Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Minutes 05-15-18
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING HELD ON TUESDAY, May 15, 2018, AT 6:30 P.M. IN COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL 100 E. BOYNTON BEACH BOULEVARD, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA PRESENT: Steven B. Grant, Mayor Christina Romelus, Vice Mayor Justin Katz, Commissioner Mack McCray, Commissioner Joe Casello, Commissioner 1. OPENINGS A. Call to Order - Mayor Steven B. Grant Mayor Grant called the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m. Invocation Commissioner McCray gave the invocation. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag Lori LaVerriere, City Manager James Cherof, City Attorney Judith A. Pyle, City Clerk Commissioner McCray led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag Roll Call City Clerk Pyle called the roll. A quorum was present. Agenda Approval: 1. Additions, Deletions, Corrections Mayor Grant requested to move item 6-C under Public Hearing, Item 8-D. Motion Vice Mayor Romelus moved to approve the agenda as amended. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida 2. OTHER A. Informational items by Members of the City Commission May 15, 2018 Commissioner McCray stated he wanted to correct information he heard on the news, which stated the City Boynton Beach was getting a Town Square at the expense of the Theater Group. This was totally incorrect. The City tried to find a space for the theater group, but was unsuccessful. Thanked staff for having the brochure "Let's Talk Trash" in Creole and Spanish. Informed the public the City of Boynton Beach will be hosting the Transportation Planning Agency (TPA) at the Intracoastal on May 17, 2018 at 9:00 a.m. On May 31, the Palm Beach County Criminal Justice Commission, Community Engagement Task Force, will be meeting at the St. John Missionary Baptist Church, hosted by the Reverend Dr. Jovan T. Davis, Senior Pastor. Vice Mayor Romelus attended a local church celebrating teachers. They were celebrating more than 60 teachers. She noted, being a teacher, it was always great to have individuals say thank you. Commissioner Casello had no disclosures. Informed the Commission he received calls regarding a vote for the extension of Miner Road. He contacted the County and the City and neither has any knowledge of a planned extension of Miner Road. Miner Road will not be extended in the near future. Mayor Grant stated on May 2nd he travelled with delegates from the Palm Beach County School District to Les Cayes, Haiti. Informed the Commission there was a lot of work that could be done. Met with the Mayors of Jacmel, Petionville, and Carrefour. May 7th met with the ambassador of Taiwan. Attended Bethesda Memorial "Shadow a Nurse" and on May 911 attended the Nurses' breakfast at Bethesda Memorial Hospital. Attended the Boynton Beach Garden Club, spoke with the CRA to create a community vegetable garden on the tax deed property the CRA recently purchased. Met with Trina Pulliam of Trainnovations regarding the Strategic Initiatives of branding a better Boynton Beach. May 11 th joined Steve Abrams and Nick Uhren as delegates of Palm Beach County to be the first to ride on Brightline. On May 13th celebrated Mother Day with his family. 3. ANNOUNCEMENTS, COMMUNITY & SPECIAL EVENTS & PRESENTATIONS A. Presentation of the annual "Bob Borovy Student Citizen of the Year" award by members of the Education & Youth Advisory Board Dr. Tiffany North, Chairman of the Education and Youth Advisory Board, provided information regarding the Bob Borovy award. This award was created to recognize a graduating high school senior who best epitomizes the spirit of volunteerism and giving to the community as exemplified by the late Bob Borovy, a United States Veteran and former Advisory Board member who was an active citizen of the Boynton Beach community for many years. Explained the recipient will receive a $1,000 cash award 2 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 and have his/her name placed on a permanent plaque at City Hall The winner selected for 2018 was Alana Thomas. Dr. North indicated Ms. Thomas will graduate from Santa Luces Community High School, has a 4.49 GPA and over 1300 hours of community service. Dr. North stated Ms. Thomas was described by her teachers and school counselors as intelligent, goal oriented, with a humble spirit. She held the rank of corporal and sergeant for the Criminal Justice class of 2018. She was selected by the Palm Beach Sherriff office to be the lieutenant executive officer of the criminal justice academy for 2017/2018 school year. She has been awarded Cadet of the year by the Palm Beach County Sheriff Department. Ms. Thomas believes in serving others. She has chosen to volunteer for the Palm Beach County Youth Court program, where she has served as a lead youth volunteer attorney. She has 1335 community service hours. She is a member of the Education and Youth Advisory board, Empower Leadership Academy for Girls and Criminal Justice honor guard. She is active in her church where she volunteers in the technology and nursey ministry. She also tutors at risk -youth at a local elementary school during the summer. Ms. Thomas will attend Howard University. She has put in a lot of work and should be awarded. Alana Simone Thomas thanked the Education and Youth Advisory Board for awarding her this honor. She indicated it has always been instilled in her to give back to the community. She takes pride in serving her community. She grew up in Boynton Beach and hopes to inspire future generations. Commissioner McCray recognized Alana Simone's parents and grandparents. B. Proclaim the month of June as Men's Health Month. Mayor Grant read the proclamation. Wayne Carrels, Parks and Recreation Crew leader, accepted the award. Stated he was thrilled to be a part of the Health and Fitness movement. C. Proclaim June 1, 2018 as National Gun Violence Awareness Day. Mayor Grant read the proclamation. Miriam Lane accepted the proclamation for Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America of Central Palm Beach County. Thanked the Mayor and Commission for the proclamation and stated this was an honor to accept on behalf of all those affected by gun violence. Ms. Lane noted large mass shootings make the news, but American families are devastated by gun violence every day. Explained since 2013 there have been more than 300 school shootings. Black men are 13 times more likely to be shot than Hispanic or White men, and Black Americans only make up 14% of the US 3 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 population. She continued to say at least 52% of women killed with guns are killed by intimate partners or family members. Ms. Lane stated 21,000 Americans die by gun suicide each year. American children are 11 times more likely to die by gun suicide than their peers from other high income countries. Please join this cause on June 2nd at Meadows Parks at 10 a.m. be sure to wear orange. D. Announce that the Solid Waste Division will be having Tire Amnesty Week for the City Residents the first week of June from June 4th, 2018 - June 8th, 2018 Andrew Mack, Director of Public Work and Engineering, stated the City residents can place up to eight car and /or passenger truck vehicle tires at the curb for pickup on the scheduled bulk trash day. The tires must be separated from all other bulk trash piles. If there are any questions, please call 561-742-6200. Commissioner McCray asked how the public was being notified. Mr. Mack replied the City was using the social media, public announcements and posting flyers around the City. Commissioner McCray requested a copy of the flyer. Mayor Grant noted during last year's hurricane event, residents were looking for information regarding solid waste pickup. Inquired if the City would have some type of information line or an email to update residents. Mr. Mack replied this was something being worked on as part of the route ware. E. Announce that Hurricane Season begins June 111 and the Solid Waste Division is urging residents to do their part by conducting tree trimming early in preparation for the Hurricane season. Andrew Mack, Director of Public Works and Engineering, noted hurricane season begins June 1, 2018. Please begin tree trimming early. Vice Mayor Romelus stated residents can contact FPL to help clear tree branches from power lines on residential property. F. Announce the Public Input Budget Workshop, Tuesday, May 29, 2018 @ 6:30 P.M. at Intracoastal Park Clubhouse. Mayor Grant announced the City will be having a Public Input Budget workshop, Tuesday, May 29, 2018 @ 6:30 p.m. at Intracoastal Park Clubhouse. The purpose of this meeting was to make sure the residents have an input on the City budget. (Commissioner Katz arrived 7:00 p.m.) Mayor Grant asked if Commissioner Katz had any informational items to disclose. CI Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Commissioner Katz stated he met with JKM Developers. He requested clarification of meeting time for the budget input meeting. He recalls the meeting was set for 5:00 p.m. on the agenda it was 6:30 p.m. Mayor Grant stated he was fine with 6:30 p.m. Commissioner McCray stated he was fine with beginning the budget input meeting at 6:30 p.m. 4. PUBLIC AUDIENCE INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO 3 MINUTE PRESENTATIONS (at the discretion of the Chair, this 3 -minute allowance may need to be adjusted depending on the level of business coming before the City Commission) Susan Oyer, 140 S.E. 27th Way, noted the City of Boynton Beach should lead the way regarding debris removal, such as having an ordinances banning styrofoam and plastic straws. She explained the Town of Jupiter was considering placing a ban on plastic straws and styrofoam. Mayor Grant mentioned a green committee a few meeting ago and she has not heard anything else about this committee. Vice Mayor Romelus inquired as to the alternatives to plastics. Ms. Oyer replied there was glass, paper, and ceramic to name a few. Kevin Homer, 2505 North Lake Drive, noticed a ton of debris in the canal one day while taking pictures. He was approached by Dean of Paddle Away Sports in Boynton Beach, who suggested organizing a cleanup. Mr. Homer's first call was to Wally Mayors, Director of Parks and Recreation. Mr. Majors was extremely supportive, offering his time, knowledge and materials for the event. Dean of Paddle Away Sports donated a couple of kayaks for the event. He contacted Seacrest Recovery Center, to offer patients a sense of purpose and volunteer their time for the cleanup. Lowes donated 30 buckets and Harbor Freight provided 40 trash pickers. In addition, Carrabba's, Frankie's pizza, Souvlaki Fast, Sushi Joe's provided gift cards for a cleanup raffle. He was present to let the public know about Adopt a Park program. In less than an hour, 53 volunteers collected more than a 100 pounds of trash. The next week he received a text from Wayne Carrels regarding homeless people cleaning up the park. Diagnostic Centers of America will sponsor the next clean up. Boynton Cares was not just for animals or children, but for the homeless as well. The cleanup takes place the first Sunday of each month at 9 a.m. Vice Mayor Romelus thanked Mr. Homer and City employee Wayne Carrels. It was rare that the public come offers a "good job" story. Stephen Muckerman, 225 West Ocean, noted the trash has gotten out of control. In the 60's and 70's there was a push to clean up the trash. The City needs to focus on cleaning up Boynton Beach. With so many good things coming to the City, they need to get ahead of the litter problem. 5 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Barbara Bernadine, 9073 Lawrence Road, acknowledged the young lady being recognized tonight for the Bob Borovy Student Citizen of the Year award. Ms. Thomas' parents are doing an incredible job, and would like to thank them for their hard work. Thanked the Mayor and the Commissioners for acknowledging something positive. No one else coming forward, Mayor Grant closed Public Audience. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE A. Appoint eligible members of the community to serve in vacant positions on City advisory boards. The following Regular (Reg) and Alternate (Alt) Student (Stu) and Nonvoting Stu (N/V Stu) openings exist: Arts Commission: 2 Alts Building Board of Adjustments & Appeals: 2 Regs and 1 Alts Employee Pension Board: 1 Reg Senior Advisory Board: 1 Reg and 2 Alts Mayor Grant advised there was one applicant for the Senior Advisory board Motion Commissioner Casello moved to appoint Antonio Villatoro to the Senior Advisory Board (Reg). Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. B. Mayor Grant to discuss PBC Transportation Planning Agency, Nick Uhren, Executive Director. Nick Uhren, Executive Director of Palm Beach County Transportation Planning Agency, provided an overview of the TPA. Explained the TPA consists of 21 locally elected officials, 5 of the 7 County Commissioners are on the governing board. There are 15 municipal elected officials from the 13 largest cities. Mayor Grant sits as a representative, Commissioner McCray was the alternate. Their mission statement was to collaboratively plan, prioritize, and fund transportation. Their vision statement was to provide a safe, efficient, connected, multimodal transportation system. Facilities are designed and operated to enable safe access for all users, including pedestrians, bicyclists, motorists and transit riders regardless of their ages or abilities. Mr. Uhren indicated the agency was passionate about safety, as stated before this was part of the vision statement. In February the governing board were asked by the Federal 0 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Government to adopt a target which would be accepted for fatalities and serious injury which would be acceptable, and the resounding response to that Federal mandate, was they would accept none, they call that a vision zero commitment. They are passionate about rebuilding our road ways system to eliminate traffic related fatalities tragedy and serious injury. The Palm Beach TP was partnering with member communities. He explained the role of the TPA in allocating Federal and State transportation dollars, gas taxes and user fees to various projects as well as to maximize the City ability to influence the decisions being made by others. The TPA has maps of all of the project which would be constructed within the next five years, regardless of who complete the projects. Boynton Beach was the 3rd largest city in Palm Beach County. The TPA wanted to make sure Boynton Beach's voice is heard. Boynton Beach waterfront access was unique and distinctive. The TPA was the City of Boynton Beach planning and funding partner with the FEC quiet zones, rail crossing safety grants, the liaison to FDOT, County and neighboring cities, along US 1, Boynton Beach Blvd, Seacrest Blvd, 1-95 interchanges. They are the voice in regional transportation matters, road design, mobility fees, transit services, safe routes to schools. Help Boynton Beach influence the upcoming project on Seacrest, this was a window of opportunity, the dollars, to insure the work would maximize the work, influence the design of the interchange project, they are Boynton Beach voice in transportation matters. Palm Beach County has a road impact fee, where every developer pays for a portion of the road capacity which their new project will consume. The TPA has asked the County to discuss the transition from a road only fee to a mobility fee, which will allow developers to contribute not only to the portion of road capacity they need, but their portion of the sidewalks, the street light and the transit infrastructure, which the new development being created needs. Mr. Uhren explained the membership dues were needed to support the TPA expenditures that are not federally reimbursable which would maximize the agency effectiveness. This would allow the agency to compete for discretionary grants. Mayor Grant noted he was very excited for Palm Beach County to have a new agency. He stated unless there is a plan for more people the traffic will get worse. Commissioner McCray thanked Mr. Uhren for the presentation. Commissioner Casello inquired how Palm Beach County Administration was about the TPA becoming independent. Mr. Uhren responded they were supportive. Commissioner Casello asked if the funds for the road impact fees remain in Boynton Beach. Mr. Uhren explained the County decides where projects are funded, the projects are based on zones. Vice Mayor Romelus inquired if this would be an additional fee to the developers. 