AGENDA DOCUMENTS
3
Proposed Resolution No. R99- Re: Confirming the appointment
of Gayle easterling as Senior Planner for the Planning & Zoning Division
of the Department of Development and authorizing the Oty Manager to
execute an appointment contract and adopting a position description
D. Ratification of Planning & Development Board Action:
1. Wal*Mart Supercenter (Northwest comer of Winchester Park Boulevard
and Boynton Beach Boulevard) - Request approval to appeal the
Community DesIgn Plan, Chapter 9. SectIon llJ, to allow overhead doors
located on elevations of the proposed commercial/retail building that face
Knuth Road and Winchester Park Boulevard
2. Wal*Mart Supercenter (Northwest comer of Winchester Park Boulevard
and Boynton Beach Boulevard) - Request new site plan approval to
construct a 220,184 square foot retaU store on 39.61 acres
. .
3.
2. Proposed Resolution No. R99- Re: Accepting a Letter of Credit
Number BA404 from BankAtlantic in the amount of $142,000 as surety
for construction of the water and sanitary sewer systems for the project
known as Hunters Court
1. Proposed Resolution No. R99-69 Re: Approving the
Progress Trail plan and creating a publiC/private Progress Trail
Partnership between the Oty and the Greater Boynton Beach Chamber of
Commerce (TABlED TO 8/3/99 NEE77NG)
C. Resolutions:
7. Approve extension of the renewal of the WATER METER CONTRACT
REMOTE TOUCHREAD SYSTEM with an annual estimated expenditure of
$400,000
6. Approve disposal of Surplus and Confiscated/Unclaimed Items through a
City Auction, a Sealed Bid (for surplus computer equipment) and an
Outside Auction
5. Approve the bid extension, as per the specifications and the same terms
and conditions of the Bid - GOLF COURSE RENOVATIONS AND PRACTICE
AREA CONSTRUCTION, for seven tee renovations with Detail Turf, Inc., in
the amount of $34,144 (PROPOSED RESOJ.U170N NO, R99-)
with an estimated expenditure of $20,800 (original Purchase Order for
the amount of $9,600 plus a Change Order request in the amount of
$11,200
Regular City Commission
Agenda
August 3, 1999
..
VI. PUBUC AUDIENCE:
. INDMDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE UMmD TO 3-MINUTE PRESENTAnONS
A. . Approve funding and completion of six PilOt Projects for Neighborhood Areas
Involv~ In. the formal Neighborhood Planning process for a total of $279,920
v. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT:
G. Approve payment for contractual programming personnel from Maximum
Group/TEK Systems Inc. of 1000 NW 56th Street, Suite. 300, Fort Lauderdale, by
utilizing a State of Rorlda SNAPS Agreement and authorizing a purchase order
for $50,000
F. Approve funds for Housing Rehabilitation Case #2-9S-012/Charles and Annie
Rahming In the amount of $13,944 (ThIs amount Includes leveraging of SHIP
grant funding of $10,000 and Oty of Boynton Beach Home Improvement funding
of $3,944.)
E. Approve Change Orders #7, #10, #11, #12 and #15 totaling $45,262.24
adjusting the contract amount with Mouw Associates for the 1913 Schoolhouse
Museum Project to $1,146,S06.S9 (Original contract amount $1,112,900 plus
previously approved Change Orders $33,906.S9) and requesting a $44,310
transfer from C.I.P.
5. Height Increase (Single-family Structures) - Request to amend the Land
Development Regulations, Chapter 2. Zoning, Section 4.f to allow for
administrative approval to increase the maximum height of a single-family
home from 25 feet to 30 feet
4. Day Care in R-1-AA Zoning District - Request to amend the Land
Development Regulations, Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 5.C to include day
care as an allowable use within the R-l-AA zoning district
3. The Morris Building (161 Commerce Road, Lot 4 High Ridge Park) -
Request new site plan approval to construct a 15,104 square foot
industrial/warehouse building on 1.099 acress
Regular City Commission
Agenda
August 3, 1999
J\SHRDA T AIPLANN1NGISHAREDlWPlPROJECTSIW AL MARTlCDPA W ALMARTlAGENDA ITEM REQUEST 8-3-99.oOT
City Attorney / Finance / Human Resources
/z, -'(/~.
Planning and Zoning Director
City Manager's Signature
/'-Lc-/Z ~__
Development Acti g Director
ALTERNATIVES: N/A
FISCAL IMPACT: N/A
PROGRAM IMPACT: N/A
EXPLANATION:
PROJECT: Wal*Mart Supercenter
AGENT: Kevin M. Roberson, Kimley-Horn & Associates
APPLICANT: J. Robert Bray, Assistant Vice President of Real Estate Wal*Mart Stores East, Inc.
LOCATION: Northwest comer of Winchester Park Boulevard and Boynton Beach Boulevard
DESCRIPTION: Request approval to appeal the Community Design Plan, Chapter 9, Section 11.J. to allow overhead doors
located on elevation's of the proposed commercial/retail building that face Knuth Road and Winchester
Park Boulevard.
RECOMMENDA TION: Please place the request below on the August 3, 1999 City Commission agenda under Consent-
Ratification of Planning and Development Action. The Planning and Development Board with a unanimous vote,
recommended approval subject to staff comments and the additional comment that requires perimeter deciduous trees shall
be replaced or supplemented with tree species thar will maintain foliage. For further details pertaming to this request see
attached Department of Development Memorandum No. PZ 99-153.
o Development Plans
o New Business
o Legal
o Unfinished Business
o Presentation
o Administrative
I:8J Consent Agenda
o Public Hearing
o Bids
o Announcement
NATURE OF
AGENDA ITEM
October 20. 1999 (5:00 p.m.)
October 6, 1999 (5:00 p.m.)
o September 21, 1999
o October 5, 1999
o October 19, 1999
o November 2, 1999
August 18, 1999 (5:00 p.m.)
September 8, 1999 (5:00 p.m.)
July 7,1999 (5:00 p.m.)
o July 20,1999
I:8J August 3, 1999
o August 17, 1999
o September 7, 1999
August 4,1999 (5:00 p.m.)
September 22. 1999 (5:00 p.m.)
July 21. 1999 (5 :00 p.m.)
Date Final Form Must be Turned
in to City Clerk's Office
Requested City Commission
Meeting Dates
Date Final Form Must be Turned
in to Citv Clerk's Office
Requested City Commission
Meeting Dates
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM
To further screen potential views to the overhead bay doors, additional canopy trees are proposed along the
In order to minimize views to overhead bay doors, Wal-Mart proposes to appeal this requirement, and
proposes to construct six-foot high masonry stucco walls along the southeast entrance at Winchester Park
Boulevard and east of the wet detention pond along Knuth Road (see Exhibit "C" - Proposed site plan and
screening walls). The screen walls will be designed similar to the wall behind the Sports Authority to
maximize consistency and minimize aesthetic impact.
In order to comply with these requirements, all docking bays would have to be relocated to the rear of the
building. This relocation cannot occur without reducing the size of the parking area, and undergoing a
complete interior redesign moving the entire building northward. In addition, the multi-functional commercial
complex design is dictated by operational requirements to meet the efficiency standards for this type of
business. This limits the design flexibility, as it relates to reconfiguration of design schemes (as indicated by
the applicant).
