AGENDA DOCUMENTS
II-PUBLIC HEARING
ITEM A.
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM
Requested City Commission Date Final Form Must be Turned Requested City Commission Date Final Form Must be Turned
Meetin2 Dates in to City Clerk's Office Meetin1Z Dates in to City Clerk's Office
0 March 20. 2001 March 7, 2001 (5:00 p.m.) 0 May IS, 2001 May 2, 2001 (5:00 p.m.)
0 AprilJ,2oo1 March 21, 2001 (5:00 p.m.) 0 June 5. 2001 May 16,2001 (5:00 p.m.)
0 April 17, 2001 April 4, 2001 (5:00 p.m.) 0 June 19, 2001 June 6. 2001 (5:00 p.m.)
0 May 1,2001 April IS, 2001 (5:00 p.m.) I25J July J, 2001 June 20, 2001 (5:00 p.m.)
0 Administrative 0 Development Plans
NATURE OF 0 Consent Agenda 0 New Business
AGENDA ITEM I25J Public Hearing 0 Legal
0 Bids 0 Unfinished Business
0 Announcement 0 Presentation
0 City Manager's Report
RECOMMENDATION: Please place this request on the July 3, 2001 City Commission Agenda under Public
Hearing. The Planning and Development Board with a unanimous vote of 7-0 recommended this request be approved,
subject to staff comments. For further details pertaining to this request see attached Department of Development
Memorandum No. PZ01-109.
EXPLANATION:
PROJECT NAME:
AGENT
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
GOLDSMITH DENTAL LAB
N/..
Jesse Goldsmith
2404 S. Seacrest Boulevard
Request for conditional use approval for a Dental Laboratory in the C-l,
OfficelProfessional zoning district at 2404 S. Seacrest Boulevard
PROGRAM IMPACT:
N/A
FISCAL IMPACT:
N/A
ALTERNA~
D' tor of evelopme
City Manager's Signature
~~ (J 1(-~
Director of Planning ul1 ning ity 1>/ mey I Finance I Human Resources
S:lPlannins\SHAREDlWP\PROJECTSlGoldsmith Dental Lab Agenda Request FOnD July 3, 2ool.dot
S:\BULLETlN\FORMSIAGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM.DOC
DEVELOP' ~~ :lRDER OF THE CITY COMf 's. N OF THE
T't OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLa.. ,A
p~ z.
.
~.
tt~
~.
PROJECT NAME: Goldsmith & Shenker Dental lab
APPLICANT'S AGENT Jesse Goldsmith
APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 207 SE 23'd Avenue, Boynton Beach, Florida 33435
DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: July 3, 2001
TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT Conditional Use Approval for dental laboratory in a
C-1 zoning district.
lOCATION OF PROPERTY 2404 S.Seacrest Blvd., Boynton Beach, Florida 33435
DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO
>< THIS MATTER came before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida
appearing on the Consent Agenda on the date above. The City Commission hereby adopts the
findings and recommendation of the Planning and Development Board, which Board found as follows:
OR
THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton
Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the
relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative
staff and the public finds as follows:
1 Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with
the requirements of the City's land Development Regulations.
2. The Applicant
...K- HAS
HAS NOT
established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested.
3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or
suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set
forth on Exhibit "CO with notation "Included"
4 The Applicant's application for relief is hereby
-X-- GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof
DENIED
5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk.
6.
All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms
and conditions of this order
DATED:
7-:?'-ol
\\\\\\\II11"'lIll
~\\\oYNro III~/"
:$' ~ ~"'itj /If .A ~
~ 0.- u .. 'U" ~
~ ~p );J~ ~ ~
- ;;.. ; "0 .,,:::
=1-: 0::
- . :c E
~ '". 920 j
~.... ~
~ ........... '*
~I .c-(OR\O~ ~\~
'III".. ..\\\'\
7
Other
Non~
ity Clerk
J:\SHRDATA\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Lab\Deve p Order.doc
EXHIBIT "C"
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
Project name: Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Laboratory
File number: CODS 01-002
Reference: 2ND review olans identified as Conditional Use Site Plan. File # COUS 01-002 with a Mav 29. 2001 Planning
and Zonina Deoartment date stamn markinll.
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS - General
Comments: NONE X
PUBLIC WORKS - Traffic
Comments: NONE X
UTILITIES
Comments: NONE X
FIRE
Comments: NONE X
POLICE
Comments: NONE X
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: NONE X
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments: X
1. At time of pennit review. submit signed and sealed working drawings of the X
orooosed construction.
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comment: NONE X
FORESTERlENVIRONMENT ALIST
Comments: NONE X
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments: NONE {'JOfle ""- A X
VI
MWRlec
\'CH\MAII'MHRDAT AlPlaaAiq\SHAREO\WPlPROJECT'S'Guldomitb.li: SbaWr Denial L..ob'Collllitio... of O{lp",~al doc
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
MEMORANDUMNO PZOI-I09
TO'
Chairman and Members
Planning and Development Board
FROM.
Lusia Galav, AICP
Principal Planner
DATE.
June 13,2001
SUBJECT
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Lab - COUS 01-002
Conditional Use Approval - Dental Laboratory
PROPOSAL SUMMARY
Since 1998, the Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Laboratory has been licensed at 207 Southeast 23rd Avenue.
