AGENDA DOCUMENTS
~ 'K- 6=>fr
Requested City Commission
Meeting Dates
D August 2, 2005
D August 16,2005
D September 6, 2005
D September 20, 2005
NATURE OF
AGENDA ITEM
Date Final Form Must be Turned
in to City Clerk's Office
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM
R",""", C'ly COmmi",2 ""
Meeting Dates in t
July 18,2005 (Noon.) D October 5, 2005
August 1,2005 (Noon) D October 18,2005
August 15, 2005 (Noon) D November I, 2005
September 6, 2005 (Noon) IZI November 15, 2005
October 3, 2005 (Noon)
October 17,2005 (Noon)
October 31,2005 (Noon)
D Administrative
IZI Consent Agenda
D Public Hearing
D Bids
D Announcement
D City Manager's Report
D Development Plans
D New Business
D Legal
D UnfInished Business
D Presentation
RECOMMENDATION: Please place this request on the November 15, 2005 City Commission Agenda under
Consent Agenda. This item was tabled, at the applicant's request, from the November 1st meeting to the November 15th City
Commission meeting. The Community Redevelopment Agency Board recommended that the subject request be denied on
October 11,2005. For further details pertaining to the request, see attached Department of Development Memorandum No.
PZ 05-186.
EXPLANATION:
PROJECT:
AGENT:
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
PROGRAM IMP ACT:
FISCAL IMPACT:
AL TERNATIVES:
Majestic Gas (ZNCV 05-007)
Rajesh Patel, Raj Properties, Inc.
N/A
302 West Boynton Beach Boulevard
Request for relief from the City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations,
Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4-L, requiring a six (6) foot solid, stucco masonry wall, to
allow a six (6) foot vinyl.pr wood fence in a C-2 Neighborhood district abutting an R-I-A
Single Family Residential neighborhood.
N/A
N/A
N/A
City Manager's Signature
LtJ
?-~
Planning and Zo Director City Attorney / Finance / Human Resources
S:\PlanningISHARED\WP\PROJECTS\302 W. Boynton Beach Blvd\ZNCY 05-007\Agenda Item Request Majestic Gas ZNCY 05-007 11-15-05.dot
S:\BULLETIN\FORMS\AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM. DOC
Meeting
Date:
File No:
Location:
Agentl
Owner:
Project
Name:
Variance
Request:
Droperty
cation:
North:
South:
East:
W4!st:
PJCYCLUIIMI:NT DEPARTMENT
P' "NNING AND ZONING DIVISIC
.4EMORANDUM NO. PZ 05-186
STAFF REPORT FOR
COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT BOARD AND CITY COMMISSION
October 11, 2005
ZNCV 05-007 Buffer Wall
302 West Boynton Beach Boulevard, Boynton Beach, FL
11 r of
Rajesh)Patel, Raj Properties, Inc.
373 73/u.o-
f n sf.
. fl~ J ~ ;2 (1.:Y-
f...- 5 e' (_ W
5e;> vI' J; ~
{;
4i' '''''t, ~<:s{3 - &J4.J.. ("'t- u;<<S d- buff< (J~
Relief from Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4,L - Buffer Walls, to allow a six (6) foot
fence along the south (rear) property line in lieu of the required six (6) foot stucco
masonry buffer wall required to separate a commercial district from an abutting
residential district.
-1?~ e /L t'.:; -r5~ 1;.-.,., c.e , 6;<-.> t~"^~~J:2 akLlL- ~ rtf
Uc- v>-~ a! Ji4-,.zd2.r~ c~rn~ ,
The site is located east of I-gs::ron the south side of Boynton Beach Boulevard (see
Exhibit "A"-Location Map), The subject property, totaling 0.7 acre, is currently
zoned C-2 (Neighborhood Commercial) and classified Local Retail Commercial
(LRC). The subject site abuts Boynton Heights to the south, a residential
subdivision zoned R1A,
Majestic Gas
The following is a description of the land uses and zoning designation of the
properties that surround this site:
Right-of-way for Boynton Beach Boulevard, farther north property classified Local
Retail Commercial (LRC), zoned Neighborhood Commercial (C-2) and developed as
professional office uses;
Properties within Boynton Heights subdivision classified Low Density Residential
(LOR), zoned Single-Family (RiA), and developed as single-family residential;
Right-of-way for NW 2nd Street, further east property classified Local Retail
Commercial (LRC), zoned Neighborhood Commercial (C-2), and developed with
residential use; and,
Property classified Local Retail Commercial (LRC), zoned Neighborhood Commercial
(C-2), and developed as professional office use.
\ajesh Patel of Raj Properties, Inc., owner of the subject property (Majestic Gas), is requesting a
Lonlng code variance to seek relief from Chapter 2, Section 4,L. of the Land Development
Regulations, the applicable part of which states as follows:L \),5 Pd.-II" y cs L ~ e (cC Of
0/ ~cFn-;-r~? {(4lJ~(( '5 r= b. k,c. .e-/ ~j~ /~ - tC-,/ or-
L. BUFFER WALLS. For new construction or major modification to Clexisting developments, -rh
where a commercial and/or industrial district abuts a residential district, a solid, stucco 0 . =r
masonry wall painted on both side at least six (6) feet in height shall be located within the/l tJ'J<::-:r
required side and/or rear yards except with respect to corner lots, said buffer walls shall
be required only on interior lot lines, Said buffer walls shall not abridge any easement
rights or be constructed over any existing utilities in any easement area and shall be
setback two (2) feet from adjoining property lines.
rJ - (..to f1.etSC>^- ,y
rD 777( .=;f....cc:-->L- p'-<~ (
y,f- :.---. ~ / (
P l~ -co;.J, ~ l)G... c...-
C (r.. /e-i j ~ h. ffC5.t.
--r NATURE OF REQUEST r Ly S/Ct.. { (y S,~?~~-.r
Sc.( c~ "'-
u..r
---
, M;~orandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCY 05-007
It is important to note that commercial properties, due to the intensity of their uses, are required
to provide for additional buffering to minimize land use conflicts when located adjacent to
residential neighborhoods. Landscaping elements, including dense vegetation, berms, and
buffer walls, can provide effective barriers, and mitigate the impacts of unattractive views,
vehicle headlights, and noise, without sacrificing the functional necessities of the commercial
site, Advantages of a masonry buffer wall, rather than a fence include the following:
· walls act as sound barriers and can substantially reduce noise associated with a gas
station use;
· walls can withstand high winds and are more durable and provide more stability than a
fence;
· walls help contain gasoline emissions, headlights, and store security lighting to gas station
site; and,
· walls are attractive, fire resistant barriers, and require lower maintenance than required
for fences, :s;6-ff af'nJ )1.. ,;{a--.cf2s f,p
- e'U~ '''It!!.)r.. ~ r (~ ,,&:"5c.o-p/"y -=*....,s
BACKGROUND YJ ~r ~ <.:~~ ~.<Y JF .J
- ~ A ~f-;Cr ~~ /s- r"'t c-,r d)
The existing gas station is considered a nonconforming use due to its location and ~r.
noncompliance with current code requirements such as conditional use approval, and 5,....~;. <_
buffers/landscaping. The construction of the buffer wall became a requirement in connection .sC:"'--I'\"""I;;~
with an upcoming application request from the owner for a major site plan modification. The
applicant intends to remodel the existing gas station building by closing the automotive repair
operations in the garage and using that existing space to increase the size of the convenience
store, The applicant is prohibited from adding on to the building and increasing the building
square footage on site, which would be considered an expansion of a nonconforming use.
The buffer wall is required only along the rear property line adjacent to residential, and is
required to be at least six (6) feet in height and located at least two (2) feet from the rear
property line so that it can be maintained without trespassing onto adjacent properties. The
;--"'I1/cant is proposing to construct a six (6) foot fence in lieu of the required minimum six (6)
. ~ masonry wall along the south property line that abuts single-family residences in a
subdivision zoned RiA.
Memorandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCY 05-007
Previously, a concrete slat or louvered wall was located along the side interior and rear property
lines, however this wall was recently removed by the applicant after it was damaged, Aerial
I)hotographs from approximately 2003 indicate the site was also densely buffered along the side
.nterior and rear property lines, but current site conditions do not include any buffers, Due to
the recent removal of the buffer wall and most of the vegetation on site, the gas station site is
now very visible from adjacent residential properties to the south and southwest. The side
interior (west) and rear (south) yards of the service station, which are the highly visible areas
from adjacent residential properties, are used for dumpster service area, tanker truck parking for
filling up underground fuel storage tanks, unscreened outdoor storage of dozens of used tires,
and propane tank storage.
Florida Power and Light has a three (3) foot wide utility easement which runs along the rear
(south) property line of the subject property. Some existing vegetation along the rear property
line is located within this easement, and has been cut back so it does not interfere with the
power lines. The majority of the vegetation along the rear property line is unhealthy, weakened
by irregular pruning and storm damage, or consists of undesired exotic species. Landscape code
requirements address landscaping within easements: buffer walls are to be located outside of
easements for access purposes, and canopy trees are required to be planted outside of
easements so that roots and branches do not impact existing utilities.
ANAL YSIS
The Board has the authority to grant a variance that will not be contrary to the public interest
when, owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the city ordinance would result in
.necessary and undue hardship. However, the code states that a zoning code variance cannot
be approved unless the board finds the following:
a, That special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the lanct structure,
or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in
the same Zoning district.
b, That the special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the
applicant
c. That granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege
that is denied by this ordinance to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning
district.
d That literal interpretation of the provisions of this ordinance would deprive the applicant of
rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the terms
of the ordinance and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant.
e, That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will make pOSSible the reasonable
use of the lanct buildingl or structure.
That the granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose
of this chapter [ordinance} and that such variance will not be injurious to the area
involved or othelWise detrimental to the publiC welfare.
Memorandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCV 05-007
Staff reviewed the requested variance focusing on the applicant's response to the above criteria
':ontained in E~ "c", Staff does not concur with the applicant's justification to criteria "a"
dbove that the~ists spp.clal conditions peculiar to the subject parcel, ~ location of the
utility easement and exist/no trees within the easement. Utili easements are typically located
along the rear property line of lots and these easements are sua. ider than three 3) S
feet. The ~xisting foliage a/ono !be rear property line is considered margina~ most consisting of S
unhealthy vegetation or undesirable exotic species. The existing foliage is in the way of the
power lines and should be removed in conjunction with future site redevelopment and replanted
with more formal landscape buffer plantings. Per the Landscape Code, buffer requirements
between commercial and residential properties require a buffer depth of five (5) feet. The
required buffer wall can be located three (3) feet or more from the rear property line outside the
FPL utility easement. Required shrubs which meet FPL guidelines can be planted within the
easement along the exterior side of the wall, and required trees and shrubs can be planted along
the interior side of the wall to proVide the required buffer and additional screening from adjacent
residential properties.
With respect to criteria "b" above, the applicant states that the special conditions and
~ircumstances did not result from actions of the applicant. The applicant's justification states
#-that dense trees and shrubs were on site before he purchased the property in 2003, and the
,,/, trees caused the fence to disintegrate. The wall and much of the vegetation that was on site in
' 2003 has been cleared due to the applicant "trying to clean this property".
''''ith respect to criteria "c" above, the applicant states that the situation is unique and applies
.Iy to the applicant. The Land Development Regulations require a masonry wall between
commercially-zoned and residentially-zoned properties throughout the City. According to
Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4.L, a solid, stucco masonry wall is required along the rear (south)
'property line only, because this commercial property abuts a residential district only to the south,
In this situation, no buffer walls are required along the north, east, or west property lines, A
minimum two and one-half (2.5) foot planted landscape strip is required along the west property
line adjacent to other commercial zoning, in comparison with a five (5) foot buffer with wall
required adjacent to a residential zone.
With respect to criteria "d" above, literal interpretation would not deprive the applicant of rights
enjoyed by other property owners in the C-2 zoning district, and would not be an undue
hardship on the applicant. There is an alternative to comply with the code requirements without
the need for the requested variance, The masonry buffer wall is required to be outside of the
easement, and can be placed more than two feet from the property line. The required buffer
should include shrubs along the exterior side of the wall, and trees and shrubs along the interior
side of the wall. The side (west) property line should include a planted landscape strip of trees
and shrubs, however no wall or fence is required in this location. The applicant should
coordinate with FPL on tree removal within the FPL easement to further protect the power lines,
strive to be a good neighbor by effectively buffering the gas station from the adjacent
residences, and try to improve the property and bring the site up to code as much as possible.
.1 respect to criteria "e" above, the applicant purchased the property in 2003 and has since
had reasonable use of the property. Whether the condition of the fence was known at the time
or not, the new property owner assumed the existing conditions of the site improvements. If
M;morandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCV 05-007
the cement louver fence was aged and beyond repair, it is the responsibility of the applicant, as
owner of the property, to comply with the code requirements and replace the buffer wall outside
of the easement as required by the code, and also replace the wild undergrowth that has been
removed with more formal buffer plantings. The applicant's upcoming request for a major site
plan modification to remodel the gas station will require this nonconforming site to be brought
up to code, including landscaping.
With respect to criteria "f" above, granting the variance and allowing a fence instead of a wall
along the south property line will result in a less durable screen with more maintenance
requirements, and may not provide an effective screen for noise, emissions, and lighting,
Adjacent residential properties have been negatively impacted by the neighboring gas station,
and a fence rather than a masonry wall will not effectively mitigate the many negative impacts,
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends denial of this request for a variance from the City of Boynton Beach Land
Development Regulations, Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4.L - Buffer Walls, to allow a fence in lieu
of the required minimum six (6) foot high stucco masonry buffer wall to separate a commercial
district from the abutting residential district, It is the position of staff that the applicant has not
demonstrated that this request represents an undue hardship or the minimum necessary to
make possible the reasonable use of the property, The purpose of the buffer requirement is to
provide a visual and noise barrier between the residential and commercial properties, There are
~Iternative solutions noted herein which comply with the code requirements without the need for
e requested variance.
Staff conditions and any other condition(s) recommended by the Community Redevelopment
Agency Board or the City Commission will be included in the Exhibit "0" - Conditions of
Approval.
