CORRESPONDENCE
To: Mr. Ron Dingle
ill
Q"'\ 561-395-3072
, \ {iu~" Fax:
("
, I
(',.....-
r
(s From: Michael Rumpf
Date: March 24, 1998
Pages:
From the desk of...
Michael Rumpf
Senior Planner
City of Boynton Beach
I 00 E, Boynton Beach Blvd,
Boynton Beach, FL 33425
561-375-6260
Fax: 561-375,6259
2, including cover sheet.
I received the fax from you which was an excerpt from the
minutes of the Planning and Development Board meeting
when your annexation was reviewed, I should explain that
this issue was likely raised to be sure that the legal
description on the ordinances included the adjacent right-
of-way, otherwise the road could be construed as still being
under County jurisdiction rather than City, This is only
an issue of jurisdiction for purposes of emergency service,
Property that is annexed only changes jurisdiction, not
ownership, For example, your property was annexed by
the City, but the City does not now own it, You remain
the owner, So if the roadway is privately owned at time of
annexation, it remains in private ownership, Rights-of-way
only change ownership if specifically "dedicated" by the
owner to the local government (or if taken by the city
through an eminent domain or condemnation process), It
should be stated that dedication is not automatic; the local
government must want to accept the right-of-way in order
for this process to occur. Most older, private rights-of-way
do not meet city standards such as width or material,
therefore, the City does not typically want the liability or
cost represented by the substandard right-of-way, I hope
that I have enhanced your understanding of this
annexation process, Please contact me if I can provide you
with further information on this issue,
Respectfully yours,
il!)icbAel ~umpf
MAR-24-98 TUE 8:00 ADVENT LUTHERN SCHOOL P.01
.
,
,f!
FAX ,COVER 'SHEET
&1) /)r'y/e- tbtJl<~ 39'~g{,E;J..
I1IRft I);mk PHONE: 395.3631 FAX: 395.3072
. /' U;~1Z1t.
TO: !'ne, , .(/07 f' F
FR.OM: RON DINGLe .
DATE: .3 'tl t.f ? .
FAX TO NUMBER.: (6'"'C; I) :3 ') ~ - G Po.5' r
NUMBER OF PAGES: :L' . ~ InCluding cover sheet
.
,~
.'
(?.$
.
.
. ,
i;'
,
,
'. -MINUTES . Pl.ANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH. FLORIDA
NOVEMBER 9. 1993
Mot1on
Mr. Miller moved that we accept this proposal to rezone from RM to R-1A and show
It as consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and accept staff recommendations
for the annexation. Mr. Weigle seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
Hoplamezlln Property -
Annexation Program
(Application '10) ,
Michael H. Hoplamazlan
The 0.21 acre parcel located approXimately 400 feet
east of Federal Highway. Immediately south of
Colonial Club Condominium ('2 Virginia Gardens)
Requests to show annexed land as Moderate Density
Residential and to rezone from RM (Residential
Medium Density) In Palm Beach County to R-1-A
(Single Family Residential).
ThiS property Is Immediately west of Application '9. and the situation Is simi-
lar to that of Application 19. The current use Is a single-family home and no
change is proposed. Staff's recommendation Is the same as that of Application
1/9. _-'-'-- ' -.'___,_,___,__..,
Mr. Rumpf conf;~ed for Chairman lehnertz that Virginia Gardens road will be ~
o.nexed Into ~he City along witn Applications 119 and 1~.,_,__ ~
10. ProJect:
OWner:
location:
Description:
... .
THERE WAS NO ONE PRESENT TO SPEAK ON PUBLIC HEARING.
Motion
Mr. Dube moved to accept the P}annlng and Zoning Department's recommendation to
annex the Lewis Property*. existing land use of MR5 to Medium Density Residen-
tlal. existing zoning RM (Residential Medium Density) to R-IA (Single Family).
and to show It as consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Vice Chairwoman
Huckle seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
*See note after Application III motion.
Lewts Property -
Annexation Program
(Application '11)
Sally Lewis
The 0.11 acre parcel located on the east $'de of
Old Dixie Highway, approximately 845 feet west of
Federal Highway
Requests to show annexed land as Medium Density
Residential and to rezone from RM (Residential
Medium Density) in Palm Beach County to R-1
(Single-Family Residential).
The current use on this property Is a slngle.famlly home and no change Is pro-
posed. This application Is consistent with the Future Land Use Map and the
policies of the Comprehensive Plan.
11. proJ ect:
Owner:
Location:
Description:
- 10 -
nduent Lutheran Church
~
,~
The Reverend Dr, Roneld J, Dingle
Margue~te L, Dingle. Eerly Childhood AdministrBlOr
Rob Rose. Youth Minister
5001 N,E, fourth Avenue' Boca Raton, florida 33431-4903
phone (407) 395,3632 ' fax (407) 392-1470
The Reverend David E, Dangerfield
Philip Frlederichs, School Principal (Gr, 1,8)
Ed Lee Counseling
March 10, 1998
Ms. Joyce Costello
Administrative Assistant to the City Manager
City of Boynton Beach
P,O, Box 310
Boynton Beach, Florida 33425
Dear Ms, Costello:
Thank you for giving your sincere attention to the issue of whether or not the short road
that I live on is a private road or belongs to the city, The enclosed correspondence and
other documentation will demonstrate that my wife and I have been pursuing this decision
for nearly two years,
The fact of the matter is that city officials have only responded to our inquiries after we
have either sent copies of our correspondence to the mayor and city commissioners or have
made repeated phone calls, When I asked Mr. Wilfred Hawkins over the phone some six
months ago to please get me a response to my inquiries, he became indignant and rude but
said that he would get back to me as soon as possible, I have not heard from him yet.
