Loading...
AGENDA DOCUMENTS r. ,:"iJ *.;~' ,it' ~ ,~~l~ _' "'".',," ~''".:{ t ~'\'.:'.~,~ ~ ~,. "'. I ' ',,",1 ..,~~.." :") 't ~~'i,~~,~:~,t~ AGENDA DOCUMENTS , "~t ;J'~J ~1' ~)~:;'~~~:~;i- ".;. ~",' MINUTES - CITY COMMISSION MEETING BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA MAY 2, 1995 No one else wished to speak under Public Audience. Therefore, Mayor Taylor declared the Public AUdience closed. Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - TABLED CCl Consultants, Inc. Howard R. SCharlin, Trustee Northside of Woolbright Road, east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 Canal Master Plan Modification: Request to modify the pre- viously approved master plan to subdivide outbuilding 3 into .895 acres, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding 1 from 4,300 to 6,920 square feet; out- building 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet and outbuilding 3 from two-stories and 6,000 square feet to one-story and 2,625 square feet)~ add a drive- way on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 400 feet north of Woolbright Road, relocate the existing driveway on S.W. 8th Street, 190 feet to 260 feet north of Woolbright Road and provide a median cut on S.W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway City Manager Parker requested that this item remain tabled. She advised that negotiations are ongoing and an agreement might be reached by May 11th. The Commission agreed to address this at a special meeting before the May 11th workshop meeting if a settlement is reached by then. VIII. DEVELOPMENT PLANS A. Project: Agent: Owner: Location: Description: B. Project: Agent: Owner: Location: Description: Boynton Commerce Center PIO - TABLED Peter Reed, MIG Management Services of Florida, Inc. Boynton Commerce Center, Ltd. Southside of Woolbright Road, 100 feet west of 1-95 Use Approval: Request to amend the list of pennitted uses for the Boynton Commerce Center to allow wholesale distribution, retail, repair and assembly of lawn main- tenance equipment City Manager Parker advised that the applicant has requested that this item be withdrawn. C. Request by Janet Hall to waive application fee for Lighthouse Grille Restaurant site plan review Mrs. Hall stated that this is a request to waive a second application fee for the same stage of the project. She explained that the architect and the engineer involved in this project left town, which necessitated acquiring another architect to get the same work done that should have been done in the first place. - 17 - MINUTES - CITY COMMISSION MEETING -BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA APRIL 18. 1995 Palm Belch Leisureville Recreltion I Michael P. Corbett Palm Beach Leisureville, Inc. 1007 Ocean Drive Major Site Plan Modification: Request to amend the previously approved site plan to construct a 1,685 square foot office addition to the recreation bul1 di ng Michael Corbett represented Palm Beach Leisureville in the expansion of their recreational building. He stated that the majority of the people who use this building are retired walk-in people. No employees are being added to the staff and no units are being added to the development. He concurred with the staff comments, but reserved the right to return and request a waiver of the parking space requirements. 3. Project: Agent: Owner: Location: Description: No one wished to speak in favor of or against this application. Therefore, Mayor Taylor declared the public hearing closed. Motion Mayor Pro Tem Matson moved to amend the previously approved site plan for Palm Beach Le1sureville Recreation I to construct a 1,685 square foot office addition to the recreation building subject to staff comments. Commissioner Rosen seconded the motion which carried 5-0. At this point in the meeting, Mayor Taylor recognized County Commissioner Mary McCarty and her husband in the audience and welcomed them to Boynton Beach. B. Non-Consent Agenda - Not unanimously approved by the Planning and DeveloPMnt Board 1. Project: Agent: Owner: Location: Description: Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - TABLED CCL Consultants, Inc. Howard R. Scharl1n, Trustee Northside of Woolbright Road, east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 Canal Master Plln Modification: Request to modify the previously approved master plan to subdivide out- building 3 into .895 acres, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding 1 from 4,300 to 6,920 square feet; outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet and outbuilding 3 from two-stories and 6,000 square feet to one-story and 2,625 square feet), add a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 400 feet north of Woolbright Road, relocate the existing driveway on S.W. 8th Street, 190 feet - 21 - '\ MINUTES - CITY COIIUSSIat. MEETING BOYNTON BEACH t flORIDA APRIL 18. 1995 to 260 feet north of Woolbright Road and provide a median cut on S.W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway City Manager Parker advised that staff recommended keeping this item on the table since an agreement has not yet been finalized. Tara Oaks PUD - TABLED Ki eran K11 day Northeast corner of Knuth Road extended and Woolbright Road T1.. Extension: Request for approval of an 18 month retroactive and an indefinite time extension for zoning/master plan approval and concurrency exemption/certification City Manager Parker advised that this item is ready to came off the table. 2. Project: Agent: Location: Description: Motion Mayor Pro Tem Matson moved to remove this item from the table. Vice Mayor Bradley seconded the motion which carried 5-0. The owner of the subject property, Bill Winchester, his attorney Michael Schroeder, and Tim Hernandez of Pu1te Homes were present. Mr. Kilday represented Bill Winchester, the owner of the Tara Oaks PUD property. He stated that the. property is a very large linear piece of property located to the east of Quail Ridge and to the south of the project originally known as Stonehaven. The property extends all the way down to Woolbright Road. As part of the conditions of approval, a culvert crossing has been constructed over the canal which will allow access to the property from Woolbright Road. The project as it currently exists was approved after extensive public hearings in 1990, with final approval occurring in December, 1990. About the time it got through the approval process, the economic condition of the real estate industry deteriorated and the owner of the property has been struggling with the prop- erty. Previous extensions have been approved for this project with very little activity in the last year or so. The project sat there donmant and no exten- sions were requested until this past year. The project was approved with a medium land use density and 192 two-story garden apartments as well as a church on the south portion of the site. Mr. Kilday advised that the owner and his attorney diligently tried to move ahead. Various activities occurred on the site, the most significant of which was that the right-of-way for Knuth Road along that entire frontage was dedi- cated to the City and is now the necessary right-of-way to allow for the construction of Knuth Road. Penmits were issued for the clearing of the right- - 22 - ~,'. '.of MINUTES - CITY C0M4ISSION t rING BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA APRIL 4, 1995 The Tabulation Committee recommended awarding this bid to Rosso Paving and Drainage Inc. of West Palm Beach, Florida. Two bids were received for this project. The bid from Florida Blacktop was incomplete because they did not bid on two items in the base bid. Rosso Paving and Drainage of West Palm Beach, Florida submitted a complete bid. The Engineering consultant, Gee & Jenson, and the Engineering Department recommended deleting Section 5 (landscape) from the contract document. Therefore, the total contract amount will be $54,562.00. City Attorney Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R95-56 by title only. Motion Vice Mayor Bradley moved to approve Proposed Resolution No. R95-56. Commissioner Jaskiewicz seconded the motion which carried 4-0. VI. PUBLIC HEARING None. VII. PUBLIC AUDIENCE This item was dispensed with after Item VIII.C.1. VIII. DEVELOPMENT PLANS A. Consent Agenda - Unanimously approved by the Planning and Development Board None. B. Non-Consent Agenda - Not unanimously approved by the Planning and Development Board 1. Description: Shoppes of WOolbright PCD - TABLED CCL Consultants, Inc. Howard R. Scharlin, Trustee Northside of Woolbright Road, east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 Canal Master Plan Modification: Request to modify the previously approved master plan to subdivide out- building 3 into .895 acres, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding 1 from 4,300 to 6,920 square feet; outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square) Project: Agent: Owner: Location: City Manager Parker recommended that this item remain on the table since issues are outstanding. - 11 - VIII. DEVELOPMENT PLANS B.1 cc: Plan PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMOW Agenda Memorandum for April 4, 1995 city Commission Meeting TO: Carrie Parker city Manager Tambri J. HeYden--~;r'~ planning and Zoning Director FROM: DATE: March 29, 1995 SUBJECT: shoppes of Woolbright PCD - MPMD 95-001 Master Plan Modification ~ subdivide Tract C, redistribute square footage-within the three, Tract C outbuildings, relocate a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street and permit a median cut in S.W. 8th street for the relocated driveway. Please reflect the above-referenced request on the April 4, 1995 City Commission agenda under Development Plans, Non-consent agenda as tabled. Staff has no additional information since the tabling of this item at the last City Commission meeting on March 21, 1995. This item was tabled so that a March 24, 1995 executive session could be held to discuss the proposal of a new settlement agreement between the city and Tradewinds Development Corporation which would replace the 1986 and 1989 agreements. Until.~tbe new ~greement is executed, it is recommended that this item remain tabled since as indicated within my attached, previous memoranda (Planning and Zoning Department Memorandum No. 95-107 and No. 95-090), there are aspects of this master plan modification request that are not consistent with the 1986 and 1989 agreements. Again, these aspects are a fast food restaurant with drive-through window; addition of a third, actually forth if the northern-most driveway is not deleted as specified in the 1990 Barton-Aschman traffic study, driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street within the PCD and addition of a median cut within S.W. 8th street. It should also be noted that in addition to the conclusions drawn in the referenced 95-090 staff report, approval of the subject master plan modification should be conditioned upon reflection on the revised master plan of a note indicating the one story, 35 foot height limit on buildings within the PCD. This note is missing from the master plan, yet specified in the 1989 agreement. tjh Attachments xc: Central File A:TradMPTa ,., ,., .~ PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTI MEMORANDUM NO. 95-107 Agenda Memorandum for March 21, 1995 City Commission Meeting TO: Carrie Parker City Manager FROM: /J . ',' Tambri J. Heyden / /" Planning and Zoning Director SUBJECT: March 16, 1995 Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - MPMD 95-001 Master Plan Modification subdivide Tract C, redistribute square footage-within the three outbuildings located on Tract C, relocate a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street and make a medican cut in S.W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway. DATE: Please place the above-referenced request on the March 21, 1995 Ci ty Conunission agenda under Development Plans, Non-consent agenda. DESCRIPTION: This is a request to amend the previously approved master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD, located at the northeast corner of Woolbright Road and the E-4 Canal. The changes include approval to subdivide Tract C to create outbuilding 3 on a .895 acre property, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding I from_~,300 to 6.920 square feet, outbuilding 2 from 5,000 to 5,755 square-feet and outbuilding 3 from 4,300 to 2,625 square feet), add a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 400 feet north of Woolbright Road, relocate the exi.sting driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, from 290 feet to 260 feet north of Woolbright Road and provide a median cut on S. W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway. RECOMMENDATION: The Planning and Development Board, with a 5-1 vote, reconunended denial of this request. The basis for the denial was that the proposed changes were not consistent with the court ordered stipulation agreements. TJH/pb c : ccmtg32 1. shp 7.B.l SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD MASTER PLAN MODIFICATION ......~ .. "WI PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM NO. 95-090 *REVISED MARCH 13, 1995 TO: Chairman and Members planning and Developemnt Board THRU: Tambri J. Heyden planning and zoning Director FROM: Michael E. Haag Zoning and site Development Administrator DATE: March 10, 1995 SUBJECT: Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - File No. MPMD 95-001 Master plan modification (driveway, median cut and shift in outparcel sizes and boundaries) NATURE OF REQUEST eeL consultants, Inc., agent for Howard R. Scharlin, trustee of the property, is requesting approval to modify the previously approved master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD. The 31.99 acre planned commercial development zoned property, approved for 284,620 square feet of commercial/retail development, is located on the north side of Woolbright Road and east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 canal. The proposed changes, described in the attached letter from CCL consultants, dated February 14, 1995 (see Exhibit "A") are itemized below. In addition to the changes stated in the letter of submittal, a second driveway is requested located on the east side of S.W. 8th street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD (see Exhibit "B" - proposed master plan): 1. '-- Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate .895 acre outparcel. Tract C is located at the northeast corner of S.W. 8th street and Woolbright Road and south of the main entrance into the Home Depot. * .., ... . Change in the size of the outbuilding 3 from a one-story, 4,300 square foot building to a one-story, 2,625 square foot drive-through, fast food restaurant. A conditional use application, as required by the zoning code, is in progress for a drive-through, fast food restaurant as the use of this outbuilding. 3. change in the building area of outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet. 4. Change in the building area of outparcel 1 from 4,300 square feet to 6,920 square feet. * 5. Relocation of the existing driveway located on the east side of S.W. 8th street, 30 feet south, from 290 feet to 260 from the south property line of the PCD. 6. A(idi tion of a driveway ,on the east side of s. w. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD. This driveway was requested on a previous master plan modification that was tabled by the City Commission; therefore it has been added to this request. BACKGROUND The Shoppes of Woolbright PCD is part of a November 6, 1986 and January 24, 1990 stipulated settlement agreement between the City and Tradewinds Development Corporation. The City Commission ratified the settlement agreement by approving a master plan modification on May 15, 1990 that depicted the applicable conditions of the January 24, 1990 stipulation and settlement agreement (see Exhibit "C" - master plan pursuant to the 1990 stipulated settlement agreement). The agreement vested the project for traffic, \'1ater and sevier, so that no time extensions for 2 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 concurrency would ever be required, prior to build-out of the property. The settlement agreement approved a maximum of 320,000 square feet, to include the uses and layout depicted on Exhibi t "c" - the 1990 settlement master plan. However, the 1990 master plan reflects only 315,580 square feet. Since the original settlement agreement, the following master plan modifications have been submitted for review: 1. October of 1989 request to include the addition of a building materials s~ore (Home Depot) which included 102,250 square feet of retail and a 19;375 square foot garden center. The total square footage for the PCD remained unchanged at 315,580 square feet. The city Commission approved this request on November 21, 1989. 