BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
rrFie City of
r.Boynton 13eac/i
Pfannine & Zonine f])epartment
100 'E. 'Boynton 'Beach. 'Boulevara
P.O. 'Bo~310
'Boynton 'Beach., :FCoriaa 33425-0310
(407) 738.7490, :F5U: (407) 738-7459
January 15, 1992
Tom Digiorgio, Jr.
dk Architects/Planners, Inc.
1701 E. Atla~tic Boulevard
Pompano Beach, FL 33060
RE: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT CASE # 165
382 N. Congress Avenue
(T.G.I. Friday'S Restaurant)
Mr. Digiorgio:
Your request to reduce the number of required parking
spaces from 931 as required in Appendix A-Zoning, Section
11.H.16.d (2), to 928 parking spaces was approved at the
Board of Adjustment meeting held on January 13, 1992.
If I can be of further assistance, please contact me.
Administrator
Central Files
Project File
JImericas gateway to tfie (julfstream
~.O.A. n~
10
MEMORANDUM
January 2, 1991
TO: PRE-VARIANCE BOARD MEMBERS:
THRU:
J. Scott Miller, city Manager
James Cherof, city Attorney
Don Jaeger, Building Official
01~ euk-
Chris opher Cutro, Plannin~ and Zoning Director
FROM: Michael E. Haag, Zoning & Site Development Administrator
RE : PRE-VARIANCE MEETING - BOARD OF ADJUS'l'MBN'l'
A pre-variance meeting is scheduled for Mondav. Januarv 6. 1992 at
10:00 A.M.. in my office at the Planning Department. This meeting
is in conjunction with the Board of Adjustment meeting to be held on
January 13, 1992.
If you or a representative from your office cannot attend, please
call me regarding your input. Thar.:.. you.
A:PREVAR.DOC
--
TO:
Board of Adjustment Members
FROM:
city of Boynton Beach staff
REFERENCE:
staff Site Analysis - Board of Adjustment
CASE NO. & ADDRESS:
#165
382 N. Congress Avenue
MEETING DATE:
Janua:y 13, 1991
CURRENT ZONING:
C-3
DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY:
See Attached
OWNED BY:
J.J. Gumberg Company
TYPE OF VARIANCE:
Parking space reduction
FAC"l'S:
1. This site is presently zoned C-3 and was formerly zoned C-1.
2. Current records show the site is a 18,527 square foot shopping
center (Oakwood Square).
3. The applicant wishes to add a 631 square foot open patio to the
T.G.I. Friday's building. The proposed patio area will not affect
the existing parking area.
4. Appendix A-Zoning, Section 11.R.16.d (2) specifies that for each two
hundred (200) square feet of gross leasable floor area, within a
shopping center, there shall be a requirement to provide one (1)
parking space.
5. The existing area of 185,528 square feet plus the proposed 631
square feet equals a total of 186,158 square feet. The total area
requires that the site have 931 parking spaces. Where the number of
required parking spaces as computed includes a fraction, the number
of required parking spaces shall be the computed number rounded to
the next highest whole number.
6. Current records show the existing site contains a total of 928
parking spaces.
Request: The applicant is requesting that the Board grant a special
exception to allow the 186,158 square foot shopping center,
which includes the proposed open patio area, to provide a total
of 928 required parking spaces. The 928 parking spaces is three
(3) spaces less than the number required and computed using
the code specified parking ratio.
XC: City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
City Planner
Recording Secretary
Members - Board of Adjustment
t._
A:FACTS165.SDD
.~. -'
. .
. . '''----''.'
- ~'1, '
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION
Submittal Deadline: Five (5) weeks before meeting date
Please print or type
Submittal date: 12/9/91
The undersigned owner(s) hereby respectfully petition(s) the Board of
Adjustment to grant to petitioner(s) a special exception or variance to
the existing zoning or Sign Code of said City pertaining to the
property hereinafter described and in support thereof state(s):
Property involved is described as follows: Lot(s)
,
Block
, Subdivision
,
Plat Book ,.page or otherwise described as follows:
Property Address 382 N. Congress Ave., Boynton Beach, FL.