In regard to this matter of paving the road, if I do not receive some indication as to a date
for a definitive decision, I will take all of my documentation for presentation to a public
forum of the city commission, It is not that I am an angry or vindictive person, but after
nearly two years of looking into this matter, I am beginning to lose patience,
-* This bring me to the second item that I discussed with you and that had to do with the
~ irregularity of trash pick up (in this case, trash is defined as grass cuttings, tree limbs, palm
frons, etc,), My wife and I received information from the city that Monday was our day for
pick up of yard and trash items, At best we have had service 50% of the time, Either I or
t:Y my neighbors have called on an average of at least monthly in order to get the trash picked
up, I mentioned to you on the phone that my property taxes of $7,200 per year seem
outrageous for the services I receive,
Thank you for being such a good listener over the phone and' for pursuing these two very
frustrating concerns for me,
~
Ron Dingle
Vb)U';'''?,h 0<..-
RECEIVED
MAR I:': 1998
Enclosures (14 pages)
C.,l,'Y ~
h~;-,\NAG~R'S OFFiCE
"Wltere !1es/ls is brd tlHd tveq/Dvd!l i.< SV",(Dvd!l"
ELEMENTARY/MIDDLE SCHOOL: )95.)635 EARLY CHILDHOOD SCHOOL & DAY CARE: )95.)631
ADVENT COUNSELING MINISTRY: 997.8168 ADVENT SQUARE, RETIREMENT CENTER: )91.7207
ADVENT LIfE ENRICHMENT CENTER: )95-5929
I
i ! I I..l! -I - r-~' .
"'_ ,i/ ,- ,'/':'-"il'.;,;; I~,:;;/
_ ,.., ,.... .--
'__ _ AI""'" '~'.' - ~ ~. I
1,2) -,,; c;" /';0' I':~'. ,';7 I.: ,~'>- ';1,,-//
/';,0 cij / (P!....! - ::-... -If - -.~
I '" I~O "
I u " ~-~k.lf-
- C/ I""-t- 10" . -.,
/,.,1" k I:'~~ 1_ ~;). -yr
,,) I
1/
,k3'f !
,)
I ;'
I
ef'.!' ,
v..'
I' -- ,--
r--"-' ' , '::J
L _ .-,..........~..~~_...__......... -
.......- .-- .
... . .,.-t.-tJ
"
"I','f'; o:.EL.: ~
, I
~-
. --' i
1
t ~.... \
. J.-\
I
I ,;,\
,-,'
CC'IJ1NII\L CUJE
s~c (;1 if
~-,
r ',NOG
.,....
""
)."'.
..:..:.....!.,...
"',
.~ : -.
'0
G9
;,..;;-,
"
~4. -
I
r:.'
^'
I. ~~)
]
,
J"f
,
/
, '
1
r
-
i
.....,?.
'-LZ
..:;:^'-
,
!
a..4"".I, ~
1-3~
:;..--
1- 2.'/
~;1rj
i.",..;
.I /-;..
:!
/, ;; ~
~'-'
-
,. ~y
) I -~ ,7"1'~
I ,~ I '11. I
f 1-'",' ;; I-J. f 1-37
!1-?5
,;( 11~,j ,,;
-.- .,'
c.... "'< ~.~,( ,,,.,./
.':.JO I' ~
,It,} !1 ~
":,,,
,~ '
1%
,-
I "\ 0 0
",'b r I'
/V V- / ~ ~'
""
. ,,:)7.:
~I.r ll'C'~? ,1111 ~.~ "~I ;,,1 ~~;;' ,,;'~' 5' '" I 6D
~ .." ",'~k" ,\ ~V'? ~ ~-'4;.,' ~~ J~ ZJ:j' I
-'~--,J '0,';'). ;00 'I _~ 5';i, 1b 1"0 'I-.~.--~.I.
j~!~";:'7lJ,'?,il(tiJ2 ,_, '[~.DAD
"r'_','- _,' , , ,I (, /10' t- , ~lv 1
'1,""105--..71-'-,,,,"'. 7I'00 q-I ' ~ ./ -.-
_ _ .7 ~ . ! I," J.! r- I.
,- l--.!..I:' I "~; "I----~,'~-:/'" ,SD-
I" ~ --;--- --I I .,~~ -; D ,-.-i3t\'-
,~ ! (,0, i ~I: 7--: ' ~-'!;;; ~~ 9!;:- ,';' {-I 4_~ -
I /'. ,~' '~ ~ I IJ-O
_.-' ''I' I' '7 :'XI I I A/d-
_ ' 'I ' '10 SO '" qh'-- "l I
,- '-,', '1'-" 7'''1'' ----I"' ~ ,
,<,': '" _'" ~ -', i Ii , ,,~. I
,::-' /- "U3 ",'q; If I "p
, (4 tr, '72 ",1. V <-:/ I,' L '/
r- . - / ,l~": r.," I
j' ,- /' 'I: "0 I '"L ;\,0' L 1
,~1lP5j.~170;{; '~35~ I (<0, !~I ,',/
i,
_ J!:';,~'
/,-',( -,1'.