The dental laboratory wants to relocate their business to 2404 South Seacrest Boulevard. Contained
herein is a description of the subject project. The proposed dental laboratory will be operated out of the
existing office building located 2404 South Seacrest Boulevard. The 0 44-acre parcel is generally located
on the southeast corner of South Seacrest Boulevard and Southeast 23'd Avenue. On August 15, 1989, the
City Commission approved this lot for medical office building. The applicant now is seeking conditional
use approval to allow a dental laboratory
Applicant! Agent:
Jesse Goldsmith
Project name:
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Laboratory
General description. Conditional use / minor site plan modification approval for a dental laboratory
Property size: 19,244 square feet (0.44 acres)
Land use: Office (Oe)
Current Zoning: C-I
Location. Southeast corner of South Seacrest Boulevard and Southeast 23'd Avenue
Total Building area: (See Exhibit "B" - Proposed Site Plan)
Suite or office area: I ,624 square feet
Surrounding land uses/zoning:
North - Right-of-way of Southeast 23'd Avenue, farther north vacant property designated Office (OC)
land use and zoned Office & Professional Commercial district (C-I);
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Laboratory - COUS 01-002
Page 2
Memorandum No. PZ 01 - 109
East - Developed professional offices, designated Office (Oe) land use and zoned Office &
Professional Commercial district (C-l);
South - Developed professional offices, designated Office (OC) land use and zoned Office &
Professional Commercial district (C-I), further southeast developed single family residence,
designated Low Density residential (LDR) land use and zoned Single Family Residential district
(R-l-AA); and
West - Right-of-way of South Seacreast Boulevard, farther west developed professional offices,
designated Office (OC) land use and zoned Office & Professional Commercial district (C-I).
STANDARDS FOR EVALUATING CONDITIONAL USES AND ANALYSIS
Section 11.2.D of the Land Development Regulations contains the following standards to which
conditional uses are required to conform. Following each of these standards is the Planning and Zoning
Division's evaluation of the application as it pertains to standards.
The Planning and Development Board and City Commission shall consider only such conditional uses as
are authorized under the terms of these zoning regulations and, in connection therewith, may grant
conditional uses absolutely or conditioned upon the conditions including, but not limited to, the
dedication of property for streets, alleys, recreation space and sidewalks, as shall be determined necessary
for the protection of the surrounding area and the citizens' general welfare, or deny conditional uses when
not in harmony with the intent and purpose of this section. In evaluating an application for conditional
use approval, the Board and Commission shall consider the effect of the proposed use on the general
health, safety and welfare of the community and make written findings certifying that satisfactory
provisions have been made concerning the following standards, where applicable:
I Ingress and egress to the subject property and proposed structures thereon, with particular reference to
automobile and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire
or catastrophe.
The subject property has two points of ingress/egress. The northern access is an existinff 27-foot wide
opening providing right/left turn in and right/left turn out only onto Southeast 23' Avenue. The
southern access is an existing 35 4-foot wide driveway providing right/left turn in and right/left turn
out onto South Sea crest Boulevard.
The on-site traffic circulation system for this parcel consists of two (2) existing two-way drive aisles
with widths that fluctuate between 19 feet and 28 feet. The driveways run along the parcel's east and
southern property lines. These two drive aisles provide access to the proposed use and its respective
parking areas. The sidewalks are located along South Seacrest Boulevard and Southeast 23'd Avenue.
2. Off-street parking and loading areas where required, with particular attention to the items in
subsection above, and the economic, glare, noise, and odor effects the conditional use will have on
adjacent and nearby properties, and the city as a whole.
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Laboratory - COUS 01-002
Page 3
Memorandum No. PZ 01 - 109
The parking that is required for the site has been tabulated for dental laboratory use. The ratio is
based on one (1) space for each 200 square feet of gross floor area. The parking that is required for
a dental laboratory does not exceed the parking that was required when the site was originally
approved. The total number of parking spaces required and provided equals 19, of which, one (1)
space is designated for handicap use. TIle handicap space is presently situated in the most
appropriate on-site location, closest to the building's front door
3 Refuse and service areas, with particular reference to the items in subsection I and 2 above.
The dumpster enclosure is located at the southeast corner of the site. This site is not required to have
a loading zone. The dumpster shares the access aisles. It is located in an area that is unobtrusive to
pedestrian and vehicular traffic and is unnoticeable from South Seacrest Boulevard.
4 Utilities, with reference to locations, availability, and compatibility
Consistent with Comprehensive Plan policies and city regulations, all utilities, including potable
water and sanitary sewer are in place via construction of the original permitted building.
5 Screening, buffering and landscaping with reference to type, dimensions, and character
With exception of the driveways, a landscape buffer up to 31 feet in width exists along the west
property line (South Seacrest Boulevard) and up to 25 feet in width along the north property line
(Southeast 23rd Avenue). These landscape buffers contain clusters of Sabal Palm trees and Silver
Buttonwood hedges. The interior and parking areas contain a wide varietv of plants, shrubs, and
trees, most of which are drought tolerant.
6. Signs, and proposed exterior lighting, with reference to glare, traffic safety, economIc effect, and
compatibility and harmony with adjacent and nearby properties.
This conditional use application is proposing no additional signs or lighting. There is an existing
monument sign located on the corner of South Seacrest Boulevard and Southeast 23rd Avenue.
