CORRESPONDENCE
C ;,'/
)--"" -f "
/..... --'. 1':""
:J
, ,
, _ _T5~~n, " . '__ __ ':_'_ ---:::cc-- " /L_":l-:"Cf..-:'_'-~:~~/(1;~ _ ~:--:-:_~
T R EASjJ'jrt:~~C iJ i~ ~~jitfi?-NA!~: p ~A NN IN G Co U N-C:L
;if t,;,:'1' .
t "__ ,_ ,- _~
I ~DIA;'N:-lll~ E k "" '~K~~~-
C';
p tL\I BFA C H (j_-lST; I::iu C lit'
MEMORANDUM
From:
Mr_ Michael Rumpf
Planning & Zoning Director
City of Boynton Beach
Peter G_ Merritt r:h
Regional Ecologist\r
To:
Date:
September 14, 2004
Subject: Notice of Permit Application No. 040825-3
Bayfront
Attached is a notice of application for an environmental permit to conduct dredge and fill
or similar activities within or adjacent to your community. We are disseminating this
information for your review and comment.
The information provided with this notice is very brief: but you may contact the
permitting agency directly for further information if needed in order for you to assess the
impacts ofthe proposed activities on your community_
If the proposed activities are not consistent with your comprehensive plan or other locally
adopted plans or regulations, or if you have any other comments, please submit them to
the permitting agency by the deadline date indicated in the attached materials. We would
also appreciate receiving a copy of any comments you may have for our files.
Attachment
"Bringing Communities Together" . Est. 1976
lit Ealll Ocean Boulevard - Suite lit - Sluart, Florida 34"4
Phone (772) 2l1-4'" - SC 2"-4'" - Fax (772) 2ll-4'" - E-m.ail . .d.infi)tCI'DC our
.,'.
SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
3301 Gun Club Road, West Palm Beach, Florida 33406 . (561) 686 8800 . FL WATS 1-800-4-32-2045 . TOD (5(11) hY7-2."i74
M.liling Addre<o;s: P.O. Box 246~O, West Palm Beach, FL 33416 4.6t!U . www,5fwmd.gov
:?""".i'i~.
.'t~";, :;~'~:
i"', "''''1I'"i
: ';',f g.~ kf
NOTICE
t:J:; ~' 1 ?nn~
i-',~ .-
11:,)[ i.
August26,2004
Subject:
Environmental Resource Permit Application
Application No. 040825-3
Applicant Southern Homes of Palm Beach IV, LLC
Palm Beach County, S 4fT 46 SIR 43 E
The South Florida Water Management District is currently processing the attached application. If
you have any comments or objections concerning this project, please submit them in writing to
this office within 30 days of receipt of this notice.
This is also an opportunity for applicable State agencies to concur with or object to the proposed
project under the federal consistency provision of the Coastal Zone Management Act. Review
must be in accordance with the procedures adopted by the Interagency Management Committee
on October 25, 1989. Findings of inconsistency must describe how the project conflicts with your
agency's statutory authorities in the Florida Coastal Management Program and provide
alternative measures, if any, which would make the project consistent. Commenting agencies
must provide a copy of all consistency comments letters to the Florida Coastal Management
Program Director, Department of Community Affairs, 2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard, Tallahassee,
Florida 32399-2100.
Please refer to the applicants name and application number as referenced above in any
correspondence to help facilitate processing. Questions concerning this project should be
addressed to Rob Robbins at (561) 682-6951 or Tony Waterhouse at (561) 682-6867.
BAC:mw
Attachments
c:
US Army Corps of Engineers
Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Bureau of Protected Species Management
Department of State, Division of Historical Resources
Regional Planning Council
Department of Community Affairs
Palm Beach County DERM
G()VI.K'\i1r\'l~ Rtl/U\.I1
EXLCUllVL OnIG
Nicol:is J. L,util;rrez, Jr., Esq., Cllllil
l'.l111ela Brpoks Tho111a"" Fict'-Clllnr
lrl'la M. Bagul'
Michael Cullins
Hugh M. English
Lennart E. Lindahl. r.E.
Kl'vin McCuty
Harkley R. Thornton
Trudi K. Williams, r.E.