7 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Mr. Uhren explained the TPA wants to replace the road impact fee with the multimodal fee. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if TPA was reaching out to the development community and if positive feedback was being received. Mr. Uhren replied the general feedback was very positive to allow for active living. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if the developers are in support of making this move from a governmental agency verses an independent one. Mr. Uhren explained the development community would not be affected whether or not the agency was governmental or independent. Vice Mayor Romelus asked about the oversight of the agency, if the agency was not under the umbrella of the County. Mr. Uhren stated the oversight was from the 21 board members. Mayor Grant explained decisions were made by the board members, then it goes for approval before the five County Commissioners which are on the board. He stated the County have the final approval of the TPA budget. Vice Mayor Romelus said she needed clarification on the oversight, once the TPA leave the umbrella from the County. TPA was now operating independently. How will the public know how the money is being spent? Mayor Grant explained TPA was governed by the Sunshine Law, all of the meetings have minutes and all meeting are noticed to the public. Mayor Grant said the TPA have elected government officials sitting on the board. Mr. Uhren explained they operate much like the City, which employs a manger subject to the parameters. He operates the TPA as an agency with those parameters which have been given. TPA Board of Directors, the 21 members, are subjected to the County administration they are hosted by the County Administrator. Vice Mayor Romelus asked what the benefit for Boynton Beach was partnering with the TPA. Inquired as to what was the current contribution? Mr. Uhren responded currently the TPA does not have any local dues. Commissioner McCray indicated the dues to be taken as part of the advocacy, they cannot spend federal dollars on certain items. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if the City would have more empowerment over what was being spent on roadways. Commissioner Romelus inquired if this was the purpose and the benefits of transitioning. Mr. Uhren explained the primary benefits were for the advocacy funding are on State and Federal discretionary grants. 10 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Commissioner Casello asked if the TPA became independent and a municipality decide not to pay the dues, would the City get the same representation. Mr. Uhren stated it would create a question as to how to proceed. Commissioner Casello inquired if the City does not pay the dues, will the City be held hostage. Mr. Uhren stated that was not how the TPA worked. Commissioner Casello noted the City do not know if all municipalities were on board. Vice Mayor Romelus asked about increasing the dues in the future. Mr. Uhren explained the dues would be fixed for the first five years. He explained the dues would not be used to pay staff salary. Commissioner McCray asked if this would be discussed at the budget hearings. Vice Mayor Romelus indicated she would like to see something more tangible. Her concern was transparency. She indicated she would like to see this in writing in the near future. Commissioner Katz stated there was more information which needed to be explained. He indicated he has zero concerns regarding the dues which would be paid to the organization if it would have resulted in more funds being kept in the City as a result of not having the County delegating projects outside of the City limits being funded with City dollars. Requested staff to provide an analysis of the amount of impact fees which has been generated within the past five years and how much money has come back to the City from the County. He was willing to pay the dues assessment. He was more concerned about the cost benefit of the impact fees being retained within the City. Mayor Grant asked fora motion to approve the dues and for the City staff to move forward. Vice Mayor Romelus stated she was not ready to move forward with this item. Commissioner Katz indicated he was not prepared to vote on this item. Motion Commissioner McCray motioned to table to discuss in the future. Commissioner Katz seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. 0 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 6. CONSENT AGENDA Matters in this section of the Agenda are proposed and recommended by the City Manager for "Consent Agenda" approval of the action indicated in each item, with all of the accompanying material to become a part of the Public Record and subject to staff comments. Mayor Grant moved item 6-C to 8-D. A. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R18-069 -Assess the cost of nuisance abatement on properties within the City of Boynton Beach. B. Accept the Fiscal Year 2017-2018 Budget Status Report of the General Fund and the Utilities Fund for the six (6) month period ended March 31, 2018. C. Approve the "Cortina PUD Replat Three" record plat, conditioned on the approval being the certification of the plat documents by Gary Dunmyer (City Engineer). (Moved to 8- D) D. Accept the written report to the Commission for purchases over $10,000 for the month of April 2018. E. Approve the minutes from City Commission meeting held on May 1, 2018. Mayor Grant requested a motion to approve the Consent Agenda. Motion Commissioner Casello moved to approve Consent Agenda as amended. Commissioner Katz seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. 7. BIDS AND PURCHASES OVER $100,000- None A. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R18-070 —Authorize the City Manager to sign a contract with R&D Paving, LLC of West Palm Beach, FL for the "NW 1th Avenue Reconstruction —Model Block project" Bid No. 011-81-8TP in the amount of $461,147.50 plus a 10% contingency of $46,114.75 if needed for staff approval of change orders for unforeseen conditions for a total expenditure of $507,262.25 10 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida Motion May 15, 2018 Commissioner McCray moved to approve with discussion. Vice Mayor Romelus seconded the motion. Commissioner McCray asked if the City hired a local contractor. Mayor Grant stated this was an RFP process. Commissioner McCray noted he understood the RFP process, asked if the City have any local contractors. Mr. Colin Groff, Assistant City Manager, indicated this was a bid on the work. The engineering was done over the past three years. Under the new program the local preference would have been included. He could not say if this was a local contractor. Commissioner McCray stated this project needed to get underway. This was a positive for the City of Boynton Beach. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if the representative for R&D Paving was available for questions. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if staff discussed with them to work with the local contractors. Mr. Groff explained many of the projects began before the new ordinance was in place. The City always asks the contractor to use the new process. Ms. LaVerriere stated this was finishing up the model block project, once the City has the improvements in place, such as paving, sidewalk, underground electric, new utility, this will pave the way for 11 new homes. Mayor Grant asked if this created a connection from Seacrest to N.W. 11 th Avenue. Ms. LaVerriere said this will help with the traffic flow at the school. The City has partnered with the schools to complete this project when the children are out for the summer. Chris Roche, Engineering Division Manager, introduced himself to the Commission. Vote The motion unanimously passed. B. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R18- 071- Authorize the City Manager to sign a contract with Ric -Man International, Inc. for "PROGRESSIVE DESIGN BUILD FOR CENTRAL SEACREST CORRIDOR UTILITY IMPROVEMENTS PHASE II"; as a result of RFQ No.037-2821-17/TP in the amount of $3,233,885,33 for Design services, and a total project value of $10,000,000. 11 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Mayor Grant read Proposed Resolution R18-071 by title only into the record. Motion Commissioner McCray motioned to approve with discussion. Seconded by Commissioner Casello. Commissioner McCray asked how long the City has been working on this project. Michael Low, Deputy Utilities Directory/Manager Technical Services, stated this was the second phase of the actual construction work, the original design was done 8 years ago. Ms. LaVerriere stated this was phase 2 of what will be a three phase project. Mr. Low stated once Town Square was complete the last phase will be completed. Commissioner McCray stated this was long overdue. Vice Mayor Romelus asked how long before work would begin. Mr. Low provided an overview of the project. Explained the City will be replacing undersized and old water lines throughout select neighborhoods. Moving water lines from the rear easements to the front of the property. There will be more fire hydrants to meet the updated standards. Storm water improvements, such as adding storm water collections features in areas prone to flooding, restore the right of way, add swales and improve driveways and sidewalks, replace driveway aprons, replace and add sidewalks. This would also include improve landscaping on Seacrest Boulevard, wastewater design and construct a new force main to serve south Federal Highway area and the southern end of the barrier island service area. The total project budget was $10M. Mr. Low indicated the next steps were to prepare and send individual letters to property owner. There will be community meetings to review the project. Mr. Low showed a slide of the overall project area, which will be constructed in 2 separate phases. It also shows where the exfiltration trenches will be installed to alleviate flooding and promote aquifer recharge. Vice Mayor Romelus asked when the work will begin. Mr. Low replied the work should begin within the next 3-4 weeks. Vice Mayor Romelus asked the expected completion date. Mr. Low responded after the guaranteed maximum price was received it should be about 18 months for completion. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if the City intention was to engage the community. Mr. Low responded City staff has spoken with the neighbors in detail about what was happening and will provide a dedicated telephone line to deliver updated information. 12 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida 15, 2018 Commissioner Casello, stated the gentlemen from the TPA mentioned the resurfacing was in the que. Asked if this was any type of conflict. Mr. Low explained this was separate; which was the setback at the end of the right -of way. Commissioner Casello asked for clarification regarding the water mains being replaced Mr. Low indicated there are no water mains on Seacrest. All of the water mains will be on the side roads. Ms. LaVerriere stated Seacrest was not being torn up. Commissioner Casello stated he did not want to do the job twice. Commissioner McCray asked if there has been a citizen meeting. Mr. Low explained there has been a citizens meeting. There were earlier meeting, now there will be a formal follow- up meeting. Commissioner McCray indicated there will be a follow-up meeting, and telephone number will be provided. Mr. Low stated staff has already spoken with the general contractor regarding communication with the residents. Mayor Grant asked if the sidewalks and swales along Seacrest Boulevard were part of the project. Mr. Low stated Seacrest was a County road. Mayor Grant inquired if the road from Seacrest to Forest Park Elementary could be wider. Mr. Low stated they have spoken with staff about the width of the sidewalks and how to move forward. Vote The motion unanimously passed. C. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R18-072 - Authorize the City Manager to sign a contract with Murphy Pipeline Contractors, Inc. of Jacksonville, FL for construction of water distribution system water main upgrades in the area of SE 27th Ct to SE 31 st Ave as shown in the attached drawing in the amount of $1,352,112 and a 10% contingency amount of $135,211 for unforeseen issues for a total cost of $1,487,323. Murphy Pipeline was awarded as Primary Vendor as a result of Bid No. 036-2821-16/TP by the City on May 17, 2016. Mayor Grant read Proposed Resolution R18-072 by title only. Commissioner McCray stated he has some concerns about this project. Mr. Groff introduced Mr. Tremaine Johnson, Interim Manager of Field Operations Mr. Johnson explained the project consisted of upgrading 10,623 of 4' AC pipe to 6 HDPE (High Density Polyethylene), upgrading 1,950 feet of 6" AC pipe to 8" HDPE. Impacts 13 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 eleven streets throughout Dewey Heights/Seacrest Estates, Additional eight fire hydrants to bring fire suppression up to code. Mr. Johnson provided some photos which showed the advantages of pipe bursting, minimal disturbance to neighborhood streets, and minimal impact to individual residents, ability to easily make improvement to fire suppression, new hydrants. During the operation of the pipe bursting, the pipe was pre chlorinated, the water was ready to be used. There would be no need to test the water or trenching. Commissioner McCray asked was this the same thing which had taken a very long time to complete and would this block the flow of traffic. Mr. Johnson explained there should not be any impact to traffic. Vice Mayor Romelus said the City will be adding additional fire hydrants and protecting the citizens. Mayor Grant stated the City was replacing trees which are in the swales or the right -a- way area. Mr. Johnson explained the areas for the pit was in an area where there were no trees to be removed. Motion Vice Mayor Romelus moved to approve. Commissioner Casello seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. 