2. May of 1991 - request to include the following: a. Addition of a new driveway onto Woolbright Road, located west of S.W. 8th Street; b. change in use ~nd size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th Street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 1,250 square foot gas station (this portion of the request was withdrawn by the applicant, from the submittal); c~~ Change in size, number of stories and designation of use of the outparcel at the northeast corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th street from a 4,300 square foot retail building to a two-story, 6,000 square foot bank with drive-through; d. Addition of another driveway from S.W. 8th Street to the shopping center outparcels located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street; e. Relocate southward the approved driveway located en the east side of S.W. 8th street that leads to the shopping center outparcelsi and f. Eliminate the north access aisle connection between the outparcels located on the east side of S.W. 8th street and the Home Depot site. The modifications to square footage resulted in a net increase of 1,700 square feet, thereby increasing the total square footage for the PCD from 315,580 to 317,280 square feet (within the limit allowed by the 1990 settlement agreement). This request was presented to the Planning and Zoning Board (now known as the planning and Development Board) on August 13, 1991. The Board recommended approval of the reques t, with the exception of the additional driveway on Woolbright Road. The minutes from the August 20, 1991 and september 19, 1991 City Commission meetings state that the request was tabled at the request of the City Attorney because of a pending motion in the Tradewinds case and that the Ci ty Attorney wished to confer with counsel for Tradewinds on the issue. A review of City records indicate ihe request was not removed from the table. ., J. Harch of 1993 - request to include the addition of 8,745 square feet to the garden center at the home Depot. The gard-:l1 centel- increased from 19,375 square feet to 28,120 square feet. Pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement, the square footage of the garden center is not included as part of /l J- ~ ., 3 To: Planning and Development 'Board March 9, 1995 the retail gross leasable area. The request included adjusting property lines to accommodate the expansion and the total square footage of the project remained at 315,580. On April 20, 1993 the City Commission approved the 8 745 square foot expansion subject to staff comments, and on August 10, 1993 the Planning and Development board approved a waiver of platting for the adjusted property lines in connection with the expansion. 4. March of 1993 - request to include the following: a. < Subdivision of Tract B to ~reate a .957 acre outparcel. Tract B is that portion of the PCD that is located on the west side of S.W. 8th Street; b. Change in use and size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th Street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 3,040 square foot gas station (resurrection of the portion of the 1991 request that was withdrawn by the applicant); c. Add two new driveways into the proposed service station outparcel - one on S. W. 8th street and the other on Woolbright Road; d. Allow a canopy over the gasoline pumps to encroach the setbacks due to a difference in the service station regulations in effect in 1986 vs. the service station regulations in effect in 1993; and -...~~ e. Reduce the building square footage specified on the master plan for Tract B from 62,000 to 55,040 square feet. wi th this request, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 6,960 square feet from 315,580 to 308,620. On April 20, 1993 the city Commission approved the request, subject to staff comments. As a result of the traffic evaluation of the proposed service station use, the square footage on Tract B decreased 24,000 square feet from a total of 55,040 square feet (52,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) to 31,040 square feet (28,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) . Therefore, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 24,000 square feet from 308,620 to 284,620 square feet. ANALYSIS Changes in Planned Commercial Development (PCD) master plans are reviewed consistent with, Section 6.F.13.b. of Appendix A - Zoning as follows: b. "Modifications to approved plans which resul t in 3.n increase of less than ten (10) per cent in measurable impacts as determined by including any changes in traffic generated, water consumed or sewage to be collected will require review and recommendation the planning and zoning board and final approval by the city commission. The city commission decisi0n to approve, approve with modifications o~ deny, shall be predicated upon a finding of consistency with the comprehensive plan and a finding that any such increase will not result in a negative impact on infrastructure delivery systems or the surrounding area in general. It is the intent of this --, ..:..) 4 To: planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 section that all additional impacts be mitigated. .." Based on the documentation provided, the changes to the three outparcels would generate in excess of a ten (10) per cent increase in water consumed and sewage collected, if the approved outparcels are evaluated against the proposed outparcels. An increase of only 2.8% in water consumed and sewage collected results if the proposed outparcels are evaluated against the entire PCD water and sewer impacts. In either scenario, the utility Department does not have an objection to the analysis provided and has not indicated that the increase will have a negative impact on the infrastruture delivery systems. A slight increase in pervious area will result in a minimal, positive impact on th~ PCD drainage. with respect to traffic, the traffic information submitted indicates that the traffic generated by the three outparcels will generate less than a ten (10) percent change. This information has been forwarded to Palm Beach county. The results of the review by the County have not been received at the time of this report. The following is an evaluation of each of the proposed changes listed on page one of this report: 1. Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate outparcel and the redistribution of square footage among the outparcels As indicated in the stipulation settlement ~greement, this is acceptable. Platting or a waiver of '~~atting. (at the determination of the city Engineer) to subdivide this parcel is required. As required, outparcels shall be self-sufficient with respect to lot size, setbacks, parking and other PCD zoning district requirements. 2. Relocation of the existing driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, south of the main entrance into the shopping center (Home Depot) - One entrance, in addition to the main entrance, was allowed pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement. This existing driveway is the additional driveway referenced in the agreement. The proposed location of this additional driveway is closer to the original position (centrally located) identified in the Barton-Aschman traffic report, upon which the traffic conditions of the 1990 settlement agreement were based. 3. Addition of a second driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, between Woolbright Road and the main entrance to the shopping center (Home Depot) - As mentioned in previous item =2, the number of driveways is specifically limited in the 1990 settlement agreement. The addition of a second driveway is inconsistent with the 1990 settlement agreement. Since the Barton-Aschman report does not require an additional driveway to be added, it could be argued that this driveway is not needed and that safety and level of service are not impaired without it. Furthermore, this type of access design is contrary to the intent and purpose of a PCD, which is to provide for a planned (not piece-meal), programmed series of development operations, designed as a whole through integration of principle buildings and ou~buildings that are linked via common use of access and infrastructure and similar architecture and other aesthetic elements. specifically with respect to access, this additional driveway defeats the purpose of requiring internal ~ccess roads and driveways to serve parcels within a planned develcpment. It should also be noted that the Barton-Aschman report stated 4 .., .... 5 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 that the driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street located north of the eXisting main entrance driveway was to be de:etej. The proposed master plan still reflects this driveway as being approved. 4. Median cut in S. W. eth street If approved, this new intersection would capture much of the traffic anticipated and designed to be received by the main driveway that is located at the entrance to Home Depot. The main driveway is centrally located for the major portion of the retail uses located on the east side of S.W. 8th street. Since the Barton-Aschman report did not recommend a median cut, it could be argued that the proposed median cut is no~ consistent with the traffic report referenced in the 1990 settlement agreement and therefore not needed or possibly affecting level of service. Therefore, if the median cut is approved, it is recommended that a new analysis of the turning movements be submitted to determine the impact the median cut will have on S. W. 8th street and woolbright Road. Also, the proposed median cut would cause the east driveway into the site to become a major driveway which requires a one hundred (100) foot throat; the distance from the property line to a parking space or an access aisle. This would significantly impact the parking design of outbuilding 3. CONCLUSION This'reqUest was reviewed by the Technical Review Committee (TRC) on February 28, 1995 and the committee raised no objections at the time. However; -the committee did not have technical data regarding the impact the median cut and additional driveway would have on the surrounding roadways or the project itself. If this driveway and median cut are approved by the Commission, the Police Department recommends that north and south deceleration lanes be required at the cut to avoid congestion from motorists slowing down to make turns at this location (see Exhibit "0" Police Department Memorandum No. 95-0121) . It is also recommended that if any changes are approved by the Commission that are not reflected, or are contrary to, the proposed master plan, that three copies of a revised master plan be submitted to the Planning and Zoning Department, prior to submittal of any future PCD requests. The Planning and Zoning Department is not making a specific recommendation on this request since components of the request are inconsistent with the latest settlement agreement. Deviation from this agreement are viewed as policy decisions of the Commission. tjh Attachments xc: Central File A:WoolPCD '- -~ EXHIBIT A . . r () ---------- ----------------------- '-f CC~ONSULTANTS, INC. Con.u/tlng Englnee" m Surveyo" Planne" , ;~ 2200 PARK CENTRAL BLVD., N, SUITE 100, POMPANO BEACH, FL 33064, (305) 974-2200. FAX (305) 973-2686 February 14, 1995 Hand Delivery Ms. Tambri Heyden Planning Director CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd. Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310 Re z SHOPPBS OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD Boynton Beach, Florida CCL project; No. 3~O~ Dear Ms. Heyden: Enclosed herewith please find the following: 1. Twelve (12) signed and sealed prints of the revised master plan for the above-referenced project. 2 . A checJc made payable to the City of Boynton Beach in the amount of $500.00. ..~~ 3. Letter of Authorization form owner for CCL Consultants, Inc. to act as. agent for this matter. Please be advised that we are herein SUbmitting for master plan amendment for the above-referenced project. We are proposing to amend the existing master plan as follows: A. Outparcel 1 will be revised from 4300 SF to 6920 SF. B. Outparcel 2 will be revised from 5000 SF to 5755 SF. C. outparcel 3 will be revised from a 2-story 6000 SF bank to a 1-story 2625 SF Taco Bell Fast Food Restaurant with a drive- thru lane. D. The locations of the driveways for these outparcels onto S.W. 8th Street will be revised from what is presently shown on the existing master plan. In addition, we are proposing a median cut in the S.W. 8th Street median which aligns with one of the proposed relocated driveways as well as prior-approved driveway location on the wes~ side of S.W. 8th street. ,- I -- Ms. Tambri Bey4eD CCL project No. 3101 February 14, 1995 Page two We respectfully request that this proposed master plan amendment be placed on the next Technical Review Committee agenda and thusly on the next available Planning & Development Board as well as City commis.ion Agenda. Should you have any questions or need any additional information, >-'. please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, panile, Jr., P.E., P.L.S. ject Manager LRC/kaq Enclosure cc: Mike Morton, Tradewinds Group Eduardo Carcache, P.E., .CKE Group, Inc. '~- 00 CCl CONSULTANTS, INC. '.7 .."", ..."" "-- y."}{U1. B1.'t B r:r ~ n% \\\ i' ,,~ .. ~ ~ . ~ -:;:;.- _..--- l .. .. , l\ !.. ~i ~ .. '" i '" \ \ ~~l i~il ~, ~~,. ~l .~... ~J'!:'~ 'i ~C1l'" ..\ u.~1 jlltl\ \,.. \~\ .~\\ ,\ ~..?> . ~%~ 'i :$; \ ~\~ lOt \ ,~ \ , ' . , . t:' ~ J . .. . ~ I ~ \\\ \\\ \gg .\\ ~ '\\\ !~~ ~ --u ?\\ \\\ ~\ ~ o.\.~~ Of-""'.~~~ F'~NO~~ Of...-""tt+O ~ ~ .z ..:'1"'''13 ,~~O ~..",p'" .>1 tell,.... ..~'ic:elI · ~ h~~~..i. '1\ (I) '""'''''''a\ ~- a a~\"" J \~ \ "i"'\\elI" \i l.~\!.~;l ~\ \.., iI, ;~ 1. ..;~\%S~ \\ - f.... S 1'1 .\ ~ ..;:.\i..;. ~.., "'_\It ",0""'_ ii ,,"C" c....o'l. :; , o"i",t;.. ~.. '!I.~~a'".... , d~~~'~ l-t 0..00...:1 \. ""s....- a 04 ........t11 ... ';!.. _ ..,'if,- 1 i 02.:&0..... .- ..r.n_r"D · \~~~i~! i: "ao ~..'" . \ _zg"s. .. as",i-:' \ \ ~!dC!' \ . >>0' .",F .- ~~ 'i~ !l .. :& .._,If"" ,...lll 1\\\0 .. ~~\\ i ~~ ~~ Gl .. ~ ..~w#olltft ,\;;'::"'~ :\:,0'7l' :Ii"'\ ~\.. ~ . ~ :i: ~ w ~ ... ... ~\~ " ~ f; ..... ~ ill' ... ~ .. ~\#; -: i \1 \' \ ~\ ~ i \ ~ .. "~""..,,, I \ i~ i ;l 9. 0 ,.. 1:\01 ~ \ a \ i t !\ i " \ ,. '" 0 0 ~ ,- in i\ & ~ ; ~ ~ N ~ ... ~ ~ J:" \ .. ,. . " # ~ ~ ''C ~ .. . ':~.:~ ...... 11 \II" ;0##' '4 ~ .. ... : fJ'J ('I l!. 11l StlOPPES Of yjOO\..6R;" rT,. p.e.D. _..&I"M f\.Of'\~ ,j~__..71 &O'fM1Ot" ~.f ,- " --,., t.\~1B """Mt' j('lcI." IS ",..oC'.'.. l.;"'d.C:~P" "rc:t"\C,t'II'\...,,,~r. ,ss' Foru.... 1'10<:" ~.::\ ~~~ BeaG" FIOflda 3340' r30S1689SS22 PROPOSEO .('> I ..", ..".1 '~- E~ll1.B1.'t C I I ;;;a;;a . '..- ..~1i4 ~ --.;!l..... ...... T~ · =c 1: ::=~R ~~!l ~!~ i.... 3a.=I "0" ..;I .. I '" " Se,l, 1 . sa Dill 112AI gO Or,1wn B... CA.' j:"I@r-.O 4211 Dr......'f'Q No eS-]4 SI'1_t---1-.:;! .., .::~ lS!~ ;~; !l=!; ~J: ~I~ j...:!! ~o; wJ~ :Ji 'l'!" :.:=l ....I ... lii .. .. a . .. '. a-OJ ::1. ....-c J a' .~I ::E! ~I. , .- ....r" a!! .. . .."'~ ..g' ....r" ::zl -~~ ..n =1 1= r" ; ;: ~ n m III III I: ... i: ... a~ ;i ." i!J t ; ~, : ~ ; 11'li illu ~ . aI 11111; . ,,- ,-' . ~ ' -' .... .. ::I':' . jiSll: ,~ ~ ~ ~ ,~ i!'li 1:!~~~~lli~~ nJ~ ~ I I !I mlfii~~llj~" ~i I' I ;\ l:uiP ~I~~~t~ :I~ J! I": '1'!!Ir. I~~..'tifl I~ H II ;13,1','" ai I' I' !i:!Ji'III!ml :J:~ II!~~~!~I ,. JI"~I'q:I!;";r~i ~1I h ,.. kd;l~Ii:'~1& :Ie; II l~!~~ll~=p.~e~'~i i ! "'~:'I~,r,:mi:;' ~m~~!,i'! JI ., "II II' "11/11'11 J ! ' 'II ;.~," "I I,!J' 'i! J: I : HiJI~:!~II'il,~t1'III~d II Illhi!tll~,!,~!~cJI:~~I!!I;!e Ii . J ..,~ ".~I!e~~I'hi'lia:!!II' I 'I 'I oJl!f,;!.\I,." ~I 'I' I '.'Ii ,-1; 111";fil"1111 '. I ~I;;lr~' ,hno . 11!~.. I' /'1.1 n" . Inl"bdo · ~ ~!n~a. ,;II! d 1:.114 .1 . , . .... N , :a, iI :;l ~ ~ ;= 5 !:> ;l ': ~ '" . '/~ .-- ,,~;. I'; I oJ' I'; SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT - ..,,~" 'peD -~~ ., BOVN.TdN BEACH, F70RIDA I;.... ~ - MASTER PLAN' \ Kilday & Associates Landscape Archllecls/Planners 1551 Forum Place SUlle 100A West Palm Beach. Florrda 33401 . {J051689 5522 .."" .., .'............ E~l:l1.B1.'t D /3 L-V\Jf\IIUI\t MA~ SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT P .C.[ 11\11 U I~'~~{ 1111 - ; ~~[ E ~ ~ c ....- ."" ~.. I , L.;-t . IIIJill I I -tffi]} ~ R S:-ll.J..Ll.,.kt.1l. ,1' L-~ L! I. J~~':~H~ ~-::L ._~ .-: -.-~. ., '. ",' ,~">...~ ~ - "\_ .- 1- I TTT 1 J t-WJ-r'-J. t '~7" ~~:: ~rt. T II ~ ~ : ~ I 'I' ~.~ If .:1 '-H~' ~ - l'~ - ' :.. I 1 <::>. !!!!!! I- 'I:: IWI '~rTl \ !.~ ~ Iil.. C .... I---~H I ~.. -tLD II~~: ~,. " ,,~.. r-r " ...... ...., ~"'" - '. '~ ~ .7;:...........1. iIiW11 II II ~ ~ -' pee ~ ~~~.fr . BIll' . l: , - ~ ?":>-'./ ~C;~ ~rolV ..?gc.~ "~l~ ~ ~ I I · ' \..: -c -:J L - ='-1 ' "l'TJ '1}o"') ~. r! I 1 "fl' m~ " ~Aa.!~_J::---!-1.: '1 ... t-" 1 If llllllf 'HU..J/(' ~ \'V"/ .. 'v:";' ~ ~- ,1 l11 11 1\1 \ff, I'l\\?y<\ , ~ \' ' _. t'. ,~ ;~~ V , R3- -'T .f 1 11lJ..W;rT I "R , >-- _ i: :....~l ", ~::... III \I ." .~ tt 1.7' f=.::" t.:;;::; ~\ ~~,~: \,,.1 ,;:~ I'!!II'" ~~11I1 [llJ~ .:; :' ,: j. 1'1 ,l;:l' Ul1!l11lJUI ....- /'Y11T I M - .. .' r ,. .... '"-=:II · '" ",..,.........:,; \) ': ~r ~ ~ I ...... IIDIIIIlIlD 1\ (I ill T ' ,;...f.I I QCe"" " - ~ lH ,'. rr::!!D I nil: rI \ 'I .