ANALYSIS
This analysis first focused on necessity for the appeal, then on impact and mitigation measures.
Knuth Road and Winchester Park Boulevard are listed in Section II.J of Chapter 9 - Community Design Plan
of the City's Land Development regulations, with those other roads along which building elevations fronting
these streets shall not display overhead doors. Due to the high degree of visibility, these roads are within areas
which the City desires closer architectural scrutiny and higher standards.
BACKGROUND
The proposed Wal-Mart Supercenter will be a building totaling more than 220,000 square feet and will contain
a large variety of commercial activity. To continue its operational efficiency requirements, and to move such
large quantities of merchandise, the applicant states that it is necessary to have the overheads doors on the east
and west facades.
NATURE OF REQUEST
Todd J. Howder of Kimley - Horn and Associates, Inc., agent for Wal-Mart Stores East, Inc., owner of the
property located between Old Boynton Road and Boynton Beach Boulevard, and between Knuth Road and
Winchester Boulevard, (see Exhibit "A" - Location Map), is requesting approval of a Community Design Plan
appeal to allow overhead doors, located on the elevations of the proposed commercial building, that face
Knuth Road and Winchester Park Boulevard, (see Exhibit "B" - Proposed Elevations).
Wal-Mart Supercenter - CDPA 99-001
(overhead doors)
SUBJECT:
July 22, 1999
DATE:
Chairman and Members
Planning and Development Board
/>1?t72-
Michael W, Rumpf
Planning and Zoning Director
FROM:
TO:
Staff Report For
Planning and Development Board and
City Commission
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
MEMORANDUM NO. PZ99- 153
xc: Central File
J :\SHRDA T A \Planning\SHARED\ WP\PROJECTS\ Wal Mart\CDP A W ALMART\ST AFF REPORT REVISED.doc
RECOMMENDATIONS
The proposed overhead doors should receive adequate screening from the combination of wall and landscaping
treatments proposed by the applicant. Therefore, staff recommends approval of this request, subject to the
condition of approval included in Exhibit "E", which is intended to confirm that sufficient buffering would be
accomplished.
southeast border to reduce tree spacing. It is noteworthy that the overhead doors are over 380 feet from the
westernmost right-of-way of Winchester Park Boulevard, and 560 feet from the easternmost right-of-way of
Knuth Road. Distance, along with proper screening including walls and landscaping should minimize the
degree of visibility and impacts upon the subject right's-of-way. (see Exhibit "D" - Landscape Plan). To
confirm that the necessary buffering is accomplished, staff is requiring that a cross-section be provided to staff
which shows the elevation relationship between the road, buffer/landscaping, and overhead bay doors. If
insufficient buffering is provided, as indicated by this graphic, the deficiencies shall be addressed with a berm
and/or additional landscaping options and enhancements.
Page 2
Memorandum No. PZ99-153
WalMart-overhead doors
CDPA PZ99-001
, .r::;JI-...." ..... ,,~ . .. ~
\~ .
. o-r/!'
h
(:,'t
~:;~
\~3...,~
\~. K~
\,~
~~
peO
C
,,,\
-I
'----~
l' _~- .J.-.
- .-
t' ..--'
-
,', --
ii"
\L~-1~'3' lC"\
,'.' l~ \
': \''-...;...... --- --'
~ ~----
--~). ''') \.--
.-/. /
~~
J _ -"' 1
~ ..&"~'''-'- "'\ ~
\ ,'" -";> J.
. ./^-- .-
. ."-'
!'"
\\\.~ S\TE
'"
')
{
_.' --- -
,
-'
,..
"t.
\,
\',
/
~'\ ~ p..
"
\,
~
Q',Ji -:.0
.h ';'
...... +
"
J~
"
;.;
l
1
.. i ~
ii
-$-
*
T
...,.
:11
p~ ~,
;li H
f;! l~
~n ~!
Pi ~i
J~ i!
a~ .
I
I
I' '"II U~'l ~.@@(!) H ~Hil J l~ j , i ~. .,.. II J .~
ll.j ~ i!11 . , i I~ ! ' .; i,! r. ;j
III ~" if 't;! . . , . & ~ p II · 1 r ,. . l-.l.. II
~ 1111'1 ; illl;1 i i ~ ' it I. ail,!'
i ,> I .' 1 '"
~ · i Uliil i i " ~ , I q' ,~
~ ..... - f I la I I I " - ". - - . . ~ .".. '. ~
i~ fl~~iJ III . I! Ill1;j ~ ~ ~ I
~ i i . . - , \1; I' · ,. . , · , . · , . · ,'- ri
. " '.~ ,., ~. ~ "f'r .. H \ · t
;, !& J 2. j I.-f ~ Ai " . . :. . ' . . , i' ~ ~
, .,. ~ . ~ ,~~:ll ~ ., ~ , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ :~ ..
I .., l'II "Un. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; I;~
I .. 1 r- < I 2 u;." .. it
:1 p ~~, I 'If I III "'j"
" 1 .. '~";:'l ~:;~ I ,
n ~ ----
H
It
n
t
~
H
Ii
(~
~I~
~~
~
<
!<
2
-+
2"
'iIi,
"
J"
,'i
-h
H
"
/I
~ lid' ·
i,? -=1 .
:l "J '. -'.
al_,~ 'OJ
'~'! I, I
......'.'- ,', .-; :,!~
' ;; '1'.
i~p
r=.---=
I
J"
,~i
-H
~i
I~
)
n
"
I'
l.j
;~
J;
'"
.,
~
I
il~
. ..
..
!""
m
<
~
..
~
U1
~-,_.~-,---_.,-_...-
~-------------------
'"
;j
~~
t
,
n
H
"
if
l'
I:
i
,
~
~rtf:
i
,
i'
II
........
H
,"
l'
!
.'
J~
1 ~
! !
.;j..
'"
..--'
-+
:-==
I :Jll
t..:l'
it: I
~'r
I
~" ~
"~j =:
OJ - I
snE PLAN n!~~ ~ ~l! (l!~
, . 0: Fs i H
I WAL- _. ~ 1I!AOIlEl. fI,.CIElA ~ . ~ ;- ~
NO. ~ _ 8C IC-......-<llJ ; . :,.:~~. ~ a>!; ~ !C
PALM 1I!AOI1XIlMY. P'UlN)A i t
WNH!IrIER 1111!
F .-]:'P
. ;.ED CJ
:...... .. ............. .'U .', - OC ... .. ..
,..................... :.::::::::::...:"70_"""."""-'" IIIJl!lli'I'I'illliul-a ~:~I~I ifiUA"lll n
IT~~~;=: !li'II~!;!I!lh,l!iii' ~iIJ~h diil!~.111 ill;~;mU!!I !HI!ili=
i: ,.,,!:' '". _ ~ 9 Isl'J.,!IHI11:'.;h.1 ,:.11111 1,1116,11 ::!li1Iti: I~~,i lm!i 10:
, ," .. .~ . ,!I ,.. ..' ". I . ,r' · '. ,.... ... ,..",
\ 'I ".,...," .- =,~ . c,. II III ..~'d li',.;liPI liS' U I If !:ii
,.. ..c.... .! ' :. ill" I . ~ ': , .. .... llji
.: _ ~ i , I ~!3 '" , e . . ' 1l D. il': l \ III \il~!!11 ~d,li~I!;'l :'!i ~I!ij!i~i 'i i
i , ,j' :,' I 'I.' I . \ '1' "II III'" ,"" .;....:!'.