7 Required setbacks and other open spaces.
The existing building meets or exceeds all setback requirements required of the C-1 zoning district.
8. General compatibility with adjacent property and other property in the zoning district.
In general, the proposed project is compatible with the existing medical/office use. The Bethesda
Hospital is nearby and there are numerous medical offices located within the immediate area. The
proposed dental laboratory is located within an area historically characterized by professional and
medical offices, comparable to that of a medical district.
There will be minimal on-site impact and no adverse effects will occur from the proposed dental
laboratory use. There will be little or no impact to the adjacent properties or to the general area.
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Laboratory - COUS 01-002
Page 4
Memorandum No. PZ 01 -109
9 Height of building and structures, with reference to compatibility and harmony to adjacent and nearby
properties, and the city as a whole.
The existing building was originally designed as a one-story office building. The exterior shape,
height, and appearance of the building will not be altered as a result of this conditional use
application. The current building height meets code and is compatible with neighboring properties.
The existing building facade, as viewed from South Seacrest Boulevard and Southeast 23rd Avenue,
has been designed to be architecturally compatible to this predominately professional and medical
office use area.
10. Economic effects on adjacent and nearby properties, and the city as a whole.
The proposed use will constitute additional convenience and choice for the members of the medical
and dental community It is anticipated that South Seacrest Boulevard will continue to develop,
redevelop, and intensifY as a professional office and medical district corridor The proposed dental
laboratory would be an appropriate use for this site.
II Conformance to the standards and requirements which apply to site plans, as set forth in Chapter 19,
Article II of the City of Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances. (Part III Chapter 4 Site Plan Review).
With incorporation of staff comments, the proposed project will comply with all requirements of
applicable sections of city code.
12. Compliance with, and abatement of nuisances and hazards in accordance with the performance
standards within Section 4.N. ofthe Land Development Regulations, Chapter 2, also, conformance to
the City of Boynton Beach Noise Control Ordinance.
With incorporation of all conditions and staff recommendations contained herein, the proposed dental
laboratory use would operate in a manner that is in compliance with the above-referenced codes and
ordinances of the City of Boynton Beach. In particular, the applicant will have to apply for and obtain
all necessary approvals and licenses from all applicable governing bodies.
RECOMMENDATION
Based on the discussions contained herein, compliance with development regulations, and the consistency
with the Comprehensive Plan, staff recommends that this request be approved subject to satisfying all
conditions of approval as contained in Exhibit "c"
LG/elj
\\CHIMAIN\SHRDATA\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Goldsmith & Shenker Dental LablCOUS suff report_doc
LOCATION MAP
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental Lab
EXHIBIT "An
I
11/ .," --I -!t ,1.>>;/ - ,:;1 LJ
1/ Jl _Jt!f.;; ~ L
Ifl_--~.- fR~ Ll..! " "YlP !~
Ii:; i_~ _ l~lb:;{h~~ JJ ; , "
fjj'l puc 11,67b. . !=
~._- ~i fhr.i'/.III'" :::;:,';;-' . I
h-;' ~.~,- "!~ hl_~'=lt C),lj
'/;;'1 .,~..".. ~ I ':';-":::C1,;- .JL.-,........
U( 6 II;~~~~.~J 1 ~ _~ ,:=-t- :J,
~. 'm - J'Jr:~J SITE~~""N \ C2 :1: \:-
rnw = I), ~. .l'1i~" I
Jl1 tB I-~ ,,/1 . ',~. i I II
C;:::;-' 'TI !~ .,) I ,:' . ; I
jJ == I- ~1 J', I 111 III
~- O-~V(, ~II
,
.I -~ .' ~ I III II
~Ipl ~,...., ~ [ , II h!
;...,---' HI- J~_' IIIIL
i' ---'- .. 1I.1....=
-'-' __ ~ ,I I
m - au. ~. (- I'
.::rn ,-1= jH , I
JJJ I-- j 1-.1. I
I-- I- . t1-!7 1 -....,
=t ~~ ~/II
II III ::J1L,~.
~ ~(l
.,~r 1 1
~l
- .
." w r:- f=g
II I I
T I ! I }-.- _ ._
+-l-- -
I I
T -
I
I '
'-- ,.
II-J-
.
IL-- .
'~.,.:
. - ,. -
. ,- -
- ..
.; F~Uil!tI!"'.'"
: -.....=Jf.;:I'iTI~~
:~
;~
~' :..-,..~
=,- ,; ~rl~:;~
l/')!~.',-"
l........~ ~:~".,
." _: ;~L!.,'I' :'1 EJ,
l -.. .'gli",,'::lrli
-:1 i . .. mrHiP~
!~_. -.-~.
I .'
t. ..el=l:
!_C)~ -
.i~'..
R3 !
Sj~ L:_
L.
;-
.
'r-
t,;- .- l'R f-
,I ,~t _ II
:/:bU:J-j"il __-- u l
U :,r\ Ii r-
i!L <~ i;j' '""'" I-"IEC
!r""-~ :3 -
i~:F~- IL ~ ~
.!~~ Q~: ,-/ l
. w! -
, ----' J
:=.ri'.~-~ 11::::1 !:Iv-
: 1---'-...:: ---- '
! //J '~
, I.. ....::11
, .
. .
.. f iF
I !. ,Ii ~ --
I :1 : '-.jI -
I, , ~ I-~ -
:'.p.~ ;,. ~ -.:: j!