',; I
-
, I
)/
j
r~
~
~~
f-~ '
Cw I
~I
~r~
i:
I I
I
I
f
Ii
"
, ,
, ,
i I
! I
,~L-
--
-
I --
0'
f
J
I
I
I
--_I
"
,
I
,
-71
, "
I 'j '.
! ,
,
-'-
-'
.-
'--
i
-'
- - -
"-,
I
I
I
!
I
/
I
.... -... .. -
.
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
"
f:
,
-. -.J
'.
NW OI-BAR/1ETT HGTS,.'PfJJ
paz,:; PI28 ' '-'
" 02~E80NA1RE ESTS~ ' '. .
PB 23 P z:n ;~gi L '
1\ 03wGRAY.SPN HGTS "@ . ,- ,I: '
P82J-P220 ''':~.'
" 04 -GULF STREAM ESTS p[~~
PB IJ PSI \ ',' , '(
j. OO.-GI.1LFS,TREAM ESTS PL.?,t;:..
. ,,' OF.PORTirJN-,W
PB I e P; I '~, :.
., 06-MJ,SSIQN H/L,L -fl'\ ' ';,
PBe:4 pot? .;.' " ..1,'
sw 07- DECARIE 5 UB -: /00., I' -~ .,: ; , ,',
PIC') ~., =', ,- 'N~
PB zr" ,G' '.' r '. ';-. ", ;" '
',[ 08~ Dt.L RAY.BEACH E'57 $ViB,': 12\ ,1--' . ,.,r ",' t
, p~ ~, P' _ "', 1!.51 ....' .
C'" I) "', "
SvW9-GULFSTREAM Esis-@. ' 7-' , i\"
, PB/2 P?:i3 " .(, ',.., ,""
" iO-GULFSTREAM ESTScRFP, 2" '~'r:,.r.::: ',~'] ~,,::,'
'vf BLKS 2 - 5 I Ne 'r@ "" t~ ';, .i'?f
.. " PBZ3 P4b" , ' :' ",~:."
Nt, //-KI LLI "N''S SU"', IY'\, "~~ " " ,': ," :- ,i
" Q \.-_......._#... -t' . .'J . " ;J."~,
" Pe2':lP'qJ:: "~"~""" ,.,i..\; ,.
, " 12-K/WGS, sUB P82i)P47 ~i.o,'ij.: .141 .,::...,'.. '.,':i;lf''i ~~.
5~!/7'-L AVE HEIGHT ,1i?,4B'2~P.20j:;~l:#'_,~' ,: ~~,
_ r:v'.. ~. ~~"f "1-' " ;,....
"/4-f,{,At LARENS SUB",@",.':!tdr'
_ PEE"! P36, ' .. ",:.1, '. "~
,'I:'-,?f:~c;,\'EST SlJB-'@ , ~
P B 23 P 3.~ '
N~f 16-5/-:1' RANC/-I ESTS -'<9 "
PC"?P9~
" r.;;::~_ ..' t,;,.I'
(JEll' r., 'R~:O:.\IlJIN[) F..STS ' '
AMN!';EO PL-c:'9 '.
. (-'f. 2 ; P 73 ", .,
" F-TRADEV//ND E5TS- PB21P45 - @
A /vtNDED PUI T OF /Iil PB 21 f 1.3 i
Nila TR/.JJJt:WI ND E~:TS 1ST ADP~ @. ,
P822 'P44 .,
I-.JE 1')..rr.!i,DE WINDS i::rrs, /SJ'i,J;OO:C-I'0\,
REM Of' tNTRANCE.' ,,~J .
L , " ' ,I
5~.f20~~::T;~~~~!2~P.B~3 ~J68 ~'~f,fJ'
2 I ,SEACRE5T ~ARK - 1@ '-_J',_-1.\",-",'~
.' PB 24 P 33 ';';, I-t'J:'1'i
5- 22 -PLACE AU soqEL -:-@..__.<:\ . ,;J:~, ~J
, pe27 P G'?J, . : j~,:?~' V~:'. (",;:
SE 23' PLACE' AU, SqLE! L ;.~Q,Cl,~\#Br~~fEi-4..;~lJ.;,:~
"'" 24 GULF ST~AM,' EST$:...p1;.~(I.lFp~3Z,'P!'4;";J,, ,
REPLAT 08 >.'.' i ,I '.,J ' "
, '1 " . .... ,/ .'
. ,.;,- -~: --....., ,.'
II/Or(: GU( FSTR[AM,' @ - r, ~ ',",: ;:'
:L ~~r.~~!N 88(r;g{1 ~.,l.' I,', "I"(":,,r,, ~'
.' COUNT. 0,,5' ..: ,'\' ' I
. . r"
,~\'I:'J('ISEi-'H!: I:: 5, LA \'INOSUB'<~Q80) .FJ33.8,f.}!,Jti!,
:''''26 St.NFr.EST ELVD CONT/N<'1ING ,"', , '
PRESE:YTER/AN' CHURCH (88) PB55P/74:@ .,
, " r-?'~;1W\
______________n. '. ___~jJ..
,~
~t
~.
r
S
1~
j:
\
.
I r'
I
!
~.
,,', ....
1:,;.' '~
~"
W," f
"f' "i\
"-\~
;., ',:.
~ ..?, ,:';'
.) .l. *'
,..~
\
,~
,-'\ ..,,'.....
~"
.,
\., ,
~, i~
, , IL "-
\,
~
:Of!