. ~, 1 . -
The following documents are required to be submitted with this
application to form a single package. Incomplete package will not be
accepted:
1. A sealed survey by a registered surveyor in the State of Florida,
not over six (6) months old, indicating:
A. All property lines
B. North arrow
C. Existing structures and paving
D. Existing elevations
E. Rights-of-way, with elevations
F. ~ Easements~on or adjacent to the site
G. Utilities on or adjacent to the site
H. Legal description .
I. Number of acres to the nearest one-hundredth (1/100) of an acre
J. Location sketch of property
K. Surveyor's Certificate
2. A site plan properly dimensioned and to scale showing:
D.
E.
All proposed strus;:tures -
All existing struc~res tnat are to remain on site
Setback lines for all structures drawn perpendicular from
properly lines to the closest vertical wall of structures
Use of each structure (or uses within multiple occupancies)
Use of adjacent properties including right-of-way lines for
streets and alleys, sidewalks, ~urn lanes and driveways
Elevations of the lowest finished floor of all structures
the site
the
A.
B.
C.
all
F.
011
" -
3. Certified list of names and post office addresses of property
owners and legal descriptions of their property within 400. feet of
subject property, as recorded in the County Courthouse. Such list
shall be accompanied by an Affidavit (see attached) stating that to
the best of the applicant I s knowledge, said list is complete and
accurate.
4.
Proof of ownership of property
purchase contract agreement.
petition, a notarized coPY of a
accompany 'the petition.
by peti tioner ( s), such as deed or
If an agent is submitting the
letter de~ignating him as such must
.
s. Statement of special conditions, hardships 'Or reasons justifying
the requested exception or vClxiance. Respond to the six (6)
questions below (A-F) on a separate sheet JPlease print or type):
A. That special conditions and circumstances exist which are
peculiar to the land, structure or building involved and which
are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in
the same zoning district;
" ,
=
. . .
, " l
. ~ O~ ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION
Ie 2
B. That the special conditions and circumstanc~s do not result
from the actions of the applicant;
C. That granting the variance requested will not confer .'on the
applicant any special privilege that is denied by this
Ordinance to other lands, buildings or structures in the same
zoning district; .
D. That literal interpretation of the provisions of this chapter
would deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other
properties in the same zoning district under the terms of the
Ordinance and would work unnece~sary and undue hardship on the
applicant;
E. That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will
make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or
structure; .
F. That the granting of the variance will be in harmony with the
general intent and purpose of this 'chapter and that such
vari~nce will not be - injurious to the area involved or
otherwise detrimental to the public welfare.
6. Application fee in the amount of $275, payable to the City of
Boynton Beach, must accompany this petition.
7. Name and address of owner:
.J. J. Gumberg Co., 3200 N. Federal Hwy
8. Name of applicant: dk archit2cts!planners, 1nc.- T.H.Digiorgio, Jr.
Da t-e :
12/9/199]
1701 E. Atlantic Blvd, Pompano Beach, FI 33060
10S- q41-11?q ~ ~/1
Signature of Applicant: -'-7It1J,.41 ~~-
.
Applicant's address:
Applicant's phone #:
-~-~-----------------------------------------------~-------------------
To be completed by the Building Officia: or Representative
1. Property is presently zoned:
C-3
Formerly zoned:' C-l
2. Property Control Number:
08-43-45-20-01-000-0588
3. Denial was made upon existing . zoning or sign requirements ( list
sections[s] of Code .fr-bm which~reliefis required):
..
Section 11.H.16.d (2) Appendix A-~oning
4. Nature of exception or variance required: Code reauires 931 parking
spaces, 928 parking spaces are provided. A variance of 3 parking _,_
#165
Meeting
1/13/92
Date: /~/1 /9/
S. Case Number:
--------------------------------------- -------------------------------
To be filled out bv Board.
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ACTION: Approved
Aye
Denied
Nay -
Stipulations:
Signed:
Cha.i:rman
.....
~,
dkdeSign kollaborative
g architects / planners, inc
MEMBER: AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS
DATE. DlCI.blr 4, 1991
PROJECT a T.G.I.F. Restaurant
LOCATION a Oakwood Square, Boynton Beach, Fl.
SUBJECT a Response to City of Boynton Beach, related to justification
for eMe.ption as requested.
REa New EMterior Patio attached to West face of building.
A. The soecial conditions and circumstances which eMist is that this
restaurant is located within a self-contained shopping center.
A patron who arrives by auto-mobile, will park the vehicle and
become a pedestrian. Strolling pedestrians enjoy the opportunity
to sit and relaM at an outdoor facility. The outdoor dining
atmosphere, during pleasant weather, will compliment current
operat ions.