. . r ,- ~I ,:3.: ~ I ,-/- i -
, '" .J -r --'--Te.- ",".
, I · i ;::, t-
IH s:: ..... -1--
j, , ~ I I~
R~ ~ I I ~. I 'LJ
':' ':,' ',,: r9. .' ~ I ': 1 J{J
, I ~ -1 . g. crbH----, 1/ f
,_ ;1 c rC;JT~' ~:' ~" . ~/l ~- L ~ Lt
--1 . '/ ~ .-- ,0 1/8 MILESV'" ~
. i' -j~~~:1 ~qfJj:~~c/~ II1I II
aJ~]-Hf-r NOT 1,_ _ 1~ 0 400 89.? F~~T "~"Y" 113/01
.l!\
I
i
I.-
I
I
1
11
I II11 II
R I ~~._
L-'-
~J:
pluo
.I...~ ......
~
~ . - .
~ i:
. . ~1
.
0
II ! ~ _, . . . i :,'
~.~'
0"
I::; ~
:lja", e
~~'i :
.3 0
"<jU !!O
~~~ 0
~
w
::J
Z
W
>1
~I
n
NI
~I 0
0
~
~
1 "
I
I
~ I
,
"},
~
,
!
.
I, ~
;1 . .
..':C 'i :r ~
!L : I".
. "-
'II II I ~
i . . .
- - -
f; 0'0 ....
i~ ~, ~ ~ ~
Ii i ~ ' , -
l;~ ~,Ze ~
; ~
."
<:=
,m <::::::::?
."
.!t'i~
~~
li
~ "': ~
~ ~ '3 d
~ ~ l!l ~
C :;~}!
i =
" ~
>
0-
(IJ <:.
" .
N.
~'"
,
i>
,
~
~
i~
!:\l_
. ,"
5!~ 1Ii~;
.~ l!Ii
h ;.,l~
I- ! '.
a;~ ~lll
a_.Il ~ al
! I ,1
'," I 11
""._~"_.~I
I'!I i
." .
t I~ i
liI;Jj .
l.o!;!, 1
J~!~!i i='~II!11111
(hhi~!:!~iiiiiii
il,l!
':2 , , ~ Io"''':g::!
.111> I,"' I,'!l~'l"
I .. , l$!"" ~lS
;;:!" 1-'; ,ll!~il,;;!
22'" ':1 'li !;; ..:/I
,I - !!'~'''!''
;,,1 ,I. ol.,'l"'l
!".,-, .11 ....'.~"~l
..~ s,!. l..b""i!5"!"~1=
'!'I'=.g I~~ .I;~; ~l~.
.',' ,.-'"
~.. ~ClS .i!;;~e ~~~=-
Iii';! !!~ i :i~!!i;'1
1.1,. 1" Ili'll:;,'I'
,lj" !~j '!' ." , ,
..~.;, lS~"~ .. ~i!l~i!lblig;
1'!lll 1.1, 11'1.11',,,
: ..~.... ..i.~ "illl;;~;~::
~=!ld ...~s 1Ill!l~.. ~d..:b~
~I
:-7 ""'......---....d'"
O.
"
.alii
b
>"
.. ~:;: ",.
",-.1<1 I( .
11~~]: C) i;- ~
~<1If-"":: Z .. ~..,
~~~ ~': >- Cl cr g ~ "',;
~~ a::: ~ 8(1)....
0::) .....<-
___ t/i_CD__~5_ ,O~ .., t
w w ~~ - ~
Z ~ ~G:; ,9 t
o t: G:':::: '"
o ~
t
,;n
.,
~
~
.'
,
~
,
I
I
I
I
I
10
I~
10
/:
.10
~I
I
I
I
I
I
! ~
I~
-c:: . 11'
I~
I ~ ~I
I I I
-Co=~~ 1 i~ I
I 15 I
I 10 I
I ::J ~ I
I~;'I
I ~ ~ I
I~-I
I I
I"'> :
I' I
1 ~ !
~I' I
I ~ I
1 S I
I. I
I I
~___ I I
I I
.;-.1 I I
1.9 /
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
~I
'I
EXHIBIT
iill ~ UIII
1.11 1.P'l
!I' ,"111
~ ! ,,'il - .Iili!
~ ;l!l It ~li:1
>l · ~I! I:,. 1llllli!
~ I :! Ill'! ii!lIi :
; i!1!'llli 'l!l:!~
~ "I;;ln! ..lllll
g i 11'!j' rli!.j.
~!.i 1 !;~l!!1
!!!'!~ 1 ".'lli! ~
'Ii! ~ ,1'11'1
j~!1 ' . !S'F.1I.
,..1, " 1 'b" -
,.l', , Iii"!
mil ! Ilill!i
.BL'Lal
1'I.81.(1I".IOS
~Y1d ,9ln,
.~
,
.
~
~
.
o
m
~
~
u
io
z c-
~
.
liB'!!
~~
~~
.'
_0
o.
~a
I ~ I~
. ~ I"
I! ~ ~
~ .
<
~
<
~
<
~ I
, .
~ .
~ I
I
.! ~
. <
, '
11 ~
III
1M
i h7
" l.!
P
'I
!
'I
('
'11 ~
I .
"I ~
II ~
'I ~
k ~I
II =
,I ~
II ~
,I .