S:\SHRDATA\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\302 W Boynton Beach Blvd\ZNCV 05-007\staff report buffer wall.doc
MWR/kz
~
. 1 In. :: 102.1 feet
EXHIBIT "A" LOCATION MAP
-- <11 .f ~O, ~ .. -.'C :;
'. . a ~ ~ \ ""....;: . ~. '. 'N
, . E> "'~ F. ::: ....
.' = - '=.-
'Z" \ '.. .
, B .: :to- ". 'I J '. .
2 8 ,< '. . I' . 'Z/, ''j; ._/\ :: lil
" . '\ . . 0 '.'. :l! C,'." 'J
~ r'v",' : ..:....~. .~ ~r~ :; .' ~
O "'? y-\ .~ . (. 0 ," "" ~ ~'c>~ '. \fl.
-J:' L0 ~ ".t..iu~( "'~1
';:< ~ .. ~. '\ ': E'l) .
2.'.S ,. L:J ".
.. ",
.' '.';'.~., ". ,." """'/"..'
. . . I ( :',.
'.' . "" '",,:v .~
8 " . . '. . "
14,S' ..' '1
''''. " .... CPI.;Q
r--: ]
r-~ ~ ?'.: :"'.J j. .. ~
. It" . ~
~.- '.: .: ~". . ' I ' :' ., ..,'
-.;f '. ': :. ~ "'~" ~ ~:~,~.~ ~,-; ~ -' - Q. - -:':
~ ':;'1"":' " \ <k>' El .' .' "
;:, ~~ ~
.;. '.~. 1Al 10' - '(0''':'''' ,'. :
:.-", ' 'P , " , ..: . '-\ .
." .-
'"
~ :.~.-
\S. ,
J.' ': ,;:
__ , ": ~:i ~ oj:;, ~, .. . .' '. ;..
\-...a. .,' .......~.s'.J ., ~
N ':1- " \ ..;'f '",
, ", ~~, '~~ .'l ~~
:. '$, .5: ~ '2 ~ ~ ~ _
" .:. ~a ~! ~ y -> ~
c: :; :., ~ 'i~ '. ~,~l ~
n:. " ~~t ~
~
I'"'.~'"
> I.I:>~T'H 10'
13S,41 eM)
till
!,'
v
~! l>- c.t-IT
r,.1
, sl
+--. ~ 1 .
I ~x~- ....
r.~ ~ " ''-
~....- ,.:,..~',.
40.0/
r.;-
';7
Ji
~
d
::r
-:::
~
~
::J
'"
<1...
>
..u
---1
"=>
~
~ 10'
''ti.9~
'!i~ . ':.
:s ~ '.' ".
~. .
,,(\ ;: i :.
-:J '(, ;":
I"
-L
\J
~
ill
:0-
2.
:J.
,
2.
>-
'J'
~1
:1
s
,..... .: .
A.. . .
'-- :..:
I.~
"
I:
"
f--IO~TI4~
~. W. 2b!E> ~TRe.ET '
-tt
EXHIBIT "B"
,~
~
.1,u
't5
~:
f.G<l.c.
11102.0 '
'P
~
t-
.5
'I~? -?2-' (}>)I?;S.7 if (I"j) to'
" .' " :, ".-:-'..' :.~ '4bi-1:-RE'-r~ ':~: ....,:.:::;'
\!l
'0
Ui
'"
I-
fJel
l ~ u
'" .~~
... ~:::;S "' N
-&'I:~~ '" X'
jti~ i ~
\/IN
~~
.3,Q
~ ~
:2
;..
<:i
,
ul
~
:!:
~r- ...)
::Jgf
i=-n
~~
\0' .r--
~~ 1..
3 -~-
\10"- 0-
'" ~
~~ -
-r3 ~
\=-
::>1"-
~<:i J:\
~
\;'.\
~
.-.. 'N
.~ ~
3",
. ,.].' . ~
. . t:i:
,.." r
"",
\-,
S?,~
~
~
""
\-
~
--' I
4?,~1
N)
~~. }
~ .'-- t'f'
L T.
~
..
'"
-()
, ~f
:J~
52
-
%
r-.:
\l
0-
N
t-
"
--I
'-.
-<sl-'
IG
~-
,d
';I {
.0
':l
01'
~
\-
.!l
I~. ?2.'(P)
...-..
ll!
-~~ ~
~~ ~
Fb1?,+l ~(M)
.'
Raj Properties Inc.
P. O. Box 248
BOYNTON BEACH, FL 33425.
(561)758-51 to
(561)752-2806 FAX
August 22, 2005
Re: Majestic Gas Station's Fence. 302 w. Boynton Beach Blvd, B.B., Florida 33435.
Dear Mr. Rumph,
I am writing you in reference to Variance application for above listed property. I am going
to try to represent the situation to best of my ability.
A. That special conditions & circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure or
building involved & which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the
same zoning district.
Answer: We used to have Fence wall made of cement louver pre cast right on property line.
I think that fence was installed long time ago. Now, about five trees have grown right in to
them. And by those trees being there it would be impossible to build a cement block wall
there. See Appendix "A". Also if we put the wall 2 feet from adjoining property line, then
we run in to Trees plus Electrical and Telephone poles.
B. That the special conditions & circumstances do not result from the actions of the
applicant.
Answer: We purchased that property in January'2003, and ever since than we are trying to
clean this property. The trees that caused the fence to disintegrate are much older that 30
months. Initially the fence was fully covered with dense bushes, barely visible of its
condition.
C. That granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special
privilege that is denied by this Ordinance to other lands, buildings or structures in the same
zoning district.
Answer: I think our situation is unique, and that is why it will apply to us alone.
D. That literal interpretation of the provisions of this chapter would deprive the applicant of
rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the tenns of
the Ordinance & would work Ullllecessary & undue hardship on the applicant.
Answer: For us to have six feet tall block wall there, first we need to cut down about nine
large trees. Grind all the roots out. Also there is a issue for utility poles. And then put the
wall up.
E. That the variance granted is the minimwn variance that will make possible the reasonable
use of the land, building or structure.
c^Hltjll HL;H
"
EXHIBIT "e"
Answer: By letting us putting a six feet tall Vinyl Fencing or Wood Fencing there we do
not have to cut down any of those trees or interfere with utility poles, It will also give
privacy to the neighbors.
F. That the granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general intent & purpose of
this chapter & that such variance will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise
detrimental to the public welfare.
Answer: I think by allowing us to build a Vinyl or Wood Fence, we achieve two goals at
the same time. One keep all those full grown trees and second have nice looking fence for
privacy,
Thank you very much.
Sincerely,
~&
EXHIBIT "D"
Conditions of Approval
Project name: Majestic Gas Buffer Wall
File number: ZNCV 05-007
Reference:
I DEP ARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I
PUBLIC WORKS- General
Comments: None X
PUBLIC WORKS- Traffic
Comments: None X
UTILITIES
Comments: None X
FIRE
Comments: None X
POLICE
Comments: None X
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: None X
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments: None X
P ARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: None X
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENTALIST
Comments: None X
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments: None X
ADDITIONAL COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD
COMMENTS
Conditions of Approval
2
DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
Comments:
1. None X
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION COMMENTS
Comments:
1. To be determined.
S:\Planning\SHARED\WPIPROJECTS\302 W Boynton Beach\ZNCV 05-007\COND OF APPROV AL.doc
CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH
AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM
Requested City Commission Date Final Form Must be Turned
Meeting Dates in to City Clerk's Office
Requested City Commission
Meeting Dates
Date Final Form Must be Turned
in to City Clerk's Office
D August 2, 2005
0 August 16,2005
0 September 6, 2005
0 September 20, 2005
July 18,2005 (Noon.)
o October 5, 2005
o October 18, 2005
[gI November I, 2005
o November 15,2005
September 19,2005 (Noon)
August 1,2005 (Noon)
October 3, 2005 (Noon)
August 15,2005 (Noon)
October 17,2005 (Noon)
September 6, 2005 (Noon)
October 31, 2005 (Noon)
NATURE OF
AGENDA ITEM
o Administrative
[gI Consent Agenda
o Public Hearing
o Bids
o Announcement
o City Manager's Report
o Development Plans
o New Business
o Legal
o UnfInished Business
o Presentation
RECOMMENDATION: Please place this request on the November 1,2005 City Commission Agenda under
Consent Agenda. The Community Redevelopment Agency Board recommended that the subject request be denied on
October 11,2005. For further details pertaining to the request, see attached Department of Development Memorandum No.
PZ 05-186.
EXPLANATION:
PROJECT:
AGENT:
OWNER:
LOCATION:
DESCRIPTION:
Majestic Gas (ZNCV 05-007)
Rajesh Patel, Raj Properties, Inc.
N/A
302 West Boynton Beach Boulevard
Request for relief from the City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations,
Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4-L, requiring a six (6) foot solid, stucco masonry wall, to
allow a six (6) foot vinyl or wood fence in a C-2 Neighborhood district abutting an R-I-A
Single Family Residential neighborhood.
PROGRAM IMP ACT: N/A
FISCAL IMP ACT: N/ A
ALTERN:~~iLto,
City Manager's Signature
A~J L. ~
~lanning and Zoning Jil ector City Attorney / Finance / Human Resources
S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\302 W. Boynton Beach Blvd\ZNCV 05-Q07\Agenda Item Request Majestic Gas ZNCV 05-007 II-I-Q5.dot
S:\BULLETIN\FORMS\AGENDA ITEM REQUEST FORM.DOC
Meeting
Date:
File No:
Location:
Agentl
Owner:
Project
Name:
Variance
Request:
Property
Location:
North:
South:
East:
West:
OEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
P~ .HNING AND ZONING DIVISION
MEMORANDUM NO. PZ 05-186
STAFF REPORT FOR
COMMUNIlY REDEVELOPMENT BOARD AND CIlY COMMISSION
October 11, 2005
ZNCV 05-007 Buffer Wall
302 West Boynton Beach Boulevard, Boynton Beach, FL
Rajesh Patel, Raj Properties, Inc.
Majestic Gas
Relief from Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4,L - Buffer Walls, to allow a six (6) foot
fence along the south (rear) property line in lieu of the required six (6) foot stucco
masonry buffer wall required to separate a commercial district from an abutting
residential district,
The site is located east of 1-95 on the south side of Boynton Beach Boulevard (see
Exhibit "A"-Location Map). The subject property, totaling 0.7 acre, is currently
zoned C-2 (Neighborhood Commercial) and classified Local Retail Commercial
(LRC), The subject site abuts Boynton Heights to the south, a residential
subdivision zoned R1A,
The following is a description of the land uses and zoning designation of the
properties that surround this site:
Right-of-way for Boynton Beach Boulevard, farther north property classified Local
Retail Commercial (LRC), zoned Neighborhood Commercial (C-2) and developed as
professional office uses;
Properties within Boynton Heights subdivision classified Low Density Residential
(LOR), zoned Single-Family (R1A), and developed as single-family residential;
Right-of-way for NW 2nd Street, further east property classified Local Retail
Commercial (LRC), zoned Neighborhood Commercial (C-2), and developed with
residential use; and,
Property classified Local Retail Commercial (LRC), zoned Neighborhood Commercial
(C-2), and developed as professional office use.
Page 2
Memorandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCV 05-007
NATURE OF REQUEST
Rajesh Patel of Raj Properties, Inc., owner of the subject property (Majestic Gas), is requesting a
zoning code variance to seek relief from Chapter 2, Section 4,L. of the Land Development
Regulations, the applicable part of which states as follows:
L. BUFFER WALLS, For new construction or major modification to existing developments,
where a commercial and/or industrial district abuts a residential district, a solid, stucco
masonry wall painted on both side at least six (6) feet in height shall be located within the
required side and/or rear yards except with respect to corner lots, said buffer walls shall
be required only on interior lot lines. Said buffer walls shall not abridge any easement
rights or be constructed over any existing utilities in any easement area and shall be
setback two (2) feet from adjoining property lines.
It is important to note that commercial properties, due to the intensity of their uses, are reqUired
to provide for additional buffering to minimize land use conflicts when located adjacent to
residential neighborhoods, Landscaping elements, including dense vegetation, berms, and
buffer walls, can provide effective barriers, and mitigate the impacts of unattractive views,
vehicle headlights, and noise, without sacrificing the functional necessities of the commercial
site. Advantages of a masonry buffer wall, rather than a fence include the following:
· walls act as sound barriers and can substantially reduce noise associated with a gas
station use;
· walls can withstand high winds and are more durable and provide more stability than a
fence;
· walls help contain gasoline emissions, headlights, and store security lighting to gas station
site; and,
· walls are attractive, fire resistant barriers, and require lower maintenance than required
for fences.
BACKGROUND
The existing gas station is considered a nonconforming use due to its location and
noncompliance with current code requirements such as conditional use approval, and
bufferS/landscaping. The construction of the buffer wall became a requirement in connection
with an upcoming application request from the owner for a major site plan modification, The
applicant intends to remodel the existing gas station building by closing the automotive repair
operations in the garage and using that existing space to increase the size of the convenience
store. The applicant is prohibited from adding on to the building and increasing the building
square footage on site, which would be considered an expansion of a nonconforming use.
The buffer wall is required only along the rear property line adjacent to residential, and is
required to be at least six (6) feet in height and located at least two (2) feet from the rear
property line so that it can be maintained without trespassing onto adjacent properties. The
applicant is proposing to construct a six (6) foot fence in lieu of the required minimum six (6)
foot masonry wall along the south property line that abuts single-family residences in a
subdivision zoned R1A.
Page 3
Memorandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCV 05-007
Previously, a concrete slat or louvered wall was located along the side interior and rear property
lines, however this wall was recently removed by the applicant after it was damaged. Aerial
photographs from approximately 2003 indicate the site was also densely buffered along the side
interior and rear property lines, but current site conditions do not include any buffers, Due to
the recent removal of the buffer wall and most of the vegetation on site, the gas station site is
now very visible from adjacent residential properties to the south and southwest. The side
interior (west) and rear (south) yards of the service station, which are the highly visible areas
from adjacent residential properties, are used for dumpster service area, tanker truck parking for
filling up underground fuel storage tanks, unscreened outdoor storage of dozens of used tires,
and propane tank storage.
