Loading...
LEGAL APPROVAL (~~6\~~O" X \0 7\ "~ 0 ,'V,. ",v ~,.QN DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION . Building . Planning & Zoning . Occupational Licenses . Community Redevelopment August 28, 2001 Ms. Octavia S. Sherrod Community Development Manager City Of Boynton Beach 100 East Boynton Beach Boulevard Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Re: For FileNo. Location: Cherry Hill Lot 62 Zoning Code Variance ZNCV 01-015 N W 9th Avenue Dear Ms. Sherrod: Enclosed is the City of Boynton Beach Development Order for application item ZNCV 01-015, which represents approval of the above-referenced zoning code variance. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to contact this office at (561) 742-6260. Sincerely, f7UJ2- Michael W Rumpf Director of Planning & Zoning MRW.AD Attachment: Development Order Conditions of Approval S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Cherry Hill Lot 62\Approval form letter after CC.doc City of Boynton Beach. 100 East Boynton Beach Blvd., P.O. Box 310 . Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 Phone: (561) 742-6260 . www.ci.boynton-beach.fl.us DEVELC''''I\IIE'-- ORDER OF THE CITY COIII'L"S~~N OF THE cr. (OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLl..dDA PROJECT NAME. Lots 62, 63, and 64 (portions) Cherry Hills Subdivision fJ. !>d. ~:~.....~'" "r,','.. ' ',~; , ..-.(..... ~" ~.~. I APPLICANT'S AGENT City of Boynton Beach APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: PO BOX 310, Boynton Beach, FL 33425 DATE OF CITY COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING: August 21,2001 TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT Lot area ; " i ,~! ':~ L 4 iUi!i ! --' LOCATION OF PROPERTY South side of NW 9th Avenue, between NW 4th sli'eet and NW 5th stre~~' DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "A and B" ATTACHED HERETO X THIS MATTER came before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida appearing on the Consent Agenda on the date above. The City Commission hereby adopts the findings and recommendation of the Community Redevelopment Agency Board, which Board found as follows: OR THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: 1 Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applicant L HAS HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit "F" with notation "Included" 4 The Applicant's application for relief is hereby ~ GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof DENIED 5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 8-~/-OI All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order \11111111111111 ~\\\\ III/, ,:$I- J. .. :t,.." ~ 0" <TQ ~ f.~ G<l~<~o\ - lll; ~~ ~ :: ~ . u.. - _ 2 !~ :: :: 0 '0 $ %~.,~ ~ ~ -t ....90M' ^ ~ ~ -' ~~J~ :///, ';\\,,,,, ~111"1/I111111\\\\ Other Non~ 6. 