B. The special conditions and circumstances are not directly caused
by the applicant.
C. The arantina of this eMemption certainly will not confer any
special privileges to this applicant (which are not available
to others) because this applicant has prevailing conditions
which are not si.ilar to other la~ds, buildings, etc.
D. Literal interpretation of the provisions of this chapter will
curtail/prevent an atmosphere which is consistent with the
activity of T.G.I.F. restaurant operations and consequently
would result in unnecessary and undo hardship on T.G.I~F.
operat ions.
E. The exemption granted is certainly the minimum variance that will
make p~ssible the reasonable us~ of the land/building.
F. The granting of the exemption will not only be in harmony with lhe
general intent and purpose intended, it will ~bsolutely compliment
the area and be an asset to the public welfare, as this will be
aesthetically pleasing and offer the public the convenience of
outdoor dining which opportunity exists in our tropical climate.
D
{)6'IN~~
~;[;;J~
Authorized Signature/dk
1701 E. ATLANTIC BLVD. · POMPANO BEACH, FLORIDA Z ....l60 · AREA CODE 305 . 941.33291941.3332 D
THOMAS H. DiGIORGIO, SR., PRESIDENT FAX 305.941.3335 THOMAS H. DiGIORGIO, JR., V.P.
, ,
~
~ .'
~, i
a
Co)
~;.'
I';".'
~,
( ',..} 40
"'.!l . ,', ' "
,..'- 1
,~,~~~ ".
~~ ' .r'.
',:'
'..~ ...
.~e'
(.,'
i
..' -
,
::;:"'.
t~'\
1:\
", "s.
CANAL
~-.-
(@) F./~
EE\( CEN"{RE ~~
_ \27) T~.'" pC
.,......SEACt\ ~
" ,.coNDO C
D
. ","
r--r
v~
@
coNDO ~/ ~
~3 'F"& 'to" ~
u \\ k'?i .
_.;:~,.,:..'"
~~~
4-
~0
" .~.//
. .~. A "
~ ffaa~
~.,,-
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
MEMORANDUM
TO:
'"
See Below
DATE: December 27, 1991
FROM:
Sue Kruse
City Clerk
RE: Board of Adjustment Mtg. of
January 13, 1992 at 7:00 P.M.
Case H65
Forwarded herewith are the following copies of documents regarding subject
Case #165, DK Architects/Planners (T.G.I. Friday's Restaurant):
1. Board of Adjustment Application
2. Statement of Conditions
3. Letter of Authorization from Massachusetts Mutual
4. Letters dated July 17, 1991 and December 10, 1991
from J. J. Gumberg Co
5. Certificate of Occupancy issued September 16, 1991
to T.G.I. Friday's Restaurant
6. List of property owners within 400 ft.
7.
Notice of Hearing as advertised and sent to
property owners
A Site Plan of the Oakwood Square Shopping Center, including the T.G.I.
Friday's Restaurant site, will be brought to the meeting by the Recording
Secretary.
r-x~ ~./-'/)t?~
SK:slb
attachments
cc: Raymond Eney
James Miriana
Thomas Newton
Andrew Haynes
Henrietta Solomon
Vernon Thompson
Ben D1eck
Bradley Miller
Paul Slavin
Mike Haag
RECEIVED
I
DEe 27 C; /
PLANNii'iG DEPT.
..
.:;
.0_0" '0;;, ~'~~~Riii~r;~ ir~~\ .~.o. "FAx' '3ef~~6~ '!I~3~ ~-~~'~'~'~'-'~i: ':j:'(jUMBEftC'~~'" ~ ~",'~'~" ......~ ~._;;.~.. .~~....~'O~. . ~~.~~ -.. ..,..
" .'.
....
..
... ..
.
Mo&YMutual
RIfII Hnalt J"",,'lHtJI'
ItUo <':'fIIIl'n P"illCCf FQrkIlVJ,I' Sn/le: 1:100_
AIII4,,11I (M .10.1.18
~04 8tH-8'"
",l X 4104 /W4.t)1) 11
M,. MiJr" Balg
OJ/kt of Planning
CUy of BoymM Bnch
1.00 &It Doynton Beach ~nJ
P. O. Bnx 310
RQyllllDlf RMCh, Florida "il2'
December 12, 1991
RBI OdWIIIHI $q.." Shop'" C",r.,.