-.1 W ~ )l ___' , . ~ ~II ... ~ f.Imur1 IT r~ p J:'fJ "'T' 1DJ~ AltRT 1, , . ,_ ., .../1 ~; ! ~l I I 'fT"!.'l.rr. i 11m rT ITT' I rEC;..'.-"'? ~~=--' ~:. C, , ~ \ c ,-.. . ~ . .. 1,.:, '-I' . . ~ \ h If \ f ill ~'1 I ~l'l .1\ ~ ~~. . .~ I', I' PUD \ ffitIiIB ':'" . 1\ ;..v '-; · . '. -.,...".-.,,~ 1- ~'[ L U 1:!5. 0 1--- lTIlIITll In! '- I' t, 'T/ ~.' . "" " ',. . .';' \ '\IlIllill.li.l . ~ '"i[l~ .' .....-;'~ .... ",:::,:" ,./:.~. ~ 'W~01-aRIGHT. !~ I'~ ~;:::::; :~ I TlTf"i,,~ ~&~.....~</r~'b\i.~'.:'> '\\\Z\\\.. . \ "'u t~ ,.,_,.',.;j;" .,' ;:; ~ 0-\\ '.\\.w.-~~\ .... C ~1~1. ".., ,~.~ :fl p' r f i\\\ ~ ~ I[ \mti1:'l' ~~ ~~ fSIT~ ~~~~HjA ~ ~ r. Jfl~ _..,,,.,....~ '- --~ w. -~, a. .,Ifft :..e. ... '~i !.. ~ _..... ,. ~ IV" ~ ~!:. ~ /-r--' , I" r /--. IS _ ". ~,~, ."", .....", -:"1'1..:1: ~. C~ 1, C 3 .... 71 J 1'T" i l:ur r II..' I I '~......... 4 'l- ~~~ \ ~.J ~~. ~ ,,." ,~I f'// -j , I __~-.c \; ;:~ .Cr< ~'l( 70 ~'.:: lti~ Vi/I!. -~_j~ I J ~-=d ~ ;:: ~ _ ~ -\1 ~) y 1"-..- ~.: 1 ~'~ I r JI~" x . .j< -/' 7! ~ II: - , ' ~ ' ' I, , \ \.' ;::1~1/ =.. -r-rt _ Jl x >'(' ~ 111 4~~ , ~ I rlC'l 0 --.,: R ,,' / I l_ I L...r'IEC -\( I~;:: ~ "" . I,' E 'I 1/ ./ p-u-:: C' ........ . ~ ~l I 1\ \ I oN ~ .>'/. ~ >+ V ~~ J..~ '-, ~ \.J i/ r~ . - .. · - - ~~1, _ ~ c ~..~7 =-= -,'. ~/ ~ ~ "iT ,=-~ ~ ~ "'~. ~ :=,1). 1.,' & L~""" ,.- i ,y ':" i 17~~:;~ '" "'" """: < ... .:- ~ /L 7:h f 1// "6 ~-~ I "j ':f. ~ ~ 'Y -l-'\~( , '" i It~".tJ t/'/ 1m f' ~: ~V~~1:JJ~>~~~.&'~ W~E~ &J:~1l . -/"A '-, 'II ~ IOJ -~ V "" ,1' I' .. ~/h I I I \I m -~ rj 13 '0 1/8 MILES} ~1 '-I.: :~ IJ// }OJ;::f- - .)= )~. . 0 FEET - - :rm:' · c'i ;r-, ..~ ::~~~E1'~ :~ " ~I~~ , J 0 40.800 OF--I1r. 3~'5 ~ ~ ,..' 1~ - ~ it. -1' ~ -~ n fiLA NN/N r. ,'1 I ~-I:, .... j c' \'I ,\ - .... '",<1 , If ~ !1 ,. '..1', \ r II { it" "n';1:..."'17/-1::J vMI _ ,~. "'1f'-'O- I I 1-' f- f- ! 1 \ 1 I fo- It ..., ..., BOYNTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Office of Professional Standards To: From: Date: Re: Tambri Heyden. Directo~ Lt. James Cwnmings ~ 28 February 1995 Shoppes of Woolbright, P.C.D. TRC Memo # 95-0121 The comments that I have regarding this project concern S.W. 8 Street, and the curb cuts made north of the entrance at Woolbright. Although I have no problems with the curb cuts themselves, I would like to see deceleration lanes placed at the sights of tbese cuts, in order to facilitate motorists, and to keep tbe roadway free from unnecessary congestion. ~....~ 00 mn\Ylrn~ I~'l' FE"" .~ 8 ' Ii Ii o .: ! ' I ~ ,'. PLANNING AND ZONING DEPT. //f MINUTES - CITY COMMISSION MEETING BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA MARCH 21, 1995 Description: Ttme Extenston: Request for approval of an 18 month retroactive and an indefinite time extension for zoning/master plan approval and concurrency exemption This item was tabled until the April 18, 1995 City Commission meeting. 3. Project: Agent: location: Boynton Beach Boulevard PCD Kieran Kilday South side of the intersection of Boynton Beach Boulevard and Winchester Park Boulevard Tt.. Extension: Request for approval of an 18 month retroactive and an indefinite time extension for zoning/master plan approval and concurrency exemption This item was tabled until the April 18, 1995 City Commission meeting. Description: Mayor Hanmening stated that he will not be here when these time extensions are discussed. He hoped the Commission does not grant them. 4. Project: Agent: Owner: location: Shoppes of WOolbright PCD CCl Consultants, Inc. Howard R. Scharlin, Trustee North side of Woolbright Road, east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 Canal Master Plan Modification: Request to modify the previously approved master plan to subdivide out- building 3 into .895 acres, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding 1 from 4,300 to 6,920 square feet, outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square This item was tabled by City Attorney Cherof so that it can be discussed at a shade meeting this Friday at 3:00 p.m. Description: C. Other None. IX. NEW BUSINESS A. Items for discusston requested by Vice Mayor Matson 1. Report on ..eting reference Lawrence Road 2. Two Resolutions Pertaining to Lawrence Road Vice Mayor Matson stated that last Wednesday, she facilitated a meeting between City Manager Parker, City Attorney Cherof, Director of Development William Hukill, herself, and representatives from GL Homes and Nautica, two communities - 10 - MINUTES - CITY COMMISSION MEETING BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA MARCH 21, 1995 should vote on this matter without the applicant making a presentation. Mayor Hanmening pointed out that their current concurrency in all of their master plan approvals expired months ago. Therefore, they are in arrears. Motion Vice Mayor Matson moved to table Items VIII.B.1, VIII.B.2 and VIII.B.3 until April 18, 1995 City Commission meeting. Mayor Pro Tem Bradley seconded the motion which carried 4-1. Mayor Hanmening cast the dissenting vote. City Attorney Cherof requested that Item VIII.B.4 be tabled so i~ql...5i~I>~~il~e discussed at a shade meeting this Friday at 3:00 p.m. He added Item X.D.1 (Update on the Finizio Appeal). 2. Adoption Motion the ;1::; [) ... /.//1,'_./ Vice Mayor Matson moved to approve the agenda as amended. Mayor Pro Tem Bradley seconded the motion which carried 5-0. II. ADMINISTRATIVE A. Appointments to be made Appointment To Be Made II Bradl ey II Bradley III Jaskiewicz I I Bradl ey II Bradley III Jaskiewicz I Rosen III Jaskiewicz IV Matson Mayor Hanmening I Rosen IV Matson I Rosen III Jaskiewicz Mayor Hanmeni ng I Rosen Reg/ Board Alt Education Advisory Board Alt Board of Adjustment Alt Cemetery Board Alt Education Advisory Board Alt Board of Adjustment Reg Nuisance Abatement Board Reg Civil Service Board Alt Education Advisory Board Reg Education Advisory Board Reg Planning & Development Alt Code Enforcement Board Reg Senior Advisory Board Reg Education Advisory Board Reg Community Relations Board Alt Community Redev. Adv. Brd. Reg Children and Youth Adv. Brd. Reg Length of Tenm Expiration Date Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED 2 yr tenm to 4/96 TABLED 1 yr tenm to 4/95 TABLED Tenm expi~es 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/97 TABLED Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 9/97 TABLED Tenm expires 4/96 TABLED Tenm expires 6/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/95 TABLED Tenm expires 8/95 TABLED Tenm expires 4/96 All tabled appointments were left on the table. Commissioner Rosen tabled his appointment to the Children and Youth Advisory Board. - 2 - MINUTES OF THE CITY COMMISSION MEETING HELD IN COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, ON TUESDAY, MARCH 21, ~99S, AT 6:30 P.M. PRESENT Edward Hanmening, Mayor Lynne Matson, Vice Mayor Matthew Bradley, Mayor Pro Tern Shirley Jaskiewicz, Commissioner Sidney Rosen, Commissioner Carrie Parker, City Manager James Cherof, City Attorney Sue Kruse, City Clerk I. OPENINGS A. Call to Order B. Invocation - James E. Henry - Deeper life Fellowship Full Gospel Church C. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag Mayor Hanmening called the meeting to order at 6:31 p.m. James E. Henry of the Deeper Life Fellowship Full Gospel offered the invocation. The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag was led by Mayor Hanmening. D. Agenda Approval 1. Additions, Deletions, Corrections Mayor Pro Tern Bradley tabled Item IX.B.l (Authorization for Goal Setting Team Building for the City Commission and City Department Heads) until the next meeting. He felt this item should have the new mayor's input. He replaced this item with an update on the Poinciana Elementary School MarJnet, and added Item IX.B.2 (Update on the Funding for the Boynton Commun~ty Life Center). Vice Mayor Matson added Item IV.A.2 (Pennies fOr P.A.L.) and Item IV.A.3 (Easter Egg Hunt Extravaganza). She changed iteril IX~A,2 to read, "Two Re'solutions Pertaining to Lawrence Road". She also added Item IX.A.3 (Florida League of Cities Legislative Session). Commissioner Rosen asked that Item III.C.3 be tabled. City Manager Parker asked Mark Law of the Utilities Department if there is a timetable on the Joint Participation Agreement. Mr. Law advised that a specific deadline was not given. City Manager Parker deleted Item 111.B.3. She explained that this needs to be rebid because it is not a one-year extension for the same product. ~~. _~ \') h\L Z ...-t':..' ~. ....;. City Manager Parker advised that she received a letter from Kilday & Associates, requesting that Items VIII.B.I, VIII.B.2 and VIII.B.3 be tabled until the April 18, 1995 meeting. Mayor Hanmenin9 was not in favor of tabling these items. Vice Mayor Matson felt the Commission should honor the request to table because the letter states that an additional thirty days is needed to solidify timetables for development. In addition, she did not think the Commission _....- - ._-^"- - 1 - .,--, ' VIII. DEVELOPMENT PLANS B.4 cc: Plan, Dev, Util PLANNING AND ZONING DEPART! MEMORANDUM NO. 95-107 Agenda Memorandum for March 21, 1995 City Commission Meeting TO: Carrie Parker City Manager FROM: ~ I Tarnbri J. Heyden )/J Planning and Zoning Director SUBJECT: March 16, 1995 Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - MPMD 95-001 Master Plan Modification subdivide Tract C, redistribute square footage within the three outbuildings located on Tract C, relocate a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street and make a medican cut in S.W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway. DATE: Please place the above-referenced request on the March 21, 1995 Ci ty Commission agenda under Development Plans, Non-consent agenda. DESCRIPTION: This is a request to amend the previously approved master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD, located at the northeast corner of Woolbright Road and the E-4 Canal. The changes include approval to subdivide Tract C to create outbuilding 3 on a .895 acre property, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding 1 from 4,300 to 6.920 square feet, outbuilding 2 from 5,000 to 5,755 square feet and outbuilding 3 from 4,300 to 2,625 square feet), add a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 400 feet north of Woolbright Road, relocate the existing driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, from 290 feet to 260 feet north of Woolbright Road and provide a median cut on S. W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway. RECOMMENDATION: The Planning and Development Board, with a 5-1 vote, recommended denial of this request. The basis for the denial was that the proposed changes were not consistent with the court ordered stipulation agreements. TJH/pb c:ccmtg321.shp 1 .... ., L. 7.B.l SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD MASTER PLAN MODIFICATION II PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM NO. 95-090 *REVISED MARCH 13, 1995 TO: Chairman and Members planning and Developemnt Board THRU: Tambri J. Heyden planning and Zoning Director FROM: Michael E. Haag Zoning and site Development Administrator DATE: March 10, 1995 SUBJECT: Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - File No. MPMD 95-001 Master plan modification (driveway, median cut and shift in outparcel sizes and boundaries) NATURE OF REQUEST eeL Consultants, Inc., agent for Howard R. scharlin, trustee of the property, is requesting approval to modify the previously approved master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD. The 31.99 acre planned commercial development zoned property, approved for 284,620 square feet of commercial/retail development, is located on the north side of Woolbright Road and east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 canal. The proposed changes, described in the attached letter from CCL Consul tants, dated February 14, 1995 (see Exhibit" A ") are itemized below. In addition to the changes stated in the letter of submittal, a second driveway is requested located on the east side of s. \.J. 8th street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD (see Exhibit "B" - proposed master plan): 1. Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate .895 acre outparcel. Tract C is located at the northeast corner of S.W. 8th street and Woolbright Road and south of the main entrance into the Home Depot. * ") .. . Change in the size of the outbuilding 3 from a one-story, 4,300 square foot building to a one-story, 2,625 square foot drive-through, fast food restaurant. A conditional use application, as required by the zoning code, is in progress for a drive-through, fast food restaurant as the use of this outbuilding. 3. Change in the building area of outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet. 4. Change in the bUilding area of outparcel 1 from 4,300 square feet to 6,920 square feet. * 5. Relocation of the existing driveway located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 30 feet south, from 290 feet to 260 from the south property line of the PCD. 6. Ac;idition of a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD. This driveway was requested on a previous master plan modification that was tabled by the City Commission; therefore it has been added to this request. BACKGROUND The Shoppes of Woolbright PCD is part of a November 6, 1986 and January 24, 1990 stipulated settlement agreement between the city and Tradewinds Development Corporation. The City Commission ratified the settlement agreement by approving a master plan modification on May 15, 1990 that depicted the applicable conditions of the January 24, 1990 stipulation and settlement agreement (see Exhibit "C" - master plan pursuant to the 1990 stipulate~ settlement agreement). The agreement vested the project fOl- trafflc, t'later and sevler, so that no time extensions for .., -( v '-' JO ~J~d SE papnI~u1 ~OU 51 Ja~ua~ UapJED aq~ JO a5e~00J aJEnbs aq~ '~uaWaaJfiE ~uawaI~~a5 0661 aq~ o~ ~UEnSJnd "~aa~ 6JEnbs 021'8~ o~ ~aaJ a_1Enbs SLE / 61 WO.1J paSEa_l~tq: _la~ua; Uc-p.1ED aq.L "~odaa awoq aq~ ~E Ja~ua~ uapxe5 aq:+ O~ ~aa.J a.1Enbs SvL'8 JO u01~lPPE aq~ apnl~u1 o~ ~sanb6_1 - [661 JO lp.H'J.-I . .... c. 'atqE~ aq~ WOJJ paAOW8J ~ou SEM ~sanba~ aq~ a~~~lpul spJo~a~ ~~1~ JO Ma1AaJ V "an5s1 aq~ uo spUTMapEJ.1 JO~ tasuno~ q~TM Ja~uo~ o~ paqsTM ~auJo~~v ~r~~ aq~ ~Eq~ pu~ as~~ spUTMap~J.1 aq~ uT uOT~oW 5u1Puad E 10 asn~~aq ^auJo~~v A~ 1;) aq~ JO ~sanbaJ aq~ ~E palqE~ 5EM ~sanbaJ aq~ ~Eq~ a~e~s s5uT~aaw UOT sSTwwo~ ~~ 1~ 1661 '61 Jaqwa~das pue 1661 /o~ ~sn6nv aq~ WOJ~ sa~nu1w aq.L "peo~ ~q5TJqtOOM uo ~eMaATJp tEUoT~lPpe aq~ 10 uOT~da~xa aq~ q~TM / ~ sanbaJ aq~ 10 IeAo~dde papuaWwo~aJ pJeog aq.L . 1661 '(1 ~5n6nv uo (p~EOa ~uaWdOtaAaa PUE OUTUUetd aq~ se UMOU~ MOU) pJEOg fiUTUOZ pue fiu1uueId aq~ o~ pa~uasaJd SEM ~sanbaJ slq.L '(~uawaaJoe ~uawaI~~as 0661 aq~ ~q paMoIt~ ~TW1t a~~ ulq~lM) ~aaJ aJenbs 08<::' L It: o~ 08S / S T e: WOJJ a~d aq~ JOJ a5E~00J o:uenbs 1iqo~ aq~ oUTsea_l~u1 ~qa_laq~ '~aa1 aJenbs OOL'l JO aseaJ~ul ~au E u1 pa~tnsaJ a5E~00J aJenbs o~ 5uoT~e~TJ1Pow aq.L 'a~Ts ~odaa awoH aq~ PUE ~aaJ~S q~8 'M"S 10 apTs ~sea aq~ uo pa~E~oI sta~Jed~no aq~ uaaM~aq uOl~~auuo~ aIsTe ssa~~e q~Jou aq~ e~~uTWlt8 "J pue 1SIa~JEd~no Ja~ua~ oU1ddoqs eq~ o~ speet ~Eq~ ~eaJ~S q~8 'M'S 10 epTs ~sea aq~ u~ pa~e~ot AeMaA1Jp paAoJddE aq~ pJeMq~nos a~e~Ota~ '6 1~aeJ~S q~8 'M'S 10 ep15 ~SEe eq~ uo pa~e~ot sta~JEd~no Ja~ue~ oUTddoqs aq~ o~ ~aaJ~S q~8 'M'S WOJJ ~eMaATJp Jeq~oue 10 UOT~lPPV .p 1 qonOJq~-eA l.lp q~TM )(UEq ~ooJ aJEnbs 000' 9 ' AJO~S-OM~ E o~ OU1PITnq tlE~aJ ~001 aJEnbs OOe:/v E WOJJ ~aaJ~S q~8 'M'S PUE peo~ ~q5lJqtOOM JO JaUJO~ ~seeq~JOU aq~ ~E te~Jed~no aq~ JO asn 10 UOT~EuoTsap PUE seTJo~s 10 Jaqwnu 'azTs uT a5ueq~ "~ 1(tE~~lwqns eq~ WOJ1 '~uE~TIddE aq~ ~q UMEJpq~lM SEM ~senbeJ eq~ 10 U01~Jod slq~) uOl~e~s se5 ~ooJ aJEnbs OS~/1 E o~ tEl~Jewwo~ 11E~eJ 10 ~aeJ aJEnbs OOO/v WOJ1 ~eeJ~S q~8 'M'S PUE pEOH ~q6TJqlooM 10 JaUJO~ ~seMq~JOU eq~ ~e le~JEd~no eq~ JO eZTs PUE esn uT e5ueq~ 'q !~eeJ~S q~8 'M'S JO ~seM pe~e~ot 'PEoH ~qfiTJqtOOM O~UO ~EMeATJp Mau E JO uOT~lPPV 'E :nulMOltOJ eq~ epnl~u1 o~ ~senbeJ - 1661 JO ~ew 'Z '6861 '1~ JeqweAoN uo ~sanbaJ slq~ paAoJddE uOlSS1WWO;) ~~ l~ eq.1 . ~ea1 aJ~nbs 08 S 's 1 E ~e peouEq~un peulEweJ a~d eq~ JOJ a5E~001 eJenbs te~o~ eq.L "Je~ue~ uepJED ~001 eJenbs SLe:'61 e PUE tle~aJ 10 ~aaJ aJenbs OS~/,ot papnt~ul q~lqM (~odea awoH) aJo~s stelJe~ew 5ulPlTnq E 10 uOl~TPPE eq~ apnl~uT o~ ~senbeJ 6861 10 Jaqo~~o "I :MelAeJ JOJ pe~~lwqns ueaq eAEq SU01~E~T1TPoW uetd Ja~sew OUTMOttOJ eq~ '~uaWaeJOE ~uewat~~as TEUlfilJO eq~ e~ulS '~eeJ aJEnbs 08S/Ste: ~TUO s~~atJaJ uetd Je~sew 0661 6q~ 'J6A6MOH 'UEtd J6~SEW ~uewaT~~as 0661 aq~ - II~II ~ Tqlqx3 uo pe~~Td6p ~no~El PUE sesn eq~ epnT~uT o~ / ~6aJ eJenbs OOO/OZe: JO wnwlxew e peAoJdde ~ueweeJfie ~ueweI~~es eq.1 "~~JedoJd eq~ JO ~no-Pt1nq o~ JOTJd 'peJTnbaJ eq JeAa PtnOM .l~ueJJn~uo~ 5661 '6 q~JEH pJeog ~uewdoTeAea pue 5uTuUEld :0.1 , " 3 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 the retail gross leasable area. The request included adjusting property lines to accommodate the expansion and the total square footage of the project remained at 315,580. On April 20, 1993 the City Commission approved the 8,745 square foot expansion subject to staff comments, and on August 10, 1993 the Planning and Development board approved a waiver of platting for the adjusted property lines in connection with the expansion. 