Loading...
TRAFFIC STUDY REV 8/27/1997 LAWRENCE AND HYPOLUXO COMMERCIAL CENTER TRAFFIC STUDY PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA Kenneth J. Cox, P.E. Florida Registration No. 46572 Robert Campbell, P.E. Florida Registration No. 26732 Carnahan-Proctor & Associates, Inc. 6191 West Atlantic Boulevard Margate, Florida 33063 (305) 972-3959 FAX (305) 972-4178 August 29, 1995 Rev. August 27, 1997 (Note: August, 1997 Revision Limited to Responding to City Comment about Driveway Volume) !fO) rn @ rn u w m 00 1 f"l' .., I JlJ SEP 31991 ~ PLANNING fINO lONiNG DEPI TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION STUDY OBJECTIVE TRANSPORTATION ANALYSIS Project Trip Generation Study Area Existing Conditions Future Roadway Improvements Development Access Background Traffic Project Traffic Distribution & Assignment Future Traffic Level of Service Analysis Test I . Link/Buildout Test Alternative Test I Test 2 . Model test CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS Page I I 3 3 3 5 5 5 5 10 10 14 14 14, 15 & 16 16&17 17 INTRODUCTION DeSanti & Associates retained Carnahan-Proctor & Associates, Inc. to evaluate the traffic impact associated with the proposed Lawrence and Hypoluxo Commercial Center. The Development Site is about 8.3 acres and located in the southeast quadrant of the Lawrence Road and Hypoluxo Road intersection. Figure 1 depicts the general location of the site. This was the former location of the Living Color Nursery Retail and wholesale garden center until December of 1989. The proposed site modifications consist of the followings type and gross floor area of building space: . 18,500 Square Feet (S.F.) of general retail . 3,800 S.P. of bank with drive-through . 7,200 S.F. of fast food restaurant with drive-through Site access will be by driveway connections with Lawrence and Hypoluxo Road. STUDY OBJECTIVE This traffic impact study has been prepared following Section 7.9 (Traffic Performance Standards) which amends the previously adopted 1990 Countywide Traffic Performance Standards Code (Ordinance 90-40). These Standards require development to meet two "tests". Test 1, Link Buildout Test, requires that total traffic on any roadway link within the project's radius of Development Influence that would result in an average annual daily traffic volume that is less than the adopted threshold level of service during the buildout period of the project. Test 2, Model Test, requires that total traffic on any link within the project's Model Radius of Development Influence would result in an average annual daily traffic volume that is less than the adopted threshold level of service, as determined by the FSUTMS model. 1 CRESTHAVEN r ( a:: .... 0 loJ a:: 0 u. 0 0 i a: w In 10th o 4( o a: L KE ~ :t: a: loJ > 4( :t: Q c( o a: :w:: a: :w:: ...., :w:: Q. Z a: :;:) .... t.4ELALEUCA LANE o 4( o a: ~ c( a: .... Cl o '") >- a:: c( .... ~ :i LANTANA t 0 4( \I) 0 a: .c 0 - Cl a:: 0 0 ., ~ "- o c( o a: W <...l Z w i c( ~ GATEWAY BOYNTON BOYNTON BOYNTON B(.\CH ~ c( a: .... >- a: c( .... ~ ~ LOCATION MAP N.T .s. 8 ~"" ASSOCIATES. 111:. P ClISllTIJC ElCJJHRS SURVEYORS LAND OEVELOPWENT CONSULTANTS I I I ..." ~I -. AVE WORTH ROAD If) III \U a: Cl 5 (.) . BLVD CANAL RD WOOLBRIGHT .,.. .... A.I~lo .Iv~. C~DS).T2-3.S. (~AXJ 8TZ-4IT. ~~.. ~lor'OG ~~o.