Loading...
CORRESPONDENCE From: Sent: To: Subject: Livergood, Jeffrey Wednesday, May 30, 2001 9:59 AM Rumpf, Michael Manor Drive ~~~ fit::- j31?4~ 8>:/: <S"'-.\ S kl--/ (~61 0'.'\t,)(~ 'w ~ ,{ 1::. ~f, Michael Mike, Sorry to dump this on you. I understand you have a history with Barbara Bradshaw on Manor Drive relative to the Park Shores Manor Bed and Breakfast. Barbara is very complimentary of you by the way. Barbara visited me this morning because she was recently passed from several departments and finally ended up with me. She is purchasing a property across the street from her property in an effort to clean up a neighborhood eyesore, so she says. As part of the purchase process, the Title Insurance company has raised concerns about the status of streets in the area. In particular, the Title company has evaluated access agreements for those portions of Manor Drive that are privately owned. The company found that agreements/easements on Manor are in order. However, the Title company expressed its opinion that Mariner, north of MLK is private street and does not have the necessary access agreements for Manor Drive. Thus, the Title company is opining that the subject parcel on Manor is landlocked and as such they are blocking the sale of the property. I tried to research this the best I could since I don't really have any files over here at PW. I looked at the plat book in the Clerk's office and it appears that there is a small portion of Marine north of MLK that is dedicated, yet our street records from Engineering show it as private. Thus, I could not give Barbara a definitive answer. I advised Barbara that I would ask for your help. Again, she was pleased that I was going to talk to you since she admires you (she does not have the same admiration for many other staff). Could you please contact her? She is planning to buy 653 Manor Drive (PN 08-43-45-22-00-003-0080). Her phone number is 734-9142. Time is of the essence for her. I will help any way that I can. I have a vested interest in the street ownership issues. Jeff Jeffrey R. Livergood Director of Public Works City of Boynton Beach 1 DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT Building . Planning & Zoning . Neighborhood Services . Occupational Ucenses · Community Redevelopment October 25,2000 Mrs. Barbara Bradshaw Post Office Box 1342 Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 Dear Mrs. Bradshaw: In response to your letter and a follow-up to our telephone conversations, I am prepared to make the necessary changes to your Occupational Licenses. As I stated to you on the telephone, the State Department of Hotels and Restaurants has been in contact with me in reference to your licensure position. They indicated a need to do an inspection of your property, of which we require a passing grade before issuing you an Occupational License for "Bed and Breakfast". As soon as that is done, we will issue you your "first" Bed and Breakfast license. I apologize for any confusion my staff, or I may have caused you, but rest assured we are most happy to assist you in accomplishing your goal. Sincerely, -u..-:- :/l ~~ Edwin A. Yates Occupational License Manager EA Y:aIW CC: Quintus Greene, Director of Development Kurt Bressner, City Manager Mike Rumpf, Planning and Zoning Director \\CH\MAJN\SHRDA T A \I)evelopment\DlRECTOR\Occ.Lic.Ltr.Barbara Bradshaw ID-25-OO.doc.dot City of Boynton Beach. 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd., P.O. Box 310 . Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 Phone: (561) 742-6350 . www.ci.boynton-beach.fl.us y "- (c-V> "-) (~~.~ & W G.,.. i!IAAJ " Oct:.cber 16, .2000 @ ~r: U"~: Ed Y&tes, ~irec~or Occupat1enal License. C~:y of Boynton ~each 100 Saat Boynton Beach Boulevard Poet Office Sox 190 Boynton Beach, Plorida 33425-0190 .... Oocupat:Lo:DAl Lice.., .ed . ~eakf..t latAbli.bmsDt C.ar Mr. Yat.lI: ~ you may Ce awa::e/ 1 have :C.ae::. proeeed.:l.ng fQ::ward. w:.th obtaining an oceupational lic.n.e relative to the operation of my proparey located at 658 Ma~or Drive in eh. Ci=y ot Boynton Beach. This p..t F:r1aay, whi:"e at City Hall on a:1Other mat~l!lr, I met Mic:hael I.umpf I Dirac:tor ot. E'lanning and Zoning, who inquired. .s to the statuI of my oQta~n1ng an occupational license to operate my property aa a. Bed & !reakfa.:. I informed Mr. Rumpf that the occupational license division of the City had previously informed me that I needed to pet1t:l.on tbe City of Boynton Beach Plann1ni and Cevelopment Board to determine the appropria.te fee for such an occupational license since the City did not have any information as 1:.0 what they were lIuppoaed to charSle me. r I \'& . At t:.hat time, Mr. Rumpf indicated that that did not seem appropriate and he perlonally inqu1rea of your office as to what needed to be done !!or ma to obtain an ooeupational liolin.. for my Sea, Breakfast .ata1)11ahment. Apparently, sor.teone in your office 1nformed Mr. Rumpf that I n.eded. to submit a. letter, .i;n8d by me, and notarized, stating that I will alway" abide by Orc1inano. Number 000-47 in full, an~ will not ..11 any merchand1.., or otherw1se hold unauehc~ize4 event., at my prope~ey. perhaps, needle.. to