4. March of 1993 - request to include the following: a. Subdivision of Tract B to create a .957 acre outparcel. Tract B is that portion of the PCD that is located on the west side of S.W. 8th street; b. Change in use and size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 3,040 square foot gas station (resurrection of the portion of the 1991 request that was withdrawn by the applicant); c. Add two new driveways into the proposed service station outparcel - one on s. W. 8th street and the other on Woolbright Road; d. Allow a canopy over the gasoline pumps to encroach the setbacks due to a difference in the service station regulations in effect in 1986 vs. the service station regulations in effect in 1993; and e. Reduce the building square footage specified on the master plan for Tract B from 62,000 to 55,040 square feet. With this request, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 6,960 square feet from 315,580 to 308,620. On April 20, 1993 the City Commission approved the request, subject to staff comments. As a result of the traffic evaluation of the proposed service station use, the square footage on Tract B decreased 24,000 square feet from a total of 55,040 square feet (52,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasol ine sales) to 31,040 square feet ( 28,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) . Therefore, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 24,000 square feet from 308,620 to 284,620 square feet. ANALYSIS Changes in Planned Commercial Development (PCD) master plans are reviewed consistent with, Section 6.F.13.b. of Appendix A - Zoning as follows; b. "Modifications to approved plans which resul t in an increase of less than ten (10) per cent in measurable impacts as determined by including any changes in traffic generated, water consumed or sewage to be collected will require review and recommendation the planning and zoning board and final approval by the city commission. The city commission decision to approve, approve with modifications or deny, shall be predicated upon a finding of consistency with the comprehensive plan and a finding that any such increase will not resul t in a negative impact on infrastructure delivery systems or the surrounding area in general. It is the intent of this ~ ~) ..., .., 4 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 section that all additional impacts be mitigated..." Based on the documentation provided, the changes to the three outparcels would generate in excess of a ten (10) per cent increase in water consumed and sewage collected, if the approved outparcels are evaluated against the proposed outparcels. An increase of only 2.8% in water consumed and sewage collected results if the proposed outparcels are evaluated against the entire PCD water and sewer impacts. In either scenario, the utility Department does not have an objection to the analysis provided and has not indicated that the increase will have a negative impact on the infrastruture delivery systems. A slight increase in pervious area will result in a minimal, positive impact on the PCD drainage. with respect to traffic, the traffic information submitted indicates that the traffic generated by the three outparcels will generate less than a ten (10) percent change. This information has been forwarded to Palm Beach County. The results of the review by the County have not been received at the time of this report. The following is an evaluation of each of the proposed changes listed on page one of this report: 1. Subdi vis ion of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate outparcel and the redistribution of square footage among the outparcels As indicated in the stipulation settlement agreem@nt, this is acceptable. Platting or a waiver of platting (at the determination of the City Engineer) to subdivide this parcel is required. As required, outparcels shall be self-sufficient with respect to lot size, setbacks, parking and other PCD zoning district requirements. 2. Relocation of the existing driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, south of the main entrance into the shopping center (Home Depot) - One entrance, in addition to the main entrance, was allowed pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement. This eXisting driveway is the additional driveway referenced in the agreement. The proposed location of this additional driveway is closer to the original position (centrally located) identified in the Barton-Aschman traffic report, upon which the traffic conditions of the 1990 settlement agreement were based. ~ ...) . Addition of a second driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, between Woolbright Road and the main entrance to the shopping center (Home Depot) - As mentioned in previous item =2, the number of driveways is specifically limited in the 1990 settlement agreement. The addition of a second driveway is inconsistent with the 1990 settlement agreement. Since the Barton-Aschman report does not require an additional driveway to be added, it could be argued that this driveway is not needed and that safety and level of service are not impaired without it. Furthermore, this type of access des ign is contrary to the intent and purpose of a PCD, which is to provide for a planned (not piece-meal) , programmed series of development operations, designed as a whole through integration of principle buildings and ou~buildings that are linked via common use of access and infrastructure and similar architecture and other aesthetic elements. Specifically with respect to access, this additional driveway defeats the purpose of requiring internal access roads and driveways to serve parcels within a planned develcpment. It should also be noted that the Barton-Aschman report stated 4 5 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 that the driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street located north of the existing main entrance driveway was to be de:eted. The proposed master plan still reflects this driveway as being approved. 4. Median cut in S.W. 8th street If approved, this new intersection would capture much of the traffic anticipated and designed to be received by the main driveway that is located at the entrance to Home Depot. The main driveway is centrally located for the major portion of the retail uses located on the east side of S.W. 8th street. Since the Barton-Aschman report did not recommend a median cut, it could be argued that the proposed median cut is not consistent with the traffic report referenced in the 1990 settlement agreement and therefore not needed or possibly affecting level of service. Therefore, if the median cut is approved, it is recommended that a new analysis of the turning movements be submitted to determine the impact the median cut will have on S. W. 8th street and Woolbright Road. Also, the proposed median cut would cause the east driveway into the site to become a major driveway which requires a one hundred (100) foot throat; the distance from the property line to a parking space or an access aisle. This would significantly impact the parking design of outbuilding 3. CONCLUSION This request was reviewed by the Technical Review Committee (TRC) on February 28, 1995 and the committee raised no objections at the time. However; .the committee did not have technical data regarding the impact the median cut and additional driveway would have on the surrounding roadways or the project itself. If this driveway and median cut are approved by the Commission, the Police Department recommends that north and south deceleration lanes be required at the cut to avoid congestion from motorists slowing down to make turns at this location (see Exhibit "D" Police Department Memorandum No. 95-0121). It is also recommended that if any changes are approved by the Commission that are not reflected, or are contrary to, the proposed master plan, that three copies of a revised master plan be submitted to the Planning and Zoning Department, prior to submittal of any future PCD requests. The Planning and Zoning Department is not making a specific recommendation on this request since components of the request are inconsistent with the latest settlement agreement. Deviation from this agreement are viewed as policy decisions of the Commission. tjh Attachments xc: Central File A:WoolPCD !~... '- ., ."", ..", f,Xll1.B1.'t p.. () CCl CONSULTANTS, INC. Consulting Engineers m Surveyor, Planners / 2200 PARK CENTRAL BLVD., N, SUITE 100, POMPANO BEACH, FL 33064, (305) 974-2200 · FAX (305) 973-2686 February 14, 1995 Hand Delivery Ms. Tambri Heyden Planning Director CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd. Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310 Re: SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD Boynton Beach, Florida CCL Project No. 3~Ol Dear Ms. Heyden: Enclosed herewith please find the following: 1. Twelve (12) signed and sealed prints of the revised master plan for the above-referenced project. 2 . A check made payable to the City of Boynton Beach in the amount of $500.00. 3. Letter of Authorization form owner for CCL Consultants, Inc. to act as. agent for this matter. Please be advised that we are herein submitting for master plan amendment for the above-referenced project. We are proposing to amend the existing master plan as follows: A. Outparcel 1 will be revised from 4300 SF to 6920 SF. B. Outparcel 2 will be revised from 5000 SF to 5755 SF. C. Outparcel 3 will be revised from a 2-story 6000 SF bank to a I-story 2625 SF Taco Bell Fast Food Restaurant with a drive- thru lane. D. The locations of the driveways for these outparcels onto S.W. 8th Street will be revised from what is presently shown on the existing master plan. In addition, we are proposing a median cut in the S.W. 8th Street median which aligns with one of the proposed relocated driveways as well as prior-approved driveway location on the west side of S.W. 8th Street. t ~ , ..... .. .., , . Ms. Tambri Heyden CCL project No. 3101 February 14, 1995 Page two We respectfully request that this proposed master plan amendment be placed on the next Technical Review Committee agenda and thusly on the next available Planning & Development Board as well as City Commission Agenda. Should you have any questions or need any additional information, '" please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, panile, Jr., P.E., P.L.S. ject Manager LRC/kaq Enclosure cc: Mike Morton, Tradewinds Group Eduardo Carcache, P.E.,CKE Group, Inc. CCl CONSULTANTS, INC. ~ (7 f,1.\l1. B1.'t B ';r lOt"'''', ....-0 ;-4...~ T~~" :EC: ~=;t~ M,- .:z:"'~ ;!,: Q'" JI.... o....::i .0" ~;! . z z .. .. ~nN .. ::e:;( alloZ! ,-I...Z wicg =-... i" w,-m", 0"< i!~J! ",,0 .. " w..K ~S~ ..... .. .. n i10 ... (Il " ~ C5 z _QlI"'O ~g~~ =:~~ 't~&n; ;0"'.. ~,;Z:~ ~~; i~~ ~d~ t:!~ :..~ 't:D", wO.. ..0 :0 >> .. ~ .. is o . ;~Ncn ;;gi :,,~:;; ,..0..(; '!'~In :~~~ 1; ".. . %~e- . .... .....z ,..... o -4QS- .. . ;; .. .. z w " ~ i ~ ~ ~ .. F 'Y. ~;I -~... 1"0" ....utO. ..ool~~ j!1 .....c. W>>Of6U1 1~-1Z "~11... !;;a. :.~3 ~~I .mr''21 l;~.o ~~~ .% ..~ ...<.- ,..... 00", oz.. i~ a~:W )Io_~ t:g~ '. ;l . .... I 0%" , .. 4.... , ~ S,. , ..n .. ..0 'J i ~! r .... 1!! -rn ~ gP .. In ~~J~ ....!II g/'ji:l,. zH ;!l~' WII!~ ~ ;; 8= n 0 !II F CJl 0 n . III CD 0 CD ~ CI I CD q <= 0 ~~ I at"'.... ....,,,~ ~~ . -=-'0 of/:::::=- ,e .\(;. "\ ,~~.,lJ.' ~ lf~:f;:----=--- ~"~'i' ~';*----~" . ....so - 'i'~ ( - - .~~ , !=I...,....."'C.TI.""A..,,~ W.. TH ~~ ----~l.: r-!! ~~.:.Q::.:'.:..~::~.;Hi1 ~. ,- . ".I:.L...b"'.......". _--::::=----.,'>----: "L \"" --'-------.:&---,!4f \---. " ~\ - ~iF n. - _ ---:;1-":'" I - __ ," '"" ~---" : ~ - i ,-.=4... ~ ~....~ r \{~.. ~-~ ~-7 ~: 71 ",~~7i~~ :l-lll ~~- -__;Jf>. "I ~'II m ~ I ,"'~i ~.- ~ ~~I r y~ ~ .~ " ".,S , ~ F -=... = ""+ ~ _:..' p!' ~ ~I I ,I /.----.....~=<"'-!' :t'" ._1: \'_ ~-~.::. '~-J ,_ " '" - /" 1- ~~ ...", -.. . - :'L; ',--:: \. I /.......----:--/' :~' I T-;~-I-:b:t~= "".... .u L, /X ~ _d ..~ 'T'l' _ i,.... - ~ . I --<: /'. I " 'I \ ~~. ~f:r r~"~- :( ~- ~', ~l"t It- - \~~A' ~ '-',,- I , ~\) ~I i ~I "" -- la; /. = /.. i '1 :f . . -~ \; = J/ -v"\ - -/JL~ II ~~. ~(- ' '~ll~~=" It II I , I , II It' -+t ______ ../ .: \ . 0.... ~ '.' \ "\ -- :vv';>-", d I ~i'l -j ,0, -,: \ 'i!~';~i\ ~~':"~+H:C~\,:" I , , . I. .,'''-lU!:., .;;:: Sir 'i\~' n ~~- c_._:~J.:-..JtU=:= I (' :' '- \""~ ,-1.'1, \If'\ II si I~ c.J" f1 t-- , ."! U' k. : ~ \ ~ II . I , \'" ...~ \ ~ ai 'I~I --,', \ .: '~1 ~ .z IV % ) II I I, I " ~.~~~~II ~O..I:~. f:'-=,\'~: W ~:~::I ,,, J,,...L I H~; I ~lil ....:....' ~ ~ ~ I ~"'~ \ '"a '4 F". ..,,1.. i~' ~ \ Et ~. r i 1:1 II' -.. .~~....~ "L j I,~.. ! ~~, ' , I . '- . r 1- .'<'~ ..,. ,-- i :' i so"':rc..~.. - ~+-- ----'-L- " / ,'-~--;g!J :: \ .0 ~ - -- - J SO'WCIDllNI " ! e; I =Q" r - - -:: -_ - -- . -- - ~ - --J. - -; , ~ ,- , ,., -;"" I "1'-.:..1 - -=- -=- I :I I :c I - - - ' "- -- - 'f' -- -- -- - -- -- - - >:"...-u.. ".,;;0..-..-- - - - ~ -- - - -- - - -. H~~ - - ~g ;,~-: 1 ".., 01-- = ! Co~1 .: :i I i ~; ~ ~ S.C;L,~ ~.;'l~ROAD ~ ~ _ ~ i~i ~i ~ ~ ~. ~ ~! : :c: ('"I o 0 ; \. " .1, ... '" o \ I. I \. I'~ '" l \'\1 \ ,I . 1.l ') .. ~ :'11 ~ " . I :: , i ~ '{' "~i '" lD .,t- ~ Q 01 i '~... -j Ifl ur !Ii 111 [u 14~ ~!JI IU ~U ;1- ~J !- !' lis ~z~i:~: ::::;;apce::a :;~~::~; ~~~~~im ~E~::~~2 ",6;:~g..." ~~;CII~5: g.....e ii' -4:i~.~Qi -4~!:~!2n~ %212: c.~- ,.t )ooUJE 0 ~"'aO ...z ~~~~~~~ ~ca:~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~.J-:!~a:lt ~~~o=~J <"Hn~z,.; ;~.ia~E ~~$S=~: ,"o"l)zo.. -4~o>>O,,"c 3~g~i! 0=:"'% '" z- UI~ :;o~~~ :aut On "'~ '21.. .. '" .~iZ :o!~ ..2 m ~i:en I; i .!. t ii :: .-'0 ..!. . la I' ... ~ ~j i ~~ : ~: I:i - . . ' i.c . .. 1 ~ :. i! it ft - : ! " . So . ~ ; ~ g .. i .. .. ~ " 1ft ... !!2 ~ ~ ~ ~~;;. 1ft ~ill ~ r ell ~ ~ !l~ ::!~ o .. .. ... ... w .. :. i.o .. .. ~ r; w '" '" '; i .. co .. ... ... ~ '" .. 0 ... '" ~ ~ - ~ n8 ~i ~:II15 10!1~ ~:;i ~~ l!!m 'V F !' o ~ ~ , ;i ~ - .. ~ z ~ en ~ :II ~ l') n m en en :II o ~' c i ~ ~~ :a ~ ~< m m i; sa ! ~~ liil ~ ~.. Z ~o -f "a ~~;r- ~d r- ~ z m :: ~ ;: != ~ ? .. 101110 w . ; g ! ~ ; ~ i Q ~ ; r- . Z C C (/) m al '" ;U .. m = ~ 08 '3. ; ~ e .. i ;t : ;~ ... .. .. en 'rll' '!rl~"!!'H!I'!t'!'lllll'!; 2 .. ,. 0 0 S ;;; " .. .. .... g ~ .. =4 i1tiJ; ;' }!)J.l ~ !~4i ;:. f i ~ .. .. ., " " " ~ .. .' ,'f'?,I'" "11..1.,' !iI I i :D g I ~i .. .. ,. m . II I. - . 11 'I: < ~I U 1~~.11- rJhl~'.~.!'i~ I if!! l[ ~ I 5 .. ... ,. N C .. I gjl .. ,. 2 c , ,I ''rI'i' d', I'i i .. .. .. g ~ If! 1:1.. "11 :\ .. .. ..D 1: .. .. .. ~!i .. !,I '''11' !I .. ~ ;; ,. .. .. . .. .. S .. .. I'. fo. '1 ~ .. 1ft .. (.;' li-: II 0 0 .. .. - I II f ~~( II .. n .. 0 I l~ I, ..', !I . I: ( t \I .1.. j:; " I: :, 'it,u!' I,oi. Pt" i: = .. ii;liiniji1ij;:iI il :D ;; 0 ~ II' ~::il! ",:,;.:rl ll~ il ii ,. ~h.h.'.fIJJn.,..t, tn' ~: .. i~ i'ilif'~l!i~:'fl~"!t f'.'" -I ,rii .. l ~. ~It! 1" r; '" ... '" '" w .. 0; '" . ... ji n ... .. ... N .. : '" b '" ~ .. '" .. .. .. # .. .. # ::: .. i! ~ " " 0 .. i, ~ .. .. ~ n .j .. .. ... I, .. .. , ;! H r! !! l:l5 ~O "'~ ~- ~O zZ ~3: Ul~ :rt~ z l:l . ... m /Ii v~J ~~. ~~ / ,.....;! . k~7?it Scalf 1 . 10. D_te 117.J.1III DrllW" B,. DA~ F,leNo uos.' XR 421.' O,,,,,,,,ng No 15-34 ShHt---1-.af SHOPPES OF WOOLBR,L,G,tIT :O,fN~ BEACH. F~ORIDA .;?--:~ MASTER PLAN' ~ - Kildav b Assoclales Landsc<1pe Archltccls/Plal1nt:!rs 1551 Forum Place SUite l00A West Palm Beach. Flonda 33401 (30516895522 PROPOSED it') I f,X1:l1.B1.'t C << . II -~-- CJl n III ii' -; I a:l q z o ... :r i8n= .. - =:~ !a~ !.z: .... ..c Om ~~ ..0 ~! ;:" Z8 ... ..a .", 5 .. m ~ o .. ~~ .~- Scale: 1 . 80 Dale. ]{28HIO Drawn By CAP Fill! No ~211 Drawing No 85-J4 Sheet-L-of ... ~.~ ::21 ....'" -"c:.-< >> ...us ....'" ;r:"'.. ..Ie:! m"'" ~;O ",Z'C. . JIo? .,,<.. ..mm OZ", ~i~ "UI~ ..go ...... :Z; -.... 50" ..n mO :::i 0'" m .. ,. ~~ . ~ '. 'f- ~ . . II~I~ I .. ~ ~ Ill"' C a m..!~ .. ~ . III , ';: :: ;: = ~ ........:.. c~-:...~ ". .I_I ,'" : i ; ,!.t.. \ .. Q':" . ~::... ........... :& ii ~ ~ ~ . . . . .' ; . III Ilrt o .. W .... N ##### 1111 it ! ~ j ~ ~ i ;a:'" ill 8 ~ g Ii .. i ~ ~~ t '" ~ ~ ! ! .. ~ -72 ~ ! ~ CI Q........ '" n : i '" I: ~ ; . 0 II ~ '" m = ..... 1lI- -N~W n~ ~~ "1lI-- ~~W. ;.~: r~", ..~.. ~ ~ .:: '" '" ." n .... . 'WI ~. . :..; ."- ~....3'ii-l~->..~ti({~.,,.,. .~,...; ...... .(~ . - ;;~ Is -~ sOii41,' E ,rltl JII" :IJ:'~"tHn'n;IIIIPl II: I '11":it ,1:',:",:1 1"111 ;,1 . ~. . at, ~ ".( . u ' 111l1"I'llllp~'':'I,,1 "lIlq ",:rl~ ~'d'I:il~1' "~ J i I ;111!li~:'~~~~!~ :l~ I! I ;: iP'I!p'~~:::ia'l II~ " 11,;""11"'1;:; · " I Ji !::!:':iill,!.!,~ ~~ I' 'l'I!I:i\,Wt'I:I!9IIJ'i~ !"i " . ' I.' (., irt:I.;J ,1 II' '1' "I.j'I'. 'J!o,,~,1 jljl It . ,':1.. ft. .IL..., :J.. .. r. ''1JI"'I''fl. "~lli II" i .11,. .111..... "'lIr.", II o :' 'II ~ lJ:.;;r' I. · I ,I;, !. ~Ii,'l!r;.' I' . ,;.'I!h;'/ ~ Ill~!1 .f Ii I~ . , JI ii !i ., I' I!i ,i UBI" Ie: I ~' I c: SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT - .. REVISIONS . P C 0 -~~~ BOYNTO'N BE~H, F~ORIDA IJ- ~ MASTERPLAN' ~ i 8 , 11 i i I: ~1Il =iI :II ~< m ..en ..