8. PUBLIC HEARING 7 P.M. OR AS SOON THEREAFTER AS THE AGENDA PERMITS The City Commission will conduct these public hearings in its dual capacity as Local Planning Agency and City Commission. A. Approve Quantum Lakes Villas West Major Site Plan Modification (MSPM 17- 001) for 104 Multi -family rental units and associated recreational amenities and site improvements, as well as a request for four (4) setback waivers, located on Lot 52 of Quantum Park, in the PID (Planned Industrial Development) zoning district. Applicant: John Lyon, Olen Properties. Staff to review PBC Ordinance on Panhandlers. Attorney Cherof swore in all those who wished to testify. John Lyon, Represents Olen Properties on Gateway and Quantum Lakes Drives, said the project has set idle since 2011. Olen Properties was seeking a Site Plan Major 14 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Modification to reduce the setback to 15 feet on the roadway and 7 feet along the lake back and project side. Motion Vice Mayor Romelus moved to approve. Commissioner Casello seconded the motion. David Katz, Chair of the Planning and Development Board, indicated the board was asking the developer to add an additional handicap parking to the second building which only had one. There are four buildings; two of the buildings have two, and two of the buildings have one. Staff saw no problem with this happening. During the Planning and Development meeting the representative stated there would be six handicapped parking spaces, but they had four buildings. He stated half of the apartments were ADA compliant. As the chair of the board he would like to see additional handicapped parking. Mayor Grant asked if the applicant had an issue with adding an additional handicap space for a total of eight. Mr. Lyon indicated this would require a modification to the Site Plan. The project was at its maximum capacity in terms of its green areas and parking spaces. He indicated they were required to have 186 parking spaces; they have 187 with 6 being handicapped parking. They have met and exceeded the requirement of a residential property, this was not commercial. He stated to make up and add two spaces was not that easy, there was a minimum width, this would cause to reduce the amount to green areas or reduce the overall number of parking spaces. Mayor Grant stated they have designed handicapped accessible apartments, was it possible for the management to identify some regular parking spaces as handicapped parking. Mr. Lyons stated anything on the first floor by current standards of FHA and ADA must be compliant. There are a total of 52 apartments. In Florida they owned and manager about 5000 apartments, there has not been a need. Stated there was a shortage in standard parking. Commissioner McCray asked if they add two additional parking this would reduce green space. Mr. Lyons stated the space has to come from somewhere. Indicated handicap space is 1 foot, plus the 5 feet access lane. He stated they would lose two standard handicapped spaces. Commissioner Katz asked if there was consensus on the Commission to increase the minimum requirements for handicap parking spaces. He stated every single time a project comes before the Commission there seems to be a request to add more than the required 15 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 amount. If there was consensus in the future to change the specification to change the amount of the handicapped spaces. If we want to have more handicapped parking lets mandate this. Commissioner Casello asked if the project was in compliance of all regulations. Mr. Lyons stated they are in the final stage and they are good to go. Vice Mayor Romelus asked the commitment of hiring local workers in the management of the facility. Mr. Lyons stated when doing major projects like this, the company usually hires outside contractors, his company has changed their policies. They will hire local contractors, from qualified GC and local contractors. There is no exact listing. They are making every effort to hire local Boynton or Local Palm Beach County. Mayor Grant asked if the Commission needs to remove the Planning and Zoning condition of approval. Attorney Cherof stated it should be addressed and rejected. Motion Commissioner Casello motioned to reject the condition of approval to add two handicapped spaces. Commissioner Katz seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. B. Approve Boynton Village & Town Center Master Plan Modification (MPMD 18- 002) to amend the previous approvals for SMU Parcel 1 from 115 single-family homes to 378 apartments and 55 townhomes, while reducing the total number of the approved residential unit allotment within the entire master plan from 1,120 to 1,115. Applicant: John Markey, JKM Developers Mayor Grant read the Master Plan into the record by title only. Asked if the applicant was in agreement in combining both B and C. Bonnie Miskel, attorney for the applicant, agreed with combining the two items. The presentation has been consolidated. Mayor Grant instructed to add the consent item for approval of the Cortina PUD Replat 3, record plat on the condition of approval being certified. 16 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Bonnie Miskel, attorney for the applicant, reported the original approval for the 106 -acre master plan for Boynton Village & Town Center has been amended numerous times since 2012. This latest request is to amend the previous approvals for SMU Parcel 1 from 115 single-family homes to 378 apartments and 55 townhomes. The SMU Parcel 1 is approximately 20 -acres in size, and is located at the NE corner of Old Boynton Road and Renaissance Commons Boulevard. It is the last remaining vacant parcel of the Boynton Village & Town Center master plan to seek site plan approval. Staff considers the modifications to the approved master plan to be non -substantial, as the requested development falls within the parameters of the original master plan allotments, and is actually a reduction in total dwelling units from 1,120 to 1,115. Ms. Miskel indicated the applicant was proposing a Major Site Plan approval of the SMU. Ms. Miskel showed a map of the proposed plan including a dog park. Ms. Miskel noted on March 17, 2015 the most recent approval Master Plan Modification and Conditional Use request, amending the plan from 34 townhomes, 348 apartments and 80 single family detached homes, to 643 condominiums, 350 apartments and 115 single family detached homes. The subject parcel is currently platted for 15 single family lots as the Cortina PUD Replat 2. Ms. Miskel stated her client was purposing 55 townhouse units and 378 multifamily units for the SMU parcel area of the Cortina of Boynton Village development. Ms. Miskel presented a chart of the existing traffic vs. the proposed traffic. She understood there were a number of neighbors which spoke out regarding the traffic. She stated they were reducing the living units. There were many benefits to the project. There would be $19M in roadway improvements, an additional $500,000 plus in improvement to the expanded City owned Dog Park. High quality development compared to prior condition with a mix of unit types, Electric car charging stations, adding $430,000 annually in additional tax base. Mayor Grant asked if there was a parking garage. Ms. Miskel stated there was surface parking. Vice Mayor Romelus stated she moved to approve. Commissioner McCray indicated he heard some complaints regarding the apartments looking into the homeowner's backyards. Ms. Miskel stated this has been addressed. The buildings were stepped down, and the building was more than 250 feet away, with three tiers of landscaping. Commissioner McCray asked if he was on the 4t" floor he would not be able to look over into the neighbors to the east backyard. The building which have 4 floors are 400 feet away and they are separated by the townhome building. Commissioner Katz said he has been in conversation with the developer, since the density was downgraded. When the dog park was built it became very clear the dog park 17 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 was being over utilized. The developer decided to increase the size of the dog park. The combined population of Renaissance Commons and now the Cortina project was significant, stated there was no public park in this area other than the existing dog park. The City should maximize the use of this park, there are some park impact fees available. Commissioner Katz stated he spoke with Wally Majors, Parks and Recreation Director, indicated a fraction of those fees could be used for this project. In addition, this was generating almost $500,000 in potential additional annual revenue. The maintenance for the existing park was funded in perpetuity by the master association of all the new developers. As a condition of approval try to move forward on maximizing the offering of the park. The opportunity to increase parking, would have more people, additionally by spacing the new track south of the green space, the center space could be used in the future or playground equipment, pavilions, barbeque pits. He was requesting the board to give the park the honor it deserve. The park could become a true focal point. John Markey, 2300 Glades Road, Boca Raton, remarked it has been a very fast project to add $500,000 worth of improvement to the dog park. They are seeing so much use of the dog park; they have decided to improve the park. The package included a larger dog enclosure, benches, open spaces, utilizing the entire dog park. They are happy to be a part of this effort; they are providing $500,000 for the new dog park. Commissioner McCray asked who will pay for the pavilion. Mr. Markey stated he will pay for the pavilions. Commissioner Casello stated Mr. Markey took the idea of a dog park and ran with it. This would be great. He stated he would go along with the park impact fee to maintain the park. This would be a great amenity in Boynton Beach. Many people would enjoy this dog park. Mayor Grant opened up to Public Audience. Guy Borg, 501 NW 11 Street, lives in Sky Lake, currently the president of the homeowner's association. As homeowners they see more apartments and more transients. He stated he appreciate the design of the buildings. They are putting 800 more cars on the roads. Mr. Borg stated he would rather see single family homes. Jane Gibas, 1001 NW 10 Court, preferred the single family homes, and improve the dog park and make it into a larger park. She stated the traffic was bad already and the crime, there are drug rehabs over there, people selling drugs and overdoses. If there are more apartments we will have the same type of issues in this area. She hopes the Commission would reconsider. Mari Hoover, 1005 NW 10 Street, asked has the City considered the impact this would have on the City services, such as Fire Rescue and Police departments. They have too much traffic on the road way. Me Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Wayne Gibas, 1001 NW 10 Court, stated there was a very big difference between apartments and single family homes. He stated he was a mail carrier for 32 years, and the only time he had been assaulted was in apartments. He indicated since Motorola moved the City has built so many buildings. He stated he would prefer single family homes. He stated Old Boynton Road was a very dangerous road. No one was going 35 miles an hour. Kim Black 973 NW 11 Street, stated she was a licensed Real Estate broker, and a property manager in Boynton Beach. Please think about doing this before you make a decision. Lynn Myers 1002 NW 10 Court, indicated she was strongly opposed to apartments being built. She believes there are many apartments being built. She stated the City needs single family homes, especially along the canal. Ms. Myers stated the impact that the apartments will have on the Fire and Police. Ms. Myers stated they could have a two- bedroom apartment and could house 4 or more people. Old Boynton road speed limit is 35 miles per hour, but the traffic was flowing at 40-50 miles per hours. This road will look like 1-95. The Developer was saying the 4 story apartment would be in the middle, she does not believe that was the case. This purposed development was wrong, please go back to the single family homes originally proposed. Erica, lives in Renaissance Commons and at first there was going to be single family homes, now there will be apartment buildings. She stated Boynton Beach has enough apartment buildings, The City of Boynton Beach needs single family homes. As far as crime goes in Renaissance Commons, she must disagree, she does not see the area as a high crime area. There was more traffic to the area, and more money to the businesses. The single family homes are a better choice. Mayor Grant said when ALTA came in and requested a Major Site Plan Modification they did not need to change the master plan, because it was being reduced from 630 condos to 300. He was hopping the City would get the single family homes as well. After a closer look it was impossible to put a single home on 4000 square feet. He stated maybe in 2006 this may have been possible, but not now in today's market. In Town Square the home will cost approximately $200,000 for a home on .6 of an acre, this cannot be done in this area. The Developer stated with the 55 townhomes along the canal was actually less density, then what was currently planned with the single family lots lining that road. As for the apartment and the traffic. He continued to say the perception that traffic engineers use, the chart was provided and shows that apartment use was less traffic. Mayor Grant stated he understands it was very difficult to get out of Sky Lake. This was something the City needs to address. There are three entrances and there are no lights. He was not sure if this was a county road or a City road. There should be a light for one of those entrances. The City may need to get with the County regarding the traffic light timing. Mayor Grant explained the developer only needs to provide competent substantial evidence this was ok, because it was less than the total density of the Master Plan. He 19 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 explained if the developer was asking for additional density, it would be a different type of legal standard. Because it was less than