Loading...
R20-146 1 RESOLUTION NO. R20-146 2 3 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, 4 FLORIDA,APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO 5 SIGN AN EXTENSION OF A CONSULTANT AGREEMENT 6 WITH FLORIDA CARIBBEAN ARCHITECTURE, INC (FCA) IN 7 THE AMOUNT OF $101,250 FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT 8 AND PROFESSIONAL ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES FOR THE 9 NEW PUBLIC WORKS FACILITY AND THE RENOVATION 10 AND IMPROVEMENTS TO THE EXISTING BUILDING AND 11 SITE FOR THE NEW UTILITY WATER QUALITY 12 LABORATORY; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. 13 14 15 WHEREAS,On May 1st,2018 the City Commission approved,by Resolution R18- 16 068, a Consultant Agreement with FCA to provide project management services/owner's 17 representative services for the Town Square project which included: Fire Station#1, Police 18 Department Headquarters, City Hall/Library, Cultural Center, District Energy Plant,Kapok 19 Park, amphitheater, and related site improvements; and 20 WHEREAS, Staff is requesting to extend this agreement to include two (2)current 21 projects, the New Public Works Facility and the Utilities Water Quality Laboratory, and 22 believes that based on the consultant's direct knowledge of City operations and previous 23 experience in managing and working on utilities and public works projects,it is in the City's 24 best interest to continue our contractual arrangement with FCA; and 25 WHEREAS, staff is recommending approval of this extension of the Agreement 26 based on the Quotes attached hereto as Exhibit"A"and"B"which will provide the necessary 27 professional services for the construction of new modern buildings at the Public Works 28 facility at the Rolling Green site,just west of I-95 and north of the Boynton Canal and the 29 Utility Water Quality Laboratory to be located at the former Fire Rescue Station#2 site at 30 2201 S. Congress Ave.,Boynton Beach,just south of Woolbright Road. 31 NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF S:\CA\RESOWgreements\Extending Florida Caribbean Architecture Consultant Agreement-Reso.docx 32 THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH,FLORIDA,THAT: 33 Section 1. The foregoing "Whereas" clauses are hereby ratified and confirmed 34 as being true and correct and are hereby made a specific part of this Resolution upon adoption 35 hereof. 36 Section 2. The City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida does 37 hereby approve and authorize the Mayor to sign the quotes attached hereto as Exhibits"A" 38 & "B" extending the original Agreement which will provide the necessary professional 39 services for the construction of new modern buildings at the Public Works facility at the 40 Rolling Green site,just west of 1-95 and north of the Boynton Canal and the Utility Water 41 Quality Laboratory to be located at the former Fire Rescue Station # 2 site at 2201 S. 42 Congress Ave.,Boynton Beach,just south of Woolbright Road. 43 Section 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon passage. 44 PASSED AND ADOPTED this 15 day of December,2020. 45 CITY OF BOYNTON BEACII, FLORIDA 46 47 YES NO 48 Mayor—Steven B. Grant 49 50 Vice Mayor-Ty Penserga V 51 52 Vice Mayor-Justin Katz G.,4 S e..2r\N- 53 54 Commissioner-Woodrow L.Hay 55 56 Commissioner-Christina L.Romelus 57 58 A1'lEST: VOTE - O 59 V �. 60 61 C stal Gibson,MMC # ''y ��0%P(14' :, � 62 City Clerk , . A `� •� , t"' z r64 192063 " °' � d 65 (Corporate Seal) '.' ' 4A • • ', 17 p2iJy S ICA RESOVvreementsWxten6ng Florida Carbeean ArchitectetosaiitantAgaleent•Reso.docx City of Boynton Beach—Owner's Representative/ Florida-Caribbean Florida Caribbean Architecture Inc. orida6 Boynton Beach,,Florida,33426 Tel:561 308 6694(C) Architecture 561 287 5420(0) anderson@fcarchitecture.com www.FCArchitecture.com December 1,2020 Mr.Andrew Mack,Director of Public Works City of Boynton Beach Development 100 E.Ocean Avenue P.O.Box 310 Boynton Beach,FL 33435-0310 Re: City of Boynton Beach—New Public Works Facility-Owner's Representative Dear Mr.Mack: Florida Caribbean Architecture Inc.(CONSULTANT)appreciates the opportunity and is pleased to provide our proposal for Owner's representative/Project Management services for the City of Boynton Beach on a"continuing services/as needed"basis.It is our understanding that the City intends to develop a new Public Works Facility,located at the existing Rolling Green site,515 NW 14th Ct.Boynton Beach,Fl. Project Description/Intent: The intent of the scope of work is for FCA to be the Owner's(City of Boynton Beach)Representative/Project Manager and act as an extension of the Owner's staff managing the day to day operations of any given project during the design and construction phases.FCA will act as a liaison between the design team and the City to ensure that the City/ Owner's best interest are at the heart of every decision made. Scope of Services: It is Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.understanding that the scope of work is based on the development of the new public works facility is currently limited to the development of the programing/conceptual design and schematic design phases at this time. The Owner maintains ALL decision making authority and all contractual relationships flow back to the Owner.As an extension of the Owner's staff,the Owner's Representative/Project Manager interfaces with all project team members, tracking issues and facilitating and expediting solutions.The Owner's Representative/Project Manager will be responsible for maintaining clear and concise communication,keeping accurate records and thorough documentation throughout all phases of the project. FCA will be responsible for monitoring the following: 1. Project coordination 2. Programming and Conceptual Design 3. Schematic Design(30%)Documents 4. The overall project budget/costs Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.(CONSULTANT)will provide Owner's Representative/Project Management services noted above.Services include monitoring the following: A. Project Coordination with design team and City/Stakeholders. B. Review and development of project space programing requirements(site/building) C. Review and development of conceptual site and building plans D. Review and development of schematic design documents - Preliminary Site/civil plans - Preliminary floor&roof plans - Preliminary building sections and elevations. - Comprehensive project budget/costs. - Provide advice regarding potential project pitfalls and suggesting solutions Page 1 of 3 City of Boynton Beach—Owner's Representative/ Schedule: Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.shall commence services immediately upon authorization and receipt of"Notice to Proceed"but is subject to adjustments for delays which are beyond the control of FCA. Assumptions: 1. Owner to provide copies of all pertinent information,i.e.design criteria,schedule,scope of work,team chart, etc. 2. Access to site for field inspection by the architect and sub-consultants shall be made available. 3. Any assessment or removal of hazardous or toxic materials shall be handled by others. 4. Any delays in schedule which are outside the control of Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.(including reviews and approvals)may constitute a change in schedule and require an amendment to the schedule herein, and may constitute additional services/compensation. 5. Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s and its sub-consultants liability for damages will,in the aggregate,not exceed the amount of the fee.This provision takes precedence over any conflicting provision of this or any document incorporated into it or referenced by it.In no event shall Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.,its officers or any of its sub-consultants be liable for any incidental,indirect,special,punitive,economic or consequential damages,including but not limited to loss of revenue or profits,suffered or incurred by the Owner(s)as a result of this agreement or Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s performance or non- performance of services pursuant to this agreement. 6. The standard of care applicable to Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s services will be the degree of skill and diligence normally employed by professional architects or consultants performing the same or similar services at the time Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s services are performed.Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.will perform any services not meeting this standard without additional compensation. 7. The presence or duties of Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s personnel at a construction site,whether as onsite representatives or otherwise,do not make Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.or their personnel in any way responsible for those duties that belong to the Client or its Construction Contractor,or other entities and does not relieve the Construction Contractor or other entities from their obligations,duties and responsibilities, including but not limited to all construction methods,means,techniques,sequences,and procedures necessary for coordinating and completing all portions of the construction work.Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s personnel have no authority to exercise any control over any Construction Contractor or any other entity in the performance of the work or any health or safety precautions,and have no duty of inspecting,noting,observing, correcting or reporting on health or safety deficiencies at the site,except as related to Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s own personnel. Compensation for Services:Hourly rate) Compensation shall be as follows: 1. Compensation for the project services described above shall be based on an hourly basis scale unless otherwise agreed to with the City and shall be paid at the Hourly rate as noted below for a not to exceed a maximum total of 160 hours(4 weeks): - Hourly $110/Hr. ($110.x 160=$17,600.00) 2. Owner has agreed to cover all expenses related to project equipment,supplies and postage where/when applicable. Payment—In consideration for the services to be rendered by the Consultant hereunder,Owner agrees to pay Consultant subject to the provisions of this agreement. 1. Consultant will submit monthly invoices to the Owner pursuant to the terms of this agreement.Owner shall pay invoices within 15 days of receipt. 2. Owner will be charged interest at a rate of 1.5%per month or that permitted by law is lesser,on all past due amounts starting 30 days after receipt of invoice. 3. In the event of a disputed billing,only the disputed portion shall be withheld from payment.Owner shall exercise reasonableness in disputing any bill or portion thereof. Page 2 of 3 City of Boynton Beach—Owner's Representative/ Termination: Provided that the terminating party is not also in default hereunder,this Agreement may be terminated by any party upon written notice that a material obligation,except for non-payment,has not been performed.The party to whom the written notice is provided shall have thirty(30)days to correct the non-performance of the material obligation or the contract shall be deemed terminated. In the event of a non-payment,written notice shall be delivered and the payment identified in the notice shall be made within seven(7)days or the contract shall be deemed terminated.Proof of correction or payment must also be submitted within the respective time periods referenced above. Miscellaneous Provisions: a. No Third Party Beneficiaries:Nothing contained in this Agreement shall create a contractual relationship with or cause of action in favor of a third party against either the Owner or Consultant. b. Delay and Additional Services: If and to the extent that the time initially established for the Construction Phase of the project,as established by the construction contracts, is extraordinarily exceeded or extended through no fault of the Consultant,compensation for services required for such extended period of Administration of the Construction Contracts shall be computed in the manner set forth for additional services. c. Arbitration:Any controversy or claim arising out of or related to the contract,or the breach thereof,shall first require mandatory mediation. In the event mediation is unsuccessful then it shall be settled by arbitration in accordance with the Construction industry Arbitration Rules of the American Arbitration Association and judgement upon the award rendered by the Arbitrator or Arbitrators may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. d. Entire Agreement: This Agreement represents the entire agreement between Owner and Consultant and supersedes all oral and prior negotiations. We thank you for the opportunity to be of service to you on this project.Should you have any questions,please call Mr. Anderson Slocombe,AlA at(561)308-6694. APPROVAL OF SCOPE AND FEES Florida Caribbean Architecture, Inc. CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 0...-54_.1--10_' ___ - t . Steven B.Grant,Mayor \ Authorizing Signature Attest/Authenticated: „i igr �"�� rid5--/-/---/I C .\ Anderson Slocombe, AIA.NCARA tal Gibson,City Clerk ..-= 0Y Printed Name Approved asFoin: Title:President Officeofthe�C:ir'c Attorney Date: 12/1/20 Page 3 of 3 Boynton Beach Utilities-Water Quality Lab. Florida-Caribbean Florida Caribbean Architecture Inc. jl 7 Erwood Place FBoynton Beach,Florida,33426 Tel:561 308 6694(C) 1�t Iwo 561 287 5420(0) anderson@fcarchitecture.com Architecture www.FCArchitecture.com November 25,2020 Mr.Joseph,Paterniti Jr.PE,Utility Director City of Boynton Beach Utilities City of Boynton Beach. 124 E.Woolbright Road Boynton Beach,Florida 33435 Re: City of Boynton Beach Utilities—New Water Quality Lab—Renovation of Old fire station#2 Dear Mr.Patemiti: Florida Caribbean Architecture Inc.