- w" 0 .m m ~.. Z GO ~ . <- 3z )> .....r- .0 z .m .. .. ~ III III -a"'''' :,"0; i~:~ ::~g= !..cln :=~i ~a.. :=e :,,~~ s= r~I"Jt.. ... ", ;: ~ ~ : \ ~! ~ ~ I \ ~ 'I.. ~ ,1\ " l 1 I' :1 \ II ! ~ " c". ',. \ '. ~ ' , I' ' i Ii I i \ .~ >~j k~ ~ \ , ~ I ! ~ \ [ .: I I i , ..' . '.J1 I I' II"'" i III 'Il 'S"'II:. 01 ' i .>' ~ 'f "~r' "1, ,1 i.': [ ,il '1 ~~. r- ,[ >~l "'!I'. d)::' ~! ' j II j w 'I , ~, I ; I i : I i!J )> a .j \ L~~' -= q , ; :; Ij !~ ~ ~ i ~ ; I -~ o~ '0 .. . =- ~~ ai ~! , ! 5 ~ ~ .. Ul ~ ~ Z a co en ::rt Z l:l Kilday & Associates Landscape Architects/Planners 1551 Forum Place Suite l00A West Palm Beach. FlOrida 33401 .130516B95522 E X H I BIT D /3 .... ~ BOYNTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Office of Professional Standards To: From: Date: Re: Tambri Heyden. Directo~ Lt. James Cwnmings ~ 28 February 1995 Shoppes of Woolbright, P.C.D. TRC Memo # 95-0121 The comments that I have regarding this project concern S.W. 8 Street, and the curb cuts made north of the entrance at Woolbright. Although I have no problems with the curb cuts themselves, I would like to see deceleration lanes placed at the sights of these cuts, in order to facilitate motorists, and to keep the roadway free from unnecessary congestion. 00 rn III rn U \If rn,~ tt""l ,", 8 II ! I 1 ' rcu ~ t I . .- I PLANNING AND ZONING DEPT. //f uJ\..If\' ,UN N\/U" ,HOPPES OF WOOLBR\GHl P .c.O ", \' \ \ U ~; .~ R e - c peO ..-cN 6~~i"(''''' . ~ ~ .!--=r -:J c::- - \~\ r'=:../i '., _ ::,-3.." vr-- ::'.. 'l . ~, ' :'''' " I \ I, ~ \ '.:: ", \ ; ..,' . ,../ ~~q" ,I W' .. MINUTES - PLANNING ANt !YELOPMENT BOARD MEETING BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA MARCH 14, 1995 Chainman Lehnertz suggested giving the applicant six months to make a good faith effort. Ms. Heyden pointed out that all that would involve is submitting an application for a site plan or plat within six months. Mr. Kilday said he could probably have a submittal of the plat within six months. Motion Vice Chainman Dube moved to approve an 18 month retroactive and a 6 month time extension for zoning/master plan approval and concurrency exemption for the Boynton Beach Boulevard PCD based on the owner submitting a site plan for approval within that period of time, subject to staff comments. Mr. Weigle seconded the motion. Mr. Golden pointed out that a letter of intent is a pretty vague commitment. The motion carried 6-1. Mr. Golden cast the dissenting vote. 7. NEW BUSINESS A. Public Hearing Land Use Element Amendment/Rezoning Mlinstreet Car wash Jim Zengage Forward Progress, Inc. Between N. E. 1st Street and N. E. 2nd Street, imme- diately north of Mainstreet Car Wash Request for a map amendment to the Future land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan from Medium Density Residential to local Retail Commercial and rezoning from R-2 (Single and Duplex Dwelling District) to C-3 (Community Commercial) This item was rescheduled until April 11, 1995. 1. Project: Agent: Owner: location: Description: 8. Subdivisions Mister Plan Modification 1. Project: Agent: Owner: location: Description: Shopp.s of WOOlbright PCD CCl Consultants, Inc. Howard R. Schar11n, Trustee Northside of Woolbright Road, east of the l.W.D.D. E-4 Canal Request to modify the previously approved master plan to subdivide outbuilding 3 into .895 acres, revise the outbuilding sizes (outbuilding 1 from 4,300 to 6,920 square feet, outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square - 12 - MINUTES - PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA MARCH 14, 1995 feet to 5,755 square feet and outbuilding 3 from two stories and 6,000 square feet to one story and 2,625 square feet), add a driveway on the east side of S. W. 8th Street, 400 feet north of Woolbright Road, relocate the existing driveway on S. W. 8th Street, 190 feet to 260 feet north of Woolbright Road and provide a median cut on S. W. 8th Street for the relocated driveway. Ms. Heyden stated that the applicant is requesting approval to modify their pre- viously approved master plan. The property is 31.99 acres and is approved for 284,620 square feet of commercial retail development. This request is comprised of six parts. The first change is subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate .895 acres outparcel. Tract C is located at the northeast corner of S. W. 8th Street and Woolbright Road and south of the main entrance into Home Depot. The second part of the request is a change in the size of outbuilding 3 from a two-story 4,300 square foot bank to a one-story 2,625 square foot drive-through fast food restaurant. The issue of the drive-through is being reserved to the discussion of a conditional use application, which is pending for a Taco Bell Restaurant. The next part of the request is a change in the area of outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet. They shifted around the square footage of the outparcel. The overall square footage of the project has not changed. The fourth change is a change in the building area of outparcel 1 from 4,300 to 6,920 square feet. The fifth change is relocation of the existing driveway located on the east side of S. W. 8th Street, 30 feet south, from 290 feet to 260 from the south property line of the PCD. The last change is the addition of a driveway on the east side of S. W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD. This driveway was requested on a previous master plan modification that was tabled by the City Commission in 1991. . , The Shoppes of Woolbright PCD is part of a stipulated settlement agreement between the Tradewinds Development Corporation and the City that was entered into on January 24, 1990, which was a revision of an earlier stipulated settle- ment agreement from November 6, 1986. That stipulated settlement vested the project for traffic, water and sewer so that no time extensions would be required prior to build-out of the project. Ms. Heyden advised that some of the changes are inconsistent with the stipulated settlement agreement. Those changes will be discussed by the City Commission. - 13 - MINUTES - PLANNING AND _~VELOPMENT BOARD MEETING BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA MARCH 14, 1995 Since 1991, Mr. Morton, the primary agent for this piece of property, has iden- tified a punch list of items that are in dispute. The City has been working for the past three years toward revising the stipulated settlement agreement. Some of those issues are impacting the current applications that are in the process, such as the conditional use application for Taco Bell. However, since the agreement has not been finalized yet by the City Commission, this master plan modification is being submitted to reduce the punch list. The subdivision of Tract C is addressed in the agreement and is acceptable. According to the agreement, platting or a waiver of platting would be required to subdivide the property. With regard to relocation of the existing driveway on the east side of S. W. 8th Street, one entrance, in addition to the main entrance, was allowed pursuant to the 1990 agreement. This existing driveway is the additional driveway referenced in the agreement. Therefore, the proposed location of the additional driveway is closer to the original position, which was centrally located, iden- tified in the Barton-Aschman traffic report, upon which the traffic conditions of the 1990 agreement were based. Mr. Rosenstock left the meeting at 8:52 p.m. The addition of a second driveway is inconsistent with the agreement. Furthenmore, there are other reasons that this s~cond driveway is inconsistent. The intent of PCDs is to encourage a planned program series of operations that integrate all the buildings as one whole picture (integration of access ways, infrastructure, streets, landscaping and some kind of unifying element with respect to architecture). Therefore, this defeats the purpose of requiring internal access roads and driveways to serve parcels. In addition, the Barton-Aschman report indicated that the driveway on the east side of S. W. 8th Street, north of the existing main entrance driveway, was to be deleted. The proposed master plan still reflects this driveway as being approved. If the median cut in S. W. 8th Street is approved, this new intersection would capture much of the traffic anticipated and designed to be received by the main driveway. The new median cut would encourage the additional driveway being requested to become a major driveway as well. Therefore, the additional drive- way that would serve the Taco Bell Restaurant would have to meet the City's 100 foot throat requirement. If the median cut is approved, staff recommends that a new analysis of the, turning movements be submitted to detenmine the impact the median cut will have on S. W. 8th Street and Woolbright Road. Also, the Police Department recommended north and south deceleration lanes along 8th Street to serve the new driveway. It is also recommended that if any changes approved by the Commission are different than what is reflected on the proposed master plan, three copies of a revised master plan be submitted to the Planning and Zoning Department to reflect those changes. Vice Chainman Cube noticed that the building on the northwest corner is not the same shape as the building that was approved last year. Ms. Heyden explained - 14 - MINUTES - PLANNING AND 116ELOPMENT BOARD MEETING BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA MARCH 14, 1995 that she had recommended a master plan modification be submitted to address splitting that building. The site plan came in before the master plan modifica- tion. The site plan was approved and expired. Therefore, the master plan was never changed to reflect the change. Louis Campanelli, Vice President of CCL Consultants, felt that the median cut issue and also the major driveway issue should be left up to the attorneys and the City Engineer. He reminded everyone that the second driveway was approved by this Board in 1991. The driveway spacings meet the requirements. He respectfully requested that this application be approved. Mr. Weigle did not think the property owner should get anything except what is required by law. Chainman Lehnertz agreed. Mr. Golden agreed that the property owner should not be given anything further than what has been granted in the settlement. On the other hand, in order to develop this property, he felt that there are going to have to be some minor modifications to get things to work right. However, he did not think major changes are appropriate. It appeared to Mr. Golden that the additional driveway is being driven by the bank being changed to a fast food restaurant with drive-through. Chainman Lehnertz inquired about the status of the gas station that was previ- ously approved. Mr. Campanelli stated that it is presently under design. Chainman Lehnertz referred to the Woolbright Place PUD church parcel and asked if Mr. Campanelli is aware that the City has ordinances in tenms of the minimum distance between gas stations and churches. Mr. Campanelli indicated he was not aware of that. Vice Chainman Dube pointed out that the gas station was supposed to be built once the power l.ine was moved, which was about fourteen months ago. Mr. Campanelli stated that they also had to relocate an abandoned force main, which was recently done. With regard to the median cut, the engineer for Taco Bell was present and said he would be willing to work with Mr. Morton and remove that from the applica- tion. He is planning to submit the plans so that he can be in front of this Board at the April meeting. . Mr. Weigle stated that the area where Taco Bell is proposing to locate was approved as a bank and he felt it should remain as a bank. He stated that any site adjustments that the property owner wanted should have been included in the settlement agreement. He did not feel it was up to the Board to give anything to the property owner that is not in the settlement agreement. Mr. Golden noticed that the staff report addresses what was approved under the master plan for the settlement agreement in tenms of the square footage. However, it did not reflect all the square footage that was approved under the settlement agreement. Ms. Heyden stated that the latest approved master plan - 15 - MINUTES - PLANNING ANt' --~ELOPMENT BOARD MEETING BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA MARCH 14, 1995 allowed 284,000 square feet, and the settlement agreement allowed 320,000 square feet. Mr. Golden asked if the Board is obligated in any way to approve any square footage above and beyond what is reflected on the master plan that was tied to the agreement. Ms. Heyden could not answer that question. She said the 1990 master plan that was approved was a settlement master plan and showed 315,580 square feet. Both parties agreed that that was the settlement master plan and that was the square footage they wanted. Vice Chainman Dube felt Taco Bell would be a nice asset. The engineer for Taco Bell believed that when Taco Bell submitted an applica- tion, Michael Haag took it to the City Attorney and that the restaurant was going to be incorporated into the revised settlement. Mr. Golden asked what exactly is going on with the conditional use application. Ms. Heyden advised that Mr. Morton turned in the conditional use application because he contended that because the 1986 stipulated settlement agreement pro- hibits fast food restaurants and drive-throughs, but the 1990 agreement is silent, that the 1990 agreement supersedes the 1986 agreement. This is not staff's position. Therefore, since there was some doubt, when the application came in, it was put on hold, not only because of the drive-through issue, but because of the issue of subdividing and the new access issues. It seemed to Mr. Golden that this entire discussion is premature until they work out exactly what is what between these two versions and come to some consensus. Motion Mr. Weigle moved to deny the request to modify the previously approved master plan. Mr. Golden seconded the motion which carried 5-1. Vice Chainman Dube cast the dissenting vote. C. Consistency Review 1. Dental 'aborator1., as . conditional use in the C-l. Office Professtonal. zonint district Ms. Heyden stated that the City is initiating an amendment to the zoning code to allow dental laboratories in the C-1 zoning district. Due to the pyramiding of uses in the zoning district, if approved, this use will be allowed in the C-1, C-2, C-3, and C-4 zo~ing districts, subject to conditional use. Currently, den- tal laboratories are allowed only in the M-l zoning district. Ms. Heyden stated that this has come about because of a recent denial of an occupational license request for a laboratory in a multitenant building where a dentistry was located. The original occupational request for that dental laboratory was based on an interpretation that it was accessory to the den- tistry. The dental lab wants to move to a different bay within the building. Since it will no longer be adjacent to the dentistry, it will no longer be detennined to be accessory because it will be in and of itself a principal use. - 16 - ----~---~-~ .-'--- --------'.-.-- HANDOUT 7.B.l SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD MASTER PLAN MODIFICATION TO: THRU: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM NO. 95-090 *REVISED MARCH 13, 1995 Chairman and Members Planning and Develop~t Boarf2~ ~ Tambri J. Heyden --===:/~"- ~ Planning and Zoning Director /' Michael E. Haar1fj.~~ Zoning and Site opment Administrator March 10, 1995 ' Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - File No. MPMD 95-001 Master plan modification (driveway, median cut and shift in outparcel sizes and boundaries) NATURE OF REQUEST eCL Consultants, Inc., agent for Howard R. Scharlin, trustee of the property, is requesting approval to modify the previously approved master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD. The 31.99 acre planned commercial development zoned property, approved for 284,620 square feet of commercial/retail development, is located on the north side of Woolbright Road and east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 canal. The proposed changes, described in the attached letter from CCL Consul tants, dated February 14, 1995 ( see Exhibit "A") are itemized below. In addition to the changes stated in the letter of submittal, a second driveway is requested located on the east side of s. W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD (see Exhibit liB" - proposed master plan): 1. Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate .895 acre outparcel. Tract C is located at the northeast corner of S.W. 8th Street and Woolbright Road and south of the main entrance into the Home Depot. * "') <.. . Change in the size of the outbuilding 3 from a one-story, 4,300 square foot building to a one-story, 2,625 square foot drive-through, fast food restaurant. A conditional use application, as required by the zoning code, is in progress for a drive-through, fast food restaurant as the use of this outbuilding. 