" ~Je. , " "
A. pl\RCEL .REstRIbT~b
JPE~~ 'lffITY ,~F ,??TL~,) > ~
*,GOM~~ARC~L YV..l!'9t.i~~T~A lo"'O'L:,: '1fi8f11
PER:S.G.H.- PROPERTY CON-mOL NU!f,;::, .
, .. , CC1!W" CClCIE lWfCt .... S[V'llCIH, ~
GO 00 co _~ . ~ -0
,
.'
,).
.~- . .--- ~-
.......... I
;
t
\
-
----
\
\
\
\
\
I
I
\
-- 'V r-
[0,'33
, .'
Ie)
36 31 32 33 34 35 36 31
1653216
12 7 8 9 10 11 12 7
'131817 16 1514 13 18
2 19 20 21 22 23 24 19
25 30 28 28 27 26 25 30
. 36 31 32 33 34 35 36 31
165432,16
....-..
. ~ l~!=:f'
!
, ....
::",
Ronald and Marguerite Dingle
3 Virginia Garden
Delray Beach, FL 33483
Property Control No. 08 43 46 04 00 001 0100
August 13, 1996
Ms. Carrie Parker
Boynton Beach City Manager
100 E. Boynton Beach Blvd.
Boynton Beach, FL 33425
Dear Ms. Parker:
Regarding: Road paving - Virginia Garden
This letter is a request for completion of road paving of Virginia Garden. This road is
approximately 500' long. Its westerly end is at Federal Highway (directly north of Sun Wah
restaurant) and its easterly end is at the entrance to our own property, About 360' of
Virginia Garden is already paved. This is the portion from Federal Highway extending east.
The remaining 140' of Virginia Garden is a dirt road.
At the November 9, 1993, meeting of the Boynton Beach Planning and Development Board
(copy attached) Virginia Garden road was annexed into the city of Boynton Beach, as was
our property as well, Along with this annexation from the county to the city, our property
taxes have increased a considerable amount (copies of tax bills before and after attached)
and our assessed value has decreased. As you can see from our address, we are also in
somewhat of an "in the middle" situation as we are in Delray for mailing purposes and in
Boynton for taxes, telephone, cable and utilities.
This letter is a request for paving the remainder of Virginia Garden, Please let us know
what needs to be done on our part to facilitate this request. We appreciate your attention
to this matter.
Sincerely,
Ronald and Marguerite Dingle
cc: Jerry Taylor, Mayor
MINUTES - PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA
NOVEMBER 9, 1993
Motion
Mr. Miller moved that we accept this proposal to rezone from RM to R-1A and show
it as consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and accept staff recommendations
for the annexation. Mr. Weigle seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
Description:
Hoplamazian Property -
Annexation Program
(Application #10)
Michael, H. Hoplamazian
The 0.21 acre parcel located approximately 400 feet
east of Federal Highway, immediately south of
Colonial Club Condominium (#2 Virginia Gardens)
Requests to show annexed land as Moderate Density
Residential and to rezone from RM (Residential
Medium Density) in Palm Beach County to R-1-A
(Single Family Residential).
,
10. Project:
Owner:
Location:
This property is immediately west of Application #g, and the situation is simi-
lar to that of Application #9. The current use is a single-family home and no
change is proposed. Staff's recommendation is the same as that of Application
#9.
Mr. Rumpf confirmed for Chairman Lehnertz that Virginia Gardens
nexed into the City along with Applications #9 and 10.
THERE WAS NO ONE PRESENT TO SPEAK ON PUBLIC HEARING.
Motion
Mr. Dube moved to accept the P}anning and Zoning Department's recommendation to'
annex the Lewis Property*. existing land use of MR5 to Medium Density Residen-
,tial. existing zoning RM (Residential Medium Density) to R-1A (Single Family),
and to show it as consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Vice Chairwoman
Huckle seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
*See note after Application III motion.
Description:
Lewis Property -
Annexation Program
(Application #11)
Sally Lewis
The 0.11 acre parcel located on the east s'de of
Old Dixie Highway, approximately 845 feet west of
Federal Highway
Requests to show annexed land as Medium Density
Residential and to rezone from RM (Residential
Medium Density) in Palm Beach County to R-1
(Single-Family Residential).
11. Project:
OWner:
Location:
The current use on this property is a single-family home and no change is pro-
posed. This application is consistent with the Future Land Use Map and the
policies of the Comprehensive Plan.