'ltJI Fr~ P,.fJpMM 6p4n,,1Nt.
DMr Mt. J1aiG.'
We (ire C/Wllff thaT TO/ Friday',5' II cOIJt.mplllting tl.~ ~Mt'm Qllhetr {a.cil.il.Yt inc;1udhlg
the patio Qrt!a, in tl" abov, r'/~renc<<l pmJlcmy. In Qrder 10 proceed will, (he proJ}osed
~1J.fjon, 1},(..'Y u,.- upp/ying lor a vlll1ance from tile a,y of Boynum Beuch and (lr~
beillg ~pJWa,ucd by Mr. T.H. D{gkJtgW, Jr. n! dk Art:~dltfCl.SIPJunnt!1'# Inc. W~ QIW
Cllt;oum8<<f by 11ft faCllhal PridaY'$ wislzes t() expaml and fo,' #Ib ttxpalzsion will prove
benefici"l to aU parllts i'lvolvM.
Pluu*/,,,l fr~~ t() (.'OfUtJct me should )lC1l11~Ye uny qUe.fJJo,rs.
Sitv;msly,
.,tJ~~ -.;; r:; e~
William P. .Runge
Assistant DlM:wr of Rul F:.feQ~ InlJesuncm
WFll:k4
(~ ,....
UII/fMf.hILWfl. Mill"'" J.i/~. Jrr.1ItrtlnN' cW"/"If}' and qt1lllttrl'(f Itl.f/lffJ"&\' n"'II~UI"tJ 5'pOIIJ:!II'ft; "III fl/III,f)r}f"
........... ...... .........~
..w...... ...................................,
. . ~ . .. . . ... ... ....... ... ., .. .. I .. ... ." ",' ... .." ......... ........ .... .. ..... .. .. -.. ..... ..
Z:Od
.....o"'..~'-{O...e' ~p
--
--
12/04/01
09:38
FAX 305 565 6173
J. ,J. CUMBERG CO.
If.! \_: \)2
'~--_.-
, J
r
~
J J GUMBERG CO
roUTIiE^~T
July 17, 1991
CERTiFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEWf REQUESTED
-
Re: Oakwood Square
Boynton Beach, Florida
Dear Tenant:
We are pleased to announce that on July 21, 1991, JJ. Gumberg Co. will assume the management of the Center.
This letter has been signed on behalf of tile owner of the Center, MassachusetlS Mutual Life Insurance Company,
to confirm the change of managcmcnL
We will take every step reasonably possible to ensure a smooth transition. Should you have any inquiries. feel free
to conlact the following people, as applicable, Ilt any time:
Accounting/Tenant Billings
Leasing/J nSurance
Opcrations/l\.1aintcnancc
Diana Hess
Linda Whipple
Toby Holland
(305) 537-2700
(305) 537-2700
(305) 537-2700
Commencing on July 21, 1991, please make all payments to "JJ. Gumberg Co." In accordance with your Lease,
rent and other monthly chargcs are due not later than the first day of each month. All checks should be sent to;
J,J. Gumbcrg Co.
3200 North Fe.dcral Highway
Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33306
Attention' Diana Hess
Please complete, sign and date the enclosed form and return it in the e,nclosed postage-paid envelope, The form will
provide us with your official address for all notices and other communications required or pcnnilled by yoU! Lease.
If we do not receive Ihe signed Conn within 14 days after the dale of this lettcr, 'we will consider the notice address
stated in your Lease to be correct.
We look forward to the growth nnd success of the Center.
Sincerely,
].J. GUMBERG CO.
I
Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company
"
. " ,{ /, /
By: j;~:J;t "y/(/ ~
Arldrew D. Gumberg
President and Chief Execu~ ve Omcer
Enclosures
nnd
By:~ 'P ,t!.~
William F, Runge
Assistll1l Director
',)2C'\:./ N'>2!lldSo:.,.l;:;;; 1:,Ili.:;h~".I) " t', "1, .i~ll},(~s.~di dc, n~ri(~;~~f~
"
~'1.7 y
!
) f
G.U0MJ;}2J~(} (~()
~---_._--_._--- ---- -- ~--~--
S,I ',i ~17~11 F .A,. (..;,C['
~_~'-j 1.._, 1...:.. .i....:J
December 10, 1991
EXPRESS MAIL
Mike Haig, Office of Planning
City of Boynton Beach, Florida
100 E. Boynton Beach Blvd.
P.O. Box 310
Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-036
RE: Oakwood Square, Boynton Beach, Florida
Premises leased by "T.G.I. Friday's"
Dear Mr. Haig:
J. J. Gumberg Co. is the managing agent for Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company, the owner of
Oakwood Square ("the Owner"). .