Florida Power and Light has a three (3) foot wide utility easement which runs along the rear
(south) property line of the subject property. Some existing vegetation along the rear property
line is located within this easement, and has been cut back so it does not interfere with the
power lines, The majority of the vegetation along the rear property line is unhealthy, weakened
by irregular pruning and storm damage, or consists of undesired exotic species, Landscape code
requirements address landscaping within easements: buffer walls are to be located outside of
easements for access purposes, and canopy trees are required to be planted outside of
easements so that roots and branches do not impact existing utilities,
ANALYSIS
The Board has the authority to grant a variance that will not be contrary to the public interest
when, owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the city ordinance would result in
unnecessary and undue hardship. However, the code states that a zoning code variance cannot
be approved unless the board finds the following:
a. That special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure,
or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in
the same Zoning district
b. That the special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the
applicant,
c, That granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege
that is denied by this ordinance to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning
district
d. That literal interpretation of the provisions of this ordinance would deprive the applicant of
rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the terms
of the ordinance and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant,
e. That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable
use of the land, building, or structure.
f. That the granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose
of this Chapter [ordinance] and that such variance will not be injurious to the area
involved or otherwise detrimental to the publiC welfare,
Page 4
Memorandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCV 05-007
Staff reviewed the requested variance focusing on the applicant's response to the above criteria
contained in Exhibit "C". Staff does not concur with the applicant's justification to criteria "a"
above that there exists special conditions peculiar to the subject parcel, namely location of the
utility easement and existing trees within the easement. Utility easements are typically located
along the rear property line of lots and these easements are usually much wider than three (3)
feet. The existing foliage along the rear property line is considered marginal, most consisting of
unhealthy vegetation or undesirable exotic species. The existing foliage is in the way of the
power lines and should be removed in conjunction with future site redevelopment and replanted
with more formal landscape buffer plantings. Per the Landscape Code, buffer requirements
between commercial and residential properties require a buffer depth of five (5) feet. The
required buffer wall can be located three (3) feet or more from the rear property line outside the
FPL utility easement. Required shrubs which meet FPL guidelines can be planted within the
easement along the exterior side of the wall, and required trees and shrubs can be planted along
the interior side of the wall to provide the required buffer and additional screening from adjacent
residential properties.
With respect to criteria "b" above, the applicant states that the special conditions and
circumstances did not result from actions of the applicant. The applicant's justification states
that dense trees and shrubs were on site before he purchased the property in 2003, and the
trees caused the fence to disintegrate. The wall and much of the vegetation that was on site in
2003 has been cleared due to the applicant "trying to clean this property".
With respect to criteria "c" above, the applicant states that the situation is unique and applies
only to the applicant. The Land Development Regulations require a masonry wall between
commercially-zoned and residentially-zoned properties throughout the City. According to
Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4.L, a solid, stucco masonry wall is required along the rear (south)
property line only, because this commercial property abuts a residential district only to the south.
In this situation, no buffer walls are required along the north, east, or west property lines. A
minimum two and one-half (2.5) foot planted landscape strip is required along the west property
line adjacent to other commercial zoning, in comparison with a five (5) foot buffer with wall
required adjacent to a residential zone.
With respect to criteria "d" above, literal interpretation would not deprive the applicant of rights
enjoyed by other property owners in the C-2 zoning district, and would not be an undue
hardship on the applicant. There is an alternative to comply with the code requirements without
the need for the requested variance. The masonry buffer wall is required to be outside of the
easement, and can be placed more than two feet from the property line. The required buffer
should include shrubs along the exterior side of the wall, and trees and shrubs along the interior
side of the wall. The side (west) property line should include a planted landscape strip of trees
and shrubs, however no wall or fence is required in this location. The applicant should
coordinate with FPL on tree removal within the FPL easement to further protect the power lines,
strive to be a good neighbor by effectively buffering the gas station from the adjacent
residences, and try to improve the property and bring the site up to code as much as possible.
With respect to criteria "e" above, the applicant purchased the property in 2003 and has since
had reasonable use of the property, Whether the condition of the fence was known at the time
or not, the new property owner assumed the existing conditions of the site improvements. If
Page 5
Memorandum No. PZ 05-186
ZNCV 05-007
the cement louver fence was aged and beyond repair, it is the responsibility of the applicant, as
owner of the property, to comply with the code requirements and replace the buffer wall outside
of the easement as required by the code, and also replace the wild undergrowth that has been
removed with more formal buffer plantings, The applicant's upcoming request for a major site
plan modification to remodel the gas station will require this nonconforming site to be brought
up to code, including landscaping,
With respect to criteria "f" above, granting the variance and allowing a fence instead of a wall
along the south property line will result in a less durable screen with more maintenance
requirements, and may not provide an effective screen for noise, emissions, and lighting,
Adjacent residential properties have been negatively impacted by the neighboring gas station,
and a fence rather than a masonry wall will not effectively mitigate the many negative impacts.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends denial of this request for a variance from the City of Boynton Beach Land
Development Regulations, Chapter 2, Zoning, Section 4,L - Buffer Walls, to allow a fence in lieu
of the required minimum six (6) foot high stucco masonry buffer wall to separate a commercial
district from the abutting residential district, It is the position of staff that the applicant has not
demonstrated that this request represents an undue hardship or the minimum necessary to
make possible the reasonable use of the property, The purpose of the buffer requirement is to
provide a visual and noise barrier between the residential and commercial properties. There are
alternative solutions noted herein which comply with the code requirements without the need for
the requested variance.
Staff conditions and any other condition(s) recommended by the Community Redevelopment
Agency Board or the City Commission will be included in the Exhibit "0" - Conditions of
Approval.
S:\SHRDATA\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\302 W Boynton Beach Blvd\ZNCV OS-007\staff report buffer wall.doc
MWR/kz
...
1 in. = 102.1 feet
EXHIBIT "A" LOCATION MAP
~.;.:
!;
I:
"
~o~i
~.w. Z~~TRe.ET i
-~
.:...-~-~~~
EXHIBIT "B"
IO.~~
> I.P~TH 10'
13'S.41 eM)
.~
~
~\11
't5
l~
r.J
.' s}
~~~
111:20'
~
J\
~
'1??,l;>2-' (l>) VJ?7 11 (rl)
I-
~cl
~ .'\u
'" "'" ~~
_ ~~8 r1
=-4:4.1- ~ if
~ ,0( 0 oil ~
l i~ i ~ ~
"
47.171
fa;"
~
.n
':)
d
:% .' =
"
~
~
\II r1
~ ~
~.a
'UJ
:%
_:1
l~
~t
- ...
~ ~
~
':.t-
()
f.s
7J
~
~~ ...)
~Ji
~~
'" ~
i~ L
3 -.,.-
~.... 0-
... '--
~~ -
....:3 ~
t=-
:>r-
~~ ~
4?,~I.
C'-l
~
~'N
.~ ~
~.a;
:J
~
<{.,
>
..u
-1
':)
~
8 .'. . . '. '. ..
..I~'~' ",~ I; 'I' '.' . I
. ". . .' h" I.Y,.C? :.'. ~:v
;..~ ~.;.:.:,':.' !:. 'J":~O : ".:::
'5 (. ~,' ':!!' . ,,]. . ""
r - :' '.' ~:' L~' .': x ~ " '. . : : ..
~:, '. ..,: i: I.... . d' l ,:: Q ,,'
~ '~'1'-:" '..".~.,-' -;-~-:.:,-::.- ~7"' :'~',~ ::....~>
N: .... ., '.
. . .
,." r
..... ,
\-,
. ~ ~
N'
M
\-
(:.
-' ,
..L
\)
--(
111
:Q.
2
:.J.
,
2-
>-
~.
~,
%&.0'-
.' A ~.
. 0 J
"'\..~g
;-0/1 '
e :';~l':( .
-~ :.':'.
~ :.":
t\ :. : "
'\.J.: . . I.
N
~.
....":-
s
;0
~
'P
~,4' ,~ ;
L T.
-~
..
..
()
~E
:s'!i
52
)I
t-
.9
:: .;:;.~. . .. t--
....... ~.s' . , . " "
h \ ..,"t "",
~'i=' ~~ .' l ~~
.':t ~:z.~ ~~
~ '!\ I".! 0 'l( -..
-3'" ~..... ~ 't-
'-l~ ~OII
~ -- ~,"'i
. ~~~
. ~'ti..
!.
~:
~
I '.
~
n "
"
-
~
\l
.s
~
-
'%
r.:
\i
~
I-
o
-'
3.
1l~'.
t
~-
,d
:to(
:!)
:z
lI'
~,uJ
t~
.:z.
)
~
\-
~
...
~
1
I
oS
l
-~~
'40.0'
I~. J?2.'(P)
I~t:;,+l ~(M)
J
EXHIBIT "e"
Raj Properties Inc.
P. O. Box 248
BOYNTON BEACH, FL 33425.
(561)758-5110
(561)752-2806 FAX
August 22, 2005
Re: Majestic Gas Station's Fence. 302 w, Boynton Beach Blvd, B.B., Florida 33435.
Dear Mr. Rumph,
I am writing you in reference to Variance application for above listed property. I am going
to try to represent the situation to best of my ability.
A. That special conditions & circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure or
building involved & which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the
same zoning district.
Answer: We used to have Fence wall made of cement louver pre cast right on property line.
I think that fence was installed long time ago. Now, about five trees have grown right in to
them. And by those trees being there it would be impossible to build a cement block wall
there. See Appendix "A". Also if we put the wall 2 feet from adjoining property line, then
we run in to Trees plus Electrical and Telephone poles.
B. That the special conditions & circumstances do not result from the actions of the
applicant.
Answer: We purchased that property in January'2003, and ever since than we are trying to
clean this property. The trees that caused the fence to disintegrate are much older that 30
months. Initially the fence was fully covered with dense bushes, barely visible of its
condition.
C. That granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special
privilege that is denied by this Ordinance to other lands, buildings or structures in the same
zoning district.
Answer: I think our situation is unique, and that is why it will apply to us alone.
D. That literal interpretation of the provisions of this chapter would deprive the applicant of
rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district under the tenns of
the Ordinance & would work unnecessary & undue hardship on the applicant.
Answer: For us to have six feet tall block wall there, first we need to cut down about nine
large trees. Grind all the roots out. Also there is a issue for utility poles. And then put the
wall up.
E. That the variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable
use of the land, building or structure.
"
EXHIBIT "G"
Answer: By letting us putting a six feet tall Vinyl Fencing or Wood Fencing there we do
not have to cut down any of those trees or interfere with utility poles. It will also give
privacy to the neighbors.
F. That the granting of the variance will be in hannony with the general intent & purpose of
this chapter & that such variance will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise
detrimental to the public welfare.
Answer: I think by allowing us to build a Vinyl or Wood Fence, we achieve two goals at
the same time. One keep all those full grown trees and second have nice looking fence for
privacy.
Thank you very much.
Sincerely,
~~
EXHIBIT "D"
Conditions of Approval
Project name: Majestic Gas Buffer Wall
File number: ZNCV 05-007
Reference:
DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT
PUBLIC WORKS- General
Comments: None X
PUBLIC WORKS- Traffic
Comments: None X
UTILITIES
Comments: None X
FIRE
Comments: None X
POLICE
Comments: None X
ENGINEERING DIVISION
Comments: None X
BUILDING DIVISION
Comments: None X
PARKS AND RECREATION
Comments: None X
FORESTER/ENVIRONMENTALIST
Comments: None X
PLANNING AND ZONING
Comments: None X
ADDITIONAL COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD
COMMENTS
Conditions of Approval
2
I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I
Comments:
1. None X
ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION COMMENTS
Comments:
1. To be determined.
S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\302 W Boynton Beach\ZNCV 05-007\COND OF APPROV AL.doc
09/28/2005 15:28
5517425259
PLANt-.J I !'-JG
PAGE 03
To the City Clerk - City Of Boynton Beach
RE: Property Address:
Project Name:
File #:
AFFIDA VIT
ff1 ~ _\. V31vJ,
30 z W' ~ ~v&v- T\ ~-e.~ CX\
Bc9~~cr-n 't)~0(~~ FL 834g 0 "
/'
UWe, tile undersigned do certify that to the best of my knowledge, the
attached ownership list, 400' radius map and mailing labels are a complete
and accurate representation of the real estate property and property
owners within at least 400 feet of the above~referenced subject property.
This reflects the most current records on file in tlte Palm Beach County
Property Appraiser's Office.
The notifications were postmarked a minimum of 10 days ill advance of
the public hearing.
Site signs were posted 01' the premises 10 days in advance of the public
hearing in accordance with City Ordinance 04-007. Attached are
photographs of the s;glls showillg their placeme12t on the property.
sincer[ill7 J1
APPliC~
Notary Public, State of Florida q - 20 - c6
Cc: Plannillg & Zonillg Department ~ ~+-
......",'. AMY ERNST
~~,\;r.tr~~ ,
?o/i!i."\*; MY COMMISSION # DO 456477
~.~~~~! EXPIRES: AuguSl15, 2009
":t.iif. .~'ofj:-' Bondea Thru NoIIry Public Unl!erwriters
S!IPlftnninglPlall"i"g Tl!mpltlteslP&Z letters and memDs\A.FFIDA VIT.d(lc
.',
.;
OJ.......CCO
ooo'/"
-<0-<....
zmZ'f
-Iw-l....
000';"
z-<z~
wzw'
~d~~
ozog
IWI....
;:'J~Q~
~o~~
....IO
(,.)w"
"',
<
(,.)
'"
(,.)
'"
rw-l<)>
)>,)>)>0
~g6'3:::~
~6b~Cf'
'"
m
(,.)
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
r,n:;"mm
<o~k:':"':E
~g~ao
....0
o
....
~;g; ):! ;g S
<:'~i:j~0
00_ I
c.nOCl)CO
"'-1<0
" , 0
go
<0
'"
......
~~8~
-<......w....
ZZC't'
d:E~~
ZWr-N
0)::::007'-
~~~~
~-I:::~
" ....
, ......
(,.) 0
(,.) 0
....
(,.)
