LEGAL APPROVAL
MEETING MINUTES
SPECIAL PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
JUNE 25, 1996
Knuth Road PCD Major Site Plan Modification for Signage
- This board's recommendation regarding curved tops for all
signs and substituting Sign Band 0 to lower the size of the
sign was approved by the City Commission.
Discussion Item Relating to Telecommunications'
Ordinance - This Ordinance was scheduled for second
reading at the last City Commission meeting. It is being
readvertised and will be back before the City Commission on
July 2.
With regard to this item, the Planning and Development Board discussed the possibility of
a half-mile radius or a one-mile radius between poles. Ms. Heyden mapped this, and
found that a one-mile radius was very, very large. Her recommendation is for as half-mile
radius.
Mr. Aguila questioned whether when it was mapped out, there would still be room for a
"toothpick factory". Ms. Heyden responded that there are a lot of sites, but this use is
subject to conditional use approval. The sites are scattered and some are as close a one-
quarter mile apart.
6. OLD BUSINESS:
None
7. NEW BUSINESS:
A. SUBDIVISION
Master Plan Modification
1.
Project:
Location:
Quantum Park PIO
West side of the intersection of Interstate 95 and
Gateway Boulevard
James Willard. Shutts & Bowen
Quantum Associates
Request to amend the previously-approved PIO master
plan in connection with an amendment to the DRI to
add 13.17 acres (the PCD Center subdivision) to the
PIO boundaries and change the use designation from
office to commercial/Industrial use, add the option of
commercial use to the existing use designated for lots
65A, 65B,66, 67A, 67B, 67C, 68A, 68B, 69,70,72,
Agent:
Owner:
Description:
3
MEETING MINUTES
REGULAR CITY COMMISSION
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
JUNE 18, 1996
comments except rejecting Comment #18 to allow for 40' right-of-way, including all other
staff comments and including the Planning and Development Board conditions. Vice
Mayor Jaskiewicz seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
D. PROJECT:
AGENT:
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
Knuth Road PCD
Kieran Kilday, Kilday and Associates
Bill Winchester, The Winchester Family Partnership, Ltd.
Southwest corner of Boynton Beach Boulevard and Knuth
Road intersection
MAJOR SITE PLAN MODIFICATION: Request for PCD sign
program approval
Kieran Kildav. Kildav and Associates. advised tha~ this application is strictly for signage.
The conditions, as amended by the Planning and Development Board, are acceptable to
the applicant. He reminded +he Commissioners that the applicant made one modification
at the Planning and Development Board meeting which was agreed to by everyone.
Ms. Heyden had no comments to offer.
Motion
Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz moved to approve the request for PCD sign program approval for
the Knuth Road, Winchester Family Partnership, Ltd., southwest corner of Boynton Beach
Boulevard and Knuth Road intersection, including all staff comments and Planning and
Development Board conditions. Commissioner Tillman seconded the motion which carried
u nan imously.
E. PROJECT:
AGENT:
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
Casual Male - Big and Tall at Oakwood Square
Joseph P. Braga
J. Baker. Inc. .
Southeast corner of Old Boynton Road and Congress Avenue
Request for an administrative appeal to allow color changes
for the exterior wall and canopy of the southern-most
outbuilding at Oakwood Square
Chuck Foltz, contractor for the project, advised that Mr. Braga was unable to be present
this evening. He advised that the existing building is dark pink with a green awning. The
applicant proposes a yellow canopy with a gray building. These are the corporate colors
of Casual Male. Staff recommended retaining the green awning and repainting the building
with a softer pink. Because thiS is a men's shop, the applicant would like to eliminate the
pink building. Mr. Foltz said the applicant is open to anything the Commission would like
done.
22
MEEnNG MINUTES
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
JUNE 11, 1996
Estates PUD, subject to staff comments with the following exceptions:
Comment #27 be deleted, and Comment #28 read that the exterior driveway
be 20' and that the comment (Comment #24) about the meeting hall versus
the pool in relationship to the road remain as per Sheet SP 1 of our submittal
package. (In other words, that the meeting hall building be adjacent to the
road was opposed to the pool area.)