the original Master Plan which was approved in 2005, this was a permitted use. He was not sure if the light was of any help, there was traffic coming from Boynton Beach Blvd. The City and the residents need to work together. It was within the developer's right to ask for less density. There is no single family competition. The developer was planning on being a good neighbor and is paying for the park. The question was does the residents want to add more to the park. Mayor Grant addressed the neighbors' concerns regarding overlooking the single family homes backyards. Mayor Grant stated the building was 400 feet away and there was a 25 foot building between the neighbor's backyard and the building. If additional landscaping was needed, he was sure the developers would be willing to provide the additional landscaping. The City will receive additional tax base and some retail stores. Commissioner Casello indicated speeding has always been a problem on Old Boynton road. Maybe putting an additional traffic light. He believed this was a County road. Mr. Mack stated the County has criteria on when and how to place a traffic light. A study would need to be done. Commissioner Casello asked staff to have a conversation with the County regarding the traffic light on Old Boynton Road. Commissioner Casello explained when projects are presented the issues regarding public safety were always addressed. Commissioner Casello stated everything has been addressed regarding fire and police. Vice Mayor Romelus stated she wanted to increase the police presence on Old Boynton Road. She would like to have the developer's representatives answer some questions. Vice Mayor Romelus asked if these units have been designed so that they could be converted to condos or home ownership. Ms. Miskel indicated these units could easily convert to condos. Vice Mayor Romelus stated in the interim it would be the developer's responsibility to maintain the property and its appearance. Ms. Miskel stated a number of municipalities found it was easier to enforce the code rules and regulations when dealing with a large company than dealing with individual owners. Vice Mayor Romelus asked what the commitment to work with local workers. Ms. Miskel responded they are happy and enthusiastic to work with the City with finding competent workers and contractors. Commissioner McCray stated in regard to police sitting out at Old Boynton Road, he was not in favor. The police should be utilized where they are needed. 20 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Commissioner Casello said if the City identifies an area where people are speeding and endangering pedestrians and other motorist this needs to be addressed. If this means placing more police officers in the areas during certain times, then he believes this should be done. Vice Mayor Romelus said she agrees with Commissioner Casello. Commissioner McCray wanted to explain the reasoning behind his comment. The residents want a free road where nothing was happening. He stated times have changed, there was a lot of development in the area. Commissioner Katz indicated he sympathizes and he agrees it may be better to have single family homes. He shared that he lives in a townhome. They have sober homes in the area which the City cannot prohibit. He knows that apartments would not allow sober homes. The market does support the ability to price the single family home in this area. With regards with trying to dictate ownership versus rental property, the City does not have the ability to force the developer to build single family homes. Attorney Cherof stated the City of Boynton Beach Code does not regulate the type of ownership. Commissioner Katz said he would like to see more homeowner opportunities. This was what the market could bear right now. This was what was legally permissible under the current rule. The fact there was a canal between the adjacent communities providing a strong buffer, making it almost impossible for people to walk into the area. The perception was that it changes the community, it will lead to more cars, and right now it was an empty lot. The affect was more when people leave the community. He was not sure if owning a single family unit was less quality because across the canal there was a managed rental community. He would have loved to be able to live in a single family home. It was a sound project. There are a number of those businesses have been doing well, also number of the smaller commercial space was not able to sustain themselves. Vice Mayor Romelus wanted to make sure the City does not forget about the impact fees for the parks. In terms of the numbers and what that would look like, to bring up as an agenda item in the future. Mayor Grant asked if there was a gate to the community. Inquired if there would be some type of security? Ms. Miskel stated this will be a gated community. Attorney Cherof indicated the Commission has three different agenda items, 8-A, 8-13, 8- C and 8-D which was moved from 6-C. Commissioner Katz noted pending the cost to the City, they move forward with the enhancements to the park, where would that language need to be attached. The site plan as offered now, does not have the upgrades because they are subject to the City's willingness to fund those upgrades. Attorney Cherof indicated the Commission has the public representation which would occur with a follow-up item when the time comes. 21 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Mayor Grant stated they are moving to approve the Boynton Village and Town Village Master Plan Modification 18-002. Motion Commissioner Casello moved to approve. Commissioner Katz seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. C. Approve Cortina III Major Site Plan Modification (MSPM 18-003) to construct 378 apartments, 55 townhomes, and related site improvements on SMU Parcel 1 of the Boynton Village & Town Center master plan. Applicant: John Markey, JKM Developers Mayor Grant requested a motion to approve. Motion Commissioner Casello moved to approve. Vice Mayor Romelus seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. D. Approve the "Cortina PUD Replat Three" record plat, conditioned on the approval being the certification of the plat documents by Gary Dunmyer (City Engineer). (Moved from 6- Q Mayor Grant requested a motion to approve. Motion Commissioner Casello moved to approve. Commissioner Katz seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. 9. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT -None 10. UNFINISHED BUSINESS - None 11. NEW BUSINESS -None 22 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida 12. LEGAL May 15, 2018 A. PROPOSED ORDINANCE 18-006 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approval of Ordinance amending Section 18-164 of the Code of Ordinances to provide for mutual consent regarding use of the 185 money; amending Section 18- 169 to add normal retirement age definition for members who retire with (20) years of service only retirement, to provide for payment of death benefits to a designated beneficiary in the event that there is no spouse, and to add ten year vesting for Police Officers hired on or after October 1, 2016; adding a new Section 18-178 to add a rehire after retirement provision. Mayor Grant read Proposed Ordinance No. 18-006 by title only on second reading. Motion Commissioner McCray moved to remove Item A and B from the table. Vice Mayor Romelus seconded the motion Vote The motion unanimously passed. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance #18-006 into the record by title only. Attorney Cherof stated this was tabled because it was a notice requirement to be sent to the State of Florida. That information has been attached to the backup and an actuarial report. This was implementing the collective bargaining agreement previously approved. Motion Commissioner Katz moved to approve. Vice Mayor Romelus seconded the motion. City Clerk, Judith Pyle called the roll Vote 5-0 B. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 18-007 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve Amendments to Abandoned Personal and Real Property Code (10-51.5) - Amending the GARBAGE, TRASH, AND OFFENSIVE CONDITIONS, Chapter 10, Article III, Abandoned Property, Section 10-51.5; to clarify the definitions of default and mortgagee; and to clean up language as to Attorney Cherof read the Proposed Ordinance 18-007 into the record. P493 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Motion Commissioner Katz moved to retable. Vice Mayor Romelus seconded the motion. (Tabled to 6-5-18) Vote The motion unanimously passed. C. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. R18-008 - SECOND READING - Approve the revised and updated City ordinances to regulate the Fire Department. This is a revision of the local fire prevention ordinances as is required by Florida State Statute when a new edition of the Florida Fire Prevention Code has been adopted. Approval of this revision by the Board will allow our fire prevention ordinances to be consistent with the latest version of the Fire Prevention Code Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance #18-008 by title only on second reading. Attorney Cherof indicated he needed the Commission to adopt an amendment to change the effective date to July 18, 2018 to allow some fee issues to catch up with the ordinance. Motion Vice Mayor Romelus motioned to adopt and change the effective date to July 18, 2018. Commissioner Casello seconded the motion. City Clerk Pyle called the roll Vote 5-0 Mayor Grant stated the next meeting was a public input meeting on May 29, 2018 at 6:30 pm. indicated if the Commission had any items they wanted on the agenda, please contact staff. Commissioner Casello stated some items on the future agenda have been there for quite a while. He would like to get some of the future items onto the agenda. Mayor Grant indicated most of those stated June 2018. Commissioner Katz needed to clarify this was a public input meeting, the entire agenda was for public input. The Commission was not going to have a budget meeting until the summer. 24 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 Mayor Grant stated if he wanted to speak about the trolley system he needed to have it publicly noticed. Commissioner Katz stated this was a public input meeting, he was concerned this could turn into a Commission budget workshop meeting. He was happy to entertain a motion to place this item as future agenda item. Mayor Grant indicated this was to be placed on the future agenda item for a Trolley system in Boynton Beach. Vice Mayor Romelus would like to have the Commission begin to discuss a downtown police unit in order to increase the police presence, as they go forward with creating the downtown areas, and allocating funds. Commissioner Katz asked Vice Mayor Romelus if she was asking about a physical structure or a task force. Vice Mayor Romelus stated this would be a task force. Commission Casello inquired about the police substation in Renaissance Commons. Ms. LaVerriere indicated it was some office space for the crime prevention staff. This space was not manned. Commissioner Casello asked how much was the rental for this space. Ms. LaVerriere indicated there was no cost for the facility. The City has been asked to move out of the facility. Vice Mayor Romelus inquired about 500 Ocean? Ms. LaVerriere stated she spoke with Acting Chief Harris and a space was offered by 500 Ocean. 13. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS A. Staff to review PBC Ordinance on Panhandlers - June 2018 B. Staff to bring information concerning the following land parcels for the Commission to review - TBD Nichols Property Rolling Green Girl Scout Park C. Commissioner Katz has requested the City Attorney to provide update on legal issues with QPODD — TBD D. Staff to bring back to Commission results of negotiation with properly owner a real estate purchase and sale agreement between the City of Boynton Beach and Brittany Bumgardner for a vacant parcel at the end of SW 24th Avenue adjacent to 1-95. - TBD E. Announce Budget Workshop dates and times Budget Workshops at Intracoastal Park Clubhouse; Monday, July 16, 2018 @ 5:00 P.M. Tuesday, July 17, 2018 @ 10:00 A.M. Wednesday, July 18, 2018 @ 2:00 P.M. 25 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida May 15, 2018 F. Staff to report on the possibility of the City beginning a Bike Share Program - June 5, 2018 G. Agreement for Textile Recycling Franchise Agreement with FLSC, LLC dba Florida Textile Recycling Program for an exclusive City -Wide program - June 2018 H. Consider approving ILA with the CRA for funding associated with the NW 11th Avenue reconstruction bid associated with the Model Block Project - June 5, 2018. 14. ADJOURNMENT Motion There being no further business to discuss, Commissioner Katz moved to adjourn. Mayor Grant seconded the motion. Vote The motion unanimously passed. The meeting was adjourned at 9:22 p.m. (Continued on next page) 26 Meeting Minutes City Commission Boynton Beach, Florida ATTEST Jud' A. Pyle, CMC Cir ueenester Nieves Deputy City Clerk 27 May 15, 2018 CITY OF BOYNT B H mayor - Steven B. ant Vice Mayor ristina Romelus Comml'ss�ner — J er missioner - Joe Casello DEVELOPMENT ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA PROJECT NAME: Cortina III at Boynton Village & Town Center (MSPM 18-003) APPLICANT'S AGENT: Joni Brinkman, Urban Design Kilday Studios AGENT'S ADDRESS: 610 Clematis Street, Suite CU02, West Palm Beach, FL 33401 DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: May 15, 2018 TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Major Site Plan Modification approval to construct 378 apartments, 55 townhomes, and related site improvements on SMU Parcel 1 in the Boynton Village & Town Center development. LOCATION OF PROPERTY: NE corner of Congress Avenue and Old Boynton Road DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO. THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applicant HAS HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit "D" with notation "Included". 4. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof. _ DENIED 5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order. 7. Other DATED: City Clerk S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Boynton Village & Town Center\Master Plans\MPMD 18-002\MSPM 18-003 DO.doc 3 EXHIBIT "C" Conditions of Approval Project Name: Cortina III at Boynton Village File number: MSPM 18-003 Reference: 2nd review plans identified as a Master Plan Modification with a March 13, 2018 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking. DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT ENGINEERING / PUBLIC WORKS / FORESTRY / UTILITIES Comments: 1. At time of permit submittal, please provide engineering justification for the lack of an 18 inch offset from the edge of curb for the post located on the raised island between the swing gates at the entrance. X FIRE Comments: None, all previous comments addressed at DART meeting. X POLICE Comments: None, all previous comments addressed at DART meeting. X BUILDING DIVISION Comments: None, all previous comments addressed at DART meeting. X PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: None, all previous comments addressed at DART meeting. X PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: 2. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the application requests are publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04- 007 and Ordinance 05-004 and an affidavit provided to the City Clerk. X 3. At time of permit submittal, please revise Sheets SL -1 thru SL -5 to demonstrate a minimum average light level of one (1) foot-candle is provided, with no more than 10% of the spot readings below one (1) foot-candles, and none below 0.5 foot-candles, other than those readings proposed at the property boundaries. X Cortina III at Boynton Village (MSPM 18-003) Conditions of Approval Pane 9 of 9 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 4. Please add some colorful accent plants, approximately 6' in height X into the streetscape design at the fence along Renaissance Commons Boulevard, in an effort to provide some mid-level plantings between the 2' tall shrubs and palms and canopy trees. 5. Per City Code (Chapter 4, Article II, Section 4.A.3.d.), please remove X any sodded areas, other than for passive or active recreation purposes and replace with shrubs and groundcovers. 6. Please provide all required canopy trees with caliper inches in X compliance with the City code minimum of 4". 7. The proposed 6 -foot tall fences along Old Boynton Road and X Renaissance Commons Boulevard shall be decorative in nature, such as those utilized by the Cortina Apartments/The District development immediately to the north. Chain link fence, clad or not, is expressly prohibited. 8. Please note that approval of the Major Site Plan Modification is X subject to approval of the companion application for Master Plan Modification. 9. Prior to the issuance of any permits, please demonstrate compliance X with School District requirement to provide $26,053 as part of the school capacity contribution. 10. Applicants who wish to utilize City electronic media equipment for X recommended PowerPoint presentations at the public hearings must notify the project manager in Planning and Zoning and submit a CD of the presentation at least one week prior to the scheduled meeting. COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Comments: N/A PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS Comments: None CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS Comments: To be determined. y S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Boynton Village & Town Center\Master Plan\MPMD 18-002\MSPM 18-003\COA post PBD.doc §Y 9 j[E +y�� � . _ •3. fi '?E ' � T AIR? ' YY 14 a' - °Congress''Ave Y 1 - "' -41 . J, W40 A?+1 4' El �P < it E Y. -' 'a . .t. �ndola Ct p T Morieda St I JO r f a �a Z NW 11 th' m rt s NW 10th Ct a I -M A -SP -1 Overall Site Plan See SP -2 for Slb DeNils Site Tabulations u io:om,� 3K 1. 20 1% �. .=.. oss ma.x edNl,e Comp. a n.o. z r.�. ,.. .�. 1% Multi Family Parcel (SMU?Parcel 1) 4 SMry Apartment 8 2 Story Towntwmrs Unit & Parking Tabulatbrls -- ,A. .o.... 1, 51-' TA -11.1 . ®:.o=,.e.,.... T -I 378 c—et a.,...r.w... -11016.8... Multi Family Parcel - 4 Story - P-1 z) Unit & Parking Tabulations 7 Buildings - 350 Tobl Unks Idzm- .]Evc erv..Ib,u ILMI Multi Family Parcel - 5 Story Unit& Parking Tabulations ISMu- Parcel 3) 5 Building. - 324 TOMI Unks 1 171 m, s�:5, ,.�.. iI at! -,...,.a, GO G2 D- 120 a.��. ...s.. cmew�r Blvd. n SITE Ber lIn B hh Blvd. Site L—fion Map rN tADCn NdQTIST .. a o..,k. a� cwt. ® Total Residential Uses ..�a..e.,..,....nl— Denotes Not Included in Thi. Appi—t— wn p nn. S5 ....enaen +ama��, '.*."!ia�io dm. Match Una SP -3 HAIDIGRP 516= TyPIGei Pe�xmg sPeGes Demu Accessible Route Il illllllllllllllllllltlllll \ ccEsve�E Hoch uoTEs . T. mlm ..uab�ol��m Legend eEHCH a TsnsH RECE CLE M VC UNITS urbanclwgnkild- STUDIOS c�mk. NORTH YIT S - of 5 urban ISI ®� ®`�j•4• SRI \ 0 el .GH LIro Accessible RouteTV SCCESSISLE ROUTE ROTES 1 .=Z"lu 2.m- ° NgtTX Il�fi`.��vsn z vllbinwmprt.wMGb.N.6ap T.b.'ew YIT bag S�d 1-1, Watim �B9efld STREET M_SS—. eECE—LE o -R- SP -3 e.. F.— Z � �1CIL Nees•'®��s,,,_qe� �-„� Lake Tract "L'i SMU LAKE PARCEL A r 20 542 AC e. '�ur�. •' urban ISI ?y� e P.MCO \ 0 el .GH LIro Accessible RouteTV SCCESSISLE ROUTE ROTES 1 .=Z"lu 2.m- ° NgtTX z vllbinwmprt.wMGb.N.6ap T.b.'ew YIT �B9efld STREET M_SS—. eECE—LE o -R- SP -3 ♦j_ a 4 a O Fs PREVIOUSLYaw PPROVED -NOT PART OF THIS '-� APPLICATION Leasing 4 Building Type II ;» 5`T a �' \Pm ' 2 story ❑ ❑ 54 d.0 - 5 story 1 ar i I 6 Bwlding Type II c. 54 d u 5 story d YI IfY �l Ex. Retention Area Gd Swing metes 6 Keeper n I I r, post (I ea. side) llf\ Boynton Canal mild r rr� rrri�r�r� .. i1 Ass". �r�!MEMO In ♦j_ a 4 a O Fs PREVIOUSLYaw PPROVED -NOT PART OF THIS '-� APPLICATION Leasing 4 Building Type II ;» 5`T a �' \Pm ' 2 story ❑ ❑ 54 d.0 - 5 story 1 ar i I 6 Bwlding Type II c. 54 d u 5 story d YI IfY �l Ex. Retention Area Gd Swing metes 6 Keeper n I I r, post (I ea. side) llf\ cM-4 Ila b iii° i ■ ter. �I\ Wit. • Accessible Route ,, es ab; - es, IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII se mc'ption r,.cun —,m.t. ca m.b T. bre °-:� .-F,t:awa��� SP -4 of 5 4 cM-4 Ila b iii° i ■ ter. �I\ Wit. • Accessible Route ,, es ab; - es, IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII se mc'ption r,.cun —,m.t. ca m.b T. bre °-:� .-F,t:awa��� SP -4 of 5 Community Entry Signs-.........,e..M,�......,..�^E.^a„o yayE: com.^ey Er+nag^. m m s�.KmM.^a ^o�mN »nn �a^rMo^ Tw.caM•, T•�m sbn cmn. san�.r rot ae.g^. locate^, ens, IlgMep ena arbr assns •^Meinaa lnerem. Boynton Village Entry SignEntry Gate Plan THE DISTRICT NAME CORTINA NOTE:B,—Maps E"sign. byc..—erd mmpy-1,*oy.-T—Cm TeM Sign Cc— Merx®r.r Eeegn..m .e a., lot, eM MMr -.6. coMeiren-.in. Dog Park Plan M 1 1 W Swing Gates & Keeper Post (t ea. side) Park entrance shall be - tima.msMu perwu IriprovemeMe.Typ. signed "Park hours T SunrsetoSunset X —_--ia—_ 1, 5 T u D I OS �Ip^ Is Statue aop�ic• Conc. entry with waste _ bag and trash station - (one each side). 6'x 6' conc. slab with dog waterer and drainage, 8r a I m DOO (one each side). Lake Tract -1.. SMU I MP- S— of 5 Cortina III at Boynton Village Landscape Plans SHEETINDEX COVER st*ET & SHET — WP........ .. ............ L- --E I . .. .......... ................................ LN 210 LF S DOG — U— —pa—E PLAN......-- – LA -IG LAKE LITTORAL LANDSCAPE PLAN .......... *................. LA -1,P— oETAI S .......................... .......... .,*.*.* ............... LA 12 _—clmcsTIONc I �:LA : I P— UsT ........................ .......... -.............. LA OVERALL LANDSCAPE PLAN &SHEET KEY MAP NOTE, The- Landscape Plans have been prepared to satisfy City of Boynton Beach zoning requirements and to conceptually reflect landscape requirements for the site They are not to be utilized for construction drawings until f final engineering and architectural plans are available. These dravvings are not to be used for Building Permit application until these plans are finalized WR -1 P.ARCEL PARCEL .WR -2 � LAKE ' 1% Subject WCEL Site LANDSCAPE DATA TABULAR LANDSCAPE EXCAVATION & BACKFILL NOTES J-1 DEVELOPMENT TEAM SITE Fn LOCATION AMP NOTES C ......... 0 0 Lt 0�1 0 C 'A 0, �9 L) 0 LA -1 of 14 SHEET KEY MAP txlmn IAI IA -11 i LA -2 of 14 SHEET KEY MAP urbanlarnne 1�� ��(gn STUDIOS) LA -3 o114 SHEET KEY MAP urban wSTUDIOS Plannln9 Oespn LaMscape RrchMa<Nra a LA -4 of 14 Cortina III r,,, a a� at Boynton Village ij t+i ,31 Boynton Beach, Florida �f3sl� gRN 7 s Landscape PlanAT��W.`. GI via ooyman rtoaa Old Boynton Rc SHEET KEY MAP LA -7 of 14 SHEET KEY MAP STUDIO xoRn� Yl�f� LA -10 of 14 SHEET KEYMAP � u bban _ wTdgn STUDIOSJ A ` ' b€ —N of 14 EN. IV I ZI, I E n; 'ry - T- I ZT z! V, I -El MT X1. "I 11. DrTlIll zli -E. C) HRUIIA�NDOROUNIIOOVEI AJL T T. C_IWEGU� PLANTING DETAIL_T,._ 000 0 ROqTuAi«„EIER DETAJL E Z ��l x T ENR D-1- OSHRUB ,&,GROUNDCOVER LAYOUT DETAIL/1 MULCH RING IN SOD DETNL Ion LA -1 2 N .ALM PT�TINGDETAJL 0 APILNG BED EDGE DETAIL0 GROUND COVERS & ROOTED CUTTING PLANTING DEDETAILof 14 ;o;TT_ urban STUDIOS 0 ROqTuAi«„EIER DETAJL E Z ��l x T ENR D-1- OSHRUB ,&,GROUNDCOVER LAYOUT DETAIL/1 MULCH RING IN SOD DETNL Ion LA -1 2 N .ALM PT�TINGDETAJL 0 APILNG BED EDGE DETAIL0 GROUND COVERS & ROOTED CUTTING PLANTING DEDETAILof 14 ;o;TT_ .w.e�oae�o ....... ...... ... _ c STUDIOS LA -13 of 14 SECTION T' LANE =M"ECn N AT L -ORAL SHELF N.T.S. TREE REPLACEMEMENT M ',!P mWOLL IM. P= pt, pt, RE R RE =EO �%,�E— PlIST;I'll �Ipl EO IE XCP w LANDSCAPE ISLAND SUMMARY — —N. Mr W -161L LA -14 of 14 II+ + 19 BOYNTON 1 .. TOWN CENTER y cm Ir .EauYecrlEEcaESPonE wj ST' 1 - — iI ITI .. BbNC Qf{' LGE I ' M x � -_� '+���� I y`,-�, �C tit. 11 �T �I �j 1 �.,� � .•�� � P• SY *, I I . ji �'i tl I I v.E �. � •' � k % _ �. _ ���q •. -r .r. C 'y II `.�, .-ce^ 'kms' / r , S _ A � I j 101, - : -�. � I t 1L Ir'11 � rs, -r - y_• 1 t� I I M . � I i ,'' � j 'f - - k Ij ------ - 1, . EM[O WM�F� ,SCHNAR� BR CGR1tU ACGUI811N)N, LLC CGRTMA PHASE 7 MASTER WATER, SEWER 8 I ,••-m.- . a.�, .,s `"°'"""'"" `�"•� "`" /OO NgIMID61RBef,70RJ000. DRAINAGE PLAN �•••�•• -- o--_. --- . .< nE mae.be aY.r .� -:"•c MN HWNCIICQG ut— BEACH R.pW -'°"•:"='_- v..r C1o7 r iPs: r ,.. r a,, SITE LIGHTING PHOTOMETRIC PLAN frcFh Y 5 3 Ego SLA - "I, R dom !0 ; M T -A .1z 0 0 ". *1 u I UDKS Palm Bewh, Flonda Cortina III Site Lighting CO) :(� ��)(FR� UDKS West Palm Beach. Flonde Cortina Ill Site Lighting I °.� N Jill ( � r N , tt: UDKS West Palm Beach. Florda Cortina III Site Lighting ill R 1!� UDKS West Palm Beach, Flanda Cortina III Site Lighting Ac shbery Pedestdan light, 1i single luminaire, with cover plate, no twist -lock Date: 8/30/2016 Product Drawing www.lar)dscapeforms.com Ph: 800.521.2546 (4) 3/4-110x 18" THREADED RODS AND LEVELING NUTS INCLUDED 91 LED OPTIONS: 144 1/2" TYPE 3 TYPE 5 3000K 3500K 4000K [505] 19 7/8" `TENON MOUNT [102] 04" [4877] 192" [278] 10 7/8" [5034] 198 1/8" [944] 371/8" i [625] 24 5/8" CENTE ELEME 2000K Drawing: AP0022 CONFIDENTIAL DRAWING INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS THE PROPERTY OF LANDSCAPE FORMS, INC. 9 INTENDED USE IS LIMITED TO DESIGN PROFESSIONALS SPECIFYING LANDSCAPE FORMS, INC. PRODUCTS AND Dimensions Pend ng O LANDSCAPE FORMS, INC. NF'8 in inches [mm] DIRECT NG IS B�WF3 fd N WTHOUT THE CONSENT Patent DSCAPE FORMS NC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Ashbery Pathlight, Type 4, surface mount Product Drawing AVAILABLE COLOR TEMPERATURES: 3000K 3500K 4000K [243] ANCHORING HARDWARE 9 1/2'. INCLUDED. SEE INSTALLATION GUIDE FOR MORE DETAILS. L��l [178 7" [s 36 Date: 5/23/2016 www.landscapeforms.com Ph: 800.521.2546 CONFIDENTIAL DRAWING INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS THE PROPERTY OF LANDSCAPE FORMS, INC. Drawing: AP600-01 INTENDED USES LIMITED TO DESIGN �PgRiOFESSIONALS SPECIFYING LANDSCAPE FORMS, INC. PRODUCTS AND Dimensions are in inches [mm] THEIR DIRECT CLIENTS. DRAWING IS I ftj %etyE 'J GySCLOSS DTO�OTTHERS WITHO��S CONSENT Patent Pending OF LANDSCAPE FORMS, INC. yC 'C 2@ SCAN ASHBERY PATH UGHT Product Data Sheet General Description • Cast aluminum I -ED cartridge and structure • Surface mounted; base plate mounting template included • Asymmetrical and symmetrical distribution types available • Zero up -light, International Dark -Sky approved • UL Listed, suitable for wet locations Electrical Surge protected 100V -277V 50/60 Hz, Class 2 driver. LED cartridge with weatherproof quick disconnect provides ease of installation and serviceability. Ashbery ships prewired. Path Light Type 4 Path Light Type 5 Lar p o - ee XP -G2 LEDs I an p 19 Cree X= -G2 LEDs CCT: 3000K, 3500K, 4000K CCT: 300DK, 3500K. 4000K L70: >100,000 hrs L70: >100,000 hrs Drive Current: 350mA Drive Current: 350mA Optic: Khatod Collimators Optic: Khatod Collimators Lens: Diffused Acrylite" Lens: Diffused Acrylfte�' Power Supply: 10OV-277V Power Supply: 100V -277V LED Driver: TRP LED -12W LED Driver: TRP LED -20W BUG Rating: BO UO G1 BUG Rating: B1 UO 01 IP Rating: IP66 for LED Cartridge IP Rating: IP66 for LED Cartridge Weight: 30 Ibs Weight: 30 lbs Ashbery is a trio of lights that brings together advanced LED technology and optics with an homage to traditional -style lights that have a special place in the American lexicon. The pathway light is 3' tall, and is ideal for illuminating footpaths for safety and extended use. Cast aluminum parts in a full color palette are finished with Landscape Forms proprietary Pangard II® HAPS. VOC, lead-free polyester powdercoat. Ashbery Path Light Type 4 lighting facts Light Output (Lumens) 444 Watts 7.4 Lumens per Wall (Efficacy) 60 Col Accuracy 82 LED Lumen Malntenance Projeclion 96.11% at 60,000 Hour, at 25-C Ambient' Warranty Yes B•••a on TM21 propction• for en IIpM source. a•• www.11pMNppcnwMDroaun• Ior W i•In. Ashbery Path Light Type 5 D fighting facts Light Output {Lumens) 885 Watta 14.7 Lumens Der Watt (Efficacy) 60.2 Color Accuracy 82 LED L..n Malntenance Projection 96.11% .160,000 Hour. at 26`C Ambient' Warranty" Yes • 9—aon Twit prop—, Ior It, Ilabt•wru. See www.ogtur '._ convP-- for tlaulls. Max Intensity' 305.5 ca we ,bo p Ma, page 1 of 2 Landscape Forms, Inc. 1 800.521,2546 1 F 269.381.3455 1 7800 E. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI 49048 landsca ASHBERY PATH LIGHT Product Data Sheet Finish Pangard Ilm, offered exclusively by Landscape Forms, is a 19 step program of cleaning, priming, and powdercoating that resists rusting, chipping, peeling and fading to produce the finest metal finish available for site furniture and outdoor lighting. In addition, Pangard III contains no heavy metals and is free of Hazardous Air Pollutants. To Order Specify: Product, Lamp, Drive Current, Color Temperature, Input Voltage, Mounting Option, and Powdercoat Color, EXAMPLE: AP - 0061_4 - 035F - 35K - UV1 - SM - Powdercoat Color Product Modifications Don't see what you are looking for? Our goal. is to partner with you as the designer to manufacture solutions needed for the space you are creating. We offer the option to modify our standard product to meet certain design specifications or needs. Contact your local Landscape Forms representative to learn more about these offerings, Warranty LED lighting products are warranted for six years. Other UL Listed, RoHS Compliant, Dark -Sky Approved US patent Pending fighfiog cV� US RoHS facts 3 KUM warmer Ashbery is designed by Robert A.M. Stern Architects /m 244 3 mm 7/4„ 164 mm 36 3/4" 936 mm 1 Visit landscapefonns.com for more information. Specifications are subject to change without notice. Landscape Forms supports the Landscape Architecture Foundation at the Second Century level. 02017 Landscape Forms, Inc. Printed in U.S.A. page 2 of 2 rev. 01/2018 Landscape Forms, Inc. 1 800.521.2546 1 F 269.381.3455 1 7800 E. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI 49048 0061_4 40K (4000K) (6 LED, Type 4 ) AP ASHBERY 035E ( 350 mA) 35K (3500K) UV1 (100-277VAC) SM ( Surface Mount) 0121_5 ( 12 LED, Type 5) 30K (3000K) EXAMPLE: AP - 0061_4 - 035F - 35K - UV1 - SM - Powdercoat Color Product Modifications Don't see what you are looking for? Our goal. is to partner with you as the designer to manufacture solutions needed for the space you are creating. We offer the option to modify our standard product to meet certain design specifications or needs. Contact your local Landscape Forms representative to learn more about these offerings, Warranty LED lighting products are warranted for six years. Other UL Listed, RoHS Compliant, Dark -Sky Approved US patent Pending fighfiog cV� US RoHS facts 3 KUM warmer Ashbery is designed by Robert A.M. Stern Architects /m 244 3 mm 7/4„ 164 mm 36 3/4" 936 mm 1 Visit landscapefonns.com for more information. Specifications are subject to change without notice. Landscape Forms supports the Landscape Architecture Foundation at the Second Century level. 02017 Landscape Forms, Inc. Printed in U.S.A. page 2 of 2 rev. 01/2018 Landscape Forms, Inc. 1 800.521.2546 1 F 269.381.3455 1 7800 E. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI 49048 ASHBERY PEDESTRAN Product Data Sheet General Description • Available in single or double pole mounted configurations • Offered in 3 standard pole heights (12% 14', and 16') • Optional ANS1136.41 7 -pin twist lock receptacle • Mounting template and anchor hardware included • International Dark -Sky approved UL Listed, suitable for wet locations Electrical Surge protected 10OV-277V 50/60 Hz, Class 2 integrated dimmable driver. LED cartridge with weatherproof quick disconnect provides ease of installation and serviceab'lity. Ashbery ships prewired, Pedestrian Type 3 Lamp: 6 C,ee XHP50 LEDs CCT: 3000K, 3500K, 4000K L70: >100,000 hrs Drive Current: 1000mA Optic: Carclo Optics Lens: Diffused Acrylite6 Power Supply: 100V -277V LED Driver: TRP PLED -50W Dimmable: 0-10V BUG Rating: B1 U1 G1 IP Rating: IP66 for LED Cartridge Pedestrian Type 5 La' -p, 1 L Gee X=P50 LEDs CCT: 3000K, 3500K, 4000K L70: >100,000 hrs Drive Current: 1000mA Optic: Carclo Optics Lens: Diffused Acrylftel Power Supply: 100V -277V LED Driver: TRP PLED -96W Dimmable: 0-10V BUG Rating: B2 U1 G1 IP Rating: IP66 for LED Cartridge Ashbery is a trio of lights that brings together advanced LED technology and optics with an homage to traditional -style lights that have a special place in the American lexicon. The pedestrian light is offered in 12', 14', and 16' heights and Is ideal for campuses, parks and plazas, helping to create public spaces that are usable 24 hours a day, Options include single luminaires or a double -mount option for dual luminaires, one on either side of the pole. Patent -pending glare control requires less eye adaptation, enabling lower light levels and lower energy use with excellent visual acuity, while tenon -mounted luminaires can be retrofitted in the field. Cast aluminum parts in a full color palette are finished with Landscape Forms proprietary Pangard II® HAPS, VOC, lead-free polyester powdercoat. Ashbery Pedestrian Type 3 lighting facts - Light Output (Lumens) 2162 Watts 47 Lumens per Wall (EfOcacy) 46 Color Accuracy 84 93.29% LEO Lumen Mahltenance Projection at 36,000 Hours at 25"C Ambient' Warranty-" Yes Max lnle�siry i vanic.l Pia,,,. s - 26• Ashbery Pedestrian Type 5 lighting facts Light Output (Lumens) 4100 watts 82.5 Lumens per Watt (Efficacy) 49.7 Calor Accuracy cni 84 I LED Lumen Maintenance Projection 93.29% at 36.000 Hours at 26°C Ambient' Warranty'. Yes -21 PtaMctiens ror ua I,enl awru. 5e... ww.lgnlun2laeu eoMp,Muetx hr eau Me. page 1 of 4 Landscape Forms, Inc.1 800.521.2546 1 F 269.381.3455 1 7800 E. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI 49048 c + o v v� a; m z s _ mvm ED z ° I z R 6 cn El r ;u O 'n= m r 0 ^5 FN 0O p 3 a Z r Q D ,SARCHITECTURE MSA '°°°rtC5' 1M0� CORTNA III at e i N /�RCHITECTS ,,,__„r.ANCRO ,MLAaEgtGAN GRW�DEKLDCMEN i, LLC & PLANNING BOY TM BEACH, FLORIDA �rra.a�nu�„�s�a.c as �,a•ae;�,xm �-�vrrrawe....m....,.,-. �.,,...... �,,._�,.-.....a..-.. G) m (n 0 m m t's MSA coR,nmA m at BOYNTON VI LLAGE ARCHITECTS ARC V�Gm �p DEW FRONT ELEVATION - BUILDING TYPE I SIDE ELEVATION - BUILDING TYPE I I T, IF lei T:[ IR T- SIDE ELEVATION - BUILDING TYPE I KEY PLAN < U) COLOR VARIATION El 1:1 BUILDING TYPE.1 ELEVATIONS A -3.1.2A SF^ g? z L� aP a 6Sy' 3P k " MS/ \ BORIII A EOY PlTO ON �III � D 'ARCHITECTS "' . MORGAN GROUP DEVELOP REN i. LLC A aorto IT BOYNTON REACH. FLORIDA ARCHITECTURE & PLANNING r1 " MS/ \ BORIII A EOY PlTO ON �III � D 'ARCHITECTS "' . MORGAN GROUP DEVELOP REN i. LLC A aorto IT BOYNTON REACH. FLORIDA ARCHITECTURE & PLANNING c S c c m m w c r 0 z G) AT �s sZ q °�S Aw.Tcns. Mc. CORTINA III sa e a n P „ MS/ ` _'. "m•" XiXs ®®M6tlT® A�IiLAGE ,ARCHITECTS MORGAN GRODP DEVELOPMENT, LLC 80Y TON REAONf�FLM A ARCHITECTURE & PLANNING AVE 50 WIM S n "s'' D"T"s' "` V, ` ^� 040M � °� 6O TON III e! BOYPITOi�NILLAQEnRCHITECTS MORGAN MWO ODEWL LENT. ILC g ARCHITECTURE & PLANNING 80mTON SEAN. FLOA— r•em.r.. r.rw� r.. r.n .i sr — 'Q�3.`..:5a a94' --4%=4r ®�'Y'C�'M'.t7 g�u O 2� M x m m FF -< ` i;jp�97 aj 1( E �s .D.I`D O �� 1 t a A x,6� nnsn s ARCHITECTS'F IJTEC7LF-. t- PLANNING �....,_.,..,„'.d:.!•;73dA.'7r.;s.b",.Si••;r�.;'.?:'.=r.itttr ,�. CORTINA m .t ,y ®OVNYONyVILLAGE? MCRCAN MOUP OEVELDPMENT, LC BMT BE„CN, FLORIDA^•. ,.so GARAGE ELEVATION SIDE ELEVATION SIDE ELEVATION KEY PLAN COLOR VARIATION I TOWNHOUSE ELEVATIONS TH-3.1.2A 71 1- m 1 SA RFMI CIA CORTINA III at SOYNTOW VILLAGE '-040MARCHITECTS MORGAN GROUP DEVELOPMENT, LLC VOBOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA ARCHITIECTURF & PLANNING W . V&W,=y -n—OT Wmimriffl4k, am m Nm go z m 0 On m Z SA RFMI CIA CORTINA III at SOYNTOW VILLAGE '-040MARCHITECTS MORGAN GROUP DEVELOPMENT, LLC VOBOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA ARCHITIECTURF & PLANNING W . V&W,=y -n—OT Wmimriffl4k, DEVELOPMENT ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA PROJECT NAME: Boynton Village & Town Center (MPMD 18-002) APPLICANT'S AGENT: Joni Brinkman, Urban Design Kilday Studios AGENT'S ADDRESS: 610 Clematis Street, Suite CU02, West Palm Beach, FL 33401 DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: May 15, 2018 TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Master Plan Modification to the Boynton Village & Town Center development to amend the previous approvals for SMU Parcel 1 from 115 single-family homes to 378 apartments and 55 townhomes, while reducing the total number of the approved residential unit allotment within the entire master plan from 1,120 to 1,115. LOCATION OF PROPERTY: NE corner of Congress Avenue and Old Boynton Road DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO. THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applicant i---�AS HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit "D" with notation "Included". 4. The Appli�nt's application for relief is hereby 6 GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof. DENIED This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order. Other 1 �-w""` DATED: ty Clerk S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Boynton Village & Town Center\Master Plans\MPMD 18-002\DO.doc EXHIBIT "B" Conditions of Approval Project Name: Boynton Village & Town Center File number: MPMD 18-002 Reference: 2nd review plans identified as a Master Plan Modification with a March 13, 2018 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking. DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT ENGINEERING / PUBLIC WORKS / FORESTRY / UTILITIES Comments: None FIRE Comments: None POLICE Comments: None BUILDING DIVISION Comments: None PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: None PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: 1. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the application requests are publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04- 007 and Ordinance 05-004 and an affidavit provided to the City Clerk. X 2. Any changes to the Major Site Plan drawings as a result of staff comments shall be reflected on these pages as well. X 3. Applicants who wish to utilize City electronic media equipment for recommended PowerPoint presentations at the public hearings must notify the project manager in Planning and Zoning and submit a CD/thumb drive of the presentation at least one week prior to the scheduled meeting. X Boynton Village & Town Center (MPMD 18-002) Conditions of Approval Pane 2 of DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Comments: N/A PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS Comments: None CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS Comments: To be determined. S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Boynton Village & Town Center\Master Plan\MPMD 18-002\COA post P&D.doc EXHIBIT A BOYNTON VILLAGE AND TOWN CENTER (MPMO) t 15'f k ' "M Cortina Blvd A., c Sagrada'Ave 7-i 0 0 VLO nit 0, as c 0 z IF 41Z1 jj� : _NW 13tl Averr * Is A Cabrera Dr 4 j Montoro Way, 0 Z IL Balerdi Way Cortina Blvd 'u -M A -J T77 pvt q N Yf, Old Boynton Rcl,. K P k— N 062.525 250 375— 500 77770"14149? of VICINITY MAP: I T / B7 JV6 ARCHITECT, LLC BOYNTON VILLAGE MASTER PLAN & MINOR SITE MODIFICATION _ BUILDING "L" SMU PARCEL 7 1100 CONGRESS AVENUE BOYNTON BEACH, FL 33426 — nccE--- / O auT o PLAN PROJECT TEAM: TENANT LOCATION: ARCHITECT: JVB ARCHITECT LLC ---' —- — """- SHEETINOEX x ` . 2 z i <PROJECT SCOPE OF WORK' m � / F - ��m_m I E io"x611 MASTER PLAN NNiREH AVfxJE EEreE xuuMP x 1 95 g SITE Congress Ave. ��p_� Site LDntion Map] i u 0 m SMU - PN 3 (B.W. Tred IPi 0.253 W q 4 , 000�V01 I AiSSANCE COMMONS '❑ y �J4 —777777,7 1 I ' _ L f\..: •.. i _ SMU P.,er6el� l Mxen Ud 426 Ad PNa.1PNB6e 1 PNase l CONGRESS AVENUE SMU -PaaW SMU-Par.IT SMU-P1rcel6 M8.6 U. MI4o6 U. MIrcE lko 1.170Ac. 1,414 AG.-- 1583 Ac. Usable Open Space Calculations (SMU Zoning) PARCEL AREA(ac) P '142 MuPem451ay 10.0 P-1 4 3Mux Femay-5 Slay PI 10245 ( 6 P4--81) Parwl 16 -Muetl Use 115. /23 P—:,Moen Uae 383 Pete X 1- M.eO Use PP -1 46 Mx. Uae + 414 1.1n1 Perk PP -1(.n-- v Op. Spa4e) 2.828 Lake Pawe A 8 B (G— A—) 2,08+ B ON VILLAGE PARCEL 1 ADJACENT I e u+u uow el PARCEL1 LAKE G. AC. TOTAL 20.542 2081 22.832 R n —d, 0 Spew W 3050 d TWAT Ib b H ttl (M 5091d Open SD ) 8.162 3081 D.824 a.186 0.312 3383 Requ ren 15 — Open SPm (Mn S , 01 Req. Open Sped) 3.061 0312 3383 Prpvlae Open Specs EM 8113 1301 8.920 ,—. 11 — mn. Open spate HN 4313 0 4,243 BOYNTON VILLAGE PARCELS 2,3 (6 4),5 1au 8 PARCELS PARCELS IMc'�xc 4or1c8rG CR[LN MVA 4RtM IM¢AI 2A3(M) 5.6,7,88 TOTAL Ala 21.183 18.58 "M Requren U-1, Open SPo a® dTe [el. 4.861 3A18 8.875 P—.. Usable Open Spew `aM 6.818. 3120. 9.239. • NO CHANGESTO PROVIDED ® OPEN SPACE um m 2m ncrrviC SG�._L 1-=1110 . --- ..�r _R _I.� � e � §■�L7° U ��a_ems 33426 < /till'. - ©- / .. :_:.. �.. . --- ..�r _R _I.� � e � §■�L7° U ��a_ems 33426 {tP Boynton Village ia,1I 3€ SMU & C3 F, 'Po Boynton Beach, Florida P�13za gpPa 7 Master Plan S@e Location Map 4® Usable Open Space Calculations (SMU Zoning) PARCEL AR ) P.—t-TrnMwmn-2 SIwy6 OAhC1- S4.rN—V-4-,, PercNN 2-MJli SSt Family -1 Story 1.100 Pcw N3 MJLi Family - 10118 (i Wl. Parcel N d eM Trect RI)) Parcel N 2-Muetl Use I— P arcel N 6- Uce 1.683 Pew N V— u" u1. Paw# 8-Mi.etl the 1.1. PoM-1IW-nwed hr OWn Space) 2,BZ8 LeFe Pow A(Gram A—) tAB3 ROVMON VBIA(iE PARCEL 1 .—E. cxGLWirvc A-1 A-111— PARCELI LAKE G. AC AJ—.—OWn SWm®308vdT—) 8.183 OM2 8.838 Alloxe6k NmdewWlMe1. 60%dOp8n8PNs) 3.083 0.313 3.311 Prodtletl 1.—OWn Specs= ® 8.W2 1.183 8.388 --N VILLAGE PARCELS 3,3((1) 58 8 PARCELS PM LS 8 283(&4) 6, 8, T.BH TOTAL A— 21.]83 18.68 11.1. Req Usele Open SPH. W 3O6 dTpd ars I.O2T 3A18 B.BT6 Provided L-. Open Spew® 2.810- 3.820ec 8138 - w a 0C Q: C yL CL, — d) cU " 008 �= a a! O� r» co (0 .i NORTH YIT 1.95 SITE 17 site Location Map Master Site Plan Parcel Data —TER — PWft A—D 1AE gqo" ...I 17 DEVELOPMENT ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA PROJECT NAME: Quantum Lake Villas West — Lot 52 Quantum Park (MSPM 17-001) APPLICANT: John Lyon, Olen Properties APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 1062 Coral Ridge Drive, Coral Springs, FL 33071 DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: May 15, 2018 APPROVAL SOUGHT: Request for Major Site Plan Modification approval to construct 104 Multi -family rental units and associated recreational amenities and site improvements, as well as a request for four (4) setback waivers, in the PID (Planned Industrial Development) zoning district. LOCATION OF PROPERTY: SE corner of Gateway Boulevard and Park Ridge Boulevard (Lot 52 Quantum Park). DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO. THIS MATTER was presented to the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the approval sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: 1. Application for the approval sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applicant HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the approval requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit "D" with notation "Included." 4. The Applicaos request is hereby 1 -'GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 above. DENIED 5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order. �/ 7. Other: 41 DATED:�d- ity Clerk G S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Quantum Lot 52\ MSPM17-00100.doc EXHIBIT "D" Conditions of Approval Project Name: Quantum Lake Villas West (Lot 52) File number: MSPM 17-001 Reference: 3 I review plans identified as a Maior Site Plan Modification with an April 24, 2017 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking. DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT ENGINEERING / PUBLIC WORKS / FORESTRY / UTILITIES Comments: 1. Please depict drive dimensions and use a type "F" curb. X 2. Please provide drainage calculations. X FIRE Comments: 3. Please apply for, and provide a flow test conducted by Boynton Beach Fire Rescue, Fire & Life Safety. X 4. Please provide fire flow calculations in accordance with the Chapter 18 of the 2012 edition of NFPA 1. X POLICE Comments: None, all previous comments addressed at DART meeting. X BUILDING DIVISION Comments: None, all previous comments addressed at DART meeting. X PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: 5. Per City Ordinance, the Park Impact Fee is $61,880 (104 units x $595) X PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: Quantum Lake Villas West — Lot 52 (MSPM 17-001) Conditions of Approval Pape 2 of 2 F- DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE REJECT 6. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the application X requests are publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04- 007 and Ordinance 05-004 and an affidavit provided to the City Clerk. 7. Please provide a copy of Palm Beach County School District X concurrency approval letter. 8. Please revise the landscape design and planting scheme to match X the previous approval in the area from the north terminus of the hedge on the west side of Building 4, around the corner, to the walkway along the west side of Building 1. 