'"
.
....
o
....
o
o
rW-l<)>
)>,)>)>0
ZOX,:;O
oCflwCm
~m~~Cf'
...s::...U10c.o
co w...... w
w""Wco
01'-.>0'0
(,.)
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
r:n?,r:nm
-'"o~CnC>
~~~~C>
cn<DU;o
"'......0
....
~~g; :t:! ;g S
o<Xen0
:'I:bQr,n'
xoeno
_ 1'-.>-1.......
~~6g
00'"
9~~
~o-.J
o
'"
w
o
-<
Z
-I
o
Z
I
;=
,
(f)
,
~
......
'"
w
,
:;<;
)>
~~~~
-<"':;0....
ZZO't'
-I:E-<....
Ow,--V'
Z:;om~
g::~~~
f;-I~6
I -I~
" ....
, ....
(,.) o:l
W 0
....
(,.)
'"
...
o
....
';W-l<)>
z5S<f::o
00WC~
~~~~f{J
..........0
'" <0 (,.)
WO~
(,.)
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
r:'1?,r;nm
::::J~~l.>:E
c.n01::7i:~O
.,f:).l"VcoC>
....<00
o
~~:t:!;gS
<:'~i:j~0
0_ .
O(f)o
"'-I~
" , 0
o~o
0<0
(,.)'"
g......
w
o
-<
Z
-I
o
Z
I
;=
,
(f)
,
-I
en
......
o
QO
~
w
,
:;<;
)>
w",:;;:O
o""cC;O
-<"':;0....
zZ-oCf
-I:EI....
0(,.)<-';"
Z:;om~
WO)>.
moZ~
f;-I~6
I -10
m....
" ..:..
, ....
(,.) 0>
(,.) 0
....
(,.)
'"
...
o
:::
o
rW-I<)>
)>,)>)>0
5g~:::~
~~&~CfJ
~oo~-.J
col'-.>wm
w......O"'"-,J
c.otORSo
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
m?,r:nm
6......:e:~D
~o~~o
w","""-
",<0
<0
'"
~~:t:!;gS
<:'~i:j~0
IgCi5b
><"'--1"""
~~g
0<0 I
(,.) '" w
g-.. 00
W
o
-<
Z
-I
o
Z
I
;=
,
(f)
,
-I
en
00
QO
<0
W
,
:;<;
)>
~~E:~~
~:E~E;~
-Iwmmt:;
OO-<I'
Z-<Z)>~
WZm:;06
~dG';-;-,
oIz~~g
w ....
11m QO~
I)> )>......
~~ ~~
.... -
ww m
'C< I
00 QO
'"
'"
';~:t:!~f;
5g~:::~
~t;~~Cf'
"''''....
t:3;~ 0
o (Xl i-..J
m <0
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
~?'~r:n
",g~~:E
~8~~o
wc08
<00
'"
~~):!;gS
<:'~i:j~0
oCi5~
"'-I....
b~g
0<0
(,.)00
g......
w
o
-<
Z
-I
o
Z
I
;=
,
en
,
-I
en
m
QO
......
w
,
:;<;
)>
w~""":;;::i:
QC;gJf2J.
zmmz't'
-I O)>t:;
o O'--N
Z mm....
w )>)>.
m ZZ~
)> )>Z'
o <mg
I m=l~
~ m::
(,.) -0'"
w 0
....
(,.)
'"
'"
......
m
';~):!~f;
~g~:::~
~~~~CfJ
0(,.)......
........'"
000......
08;:0
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
m:;<;mm
~i;;~"':E
<O......~~O
+:a.~~g
~o
o
....
mZ-I-o:;;:
X)>s<C-I
<:'~0~0
gCi5b
"'-I~
b~g
0<0
w",
g......
~ w
"'0
- -<
hiz
en-l
enO
enZ
....I
0;=
:!l~
Z
m
'"
Z
o
~:E
m",
'"
:;0"
~~
W"
"
:;<;-1
)>~
.(,.)
,
-I
....
QO
,
-I
~~~~
~~~~
d,,6;~
ZgJ6~
g::z:;;:6
)>-1)>-;-'
~~~~
"m)>.
':E~:::
~~-tg
t; :;;:
m QO
....
......
....
m
';~:t:!~f;
~g~:::~
~<nr:-r:nCl)
3;~~OI
(,.)....<0
0~0
..J:lo. ~ 0
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
)>0)>:;0-1
00-10'
r,n:;<;r,nm
~ge~:E
~~~~o
00<00
<00
m
~~:t:!;gS
<:'~i:j~0
OOO~
"'-I......
" . 0
o~o
0<0
(,.)'"
g......
~~
en-<
enZ
en-l
~~
"I
-1;=
~G
'"
o
!;::
W
,
;~
:::
'"
QO
m
'"
'"
"
-I
o
"
,
-I
:::
(,.)
o-..mO
m-Jooqo
.or.
~~zJ::
-<"0,,,
wm:;O",
mIl>......
)>oZ6
000......
IO)>6
-ncJ=~
r:::Or~
W--Ipoo
~ s:~
.... )>
~ ~
~ )>
';~:t:!~f;
5g~:::~
~~r;-r;nCl)
.,c:::...~"""OI
(,.)",,,,
<om'"
"'m......
(Xl <g a
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
e;g~~-;-i
r,n:;"r,nm
g8:i~g
~~~g
............0
<0
~~:t:!;gS
<:'~i:j~0
0_,
o en ~
"'-1<0
b~g
0<0
w",
g......
- w
hiQ
~Z
en-l
o
~Z
"I
-1;=
en'
:;0 en
00
o
....
:;0
~
'(;;:E
,~
:;<;....
)>"
-I
o
"
,
-I
o
QO
,
-I
ro<.n;oO
O......)>'/"
-<"'c......
zco-oCf
-10:;0....
OmO';"
Zen-O"-'
OJ()m~
m)>:;O....
)>:;o::!'?
O-lmo
Imen~
"en-.
r()Z~
~SOOg
....
(,.)
......
~
-.J
i3
o
'"
w
(j,
<D
:,;.
W
-u
;;::
'"
....
'"
<0
,W-l<)>
)>,)>)>0
~g~:::~
l::..~r;-r:nCf)
l"V......Olo.
"''''....
"'00
"'......w
ow~ 0
-u
a
-0
'"
.z
:t>
-0
-0
ii3
0;'
~
G)
en
en
)>
,
m
-owo-ot5
e;g~~-;-i
r:n?,r:nm
~:::j~~~
::!~NOO
",g
....
'U
'"
(l
~
r
21
CT
'<
'U
'"
(l
~
(')
o
::e.
Q.
z
c
3
CT
~
~~:t:!;gS
<:'~i:j~0
gOON
"'-1m
"bo
.0000
0<0
(,.)'"
g......
;0
'"
0-
~-
o
.t>-
o
o
, W
-10
~-<
~~
1"'0
mz
~~
enf=
~ en
o
"
-I
en
:;0
'"
~:E
(,.)
;u'"
~21
~~
:;<;,
)>~
o
<0
QO
m
(,.)
Q)
"
-I
o
"
:;ow
00
~~
~d
wz
~ffi
"'-
o
:I:
-I
en
)>
o
o
:;0
m
<
Ci5
m
o
-0
,
,
-I
en
~
-I
o
o
"Tl
<D
'U
'"
'lil
'"
z
o
r
m
en
en
Z
~
"
-I
8fd~~
-<-'-f~
zz:x:<:>
b~05Y;
Z,....",e-N
COz~-;"
mOm~
f;~C/)b
:c po~
" .:.-
, co
W w
W '"
J>.
W
'"
J>.
o
'"
'"
):~);!:;;fi
20X,;o
~~~~rn
co~C.Do'
"'....W
~g~ ~
N
COWIO
O"'cc;o
-<-'CI)~
zZm~
b~~~
2Z0~
lDO;o-
mU))>~
fi-ls::6
I ~
" ....
, co
W W
W ....
J>.
W
'"
J,..
o
'"
'"
):~);!:;;fi
~gi'i5c~
c5b~~C{J
-J 0
co -J
'" co 0
'" 0
-J
OJC/)~G)~
Qrri"'O,/..
~~f\.J~~
o ~IY'
z COO'"
CD 007"
m -<"'0
)> Z ....
0-16
I 0 0
2 ....
" CO .:...
~ ~ ~
WOO
t:; I
01 OJ
,
<
J>.
01
W
W
):OJ);!<)>
z5xf:0
OG)OJC~
~~~6Cf'
J>.....o
co........
w~ffi
-J
OJWG)O
o~ot
~2S;'t'
b~IY;
z~O~
OJOO.
m)>;;<;~
)><0'
OmQOg
~ ~!
, )>....
W Z'"
W ZO
t:; m
'"
J,..
o
N
J>.
o
): OJ);! <)>
z5xf:0
OG)OJC~
~~~~Cf'
'" '" ....
001....
o 01 '"
(XI ~ 0
OJOlIO
OW)>,/,>
-<co;o....
Z"';ow
-Io05~
OOmN
zCO....
~~~~
)>;0;06
~:;;a~
-n::J>S:":'"
r- ....
w:::O co
wO 0
....-
w:::O
-J
N
co
N
W
):~);!:;;fi
20X,;o
OG)COCm
~6~6f{'
N -J
01 '"
"" 01
"" 0
OJCXlCCC)
000'/'>
000....
)>S::)>'t'
~~~Y;
-fO--l~
000'
2~2~
"cnoo
':::000
""os::....
W s::':'-
g; c::::1
9> z...
~ =t
o -<
.... I
o
(J)
'U
Z
o
):~);!:;;fi
20X,;o
oG)f!!Cm
~b&6C{>
"" 01
.... ""
fDw:r:~
Q~~'/"
22;;<;'t'
b~gJY;
Z"""cnl"ro,)
~a~b
)>(J)~7'
0-1_8
:;; E.-a-
r- m~
~ ~~
t:; m
'"
....
o
'"
01
o
): OJ);! <)>
25xf:0
OG)OJc~
~~Z:~G1'
CD-...tNco
(XI 0'1 w-...t
CDO-.W
"''''0
;z:",,'U0
m~)>qo
~~~~
'U;Z:OJ~
)>,J::o..m.
~~f;~
OJII~
~~8g
o c....
:I: z":'"
" -I....
r- -<~
"" I
"" 0
J>. C
s:l (J)
z
G)
)>
C
-I
I
00
....
....
rOJ-I<)>
)>')>)>0
~gi'i5c~
ffi~66Cf'
o '"
0""
'"
(D1'Vr-O
ONO'/'>
-<OlC....
225't'
b~O~
ZW;;oN
;0-1....
tDono
m)>)>....
)><06
~m~~
" en":'"
~ QOtj
"" 0
J>.
""
'"
~
.......
N
o
C>
<r>
w
(j,
<D
:.;.
w
-0
s::
J>.
o
""
'"
o
COJ-I<)>
_,)>)>0
~gi'i5c~
~~Z~Cf'
(,Omc.n.......
co~-.lm
<O-.01w
.... 0 0
-0
a
-0
<D
~
)>
-0
-0
iil
en'
~
G)
en
(J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J)
)> )> )> )> )> )> )> )> )>
, , , , , , r , ,
m m m m m m m m m
'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'UOJO'U~ 'U
)>0)>;0-1 )>0)>:::0-1 )>0)>;0-1 )>0)>;0-1 )>0)>:::0-1 )>0)>;0-1 )>0)>;0-1 )>0)>;0-1 )>0)>;0-1 ~
G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' n
m;;<;mm r:n?,r:"'T' m;;<;mm r;n::;"r;nm r;n;;<;r;nm r:n?'~r:n r:n:;"r:"m m;;<;mm ,:"?,r:nm !J!.
~~~i:;:E ~C::;~&';z: ~~~~~ ~8~&to 80_-'0 ....a.o~"'o ~8~~:E ~~~~~ ,
....a.....a......... -. 0 !e
,J::o...-.<D 0 -.(O::;:~o ~g:::i:~O ~~~go ~~~go w(O-O') ~!:::3::;:go ~::!~~o
Ol-J- (00)(,00 .t:o.........U;o t:T
....'" c.o~~ ",,,,0 ",'" ",'" O1~O '<
0 "'",0 co -J ""-JO 00
0 '" ",0 0 01 0 0 'U
J>. '" Ql
i3
!J!.
~~);!~~ ~~);!~~ ~~);!~~ ~~);!~~ ~~);!~~ ~~);!~~ m2);!'US:: ~~);!~~ ~~);!~~ 0
~~xf5-1 0
0-;::~~0 0-;::~~0 0-;::~~0 0~~~0 0~~~0 <i'-;::~~0 O<X(J)G) O<X(J)G) ;3.
0_, 0_ , 0_ , 8056 :i::6~r;n0 66~m' :i::60m. Q.
o (J) 0 o (J) 0 0(J)0 oU5~ 0056 xO(J)o WO(/)OO xoCi5b
"'-I.... "'-10 "'-I.... "'-I'" "'-10 "'-10 "'-I.... "'-101 _ f\,.) --I ........ 2
b~g " , 0 "60 "60 " , 0 " , 0 ~gg " , 0 I"'T1IO c:
~O oCX>o OOJO ~O ~o ~O Xo~o 3
0", '" 0", 0 0", '" '" 0", '" O<D t:T
""00 00 ""00 .... ""00 00 00 Wco 00 ""co ~
8-J '" g~ 0 g-J -J -J 8.... '" 8'"
, OJ OJ OJ ' OJ OJ OJ OJ OJ OJ
-10 0 0 -10 0 0 0 0 Q
....-< -< -< ....-< -< -< -< -<
CO2 2 2 002 2 2 2 2 2
J>.-I -I -I 0-1 -I -I -I -I -I ;0
OJO 0 0 OJO 0 0 0 0 0 Ql
~2 2 2 ~2 2 2 Z 2 2 a.
)>~ :r: I )>~ I I :r: I I c:'
, F F , F F F F F 5"
, , , , , , , , , 0
Ul (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) Y' Y' (J)
, (J) , , ....