(CONSULTANT)appreciates the opportunity and is pleased to provide our proposal for professional architectural/engineering(minor structural,MEP)services for the renovation& improvements to existing building and site to accommodate new Water Quality Lab,located at 2210 S.Congress Ave., Boynton Beach FL.The existing building is approximately 5,322 SF and located on a site that is approximately 21,062 SF(0.36 Acres). Notes: - Minor civil engineering and landscape/irrigation services will be done"in-house"(with City staff)and will be coordinated by FCA. - Based on the size of the building and preliminary research,it's assumed that fire sprinklers will notbe required. - Fire alarm system will be addressed if determined to be required by code. - Low Voltage design is not included in scope.However,low voltage requirements will be coordinated with the Owner and devices,i.e.cameras,card readers,CCTV,etc.will be shown on plans for locations andinstallation of conduit and boxes only. Project Description/Intent: The intent of the project is to provide professional architectural/engineering(structural,MEP)services for interior/exterior renovations and improvements of the existing building to accommodate the City's new Water Quality Lab and coordinate minor civil/landscape/irrigation requirements with City staff for minor site improvements Scope of Services: Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.(CONSULTANT)and its sub-consultants will provide architectural and engineering(Structural,MEP)and coordination with city staff for minor civil/landscape services as necessary for the proposed project noted above. Services include the following: A. Preliminary Design: Site visit to get design team familiarized with existing site conditions and project expectations.Update base plans as necessary and create new elevations. B. Design Development: Based on approved preliminary design documents,further develop plans, elevations,and sections and develop details,schedules and preliminary specifications for submittal. C. Construction/Permit Documents: Based on approved design development documents,provide fmal drawings,details,schedules,notes and specifications as required for construction/permit set of construction documents. D. Permitting Assistance: Provide signed and sealed copies of the permit documents to the CLIENT for permit submittal to the City of Boynton Beach Building Department and respond to questions/ comments from the Building Department—including revisions to documents as may be required. Page 1 of 6 Boynton Beach Utilities-Water Quality Lab. E. Bidding Assistance: Assist CLIENT with the development of bid packages and attend pre-bid meeting/conference with CLIENT and prospective bidders as necessary;conduct bid evaluations as necessary. F. Construction Phase Services:Provide basic construction phase services-Attend pre-construction meeting;review shop drawings;answer BFI's;review change orders;conduct site visits during construction;conduct substantial/fmal completion site inspection,provide punch lists and conduct/coordinate project close-out. Tasks: Task A:Preliminary Design/Review/Coordination: 1. Conduct a"kick-off'meeting with design team and stakeholders,visit the proposed site and the existing lab(West Water Treatment Plant)with the design team to familiarize the team members with the site conditions and project expectations—includes photographic documentation. 2. Prior to"kick-off"meeting,review and analyze all existing documentation/information provided by the CLIENT. - Preliminary building design plan layout of proposed Water Quality Lab. - Lab equipment list and requirements - Other miscellaneous documentation 3. Based on preliminary design floor plan,information provided by the CLIENT and results of meeting/site visit investigations,set up base CAD plans and files,create demo/new site/floor,ceiling plans,create preliminary equipment schedule,conduct building code research/analysis for wind load requirements, occupancy/construction type,etc.and develop life safety plans.Provide updated design plans and elevations,addressing the scope and extent of work to be completed for CLIENT's review • Structural scope includes: - Provide structural design wind load criteria. • Mechanical/Plumbing: - Site visit,review of existing information and evaluation of mechanical/plumbing systems. • Electrical: - Site visit,review of information and evaluation of electrical system and new generator requirements. 4. Provide a preliminary statement of probable construction costs. 5. One review/coordination meeting will be held with the CLIENT toreview,revise and fmalize the preliminary design layout. Labor/Expenses: $7,950. Includes coordination with design team,CLIENT Deliverable:Two(2)hard copies and pdf s of preliminary design documents(Plans). Task B: Design Development: 1. Based on approved preliminary revised plans develop elevations and provide further detailed design drawings for the new water quality lab.General information for architectural/engineering(basic structural,mechanical,plumbing and electrical)systems will be conveyed—including plans,sections, elevations,schedules,details,notes and preliminary specifications. • Structural scope includes: - Update structural wind load design criteria,miscellaneous details and notes. • Mechanical/Plumbing: - Provide plans,showing mechanical/plumbing layouts,preliminary schedules,details,notes and specifications to meet all applicable code requirements. • Electrical: - provide electrical plans layouts showing power,data and lighting layouts,preliminary schedules,details,one line diagrams,low voltage device locations for conduit/boxes only and preliminary specifications,etc.to meet all applicable required code requirements. Page 2 of 6 Boynton Beach Utilities-Water Quality Lab. 2. Update statement of probable construction costs. 