say, this process is all very oonfusing to me aa a la.y person. As a r.sul t , please .end me a let tar outlining, 1n aeta1l, what a4d1t1onal ateps I nee4 to Qo 1n order Ed Yates, Direc:or October ~6, 2000 page 2 to obtain my occupational licenee ~o opera~e my property &6 ~ Bed & BreakfaBe. Hopefully, your letter will elimina~e any further contusion. Thank you for YOUI' cQoperat1on, Sineerely, /3;ky(~~ Barbara R. Bradsnaw cc: Michael ~..lmpf city Manager's Office Oirector of Development Mayor All City Councilmen Facsimile TRAlVSM/TT/U. CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 100 E. BOYNTON BEACH BOULEVARD P.O. BOX 310 BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33425-0310 FAX: (561) 742-6259 PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION to: Peter Schmidt fax #: 561-394-6775 date: 3/14/00 from: Lusia Galav, Senior Planner re: Bradshaw Bed and Breakfast-Additional Information. Please find attached the first review comments for your project. To stay on the current review schedule, please do the following steps listed below, and bring all documents to the TRC scheduled for March 21, 2000. 1. Revise your plans incorporating all comments listed herein, including the addition of notes on plans to confirm response to general statements/ comments, and bring 10 copies to the TRC review meeting (full sets including all pages originally submitted); 2. Submit the additional information as requested within the attached comments; ( i.e. traffic analysis, engineering certification, etc.) 3. Prepare a written response (7 copies) consisting of a list briefly summarizing how each comment has been addressed on the revised plans or with the supplemental information including location on the plans ( this promotes an expeditious 2nd review by staff and your project representatives during the TRC meeting );and 4. Submit reductions (8 Y2 X 11) for the proposed site plans, elevations and landscaping plan (this is required for the final report and public presentation). Planning and Zoning Division City of Boynton Beach Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 742-6260 Fax: 742-6259 I I _~I 1 it The applicant should not attend a TRC (2nd review) until all documents have been revised and copied for staff review. If plans will not be fully revised and brought to the scheduled TRC meeting, contact Lusia Galav in this office by the Thursday prior to the scheduled meeting date. Projects deviating from the original schedule are eligible for review at subsequent meetings, which are held every Tuesday. To reschedule, contact Blythe Williamson, by the Thursday prior to the Tuesday TRC meeting that you desire to attend. The remainder of the review schedule will be adjusted accordingly. If you have questions on the attached comments, please contact the respective reviewer using the attached list of TRC representatives. If the plans are reasonably complete and all significant comments are addressed following TRC (2nd review), the project is forwarded to the Planning and Development Board Meeting that falls approximately 2 to 3 weeks following the TRC meeting. An "*,, by any comment identifies a comment that must be addressed prior to moving forward to the Planning and Development board. Note: Items recognized by staff as typically outstanding at this point include a traffic report and/or confirmation of the traffic concurrency approval from the Palm Beach County drainage certification by a licensed engineer, signed "Rider to Site Plan Application" form and colored elevations ofthe proposed project. This information is necessary for the project to proceed. If you have submitted this information, please disregard this note. Engineering Building Fire Department Police Department Utilities Public Works John Guidry Don Johnson Steve Gale Marshall Gage John Guidry Larry Quinn Barbara Meacham Kevin Hallahan Michael W. Rumpf, CHAIRMAN Parks & Recreation Forester/Environmentalist Planning & Zoning Mike Haag Bob Borden S gt. Mike Lane Pete Mazzella 742-6283 742-63 742-6350 742-63 742-6600 742-63 742-6164 742-61 742-6404 742-62 742-6206 742-62 742-6226 742-60 742-6227 742-60 742-6260 742-62 John Wildner Kevin Hallahan J :\SHRDA T A \Planning\SHARED\ WP\AGENDAS\ TRC\correspondence\ TRC FAX-I st Review.doc _~ UNIVERSITY OF ., lUff) FLORIDA Cooperative Extension Service Institute of FOt.,d and Agrkultut'al Sciences June 16, 2000 Mike Rumpf City of Boynton Beach. . 