-I J>. -I -I 0
0 ~ 0
~ " '" ......
co -I ""
OJ 0 po OJ
2 !:j !:j , , (J) 2 ,
-I "
N (J) ;;<; N , 0 ;;<;
0 eX; ~ )> '" -I )>
" "" ~ '" "
-I r r -I ~ "
0 0 -I
m po m 01 0
" (J) (J) "
, (J) 00 (J) , po "
-I N -I 2 ,
eX; 2 OJ (J) ~ '" -I
'" , '" ~ 'U
"" 0 ;;<; 0 -J
" 01 Ql
po " )> " OJ -I <0
(J) .:::! -I , 0 OJ <D
;0 ;;<; , N
W OJ 0 )> " ;;<;
0 , r- )> 0
" ;;<; ;0 -I "
-I )> ~ '"
0 -J
-J
" po
OJ
,
;;<;
)>
~~~~
r~r-~
;o....):'t'
~o~t;;
-r(/)"
~om~
)>G)r':""
Om'O')
::x:;o06
"TI;;: 0-< 0
r)> tp
wZI........
~cj::;::1t:l
....:z:~...
<;'Z
0:>;0
~o
'"
CD....;;:O
Q::5ot
zzO't'
-l<:;ool'o
O<:m't'
z~g~
OJo~':""
~~C~
~~~g
"TI .:..
, '"
w '"
w ...
....
W
01
....
o
w
'"
:Z:~'~~
m~F=;'
-l s>~
~6~'t'
~Olo~
~~~~
~::x:zg
~~;;:%:
;!1Q ~
w;o
~z
'"
I'V
'"
01
0:>
CDW;oO
Q:::3gt
~~6~
Ow-l't'
Z;o;O'"
ooom7'-
m m'"
~~m~
::c -Ig
;:I! ffig
w ;ool'o
w ...
....
W
01
!.
o
I'V
CD
~~o~
-<....z....
zzm't'
cj:z:~~
~~~~
~~m~
~-l g
"TI 6
, 0
w W
w ...
....
""
01
....
o
I'V
CD
0",,;;:0
~i::Ft
;o....):'t'
~~~y;
~o~~
~G)s.:..
om~~
::x:;o;oo
~iE~~
t:5~s::~
....0-l0
....:z:;o
<;'Z
0:>;0
~O
'"
ml'V^O
owmc;o
-<....;ool'o
zen:z:'t'
cj:Z:zt;;
z~ffi~
~:i;o,:"
~~O't'
0<;;:0
:r:mmg
~ 3:~
"" .....
"" ...
....
""
01
&,
CD
....
....
oen~CDO
~rrig;Qt
;o...zz't'
~gencjt;;
CD ~z~
~ ~~.:..
o Oen't'
~ ~~g
~ ~h~
"" W
i:: 0
....
I'V
rn
0:>
o
S::CD-l<~ ):~:;;!:;;~ S::~:;;!:;;~ S::CD-l<~ ):~:;;!:;;~ S::CD-l<~ S::~:;;!:;;~ ):CD-l<~
,~~o ,~~o ,~~o ,~~o
15g63t:~ 6g63t:~ ZOX,~ 6g63t:~ zox';o 15g63t:~ 15g63t:~ 15g63t:~
OG)CDCm ~<f>~ffim
~~~bC(J ~91&bC(> fl>ex,r;-r:ncp g,~h~C(> ~~~o,C(J ~~Z6CfJ ~R5~bc;n ~6~6cp
"'01"" ",,~I'V ~~~o OO(X)""~ W-.lOO~ ""01 CD O1rnrn I'V I'V
~~~ rnCD01 ~CDO O'lwf',.,).....l. 0') f'VU'l 0 CDl'Vrn O:>I'VO:> o I'V 0
0.... '" t,..)o~ 00"" -......J01Na> WWO>OO 0-...... ~,t:..~ 0 ... s:
W 01 0 0 0 0 c.o~o 01"'0 o '" 0 co ~ ~ I'V tn
w 0 '" '" -..
OJ,J:::..OJO
ooc'l"
-<-";::u..c:.
Z"'G)'t'
-lzmol'o
oOen't'
zenen'"
~~26
~:Z:f!l6
I r~
"'T1 11..:...
, Qaoo
w ,ol'o
w 00
.... -l
t;; :::!
!. m
o
01
'"
~
-..
N
o
o
01
W
(j,
CD
:,;.
w
-U
;;:
,CD-l<~
~,~~O
15g63E~
~~~~C(>
--...JNW(J\
W 0'>-10. 0
0><.00"10
01010
-u
a
"0
<t>
;::l.
'<
~
"0
"0
iil
(ji'
~
G)
Ci5
en en en en en en en en en
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
, , , , , , , , ,
m m m m m m m m m
'UCDO'U* 'UCDO'U* 'UCDO'U* 'UCDO'U* 'UCDO'U* 'UCDO-U* 'UCIlO'U* 'UCIlO'U* 'UCDO'U* 'U
~O~;O-l ~O~;O-l ~O~;O-l ~O~;O-l ~0~<:2-l ~O~;O-i ~O~;O-l ~O~;O-l ~O~;O-l Q)
G)O-io' G)O-lo' G)O-io' G)O-lo' ':"~':"~' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-io' G)O-io' a
~~~r:n ':":;,,&:m ':"?,r:nm m^mm ~?'~r:n lJ1:;"rpm r:"?,r:nm ,:,,:;,,':"m ~
o;::::jN~~ ~~~~:;E ~c5~o,~ ~c5;~~~ --O~NO ~::j~~~ goo~~ ,
~~5~g ~ti)egCJ O'>WCJ'1~O ~~~~o W~NOO ~8~~g ~ffi~~o W~--"010 ~~~go ~
0<0 ~~g o CD .t:o.(j)cDO ~t:3g CT
'" - co~g <.O~g ",0 '" - O'>~o 01-" '<
'" 0 I'V go CD
0 00 00 0:> .... 0 co 'U
s: .... 01 s: .... CD Q)
a
~
mZ-i'Us ~~:;;!;:g~ ~~:;;!;:g~ ~~:;;!;:g~ ~~:;;!;:g~ mZ-l'Us ~~:;;!;:g~ ~~:;;!;:g~ ~~:;;!;:g~ 0
~~5<55-l ~~5<55-l 0
<;'-;::1:3~0 <;'-;::1:3~0 ~~i2~0 O<XenG) ~~~~0 <;'~1:3~0 ~~~~0 ~
, , om0 :Cog,:", ' , om0
0_ , gCi50 gCi50 0_ , IO- . Q.
oen 0 xoeno xoeno oeno oen-" oU5~ xoeno
I'V-l~ I'V-l-" I'V-l-" I'V-l-" I'V-i-" I'V-iCO I'V-l-" 1'V-i0 I'V-i-" Z
b~g "TI , 0 ~gg ~gg ~gg ~~g "TI , 0 "TI . 0 ~g8 c:
ago ago go 3
OCD OCD OCD G) OCD OCD "TI OCD OCD ;0 CD 0<0 0 CT
Wco Wco ""co I'V Wco ""co W Wco Wco w co Wco .... ~
g-.. 8'" 8-.1 +:0- g-.. g'" w g-.. g-.. 0 -.. g'" 0
;0 ';0 0;0 "TI;o ,;0 en::o CD;o ::0;0 -" CD
0 -l- "TIo -l- -l- -"0 0- ~o 00
~g 00 ....0 _0
G) ~G) G) OG) ZG) ~ G) "TI-<
m wm m "TI~ m "TIm Om Qam -iz
:z: :z: .....:z: ':z: :z: -i:z: ~~ ,:z: o-i ::0
0 0 0 -lo 0 eno -i0 "TIO Q)
,Z 0..
0 0 0 "'0 0 ::00 enO 000 -l::x: c'
0 0 0 0 0 ~o eno -"0 ~r= !'!
::x: ::x: ::x: ::x: ::x: ....:1: en ? 0
;= ;= ;= ;= ;= -- m ""
, 0 en
, , , , , , en CD
en en en en en en "TI en , ....
-l en ^ 0
~ 0
en
;0 0
co m "TI,
~CD -l-i Z
m m Z Z Z , ~tn ;0 en I'V
~ I'V I'V -i Oco 0
N I'V '" 0 N en "TI ;OW "TI
'--' 0-" -l ~cj -l
0 0 "TI 0 0
"TI "TI "TI -l "TI I'V "TI 0
, , -l 0 Qa QaCO "TI
~ , m~
-l -l 0 "TI (/) -i r
~ "TI , W co CD' -l
I'V I'V , -l N -.. ' m c>>
w I'V -i -.... Qa 01 en -0
po po '" (/) 0 Qa "TIen :!'> Q)
, :z: , w "TI , .:::!en , 1O
-l Qa -l 0 -l Qa -" -l CD
en 01 , en <.oJ
"TI -i 0 c>>
I'V N .... po -l w co "TI 0
.... '" co 01
0 en 0 -l "TI
W r -l Qa <D
"TI I'V "TI m 0 ::0
"TI W 0 en
-l W en
en
j;;g~~~ j;;g~~~ OJ r-.J" (:) CO'UCOO CO"'OO gs~~~ .06 '-"'S; 0 O)wmO CD~L..O ~
Oom<:o 000<:0 O~~eo PJ:t:;=t O~::u"" O~;P"" -
~OJG)Zt:; 'COG)Z-I>o -<'-"';P-l>o -<CO-<-I>o -<c.n ;.. ~~~~ -<c.n0;" -<O();" ;;:;
S;Omm'f ZZ()'f ZOZ~ ZZ.<t> ::u....,... ZZ:E'" ZZ"''''
co~~F~ ;po~;" -=
~x5:=Vi d:E~Vi dXdY' d:EFil~ -4()m.... -4::Ez;" -4::Een;" 0
m""oo' oo-<Y' -<.-<(1 o u. 0,-",0Y' 0>
)>,...,)> ~ ;p~;p0Sc: ZW-tN z""z"" ZW-<N Z::u<-..... COO~~ Z~S;~ Z::uZ..... w
()-.J;pS;. ()-.J;pS;. OJ::Um<:o OJoooc;o CO::UC-"" OJOO<:o mG)r-':" aJOPJ~ COOG)-;'" u.
I G)O~ I G)O~ mO"U..... m m~ mOO':'" ~~~~ ;Pm'o> men<m m)>mcn <0
" ZIo "'T1 ZIb )>Cf)I<? ;p ;pO ;penI,? ()::u0. f;-4zb f;~~o :,;.
()-4mo () ()o ()-4Z0 ()0'U0 :r:s;-<8 w
r- m)>o ' m;po :I z~ :c I~ I ()~ IOI~ :r: -t:5 :x: G)g -0
(...) r- m N C,...) 1m'" ~)>o<<?
~ 5~g W ir-" " z. " ()o " 0 ~)::""g " "".:... -n m~ S;
~ O:I:~ 0 wZI...a.
, 0 , ~~ , 0 ~d:il!::l , :E~ , "" .....
? QoN b po-\. "" ::t "" "" ~ ~~ ~ "" "" 001
'-" "" '-" -I>o::E 0 "" ;po "" ;pO
0 .... .... 0 .... .... ::u ....
0> 0> "" '" " "" '-"'0 ';'Z "" Z "" ::u
'" N c.n c.n c.n -;'::u 0> c.n ::u
-.J - 0> ::u J,.. ;p J,.. m
.... 0 .... c.n ~O 0 c- o
0 ~ 0 "" -.J N '-" co
0 0 "" 0> - m
<0 0 <0 0> ,
,
)::OJ-4<;P )::CO-l<;P )::~~~f; )::CO~<;P )::OJ-I<;P )::OJ-I<;P )::OJ-I<;P )::OJ-I<;P )::CO-4<;P
,;p;pO ,;p;po ,;p;pO ,;p;po ,;p;pO ,;p;po ,;p;po
rs8~ER: rs8~ER: rs8~ER: z5x~0 rs8~ER: rs8~ER: rs8fiiER: rs8fiiER: zox'::u
OG)OJcf'g 2~~~rn
ID~r;-r:nCl) ~~~bC{J c5~~~C(J ~b66Cf' 66~~C(J b6~~c,n ~~Sbf{J ~~~~cr
~NNo' ....Jo......a.N.....a. '
o 0> ~ ONN N<.O.......~ c.n c.n '" o~"" 0,:)(j)CJ)e> wo~.....a.
o~- Oc.n'" CX>.....a........O')O 0> o 0 "" o_~ (J1:<Oo(X) 0'> 0 CD '"
O-.J~ oc.o~ .......(X)-...I,J:::..w 0 N 0 NN-.J -...1(...)0')0'1 WO~W
o>-.J 0 0 0'> CClc.oW 0 0 0> 0 0 O~f:: 0 0>0>0 O1~O
0> <0 -.Jc.n_ 0 -.J 0 0
<0
-0
a
'0
ro
..z
;p
'0
'0
Q3
en'
~
G)
05
en en en en en en en en en
;p ;p ;p ;p ;p ;p ;p ;p ;p
, , , , , , , , ,
m m m m m m m m m
'UCDO'Utj -oCDO'Utj 'UCDO'Utj 'UCDO'Utj 'UCDO'Utj 'UCDO-otj 'UCDO'Utj -oCOo'Utj -0 CD 0 'Utj 'U
;P0;P::U-4 ;PO;P::U-l ;PO;P::U-l ;PO;P::U-l ;PO;P::U-l ;P0;P::U-4 ;PO;P::U-l ;PO;P::U-l ;PO;P::U-l '"
G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)O-lo' G)0-40' G)O-lo' G)0-40' G)0-40' G)0-40' G)O-lo' ~
r:n;;"r:nm ~:;"Z::r:n r,n?,~m r,n?,r,nm r:n1'~r:n r:"::;"lJIm m;<:mm m;<:mm 1Jl=:,,1JIr:n
o;&=:~~~ cx>g::;:--~ ~~~~~ --.....a.~bD o;:::~~~ ~~~~~ o,':"'~,:",O ~g!;:':"'o ,
N(..o.)-~O NW-~O g~!:!!~o ~g;~ (") ~~i'3Q')O ~~~o(") ~~::;:g(") 5[
WO~O wO(Oo -.JNN ~Ng 0<0 0-
0>0>0 0>0>0 ())~g ~o --88 0> - _<0 "<
0 80 N <0
_0 -.JO 00 "" 00 0 .... 'U
0 "" ~ '"
n
~
~~~~~ ~~~~~ mZ-I'US; mZ-I'US; ~~~~~ mZ-I'US; ~~~~~ ~~~~S; ~~~~~ 0
0-;::E:i~0 0-;::E:i~0 ~~~55-1 X;P~C-I 0-;::E:i~0 ~~~55-4 0-;:::E:3~0 o<xen(j 0-;::E:i~0 0
:Co S2 r:n0 0-;::o~0 'b!2r,n0 =>
gU5~ 0_, 5;8050, 0_. 0_ , :i:b!2r,n' IO-, ~
oeno xO(J)O oen~ oeno oen~ XOCf)O XOCf)O
N-I_ N-I~ _ N -I.....a. N-I<O N-I-.J "'-10> N-I~ N-I~ N-I~ Z
~g8 b~8 ~b~g "'0 ~~g bg8 -6~8 " , 0 ~gg c:
go 'b~O 3
0<0 0<0 0<0 <0 0<0 0<0 0<0 0<0 0<0 :r: 0-
'-"0> Wo> '-"0> 0> ""0> ""co '-"0> '-"0> ""co "" ~
8- 8-.J 8-.J - 8-.J 8-.J g- 8- 8- 0>
- CD CD CD ' CD CD OJ ""CD Z OJ ::u::u ::u ::u
Filo '0 -10 '0 c.n0 NO ~\5 \5 \5
en-< "'-< en-< "'-< Ro-< ,,-<
enz NZ -Z ~Z -G) G) G)
Z -4Z m m m
z-I -4 -1-1 -I '-I 0-4
0 0 :r:O 0 -10 :E :E :E ::u
,,~ Q)
;:;z Z ::UZ Z o>z 0 0 0 Cl.