7 DATED" S:\PLANNING\SHAREO\WP\PROJECTS\CHERRY HILL LOT 62\DEVElOPME TO EXHIBIT "F" Conditions of Approval Project name: Lots 62, 63, and 64 (portions), Cherry Hills Subdivision File number: ZNCV 01-015 (Lot area) Reference: Zoninl> Code Variance Annlication dated June 8 2001 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT PUBLIC WORKS Comments: NONE X UTILITIES Comments: NONE X FIRE Comments: NONE X POLICE Comments: NONE X ENGINEERING DIVISION Comments: NONE X BUILDING DIVISION Comments: NONE X PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: NONE X FORESTER/ENVIRONMENTALIST Comments: NONE X PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: NONE X ADDITIONAL COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS Comments: NONE X ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS Comments: To be determined. Non,. ~ - MWRlpat S:\PLANNING\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\CHERRY HILL LOT 6~NOI*,NS OF APPROVAL ZONING CODE VARIANCE.OOC DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION MEMORANDUM #01-156 Staff Report Planning and Development Board and City Commission Meeting Date: August 14, 2001 File No: ZNCV 01-015 - Lot area variance Location: Lots 62, 63, and 64 (portions) Cherry Hills Subdivision Owner' Derek and Tracy Wiley New single-family home. Project: Variance Request: Request relief from the City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations, Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 5.D.2.a, to allow a single-family house on a 7,200 square-feet lot in lieu of the 7,500 square-feet required by code in a R-1-A zoning district. BACKGROUND The subject vacant property and nearby neighborhood is currently zoned R-1-A, singie family residential, and mostly developed. The applicant desires to develop the property for a single- family residence (see Exhibit "A" - Location Map). The approved plat of Cherry Hills Subdivision, as recorded in 1926, shows the original lots being 25-feet wide (see Exhibit "B"- Cherry Hills Subdivision). In 1975 the City adopted new zoning regulations which caused many parcels to become legally non-conforming, including those in the plat of Cherry Hills. The current regulations require a minimum of 60 feet of frontage and 7,500 square-feet in lot area in the R-1-A zoning district. The subject parcels were conveyed to the applicant by the City, who would develop them with a single-family home using SHIP (State Housing Initiative Partnership) funds. The City has assembled portions of lots 62 and 64, with lot 63 in order to satisfy the 60- foot frontage requirement, but it remains 300 feet short of the minimum 7.500 square- foot area requirement (see Exhibit "C" - survey). The following is a description of the zoning districts and land uses of properties that surround the subject property' North. NW 9th Avenue right-of-way and farther north single-family homes zoned R-1-A. South: Single-family homes zoned R-1-A. East: Vacant parcel zoned R-1-A. West: Single-family home zoned R-1-A. Page 2 File No. ZNCV 01-015 ANALYSIS The code states that the zoning code variance cannot be approved unless the board finds the following: a. That special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the same zoning district. b. That the special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the applicant. c. That granting the variance requested would not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by this ordinance to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district. d. That literal interpretation