This will confirm that (a) T.G.!. Friday's is a tenant at Oakwood Square and will be applying for a variance for
an outdoor patio addition, and (b) the Owner has no objection to the granting of a variance allowing T.G.1.
Friday's to furnish and install the patio addition in accordance with the terms and conditions of its lease.
Sincerely,
MASSACHUSETTS MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
BY: J.J. GUMBERG CO., AGENT
B~~
Robert E. Howard
Vice President
REH:th
cc: David Siegel, Vice President and Director of Operations
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)ss.:
COUNTY OF BROWARD)
The foregoing was acknowledged before me this 10th day of December, 1991, by Robert E. Howard, as Vice
President of J.J. Gumberg Co., a Pennsylvania corporation and Agent for Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance
Company. owne< of O.kwood Sq".,e. Boynton Bea<h. Flo,ida, fo' ~~ o~"":;::i~n...Q
".HAIH PuLlLIC. ~IArE UI- t-LuIIIUA ... Y I'll
My Commission Expires: aVlY COMMISSION EXPIRES; MAR. 19. 1993
ONDED THRU NOTARY puau. . .
Q UNDERWRITER'" Notary PublIc, State of Flonda at Large
(Notarial Seal)
\~C0 \,-'rih I'cJcrallli,'hwav' t'~1[t blldcrdalc. n,-,ri(b'J)')Co.-l()Y~
.--. n'___ n'__ ...'-r- . ---- - --------x.Y)Ti~7-2105
...
~ <C'ot ~,.
\
..
=
,"
C E R T I F I CAT ION
TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, THE ATTACHED LIST IS A TRUE AND
CORRECT LIST OF PROPERTY OWNERS WITHIN FOUR HUNDRED (400) FEET OF THE
APPLICANT'S PROPERTY.
".
-. .
. -
.:~ oc.;..-::..
.;;
~dI~
APPLICANT/AGENT
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the following application has been made to the
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT of the CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, for the variance
as indicated, under and pursuant to the provisions of the Zoninq Code of
said City:
Case #165
Owner/Agent:
J.J. Gumberg Company
Requested
Variance:
To reduce the number of required parking spaces from 931
as required in Appendix A-Zoning, Section 11.H.16.d (2),
to 928 parking spaces.
Location:
382 North Congress Avenue (T.G.I. Friday's Restaurant)
Legal
Description:
A portion of Tracts 61 thru 67 inclusive as shown on the
plat of the Subdivision of Sections 29 and 2Q, Township
45 South, Range 43 East, according to the plat thereof
as recorded in Plat Book 7 at Page 20 of the Public
Records of Palm Beach County, Florida, being more
particularly described as follows:
Begin at the Southeast corner of said Tract 61; thence
south 87 degrees -49' -24" West along the South line of
said Tract 61; also being the South line of said Section
20 for 567.98 feet; thence North 00 degrees -57' -37"
West along a line 60 feet East of and parallel with the
West line of said section 20, said line also being the
East right-of-way line of congress Avenue for 1154.42
feet; thence North 44 degrees-381 -53" East for 35.73
feet; thence South 89 degrees -44' -37" East along a
line 20 feet South of and parallel with the Northerly
line of said Tracts 65, 66 and 67 for 542.98 feet;
thence south 00 degrees -56' -00" East along the East
line of said Tracts 61 thru 65 inclusive for 1155.82
feet to the Point of Beginning.
A PUBLIC HEARING will be held relative to the above application by the BOARD
OF ADJUSTMENT at City Hall, Commission Chambers, Boynton Beach, Florida, on
Monday, January 13, 1991, at 7:00 P.M.
Notice of a requested variance is sent to property owners within 400 feet of
the applicant's property to give them a chance to voice their opinion op~the
subject. Comments may be heard in person at the meeting or filed in writing
prior to hearing date. If further information is desired, call 738-7408,
City Clerk's Office.
All interested parties are notified to appear at said hearing in person or
by attorney and be heard. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of
the Board of Adjustment with respect to any matter considered at this
meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may need
to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be bas~d.