'j" ~ ~ ' I' 3 ~ . f d ! ~ q j Ijl . 1". ',I!! j"I' , . :l~ iI .. I ;!;:I".ii .......~; ::' ~'''':;
!l . . , ! , i III : n I ~ I'r Ililii I ;1 i hill fo ~, I '!l,mli !milnln"I'H '
'j" i ;. ~ . . . · . ! ! t Id'l II 1'"1' I' .~~~~~~'''.''
,..' .",' .. ,. " " ~"..,
_" ;j' I' ,!'II ,!' ,"~ili j
./ ' . ~ .' ~: 'i' : b zr- C" ·
I , .'" .N.D PCD '
_ _ ~I: L.4ND us-
. .' ' - oc'
" i """. .,- -" ;
"i I ., --- ~.- '
". . <0:.;.--':'um. :i--~~'''':=;;;7'''. ..... r
/3' ,___,_~ el" ,..
Q""'"'.J( ~ ~ " ,"
_ ",,' <JL:....J ",---. "....:....,"~{"\ : ~
__ ~ AP/~~ -.' '. u '
- .....// 'I - I "
_ ,-"---" @ 7"('.. //00'- D ,t '
"Q _~;;., '...:.,,; N//////// U' Ii!
. . . __"__,,..lJO.r ~ ~ ' "
. ~ f _ __ .. ,--,-"",,,,, - 'i I ~ i '~l '.
~-; "f!':: .."'. ,.~. :::c::::::.~,. ( II ( "
W il _ _ ~ . //oo/~/// - , ~ i I .~
, . r +.u..' .
I ,- ,,,..-- 0 .. . . ,
''>'"'' · J I I' 1"
,. . ., . ._"..... . . , m' I,
'; , .m_..... ~ "
'" : " (.\,n . -- .....) I ~ , \1 iJ
u .~=.."".... ~' . ,'.
. . _ ~ " . _..:.....m.::::'m - I '\ is ,.
I, '".. . ....m' .., '
"- ( "''1'''' A. ~.. --,- D U' :l, :! "':;
~YT . "-- - . ." ·
,_ . .,.. . ......... . _ .. .f
.r __ -:.. .-".,.......'- . . :' I , 0
,P' . __ ,_ - / ..-' -- ) I ' '" ~
1 !,',.. U e .. _':-::' ;""'''' -: I'! d
. ~~._" ~ -' 0/ ___.// -." I ~- ~
_ _.. . U ... , w 'L H
n . , N/' <;> ~, ~ . (~~. .:: - i .
., ..'u .,' .... .
"=.._" ""'/////00 ~ .~ t;at ,.... I' I
., '-' 0_ -' .' .. .
. ."Wf'~'"'' .m..~ (~-11i ~
II' 'j: -'- _. :y........m2 ~-""l :; i
10- ''" ,,"'-'---- .-+....... ..... "I ;
.. . 0""",,, .' ~ '-' .'. · ,.,.
QiV:~f:~~-';' 0\.S WNo./~O 9-{" ,l ~ ;:. I:: .
., .... :::1t:;;::'" u~,,--'i' S ;j.;
m\ - 4D D""""'" . 7 - I
',' . ----- -......... .-, "
. :.f. 00/"0 .....)
i. t I -1-"-, . ...,;s:.........n... . r ~o r '1 i -
~ ". ~ -+ _.." ' h
/' "'~ ,Q...'r7"'" ~ I ,: C)
. _ :.../ """..:z. 0'
. - .........('"
~".;."'._'-' ]0 _~__ 0" lii~ I 11
. oc.:. ,-. '--{ ......... ,..< " ~ \"
)&.. _ ~ ///0, i ') ., ::
-t~ <: -- . - ---;~ -1. II
" I
lef 'l~ -- ....", . i
.~ ,I. ' ..~. .,
",., u_ '
" ,!; ~ 1)1 :J.:
. F li'< ..
, - , .' ,
'~. l' 0 ~ ;; j ; r I"' ,.": ~
I' '"{J , r . ~ . ." l!:
"~13" ~ 0 "1' : .
r" m" .'~
....... .. r -
. ......._._..... ., ! I ~ Iii 'f' 0 "r .
'. . ~..."" ~ it! 'Jl 2' '
-=" " .. .. -.,.:...... -, ~ ~ ~'~ . :
, _._ ~, .. m. 0
_ i ~ 'f' ....__~~..;.c "",_ '1' ' C ~
._......- .~ I' ~ ....... ....'?--.. \ gj' ~ . c... ~ ,-"-.1
_ _ ..~,E.' ~---.::.....:::::.:.:.,c:::"..::::~ ..,! 1 8 : L_ .
zo /ir"I' -=--.0. ---.;::,_._ --.-- .'... ,.L. t l'
NED PC :.:;__.. _..... - --- ....-... -.. _. I
LA D -~- ---=- ~ '-. ...,,-..... :
ND uSE _ LRC ==- ~ i' ..._.",.,.~~~...s:. ---- ..-J ~'
---==--C;:~=~~:::~~~____J ;
~ tal:;'1 ~i!1
:::<:l 11>. .tlll ah
~ Ibr; ~ lii~h I::~I
. "!: V- ."r" II!
~ I>I~}> . 1:51: I:.,
tt> C :a:IJ .... I' ...~&!
-I i,!il~
i
~
'1(1:11
.J-
j, U~i
it ~~
':', I
l!a !; s;
~i Ii Ii.!
-. U
,
jU 54 .t.a.
l~! l~ !t~~
'c-'. .~'..
,.. II .']
:i!. Ii.
i, i ,,1
i
~.
:m
!
EXHIBIT "C
L i
-=
\V ~~ - -\ " i ;;;- .. f ~ i ~ ~
LANDSCAPE P\...AN ...,.. - 1
~~ .
r .. -
_ \ 3 W~- ~,lICMfTClI! II!JDlIl!l. ~ ro-:.~ );, ~ I
, NO. ~ IEW se IC-2IlI-P--o..l ---- -.~ ~
. "AlJA IIB/lOl (:lCtHTY. ~ ,,/l.'" '.,\'
..ft-
. ~ern: 'J1l,1" ,
~:=:::~:~~:::::;.t:,-= ~r~===
',' - - ,,' - ' ~ - ~ ' ~
\ ~ __-_ ccc_"~\ i\~
\\ \-oL 0.- ',- - :: :_-i '. ,
~" \ r''''''''-'' ,-- ? ,i ~ ~
" ',-' - ' , ..
..... ~ t . ~
,., -P: ;; · \ ~ 11 i
" . I -i ~ 11 ~ "
'!.L: h ,,,'i" \
.~. "" . \ g,.
~ ~ ;:$0"" q ~\ · ~:;
I In \'" '" ~
ii ~ ~ ' ""-
..~ \ ' Jlt~,l /):4~-
\~ \ , --,.- /
· ,Q:l y.