~ PLANNERS o 4( o a: W <.:l o a:: POLUXO I . J ltI' ~, -. I . I . I ( -' c( a: ~ . lU I ... BLVD I I 11>1 "'. ~I . RD J . I FIGURE >- c( lI= % <.:l % ~INER RD / TRANSPORTATION ANALYSIS Project Trip Generation The traffic to be generated by the proposed development is based on the trip generation rates presented in Table 10.8-1 of Article 10 in Palm Beach County Land Development Codes for daily trips and I.T.E. Trip Generation, 5th Edition for peak periods. General Commercial Retail (18,500 S.F.) Total Daily Trips = Ln(T) = 0.625 Ln (X) + 5.985 Total Daily Trips = 2460 tpd Less 44.70% Pass-By Trips = (1100) tpd Net Daily Trips = 1360 tpd Bank with Drive Through (3,800 S.F.) Total Daily Trips = 3,800 S.F. * 265.21 K.S.F. = 1008 tpd Less 46% Pass-By Trips = (464) tpd Net Daily Trips = 544 tpd Fast Food Restaurant with Drive Through Total Daily Trips = 7.200 S.F. * 632.12 K.S.F. = 4,551 tpd Less 30% Pass-By Trips = 1,365 tpd Net Daily Trips = 3,186 tpd Subtotal = 1360+544 + 3,186 = 5090 trip ends Internal Site Trip Ends 5% Internalization = 255 Total Vehicles Entering and Leaving Development = 4835 tpd Study Area The study area is based on the radius of development influence for Test I & Test 2, which is outlined in Table 2A and Table 2B of the Traffic Performance Standards. Table 2A and Table 2B relate the maximum radius of development influence distance to the net trips generated by the site. For a net trip generation of 4,788 trips per day the radius of development influence is 2 mile for Test I and Test 2. Figure 2 displays the 2 mile radius of development influence. 3 L KE WORTH ROAD Cl ~ o Q: o oot o Q: 110:: Q: :.G' LLI ::l Z LLI > oot MELALEUCA t.€LALEUCA LANE 0 oot 0 a: C) 0 .., lANTANA ROAD -' oot a:: to- >- a:: oot to- o ~ o Q: , I , I , I . I , L , I , I , 11'11 0', ':'1 , I . I . BOYNTON CANAL I f LEGEND: EFFECTED ROADWAY LINK IIIIIIII STUDY AREA N.T S. STUDY AREA (RADIUS OF DEVEWPIJENT INFWENCEJ . C8U1=I~1Ii '1Ii'i:J:TES. liE. SURvEYORS LAND DEVELOPMENT CONSULTANTS FIGURE. ~ PLANNERS 2 ..s. w..~ A~lon.lo Blvd. CSOSt97Z.3.59 (~AXJ '7a.~I? warOO... ~I~rda 330.3 ~I,r:. ....'_...,_...'...I.~'._..-"""" Existing Conditions Existing traffic counts were obtained from the Palm Beach County Metropolitan Planning Organization for 1994-95. Figure 3 shows the available traffic counts for the roads within study area. The existing number of lanes for the roads was also obtained from the Palm Beach County Metropolitan planning Organization and is presented in Figure 4. Future Roadway Improvements Palm Beach County "Five Year Road Program" and Florida Department of Transportation ''Transportation Improvement Program" were the sources for the funded roadway improvements expected to be completed by the developments build out year. Gateway Boulevard is funded for a future improvement from 2 lanes to 6 lanes divided. This study will depend on this improvement. Development Access Development access will be driveways connecting to Hypoluxo Road and Lawrence Road. Hypoluxo Road at Lawrence Road location is a four lane divided arterial with exclusive left-turn and exclusive right-turn lanes. Lawrence Road northbound direction, south approach, consists of a single left-turn lane and a through and shared right-turn lane. The southbound direction, north approach, consists of one through lane and exclusive left and right-turn lane. Background Traffic An analysis of background traffic growth was conducted for the radius of development influence using the latest available growth rates provided by Palm Beach County. The compound growth rates are estimated using the increase/decrease of average daily traffic over the most recent three- year period. Palm Beach County requires engineering judgment be exercised in applying historical growth rates. Table 1 summarizes the growth rate analysis. In addition to the compound growth rates, the study consider all major projects that could have an impact on the roadway network within the study area. Palm Beach County "Major Projects Map" was the source for the location of these projects. No major projects were identified within the study area. Figure 5 is a roadway network map annotated with the total background traffic within the study area. 5 L KE WORTH ROAD 0 lJJ ~ ;:, 0 z ~ lJJ > ~ ~ MELALEUCA ~ MELALEUCA LANE ~ ...J 0 4. 