II e
I "
i:
"I
~
,
o ~ ".i
'" ~. ~ ~~ci~
~ : ~i~
,O'~ ~ ~ }nt:
.. ~~;~.;.
}~~~~
t~H~
:i~(<i~_
o~
~ ~ ~--
""'0 . -
~z
~~
"
wo
~z
~m
u~
z~
au
u~
~
0, i
,0..
"
"
,O-r! '~I
~03.
-.. . _.... :~f
.(-, /'tl~~ ~
'""/ "."j!'~
ltt~i!..'
~h-t!~
~h:h
':l;t~~~t
'"
.~
=
o),~,'>"
'Vfy " 'It..
. -1,), -""::"
';1 II), ""-
,!;,. 0.0 '
i;~i ! V / "'--
i'~~ i ,I ~s.., ""-
11'1 !". v<:\;"
~h liQ= VL.
I!Il!i;1 v,) ""-
!iii!id!~ s ""-
~
~
=
i>
,
,
~
~I
Reference: Zonin" Code Variance Annlication ated Mav I
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS
Comments: None X
UTILITIES
Comments: None X
FIRE
Comments: None X
POLICE
Comments: None X
ENGINEERING DNISION
Comments: None X
BUILDING DNISION
Comments: None X
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: None X
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST
Comments: None X
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments: None X
ADDITIONAL PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS
I To be determined. X
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS
I To be determined.
EXHIBIT "C"
CondItions of Approval
Project name: Marie E. Premier
File number' ZNCV-OI-OIO (rear yard setback)
d
7 2001
S:\PLANNING\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\MARIE E. PREMIER ZNCV 01-010\CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL REAR SETBACK. DOC
DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION
MEMORANDUM #01.108
Staff Report for
Planning and Development Board and City Commission
Meeting
Date:
June 26, 2001
File No:
ZNCV 01-010 Rear setback from property line
location:
1521 NE 2nd Avenue (Lot #41, Block 17, First Addition to Rolling Green subdivision)
Owner"
Marie E. Premier
Project:
Tool shed addition to a single-family house zoned R-1-A
Request:
Request for a variance from the City of Boynton Beach land Development Regulations,
Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4.B, to allow a 16.58 foot reduction from the minimum of
twenty-five (25) foot rear setback required by code for a tool shed on a R-1-A zoned
property, resulting in a 8.42 rear yard setback.
BACKGROUND
The subject property and neighborhood are currently zoned R-1-A , single-family residential, and within
the First Addition to Rolling Green subdivision. The property is located on the west side of NE 4th Street.
Existing lot dimensions are the same as approved by plat in 1986 (see Exhibit "A" -location map). The
applicant has requested relief from the above-referenced code requirement to allow for the continued
existence of an approximately 224 square foot tool shed built within the rear yard set back. The tool
shed measures sixteen (16) feet by fourteen (14) feet, and eight (8) feet height (see Exhibit "B" - shed
floor plan). For a shed with those dimensions the code requires a twenty-five foot (25) rear yard
setback. The applicant placed it at 8.42 feet from the rear property line (see Exhibit "C" - survey).
Alternatively, if the improvement was not greater than one-hundred (100) square feet, and not higher
than seven (7) feet, the minimum required setback would be reduced to three (3) feet, side and rear,
providing that no easement is encroached.
Permits were not pulled for the work, and consequently, the project was cited. In response to the
citation, the applicant has submitted this variance request in hopes of obtaining the necessary permits at
a later day, and thus rectifying the code violation.
ANALYSIS
The code states that the zoning code variance can not be approved unless the board finds the following:
a. That special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or
building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the same
zoning district.
b. That the special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the applicant.
c. That granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is
denied by this ordinance to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district.
Page 2
File No. ZNCV 01-010
d. That literal interpretation of the provisions of this ordinance would deprive the applicant of rights
commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the terms of the ordinance
and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant.
e. That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of
the land, building, or structure.
f. That the grant of the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this chapter
[ordinance] and that such variance will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental
10 the public welfare.
According to the applicant's responses to the above criteria (see Exhibit "0"), it is the position of staff
that the applicant fails to satisfy hardship conditions for the following reasons:
1)- No circumstances appear to be peculiar to the land on which the structure is built. The subject
parcel's size and dimensions, as approved by plat, meet the current code requirements for a R-1-A
zoned lot;
2)- The variance is made necessary by actions taken by the applicant; and
3)- Staff does not concur with the position of the applicant in reference to the criteria "d' above, that if
this request is denied she will be" .deprived of certain rights." The subject property contains
sufficient space for the construction of a smaller shed within the required setbacks, and thus making
possible the reasonable use of the property
However, staff realizes that the subject structure impacts into the neighborhood will be minimized due to
the lack of visibility from adjacent properties. Therefore, staff feels that the variance request will not be
injurious nor detrimental to the public welfare.
