Loading...
REVIEW COMMENTS DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT,' ,.:~--':-"~---, --., , r;; ~~ r2 nl IV) R G <'IAI ,c ,lj l~ U \!J u; PLANNING AND ZONIN J!r'~~-"'-:<-'7 " . Memorandum PZ U~ L L" ? 6 lllOti I ENGINEERING TO: FROM: DATE: RE: Jeff Livergood, Director of Public Works Sherie Coale of behalf of Ed Breese, Principal Planner October 25, 2006 Ellipse (fka Sunshine Square) Shared Parking Study Dear Jeff, Please review the attached Shared Parking Study for the above- referenced project. This study was recently provided to Planning and Zoning by the client. Kindly provide a written response or comments to Ed by Monday, October 30, 2006. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation. (;) ~+U;C(~1 ~fvA'1 o All rib] wvd l,." Tf1 Tral Tech ENGINEERING, INC. October 16, 2004 Mr. Hugo Pacanins Ram Development 5555 Anglers Avenue, Suite 21 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33312 Re: Ellipse - Shared Parking Study Dear Hugo: Traf Tech Engineering, Inc. was retained by RAM Development to undertake a shared parking analysis in connection with the proposed re-development of the existing shopping center located on the southwest comer of Woolbright Road and US 1 in the City of Boynton Beach, Florida. Figure 1 on the next page illustrates the location of the project site. The existing shopping center consists of approximately 150,000 square feet of commercial space including a Publix Supermarket. The re-development plans include the demolition of the existing commercial center and replacing it with a mixed-use project. The land uses associated with the mixed-use development are: o 594 townhome units (154 are one-bedroom units, 18 live/work units, and 422 two and three bedroom units) o 140,449 square feet of retail space, including restaurants o 13,490 square feet of office space Proposed Development As indicated above, the proposed mixed-use development will include residential, retail, and office land uses. The project parcel is divided in four quadrants by providing two main internal roadways, one in the north-south direction and the other oriented east-west, as depicted in the site plan contained in Appendix A of this study. The northwest quadrant of the site plan is anticipated to include a Publix Supermarket, retail land uses, office space, and residential units. The remaining portion of the site is planned with retail space and residential units. Access to the site is planned via two access driveways off of Woolbright Road, one access driveway on US 1, and two access driveways off of SE 18th Avenue. The easternmost driveway off of Woolbright Road is planned with a traffic signal in order to allow all turning movements at this main entrance. The west driveway on Woolbright Road is planned as a right-turn outbound-only driveway. The US 1 access driveway is planned as a right-turn in/right-turn out driveway. All movements will be permitted from the entrance/exit driveways located on SE 18th Avenue. 8400 North University Drive, Suite 307, Tamarac, Florida 33321 Tel: (954) 582-0988 Fax: (954) 582-0989 E-mail: joaquin@traftech.biz ........ """"" " I I!!lli i iii~i ~. '~~I~,l~,,,~-= ....~ . " '"""., ,"",.. .,. . ' . :'~:;~TI " '," ~" ~::' '., !~~' ; ~ j>-'::1~jLw~_ -r . >>~~...., >>'>> :,',.:';l_~!l' _:._::~ ~..' I:: ~~. - - . . ' f _____,;. :.,_, " ';-_..:... _; ;~ ".. ~ r ~~ t1;'\ C _ _ ~ " "il @,:.,. T~-~~ 't'.;'.' <;":!. ~-<- -~---.. ; ~ , '~. 0:::: .t2 ,~, 10" :':;e .. '," , J _. ~ . ~ -. -'- .,,;l l . ~ '~r :-i~ ~ i i~~,.ij(1(1jGE RD.n; . L, . ,.' c, I.- '6 ~ .'0 i ..... , i: . U'I . C. ::Ii Q, .' . r..I~-fi.A~Y TRl' !,>--;i....', ~ .:L > ! ~ .i ~ f; '(I) ~:'" -,~'_.' ~, '- -'..; i '- f~~~ : ~. :,THl~ ~ttrAA~i~1 ~ ~ (!) ~- 0) , . , , - -:-;~~.. . :: ....1.....,. . ~.,.,_.:..... ~, ~ ';-:'~.,,~ ~ .f '";"'".s. ! ; I , ~~ . J.OG Rf) '.d ,. , :8"n~ 1:3 '.~I mJ.~. . 11' . n =1'. .. II: II JOG RD < ~"",. -- ., . i ; ~ H co "0 'C o u. 't'" W 0:: ::) C) i:i: - Q)..c l/) () c..CO .- Q) =r:::c w c o +-' C >- o r:::c c. co :E r::: o ;:; co (J o ...J ... (J Q) "-. o L- a.. '=<.3 ~ ~- G~ ....ffi .... w ca~ ~'-' ....15 Shared Parking Analysis A shared parking analysis was undertaken for the proposed mixed-use development. Shared parking is defined as parking spaces that are shared between different land uses, especially if the land uses have parking peaks at different times of the day. The parking spaces required by the individual land uses were based on information contained in the City of Boynton Beach Land Development Code. The parking requirements of the individual land uses located within the site are presented below: o Residential (594 units 1): o Retail (140,449 square feet2): o Office (13,490 square feet): Total 1,084 parking spaces 702 parking spaces 68 parking spaces 1,854 parking Spaces Using the percent parking distribution (shared parking principles), by time of day, as published in the Urban Land Institute's (ULI) Shared Parking document, the maximum number of parking spaces required to serve the land uses located at the site is 1,656 parking spaces. Table 1 presents the results of the shared parking analysis. Therefore, the 1,661 proposed parking spaces are anticipated to be sufficient to comfortably accommodate the peak parking demands of the proposed land uses associated with the Ellipse mixed-use development F T, ECH EN, flrJ.E~ING, INC. Ig V1/} , r: E. Vargas, P.~ PTOE 10;;' ransportati lngineer lOne hundred fifty-four are one-bedroom units, 18 are live/work units, and 422 are two and three bedroom units. 2 Includes restaurants. 3 II (/) Q) () ro 0- en >; IV "C ~ CI) CI) ~ .! III ....CI)~N WIIlIVO= :::!c.s:::r--!9 ... = <C Q) <CWCl 0::: I- s::: ~ ... IV a.. II "C (/) CI) Q) ... () IV ro J: 0- tJJen ;1; 00 T"" 00 Q) CO ,~ ll::: o (/) Q) () ~ CJ) '<:tro gs'E T"" Q) -C '00 Q) 0::: c o :+= ro .!:::! :+= :) II (/) Q) () ro 0- en roCO~CO~Noo~~r--T""~T""~~~~O~'<:t OgsO~~~~~~~~~~~~~~g~gs ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ (/) Q) ~N~~~ffiffiww~~~~~~~NNOO en c o ~~~oo::::::oo::::::oo~~~~oo::::::ooo~::::::oo::::::oo::::::oooooooo ro~o~~oooor--~r--r--~~~~~~~ ~~NCO~~~~~~~r--'<:tNr--r--~~OO :+= :) .1:: (/) ~ ~ COCO~r--T""T""NT""r--T""~CO~T""oo~ ro ~o~~~~wffiRffi~w~~~w~~moQ en ~ ro .c: C/) _(/) ~ ~ ..... (/) .s: "0 I:: ro -J I:: ro -e :::> "0 I:: ro Q) "0 o o c: Q) i ~ Q) a "0 I:: ro -J .c: () ro Q) co I:: .9 S- o co c o ~ ~oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::ooo~~~~oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::oo::::::oo~ ro~~ooNoor--r--O~~r--~N~r--T""N~~ ~OooT""'<:tCOoo~~~~oor--ooooooCO~T""O :5 '<:t~COT""r--OOOOT""~~T""~T""N~'<:t'<:t oo'<:t~~~'<:t~'<:t~COT""~NT""'<:tCOr--oooo ~~oor--r--COCOCOCOcor--oo~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 8~~~00~0~0T""cor--~'<:tcooo~88 T""oor--r--co~co~cococor--OO~~~~T""T"" ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ _0000000000000000000 ~0~~~~~~~~~~~0~~~~~~~ o ~~~ ~~~5 I 0 C/) co en .... II (/) CI) CJ IV tJJ "C CI) ... IV J: tJJ DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISION MEMORANDUM NO. PZ 06-204 STAFF REPORT FROM: Chair and Members Community Redevelopment Agency and City Commission Michael Rum~ Planning and Zoning Director Ed Breese ~ Principal Planner TO: THRU: DATE: October 23, 2006 PROJECT NAME/NO: Ellipse (fka Sunshine Square)/ NWSP 06-021 REQUEST: New Site Plan PROJECT DESCRIPTION Property Owner: Sunshine Square CRP LLC Applicant: Sunshine Square CRP LLC Agent: Ms. Bonnie Miskel, Esq. Of Ruden McClosky Location: Southwest corner of the intersection of Federal Highway and Woolbright Road (Exhibit "A'') Existing Land Use: Mixed Use (MX) Existing Zoning: Mixed Use-Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3) Proposed Uses: Retail/Office: Condominiums: Townhouses: 153,939 square feet 558 units 18 units Acreage: :t14.42 acres Adjacent Uses: North: Right-of-way of Woolbright Road, then property designated Mixed Use and zoned MU-L Mixed Use-Low Intensity, currently being developed as Uptown Lofts. ApprOXimately 0.48 of an acre of property located at the southwest corner of the intersection of Federal Highway and Woolbright Road contains a gas station and is classified Local Retail Commercial and zoned C-3 Community Commercial. It is not included in the request for land use amendment and rezoning; Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 2 South: To the southeast, a parcel of approximately 1 acre classified Local Retail Commercial and zoned C-3 Community Commercial and containing a small strip commercial shopping plaza, south of this, the right-of-way of SE 18th Avenue, then developed property classified Local Retail Commercial and zoned C-3 Community Commercial; East: Right-of-way of Federal Highway, then property classified Local Retail Commercial and zoned C-3 Community Commercial and developed as the Riverwalk shopping center; and West: Right-of-way of the Florida East Coast railroad, then the City's Utilities Department facilities designated Public and Private Governmental/ Institutional and zoned PU Public Use. PROPERTY OWNER NOTIFICATION Owners of properties within 400 feet of the subject parcel were mailed a notice of this request and its respective hearing dates. The applicant certifies that they posted signage and mailed notices in accordance with Ordinance No. 04-007. BACKGROUND Proposal: The Sunshine Square shopping center, which encompasses 14.42 acres at the southwest corner of Woolbright Road and Federal Highway, is part of a Comprehensive Plan amendment to change the land use designation from Local Retail Commercial (LRC) to Mixed-Use (MX) and rezone the property from Community Commercial (C-3) to Mixed-Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3). Because of the size of the property under consideration, the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) classifies the amendment as "large scale". A "large scale" amendment is transmitted to DCA for their review and comment prior to City adoption. The City Commission reviewed the LUAR at their July 5, 2006 meeting and voted to transmit the amendment to DCA. The Department has completed their review and the amendments are ready for adoption by the City Commission, as is the requisite site plan. The site plan shows the existing Sunshine Square shopping center being demolished in phases (in order to relocate and accommodate as many of the existing tenants as possible), and replaced with a mixed-use project. The site is divided into four (4) quadrants by a central street running north/south between Woolbright Road and SE 18th Avenue and another running east/west from Federal Highway to the FEC Railroad right-of-way. The north/south road has an elliptical median containing landscaped areas. Sidewalks front arcaded retail structures on each side of the street. Retail/office structures front on Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and the east/west internal drive. The center of three of the quadrant buildings house parking decks, while the remaining quadrant, located on the northwest corner of the site, contains the relocated Publix supermarket under a parking deck. The details of the site plan will be discussed in the body of the staff report. Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 3 ANALYSIS Concurrency: Traffic: A traffic study was submitted by the applicant and reviewed by the Palm Beach County Traffic Division. However, comments were generated by the Traffic Division and as of today, the project has not received a letter of concurrency approval from Palm Beach County. The applicant has re-submitted the information addressing the County's comments and is awaiting their response. Additionally, the applicant continues to participate in meetings with Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering, the City Engineering Division and the developer of the parcel to the north, across Woolbright Road (Las Ventanas), to coordinate the necessary roadway and signalization improvements. No building permits are to be issued until the Palm Beach County Traffic Division approves the study for traffic concurrency purposes (see Exhibit "C" - Conditions of Approval). Utilities: The purchase of up to 5 million gallons of potable water per day from Palm Beach County Utilities represents a portion of the City's potable water supply that would support the needs of this project (projected to total 254,566 gallons per day). Local piping and infrastructure improvements may be required for the project, dependent upon the final project configuration and fire-flow demands. These local improvements would be the responsibility of the site developer and would be reviewed at the time of permitting. Sufficient sanitary sewer and wastewater treatment capacity is currently available to serve the project total of 211,942 gallons per day, subject to the applicant making a firm reservation of capacity, following approval of the site plan. Police/Fire: Fire staff reviewed the site plan and determined that current-staffing levels would be sufficient to meet the expected demand for services. Infrastructure requirements such as hydrants and roadways would be addressed during the permitting process (see Exhibit "C" - Conditions of Approval). Police staff indicated that the service requirements of the department will be impacted by this development and that additional officers and equipment will be needed to serve this and other approved projects in the vicinity. Drainage: Conceptual drainage information was provided for the City's review. The Engineering Division is recommending that the review of specific drainage solutions be deferred until time of permit review (see Exhibit "C" - Conditions of Approval). School: The School District has determined that adequate capacity exists to accommodate the projected resident children. Driveways: The project can be characterized as "urban infill, mixed-use" development whereby front building setbacks are minimal and off-street parking is relegated to a subordinate role. The site plan shows that the development would be divided into four (4) distinct sections. The plans show that parking garages would provide for the majority of off-street parking spaces for the entire project. The garages are Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 4 intentionally proposed as hidden structures located within the core of the project and virtually unseen from the major roadways. Likewise, the project is not proposing traditional driveways or surface parking lots like that of "suburban"-type of projects (where driveways connect to off-street parking located in front of the buildings). The site plan shows that vehicles would enter the site from three (3) locations. The main entrances are proposed on Federal Highway near the center of the roadway frontage and on Woolbright Road, again near the middle of that roadway frontage. The Federal Highway entrance would have a deceleration lane for southbound Federal traffic and no median cut for northbound traffic. Egress from this curb cut would be limited to right hand turning movements only (southbound Federal Highway). The Woolbright Road entrance would have an eastbound deceleration lane and two (2) ingress and two (2) egress lanes, separated by a 12-foot landscape island. This would be a full access entrance with a proposed traffic signal aligned with the Woolbright Road entrance of the project to the north (Las Ventanas). Motorists would be able to enter or exit this location from all directions. The project's third entrance is proposed along SE 18th Avenue, at the southern terminus of the Woolbright Road entry drive. This entrance would also provide access to the entire site. The driveway opening would be 24 feet in width and provide ingress/egress from a road with lower volumes of traffic. Lastly, there is an exit drive proposed at the northwest corner of the site at Woolbright Road and the railroad tracks that is designed as an "egress only" for the service/delivery area at the rear of Publix. All driveway, drive aisles, and turning radius, internal to the development, would be improved to conform to current city engineering standards. Parking Facility: Off-street parking proposed within the development must meet the requirements in Chapter 2, Section n.H. of the Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations. The project proposes a mix of residential, office and retail uses. One-bedroom apartment units require one and one-half (1'12) parking spaces. Two or more bedroom units require two (2) parking spaces. The project proposes a total of 558 dwelling units (with a mixture of one, two, and three bedrooms) and 18 live/work townhouse units, in conjunction with 153,939 square feet of retail/office space. When combined, the total parking requirements equal 1,854 spaces. The project proposes 1,656 parking spaces, a deficiency of 198 parking spaces. However, the code allows a mixed-use project to present a shared parking analysis in compliance with the Urban Land Institute's (ULI) guidelines. The applicant submitted the shared parking analysis prepared by their traffic consultant, TrafTech Engineering Inc., indicating that the maximum number of parking spaces required for the mixed-use project would be 1,656, based upon the greatest demand for parking being a weekday evening at 8:00 PM. The analysis concludes that there would be sufficient parking during the highest demand, with no excess. During the other hours of the day (10:00 AM - 10:00 PM), the parking demand ranges between 1,300 and the 1,656 parking spaces noted above at the 8:00 PM hour. As in all cases, the City Commission must accept the shared parking analysis when approving a site plan (see Exhibit "C" - Conditions of Approval). Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 5 The parking spaces would be provided as follows: 1,611 parking garage spaces, and 45 on-street parking spaces. As previously discussed, the site is divided into four quadrants by bisecting streets. According to the site plan (Sheet A1.01), the Phase IA parcel (NE quadrant) would contain 31,675 square feet of retail/office space. Based upon parking calculations for shopping centers, which is utilized when analyzing mixed-use projects, this building would require 159 parking spaces. The building also accommodates 126 residential units (42 - 1 BR units). Based upon 1.5 spaces for 1 BR units and 2 spaces for all other, 231 parking spaces would be required for the residential units. Therefore, 390 parking spaces are required in Phase IA and 312 are provided as a result of the shared parking analysis. The Phase IB parcel (SE quadrant) would contain 26,235 square feet of retail/office space. Using the same methodology used for Phase lA, this building would require 132 parking spaces. The building also accommodates 102 residential units (30 - 1 BR units). Based upon 1.5 spaces for 1 BR units and 2 spaces for all other, 189 parking spaces would be required for the residential units. Therefore, 321 parking spaces are required in Phase IB and 281 are provided as a result of the shared parking analysis. The Phase IIA parcel (NW quadrant) would contain 81,684 square feet of retail/office space, which includes the proposed 54,064 square foot new Publix store. Based upon parking calculations for shopping centers, this building would require 408 parking spaces. The building also accommodates 90 residential units (24 - 1 BR units). Based upon 1.5 spaces for 1 BR units and 2 spaces for all other, 168 parking spaces would be required for the residential units. Therefore, 576 parking spaces are required in Phase IIA and 1,039 are provided as a result of the shared parking analysis. However, the parking garage associated with Phase IIA is connected to and provides the required parking for Phase lIB, immediately to the south. Phase lIB is the southwestern-most parcel and would contain 14,345 square feet of retail space. Again, based upon parking calculations for shopping centers, this building would require 72 parking spaces. The building also accommodates 258 residential units (58 - 1 BR units). Based upon 1.5 spaces for 1 BR units and 2 spaces for all other, 451 parking spaces would be required for these residential units. Additionally, there are 18 live/work townhouse units proposed around the south and east sides of the building which require 2.5 parking spaces for each unit, thus necessitating 45 more parking spaces. Therefore, with the 568 parking spaces required in Phase lIB plus the 576 in Phase IIA, a total of 1,144 parking spaces are required and 1,063 are provided as a result of the shared parking analysis. Should the applicant propose to place a gate within any or all of the parking structures to separate the residential parking from the general use parking, the applicant shall be required to provide an updated shared parking analysis to ensure that the assumptions made in the analysis are not voided by such action (see "Exhibit C" - Conditions of Approval). Landscaping: The Site Plan tabular data (Sheet A1.01) indicates that the proposed pervious areas would equal 21.2% of the site. The MU-L3 zoning district requires a minimum 20% pervious area, which is satisfied with the proposed site plan. The Landscape Notes (Sheet TD5) indicates the subject site currently contains 153 trees, 33 of which Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 6 would remain in place, 66 of which would be relocated on site, and 54 designated for removal. Most of those to be removed are in poor condition and the applicant will be required to replace the total caliper inches of those trees removed with new specimens. The landscape plan plant list proposes the installation of 92 new canopy trees plus the relocation of 40 existing trees and the retention of 6, for a total of 138 canopy trees. 341 new palm trees are proposed, as well as 54 existing or relocated palms, for a total of 396. The plan also depicts 9,555 shrub and groundcover plants. According to the plant list, 50% of the canopy trees would be native and 57% of the palm trees would be native. The landscape plan also proposes in excess of 50% native shrubs / hedges / accent plants. The plant list indicates the following species to be utilized throughout the project: Medjool Date palms, Sabal, Coconut and Royal palms, Purple Glory, Live Oak, Black Olive, Mahogany and Pigeon Plum trees, Dwarf Schefflera, Cocoplum, Ixora, Hibiscus, Plumbago, Viburnum shrubs, as well as, Crinum Lily and Annuals. Royal palm trees are proposed in front of the buildings (along Federal Highway and Woolbright Road) and are proposed to be installed at an overall height of 22 feet. Staff recommends that the Royal palm trees along these thoroughfares be installed at approximately half of the building height, in the range of 30-35 feet (see "Exhibit C" - Conditions of Approval). These mixed-use buildings would be located close to the east and south property lines and therefore, would be consistent with the intent of the Land Development Regulations of the MU-L3 zoning district. However, the landscape plan still would provide for plant material along these main roadways to help break up the building mass. In fact, these areas would be 10 feet in width to accommodate the installation of the larger-size palm trees. The south landscape buffer, along SE 18th Avenue and the live/work townhomes, would be approximately 13 feet in depth at its narrowest point. The south buffer is proposed to include Laurel Oak, Green Buttonwood and Bougainvillea trees, Royal and Cabbage palms, and among others, hibiscus, dwarf sch effl era and wax jasmine shrubs. Although not dimensioned, it appears as though the west landscape buffer adjacent to the Florida East Coast railroad right-of-way would vary in width from six (6) feet at its narrowest point (behind Publix) to approximately 70 feet, near the southwestern portion of the site. Live Oak trees and Sabal palms are the predominant trees proposed for this buffer, along with Cocoplum hedge material. Additionally, there is a water feature with arbors and a variety of landscape material proposed along the west buffer, at the west terminus of the main east/west drive through the site. The interior of the site would basically contain the same plant material as the perimeter buffers. The interior street system would have intermittent, parallel (on- street) parking spaces and wide sidewalks that accommodate a pedestrian friendly window-shopping environment, landscape cutouts and adequate area for outdoor seating/dining. Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 7 Building and Site: The site plan proposes a mix of residential, office and commercial uses. The commercial/office square footage would total 14.3% of the total building area. Building and site design as proposed would generally meet code requirements when staff comments are incorporated into the permit drawings. The maximum allowed density of the Mixed-Use land use category would be 40 dwelling units per acre. The proposed project density would be 39.94 dwelling units per acre. As previously mentioned, the existing shopping center would be replaced with four (4) seven (7)-story mixed-use buildings, three (3) of which wrap interior parking structures. The depth of the parcel extends westward from Federal Highway to the Florida East Coast railroad tracks. The subject property fronts on two (2) major roadways (Federal Highway and Woolbright Road). The parcel located at the southwest corner of the intersection of Federal Highway and Woolbright Road (approximately half an acre in size) is not included in the request for land use amendment/rezoning and site plan approval. This corner parcel contains a gas station and is classified Local Retail Commercial and zoned C-3 Community Commercial. The proposed building in Phase IA would wrap around the gas station parcel with retail on the first floor and residential units above and parking structure inside. The first and second floors are setback 10 feet from the property lines and then the building steps back approximately 15 feet further from Federal Highway and 7 feet further from Woolbright Road, at a height of approximately 30 feet. The MU-L3 zoning district allows for a maximum building height of 75 feet, for properties not abutting the Mixed-Use High (MU-H) district. The elevations (Sheet A1.06) of the Phase IA mixed-use structure, depict the height at 77 feet to the roofline with a total height to the tallest of the stair/elevator towers at 91 feet. This would not comply with the height limitation of 75 feet. While the stair/elevator towers are eligible for a Height Exception, the roofline itself cannot exceed the 75- foot threshold. The applicant has been made aware of this situation and has agreed to modify the height of the structure to conform at time of permitting, and has applied for a Height Exception for the eligible towers (HTEX 07-001), which is being processed concurrently with the site plan. Staff has recommended that the building be modified by the two (2) feet it exceeds the maximum allowed height and placed a condition to that effect in the Conditions of Approval. The proposed building in Phase IB (SE quadrant of the site) would be constructed immediately north of a parcel (approximately 1 acre in size) classified Local Retail Commercial and zoned C-3 Community Commercial and containing a small strip commercial shopping plaza and residential property, fronting on SE 18th Avenue, and not included in this request for land use amendment/rezoning and site plan approval. This seven (7)-story mixed-use building would also have retail on the first floor and residential units above and parking structure inside. The south side of this building does not however have the parking structure wrapped with storefronts, and the condominium units/recreation amenity does not begin until the fourth floor. A 10-foot setback has been depicted to provide the necessary landscape buffer, at the appropriate height. Staff recommends that applicant provide the necessary landscape at varying heights to assist in the screening of the three levels of parking (see "Exhibit C" - Conditions of Approval). The first and second floors are setback 10 feet from the east property line, like in Phase IA and then the building appears to step back at an angle, between 10 and 25 feet further from Federal Highway, at Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 8 a height of approximately 30 feet. The elevations (Sheet A1.06) of the Phase IB mixed-use structure, depict the height at 77 feet to the roofline with a total height to the tallest of the stair/elevator towers at 91 feet. Like the Phase IA building, this would not comply with the height limitation of 75 feet, and staff has recommended that the building be modified by the two (2) feet it exceeds the maximum allowed height and placed a condition to that effect in the Conditions of Approval. The proposed building in Phase IIA (NW quadrant of the site) would house the relocated Publix. Fronting the Publix on Woolbright Road would be office uses on the first floor with residential above to the ih floor. Wrapping around the Publix on the east side is retail on the first floor and residential units above, with one level of parking deck above the Publix and a bridge connection to the interior parking structure in Phase lIB. The first and second floors are setback 10 feet from the north property line abutting Woolbright Road and then the building steps back approximately 12 feet further, at a height of approximately 27 feet. The elevations (Sheet A1.06) of the Phase IIA mixed-use structure, depict the height at 77 feet to the roofline with a total height to the tallest of the stair/elevator towers at 91 feet. Like the previous two (2) phases, this would not comply with the height limitation of 75 feet, and staff has recommended that the building be modified by the two (2) feet it exceeds the maximum allowed height and placed a condition to that effect in the Conditions of Approval. On the ground level, in between the office/residential structure facing Woolbright Road and the Publix building, is a service court for deliveries, refuse collection and other utility purposes that is screened from the residential units above by the parking deck connecting the Publix building to the office/residential structure facing Woolbright Road. Lastly, the proposed building in Phase lIB (SW quadrant of the site) and current location of Publix, would be the last phase to be constructed, once Publix relocated into its new building and the old structure could be demolished. This seven (7)- story mixed-use building would also have retail on the first floor and residential units above along the northern portion of the building on the east side. The remainder of the east fa~ade and south side would be live/work units, with regular condominium units above. The live/work units would be setback approximately 12 from the SE 18th Avenue right-of-way and then the building steps back approximately 10 feet further from SE 18th Avenue, at a height of approximately 27 feet. The elevations (Sheet A1.06) of the Phase lIB mixed-use structure, depict the height at 80 feet to the roofline with a total height to the tallest of the stair/elevator towers at 94 feet. Like all of the previous phases this building would not comply with the height limitation of 75 feet, and staff has recommended that the building be modified by the five (5) feet it exceeds the maximum allowed height and placed a condition to that effect in the Conditions of Approval. Desig n: As noted previously, the proposed development can be generally described as being separated into four (4) quadrants of similarly designed seven (7) story structures. The proposed architecture could be described as contemporary design, with varying rooflines and fa~ade step backs for interest and shadowing. Also noteworthy is that the project parking would be virtually hidden from most all views and is considered to be a subordinate, mostly unobtrusive element of the plan. Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 9 Staff recommends that those areas in which the parking garage is exposed to the exterior of the project, especially abutting the gas station, the commercial/residential to the south and along the west elevation, the garage openings be enhanced with decorative metal work, decorative shutters, awnings, and in some instances landscaping (see "Exhibit C" - Conditions of Approval). Vehicular traffic is contained within the internal framework of the project, utilizing the cross-shaped road pattern created by the north/south and east/west drives, including the elliptical parkway/landscape median through the heart of the project. The elevations indicate the proposed exterior finish and colors of the buildings and a color schedule has been provided via ledger-sized color board. The applicant is proposing four (4) colors throughout the entire development. The project's proposed building colors are as follows: Off White Medium Tan Dark Tan Light Beige Snow White Roxbury Caramel Richmond Gold Sag Harbor Gray OC-66 HC-42 HC-41 HC-95 BM Paints BM Paints BM Paints BM Paints The majority of the body of the buildings would be painted white, with most of the articulated wall portions and towers proposed to be painted the medium tan. Certain sections of recessed wall are painted the light beige, while prominent wall features along the lower building elevations are painted the dark tan. A feature element in the design of the project is the elliptical shaped central plaza that graces each side of the intersection of the two (2) drives. This feature is labeled as the north and south commons on the plans, and includes a series of walkways meandering around pockets of landscape and terminating at large scale fountains (which the applicants proposes to fulfill the Arts in Public Places requirement), along the north and south sides of the east/west cross street, at the heart of the project. The architect has carried through the theme by designing the footprint of the retail buildings rimming the elliptical feature to follow its perimeter, thus providing a concave look to the row of storefronts. Above the retail space, the large continuous balcony for the residential units above also conform to the shape of the common area below to accentuate the unique design. Then the residential units are proposed to be constructed in a staggered pattern, again to carry through the design scheme below. Signage: Minimal project detail regarding proposed signage was shown with this submittal. Staff recommends utilizing a Sign Program for the entire project to ensure sustained continuity throughout the life of the project (see Exhibit "C" - Conditions of Approval). All project signage shall conform to the regulations as set forth in Chapter 9 (Community Design Plan) and Chapter 21 of the Land Development Regulations, as formalized in an adopted Sign Program for this project. Staff Report - Ellipse (NWSP 06-021) Memorandum No PZ 06-204 Page 10 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION: Concurrent with the processing of this site plan application staff is proposing amendments to the mixed- use zoning district regulations to implement recommendations from redevelopment plans and the conclusions from recent workshops and hearings. The major change in the proposed code amendments is the division of the Mixed Use-Low Intensity zoning district into three distinct low intensity districts; Mixed Use-Low 1 (MU-Ll), Mixed Use-Low 2 (MU-L2) and Mixed Use-Low 3 (MU-L3). Specifically related to this project is the new accommodation of supermarkets, changing the maximum size from 30,000 square feet to 80,000 square feet, in part, to accommodate the subject Publix store within this project, and to acknowledge our understanding of current trends and strategies of the large grocery store chains. Other notable changes represented by the new districts include 1) building setbacks, increasing to 10 feet on the sides and rear to reduce potential impacts upon adjacent properties; and 2) the introduction of the Sky Exposure Plane provision that sets a building envelope that narrows uniformly around the building as height increases. Simply stated, this requirement is a six-foot to one-foot (6' to 1') step-back slope applied to each side of each project in a mixed-use district. This requirement is also intended to reduce potential impacts on adjacent properties and the streetscape, by reducing building bulk without inhibiting flexibility in design. This increased setback requirement appears to be satisfied on all sides of the proposed project except at the northwest corner. With respect to building step-backs, although the relief proposed on several of the elevations exceed the requirements of the new Mixed-use Low 3 district, those elevations with no or minimal step-back must be reconsidered by the applicant and redesigned accordingly. As required by the conditions of approval, the permit drawings must reflect the minor adjustments required to meet the new minimum building setback of 10 feet, and new slope plane of 6' to 1'. Staff has reviewed this request and recommends approval, contingent upon the approval of the accompanying request for Height Exception (HTEX 07-001) and all items noted within Exhibit "C" - Conditions of Approval. Any additional conditions recommended by the Board or City Commission shall be documented accordingly in the Conditions of Approval. S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Sunshine Square\Ellipse\NWSP 06.021\Staff Report.doc ELr ~PSE LOCATION M~'" SNUG HARBOR DR ! ' SE'14TH AVE t- III In ... III III SITE N w_w.' s o 62.5 125 250 375 EXHIBIT A EXHIBIT B . ~:1- .:t:::t-, -:'''Lt '=to: 1, 1=:::" .:1===1:'t~ ~t, ~ ~:~ t=t E ':1===1:' AST e" .I':t::: vAST t'q_ _1__ RAILROADt'=to::1'1=:::' __ ""===1: 'to/::: t'q ..~lll~e: ..~_71' @ (ll ;;j "'l s: Z !'I'Wi'!P1lil !I !1l!!~!IMj!!!l!!ml!i!ill!r' i illliii i!ii!!i!IW!li,!lHU!I!i,'I!ll11h I mmm I !II:! I , I' j! I i !...i..,....!'.;, I 'I!' 1'!li','" 1"'11 I i !1!! il, !Ph!HHI!lh;~I!ii!ii II II jlln!1 Jill I ! !II! Iii Ii :!li!;' il!' I"ill! ;! 1!III.II! !Ii! " i"''''!!!'' 'j"'" ", '" ! i'l II II! ," lli",,,.!!I:.II,!I'" !! ii'! I",' I, j. . ij 01 iii: ! ~~~ i1~> h~ ~ .~ ~ ! . 'I 'i~~ ~~!.'! ~ ~~ i~ ~j, " '1~;ii"!P~~~ i~;i ~ .i. ,',ai~ i'~ ~,,' j "I " 'I i' ,. 'I'''''' I I. Ii .., I~ ~~ d HI .~! ! ;,! iii ~i ,i ",',H t I~ i~ n.i~ i~! !!i I"'" .' "j" i' j' .., ." ,., Ii! Hi!i! ill Ii IH i,'i ,ai! II Ii 1m I liP,' . 'I" ," ,.." I 'j' ,I , .. , , , , i" I" ,., . .,., " j l i' !' . I I .iI P . j; I !' Ili' i I~ . lli " , .' i -," . !,'l;' I I' III j ,..! Ii!' ELL! PS E u~.~ ~ u~..~..~ OOYNTON !lEACH . FlD'JD^ 05081 -1.06 ELEV De. '0-12-06 I"LOT : VJ..M-Oe '" ~ 5' ~ ~ '" ~ . ::! ,0 ~ Z " ~ '" ijj ~ m ~ ~g ~Z '" :I! >- ~ ijj ~ J!! ~ . ::! ~~ " :I! ili m ijj g: ~ m ~ ~g ~Z ~ (j) iT! ~ m e- m >: ::l 0 z (j) (j) :E ($ m ~ r m ~ m -; m :j e- m 0 >: z -; U'l <5 z (j) II~" r"r"I~"r~rT"1 ;[1 ~ ~ ~'" ~ H ~ ! I I I I I a~ nTTTT"j 'i !!"!.' 'i nUdf t ""'" 1 61 I I i !! !:! I I ! , I I I I > ~~ ~;; ~~ "!1l;ll .," fl~~ t;;~ ~az IJI :I! >- III m ijj !:! ~ J!! ~ ::l '0 ~z IJI ~ 5' !:! ~ J!! ~ ::l ~!l EXHIBIT "B" rf1'TTTTT"r I HUH)' >- :I! >- ~ 5' ~ '" ~ .::! '0 ~z >- :I! >- III m ~ ~ J!! ~ ~~ :E " " .~ 8 i'lr ~~t!l~~ OJ 8;;!~1 ~ Ih~; ~ fiH -; H!~~ ~ ~~~.~i > ~~~ . ~ ~~l ~ F;; H ~ >: h ~ g j j z ~' . (j) !! tHHt.i, - .,'" ~ ' i',,~ ~ai""I~vl:~ar~H . r ~ r J r 1 I f I E L L I P S E I ~ u~utu~u~__~u~u~__~__!__!u!~~~""v..~ . 2: .U__U__,__,__,__,__i~1tl!1i__ i ~ i : : : : : : : : : : : : : :A(. 00lQ4Ie: g ~~IJ~~I~I~l:I~~~~~~~~L I ....boIOoMe: : : : : : : 1IOCA1:A1tlN.:1'LQIlI;J":etZIl: MYNT'ON DEACH . Fl.OItJDA ~ --:--:--:--t--t--t--:--t--:--:~Mi,-~:.- ~ Ii D!5Oel -UYT Eta' De -10-14-06 I I"lOf : '10-14-06 :t :I! > <J> "' ;;; ~ ~ , ?J ~~ ~ -....., -- -~-- mi, = '< ' > ~ ::l ~ S U'l ~ ...- ~~r'fJPlfl r ~ ~ ! ~), I' V ) I ~ ~~ 31~ ~0- ~ '" ~ I ij ~ ~ ELL! PS E llOYNTON DEN>! . fl.DKlD^ ~ 11'1/1' lTIA III I ,,~ ---- ~ m1 ~ f\o I I I 1) 1/ ~ G :I! > m ;;; m "' ~ ~~ -Ii ~ ~ ~ .q -Ii II ~ <l> .. :t > <J> "' 5' ~ ~ ,2; H :I! > III 5' m "' ~ ::l ,0 .z ~ I 1M IUTi'lTT'1 + ""',' j III t 11 i I '" 8': III! '/ ~ '~ o ~ III ;;; !:! ~ "' ~ ~ ,'-.", if'" ~~ '!!! i1 ,~ III I I i i i 1,,( d'// Y :/1 ~ ". '"' l II. lu '~ ;11/ 1/ ~ , J 8~ ~a 0" ~ III ~ !:! ~ "' ~ ~~ EXHIBIT "B" W~' '" ifu.a'v ~,u h at~, , !! !~)! ,1 I t/Vj vI F= ~ 1== . I '~ I I I l[ I rl ~ I 'l: N II E"l: ~ II .1 I I ~ ,,~I), bmmlllut I) I I I ;If I I I I J ~ I I I" , ~ ' i'-- f'..- hi "0~' ~; . '''~fMll ii I III III1II I u~__~n~__~u~u~ul__l__lululM~~~A.~J-_ "r n'..'_.'n'n'n'..'_.'_';~!!~;_' L" : : : : : : : : : : : : : :M:.__: , iiW~i:II:I::I::I::ii'ii~~:~!'oJ:: .......boIc)Ml::::::IlOCAU.toI.:I'ILf>>A~: ~ n~__~__~n~n:n:-_~__~_-:n:_~Mt.-___:-- 1',11 ,lu ~ ~ "" N -f ~~~;l,Rl ;;;:::Ii, !::.a" n~i .~.~. f.~~~[ i~~~~ ~~~ ~;. !~~ ~ ~.H pI; p . [ . EXHIBIT "B" <'i I ~ '" ~ ... ... ~ .. u ~" a~ ~~ JI ___ D ~.. 01Wl5"W 140,00' fj- r:-, .- a, cas ~L ~_J DUMPSTER PAD 1% ~ & I " I I I II ]: II ~ 1/ ' I ! I 1 /;1 ':"_-==========-p 'l ~ r> -==-=="..= --::~~ - ~--=- -=-=-~ ~:; ~ = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ PHASEIA " I . ~;'~ ',. . , l . ....1 ~ ' 'l' nmm BLLlPSB CITY OF BOYNTON BBACH, FLORIDA RAM DEVBLOPMENT LANDSCAPB PLAN Carter- Burg... Cl) CMtWt'IlIIIIIII,tC. _...w........__ -~,...- ..-- --- ""-, I;,,,, ~?< I 1 "\CI) ! I~. f~t>:J .'=' . i ~ Q:l .... t ~ I ~ ~ ~ ;;j I t :<: ;, c::: t>:J I I l' '(' If II I;~ I 11, I I if I:, 1"\ ~ I:f ) l f ________ 11 r , I ~~ \I~ ii~ f: !n f/ (~ I I I'" I ~ 1 I I, I I 'r It j' :1 I ! ~~ i'~ '?'~ '~ l' EXHIBIT "B" MA.TCH LlNE 'D' - SEE SHEET LND3 S 01012'13" E 125.00' ~ C) OJ '" ;z: p ~ ~ ~~ ]il.. I "~ ~~ t- O ~ , I ~~ <i I II [:J '" ~~ ~ '" "', .., C) t- >: '" b . '" '" ~I \ ~ \Ii ~ - - '1 " f"' -,~_.~ ,,-===;~,.~-~-:- =? · f d:. ;;f'n .,-.,--" ,-- b~'7'= ~.~""~ = = - _ U.S':S'Ifff!ff1lii- . -, ~ = = = = = ~ - ::~=~: ~ -:::: === ==-= ~ ~ = = ~ = = = ~==;=~-=~=========~~~~~~~===- I I ~/~ "'1 ~ . 'to Cl) PHASEIB I' I . ~;~ '.. ~ ' ~ . ELUPSE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA RAM DEVELOPMENT LANDSCAPE PLAN Carter. Burg... CMt1IlI.&IlIMIII,M:. _".w........... ..................- ..-- EXHIBIT "B" '-.............. g~ ~ tzi " '" I ~ ~ ~ ... ~ " PHASE IIA I I~ .J~/ I I T I , __ :ll~ ~. ~ . ~ . "'I ~ ' .. ~nmm ELL/PSE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA RAN DEYELOPNENT LANDSCAPE PLAN Carter. B........ 0) CMfMI,-,lNC. -"".'",",,-- l'tol~......_ ..-- --- EXHIBIT "B" - .. " ~ ~"" - '- '- " ~ .., f--Y~ ~ _ N08'f1'16'E .. 5l \:~:::{X~"'''-';'-r25~~ -~- i ~ ~ ~'@) .e" ~ ~ ~, .If''''V1 ^ - =--- - ! . ~.~ ., ~ .. -t"':'\-~"-1:k'<.Y~\ "n:~, g ~ (.~..!~ e 6T;"'\..~..:>-:~~~ . -A" - ~\ ... 8 r" ~~. '" ,.. 'C..../ 'C./, \ ~x 6" w;ii<--..S,:)I '-"-", ,/~. 7'C t'J I." .. ..L......,.\. . . .. ..... _......_"',......~.' ~ (,>-<= ~,J < -;.~ : .--w ww W.~.H.~- W W W& w (:r We;rW-r- ~- .~1 >:s;;J!Y!:~ !' I VI ~WA," ~ 'rr~-~',0~,.g~N!~ III . JllLHULl . " :1 ~.Ji~:~~~~=: ~ ': ::~ ~l (111 iJ I1I1 I ~ J1 ~ (XlI - dZS .,~ (i ~~ ' - ~~ ~~ ~ I : ~~ \ ~~ == II r : I it i \ \~:< = - - i~ / / ~ ~ = cr T 1 TT 111 II ~ - - - - L .".. - - , \ ~~ ',',' / U ,. , ....~~ I I ~t. I . ~/. , ; 1 = - - I - l' - . ,'t~ -I I 1:1 II II ~ 1 ~ I I I I I (JO./ b I i ~ I / . ( ~ I I \. ~ ~ .. ... '\ ~ 0 <xi I / [:l ., ~ .., I rrr ~ .. o ! .. I I "" Wv~ 1:..;(."./ ~ Cl) ~ it I I I_ I, \ I , = PHASE lIB J . ~;I ~, ~ ' ~I t::i · 'l' '" mnmm ELLIPSE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA RAM DEVELOPMENT LANDSCAPE PLAN Carter- Burg... CllMMt.-'1IC. _III............ ...,--I'WIt_ ....._ .n NO. M 1#fW:N. ,oF EXHIBIT "C" - CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL New Site Plan Project name: Ellipse / Sunshine Square File number: NWSP 06-021 Reference: 2nd review plans identified as a New Site Plan with an October 17.2006 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking. DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: None PUBLIC WORKS - Traffic Comments: 1. Provide a traffic analysis and notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic study shall include an evaluation of the need for an additional right turn lane (eastbound to southbound) on Woolbright Road using proposed generation rates (pre- and post-development.) 2. Dedicate right-of-way as necessary should a right turn lane be warranted in the future. Consider growth in background traffic for the year 2020. Also, coordinate the design and construction of all traffic improvements necessary to support this development with the developer of the Las Ventanas site on the northwest comer of Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. Provide written proof of this cooperation to the City. 3. Show loading areas on the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans; include a pavement message in yellow indicating "No Parking - Loading Zone". PUBLIC WORKS-Forestry & Grounds Comments: 4. Show sight triangles on the Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5 .H.) Reference FDOT Standard Index 546 for the sight triangles along both Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. Sight triangles in the interior of the development shall be IS-feet. 5. The medians on Federal Highway have existing irrigation and plant material belonging to the City of Boynton Beach. Any damage to the irrigation system and/or plant material as a result of the contractor's operations shall be repaired or replaced to the equivalent or better grade, as approved by the City of Boynton Beach, and shall be the sole responsibility of the developer. The contractor shall notify and coordinate with the City of Boynton Beach Forestry & Grounds Division of Public Works a minimum of six (6) weeks in advance of any underground activities. Please acknowledge this notice in your comments response and add a note to the appropriate plan sheets (PG&D, Utility, Landscape) with the above stated information. 6. Correct sheet LND 5 of 6 to delete reference to Boca Raton. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 P 2 age DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT UTILITIES Comments: 7. All utility easements shall be shown on the Site plan, Landscape, and Hardscape plans (as well as the Water and Sewer Plans) so that we may determine which appurtenances, trees or shrubbery may interfere with utilities. In general, palm trees will be the only tree species allowed within utility easements. Revise Sheet LND 3: 10' VE with QV at SW comer of sheet. 8. Palm Beach County Health Department permits will be required for the water and sewer systems serving this project (CODE, Section 26-12). 9. The CODE, Section 26-34(E) requires that a capacity reservation fee be paid for this project either upon the request for the Department's signature on the Health Department application forms or within seven (7) days of site plan approval, whichever occurs first. This fee will be determined based upon final meter size, or expected demand, 10. Water and sewer lines to be owned and operated by the City shall be included within utility easements. Please show all proposed easements on the engineering drawings, using a minimum width of 12 feet. The easements shall be dedicated via separate instrument to the City as stated in CODE Sec. 26- 33(a). 11. This office will not require surety for installation of the water and sewer utilities, on condition that the systems be fully completed, and given to the City Utilities Department before the first permanent meter is set. Note that setting of a permanent water meter is a prerequisite to obtaining the Certificate of Occupancy. 12. A building permit for this project shall not be issued until this Department has approved the plans for the water and/or sewer improvements required to service this project, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-15. 13, Appropriate backflow preventer(s) will be required on the domestic water service to the building, and the fire sprinkler line if there is one, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-207. 14, The waste stream from any food preparation area processes must meet the City's pretreatment requirements. A sampling point must be provided to allow monitoring of this waste stream (refer to CODE Section 26-143 and Section 26-147.) 15, Vpsize the water main in Woolbright Road to meet the requirements of the Utility Master Plan, The main shall be upsized from the west side of the FECRR east to the point of connection (west driveway) for the project. 16, Coordinate with Boynton Beach Fire-Rescue to determine flow requirements for multi-story buildings over four stories. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 Page 3 DEPARTMENTS 17. Utility construction details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All utility construction details shall be in accordance with the Utilities Department's "Utilities Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" manual (including any updates) and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. ENGINEERING Comments: 18. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. 19, Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. 20. Upon satisfactory Commission approval of the site plan, the applicant shall enter the plat process through the City's Engineering Division. A preliminary plat application may be initiated during the site plan review to expedite issuance of the Land Development Permit. A plat will be required for this development. 21. Show proposed site lighting on the Site, all Civil and Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA.) The lighting design shall provide a minimum average light level of one foot-candle. On the Lighting Plan, specify that the light poles shall withstand a 140 MPH wind load (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.1.a and Florida Building Code), Provide a note that the fixtures shall be operated by photoelectrical control and are to remain on until 2:00 a.ill. (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.1.a.) Include pole wind loading, and pole details in conformance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 11, Chapter 23, Article I, Section 5.B.7 and Chapter 23, Article II, Section A on the Lighting Plan. Lighting shall not be used as a form of advertising in a manner that draws more attention to the building or grounds at night than in the day (LDR, Chapter 9, Section 10.F.5). Provide photometrics as part of your T ART plan submittals. 22, Full drainage plans, including drainage calculations, in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5 will be required at the time of permitting. 23. Paving, drainage and site details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All engineering construction details shall be in accordance with the applicable City of Boynton Beach Standard Drawings and the "Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. INCLUDE REJECT ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06.021 P 4 age DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT FIRE Comments: 24. Provide the fire hydrant layout for this project with the hydrants clearly shown on one sheet. Show all water supply lines for fire protection and hydraulic calculations using data from a flow test conducted within the past six months. This test will be conducted by the Boynton Beach Fire Department. POLICE Comments: 25. None. BUILDING DIVISION Comments: 26. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the TART (Technical Advisory Review Team) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the commission and at permit review. 27. Indicate within the site data the occupancy type of each building as defined in 2004 FBC, Chapter 3. Indicate all occupancies in mixed occupancy buildings. 28. The height and area for buildings or structures of the different types of construction shall be governed by the intended use or occupancy of the building, and shall not exceed the limits set forth in Table 503 of the 2004 FBC. 29. Place a note on the elevation view drawings indicating that the exterior wall openings and exterior wall construction comply with 2004 FBC, Table 704.8. Submit calculations that clearly reflect the percentage of protected and unprotected wall openings permitted per 2004 FBC, Table 704.8. 30. General area modifications to buildings shall be in accordance with 2004 FBC, Section 506. Provide calculations verifying compliance with the above code sections and the 2004 FBC, Table 503. 