3. One review/coordination meeting will be held with the CLIENT to review,revise and fmalize the design development plans. Labor/Expenses: $ 12,850. Includes coordination with design team and CLIENT. Deliverable:Three(3)hard copies and pdf s of design development plans and specifications Task C:Construction/Permit Documents: 1. Based on approved Design Development drawings,fmal drawings and notes/specifications for the purpose of Construction/Permitting of the new water quality lab will be prepared.All basic architectural and engineering(structural,MEP)drawings,details and notes will be finalized for the purpose of permit submittal and construction.Documents,includes required NOA's for permit submittal. • Structural scope includes: - Finalize any miscellaneous details,schedules,and specifications/notes required. • Mechanical/Plumbing: - Finalize mechanical/plumbing design,schedules,details,energy calculations,notes and specifications • Electrical: - Finalize electrical design-power,data and lighting,schedules,details,one line diagrams, low voltage device locations for conduit/boxes only and specifications. 2. Update/fmalize statement of probable construction costs. 3. One review/coordination meetings will be held with the CLIENT to review,revise and finalize the construction documents. Labor/Expenses: $20,550. Include coordination between disciplines and with CLIENT Deliverable:Three sets of documents;Electronic signed and sealed documents(includes applicable NOA's for roofmg,louvers,doors,etc.)for permit submittal;electronic files of documents(pdf,format) Task D: Permitting Assistance: 1. Provide signed and sealed documents for permit submittal to the building department. 2. Responding to building department comments and revision of drawings as required. Labor/Expenses: $7,350. Includes written responses to building department comments and signing and sealing of revised drawings for re- submittal to the building department as may be required Task E: Bidding Assistance: $5,000. 1. Assist the CLIENT with the Development of bid package;attend one pre-bid meeting/conference with CLIENT and prospective bidders.Assist the CLIENT in answering questions,prepare addendums asmay be required. 2. Conduct bid evaluation as necessary. 3. Prepare Conformed Documents as necessary Task F: Construction Phase Services: $29,950. 1. Attend the pre-construction meeting 2. Attend/conduct bi-weekly construction meetings during construction Page 3 of 6 Boynton Beach Utilities-Water Quality Lab. 3. Review and process shop drawings,RFI's,change orders and pay applications 4. Conduct site visits/inspections during construction—to coincide with monthly pay applicationreview. 5. Conduct substantial inspection and provide punch list. 6. Conduct final inspection and project close-out. Total basic Services: labor and expense(Tasks A,B,C,D,E and F)(Lump Sum) $83,650. Work Not Included: •Movable Equipment and Furnishings •Site utility Infrastructure Improvements •Landscape/Irrigation Design—FCA to coordinate with City"in-house"staff. •Civil Engineering requirements—FCA to coordinate with City"in-house"staff •Destructive/non-destructive testing •Security systems,including access control and CCTV. Locations of devices will be shown on plans for conduit and boxes only. •Cathodic protection •Lightning protection ADDITIONAL SERVICES: Additional services beyond the scope of work or for changes due to actions of the CLIENT will be pre-approved by the CLIENT and billed at the rates below: Schedule of Hourly Rates: Principal $145 Project Manager $125 Architect $110 Engineer $110 Administrative Assistant $ 60 Reimbursable costs for additional services,in addition to the reimbursement for hourly rates above,client shall pay all usual and customary out-of-pocket expenses incurred by Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc. Additional services not presently contemplated in this proposal will be scoped and priced separately under a subsequent Work Authorization amendment as appropriate,where so authorized by the CLIENT. Possible additional services may include: a) Any additional work not listed above b) Permit Fees c) Extension of Tasks A-F beyond that described herein d) Management of sub consultants associated with additional services e) Revisions to previously approved work f) Communication system selection,specification or design Schedule: Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.shall commence services immediately