,\ ~ ':0\
I _..:.~ '1IID' \
\" };, (j:~ = B~
~ . '..... ....._---~ i '\;;;hI
(J '0,.... : ~ \'
:' ..... ! -:::Ji
~ \ CJ \ : L:::iII
~~ __ __ _ _____ ~.J-- ___ _ - L __.e- -!- -- --"",J'
~_ ~-~~~=~";~1f \'5 -- ~ - \ --"'0: 'F - - - ~;':
,~r~ .... e' ! Q\
'~ \ I.J? "~ ,;;:J t.........-.....t3I".r-'
: \ .l." _ _ \ ' \ ,,!_L-.
I C'~'--"" . \ ~ \ <Q.! ~ @I ,
i r.:.-\ . \ ! i
,__: ,! a! ~I
;..~_:-r \ j :+
~;f..r" - - \ ~ I ~~ \ f!1~
i,~ 1 ~' t-.!'-- . I
~\' \ . ~..-\-
: \ . .. ..-....--.. \
\ ~ j ~, '0. \ ~ "~' -.......?F-
lra-! ' ! . .,. @ '"'
\-.I~i !# I @\- ~, .i
\ IfJll i I : I \ '0
'\\~i I '0.! ~ ,(: -<
\~. 'Q 1 · '3\ ' -,
II ' r:;L' ~
_ _ ""l. \ t:l '-.. ~ _.\
'~1- ~~ t:J \-----.---. - ..... Ir~ 19\
"'" ~ -.. .--------- . - <"
tI,i"<l"<-"_'~- ~>~/-,.~\ i ~~
l' \~ ~-.. ,,;0/ ~, J ;::m
. \ __-~~---4.f,ZL'T--- m
.. ..-" 6;l -.. ~ /// -
- ',\ // \" -
_.'". I" ~
..."""".~ '
_------l---~~J~~-~
1---:-tf:~~~~:J;j-~~-;~:." -c~~ .': - ~:~::rl\
r to: ,'t "
IS ~ ~ ~~ ~) !\~~
l~ ~ ~r ~ ~ ; ! ~ ~ l { 1h':-" - - ~
~ 2 ~ ~ I 2 0 11 :>:."
I ,. I / ~ "r'~ c
~ .. ~ 3. 1-\"';:: ~ !~ ~ ~
, "' ~ '" t:"". ~
, "'l ~ ,,'ti
~ I l:;l
._..__._~ ._ d ,~...- _
~ ---------
,
- /~-
~
"""
S~
-o:D
;::m
m ./
3.
~lli iUI
.1= \~ I\.
~!.. --iii\,=
~~~ iaf
;tOI' O~\\l~
S\ \..,,;;1
~ .......1
_ i'
i ~ ~ ~a
i~ 2,:1;
~i l~~
~ i'\
..' ~\
n J)' .:r~
---~--.--.-_;_r.~'~
. ,
i \
'l
L.:'
~
-
~
~1i'~1> ,
~ ~ r; IJ';.-
~ , 3: 't--
~n ~~
~
<
usn~
Iht-t
H~lh
lj~\l
H t
)
f- .
('
:c
~
t:.^nIDI I
j
~J
\ .:
..:~~~--:-
= Q
\
---~-------_.
J:\SHRDATAIPLANNING\SHAREDIWP\PROJECTS\WAL MARTlCDPA WALMARTlCOND. OF APPROVAL P&D.DOC
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS
Comments: N/R
UTILITIES
Comments: N/R
FIRE
Comments: N/R
POLICE
Comments: N/R
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: N/R
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments: N/R
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: N/R
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST
Comments: N/R
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments:
1. To confIrm that the overhead bay doors are adequately screened from view, X
provide a cross-section or comparable diagram showing the needed relationship
(elevation) of the road, wall and landscaping, and the bay doors (both east and
west sides) to provide visual buffering. Buffering defIciencies identifIed by the
cross-section shall be off-set with additional and diverse landscaoinl!.
ADDITIONAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS
2. Perimeter deciduous trees shall be replaced or supplemented with tree species X
that will maintain foliage and therefor buffering characteristics with greater
olantinl! intensity in vicinity of overhead bay doors.
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS
3. To be determined. I
Project: Wal*Mart Supercenter
File number: CDPA 99-001
Reference: A letter of reauest dated Mav 18.1999.
EXHIBIT "E"
Conditions of Awroval
City Clerk
J:\SHRDATA\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Wal Mart\CDPA WALMART\Develop Order CC 8-3-99.doc
DATED:
7. Other
6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms
and conditions of this order.
5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk.
4. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby
..lL. GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof.
DENIED
3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or
suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set
forth on Exhibit "D" with notation "Included".
established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested.
2. The Applicant
..lL. HAS
HAS NOT
1. Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with
the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations.
THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton
Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the
relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative
staff and the public finds as follows:
OR
X THIS MATTER came before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida
appearing on the Consent Agenda on the date above. The City Commission hereby adopts the
findings and recommendation of the Planning and Development Board, which Board found as follows:
DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "C" ATTACHED HERETO.
LOCATION OF PROPERTY: Northwest Corner of Winchester Park Boulevard. & Boynton Beach
Boulevard
TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Community Design Plan Appeal
DATE OF HEARING BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: August 3,1999
APPLICANT'S AGENT: Todd J. Howder, Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 601 21st Street, Suite 400
PROJECT NAME: Wal*Mart
DEVELOPMENT ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
9
lepJawwoJ I!~a'd le:>01 O~ ~unoJ lpeag wled
ul (lI6lH lepJi9WwoJ) H-J wo.ij uopeu6lsap asn puel alp 6Ul6uell:> Aq ~lJ
alp }O ueld a^lSuallaldwCQ alp JO ~uawal3 asn pue, aJrQn:J alp 6ulPuawe
Aq 8E-68 aJueulpJO 6ulPuawe ~'JUI '~e3 ~JO~S ~eW-leM Aq paUMO
puel }O saD2 vg'6 6U1PJe6ali :a'd -660 'ON a:>ueuJPJO pasodoJd 'E