31. Buildings, structures and parts thereof shall be designed to withstand the minimum wind loads of 140 mph. Wind forces on every building or structure shall be determined by the provisions of ASCE 7, Chapter 6, and the provisions of 2004 FBC, Section 1609 (Wind Loads). Calculations that are signed and sealed by a design professional registered in the state of Florida shall be submitted for review at the time of permit application. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06.021 P 5 age DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 32. Every building and structure shall be of sufficient strength to support the loads and forces encountered per the 2004 FBC, Section 1607 and Table 1607.1. Indicate the live load (pst) on the plans for the building design. 33. Buildings three-stories or higher shall be equipped with an automatic sprinkler system per F.S. 553.895. Fire protection plans and hydraulic calculations shall be included with the building plans at the time of permit application. 34. Add to all plan view drawings of the site a labeled symbol that represents the location and perimeter of the limits of construction proposed with the subject request. 35. At time of permit review, submit signed and sealed working drawings of the proposed construction. 36. On the site plan and floor plan, indicate the number of stories that are in each building. Indicate the overall height of each building. 37. Add to each building that is depicted on the drawing titled site plan and floor plan a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building. 2004 FBC, Sections 11-4.1.2, 11-4.1.3, and 11-4.3. 38. As required by LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7, submit a floor plan drawing. The building plans are not being reviewed for compliance with the applicable building codes. Therefore, add the words "Floor plan layout is conceptual" below the drawing titled Floor Plan found on sheet/s _' However, add to the floor space drawing a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building. The location of the door shall match the location of the accessible entrance doors that are depicted on the site plan drawing. 39, Compliance with regulations specified in the FFHA, Design and Construction Requirements, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.205, is required. 40. At the time of permit review, submit details of reinforcement of walls for the future installation of grab bars as required by the FFHA, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.205, Section 3, Requirement #6. All bathrooms within the covered dwelling unit shall comply. 41, Bathrooms and kitchens in the covered dwelling units shall comply with the FFHA, Title 24 CFR 100.205. Indicate on the plans which design specification ("A" or "B") of the FFHA is being used. The clear floor space at fixtures and appliances and turning diameters shall be clearly shown on the plans. 42. If an accessible route has less than 60 inches clear width, then passing spaces at least 60 inches by 60 inches shall be located at reasonable intervals not to exceed 200 feet. A "T" -intersection of two corridors or walks is an acceptable passing place. 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.3.4. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06.021 P 6 age I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 43. Identify within the site data the finish floor elevation (lowest floor elevation) that is proposed for the building. Verify that the proposed elevation is in compliance with regulations of the code by adding specifications to the site data that address the following issues: a. The design professional-of-record for the project shall add the following text to the site data. "The proposed finish floor elevation _' _ NGVD is above the highest IOO-year base flood elevation applicable to the building site, as determined by the SFWMD's surface water management construction development regulations." b. From the FIRM map, identify in the site data the title of the flood zone that the building is located within. Where applicable, specify the base flood elevation. Ifthere is no base flood elevation, indicate that on the plans. c. Identify the floor elevation that the design professional has established for the building within the footprint of the building that is shown on the drawings titled site plan, floor plan and paving/drainage (civil plans). 44. As required by the CBBCO, Part III titled "Land Development Regulations", submit a site plan that clearly depicts the setback dimensions from each property line to the leading edge of the buildings. The leading edge of the buildings begins at the closest point of the overhang or canopy to the property line. In addition, show the distance between all the buildings on all sides. 45. CBBCPP 3.C.3.4 requires the conservation of potable water. City water may not, therefore, be used for landscape irrigation where other sources are readily available, 46. A water-use permit from SFWMD is required for an irrigation system that utilizes water from a well or body of water as its source. A copy of the permit shall be submitted at the time of permit application, F.S. 373.216. 47. If capital facility fees (water and sewer) are paid in advance to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department, the following information shall be provided at the time of building permit application: a. The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. b. If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. c. The number of dwelling units in each building. d. The number of bedrooms in each dwelling unit. e. The total amount paid and itemized into how much is for water and how much is for sewer. (CBBCO, Chapter 26, Article II, Sections 26-34) 48. At time of permit review, submit separate surveys of each lot, parcel, or tract. For purposes of setting up property and ownership in the City computer, provide a copy of the recorded deed for each lot, parcel, or tract. The recorded deed shall be submitted at time of permit review. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 P 7 age DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJbCT 49. At time of building permit application, submit verification that the City of Boynton Beach Parks and Recreation Impact Fee requirements have been satisfied by a paid fee or conveyance of property. The following information shall be provided: a. A legal description of the land. b. The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. c, If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. d. The number of dwelling units in each building. e. The total amount being paid. (CBBCO, Chapter I, Article V, Section 3(f)) 50, Add a general note to the site plan that all plans submitted for permitting shall meet the City's codes and the applicable building codes in effect at the time of permit application. 51. Pursuant to approval by the City Commission and all other outside agencies, the plans for this project must be submitted to the Building Division for review at the time of permit application submittal. The plans must incorporate all the conditions of approval as listed in the development order and approved by the City Commission. 52. The full address of the project shall be submitted with the construction documents at the time of permit application submittal. The addressing plan shall be approved by the United States Post Office, the City of Boynton Beach Fire Department, the City's GIS Division, and the Palm Beach County Emergency 911. (Palm Beach County Planning, Zoning & Building Division, 100 Australian Avenue, West Palm Beach, Florida (Sean McDonald - 561- 233-5013) (United States Post Office, Boynton Beach (Michelle Bullard - 561-734-0872) 53. Show the proposed site lighting on the site and landscape plans. (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7,BA) If possible, provide photo metrics as part of your TART plan submittals. 54. Add to the floor plan drawings of the individual units a breakdown of the area within the unit. The area breakdowns for each unit shall specify the total area of the unit, area of the balcony, total area that is air-conditioned and, where applicable, total area of storage and garage space. If the garage and storage areas are not part of a specific unit, the area shall be included and identified within the area of the building. Indicate how many of each type of unit will be on each floor and within the building. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06.021 Page 8 DEPARTMENTS 55. Add to the site data the total area under roof of each residential building. Provide tabular area data for each floor of each building. The breakdown shall include the following areas and each area shall be labeled on the applicable floor plan drawing: a. Common area covered walkways; b. Covered stairways; c, Common area balconies; d. Entrance area outside of a unit; e. Storage areas (not part of a unit); f, Garages (not part of a unit); g. Elevator room; h, Electrical room; 1. Mechanical room; J. Trash room; k. Mailbox pickup and delivery area; and 1. Any other area under roof. (Chapter 4 - Site Plan Review, Section 7.E.2 and 3) 56. This structure meets the definition of a threshold building per F.S. 553.71(7) and shall comply with the requirements of F.S. 553.79 and the CBBA to the 2004 FBC, Sections 109.3.6.1 through 109.3.6.6.The following information must be submitted at the time of permit application: a. The structural inspection plan must be submitted to the enforcing agency prior to the issuance of a building permit for the construction of a threshold building. b. All shoring and re-shoring procedures, plans and details shall be submitted. c. All plans for the building that are required to be signed and sealed by the architect or engineers of record shall contain a statement that, to the best of the architect's or engineer's knowledge, the plans and specifications comply with the applicable fire safety standards as determined by the local authority in accordance with this section and F.S. Section 633. 57. If this project is located within the Downtown Stormwater Improvement Watershed, appropriate fees must be paid to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department prior to the issuance of a building permit per the CBBCO, Chapter 26, Section 26-406. Proof of payment shall be submitted to the Building Division at the time of permit application submittal. 58. Indicate on the plans the square footage per floor of the parking garages. Comply with the area and height requirements of 2004 FBC, Table 503. 59, A Mechanical ventilation system is required in the parking garages per the 2004 FBC, Section 406.4.2. 60. The passenger loading zone for the CRA trolley shall comply with the handicap accessibility requirements of the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.1,2( c). INCLUDE REJECT ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 9 Page I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 61. Van accessible parking spaces shall be provided in the parking structures per the 2004 FBC, Sect6ion 11-4.6.2. 62. Location of exits in residential buildings shall comply with the 2004 FBC, Section 10 15.1 and Table 10 15.1 for exit access travel distance. 63. Indicate the overall height of the buildings on the elevation plans, 64. The buildings shall comply with 2004 FBC, Section 403 for high-rise buildings. 65. Indicate the occupancy type and type of construction for the residential buildings. 66. Sheet A2.04 IB - The floor plan does not depict all rooms, corridors, stair enclosures, etc. PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: 67, Park Impact Fee: 576 multi-family units x $924.00 = $532,224.00. FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST Comments: 68. Boundary Survey, Existing Trees Management Plan Sheet 1 of 1: The Landscape Architect should tabulate the total diameter inches of existing trees on the site. The tabular data should show the individual species of trees proposed to be preserved in place, relocated or removed and replaced on site. The replacement trees should be shown by a separate symbol on the landscape plan sheet LND5 of 5. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article I Sec. 7.D.p, 2.] 69. Plant Palette Legend Sheet LND5 of 5: All shade and palm trees must be listed in the description as a minimum of 12'-14' height, 3" DBH (4.5' off the ground) not caliper, and Florida #1 (Florida Grades and Standards manual). The height of the trees may be larger than 12' -14' to meet the 3" diameter requirement; or any clear trunk (c. t.) specifications. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C. 2.] 70. All trees proposed under any existing overhead electric power lines must meet the FP & L Right Tree in the Right Place manual selection for small trees only. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 P 10 age DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 71. The applicant should show an elevation cross-section detail of the actual heights of the proposed landscape trees and vegetation at the time of planting to (proper scale) visually buffer the proposed buildings and parking lot from the Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and S.B. 18th Avenue road rights-of- ways. 72. The total quantities of each of the plant materials are not shown in the legend. 73. Irrigation Plan: Turf and landscape (bedding plants) areas should be designed on separate zones and time duration for water conservation. 74, Trees should have separate irrigation bubblers to provide water directly to the root ball. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5. C.2.] PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: 75. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon the approval of the corresponding request (LUAR 06-016) to amend the future land use designation from Local Retail Commercial (LRC) to Mixed Use (MX) and to rezone from Community Commercial (C-3) to Mixed Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3). 76. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon submittal and approval of a corresponding request for a height exception, HTEX 07-01, (max building height in MU-L3 is 75 feet). 77. Provide a notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic impact analysis must be approved by the Palm Beach County Traffic Division for concurrency purposes prior to the issuance of any building permits. 78. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the new site plan is publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04-007. 79. The applicant is responsible for compliance with Ordinance 05-060, the "Art in Public Places" program, and must demonstrate their participation. 80, Indicate on all plans all existing easements to remain and those to be abandoned or relocated. Indicate location, purpose, and width of all proposed easements on site and adjacent to subject property. 81. All proposed uses must be consistent with the MU-L3 ZOnIng district identified in Chapter 2 of the Land Development Regulations. 82. The submitted list of permissible uses for the Live/Work units shall be included into the bylaws for the development. ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 P 11 age DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 83, All proposed outdoor dining areas shall comply with applicable sidewalk cafe requirements. 84. All required shrubs are to be at minimum 24 inches in height, 24 inches in spread, and planted with tip-to-tip spacing measured immediately after planting to adequately cover the planted areas on the site (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.CA.). 85, Revise the typical drawing of freestanding outdoor lighting poles to include the height and color / material proposed. The design, style, and illumination level shall be compatible with the building design (height) and shall consider safety, function, and aesthetic value (Chapter 9, Section 10.F.1.). 86. Show proposed freestanding site lighting locations on the site plan and landscape plan (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA.). Photometric plans must be submitted and approved prior to issuance of first permit. 87. Revise plans to include a detail of the upgraded Palm Tran bus stop shelter on Federal Highway. 88. The applicant shall submit a Sign Program for the project prior to any approvals for individual signs for the project, and no sign permits shall be issued until such time as the Sign program has been approved. 89, Revise building elevations (Ph IIA West) to provide architectural enhancements (faux features) or artistic components (mural, etc.) to west side ofPublix building, and provide varying levels of landscaping up to a minimum of Yz the building height. 90. Staff recommends that those areas in which the parking garage is exposed to the exterior of the project, especially abutting the gas station, the commercial/residential to the south and along the west elevation, the garage openings be enhanced with decorative metal work, decorative shutters, awnings, and in some instances cascading landscape, as approved by staff. 91. Staff recommends that prior to submittal for building permit, all of the building plans be modified to ensure that the actual roofline is 75 feet in height, in order that only those building elements eligible for Height Exception exceed that figure. 92. Staff recommends that the Royal Palm trees proposed along Federal Highway and Woolbright Road facades of the buildings be installed at approximately half of the building height, in the range of 30-35 feet. 93. Staff recommends that applicant provide the necessary landscape at approximately half of the building height in order to assist in the screening of the parking structure portion of the Phase IA building, behind the gas station. 94. Staff recommends that applicant provide the necessary landscape at varying heights to assist in the screening of the three levels of parking at the south end of the Phase ill building from the those properties not included in this project and abutting SE 18th A venue, ELLIPSE/SUNSHINE SQUARE Conditions of Approval NWSP 06-021 P 12 age I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 95, Staff recommends that applicant provide buffer hedge and trees along the east side of the ingress/egress drive at SE 18th A venue, to buffer those properties not included in this project and abutting SE 18th Avenue. 96. Include details on plans of fountains proposed in north and south commons. 97. The site plan depicts 12 off-premise parking spaces located along SE 18th A venue. These spaces cannot count towards the required parking for the project. The spaces must be removed from the parking tabular data and the spaces either created on-site or the shared parking analysis updated to ensure adequate parking is provided. 98. Should the applicant propose to place a gate within any or all of the parking structures to separate the residential parking from the general use parking, the applicant shall be required to provide an updated shared parking analysis to ensure that the assumptions made in the analysis are not voided by such action. 99. Provide an interim improvement/enhancement plan that depicts infrastructure and landscape improvements to be performed in the event of a lag time of greater than six (6) months between the completion of one (1) phase and the beginning of the next phase of construction. lOO.At time of permitting, the applicant shall submit the necessary drawings to graphically demonstrate compliance with the Sky Exposure Plane requirement of the MU-L3 district and lO-foot setback requirements, where deficient. CRA STAFF Comments: None ADDITIONAL COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD CONDITIONS To be determined. ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS To be determined. MWRleb S:\Planning\SHARED\ WP\PROJECTS\Sunshine Square\NWSP 06-021 \COA.doc DEVELOPMl r ORDER OF THE CITY COM MIS IN OF THE .." " "o";.,,,J CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA PROJECT NAME: Elllipse APPLICANT'S AGENT: Bonnie Miskel, Esq. - Ruden McClosky APPLICANT'S ADDRESS: 222 Lakeview Avenue # 800 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: December 5,2006 TYPE OF RELIEF SOUGHT: Request New Site Plan approval for a mixed-use complex in the Mixed-Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3) zoning district on a 14.43 acre parcel LOCATION OF PROPERTY: SW corner of Woolbright Rd and Federal Highway DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO. THIS MATTER came on to be heard before the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the relief sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: 1. Application for the relief sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applicant HAS HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the relief requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit "C" with notation "Included". 4. The Applicant's application for relief is hereby _ GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 hereof. DENIED 5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order. 7. Other DATED: City Clerk S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Sunshine Square\NWSP 06-021\DO,doc ~ot>-. ~'...lf~~ I Ruden ~~ McClosky l'iY\~oc.~ ~-e 200 EAST BROWARD BOULEVARD SUITE 1500 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33301 POST OFFICE BOX 1900 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33302 (954) 527-2476 FAX: (954) 333-4076 BONNIEMISKEL@RUDEN,COM October 11, 2006 To: Ed Breese and TART Members From: Bonnie Miskel, Esq. ~ RE: Ellipse / Sunshine Square NWSP 06-021 We look forward to meeting with TART on October 17th. Revised plans and materials have been compiled to address the 151 Review Comments issued September 15, 2006, More specifically, the following changes or clarifications have been provided: DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: 1. Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742- 6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10- 26 (a), Acknowled!<ed, 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is ten (10) feet (inside dimension including gates). (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.J. and Article III, section 9.A.9.a.) Acknowled!<ed. , _'~ / J J C4!h ~ PL~(~ (M ~""vlll."" ~ Cffitvvv1-V~ CUUA . DM-vL /.}.It l 0 ( CA.-,f; ~ (v, [kVL "'~,{ (?v D A FcL- " t 4jJ.J~# 1,1 /1 . I J) - / f)./ h J-. lit p. (2vV\. ()/Vt S I (~-...-' ~ vvvVt-vv QL,l/U: VV~ ' l 0 ri~f-iA-, " WPB271610,1 IY'{ Cl V'C,~ Ph to 70 J), ;t- /" e,r-Q ov t. p (710 fwu I"'...___-vtd (J~l:~)rA-- ~~t (fit, LA- ., uvifh t1~ ,Vv J . -- ~A)-\.f- f/;l-L~ NAA"L (Juhic ,1J-vr /-t"{,rvVU~ Pf3 6tt1.~ ex. ft,..{J{[;( n Y -' kUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. (Jv-- jU-tT CARACAS' FT.lAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORlANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE' SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG' TALlAHASSEE' TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 24 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 106. Indicate the occupancy type and type of construction for the residential buildings. See site plan Ai.Oi. 107. Sheet A2.04 ill - The floor plan does not depict all rooms, corridors, stair enclosures, etc. Corrected. ~~~"- \ V'V\ \>0<- ~ ~~ PARKS AND RECREATION 5"1V ~~\~ ~~\.\'l \.&.."'- \ .~ It. l> qz.A. 00 - b\ S?:> 1..' ~2...4..~ - Comments: 108. The landscape plan IS incomplete. Quantities and speCIes are not indicated on the call outs on the plan. Quantities are not shown on the V plant list Landscape Plans have been updated to include all quantities and species. 109. Native species should be identified on the plant list / Native species have been indicated on Plat List, 110. The Ficus family can not be used in Boynton Beach. ~ All Ficus species have been removed. 111. Irrigation should have 110% coverage, be from a non-potable water ~ source, have separate bubblers for each tree, and have separate zones for sod and bed areas. Acknowledged. FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST Comments: 112. Boundary Survey, Existing Trees Management Plan Sheet 1 of 1: The Landscape Architect should tabulate the total diameter inches of existing trees on the site. The tabular data should show the individual species of trees proposed to be preserved in place, relocated or removed and replaced on site. The replacement trees should be shown by a separate symbol on the WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, PA CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH ., 11/ () ~ \D ' ~ ~ Page 24 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 106. Indicate the occupancy type and type of construction for the residential buildings. See site plan AJ,OJ. 107. Sheet A2.04 ill - The floor plan does not depict all rooms, corridors, stair enclosures, etc. Corrected. PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: 108. The landscape plan IS incomplete. Quantities and speCIes are not indicated on the call outs on the plan. Quantities are not shown on the plant list. Landscape Plans have been updated to include all quantities and species. 109, Native species should be identified on the plant list Native species have been indicated on Plat List. 110. The Ficus family can not be used in Boynton Beach. All Ficus species have been removed. Ill. Irrigation should have 110% coverage, be from a non-potable water source, have separate bubblers for each tree, and have separate zones for sod and bed areas. Acknowledged. FORESTERJENVIRONMENT ALIST Comments: 112, Boundary Survey, Existing Trees Management Plan Sheet 1 of 1: The Landscape Architect should tabulate the total diameter inches of existing v--- - trees on the site. The tabular data should show the individual species of trees proposed to be preserved in place, relocated or removed and replaced on site. The replacement trees should be shown by a separate symbol on the WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH <' Page 25 DEP ARTMENTS landscape plan sheet LND5 of 5. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article I Sec. 7.D.p. 2.] A set of Tree Mitigation plans has been added to the plan set depicting the existing trees on site by species, caliper inch, condition and disposition Remove/Remain/Relocate. Re er to sheets Tl thru T5, 113. Plant Palette Legend Sheet LND5 of 5: All shade and palm trees must be listed in the description as a minimum of 12'-14' height, 3"DBH (4.5' off the ground) not caliper, and Florida #1 (Florida Grades and Standards manual), The height of the trees may be larger than 12'-14' to meet the 3" diameter requirement; or any clear trunk (c.t.) specifications. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C. 2.] eci lcations. 114. The landscape design does not include the City signature trees (Tibochina granulosa) at the ingress / egress areas to the site. These trees must meet the minimum size specifications for trees. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C.3.N.] The Ci Si nature Tree(s has been added to all main entrances 0 115. All trees proposed under any existing overhead electric power lines must meet the FP & L Right Tree in the Right Place manual selection for small trees only. Acknowled ed, 116, The landscape sheet shade tree planting detail should including a line indicating where the diameter and height of all of the trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. Dimensions have been added to the detail as re uested and re uired, 117. The landscape sheet palm tree planting detail should include a line indicating where the height of all of the palm trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. Dimensions have been added to the detail as re uested and re uired. 118. The landscape sheet shrub and groundcover planting detail should include a line indicating where the height and spread of the shrubs and groundcover lants will be measured at time of lanting and inspection. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. INCLUDE REJECT / CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH r Page 26 I DEP ARTMENTS !INCLUDE I REJECf I Dimensions have been added to the detail as reQuested and reQuired 119. The applicant should add a note that all utility boxes or structures (not V currently known or shown on the plan) should be screened with Coco plum hedge plants on three sides, The landscape sheet details indicating use of soil v:r V amendments for each of the plantings should indicate structural soil for all planting areas on the site. The total quantity of required structural soil should be added to the plant palette legend. A note has been added to all Landscape Plan sheets. 120. The applicant should show an elevation cross-section detail of the actual heights of the proposed landscape trees and vegetation at the time of planting V to (proper scale) visually buffer the proposed buildings and parking lot from the Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and S.E. 18th Avenue road rights-of- ways. A cross section shall be provided as reQuested. 12L Many of the landscape symbols are mIssmg the speCIes number or V identification letters on the landscape sheets. Symbols and auantities have been added to all sheets, 122. The total quantities of each of the plant materials are not shown in the legend. ~ Total Quantities have been added to the le~end. 123. Irrigation Plan: Turf and landscape (bedding plants) areas should be / designed on separate zones and time duration for water conservation. Acknowledf!ed. 124. Trees should have separate irrigation bubblers to provide water directly to V the root ball, [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec, 5. C.2.] V A cknowledf!ed. PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH ~-.i.!;.. 7 j1~~' .~/"'7 ~.., , ,'::- ,j /' (I-'---n1l.ie4;.) -, }t~LJ ( I./, . ~ - , d v . ()I,.j, / ujl ? / t, 1V)1' d v ~d ~cc?l~sky 200 EAST BROWARD BOULEVARD SUITE 1500 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33301 POST OFFICE BOX 1900 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33302 (954) 527-2476 FAX: (954) 333-4076 BONN IE. MISKEL@RUDEN,COM October 11, 2006 To: Ed Breese and TART Members From: Bonnie Miske!, Esq. ~ RE: Ellipse / Sunshine Square NWSP 06-021 We look forward to meeting with TART on October 17th. Revised plans and materials have been compiled to address the 151 Review Comments issued September 15, 2006. More specifically, the following changes or clarifications have been provided: I DEP ARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECf I PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: 1. Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742- 6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10- 26 (a). A cknow/ed!Zed. 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is ten (10) feet (inside dimension including gates). (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.1. and Article III, section 9.A.9.a.) Acknow/ed!Zed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. fT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 11 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJ 45. The minimum diameter for a storm sewer is 15 inches (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A.2.a.) Please correct plans accordingly. The plans have been corrected. 46. Lengths of perforated and non-perforated pipe do not appear to have been called out correctly on the Paving, Grading & Drainage plans (Sheets C2 and C3.) Please correct. The plans have been corrected, 47. Provide an engineer's certification on the Drainage Plan as specified in LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2. The enKineer's certification has been added. 48. Indicate by note that catch basin and manhole covers shall be bicycle proof (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A.2.g). The note has been added. 49. Specify storm sewer diameters, inlets types, etc. on drainage plan. Indicate grate, rim and invert elevations for all structures. Indicate grade of storm sewer segments. Indicate material specifications for storm sewer. The information has been provided. 50. Full drainage plans, including drainage calculations, in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5 will be required at the time of permitting. The drainaKe calculations have been provided. 51. Paving, drainage and site details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All engineering construction details shall be in accordance with the applicable City of Boynton Beach Standard Drawings and the "Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. Acknowledged. FIRE / Comments: All Fire comments are acknowled$l.ed. .v WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' fT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA' S1. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 12 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 52. All entrance gates to construction area shall have a Knox lock system that will also open in case of electrical power failure. All gates shall be a minimum of 20 feet wide if two lanes, and 12 feet wide if single lane, Fire Department apparatus shall be able to turn into the construction site in one turn. Fire Department entry through locked gates shall be by Knox Locks. A cknowled$!ed. 53. The construction site access roads shall be maintained free of obstructions at all times, Acknowled~ed. 54. All required fire hydrants, standpipes or sprinkler systems shall be in place before going vertical. Vertical construction shall be protected by standpipes and the sprinkler system to one level below the highest level of construction throughout the building. Acknowled$!ed. 55. Any cost of damage to Fire Department vehicles because of improperly stabilized roads or any towing fees if a vehicle becomes stuck will be the responsibility of the contractor, A minimum of 32 tons is required for ground stabilization. The pouring of the foundation pad is considered vertical construction, The roads must be acceptable before construction begins. Acknoled$!ed, 56. Adequate Fire Department vehicle turn around space shall be provided in the construction area. Acknowled~ed. 57. Provide the fire hydrant layout for this project with the hydrants clearly shown on one sheet. Show all water supply lines for fire protection and hydraulic calculations using data from a flow test conducted within the past six months. This test will be conducted by the Boynton Beach Fire Department. Acknowledged. The Boynton Beach Fire Department test and the hydraulic calculations have been provided with this submittal. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, PA v / V' v/ v v CARACAS' FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 13 DEP ARTMENTS 58. Sprinkler systems installed in commercial businesses shall be in accordance with NFPA 13. All residential systems shall conform to NFPA 13. INCLUDE REJECT v Acknowled~ed. 59. Buildings that exceed 75 feet in height, measured from the point of lowest entry to the bottom of the highest floor that can be occupied, shall be equipped with a Rescue Air Breathing system. v All upper floor slabs are below 75', POLICE Comments: All Police comments are acknowledged. 61. Construction Site Approval: The Staff recommends that prior to issuance of the first building permit, the applicant shall prepare a construction site security and management plan for approval by the City's Police Department CPTED Official. The developer/project manager after site clearing and placement of construction trailers shall institute security measures to reduce or eliminate opportunities for theft. The management plan shall include, but not be limited to, temporary lighting, security personnel, vehicle barriers, construction/visitor pass, reduce/minimize entry/exit points, encourage subcontractors to secure machinery, tools at end of work day and/or any other measure deemed appropriate to provide a safe and secure working environment. The security management plan shall be maintained throughout the construction phase of the project. Acknowled~ed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH r I Ruden ~j McClosky 200 EAST BROWARD BOULEVARD SUITE 1500 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33301 POST OFFICE BOX 1900 FORT LAUDERDALE. FLORIDA 33302 (954) 527-2476 FAX: (954) 333-4076 BONNIE,MISKEL@RUDEN,COM October 11,2006 To: Ed Breese and TART Members From: Bonnie Miskel, Esq. ~ RE: Ellipse / Sunshine Square NWSP 06-021 We look forward to meeting with TART on October 17th. Revised plans and materials have been compiled to address the 1st Review Comments issued September 15, 2006. More specifically, the following changes or clarifications have been provided: DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJhCT PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: 1. Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742- 6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10- 26 (a). Acknowledged. 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is ten (10) feet (inside dimension including gates). (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.J. and Article III, section 9.A.9.a.) Acknowledged. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.^- CARACAS' FT. LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE' SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH , ,,40 Page 40 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT Fountain details not yet provided. eRA STAFF Comments: 214. Add shared parking calculations to site plan. V Calculations noted, 215. Application for height exception needed. ~ A request for a height exception is enclosed with this resubmittal. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. fT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH ~ Ruden ~~I McClosky 200 EAST BROWARD BOULEVARD SUITE 1500 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33301 POST OFFICE BOX 1900 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33302 (954) 527-2476 FAX: (954) 333-4076 BONNIE,MISKEL@RUDEN,COM October 11,2006 To: Ed Breese and TART Members From: Bonnie Miskel, Esq. ~ ~ .: RE: Ellipse / Sunshine Square NWSP 06-021 We look forward to meeting with TART on October 17th. Revised plans and materials have been compiled to address the 1 st Review Comments issued September 15, 2006. More specifically, the following changes or clarifications have been provided: I DEP ARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: 1. Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742- 6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10- (~ '., 26 (a), Acknow/edfled. 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is ten (10) feet (inside dimension including gates). (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5,J. " and Article III, section 9.A.9.a.) Acknow/ed~ed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. fT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 2 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT A minimum overhead clearance of 14 feet is noted on the Site Plan for the dumpster/compactor areas in Phases lA, m, and 1m. No clearance is noted for Phase IIA. Fourteen (14) feet of clearance will allow Solid Waste and Fire/Rescue to use the ground level of the three noted buildings. It is not sufficient for the overhead pick-up required for dumpsters or "raised bed" conventional pick-up of compactors. Indicate exact method of trash pick-up that does use these methods. All vhases shall have 14' clearances. 3. Provide a minimum turning radius of 60 feet to approach dumpsters. Provide a minimum backing clearance of 60 feet (measured from the front edge of the dumpster pad.) (LDR, Chapter 2, Section 11.J.2.b.) A cknowled!.!ed. PUBLIC WORKS - Traffic Comments: 4. Provide a traffic analysis and notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic study shall include an evaluation of the need for an additional right turn lane (eastbound to southbound) on Woolbright Road using proposed generation rates (pre- and post-development.) Our team is currently working with Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering regarding the traffic impacts associated with the proposed re-development of the Sunshine Square shopping center. We are awaiting the results of additional traffic analyses being performed by Kimley-Horn along Woolbright Road, from us 1 to the FEC railroad, including the proposed Ellipse project, the proposed Epoch development located on the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and US 1, and the proposed relocation of the traffic signal located on Woolbright Road, just east of the FEe railroad, to a more central location (between the railroad and US 1), as requested by the City of Boynton Beach. The results of the Kimley-Horn analysis will be incorporated into our final traffic study for this project and submitted to Palm Beach County Traffic Engineeringfor final review. The final traffic study will include an evaluation of an eastbound right-turn lane at the Woolbright Road access driveway. The subject WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P,A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST, LUCIE' SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 3 DEPARTMENTS auxiliary lane has been incorporated in the site plan for the project. I INCLUDE I REJECf I 5. Dedicate right-of-way as necessary should a right turn lane be warranted in the future. Consider growth in background traffic for the year 2020. Also, coordinate the design and construction of all traffic improvements necessary to support this development with the developer of the Las Ventanas site on the northwest comer of Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. Provide written proof ofthis cooperation to the City. ',' A meeting was held with the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) regarding the access driveways along Federal Highway (a state roadway). The FDOT will require the construction of a southbound right-turn lane on Federal Highway at the main project entrance as part of the driveway permit process. The site plan reflects the implementation of a southbound right-turn lane at the Federal Highway access driveway. The Ellipse development team has been coordinating all improvements along Woolbright Road, between the FEC railroad and US 1, with Palm Beach County, Epoch (Las Ventanas), and the City of Boynton Beach. A joint meeting was held between all parties on September 1, 2006 at Palm Beach County's Traffic Engineering Department (see attached sign-in sheet). 6. Show loading areas on the Traffic Marking &, Signage Plans~ include a pavement message in yellow indicating "No Parking - Loading Zone". -See City Standard Drawings "K" Series for striping detail. :.\ \. 'I... The loadin~ zones have been identified. 7. Provide Fire Lanes in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section B.2 and Section M. Fire Lanes have been added, 8. Sheet C6 of 12 of the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans incorrectly references Broward County standards. Please correct to specify City of Boynton Beach and Palm Beach County standards. The sheet has been corrected. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, PA CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT S1. LUCIE. SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 4 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT PUBLIC WORKS-Forestry Comments: 9. The Landscape plan included with this submittal is incomplete. A complete review cannot be made at this time. The Landscape Plan has been substantially completed since the last submittal on 8/4/06. 10. Show sight triangles on the Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.H.) Reference FDOT Standard Index 546 for the sight triangles along both Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. Sight triangles in the -interior ofthedeV€lopment shall be I5-feet. Site trian~les and FDOT si~ht lines have been added to the Landscape Plans. 11. The medians on Federal Highway have existing irrigation and plant material belonging to the City of Boynton Beach. Any damage to the irrigation system and/or plant material as a result of the contractor's operations shall be repaired or replaced to the equivalent or better grade, as approved by the City of " Boynton Beach, and shall be the sole responsibility of the developer. The contractor shall notify and coordinate with the City of Boynton Beach Forestry & Grounds Division of Public Works a minimum of six (6) weeks in advance of any underground activities, Please acknowledge this notice in your comments response and add a note to the appropriate plan sheets with the above stated information. I Acknowled~ed. 12. Per the LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2. Ficus species are not permitted. Ficus species have been removed from the Landscape Plans. I UTILITIES Comments: WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 5 DEPARTMENTS !INCLUDE I REJECT I 13. Please provide a timeline that clearly illustrates when water and sewer services will be required to serve the proposed project. Your starting date for the timeline should be the date of City Commission approval. Also provide milestone dates for permit application, the start of construction, and the setting of the first water meter. This timeline will be used to determine the adequacy of water and wastewater treatment capacity for your project upon the project's completion, so please be as accurate as possible. City Commission approval is expected in April 2007, Water and sewer permit application is expected to occur March 2007. Construction is expected to begin June 2007, First water meter settin}! is expected in June 2008. 14. All utility easements shall be shown on the Site plan, Landscape, and Hardscape plans (as well as the Water and Sewer Plans) so that we may determine which appurtenances, trees or shrubbery may interfere with utilities. In general, palm trees will be the only tree species allowed within utility easements. .' - . I .' All easements are depicted on the Landscape Plans and all canopy trees have been removed from within them, if necessary, 15. Canopy trees may be planted outside of the easement so that roots and branches will not impact those utilities within the easement in the foreseeable future. The LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article I, Section 18.1 gives public utilities the authority to remove any trees that interfere with utility services, either in utility easements or public rights-of-way. A cknowled}!ed, 16. Palm Beach County Health Department permits will be required for the water and sewer systems serving this project (CODE, Section 26-12). Acknowledged. Acknowle}!ed, 17. Fire flow calculations will be required demonstrating the City Code requirement of 1,500 g.p.m. (500 g.p.m. some residential developments) with 20 p.s.i. residual pressure as stated in the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16, or the requirement imposed by insurance underwriters, whichever is greater (CODE, Section 26-16(b)), Please see attached calculations. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 6 DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 18. The LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16 requires that all points on each building will be within 200 feet of an existing or proposed fire hydrant. Please demonstrate that the plan meets this condition, by showing all hydrants. The northernmost eastern building, the easternmost northern building, the middle of the northernmost western building, a small portion of the Public supermarket, and the easternmost southern building lack sufficient coverage. Please correct. '. ' Hydrants have been relocated and two hydrants added to provide full coverage to the site. 19. The CODE, Section 26-34(E) requires that a capacity reservation fee be paid for this project either upon the request for the Department's signature on the Health Department application forms or within seven (7) days of site plan approval, whichever occurs first. This fee will be determined based upon final meter size, or expected demand, Acknowled$!ed. 20. Comprehensive Plan Policy 3.C.3.4. requires the conservation of potable water. As other sources are readily available City water shall not be allowed for irrigation. A cknowled$!ed. 21. Water and sewer lines to be owned and operated by the City shall be included within utility easements. Please show all proposed easements on the engineering drawings, using a minimum width of 12 feet. The easements shall be dedicated via separate instrument to the City as stated in CODE Sec. 26-33(a). All required easements for water and sewer, with minimum 12' width, are shown on the plans. 22. This office will not require surety for installation of the water and sewer utilities, on condition that the systems be fully completed, and given to the City Utilities Department before the first permanent meter is set. Note that setting of a permanent water meter is a prerequisite to obtaining the Certificate of Occupancy. It is expected that the system will be fully completed before the first permanent meter is set. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 7 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 23. A building permit for this project shall not be issued until this Department has approved the plans for the water and/or sewer improvements required to service this project, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-15. Acknowled~ed. 24. PVC material not permitted on the City's water system. All lines shall be DIP. All water mains will be DIP. 25. The Water & Sanitary Sewer plans reflect numerous 450 bends; please revise to read 22-1/20 bends as no 450 deflections are shown. Check all call-outs to assure they have been correctly identified. Call-outs have been checked and 22-1/2 degree bends indicated. 26. Appropriate backflow preventer(s) will be required on the domestic water service to the building, and the fire sprinkler line if there is one, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-207. Backjlow preventers will be provided on domestic and fire sprinkler lines as soon as the plumbing information are available, 27. Provide a minimum of ten (10) feet separation between water main, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer lines. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. Ten foot separation has been provided, 28. The waste stream from any food preparation area processes must meet the City's pretreatment requirements. A sampling point must be provided to allow monitoring of this waste stream (refer to CODE Section 26-143 and Section 26-147.) Food preparation areas have not been identified at this time, Pre-treatment will be provided as soon as these areas are delineated. 29. All retail buildings are indicated as being fully sprinklered, yet nothing is indicated for the live-work townhomes. Are they to be sprinklered also? All buildin~s will be sprinklered as indicated on site plan, 30. All multi-level parking structures (garages); are they to be sprinklered? WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT Sf. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 8 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I Spacing of the fire hydrants (see Comment #35) reflects several coverage gaps. All buildinf!s will be sprinklered as indicated on site plan, 31. There is an existing six (6) inch DIP water main running east to west immediately north of the existing Public supermarket, which is not addressed as to be either removed or relocated. In addition, the proposed eight (8) inch water main run in the middle of the property running north-south direction is shown as connecting to an existing six (6) inch line along the north side of SE 18th A venue. This is not acceptable. This project will be required to develop a Hardy-Cross analysis of the project site and the surrounding area to determine which external links will need to be upgraded to support this development. The existing 6" line north of Publix will be abandoned. Although our analysis of the water system shows that no external upgrades are required on external links, we are contemplating upgrades to the 6" line to 8" at Woolbright and S.E. 18h Avenue adiacent to the site to comply with the Utility Master Plan. 32. Upsize the water main in Woolbright Road to meet the requirements of the Utility Master Plan. The main shall be upsized from the west side of the FECRR east to the point of connection (west driveway) for the project. Consideration is been given to upsizing the existing line from east of the railroad tracks-east to the driveway entrance, 33. Coordinate with Boynton Beach Fire-Rescue to determine flow requirements for multi-story buildings over four stories. . Acknowledf!ed. 34. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3(0) requires Master Plans to show all utilities on or adjacent to the proposed tract. The plan must therefore show the point of service for water and sewer, and the proposed off-site utilities construction needed in order to service this project. Proposed off-site utilities construction are shown and point of services are also shown. 35. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3(P) requires a statement be included that utilities are available and will be provided by all other appropriate agencies. This statement is lacking on the submitted plans. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT. LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE' SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 9 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I Note added on site plan AI.OI. 36. Utility construction details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All utility construction details shall be in accordance with the Utilities Department's "Utilities Engineering Design Handbook and ...... Construction Standards" manual (including any updates) and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. Acknowled!i!ed. ENGINEERING Comments: 37. Add a note to the Site Plan stating "All plans submitted for specific permits shall meet the City's Code requirements at time of application. These permits include, but are not limited to, the following: paving, drainage, curbing, site lighting, landscaping and irrigation. Permits required from other permitting agencies such as Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), Lake Worth Drainage District (L WDD), Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), Palm Beach County Health Department (PBCHD), Palm Beach County Engineering Department (PBCED), Palm Beach County Department of Environmental Resource Management (PBCDERM) and any others, shall be included with the permit request." Note added on site plan AI.OI 38. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. Acknowled!i!ed. 39. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. Acknowledged. Acknowledf?ed. 40. Upon satisfactory Commission approval of the site plan, the applicant shall '.", enter the plat process through the City's Engineering Division. A preliminary plat application may be initiated during the site plan review to expedite WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 10 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I issuance of the Land Development Permit. A plat will be required for this development. Acknowledged. Acknowled~ed. 41. Provide written and graphic scales on all sheets. The scale shall match between all sheets depicting the site (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7 .B.l, 7 .C.l, and 7.F .1. If desired a "master" sheet may be provided for each section with enlargements provided for additional detail on subsequent sheets. Acknowledged. Acknowled~ed. 42. Show proposed site lighting on the Site, all Civil and Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.4.) The lighting design shall provide a minimum average light level of one foot-candle. On the Lighting Plan, specify that the light poles shall withstand a 140 MPH wind load (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.l.a and Florida Building Code). Provide a note that the fixtures shall be operated by photoelectrical control and are to remain on until 2:00 " a.m. (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.1.a.) Include pole wind loading, and pole details in conformance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 11, Chapter 23, Article I, Section 5.B.7 and Chapter 23, Article II, Section A on the Lighting Plan. Lighting shall not be used as a form of advertising in a manner that draws more attention to the building or grounds at night than in the day (LDR, Chapter 9, Section 1O.F.5). Provide photometrics as part of your TART plan submittals. To be provided at a later date. Light Poles shall be depicted on Landscape Plans and all trees shall adhere to minimum distance requirements, 43. The minimum size for a 900 parking stall is 9 feet x 18 feet and for 00 (parallel) parking is 9 feet x 25 feet. (Engineering Design Standard Drawing K-2.) Please correct the detail shown on Sheet C3 of 12 and on the plans. . , The sheet has been corrected. 44. Provide a minimum ten (10) feet clearance between water, sanitary sewer and/or storm sewer. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. Ten foot clearance has been provided. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P,A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 11 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 45. The minimum diameter for a storm sewer is 15 inches (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A.2.a.) Please correct plans accordingly. .. The plans have been corrected. 46. Lengths of perforated and non-perforated pipe do not appear to have been called out correctly on the Paving, Grading & Drainage plans (Sheets C2 and C3.) Please correct. The plans have been corrected, 47. Provide an engineer's certification on the Drainage Plan as specified in LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2. The enf!ineer 's certification has been added. 48. Indicate by note that catch basin and manhole covers shall be bicycle proof (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A.2.g). The note has been added. 49. Specify storm sewer diameters, inlets types, etc. on drainage plan. Indicate grate, rim and invert elevations for all structures. Indicate grade of storm sewer segments. Indicate material specifications for storm sewer. The information has been provided. 50. Full drainage plans, including drainage calculations, in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5 will be required at the time of permitting. The drainaf!e calculations have been provided. 51. Paving, drainage and site details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All engineering construction details shall be in accordance with the applicable City of Boynton Beach Standard Drawings and the "Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. Acknowledged. FIRE Comments: All Fire comments are acknowled$!ed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH , , Page 26 I DEP ARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECf I Dimensions have been added to the detail as requested and required 119. The applicant should add a note that all utility boxes or structures (not currently known or shown on the plan) should be screened with Coco plum hedge plants on three sides, The landscape sheet details indicating use of soil amendments for each of the plantings should indicate structural soil for all planting areas on the site, The total quantity of required structural soil should be added to the plant palette legend. A note has been added to all Landscave Plan sheets. 120. The applicant should show an elevation cross-section detail of the actual heights of the proposed landscape trees and vegetation at the time of planting to (proper scale) visually buffer the proposed buildings and parking lot from the Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and S.E. 18th Avenue road rights-of- ways. A cross section shall be provided as requested. 121. Many of the landscape symbols are mIssmg the speCIes number or identification letters on the landscape sheets. Symbols and Quantities have been added to all sheets. 122, The total quantities of each of the plant materials are not shown in the legend. Total Quantities have been added to the legend, 123, Irrigation Plan: Turf and landscape (bedding plants) areas should be designed on separate zones and time duration for water conservation. Acknowledged. 124. Trees should have separate inigation bubblers to provide water directly to the root ball. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5. C.2.] Acknowledged. PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH , Page 27 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 125. At the technical advisory review team (TART) meeting, provide written responses to all staffs comments and questions. Submit 12 sets of revised plans, Each set should be folded and stapled. Acknowled~ed. 126. At the technical advisory review team meeting, also provide a full set of reduced drawings, sized 81'2 inches by II inches of each plan. Save each plan to a compact disk and submit that to staff as well. Acknowledged. 127. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. Acknowled~ed. 128. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. v Acknowledged, 129. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon the approval of the corresponding request (LUAR 06-016) to amend the future land use designation from Local Retail Commercial (LRC) to Mixed Use (MX) and to rezone from Community Commercial (C-3) to Mixed Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3). v Acknowled~ed. 130. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon submittal and approval of a corresponding request for a height exception (max building height in MU-L3 is 75 feet). V Acknowledged. A request for a height exception is included In the resubmittal package. 131. Clarify total building height on all building elevations. Measure building height as specified in definition of Building/Structure Height (Article II of Land Development Regulations). WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. v/ '"r v L/ ~ v CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 28 DEPARTMENTS See elevations and hei~ht exception request. 132. A drainage statement is required prior to the Technical Application Review Team (TART) meeting (Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2.). 133. All proposed uses and their respective building areas must match between the traffic study and the site plan. In addition, the letter from PBC Traffic dated June 21, 2006 requires a revised traffic study. The revised traffic study will be required prior to the eRA meeting (Chapter 4. Section 8.F.). Staff would prefer to have the revised traffic study by the TART meeting tentatively scheduled for October 3, 2006, Acknowledf!ed. 134. Provide a notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic impact analysis must be approved by the Palm Beach County Traffic Division for concurrency purposes prior to the issuance of any building permits. Our team is currently working with Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering regarding the traffic impacts associated with the proposed re-development of the Sunshine Square shopping center. We are awaiting the results of additional traffic analyses being performed by Kimley-Horn along Woolbright Road, from us 1 to the FEC railroad, including the proposed Ellipse project, the proposed Epoch development located on the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and US 1, and the proposed relocation of the traffic signal located on Woolbright Road, just east of the FEC railroad, to a more central location (between the railroad and US 1), as requested by the City of Boynton Beach. The results of the Kimley-Horn analysis will be incorporated into our final traffic study for this project and submitted to Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering for final review. The final traffic study will include an evaluation of an eastbound right-turn lane at the Woolbright Road access driveway. The subject auxiliary lane has been incorporated in the site plan for the project. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. I INCLUDE I REJECT I ~/ V l'\JI'f( aJ tILe US 1 I tL-t€Sr H () l'~ 5 f'l {d.f.J f(r () L1. ~ . l-\Q,-j"r c) fi'L( '/ [Gorki \J~ ~)/ P8t~ UN .JetOr!. t ~LO^-,\ of. a XI' IVS CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.IUClE . SARASOTA. Sf. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 29 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 135. Revise site plan application: (page 1, Section I.l.) to include new project name; (page 2, Section 11.1.) to revise to MX land use; (page 2, Section 11.2.) to revise to MU-L3 zoning district; (page 2, Section II.3.) to switch site area to 14.43 acres and square feet to 628,727 sf. v I . 136. Revise site plan application (page 3, Section 5.e.) to include pervious area of 3.44 acres or 23.83% of site (5.h. should be total of5,e.-5.g.) v 137. The site plan application (page 3, Section II.6.) and site plan tabular (A 1.0 1) for floor area breakdown do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed square footage for each use and to make application and plans consistent. V' 138. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.7,c.3-4) total 404 2- and 3+- bedrooms, and site plan tabular (Al.OI) bedroom count info for required parking does not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number for each unit type / size and to make application and plans consistent. v 139. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.8.) and site plan tabular (Al.OI) density is 39,9168 dulac, this should be rounded to 39.92 dulac. '\../" 140. The site plan application (page 4, Section II,9.) should also include maximum number of stories proposed. .L,./ I 14l. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.IO.a.) should clarify requirement of 14 spaces per 200 sf and what code provision this is based upon. Also each live/work unit requires 2.5 spaces per unit. v 142. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.IO,b.) requires a calculation WPB:271610:1 ~/ RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 30 DEPARTMENTS for required number of handicap parking spaces. INCLUDE REJ ly 143. Submit two (2) copies of the shared parking analysis (signed and sealed by a licensed traffic engineer). 144. Provide details of shared parking analysis on site plan application (page 4, Section 11.10.) and site plan (Al.Ol). ~7 N Acknowled ed. 145. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.10.a.) and site plan tabular (Al.Ol) parking counts do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number of spaces required and number of spaces provided and to make application and plans consistent. Ian 146. Clarify that site will be developed as one parcel under a Unity of Title, or if there will be separately owned parcels under a Unity of Control. If separate parcels, provide parcel boundaries, lot dimensions, and setbacks from the lot lines. A recorded Unity of Title or Unity of Control will be required prior to the issuance of a building permit. Engineering is requiring platting - this nullifies the need for Unity of Title or Control. 147. Indicate bolder phase lines on all plans. Provide phasing information, including building square footage per use, total square footage, and parking required/provided per phase in site tabular on sheet A 1.0 1, lan, and site tabs Al,Ol, 148. Submit LLC corporate papers which name principal authorized to sign on behalf of Sunshine Square CRP, LLC. 149. Submit large (24" x 36") colored renderings (clipped not glued to foamboard) of project at the TART meeting. These will be displayed at the public hearings. Acknowled ed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. ~ ~ v V' v v v v- t/ ~ CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST, LUCIE' SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 31 DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 150. Submit color chips of proposed building colors noted on elevations. Acknowled~ed. 151. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the new site plan is publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04-007. V Acknowled~ed. 152. The applicant is responsible for compliance with Ordinance 05-060, the "Art in Public Places" program, and must demonstrate their participation. Update and complete the Public Art Information Form submitted May 19, ~ 2006. Acknowledfled. 153. Correct zoning district (not category) in tabular site data on cover sheet A1.01 to MU-L3 (Mixed Use Low Intensity 3) and Land Use Designation is Mixed Use (MX). Corrected, \54. Revise parcels labeled as "NIC" to "Not Included". office as "NOT IN CITY". NIC is used by this Corrected. 155. On site plan and landscape plan, show as-built conditions of adjacent parcels which are not included in the project. Demonstrate how proposed structures with minimal or no setbacks and required landscaping will be maintained (including the side of Publix adjacent to the RR tracks). Foundation landscaping is required in these areas, but not provided. Buffer areas have been provided, see site plan, Where applicable structures have been moved further off the property line where applicable (J 0') and additionallandscapj!JR-has been added. 156. The review of applications for MU-L3 shall emphasize aesthetics and design quality, and physical compatibility with adjacent land uses. Demonstrate how the proposed development will tie in with gas station on comer and parcel on SE 18th Ave. through fa<;ade and landscaping upgrades and connectivity. Buffer areas have been vrovided, see site plan. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. v ~v \,../ v--- v CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT Sf. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 32 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 157, Perimeter landscaping is required along the common property lines adjacent to the gas station and adjacent to properties fronting SE 18th Ave. Revise landscape plan to provide required perimeter/foundation landscaping in these locations. A landscape easement on adjacent property may be considered if parties agree to all terms. v- Buffer areas have been provided, see site plan. The existing gas station currently has existing trees and shrubs along its perimeter. Where applicable, additional landscaping has been provided. Additional landscaping has also been provided, where possible, for properties rontin SE 18th Avenue. 158. Submit a perspective view from Federal and Woolbright of Ph IA North and East elevations which includes the existing gas station to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing gas station, and to accentuate a focal V point and provide for transitional possibilities (should adjacent development be acquired in the future). To be rovided at a later date. 159. Submit a perspective view from Federal and SE 18th Ave of Ph ill South and East elevations which includes the existing development on parcel not included to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing development offsite, and to accentuate a focal point and provide for transitional possibilities (should adjacent development be acquired in the future). v To be rovided at a later date. 160. Prior to TART meeting, submit draft cross-access easements for future cross access to gas station, and a letter from gas station owner that he is willing to enter into the recorded cross access easement agreements prior to the first CO. \,/ Easements documents have been drafted, however, the gas station owner is not coo erative at this time. 161, Submit a phasing plan and construction time line which details what will be completed in each phase before starting next phase (road improvements, parking, traffic circulation~ Ipnds ping) and how existing tenants are to be relocated. -e - ~ I { . { ~ v WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST,LUClE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 33 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 162. On the site plan tabular data (A 1.0 1 and .02), indicate the maximum allowable FAR in MU-L3 district and the proposed FAR, V Corrected. 163. Provide tabular parking space breakdown for residential versus nonresidential uses and number of spaces for each type. t.--"' See tabs Al,Ol, 164. Clarify within tabular information on plans if multifamily units will be 1--' rentals or condominium. The units will be Rentals. 165. Clarify on plan if interior streets will be private streets or public rights-of- way. If private streets, documents regarding who will maintain streets will be V required, Interior streets will be private, maintenance af!reempnf<: will be provided. ...... 166. Provide graphic and written scales on all plans. ;/" -.. Corrected. 167. Provide legible floor plans for each proposed building. V Corrected, 168. The area west of Publix is shown as pervious (sod) on landscape and hardscape plans, yet the site plan shows a walkway along side of building. V Please revise plans to match. Corrected, the sidewalk has been deleted. 169. Provide details of where residential parking spaces are located, and how the spaces for residential will be differentiated from the spaces for nonresidential. V' One space per unit shall be assigned at the upper floors of the garages, Lower decks shall be shared by residential and commercial uses. See notes Al,Ol, 170. Clearly label all bearings and distances for all property lines on plans, U- WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT. LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST, LUCIE' SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 34 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT See site plan. Acknowled ed. 171. The property legal description on sheet A1.01 is not consistent with legal on survey (typos noted). 'v Corrected. 172. Revise legal description to include acreage to the nearest 1/100th of an acre and total square footage of property (at end of legal). Submit a copy of revised legal with acrea e/sfin Word format on a CD for file. v 173. Clarify actual acreage of property (legal description is 14.42, application and tabular is 14.43), Corrected. 174. Dimension ultimate R/W and V.E. widths and depict/label centerlines of all rights-of-way. v v Corrected. 175. Indicate all existing easements to remain and those to be abandoned or relocated. Indicate location, purpose, and width of all proposed easements on site and adjacent to subject property. rll.ASR, fu ~?tO it) C t1 ~e rn~ .,J -tS \.).tJ bl1:f f-) L ct-tJ v Easements depicted on plan. Easements are on landsca e lans, 176. Include a typical floor plan for each residential unit model which notes exterior dimensions, number of bedrooms, A/C area sf, total unit size, etc. (Chapter 4, Section 7.D.1.). v See bid lans, 177. Indicate additional detail on the building elevations regarding the MV-L3 locational requirements for arterials to clarify how much of a stepback is provided between the residential units and retail uses. For structures greater than 45 feet in height the frontage on any street is required to provide a 10 foot stepback at 35 feet of building height, plus a 10 foot stepback for each additional 50 feet in building height. For heights greater that 75 feet this shall be provided in two 10-foot stepbacks. Clearly label architectural features on elevations (such as decks and r, ailings)/ indicate height at sttfpback ,and amount of each stepback. d u...S//U-Cl I ('ILK., 0 AJ P "La ~rN . pL.a4\) cI;d J.J f ~l"-OL,~ 0~ h'ltlS, J ~ Acknowled ed, see elevatIOns,' . WPB:271610:1 v RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 35 DEP ARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 178. Provide building elevations (of all buildings sides) of each building and provide the floor area of each building (Chapter 4, Section 7,E.2.). Provided. 179. Provide a graphic depicting view of the garage from the courtyard of the building in Ph lID. Supplemental landscaping especially around foundation of building and parking structure, decorative features, and benches are needed in this location (add to landscape plan). Provided. P f/OS p-€..d-/ i^-( --Psc+l/\, ~/O fYl i ~ / 180. Label each building on the site plan with the number of floors and building height. Provided. 181. Please provide an additional unstapled set of separate building elevations for each building that is subject to the height exception (exceeding 75 feet). These elevations will be used separately as part of the height exception presentation to the Board, Provided. 182. Revise all plans to demonstrate that front setbacks are measured from arcades along Federal and Woolbright in compliance with the MU-L3 front setback of 0-10 feet (plan shows a 10' UE and a 5' setback from UE for a total setback of 15 feet), Also, the LiveIWork units fronting 18th are subject to the 0-10 foot setback requirement, unless public spaces (wide plazas, not sidewalks) are provided. BuildinJ!s have been moved to the 10' setback line. 183, Specify if proposed development will include a bank. If so, provide details in tabular for bank use, floor location, square footage, and specify with or without drive-thru teller facilities. A bank with drive up teller facilities requires conditional use approval (separate application). No Bank olanned. 184. All proposed uses must be consistent with the MU-L3 zoning district identified in Chapter 2 of the Land Development Regulations. A cknowled~ed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. j/" V" V' 'v/" v \,/ v @ CARACAS' FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST, LUCIE' SARASOTA' 'ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 36 ~_ fl DEP ARTMENTS ~::J 1CU ) INCLUDE REJECT 185. - fh:ase SllLJll~ ~ list of permissible uses for the Live/W ork units that v:iH be included into the bylaws for the development (n::fta tv Ch.2, Scetion U0 {S.H.15. Liv~/Wolk rCllhi,,~~Lk U"c~ in the SMU Dj~tl~d fOl pI\"f~l1~J u&e~). - 186. All proposed outdoor dining areas shall comply with applicable sidewalk cafe requirements. V See note Ai.Oi. 187. The trash enclosures shall resemble with respect to the color and materials, the design of the principal buildings and shall be integrated with other site elements (Chapter 9, Section 10.E.3.). On the site plan, place a note indicating this requirement. V Acknowledged, however all but one trash enclosure are enclosed with the buildinf.!. 