"I I CI :r: ?I ':r: 0 0 0 c:'
-IJIl m ~m m mm -1m 0 0 0 ~
::uG) G5 ;::G5 G5 en - '-"- I :r: :r: 0
enG) CD'"
o:r: :r: r- :r: :r: ::E~ ,:r: ;= ;= ;=
~~ -I m-l -I ",-4 , , r- ....
en en en en ~en ~en en en en <::>
;p en;p ;p o;p ;p 0
-0 0 :EO 0 ,,0 0 , ,
CDO 0 ~O 0 .:j0 0 -I -I
, ,
;<:::u ::u 0;0 ::u CD::U ::u ;:::; ;:::;
Nm m "m m ,m m !:i 0> c.n
< < -1< < ;<:$ <
05 05 0;05 05 ~en 05 en
m m ,m m m m
0 0 ",0 0 0 0 N
'U 'U ~'U 'U 'U -0 -.J
, , , , ! , ""
Z en :z: ,
-.J -.J , -4 N
c.n 0 ;:; -I en 0>
" <.n '-" ;== "U
"
-I N -I ? ;== m Q)
(Q
0 " 0 m m en <D
" -4 en en en
0 " en en ....
, en
-I " , z Z 0
en , -I ~ "
en N ;:;
-I 0> " " <0
en
-I -I .::! " -I
0 0 -4 ::u
.... -I "" ::u 0
Z 0 , ~
.... -I
() Z en
Z () .... N
0 ""
~~~~ CD{,.o.)<-O ~~'~~ ~~e5~ (IJ~2:::a:~ (IJWGlO -0-0:.>0 (IJW;:UO ~~~~~ ~
00:'>0:> QWhi?Oj.. o~mC'F :'>OGl'1" ~~~t .::::'
-<o~J;. -<Woj.. -<"':.>.... -<(IJ;:u.... -<z;:ut; ,(IJz.... ,(IJGlz....
z:a:-i':" zz^':" zz:r:Cf ZO-i':" zzmz':" :;!:Om~ ~:a:F~ :;!:omm':" '"
~:a:~j.. 0
-i(IJ:r:.... (j:a:8t;; (j:a::.>t;; -ixot;; (j:a:zmt;; (IJXFUl (DX5~~ 0
Oom.... z"":O'~rV o....z. o~;:u"" ~o:>o":" 0(IJG5.... mo:> O' <7'
z-<:a:Sl z"""ZrV z....enSl z~:a:;:U":" zen:.>Sl ZOO"" :.>"':.> "" <.oJ
g{~~~ (IJeno'1" CD~~~ (IJO>C' wen:.>:.> 0:> (])-4C~ O~)>cp W-<:.>'1" O.....:.>:;!:'1" c.;,
m~:r:-' m:.>;:uO m-...JNO m~:::or=~ m:.>OO :r: Z~ mZ<-, :r: GlO~ '"
:.>O:.>'? :.>:'>:.>'? f><~6 :.> :.>' :.>:.>zmo :.><;:U. -n Gl'? f>(j5~ ~ ~$:g :,,;.
oz;:ug o<;:uo ~ ~~ 0<mm6 ~m~~ , mO <.oJ
:r:m,o moo :r:m;:Uz~ ,0 :r:z:;!:~ -0
:r:www :x: m~ W W ,m ""
Ilm)>6 -n m~ ~ :a:~ -n m6 ~ ;d ~ -n 06 <.oJ 0":-' -rrOJQOo w 5~g :s
1)>:::00 r cn~ , m"" , ~ .... :.>~ r~L.o ....
0:> 0:>
c:....>())>...... W 'W W ~ W ..... w :r: w w 0 to ~o6~ 0 Ul
~IO-- w QO~ W 0 w 0 w , 0 w 0 0 6 QO ""
.... .... .... .... 0 .... ....:r:_
WOJ W W N W ;:u W = ~~~ 0:>
"', (n (n .... (n (n 0:> N
N .....
J,.< .... J,. ..... l:.<~
5:0 .... .... 0
0 0 0 0 0
'" 0 0 0 (n N
'" (n (n (n
>~~j;f> >OJ-i<:.> >w~<:.> ,W-i<:.> >~~j;f> >OJ-i<:.> >OJ-i<:.> >~~j;f> >~~j;f>
,:'>:'>0 z5xf:0 :'>,:'>:'>0 ,:'>:'>0 ,:'>:'>0
~gEi'3E~ ~gEi'3E~ ~gEi'3E~ ~gEi'3E~ zox,;:u ~gEi'3E~ ~gEi'3E~ ~gEi'3E~
OGl(IJC~ OGlOJCm
~8S:~cr a,~r;-r:ncn ~~~~'fJ ~~~~cp ~~&:~C{J ~~r;-r:ncn ~~~~'P ~mr;-r:ncn ~8~~CfJ
.......o.J::o........' <..nw<..n....:o.' oen.-.o'
wo:>..... m-...Jr-.Jcn ~wf',.J..,::.. 0> ~.... O>f',.Jo.J::o. NOlWCXI NO>O ~ 0> 0> ON~
....."'..... <.0 .-. W en oa>CXlw '" 0 ~ <.Da><ClC) WNWO <.oJ",O> Nc..n<.o 0 0"'....
..........0> o~OenO OO())-"-...JO 0.......... OU'1 (0 (0 <.00<0..,::.. "'0'" ~o~ r-v o~'"
'" w 0 O~W;.." <'O-...J~ '" 0 -...J~o ~.l::>-~o N 0 '" 0
N 00:> 0> <0 ..... W <0 o ~
....
-0
a
'"
CD
;+
'<
:.>
'"
'"
OJ
Vi'
~
Gl
en
en en (/) en en en en en en
:.> :.> :.> :.> :.> :.> :.> :.> :.>
, , , , , , , , ,
m m m m m m m m m
-owo-ot5 -0 OJ 0-0 t5 -oOJo-ot5 -owo-ot5 -owo-ot5 -owo-ot5 -owo-ot5 -o(IJo-ot5 -owo-ot5 -0
:.>0:'>;:U-i :'>O:'>;:U-i :'>O:'>;:U-i :.>0:'>;:U-i ~8::;~-;-l :.>0:'>;:U-i :.>0:'>;:U-i :.>0:'>;:U-i :.>0:'>;:U-i Ql
Glo-io' GlO-io' Glo-io' GlO-io' Glo-io' GlO-io' GlO-io' GlO-io' n
m^mm m::;"r:nm r:n?,':11m ~~~r:n r;n?,r;n~ r:n::;"r:nm m^mm m^mm r;n^r;nm ~
~6~j,.0 J,.~~j,.o "'.-.~~o <Doe~~ :::j::::~~~ ;::;~~~~ J,.~~Co:a: ~b~~~ U;~~~:a: ,
~~~go gj~~;::jo t;;:!:::~00 -"~WCO ~~~~o ~
~:j~gO ~~NOO c:oc.o-ffio '-'-...J"""'oo ~w::;:go
o~g ~~~ ",'" cnoc.oo ~28 -...J.J::o.-O ~<Oo rr
0:>0 a>~o 0>0 w",o DU;O 0>0:>0 '<
= 0
0:> 0 N '" 0 (n 0 0:>0 ..... -0
w <0 W 0> Ql
0:> n
~
~;~g; ~ ;:g S ~g; ~ ;:g S mz~-o:s mz~-o:;!: ~~~;:gS ~~~;:gS ~~~;:gS ~~~;:gS ~~~;:gS 0
x:'>XC-i ~~X~-i 0
~~~~0 ~~~~0 ~~0~0 ' , om0 o<XenGl ~~f2fP0 ~~~~0 ~~f2fP0 ~~~~0 ~
0_, :r:gen6 ~~U56 0_, :i::6Qr;n' 0_ , 0_ , Q.
0(/)0 oeno Xoeno XO(/)O oeno oen~ oen~
N-i~ .?<N-i~ -i ~ N-i~ - "" --i -" N-i~ N-i~ N-i..... N-i'" z
~~8 I"TlIO ~~g -n . 0 ~~gg ~~g ~gg bg8 ~gg
XboO o~O c:
I8~ F5 3
0", 0", -0 0", 00<0 0<0 = <0 0<0 =0 0", rr
Wo:> Wo:> w Wo:> Ow 0:> Wo:> Wo:> Wo:> -0 Wo:> ~
g..... xg-...J 0 g..... <0 g..... 000-." g..... g..... g..... g.....
;:uO
0
0:>
~
X
ow ww WOJ W OJ W W ,(IJ 0:> W
-nO ....0 Wo Q 0 0 0 -i0 ~Q
,-< -i-< w-< -< -< -< (/)-<
-iZ oz 'z Z Z Z Z .....z wZ
en-i w-i ^-i -i -i -i -i -i-i , -i ;:u
~O 0>0 NO 0 0 0 0 :r:O ^O Ql
- Z -z Z Z Z Z z ;:uz NZ a.
!"':r: z:r: :r: :r: :r: :r: :r: C:r: :r: E'
en m om m m m m m <0 m m ~
~G5 w - G5 G5 G5 G5 G5 r=:=G5 G5 0
,Gl
"':r: ^ :r: :r: :r: :r: :r: :r: m :r: :r:
-n -i N-i -i -i -i -i -i en-i -i ....
-ien en (/) en en (/) en en en en =
0:.> :.> :.> :.> ;:u :.> :.> z:.> :.> 0
-no 0 0 0 m 0 0 ~O 0
:a:'? 0 0 0 < 0 0 00 0
~;:U ;:u ;:u ;:u -0 ;:u ;:u -n;:u ;:u
-m m m m , m m -im m
N< < < < :.> < < z< <
0- en en en -i en en :a:-o en
-nen
m m m m m m N' m
'0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-i-o , Z
-0 -0 -0 -i -0 -0 0 -0
w, , , , en , , ,
QO, m , , N , , :.> ,
Z-i U; -i -i W -i -i < -i
~en en en en en m (/)
o~ " ~ N -i ~ ~ ;:u '" -0
-n-i -i ..... 0 <0 ~ QO Ql
-i0 0 QO -i N QO QO 0> co
0 0> CD
O(n " W N N OJ r
" - N W Z N 0 '"
,z , QO 0 0 OJ OJ , m 0
-i ^
-i0 :a: z OJ , , en "
en _ W ^ ^ N en <0
~hi 5-> 0 ,
0 ^ N N Z
-ien :.> OJ N 0
, " ,
oen , -I ^
"
'" en 0 0 N -i
" " en
(n , , ;:u
" -i -I
-i en
w~wo CDI'V^O OJ""" {... ~ (lJ-C::lo-G)o W~O<:> (])->.(")o (Df'V110 ~~~~ OJf'V"'Uo ~
oNm'l" 00c:'l" O~)>~ g~~t O~I'l" O~I'l" OO:;o'l" 00)>'l" .....
-<O~t; -<-..I>.m.p.. -<Z~w :;;::~~t; :;;::~~t; -<N)>~ -<O~~ -<...O~ ~.
zZI'f )>~:s:W ~:E~t: z:E~'f ZZ-W
~om~ ~:Ez~ ~:E)>~ :;o-n:S:~ ~enen~ ~enen~ ~WI~ ~:E:=i;; 0
OG);O.... O~o"" 0~G).... )> 0 en"" 0:EiT1.... 0::ii:iT1.... oro-01 OOm.... ON)>' <.n
Z:E~~ ZenI'" ZenZN cg~ G) ll<l ~~t5~ ~~~~ zOen..., Z-<:E~ ZZ(J)'" (,.)
wOO":" CO-l;o~ ro~O'l" ro-<C~ OJZcn~ roO)>'l" U;
mOIo ~~(i5c? m)>CC; zc~~ m-lm-- m-tm....a. mZr--- m-lOJO ~~~C? <D
)>0)>6 )><ro' -nzo. )>IZC;:> )>IZC;:> )>~_o )>0)>' :,;.
om"o ~m~~ 1--1)>8 ~~b~ ~~b~ 00C:6 oz:;o8 o )>0 (,.)
00;00 I poS IZeno :r: -8 'U
I_OO1 w~ W -nroG)'f Irorow
,,:::0.0 -n <-6 -n Z' ~~ b ;TImg~ ;3Jmg~ -nm)>6 -n 6 $:
r _0 r 0'" r 0;;3 ~ ~ ,m g r)>:;Oo r ~
W -~ W )><<> W po~ ~ ~~ W )>~ w)> CD wo)>a> w
w 0 w ZO w w wO <:> ~:r:()o w '"
... ... ~ ... po ... po "'I ...
w w 0 W N N N Wro Wro W
en '" '" en en "'r ~~ '"
~ ~ '" ~< .l:.
