spaces… 15 16 Section 6. Penalties…. 17 18 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE VI PARKING LOT, VEHICULAR USE 19 AREAS, AND LOADING STANDARDS 20 21 ARTICLE VI. PARKING LOT, VEHICULAR USE AREAS, AND 22 LOADING STANDARDS 23 24 Section 1. General… 25 Section 2. City Approval Required… 26 27 Section 3. Standards. 28 29 A. General. 30 31 1.Movement. 32 A clearly defined vehicular 33circulation system shall be provided which allows free 34movement within the proposed development while 35discouraging excessive speeds. Vehicular circulation 36systems shall be separated as much as practicable from 37pedestrian circulation systems. Off-street parking facilities 38and other vehicular use areas shall be integrated with 39surrounding structures and with the building or group of 40buildings for which they serve. See Chapter 4, Article III, 41Section 3.C.2 for additional regulations. 42 2.Points of Access… 43 3.Through Traffic… 44 4.Storage Demand… 45 5.Emergency and Service Vehicles… 46 - 53 - 6.Sidewalks… 1 7.Compliance… 2 3 B. Off-Street Parking and Vehicular Use Areas. 4 5 1. General… 6 2. Required Surface… 7 3. Minimum Dimensions and Accessibility... 8 4.Vehicular Traffic Control Markings. 9 All traffic 10signing and pavement marking shall comply with the U.S. 11Department of Transportation Federal Highway 12Administration Manual on Uniform Traffic Control 13Devices. Particular attention is directed toward Section 3.G 142A, which contains sign design, shape, color, mounting 15height and other conditions. Fire lanes shall be identified 16with marking and signage in accordance with Section 8 of 17this article. Parking stalls shall be delineated in accordance 18with the Engineering Design Handbook and Construction 19Standards. 20 5.Landscaping… 21 6. Irrigation… 22 7. Curbs and Car Stop… 23 8. Drainage… 24 9. Illumination… 25 10.Sidewalks… 26 27 11. Structures. 28Parking facilities may contain small, 29permanent structures such as shade structures and booths 30used by parking attendants. 31 Section 4. Community Design. 32 33 A. General… 34 B. Off-Street Loading… 35 C. Dumpsters and Trash Receptacles… 36 37 D. Off-Street Parking Areas and Parking Garages. 38 Public 39or private off-street surface parking lots, understory parking, and 40all types of parking garages shall comply with this section, the 41Florida Building Code, and with county-wide amendments thereto. 42Where appropriate, security systems may be required. 43 1. On-Site Parking. 44 Required parking spaces for 45all residential uses shall be located on the same lot or 46development as the dwelling to be served. Parking spaces - 54 - 1for non-residential uses may be located off-site but only in 2accordance with Section 9.D.2 below. See Chapter 4, 3Article III, Sections 6 and 7 for additional community 4design standards pertaining to off-street parking. 5 a.District Regulations. 6The location 7and appearance of on-site parking facilities shall 8comply with Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.C. 9 b.Large Non-Residential (Big Box) 10 Development Regulations. 11The location of off- 12street surface parking areas for large non-residential 13(big box) developments are further regulated in 14accordance with Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.I. 15 2. Off-Site Parking… 16 3. Interconnectivity… 17 4. Required Off-Street Parking Calculations, By 18 Use… 19 5. Shared Parking… 20 21 Section 5. Penalties… 22 23 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE VII EXTERIOR LIGHTING 24 STANDARDS. 25 26 ARTICLE VII. EXTERIOR LIGHTING STANDARDS 27 28 Section 1. General… 29 Section 2. City Approval Required… 30 Section 3. Standards… 31 Section 4. Community Design… 32 Section 5. Prohibited Lighting. 33 34 35The following types of outdoor lighting are prohibited: 36 A. Spillage… 37 B. Unauthorized Traffic Lighting… 38 C. Beacon or Searchlights… 39 D. Drop Lens Fixtures… 40 E. Neon Tubing, Bare Bulbs, and Miniature Lighting… 41 42 F. Awnings. 