AGENDA DOCUMENTS
PLANNING AND ZONING
LASERFICHE TEMPLATE
PROJECT NAME:
~I/ Su ftL IJ1 E IfJ !3r 'G V 7llLL
1}j)/l1;/lJ /)f?fJEI9'-
3~~}/, &AJ&ee$5
Il f)1l ~ r~- ()O ~
PROJECT TYPE:
PROJECT ADDRESS:
PROJECT NO.
PCN:
DOC TYPE:
(RIGHT CLICK FOR PULL DOWN MENU)
STATUS:
(RIGHT CLICK FOR PULL DOWN MENU)
to/lg/~0
~ 3 / ,'Zo/(
APPROVAL/STATUS DATE
DESTRUCTION DATE:
/
S :\Planning\Plan n ing\Laserfiche tem plate.doc
AGENDA
OOCU tJ\ E ",1"5
PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM NO. 96-319
Agenda Memorandum
for
June 18, 1996 City Commission Meeting
TO: Carrie Parker
City Manager
THRU: Tambrl J. Heyden
Planning and Zoning Director
FROM: Jerzy Lewicki
DATE: June 6, 1996
SUBJECT: Oakwood Square (Casual Male-Big and Tall tenant space) - ADAP 96-002
(modifications to the approved color scheme for southern outbuilding)
NATURE OF REQUEST
Joseph P. Braga, project manager for J. Baker Inc., owner of Casual Male - Big and Tall, is
requesting approval of an administrative appeal to staff's determination regarding proposed
changes to the facade of the Casual Male - Big and Tall outbuilding, the southern-most outbuilding
located within the Oakwood Square shopping center. More specifically, the petitioner is requesting
a color change of the building to employ their corporate colors. The following two color scheme
alternatives have been presented:
1. Building exterior - ,Light Grey (SW #2128)
Canopy - Yellow (SW #6174072)
2. Building exterior - Light Pink (to match shopping center)
Canopy - Yellow (SW #6174072)
(see Exhibit "A" - letter of request and proposed tenant space exterior elevation view drawings).
BACKGROUND
The Oakwood Square shopping center is located east of Congress A venue between Boyntoll Beach
Boulevard and Old Boynton Boulevard (see Exhibit "B" - Location Map).
The color scheme for the Oakwood Square was approved by the Community Appearance Board
on April 11, 1991 as follows:
a) main shopping center - medium pink (Bruning Paints, Spoon Sugar 840-2W),
b) out parcel buildings - light pink (Benjamin Moore Paints, Moore Guard 1-81289).
The Board also recommended that the yellow canopy of the northern-most outbuilding for one of
the existing tenants at that time (Perkins restaurant), be repainted to blue to match the existing,
blue, spanish tile roof of the main building. Subsequent to 1991, as part of tenant changes to the
middle outparcel buildings, the canopies for the two middle out parcel buildings were allowed to
be painted in stripes of red and white.
Staff's site visit conducted on June 7, 1996, revealed that over the last five years, since the color
scheme was approved, the consistency of the approved color scheme has been eroded by changes
that have not been approved by the city, which may not hove be~n detected p8 110 pet'mlt Is
rcquh'cd I'()I" mCI'e color chunges. l?or example, the color of the main shOI)ping center was changed
to off-white, both northern outparcel buildings were repainted light-pink and different colors
Page 2
Memorandum No. 96-319
(lakwood S(IUare (Big and Tall Casual Male)
ADAP 96~O()2
accents were added to both structures.
The subject outbuilding Is currently painted medium pink and has a dark green canopy (see
Exhibit C - elevation view drawings of the existing building facade).
ANALYSIS
Based on reylew of the proposed changes and field visits to the site, It Is staff's position that the
consistency of the approved color scheme be restored. The proposed light pink color of the
building matches the approved scheme for outbuildings, however, the yellow canopy does not. As
previously mentioned, at the April 11, 1991 meeting of the Community Appearance Board, the
noard members recommended that the approved color of the canopy of the northernmost
outparcel, Perkins Restaurant, be restored.