Ilenry Deem, E'-t"t"liti"t" Dirt'd"1"
, OWNERISI OF LAND ENTITY TO RECEIVE PERMIl ,or OTHER THAN OWNER)
NAME SOUTHERN HOMES OF PALM BEACH IV, LLC. NAME SAME AS OWNER
ADDRESS 12900 SDUTHWEST 128'" STREET ADDRESS
CITY, STATE, ZIP MIAMI, Fl 33186 CITY, STATE, ZIP
COMPANY AND TITLE SOUTHERN HOMES OF PALM CDMPANY AND TITLE
BEACH IV , LLC,
TELEPHONE 13051 971-0102 TELEPHONE I I
FAX I 305 I 971-6662 FAX ( I
AGENT AUTHORIZED TO SECURE PERMIT IIF AN AGENT CONSULTANT IIF DIFFERENT FROM AGENTI
IS USED)
NAME SAME AS CONSULTANT NAME ANTONIO QUEVEDO. P.E.
COMPANY AND TITLE COMPANY AND TITLE KEITH & BALLBE, INC,
ADDRESS ADDRESS 2201 WEST PROSPECT RDAD. SUITE 100
CITY, STATE. ZIP CITY, STATE, ZIP FORT LAUDERDALE, FL 33309
TELEPHONE I I TELEPHONE 19541 4B9-9B01
F-AX ( I FAX (954) 489-9802
Name of proJect, including phase if applicable BA YFRONT
Is this application for part of a multi-phase project' D yes [2J no
Total applicant-owned area contiguous to the project L46 ac
Total project area for which a permit IS sought 2.46 ac
Impervious area for which a permit is sought 1.14 ac
What IS the total area (metric equivalent for federally funded projects) of work in, on. or over
wetlands or other surface waters?
acres ~ square feet ~ hectares ~ square meters
Number of new boat slips proposed. Q
Project location (use additional sheets, if needed!
Countylies) PALM BEACH
Section(s) -1 Township 46 S Range 43 E
Section!s) Township Range ~
Land Grant name, if applicable N/A
Tax Parcel Identification Number
Street address, road, or other location 3440 NORTH FEDERAL HIGHWAY
City, Zip Code if applicable BOYNTON BEACH, FL 33483
"04(1825
"
,~
2
Desc'ibe in general terms the ~,oposed project, system, or activity. CONv I'RUCTION OF 3
STORY APARTMENT BUILDINGS CONTAINING 48 UNITS WITHIN A 2.46 ACRE SITE.
If there have been any pre-application meetings, including at the project site, with regulatory
stafL please list the datels), location(8), and names of key staff and project representatives,
Please identify by number any MSSW/Wetland resource/ERP/ACOE Permits pending, issued or
denied for projects at the iocation, and any related enforcement actions.
Agency
)ilIA
Date
No.\Type of Application
Action Taken
Note:The followino information is required only fOUJ.Qj~~....Qroposed to occur in,on or over
wetlands that need a federal dredae and fill Q...ermit and/or authorization to use state owned
submerqed lands and is not necessary when 8oo1vinQ solelv for an Environmental Resource
Permit. Please provide the names, addresses and zip codes of property owners whose property
directly adjoins the project (excluding applicant), Please attach a plan view showing the owner's
names and adjoining property iines, Attach additional sheets if necessary,
1. 2.