Staff surveyed the surrounding area and it was observed that none of the adjacent properties have
similar sheds in place. It should be noted that City records show that a total of twelve (12) properties
within the Rolling Green First Addition subdivision have been the subject of variances approved since
1968. Eleven (11) of these variances have relieved code requirements for lot area, only one (1) has
been approved for a rear setback for an addition attached to the main buiiding.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that this request for relief from Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4.B, to allow a 16.58 foot
rear setback variance within the R-1-A zoning district, be denied due to the lack of traditional hardship,
and due to the circumstance being created by simple home improvements and unit iayout on a standard
platted lot. No conditions of approval are recommended; however, any conditions of approval added by
the Planning and Development Board or City Commission will be placed in Exhibit "E"
Staff shouid indicate that past variance requests have been reviewed by the city using more than the
traditional criteria, or interpretations of this criteria placing greater emphasis on economic potential,
minor home expansions, and characteristics of surrounding properties. For this reason, and to indicate
the consequences of denial, staff offers the following information.
1 The variance request is not for the main structure but for an ancillary use. a tool shed;
2. The subject variance request is supported by two (2) adjacent neighbors, one to the side and
another to the rear of the property (It should be noted the letters of support are for the
construction of the shed, not for the variance request); and
3. Approval of this variance request could be construed as support of or justification for
construction of improvements without proper permits.
MR/JA - Attachments
S:\PlannlngISHAREO\WPIPROJECTSIMane E Premier ZNCV Ql-01QISTAFF REP varrance setback.doc
; : II ' ! ! II i.tmrnJ 111111111 E l-liS' , ' I ! 1111111 I i Ii! ; I : 1111 I I i III1I11 i III ' ;,
,:::! I"I!I ~ = c Ill: 1 PLI. ffiHEHlEffittHiIleHrHiHJHEBs ~
lifT,' i I 111111 ., I! ",
", Ii' " r!TT' 'T . I, I" r--- :
I- ,II, ;., , li'lIl11 I II I :,.___,
Hili . . 'I ' L I l ! ; ill I I I . i I I I : ~ ! I , ' f
E 1lIl:lIi~illiilllllI!lIll!1Iill[]]!]!![ffi]]!] . II: II II 1/ ~ III '" v ~: . "1111
c ~:==~::::::::::I 'iU;:I~ h j::, Ir: I '~ ~t:: ::;:
~~li;I;~.';;JA ~~ ~ =U-11'lrRlltrmr I, '1= ::1111' .
f= ..~ =:='~F tt;\<<9M C .w 1'~rTJ7:>-. ~I-- 1= 'II:I!II ,
f::-' . ~I=:. c ( C'~ ~_!'\-- :::::::::: -'- 1= lllilll __
1= =i:il fiLnll! ~ rw ""L!.I" 1_ __. ~ ~ ~ ~ f- ! 1111
f- ~ .....\ fTiITIIill- / IIIT1 [Till - - f,....
~"~P~I'\ Urnl;~TT ~ ,ill I ==
P . - , ' I e:~~ f-r J :J IT :=
U l= = - lFiI 0 j =-
~1\\1 1-' - '= ,.. T')~I ::J I- H- H -
~ IN I- '--::-. Q:lITIIIJ... J- ,/ ,'\1::1 '. l:J
R ~ ar:arm 1-...... ~ 7 Ai -1 3 1I1I II t:O 1 /8
E - 11111 = 0 1 I I
C =- II III I J.J111JJ-f;l1. ~\ II1I1 II
l-- ,. , crlrnlliL-/ .1"1.1 Ili\ II' 'i
.::: ,,,,,.,,- ~-"O'''8E~~'f8L''fl- ."0 400800 FEET
I ~'1Tl11l I! II ==r-,.:I'II;lll'!"iTT'lt.JlT I " . 1111I'II'!dlilili .1 I IIT!II I ' ,
)'
----......
7
~i.
J 5
f
~
!
..I.
-I .-
I
~!I JIlt 1.~'~ !l.~:e-~ H- t ~ 1-- :~rn .. I -
;;/!f;. ~j' 1---1-- -- 1:: V- I,nfrtdll .
;ij ''f----~ ~I . H- I~' I I I I 11 r I . I: I. ;.1 I II c;:
\:I I I l.ftt (( ~ I
1// If :':~r'\-~ 11,Ir"II!i''''' I--,~\l,
! I'LI1' f-. ~ ,-
f!R C - I tT~m f-- - t"3 I ~
'/ -1' . ~rl r' 'I I _ _ ,~ '=\. ':
N'~,~Ir;:; ""-',,-c-. c- ,: ~ 1:11J: I--~l--jll'~ J--~
, c:::>,,\ ~ I ' III IF-
I,..f .: r- ~\: ~ I.-- ~r~ ONI c-c- r= 0.. ~
J"I,_j i ~- - ~0- ~~x~ "~-- L- -; ~ fcc-/
..w ~~.!- _ =:) : 'I-,~"'- Le-
, ::R'~. ?), +- -~ IIIf'1 n rCl--1 J:I:
/, . '. : ~ C-,.
~ ~ ' - <---A i ;--::t,.;SITE ;:::: l- .-;;
II ! I III1 _
: II : 1 I 111111 I "\
.. 'IIII!! ! 'I,
LOCATION MAP
Marie E. Premier Property
PU
~t:_'J_-__
"
._O"O_'h_'.._. ,
EXHIBIT "AU
..".""
""
If-REC--
, El3CUni
EC:
~
, ""'1"1
J H!i,.!i:'
:,;
><:
/,
': II'!.. ,Jl1Iillilf--
l ' ,; ,J II
~i '/93 ~ .(~":R 3
~_ -i ~~
, / i',
, "
........ . =
: II II"
I "'--I
,I. : ,
:/,
I' AI.'I
'... h ... , " G!:
,,,_ I! ,r-
~; ,
II t. I I'
t- I ,
~nm~~_
L "-
11I1111:f--ll..E
...