of the provisions of this ordinance would deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the terms of the ordinance and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant. e. That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use ofthe land, building, or structure. f That the grant of the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this chapter [ordinance] and that such variance will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental to the pUblic welfare. Staff has conducted this analysis using the above criteria, which require that the request not be based on actions taken by the applicant; not deprive the applicant of rights and privileges already enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district; be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of City regulations, and not be detrimental nor injurious to the area and public welfare. According to the applicant's response to the above criteria. as contained in Exhibit "D", other property owners in the neighborhood have been allowed the privilege of reduced lot size. The applicant therefore feels that he is also entitled to the same privilege, and therefore has provided a plan depicting a proposed (approximately) 1,900 square foot residence for the subject 7,300 square-foot lot (see Exhibit "C" - survey). The applicant has also stated that the requested variance would allow development of a parcel that is consistent with other lots in the surrounding neighborhood. Furthermore, as per the applicant, the proposed structure will be harmonious with both the typical size and architectural style of other new houses in the area, therefore, minimizing negative or injurious impacts to the neighborhood. Page 3 File No. ZNCV 01-015 City records and on-site inspections of the neighborhood, have verified that several similar variances for lot area have been granted within close proximity to the subject property City records indicate that a total of fifteen (15) properties within the Cherry Hills Subdivision have been the subject of variances approved since 1964, the majority for rear or side setbacks, but five (5) of them for lot area reductions to allow construction of single-family homes on non- conforming lots (see Exhibit "E" - variance locator map). Therefore, staff concurs with the applicant that the granting of this variance request will not confer any special privileges to the applicant. Staff acknowledges that by modifying the site development regulations in 1975 to require a minimum of eO-foot frontage and 7,500 square-foot lot size, the City created certain hardships and non-conformities for owners of older platted lots. The applicant has made a good faith effort to comply with the City's minimum site development requirements by combining portions of several lots to meet the minimum frontage requirement. Therefore, staff agrees that the applicant has demonstrated that approval of this request is the minimum that will make possible a reasonable use of the property CONCLUSIONS/RECOMMENDATION Based on the analysis contained herein, staff acknowledges that the applicant has proven that a hardship condition exists, and that the applicant