Mr. Wische seconded the motion.
Mr. Rosenstock requested that the following comments be transcribed verbatim. "I think
its improper for the members of this board to vote on an issue, as much as we might want
to approve it or disapprove it, when you have 52 comments that are going to be bargained
for by the Engineering and Planning Departments without the knowledge, and beyond the
scope of this board. I'd like to see these items resolved before they come to this board in
the future. We've asked for this twice now, and it seems to me that its getting worse, and
not better, and my comments on my sheet that I'm going to give to the City Manager are
that maybe we ought to reinstitute the TRB so that all of these issues, or most of these
issues are resolved before they come to a board for approval or disapproval."
Ms. Heyden advised that approximately four or five years ago, the TRB had the authority
to hold back plans if there were voluminous comments. We no longer have that authority.
We have to pass on plans within a certain number of days of submittal.
Mr. Rosenstock feels that this is precisely the reason why the TRB should be reinstituted.
However, Mr. Aguila pointed out that part of the problem that existed when the TRB was
functioning was that there were certain staff members abusing this process, and projects
were indefinitely postponed.
The motion carried 6-1. (Mr. Rosenstock cast the dissenting vote.)
MIJor Site Plan Modification
2.
Project:
Agent:
Owner:
Location:
Description:
Knuth Road PCD
Kieran Kilday, Kilday and Associates
Bill Winchester, The Winchester Family Partnership, Ltd.
Southwest corner of Boynton Beach Boulevard and
Knuth Road intersection
Request for PCD sign program approval.
Kieran Kildav. Kildav and Associates. agreed to all conditions with the exception of Item
#9 which deals with the number of signs.
18
MEETING MINUTES
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
JUNE 11, 1996
Mr. Kilday displayed the plan which depicted the site. Along Boynton Beach Boulevard,
on the north side of the property at the primary entrance to the project, there are plans for
two signs. One of the signs will be a shopping center sign, and the second will be a
monument sign identifying the south parcel which is planned for a bank. The third sign
(Amoco sign) is located on the corner. Along Knuth Road, at the northern entrance, there
will be two signs. One sign is a shopping center sign, and the second sign is an Amoco
sign on the north side of the entrance. The last sign is a shopping center sign at the south
entrance. The applicant is willing to reduce the Amoco sign on Knuth Road to a monument
sign, but would like to retain the six signs as shown.
Vice Chairman Golden explained that he does not have a problem with the sign program
submitted; however, he will vote no because he has a problem with the original rezoning.
Motion
Mr. Wische moved to approve the request for PCD sign program approval for Knuth Road
PCD on the southwest corner of Boynton Beach Boulevard and Knuth Road intersection,
subject to staff comments, and eliminating Comment #9 as amended by Mr. Kilday. Mr.
Aguila seconded the motion.
Mr. Aguila confirmed with ~r. Kilday that this sign program can change with the bank and
cross access arrangement. However, Mr. Kilday pointed out that he will come back in for
site plan approval on the bank.
The motion carried 5-2. (Vice Chairman Golden and Mr. Rosenstock cast the dissenting
votes.)
C. OTHER
Discussion
1. Change to the zoning code to add communication towers as a
conditional use In the REC (Recreation and PU (Public Usage) zoning
chtrIcta and prohibit In all other districts.
Chairman Dube was of the opinion that this change would result in not being able to put
towers on anything but City property. Ms. Heyden responded negatively. She said
approximately one-third of the REC and Public Usage zoned properties are other than City-
owned. The School Board, FPL, and DOT own some of this property.
Chairman Dube questioned whether or not this would present a problem. He referred to
the Congress Middle School property where the satellite dish is located. The City is unable
to do anything to improve the looks of that property.