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
SUZANNE M. KRUSE
CITY CLERK
PUBLISH: BOYNTON BEACH NEWS
December 28 and January 4
aId
A:LAD#165.ALD
;.;.,;
~
MassMutuaI
VIA AIRBORNE EXPRESS
March 25, 1991
RECEIVED
DEe 1 1 1991
SITE DEVEL.
BOYNTON BEACH. FL~
Yamile Trehy, Esq.
city Attorney's Office
100 East Boynton Beach Boulevard
Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310
Re: Building permit application; Oakwood Square
Dear Ms. Trehy:
Enclosed as we discussed over the telephone is an original
certificate executed by an Assistant Secretary of Massachu-
setts Mutual Life Insurance Company (IMassMutual") entitled
"General Signing Authority. II As you will see, this document
indicates that under the Rules and Regulations of the Board
of Directors of MassMutual, any officer at the level of
Second Vice President or higher has the authority to "exe-
cute, acknowledge and deliver in behalf of" MassMutual all
instruments "relating to the properties, rights, interests or
investments of the Company." The names of all such officers
are listed.
I have advised the Atlanta Regional Office of the Real Estate
Investment Division of MassMutual to forward the building
permit application, signed by steven P. Wallace, Second Vice
President and Regional Director, directly to you at the above
address. Mr. Wallace is listed in the General Signing
Authority.
I believe this letter and the enclosure, together with the
application signed by Mr. Wallace, should resolve the issue
of compliance with the signature requirements of the revised
Florida Construction Lien Law, Ch. 713, Florida Statutes. It
is very important that the building permit be issued as soon
as possible. so that MassMutual may fulfill -1 tj contractual
obliqations under the related lease. ,o: /;..Y ,. ". -~:'''</t:..
(.f/ ~L~~".~E~~ \:~
~~~~ ~lDJlr' ;7 APR031991~~)
\ ~~. . ~ ~i;'
'\ "," ."
. . .".......
. . /'> ...
.Hassachl/setts "-Jurl/al L(re Insurance Company Springfield. .\I.-J OI/lI.()()(J1 \; I~t~\\"',,:,,
"--~/-
Yamile Trehy, Esq.
March 25, 1991
Page 2
Thank you for your assistance in this matter. Please call me
if you have any questions or need any additional information;
my direct line is (413) 730-6117.
cc: steven P. Wallace
Julianne M. Echols
Melanie S. Scussell
.
w,"
ft nO j0=--J
,I i I rrr,/~ "'.:.--..
LJ l.!! l f::3 I (!. ! I .'.. ' r/ 'ill .'"
e:::~ 11"1.:)\,,
, \S-~) if '
APR 0 2 1991 .
GENERAL SIGNING AUTBORl1Y
MASSACHUSEITS MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
The undersigned hereby certifies that he is Assistant Secretary of Massachusetts Mutual
Life Insurance Company and further certifies all matters hereinafter set forth.
BYLAWS: The following are correct and fair extractS from the Bylaws of the Company, now in full force
and effect:
Article In
"The Board of Directors shall elect from its number such committees as it may deem
necessary or convenient for the conduct of the business of the Company, and may delegate to any
such committee or committees some or all of the powers of the directors except those which by
law or by these By-laws it is prohibited from delegating....
Article n. Section 2
....The Board of Directors shall make such rules and regulations as it shall deem necessary
or convenient for the regulation and management of the affairs of the Company..
RULES AND REGULATIONS: The following are correct and fair extractS from the Rules and
Regulations of the Board of Directors of the Company, now in fuD force and effect:
Rule LE
.... The Investment Committee shall exercise supervision and control of investments and
related financial matters, including the approval of banks of deposit for Company funds- The
Committee may authorize any officer of the Company to exercise the powers granted by this
paragraph relating to the acquisition and disposal of investments, subject to such restrictions as
the Committee may deem advisable....
Rule 3.F
"The following procedures as to execution of instruments in behalf of the Company are
hereby adopted:
(2) The Chairman of the Board, if a Company officer, the President. any Senior Executive Vice
President. any Executive Vice President. any Senior Vice President. any Vice President or any
Second Vice President shall have the power to execute, acknowledge and ~er, in ~ of the
Company all contractS, agreements, leases, receipts, discharges, deeds" " , ~!llf.;'~
consent. waiver, purchase or sale, renewal, exchange or transfer, ass' ts end ~{ oth~ )
instruments, including powers of attorney, relating to the properti 'g~YU\. ~~ermi~1~.' v~.
investments of the Company. 2, Pl,), ~ . - .' · t:.