(lepJaWwoJ
}qlunwwoJ) (-J o~ (leAuaplsa~ leJrQln:>!J6v) 'dV wo.ij puel JO :pe.Q
Ule+Ja:> 2 6ulUOZaJ Aq OL -16 a:>u2ulpJO 6ulPuawe ":>uI ':)5e3 saJo~s +Jew-reM
lO uORe:>!Idde a41 6U1PJe6a'd :a~ -660 'ON a:>ueU1PJO pasodoJd ''Z
(12pJaWwoJ ~lunwwoJ)
(-J Ol (leJfqln:l!J6v) r:.JV wo.ij (saJ:le L(''Z( JO 6u!lS!suo:>) puel JO :Pe.Q
ule+Ja:> 2 6U1UOlaJ Aq OL-16 a:lUeU1PJO 6UlPuawe "JUI 1523 saJO~S +J2W-12M
JO UOR2:>!Idde alll 6U1PJe6ali :a~ -660 'ON a:>ueU1PJO pasodoJd '1
E)NI~V3H ~118nd - 6ulpea~ puZ - saoueulPJO 'V
:1V931 'IX
('OOS'E;$ S! uOllnq!Jluoo Lpeaq
UO~U^08 JO 41:::> - ~'6Z6'9$ S! ~o9foJd JO ~SOO letO.l) .uOI}epOSSV po04JoQ46!9N
alsl uell9uaA 9l1l WO.JJ uone:>!Iddv weJ60Jd dlllSJ9lJl,Jed POO4Joq4619N 9Ln 9^oJddV '8
(.OOO'S$ Sl uO!~nq!Jluoo 40B98 UO~U^08}0 ~!:::>
- OO'l7' ~Z$ Sl 1:>9foJd !O lSOO letO.l) .,.eselld JOI uOlleposSV' ,$J9UM09WOH SU9pJeE>
9Jl4SdweH 941 WOJI UO!le:>!IddV weJ60Jd dlLlSJ9UlJed POO4Joq46!9N 94l 9^OJddV 'V
:SS3NIsns M3N 'X
eUON
:SNV1d .1.N3Wd013^30 'XI
9UON
:S0I8 'III^
sa!l!l!oej 6u!)\Jed pue awoLl OPOlS!4
JO asnaJ a^!ldepe JOJ MOlle 01 Z~ Ot V- ~ -~ WOJJ ,4JadoJd
941 aUOZ9J pue (:::>~,) lepJ9WWOO 1!E!l9~ 1e:>01 O~ (~a')
IB!luap!Sa~ ~!SU90 MOl WOJJ ueld a^!sUaLlaJdwo:::> aLll JO
dB~ asn pue1 9Jn~n.:l 9lH Olluawpuawe }O IB^OJdde ~sanba~
9nUa^v \S~ 3S 90E;
2le)f lJaqo~
eaLlS,O u!lJe~
a~nOH OlJOlS!H 2lB)f lJaqo~
\ \
:UO!ldlJosaa
: UO!le:>01
:J8UMQ
:lua6v
:~o9fOJd
'8
66/ol/~
NOISSIHHO:> J..1D lIYl093l1
YQNi9Y
l
~U9Wl!ru:>9~ J96eue~ ~!:) uo 9~epdn .V
:SS3Nlsns 03HSINI:JNn 'UX
8 ~ .9Z8$lO S~SO:> 9^!~e.JlS!u!wpe
9L1l Ol SZg'€$ WOJl (9UMOJS J9l9d) 606-L6# 9se:) U! 9uIl 94l 9:>np9~ 'q
Z ~ '€V€'9$lO SlSO:> 9^!~eJlS!U!Wpe 94l o~ SL ~ '6$ WOJl (':>UI 'S9:>!AJ9S
~!nb3 9WOH S9lepossv S,J9PU91) S6Z€- L6# 9se:) U! 9uIl 9ln 9:>np9~ .e
:uo!pe pJeOS 9:>ue!ldwo:) 9pO:) lO UO!le:>!l!le~ 'Z
~e ~9 'L1:>e9S UOlU^OSlO ~!:) .^ WOOlS 9!UUOS
9Se:> 9L1l U! oos'z ~$ lO lunowe 9L1l U! ll!lU!eld L1~!M ~U9W91U9S 9L1l ~d9:>:>V . ~
:J9L1~O . a
UOnez!ue6JO 6u!UUeld uet!lodo.Jl9~ 9L1~ o~ ~^netu9S9Jd9J 9~eW9ue
pue 9^!le~U9S9Jd9J e. 6u!lU!oddV :9~ -66~ .ON UO!lnIOS9~ p9sodoJd .€
9n6ealled!:>!un~ ~uno:) L1:>e9S Wled aln o~ 9^!l€lUaSaJd9J alewaue
pue a^!~elUaS9Jd9J e 6u!lU!oddV :9~ -66~ 'ON UO!~nIOsa~ p9sodoJd 'Z
wruO.:l
UO!leU!pJOo:) sanSSI leuo!P!ps!Jnr-!~ln~ 9ln o~ 9^!letUaS9Jd9J 9lewaue
pue a^ne~uas9Jd9J e 6u!lU!oddV :9~ -66~ .ON UO!lnIOSa~ p9sodoJd . ~
:SUO!lnIOS9~ ':)
9UON
6u!pea~ IS ~ - sa:>ueu!pJO 'S
^lsnoaU2~lnW!S pass2d
SaJU2U!pJO a~2J2das U! papalJaJ aq 1124s ^+JadoJd a4~ JO 5u!uoz JadoJd pue
uO!~2u5!sap asn pU21 JadoJd a4~ 5u!P!^oJd '~unoJ 4J2aS Wl2d U!L1~!M 5:l!W!I
~!J aLl~ o~ snon5!~uoJ S! ~24~ pU21 JO p2J~ pa~2JodJoJu!un U!e+JaJ 2 5u!xauue
~(pJ2^alnOS )jJed Ja~Sa4JU!M pue pJe^alnOS 4Jeas UO~U^OS JO JaUJOJ
~saM4+JOu a4~ uo pa~eJOI laJJed aJJe 179.6 e) "JUI '~e3 saJO~S +JeW-leM
JO UOA2J!ldde a4~ 5u!pJe5a~ . :a~ -660 'ON aJUeUIPJO pasodoJd 'v
66/0z/t
NOISSIHHO:l .uD 1IY1n9ill
VON:l9V
1:ISHRDATAIPLANNINGISHAREDlWP\PROJECTSIWAL MAR1\LUAR\AGENDA ITEM REQUEST 4-20-99.DOC
City Attorney / Finance / Human Resources
~___ (-/ --z:-
Planning and Zoning Director
City Manager's Signature
Acting Development Department Head's Signature
ALTERNATIVES: N/A
FISCAL IMPACT: N/A
PROGRAM IMPACT: N/A
EXPLANATION:
PROJECT: Wal Mart Supercenter No. 2789-00
AGENT: Keith Phelan, Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
OWNER: Wal Mart Stores East, Inc.
LOCA nON: Northwest corner of Winchester Park Boulevard and Boynton Beach Boulevard
DESCRIPTION: Request for annexation, amendment to the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan from CH
(Commercial High) in Palm Beach County to Local Retail Commercial and to rezone the property from AR
(Agricultural Residential in Palm Beach County), and AG (Agriculture) to C-3 (Community Commercial
District) to allow for commercial development.
RECOMMENDATION: Please place the request below on the April 20, 1999 City Commission agenda under Legal:
Ordinances-2st Reading (Ordinances for Annexation, Land Use Amendment and Rezoning). As you may recall, the
Commission approved the first reading of the ordinance at the April 6, 1999 meeting.
Legal
Unfinished Business
o Development Plans
o New Business
[8J
o
o
Consent Agenda
Public Hearing
Bids
o
o
o
o
o Announcement
NATURE OF
AGENDA ITEM
Presentation
Administrative
April 9, 1999 (noon)
o March 16, 1999
o April 6, 1999
[8J April 20, 1999
,
o May 4,1999
Requested City Commission Date Final Form Must be Turned
Meeting Dates in to City Clerk's Office
0 May 18, 1999 May 7, 1999 (noon)
0 June 1, 1999 May 21, 1999 (noon)
0 June 15, 1999 June 4,1999 (noon)
0 July 6, 1999 June25, 1999 (noon)
April 23, 1999 (noon)
March 26, 1999 (noon)
March 5, 1999 (noon)
Requested City Commission Date Final Form Must be Turned
Meeting Dates in to City Cler!<'s Office
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM
DESCRIPTION: Request approval to appeal the Community Design Plan,
Chapter 9. Section 11.J, to allow overhead doors located on
elevation'softhe 'proposed commerciallretaH building that
face Knuth Road and Winchester Park Boulevard.