100 E, Boynton Beach Blvd. Boynton Beach, Fl33435 Dear Mr. Rumpf: I received a call from Barbara Bradshaw, a property owner in Boynton Beach. She is currently trying to establish a Bed & Breakfast on her property. There seems to be some concern over her landscaping. A request was made for someone to explain what a "Certified Florida Yard" means. The University of Florida developed a statewide Florida Yards and Neighborhoods (FYN) program based on landscape maintenance practices which could help reduce stormwater runoff and non-point source pollution dumping into our water bodies. Many counties around the state are participating in the program, including Palm Beach County. There are nine (9) principles to the FYN program including water efficiency, use of native plants and attracting wildlife, Due to our rapid urbanization many of our native habitats have been destroyed reducing the area where birds, butterflies, rabbits and other wildlife inhabit. Once established, native plants require less water. fertilizer and pesticides to remain. vigor04~~ Se..condly, these plants provide native habitat for wildlife in urban areas, Barbara Bradshaw has indicated she has several native trees and shrubs on her property. She also has two pairs of woodpeckers, song birds and a variety of butterflies making use of the natural habitat she is providing. Studies have shown that turfgrass requires one of the highest uses of water, fertilizer and pesticide. therefore, increasing the amount of nitrates and phosphorus going into our waterways. In addition, lawn mower emissions are 50 times greater than that of a new car. The use of trees and shrubs is a preferred method to reduce stormwater runoff and also improve both water and air quality. A Florida certified yard must score a minimum of 36 points from a checklist defining maintenance practices denved from FYN's nine principles. I have enclosed a copy of our brochure, checklist and property owner Questionnaire that must be filled out to even be T~\. :~'~.~1\\\~~ ai ~":,_.,o:.1 ,HH,f AA.tk\lH~i.d ~-<;enf,:l~ lS S1~ ~.A.l\.h11 Ijmp[O.Yl11\:nt O?;)Ortu~\:)' '. Affit'1]""',,'ivt- .!\('Uon ~l,:..pll'Yl!'r ~uthori;.~cd I(t prc:vi.;h: rt.~t~lIf("h. c..:1:..;,;~"Iti(':!/" lnfl~rm.Atlt)!t i\nd flth":r y.uTV,l'ltS 01)\y tC) indivic.hM1... .no\.1 ifl.s.::tntlons. that n.~~""ClHm ....''In'.vet t('AtI,rcJ ft' r'Ic.:~1 colOt. ~~.. "~C. l'1..lj':d~t.;!n ''"'1'11"_\.'""')1,......"..:,, CC)()PERATIVJ3 EX-n;1\:~'~)N ":'~)1:'l.~~~C'-"~'~.'...::-:::~:-'...."~ .. '.... . _. FROM: FAX 'iO. Ju~. 19 200a 10:00AM P2 Page 2 June 16, 2000 considered for a certification. The FYN program is also partnered with the Department of Environmental Protection to help the community fulfill requirements for the NPDES MS4 permits. Please see enclosed letter. We have aCknowledged that Barbara Bradshaw is practicing sound landscape management practices and is doing her part to protect Florida's natural resources. If I can be of further assistance or you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call . me at 561-233-1748. Sincerely, /J' ~ L WtCiy /'VI ~ aJ:t Carolyn 5 aft, Extension Agent PBC Cooperative Extension Service Florida Yards and Neighborhoods 531 N. Military Trail West Palm Beach, FL 33415 CSIII ends. cc: Barbara Bradshaw ,. ',,- DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning and Zoning Buitding Planning & Zoning Engineering Occupational License Community Redevelopment June 23, 2000 Barbara Bradshaw 658 Manor Drive Boynton Beach, FL 33435 Dear Ms. Bradshaw, As per your earlier conversation with staff and my discussion with Peter Schmidt earlier today regarding the status of your project, please be advised that the approval of your request for a conversion of the nine existing rental units on the property at 658 Manor Drive into a bed and breakfast establishment is contingent upon the full compliance with current regulations, in particular regulations pertaining directly to such establishments as contained in Chapter 2, Section 16 of the Code. Section 16, p. g(l) states that "there shall be no cooking facilities or food storage in any rental room/unit". This provision reflects the generally accepted character of bed and breakfast accommodations in the U.S and elsewhere. Exempt from this provision in the code are one- room cottages with existing kitchenettes. Your property includes one such one-room cottage; however, the remaining buildings do not come under the definition of a "one-room cottage" and thus the presence of kitchen facilities in units contained in these buildings is not consistent with the current regulations. Please note that the language of the selected sections of the Ordinance 098-42, which provided for the establishment and related regulations for bed and breakfast establishments, was altered for the fmal reading and passage of this Ordinance on December 1, 1989. In particular, at first reading of the Ordinance, Section 10 read:" Conversion of small cottages with optional kitchenette would be considered applicable to the intent of this Ordinance". Although the Code does not provide a definition of a cottage, this language would have accommodated your circumstances and such was an initial intent of this provision. I believe the language was altered in response to concerns about the ambiguity of the term" cottage", and thus "one- room" was added for an additional clarification. No one, including you or your representative, made any comments on this Ordinance at the public hearing for the final reading and passage on December 1. Unfortunately, as altered, a term "one-room cottage" cannot possibly be applied to the two buildings proposed for the conversion. America's Gateway to tlte Gulfstream 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd.. P.O. Box 310 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 Phone: (561) 742-6260 FAX: (561) 742-6259 .. Since, under your circumstances, bringing the property to compliance with the Code may be cost-prohibitive, you may prefer to apply for the modification of the regulations, which, if approved, could possibly reinstate the original intent of the said section 10. Please contact me at 742-6260 if you have any questions. Sincerely, ~<::.