The letter of request submitted by the applicant (Exhibit II A ") and the phone conversations with
the representatives from Casual Male - Big and Tall indicate the following reasons for the
proposed changes:
a. colors as indicated in Alternative 1: building exterior - Light Grey (SW #2128) and
canopy - Yellow (SW #6174072) are the corporate colors of the company,
b. the medium pink color of the current structure is perceived as inappropriate for a mens
clothing store.
During a phone conversation with the petitioner, he indicated that he would be agreeable to
l'etaining the dark green color of the canopy, along with light pink or gray for the color ot' the
exterior walls, although this option was not included in any of the color alternatives presented to
the City.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Staff recommends approval of Alternative 2, which proposes light pink painted exterior walls, with
a modification that the canopy would be repainted darl{ green as it currently exists, or dark blue
to match the canopy color of the Clock restaurant. This proposal would allow the approved color
scheme to be restored.
JL:dim
xc: Central File
ll:\11I:&TlllI.llcl'
"
~
't,'.."
E X H I BIT
"A"
I
J. Bal(el., Inc.
,_-.~~-- 1-,-- ',.~._- ,~:-,'!-----:-~" ~..:
'~; ~ ,\1 :', ; 1 I
~ ~-~I'\V --I "-J .~~-: -"; It.
IU ,- ~.... ~
IS IS B T U III H .. I K. .,..... Ie T . C A H T 0 H, M A . 0 a 0 z , .. 7-82
May 9, 1996
Mr. Jerzy Lewicki
City of Boynton Beach
Planning & Zoning Department
100 East Boynton Beach BIV"d
Boynton Beach. PL 33425
407.375-6260
VIA: Regular Mail and Fax #407-375-6090
RE!: Casual Male-Big & Tall #9556
Oakwood Shopping Center
324 North Congress Ave.
Boynton Beach, FL 33426
Dear Mr. Lewicki,
I understand that the City of Boynton Beach has rejected the proposed colors for the
exterior of the building.
The colors that were proposed are the corporate Casual Male-Big & Tall colors that we use
in our stores nationwide.
I am aware that there is a certain criteria for the shopping center which consists of "medium
pink" and "light pink" colors.
The existing color of our building is the "medium pink" color and being a Men's Retail
Clothing Store, [ am requesting your approval to tone down the color to something that will
closer resemble our corporate image.
Please reView the following information and option :# 1 & #2 (color samples have been
submitted);
Existing Building Colors:
Entire Building Exterior - Medium Pink
Building Metal Canopy - Dark Green
Original Proposal (corporate Casual Male-Big & Tall colors):
Upper Building Exterior - Medium Grey (SW #2117 Touchstone)
Lower Building Exterior - Light Grey (SW #2128 March Wind)
Building Metal Canopy - Yellow (SW #6174072 Safety Yellow - B54-Y37)
Option #1:
Endr. Building Bxterior . Ught Orey (SW #2128 March Wind)
Note: TIll, "Ilaht gf.)''' color 18 almost "white" which i. very
Ilmllar to the "light pink" color in the shopping center.
Building Metal Canopy - Yellow (SW #6174072 Safety Yellow - B54.Y37)
Option #2:
Entire Building Exterior - Light Pink (shopping center color)
Building Metal Canopy. Yellow (SW #6174072 Safety Yellow. B54.Y37)
Please review and call me with your comments and/or approval.
Thanking you in advance for your cooperation in this matter.
Sincerely,
Joseph P. Braga
Project Manager
cc: Foltz Development & Construction
. ,: :;:~<":'"
,':.:'.:-....i:'
:'".~:;j'
;, ~';";
:;'~-':'
i,,~,<
".'~,:"
:~':
'::, "'-' -.:.
-
i
~,~
9.:;
5Z",
al:;e"-
~ r~ ~
E~fJ>
z"'....
UI
~
it
-
,
1\
:;::....
, ij
i., ~ :::
l>:.()
lU ~
iJi....
~
~
~
lr\
\ti
"
~
~
~
R
~
- U~
l
~
~
~
~
~
Q\
~
~
~
~
i::
~
ill
"
~ ~
~ U
it (I)
~
...'