- 10 -
o :R::ER4: C;:%tLNOU07~::1 o~;1 1995
'ASSES~ "., IIF " EXEMPTION
~07.73;'; 25.000
1 CODE
: 41
TAXABLE VALUE
282,731
LfGAL DESCRIPTION
4-46-43, E 150 FT OF S 104.5
FT OF N 165.7 FT OF GOV LT 1
W OF FIND CNL & E OF SR 5
1"II",II"I"II"I",IIIIIIIIf1IIIIIIU1III.II'Il"II",I,11
DINGLE RONALD J & MARGUERITE L
3 VIRGINIA GARDEN
DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-6305
JOHN K. CLARK. CFC. TAX COLLECTOR
AD VALOREM TAXES
TAXING AUTHORITY TELEPHONE NO. MILLAGE TAX AMOUNT
COUNTY 407 355-2027 4.2177 IH92.47
SCHOOL STATE 407 434-8B37 6.6320 1,875.07
SCHOOL LOCAL 407 434-8837 2.6450 747.82
CITY DF BOYNTON BEACH 407 375-6060 7. 9251 2,240.67
SO FLA WATER MANAGEMENT DIST. 407 686-B800 .5470 154.65
SOUTH LAKE WORTH INLET DIST. 407 969-9024 .1008 28.50
CHILDRENS SERVICES CDUNCIL 407 655-1010 .3730 105.46
F. I. N. D. 407 G27-333G .0400 11.31
PBC HEALTH CARE DISTRICT 407 659-1270 1.4250 402.89
SFWMD EVERGLADES CONST PROJECT 407 686-8800 .1000 28.27
COUNTY DEBT 407 355-2027 .3014 85.22
SCHOOL DEBT 407 434-8837 .5200 147.02
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH DEBT 407 375-6060 .4816 136.16
TOTAL
7.155.51
-
NON.AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
LEVYING AUTHORITY
SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY
407 697-2700
RATE
151.00
AMOUNT
151.00
TOTAL 151.00
COMBINED TOTAL 7.306.51
****ORIGINAL STATEMENT REOUESTED BY: BARNETT MORTGAGE
COMPANY
SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR INSTRUCTIONS AND INFORMATION
COUNTY of-PALM-sEACH:NO-TICE -oF AD VALOREM TAXES-AND NON-=-ADVALOREM-ASSESSMENTS -
I, PROPERTY CONTROL NUMBER: '""""",?: 1995 CMC 41 DDC .36 ACRES MTG B22
! 0845460,,'00001"'0100"; COUNTY 1,277.69 ,SCHOOL 2.769.91
, ' ',,,'" ,,' , _ CITY 2,576.85 S FL WATER 154.65
ASSESSED VALUE 507,731 INLET DIST 28.50 CHILD SVCS 105.46
EXEMPTIONS 25.000 FIND 11.31 HEALTH 402.89
TAXABLE VALUE 2B2,751 EVGLDS C P 28.27 SWA 151,00
DINGLE RONALD J & MARGUERITE L
5 VIRGINIA GARDEN
OELRAY BEACH FL 33483-6305
06295276270000730651010
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
4-46-43. E 150 FT OF'S 104.5
FT OF N 165.7 FT OF GOV LT 1
W OF FIND CNL & E OF SR 5
COLLECTOR NO. I MAKE CHECKS PAYABLE TO:
7 : TAX COLLECTOR. PALM BEACH COUNTY
2 - 952 - 62- 7 I P.O. BOX 3715 WEST PALM BEACH. Fl 33402-371:'
_._._~~____.--l
AJ.IOUNT"
DUE
IF PAID IN
.ED:'~
7.087,311 7.160,381
DECEMBERi ': ~::~~ ..JANUARY
7.233,4417,306.511
: FEBRUARY::;:.L. ;,:i;l2::\'MARCH,.,~~
7.526.711 8.304,40
APRIUMAY JUNE/JULY
DEUNQUENT --~~
"=:;'::;.<1:2 li~
YEAR CODE
994 41
TAXABLE VALUE
274.641
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
4-46-43, E 150 FT OF S 104.5
FT OF N 165.7 FT OF GOV LT 1
W OF FIND CNL & 'E OF ,SR 5
"<O':~k~ir~f~~li&\f&ffitlfr:fil~~~i
ASSESSEO VALUE EXEMPTION
(299.641.:::> 25.000
1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIlIIIIIIIIIIIIII.II'IIII.I,IIIIIIII1IIII.11
OINGLE RONALD J & MARGUERITE L
3 VIRGINIA GARDEN
DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-6305
TAXING AUTHORITY
COUNTY
SCHOOL STATE
SCHOOL LOCAL
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH~
SO FLA WATER MANAGEMENT DIST.
SOUTH LAKE WORTH INLET DIST.
CHILDRENS SERVICES COUNCIL
F. IoN.D.
PBC HEALTH
EVERGLADES
COUNTY
SCHOOL
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH,
AD VALOREM TAXES
TELEPHONE NO.
355-2027
434-8837
434-8837
375-6060
'686-8800
969-9824,
655-1010
627-3386
659-1270
686-8800
355-2027
434-8837
,,375-6060
CARE DISTRICT
CONSTRUCT. PROJECT
DEBT
DEBT
DEBT,
TOTAL
7~OS3.46':'-.'. . .
,....':.