- Michael W. Rumpf Director of Planning and Zoning America's Gateway to tile Gulfstream 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd., P.O. Box 310 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 Phone: (561) 742-6260 FAX: (561) 742-6259 Department of Engineering and Public Works P.O. Box 21229 West Palm Beach. FL 33416-1229 (561) 684-4000 www.co.palm-beach.f1.us . Palm Beach County Board of County Commissioners Maude Ford Lee. Chair Warren H. Newell. Vice Chairman Karen T. Marcus Carol A. Roberts Mary McCarty Burt Aaronson Tony Masilotti County Administrator Robert Weisman "An Equal Opportunity AflirmJJtivI! Action Employ,.,." @ printed on recyr;Jed fJIIP<< li::~~-~-::;'~ , 'J/ n j' : ;,.~J J.r ~' 1 . 7~1 J ~-..... FEa J.5 2000 January 4, 2000 Mrs. Hanna Matras City of Boynton Beach Planning and Zoning Department 100 East Boynton Beach P.O. Box 310 Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310 RE: 658 Manor Drive - Bed and Breakfast Traffic Performance Standards Review Mrs. Matras: The Palm Beach County Traffic Division has reviewed the traffic letter (dated December 15, 1999) for the project entitled 658 Manor Drive - Bed and Breakfast pursuant to the Traffic Performance Standards in Article 15 of the Palm Beach County Land Development Code. The project is summarized as follows: Location: Manor Drive, east of Federal Highway Municipality: Boynton Beach Existing Use: Residential - SF Attached Proposed Use: Bed and Breakfast New Trips: 0 trips per day Buildout: 2000 This project is a modi{u:ation of existing facilities. (7 du) (5 du) Based on our review the Traffic Division has determined that the project meets the Traffic Performance Standards of Palm Beach County. Please contact me if you have any questions regarding this review. Sincerely, OFFICE OF THE COUNTY ENGINEER cc: Peter Schmidt" Schmidt & Pheterson Flle: General- TPS - Mun ' Traffic Study Review F:'\TRAFFIC'\apf\tps'\99178app.wpd. TAZ ljO;) - " -""11'", II ",,\\\\"~ " p EXHIBIT "E" Conditions of Approval Project name: 658 Manor Drive (Barbara Bradshaw) File number: ZNCY 98-003 (rear and side setback) Reference' Zoning Code Variance application dated Februar'\' '"15 1998 - . I DEPARTME!':TS INCLUDE \ REJECT I PUBLIC WORKS Comments: None X i I L'TILITIES Comments: None X FIRE I Comments: ~one X . I I i I POLICE I Comments: None X I ENGThrEERING DI\lSION Comments: None X I BUlLDING DI\-lSION Comments: I 1. All units shall meet all building related codes and regulations. X I PARKS A..llID RECREA nON Comments: None X FORE S TER/E1'-.rvIRONMENT ALIST Comments: None X PLANNING A.~ ZONING I Comments: None X ADDITIONAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPr-vlENT BOARD CONDITIONS I 2. None. X I ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS 3. Te Be aetefB\iee9. ~NI" V I !bmeJ ISHIU>A T A\PLA."lNING\SHAAED\WPlJ'ROJECTSIiiSI MANOR. Oil . B.BIlAOSHA W\ZlIIC\' 91-.JOJICONO Of .-.!'PIlOV Al..qc.ooJ.OOC .' . . r DEVELP. - 'C:NT ORDER OF THE CITY CO.----'ION - . -. TV OF BOYNTON BEACH, F.... .J~.JA I n PROJECT NAME: 658 Manor Drive (Barbara Bradshaw) \ APPLICANrS AGENT: Peter H. Schmidt I ! APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 400 South Dixie Highway. Suite 420, Boca Raton: DATE OF CITY COMMISSION RATIFICATION: June 2,1998 Jw. ~::rn 00\ L \ PLANNING AND ZONING DEPT. TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Zoning Code Variance (minimum dwelling size - apartments) LOCATJON OF PROPERTY: 658 Manor Drive DRAWlNG(S): SEe EXHIBIT 'B' ATTACHED HERETO. X THIS MA TIER came before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida appearing on the Consent Agenda on the date above. The City Commission hereby adopts the findings and recommendation of the Planning and Development Board, which Board found as follows: OR THIS MA TIER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach. Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant. members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: 1. Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applicant .lL HAS _ HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence ~ basis for the relief requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant. administrative staff, or suggested by the publiC and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit 'C' with notation "ncluded'". 4. Thr Applicant's application for relief is hereby K- GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof. _ DENIED 5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order. DATED: ~--,~ ~ /998 V J:'oSHRDATA: ~\,\\' ,n 1111 11111111. ..~'''',_ ~o y IV.,. ~.I~ :">.' .... 0 ~ ~ e: ..~,.,,.... 1- ~ :s... ..- \.) J~ '-. ~ *'" .... " ....?':: :- ,.. . ~ ~.... \" ~ -- i 0: );0 = ...... .. .0 . S \ 1 r~2?J/. ~ ~ ~ ~I~ ~ ~.~ ~ ~r~~~~~"" ~ ~ ...... ~ City Clerk ".I~ FtlD ~ ~~ u.nor Dr.8.~ II-004'DEVELOPMORDER. .,"\\\\~ .