has made a reasonable attempt to bring the subject parcel into conformance with current regulations. Furthermore, staff concludes that the approval of this request will support affordable housing goals of the City's Infill Program; will increase the property values of the neighborhood; decrease unsightly conditions; and beautify the streetscape. Therefore, staff recommends that the requested variance be approved, thereby granting the relief necessary to allow the construction of a single-family home on a non-conforming lot with 7,200 square-feet in lieu of the 7,500 square-feet required by code; No conditions of approval are recommended; however, any conditions of approval recommended by the Community Redevelopment Agency Board or City Commission will be placed in Exhibit "F" MRlad S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTSICherry Hirf lol62\STAFF REPORT.aae J~~dI/I.1-~r-'-J ~>'-.J~~ '~lr ~' \\-'.1 ."" 'f' __ . "':::; .{;-I." ... ,"""",-rOM CA",."T " , "I' J,.-- " , h, ','. C-' __ O=- .',:"'--.," i== "- I, ,.' '" ,-I., ',I , ,"" .~ Illliil,!:1 '"i"11 eg;r . , , , .... : , . I", 'II' ~ I I IIIITI'! 'I ,. '!. ., f '~"iI,',!"" Ii,I;II:,TITTTT, r- ' II! illITlTTTTil!' ,III',:" i J! 11'1 II " iF' t:' ..;,~~U!11i111111 I PU u.Jir;rrrn~el-ci:'-i"llli.': ~.I<~' ~r' t= , '.:Jl"itn~; if;'1 'i'; ,!I,I 1111 llIT.II:EIJC'.""Ul I)' il=-C " "tlill!"I'IIIIII'" I . . 't I I I'I" III' ", L , R 1I"'IiiJTIi'11~' ", "I' Tf j 1111Iill~ ! 'III 'If' " --, ',I '\~ JITI E I '1TIDj1Tm , , , I." C!, ,r~l ' II 1 I f:c=.;.. LlJ IW "JIITIIlB]]]J!]I 'lIil "711 ~ c Ui'r"jI'I' i~1 ,~~ III 'T ~ f'm'l' ~' ;~ I '..ifrI.- lWJ t~ rri1lfIlIIIIlll :~ 1111 ~II,II/I II,~" ~.- .E ~~o= L "rn!-. ~'YO\i1:tb lih CC ,;,~ " C',~ ,::;: ~,-E(f' (:D~-~:!'-;' te;zFl -ill: ~~I!' I~ == ,-t= OJ:: 'illp , _ '~: 1,~~Jl]J ~ ' ,S:~7fl"1 ~ ,-'II , rrt!., i'M'T ~ ,I' I- =1 ~ "' "_Tl =- ',., - h-... <1 =i RI II r:= ,ZllC.. ' - /= II" I iT C '-' :2 1'_ I-./,?- I I L.j lioo T1-- 3"' ~ ~ t::J...:::>w'! ~ :3 : I i 1 i= __ I" I-I 1;'cJ ['l ...., .ft ~ ;o::-'f-- I", 'I' _ ' 1....,...,.J!!l 'I ,I _LiT r\. T ~11 ~ ~ L-.; p _,_ ::IIIIIIf-II' ;,T~ 7 ~ I '" --IF ;'1111' U'-- ,'11'1 r:: 'Tii.l:1 'Ie.- =. _ 11:111 = ~ 0 ~ :1, ~:!3. ~ H li~ I H' I'!: '1.iJ r~ . ~':~' ~ Ri 1...., ~ Ef',~" 'I R ~ riTm'fD fl\. \; I I -= e illllln-..,-t::t!Jt(\'YMn:' 3 J] IllfT-' C ;; III ;llll ='-I~ 1Jo~sJF~ III TIT = C~4 J.,\" ,_ "" 'tll ~ I L _H1J'N J IIII IT " i.. ", .Ii, I 1'/ ,: I iT.. -- r5l!l 'i i ---'-'1' il L" ~,o(,1itir;~~~,~'" BLv , .11111 ((I' I ':IJo.oIiI IT n CiS I: 'L . t' J_ ,." ..""." Ii"""'. . ' . "I' II . ,,01, H,. II"" 1:<' . EI~v=:J" . . .'A' , '. ,'."III!II::ill.l,l!' 1 rrC:'J"J. . '.': '..,. .' .'" ',I 1!t~1.l.:18 ':"' ,,111., ~ ill II".": I ~8_.V:> i I "",i,lii 1"'''1 I ' 't"~ .' . "I '" ,r 'm ~ . ---.1 ! fTiT. 'g" ' I~ _ ;d,;' I ~lfi'" '",II'I;m.. 1:111I'1!r;ji:lli';'-'rffi ," I' r"\l ~ i.1 ~ ' . j": . 6]'- , '~~ Ii. ..", ,,~. ~ - ' ' ,I - ~,. H i. I i~ ' - I:::'::'::::: :1'11", ;n 1I11'rmIT 1 t; , 1 : I ~ ~ G:IJ.I .:, !~;;j_' Hili . .",1;'['1" I, lillliE! ~ J:RI I I' i " ,L::::IJ. I .Illi!fJ11111 ! ' I ~~.~ ."'&ill!111111 I'.,"':" ',I "2" ""I'I'l~.' i, ' I:', ..j i CTjl iEtc: : :L.