3,
4
)
3y signing this application form, I am applying, or I am applying on behalf of the applicant, for the permit and any
proprietary authorizations identi above, according to the supporting da nd other incidental information filed with
this ap~ication. j am familiar wltn the information contained in this application and represent that such information is
true, complete and accurate. I understand this is an application and not a permit, and that work prior to approval is a
violation, I understand that this application and any permit issued or proprietary authorization issued pursuant thereto,
does not relieve me of any obligation for obtaining any other required federal, state, water management district or local
permit prior to commencement of construction. I agree, or I agree on behalf of my corporation, to operate and maintain
the permitted system unless the permitting agency authorizes transfer of the permit to a responsible operation entity, I
understand that knowingly making any false statement or representation in this application is a violation of Section
373.430, F,S. and 18 U.S,C. Section 1001,
or Agent Ilf one is so authorized below I
Date
AN AGENT MAY SIGN ABOVE ONL Y IF THE APPLICANT COMPLETES THE FOLLOWING:
I hereby designate and authorize the agent listed above to act on my behalf, or on behalf of my corporation, as the
agent in the processing of this application for the permit and/or proprietary authorization indicated above; and to
furnish, on request, supplemental information in support of the application, In addition, I authorize the above-listed
agent to bind me, or my corporation, to perform any requirement which may be necessary to procure the permit or
authorization indicated above, I understand that knowingly making any false statement or representation in this
application is a violation of Section 373.430, F.S, and 18 U.S.C. Section 1001,
HECTOR GARctlA JR, \
iV\~I!\
Typed/Printed .~~ ~~~caot
''-- 1;Y~ '-'\ \~~1
" ,
Signature of APPli~ant1~.ent ')
-....~_/ ' ,
PRESIDENT '---./
(Corporate Title if applicablel
Date
Pl~,9~~~Jto~~..;~IhEt ilRPlicaJ,l( s__gdginaLs_igJJ~:t.Yre_lnoL~_f_QJ~Y-~~_.@J:Illire.d _~p_o_v_eo!
PERSON AUTHORIZING ACCESS TO THE PROPERTY MUST COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING:
I either own the property described in this application or I have legal authority to allow access to the property. and I
consent, after receiving prior notification, to any site visit on the property by agents or personnel from the Department
of Environmental Protection. the Water Management District and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers necessary for the
review and inspection of the proposed project specified in this application. I authorize these agents or personnel to
enter the property as many times as may be necessary to make such review and inspection. Further, I agree to provide
entry to the p/\oJect Sit \:or such agents or personnel to monitor permitted work If a permit IS granted.
HECTOR G~i;
TypedlP"nteu'~,a, ~ V!
,
I
Signature of Ap~llcan\;JAgent )
'---..-/ ',~~
PRESIDENT
(Corporate Title if applicablel
R,ts'M..t1'
Date
4
ACOE Application #
Date Ap;:llication Received
,Proposed Project Lat. _0__
FOR AGENCY USE ONLY
DEP/WMD Application #
Date Application Received
Fee Received
$
Fee Receipt
Proposed Project Long. _0__
#
SECTION A
Are any of the activities described in this application proposed to occur in, on, or over wetlands or other surface
waters? 0 yes [;2J no
Is this application being filed by or on behalf of a government entity or drainage district'
o yes ~ no
A. Type of Environmental Resource Permit Requested (check at least onel
o Noticed General - include information requested in Section B.
o Standard General (Single Family DwellingHnclude information requested in Sections C and D.
~ Standard General (all other projects) - include information requested in Sections C and E.
o Individual (Single Family Dwelling) - include information requested in Sections C and D.
o Individual (all other projects) - include information requested in Sections C and E,
o Conceptual - include information requested in Sections C and E.
o Mitigation Bank Permit (construction) - include information requested in Section C and F.
( If the proposed mitigation bank involves the construction of a surface water management
system requiring another permit defined above, check the appropriate box and submit the
Information requested by the applicable section, I
o Mitigation Bank (conceptual) - include information requested in Section C and F.
B. Type of activity for which you are applying (check at least one)
~ Construction or operation of a new system Including dredging or filling in, on or over
wetlands and other surface waters.
o Alteration or operation of an existing system which was not previously permitted by a WMD
or DEP,
o Modification of a system previously permitted by a WMD or DEP. Provide prevIous permit
numbers.
o Alteration of a system 0 Extension of permit duration 0 Abandonment of a
system
o Construction of additional phases of a system 0 Removal of a system
C. Are you requesting authorization to use State Owned Lands. 0 yes [;2J no
(If yes include the information requested in Section G.)
D. For activities in, on or over wetlands or other surface waters, check type of federal
dredge and fill permit requested:
o Individual 0 Programmatic General
o General 0 Nationwide CZJ Not Applicable
E. Are you claiming to qualify for an exemption? Dves 0 no
If yes provide rule number if known.N/A
~.:-c;,v
=;l
!