LOCATION: Northwest corner of Winchester Park Boulevard and Boynton
Beach Boulevard
APPLICANT: J. Robert Bray, Assistant Vice President of Real Estate
Wal*Mart Stores East, Inc.
AGENT: Kevin M. Roberson, Kimley-Horn & Associates
Wal*Mart Supercenter
PROJECT:
1.
Community Desion Plan Appeal
A. APPEALS
6. Old Business
1) Final disposition of the July 13, 1999 Planning and Development Board meeting
agenda items.
A. Planning and Zoning Report
5. Communications and Announcements
4. Approval of Minutes.
3. Agenda Approval.
2. Introduction of the Board.
1. Pledge of Allegiance.
PLACE: Commission Chambers
100 E. Boynton Beach Boulevard
Boynton Beach, Florida
TIME: 7:00 P.M.
DATE: Tuesday, July 27, 1999
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING
AGENDA
Request to amend the Land Development Regulations,
Chapter 2. Zoning, Section 4.f to allow for administrative
approval to increase the maximum height of a single family
home from 25feet to 30 feet.
DESCRIPTION:
Woody H. Freise, NCARB
APPLICANT:
Height Increase (Single Family Structures)
PROJECT:
2.
Request to amend the Land Development Regulations,
Chapter 2. Zoning, Section 5.C to include day care as an
allowable use within the R-1AA zoning district.
DESCRIPTION:
Scott and Catherine Freeland
APPLICANT:
Day Care in R-1-AA Zoning District
PROJECT:
1.
Code Review - LDR Te.xt Amendment
A. CODE AMENDMENT
7. New Business:
DESCRIPTION: Request new site plan approval to construct a 15,104 square
foot industrial/warehouse building on 1.099 acres.
LOCATION: 161 Commerce Road, Lot 4 High Ridge Park
AGENT: Richard C. Ahrens, Ahrens Companies
The Morris Building
PROJECT:
2.
DESCRIPTION: Request new site plan approval to construct a 220,184
square foot retail store on 39.61 acres.
Northwest corner of Winchester Park Boulevard and Boynton
Beach Boulevard
LOCATION:
J. Robert Bray, Assistant Vice President of Real Estate
Wal*Mart Stores East, Inc.
APPLICANT:
Kevin M. Roberson, Kimley-Horn & Associates
AGENT:
Wal*Mart Supercenter
PROJECT:
1.
New Site Plan
B. SITE PLANS
Page 2
Planning and Development Board Meeting
Ag~nda July 27, 1999
; ~
J:\SHRDATAIPLANNINGISHAREDlWP\AGENDASIP&D 111999 P&D AGENDASI7-27-99.DOC
xc: Central File
~Y PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION OF THE PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD WITH RESPECT TO ~Y MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING
WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS ~D FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE. WHICH RECORD
INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY ~D EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. (F.S.286.0105)
ALL ITEMS WHICH ARE NOT PUBLIC HEARING, WILL GO FORTH TO THE CITY COMMISSION AS CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS.
THE CITY SHAlL FURNISH APPROPRIATE AUXILIARY AIDS AND SERVICES WHERE NECESSARY TO AFFORD ~ INDMDUAl WITH A DISABILITY ~ EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO
PARTICIPATE IN ~D ENJOY THE BENEFITS OF A SERVICE. PROGRAM. OR ACTMTY CONDUCTED BY THE CITY. PLEASE CONTACT JOYCE COSTELLO. (561) 742-0013 AT LEAST
TWENTY (24) HOURS PRIOR TO THE PROGRAM OR ACTIVITY IN ORDER FOR THE CITY TO REASONABLE ACCOMMODATE YOUR REQUEST.
NOTICE
10. Adjournment
9. Comments by members
None
8. Other
Page 3
Planning and Development Board Meeting
Ag~nda July 27, 1999
. ..
6.A.1
APPEALS
COMMUNITY DESIGN PLAN APPEAL
WAL*MARTSUPERCENTER
,
Knuth Road and Winchester Park Boulevard are listed in Section 11.J of Chapter 9 -
Community Design Plan of the City's Land Development regulations, with those other roads
along which building elevations fronting these streets shall not display overhead doors. Due to
the high degree of visibility, these roads are within areas which the City desires closer
architectural scrutiny and higher standards.
BACKGROUND
The proposed Wal-Mart Supercenter will be a building totaling more than 220,000 square feet
and will contain a large variety of commercial activity. To continue its operational efficiency
requirements, and to move such large quantities of merchandise, the applicant states that it is
necessary to have the overheads doors on the east and west facades.
Todd J. Howder of Kimley - Horn and Associates, Inc., agent for Wal-Mart Stores East, Inc.,
owner of the property located between Old Boynton Road and Boynton Beach Boulevard, and
between Knuth Road and Winchester Boulevard, (see Exhibit "A" - Location Map), is
requesting approval of a Community Design Plan appeal to allow overhead doors, located on
the elevations of the proposed commercial building, that face Knuth Road and Winchester
Park Boulevard, (see Exhibit "B" - Proposed Elevations).
NATURE OF REQUEST
SUBJECT: Wal-Mart Supercenter - CDPA 99-001
(overhead doors)
DATE: June 17, 1999
TO: Chairman and Members
Planning and Development Board
jJ(c;--fC__
FROM: Michael W, Rumpf
Planning and Zoning Director
Staff Report
For
Planning and Development Board and
City Commission
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
MEMORANDUM NO. PZ99-153
2
S:\Planning\SHAREDlWP\PROJECTS\Wal Mart\ZNCV WALMARTiSTAFF REPORT doc
xc: Central File
The proposed overhead doors should receive adequate screening from the combination of
wall and landscaping treatments proposed by the applicant and recommended by staff.
Therefore, staff recommends approval of this request, subject to the conditions of approval
included in Exhibit "E". The conditions of approval are also included as conditions of site plan
approval which is being reviewed concurrently with this request.
RECOMMENDATIONS
To further screen potential views to the overhead doors, staff recommends that the proposed
wall along Winchester Park Boulevard be extended westward to the corner of the building
extended southward, dense landscaping additions be placed along both sides of the
southeast driveway, and additional canopy trees be placed along the southeast wall to reduce
the proposed spacing width. It is noteworthy that the overhead doors are over 380 feet from
the westernmost right-of-way of Winchester Park Boulevard, and 560 feet from the
easternmost right-of-way of Knuth Road. Distance, along with proper screening including
walls and landscaping will minimize the degree of visibility and impacts upon the subject
right's-of-way. (see Exhibit "0" - Landscape Plan).
In order to minimize views to overhead doors, Wal-Mart proposes to appeal this requirement,
and proposes to construct six-foot high masonry stucco walls along Winchester Park
Boulevard and east of the wet detention pond along Knuth Road (see Exhibit "C" - Proposed
site plan and screening walls). The screen walls will be designed similar to the wall behind the
Sports Authority to maximize consistency and minimize aesthetic impact. The project will also
include a wall extending eastward from the building along the south side of the eastern
loading area.