-+: .J ,.1., I 1"'j,I!i,,,"IIr "1M'i k;:;r 4' it:) ii'" ~~" I, _'i 111'11'1'''' ". . 'Ii :Zu i--"'" ,:1111; mo:::=m -"fie+="[ : ,'.! IJT' I III III Tn '_, 111:l'f;, 4h ..,j" -I , 1 I I . , , 11., I I I 'T..... -Hi ! , " 1'Tl I' 1 ' I I i I I: 1 III! , II I r I I 1 I , ......~ ~ '" I' i' rTr I ill, =, +. _. n I' 'I,' I'" 'T' . : ! ' I ' , I' 'I.~' ' C IT, ~' . I ,I .i: : I '! T . ..J..lJJ I' I Iff;- - =i I I 'T ": r ,:" , --n II , '" I r I rITE: - , =F T'I ."lll'T'rT ,,11U :'1, -- h',~ .J+, [EE=[illl:,.. "9 1/2 NIILES~) Rill';;] ',I ';"i:fJJJlTTljl'i""il'il!" ""1' . ; r:- i , I ,I I I I I " _''TTT "..I!JI;;;m;1I','" _'h___.' I \ / , ..'. ," i" f-- I I' I' I ' tel ,',llII!' !J",:"nll::lliI'1I'~'U~ '1 t::r! '~~ _ 11_. ;jRT1H,'!;-q------.-~ t~? 400800 FEET' / PUl//NIN 6 Ii.U"-' 08/01 .I , T L! , I~ 'fl~ -I-- ' - . I-- '....: - :::==: =~ ~ iM, _= ~t II~ = : r k.- i'IUf c-!'~ ~~t~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ 0r lil m jV' 11''''2,1 Ir= .~ "I 111111 111m !TiT i l-b~ i j I -TTJTT c- I J ~ .~ - I , L.- ~1 I LOCATION MAP Cherry Hills- 62-63-64 EXHIBIT "A" --1[:' --~ ~ \\~{~'~.:\.~ W.t~:' on " _ ..,." ,,,'k'; " r: \tl1!, ul~ Q3~ti~4' - p::. _ .... o~o"O ~ ",.." '" "" :l',"~ ' tl 15 """' lu~~\l --; \;,,' ,,' ~ '1~%'\~) ~;;; "'- .- ~ ~ ".toe.~" .'5,i!"<~' " ~ I> ~ 'Ii 'I, ~ . \i\fi. "": '\li\W;!l'j5 ,~~ " << J 1i ,1\\1\ \ \ ,\"W \y:~ o.,..l <:>.,-; '1. (;) ""' I.< ,1,.~, dCh, ~- _",,- ~ Q '" "" ,. H'"'' . .'~~U""~~ ~~ _ ,. ..... \i. .",,0 " ., nO __: ,.:.. ,,-, ~ ~ (;~_~~~ ~ t ~ "p.Qoo. ~ , ", 0 .- "' ~ > ...-,.' " '.', " OOr- t,: 7, 2'.: \ .~ ,_. c:. ~%,>" ,,~ l:" ~~"o 0 ~ 1-61~J~ r~ ~'::i g. ! ~..1:t ~ ::; iii If,h~ \ f t'i~eJ ~i)~ ~.. ;:; :) ~ '"" ~ ~ "~.,, "'1;,\'\' . .' < ,. ,,,,,, " , 1 ~ 0 \.J 'c: ~o "'" 0 ~i..'" "' ,~" ,.' _, <Jl ':? ",."'" ."h' < ,,0;..3 '" [l 'i'"'' l. ~~.", " CC ' ~', '" , ,,' ,,,,,," ,'" ,\ ." 0> " " ~ <M 'VI I' _,,~ 0 i>.l '::i '" .-( , > \;'ioi' lit""" ~ ~ ~~uJ ~,.-... 4.. /' 0 I'- "'~\',,' ,,"%[ .~(C",_u '" ,o,~-., ",.', '.,' 0 ~ '" w (il ~'''''', ,..,., ~ CJ) 0 ~? ' ~l'~; 8'i ,~..t ' :', g -' cc. In 8"!'~'~' '-''''oe' . 7;?; 0 r. '" ~A,"~' 3a~~<~' , .(; ~ ~ y. - '7 ~.." ," ...." \.' :c "'"- "' e ",,"," ,,,,,,." " _ ,'i: ~ .... ,0.,""' 0>>0>- ;-/f-" " ~~ 4, O?;O:&>-~C::' ",l<->~"% -t,'"." "" .. 0 " ."' " ", ' ' ,_ c, i "''' H0' " It' .,,;, ~, ';'..\\; '"-" is ," .:' ,,,,, \1' j;\ . ~- j , , ,.' _; ,.j " :,.__,-,---- "",o"..! \;'''':',1>1'::-:''''2'''-' \' \' "," ""'""'," .--" /,,- ,o'- ........., .' ; , " \ .' c ," ~Z .\ >-.-:1:1>-'- ':)';:;~:;: - 1 ~1' _Oll- ~ .... .., .. -i '.,; ~.~ ;;;:: ~:: .; i-:' .' .w ~ ~ S ~ ~. .- ~, ,.. >- C. "'. ,', ,:;. :; I': ;" l \.; ,,' I': " .~ ,.'. \' ~' ~\~ .; 0"'-- r . . ",..:11-" ~ <)..... (' ~ ,------ - <5 ~ 'Z 4 ~ _, 'i;: :z:; <J' i ~ ~;~: ~ 'l. -, 1:': ~~~~ U'" "l "" ~;! ,,;'3. ~ G t ~ ~ ~S " <' U : r.JJ ~ ~ ~ ?; ~ ~~.., ------ ~ '("-:;' 0<;" .'r:o .~ ::. -:r~." .. """ ~ . G <. "" e ~ , . , -. ,. ~ ~ ;<; ;-i .~. E . " (.....; -; ;3;, '1:- ~ ~ ~ , f ~ ~ . " -%-~ ~ " ~ Z ? b; .,'-", . ,. p."; ." III ; "Z :. ~ ,,, -: ","" .,.,.. ,,:;coO ....:' ." "* .....:, :r: f 5';~; ''''.' tr.:~ ~:~ ~~ ,~.. ~ . . " , .;. ~. " '" ~ ~ " (; f; ~ ":\. ., " ;\ ':. ~ 'f. C. ~ " ~ ~ ~ ," ... ~ ",;! " .....'" ."" 