~~ ..- .... 7. Other -! . . EXHIBIT "G" CQnditions of ^ooroval Project name: 658 Manor Drive (Barbara Bradshaw) File number: ZNCV 98-004 (dwelling size) Reference" Zonin2 Code Variance amzlication dated February 2S 1998 . . " DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT PUBLIC WORKS Comments: None X UTILITIES Comments: None X FIRE Comments: None X POLICE Comments: None X ENGINEERING DMSION Comments: None X Bun..DING DMSION Comments: 1. All additional building requirements are met through permitting in the X city' 5 Building Division. PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: None X FORESTER/ENVIRONMENTALIST Comments: None X PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: None X ADDITIONAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS ~" None. X ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS 3. .Xe h del-..IU~~ ~ V /bnie J:\II'4RD4TAIPI.N'.IG\IW~ ~ IIWIOR OR. .......WWZNCVINlMlCGND. Of- NlfIIIlQVAL..-.olM.DOC I "u-1CJ-1m 11112_ 99-111S8S -QRB 10'9'96pg 427 THY H. "lUtEN, a.ERK PI CCUITY Fl 1~..I.......I.I...I.l. . . . r" If prepared~Y: icholas I. Igwe, Assistant City Attorney City of Boynton Beach P.O. Box 310 Boynton Beach, FL 33425 CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH BUILDING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT & APPEALS ORDER GRANTING RELIEF INRE: 6SR Manor Drive, Boynton Beach, Florida Peter H. Schmidt, Esq., agent for Barbara Bradshaw The Appellant, appeared before the Building Board of Adjustment & Appeals on February 11, 1999 and requ~sted Relief from Section 2001.2.1, Standard Building Code, 1991 Edition, which requires that habitable rooms have ceiling heights of not less. than 7 feet 6 inches. Based on the testimony of Peter H. Schmidt, and the evidence presented, the Board finds that a basis for relief has been established. Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED THAT: The request for Relief from Section 2001.2.1, Standard Building Code, 1991 Edition, which requires that habitable rooms have ceiling heights of not less than 7 feet 6 inches is hereby granted, subject to the following conditions: 1. Relief for Units #6 and #7 be granted provided that no electrical fans shall be allowed in the ceiling, and that this document be recorded for any future reference. &~~~ C airman DATED: ~t::)/P? ATTEST: ~~u Ci lerk ".\\\\\\1111111//11 ~".... TOll/. BBA&A -..# dJ}hG...:V !}.~;.. 3/4/99 ~ 4..*..~~OFl..:..~.::......"'9. ~.:. :: 0 . 0 ~', .:'1 -;.. .:: lCJ .~ ~ ~ = > :2 : = =:- : = : ':. \ .."." i : ... ,,' ,....... .. , . ..... :..-U. ,~._.. ...... ~ -.. ;j ...,. .... ;:: ~ .... ..' - ~ ~ ......... '() 1'- .;::. ~{f1'1. FLO~\ ~,#" 11/111"")\\\\\\,.... "'ITY C ': :10 -niT:~ BEACH v I - - ,..--\Cr" ""\ T ....1 :~ 1 =.........! ~ ' -:::; ,'" r ,.. l." J . v". ..- i. ...", ...1 - 00 U'R 2' PH 2: 48 J.I riM \ \) 1 ., '. . >~.~'~'" ":, ,~.. '~.J' 1"._. . .- _ i" >. ORDINANCE NO. 0 00- AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2 - ZONING, OF THE BOYNTON BEACH LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS, SECfION 16, BED AND BREAKFAST, BY AMENDING SUBSECfIONS AS FOLLOWS: B. REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS, PROVIDING FOR CLARIFICATION OF DEFINmONS AND AN AMENDMENT TO USE RESTRICTIONS; PROVIDING FOR CON FUCfS, SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION AND AN EFFECfIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida, adopted Ordinance 098-42, which provided for the establishment of bed and breakfast establishments; and WHEREAS, it has been determined that this Section should be amended to clarify definitions as well as to amend certain use restrictions; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA, THAT: Section 1. That Chapter 2, Section 16, Bed and Breakfast, Subsection B. 1. Regulations and Standards, is hereby amended by adding the words and figures in underlined type and by deleting the words and figures in struck-through type, as follows: 1. "Bed and breakfast establishment" shall be defined as follows: A private owner occupied residence having more than three and less than ten guest bedroom units. The bed and breakfast establishment is subordinate and incidental to the main residential use of the building. Section 2. That Chapter 2, Section 16, Bed and Breakfast, Subsection B. 2. Regulations and Standards is hereby amended by adding the words and figures in underlined type and by deleting the words and figures in struck-through type, as follows: 2. In addition to the requirements of the underlying zoning district, all other applicable general regulations, parking regulations, special conditions imposed through the conditional use process, and local, state and federal building codes, the following requirements shall apply to bed and breakfast establishments; a. Each application to the Department of Development shall be accompanied by: (1.) A detailed site plan illustrating the location of all structures and improvements, parking, buffering, landscaping the location of guest rooms/units and guest parking spaces and signs shall be submitted for conditional use approval by the City. (2.) Floor plans drawn to scale of the