19
%e City of
r:Boynton r:Beacfi
100 'E. 'Boynton 'Bead.. 'Bou1.evartf
P.O. 'Bo;c310
'Boynton 'BUJCh., 1foritfa 33425-0310
City 9iaf[: (407) 375-6000
:FJU: (407) 375-6090
July 3, 1996
Marcie W. Tinsley
Kilday and Associates, Inc.
1551 Forum Place, #100A
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Re: Knuth Road PCD
File No: MSPM 96-004
Location: Southwest corner of Boynton Beach Boulevard
and Knuth Road intersection
Dear Ms. Tinsley,
Enclosed is the City of Boynton Beach Development Order regarding
the above captioned, for relief sought to amend the previously
approved site plan.
Should you have any questions concerning this matter, please feel
free to contact this office at (561) 375-6260.
S~in:erelY' '9-Y4L
..1 ", ~ 'J
~./:Z-7PIU. , , /.;/.
Tarnbri J. Heyden
Planning and Zoning Director
TJH:dar
Enclosures
xc: Central File
a:develord.knu
;Irrrerial's (jattway to tfu (jutfstream.
DEVELOPMENT ORDER
OF THE
CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
C:!~: ~.~~.
p~--,.
lli ~ :~;:~
PLANNING ANI)
ZONING DEPT.
l
APPLICANT: KNUTH ROAD PCD
APPLICANTS AGENT: Kiernan Kildav. Kildav and Associates. acent for Bill Winchester.
The Winchester Familv Partnership. Ltd.. Owner
DATE OF HEARING BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: June 18.1996
TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Reauestinc approval of a sicn procram for the Knuth Road
PCD.
LOCATION OF PROPERTY: southwest comer of Bovnton Beach Boulevard and Knuth
Road intersection
DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "8..." ATTACHED HERETO.
TH IS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of
Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having
considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant,
members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows:
1 . Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner
consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations.
2. The Applicant
~HAS
HAS NOT
established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested.
3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative
staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as
set forth on Exhibit ".k.." with the notation "Included".
4. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby
X GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3
hereof.
DENIED
5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk.
6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the
terms and conditions of this order.
7.
Other: N()lVt
DATED: June 18. 1996
~~L4c~~ ~
C:devord.frm
r1lII.112419ll
Knuth Road PCD(6/17Ill6)
"
I
o
II
.,.1
)>
..... ..
itl )l .....
I.
:. - ' . ,
- . J
,,, ,~~I'- C"
'1'1 -'"
OJ
\.0
.11 0
III
III. .
-I ~
o
o
(.)
rJ
o
o
.l~ : i
\i \i _' n\~ 1
.~~ \t\t'N~k\l. \1 t!
_ JJ~ -U 1'~\
. ~. \ ,1
~. \,'
. ""." '0>"'''''' oe.C~ "LID 5< 00. J .. -----
, ..~:.~tr==iij~~"O-:;:;;; ':=nr~"\~,\: .. -=~-- i':"! ii: If
IL-\. 1\~~1n~f~if11C~' : l~;'~~~ W"": ~lf~j\ 'l\
.! ,i - . ". " I · I""
. .L ..:)-' .. - \,
~ ....... ' \II t ; , iJ~ , -et[!. . :i I ;
, I .- II '\'
. \ u- n:e~ .";.~ ; ~ I. ': ~\d...:r I
~' 'lOT ~ ~) '." \" l' ..
, 1 -
~ _ _ "'I- LJ;lUU.;);f' \ ' -
, ,~ ,tl hi ~' q : = : ,~~ il~ : \ \ \ ~'}\ II ~J ~ ~ :. ~ i \ \ -
"",;- 'q ';1 eo I".. : :; =" =,\.\l j ~/
,__:..--: ", ~~.~ \= =\ ,~ ~E ~\ 3 ~~. ~~ ~ I\~ ~'-~rn
1 0 t= _ .- :::l ~ - ~ E - ,I I' M" Q
\ . r- _.\ . :::: -l:= -=., -3" -- ::; E - II ... (0
,il t:::::l " ." .. ., ...... I .. =:l" ... ..'