In order to comply with these requirements, all docking bays would have to be relocated to the
rear of the building. This relocation cannot occur without reducing the size of the parking area,
and undergoing a complete interior redesign moving the entire building northward. In
addition, the multi-functional commercial complex design is dictated by operational
requirements to meet the efficiency standards for this type of business. This limits the design
flexibility, as it relates to reconfiguration of design schemes.
This analysis first focused on necessity for the appeal, then on impact and mitigation
measures.
ANAL YSIS
Page 2
Memorandum No. PZ99-153
WalMart-overhead doors
CDPA PZ99-001
LOCATION MAP'=XHIBfT
WAL *MART
, :rJ~~1
~c~~.. ~~~.
- :... - ----..-- [ - --
-/ i ~ :'.
( . / ,"
I :1 I ~
(I 3 I L..!
_.r-~- I I n
I "80':-:1 ~ .
. Y"fTO~aeACH 11__~~
I I .' I I r;:~~~"
. ~ ....l ___I '.j r
.;L
_. __J _
l ~ ~"!~l -" I
~+:'''''' __ -:I' ~ \ ~
: ~-*,~'. ~. .
/"'" .
\
\,?~'
" '~
\I ,
I
\~ II
'\' '.
" \:
~. .
\.
\',
L
\:
t:
\.
\\
....J
)
,
/
R1AA
r
-- I- \
I -:
: /
--- --.-J.. ',.' ---
...~\ -':'"
. .
. '
, ;
, ,
,
\
A
"1
I '
'-~ . so
j l_ ~_-w
1 c:~N~l...
1,--- ",
: i--- _ ._- L_....l.
')
; ~-- ./
. ----/ ~,,-
\~'-
'~,~)]~3: llC1
ll~~l =
~\
~\
11),
\1'
1(\
"'l~\
l <: I
........... C'
\J
j
'i .,./
1\-sSITE
,
- I'
i._ - . .
__, . _, ( 7.' -")III" ,. -
. -j. I ,I j
, '
. L . '. .m." I
. . l~ ,:r. r' f
. I. ..::. --,
.: .,. t" ~ ,1, .
.1-; ,I.:.
.~. .. L . I. l l. .
. "_ I' \..'1.1' \,,-,
I .
- ~I l! . . ',' 1 "
_ \, ____f:,.r..,J..~~.,... ... ...
------, ~":h' ~-("""7.ff~~lln-1
.. ' I ' .
-- . i. . "I ~: J q I
--J..-", . . . .- t
_' .~.-"-l.~ .ll r
_ .1)0'.
I . " 'I' I
_' --I. . . I .. ,.
, I:" I .:' I
\ "1 L '"'''1 'i '\
\, I
- ',""T~ , -I. I: I
i . ' .' ~ : \ :;1 '
. I .,
"'''''''--
. T--; "t-f".,........... . t
. ~ : .~: ; ~~ ~ ~...; . ;-,~ I, ~L~'ljj ~:ULJ'
, I: . j.. .' ..' I. .. '1l .
\ \ , . - \....- . r<'- . . \ , .'. --:;
. ..-~ 1 r ' I I' 1 1 . 1 .
-1 \ q
.; . I . I j .
.... .' ..... .
'"
II iiI II ~ IIF.~I oo@oooo II lllll!q/ i 1'!!11l\1' ! I
:g @ j: .,' \-. I )
I[ !!i1il 11 ~ I II 'j ~ . I I I'! II , ~ !U Il "
"il"l! ~I! 1 r ~ !Il~i~ I q ~ ~ I I -, I i;l ~ HI
I. 1 "." ".-..-..~. , 1
II lb:i! I f! ~ ~ i \ · H t H... q H t t ,II ~I 1'" 1'"
.. r 0 ,." . ~
;. Hi ~ ~ !I"'j ~ I i~' ~! L1
.~ '" 0 ~ 11 ..: In. .
"" ~ ~ ~1I11. .. 1 :1' ~;'ii' ~i"t'ti'a .
. r-
l> I ;~~~ i Ul liiU! : : I ~ . ~; ~ ~ to ~ ~!; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..
,W 0'.. .H;
n
~i
'" 'j I
~t >;' ,\ j 11\ H
, Ii; + ! 111.". l4
Ii,
Ji II ~
l' at~1 1\ n' :~', :11
I" "'~"ts" I.
t . "'"..1 JA ~ - I~,
r.ii ~'';' I . I ~~
H
,.
EXHJBIT ','B'~
t 1:
~I "i
~I~ 'I
~ ~ 1i
(I it
~ I'
~ '-.....
2
"
,J::..
:1;:1
...
~1I
~
:1
2
H n
,. !.
l~
.~ 1\~ H
;l~ nil~~jj'
~ I..
,. 1-:'
e:';j ..-.";; j
r-'
t-.J
~I~
q
II
~
~
2
g
,"
-+
'!\i
J
~ ~;
"
, ~
_/~
,-
a':
!l
lJ.)
'\ffl
IIJl
\ ...
m
r-
m
<
J>
...
~
Ul
.~
:'
C),~t
a
~nf:t . filIi PIp'
a r -8 I. .
ll:T . ~ .-
'l'll: ill II.
1~~'~WIri~ Ii rr !~
I
"0
:0
o
cg
r.J)
m
00)
~:i
<-
~~
Jl~
:;~
~r-
Z
-4
""""
--
""""
WAL- 1olAft1'. IlO'INRlN EAal CEl. PUlMlA
NO. 27IHlIl.... Be lC-2llI<<IL-<llJ
P'ALIoI EAal COlMY, fUII'IDA
WNCt&lBI ~
CD
UJ
SITE PlAN
"fij! . ~ ,. 'I'll ~
I.. I ' . ~ . I.' ".. !II
it ).: . i,' 0
J II' ~~; !.'~;: :.' :.U 8 ,\ i'lll.....' ..~ ~
II' 11 :.i'.. II~ 'i I~ ~
_ ~ " _ '1 I ',.. . ~ _ I J i ~
I;
ft. ,i
&~
~.,..~ ~i I~r::.l J g ='J~' T
_.~::;::---=;:. ;J ~~ ......<...~~.._'V~...t . . ~ II ~
& II ~-- --..-.-...::::--.....-..- "". . -- i ~
--~------ .-~-.------.---._-- !Ill ---- :
:~e:t.:Z_-=--=~~I! ,,~~ ~ ,,_~,~~_,<<_~, _____' I:~I
l-1..._~:.;..:::~..... .---.:> ~,PMI.a'lD i~
ZoHED PCD --=~.- - ~tJ '"~-------=--===-----::::~ li~
-------..::.:.-~ 8: (708' NWJ - r ~
ILAHD U$E - Lilt: ----=;.~ . ::::::::...-....:...-.:-_:-:_-;:~~:_;:.=::::.:=:::==::::=::~ _ _ _ _ _ __
~ I (
~ i' i!: ,Thl
~ \ \1 :ill
. ". i!!:
ill~ ~
illl.....~
:.;i~
I il :~!
: I'
I'" ri'
Ii... :' !
d.:h
_I . . '._ "". . '. L~._ ~..\' ~ 1
. ,};. :,or.'- .- _. _'_ _ __ '
-:.'~' ",.-.,". :~I
, 'r-
~I r~ filS ~
~ ~t~ !'tC::~
.! "'~ml
! ;ii~ ti
I ,!i I ""
: :t\ "
~ r1 :'lr- @a
. :I~
/'--"'\ III :il~
r . : i ' :1,
\} : :
"---/ II
-<~~
I l.x
r .'~.