d'Nelling unit showing each of the bed ;:md breal<fust guest units to be designated and the access to, and egress from, each such unit. All walls separating bed und brcal<fust guest units in a structure shall be fireguarded to the two hour time limit. d. Parking: Required parking spaces shall be calculated on the basis of one space per each employee, manager or owner and one parking space for each guest room/unit. Newly created parking may be located only in the rear and side yard. g. Restrictions on use and employees: (1) Except as hereinafter provided, there shall be no cooking facilities or food storage in any guest unit. Breakfast shall be the only meal provided for paying overnight guests. rentul room/unit. ~~euls shull be served by the ~~unuger und/or O'v'mer only to the ~~unuger undfor owner, und nonpu'fing bonufide guests of the munuger und/or O'vvner. Brcul<fust shull be se~ed by the ~~unuger und/or owner und shull be the only mCul provided for puying guests who ure using the fucility overnight und their guests. The breakfast meal shall not be served after 11:00 A.M. (2) The maximum stay for each individual who is using the facility shall be 14 consecutive days and not more than 14 days during any 45 9G day period. The owner and/or manager shall maintain a guest book, which accurately identifies all customers for each night's lodging. This register of guests shall be available to City Inspectors during reasonable business hours. Checl< in und checl< out shull tul<e pluce between 8:00 u.m. und 8:00 p.m. eRfy-; j. One room cottuges with existing I<itchenettes 'Nould be considered .....ithin the scope of this section und will not be rcquired to remove the I(itchenettes. Existing kitchenettes within one or more guest units of a Bed and Breakfast Establishment are considered within the scope of this section and will not have to be removed. Section 4. All other provisions of Chapter 2 - Zoning, Section 16. of the Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations, not herein specifically amended shall remain in full force and effect, as previously enacted. Section 5. All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith be and the same are hereby repealed. Section 6. Should any section or provIsion of this ordinance or portion hereof, any paragraph, sentence or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the remainder of this ordinance. Section 7. Authority is hereby granted to codify said ordinance. Section 8. This ordinance shall become effective immediately upon passage. FIRST READING this _ day of , 2000. SECOND, FINAL READING AND PASSAGE this , 2000. day of CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Mayor Vice Mayor Mayor Pro Tern ATTEST: Commissioner City Clerk Commissioner S:ca\ord\bed\breakfast - Rev082200 JUN-02-2000 09:17 AM ~RECISSICN DRAFTING ,...... -.. 561~655141 ?, 01 ,/ P~CI5\ON 1?r<H'flNu & ~CHI-reC~ i~"":;':;' ~_.''f:;:;:(ilt:i---"..:-"~-".j IZO MAYf AII1l.>>.f W/NfON ~!OI. 1'\..0l11l?^ '~6:2 PhtJW M. pN.~.ue}Qt{ %\) %~'1~10 ~. ,/Il.M ~1D1 (~) Z18-~ 10 M A1'1rNllON cr~ . .l- v:>t.., (.>.. "Are: U JZIDu fWM: 'vb.,,.l\,D. f~~\G- 1'tT\.t ~, ~ PillS: \,. CO~Nf5 ?- ~QV\ ~ S"\~(..... rv\ \~ \~ ,\ rJ [- . ~o:rL :..~U~\~ (p-(\.. ZVJo .__... _~ J,,,i. t.::~" L~o-v-JI ---- I: \ " I' 'i & /2,/ ()V '1 I , ----~._-~----~---- 03/16.00 THU 16:39 FA! 15613946775 SCH~IDT-PHETERSO ~OOl L-. FAX TRANSM SSION LAW OFFICES i SCHMIDT & PHETERSON 400 South Dixie Highway, Suite 420 Boca RElton. Florida 33432 (561) 394-2700; (954) 428-0433 Fax:(561)394~775 To: Lusia Galav, Senior Planner Date: March 16, 2000 '1'. 40 p.~' Fu#: (561) 742-6259 Pales: ....L..' including this cover sheet. From: PETER H. SCHMIDT Subject: Barbara R. Bradshaw Bed & Breakfast-Conditional Use Application 0' , 4' J"} - ~'J~~~\p( 00 h {yr 'v -<'~ ~ ~y "\,,,"'\.lY" ~/\1 /' oJ..-~J- v)~\~\c;.~. .'-2~ ___ (: \~~f~~ ~)~ . -'0" vi ~>>6 ~)<17 COMMENTS: The information in this facsimile is confidential and also may be attorney-privileged. The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, the employee, or the agent responsible for delivering this facsimile to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, distribution. or copying of this facsimile is strictly prohibited. If you received the facsimile in error, please immediately notify us by a collect telephone call to (561) 394-2700. and return the original facsimile to us at the above address, via U.S. mail. Thank you. 03116,00 THlT 16: 40 FAX 15613946775 SCHMIDT-PHETERSO ~002 LAW o"r'CES SCHMIDT & ~HETEA50N peTER M. ac"MIOT I. Jt"R~ "H~TE:ASON <tQO SOUTH DiXlr: HIGH.......f THE _BOil . $IJIT~ 420 Boe... RATON, FLoRia... 