3. Change in the building area of outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet. 4. Change in the building area of outparcel 1 from 4,300 square feet to 6,920 square feet. * 5. Relocation of the existing driveway located on the east side of S.~i. 8th street, 30 feet south, from 290 feet to 260 from the south property line of the PCD. 6. Aqdition of a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD. This driveway was requested on a previous master plan modification that was tabled by the City Commission; therefore it has been added to this request. BACKGROUND The Shoppes of Woolbright PCD is part of a November 6, 1986 and January 24, 1990 stipulated settlement agreement between the city and Tradewinds Development Corporation. The City Commission ratified the settlement agreement by approving a master plan modification on May 15, 1990 that depicted the applicable condi tions of the January 24, 1990 stipulation and settlement agreement (see Exhibit "CH - master plan pursuant to the 1990 stipulated settlement agreement). The agreement vested the project for traffic, water and sewer, so that no time extensions for 7.B.! SHOP PES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD MASTER PLAN MODIFICATION PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM NO. 95-090 FROM: Chairman and Members Planning and Developemnt Board Tambri J. HeYdenJ~~'):? OIt-l~A"L Planning and Zoning Director ~ Michael E. Haa;--fjl.'f: I!u& Zoning and Site _ elopment Administrator March 10, 1995 . TO: THRU: DATE: SUBJECT: Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - File No. MPMD 95-001 Master plan modification (driveway, median cut and shift in outparcel sizes and boundaries) NATURE OF REQUEST CCL Consultants, Inc., agent for Howard R. Scharlin, trustee of the property, is requesting approval to modify the previously approved master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD. The 31.99 acre planned commercial development zoned property, approved for 284,620 square feet of commercial/retail development, is located on the north side of Woolbright Road and east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 canal. The proposed changes, described in the attached letter from CCL Consultants, dated February 14,1995 (see Exhibit "A") are itemized below. In addition to the changes stated in the letter of submittal, a second driveway is requested located on the east side of s. W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD (see Exhibit "B" - proposed master plan): 1. Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate .895 acre outparcel. Tract C is located at the northeast corner of S.W. 8th Street and Woolbright Road and south of the main entrance into the Home Depot. 2. Change in the size of the outbuilding 3 from a two-story, 6,000 square foot bank to a one-story, 2,625 square foot drive-through, fast food restaurant. A conditional use application, as required by the zoning code, is in progress for a drive-through, fast food restaurant as the use of this outbuilding. 3. Change in the building area of outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet. 4. Change in the building area of outparcel 1 from 4,300 square feet to 6,920 square feet. 5. Relocation of the existing driveway located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 70 feet north, from 190 feet to 260 from the south property line of the PCD. 6. Addition of a driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD. This driveway was requested on a previous master plan modification that was tabled by the City Commission; therefore it has been added to this request. BACKGROUND The Shoppes of Woolbright PCD is part of a November 6, 1986 and January 24, 1990 stipulated settlement agreement between the city and Tradewinds Development Corporation. The City Commission ratified the settlement agreement by approving a master plan modification on May 15, 1990 that depicted the applicable condi tions of the January 24, 1990 stipulation and settlement agreement (see Exhibit "C" - master plan pursuant to the 1990 stipulated settlement agreement). The agreement vested the proj ect for traffic, water and sewer, so that no time extensions for / 2 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 concurrency would ever be required, prior to build-out of the property. The settlement agreement approved a maximum of 320,000 square feet, to include the uses and layout depicted on Exhibit "C" - the 1990 settlement master plan. However, the 1990 master plan reflects only 315,580 square feet. Since the original settlement agreement, the following master plan modifications have been submitted for review: 1. october of 1989 request to include the addition of a building materials store (Home Depot) which included 102,250 square feet of retail and a 19,375 square foot garden center. The total square footage for the PCD remained unchanged at 315,580 square feet. The city Commission approved this request on November 21, 1989. 2. May of 1991 - request to include the following: a. Addition of a new driveway onto Woolbright Road, located west of S.W. 8th Street; b. Change in use and size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 1,250 square foot gas station (this portion of the request was withdrawn by the applicant, from the submittal); c. Change in size, number of stories and designation of use of the outparcel at the northeast corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th street from a 4,300 square foot retail building to a two-story, 6,000 square foot bank with drive-through; d. Addition of another driveway from S.W. 8th Street to the shopping center outparcels located on the east side of s. W. 8th Street; e. Relocate southward the approved driveway located on the east side of S.W. 8th street that leads to the shopping center outparcels; and f. Eliminate the north access aisle connection between the outparcels located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street and the Home Depot site. The modifications to square footage resulted in a net increase of 1,700 square feet, thereby increasing the total square footage for the PCD from 315,580 to 317,280 square feet (within the limit allowed by the 1990 settlement agreement). This request was presented to the Planning and Zoning Board (now known as the Planning and Development Board) on August 13, 1991. The Board recommended approval of the request, with the exception of the additional driveway on Woolbright Road. The minutes from the August 20, 1991 and september 19, 1991 City Commission meetings state that the request was tabled at the request of the City Attorney because of a pending motion in the Tradewinds case and that the City Attorney wished to confer with counsel for Tradewinds on the issue. A review of City records indicate the request was not removed from the table. 3. March of 1993 - request to include the addition of 8,745 square feet to the garden center at the home Depot. The garden center increased from 19,375 square feet to 28,120 square feet. Pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement, the square footage of the garden center is not included as part of 2. 3 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 the retail gross leasable area. The request included adjusting property lines to accommodate the expansion and the total square footage of the project remained at 315,580. On April 20, 1993 the city commission approved the 8,745 square foot expansion subject to staff comments, and on August 10, 1993 the Planning and Development board approved a waiver of platting for the adjusted property lines in connection with the expansion. 4. March of 1993 - request to include the following: a. Subdivision of Tract B to create a .957 acre outparcel. Tract B is that portion of the PCD that is located on the west side of S.W. 8th street; b. Change in use and size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 3,040 square foot gas station (resurrection of the portion of the 1991 request that was withdrawn by the applicant); c. Add two new driveways into the proposed service station outparcel - one on S. W. 8th street and the other on Woolbright Road; d. Allow a canopy over the gasoline pumps to encroach the setbacks due to a difference in the service station regulations in effect in 1986 vs. the service station regulations in effect in 1993; and e. Reduce the building square footage specified on the master plan for Tract B from 62,000 to 55,040 square feet. With this request, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 6,960 square feet from 315,580 to 308,620. On April 20, 1993 the City Commission approved the request, subject to staff comments. As a result of the traffic evaluation of the proposed service station use, the square footage on Tract B decreased 24,000 square feet from a total of 55,040 square feet (52,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) to 31,040 square feet (28,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) . Therefore, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 24,000 square feet from 308,620 to 284,620 square feet. ANALYSIS Changes in planned Commercial Development (PCD) master plans are reviewed consistent with-section 6.F.13.b. of Appendix A - Zoning as follows: b. "Modifications to approved plans which result in an increase of less than ten (10) per cent in measurable impacts as determined by including any changes in traffic generated, water consumed or sewage to be collected will require review and recommendation the planning and zoning board and final approval by the city commission. The city commission decision to approve, approve with modifications or deny, shall be predicated upon a finding of consistency with the comprehensive plan and a finding that any such increase will not resul t in a negative impact on infrastructure delivery systems or the surrounding area in general. It is the intent of this 3 4 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 section that all additional impacts be mitigated..." Based 011 the documentation provided, the changes to the three outparcels would generate in excess of a ten (10) per cent increase in water consumed and sewage collected, if the approved outparcels are evaluated against the proposed outparcels. An increase of only 2.8% in water consumed and sewage collected results if the proposed outparcels are evaluated against the entire PCD water and sewer impacts. In either scenario, the utility Department does not have an objection to the analysis provided and has not indicated that the increase will have a negative impact on the infrastruture delivery systems. A slight increase in pervious area will result in a minimal, positive impact on the PCD drainage. with respect to traffic, the traffic information submitted indicates that the traffic generated by the three outparcels will generate less than a ten (10) percent change. This information has been forwarded to Palm Beach County. The results of the review by the County have not been received at the time of this report. The following is an evaluation of each of the proposed changes listed on page one of this report: 1. Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate outparcel and the redistribution of square footage among the outparcels As indicated in the stipulation settlement agreement, this is acceptable. Platting or a waiver of platting (at the determination of the City Engineer) to subdivide this parcel is required. As required, outparcels shall be self-sufficient with respect to lot size, setbacks, parking and other PCD zoning district requirements. 2. Relocation of the existing driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, south of the main entrance into the shopping center (Home Depot) - One entrance, in addition to the main entrance, was allowed pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement. This existing driveway is the additional driveway referenced in the agreement. The proposed location of this additional driveway is closer to the original position (centrally located) identified in the Barton-Aschman traffic report, upon which the traffic conditions of the 1990 settlement agreement were based. 3. Addition of a second driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, between Woolbright Road and the main entrance to the shopping center (Home Depot) - As mentioned in previous item #2, the number of driveways is specifically limited in the 1990 settlement agreement. The addition of a second driveway is inconsistent with the 1990 settlement agreement. Since the Barton-Aschman report does not require an additional driveway to be added, it could be argued that this driveway is not needed and that safety and level of service are not impaired without it. Furthermore, this type of access design is contrary to the intent and purpose of a PCD, which is to provide for a planned (not piece-meal) , programmed series of development operations, designed as a whole through integration of principle buildings and outbuildings that are linked via common use of access and infrastructure and similar architecture and other aesthetic elements. Specifically with respect to access, this additional driveway defeats the purpose of requiring internal access roads and driveways to serve parcels within a planned development. It should also be noted that the Barton-Aschman report stated 4 5 To: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 that the driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street located north of the existing main entrance driveway was to be deleted. The proposed master plan still reflects this driveway as being approved. 4. Median cut in s. w. 8th street If approved, this new intersection would capture much of the traffic anticipated and designed to be received by the main driveway that is located at the entrance to Home Depot. The main driveway is centrally located for the major portion of the retail uses located on the east side of S.W. 8th street. since the Barton-Aschman report did not recommend a median cut, it could be argued that the proposed median cut is not consistent with the traffic report referenced in the 1990 settlement agreement and therefore not needed or possibly affecting level of service. Therefore, if the median cut is approved, it is recommended that a new analysis of the turning movements be submitted to determine the impact the median cut will have on S.W. 8th street and Woolbright Road. Also, the proposed median cut would cause the east driveway into the site to become a major driveway which requires a one hundred (100) foot throat; the distance from the property line to a parking space or an access aisle. This would significantly impact the parking design of outbuilding 3. CONCLUSION This request was reviewed by the Technical Review Committee (TRC) on February 28, 1995 and the committee raised no objections at the time. However, the committee did not have technical data regarding the impact the median cut and additional driveway would have on the surrounding roadways or the project itself. If this driveway and median cut are approved by the Commission, the Police Department recommends that north and south deceleration lanes be required at the cut to avoid congestion from motorists slowing down to make turns at this location (see Exhibit "D" Police Department Memorandum No. 95-0121). It is also recommended that if any changes are approved by the Commission that are not reflected, or are contrary to, the proposed master plan, that three copies of a revised master plan be submitted to the Planning and Zoning Department, prior to submittal of any future PCD requests. The Planning and Zoning Department is not making a specific recommendation on this request since components of the request are inconsistent with the latest settlement agreement. Deviation from this agreement are viewed as policy decisions of the Commission. tjh Attachments xc: Central File A:WoolPCD 6" E X H I BIT A o . ~ CCl CONSULTANTS, INC. Consulting Engineers m Surveyors Planners ~ 2200 PARK CENTRAL BLVD., N, SUITE 100, POMPANO BEACH, FL 33064, (305) 974-2200 · FAX (305) 973-2686 February 14, 1995 Hand Delivery Ms. Tambri Heyden Planning Director CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd. Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310 Re: SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD Boynton Beach, Florida CCL Project No. 3~O~ Dear Ms. Heyden: Enclosed herewith please find the following: 1. Twelve (12) signed and sealed prints of the revised master plan for the above-referenced project. 2. A check made payable to the City of Boynton Beach in the amount of $500.00. 