"f,:"
NON.AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
LEVYING AUTHORITY
SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY
697-2700
TOTAL 152.00,
COMBINED TOTAL 7,205.46
****ORIGINAL STATEMENT REQUESTED BY: BARNETT MORTGAGE
COMPANY
MILLAGE,
4.2931
6.9170
2.6490
'7.9251
.4970
.1014
.3522
.0490
1.4500
.1000
.2262
.6190
.5035
RATE
152.00
TAX AMOUNT
\
1,179.06
1,899.69
727.52
2,176.56
136.50
27.85
96.73
13.46
398.23
27.46
62.12
170.00
138.28
AMOUNT
152.00
_ __ ___ _ _ _.~-...::. =--.:...:~SE...E.~m~r <::,n~'f~a:..mS:rL'..t;:nQtl.V~&"'J.NEPf:.MbW:L---._........., -.- ~- ~ - - - - - --- -
'mcoUN1:y"oF'PAiiiifs'E"ActCriio'fic'e"oF'AO"VALOR'e_\Vj,TA'X'e's"AN'D"jijo'N:AD-'vALoRe'M"~ssEssMEjij'fS.m-
':iMN~R<lP~RTV;;l:;QN:plDti~t,iM!lcEil~#~K 1994 CMC 41 DOC .36 ACRES MTG B22
U't08%'(i3'W46i~:O;4!#DiW'ol1il,wOttil':ii CO U N TV 1 24 1 . 1 8 S C H 0 0 L 2 . 7 9 7 . 2 1
l.:,.,:.:.:.:....:.:.:.:.~:.::.~:.:.:.~::~;:~;.,..,::r:.;::~:~:~i;;~~::.;t:;;. "/' :;:.+..~;:;:.;:-.:~~.:>;;~.: C I TV 2: 314 . 84 S F L WA TE R 136 .50
ASSESSED VALUE 299,641 INLET DIST 27.85 CHILD SVCS 96.73
EXEMPTIONS 25.000 FIND 13.46 HEALTH 398.23
TAXABLE VALUE 274.641 EVGLDS C P 27.46 SWA 152.00
DINGLE RONALD J & MARGUERITE L
3 VIRGINIA GARDEN
DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-6305
08290837100000720546010
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
4-46-43. E 150 FT OF S 104.5
FT OF N 165.7 FT OF GOV LT 1
W OF FIND CNL & E OF SR 5
COLLECTOR NO,
2-908-371-0
MAKE CHECKS PAYABLE TO:
TAX COLLECTOR, PALM BEACH COUNTY
P.O. BOX 3715 WEST PALM BEACH, Fl 33402.3715
JOHN K, CLARK, CFC, TAX COLLECTOR
6.917.2 6.989,301 7,061.351 7.133.411 7.205.461
..~!:~DECEi.laEm"{l;.~iirr;t.t1~~WAN.ii~~t~~;t;;,~:i:J1EBROA.RYW.mij~~~r..IARC1ei!~~
7.422.621 8.189.64
APRIUMAY JUNE
DELINQUENT 1
~~~~~]
IffiPAJI1..IN:ttf;r,;j"
PALM BEACH COUNTY NOTICE
PROPERTY CONTROL NUMBER:
00 43 46 04 ~O 001 0100
ASSESSED VALUE EXEMPTIO
(320,268:) 25,000
AND NON,AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
4-46-43, E 150 FT OF S 104.5
eFT OF N 165.7 FT OF GOV LT 1
W OF FIND CHI: & E OF SR 5 '
"-,,. ".
lullllllll,lullullllllllll'IllII,Il'IlII.I.IfIl'IlIl,ul,1l
DINGLE RONALD J . MARGUERITE L
3 VIRGINIA GARDEN
DELRAY BEACH FL 33483-b305
~ ~'i
~.~ 1-r:;";: ..
. ";':~'"
AD VALOREM TAXES ,~.-:t- ,. ,'. -,' '-" .\ .
TAXING AUTHORITY TELEPHONE No::~3>,' MIUJlGE',f,:,' ":, TAX' AMOUNT
COUNTY:"':: ... " .. ,,355-2027f'-,::S'<' ':4. 327B:/,,'.... 1,27,7.86
. FIRE/RESCUE- MSTU" .: ." -. ':. 355-2 o 27':::'3,.)rl'"-; ",.::, 2; 620 1".:'.~.,.~:f.-"-"'1,'-773. 63
LIBRARY , 355-202f',~"':;-'" ,;, ; 3915 ': .. '...',,:, 115.60
.''', SCHOOL STATE 434-8837;,,',; 6.?470 :';, ",2,051.23
;,,/:SCHOoLi LOCAL " 434-8837,," , '\ 2.5100 :; ",;;,. 741.12
" "...SO FLA: WATER MANAGEMENT DlST. ...., 687-6207,....."., ',.,..-5970"'...,' ".." :,176.27
: :,~~i:~~~~~:,~::RVICES COUNCIL", ,:':" :.:_:,.~..~~=_~~,~;3.iE~:~&,~~~~iFj;U:,:::.~~: ~~
.,':___.":P8C~HE'AL:rFr"t:'ARE:"'1ITSTR ICT-.'..'-..--,' ,. '" - 659-1270,: ,': ': 1. 475 0:' ':., """ 4:\5,52
li~~.;,;,~~:COU_N:rY~~~':i;~r' >..,:~~_:~:..;.~'~__ _ ; :": ::", DEBT _.>.':;:<~.::: ._~;):'" 355-2 0 2.l:.!/r::b(-:. :,: :-:t'f;,!:-;."22_215:.:',:::.~:;:.',,~:,,::: 6 5.58
'~~~~.!~:~S.~~;~,~~!~;,~r?'~~:,'~'~';:';":<':'~' DE,B~":"::~;1~~J:0~.:~~~~~i~::~;'{,~~~I~~13r:(\:'1 ~;,: 93
:-..rt.....t.~...,....~il~~l;-;..::'"r'"-'~- ..',.. ''" " I__"".tl.~";;;-"~-t;.r~f."" ,l'.:....;.....)_\i.::?!.~~.Ill:.,,~~.,~......l.tfjt.:'"':'..i."l....~;:..~., ' '~
: .r.~:>:~\-.:r..i-~:r*.il.~;t--.":".',. . '.-., ....:,.: :., ~ .;-:~:.:~::~~ :..t.~~~~~1::,:.~ ......"r.'..._' f.l~)':-.~:'~;'L:;:"'" '.. ,.