43 No awnings, valances, or support structures 44shall be internally-illuminated or backlit pursuant to Chapter 4, 45Article III, Section 3.E A.5. 46 - 55 - Section 6. Penalties… 1 2 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE VIII ROADWAYS, UTILITIES, AND 3 INFRASTRUCTURE STANDARDS. 4 5 ARTICLE VIII. ROADWAYS, UTILITIES, AND INFRASTRUCTURE 6 DESIGN STANDARDS 7 8 Section 1. General… 9 Section 2. City Approval Required… 10 Section 3. Standards. 11 12 A. General Standards for All Required Improvements…. 13 B. Utilities… 14 C. Roadways and Streets 15. 16 1. General… 17 2. Designation System… 18 3. Naming System… 19 20 a. Curvilinear Streets… 21 b. Streets Crossing Ocean Avenue… 22 23 c. (Table 4-23) Suffixes… 248 d. Street Name Changes… 25 e. Standard Street Name Numbering and 26 Addressing… 27 f. Vanity Street Name Numbering and 28 Addressing… 29 30 4. Street Layout and Configuration. 31 32 a. General… 33 b. Width of Ultimate Right-of-Way. 34 35 36(1) (Table 4-24 9) General Standards… 37(2) Within All Planned Residential 38Developments… 39(3) Within All Commercial and 40Industrial Districts… 41 c. Width of Pavement… 42 d. Dimensions of Blocks 43… e. Dead-end Streets… 44 f. Street Jogs… 45 g. Half-streets… 46 - 56 - h. Marginal Access Streets… 1 i. Local Streets… 2 j. Railroads Abutting Developments… 3 k. Thoroughfare Intersections… 4 l. Alignment, Tangent, Deflection, Radii… 5 m. Traffic Calming Measures… 6 n. Lot Access… 7 o. Driveway Spacing… 8 p. Street Connections… 9 q. Cross Access Roads… 10 r. Median Strips… 11 s. Entrances to Developments… 12 t. Collector Road Dedication… 13 u. Visual Obstructions of Intersections… 14 v. Right-of-Way Improvement & 15 Construction Standards… 16 17 5. Construction, Repair, or Alterations… 18 19 D.Sidewalks. 20 21 1. General… 22 2. Standards… 23 3. Construction, Repair, or Alterations… 24 4. Abandonments… 25 5.Miscellaneous… 26 27 6. Community Design. 28SeeChapter 4, Article III, 29Sections 6 and 7 Section 4 below for additional regulations 30community design standards related to sidewalks and 31pedestrian pathways. 32 E. Pedestrian and Bicycle Paths… 33 F. Bridges & Culverts… 34 G. Drainage, Stormwater, and Wastewater Management… 35 H. Canals and Waterways… 36 37 Section 4.Community Design. 38 A.General. 39 40 1.Purpose and Intent. 41The purpose of this section is 42to promote harmony with nature and a pleasant and 43comprehensible cohesiveness among development within 44the City. Through enforcement of the Community Design, 45the local elected officials shall determine the basic aesthetic - 57 - 1character to be achieved in the development of the 2community. 3 2.Administration. 4The Director of Planning and 5Zoning shall have the authority to coordinate, interpret, and 6administer this section. 7 3.Waiver. 8Any deviation or variation from the 9regulations of this section requires the approval of a 10Community Design Appeal (CDPA) in accordance with 11Chapter 2, Article II, Section 4.B. 12 B.Sidewalks. 13 The following regulations shall apply to 14sidewalks: 15 1.“Urban Mixed Use” Districts. 16The following 17regulations shall apply to sidewalks in the Mixed Use-Low 18Intensity 1, Mixed Use-Low Intensity 2, Mixed Use-Low 19Intensity 3, and Mixed Use-High Intensity districts: 20 a.Materials. 21Sidewalks shall, where 22practical, be Holland-Stone pavers, red/charcoal 23color mix 2 by Paver Systems, Inc., or equal, laid in 24a 4 S herringbone pattern to continue the consistent 25with the current design elements in place along 26Federal Highway. 27 b.Design. 28Pedestrian circulation should 29be carefully planned to prevent pedestrian use of 30vehicular ways and parking spaces. 31 32In all cases, pedestrian access shall be provided to 33public walkways. 34 2.Mixed Use-High Intensity (MU-H) District. 