"
L~-~
I S:;'J ;;; I <3 ~:;; i ,},"::
l :,\'-; i ':1 I;:"\/E
11.~Gj~yt.IIIL~lllJ : :. Vr;:
'lpr..ClJ'NI -
:;V 11 i iJ,vE:
,
'I \NM,C,'qU(\F'l:','~; I
.y," ~ 1,\,.jF
'~~v'IUT 13 I i-Wr-
SW ~I 11} ~I AVE
IDOt,JR1IFlUGI}{l Ii
,,?....
~
"
!':II -
~\ .. ,
,~' l.t.J
V
0
'-'
,,~ I,'.' j,C'
_L__~
:::;,1
',';1-.1,:..
~':r~-"
r.s.
(" J
-
:T LOCATION
~
:E 34 AVE
~
~ ~
35 ~
w_
.......
[-.,
~
~'
"---<
~
,
-J
:-...,
~.}-1t-2004 03:26pm From-RUDEN t.<<:CLO' 18TTH NTST
+9547644996
T-614 P 002/002 H70
~~ Ruden
~IIMcClosky
200 EAST BROWARO BOULEVARD
FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33301
~ST OFFICE 80x 1900
FORT I.AUDERDA~[, nORIDA 3;no:t
(954) 527-2476
r.....x: (954l D).o1.076
BON N1E,MIS KEl@RUDEN,COM
May 18, 2004
~o~--;'r- r'
"
VIA FACSIMILE
MAY ".
Mike Rumpf
Director of Planning & Zoning
City of Boynton Beach
I 00 East Boynton Beach Blvd.
Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310
.----__1
-----
Re: Items JIl.E.2 and E.3 and Item JIlIl.A. 011 tile May 18'h City Commission
Agenda
Dcar Mike:
This letter is intended to clarify a misstatement contained within the reports provided to
the City Commission for the above referenced items. As you know, 1 represent Southern Homes
in connection with the development of their multiple projects_ Contained in the reports for the
items referenced above is a representation that the units are to be sold as fee simple townhomes-
That statement should be corrected to reflect that the units shall be sold as condominiums_
As the description is nothing other than a description and is not substantive by nature, I
am sure that the clarification will have little effect on your conclusions of your staff report;
however, I felt that it was important to clarify the record to reflect that the units shall be sold as
condominiums.
If items Vl.E.2 and E.3 need to be pulled from Consent to correct the nature of the sale,
please leI me know. Otherwise, please forward this information to the City Commission for their
reVlew.
If you need additional infonnarion, please call.
Sincerely,
~~~
Bonnie L. Miskel ~6)
BLMfbab
cc: Carlos B[,lIbe (via fax)
FTL:t216670:1
RUDEN, McCLOSKY. SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL. PA
CAItAC\S. FT. LAlJO~KOAU . MIAMI. NAPI,ES - ORLANDO. PORT SI. LUCIE. SARASOTA . ~T_prnRSBlJRC - TALlAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH
~ay-la-2004 03:26pm From-RUDEN MCClO' 18TTH NTST
+9547644996
T-614 P.OOI/002 F-970
~ Ruden
~bMcClosky
zoo EAST 6ROWARD BOUlEVA~D
FORT lAuDERDAL~, FLO~IOA 33301
(9S4) 527-2476
FAX: (954) 333-4076
eON NIE.MISKEl@RUDEN,COM
FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
DATE:
May 18,2004
FROM:
Bonnie L. Miskel
FILE NO.:
40086-0006
NUMBER OF I'AGES:
2
(Including this Cover Page)
lfthere are any problems or complications, please notifY us immediately at (954) 764-6660.
TO:
Mike Rumpf
COMPANY:
City of Boynton Beach
FAX NO.:
(561) 742-6259
COMMENTS:
~~
~
~-{ ;-:;-
("Llfl,
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN TJ-IIS FACSIMILE MESSAGE IS ATTORNEY PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION INTENDED ONLY FOR THE USE OF THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY NAMED ABOVE. IF THE READER OF THIS
MESSAGE IS NOT TliE INTENDED RECIPIENT, YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT ANY DISSEMINATION. DISTRIBUTION OR
COPY OF TIllS COMMUNICATION IS STRlCTL Y PROHIBITED. IF YOU HAVE RECENED THIS COMMUNICATION IN ERROR,
PLEASE IMMEDIATELY NOTIFY us BY TELEPHONE (IF LONG DISTANCE, PLE"SE C"LL COllECT) AND RETURN THE
ORiGINAL MESSAGE TO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS VIA THI! U$, rOSTALSERVICE. THANK YOl!o
FTL; 1156050; 1
RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A.