~~~~~~:~r:~~N~*"~:t~~'~-:'1~~ ~-+ '\: :,,~: "~~iEf~ ~~~!~':}o~l..ts:'j.,<<~~!'"J1i~~'~~Jl::t,~,~~:JI:-: .- P~,:t~P.i:-;;,'). -'. c'; .;..-: ;
.:;-,r J,:.,':"!i-"T'O\T'~"L-W~'=''\(~.5'''''''9'''2''8(/;'!>15''.!<:-'''''':'~~'~f2.'EflJZ..~):':;";'G'~1;.~,f ;)tiU-;l~~~~~1t1.1J;!~ .. ,'t~~;t~'il~ ;/~f i~ '-
..~~,... A ,.~w.!:_'_~ I . ......!. - . '.. .I_..~,' ......''.T.~~~~.._~, "'~.r",~'{.',"'p':J-~.,J~ 1::,"- ....
-... -.._.....-_.~ -~..
':?Yl~~ !!,."j,t~r~~'f<:~.(nt-~.?t~"fI" ". ',,~ ~ .f~.NO~-Ao-VALOREM ASSE~SMEN-rs;~tr:if'-:}l~-l'~j$;;';~ :~:(;!~'$-" -..;.. :~,~ ,:f '
~,,~~'~:-;~"J'CVYJNGAUTHORITY '.- . ~ ...... . ~:~'...!,.>:"i~.~....RATE1;'~~~i?-:;~.;~f-:AMOUNT..
...,t.'~:r,.,.~..~. ..,. ;..;.' ..>:..:{.....- ..~....-' ..,~...)' .li........~.I............,
..~.:-. fi51'soL:lu.rwAsTEf AUTHCf!;I1"':' _~', '~., ." .~:: :.. "': YJ,.;.':'-'6 97:':270 O~' :233'~-O Q ~ ';'J.::r.iii~... 233.00
.~~i;.'J:~"';; .. .': ....; '" .~..._.". ,.<<:.~..~.~~.,.,.:it4"'':':i~~J.:,,,,,,~~'~~')'':'';:'-J',,;;.~~.;~i;~~rJ:ii~l:i~..,..,>-.'{:}; ~"'~~'''' ~""<"l.~."
.. I.. , . "',_ }~~JSE:'';\:.j'' ", . ;_-:;-~--- 'l.I I _'~,.. ~ =~l)ll '. in:;,,,';" .~. ........~...
....r.::',.~,...~\o1, "":t!'..",)'..':I. ,',"". . . 1 " _.' _'j _.. .~ .-. "~M"'",;,-\~,,-;~~~, ...'.... > I J.., '
,'::~:~".~'~'~!,-i....;~::...t..'~,. ,,:j~~' ..:' _ i 'i. }~;. :~~t~i .. -:'~~1';:.;'.:?~~:;"~ ~~~i ~,- ' "
~;i~,l:1;;~\i~~,,~u:~~\,l.-\:. .'_~.y"" :.1 ".' ' I' ~',; ,,1" ..:,; ~ \""..J.!:! O:~"~;L...._..f ....'-. '.'
:~~1Cl!t:"l~:l:l7'"~.f..":~.t~~,,;:,'-~'~'."-~r:- I".' I, ~~.::-.. ~ <-" "t&;, r;m :~ v.'.J : .:.f1~~, ':', -';', i":
f!l.........,r,.>J!r.r--..J~:h,.;..~.t'"~J"\'......r~. :... '~-.....~:-.~ ::t.r"):;\ ,..-::.t..1t..~."".-,,,* +~""'~. ~..- ....-.,.
....r-:-J:;l"i_l'--X r<.:~,~ rc:...i".r,-"'I ''i~- . ~. ..~-.: .,'t"'"~ -. '".. ~'~ .....". ~\."'<i'1 ...Etj\~~ "".1. .'
. ~?O~ ~L";;(~r.ii.'".....t-:,:23~~:.00:';~:'~~~-"'''~~:;'::::'~:('~;'~~- ~ '~%t:w{::'~~:" , ..."i:...Z.J_.-.... ....
. COM.~.I~~D)J.T,))T,Al:~~t'~~'7'6':'I'6l".15~'oj"";:,)f :J..f--';:~~ ';';;;~::~'ii:Ji"i-..
."ii.ORIGINALi"STATEMENT'REQUESTED;' BARNE,1;i!E., ii,:,,::,';;;'tt:,r,
'fI'" ' , :;,N~~1"'''' ',H'",d."",',~""""r'-" 'COMf'AN' """,j...::
" ,} ~~, "~~;:;Y~)J;I~~~rt.~h~~,'~"'~;'ili~'gi;:~~~
... ",,' "SEE: HEVERSECSID EOR~I "~",;..,,,'!'h"",
[,,:, _: ~,' ," ,.--
PALM BEACH COUNTY NOTICE' OF ,NON.AD VALOREM"ASSESSMENTS
~,,, PROfERT:Y.iCONTROl:: NUMBER"" :i,.
~,~O 0;;r4'31i4"~b, '~tro Ot'O oit 0 1'00
.ft)';v.....\.).~ l'iJ!i.~~"""~".~'p'~""""';"(.,:",;,,, ,'.
1993
CHC 35
COUNTY
, LI 8RARY
S FL WATER
CHILD SVCS
HEALTH
DDC .36 ACRES
'1,343.44 FIRE,DIST
115.60 SCHOOL
176.27 SWA, '", '
97.35 FIND'
435.52
MTG 822
773,63
2,971.28
2:\:\,00
15,06
ASSESSED VALUE
EXEHPTIONS
TAXABLE, VALUE
320,268
25,000
295,268
.,
. ~;'\;.i.t~~"."