0 a: <.:) 0 ~ 0 <( - 28169 0 0:: LANTANA ROAD :E < >- -< :> 23140 2269:1 ~I 30439 HYPOLUXO ROAD '< >- I >- I -< I 12693 VI lJJ I c \I') <.:) I -< W t- o III I 0 0 a:: N - O'"tl 0:: -< C> ,., a:: ~I 0 :z <ID 0:: 0 N , CI U) 0 Mlt-'ER R , 0 U) I ~ U1 <ID I u ,... :z , lJJ I 0:: ~ I ~ ...J GATEWAY BLVD -< 14219 >- --< 2 I I 90 ".. BOYNTON CANAL --=--= ( 0'\ 0 ~ EX/STING TRAFFIC FIGURE N.T S. a tUltWfAH-flfm1Jl All) ASSOCIATES. lIE. P allSll.TIIC EltItEERS SURVEYORS LAND OEVELOP~NT CONSULTANTS PLANNERS 3 ...1 w..~ A~I~~lo 8Iv.. (~O~'.?2-'.5' C~AX) '7Z-41~. wargo... ~IOr'dG ~30.3 ~l'ti: li~!;;~.~~:r~h_..dgn TABLE 1 ANALYSIS OF AVERAGE TRAFFIC GROWTH RATE 1!lilllillllli~iilliiii!li!illilllilllil~lllli!i~II~111~lill!lilliliiii!ll~i!~I~illllll!111 iill~A'!I~!lliil!illi!!illlllliiliiiiii~l!il lilli~l!iii Lawrence Rd. Lantana Rd. Hypoluxo Rd. 7,763 8,217 6,796 7,004 -3.37% Lawrence Rd. Hypoluxo Rd. Gateway Blvd. 7,751 7,382 7,646 7,866 0.49% Lawrence Rd. Gateway Blvd. Old Boynton Rd. 10.721 10,559 10,652 10,911 0.59% Military Trail Melaleuca Ln. Lantana Rd. 24,930 31,9n 31,639 30,968 7.50% Military Trail Lantana Rd. Hypoluxo Rd. 20,599 24,143 24,849 25,632 7.56% Military Trail Hypoluxo Rd. Gateway Blvd. 20,237 25.138 23.873 23,072 4.47% Congress Ave. Lantana Rd. Hypoluxo Rd. 27,132 23,719 23,439 23,854 -4.20% Congress Ave. Hypoluxo Rd. Miner Rd. 30,390 28,972 25,540 28,327 -2.32% Lantana Rd. Jog Rd. Military Trail 18,106 22,924 21.064 23,140 8.52% Lantana Rd. Military Trail Congress Ave. 24,960 27.382 28,259 28,169 4.11% Hypoluxo Rd. Jog Rd. Military Trail 7,688 10,810 10,556 12,693 18.19% Hypoluxo Rd. Military Trail Lawrence Rd. 18,204 23,179 21,716 22,696 7.63% Hypoluxo Rd. Lawrence Rd. Congress Ave. 24,898 27,381 23,995 26,947/ 2.67% Hypoluxo Rd. Congress Ave. 1-95 30,6n 31,720 27,973 30,439 -0.26% Gateway Blvd. Military Trail Lawrence Road 8,391 10,706 14,130 14,219 19.22% Gateway Blvd. Lawrence Road Congress Avenue 14.944 17,528 19,783 21,190 12.34% Areawide --- - 297,391 331,737 321,910 337,127 4.27% 1:\exceI5\lIleslalt\misclraNw-hypo2.xIS L KE WORTH ROAD 0 c( 0 a:: :.:: a:: LALEUCA LANE -I 0 c( c( 0 a:: a:: t- a >- 0 a:: , c( t- o -I < 0 LANTANA ROAD ~ Q:' . . . . . . . . . HYPOLUXO ROAD . . . VI I.LJ I 0 VI a . c( I.LJ 0 11'1' 0 0 a:: - Ol. a:: c( a a: .:.. 0 z a: 0 . C) u MINER 0 , I.LJ U Z I.LJ i ~ ..J GATEWAY BLVD BOYNTON CANAL , I .-.-.-.- 6 LANE ARTERIALS et 01 6 LANE 4 LANE 2 LANE ~ EXISTING LANE GEOMETRY F/G(JRE N.T S. 1ft C8IUI.PIIlrlt MIl ASS<<IAIES. nt. V- aJI5I. mG EIGIIIERS SURVEYORS LAND DEVELOPWENT CONSULTANTS PlANNERS 4 a"1 w... ..lan.IQ B'vd. C305..?Z-SeSe I~AX' '72-..7. ~go... FlorIda 330.3 ~.I... ..._^._..,...I.~I._............ L KE WORTH ROAD MELALEUCA LANE 0 <( 0 0: C) 0 J LANTANA ROAD -< 24637 Cl <( o 0: ::.::; a:: .... ::.::; I.aJ ::> z I.aJ > <( MELALEUCA -' .... <( a: l- N r- O'l >- N a: ,.., <( I- ..J 29992 - ~ < >- >' o ~ o a: 32409 HYPOLUXO I >- 1 -.: I 13514 I.aJ I Cl <.:) I <( Cl 101 0 - en, a: a: ~I lO U) I <.:) lO Itl I 0 v r- J N W ,.., I U ex) I z I I.aJ I 0: ~ I <( -l , GATEWAY BLVD I , 15139 t~ 22561 I ~ :>- \D-C >- , BOYNTON - CANAL { LEGEND: -< 395 :- TOT At BACKGROUND TRAFF 1 C ~..- ~ BACKGROUND TRAFFIC FIGURE N.T S. SURVEYORS , ~1Ii~=TES. 11& LAND DEVELOPWENT CONSULTANTS PLANNERS 5 .... ~ A~lon~lo aIVG. C3OD).TZ~~.S. C'AWI .Ta-~IT. YGroo... Plor'a. 330.3 ~l\l: r.