'"
"
~
~
f.J :~Y/.'/:?(I;{. t. ~
:!: - . .: ~ j ..:
.'0_,..- " ',:,'.!:t;
~ :.. , .(. ':~
!:.' )";;.;',
'~"'."':".';i;
. "-'
"N.,
'~',;
. t,:.
~':"":
. .,',...
. ,
· f"'\ . ,.
''-I '
~
u
II
m~~
li:c:
~~9
iii~8
1
F::::
~
~
-
~
ul
":z~
~;j
....
z
o
~
u..
w
~
a
...!...
+
"::)
I
N
10
m
:t:
~
~
g
, i~
'-u
\!, ~
~
~
. -
~
i:::
~
it:
~
~
'i:
II
.
I
~
~
~
~
ltJ
~
c:s
~~!~!im{;I
t
~
? ~Zl!lO:O:Z ~
,".', -15 :J 0 W
J:,. u1 ~fiJl:
i\': ~~~~!\~
.", ::;l i.iJ(j
,:;). 0.....01- Ii!
;. w <{ >:J 'm
Oil;: !;( ~ 0: 0 Ii! U)
~.. Wmow~w
:{l~ 5 ffi II Z Ei If
','1 (!)n.fil~~~
, zo:z~fh
:,' \, ~:J~o~!I!
,... ;SO~I- I-
;.',~)'. ~fill- I
,;j 0 0: ~ S III i3 ~
(~:: w!2m~::;l:I: ,
"" J: U) wI-.
,{.' m r 5i'
.:,.' ::JfiJ wlll>
',. Cil lIlo '.
::; irl:~ol"-~ffl "
;;; z:i d I-!:: I ii'~:~
;,,'J': :>~If15U)~lii i
'~i ciU) c{z~U:5 ~
'!; ~~:d!~o~~ ,ll
"."!2 FI-Z_lIlt,
'.', 0: I- "5 - ,~>" .
'.;< 0 - > z 0 .
'C;', .z .O~LL
",' III Ul- 0 .'
>: ~!!!Qw~fll- }
:,';" ~r.~ z!::a1~:
'l: ~ m ~ 1ft c{ !!! U) ~j
C:.:.l 'ft:JzO~(!):I:8Z '.'
." v'08 0:)( .
-.(t., ~~ ~OUJ ,_
,I ~',
"-
"-
~
~
~
Qi
~
~
~~t~WJ,~tt,
t,:; .
l::..l'
~
....
"-
II
III
~
'"
at'
~
~
:it:.,:'
;.~~: '
:~r ~
~! ~~
!t~ ~ \...:J
:f.\;: ~~
n: ~
?':' ~~
~~
~~
~~
~
~
.', ~.
.'11
'l~','
I.:
",:
E1tii1.B1."r
" B "
I
LOCATION MAP
BIG & TALL CASUAL MALE Sl-ORE
OAI<WOOD'SQUARE SI-IOPPING CENTER
, . I I, i I j l .J ~ I I . "='~ '----I I j \
.. . . , - . . .',' . ~ .1 _ ,. . .. _ _ _. ..
-: tiO"t~rON CAAlI4-'- C-/(P", __"_h_',_ -- --- _. _..:', _.
- ! ~ lL_'..J~r~ ! P RBC " ,.... - . -- .~ - ,': -;;~' - . - .,~. \. _ 11"11
- -, ~ r :;' I i I ['j;: //'-....: \ \ -- JJ I
= ~.~; ~ r -,"rJfiTJ::f: 'I' L-. T/ ------ _ ;: \:, 1=1
-==1 E:'~+1i;n': ,lll..1i~'1=1 , ;j , ' ! [1L ~ \ '.., "".13
~~t~l~i~~:.~~rtt'i Ii :3 ;! ~ ~ "'\,,:\\,'.