(:ARACAS.fl LAUDER[).\~~ 'MIAMI' NArl.fS' PORT ST.lUCIE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG 'TAl~AHASSEE' TAMPA -WEST PALM SEACH
3-25-20042,18PM
FROM PLANNING AND REAL ES 561 434 8187
P.4
lHESCHOOI. OlSlRICTOF
PALM BEACH COUNTY. flORIDA
PlAN>IINGDEJ'W(TMENf
3320 FOREST HIll. BLVD., C-331
WEST PALM BEACH. FL 33406-5813
(561)' 434-8020 FAX: (561) 4~187
ARlMUR C. JOHN5ON, Ph.D.
SUPERlNl1lNOENT .
March 23, 2004
Mr. Dick Hudson, Senior Planner
City of Boynton Beach
100 E. Boynton Beach. Blvd_
Boynton Beach, FL 33435
RE: C9NCURRENCY DETERMINATION - CASE NUMBER #04031901C - BAYFRONT .
Dear Mr. Hudson:
The Palm Beach County School District has reviewed the request for a Concurrencl'
Determination on the above referenced project for 48 apartmemts for Bayfront.
Attached please find the approved' Palm Beach County School District Concurrenc~'
Application and Service Provider Form for Bayfronl This Concurrency Determination is valid
for one (1) year from the date of issuance. Once a Development Order has been issued fo-
the project, the concurrency determination will be valid for the life of the Development Order.
If you have any questions regarding this determination, please feel free to contact me at
(561) 434-7343. .
David L. DeYoung,
Planner
cc: Carlos J. SaUbe, P.E. of Keith & Ballbe. Inc.
i"; MARl52UU4
l__~~__;';.- ._-
i
__-1 I
,',''1'1 (
l___J
ene.
S:\Planning\Public\1NTERGOV\Concurrency\Con=nc)' Determination Lell0ls\Concurrency\C0403190 I.doc
AN EQUAL QPPOI(rUNITY EMPlOYEIl
3-25-2OOIl 2.19PM
FROM PLMN I NG AN:> REAL ES 561 A.34 81 87
P.5
~OOLO~
~(2Ja
~1WOt~
The Sohool DIstrIct at Palm ....ch Count]
-ng-'
3320~H11I31vd.c.1R
WaI: ~ Beech,IIl.. 334OI-6G1~
Phone; (561) 434-1800 01'(561) 96S-38'77
F.x= (581)'3408187 or(581)~1~
-,eoncun.nq
The School District of Palm Beach County
School Concurrency Application & Service Provider Form
lnstnldlons: Submit one copy of the oompIeted app8catlon and fees for uch new residentlBl ~c:t
requiring a detenninaUon of c:oneulftnCy for schoo... A detenniMtion wbr be provided within fifteen (15)
wor1dng days of .-ceipt of a comptete application. A determlllatIon Is not Inll\$ferable and Is valid for one year
from date or ~. Once the Development Order Is issued, the concurrency de1erminlltil:m shaQ be valid
for the lie oftt,. D9vetopment Order.
PIMa ched( ("') type of .pplk:atlon (l)ftf onIy):
I J Conourrenoy Dele""....... I l Concun.ncy ___ r I ConcIJITOflCy equivalency
I J Adequate Sd100I FocIIIti.. DolormlMtion I l L_ of No Imp... I J TIme Extension
IIMs: Cancunwncy D*rmInatIon ,. AdtqtMI!I School F.acII6H DetilnnIN&n ($200.00 fw men than 20 units '20
unIII or.... $100.00); EqulvWncy ($12S.00); &x.nptian or Letlerof No Impact ($25.00); Tbne ~
($10.00)
. ~';;";;:~;;;';;~~~~!!2!:V~;;:.,~~?