~!;;t.~::~~f.GhI." Project Traffic Distribution and Assignment Distribution of project trips came from proportioning trips by using the Palm Beach County Metropolitan Planning Organization's socioeconomic data and knowledge of the area. The socioeconomic data are available through the "ZDATAl files" of the Urban Area's Transportation Models for all zones within the study area. The generation files include all single and multi family development within the study area. Residential land use was the basis for distribution of trips. Non-home based trips were considered significant for this area. The following distribution was obtained: TRIPS DISTRffiUTION DIRECTION North South East West PERCENTAGE 27% 33% 24% 16% The distribution rates came from the premise that the percent of site traffic produced is directly proportional to the attraction size and inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the site to the attraction. "" 'I The assignment of site traffic was performe~he minimum travel time that drivers would more frequently favor in their route solution~'f7~gure [;.eports the assigned project to the area's roadways. Four access driveways are proposed. Three will be limited to right entry and exit: one intersection with Lawrence Road and two intersections with Hypoluxo Road. The fourth driveway will be the eastern most entry and exit access point and will have full access. That is, the intersection will have an eastbound right turn lane and a westbound median left turn lane and the exiting vehicles may turn left to go west on Hypoluxo Road. The traffic volume using the driveways by direction are related to the trip distribution are related to the trip distribution and site circulation. Twenty percent (20%) of the development entering traffic will likely use the westbound left turn lane for entry, that is 80 vph during the AM peak hour and 70 vph during the afternoon peak hour. During the PM peak hour the median opening would serve 110 vph development generated eastbound-to-westbound "U-turn" and 48 vph outbound "Left-Turns." Future TraffIC Figure 7 confirms the total 1996 traffic volume for the commercial development. The total traffic volumes are the summation of the assigned project traffic, the projected 1996 background traffic growth, and the existing 1994-1995 traffic volume. The future traffic volume served as the basis for determining level of service compliance. 10 J L KE WORTH ROAD I c w I or( ::l I 0 :z a: w > , I ::.::: or( MELALEUCA a: , MELALEUCA LANE ::.::: 0 or( 0 a: "i C) 0 ~ ;j 0 'j 00::( I 0 ' ,1 248 406 a: LANTANA ROAD .. ~-E: >- :- i < 92 >- 341 HYPOLUXO ROAD < >- . >- I ..:: . 148 (/) w I c (/) C) I or( W 0 It) I 0 c 0: (1) - CTl. a: .0:( C) 0 a: ~I 0 :z N ,." a: 0 , C) (\j 0 (.) R I 0 N ~ W CD . III I u :z I w I a: ~ . < ..J GATEWAY BLVO ~ >- ~ >- 395 592 BOYNTON CANAL I f LEGEND: '< 395 >- PROJECT TRIPS " ~ PROJECT TRAFFIC , ~1C~=ms. U& SURVEYORS LAND DEVELOPMENT CONSULTANTS PLAHNERS N.T .5. ..,. .... A?'an.'o B'Yd. C~OS~'7Z-3.S. C~AM) .T2-~'T. ~O~.. "arfoa 3~O.3 .' FIGURE 6 '1\1: fi~!;;t.i2~:~'~.'" L KE WORTH ROAD MELALEUCA LANE Cl < o cr: :.:: cr: ..