, ,.. ' ..1, L.......J.. L- '1 ' ; ... " ;
~-'~~.T~iTrr:l~riirf " r:-::.';~'f'otGl".ACH ~ ~ R1A A .\\: ,1,1
:,! ~j : ,1HPJ,J,lf:: I ~~ LI '\ t~ ~ ' : r -
:- ~ rr .ll~ft I.~ Il / . r .., r- ~
~ I I, -r11 "I ,., II . I . r l: ~
. I . I I. . I ,. r:)
I I. ''': I I " - 1 ) , \.J
.. I I . I I '.
1)~l~rLF:1 - p
II"~ 1 I g
I '
....~.!'"n:.--:-.1.. '
.- --"I..
1 ~
.......-~~:-::.::-:::.-.., ~_... -'"
..- ------;-::; :f~- ---.-...,.
_.__ I . _ _
'~t"' L>
) I - ---"--~l p
c' ff c ~~.rlr"}~'~ ~.'i U
I Lf ('11 T5 1 : . ,'. i POI ,I .., 3 . _ I~ ;lr
\ {/ PC 0 lJI~:o "~~.' _~I J 1-'1 I':",;'
\ (~ . 'IJ'9J~ . NIC ~' . ill {~~ i _11.~.f
I. \ . t. _ ...~ " I' (1-: e \- /ill:' I III I . I. ~ j IJ,}, ._1 .1'
'," '~"'l: \.Jll": " 'j ~\ 1 ~ """", I Jcl.C- "
\. \ r~. -, '\;, r'-=: ~U' . 1,1.:>, ! . :. !) l '
J ) ~~ I ':. . Il'l " . ,( ""J ' / I ; "I .
) ): ~..-... i -'0 ,(;:~I,jrt~ .- ,I \ ,r, ,.I \ ! f.~fI f I Ii
'\ \,.. /~\\\ P: 'I" ,~! I i:'l 3}" IJI"Jr?-I"i'~lf I I II
://J ,1\) -1\' \: ill'\" ';,}ti\' ".'. - '\ r..,..,:' ~~i;({iiII:l;:_1'
t: ,1 ~--- '- J. .", '1' _..\-. .~v.. .~:-:: cU-:-:~. ...c--r-.(l~' T.' 4-' .:z...lir'--'- ~ :;:-;::. "T, J I H. \-:-\'~: ~ '. '.:.; "f,'f' I.. ' I
H, :---... \..' . I'!:-=' ' ; I I W ,I: ~' '.' :4"f t\ ':;_ ,~:' ',?"' "i
)~i \()" j" '\," ,\ l--~-;-:-I~Y~f '",', II]. .~-c,' , .' I : ~'~t<;.;>;;"'~" .......' ./!
. I y' . I - -- r '. ..(-.), , 'i. .
III / . ( i . I '.f' .)j . .. ~. '
~I . \ I::J '- --. -...! _' ,", ._~'?~~, ,:(( .+/.'. ~.,. l'
, J ~ ~ ~' I 'I ': ".\ I - -:;.~.~:-::' . .~ . . .~,~(. '. .-. /',
, V' E1 ' -.). . -'~, , /. ,
\ ~ . .. .. . - ~' " J .' 1 ""f'r'.,'" /~... . '..Ir. . '.
q, ~ '\tl\ : .., .~..I f' ( ''''-='''~::~\,.'': : : .~~~ l'~J'~< '):"~ II' ....,. \. I
.I \ '. \ I ,.- .' ,: I .' I If , .' , " ..... (~,. (,' ..1.... . l R ::1, :
.... "., \ , .. . - . - - - . ~.. ~ . ' . . \. I',. n '
we. ~ crt. . ~ 't.-t'I;;;.I......\.\'...nlfnil1l '.' "{.\
') 1/8 MILES !~ ~;~.: ! .~{z j,\titH~" ~ : \':1 \'(j~~t;d\ I-! I,
"11 \ I \ \ . - -:;. ~I'~'!_;;lJl{~ C1 -~li'H"n: ~l' fi[nll\Jlrrtili' Ij :' "
, . _ .~!tl-.i~~?~l1P..;~,l IE); tl:~.~D~..1rt.,U~~ ~ 1. '.