"'*"' Name, BAYFRONT MunloipalH", OTY OF BOYNTON BEACH
P_ Control Number (PCN)' SEE ATTACHED EXHIBIT 'A"
Looatton/_ oISu_ Propeny, 3440 N. FEDERAL HIGHWAY, BOYNTON BEACH FL. 33483
oevaOPUENT REQUEST:
-
SA c 2-/5
Sir\! leF
Mulli-Femll Other Ihf:n.. rtments:
... lrtments 3 stories or Ie88
H h RIse r1men\s
e Restricted ufts On
"~.pluuMlaCtl.PI\f$Il'IgPlllrlshcMtnsllhlinumb8randlypedtnllltl..:eiVe~c*ofocoup~yMr1y.
.. A~8l/klMCowInMl;iI~for~llOIMll//'IllII&.
OWNeRSHIP I AGENT INFORMATION,
0Wner'. Name, SOl1Tl1ERN ~ES OF PALM BEACH IV. LLC
Ag*r'rt". Name: KEITH &. RA!_ me. .
Mailing _s: 2201 W. PROSPECT ROAD. sum 100
Telephone Number:
. t.Nby certlfy tIlII ........... Of Ir1rormdon IMde In tiny ,.,.,
""_.
',",.
OWner or
D
'k ::\
Date Application Filed:
_!ly:
&~~~~~~?
vernment ~ Signature
A1i'GOVl: 1M"
P '."Number. ~ ~I
Tfde: H:~"A' ..-
~s (P'j._lIIlachgrooto(~)
~iO 1~~~canl!TlUlt~trteSo:fto;ll~The
~""","""""'_""""'_,
"'Dote:L/ecel:~ART.~fi3iOf-=$=:~~~~3f~'oid
I Wlrify thai: the projoct COlTllfies \'ltlh tie al2optecll..... 01 s.Mot (I.OS) for SchooIa
I WfIry Nt II>> pro;ect wi.,.Qllrfw with the adopIed lAvel 01 SelvIce (LOS) for Schoolt ~ct Ie ..
--ev
Icannot_........_~oI:-(LOS~'i..~O, I
~.~
Department of Engineering
and Public Works
P.O. Box 21229
West Palm Beach, FL 33416-1229
(561) 684-4000
www.pbcgov.com
.
Palm Beach County
Board of County
Commissioners
Karen T. Marcus, Chair
Tony Masl!otti, Vice Chairman
Jeff Koons
Warren H, Newell
Mary McCarty
Burt Aaronson
Addie L Greene
County Administrator
Robert Weisman
"An Equal Opportunity
Affirmative Action Employer"
@ printed on recycled paper
February 20, 2004
Mr. Michael Rumpf
Director Planning & Zoning
City of Boynton Beach
100 East Boynton Beach Boulevard
Boynton Beach, FL 33425-0310
RE: Bayfront
TRAFFIC PERFORMANCE STANDARDS REVIEW
Dear Mr. Rumpf:
The Palm Beach County Traffic Division has reviewed the traffic statement for the
proposed residential project entitled; Bayfront, pursuant to the Traffic Performance
Standards in Article 15 of the Palm Beach County Land Development Code, The project
is summarized as follows:
Location:
Municipality:
Existing Use:
Proposed Uses:
New Daily Trips:
New PH Trips:
Build-out:
West side of Federal Highway, near Turner Road.
Boynton Beach
Vacant
48 MF Residential Units (Apartments)
315
25 AM and 30 PM
2005
Based on our review, the Traffic Division has determined that the proposed residential
project is located within the Coastal Residential Exception Areas of the county, and
therefore meets the Traffic Performance Standards of Palm Beach County. No building
permits are to be issued by the town, after the build-out date, specified above. The
County traffic concurrency approval is subject to the Project Aggregation Rules set forth
in the Traffic Performance Standards Ordinance,
If you have any questions regarding this determination, please contact me at 684-4030.
Sincerely,
File: General - TPS - Mun - Traffic Study Review
"1,'
L '"
F :\TRAF F IC\malAdmin\Approva 18\040214 C. doc