~ 0 0 '" '" ~O 0
0 0 ... ... 0 m
... W W ... ... N '" 0>
'" <<> <0 (,.)
~~~;;f; ~~~;;)> ~ro~<)> ~~~;;f; ~ro~<)> ~ro~<)> ~ro~<)> ~ro~<)> ~ro~<)>
r)>)>o r)>)>o r)>)>o r)>)>o r)>)>o r)>)>o
zoxr:;o zoxr~ 5.gfi:lc~ ~gfi:lc~ ~gfi:lc~ ~gfi:lc~ ~gfi:lc~ zoxr:;o ~gfi:lc~
oG)wC:m oG)roC:m ,0 G) ro c: m
~~Z~Cf' mthr:-r:ncn b1cb'r:"cn ~~~~f{> ~~~~C{J ~~~6:C{J ~~~~cp ~~~bCf' w~r:-r:n{J)
t.n<ot.n-..l>.' ~w~~, -.I-.....JI'..>......'
"'<0'" (X).s::..Q)CJ') ~tOrv~ enmW "'m~ ~N"'" w",<O ~ ~ 0> ON 0......
",,,,01 Oo~c..n OtD~t.n <0<00 0...0 <00>..... 00>0> N.....O .....a.c.otO.,J:::lo.
-.J0'l~ I'V--Q)rv (X:l-......J-Jr,.~ OW~ 0><00 "'W~ o ~ 0> "'0>'" .,J:::.........Ow
0 -..J~o tOga a '" 0 a 000;; 0 o N 0 "'00
N W ..... 00 '"
'U
a
'Cl
CD
~
)>
'Cl
'Cl
OJ
Vi'
!:!;
G)
Ui
en en en en en en en en (J)
)> )> )> )> )> )> )> )> )>
r r r r r r r r r
m m m m m m m m m
'Uwo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'Uroo'U~ 'U
)>O)>;o~ )>O)>;o~ 1;g~~-;-I )>O)>;o~ 1;g~~-;-I 1;0~~~ )>O)>;o~ )>O)>:;o~ )>O)>:;o~ OJ
G)O~o' G)O~o' G)O~o' G)O~o' G)O~o' G)O~o' Ci
r;n:;"r;nm ~?'~r:n f71?,r:n~ r;n:;"r;nm r;n:;"m~ mOmo' r:n::;"r:nm r;n?'~r:n r:'1;;"r:nm ~
.1',m
~c:;i5Cn~ ~w~~~ ~r:::;~cJ,~ ~N~~:E ~w~"'~ ~~::a:~g ~~e~:E r
tO~~c;g $[
tO~~gO fd::t::a:o r-u......-"'()'lD --O1~~O 0)0'>00 ......c:...>~~o COex>-o ~~~~o
8~~ ~~g ~~g ~~8 -..1-.1 cD 0 c:r
OJ~o 0<0 ....."'0 N<oO '<
'" ~C>
a '" 0 ~ ~ 00 'U
'" ~ 00 OJ
Ci
~
mZ~'U$: ~g;~~S ~g;~~S ~~~~S ~~~~S ~~~~S ~~~~S ~~~~S ~~~~S 0
x)>xc:~ 0
<:>~0~0 <:>-;:::fj~0 o<XenG) <:>-;:::fj~0 <:>~fj~0 <:>-;:::fj~0 C;>C;=:t3~0 <:>~fj~0 ~~fj~0 ::J
IO-, :tc,Qr;n' 0_. 0_, 0_ , ~
acnb xoeno XO(J)O 0(J)0 acne o en 0 oen--.. oCi5~ xoCi5b
N~~ N~~ _ N-I-" N~~ N~~ N~O> N~N N~--" _ N --I -to. Z
~~g b~g I"'T1IC) ~~g b~8 -n . a -n . a b~g :E-n.o c
.?<g~O ago 0:$0 xggo 3
0<0 0<0 ~~~ 0<0 0<0 a to 'U 0<0 0<0 ~~ c:r
<->00 Woo Woo W 0> W 0> Woo Woo
g--.. g..... 0--" g--.. g..... g--.. 'U g--.. g--.. 0--" !:!;
ro ro ro ro roro -nro en w o>ro ow
0 0 0 0 ro ~O :;00 gQ -nO
-< -< -< -< "-< 0-< 00-< :E:;;::
Z Z Z Z WZ -nZ oZ WZ
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :Eb ... ~ r~ ~~ :;0
0 0 0 0 0 -0 7'0 NO OJ
Z Z Z Z Z ~z ~z wZ OZ Cl.
I I I I I NI "I I -nI E'
m m m m m Om wm m rm ~
G) G) G) G) G) -nG) G) G) ~G) a
:J: :J: :J: :J: I rI :J: I WI
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ -l ~ ' ~ ...
en en (J) en en ~ en en en Zen 0
)> )> )> )> )> (0)> )> )> "')> a
0 0 0 0 0 WO 0 0 "'0
0 0 0 0 0 ~O 0 0 ::!:jO
:;0 :;0 :;0 :;0 :;0 w:;O ;0 :;0 0:;0
m m m m m m m m -nm
< < < < < < < < <
Ui Ui Ui Ui Ui Ui Ui Ui rUi
m m m m m m m m ~m
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 enO
" 'U 'U 'U 'U 'U " 'U -~~
r r r r r r r r
r r ~ r m en r r ~ en
~ ~ ~ ~ --.. ~ ~ ?>~
en en (J) en N '" en en Qo'"
:-" N N N <0 0 'U
<0 ()) N 0 -n z::!:j
N ~ ~ --.. OJ
~ ~ ~ -n 0 0 "'0 <0
po 0 0 0 r po "'" CD
W W N N ~ -n en 00 ~~ ())
ro N 0> '" to r r 0
~ Z
r Z Z Z en m OU> -n
" 0 0 0 po 0 en -n ~ <0
'" r ---.. r en ::ii::N
ro ro ro ~
r r r en m Z
" " " 0> en <:; ~~
N u>
W W W 0 po
po en Z -n '"
<:; ~ "
~ --.. en ~
<.n -n :;0
~
OJWGJO OJ"';>; 0 CD W","" ::J OJWCJC O)(..o.)^C OJwrC >/lJ"'GlO 00(...)00 OJ->.roC ~
0"'0'P o"'m CO OO;:o'P o~m'P 0~:c'P 0"'0'P oWr'iO ~~gt 0=0'P
l. --l
-<<.n;:o.... -<"" -<"'-I.... -<OW.... -<"')>.... -<....(J).... -<0)>.... -<Zot; ~
~~m~ ~~~ ..... ~~en~ ZZ;:o..... ZZO't' zzm'f zz(J)'f zz;:o't'
l. -I~ol. -I~m"" -I~;:O"" b~~~ b~~~ ~~uJl. 0
ooGl':'" oo~ U'O O.-~Y1 ~~~:c o~;:o':'" ~cn~:C 0"';:0':'" <.n
Z(')C:'" z(')m IV ~~C~ z(J)(J)'" z~o", zcn~Scl z;:ooScl '"
m-<CO wmz ~ (J)ZCO w-lC:'P OJ-i:;:Oqo ffi~~~ (j,
OJ)>--4~ m)>O m)>)>..... W-l~.:... m)>S;!o ~~~~ (I]-i)>~ CDOOJ~ ~
~ZQO<;=' )>Z-< 0 )><Z<;=' m)>)>O )>:t><? m)>-<O m(/)mO :0;.
('))> 0 ('))>(J) b ~m;:O~ )><;:ob )><zb (')mzo (')<mo )><zb f)-I~g '"
:J:< ~ 0 ~m;:o~ ~mz~ :J: z~ :J:m;:oo (')mmo 'U
:J:< m -n z~ :c '" :c mU'O
11m b "m ~ " ~ ;:D ~~ " mb " mb " b ;:!J Qog S
, '" , , ' :c..... , 0 r mg , ~
'" w '" <0 '" m '" <- w ..... 0 '" U'O '" QO", '" '" (')....
'-" 0 '" 0 '-" 0 '-" QOO '" 0 '" 0 '" 0 ..... 0 '-" -0
.... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... z
'-" '-" ..... '-" '-" '-" '-" '-" W 0
<.n <.n <.n <.n <.n <.n <.n <.n <.n -<
l. j". j". .6. ,
.... .... 0 .... 0 0 .... .... ....
.... .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 '"
'-" '-" '" 0 '" '" 0 0 ....
--J --l '" '" '"
S;:~~;;f) S;:~~;;f) S;:W-l<)> S;:OJ-I<)> S;:w~<)> S;:W-I<)>
,)>)>(') ,)>)>(') z5x~(') ,)>)>(')
~8~E:fg ~8~E:fg ~8~E:fg ~8~E:fg OGlwc:fg ~8~E:fg
~~~~cp Cr>~r:-r:n(f) &.~r:-r:ncn ~~Z6cr ~~~bCP .!...tcbr:-r:ncn
OlO-......J->.' ~NOl-'" .-otn-,,'
Q')WOOl (X) o.;=.. 0') ';="ON-.I ...."'.... ....0'-" <0 -" C,.o.) 0')
c.o.:;:...()'\01 o o::>W 0'> orv-......J---t. O<.n'-" O~'" -..aO'lNN
c:>~c.oO NN"'O'> (X) 0 C,.o.)o> (x)<D~ OJ(x)~ -"'0<0..-0
..... '-" 0 (O-"'~o NOlOO 0 0 mrv(....>
.... --J '" ~....
s;:~~;;f)
~8~E:fg
~~r:-r;n(/)
OlO-"O'
'" 0 ~
W--l<.n
c.orv~
S;:~~;;f)
~8~E:fg
.h~r;-r:ncn
O'1tnNO'
",coO
(..o.)(J'lW 0
<O<D(X) :-.
",,-,, w
co --l
--l
S;:~~;;f)
~8~E:fg
~~l:~CP
~<om~
o-..ww
co-",-.....Iv..>
<.n--l0
'"
'U
a
"tl
ro
~
)>
"tl
"tl
iil
tn'
~
Gl
en
!='
W
--l
--l
(J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (J) (j)
)> )> )> )> )> )> )> )> )>
, , , , , , , , ,
m m m m m m m m m
'UOJo'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'UOJ 0 'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'UWo'Ut5 'U
)>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 )>0)>;:0-1 OJ
Glo-lo' Glo-lo' Glo-lo' Glo-lo' GlO-lo' Glo-lo' Glo-lo' Glo-lo' Glo-lo' C'l
r:"::;"r:nm m;>;mm m;>;mm r;n~r:nm fll:;"fllm ~:;"~r;n r;n:;"r;nm r:n:;"r:"m r:n~fllm ffi.
~c;~cO~ ~~~N~ ~~~o,~ ~~~N~ ~&i:iN:E ~O;~~~ :::j:::j~N~ ~~NCr>~ ,
COO~O~ ~
~Ol::;;~O Ol~~~O oc.o-~o ~8t;2g;o w-.l:.".:i:~O -"CO-"'O CXlWi':3~O ~c.nO">~o cn-......J:.".:i:oO
~",O (J'lNU;O .p.-"'c.oc> o::~ ....o<.n ~N~ N.b.:::;:O 0-
...."'0 "'gg <O~O c>~g ....~O "'00 go ....."'0 '<
co 00 '" ....0 co 'U
<.n <.n '" .... <.n OJ
co C'l
ffi.
mz~'Us mZ-l'Us ~;g;~~~ ~g;~~~ ~g;~~~ ~g;~~~ ~g;~~~ ~;~g; ~ ~ ~ ~g;~~~ (')
X)>xC:-I ~~~55-1 0
~~Q~0 ' , om0 (')<X(J)Gl 0~E:J~0 0~E:J~0 0~E:J~0 0~E:J~0 0~E:J~0 0~E:J~0 ::J
:1:0-, :cbS2r;n' genb 0_ , :Coenb 8006 0_ , :cgenb ~
XO(j)O XO(J)O xO(J)O O(j)o o (J) 0
- N --t.- "'-I..... "'-I..... "'-I..... "'-I..... XN--i-'" "'-I~ "'-I..... X "'-I"'" Z
:C"bo " , 0 " , 0 bg8 " , 0 b~g b~g ~gg ~~8 c
Xoc:oO o~o o~o b~O 3
0", 0", 0", 0", ~ 0", 0", 0", 0", o '" 0-
wco '-"co wco wco wco wco wco wco w co
g--J g-J g-J g--J 0 g-J g-J g-J g-J g-J ~
....
W W W W W W ' W ' W W
0 0 0 0 0 0 -10 -10 0
-< -< -< -< -< -< (J)-< (J)-< -<
z z z z z z wz .....z Z
-I -I -I -I -I -I QO-I QO-I -I ;:0
0 0 0 0 0 0 ....0 ",0 0 OJ
Z Z Z Z Z Z WZ WZ Z D..
:c :c :c :c :c :c ,:C ,:C :c i::'
m m m m m m ;>;m ;:<;m m ~
Q Q Q Q Q 0 "'0 "'0 Q 0
:r: :r: :r: :r: :r: :r: :r: :c :c
-I -I -I -I -I -I -I -I -I ....