35 36Sidewalks constructed along arterial roadways shall 37be a minimum of ten (10) feet wide, measured from the 38back of the curb. 39 3.Mixed Use Developments 40.Sidewalk accents via 41pavers or stamped colored concrete shall be utilized in all 42central pedestrian ways of mixed-use development areas. 43 4.Large Non-Residential Development (Big Box) 44 Regulations. 45See Chapter 4, Article III, Section 3.I for - 58 - 1additional regulations regarding pedestrian pathways within 2large non-residential (big box) developments. 3 Section 4. Penalties… 45 5 PART III (LDR), CHAPTER 4, ARTICLE IX BUILDING, CONSTRUCTION, 6 AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION REQUIREMENTS. 7 8 ARTICLE IX. BUILDING, CONSTRUCTION, AND HISTORIC 9 PRESERVATION REQUIREMENTS. 10 11 Section 1. General… 12 Section 2. City Approval Required… 13 Section 3. Certificate of Occupancy or Completion… 14 Section 4. Florida Building Code Requirements… 15 Section 5. Coastal Building Zone Requirements… 16 Section 6. Historic Preservation Requirements. 17 18 A. General… 19 20 B. Designation of Historic Properties and Districts. 21 22 1. Guidelines for Historic Designation. 23 To 24qualify as a Property or a District, individual properties 25must have significance in American history, architecture, 26archeology, engineering or culture and possess integrity of 27location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, 28and association. For Districts, eligibility is based on the 29establishment of historic contexts or themes which describe 30the historical relationship of the Properties within the 31district. Individual Buildings shall normally be at least 50 32years old and, in the case of a District, at least 50% of the 33Buildings shall normally be at least fifty years old. 34Buildings shall also be significant in one or more of the 35following areas; 36 a… 37 b… 38 c… 39 d… 40 e… 41 42 2. Criteria Considerations… 43 3. Procedures… 44 4. Removal of Designation… 45 46 - 59 - 5. Designation of County, State or Other Political 1 Subdivision Properties… 2 6. Maintenance and Repair of Designated 3 Properties; Demolition by Neglect Prohibited… 4 7. Nominations to the National Register of Historic 5 Places… 6 8. Designated Historic Sites… 7 8 C. Certificate of Appropriateness. 9 The Board or staff 10shall review actions affecting the exterior of Properties and all 11Resources, including non-contributing Properties, within Districts. 12 1.Board Approval Required. 13 14 a.Board Approval. 15Utilizing the Design 16Guidelines Handbook, the Board reviews 17applications for Certificates of Appropriateness for 18alterations, new construction, demolitions, 19relocations, and Certificates of Economic Hardship 20affecting proposed or designated Properties or 21Properties within Districts. 22 1. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for 23 Rehabilitation… 24 25 2. Additional Criteria… 26 27 a. New Construction and Alterations. .. 28 b. Additions… 29 c. Demolition… 30 31 32(1) Simultaneous certificates required… 33(2) Demolition Delay Period… 34(3) Salvage and Preservation of Specific 35Features… 36 37(4) Authority to Initiate Designation. 38 If an undesignated property warrants 39it and it is otherwise authorized under this 40ordinance, staff may initiate, or recommend 41that the Board initiate, the designation 42application and review process. Staff may 43further request that the Board require that 44the issuance of a demolition permit be 45stayed pending the Board’s review of the 46application and the City Commission’s - 60 - 1decision to designate or deny designation of 2the property. However, the maximum 3period during which the issuance of a 4demolition permit may be stayed pursuant to 5this paragraph is one hundred twenty (120) 6days, unless extended by the City 7Commission. If for any reason the 8designation process is not completed and the 9demolition application is approved, the 10owner shall, at his/her expense, fully record 11the building prior to Demolition and make a 12reasonable attempt to salvage and preserve 13specified classes of building materials, 14architectural details, ornaments, fixtures and 15the like. 16 d. Relocation… 17 e. Changes in Approved Work… 18 19 D. Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption 20 Program. 21 22 1. General… 23 2. Tax Exemption for Historic Properties. 24 25 a.Definitions. 26 27 28(1)Alteration. Any construction or change of 29the exterior of a building, site, or structure 30designated as a site or site within a district. For 31buildings, sites, or structures, alteration shall 32include, but is not limited to the changing of roofing 33or siding materials; changing, eliminating, or adding 34doors, moldings, fretwork, door frames, windows, 35window frames, shutters, fences, railings, porches, 36balconies, signs, or other ornamentation; regrading; 37fill; imploding or other use of dynamite. Alteration 38shall not include ordinary repair or maintenance, or 39changing of paint color. 40 41(2)Noncontributing Property. A building, site, 42structure, or object which does not add to the 43historic architectural qualities, historic associations, 44or archaeological values for which a district is 45significant because 1) it was not present during the 46period of significance; 2) due to alterations, - 61 - 1disturbances, additions, or other changes, it no 2longer possess historic integrity reflecting its 3character at that time or is incapable of yielding 4important information about the period; or 3) it does 5not independently meet the National Register of 6Historic Places criteria for evaluation. 7 8(3)Notice. To an Interested Party, notice shall 9be by U.S. Mail and deemed given as of the date of 10mailing. For all other persons, notice shall be by 11publication. 12 a. 13The City Commission hereby creates a tax 14exemption for the appropriate restoration, 15renovation or rehabilitation of qualifying historic 16properties designated herein. Qualifying property 17shall be exempt from that portion of ad valorem 18taxation levied by the City on one hundred percent 19(100%) of the increase in assessed value resulting 20from any appropriate renovation, restoration or 21rehabilitation of the qualifying property made on or 22after the effective date of this ordinance. 23 b… 24 25 3. Qualifying Properties and Improvements… 26 4. Evaluation of Property Used for Government or 27 Nonprofit Purpose… 28 5. Application for Exemption; Fees… 29 6.Preconstruction Application… 30 7.Review of Preconstruction Application… 31 32 8. Appeals to the Historic Resources Preservation 33 Board. 34 35 a. 36 Within ten (10) days of receipt of notice that 37the City has denied a Preconstruction Application, 38the applicant may file anwritten notice of appeal of 39the denial to the Board. The appeal shall be filed on 40a form prepared by the City and processed in 41accordance with the public meeting and notification 42procedures required of the City’s quasi-judicial 43hearing process, except that public notices need 44only be mailed to owners of abutting propertiesor 45adjacent property as determined by the Historic 46Preservation Planner. - 62 - 1 b… 2 3 9.Issuance of Other Permits or Approval… 4 10.Completion of Work… 5 11.Final Application and Request for Review of 6 Completed Work… 7 12.Recommendations to Historic Resources 8 Preservation Board and City Commission… 9 13. Approval by the City Commission… 10 14.Notice of Approval to the Property Appraiser… 11 15. Effective Date and Duration of Tax Exemption… 12 16.Property Maintenance, Penalty, and 13 Revocation… 14 17.Annual Report… 15 16 E. Standards for Archeological Work; Discovery of 17 Archeological Site… 18 19 Section 7. Enforcement and Penalties… 20 21 22 23 C:\LDR Amendments\Future\M-1 District and Landscaping\Proposed Changes for P&D Final.doc - 63 -