3. Letter of Authorization form owner for CCL Consultants, Inc. to act as agent for this matter. Please be advised that we are herein submitting for master plan amendment for the above-referenced project. We are proposing to amend the existing master plan as follows: A. Outparcel 1 will be revised from 4300 SF to 6920 SF. B. outparcel 2 will be revised from 5000 SF to 5755 SF. C. Outparcel 3 will be revised from a 2-story 6000 SF bank to a 1-story 2625 SF Taco Bell Fast Food Restaurant with a drive- thru lane. D. The locations of the driveways for these outparcels onto S.W. 8th street will be revised from what is presently shown on the existing master plan. In addition, we are proposing a median cut in the S.W. 8th street median which aligns with one of the proposed relocated driveways as well as prior-approved driveway location on the west side of S.W. 8th Street. '7 ""-' -' Hs. Tambri Heyden CCL Project No. 3101 February 14, 1995 Page two We respectfully request that this proposed master plan amendment be placed on the next Technical Review Committee agenda and thusly on the next available planning & Development Board as well as City Comm1s$ion A~anaa. Should you have any questions or need any additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, panile, Jr., P.E., P.L.S. ject Manager LRC/kag Enclosure cc: Mike Morton, Tradewinds Group Eduardo Carcache, P.E., CKE Group, Inc. 00 ~:~IJ ~ ~w ~ 1001 PLANNING ANO ZOt:WiGJ}IEL_,_"~.__,, i . .....-- CCl CONSULTANTS, INC. ~ ? E X H I BIT B l' ..=~ 0....,... ....'...0 .~.... .,,0"< T~~. :EC~ ~=;ts l;l;!! ~'"!; ;!!~= 0-1' ill.... g"~ ..om 0... ..,. .. Z Z m .. :!:,;: c ... n''''''' rn ::2~ < ...z! m ...........z ~..iE~ .....!il'" Iot,.."'m O:D< ;eom ~~~ ....I: is! .. mn ;;\0 ... i!! :D ~ o Z _aJ...n 5g~~ =:~iii 'i'!;U'6 ;0--4.. !~~:E ""z ...em omm :!::::;; i02>> .....' ....... .:De: ..":D ~:II~ ...0< ....0 ..0.. .. .. e: :; m .~Ncn ~:g~ ii-lO~ 1~6~ ...:lin .. ... .. ~ o o .. ~;I I~' !ft~i ;!I!"i ~m~ ~gi ;! .. ~ ~ i '" -~.-a ~mC)m ...unO~ :~~.~ w.. "-.ut ,,.......% "1::11)10 ~l:D!::s! Ilomr-::a JIo;;O qZ"E ~ JI! r= "oc,. ,.mm OZ:D 6~:D JIo",-,. ~g~ ~~m -.... e:" :;n mO ...e: oZ .... m ,. -~N(") ~it;:p "' 0 .. ;en ~i5~~ ~Ih jlI/i:' ::: ~~ :d g~ n o ~ CIl () III iD ~ I' J:l) q ~~ Scale: 1. . 10 Oate: ~12"J.D Dr~9v; hAP Fi~ NoJ205 t XA '21.1 er-w;nO No. 85-34 S",,~of ~ , -~+ "I~~ ~ ~ -~ '" ~ (ll ; ~ m 'j \" .~. \, ~\\ I '- - :: '" \;-f- ii,' --- '\ < , \ ;1.-.j- ~ f- - ~ ~- : I ", ;.m'il ' '= so,,,~,,~.,, -~ - , ," ~~_o;;<J .0 ~_ - - _ / SEAVICEDAlVE 1; ~ ~o, r -- ~_ __ _'_ - ~ --~ ~" : ~~ SOlU16 ~IiIOOO _ r ~I~: _ ~c:r-- "'"- -- -~ :f z ~~'i~ _ _ ~o,. _c--=- -~Cw'lSf~INE;cnO"'-2'----- is ~:f%l'" ": &;;371&"( snit o~ z i:~~i ~ :~ ~m~ ~i~g S.C~~o_~tl~ROAD ~~ ~ c:" ~ ~ ';: ~~~. Gl:~ o 2l ~, ~~ ~ ~ - ~ o ~ ~ m Z Cl Z m m " ~ III Jo F !\ I I l .~ ! :' 1\ ,;) \ \ , , < \ "l' ,lD '!' . 61 \ ~ ,~~ '. 'il " ,i ',I; . o 'I 1" " I I ;; o :. 1"0> d ~ g " o I" " I" II ,\ '\ j . j.J . I " ;"1' ~ " ~ 1:1:' if \ i \ ~ I ~ \ : \ \ , t_unn n o i m 11 : HI In !ii In [if t~- :"'.!I' IU ~H Hi I~!! Ul-Ul-a;tn"1ll C:~l"'"tirt1zm =i::DQI"'" e~ ~m:Z:C:OZ~ m'V-Icn"'m% ~~!;~~a!m dE~t.=!5Q Ul6;;:~Cl""'" ~z'"cn~:m ~~~erni~ ~~g~~G)i i$io~~~ '''-tJoo~I:-tg: ~m~ii:-I%::D ~~om~:~ OC~~imO ~!4!i!;em~~ ~:s~g~'; m:l: 2. 0.'" 221 ~"l~:;~)j ~e=z~~;: ~~~g~;;;~ zocfjzo-c ~~o~o.,.c 3~~~~~ ~=m%cn~ :;a~~~ ::DctI On m: :a~ '2: ~ill~O eOa-l .~ ~ m a~~cn ..- Q: ft ~ _ .. . ;6; t !;ft .. lt~~ ..!!. .. ig ~ ~ ;" ~ s!'" !!.2: g ~ t. ~i o 1:'" 5' ~ 3'" c :: 3 ~ . ". .. -. : . n !~ . ( " ,. . ~ ,,~ ilD .1 .' ; -------- ----- ~ Cp.~""," A ~ n8 ~e ~:II E) ):Q:!j ~~"lI :II'" of; \!!m "lI != ? it n -0 :~ ,g; "'n ,,- .. ,. -,: , c.."=- ~:- i I ~ ~ ------ , ---- !l ~ ~I.e !'I ~ :: A o .. ~I'" ~\::: =\::: .. Jo f' p 01 ~ ~ :11 ~ .. r- ~ z o c en m l:II N :D .. m i> .. " ",0 "-0 ;~ Cl 1ft i ... j\! Ui: " ... ... CIl Hi(J;l ;il\i1\1:\i ,. " m 8 0 0 I iii ... " :D .." ... ... ~ ... "' < " ..." ~ .. ,;ir;\ " z < 6 i ~~ " ,. m ~i Ii . I Cl 6 e: Cl .. " ,. .. ,. 0 0 N e: ... g~ " 0 -I ~ rl :~;I !f~ 0 .. .. " m 0 ~ Z .. .. ~ .." !: .. .. ,il ;'i -; ~ m ~S :D > .1,1 i; :D . 5 ... .. "' lEi m .. ~ .. .. i;~! fr .. 1ft m 1ft I': li~; Ji c 0 .. - .. ,I; ~l~i " :D n m 0 I !~ i! .. r:: a;~ " r:: Lt !; 1ft f n ,m 'I " if: 6 n h~! I' ~ ir i! c u:r " m H'.:;; -I ri: .. N ... F !: ;0 N '" A N ~ ~ .. n ... '" .. Ii i:: g: "' .. !> "' ~ N ~ '" .. .. "' .. ~ '" '" N .. '" ... ... .. .. " !; !; ~ m m ~ l~ .. '" Ii ~! ]I " .1 ~r "1lI ~ 0 m ~ ~ ~ ~ G) ; "1lI 2 U' ~ ~ ~~(;.. "'~~~ ~ ~.. "' '" '" ~ ~ is .. '!' '= .. ... .. '" .. 0 l;: !; ~ ~ - '" ~ ~ SHOPPES OF WOOLBR!Gl::1T PCD ~~ BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA ,''(jI~,!1'; MASTER PLAN" ~ - Kilday & Associates La"dsCllpe Architects/Planners 1551 Fo,um Place Suite 100A West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 (305) 669-5522 PROPOSED /D -- " i ~ m 0 ~:nr- -< mal ,. Ul ::a ~c ~ :~~ o-l"tl <;:r- ~ l"" II Z m :; :u E F m C .. . o m ~ 5; ! o m ~ ~ ~ 2 ! m z ~ !Ill; ~n "'~ -1- :lE0 zZ ~~ (II> ::a" z Cl .. '" m v3 ~t . ., : ~~ . ~ / , 7?,..;;u'/7ii- E X H I BIT C /1 '. ", ",..n ow. , n~? "':.e:!! ;~~ 0..... ;r~, ~J~ '. ....:: ..I:.. 0.... "'''''' Ed~ . , w~U) E~~ tt~~ ~.o ..0'" .... c: :0 .. " " . :E..... 10..10 Ill"'" ....'" ." c:< ~ (A..en .....:: 1:"'. m!::2 10"'" 1; ~.o- :: I: ~ Jio? ...... ..10.. oz", 6~:a >>O0~ ~g~ :~; -Ill. C:" g :;n ~ 100 /l <; wc: ..z '~ " o III ~ 10 .. Ii " ~ C/l () III if '"'I I CI) Cl ...& Ii~ ~;~ -.. Z .... o ..0 .. o. :r mr; , ~ i ~~ nO; ~ l:~ 0 lOr! I: ~~ ~ :; ~ ; ..::I ;II . z / 1:{t. * . :z- Scale; 1. . 80' Date: 3'28/90 Drawn By: CA.P File No, 4211 Drawing No. 85-34 Sheet~of " ~ III CO n n :; :.:j -< -< g S g i ~ ~ ~ ;:: ;:: ~ ~ II '" .. Gi 11- F_~ ,. ~ ~ '. '1--- ~ .~ I ~~ i II e;i~d~ ill ... ii~!;; ; l!l..... --I- ~ m ....:I..: If:. .. ;II 1= ~"D.&io ~&i .....%:11 '" a ... 9' :i!l!!lfj~~~ It! . "=~l!l& !i! .iI' J....c..:i!'" 11..1 OlD ...0.... ... i!l~g<~~i!l. .5.1 ~i5e!l .~ilI D. 3~d 1_ 2:i!!i!0~~;: ~ ! ~:.!"=jJi i: 601Dzl:J~:D i! ~F:n.;:~ N. fin..o .... . zODE;zooC . : :-t~O:DCJ""c a. -zo:e....i!i ~ 3 6ii~~:; i S ~<....pc!i: ~. .1 z..~ a;- ill~ ~ i ai Z Iliii I'll!!. C s .."'!fft ~ aI .. ".., M _ W :a ..CIIN,.Om ..........:D- t==::::rc N ~- ". III 0 8 o '1'l. 'l ~~:, ,,:e ~!=!::8Z :~ ~ ~ ~ .~ o .. N N ~ :t:= iI ~ i 11.1 ;1 i ~ ~ ~ !i ill m ill.;!! Ei N C "II g:a i 8 ... c ~ : t ~ !ll2: t '" t !j z :IJ ~ Ei -= ,.. )II m ~ Q: a ~~i::' . . '" n 10 0 .. & '" & !t !II . 5 D ~ '" .. ;! N ~ W ~ N ... ~ :. , S : J 0 III ~ ~ P II> \ It :, 6 -< I :: ~.. I ~5 j ..;: ~ Om", < 00/ , ""~' 1 ... '"' n ~ 9 ~ ..- w" , ... w" ~en ~ m .. " 1..- .'_. ._.::;-.....~~'~.~,..,..-:.'... '. . :~~ ~~.;,t~11 . _ .A.,~.~~""':'7...lV -........~; ; :l' ..., 11. .~ :!i I; t;lI ~ \ , z 8 ~ :II ~ ~ o m Ul Ul :a o :I> C i ~ ..; .0 !;.-:a ~ sO( mill i~ S!!! ~:~ ~ ~'" z'" ~o -I '1J a~ >... ;6 I"" Ii z m 'm III :a S ~ 10 C en . .1 U~.~. ~ ': ~ sa-" 51 ~ !J ~ !~ ~~ ~~ ,~ ~ ~ m z < m 6 ~ S.C.L, RAILROAD liQU R.O.WJ ~R ~~ "'0 ~Z ~~ Ul> ::It:"l:l z Cl .... Co> m .,').:~. I';' ,~',.- . SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT - REVISIONS .. P C"O .-: _~~~ BOYN"TdN BE~H. FLORIDA I ~ MASTER PLAN' 1 ,'7- 2 Kilday & Associates Landscape Architects/Planners 1551 Forum Place Suite 100A West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 (305) 6895522 E X H I BIT D /3 BOYNTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Office of Professional Standards To: From: Date: Re: Tambri Heyden. Directo~ Lt. James Cummings ~ 28 February 1995 Shoppes of Woolbright, P.C.D. TRC Memo # 95-0121 The comments that I have regarding this project concern S.W. 8 Street, and the curb cuts made north of the entrance at Woolbright. Although I have no problems with the curb cuts themselves, I would like to see deceleration lanes placed at the sights of these cuts, in order to facilitate motorists, and to keep the roadway free from unnecessary congestion. 00 mF:3~: W ~ i~l IIIi i i II-:. PLANNING AND ZONING OEPT. /1 -- LGCA1\ON MA\ \OPPES Of \fJOOL8R\G,..rr p .C.O. . ' ~fl~ , .' ;.. . - - -,~ ---,' . .:0\1\' \ \ '.\\\ \.oJ I::;t'\d , 7 I ~. ~ \' . n" ~;,'~:\' ~\" _ :..~ '~I'~'~~'~':~ ~~..u\.3~ . . ' \/"........ ~ .\ .. .,. . \ ~co ., _ /) ~" (\ . .... . " " I\i ,,1'1. .-?f-.~"">i C.,e<'~. 1'. 1 T ~ ... - ~ -:::l. \_ _ i '~:\'I'.'J\j \- · \. fI \I . \I \ rrrr ,\1 'C? ./" ~ ~ I@ ~ .::.:\ I d~'-:T- .' ~ -\ '''~ -', \ \ \ \ l\ II . ,,\.{~ '. ~. ~ < t (W'/ ._.../,. \. .. .._";: IT " \ ,I' F-j"" -' ~ ~,Ry\.~l \ \; .'. _ IT ,.IT \m:.:.l~ c:/ e. ". 'I \ It \TYt,~ \ ",'" __ ,,,,",,,. . . Ir \" 'I "'BJill~ . \ 1\ ~ L.. ~ ',. _-.,r _ ~. T" ,I- ' . =0'" _~I"" "~ 1.--<' \' M' ( '. \'''' _ ~"" ~ .~'" .1 ,~'1A1!! 0- -' " " , \~. \ \ :\\11 oc. rlI . ~ " I, . 'i \\ '. \~' ;'- <' .,\\" '1';;;;" t\ \ \ ""ii . 'T ' I I 'c.,.,"','''' (D \. ~ \1'~ (:II c. ~ d \ \1" \ I" ' ' I il 1\ \ \~ .J.t ...... ,,\' ~\ ,I\-<'(;\,::,.\.ll l' ~ u.-;.-; "'" 1 r ,I - '. {r I \1 \ ' ~ l' I ~c. ,":.:." ~'-- "" .' I ~ : II T ' ~,,1.j ,.1 I- ,_, <"., ._ ,....., j" T ~ . t \:: \= 1 "1\ \. \ ~. "" 1 ri rn rt l1T ~, c \\,1.1' " I ~ ,~ . U 1-/ .ILLW' ,~C"~~~ ~\Q.' ~~ ~n ,1' i'l" ~': - Q;', U@~~'!-g~ \~.\ r }... \ '. '0""~ y' 1. 1\';:"" " '..;' l L~ ' .. 1111\\ " . ~ 3,.J>a" ~ r " 1 " ,_'I - ",ill' c .-.' ".,', ...' ,",' " ~\-.~;;~"S I' \,\ \ ~ ~\r"\i , l~~ ~ ,;~ ~~_. ". .~~~~.,~ \ f ~ ~~~o \-. N .,;~~;\ '"": I} 'i /:~ ,'",::"'</: / < ~l'\I\I~C)\..ap\~,",-r ~ \ ,~II\\~t\\\\:': \ '. ...~. '. : / oj :' ',' '.' .. , ,\ _ ' W\ \ ~" · / pi- .'<., '.,' . '. \" ~ ..\ ~'! .,' " iT (..... ' '~.~ >:". ~~9'~i~ N \pU \ M.1' ,'" ,_ " ' ,N 7 "v " , .',' ,.,. c ,.' H . .:t,' ~ " " " . -. . ' '" ;;:7 Y< ' .. , .,: ' ._" \.' . 'y "v, ,~ ~ ...;~\ ,I \ \ """"i\ \" :\~. \ ',', .~ ~ " v " . \ ~-;: \ -\-w .' '""rrn' 1\ \ :; '. Vi, W,& 1: vJH. 'Z \ ~I I" \ ';.\'1\1~ I \ S\"1"'r::P\"~ ,,'" /; "I' ~....",; \ _ \ 1< ,c- T'" I , t;;;. V /-:::::""" -..c~.' ~~~ ~I t, ~'~i. 'rt:. ,11- ~~. ,;~.........~/ - : · "'\ 1r /I \..... 1 " \ "I"";Y ...........' ' "I {/ - . ' 1. ~ . . . .' .' _ lJ""" ~ 'r\ ' , c:3 i , p3 x,po<~' . "'.. , : I r I 1$ ~ ,5~' ,;,,;v'~ !;'i"sR'GNT h"~ r '~':M~{\ / ~ {;~(I!~..j L.A" t:J. .' oc .,c, '1':,..-.:>>,,' "" : I "'. . 'T ' ' ,-""j' : ' : I ,~" ' ". .' ,:J ' I ~ _, . :/:i7' ---- lit ~, ~. >)j~ ,~ld~' ~ ----.Jijl.... 'II ' ,~ ~.". c > "",- -,' ,- '~ -_::~ \~.: ,t::l 1/\" it 1-e::C'" ~'9r o.;-,:r,tS, \~. ~ - /: ~ I J po. '0 \'\\1 ,...... " > ~ ~ "" ,,+- ~~ " :.. ,... h.'~ ,T'ln"'I - ~$~"'J<~IlJ~ -...,," I; ~ II ~'l~ \ _ . ~~.r<S~ )(,. ^""v~.~ ' " c,". ' · '.' _ _ .~ ,/'~ ..;' ~ - Q ): IIA ~ " I-' \.)",. ....." y K< .00\: ' ' '<:c 'c::' : ~II _ ~/fl n''1;., >:;. _) ". u ",1' ,,,,,:::,,,..-----t: 1!J'/ r'"6. ..-::::1 ",,,,,,, " " y' v 'J' ! ('\---': I A ~o-- \' eo'1-'} ~R'11~ <~ _ v \.~<r ... v ~- i / ~ nAJ1 J. ' I \ _eJ,:1 ~ ~ ~Ct:' h G,oIc"~ "1;71 I IArfJ'V'l ~ 1=1111 ... ., ,_ ~ ~v ...,. irA'''' 'T'i.' I ~ 1-: v./ ' 'I iI/) J~'CD >-"--- \-\.. \1. '" \...f: ,~y~y~.:'~:"'\)~"'" -dl',r// ~ ri{\u.ffi~ -::_- _ . _ 1 1 1 \I : '/ ,. 1 \ \1 :> v, .' ;' 1 , .- . "^ E.S ' \ 1-': ' : II -D -- ' '\~ '0 '\ /8 IL ,....~' T 1 I J : ~ ; 'L .. .I-'-t\--' - ,- - " ___ . \ \ \' ,;:) "I: e: \. "t: ~I \ \ \ \ . _ ' -! : dl '/.~ p .~-;::I.-., ' AnO.800 r~~1 _or, ~_,~ ,.' ;.lJ, ~ ,. - -iIt-jl~.b .. . ,,11.1 ..", h'h / : ~ ~III A'l"" ~r t -1 r , ' \ \ ' \ / 1 ~~ PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM NO. 95-090 TO: Chairman and Members Planning and Developemnt Board THRU: Tambri J. Heyden Planning and Zoning Director FROM: Michael E. Haag Zoning and site Development Administrator DATE: March 10, 1995 SUBJECT: Shoppes of Woolbright PCD - File No. MPMD 95-001 Master plan modification (driveway, median cut and shift in outparcel sizes and boundaries) NATURE OF REQUEST CCL Consultants, Inc., agent for Howard R. Scharlin, trustee of the ~ property, is requesting approval to modify the previously approved ~B~0~O master plan for the Shoppes of Woolbright PCD. The 31.99 acre ) planned commercial development zoned property, approved for 20G, 320~ square feet of comme~cial/retail development, is located on the It:( north side of Woolbright Road and east of the L.W.D.D. E-4 canal. ~~ \\/" The proposed changes, described in the attached letter from CCL " ~ - Consultants, dated February 14, 1995 (see Exhibit "A") are itemized ~ iJ. .' t~\ \' ~- below. In addition to the changes stated in the letter of ~~ submittal, a second driveway is requested located on the east side of s. W. 8th S.treet, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD (see Exhibit "B" - proposed master plan) : ./" 1. " ~ ~ \) ,tj _.\.~ ,J F "'1\Y :ltP\ ,,\ '\ !,,) W- i' Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate .895 acre outparcel. Tract C is located at the northeast corner of S.W. 8th Street and Woolbright Road and south of the main entrance into the Home Depot. 2. Change in the size of the outbuilding 3 from a two-story, 6,000 square foot bank to a one-story, 2,625 square foot drive-through, fast food restaurant. A conditional use application, as required by the zoning code, is in progress for a drive-through, fast food restaurant as the use of this outbuilding. 3. Change in the building area of outbuilding 2 from 5,000 square feet to 5,755 square feet. 4. Change in the building area of outparcel 1 from 4,300 square feet to 6,920 square feet. 5. Relocation of the existing driveway located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street, 70 feet north, from 190 feet to 260 from the south property line of the PCD. 6. Addi tion of a driveway on the east side of S. W. 8th Street, approximately 400 feet north of the south property line of the PCD. This driveway was requested on a previous master plan modification that was tabled by the City Commission; therefore it has been added to this request. BACKGROUND The Shoppes of Woolbright PCD is part of a November 6, 1986 and January 24, 1990 stipulated settlement agreement between the city and Tradewinds Development Corporation. The City Commission ratified the settlement agreement by approving a master plan modification on May 15, 1990 that depicted the applicable "r)' ,,/' conditions of the January 24 , 1990 stipulation and settlement Vi t~\ />rI- ag::eement ( see Exhibit "C"1- raster plan pursuant to the ~990 ,~. ~ st1pulated settlement agreementf The agreement vested the proJect C;~ ~~ for traffic, water and sewer, so that no time extensions for ,b' (, \ TO: Planning and Development Board -2- March 9, 1995 concurrency would ever be required, prior to build-out of the property. The settlement agreement approved a maximum of 320,000 square feet, to include the uses and layout depicted on Exhibit "C" - the 1990 settlement master plan. However, the 1990 master plan reflects only 315,580 square feet. Since the original settlement agreement, the following master plan modifications have been submitted for review: 1. October of 1999 request to include the addition of a building materials store (Home Depot) which included 102,250 square feet of retail and a 19,375 square foot garden center. The total square footage for the PCD remained unchanged at 315,580 square feet. The city Commission approved this request on November 21, 1989. 2. May of 1991 - request to include the following: a. Addition of a new driveway onto Woolbright Road, located west of S.W. 8th Street; b. change in use and size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th Street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 1,250 square foot gas station (this portion of the request was withdrawn by the applicant, from the submittal); c. change in size, number of stories and designation of use of the outparcel at the northeast corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th Street from a 4,300 square foot retail building to a two-story, 6,000 square foot bank with drive-through; tl~. -..7 ./ d. Addition of another driveway from S.W. 8th street to the shopping center outparcels located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street; e. Relocate southward the approved driveway located on the east side of S.W. 8th street that leads to the shopping center outparcels; and f. Eliminate the north access aisle connection between the outparcels located on the east side of S.W. 8th Street and the Home Depot site. Tbe modifications to square footage resulted in a net increase off 1,700.' square feet, thereby increasing the total square footage for the PCD from 315,580 to .317,280 square feet (within the limit allowed by the 1990 settlement agreement). This request was presented to the Planning and Zoning Board (now known as the planning and Development Board) on August 13,1991. The Board recommended approval of the request, with the exception of the additional driveway on Woolbright Road. The minutes from the August 20, 1991 and September 19, 1991 city Commission meetings state that the request was tabled at the request of the City Attorney because of a pending motion in the Tradewinds case and that the City Attorney wished to confer with counsel for Tradewinds on the issue. A review of city records indicate the request was not removed from the table. 3. March of 1993 - request to include the addition of 8,745 square feet to the garden center at the home Depot. The garden center increased from 19,375 square feet to 28,120 square feet. Pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement, the square footage of the garden center is not included as part of the retail gross leasable area. The request included adjusting property lines to accommodate the expansion and the total square footage of the project remained at 31, ,l~. ~_~~~ /l iJ' 01 ":I, , TO: Planning and Development Board -3- March 9, 1995 On April 20, 1993 the city Commission approved the 8,745 square foot expansion subject to staff comments, and on August 10, 1993 the Planning and Development board approved a waiver of platting for the adjusted property lines in connection with the expansion. 