... [;.oS 0 2 ~99~ ~ L.
(4) The Treasurer, any Associate Treasurer or any Assistant Tr ~sl1ah have th,~_~~er ~o_;;J
endorse checks, drafts and other forms of remittance to the Comp : d3tD' "clMOwledge, ~IVC,
receipt for and give full discharge for payments of money due to the" panY',~checks, dra~ ,and
other instruments for the payment or withdrawal of funds of the Co~'R~be ~...ec\1ted''by the
Chairman of the Board, if a Company officer, the President or any Vice~--ai\d' by the
Treasurer, or any Assistant Treasurer. -._- .
. (5)...the Investment Committee may authorize the execution of any instrument by such other
officer or officers or by such employees or agents of the Company as may be determined by said
Committee.-
... . ~
- ., -r
'--.' '... '\ /-
,"; , '..' t J .~
,. '..' -', \ ~ -' \
, ,:" l'"
...::- t-..
I ~- ~
(6) The Investment Committee may authorize the placing of signatures on policies, checks,
receipts or other tnstruments by machine or other device for the imprinting or writing at
signatures. All instruments bearing authorized signatures may be continued in use for a period of
six months from the date of termination, for any reason, of the term. of office of any officer wbose
facsimile signature appears thereon, and all such instruments sball bave the same Corce and effect
as tbough such officer were still in office..
OFFICERS OF THE COMPANY: The following are officers of the Company holding the offices
appearing before their names:
President and Chief Executive Officer: T.B. Wheeler
Executive Vice Presidents: RG. Dooley, KL. Fry, Jr., J.E. Miller, J.M Naughton, JJ. Pajak, J.L.
Wenheimer and W.R Wise.
Senior Vice Presidents: P.O. Adornato, L. V. Burkett, Jr., WJ. Bunon, L. W. Cain, D.O. Cameron,
KD. Cardwell, P J. Daboul, D.J. Fitzgerald, B.H. Gottehrer, L.L. Grypp, K.L. Hargreaves, S.A
Hawkins, M.D. Hays, J.e. McKeon, D.P. Paczkowski, O.L. Reyhons, AJ. Van Werkhooven, P J.
Vogian and G.E. Wendlandt.
Vice Presidents: RP. Abate, J.1- Abbott, S.A Alfano, RP. Angelillo, G.c. Bingham, PA
Bradbury, J.P. Carey, K.S. Cohen, C.e. Collins, P.O. Cuozzo, RR Daisley, NA Dalessio, KE.
Dameron, FA Everton, W.C. Fetherston, TJ. Fmnegan, Jr., E.W. Flowers, B.W. Fraser, AG.
Garber, Jr., B.E. Gaudette, W.P. Green, RE. Guertin. RA Hague, D.N. Hertz, L Jermyn, A W.
Johnson, RE. Joyal. J.B. Joyce, W. Kelly, E.M. Kline, RL. Knowles, R W. Kumming, Jr., R.S.
LaCroix, D.P. Lauzon, CJ. Lavoie, T J. Leary, JJ. Libera. E.P. McCausland, Jr., RF. McCormick,
J.1- McEathron, W.T. McElmurray, S.B. Magee, E. Marder, J.F. Moore, Re. Morrison, MP.
O'Connor, F. Pannorfi. JJ. Phillips, U. POlverini. Jr., B.E. Pugh. Jr., C. T. Revello, T.e. Rogan,
Jr., E.F. Ryan, D.B. Salerno, M.M. Sperry, J.M. Stamant, J.T. Sullivan, W.L Tindall. G.M Ulrich,
E. Walcott, NJ. Waldron, e.E. Wallace, W.R Wellstead, D.H. Wheeler, ME. Wilson and H.C.
Wilson.
Secoud Vice Presidents: BJ. Alvord. S. Anderson, RD. Ashton, GJ. Bacchiocchi. N.W. Bennett,
AB. Bixby, M.L. Blansett. D.P. Borah, S.R Boswonh., RD. Bourgeois, GA Bradner, D.L.
Brassard, P.1- Briere, R W. Brown, T.A Bruno, A.A. Campbell, Jr., D.W. Carlson, J.M. Caner,
R.P. Castagna, Y.S.s. Cheng, J.S. Collins, RA Copes, J.E. Cunis, S.C. Dennehy, E.M. Dioo, J.P.