0"(>' '",< ._n~:; , .. " . , , ~ " , , , . . , ~ ~ " ~ , , , . " , . > " . S , , , t , " .. .- - , < . .. ~ ~ u , ;\ , ~ .- , - .. ~ - , " " " e .. , ~ .. , .- . - , ~ , . , 0 , " ~ . f'A- . , f-.--& " . ~ ~ ;:; .. " , . j;" ':: ~ ~ 0' .' " . . :~~ '1r ~ f. ~ - , , ~ .;' ., . . " ~ :a . .' ~' " , ....'...,'" = ~ " ~ ~ l,l ~ : .' .' , ....::; i. > ~ .J ..) ~ 8 0: 'P .", , -. , ". .. \.^'";- !C........ ~ ; , " , o ~ . --., \.) i\ "\ , ~ . Q 1 ~-; .~ . 1 1,:: ." ~i ~ ~e.. ,.;. H:. ~~~ i., ~ ,I i ~ ': ~ r;. ~~~ it,;','; ~ ~].. " , ~-\1 , , t'1 ",,'"< \,\'). i> , .- '( " k1 :0"1' .. > ! ~ < r~'i-\- <;.\\\' \\ ,I ~~~- --_.,---------- _..~,....- ~'-~--' _.~. I', _~~_' ~_~____-,~._._~._..__.n_ '-:---'"--.----~.~--~-'-~~~~'8,\r.,- - SURVEY /V'YV' ?,th, ,,4Vc ~. 340 49 ____ U~~~~r .\ Y\ .... l\I l~'\ ~ N 90000 00 - E f.!.q;SJ ~ 4.:;,:,v/Ylcd i3~";I'//7'1 Q") \ ~ L ~_v2:l~"d · IS' ~ T Sc:;! sj~ 'Y/Vn V> k?oc:::;l"" '1QP ;Cls ZljZ ~. G <\ \ @ ~ '" \ .. \l \\i 'J If) ~ \ ~ ".J \l ~\ ~ I s.c,L- s7$' /h:>'7\ k?ex=/ 4' Cap \ 1Zt. S 2/0Z. 10 ~ \ib~ \ \ If-iJ /5 z S /'/. 90" 00' OD' c= Cl . (\, 0.00 \ \ ~3 \ ~1) t 0~t- \ "'~\ '-15' ~ 0" \ I \ Zo Qo.,'!J) 5' , \ - - . ~ /2od #' C'q,P C) /2G. 5 'Z 1<::>2 \) ~: \ ~1~ I I\[) , ,. '. \ '" .. \ ., '1..:0i ~ ~~ (f.tJJ . 'J\..-, ~ I ,;\ \j - ~ I ~I \j i t\r- ",' ~\ ' .\ {,r>.,~ 20 0. ~I C;O. 0 = PLA PALM BE LEC 4 LOT 62, LES AND WE: \ \ \ . .? Scl s;la . )70/'} ~;2Dd 4' C4p ELS Z/02 ( ovo!!/h~C1d (. L.//lo!! \: Fo /~ 2'0' 4c:..~cY ----....-- ~ .---- --.---.-.--.- ----_.,.,- ,,-, { EXHIBIT "0" A. The City of Boynton Beach through its Infill Program acquires vacant properties. The properties are then given away to first time homebuyers qualified to participate in the City's Program. The community benefits from the Program by eliminating the slum and blight conditions (illegal dumping and overgrown lots) in the neighborhood, increasing the tax base, and providing affordable housing. The City has recently given two 60 foot road frontage parcels away Each parcel has at least one whole platted lot is 120 feet deep and contains 7,200 square feet. The 60 foot road frontage meets the requirements of RIA zoning and is the dominant sized lot in the 500 block ofN W 9th Avenue with l(one)- 52 feet lot and 2(two)-58 feet lots and the corner lots being the exception. All of the lots on the South side of the block are 120 feet deep which means that all of the inside 60 feet parcels do not comply with the 7,500 square feet RIA requirement. This zoning requirement has created a barrier that prevents the parcels from being readily developed in a manner consistent with the surrounding neighborhood. B The platting, development and construction of other homes in the community was performed by others over a long period oftime. The city has recently installed sewers and is working as a facilitator to complete the community C. There is no special privilege or particular benefit to building on a lot size consistent with as-builts in the immediately surrounding area. D There currently exists three developed properties on the same block that have least 240 square feet less than the subject property and three developed