-~'i
()
-
-
-
-
m
X
:c
-
to
-
--I
iil!i:iljll. !hill'li~j & ::ilii Ii. rl:;I.tlilll
I~ ;'1',' Iii ~ 'I!I U. ,l ee! .'."1
'~r,l: A,'.' ~la.IJ II 'I_II; II rll a'l
II' I'J ;!,I' 'tell "'.'1 !!: I~'
;. JI,I.-.!Iilll ;. .1 Ii:! Ii ,! i ,~il
_, . ~IIJ li..~U J ~~i; ii' i ! i 151
ill I!II!!; ~ilhl! il' !Iii III i i II ! i
I II I!a' 11111 I ~ I .1....1.11
:1 Ii lei: ! i~l;i n !i I ermsUi
Ii Ip ii ! Ulh :1 I i
ZO/FIED FCD
LAND U$E - DC
U:!!lfmr II! II II 1i1il
Aat~I'I:OI! 'Ii "oezl: i
,~II a- I P 11:.-
~!~~~~~IM ~i~ !m:; , !
I: : i ; ! i; ': '~Iii',.
j~~!#f:i~! 1_, 'I!! i [
.iU!I!Qil.! I ;!,!! i ,
,mlllfIU! :ii!!,,!:
.......... ,., """?'
mll~11II m ~:~fl.~
iiiiiiiii; ~ &u; 6
mm~~u I !
iiE'
/"
+!; " , e -to ~ . ife 0
:; I
". "-j' .-l
~()I~I5D Affl
PROP06ED C#
LAND 8J6E - DC .____.....0
~.;::::::::~~~:~;.=.-~~::~.;~~::~::::~~~-.-_._~-.-~:=::::~=~:::::::=~~.-::.-:::-:.::~._--....--
" .. . , , ...ft "",=,,_,:,rz ')
~fg?"i'
fI "j J
..
l~ i
.~ :
~ s
~
!
(Q
.~~:::~~.h.~',: iLfi1if:t..
.':.1;'
n {r1
ji III
i< !['3;1',
...,.
...
...
~ ~.,~'::,;~~"." ...t;-.:.
'LANoscAf'e'f;UN
.~''''.~.'=1~.!: :-- '.~.~::.
_~M. .s
,,;.Tt:"
...,.
~'" ...
"..r.
:111;
,
i
o
-~~i~~~:_---~I'i
...
J Ii
h I h
~ .J ~
{<.
l!J
~
.
iil
,II
*f<
~ .
~,
"c;ill:oo .
::0" r:-; ",
"c l!' . I;.' ..
C'~" ii: "
,~ :1>.
~3 ~
~ ~
! I~ .11.'1"" '1.
0 ,I ~ . RI
III !~ .J
'I . ~__@' -
,I . --
I I~ I
:
I . I
'B
=
....
~
Aa.e.
Xx f
. =
... . ..... ..~ I,. o. ~. ::: " ~ .
'10 '. '.: .... h~ iHI"-'
I; ". ( .-'-'~.,j Ie iO 'J .
... J.... t ,'0 0 ~.. ....ij ~ ,.
!~ .:' '...' I .;~'f'" ,.;:h ~~i) .,' ,'~
ii .'.. ;;lo~~ell ,
. * ,;::CS' 0;;1'"
~ ", ., " e"~ p~ .
I I ' ~ e~ij .
, - - I . ~ ~ ij .
. ,1 . . jl~ 2 1:
.6 ..,..." Jnl ~~'i
',j .. .' :. .' '~lI ~
~ .' ~' _' ~;1
-:: .. rII
~ ~BJI'IBI
r(<x f< rx(<
i i ti .
X
i
(< ,.; r
q<r
c
-j
g.
~~
~.
~;,!~:.;;,,;, .
. '
:i ;~.
-.
'."...
':.....~7': ;,;.' .~..'"".
;;.[
KJo;IU'fH ~
_--!~_._.__.___.._~__4___".___.,.d,.~___..~____~
EXHIBIT "0"
'l
---- -
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS
Comments: N/R
UTILITIES
Comments: N/R
FIRE
Comments: N/R
POLICE
Comments: N/R
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: N/R
.
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments: N/R
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: N/R
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST
Comments: N/R
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments:
1. All proposed six-foot high screening masonry wall shall ensure
architectural design compatibility with adjacent Boynton Commons
PCD structures.
2. All landscape material shall comply with City of Boynton Beach
landscape regulations and create dense foliage to achieve a continuos
visual screen.
3. Add canopy trees along approximately 100 feet of the West buffer wall
(west side) immediately opposite west side overhead bay doors. This is
required to properly screen doors from view in connection with
concurrent approval request. Also reduce perimeter buffer tree spacing
to 20 feet along approximately a 100 feet portion of the buffer located
west of the west side overhead bay doors.
Project: Wal*Mart Supercenter
File number: CDPA 99-001
Reference: A letter ofreauest dated Mav 18-'. 1999.
Conditions of Almroval
EXHIBIT "E"
?
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
4. Buffer wall on east side shall be extended westward along the north side
of the L.W.D.D. easement approximately to the southeast corner of the
building extended south; or be placed long the south side of the
southeast entrance and extend to some western extent.
5. To provide screening of the overhead bay doors that face east, provide
landscaping along the north and south sides ofthe southeast entrance.
Landscaping should include hedge, ornamentals and canopy trees. Or
replace south side landscaping with buffer wall relocated from perimeter
buffer and extend to southeast corner of building extended south.
6. Add additional canopy trees to east side buffer, south of southeast
entrance to decrease spacing to 20 feet and increase visual buffer. This
is r~quired to properly screen overhead doors from view in connection
with concurrent appeal request.
7. Extend western buffer wall south to landscape buffer and eastward
toward southwest end of building extended south. This is required to
properly screen doors from view in connection with .concurrent appeal
request.
ADDITIONAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS
8. To be determined.
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS
9. To be determined.
Page 2 of2
Wal*Mart Supercenter
CDPA 99-001
9
City Clerk
J:\SHRDA T A\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Wal Mart\CDPA WALMART\Develop Order CC 7 -6-99.doc
DATED:
7. Other
6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms
and conditions of this order.
5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk.
4. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby
-1L GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof.
DENIED
3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or
suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set
forth on Exhibit "D" with notation "Included".
established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested.
2. The Applicant
-1L HAS
HAS NOT
1. Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with
the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations.
THIS MA TIER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton
Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the
relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative .
staff and the public finds as follows: . .
OR
X THIS MATTER came before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida
appearing on the Consent Agenda on the date above. The City Commission hereby adopts the
findings and recommendation of the Planning and Development Board, which Board found as follows:
DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "C" ATTACHED HERETO.
TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Community Design Plan Appeal
LOCATION OF PROPERTY: Northwest Corner of Winchester Park Boulevard. & Boynton Beach
Boulevard
DATE OF HEARING BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: July 7, 1999
APPLICANT'S AGENT: Todd J. Howder, Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 601 21st Street, Suite 400
DEVELOPMENT ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
PROJECT NAME: Wal*Mart