,Ij I-::.t . .;::: =:1-= -' E:::..l :1:, ~,' -,'"
" ,. ,.. '=,," _, ,,,.... =:\'_ _ ::j ,," _, ,r,
It ,I i,i \~ '.\i, ~
) ,. .I!O:: t:,. I \ I
:;" 'H Iii : 1 : = =\ lC ::IF "'1\ oci:: =::: I = \:\ 'I ;.\1
;~l!) i U l\ \\ \ '\ = / ~\ / ' ~, ~~ ~, ~~ ~ ~ ~, r~ ~. \\' ! iil
it~; " I , ,,"" ,-- ~" ~ L \: \ \- -
\ i 1!.I" " / .. - - .
:\! ..'~ it i \ :& &\ \ " I I . _.1 "~' \ \ i' ,v./1
" , illi Ii .. - -' .. ." ',,' ..." 1 ." "
~\ I \\ li ,!; \ j q~ .L~... _.- ..:.:\~~!~" ~it\~
: ": il " - "ll "" 1. -. ~~ . \ \1. ,::.. ~~ ~~,
r """. . . ., ;. :~l\ \' , Ii' \ II \\!,ij ..
,. I"\;:'~" ." \
. '< .r i ..'''.. ~ I · Ilf ,I \
. . . =" c ' ";
L ..'" ! -~.\ .~.,,\! 'l\.I-I;,I:~\\.~ lL!'tr,.,q"l'lU.1H \ 1.\1 \ \
--r--- _.-.._.-.~;::~,~'-~' \. u.u , )~ I~ .
_ _ _ _ _ . _ . ~._. _ _ _ _ r-~.. I
I.,' Iii :, !; I; n ....... ....n.'- . ,:! <.. I ,\ 't '
~;\\ ; \ Pii\l~iJ\ \~;~~i~~!~.~ :~"\'~i41 ~\\l~~~\!in! ~_il!j "'-jii<li.\iij)'\ \~~\' t~ \"
I'"~ ~. ~ ;.- \~\ t' ..~'- ~i \:\ '\' ~\\\i\I\,\\\j\\\i\l~ .~~.~.\ .~..ht~"~~\'-'~-' !tl~'~
~ .,e' . t " \" \.! \. \' "'\ \~'\ \\\l~ ... nil. \.1\ I ... . .~q.. 0
....', ~ "",\ I~ .!Il," .! "..,. ,,:- \: ., ,. .':.. \ lit " Mt\: ,l' ~Qlli \1"
..... 10:[1 '"d. ",.5 \~~~J' . \ \ \.1..\;." I. 1.:ftS I
;~~'~i 'I~\i"; ,"", "'It\'.~" =, 'I'ltl ~. 'l,t' ',I 'itHI.' 1~ I t-
H l~l ",.,~ . I'~~ i' :;:; l;..-i I \'" ,\",.;' ,;" ~s i I
f. . . .. ,~_ 'IC\ I \ ., I . . !!.. ' /I
~~t~... I~ \1,. \ ;-'\ .. , .,' \";2' ;:;:: 'J ~ -.; - -\-; ~ _t t~ ~
cni~ II ::\,,\.)11"'\ ':..': ,i' "-'" ,I I II" ,,,' "..' I ;
i :.- , ~ . - .... -..:, \ \';. ..:::. \. · . ..... - -
! .. !. ll' I Ii ~ ~; .! '\ \.:" ", r..1 .... \\\n-
U~I II ~ :::..j! \ II 'l'..l! \ \\i!if'\i~\ l~t1! ~
:: 1111.\1 \\1\\1 r \!.\' f
~' ....., : II "..' ~ \ I:' ~ \~l~'fh"'; \j'\ ~
.1 n...1 I' H i\;' \~ i ~h! ~~:.&J 'II
e \\\ \~l i. \ \
1r.