(j) (J) (j) (j) (J) (J) (j) (J) (J) 0
)> )> )> )> )> )> )> )> )> 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0
m m m m m m m m m
< < < < < < < < <
en en en en en en en en en
m m m m m m m m m
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'U 'U 'U 'U 'U 'U 'U 'U 'U
, , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , ,
-I -I -I -I -I -I -I
(j) (j) (J) (J) (J) (J) (j)
'" ~ <.n -.... 'U
'-" '" -'" 0 -I OJ
-I -I -I -I :r: <.n <0
0 0 -J 0 0 ;:0 QO ro
'" '" QO c: '" --J
'" '" <.n N '" W 0
Z Z co Z Z , "
(') (') W (') (') z ;>; <D
, (') <.n
W W ;>; W W W
, , , ,
;>; ;>; '" ;>; ;>; ,
;:<;
'" '" '" '" '"
OJN'-O O~OO ~~.~~ ~~gg OJ>o>:;:::g CD ""G) 0 "\DW<O OJVJ(J)O lJJWOOO ~
00>0> mO;oc;o g~O~J;.. Q~5;t ooo'l" oa~c;o o~o'l" --J
-<-<>-zJ,. fCJ10~ -<ex>-t~ -<N>J,. -<c.n,~ -<<0>".. -<"':2:"" i'5
zZZ't' ::OZO't' ZZO't' Zz:;:::'t' )>t::3Z0~ ~:2:~J:: ~:2:~J:: ~:2:a;J:: Z:2:en't' 0
-t:2:;;;;"" >m","" cj:2:ent:; cj:2:-ot:; -tOmt:; 0
o~cn<{' -< mtn ~ :2:~.... OOm.... oo~.... Ooen.... 00::0' '"
Zenm'" lJJ~::U~ Z~;U':'" Z~o'" ~ ~O~ ZO-<'" zom'" ZO~'" Zmol:iil ""
OJ-tz'l" ~II':" lJJcn~c;o OJ~~~ ~ :i~~ CD~:2:~ CDm;:t>~ CDmO'l" CD)>)>~ U.
~~CC? m-l)>-- ~~~~ m>>~ <0
oenmo >>m"? ~>r="? ~zm,,? )>Zz'? mz<o :,;.
Omoo I-tF;;6 0<,0 0<'0 ~ ~~g O>ZO ~?CQg 0>>0 f)>o6 ""
I =i~ ""Tl Z~ Im>~ Immo "" 0.... Iri'i~~ :c<'-~ Iri'i~g -0
::0.... ""Tlm~b
" ~6 ~ po6 " 6 " :;:::6 "" 06 ;I! :;:::8 ;TIm~8 " 06 $:
, 0'" "" ... , 0 ~ 05: .... QOO ~ po~ ' m'"
"" >:::: ".. ... "" co 00 ... "" tn "" Z... "" CD....
"" .... 0 "" 0 "" ~o 0> 0 "" 0 "" 0 ~ ,0 "" ::00
-<>- Z .... -<>- .... -<>- -<>- t:; >
"" "" "" N "" "" ""
tn '" '" -<>- '" '" '" '" m
~ -<>- ~ ~
0 -<>-
0 N -<>- .... -<>- -<>- -<>-
0 00 0 0 -<>- -<>- -<>- ""
-<>- 0 0 "" "" "" "
-<>- -<>- " " "
S::~~~f) S::~~~f) S::CD-t<> S::CD-t<> S::OJ-t<> S::CD-t<> ,OJ-t<> ,OJ-t<> S::~~~f)
,>>0 ,>>0 ,>>0 ,>>0 >,>>0 >,>>0
zox,::o ~86H:fg ~8&'iE:fg ~8&'iE:fg ~8&'iE:fg zox,::o ~8&'iE:fg ~8&'iE:fg ~8&'iE:fg
o G) ~c m o G),CD C m
~~Cn~C(J .6.&r:-r:nCf) o,&,r;-rpCf) ~2;~~CP o,.:.,.r;-r;nen ~&;~~Cf t;;~~~Cf ~~~b'f> ~i:;~~C('
U"l<.n-lo.ol -...J~....:o.o' OlW'-"O'
mwlOQ NCTl"" 0>00-<>- ..r:=o. -...J -- (J1 OON<O N..r:=o.ex>O Nf\..)N~ NON cnO-...JlO
(0 -...J ~ (]l ""~o N""<O 00>0><.0 0-<>-00 ww-...Je....> wc:.nO'l-...J ""00-<>- <..0 ~ ex> .....
Oo>.-..lo. ~ <0",00 -...J<.n3; ex>w-a.O N<oN "'0 0> en CDOO'>-J <0-<>-"" o -Jt. <.n <X>
-Jt.N~o '" 0 0 <D..r:=o.~o 0<0 0 ~ffiC> (Jl"':to N 0 -...Jf'.)~c>
-<>- N 0>" N W
-0
a
-0
CD
~
>
-0
-0
OJ
C;;'
~
Gl
Ci5
en en en en en (/) en (/) (/)
> > > > > > > > >
, , , , , , , , ,
m m m m m m m m m
-OOJO-Ot5 -oCDO-Ot5 -oCDO-Ot5 -OOJO-Ot5 -oCDo-ot5 -oCDO-Ot5 -OOJO-Ot5 -OOJO-Ot5 -0 OJ 0-0 t5 -0
>O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t >O>::O-t l>l
G)O-to' GlO-to' GlO-to' G)O-to' GlO-to' G)O-to' GlO-to' G)O-to' G)O-to' C'l
m",mm r:"?,r:"m r:'?,r:"m fl1=?,r:nm r;n:;"r;nm ~:;"~r;n r:";;"r:r'm rr'?,r;nm ~:;"~r;n !!!.
g~~m~ O~~.:.,.~ R3Ne~~ ~O;~~~ ~~~.:.,.o ~~seoR ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ",g::;:.-a.O ,
~~2~O 55tB~~O g~8O -a.w......w ~~~oo co~~ O')cno~ NO....:o.OO :l;;!N::;gO 5[
-...J~~8 cn~~ c.o~2~ IT
())ill8 CD~g -lo.~O 0>0 ~i'3g ~ffi '<
<0 00 0 ::50 0 W ~ 80 0> -0
"" -<>- 0 0 N -<>- l>l
"" C'l
~~~;g~ ~~~;g~ !!!.
~~~;g~ ~~~;g~ ~~~;g~ ~~~;g~ ~~~~~ mz-t-o$: ~~~;g~ 0
~?C?<55-t 0
<;'>-;::~~0 <;'>-;::~~0 <;'>-;::~~0 <;'>-;::~~0 <;'>-;::~~0 <;'>t;~~0 <;'>-;::~~0 <;'>-;::~~0 =>
I ,om0 ~
:]:0-. 0_ . 0_, IO-I 0_, Iocnb :c.O-1 0_. IO- ,
XO(/)O o en 0 0(/)0 XO(/)O 0(/)0 XO(/)O 0(/)0 xoeno
N-t~ N-t~ N-tOO . f\..) --i ~ N-t~ XN-t~ N-t~ N-t~ N-t~ Z
~~8 " , 0 ~~8 I"bO " . 0 ~gg ~~8 " . 0 b~8 c
0 o~o Xo(X)O ago o~o 3
0<0 0<0 0<0 ::0 0<0 0<0 G) 0<0 0<0 " 0<0 0<0 $: ![
""00 N ""00 ""00 0 Woo ""00 N ""00 ""00 00 "" 00 ""00 -<>-
8" <0 8" 8" N 8" 8" .... 8" 8" -<>- 8" g-.! 0
CD CD CD OJ CD OJ CD OJ OJ
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q 0
-< -< -< -< -< -< -< -<
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z
-t -t -t -t -t -t -t -t -t ::0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 l>l
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z a.
I I I I I I I I I c'
m m m m m m m m m en
Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q 0
:r :r I :r I :r I I I
-t -t -t -t -t -t -t -t -l -<>-
(/) (/) en en (/) en en en (/) 0
> > > > > > > > > 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
::0 ::0 ::0 ::0 ::0 ;:0 ::0 ::0 ::0
m m m m m m m m m
< < < < < < < < <
en en en en en en en en en
m m m m m m m m m
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-0 -0 -0 -0 -0 -0 -0 -0 -0
, , , , , , , , ,
, , !:j , , , , , ,
-l -t -t -t -t -l -t -t
en en (/) (/) en (/) en en en
"" ~ 00 '" W "" ~ N -0
-t -t -t '" W " w
-t QO 0 0 0 QO QO QO -t <0
0 " w "" "" 0 CD
N 0 -<>- 00
0; 0> -<>- N ""
OJ Z -z z OJ OJ OJ 0 0
z , 0 0 , , , z "
0 '" 0 CD CD '" '" '" CD
" OJ , , 0> CTl 0> 0
CD , '" '" OJ
, '" " " ,
'" " '"
" 0>
WNCJ)O ""VJNOO OJ"-':;;::O OJ"-';:::O ~
O-",-CO O"-')>c;o O"-'cc;o O"'mlf' --J
-<CDS:~ -<~s:"" ~~~~ -<CD,. ;;0;
~~~;: ~~r=;: Z~<'" 0
ooFn'>" -lOm.... -lOZJ. 0
00'-'>" 00;:0'>" 000'>" c.n
zoO", ZO;:o'" ~m~~ Zmo~ '-'
rom:::I:C?' OJ~O! (j,
m)>Z.... m~z~ CD)>Z~ w
)>ZO'? ~ZW? mz)>O :t>
~~Qo~ O)>mO )>OJenb >)>10 '-'
I<Zo O,-lo 0<00 -u
11m(/)6 I<m.... ~m b
;:TIm ~ ;DO~~ :;;::
, ~ ' ....
'-' '" '-' 0 w m CD w ....
'-' 0 w w zo '-' 0
.... .... .... )> ....
'-' w w w
c.n c.n c.n Qo c.n
.;,.. 0 .;,..
.... .... .... ....
.... .... w C w
w '-' c.n , c.n
c.n c.n 0
m
.
s;:~:;);:f;
5gfi:iE:~
~~~~C{'
"'-'0)0>-'"
wc.oo>w
co 0) ....... CD
W~o
S;:~:;);:f;
5gfi:iE:~
b;c5~~f{'
N c.o -'" c..n
(,.o.,)-",o~
c.omW~
m-"oo
c.n
S;:~:;);:f;
5gfi:iE:~
.1..oor:-rp(/)
c..nC,...)W~'
Nc..ntTIN
Wr-v-"'CX1
C'O.,J::o.CXI.......
.......~o
s;:~:;);:f;
58fi:iE:~
';"'o,'':'1en
c.no';"'~'
N.l:lo.W",
W CD -a. tTI
c.o~N-..
-io.~C)
-0
a
-0
C1>
~
)>
-0
-0
Ql .
vr
~
Gl
en
en en en en
)> )> )> )>
, , , ,
m m m m
-oOJo-o~ -oOJo-o~ -oOJo-u~ -uOJo-u~ -0
)>O)>;:O-l )>O)>;:O-l )>O)>;:O-l )>O)>;:O-l Dl
GlO-lo' GlO-lo' GlO-lo' GlO-lo' ~
r:r'?,r:r'm r;n~r;nm ~~~r;n r;n~':'1m
~~o~~ ~oi5~~ -J~::,:-Io.D NO[;:j~~ ,
-Io.wi'3Oa toffi~8O ~~::.:8O ~~:i~o ~
...."-' rr
....- c.nwo c.nW ....wo '<
"-' w
0 w .... w -0
0 W 0> Dl
"-' n
!!<.
~~g; :; ~ S ~~:;~s ~~:;~s mZ-l-u:;;:: 0
~~~55-l 0
0-;::E:J~0 0-;::E:J~0 0-;::E:J~0 =>
:r:o-. :r:O-, Igen6 :J:02rp0 [
xoeno xocnC) xoeno
_ N -i-lo. - "'-I~ Xr-v-i~ "-' -l ~ Z
:::I: 11 I 0 :Cilia " , 0 " . 0 c:
Xo~O " Xo~O o~o o~o 3
Ow Ow ;:0 Ow OJ Ow ~
Wo> '::'.i: '-' 0> W Wo> N '-' 0>
g--J g.... 0 g--J cr> g....
OJ OJ OJ OJ
0 0 0 0
-< -< -< -<
Z Z Z Z
-l -l -l -l ;0
0 0 0 0 Dl
Z Z Z Z c.
I I I I 2'
m m m m ~
G5 Gi G5 Gi 0
I I I I
-l -l -l -l ....
en en en en 0
)> )> )> )> 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
;:0 ;:0 ;:0 ;:0
m m m m
< < < <
en en en en
m m m m
0 0 0 0
-U -0 -U -0
, , , ,
, , ~ ,
-t -l -l
en en en en
N ~ <0 ~ -0
W Dl
Qo Qo Qo Qo <0
N N "-' ~ C1>
.... N 0 0> W
OJ OJ OJ OJ 0
, , , , "
^ ^ ^ ^ w
.... .... --J
104 105
112 1101
108
106 1042
102 101
I~ IN I 0011 I 179
8 20 0201
150
0181 181
7
1481 GJ Mg] I
6 0171
1471 183
83 0161
BLKB
5 1451
15 185
4 1441 96 97 98 2
91 92 93 95
1861
3 13
143
1871
2 1412
1891
1411 103 101 100 99
P10401-95
BLKB
120
125
107 1081 090 111
1891
163
161
0101
1881
0091
1371
1871
F BOYNTON BEACH
GALAXY PARK
7030
1361
119 1171 1161 115 1131 112
1341
1321
GEJJ.....'..
120 211 ,'22...... 'i..: '. .
. -;:..',"'"
- -~",'."
lS " ~,-
1331
\$..;.,.....
125
"".<, '-""
~.~~)
. ..:'.,,,~:
105
27 11
288
5
3
5
9
7 0072 0081 10 11 28 32 36 40 42
6 18 17 16 15 .~G.
003 0011
8
8
221
8 21 26 30 34
'"
27 26 25
0012 14 3020 0291 0281
4
9
2 0061
13
12 31 32 33 36 9
1 7 3
Po91
- 0 -- -
Ill-I nr17n
10
0070
~9 31
I' 15 1~9 rn 5 9 2
11
221
7 8
4
11
0411
40 39 38 37
5
8
3
17
3
7 9
2
3
3 5
5
10
7
0041
13
0081
14
0201 0231 0261 0291
9 0221 0241 7 7 28 30 40
2117 11 12
2 3 4 2 3 4 0051 0041
0021 1010 1040 050 030
6
0441 46 47 48
11 0
28 1
4 3
2
5
4
3
2
0031
27
GARY R. NIKOLlTIS, CFA SCALE: 1" = 200' 08-17-2005
PALM BEACH COUNTY LOCATION:
PROPERTY APPRAISER Rng 43E - Twp 45S - Sec 21
NOTES:
Key:...
. .': .'.:. Subjects
N
A