Doan, JA Dolben, M.P. Drees, G.E. Dudley, W.E. Egan. L.N. Ellison, T.F. English, P.A Feige,
W.B. FISher, AD. Foresi, RJ. Fraga, Jr., J.P. Garner, B.M. Gatewood, C.M. Gibbs, B.M. Googins,
e.E. Graves, H.M Grayson, J.e. Hall, L.H. Hall. E.L. Hancock. Jr., D.E. Hannigan, W.E. Hick.
nI, e.A Hill. Jr., R.D. Hilton. Jr., D.R Hindman, BA Holmes, J.G. Hopkins, c.E. Hulett, RE.
Jackson, R.M. Howe, OJ. Jangraw, OJ. Janik, C.M. Johnson, RL. Kinton, D.C. Kline, RP.
Kocher, W.K. Koszewski, S.L. Kuhn, B.A Libby, W.E. Lord, J.F. McBride, H.J. McCullough, J.B.
Makel, AM. Maramarco, M.F. Marieb, RN. Massaro, B.B. Mattson, J. W. Meyers, J. Miller, Jr.,
H.B. Milroy, M. Montagna, N.S. Muise, C.F. Muse, J.G. Noonan, RE. Norman, BJ. O'Keefe, C.K.
Osgood. G.L Ouellette, JJ. Palamar, P.V. Paleologopoulos, P.F. Papaluca, M.M. Parrish, P.T.
Pasteris, R.G. Pouliot, FJ. Purnell, M.A Ramnarain, J.R Rankins, M.P. Reynolds, D.O. Roberts,
G.D. Roberts, J.T. Robinson, W.G. Rodger, O.A Rogeness, C.H. Rosenberg, W.A Roy, D.K
Ruddick. R.E. Scarlett, P.G. Sheran, RR Sicotte, S.A Slade, RF. Stamant, K.c. Switzer, WJ.
Taylor, S.P. WaUace, RL. White, M.D. Williams, J.A Willoughby, Jr., J.I. ~tfe~.B.,.w~~t ~nd
S.L. Wyka. , ".f (f ~ ,'C '-< " ,.
.( "..... / "__..,~. \.~r.r,.;-i ~ '.
,',-,( aO'{l'-.',l': '~". '~.'.
'. . , :., .1::-.
. " .; ..... ./',-1'-.:.
'" ';)';' '>. . -r" ./
.. / ~_\.\?
'~..
w~l[ ~(UJWJ1
TJ. Finnegan, Jr. is Secrewy; AB. Bixby is Treasurer; OJ. Gauthier, S.L. Kuhn, JJ. Phillips and
D.A. Rogenes5 are Assistant Secretaries; B.C. Frisbie, A. Kuppermann, P.G. MitcheU and M.
Stewart are Assodate Treasurers.
I !unher cenify that the imprint given below is the imprint of the seal of the Company.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I hereunto set my hand and the seal of the Company, this
?n WI cJ.... ,1991.
G.
Commonwealth of Massachusetts
ss.
County of Hampden
Then personally appeared the above named 1).e.o..n .A. 'Pt~e.yt,e.:J~ . who made oath to the truth of
the statements above subscribed by him before me this ~ S-+ '" day of ~ c.k. . 1991.
~f.~
Notary Public
3/91
l0:.' .: . \
l'~j C:
J.::-: ~ ~ ~~ wi I I i 7 1 i
N:\COR.PSEClMM1J'IUALIFORMSISIONlNO
ifgl f)@)PJf
.' 1':'\ ~ . :", I....~
. >~.~..._:..,- L....' I
~\, . ~. 'oJ ~
..').., ~y Or
.f ~ ('.'.. '2<' ~cH
"_ "t" _""'I N'O\" ,~ t
", ~vy . <.,~r-\jJ~)
; _" _ ~ ~ ,! L ,. I. ~ ~
j '. - . 0 ~.. --
".-:' -;-' 0 2 \9",\' '-
1~-4' p-y(, :-61
..:; .).t~>~ ,r-i- I
,-0, . ........., 1'1 fl. "',..... r~ I
I. I- eO': l'......,. ~."':
n"OR\DA 1. .",. .
( ~. .
~' , ,
"',
... " " I
, 1--"'1