Q\!Q
~~
-+-~--
~ t, ~ 9.
~
~
m
::
~
~.
(1\ \0
I. ) . -
\': " n l! , G
II' '0 · · \I I ·
~ ,8t5~
Q. i1\~
I
.~
.. (.
i
..
l
I
l'"~~~ . s
~,..allr~
\,10 ".. ld.i..IlIl1U1-
't .. "t., 1'0 IJl,:.J l-
I'~lh ~.\r.I.UIIUI.--
t Ih\laOl.t WjCl..l.lJA.. -
"'hrrl n' _.---lo
IlNUTII ROAD P.C.D.
80'Vtt'fON 8t:ACII rLonlllA
~ASltR =IG"...t:t 1'1I\lIOH.\'"
K"dQ) " ...ocla'"
lon"'OO' ArChll.th/!"''''''''
\J~' 't.'m '1...
"",~:f Jt)I?'~ a,oe'" 'Ic,htn 3)-"0'
14011 6119-SS:; .. Q...O' I 6e~. :~i.
~~J
(\
I" II
.-
/JA"-- ?
EXHIBIT "e"
Conditions of Approval
Project name: Knuth Road PCD
File number: MSPM 96-004
Reference:The plans consist of 1 sheet identified as 1st Review.
Major Site Plan Modification. File * MSPM 96-004 with a May 20.
1996 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking.
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS
Comments: NONE
UTILITIES
Comments: NONE
1. Proposed utility easements are not x
shown. No structures or footers are
permitted in utility easement~
(Sec.26.33(a)).
FIRE
Comments: NONE
POLICE
Comments: NONE
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: NONE
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments:
1. Sign "B" is not consistent with the x
design of the rest of the shopping
center signs.
2 . All signs shall meet setbacks to the x
ultimate right-of-way (see Land
Development Regulations, Chapter 21
Signs, Article III, Section 5
Setbacks).
3. See definition, Land Development x
Regulations, Chapter 1, Article II
Definitions: Sign, Area of.
4 . Outparcels for gas station and bank x
have a maximum of 64 sq. ft. of
signage and the shopping center will
have a maximum of 160 sq. ft. of
signage.
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: NONE
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENTALIST
Comments: NONE
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments:
Page 2
Major Site Plan Modification
Knuth Road PCD
MSPM 96-004
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
5. From the site plan, eliminate the note x
regarding future sign color
determination for the shopping center.
The colors requested for approval are
red and blue in addition to white and
black and represent the maximum number
of colors allowed by the Community
Design Plan. Additional colors must
be granted by filing an appeal.
Indicate on the plan that black,
white, red and blue are the approved
sign colors for the PCD and the
remaining wall signage for the project
will comply with the regulations
identified in the Sign Code and
Community Design Plan of the city's
Land Development Regulations.
6. All signs, with the exception of sign x
type IIBII have round tops. In order to
unify signage, which is the purpose of
the sign program and the PCD, redesign
sign type IIBII to match the shape of
the remaining signs.
7 . Indicate setbacks of all signs and x
provide dimensions for these setbacks
from the ultimate right-of-way. All
setbacks should be a minimum of ten
(10) feet.
s. Show on the plan all existing and/or x
proposed easements within the PCD to
eliminate potential conflicts between
these easements and sign locations.
9. It is recommended that the number of x
freestanding signs be reduced from six
( 6 ) to four (4) , by combining signs
type D and C facing Boynton Beach
Boulevard and signs type Band C at
the Knuth Road entrance, since the
number of signs is excessive and
located closely together.
10. As required by the sign code, show on x
the permit drawings landscaping around
the base of all freestanding signs.
ADDITIONAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
CONDITIONS
1- Delete comment 9. x
2. Sign type B shall be redesigned to not x
exceed the size of sign type D.
3. All freestanding signs shall have x
curved tops.
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS
1- To be determined. KINE
TJH/dim
a: CmDptSig. Knu