1111 li~-
illl 'f--J--
~. Uot
~--
~ .~ =:
-,--,=-
'I r-j=
I
-'--
'.- ==-
-
R3 ~
III ~
Efil i!,: Il
~'ILE~~
I.
~
= i
J ;
gh I 1-.
-' ,
.~ ~ wI' i :::J .
I III '
J~jh I U ' ~
<f) <f)<f)
(J 1~ zJ.. t <I lIJz
~ i ii I I:' o ~<I~
III "'2d)
; I !<l1JJ
I <f) lUO
,I, !: ,
" ,0
.' .'
l! '.
<0 ~ 6:
. " '2'
': li ~:t~
" ",
"j
~; lj ,I
, I
1
I
I
1
I
I
tl
~l
~
1 ~J 1
I L f
~___ ~ _~__e
~d
"
: ~
I
'i
~!
~
EXHIBIT "B"
II'
UI
- ~ ~
ft:l-ii
~w _
w~o
~::o~
lI'all!
~~~
Lu.jl-
dlZ~
~;:;;;o
r:~\!I
I
j
,
:1'
lit I
Cl t~ t
! ,,' l
J:'U t
I 1
! ,
i , : .
~ II '1
. !
,
i ,;" !
0 i{ ~ ~ , ~ ,
! ,2 . . "
,I ~ ~ ,.
"' ..
, ,I , ."
,. "
~ ~ 1ZJ8 gl
~ ~i
~l ~
",. ~I
!jj; ~ 211
~!
':
~~
I
,
q
I
Ii
3il
~[
~ ~U~~
." ~ i:
:1
L
1
0
! Z
.
! 0
, I-
:
j U
UJ
If)
UJ
~~
<t ;j
~ ~
<t ~
~s
. 1
,
.
,
8 "
! !
, .
, ~ Z
: 0
I-
U
UJ
If)
0
UJ
T.
If)s
'I
I,
II
1;1
I
I
I,
il
i
I:
I:
II
,
,
I
~ I zl
'-]~:[ ~
,. ~
II' ~ ~
~ B
~. j,
':ti ~ ~;j
"~ :;: 3 ~
~I
SK~H:O~ BOUNDARY SURVEY
, ~
). 1"=20'
I
-?
ci
~
m
~
::l
~
~_.\
-?
BLVD.
~
~
~
8
~
.
B
:=
~
~
.
HE.lsrhAVE.
..;
z
z
~,E. 15th (OURT
"IT
N E 1/.. ~h AVE.
LOCATION SKETCH
NOT TO SCALE
BOYNTON BEACH BlVQ
FOUND
2~XZ~ CONC MON
WITH IRON ROQ
lOT 3
BLOCK 17
S' UTIUTY
EA$EME.'1i
...
<-
~I
~5'
PLAT ~ 87"56')0"
MEAS ~ 88'05'02"
PLAT = 107.00
~
~
8.1.2-
I
16.1
_ .....000 _
i SHED i
~
~
:;;1
16,1
~I
~
:;:
I
51
~
;:;;:;i I
S
wI
5' 1_ 5' UTIUTY EASEMENT
I
t:
o
o
;0:1
,M
I'QUNOJ/l.IRQN \(
PIPE,NOeA? [~~ U"l
0.27 NORTH AT BASE
OF (ONC FOR FENCE PO~T
WITNESS CORNER
PLAT REFERENCE MIGlE
87"56'30"
CLF
PLAT = 110 44
.
.,;
=:
~
w
<
5-
it
LOT 42
BLOCK 17
MEAS = 107.21
FENCEPOST
ONLINE
'f
~
~
17.1
13 ,; "1521
~T 41, BLOC~ 17
ONE STORY
CONe.
RESIDENCE "
;,
21,..1
-
'i
I
MEAS ~ 110.56
LOT 40
BLOCK 17
I '
"
EXHIBIT "cr
FOR: MARJE E. PREMIER
PROPERTY ADDRESS. 1521 N.E. 2nd STREET 80YNTON 8EACH. FLORIDA 33
LEGAL DESCRIPTION: LOT 41. BLOCK 17. Firs~ Addition to ROLLING GREEN
ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 24, ON PAGE 8
OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING AND 8EING IN PALM 8EACH COUNTY FLORIDA.
SOUTH RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE
N.E. 15TH AVENUE
fOUND
lIZ"IRON ROO, (A.POESTROYED
N.E. CQRNER BLOCK 17
!1
:g<
r
~
~
:5
~
FOUND ~
Z"XZ" CO/'KMOH.l--
WlTH IRON ROO ~
1 ~
25M--'..
3.'- ~
~
3
,
~
0
,
...
r
'"
w OX
~ Q; '"
z 0;1
~ ~
~ z
< 0
~ 0
~ < Z ...
w 0 ~
< 'J "
~ r
~ w ~
< ~ ~
8 Z "
<>
': B N
25.0
S'
~
J
r~
5'
21,..37
J ,l,SPHAlT
c:! DRIVEWAY
~
~
'"
....
H
26.0
t6
,.