properties with the same (60 feet x 120 feet) 7,200 square feet. The rights of home ownership enjoyed by those property owners should be no greater than the rights of these first time homebuyers. E. The proposed homes exceed the minimum requirement of 1,250 square feet, meet all of the existing set-back requirements, will not cover more than 40% of the lot and the parcels meet the required 60 feet road frontage. The minimal 300 square feet variance is shared by other existing homes on the block and is all that is required to build on these parcels. F The granting of the variance does not affect the size of the home, required setbacks or the character of the neighborhood. It does eliminate vacant land, creates affordable housing, makes a positive impact on the community and increases the value of the surrounding"homes. i. I JUN - 8 200! L , .. rn .....:=-- n I ! ;, i 'i. " , ! .-..1 I " .J .,,, . , 1-0 4.20AC TRA I ~,. 1.- '\ .. ;;' 'j ~ ..... ~'e ~ -"'~ IL I b-- 1 1. :;".-::' ~, ;. ~ ~ .,~. ~r'~__ 13-I~Lt~-~~llftt~' ~'~' ~ ~ yo ~ . 'If 1.9 ~ W. ~:rd~!!!:1t=ri:......~"...~ "t Ji ~ ~ l :.')- I" .. '""' .!! ,i VARIA~CESJj1Ap"-; z: ~~' ~: :I~ : ,~; ~i ~~n~~ ; · .,0 z) -!- I~ .... \ .'''~ . '/" . ~ l~,..,. I" "./ ~ 1? I.~ w'~ . "'-. j, . r"'i J ;~ IJ.. 1-!- i ~~ ~ ~ .~. .~. .~..~, '~"').'_ "'V~ - JlW, . /4fTD \1 .. )..Al1E!;q"".;:;/ r~ i', ~ L} I' ~ ~ ~i. ~~.~~ j; ~.. 3-' ,1..,'). f1. "'. rw~A ';II _,._ ,,:\ ;.(;,~ /' I I \~~/ VZl If\ I '. <::7.' \JP;"~~J 2 -1- ,03AC AT IT LE....H. P....RCELS Ji41 ~ I -. .... .... ~ .... ..> \ - SF,W.M ~. .- ,oo'r:Af\TAl : " . ~ '.G;. 1Q9-3Q2j . "'.JM_ , ; ..},~;~.~ :-;~.~..d;.,; 1~'J;:'--~~:.' ~ , ;.... ~:. ,.!.:1.hf.;' 2 =~~ 2- ~ ;,.I~ } t ~ ,~;...,>:"' .. ,@<<\'~'\ ~pa:: ~";~~~~I~~1::lj4ml'~""~23.;;;~!~l':'.;.'~ ' - Iy \r - ;:,. J.. ~;;r ~"$- . ~ q ~ ~ .t/ .;y ~/ v O~,~7' x' ~.; _". j .NVr :.~" 56 .. I .,," 'M ... :' t~ .." /3' !C: : i:I;"" 51 o ';!> , ~ ~ ~!i' ~ !~r~:;i:. r~*',1~~ :~~~"I~ "" .~,; ..,?f(~ ~( · LC 'tfi~i41/;P.U.CI'I~rl?,Nr~ ~It .~~1J.~1~ i1o,H~~ i~~' ::~..)~' :305 "~RII57. ;~tt....?~ ",VARIANCES.I . . . I .'l~m~~i:::. I\.. .....f'> I..,.. .1.1. .1.\'1.'. ~, 1.46 AC P9441\\I~. t~ Am.,.. --.. I'>' . . 'i' , .". -.JIrv I"-' . . . d.';,. _ '.....~~ ~I~ ~r.lt- i ~ ltl-I~ ",L. ' ~~' ,~If!' ~ Y! ::::~:~ I~ :. )/0 I!' ~.. I~ ~,\' ~ "' :.:.:. ~ '.. ....lJ> lfl't 'I. ',. ". " :: I;;: z: :.:: ::-- ... " :; :;. ~ --:.; ~ ~!11~~ ~ ~~ <?/~~ +'i ~ ~ l;,;} 9 -~~.~ \~~!~~; 6 1 ... 51 3 t j..1b" ~ " ... . '0 .. .. ~ .. I.. r.;" 1." . ,f ...;;... "> -.. _ _ _. .... .... _ . ~ ~ N9. ..--.... -I "'l . 1.: Z!- . ~ ~ - t~ ;:~l~!. ~~ ~>. ~ t ~Jl:::::~ ~-; ~ ~~ ~~~~~; -b,;; f ~"/ .t; V t}ift ~i( 9~' .. 11- ~13 14 ~.l!- ~ '" ;iff!::.. " .:I,",-.t'I~I!'fJ; I" .. " -'- " I..~' - ~ !J.. -,,- - - -z: t! ;.,,~I~"~~I"~f5~IA~J~I~~1t .J}~}I~). ~..J..>-~4 ~' ,11; i i'~ 1. ~ f ~~ ~. " "~. In "LAI1I~LiI~Y.., I... .M>" "D'~ ' -'_ -THER VARIANCES '.NYV'; '-..' \~, \~ \~ \~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ rt ~ I~ 11~~1I1 . ~ ,j ~ll ~ . . .,. . ":::::::.:-::::=::::::: . I ~~1~ gt-- 81 ~ q; ~.i ...... y ;,.-- . . D Co" .. f7 ".30.%. 10( . ,,~ J!. t!- ?).. ~$- 32-' -I ,"0 l~" l'b:i9o J 1..:t.1.... 'f" I" I "" I C"~ .