. 400800 FEEf 11l~lUL . rli...., , .1.. .....,.1., ,_
U '.' {,- 9b ..._~. 'H'.' - .~---:...~ -r--'I~' . 1 -t ~ r--....
...-' , I R 3 I
'. '~"A'...... ..' -1~!;11.~~2.;~ii~~fl~L 'I II;L .:. ,., .../ ('--1/' f! 1'.fll,;,'l,i:~,;V" J,~,'l.~f ( If'(~::'
i'-.!__~t'iJ.'t;..;;1 H-- ~ rill,. r 1::i .,..,. .h-. . fl ~ ,'" r I I " .
. .
l~ '
~
~
~~
CQ~
~~
~~
~
~
~
1ft
~
~
~
~
~
~
o
I
1 i
R
, ~3
'J! -~!
~
~
~
-. ~
~ ~
N "
lij ~
" ~
~ ~
~ ~
lI:: CI)
, ~~
. ~5
' ;:s ~
~Q:l
:::::t~
~~
,,' ~ s:: ,
:~;l.{ ~~
r"M ~~
~;: ~
~~t ~
~,:
DEVELOPMENT ORDER
OF THE
CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
P~~~.
~.
roJ~@~U\Hrn
UlJ utL 8 ~ ~
PLANNiNG AND
ZONING DEPT. I
APPLICANT: OAKWOOD SQUARE (CASUAL MALE -BIG AND TALL)
APPLICANT'S AGENT: Joseph P. Braca, Proiect manacer for J. Baker. Inc.. owner of
Casual Male - Bic and Tall
DATE OF HEARING BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: June 18,1996
TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: ReQuestinc approval of an administrative appeal to staffs
determination recardina proposed chances to the facade of the Casual Male - Bia and Tall
outbuildina. the southern outbuildina located within the Oakwood Square Shoppina Center.
More specifically. the petitioner is reQuestina a color chanae of the buildina to employ
their corporate colors.
LOCATION OF PROPERTY: Oakwood Square Shoppina Center. east of Conaress
Avenue between Boynton Beach Boulevard and Old Boynton Road
THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of
Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having
considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant,
members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows:
1. Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner
consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations.
2. The Applicant
_X_ HAS
HAS NOT
established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested.
3. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby
_X_ GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3
hereof.
DENIED
4. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk.
5. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the
terms and conditions of this order.
7.
Other:
The a roved colors are Ii
DATED: June 18, 1996
~ ~~'
/1 J J~. I,
C"yClerk - ",,}~
C:devord, frm
_.1/24/96
CasualMalelOakwcod
6/17/96
LEGAL/APPROVAL
DOCUMENTS
MEETING MINUTES
REGULAR CITY COMMISSION
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
JUNE 18, 1996
comments except rejecting Comment #18 to allow for 40' right-of-way, including all other
staff comments and including the Planning and Development Board conditions. Vice
Mayor Jaskiewicz seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
D. PROJECT:
AGENT:
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
Knuth Road pce
Kieran Kilday, Kilday and Associates
Bill Winchester, The Winchester Family Partnership, Ltd.
Southwest corner of Boynton Beach Boulevard and Knuth
Road intersection
MAJOR SITE PLAN MODIFICATION: Request for PCD sign
program approval
Kieran Kildav. Kildav and Associates. advised tha~ this application is strictly for signage.
The conditions, as amended by the Planning and Development Board, are acceptable to
the applicant. He reminded the Commissioners that the applicant made one modification
at the Planning and Development Board meeting which was agreed to by everyone.
Ms. Heyden had no comments to offer.
Motion
Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz moved to approve the request for PCD sign program approval for
the Knuth Road, Winchester Family Partnership, Ltd., southwest comer of Boynton Beach
Boulevard and Knuth Road intersection, including all staff comments and Planning and
Development Board conditions. Commissioner Tillman seconded the motion which carried
unanimously.
E. PROJECT:
AGENT:
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
Casual Male - Big and Tall at Oakwood Square
Joseph P. Braga
J.8ake~ In~ .