334.3Z-6024 "CLCCO..lltlt 1$511384-877$ na.CPHc:I"IE: 'Mil 3li14. il7ClO .ROWAA~(854142B~33 March 16, 2000 PACSIXILB TRANSMiSS~ON (S(1) 742-6259 Lusia Galav, Senior Planner Planning and Zoning Division City of Boynton Beach Post Office Box 310 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 Re; Barbara R. Bradshaw Bed & Breakfast-Condieional Use Application Dear Ms. Galav: As a follow up to the facsimile transmittals from your office of March 13, 2000 and March 14, 2000, this letter will serve as notice to you that my client, Barbara R. Bradshaw, will not be able to meet today's deadline as set forth in your March 14, 2000 co~munication. The extremely short notice provided by your office simply does not provide a sufficient time frame within which to complete all of the additional requirements emanating from the first review of the Conditional Use Application by t.he various members of your Technical Review Committee. As soon as the applicable requests have been complied with, I will contact your office. In the interim, if you have any additional questions or comments relative to this matter, please let me know. PHS/csw Original: Regular Mail LAW OFFICES SCHMIDT & PHETERSON PETER H. SCHMIOT I. .JEFFREY PHETERSON 400 SOUTH DIXIE HIGHWAY THE ARBOR. SUITE 420 BOCA RATON, FLORIDA 33432-6024 TELECOPIER (560 394-6775 TELEPHONE (561) 394-2700 BROWARO (954) 428-0433 March 16, 2000 FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION (561) 742-6259 Lusia Galav, Senior Planner Planning and Zoning Division City of Boynton Beach Post Office Box 310 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 Re: Barbara R. Bradshaw Bed & Breakfast-Conditional Use Application Dear Ms. Galav: As a follow up to the facsimile transmittals from your office of March 13, 2000 and March 14, 2000, this letter will serve as notice to you that my client, Barbara R. Bradshaw, will not be able to meet today's deadline as set forth in your March 14, 2000 communication. The extremely short notice provided by your office simply does not provide a sufficient time frame within which to complete all of the additional requirements emanating from the first review of the Conditional Use Application by the various members of your Technical Review Committee. As soon as the applicable requests have been complied with, I will contact your office. In the interim, if you have any additional questions or comments relative to this matter, please let me know. Very truly yours, PHS/csw Original: Regular Mail Ii f o:-~... ,~_._~__~ _ "_ 03/16/00 Tar 1%:16 FAX 1561~~467i5 01l11!;/~ftO 1'3:06 561:--- '3 SCHMIDT-PBETERSO BO\'NTa-l IEAQi -~ ~a02 PAGE 01 Facsimile TAANSNIITTAL OTY Of BOYNTON BEACH 100 E~ BOYNTON lEACH BOULEVARD P.o. lOX 310 BOYNTON IMCH, FLORIDA 33425-0'10 FAX: (J61) 142-6259 PLI\Nt-lINl ~,ND zoWNG EPT. -------- PLANNIN'G AND ZONING DMSION ...: f~ #. .,t"ch~4U:. Fe. .14 - W'- t811-~ ~-~ ~. __~-;c;~ ~ tol fix#: dIU: from : - 5'wt ~.2~~~2- I I ." I !.indU;;::;;:_.~ -r:J~~ ~ ~", ~Q~~~ Qu.~ jC;::~ L ,.... ~ ~..t ..,.,... I!b~ jJte#Ifitk ~...l~ ~. :;;d- cJ.o I~ ~ ~ -- ~1D!f /Jrf11iJ JsA- ')..DOo. ,74" / h I a.Nd. ~~. r.h~ [,.eLl ~ .,q, r- . (J I ,..; atd zo,*" OIvlslon City ~8o}'rrron &O<<h 5<<:ldI. Ficrf4tt: 33425 744-b~O FrJ-x:. 7-fo2-62S9 SCHHIDT-PHETERSO EIOVNTctl I:1EAOi -- ~ f:!l ;~ ~ 'I' II ~, I - '" r ~ -' I . ~ j . - I "', T '~v oj.. 0 I) ~~ ~ . BQY/yTON. l.A.tJ , I. ' i .n. .:Q.; ~ . .......-' ,~.~ _ 'tL!. ; _ -'::!L.ll tot T ;:;,. ~ o"--~ ~ WlF ~,.. ~ "~I-; 1&1\11 - J.:J..)I{;I~" j ,fyl ~. -..::: j;;;."" ;~.. . 49.1 .1: ~:; 1-.. l ~ ~ :l ... f4 . 5 I--.!a 7 ~" - l' as ~~ · ,~",- -..; .~..: - . "~4 ' .Ji. . 16 I i7 '"i8 ""'9 "20 . I... ~... "..~ .r-::... .;ED"' ~ ~\~,~ ~ W I lP :.. 01 '-~ / ~~"~.. ~: --;.. il'-.rj 2lt~1 n:~.o ~ ." ~ ~ ~32.~ ~3v ~ :}4 . ~ ~;7) . _.. :' '-U~ ~ .~ '. v~ V." ..... ....h ~ ~ '1!1. .....- ~I.. _""If r ~~'; ... .. .1!t'l~ . I.'''' UMI'fV/ to' . L 'L 1 '! l t. .. IJ '. ta IS I:.... - ~t . .~,.,. '"'_'6 -= ."D . "f' "' ": .' ""' r;~ ~ I ; . ~'::..~ ,~:/ · ;';::,..,;,;' -. ~ . , ,. > ;:m ~ .'.. , I> .. ',' - I .,'..",. - r ~" .~A~~~~i~'~i;;~~;1 ~~~ l~7~ I ~!_ -:-v M ~j~~~", f" ,:,,,W: ~"... ,J ~~ I~~~ :l~-tI . .,. ~ !I . .1;-;J..'jo~ t'" . " ~.: rIf'7, ~J. ....1 .. lll. 'Jv-,~. 1I'..hl i - i ; ; .. I ~;.... .. r'J~'-i'" -:!..Ii ~.~l,'!. ' ..~~~ J :...,'."1 L' ".... . · J' ,~I--:f.': ,~ .~ .'J!I" ~~~ ~ -'.", _ t: .,": .~: , ~ ~~' V'~iI y~~' ~,;: ~ ;" ~ ~.'~ ~~ ~:~ ~. 11\ 'S "~.~ ~~~, J..~ "iT v ~tI rI E';' V' ff. '.,L' r:r-..z >-- 2--- I! , 17 ~ 15 ~ j,J 2.u. ti:~ ~ ~. I: .... :.. J 8:L. S ;~ I~ ~~ ~ J,/ V ~~;:&i ~~~ W. 11 of ~. . +- .. ~ ,..~~HIG~ - ,.-.. JiE: IO~ AVEr .;,. ~ ~:f ru '!:y ~~..' ; --:-!'l!-~ ~- ,V 1.-:1 "'''..< '9'"" :J.~'~..~ . !r ? -. ,:t- rr J.. iJ X'~. ~, ;I'~ 1t..L1. ~ li.. .J.a. JQ! ~ ~ ~ ~ 4..l I ,,1' ... - '- ~J:l ' ~... :~ Il -. .0.:: /:..,,~''l I. . .4', ~ r ,.... I -L'; -~~rJ ' t. .. . '... r i J~-t~ ~ Zl. .~. :..0 ~ ':!~~ ~ ~~Z :is ~ ml ~ 1Z. ~ 46l :!J ~ . J .:~ I ,~ ...". . ~,~ ...: ;.. ~.:l ._'... .., 3JJ _' .1'" .:EIIL ... _ I -t':' TtlNE~ NE ~" t Ii'. -~ ... y- '.. , ... ... ~~ iJ,;,,, iJ.l ~ l! j'!'J l.il ~ -!~ l.:!... it.). ,JJ '.'!. _ ; i A j . i- 'iaMM f i. ~_ ~__....,._. J'2.J!l:'J~[20""lI" '2" I"" ,',_ rO.,_ '~"-'-.:'"J~~... 1';J-_...~1>-- _....... J'::I~_ -- I 03r16/00 THr 12:17 FAX 1561~~46775 e~/16/2eeD lZ:OG 561?-' , :11.~ ,7 "' fJ I : ~ f~ ~ PACE II OO~ 82 ..... - 0 ~ ~l "'''(1 ...,. - , ~ I , J \1.~ 'r'~' "'t, 'F} '\ . r-. · " ~ . ~ S ... ..J a: <.r "" :J l,) I&.l , IJJ 1 ,0 \(l I Z r 0.. .' ~ I f \ 41. U~-\ i 1 ~ n 1" -f ' \ I I' -:_, L~.'.._lp.'