-. :.:: ~ ::l Z ~ > < MELALEUCA Cl < o 0::: C> o ~ o < o cr ROAD I J . ~ I Cl C> I < 0 IllJ 0 Cl - en. cr: < cr: ~I 0 cr: . C) I 0 ~ uJ I U I :z . uJ I cr: ~ . < -I GATEWAY BLVD 15534 CANAL BOYNTON 45000 ( LEGEND: 123618 , 23618 TOTAL TRAFFIC ~ EXIST. LOS D VOLUME ~ TOTAL TRAFFIC FIGURE N.T .s. , ~1Ii"'=TES. HI:. SURVEYORS LAND DEVELOP~NT CONSULTANTS PLANNERS 7 .,., .... A.'on~'o .'v.. f30S).72-~.5. '~AX) ,T2-.17. worg~.. ~1~1Ga 230.3 ~l'il: fi~!;r.:-;~:~I_..4CJ"I Level of Service Analysis This traffic analysis must demonstrate compliance with the standards contained in Section 7.9 of the Palm Beach Traffic Performance Standards. The Standards consist of complying with the adopted level of service for Test 1 or Alternative Test 1 and Test 2. The following details the analyses for each tests. Test 1 - Link/Buildout Test The analysis consists of projecting the project's new trips on the major thoroughfare links within the project's radius of development influence and evaluating the level of service for the total traffic. The total traffic consists of project traffic, existing traffic, background traffic and committed traffic. The standards state that the level of service may be exceeded by a total of 5% of level of service D provided that no one project may use more that 1/5 of the 5% or 1 % of the total available on any link within the project's radius of development influence. From Table 2A of the Palm Beach County Land Development code, the maximum radius of development influence is 2 miles for a net trip generation rate of 4788 trips/day. Therefore all roadway links within the 2 miles distance must meet Test 1. Meeting Test I consists of relating the projected total traffic to the level of service D's average daily traffic. This could be accomplished by evaluating the projected total traffic, as shown in Figure 7, and the average daily traffic for the level of service D as tabulated in Table lA of the Palm Beach Traffic Performance Standards. The following segments within the radius of development of influence exceed the allowable level of service for Test 1: . Lantana Road from Military Trail to Congress Avenue . Hypoluxo Road from Lawrence Road to Congress Avenue . Congress Avenue from Hypoluxo Road to Miner Road However, the project traffic for Congress Avenue, 209 vehicles per day, from Hypoluxo Road to Miner Road does not exceed the allowable 1/5 of 5% tolerance which is 294 vehicles per day. In addition, Congress Avenue is not a directly access link to the site. The other two segments, Lantana Road from Military Trail to Congress Avenue and Hypoluxo Road from Lawrence Road to Congress Avenue fail Test 1 and the project traffic is more than the allowable 1/5 of 5% rule. Alternate Test I was analyzed for these segments to determine if improvements are needed due to the project traffic. Alternate Test 1 Alternate Test I was conducted for the segment of Lantana Road from Military Trail to Congress A venue, and Hypoluxo Road from Lawrence Road to Congress A venue. 14 Alternate Test I can be satisfied if peak hour, peak season, peak direction volume does not exceed the allowable level of service listed for the peak hour directional volumes for urbanized areas in Table 3-1 of the FDOT Level of Service Manual, and the intersection's critical volumes do not exceed 1400 vehicles as outlined in the Highway Capacity Manual, planning analysis method. The peak hour, peak season, peak direction volumes for the failed links were analyzed for existing and future conditions. The peak season traffic counts for Lantana Road east of Military Trail and Hypoluxo Road from Lawrence Road to Congress Avenue are included in Appendix A. The peak to daily ratio and directional factors for the morning and evening peak hours were applied to the latest average daily traffic count information from the Metropolitan Planning Organization. The re:mlts of the analysis are as follows: LINK ANALYSIS Lantana Road, East of Military Trail Condition Direction Peak Hour Peak Volume Existing Eastbound AM 1512 Existing Westbound PM 