Southeast comer of Old Boynton Road and Congress Avenue
Request for an administrative appeal to allow color changes
for the exterior wall and canopy of the southern-most
outbuilding at Oakwood Square
Chuck Foltz, contractor for the project, advised that Mr. Braga was unable to be present
this evening. He advised that the existing building is dark pink with a green awning. The
applicant proposes a yellow canopy with a gray building. These are the corporate colors
of Casual Male. Staff recommended retaining the green awning and repainting the building
with a softer pink. Because thiS is a men's shop, the applicant would like to eliminate the
pink building. Mr. Foltz said the applicant is open to anything the Commission would like
done.
22
MEETING MINUTES
REGULAR CITY COMMISSION
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
JUNE 18,1996
Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz preferred the gray building with the green awning.
Ms. Heyden explained that the there was a color scheme for the center which involved the
main building and outparcels ~i~1er matching or being one shade different from each other.
The corporate identity would be established through embellishments such as the canopy.
Staff recommends that the main building colors be reestablished on the outparcel buildings
and where the colors are complimentary, the corporate image be established on the
canopies. However, for Casual Male, this would mean that the color scheme would be pink
and yellow. That is the reason why staff recommended retaining the green canopy.
Motion
Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz moved to approve the request to make the exterior of the building
light gray, and continue witn the green awning. Commissioner Tillman seconded the
motion which carried unanimously.
Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz confirmed with Mr. Foltz that a chain link fence exists in the back
of this building. She pointed out that it is not serving any useful purpose, and requested
that it be removed. Mr. Foltz agreed to remove the fence.
IX. NEW BUSINESS:
At this point in the meeting, Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz reminded the Commissioners that she
would like to reorder the agenda to address Mr. MacQuaker's request.
Motion
Vice Mayor Jaskiewicz moved to reorder the agenda to put Item "0" as Item "A", and
change the letters of the remaining items. Commissioner Titcomb seconded the motion
which carried unanimously.
A. I Have a Dream Summer Math and Reading Tutoring Program
Gordon MacQuaker, sponsor of the Bovnton Beach Chapter of the "I Have A Dream
Foundation", said the objective of the organization is to curb school dropouts in favor of
continuing education. The tools used by the Foundation are mentoring, field trips, love.
attention, and an incentive that if a child graduates ,from high school, the Foundation will
see that he/she gets tuition-free college or vocational school education. The "I Have A
Dream Foundation" adopted the third grade of Rolling Green Elementary School three
years ago.
The "I Have A Dream Foundation" wishes to enter into a project which is very important.
They are concerned that many of their dreamers are not prepared to enter middle school
23
fJJU City of
'Boynton 'Beacli
"~
100 'E. 'Boynton 'Beadi 'BoukVtJTtf
P.O. 'Bo~310
'Boynton 'Bead", 1"forit{a. 33425-0310
City 1fa[[: (4Q7) 375..(j()()()
1"1U: (407) 375-6090
July 8, 1996
Joseph P. Braga
J. Baker, Inc.
555 Turnpike Street
Canton, Ma. 02021
Re: Casual Male- Big & Tall
File No: ADAP 96-002
Location: 324 North Congress Ave., Oakwood Shopping Center
Dear Mr. Braga,
Enclosed is the City of Boynton Beach Development Order regarding
the above captioned, for relief sought to amend the previously
approved site plan.
Should you have any questions concerning this matter, please feel
free to contact this office at (561) 375-6260.
Sincerely,
~-C) / -dAltL
Tambri J. H~n t/
Planning and Zoning Director
TJH:dar
Enclosures
xc: Central File
a:develord.cau
5b,rerUas gateway to tfie guf/stream
--..-----.--...--..----.--.----..
~
~
~~
~~
~~
~~
~
~
o
z
9~
sO::
ca~
w::;)
~@
3S~
z
w
w
e
<.9
:><:
e
Ci
~
o
z
j
t-
Z
o
a::
u..
UJ
a::
~
en
~
~
~
tij
~
~
'i:
I
-
.:+-
~
N
l{)
~
~
~
ltj
!ti
"
(!
!
~
~
"
~
~
Qi
~
~
1lI
~
"
II
III
~
"
~
~
~