. I, ,_. j~J P.B.C.P.A. - NAL' EM PARCEL - CY 08 RG 43 '.....F 45 ASSN: TYPE NAME CUNNINGHAM T J ADR1 1897 PALM BEACH LKS BLVD # 201 ADR2 WEST PALM BEACH FL ADR3 SALE DATE 0984 PRICE 200000 LEGAL LAKE ADD TO BOYNTON LTS 6 & 7 & LT 8 (LESS N 50 FT OF W 29.10 FT & S 75 FT OF W 29.9 FT AS IN OR2200P1356) BLK 2 MARCH 23, 19 12:17:24 HOURS SEC 22 SUB 32 BLK vv~ LOT 0060 YEAR (C/L) L YEAR ADDED 99 DCC DATE MAINT 02/04/99 DCC DATE MAINT 00/00/00 DATE MAINT 00/00/00 DATE MAINT 00/00/00 ZIP 334093508 HOMESTEAD RECEIPT # 0000000 BOOK 4358 PAGE 1940 TYP V INST WD QUAL U NCOA: ECN HST: CMC 98 PUC 003 HOME 0 ASSDVAL 0 LANDMKT 0 SOHVAL 0 NAV FCTR MESSAGE MMC 00 NAV EXC 00 %EXC 0.0 TFR THP 00 T-CONDO CCD 07 OTH NAV OWN 0 MTG WIDOW 0 DISAB 0 OTHER 0 SYSTVAL 205507 LANDVAL 85000 CONSVAL 0 NLAND 0 OVERRIDE N SOH YEAR 0000 0.00 PRT(F10) ADD (F13) CHG(F15) - LAST YEAR EXEMPTIONS AND VALUES INFO NACRES 0.33 CTFNO 00 - ENERGY 0 BLDGVAL 120507 EAA EAA ACRES 0.00 % USE 0.0 SOH ADJ YEAR 0000 INQ(F22) DEL (F8) MENU (F24) :#-z-- P.B.C.P.A. - NAL EM MARCH 23, IS' 12:19:21 HOURS PARCEL - CY 08 RG 43 .....,P 45 SEC 21 SUB 32 BLK v03 LOT 0180 YEAR (C/L) L ASSN: YEAR ADDED 80 TYPE DATE MAINT 01/27/94 COLL NCOA: NAME VICTOR MIDROY DATE MAINT 05/15/91 COLL ADR1 13633 87TH ST N DATE MAINT 10/02/87 DATA ECN HST: ADR2 ROYAL PALM BEACH FL DATE MAINT 12/15/83 AUTO ADR3 ZIP 334122604 HOMESTEAD RECEIPT # 0000000 SALE DATE 0887 PRICE 18000 BOOK 5415 PAGE 1860 TYP V INST WD QUAL U LEGAL LAKE ADD TO BOYNTON LOTS 18 & 19 BLK 3 CMC 98 PUC 000 HOME 0 ASSDVAL 0 LANDMKT 0 SOHVAL 0 NAV FCTR MESSAGE MMC 00 NAV EXC 00 %EXC 0.0 TFR THP 00 T-CONDO CCD 07 OTH NAV OWN 0 MTG WIDOW 0 DISAB 0 OTHER 0 SYSTVAL 20800 LANDVAL 32100 CONSVAL 0 NLAND 0 OVERRIDE N SOH YEAR 0000 0.00 PRT(F10) ADD (F13) CHG(F15) - LAST YEAR EXEMPTIONS AND VALUES INFO NACRES 0.00 CTFNO 00 - ENERGY 0 BLDGVAL 0 EAA EAA ACRES 0.00 % USE 0.0 SOH ADJ YEAR 0000 INQ(F22) DEL (F8) MENU (F24) 1J~ 3 P.B.C.P.A. - NAL' EM PARCEL - CY 08 RG 43 '.&..~P 45 ASSN: TYPE NAME LE BLANC DENISE Y ADR1 660 MANOR DR ADR2 BOYNTON BEACH FL ADR3 ZIP SALE DATE 0894 PRICE 100 BOOK LEGAL 22-45-43, NLY 75 FT OF S 370 FT OF ELY 80 FT OF W 875.57 FT OF GOV LT 3 & S 24 FT OF E 46.56 FT OF LT 20 & S 24 FT OF W 33.44 FT OF LT 21 OF PLAT OF WILMS WAY MARCH 23, 19 12:16:50 HOURS SEC 22 SUB 00 BLK v~3 LOT 0050 YEAR (C/L) L YEAR ADDED 80 DATE MAINT 09/27/94 DEED DATE MAINT 03/28/91 APPL DATE MAINT 05/17/89 LOAD DATE MAINT 04/25/89 DATA 334353236 HOMESTEAD RECEIPT # 0174768 8403 PAGE 78 TYP I INST QC QUAL D NCOA: ECN HST: CMC 98 MMC 00 NAV EXC HX %EXC 0.0 TFR THP PUC 001 00 T-CONDO CCD 04 OTH NAV OWN 0 MTG HOME 25000 WIDOW 0 DISAB 0 OTHER 0 ASSDVAL 55119 SYSTVAL 74838 LANDVAL 12000 LANDMKT 0 CONSVAL 0 NLAND 0 SOHVAL 55119 OVERRIDE N SOH YEAR 1994 NAV FCTR 0.00 PRT(F10) ADD (F13) CHG(F15) MESSAGE - LAST YEAR EXEMPTIONS AND VALUES INFO Y ACRES 0.00 G24 CTFNO 00 - ENERGY 0 BLDGVAL 62838 EAA EAA ACRES 0.00 % USE 0.0 SOH ADJ YEAR 1997 INQ{F22) DEL (F8) MENU (F24) -it/ HAR-24-2000 II :54 AM j~ECISSICN DRAFTING 561 9.6.551 41 ?, 01 r.l-:(iM~ ..:.., r)""VIl:> F ~~\\... PRE:C/510N t/RAfflNcA & II .. I/O IVtAYf}JR L.ANE ~OYN1'ON BEACH, f'j,oll': N. rJN-M ~A[H ( 761) q6?- ~.;. Pf.!..M ~N.H (~6i) 7.Nj.. ~'> ';'c /\;'r..\!"~{Jf\J:::1'" 1.-0 S<..-I.~ V:i ;::./; ,: A';[~' . :.:o.~l.Jvr:;,r.c:. . t> ~ F;A.,S }S (A.l-~CE L- I,t. ~ f'\ If "r:T I N ty- 1!'o.<.. o.&~ E.~~ p~e..'b ~H~w ('61: i)... B~r.A.."F~~ .Sc HfWLJi t=> r.L)~ 1tJii\'),b-)' .NV\t:....'1 26, ;Z.~~)c:J. Wa::. ~LLL- tkL In ~~Hf1>i.h_E. Facsimile TRANSMIIT AL CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH 100 E. BOYNTON BEACH BOULEVARD P.O. BOX 310 BOYNTON BEACH, FLORI DA 33425-0310 FAX: (561) 742-6259 PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION re: f1 RL~'4ec,~1G er:;-0J- 9&5'- 5/lf} Of - /4- DO ~U,\.tA )]aLa v J ~5hC<,u ~+-8 to: fax #: date: from: pages: ~, including cover sheet. PaV:d ;(mzL~d ~ 1L-3. ~ Lon~ ~;'0 ll~fh l):1L~ ~c1tAJ1J ' ;4- CO/"'-j 0-- Yu- -zor.u'c.; YAC-jO s'hOL0'~ ~ J.ocvhd. &;-- ~ VU;0~ o.k~J.ccJ. ~O;;J?29n~~1-C::: 9~~7:;;~o~ n?~ . 41$0 ,zjjdchcJ (5 Ct.- PJ1;4- OJ- 7v~ {lUIv:Jt...,.<...1 rr...M tr ~ ~i-~ 'Yvf o/l.-i/J1 2lc ~ . Planning and Zoning Division City of Boynton Beach Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 742-6260 Fax: 742-6259 ~ ...300 -I' j-- ; - ~ \ . , '~~=.~ -~ l \' n- _. ! :. , ~l : \ !,~.' -.:-=:::.-.. ,\ \ \ ,,\ \ ~'f::::'::: I ~\ ~, .J./~ --=::~'''.. )\ . \ \1,1 r, t I ."\ I, _-' __.__-- ----:-~~. . ~ ~~.' L--- . __...L' t....-'-~J.-__L...-.. ~ . .-L- .... .-r- -..:..:'r- ...:...~ ........-T_--.-~- . , ~r-' ----. l"\l Jl~ -H- ~ l~ . (' '\ "'0) \l'1 t ;~-,\,.\f~.~,~.,; ~ ./~ '--~." _,~. --- ____..-------., .' _....\~l.;~ J, ;'. ,.t ..\.. \ n I, ~. ~ " · ~. r-----' ~~. , \ I ,. ,'_- \ \r:--- '\ '\ \f~=::::3:=}-: --...\ ......,~ ~ \ '. ~. \ \~ '. '; ';t', 1 \ I \ 'L i,.. \. \~; ~ .' \ \, .~....~ .- ,'ll, It i. -' ,. \ \ . J'~ S '\"'-' -~ rr.',:' ~. '..... "tt ' \ ~ . :\.'. \~'. \', i : \\. \ '~\r _-:Y \ lle. _.,~' \ \ . ; ~ j. '. . '. -1 \ r,. J .. \ \' \ ,t '\ ), I '\ , ~. i : , .~ r ~\ \ \ '.. . . . . .. 1 ' I '. 't .. ~ '~\ t ., ~ ,----7. ~------ ~ \ \ '\ Y I L \ \ l ;, ',t \., I" Th1\. \ . )\\ .s;;::: .,..c- . ,..::.-1 L.-J, , \ ~ , l \ r-. _ \ ' L ~ ..J.l...--4 ' : ~.... ~ L -'~ .'. - ,-- .\1 n f\ , \ \ ..., ..-!