1583 Future Eastbound AM 1643 Future Westbound PM 1721 Hypoluxo Road, East of Lawrence Road Condition Direction Peak Hour Peak Volume Existing Existing Future Future Eastbound Westbound Eastbound Westbound AM PM AM PM 1488 1334 1618 1450 The maximum peak hour, peak season, peak directional volume does not exceed the 2210 vph threshold. Therefore, the link capacity requirements for Lantana Road and Hypoluxo Road are satisfied. Turning movement counts were obtained for the intersection of Lantana RoadIMilitary Trail and Lantana Road/Congress Avenue. Turning movements were also obtained for Hypoluxo Road at Lawrence Road and Hypoluxo Road at Congress Avenue. Intersection planning capacity 15 analyses were conducted for existing peak hour turning movement counts and projected future turning movement volume with project traffic utilizing the computer program Signalized Intersection Planning Analysis (SIPA). Appendix B contains the collected turning movement counts, and Appendix C contains the SIP A output for the two intersections. These intersections will operate with the following critical volumes: INTERSECTION ANALYSIS Locations Condition Peak Hour Sum Critical Volumes Lantana/Congress Existing AM 1017 Existing PM 1564 Future AM 1078 Future PM 1356 LantanaIMilitary Existing AM 1068 Existing PM 940 Future AM 1130 Future PM 996 HypoluxolLawrence Existing AM 945 Existing PM 964 Future AM 1054 Future PM 1076 Hypoluxo/Congress Existing AM 1041 Existing PM 1276 Future AM 1118 Future PM 1382 From the above tabulation, the subject intersections do not exceed the maximum allowable 1400 sum of critical volume. The Lantana Road segment from Congress Avenue to Military Trail and Hypoluxo Road from Lawrence Road to Congress A venue will meet Alternate Test 1 for future conditions. Test 2 - Model Test The analysis consists of obtaining the project's net trips as projected in the trip generation section and utilizing the net trips to obtain the model radius of development influence through Table 2B of the Palm Beach County Traffic Performance Standards. The total traffic differs from Test 1 and is defined as model traffic. Model traffic consists of forcasted traffic volume as 16 assigned by the urban model on the future 2010 roadway network. Similar to Test 1, the Standards allow the level of service to be exceeded by 5% of level of service D provided no one project can utilize more than 1/5 of the 5%. In addition, Test 2 requires all projects that generate more than 7,000 net daily trips to utilize the model for traffic assignment and level of service determination. From Table 2B of the code, the maximum radius of development influence for the generated 4788 trips/day is 2 miles. Therefore, all roadway segments within 2 miles from the site need to be lower than Test 2's capacity. The Palm Beach County's List of Roadway Segments Failing Test 2 was reviewed and no roadway links fail Test #2 within 2 miles from the site. The proposed development passes Test #2. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS From performing Test 1, Alternate Test I and Test 2 the proposed development conforms with the 1990 Palm Beach Countywide Traffic Performance Standards. We recommend that the project be granted a Site Development Order. The proposed development will be phased to the six lane construction of Lantana Road from Military Trail to Congress Avenue, and Gateway Boulevard from Military Trail to Congress Avenue. The proposed development can be built immediately up to 1084 trips per day without causing traffic impacts that would require roadway improvements. 17 c:\wonl6lalllhypotawl\law-hyp2.doc