9. Approval of the Site Plan is subject to Commission approval of the X four (4) setback waivers. 10. At time of permit submittal please submit a Unity of Title agreement X or some other form of documentation satisfactory to the City Attorney, ensuring the continued shared use of the recreational amenities at the Villas of Quantum Lakes in perpetuity by the residents of this development. 11. Applicants who wish to utilize City electronic media equipment for X recommended PowerPoint presentations at the public hearings must notify the project manager in Planning and Zoning and submit a CD of the presentation at least one week prior to the scheduled meeting. COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Comments: N/A PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS Comments: 12. Please add up to two (2) handicap parking spaces, preferably one X (1) each at those buildings with only one (1) handicap space proposed, without reducing the total parking count below the code minimum requirement. CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS Comments: To be determined. S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Quantum Lot 52 \MSPM 17-001\COA post P&D.doc EXHIBIT A LOCATION MAP LEG D w tie 'b O IF ��401H �-' <a;: �'/`` • '�"•` n�� Ridge B��d � �� � � � � a`' � • � � park � � .. °. °°.� , ..._, _ t F— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — TABLE 503 SECTION .vw¢ l- . =-- NW AVE NUE 22ND � I SITE DATA ffi F I I o. Site Plan —S L— — — — — — — — ,. wbr•ale n da.a, m bw•w.Wtl Ess maw�a«n °io. e..radve RI«INn •aa«n•anw.a.wa u mmmdme a� ifyoll«�M bPup�G ro d and-M� ar dnp ttslvalM+W p� «a als IM Pualwsbs•iabW W b a s rw W. a d �Wa.,wr b w.. Xr.lnaar. s. �paoapalaaa.v panda,caewom�l�aysmeroamola�.+n. ��mlw oar oaroaalb Ilm �"'� p.e. aan. Nvv.na roaaa.lde poaa «wwl apmda IwsaaW da.aM,wn ). NdlxrnbnwkpdruM'Mplb woahb SWbo��•dmen�o6 N6eo bllW NorAmVo� KNOVN NOTFi 1. NaeeYbb=o.epMoeonMeleNmrowEM1an Rs9le. 1 AW dal a+lada Mr dnw:Apd b nnrna0 p Wl a mmrwb laalaa Rle iaanMl rl rsx pw apax Roolryuemdnaa er a a nWWa.na u o.pn «e e a roa mea>«ow xdn�c l veewvNPaNns rnu lE xaAVEon,xEcov>:pa+c rwrr rumuortvuun:nncam iop xaaawelunwoeva. AUNR»saa PERNa NlUIC9fpO11NDMYlIp,Il4l9E It%sIFD PpOP TO CdaaFNCNG,aN WOHON ME,rtE re RfdM uW. PROJECT NOR ALLANIBRNS ON SIZE NO! INDIGrEO t0 BE REdOV®qt RELOCATED SMNL REAVN. SFf SNffTl2 Ll l U FOR RElO(.YIfOAMIBWL LOCwMY1S. EMTWG TREE ASSESSMENT TABLE Tae N9asl � pRRolpzn ] Owcd VYRNIVW LNaOa Rae ITCapa Rebrdrf a pwcdvlylRrW uw oaRrde izCnyv ee�wwlowa oaeF.avERE+awu.eodT= lcrya a,�a "�n"au`"..�m`do Ilea Rasa, a�.aa —arT— Ic� TT. 10 -0-- ooaay. vlaaaab, IN.od,d. c� tala TT. Rana) i, snag a/a,w•ran PpRonal T. swad�«p�p«a/w.aadR ruo> a.wxa.a Is snw daw®noq/ao.a•roEn I, cora roY 16 sTa9r ��o/al..lraa Izcr�a /Qda�pan ccaya buonalae i1 Tbab.9 Fl— Ilcma%T- 11 bµada/Poi= 16Cc� YPNrw�C b.a PoT= ! draT..— C.— °" : ° w ` C a � N g b a NdPoT= CnyaRa a y F. T. Podaa Po - ry;rt ucolr. T. m Isb«a wwammaa,rde 'cars To xIWR�bw sic a,r�ml is : ro r�i.lma.a n InaroanaWwmcJWa.�Pda stay., mRema, a, uel«aw-•ucl+®b,raa r�aa ram as u.xl«a apamv�+lad,d,com sc I ,o 31 Iw'p«��n ntiw+��PnEn r „ mebml0. eo plpaEn lrc ion b aw�aoMmn/rL RnsplPdn I coca �/a RadPdn Ilcdpa io Rasa, /a RnraPaa llcar. ,o RaWal � N�a aenp�dN/Po,= IrCdba mMnanwea Ncus F. Capr iomea,w•.a'a ta��oea"papdPo,= uCacopaya ,n9aemp..e Rar>,anea�/SR«pPdR ,r`npa �o tea. a Fl �RPoRgdrdn Xr CatN tl ryt= u�C""11 gl bla, a_RoW pian ;SSCaUa la 9allal OacryNaa r."e4reE�a'e4aa Onle P-- eM,br•M, s, uacNran. a,atooyNapa ool. pdM,AL 1l CCarapa I w Wa lNaoovaleaoa One.PaRn.AL rCa io Ra.a� /ILwdw* iscroa m� v «o'«enroT�'.. ire iob..•p..a L Poi= IPCapa Ta YRenlv.al m oa�pnaW Poi= Ir Ca4a Tr 4�Rarouaa u�,s"«W� �e«.xl.•a.la�rda rcara dwwKllEd.�,Paa TT:aP. ," R wan,rt.RoaPap Csp- lu,ate d+w.,cNe..Is roln zM ,a o � bn Oar! ISCr�a ,RaM Cfya b.Wrl�uti � Mn•a/CNed bnpdn CCapa fa lbndn Rpaawo elnla/R.Yga pan ISCaya TaMM Agawmw ansa/R. Ronlpdm SCapa www/cra,=Ia,ran rcapa rorrlwaa I+waal-wm/n. ¢oclPaa rCoq To � n u.:r«a ndww/cdld.Ia•ran zcaya 71 u+bwa a�d,w/oA®�paR zcava Raom.a Rgslanm aad/0. Rap Pdn rCapa b0.elooaaa pramew dm/P. Roplpar� rCalpa )! �EeNarYw/fjt,= Il Caps La ae RanwvO n ,va aM�MrnM•AcmH - 4 — r�OsyonYNfy,= PCrp'oNllencreE 81 pucwT/9wgba9 CbrYalw TC�r RSIOI B�bucaaYYiparbpr OlPPk Wa a'CaAvar IO RwIVN �,lion/bW aRCJ[atd rCdpv Te Mndn b RaRrbaY alraara !cryo Toanm �buceraY 4ioRF bay Elrck Ws !Gaya Telhpro9l y OresnJ SNORy bar OrcEaNa a'Cn,pr to RaraJl �txlcaat/9,oRr Wyolo=toles SCapa TORpcF Y Guam bway SlwCynp anclrM1aa a•Cayr TOA�'wbmrl b NKLbauwoY RaJr baF HTCErMs PCcyar 91 ♦ JoatlgAolaMV Ac b PC�r bYYnlwvO �m �•' )• Y- v' v Y -- a(/ ..I-.R_�i► apuYw � .pammf slam 1� \ By vi liesAW OW convnw& 6 lE DARTCpMw16 R) VIAMPWACh C)dMDOUW&& tF oe ®w - T i O= .E v s 06N CL m¢� 0W � V Z�< / 0� i \�` NJ NO J s[, O / BLDG m i O= .E v s 06N CL / � V / C o i \�` NJ O NOM QN.Ci. / / i KII.D 1•-eva O111.IT / E7d6W-OWRIOm Plan a 8 ren MATP cBFoulz air kev mlpJca"ane/common name 54 pmvs WasML ss Crop VaM1aRo raarnaomerype/nlonlaonrerY Pan 16T?oc.amla. M.oabs ❑ ❑ Cor 9 CrrrsamMmoWearrre/metra nr wt6u M.oa YCeprsrAA m m Cal'rcbr/Gsn Croy punomom br Carocapearxleeeaa/rAV Gnlarm]Yee 1—. .YCalpra r I6YJo.al GlpsO(AG. m m )3 M > $y�W/^rn macubaRn lgpFraa/easlbmaeae dc IDW ama.YCapr ❑ m ❑ m bi' om—aea/oF/MRaaaen M1ory3ee 14acolo. BE m CdA CfY Carlo eaMa/aaaepelprtm codammtm/Yalbe aeN.Ree Ibde.l CaypvelAG IbYI.l CdbrerAG. m m m m rMdY b Ps+ avaa.ealrrorrn/Ile aavea relocaea Plyawsprrmabape/Nmmrpan >]-258.oa.. rebrdad Ia18M1.panrlaa. m ❑ m ❑ le Sm IB erp $amlPam Raraeneb mpdglmmbrM lnuawspam SN Ptra I?1M.aa.MynM m ❑ m ❑ m -v s Yme re.aa aarea/v pada.. ibauaM1ra Gpb reap. mysb. lo -s?a.•a oa.,ra.ul.m car m ❑ m ❑ ems 3 exam wwa/smdybdraa:aa RYomrd ❑ BE RepR' caaa Rgelorcaebla"RgapYn sraarolamr®mma/a..n can Reloeaea Rweaaaa m ❑ m ❑ 3 Iae ualr;p u.w,ava+refa gree R.lawee ❑ ❑ 311 Gr floe mlvrcapo/Geon Yam IralSr 3aalroc m m )13 Wa' Homefo palm Onl./aM. aepmr Ira) 3aa]Pac m m e� n,w„n avtrb/o..r. a;araae. oar PorypodsmsmP./Wan len Iralr3aalrac IPar saalToc m m m m T.O ia' xgaam..Rroae/srpasbpp.r 11eya6aoa/Teaw nrbr azlraxa?o� Lxalr]e.aTac m m m m s Q SN v• CKrmoaauiw/CocapPn xa]P3a.a Tac m m nears inplaawnaachtolder/mliYula pb/wayupepperlea XaeP3a.a?ee oaxalr3a.a3roe m ❑ m m - o rpbao/scow len nappai Serpa napper lralrsa.a?a� Xa]r3a.aTae ❑ m m m "a' /rm.r wrw�mn Goa asr3aelrpY. iralr3aalroa ❑ m ❑ m 2a Go Ila ca>• Spamoplolroamlo/Daum utlie cwPa wnaep/sraaletl aro, Ira IT$alroc uu>aevp� ❑ m m m ahty++oawm rorrrx len nwrla. pr slWro.waeWr w.xr n G.'Mwe Grade `a'pwroae��m aa'°'d.lall"lar` sodsadrbralpn a "ane po,1 rmada pea. wiv��.e.1r.a, roc dawnar,a a prmr.b p,ro. a n.ra»d. p. ra a. rwmad.a. NOTE: AN Landscape WBRin Sight Triartans Shall Protide lMohshucted tress-vislbBty At A Horizontal Level Belvreert 30 4srhes And B Peet hdudkq Trunks From Pavement. Note: All Above Ground Mechanical Equipment Such As, But Not Limited To, Exterior Utility Boxes. Meters, And Transformers Shall Be Depicted On All Plans And Shall Be Visually Saeened. Backflow Preventers Shall Be Painted To Match Principle Structure. Now. 875 cu.yds. (+/-) Clean brown sand, as code requ✓ed Uo kfll for of landscape areas Isee ell rote). Catroctor sloe way the quantity of HI required to complete it a oak in accordance wIM Sect 17.8 & C of the Code. Tran rro.r landeaaa. AnaFill Note Cmun laaRma Shtubs Al ksroscolse r sYol pa excavated 1? below hd9rad gads and backaled w clean tor— sand m to the elkhed grade. This Work If regayed to be lr sp ted by the City of Bomton Beach Forest, per sec 17.8 & C. Cross Section ' C -C" e aealld TMk Palm Amampmapa—e—roprobe1� raabaroRessoa.van loosawnm �Mn a poaasamae pbsas. pm lab .SmCltWaau aabb eepaalm. war mpo. b w eetPlo m a mww ha sava�oaoevalas n.vso ISRAw,t r F.�SPwserls _. _ oe�l� mow�uew o¢i1. al. a e.nr. a. e. n. bYepamnan. ode. a sramnPayeac loom nwtrla w a F. ran, am row p.awaP.dw ar 1am..me wawa. . w dal mama owl m e.r. ro roles l Ret. m pern.Gadea slpmpo.Iwan maelawa:nx m 3. a,a�rn;����aa lxabadpwm �mimardnmepmab mpwla.arer.mea.r mearee wnn roal b1. p.rera:. o.rm. aanrolrrme. spacib a m. Coale m.enwe x mom . auawro oro.,, an m. lemma earaxe a. ro x dee p a woes.. m. .m:<.,w ��;��-;«ma ee rrommlaam. «n,pwa+m.. so.omM1. plp.b. ppawa bb nSad nlvpuyvr ropenrer. ase vm.lroel ala M tYaw wAn a n V aaxn or e" a em a aanan a ma em.swap. clprnaaa.aapasmlmmasd Mnam..npnalrrmamnaraea ler. edam a,masara x eaareMn a rane.aaYa pore mrwae sop m. bpa•an. roto easaa 6. r.'swaRla. repo. isles rna q amisa ba pa+erp. prnmxocwroreoomrrrblva wpa9rm . •npmam•roasa rg1o51 araaap b aa' -"ro ,paw l sstl-aa aw.a.prrrwmve a para nor pe n.rAed wet a 3n. aa,.lraa,. riamemaetln PSlxa+ta oeaxn eoaA ct. � eepm, n.,u, upon rorrlrmn apmma raa�. roan ret sxamRr.r gpaeeeya rn rl+tss rYeB sow ore mem w � Prodsel. e,a pia+. nor a aanm a m r.ee Mbn may.,.. pewraY aaa slew ore roeR. p. r a ppe.d an. aeweam av Wad rpa:n... raebe..m. a Ya.m. xmrr++ra�m xpmbeepMb .roux me nava va+8� Im1 a xr pbn. I Al ore ralewh friars aolee ons pim11';a m a b rsnma a a palet m rmlerlri ore Mro ler Hopson w bereaM1a a epasd. Cweracly f H o� Ivaer,�w ro��Yaerlpyye6MPuitle alae ap{ra'1 arCn evl mvlabtlanra; maem a nae h a wrbni panni may. me apreaaprba. para a aMc su 4 pmrrrea a me orlon a Xre Rrrmmpp a mnlmclrt. etre pl Mara reP.ed A' dab. Na,ew. ne trme4. mnhaap M he ramarvor braaee3lpaarema.a sM1alpm lrr emgr en wears peam. n be eves rima ra vet alrn��asm� nde�sad.ran<d. m.b,m�pe conhMUYrl ro�xn.brroprrd.. I , wY aeaem. set Rra x au^ se. YeertweHmle]. uAYee tl macwa.a. pep., riratlan sarcrle sea bnlrrarpl ro row., a a mro a Ile. pr Imaan_sm k b M valred b a mina renretloley airtmaakll. Godo ore roperakeC moos, aM alert rmbvee.pbbtelapYon 1 Nkes'i plmr • aarxmcoverr e;all m wvmreeab a pab0 a ITldavadapanwla o pN oro ra. atrb. ma of wlaml sanwna. Pmrra.orm a aaaweo granas w a masianea. m sra-rvleaw. reronRrwmolbre. w a arar. d p.m a �. sad mawemrce poops rice boraces r.uaew a eenbd mrepcnpn a me p1p. maaamirratrcaemneoarx;a repam mawbemm nn ore ro preR arnsen enbro arY. °I rolirwaed YlpelmacaeaHma. is:u,a�e..a:� �a•a Raned earls. paarom.lpmba.mr.apbr�mra.wl cross Section "&8" Notes & Details REVtSK)HS BY 18117 Pit A h& SIB Cflorl(pL TE Carrrllene 18117 PelA1M 6 gleCtwpe& TE CorlyneM J LL U U 0 a) an C _O C O N m C Q CIL C O O n N O y pT O E E ad > a N o o U (p7J C O S O NJ Dela.'. dna) )roe oan.n L-5 8 ®, r- _ - Building Type 1: Side Elevation im.3a n arge reezeway nlarged Loggia/Balcony —v p �. IIIIIIIIII p . IMM \M e �- p 6 p m p O III) I�III�III I I VIII \ p ' Building Type 1: Side Elevation im.3a n arge reezeway nlarged Loggia/Balcony a � m !' IcI .yIWI p p� IIIIIIIIIIIIII 1111111111 IIIIIIIilk ° Ilolulllll�`uuuolalb` m IIIIIIIIII hl I Mod I�ii —L ;Ni s m ■11IM-1.1 L11 ■INGII O p u m 0 0 m p O ° v o� ISI I ...... ml ■ ■ ON W .z Q BUILDING j..� TVPE2 ELEVATIONS U A -6j — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -- 0 'llllllllllllll��� ■' 0 m 0 3�W co o N CD Et! 12 ) n 0 w 3 m a) ID a CL ILL CL 0 ED F! v 0 lu INS 2i z MCI 0* 1 It M, , 1 Nil Iilllllllllllllll i�� NIS i IM co W :Ab3g - 9 oti�l�,: cn SIB o 4i 11 All, JR Ln (D 0 (D 0� 0 v 'o 91 04, 040 SECURED HOLDINGS, INC. ¢' 400 QUANTUM LAKES Wmom ORIDA 130YNTON BEACH, FL Z QVA�IL.�SD�IDI IrWmRan I IONE3 V ICHIiEtT � I W ---- Patio/Balcony) Patio/Balcony NAC ---- I 1. Bedroom 2 OaU ❑ ljBedroom �i ng Master '1. I #3 �,.. �e YVi7 z Q �F a! 4 Meste B N o m W i y 1 j _ ._1 wiG nm b ..w Dnng d" W — z I Unit "A" 1 Bedroom/ 1 Bath Unit"B" 2 Bedroom/ 2 Bath M=1,.,.,o,,,,..,,,,,.. SCALL I/4"=1'd1" wen.a.wwo.,oe.w�. w.'"'� SCALE. I/4"=I'-f)• r.omm.+wo-wnoww.o-.. O _ r,V: AREA CALCULATIONS AREA CALCULATIONS H) UNIT PLANS Uu A-10 4 ----------- NW — NW 22ND AVENUE Kv 111 _ • n`�� 111 1 ..uae i1 f LjFI (/ '7 wa inrrma o m `u�'a _ o I 1 � PAVING 6 AMKF tEGFND S i — �'S• t® " [rr i ��- � „�7 R i "'"' ��✓ ."_ry{r I� �`� '®'i�,v.% _—.—�'�'_ Y// 11111 ®m1°AlmmN..JMEV Y/�� ` St^'Wl �••--,_:;9d' \ I �"m iwM p ./"'. rw nuruesnx mm GGB F.M.ry v.rr2 {xg 1 x"lrys ww unx,vi a m>... m,w�aau.,mm 12-0325 Ma o o xa 1 _ _ --- i�-(�' xva„em yr � �°wx 1111 , _ t-_ __� _ +& ('� �.:�« •'�Aa,- +..w� vx ciu az".'s �nYw acpumore mam mvowaama LL 2 13 wa.ave,c,� 22ND AVENUE ,6 4 w o C� T yrna:a�aaau. Jam^ �•• FEE�,, i • l,�.r///����ii.�� i�=.,.,.�ri�� .yam . � � ��,, WATER LEGEND ------------------------ SECURED HOLDINGS, INC. 2400 QUANTUM LAKES DRIVE BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA mummu uuuuuuu 0-11N BEA('11— -II 1P,11 11-1,A, 1P,1D .JONES -A, IR -r IF- <-- -r U JPjF- uuuuuuu uuuuuum SECURED HOLDINGS, INC. 2400 QUANTUM LAKES DRIVE BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA 0-11N BEA('11— -II 1P,11 11-1,A, 1P,1D .JONES -A, IR -r IF- <-- -r U JPjF- EXHIBIT C 01,--_ N March 16, 2018 Mr. Edgar Breese, Principal Planner, BreeseE@bbfl.us City of Boynton Beach Planning &Zoning 100 E. Boynton Beach Boulevard Boynton Beach, FL 33435-0310 RE: Justification for Setback Waiver Quantum Lake Villas West aka Lot 52 2400 Quantum Lakes Drive, Boynton Beach, FL 33426 Dear Mr. Breese, There are two areas of setback waivers for this project. The first is a waiver to reduce the set back to 7 feet along the Lake frontage. There is an approximately 15 - 20 feet of flat area from the buildings to the top of the lake bank. This area has an existing Landscape buffer that will remain. This area also will be subject to a 10 and 12 foot construction easement for buildability of the project and when done will be appropriately landscaped. See the submitted Landscape plans. This nicely landscaped area will not only be an attractive view but has potential as a place for recreational uses. The second waiver is to reduce the street set back to 15 feet. This is in keeping with what has been previously approved throughout the Quantum Park Development. A good example is the Quantum Lake Villas that are located one lot away for this project (please see reference photos I & 2). The building Architecture is well done and attractive, it too is similar if not identical to other projects that have been approved in the Development. Shrubs have been added to the landscape plans along the street and with mid-level flowering trees. These new plantings are intended to work with the existing oak and black olive trees along the roadway to provide sufficient landscaping to screen the buildings. Note that the landscape architect worked with FPL to assure that any and all plantings proposed for the utility easement meet the requirements of FPL. Thank you again for your consideration of our request. If you would like to discuss the subject further, I am available at your convenience via e-mail at jlyona,olenpropeerties.com or by phone at (561) 531-1268. Sincerely, u Lyon [ENT CORP. Director of Construction, FL. Region 1062 Coral Ridge Dr. * Coral Springs, FL. 33071 (561) 531-1268 %vNv-%%,.olenproperties.com Alm �} � � }SiK I Y LC• __� .:•..,: _ .-mss."". S �..i %� L , e The Palm Beach Post I Sunday, May 13, 2018 Local Delivery questions? 800-926-7678 1 Content questions? 