,;
1.6. 2'
~
'; CONe'" Z'(ON~W'A!Ji._
12.0
~
I""
~i ~
~j, a:
-,
~
CORD ANGL
PLAT:: 1710r
MEAS ~ 172"
0.20
SET lIZ" lRGN ROC
(APPlS 1,.299
DELTA ~ 17'24'36"
ARC LENGTH ~ 22.789
RADIUS ~ 7500
CHORD DISTANCE ~ 22.70 ~,
FaUND)l1,. IRON ROO
NO (A?
CHORD ANGLE
PLAT:: 79013'56" l'1EAS:: SQo
EXHIBIT "0"
Statements of special conditions and hardships.
1- I had to build the shed in this area in my backyard, because of the utility easement
and a tree located at the south side of the backyard.
2- I always wanted to build a shed in the backyard, and always knew that the way
it's laid out and where the utility easement is located, did not leave me much
choices.
3- Some of my neighbors do not have a shed in their backyard, by they built patio or
extended their back porch, thus this wilI not grant me any special pri vileges.
4- I believe that if I am deny this shed I wilI be deprived of certain rights, using
space available in my backyard to build a shed, and not being a nuisance for my
closest neighbors.
5- The shed is built strong, it is not a danger to me nor to my neighbors. Although
getting this permit wilI mean a lot to me, but according to the facts stated above,
issuing me this permit wilI be minimal.
6- I know that I unintentionally violated a few rules, but the main reason why this
chapter stated is the safety and welfare of the public. I know that for fact that I
did not violate this part. To support my conviction I have enclosed a letter from
my closest neighbors.
I thank you in advance for your understanding.
Marie premier, proud resident of Boynton Beach.
-lli ( ;Y;-l~ 1001
=J----
------.
rt
Zi~ . _-:-
~
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
MEMORANDUM NO. PZ 01-083
FROM:
Janet Prainito
City Clerk J!
Michael W Rumpf-
Director of Planni tning
TO:
DATE:
May 8, 2001
'It [ to"
SUBJECT
Goldsmith & Shenker Dental laboratory
Conditional Use/Site Plan COUS 01-002
Accompanying this memorandum you will find an application and supporting documentation
for the above-referenced case. A check in the amount of $1000.00 to cover the review and
processing of this application has been forwarded to the Finance Department.
The legal advertisement for this request will be forwarded to your office after review by the
City Attorney This request is scheduled for the June 26, 2001 Planning and Development
Board meeting and the July 3, 2001 City Commission meeting. Please advertise in the
newspaper and notice property owners accordingly
ELJ
Attachments
\\CH\MAINISHRDATA\Plannmg\SHAREDlWP\PROJECTSIGoldsmlth & Shenker Dental Lab\LegaINotice.doc
~
REQUEST FOR PUBLISHING
lEGAL NOTICES ANDIOR lEGAL ADVERTISEMENTS
A completed copy of this routing slip must accompany any request to have a Legal Notice or
Legal Advertisement published and must be submitted to the Office of the City Attorney two
(2) working days prior to the first publishing date requested below
ORIGINATOR: Plannina and Zonina Division
PREPARED BY Michael Rumpf DATE PREPARED' Mav 8. 2001
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF NOTICE OR AD' Conditional Use Approval for Goldsmith &
Shenker Dental laboratory in a C-1 zonina district June 26. 2001 - Plannina and
Development Board meetina and Julv 3. 2001 - City Commission meetina.
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS AND REQUIREMENTS: (Size of Headline, Type S'ize, Section
Placement, Black Border, etc.) STANDARD lEGAL AD
SEND COPIES OF AD TO' Property owners (postmarked June 16. 2001) within a 400 foot
radius of the subiecl property. applicant and the Plannina and Zonina Director.
NEWSPAPER(S) TO PUBLISH: The Post
DATE(S) TO BE PUBLISHED' June 16. 2001
APPRO ED BY J
(1) UJ.-tA B~v
(Originator)
).f/ f > ,('1.J.JAff
1:t ~ ~()O J
(Date)
(2)
(City Attorney)
(Date)
RECEIVED BY CITY CLERK.
COMPLETED'
~
I~OTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
Jesse Goldsmith has requested the following parcel located at 2404 South Seacrest Boulevard, to be
considered for Conditional Use approval.
Legal Description.
LOT 1, PLAT OF HIGH POINT, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS
RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 23, PAGE 225, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, lESS THE NORTH 15 FEET AND
TRIANGULAR PARCEL OF S.E. 23RD STREET AND SEACREST
BOULEVARD RIGHT-OF-WAYS. (A full legal description is on file in the
Planning and Zoning Division).
Proposed Use:
Dental laboratory
PUBLIC HEARINGS TO CONSIDER THE REQUEST ARE SCHEDULED BEFORE THE PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT BOARD ON TUESDAY JUNE 26, 2001, AND THE CITY COMMISSION ON TUESDAY
JULY 3, 2001, AT THE CITY HALL COMMISSION CHAMBERS, 100 E. BOYNTON BEACH BOULEVARD,
BOYNTON BEACH, BOTH AT 7'00 P M.
All interested parties are notified to appear at said hearings in person or by attorney and be heard or file any
written comments prior to the hearing dates. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the
Planning and Development Board and City Commission with respect to any matter considered at these
meetings will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim
record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the
appeal is to be based.
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION
(561) 742-6260
PUBLISH. June 16, 2001
The Post
~