DINGLE 'RONALD J . MARGUERITE L
3 VIRGINIA,GARDEN
DELRAY'BEACH fL 33483-b305
00248835220000b1b11S040
>..~..
.:.'~-..,.......-
....-....UN<eO<!~_.....m
PALM BEACH COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR
P.Q eox 3115' WEST PlWoI BIE.ACH. FL 33-'0'2.3115
JOHN K; CLARK. TAX COLLECTOR
. LEGAL DESCRIPTION
4-46-43p,E 150 FT OF S 104,5
"FT OF N 165.7 FT OF GOV LT 1
W OF FIND CNL & E OF SR 5
COLLECTOR NO,
2-488-352-2
, "
.: ;~:;::...
....,. ~.':\.~:
'.'-J.'
6,0:\7.9:\
6,099.54
6,161.15';::'6, :\57.981
7,014. ;
.
\.~.~,:!.~~::~=.~~;.::~.: ~:'_.:,: : ':..'~ ~":..:_--
..' ,:~~i~"',~:,: ;4~:
,..,., '.
"~-~"'.'~'~ .
.,.___.,__u.___'-
yo-
,fJJU City of
iBoynton iBeacli
100 ~ 'Boynton. 'lJead. 'lJoulevanl
P.O. 'lJo'l:310
'Boynton. 'lJUJdi., ~ 3342S.0310
City 1fJJll: (407) 375..(j()()()
:J!lIX: (407) 375-6090
September 27, 1996
Ronald and Marguerite Dingle
3 Virginia Garden
Delray Beach, FI 33483
Dear Ronald and Marguerite:
This letter is in response to your letter dated August 13, 1996 addressed to Carrie Parker,
City Manager. The roadway into Virginia Garden was a private road while it was within
county jurisdiction, The annexation of Virginia Garden into the City of Boynton Beach
jurisdiction does not change the fact that it is a private road, It is the City of Boynton
Beach's policy not to build, rebuild, improve or maintain private roads, We understand
your request for the city to pave tne private wacl bUl, lile City l,;annot do :;(;, 'Ne approciate
hearing from you and if you have questions you may call this office at 375-6010,
Sincerely,
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
~
Hawl,ins
ant to the City Manager
c: Mayor and City Commission
Robert Eichorst, Public Works Director
Tambri Heyden, Planning DireGtor
.9lmerial's (jateUJaY to tF.e (julfstream
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM NO. 97- 083
TO:
FROM:
James Cherot, City Attorney
Wilfred Hawkins #
Assistant to the City Manager
DATE:
February 25, 1997
SUBJECT: Determining it Virginia Garden is a private road
Attached please find a letter trom Marguerite Dingle regarding Virginia Garden. Ms. Dingle
states that the tax records show this road has no designated owner. Therefore, by default
the road is owned by the jurisdiction it is located in. Would you please provide a
detemination on the road ownership issue as, described. Ms, Dingle's original
correspondence was requesting Virginia Garden to be repaved. The City's initial response
was the road was private and therefore not the City's responsibility. If you have any
questions please call me. I anticipate your response by March 7, 1997 if possible. Thank
you.
Attachments: Map and Letter
c: Ms. Marguerite -Dingle (w/o attachments)
w
-'
-----
--
...--
.'
Ronald and Marguerite Dingle
3 Virginia Garden
Delray Beach, Florida 33483
Apr\} 8, 1997
Wilfred Hawkins
Assistant to the City Manager
The City of Boynton Beach
100 E. Boynton Beach Blvd.
P.O. Box 310
Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310
Dear Wilfred:
Thank you for sending me a copy of your February 25th memo to James Cherof, City
Attorney, regarding determining the private road status of Virginia Garden. According to
that memo you anticipated a response by March 7th.
Please let us know, what response has been received and what action may be expected.
~~M
Marguerite Dingle
.
.
,f}JU City of
1Joynton 1Jeadi
100 'E. 'Boynton 'lJeac!r. 'lJoukvarrf
P.O. 'lJ~310
'lJoyntOll 'lJeadi, !J1'oriIfa 33425-0310
City 9lafI: (561) 375-6000
jJU: (561) 375-6090
May 8, 1997
Marguerite Dingle
3 Virginia Garden
Delray Beach, FL. 33483
Dear Ms, Dingle:
Thank you for your letter dated May 5, 1997, I concur we have been corresponding over
the last eight months and we finally have a partial resolution to present. Based upon
research done by Department of Development staff, it has been determined that Virginia
Garden is a private road, However, the City Attorney's Office suggests in order to make
a definitive determination a survey should be done and then sent to a title company to
perform an cwnership search, This is a costly endeavor and how this will be paid for is the
issue, I will obtain more information on the cost of a survey and title search and pass it
along to you, We can arrange a meeting with you and City staff to further discuss the
survey and title search issue, My phone number is 375-6010, We appreciate your
cooperation in this matter.
Sincerely,
CITY OF BOYNTON BEJ~H ,
ft. 1bu~
Wilf Hawkins
As tant to the City Manager
c: Mayor and City COl!lmission (I!, J.f!fI"~'!,,)
City Manager---lf(A.A..'(4._~~.1 j ,...'" ""
City Attorney ,_:::._.._....,.{L ,.."
Department of Development Director
Public Works Director
Jlmerial's (jateway to tlit (jut/stream