upon authorization and complete tasks as indicated below from receipt of"Notice to Proceed",not inclusive of any review periods required by the Owner. Task A: Preliminary Design 4 weeks Task B: Design development 6 weeks Task C: Construction/permit documents 6 weeks Task D: Permitting (dependent on Authority Having Jurisdiction) Task E: Bidding 4 weeks Task F: Construction Phase Services 34 weeks(8 months—estimated) Schedule delays which are beyond the control of FCA Inc.may require schedule adjustment to compensate for such delays. Page 4 of 6 Boynton Beach Utilities-Water Quality Lab. Assumptions: 1. CLIENT to provide all/any other relevant information 2. CLIENT to provide any civil engineering,landscape/irrigation services required. 3. One bid package,no construction phasing or multiple bid packages,no add alternates 4. Access to site for field inspection by the architect and sub-consultants shall be made available. 5. Any assessment or removal of hazardous or toxic materials shall be handled by others. 6. Any delays in schedule which are outside the control of Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.(including reviews and approvals)may constitute a change in schedule and require an amendment to the schedule herein, and may constitute additional services/compensation. 7. Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s and its sub-consultants liability for damages will,in the aggregate,not exceed the amount of the fee.This provision takes precedence over any conflicting provision of this or any document incorporated into it or referenced by it.In no event shall Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.,its officers or any of its sub-consultants be liable for any incidental,indirect,special,punitive,economic or consequential damages,including but not limited to loss of revenue or profits,suffered or incurred by the CLIENT(s)as a result of this agreement or Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s performance or non- performance of services pursuant to this agreement. 8. The standard of care applicable to Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s services will be the degree of skill and diligence normally employed by professional architects or consultants performing the same or similar services at the time Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s services are performed.Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.will perform any services not meeting this standard without additional compensation. 9. The presence or duties of Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s personnel at a construction site,whether as onsite representatives or otherwise,do not make Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.or their personnel in any way responsible for those duties that belong to the Client or its Construction Contractor,or other entities and does not relieve the Construction Contractor or other entities from their obligations,duties and responsibilities, including but not limited to all construction methods,means,techniques,sequences,and procedures necessary for coordinating and completing all portions of the construction work.Florida Caribbean Architecture,Inc.'s personnel have no authority to exercise any control over any Construction Contractor or any other entity in the performance of the work or any health or safety precautions,and have no duty of inspecting,noting,observing, correcting or reporting on health or safety deficiencies at the site,except as related to Florida Caribbean Architecture, Inc.'s own personnel. Compensation for Services:(LUMP SUM) RECAP: Lump Sum Fees&Expenses Tasks: Basic Services—Preliminary Design through Construction Phase Services Task A: Preliminary Design/Review/Coordination $7,950. Task B: Design Development $ 12,850. Task C: Construction/Permit Documents $20,550. Task D: Permitting Assistance $ 7,350. Task E: Bidding Assistance $ 5,000. Task F: Construction Phase services $29,950. TOTAL $83,650. The total amount to be paid to Florida Caribbean Architecture Inc.by the CLIENT under this agreement for services is in the amount of Eighty Three Thousand Six Hundred and Fifty Dollars($83,650.00).Florida Caribbean Architecture, Inc.will invoice the CLIENT on a tasks or monthly basis as required for payment. We thank you for the opportunity to be of service to you on this project. Should you have any questions,please call (561)308-6694. Page 5 of 6 Boynton Beach Utilities-Water Quality Lab. APPROVAL OF SCOPE AND FEES Florida Caribbean Architecture, Inc. CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 4P/' r, • • len B.Grant,Mayor • AuthorizingSignature Y b'n r' 1 <a Attest/Authenticated: • _ • Anderson Slocombe,A1A,NCARB Zstal Gibson,City CI .., Boy • Printed Name Approved as to Fo Title:President_____ Of ice of the City ttorney Date: 11/25/20 Page 6 of 6