561-820-4441 for Editor Nick Moschella JUPITER BEACH CONSERVATION 2018 COMING MONDAY WELLINGTON ATTEMPTING TO STAY RELEVANT TO YOUNG FAMILIES Jupiter activist proposes ban on plastic straws aVF. OML%_I1L u1 Q1LJ V111111d11LC LUPI OlLeCL Lne ocean, turtles that die from consuming plastic waste. By Sarah Elsesser Palm Beach Post Staff Writer JUPITER — Twenty-four neat lines of colorful plastic shards cover a table at the Loggerhead Marinelife Center. These piles are no more than a couple inches long, but they aren't a random collection. Each represents the amount of plastic swallowed by one of 24 sea turtle hatchlings, a diet that proved fatal. These 24 were a small percent- age of the dead, or nearly dead, hatchlings brought to the Log- gerhead Center in Juno Beach last year and all had one thing in common — plastic -filled intes- tinal tracts. "There is no way of know- ing how many hatchlings die a year because of plastic," said Dr. Charles Manire, Loggerhead's director of research and reha- bilitation. "We just see the ones that wash up on the beaches." The hatchlings swallow plas- tic, perhaps mistaking it for food, and can't pass it because their bodies are too tiny. So the plas- tic blocks their intestinal tracts and they die. "The only way to curb this crisis is to pass legislation, which pro- hibits single -use plastics," said Jupiter resident Marilu Cristina Flores, who has drafted an ordi- Plastic continued on B2 These micro -plastic pieces were pulled out of sea turtle hatchlings' intestinal tracks. Jupiter resident Marilu Cristina Flores is seeking a ban on plastic straws. CONTRIBUTED BY THE LOGGERHEAD MARINELIFE CENTER L L. Plastic continued from Bl nance to ban plastic straws in Jupiter. The proposed ordinance would prohibit businesses from giving out single -use plastic straws to its patrons and discourage the "auto - straw" practice of automati- cally distributing a straw with every drink. Under the pro- posal, businesses would pro- vide only straws made from such materials as biodegrad- able paper, glass, bamboo and stainless steel, when asked. "We aren't telling people they can't have a straw," said Flores. "We are just saying no to the single -use plas- tic ones." Flores was inspired to bring the straw ban to Jupi- ter after seeing a similar one approved in Miami Beach and volunteering with the Surf Rider foundation, an organization that brings awareness to issues facing the ocean. "I realized that every beach has a lot of plastic," said Flores, who has trav- eled throughout the Carib- bean and Hawaii to study the effects of marine debris and pollution. "Other communi- ties have started to tackle this issue like Miami Beach, Fort Myers, Seattle and San Francisco." On the last Earth Day, 42 restaurants and businesses from West Palm Beach to Tequesta got a taste of the straw -free life. They part- nered with the Logger- head Center for the #Straw- FreeWithLMC day and an estimated 10,000 straws remained unused. "Our customers were really supportive," said"Pizza Girls' manager, George Poole. ,i was really impressed that so many people knew about (the straw -free day.)" The Corner Cafe in Tequesta also had recep- tive customers and its man- ager, Barry Rosenfield, liked the project so much that he made a permanent change. "We no longer do auto - straw," said Rosenfield. "You'd be surprised by how little people ask for straws. We loved this idea and would like to do more." Marilu Cristina Flores is ✓" " targeting single -use straws. But for Rosenfield the cost of alternatives to plas- tic straws is what's stopping him from switching. "It's just not cost-efficient for a busi- ness," said Rosenfield. Flores is aware that plas- tic straws cost about five to 10 cents each compared to some paper straw brands that are between 80 and 90 cents each. However, she said there are affordable options like the Aardvark paper straw that is only a cent more than a plastic straw. The Breakers in Palm Beach has already made the switch to Aardvark paper straws and eliminated plastic water bottles as just some of its green initiatives, accord- ing to Bonnie Reuben, mar- keting and communications manager for The Breakers. "There is a lot of misin- formation out there," said Flores, which is why she wants to hold an educa- tional expo for businesses and restaurants if the ordi- nance passes. Flores said she hasn't met opposition from peo- ple about the ban and after she presented the ordinance to the town's beach com- mittee, members were in favor of it. "We are always in favor of eliminating... plastic pol- lution in our oceans," said Betsy Munson, vice -chair of the beach committee. The committee plans to have a second meeting about the proposed ordi- nance before presenting it to the town council. The earliest that would happen is late June, Munson said. "The presentation that (Flores) gave was very infor- mative and interesting," said Munson. "We just need some more research." It was research the Log- gerhead Center said led to the straw -free Earth Day. "We are just starting to understand the scope of things," Manire said. The center saved 991 hatchlings in 2017, but nearly every one had plastic in their intestines, which is what doctors were sadly expecting, he said. "Twenty-five years ago we saw this happening occasion- ally, but now it's happening too frequently," said Manire. "The long-term effect of the plastic is scary to think about because if these hatchlings keep dying we could lose a generation of sea turtles." selsesser@pbpost.com l TOP TEN MARINE DEBRIS ITEMS NUMBER OF PERCENTAGE OF RANK DEBRIS ITEM DEBRIS ITEMS TOTAL DEBRIS ITEMS 1 CIGARETTES/CIGARETTE FILTERS 2,189,252 21% 2 BAGS (PLASTIC) 1,126,774 11% 3 FOOD WRAPPERS/CONTAINERS 943,233 -9% 4 CAPS, LIDS 912,246 9% 5 BEVERAGE BOTTLES (PLASTIC) 883,737 9% 6 CUPS, PLATES, FORKS, KNIVES, SPOONS 512,517 5% 7 BEVERAGE BOTTLES (GLASS) 459,531 k 4 4% i BEVERAGE CANS 4$7,631 4% 9 STRAWS, STIRRERS 412,940 4% 10 BAGS (PAPER) 331,476 3% TOP TEN TOTAL DEBRIS ITEMS 8,229,337 80010 TOTAL DEBRIS ITEMS WORLDWIDE 10,239,538 1000/0 `s i V't ��.1� • HOW LONG DOES IT TAKE TO BREAK DOWN? PAPER TOWEL 2 to 4 weeks CIGARETTE BUTT 10 to 12 years BANANA PEEL 3 to 4 weeks LEATHER SHOE 25 to 40 years PAPER BAG 1 month TINNED STEEL CAN 50 years NEWSPAPER 1,5 months FOAMED PLASTIC CUP 50 years APPLE CORE 2 months RUBBER BOOT SOLE 50 to 80 years CARDBOARD 2 months PLASTIC CONTAINER 50 to 80 years COTTON GLOVE 3 months ALUMINUM CAN 200 to 500 years ORANGE PEELS 6 months PLASTIC BOTTLE 450 years PLYWOOD 1 to 3 years DISPOSABLE DIAPER 550 years WOOL SOCK 1 to 5 years MONOFILAMENT FISHING LINE 600 years MILK CARTON 5 years PLASTIC BAG 200 to 1000 years You can crew a awarenessCO-JJ M g0Q K Share with your friends. j OUR GREEN CONI4ECTION S9 Photographer snaps seahorse tugging a Q-tip Nature photographer Justin Hofman has photographed a seahorse carrying a Q-tip off Indonesia's coast. "It's a photo that I wish didn't exist ... This photo serves as an allegory for the current and future state of our oceans. What sort of future are we creating?," he wrote. Notably, Hofman is a finalist in Natural History Museum's Wildlife Photographer of the Year 2017. E) inshorts L J FLORIDA SA- r-D4a>". I a„i,u s Bal Harbour (2014) Ordinance prohibiting polystrene at all stores, restaurants and beaches_ Bay Harbor islands (2015) Ordinance prohibiting polystrene in restaurants. Coral Gables (2016) Ordinance prohibiting use of polystyrene by chain stores, chain food stores, city vendors and at special events_ Hollywood 0996) Ordinance prohibiting the use of all plastic single -use foodware at restaurants east of the Intercoastal Waterway Key Biscayne (2014) Ordinance prohibiting polystrene on beaches and in local parks. Also prohibits city contractors and city facilities from utilizing polystrene. Miami Beach (2014) Ordinance prohibiting the sale/use of poiystyerene food service articles at all city parks, buildings, events and sidewalk cafes. North Bay Village (2015) Surfside (2015) % 1 vCies. � j/ a W At s7'�Y�r e �r'�'tr.a►�ceS Hawaii, a state with a $17 -billion tourism industry and a persistent plastic pollution problem, is moving toward a groundbreaking ban on polystyrene food containers. While hundreds of cities and counties have passed local ordinances eliminating polystyrene in food containers or in other uses, no legislation has so far been successful at the state level in the United States. A similar effort failed recently in California, while Maryland's general assembly is now also considering legislation that was introduced in early 2o18. Internationally, a few nations have imposed strong regulations against the importation and use of polystyrene, including Zimbabwe and the Seychelles, which has banned the use of all disposable plastic items. All plastic debris is a concern for marine and coastal health because it does not biodegrade and can end up polluting beaches and the ocean, where it breaks up into tiny pieces that can be eaten by marine life. Lightweight polystyrene foam is particularly worrisome in an island state such as Hawaii because it easily blows out of trash cans and eventually out to sea. CID _ caro �. 3131 t$ 500 million straws are used in Straws and other plastic harm the U.S. every day That's enough sea life, including fish, turtles to fill 125 school buses. and coral reefs. Plastic straws are among the Top Five Straws are easily carried away by the wind, items collected on the beach every yearending up littering our beaches and in our oceans and waterways. About 90% of trash in the oceans is made from plastic. 90% Plastic trash pollutes most marine habitats, including the deep sea, coral reefs, beaches and rivers. In most places, plastic straws cannot be recycled. O Every year, the U.S. uses enough straws to wrap around the earth 2.5 times. 0 fi About 90% of seabirds and 30% of turtles have plastics in "'� their stomach. Plastic breaks down into smaller pieces, but never fully goes away. TIN I I WERMAt Reduce your use of single -use plastics. Participate in beach or river cleanups. Pick up litter and properly dispose of it. Ask your family and friends to Skip the Straw! Marine Debris About Marine Debris Marine debris is anything man-made and discarded that enters the environment. Most trash comes from land-based sources, sometimes hundreds of miles away from the coast. Trash on the ground may be swept into inland waterways by rain or wind, where it will then make its way into the ocean through rivers and streams. Impact of Marine Debris Debris in the ocean can spread invasive species, become navigational hazards, introduce toxic pollutants, endanger human health, and injure or kill wildlife. Plastic debris discarded into waterways can break down into smaller pieces, but will never fully degrade. These smaller pieces, called microplastics, can be ingested by marine life giving them a false sense of satiation while potentially leaching dangerous chemicals into their bodies. Microplastics can then be passed up the food chain. FAST FACTS Marine debris comes in all A, shapes and sizes. The most common include: fishing gear, netting, derelict traps, boating debris, snorkel/dive equipment, paper and plastic trash, including straws and household items. How You Can Reduce Marine Debris ■ Build a community that recycles. Learn what's recyclable in your area, and encourage your co-workers and neighbors to learn what can and can't be recycled in your city. ■ Reduce the amount of marine debris from fishing gear. Collect all unused traps and bring monofilament fishing line back to shore for proper disposal. Look for monofilament recycling bins in marinas and at boat ramps. ■ Dispose of trash and recyclable materials in the proper receptacles. ■ Choose reusable products over disposable or single -use items when possible. ■ Take the pledge to Skip the Straw at FloridaDEP.gov/SkipTheStraw. Single -use plastic straws are pervasive in the daily lives of Florida residents and visitors. Reducing the use of straws will help eliminate some of the debris that harms shore birds, sea life and coral reefs. �;he 1�ety �orlc t�ilne� Bans on Plastic Straws in Restaurants Expand to More Cities By Daniel Victor March 3, 2018 The latest is Malibu, Calif. Before that came Seattle; Davis and San Luis Obispo, Calif.; and Miami Beach and Fort Myers, Fla. They're all cities that have banned or limited the use of plastic straws in restaurants. Straws, routinely placed in glasses of water or soda, represent a small percentage of the plastic that's produced and consumed but often end up on beaches and in oceans. Advocates said laws aimed at cutting back on the use of plastic straws can help spur more significant behavioral changes. "I think a lot of people feel overwhelmed by the magnitude of the plastic problem," said Diana Lofflin, the founder of StrawFree.org, an activist organization based in San Diego. "Giving up plastic straws is a small step, and an easy thing for people to get started on. From there, we can move on to larger projects." The City Council in Malibu voted on Monday to bar restaurants from giving out plastic straws, utensils and stirrers. Similar measures are being considered in other coastal cities, including Berkeley, Calif. A bevy of restaurants across the country have also voluntarily stopped providing straws. It's not just happening in the United States. Scotland plans to be rid of plastic straws by 2019, and Taiwan is banning single -use plastic items, including straws, cups and shopping bags, by 2030. Around the world, people have wrestled with the environmental effect of plastics, which do not naturally degrade and are frequently used once before settling in landfills, clogging storm drains or collecting in the ocean, often for long periods of time. Many countries have banned, limited or taxed the use of plastic bags. Some of the leading organizations in the plastics industry have said they agree with the idea of reducing the use of straws, but have said laws are the wrong way to go about it. They haven't fought the laws with the same vigor they used to oppose bag bans. The American Chemistry Council has taken a softer approach to straw bans than it did with bags, suggesting that restaurants provide straws only when a customer asks for one. "We believe providing straws through an `on -demand' system gives customers choice and helps prevent waste by ensuring that straws are distributed only to those who need them," Steve Russell, vice president of the organization's plastics division, said. Scott DeFife, vice president of government affairs for the Plastics Industry Association, said in an interview that the problem of ocean debris was complex, stemming more from inadequate resources for waste management. "We, as a nation, are not going to solve our marine debris issues by banning straws in restaurants," he said. He said straws had become "the new poster child" for environmentalists. A version of this article appears in print on March 4, 2018, on Page A17 of the New York edition with the headline: More Cities Crack Down on Drinking Straws in Campaign Against Plastic Waste