4. March of 1993 - request to include the following: a. Subdivision of Tract B to create a .957 acre outparcel. Tract B is that portion of the PCD that is located on the west side of S.W. 8th Street; b. change in use and size of the outparcel at the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and S.W. 8th street from 4,000 square feet of retail commercial to a 3,040 square foot gas station (resurrection of the portion of the 1991 request that was withdrawn by the applicant); c. Add two new driveways into the proposed service station outparcel - one on S. W. 8th street and the other on Woolbright Road; d. Allow a canopy over the gasoline pumps to encroach the setbacks due to a difference in the service station regulations in effect in 1986 vs. the service station regulations in effect in 1993; and e. Reduce the building square footage specified on the master plan for Tract B from 62,000 to 55,040 square feet. ;}s/s'tJO) ~tfb,v'&oj Wi th this request, the total \ square footage of ;khe PCD decreased 6,960 square feet from ~17,ceO to ~4C On April 20, 1993 the city commission approved the request, subject to staff comments. As a result of the traffic evaluation of the proposed service station use, the square footage on Tract B decreased 24,000 square feet from a total of 55,040 square feet (52,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) to 31,040 square feet (28,000 commercial/retail plus 3,040 convenience store/gasoline sales) . Therefore, the total square footage of the PCD decreased 24,000 square feet from 318,3l0 to 206,320 square feet. 30~~jO~:~.}~~O ANALYSIS tJl"G , changes in Planned Commercial Development (PCD) master plans are reviewed consistent with Section 6.F.13.b. of Appendix A - zoning as follows: b. "Modifications to approved plans which result in an increase of less than ten (10) per cent in measurable impacts as determined by including any changes in traffic generated, water consumed or sewage to be collected will require review and recommendation the planning and zoning board and final approval by the city commission. The city commission decision to approve, approve with modifications or deny, shall be predicated upon a finding of consistency with the comprehensive plan and a finding that any such increase will not result in a negative impact on infrastructure delivery systems or the surrounding area in general. It is the intent of this section that all additional impacts be mitigated..." Based on the documentation provided, the changes to the three outparcels would generate in excess of a ten (10) per cent increase in water consumed and sewage collected, if the approved outparcels are evaluated against the proposed outparcels. An increase of only 2.8% in water consumed and sewage collected results if the proposed TO: Planning and Development Board -4- March 9, 1995 outparcels are evaluated against the entire peD water and sewer impacts. In either scenario, the utility Department does not have an objection to the analysis provided and has not indicated that the increase will have a negative impact on the infrastruture delivery systems. A slight increase in pervious area will result in a minimal, positive impact on the PCD drainage. with respect to traffic, the traffic information submitted indicates that the traffic generated by the three outparcels will generate less than a ten (10) percent change. This information has been forwarded to Palm Beach County. The results of the review by the County have not been received at the time of this report. The following is an evaluation of each of the proposed changes listed on page one of this report: 1. Subdivision of Tract C to make outbuilding 3 a separate outparcel and the redistribution of square footage among the outparcels As indicated in the stipulation settlement agreement, this is acceptable. platting or a waiver of platting (at the determination of the City Engineer) to subdivide this parcel is required. As required, outparcels shall be self-sufficient with respect to lot size, setbacks, parking and other PCD zoning district requirements. 2. Relocation of the existing driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, south of the main entrance into the shopping center (Home Depot) - One entrance, in addition to the main entrance, was allowed pursuant to the 1990 settlement agreement. This existing driveway is the additional driveway referenced in the agreement. The proposed location of this additional driveway is closer to the original position (centrally located) identified in the Barton-Aschman traffic report, upon which the traffic conditions of the 1990 settlement agreement were based. 3. Addition of a second driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street, between Woolbright Road and the main entrance to the shopping center (Home Depot) - As mentioned in previous item #2, the number of driveways is specifically limited in the 1990 settlement agreement. The addition of a second driveway is inconsistent with the 1990 settlement agreement. Since the Barton-Aschman report does not require an additional driveway to be added, it could be argued that this driveway is not needed and that safety and level of service are not impaired without it. Furthermore, this type of access design is contrary to the intent and purpose of a PCD, which is to provide for a planned (not piece-meal), programmed series of development operations, designed as a whole through integration of principle buildings -and outbuildings that are linked via common use of access and infrastructure and similar architecture and other aesthetic elements. specifically with respect to access, this additional driveway defeats the purpose of requiring internal access roads and driveways to serve parcels within a planned development. It should also be noted that the Barton-Aschman report stated J' that the driveway on the east side of S.W. 8th street located . north of the existing main entrance driveway was to be (l deleted. The proposed master plan still reflects this ~iveway as being approved. \' ,\ 'V ~ . ~J ~ '" ':;;'" \10 0' \ .\ \~ \J" TO: Planning and Development Board March 9, 1995 -5- 4. Median cut in S. W. 8th street If approved, this new intersection would capture much of the traffic anticipated and designed to be received by the main driveway that is located at the entrance to Home Depot. The main driveway is centrally located for the major portion of the retail uses located on the east side of S.W. 8th street. Since the Barton-Aschman report did not recommend a median cut, it could be argued that the proposed median cut is not consistent with the traffic report referenced in the 1990 settlement agreement and therefore not needed or possibly affectinq level of service. Therefore, if the median cut is approved, it is recommended that a new analysis of the turning movements be submitted to determine the impact the median cut will have on S. W. 8th street and Woolbright Road. Also, the proposed median cut would cause the east driveway into the site to become a major driveway which requires a one hundred (100) foot throat; the distance from the property line ~ to a parking space or an access aisle. This would ~ignificantlY impact the parking design of outbuilding 3. CONCLUSION This request was reviewed by the Technical Review Committee (TRC) on February 28, 1995 and the committee raised no objections at the time. However, the committee did not have technical data regarding the impact the median cut and additional driveway would have on the surrounding roadways or the project itself. If this driveway and median cut are approved by the commission, the Police Department recommends that north and south deceleration lanes be required at the cut to avoid congestion from motorists slowing down to make ___ turns at this location (see Exhibit liD" police Department Memorandum No. 95-0121) . It is also recommended that if any changes are approved by the Commission that are not reflected, or are contrary to, the proposed master plan, that three copies of a revised master plan be submitted to the planning and zoning Department, prior to submittal of any future PCD requests. The Planning and Zoning Department is not making a specific recommendation on this request since components of the request are inconsistent with the latest settlement agreement. Deviation from this agreement are viewed as policy decisions of the Commission. tjh Attachments xc: Central File A:WooIPCD See.S BOYNTON BEACH CODE consistent with the requirements of Chapter 19, Arti. cle II. Site Plan Review and Approval and Chapter 19. Article ill. Community Appearance Board of the Boyn- ton Beach Code of Ordinances. c. Permits. No building permits shall be issued unless and until platting procedures and the requirements outlined in Chapter 19. Articles II and III of the City Code are completed in every respect. -13. Changes in plans. ~- ~', ,.---/~---_/ ~. .~,~ \ a. Modifications to approved plans which result in an / _ .1...... --!fT' increase of ten (10) per cent or more in measurable ;" c?,> &\X tJto'6 \ impacts such as traffic created, water useq or sewage ( l"\" " ,- c:)I' or storm water generated or some other comparable I ';..' olP .~'\ measure shall be processed as for a new application for ll~,t:~ o~li",-~t, zoning to PCD.. ' / ~ "',... b. Modifications to approved plans which result in an fit! ,.,J '/ ',' v' increase of less than ten (10) per cent in measurable ~ . / r t~'~ " J~~_._J.!'!1p~cts~ay be ~proved by.the planning and zoning viI . ~y '. board, howe~ changes In traffic generated. water ! ' : lJ'" consumed or sewage to be collected will require ape 1 " ~ ~~Qo>: r proval by the city council. The board's decision to ape '" Y _ t-t \ ~ l ~ prove. approve with modifications or deny or to rec. , G\ (... A\.A ommend approval, approval with modifications or denial. ~f\ V' i-t'= shall be predicated upon a finding of consistency with l' f1S he comprehensive plan and a finding that any such ~ - f..~ i crease will not result in a negative impact on infra. -1 ~< y.~, \\~,l; ructure delivery systems or the surrounding area in ~Cl\ ,I. .)...., (_ t-' \\,1"" eneral. It is the intent of this section that all addi. , \ _:;:-: I.' \) tional impacts be mitigated. Any decision of the board );r- " , \ "f I in this regard is appealable to the City council. L\; ?' 3 (.."tl" d. No. 75-35. n 7.8, 11-4-75; Ord. No. 76.16, n 1-3.6-1-76; f !,f' f/" rd. No. 76.20. U 1. 2, 7.20.76: Ord. No. 76.39, ~ 1, 10.5-76: . t <. Ord. No. 76-41. , 1, 10-5.76; Ord. No. 76-47. n 1. 2, 10-19.76; ~ r Ord. No. 76-50. t 1. 11.2.76; Ord. No. 76-58, U I, 2, 1.3-77: , f t :t" Ord. No. 7~.17, t 1,7.5.77; Ord. No. 77.20. , 1,8.16.77; Ord. No. 77-377 t 1, 1-3-78; Ord. No. 79.7, t 1. 3-6.79; Ord. No. 80-29, it 1-3, 7.15-80; Ord. No. 80-30, ~ 3, 7-15-80; Ord. No. 81-27, , 2, 8.18-81: Ord. No. 83.23, t 4. 6.21-83; Ord. No. 84.12. t 1, 3-6-84; , 'I:' - ~)"!' ~ Supp. No. 23 1924.14 l--:.'ol':=:::_;:~:~..... \~'!1' \i--::'::1 ~ i ; ;;~:I-~I I ~ 1a 'o:!t itl' '< oJ .{ '":I: --i lrt :' -' ..---0-__..__. ~ ~ :. . . .... . Ii-- . ----~-. ,. : fT." , PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM NO. 95-105 TO: Carrie Parker City Manager ~ FROM: Tambri J. Heyden jQ.Jl-. Planning and Zonin~Director DATE: March 16, 1995 SUBJECT: Copies of Development plans of Current Proj ects Scheduled for Review by the City commission at the March 21, 1995 City Commission Meeting Please find attached five (5) sets of plans for the following current development project: Master Plan Modification - Shoppes of Woolbright PCD (MPMD 95-001) Note: Please return the plans/documents to the Planning and Zoning Department following the meeting. If I can be of further assistance, please contact me. TJH/pb c:ccmtg321.swo PROJEC'f 'l'rrl'LE: DESCRIPTION: 'l'YPE: DATE RECID: 'l'RACKING LUG - SI'l'E PLAN REViEW SUBMl~l"l'AL S+\-oPf>~~ ~t~_~.).~.R.l&t\-T ~~, FILE NO.: Qi\PVV\.~ ~~ n+Q.~'" ~~\U:>\'-=>Cr $, 'Lee. ~ c:>t..J ~~ PA&,c ~ NEW SITE PLAN ~ ~O~\3\TE PLAN MODIFICATION .2J'4/~S:- AMOUNT: 4IIISOl!),OO RECEIPT NO.: oo~Otf I ' * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * l!./. TWELVE (12) SETS SUBMITTED: I:L.; 1\'\c:o.~~ ~u COLORED ELEVATIONS RECIO: 00 (Plans shall be pre-assembled. The Planning & Zoning Dept. will number each sheet of their set. The Planning Dept. set will be used to check the remaining sets to ensure the number and type of sheets match.) * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * APPLICATION & SUBMITTAL: DATE: ACCEPTED ~lr4Iqs:-- --DENIED DATE: DATE OF LETTER TO APPLICANT IDENTIFYING SUBMISSION DEFICIENCIES: 2nd SUBMIT'lIAL ACCEPTED DENIED DATE: DATE: DATE OF SUBMITTAL ACCEPTANCE LETTER: REVIEWER'S NAME: * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * (Label TRC Departments on each set of plans) DATE AND MEMO NUMBER OF MEMO SENT TO TRC TO PERFORM INITIAL REVIEW. RETURN DATE: ~/~/9~ DATE SENT: .:v1;);;/9s , MEMO NUMBER: -r~ A-6t.J..Jn(t- ~ 01-81 fjs-' 1st REVIEW COMMENTS RECEIVED PLANS MEMO # / DATE / "c" PLANS MEMO # / DATE / "c" Utile / /- Planhinn / /- P.W. I / Building / 1- Parks / I Engineer I /- Fire / I Engineer / 1- Police Yhs Cj~-c)I;;J.1 I ~b8"19S7 --cz:;, Forester / 1_- 'I'YPE DE' VARIANCE(S) DATE OF MEETING: DATE OF LETTER SENT TO APPLICANT IDENTIFYING TRC REVIEW COMMENTS: (Aesthetic Review App., dates of board mtgs. & checklist sent out w/ comments NINETY DAY CALENDAR DATE WHEN APPLICATION BECOMES NULL AND VOID: DATE 12 COMPLETE SETS OF AMENDED PLANS SUBMITTED FOR 2nd REVIEW: (Must be assembled. Reviewer shall accept amended plans & support documents) COLORED ELEVATIONS REC' D: MEMO SENT TO TRC TO PERFORM 2nd REVIEW. DATE SENT: MEMO #: RETURN DATE: 2nd REVIEW RECOMMENDATION/DENIAL PLANS MEMO # / DATE /IIR/D" PLANS MEMO # / DATE I"R/B" Utile I / Planning I I P.W. I I Building I / Parks / / Engineer / I Fire / I Engineer / / Police I / Forester / / LETTER TO APPLICANT REGARDING TRC APPROVAL/DENIAL AND LAND DEVELOPMENT SIGNS PLACED AT THE PROPERTY DATE SENT/SIGNS INSTALLED: SCHEDULE OF BOARD MEETINGS: PAD CC/CRA DATE APPROVAL LETTER SENT: A:TRACKING.SP Pl..~ So ...,\'~ \'1: BOYNTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Office of Professional Standards To: From: Date: Re: Tambri Heyden, Directo~ Lt. James Cummings ~.. 28 February 1995 Shoppes of Woolbright, P.C.D. TRC Memo # 95-0121 The comments that I have regarding this project concern S.W. 8 Street, and the curb cuts made north of the entrance at Woolbright. Although I have no problems with the curb cuts themselves, I would like to see deceleration lanes placed at the sights of these cuts, in order to facilitate motorists, and to keep the roadway free from unnecessary congestion. ill ~ @ ~ 0 W ~ '~f Ii '! I ~ 28 ~tli!! FEB Inor; i ! .' : . I. ' 1 '-", PLANNING AND ZONING DEPT. ,./ "..... T~'''' .. . . -.."..- '. ~"'':''''''''''''~'~.'''' . .. ) CCl CONSULTANTS, INC. Consulting Engineers Surveyors Planners 2200 PARK CENTRAL BLVD., N, SUITE 100, POMPANO BEACH, FL 33064, (305) 974-2200. FAX (305) 973-2686 February 14, 1995 Hand Delivery Ms. Tambri Heyden Planning Director CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd. Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310 Re: SHOPPES OF WOOLBRIGHT PCD Boynton Beach, Florida CCL Project No. 3~O~ Dear Ms. Heyden: Enclosed herewith please find the following: 1. Twelve (12) signed and sealed prints of the revised master plan for the above-referenced project. 2 . A check made payable to the City of Boynton Beach in the amount of $500.00. 3. Letter of Authorization form owner for CCL Consultants, Inc. to act as agent for this matter. Please be advised that we are herein submitting for master plan amendment for the above-referenced project. We are proposing to amend the existing master plan as follows: A. Outparcel 1 will be revised from 4300 SF to 6920 SF. B. Outparcel 2 will be revised from 5000 SF to 5755 SF. C. outparcel 3 will be revised from a 2-story 6000 SF bank to a 1-story 2625 SF Taco Bell Fast Food Restaurant with a drive- thru lane. D. The locations of the driveways for these outparcels onto S.W. 8th Street will be revised from what is presently shown on the existing master plan. In addition, we are proposing a median cut in the S.W. 8th Street median which aligns with one of the proposed relocated driveways as well as prior-approved driveway location on the west side of S.W. 8th Street. Ms. Tambri Heyden CCL Project No. 3101 February 14, 1995 Page two We respectfully request that this proposed master plan amendment be placed on the next Technical Review Committee agenda and thusly on the next available Planning & Development Board as well as City Commission Agenda. Should you have any questions or need any additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, . .,.------~ panile, Jr., P.E., P.L.S. oject Manager LRCjkag Enclosure cc: Mike Morton, Tradewinds Group Eduardo Carcache, P.E., CKE Group, Inc. R :fl: r; n \:n G ~_....~hUl~.,.,~~.L:? '1 ! ] ~ ,~ CCl CONSULTANTS, INC.