188. Equipment placed on the walls of the buildings shall be painted to match the building color (Chapter 9, Section 10.CA.). Place a note on the elevations V- indicating this requirement. ~ See note Ai.Oi. 189. The removal/relocation of trees is subject to review and approval of the V City Forester/Environmentalist. ~~ ~ Acknowledf.!ed. \ 190. Trees are required to be at least 12 feet overall height at the time of installation (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2.) and with multi-story developments trees placed around the buildings must be a minimum of ~ the V peight of the building. - -' All required trees meet minimum heif.!ht requirements. 191. The Royal Palm specifications appear incorrect, indicating only a 6 foot to 8 foot height. V- Royal Palmsar..e.slJecified at 10' of matched f.!rey wood (22' o,a. hts., min) 192. All required shrubs are to be at minimum 24 inches in height, 24 inches in spread, and planted with tip-to-tip spacing measured immediately after planting to adequately cover the planted areas on the site (Chapter 7.5, Article V II, Section 5.CA.). Al required shrubs meet minimum specifications. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST,LUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 37 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 193, A minimum of fifty percent (50%) of site landscape materials in each category (palms, canopy trees, shrubs, groundcovers) must be native species. Indicate amount of each species proposed and if native material, and indicate a total % native provided for each category in the plant list of the landscape plan (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.P). Plat list has been amended to indicate native species and percentaf!es. 194. Landscaping at project entrances shall contain a signature tree at both sides of the entrance (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5,N.). A signature tree is a tree with blossoms or natural color other than green intended to beautify project entrances and contribute to the city's image with this element of aesthetic conformity. Signatures trees include Yellow Elder, Tibouchina Granulosa, and Bougainvillea. Note that signature trees do not contribute toward the total number of required perimeter trees. Signature trees must have 6 feet of clear trunk if placed within the safe-sight triangle (Chapter 7.5, Article 2, Section 5.N.). Sif!nature trees have been added. 195. Depict paver sidewalks along Federal Highway on the site plan and landscape plan, Also note on plans that sidewalks shall be Hollandstone pavers, red / charcoal color mix by Paver Systems Inc, or equal, laid in a 45 herringbone pattern to continue the design elements in place along Federal Highway (Chapter 2, Section 5.F.8.d.(2). Pavers have been designated and specified as requested. 196. Provide a typical drawing that includes the heighLand~/ material of all proposed freestanding outdoor lighting poles. The design, style, and illumination level shall be compatible with the building design (height) and shall ,consider safety, function, and aesthetic value (Chapter 9, Section IO.F.1.). See detail sheet Ai.05. 197. Show proposed freestanding site lighting locations on the site plan and landscape plan (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA.). Lighting depicted. Lif!htinf! is NOT shown since we did not receive photometries in time. 198, Staff recommends incorporating an upgraded Palm Tran bus stop shelter into the design of the project along Federal Highway. Coordinate with Palm . Tran and provide a written response at the TART meeting. In addition, please include an architectural detail of proposed bus shelter on plans. See note Ai,Oi WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. 'V v v v L./ v CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST,LUClE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 38 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 199. Staff recommends the submittal of a master sign program as part of this site plan process to encourage continuity for signage, while allowing for flexibility with respect to type, color, and design of signs. A complete sif!naf!e Criteria Packaf!e shall be submitted at a later date. 200. On the building elevations indicate the cumulative area of wall signage to ensure that it complies with Chapter 21, Article 4, Section C.). In addition, indicate the sign type, letter colors and sign material (per the proposed Master Sign Program). Sign age will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 201. Be advised that a Publix sign may not be allowed on the parking structure as depicted in the elevations (Ph 1A East). A Publix wall sign is allowed on the building wall of Publix store, and shall not extend above the parapet of the building or beyond the building comers. The maximum sign area for Publix is 1.S sf of area for each one (1) foot of linear frontage. There may be some flexibility with the Master Sign Program details to allow a Publix sign as shown on Ph 1 A East, but not at the height depicted on the west elevation. Si~na~e will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 202. On site plan, the size of the two (2) proposed freestanding monument signs differs, yet the typical sign detail provided on sheet A1.04 appears to apply to both signs. Then there is a separate detail of an entry monument sign on H7 of 7. Please clarify by providing all signage details in one location on plans, and by noting which sign detail applies to which right-of-way. Si~na~e will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 203. Revise sign elevations to clearly identify the proposed sign area with new name of development and show the site address at the top of the monument sign (Chapter 21, Article 4, Section 5,B.). Also provide materials and colors of sign structure, sign face, and font on sign details. Si~na~e will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 204. Show the locations of fire hydrants and utility poles on all plans. ---.... -." Water and sewer utilities are on landscape plans. Fire hydrants are depicted on the plans. 20S. Revise building elevations (Ph lIA West) to provide architectural enhancements (faux features) or artistic components (mural, etc.) to west side of Publix building, and provide varying levels of landscaping up to a minimum of Y2 the building height. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P,A. v v v v v v v~ CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 39 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I Acknowledged. 206. Revise massing plan to match other plans, Clarify if plan is showing upper building levels, building footprints, etc. by labeling. V Corrected. 207. Recreational amenities for 576 dwelling units are located solely in Ph ill on fourth level of parking garage. There will be no recreational amenities available for the 126 units in Ph IA (until completion of next Ph ill). Revise plans to provide recreation throughout the development that is more available ~ to units in other phases. Staff recommends revising the other two parking ~/ garages to provide similar recreational amenities for units wrapped around those garages. p ~'l. tl.. -s.e.. I H <f-- {70 +0 ~~ ( . ) e..) AJS+rl.t t::+[ elf 0..+ <f;{lIYJ-'a- -{;.F'1 k~ The recreational facilities is sized for the entire project and be provide as part of ~ Phase 1. 208. Ph IA grade level parking has a parallel parking space designated as a handicap space. Revise location of this space V- Corrected. 209. Clarify lines for parking spaces in garages, and draw all spaces to scale. ~ All spaces are drawn to scale and are 9' x 18' min clear, HC spaces are 12' x 18' V , wi 5' access aisle clear. 210, Check parking counts for each floor plan of each garage in each phase and ensure that parking provided breakdown and totals on tabular (sheet Al.01) match. V Acknowledf?ed. 211. Provide a plan which shows pedestrian connections and pedestrian circulation, walkway widths, and plazas. . V See sheet Al,04. 212. Provide typical parking garage structure details which indicate architectural treatment and decorative features for all proposed parking structures. The parking structures are within the bldg footprints, all the exposed wall areas \../"' are depicted in the elevation sheets. 213. Include details on plans of fountains proposed in north and south OQ.,mmons, V WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT S1. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 40 [ DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT [ I Fountain details not yet provided. I I I eRA STAFF Comments: 214. Add shared parking calculations to site plan. Calculations noted. 215. Application for height exception needed. A request Jor a height exception is enclosed with this resubmittal, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH .. '1' I Ruden ~~ McClosky 200 EAST BROWARD BOULEVARD SUITE 1500 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33301 POST OFFICE BOX 1900 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA 33302 (954) 527-2476 FAX: (954) 333-4076 BONNIE,MISKEL@RUDEN,COM October 11, 2006 To: and Ed Breese TART Members Bonnie Miskel, Esq. ~ From: RE: NWSP 06-021 Ellipse / Sunshine Square We look forward to meeting with TART on October 17th, Revised plans and materials have been compiled to address the 1 st Review Comments issued September 15, 2006, More specifically, the following changes or clarifications have been provided: I DEP ARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: L Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742- 6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10- 26 (a). Acknowledged. 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is ten (10) feet (inside dimension including gates). (LDR, Chapter 7,5, Article II, Section 5.J. and Article III, section 9,A,9,a,) Acknowledged. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, PA CARACAS' FT, lAUDERDAlE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST,lUClE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 2 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT A minimum overhead clearance of 14 feet is noted on the Site Plan for the dumpster/compactor areas in Phases lA, ill, and IIB. No clearance is noted for Phase llA. Fourteen (14) feet of clearance will allow Solid Waste and FireIRescue to use the ground level of the three noted buildings. It is not sufficient for the overhead pick-up required for dumpsters or "raised bed" conventional pick-up of compactors. Indicate exact method of trash pick-up that does use these methods. All phases shall have 14' clearances, 3. Provide a minimum turning radius of 60 feet to approach dumpsters. Provide a minimum backing clearance of 60 feet (measured from the front edge of the dumpster pad.) (LDR, Chapter 2, Section II.J.2.b.) Acknowled~ed. PUBLIC WORKS - Traffic Comments: 4. Provide a traffic analysis and notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic study shall include an evaluation of the need for an additional right turn lane (eastbound to southbound) on Woolbright Road using proposed generation rates (pre- and post-development.) Our team is currently working with Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering regarding the traffic impacts associated with the proposed re-development of the Sunshine Square shopping center. We are awaiting the results of additional traffic analyses being performed by Kimley-Horn along Woolbright Road, from us 1 to the FEC railroad, including the proposed Ellipse project, the proposed Epoch development located on the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and US 1, and the proposed relocation of the traffic signal located on Woolbright Road, just east of the FEC railroad, to a more central location (between the railroad and US 1), as requested by the City of Boynton Beach. The results of the Kimley-Horn analysis will be incorporated into our final traffic study for this project and submitted to Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering for final review. The final traffic study will include an evaluation of an eastbound right-turn lane at the Woolbright Road access driveway. The subject WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. fT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH . Page 3 DEPARTMENTS auxiliary lane has been incorporated in the site plan for the project. 5. Dedicate right-of-way as necessary should a right turn lane be warranted in the future, Consider growth in background traffic for the year 2020. Also, coordinate the design and construction of all traffic improvements necessary to support this development with the developer of the Las Ventanas site on the northwest comer of Federal Highway and Woolbright Road, Provide written proof of this cooperation to the City, A meeting was held with the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) regarding the access driveways along Federal Highway (a state roadway). The FDOT will require the construction of a southbound right-turn lane on Federal Highway at the main project entrance as part of the driveway permit process. The site plan reflects the implementation of a southbound right-turn lane at the Federal Highway access driveway, The Ellipse development team has been coordinating all improvements along Woolbright Road, between the FEC railroad and US 1, with Palm Beach County, Epoch (Las Ventanas), and the City of Boynton Beach. A joint meeting was held between all parties on September 1, 2006 at Palm Beach County's Traffic Engineering Department (see attached sign-in sheet). 6, Show loading areas on the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans; include a pavement message in yellow indicating "No Parking - Loading Zone". See City Standard Drawings "K" Series for striping detail. The loadinK zones have been identified. 7. Provide Fire Lanes in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section B.2 and Section M. Fire Lanes have been added, 8. Sheet C6 of 12 of the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans incorrectly references Broward County standards. Please correct to specify City of Boynton Beach and Palm Beach County standards. The sheet has been corrected. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P,A. INCLUDE RE~ CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST,LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 4 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I PUBLIC WORKS-Forestry Comments: 9. The Landscape plan included with this submittal is incomplete. A complete review cannot be made at this time. The Landscape Plan has been substantially completed since the last submittal on 8/4/06, 10. Show sight triangles on the Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.H.) Reference FDOT Standard Index 546 for the sight triangles along both Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. Sight triangles in the interior of the development shall be 15-feet. Site triangles and FDOT sight lines have been added to the Landscape Plans. 11, The medians on Federal Highway have existing irrigation and plant material belonging to the City of Boynton Beach, Any damage to the irrigation system and/or plant material as a result of the contractor's operations shall be repaired or replaced to the equivalent or better grade, as approved by the City of Boynton Beach, and shall be the sole responsibility of the developer. The contractor shall notify and coordinate with the City of Boynton Beach Forestry & Grounds Division of Public Works a minimum of six (6) weeks in advance of any underground activities. Please acknowledge this notice in your comments response and add a note to the appropriate plan sheets with the above stated information. A cknowledKed. 12. Per the LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2, Ficus species are not permitted. Ficus species have been removedfrom the Landscape Plans. UTILITIES Comments: WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, PA CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page S DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 13. Please provide a time line that clearly illustrates when water and sewer services will be required to serve the proposed project. Your starting date for the timeline should be the date of City Commission approval. Also provide milestone dates for permit application, the start of construction, and the setting of the first water meter. This time line will be used to determine the adequacy of water and wastewater treatment capacity for your project upon the project's completion, so please be as accurate as possible. City Commission approval is expected in April 2007, Water and sewer permit application is expected to occur March 2007. Construction is expected to begin June 2007, First water meter settin$! is expected in June 2008, 14. All utility easements shall be shown on the Site plan, Landscape, and Hardscape plans (as well as the Water and Sewer Plans) so that we may determine which appurtenances, trees or shrubbery may interfere with utilities. In general, palm trees will be the only tree species allowed within utility easements. All easements are depicted on the Landscape Plans and all canopy trees have been removed from within them, if necessary. 15. Canopy trees may be planted outside of the easement so that roots and branches will not impact those utilities within the easement in the foreseeable future. The LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article I, Section 18.1 gives public utilities the authority to remove any trees that interfere with utility services, either in utility easements or public rights-of-way, Acknowledged. 16. Palm Beach County Health Department permits will be required for the water and sewer systems serving this project (CODE, Section 26-12). Acknowledged. AcknowleRed. 17. Fire flow calculations will be required demonstrating the City Code requirement of I,SOO g,p,m, (SOO g.p.m. some residential developments) with 20 p.s.i. residual pressure as stated in the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16, or the requirement imposed by insurance underwriters, whichever is greater (CODE, Section 26-16(b)), Please see attached calculations, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE' SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 6 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 18. The LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16 requires that all points on each building will be within 200 feet of an existing or proposed fire hydrant. Please demonstrate that the plan meets this condition, by showing all hydrants. The northernmost eastern building, the easternmost northern building, the middle of the northernmost western building, a small portion of the Public supermarket, and the easternmost southern building lack sufficient coverage. Please correct. Hydrants have been relocated and two hydrants added to provide full coverage to the site, 19. The CODE, Section 26-34(E) requires that a capacity reservation fee be paid for this project either upon the request for the Department's signature on the Health Department application forms or within seven (7) days of site plan approval, whichever occurs first. This fee will be determined based upon final meter size, or expected demand. Acknowledf!ed. 20. Comprehensive Plan Policy 3.C.3.4. requires the conservation of potable water. As other sources are readily available City water shall not be allowed for irrigation. Acknowledf!ed. 21. Water and sewer lines to be owned and operated by the City shall be included within utility easements. Please show all proposed easements on the engineering drawings, using a minimum width of 12 feet. The easements shall be dedicated via separate instrument to the City as stated in CODE Sec. 26-33(a). All required easements for water and sewer, with minimum 12' width. are shown on the plans, 22, This office will not require surety for installation of the water and sewer utilities, on condition that the systems be fully completed, and given to the City Utilities Department before the first permanent meter is set. Note that setting of a permanent water meter is a prerequisite to obtaining the Certificate of Occupancy. It is expected that the system will be fully completed before the first permanent meter is set, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT,LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 7 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 23. A building permit for this project shall not be issued until this Department has approved the plans for the water and/or sewer improvements required to service this project, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-15. Acknowled~ed. 24. PVC material not permitted on the City's water system, All lines shall be DIP. All water mains will be DIP, 25. The Water & Sanitary Sewer plans reflect numerous 450 bends; please revise to read 22-1/20 bends as no 450 deflections are shown, Check all call-outs to assure they have been correctly identified. Call-outs have been checked and 22-1/2 dewee bends indicated, 26. Appropriate backflow preventer(s) will be required on the domestic water service to the building, and the fire sprinkler line if there is one, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-207. Backflow preventers will be provided on domestic and fire sprinkler lines as soon as the plumbing information are available. 27. Provide a minimum of ten (10) feet separation between water main, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer lines, Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. Ten foot separation has been provided. 28. The waste stream from any food preparation area processes must meet the City's pretreatment requirements. A sampling point must be provided to allow monitoring of this waste stream (refer to CODE Section 26-143 and Section 26-147,) Food preparation areas have not been identified at this time, Pre-treatment will be provided as soon as these areas are delineated. 29. All retail buildings are indicated as being fully sprinklered, yet nothing is indicated for the live-work townhomes. Are they to be sprinklered also? All buildin~s will be sprinklered as indicated on site plan, 30. All multi-level parking structures (garages); are they to be sprinklered? WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 8 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I Spacing of the fire hydrants (see Comment #35) reflects several coverage gaps. All buildin1!s will be sprinklered as indicated on site plan, 31. There is an existing six (6) inch DIP water main running east to west immediately north of the existing Public supermarket, which is not addressed as to be either removed or relocated. In addition, the proposed eight (8) inch water main run in the middle of the property running north-south direction is shown as connecting to an existing six (6) inch line along the north side of SE 18th Avenue. This is not acceptable, This project will be required to develop a Hardy-Cross analysis of the project site and the surrounding area to determine which external links will need to be upgraded to support this development. The existing 6" line north of Publix will be abandoned. Although our analysis of the water system shows that no external upgrades are required on external links, we are contemplating upgrades to the 6" line to 8" at Woolbright and S.E. 18th Avenue adjacent to the site to comvlv with the Utilitv Master Plan, 32, Up size the water main in Woolbright Road to meet the requirements of the Utility Master Plan. The main shall be upsized from the west side of the FECRR east to the point of connection (west driveway) for the project. Consideration is been given to upsizing the existing line from east of the railroad tracks-east to the driveway entrance. 33, Coordinate with Boynton Beach Fire-Rescue to determine flow requirements for multi-story buildings over four stories. Acknowled1!ed. 34. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article N, Section 3(0) requires Master Plans to show all utilities on or adjacent to the proposed tract. The plan must therefore show the point of service for water and sewer, and the proposed off-site utilities construction needed in order to service this project. Proposed off-site utilities construction are shown and point of services are also shown. 35, The LDR, Chapter 3, Article N, Section 3(P) requires a statement be included that utilities are available and will be provided by all other appropriate agencies. This statement is lacking on the submitted plans. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST,LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 9 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I Note added on site plan Ai.Oi. 36. Utility construction details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All utility construction details shall be in accordance with the Utilities Department's "Utilities Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" manual (including any updates) and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application, AcknowledS{ed. ENGINEERING Comments: 37. Add a note to the Site Plan stating "All plans submitted for specific permits shall meet the City's Code requirements at time of application, These permits include, but are not limited to, the following: paving, drainage, curbing, site lighting, landscaping and irrigation. Permits required from other permitting agencies such as Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), Lake Worth Drainage District (L WDD), Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), Palm Beach County Health Department (PBCHD), Palm Beach County Engineering Department (PBCED), Palm Beach County Department of Environmental Resource Management (PBCDERM) and any others, shall be included with the permit request." Note added on site plan Ai.Oi 38. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. Acknowledged. 39. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments, Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. Acknowledged. Acknowled~ed. 40. Upon satisfactory Commission approval of the site plan, the applicant shall enter the plat process through the City's Engineering Division. A preliminary plat application may be initiated during the site plan review to expedite WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A, CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT Sf. LUCIE. SARASOTA. Sf. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 10 DEPARTMENTS issuance of the Land Development Permit. A plat will be required for this development. INCLUDE REJECT Acknowledged. Acknowled~ed. 41, Provide written and graphic scales on all sheets. The scale shall match between all sheets depicting the site (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7 .B.l, 7 .C.l, and 7.F ,1. If desired a "master" sheet may be provided for each section with enlargements provided for additional detail on subsequent sheets. Acknowledged. Acknowledged. 42. Show proposed site lighting on the Site, all Civil and Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.4.) The lighting design shall provide a minimum average light level of one foot-candle. On the Lighting Plan, specify that the light poles shall withstand a 140 MPH wind load (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section ALa and Florida Building Code). Provide a note that the fixtures shall be operated by photoelectrical control and are to remain on until 2:00 a.m. (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.l.a.) Include pole wind loading, and pole details in conformance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article N, Section 11, Chapter 23, Article I, Section 5.B.7 and Chapter 23, Article II, Section A on the Lighting Plan. Lighting shall not be used as a form of advertising in a manner that draws more attention to the building or grounds at night than in the day (LDR, Chapter 9, Section 10.F.5). Provide photometrics as part of your TART plan submittals. To be provided at a later date. Light Poles shall be depicted on Landscape Plans and all trees shall adhere to minimum distance requirements. 43. The minimum size for a 900 parking stall is 9 feet x 18 feet and for 00 (parallel) parking is 9 feet x 25 feet. (Engineering Design Standard Drawing K-2,) Please correct the detail shown on Sheet C3 of 12 and on the plans, The sheet has been corrected. 44, Provide a minimum ten (10) feet clearance between water, sanitary sewer and/or storm sewer. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. Tenfoot clearance has been provided. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, lAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST, lUCIE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TAllAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 11 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 45. The minimum diameter for a storm sewer is 15 inches (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A2.a.) Please correct plans accordingly. The plans have been corrected. 46. Lengths of perforated and non-perforated pipe do not appear to have been called out correctly on the Paving, Grading & Drainage plans (Sheets C2 and C3.) Please correct. The plans have been corrected, 47. Provide an engineer's certification on the Drainage Plan as specified in LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2. The engineer's certification has been added. 48. Indicate by note that catch basin and manhole covers shall be bicycle proof (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A2.g), The note has been added. 49. Specify storm sewer diameters, inlets types, etc, on drainage plan. Indicate grate, rim and invert elevations for all structures. Indicate grade of storm sewer segments. Indicate material specifications for storm sewer. The information has been provided. 50, Full drainage plans, including drainage calculations, in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5 will be required at the time of permitting, The draina~e calculations have been provided. 51, Paving, drainage and site details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All engineering construction details shall be in accordance with the applicable City of Boynton Beach Standard Drawings and the "Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. Acknowledged. FIRE Comments: All Fire comments are acknowled~ed. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. S1. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 12 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 52. All entrance gates to construction area shall have a Knox lock system that will also open in case of electrical power failure. All gates shall be a minimum of 20 feet wide if two lanes, and 12 feet wide if single lane. Fire Department apparatus shall be able to turn into the construction site in one turn. Fire Department entry through locked gates shall be by Knox Locks. Acknowled~ed. 53. The construction site access roads shall be maintained free of obstructions at all times. Acknowledged. 54. All required fire hydrants, standpipes or sprinkler systems shall be in place before going vertical. Vertical construction shall be protected by standpipes and the sprinkler system to one level below the highest level of construction throughout the building. Acknowledged. 55. Any cost of damage to Fire Department vehicles because of improperly stabilized roads or any towing fees if a vehicle becomes stuck will be the responsibility of the contractor. A minimum of 32 tons is required for ground stabilization. The pouring of the foundation pad is considered vertical construction. The roads must be acceptable before construction begins. Acknoled~ed. 56. Adequate Fire Department vehicle turn around space shall be provided in the construction area. Acknowled~ed, 57. Provide the fire hydrant layout for this project with the hydrants clearly shown on one sheet. Show all water supply lines for fire protection and hydraulic calculations using data from a flow test conducted within the past six months, This test will be conducted by the Boynton Beach Fire Department. Acknowledged. The Boynton Beach Fire Department test and the hydraulic calculations have been provided with this submittal. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 13 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 58. Sprinkler systems installed in commercial businesses shall be in accordance with NFPA 13, All residential systems shall conform to NFPA 13R. A cknowledf!ed. 59. Buildings that exceed 75 feet in height, measured from the point of lowest entry to the bottom of the highest floor that can be occupied, shall be equipped with a Rescue Air Breathing system. All upper floor slabs are below 75', POLICE Comments: All Police comments are acknowledged. 61. Construction Site Approval: The Staff recommends that prior to issuance of the first building permit, the applicant shall prepare a construction site security and management plan for approval by the City's Police Department CPTED Official. The developer/project manager after site clearing and placement of construction trailers shall institute security measures to reduce or eliminate opportunities for theft. The management plan shall include, but not be limited to, temporary lighting, security personnel, vehicle barriers, construction/visitor pass, reduce/minimize entry/exit points, encourage subcontractors to secure machinery, tools at end of work day and/or any other measure deemed appropriate to provide a safe and secure working environment. The security management plan shall be maintained throughout the construction phase of the project. Acknowledged. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 14 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 62. Parkin!! Gara!!e Parking garages are high priority security areas. Parking garages comprise a large area with relatively low levels of activity; the vulnerability to potential activity can be high risk. With this in mind the Police Department makes the following recommendations: a. Should adhere to the IESNA (Illuminating Engineering Society of North America) standards for garages. b. Design should incorporate both vertical and horizontal luminance. c. Lighting should extend into parking stalls and over vehicles rather than just into driving aisles. d. The exterior of garage should be well lighted on all sides. e. Metal Halide lighting shall be used. f. Position light fixtures to minimize glare to drivers and enhance depth perception. g. The parking garage should be designed to minimize solid walls which will assist in improving natural surveillance. Wrought iron fencing instead of solid walls would be ideal and preferable. h. First level of parking garage should have restricted access from exterior common ground area. A barrier protection will prevent open access to the first floor by unwanted persons. The exterior walls surrounding the first floor parking should be at least three to four feet high with decorative screening in place between the top of the wall and the flooring of the second parking level. The screening would discourage anyone from entering the facility on foot, yet maintain openness and natural surveillance. The lower levels of the garages service the commercial uses, public access is required and desired, security shall be accomplished by surveillance camera and lighting systems. L Any ground level pedestrian exits that open into non-secure areas should be emergency exits only and fitted with panic bar hardware, J. The two ingress and egress points to the parking garage should have raised crossed walks, subject to review by the Fire Department and City Engineering, k. Ceilings should be painted or stained white to significantly enhance the illumination and aid in reducing shadows within the facility. 1. Careful placement of signs and graphics indicating exits, stairs, and elevators should be painted or placed on walls to help orient patrons and allow for quick movement in and out of parking garage, m. The parking garage elevator should be designed to permit any individual in the elevator to have a clear and unobstructed view of the immediate surroundings and be seen from outside the elevator. The doors and two sides of the elevator shall have glass walls. The elevator should be equipped with emergency communication and not be equipped with stop button. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 15 DEPARTMENTS n. The stairwell towers should be of an open design with open metal handrails and steps. 0, For potential criminal activity detection, install a high resolution color digital video system consisting of low lux cameras, with monitoring and photo processing picture or video printout capabilities, shall be installed. p. Surveillance should be strategically placed at locations like ingress/egress points, elevators, and stairwells and on each floor of the facility. The monitoring and control of surveillance system should be at a central monitoring office or other designated location, It should be posted at all access points (pedestrian/vehicular) that the facility IS under video surveillance. o. Install convex mirrors in stairwell and elevator areas, INCLUDE REJECT Acknowledged. 63. Residential: The Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: a. Landscaping should not obstruct view of windows, building address numbers, and walkways. Acknowledged. b. Numerical Address: · Needs to be illuminated for nighttime visibility. · Must have bi-directional visibility from the roadway. · Building numbers for multi-unit buildings need to be a minimum of 12" and placed on the front and rear of the building in a conspicuous location away from landscaping. c. Mail boxes for multi-units should be placed in a high activity and conspicuous location for enhanced safety and natural surveillance of users. d, Stairways (to include riserlbanister) and balconies shall provide open views. e. Sales center, clubhouse and recreational facilities should be pre-wired for alarm systems. f. Restrict access to recreation buildings and pools through the use of key card or key. g. When placing the order for a front door that will have a side pane window it should be placed on the opposite side of the door handle and lock making them unreachable, This would not apply to customized doors. h, If front door has zero visibility to front entryway area, equip it with a 180- degree peephole. 1. Equip all exterior doors with security hinges. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 16 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 64. Commercial: The Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: Landscaping should not obstruct view from doors, windows or walkways. a. All perimeter doors should be equipped with reinforced, case hardened strike plate. b, Rear door shall have 180- degree peephole or security window. c. Delivery doors/bays should be secured with locks and alarm system. d. Directories shall be placed at the ingress points and strategically place directories with arrow indicators for buildings throughout the property at vehicle driver slight level. e, Bicycle Racks shall be installed near building entrances or in close proximity to buildings. Not in parking lots. AcknowledS{ed, 65. Li2htin2: The Staff recommends the following as a condition of approval: a. Landscaping shall not conflict with lighting (to include long-term tree canopy growth). Acknowledged. b. Building lighting (non- glare) should be around perimeter of all sides and on pedestrian sidewalk. c. Provide timer clock or photocell sensor engaged lighting for above or near entryways to residences and commercial buildings and all pedestrian sidewalks, Acknowledged. BUILDING DIVISION Comments: 66, Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the TART (Technical Advisory Review Team) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the commission and at permit review, AcknowledS{ed. 67. Indicate within the site data the occupancy type of each building as defined in 2004 FBC, Chapter 3, Indicate all occupancies in mixed occupancy buildings, All occupancies are indicated in the site data AI,OI, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST,LUClE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 17 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 68. The height and area for buildings or structures of the different types of construction shall be governed by the intended use or occupancy of the building, and shall not exceed the limits set forth in Table 503 of the 2004 FBC. Acknowled~ed. 69. Place a note on the elevation view drawings indicating that the exterior wall openings and exterior wall construction comply with 2004 FBC, Table 704.8, Submit calculations that clearly reflect the percentage of protected and unprotected wall openings permitted per 2004 FBC, Table 704,8. Note added on elevation sheets. 70. General area modifications to buildings shall be in accordance with 2004 FBC, Section 506. Provide calculations verifying compliance with the above code sections and the 2004 FBC, Table 503. Acknowledf{ed. 71. Buildings, structures and parts thereof shall be designed to withstand the minimum wind loads of 140 mph. Wind forces on every building or structure shall be determined by the provisions of ASCE 7, Chapter 6, and the provisions of 2004 FBC, Section 1609 (Wind Loads). Calculations that are signed and sealed by a design professional registered in the state of Florida shall be submitted for review at the time of permit application. Acknowledged. 72, Every building and structure shall be of sufficient strength to support the loads and forces encountered per the 2004 FBC, Section 1607 and Table 1607,1, Indicate the live load (pst) on the plans for the building design, To be provided on bld~ permit plans. 73. Buildings three-stories or higher shall be equipped with an automatic sprinkler system per F,S. 553.895. Fire protection plans and hydraulic calculations shall be included with the building plans at the time of permit application, All buildings shall be sprinklered, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT,lAUDERDAlE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST,lUClE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG' TAllAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 18 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 74, Add to all plan view drawings of the site a labeled symbol that represents the location and perimeter of the limits of construction proposed with the subject request. See submitted plans. 75, At time of permit review, submit signed and sealed working drawings of the proposed construction. AcknowledKed. 76. On the site plan and floor plan, indicate the number of stories that are in each building, Indicate the overall height of each building, See site plan Al,Ol. 77, Add to each building that is depicted on the drawing titled site plan and floor plan a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building. 2004 FBC, Sections 11-4.1.2, 11-4.1.3, and 11-4,3, All ADA and FFHA requirements shall be provided, see note Al,Ol. 78. As required by LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7, submit a floor plan drawing. The building plans are not being reviewed for compliance with the applicable building codes. Therefore, add the words "Floor plan layout is conceptual" below the drawing titled Floor Plan found on sheet/s _. However, add to the floor space drawing a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building, The location of the door shall match the location of the accessible entrance doors that are depicted on the site plan drawing. AcknowledKed. See above, 79, Compliance with regulations specified in the FFHA, Design and Construction Requirements, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.20S, is required. AcknowledKed. 80, At the time of permit review, submit details of reinforcement of walls for the future installation of grab bars as required by the FFHA, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.20S, Section 3, Requirement #6. All bathrooms within the covered dwelling unit shall comply. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE' SARASOTA' S1. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 19 DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I Acknowled~ed. 81. Bathrooms and kitchens in the covered dwelling units shall comply with the FFHA, Title 24 CFR 100,20S, Indicate on the plans which design specification ("A" or "B") of the FFHA is being used. The clear floor space at fixtures and appliances and turning diameters shall be clearly shown on the plans. Acknowled~ed, 82, If an accessible route has less than 60 inches clear width, then passing spaces at least 60 inches by 60 inches shall be located at reasonable intervals not to exceed 200 feet. A "T" -intersection of two corridors or walks is an acceptable passing place. 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.3.4, Acknowled~ed. 83. Identify within the site data the finish floor elevation (lowest floor elevation) that is proposed for the building. Verify that the proposed elevation is in compliance with regulations of the code by adding specifications to the site data that address the following issues: a. The design professional-of-record for the project shall add the following text to the site data. "The proposed finish floor elevation _' _ NGVD is above the highest 100-year base flood elevation applicable to the building site, as determined by the SFWMD's surface water management construction development regulations." b. From the FIRM map, identify in the site data the title of the flood zone that the building is located within. Where applicable, specify the base flood elevation. If there is no base flood elevation, indicate that on the plans. c. Identify the floor elevation that the design professional has established for the building within the footprint of the building that is shown on the drawings titled site plan, floor plan and paving/drainage (civil plans). See note on site plan Al,Ol, 84. As required by the CBBCO, Part III titled "Land Development Regulations", submit a site plan that clearly depicts the setback dimensions from each property line to the leading edge of the buildings. The leading edge of the buildings begins at the closest point of the overhang or canopy to the property line. In addition, show the distance between all the buildings on all sides. See site plan Al,Ol, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P,A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.lUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 20 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 85. CBBCPP 3.C.3.4 requires the conservation of potable water, City water may not, therefore, be used for landscape irrigation where other sources are readily available. Acknowledged. 86. A water-use permit from SFWMD is required for an irrigation system that utilizes water from a well or body of water as its source. A copy of the permit shall be submitted at the time of permit application, F.S. 373.216. Acknowled~ed. 87. If capital facility fees (water and sewer) are paid in advance to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department, the following information shall be provided at the time of building permit application: a, The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. b. If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. c. The number of dwelling units in each building. d. The number of bedrooms in each dwelling unit. e. The total amount paid and itemized into how much is for water and how much is for sewer. (CBBCO, Chapter 26, Article II, Sections 26-34) Acknowled~ed. 88. At time of permit review, submit separate surveys of each lot, parcel, or tract. For purposes of setting up property and ownership in the City computer, provide a copy of the recorded deed for each lot, parcel, or tract. The recorded deed shall be submitted at time of permit review, Acknowled~ed. 89. At time of building permit application, submit verification that the City of Boynton Beach Parks and Recreation Impact Fee requirements have been satisfied by a paid fee or conveyance of property. The following information shall be provided: a, A legal description of the land. b. The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. c. If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A, CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE . MIAMI . NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURG . TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 21 DEPARTMENTS provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. d. The number of dwelling units in each building. e. The total amount being paid, (CBBCO, Chapter I, Article V, Section 3(f)) INCLUDE REJECT Acknowled~ed. 90. Add a general note to the site plan that all plans submitted for permitting shall meet the City's codes and the applicable building codes in effect at the time of permit application, See note on site plan Al,Ol, 91. Pursuant to approval by the City Commission and all other outside agencies, the plans for this project must be submitted to the Building Division for review at the time of permit application submittal. The plans must incorporate all the conditions of approval as listed in the development order and approved by the City Commission. See note on site plan Al,Ol, 92. The full address of the project shall be submitted with the construction documents at the time of permit application submittal. The addressing plan shall be approved by the United States Post Office, the City of Boynton Beach Fire Department, the City's GIS Division, and the Palm Beach County Emergency 911. (Palm Beach County Planning, Zoning & Building Division, 100 Australian Avenue, West Palm Beach, Florida (Sean McDonald - 561- 233-5013) (United States Post Office, Boynton Beach (Michelle Bullard - 561-734-0872) Acknowledged. 93. Show the proposed site lighting on the site and landscape plans. (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA) If possible, provide photo metrics as part of your TART plan submittals. To be submitted at a later date, 94. Add to the floor plan drawings of the individual units a breakdown of the area within the unit. The area breakdowns for each unit shall specify the total area of the unit, area of the balcony, total area that is air-conditioned and, where applicable, total area of storage and garage space. If the garage and storage areas are not part of a specific unit, the area shall be included and identified WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P,A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST, LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 22 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT within the area of the building, Indicate how many of each type of unit will be on each floor and within the building. See site Tabulations AI.OI & AI,02 95. Add to the site data the total area under roof of each residential building. Provide tabular area data for each floor of each building. The breakdown shall include the following areas and each area shall be labeled on the applicable floor plan drawing: a. Common area covered walkways; b. Covered stairways; c. Common area balconies; d. Entrance area outside of a unit; e. Storage areas (not part of a unit); f. Garages (not part of a unit); g. Elevator room; h. Electrical room; 1. Mechanical room; J. Trash room; k. Mailbox pickup and delivery area; and 1. Any other area under roof. (Chapter 4 - Site Plan Review, Section 7.E.2 and 3) See site Tabulations AI.OI & AI,02 96. This structure meets the definition of a threshold building per F.S. 553.71(7) and shall comply with the requirements of F.S. 553.79 and the CBBA to the 2004 FBC, Sections 109,3.6.1 through 109.3.6.6. The following information must be submitted at the time of permit application: a, The structural inspection plan must be submitted to the enforcing agency prior to the issuance of a building permit for the construction of a threshold building, b. All shoring and re-shoring procedures, plans and details shall be submitted. c. All plans for the building that are required to be signed and sealed by the architect or engineers of record shall contain a statement that, to the best of the architect's or engineer's knowledge, the plans and specifications comply with the applicable fire safety standards as determined by the local authority in accordance with this section and F.S. Section 633. Acknowledged. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT ST,LUClE . SARASOTA' ST, PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 23 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 97. If this project is located within the Downtown Stormwater Improvement Watershed, appropriate fees must be paid to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department prior to the issuance of a building permit per the CBBCO, Chapter 26, Section 26-406. Proof of payment shall be submitted to the Building Division at the time of permit application submittal. Acknowledf,(ed. 98. Indicate on the plans the square footage per floor of the parking garages. Comply with the area and height requirements of 2004 FBC, Table 503. See tabulations AI.OI, all buildings shall comply with FBe 2004 allowable areas for Type IB, 99. A Mechanical ventilation system is required in the parking garages per the 2004 FBC, Section 406.4.2. Acknowledged. 100. The passenger loading zone for the CRA trolley shall comply with the handicap accessibility requirements of the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.1.2( c). Acknowledged. 101. Sheet A2,Ol lID - Phase lID Parking Garage- Relocate one of the hadicalp parking spaces to the north side of the garage, Handicap parking spaces shall be locted per the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.6.2. There exists a handicap space on each floor at the north side of the garage. 102. Van accessible parking spaces shall be provided in the parking strurctures per the 2004 FBC, Sect6ion 11-4.6.2. Van accessible spaces are shown in all buildings structures, 103. Location of exits in residential buildings shall comply with the 2004 FBC, Section 1015.1 and Table 1015.1 for exit access travel distance. Acknowledf,(ed. 104. Indicate the overall height of the buildings on the elevation plans. See elevations, 105. The buildings shall comply with 2004 FBC, Section 403 for high-rise buildings, All upper floor slabs are below 75', These are not 'hi-rise' bldgs, WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TAllAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 24 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 106. Indicate the occupancy type and type of construction for the residential buildings. See site plan Al,Ol, 107. Sheet A2,04 IB - The floor plan does not depict all rooms, corridors, stair enclosures, etc, Corrected. PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: 108. The landscape plan IS incomplete. Quantities and speCIes are not indicated on the call outs on the plan. Quantities are not shown on the plant list. Landscape Plans have been updated to include all quantities and species. 109, Native species should be identified on the plant list Native species have been indicated on Plat List, 110. The Ficus family can not be used in Boynton Beach. All Ficus species have been removed. 111. Irrigation should have 110% coverage, be from a non-potable water source, have separate bubblers for each tree, and have separate zones for sod and bed areas, Acknowledf4ed. FORESTER/ENVIRONMENT ALIST Comments: 112. Boundary Survey, Existing Trees Management Plan Sheet 1 of 1: The Landscape Architect should tabulate the total diameter inches of existing trees on the site, The tabular data should show the individual species of trees proposed to be preserved in place, relocated or removed and replaced on site. The replacement trees should be shown by a separate symbol on the WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS' FT, LAUDERDALE' MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT S1. LUCIE' SARASOTA' S1. PETERSBURG' TALLAHASSEE' TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH Page 25 DEPARTMENTS landscape plan sheet LND5 of 5. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article I Sec. 7.D.p. 2.] A set of Tree Mitigation plans has been added to the plan set depicting the existing trees on site by species, caliper inch, condition and disposition (Remove/Remain/Relocate), Refer to sheets T1 thru n. 113, Plant Palette Legend Sheet LND5 of 5: All shade and palm trees must be listed in the description as a minimum of 12'-14' height, 3" DBH (4.5' off the ground) not caliper, and Florida #1 (Florida Grades and Standards manual). The height of the trees may be larger than 12'-14' to meet the 3" diameter requirement; or any clear trunk (c.t.) specifications. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec, 5.C. 2.] Plant Palette legend contains the required information and svecifications. 114, The landscape design does not include the City signature trees (Tibochina granulosa) at the ingress / egress areas to the site. These trees must meet the minimum size specifications for trees, [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7,5, Article II Sec. 5,C.3,N,] The City Sif{nature Tree(s) has been added to all main entrances of the vro;ect, 115. All trees proposed under any existing overhead electric power lines must meet the FP & L Right Tree in the Right Place manual selection for small trees only. A cknowledzed. 116, The landscape sheet shade tree planting detail should including a line indicating where the diameter and height of all of the trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection, Dimensions have been added to the detail as requested and required. 117. The landscape sheet palm tree planting detail should include a line indicating where the height of all of the palm trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. Dimensions have been added to the detail as requested and required. 118. The landscape sheet shrub and groundcover planting detail should include a line indicating where the height and spread of the shrubs and groundcover plants will be measured at time of planting and inspection. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. I INCLUDE I REJECT I CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT S1. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST, PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 26 DEP ARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT Dimensions have been added to the detail as requested and required 119, The applicant should add a note that all utility boxes or structures (not currently known or shown on the plan) should be screened with Coco plum hedge plants on three sides. The landscape sheet details indicating use of soil amendments for each of the plantings should indicate structural soil for all planting areas on the site. The total quantity of required structural soil should be added to the plant palette legend. A note has been added to all Landscape Plan sheets. 120. The applicant should show an elevation cross-section detail of the actual heights of the proposed landscape trees and vegetation at the time of planting to (proper scale) visually buffer the proposed buildings and parking lot from the Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and S.E. 18th Avenue road rights-of- ways, A cross section shall be provided as requested. 121. Many of the landscape symbols are mIssmg the speCIes number or identification letters on the landscape sheets. Symbols and quantities have been added to all sheets. 122. The total quantities of each of the plant materials are not shown in the legend. Total quantities have been added to the legend. 123, Irrigation Plan: Turf and landscape (bedding plants) areas should be designed on separate zones and time duration for water conservation. Acknowled~ed. 124. Trees should have separate irrigation bubblers to provide water directly to the root ball. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5. C.2.] Acknowledged. PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST,LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 27 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE K "".1 "".l .1 125. At the technical advisory review team (TART) meeting, provide written responses to all staffs comments and questions. Submit 12 sets of revised plans. Each set should be folded and stapled. Acknowled~ed. 126. At the technical advisory review team meeting, also provide a full set of reduced drawings, sized 8Yz inches by 11 inches of each plan. Save each plan to a compact disk and submit that to staff as well. Acknowledged. 127. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. Acknowledged. 128. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. Acknowledged. 129. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon the approval of the corresponding request (LUAR 06-016) to amend the future land use designation from Local Retail Commercial (LRC) to Mixed Use (MX) and to rezone from Community Commercial (C-3) to Mixed Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3). Acknowledged. 130. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon submittal and approval of a corresponding request for a height exception (max building height in MU-L3 is 75 feet). Acknowledged. A request for a height exception IS included In the resubmittal package. 131. Clarify total building height on all building elevations. Measure building height as specified in definition of Building/Structure Height (Article II of Land Development Regulations). WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 28 DEP ARTMENTS See elevations and hei~ht exception request. 132. A drainage statement is required prior to the Technical Application Review Team (TART) meeting (Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2.). 133. All proposed uses and their respective building areas must match between the traffic study and the site plan. In addition, the letter from PBC Traffic dated June 21, 2006 requires a revised traffic study. The revised traffic study will be required prior to the CRA meeting (Chapter 4. Section 8.F.). Staff would prefer to have the revised traffic study by the TART meeting tentatively scheduled for October 3, 2006. Acknowled~ed. 134. Provide a notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic impact analysis must be approved by the Palm Beach County Traffic Division for concurrency purposes prior to the issuance of any building permits. Our team is currently working with Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering regarding the traffic impacts associated with the proposed re-development of the Sunshine Square shopping center. We are awaiting the results of additional traffic analyses being performed by Kimley-Horn along Woolbright Road, from us 1 to the FEC railroad, including the proposed Ellipse project, the proposed Epoch development located on the northwest corner of Woolbright Road and US 1, and the proposed relocation of the traffic signal located on Woolbright Road, just east of the FEC railroad, to a more central location (between the railroad and US 1), as requested by the City of Boynton Beach. The results of the Kimley-Horn analysis will be incorporated into our final traffic study for this project and submitted to Palm Beach County Traffic Engineeringfor final review. The final traffic study will include an evaluation of an eastbound right-turn lane at the Woolbright Road access driveway. The subject auxiliary lane has been incorporated in the site plan for the project. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. I INCLUDE I REJECT I CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG . TALLAHASSEE . TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 29 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE 135. Revise site plan application: (page 1, Section 1.1.) to include new project name; (page 2, Section II. 1.) to revise to MX land use; (page 2, Section 11.2.) to revise to MU-L3 zoning district; (page 2, Section 11.3.) to switch site area to 14.43 acres and square feet to 628,727 sf. I . 136. Revise site plan application (page 3, Section 5.e.) to include pervious area of 3.44 acres or 23.83% of site (5.h. should be total of5.e.-5.g.) 137. The site plan application (page 3, Section 11.6.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) for floor area breakdown do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed square footage for each use and to make application and plans consistent. 138. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.7.c.3-4) total 404 2- and 3+- bedrooms, and site plan tabular (A1.01) bedroom count info for required parking does not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number for each unit type / size and to make application and plans consistent. 139. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.8.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) density is 39.9168 dulac, this should be rounded to 39.92 dulac. 140. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.9.) should also include maximum number of stories proposed. 141. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.I0.a.) should clarify requirement of 14 spaces per 200 sf and what code provision this is based upon. Also each live/work unit requires 2.5 spaces per unit. 142. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.tO.b.) requires a calculation WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG . TALLAHASSEE . TAMPA . WEST PALM BEACH Page 30 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT for required number of handicap parking spaces. Modifications to application pages have been made accordin~ly 143. Submit two (2) copies of the shared parking analysis (signed and sealed by a licensed traffic engineer). 144. Provide details of shared parking analysis on site plan application (page 4, Section ILlO.) and site plan (A1.01). Acknowledged. 145. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.tO.a.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) parking counts do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number of spaces required and number of spaces provided and to make application and plans consistent. Modifications to application pages have been made to match site plan 146. Clarify that site will be developed as one parcel under a Unity of Title, or if there will be separately owned parcels under a Unity of Control. If separate parcels, provide parcel boundaries, lot dimensions, and setbacks from the lot lines. A recorded Unity of Title or Unity of Control will be required prior to the issuance of a building permit. Engineering is requiring platting - this nullifies the need for Unity of Title or Control. 147. Indicate bolder phase lines on all plans. Provide phasing information, including building square footage per use, total square footage, and parking required/provided per phase in site tabular on sheet AI. 01. See sheet A 1. 01 B for phasin~ plan, and site tabs A 1. 01. 148. Submit LLC corporate papers which name principal authorized to sign on behalf of Sunshine Square CRP, LLC. A corporate certification is enclosed. 149. Submit large (24" x 36") colored renderings (clipped not glued to foamboard) of project at the TART meeting. These will be displayed at the public hearings. Acknowledged. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 31 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 150. Submit color chips of proposed building colors noted on elevations. Acknowled~ed. 151. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the new site plan is publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04-007. Acknowledged. 152. The applicant is responsible for compliance with Ordinance 05-060, the "Art in Public Places" program, and must demonstrate their participation. Update and complete the Public Art Information Form submitted May 19, 2006. Acknowled~ed. 153. Correct zoning district (not category) in tabular site data on cover sheet A1.01 to MU-L3 (Mixed Use Low Intensity 3) and Land Use Designation is Mixed Use (MX). Corrected. 154. Revise parcels labeled as "NIC" to "Not Included". NIC is used by this office as "NOT IN CITY". Corrected. 155. On site plan and landscape plan, show as-built conditions of adjacent parcels which are not included in the project. Demonstrate how proposed structures with minimal or no setbacks and required landscaping will be maintained (including the side of Publix adjacent to the RR tracks). Foundation landscaping is required in these areas, but not provIded. Buffer areas have been provided, see site plan. Where applicable structures have been moved further off the property line where applicable (JO ') and additionallandscapWf<..has been added. 156. The review of applications for MU-L3 shall emphasize aesthetics and design quality, and physical compatibility with adjacent land uses. Demonstrate how the proposed development will tie in with gas station on corner and parcel on SE 18th Ave. through fac;ade and landscaping upgrades and connectivity. Buffer areas have been provided, see site plan. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT.lAUDERDAlE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.lUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TAllAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 32 DEPARTMENTS 157. Perimeter landscaping is required along the common property lines adjacent to the gas station and adjacent to properties fronting SE 18th Ave. Revise landscape plan to provide required perimeter/foundation landscaping in these locations. A landscape easement on adjacent property may be considered if parties agree to all terms. Buffer areas have been provided, see site plan. The existing gas station currently has existing trees and shrubs along its perimeter. Where applicable, additional landscaping has been provided. Additional landscaping has also been provided, where possible, for properties fronting SE 18th Avenue. 158. Submit a perspective view from Federal and Woolbright of Ph IA North and East elevations which includes the existing gas station to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing gas station, and to accentuate a focal point and provide for transitional possibilities (should adjacent development be acquired in the future). To be provided at a later date. 159. Submit a perspective view from Federal and SE 18th Ave of Ph ill South and East elevations which includes the existing development on parcel not included to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing development offsite, and to accentuate a focal point and provide for transitional possibilities (should adjacent development be acquired in the future). To be provided at a later date. 160. Prior to TART meeting, submit draft cross-access easements for future cross access to gas station, and a letter from gas station owner that he is willing to enter into the recorded cross access easement agreements prior to the first CO. Easements documents have been drafted, however, the gas station owner is not cooperative at this time. 161. Submit a phasing plan and construction time line which details what will be completed in each phase before starting next phase (road improvements, parking, traffic circulation, landscaping) and how existing tenants are to be relocated. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. INCLUDE REJECT CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 33 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 162. On the site plan tabular data (A1.01 and .02), indicate the maximum allowable FAR in MU-L3 district and the proposed FAR. Corrected. 163. Provide tabular parking space breakdown for residential versus nonresidential uses and number of spaces for each type. See tabs AI.OI. 164. Clarify within tabular information on plans if multifamily units will be rentals or condominium. The units will be Rentals. 165. Clarify on plan if interior streets will be private streets or public rights-of- way. If private streets, documents regarding who will maintain streets will be required. Interior streets will be private, maintenance aweements will be provided. 166. Provide graphic and written scales on all plans. Corrected. 167. Provide legible floor plans for each proposed building. Corrected. 168. The area west of Publix is shown as pervious (sod) on landscape and hardscape plans, yet the site plan shows a walkway along side of building. Please revise plans to match. Corrected, the sidewalk has been deleted. 169. Provide details of where residential parking spaces are located, and how the spaces for residential will be differentiated from the spaces for nonresidential. One space per unit shall be assigned at the upper floors of the garages. Lower decks shall be shared by residential and commercial uses. See notes AI.OI. 170. Clearly label all bearings and distances for all property lines on plans. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 34 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I See site plan. Acknowled~ed. 171. The property legal description on sheet A1.01 is not consistent with legal on survey (typos noted). Corrected. 172. Revise legal description to include acreage to the nearest 1/100th of an acre and total square footage of property (at end of legal). Submit a copy of revised legal with acreage/sf in Word format on a CD for file. 173. Clarify actual acreage of property (legal description is 14.42, application and tabular is 14.43). Corrected. 174. Dimension ultimate R/W and D.E. widths and depict/label centerlines of all rights-of-way. Corrected. 175. Indicate all existing easements to remain and those to be abandoned or relocated. Indicate location, purpose, and width of all proposed easements on site and adjacent to subject property. Easements depicted on plan. Easements are on landscape plans. 176. Include a typical floor plan for each residential unit model which notes exterior dimensions, number of bedrooms, AlC area sf, total unit size, etc. (Chapter 4, Section 7.D.1.). See bld~ plans. 177. Indicate additional detail on the building elevations regarding the MU-L3 locational requirements for arterials to clarify how much of a stepback is provided between the residential units and retail uses. For structures greater than 45 feet in height the frontage on any street is required to provide a 10 foot stepback at 35 feet of building height, plus a 10 foot stepback for each additional 50 feet in building height. For heights greater that 75 feet this shall be provided in two 10-foot stepbacks. Clearly label architectural features on elevations (such as decks and railings), indicate height at stepback and amount of each stepback. Acknowledged, see elevations. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 35 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 178. Provide building elevations (of all buildings sides) of each building and provide the floor area of each building (Chapter 4, Section 7.E.2.). Provided. 179. Provide a graphic depicting view of the garage from the courtyard of the building in Ph 1m. Supplemental landscaping especially around foundation of building and parking structure, decorative features, and benches are needed in this location (add to landscape plan). Provided. 180. Label each building on the site plan with the number of floors and building height. Provided. 181. Please provide an additional unstapled set of separate building elevations for each building that is subject to the height exception (exceeding 75 feet). These elevations will be used separately as part of the height exception presentation to the Board. Provided. 182. Revise all plans to demonstrate that front setbacks are measured from arcades along Federal and Woolbright in compliance with the MU-L3 front setback of 0-10 feet (plan shows a 10' UE and a 5' setback from UE for a total setback of 15 feet). Also, the Live/Work units fronting 18th are subject to the 0-10 foot setback requirement, unless public spaces (wide plazas, not sidewalks) are provided. Buildin~s have been moved to the 10' setback line. 183. Specify if proposed development will include a bank. If so, provide details in tabular for bank use, floor location, square footage, and specify with or without drive-thru teller facilities. A bank with drive up teller facilities requires conditional use approval (separate application). No Bank planned. 184. All proposed uses must be consistent with the MU-L3 zoning district identified in Chapter 2 of the Land Development Regulations. Acknowledged. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 36 I DEPARTMENTS I INCLUDE I REJECT I 185. Please submit a list of permissible uses for the Live/W ork units that will be included into the bylaws for the development (refer to Ch.2, Section 6.H.15. Live/Work Permissible Uses in the SMU District for preferred uses). 186. All proposed outdoor dining areas shall comply with applicable sidewalk cafe requirements. See note AI.OI. 187. The trash enclosures shall resemble with respect to the color and materials, the design of the principal buildings and shall be integrated with other site elements (Chapter 9, Section IO.E.3.). On the site plan, place a note indicating this requirement. Acknowledged, however all but one trash enclosure are enclosed with the buildin~. 188. Equipment placed on the walls of the buildings shall be painted to match the building color (Chapter 9, Section 10.C.4.). Place a note on the elevations indicating this requirement. See note AI.OI. 189. The removal/relocation of trees is subject to review and approval of the City ForesterlEnvironmentalist. Acknowled~ed. 190. Trees are required to be at least 12 feet overall height at the time of installation (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2.) and with multi-story developments trees placed around the buildings must be a minimum of 12 the height of the building. All required trees meet minimum height requirements. 191. The Royal Palm specifications appear incorrect, indicating only a 6 foot to 8 foot height. Royal Palm~ nr.~uU)ecified at 10' of matched ~rey wood (22' o.a. hts., min) 192. All required shrubs are to be at minimum 24 inches in height, 24 inches in spread, and planted with tip-to-tip spacing measured immediately after planting to adequately cover the planted areas on the site (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.4.). Al required shrubs meet minimum specifications. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 37 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 193. A minimum of fifty percent (50%) of site landscape materials in each category (palms, canopy trees, shrubs, groundcovers) must be native species. Indicate amount of each species proposed and if native material, and indicate a total % native provided for each category in the plant list of the landscape plan (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.P). Plat list has been amended to indicate native species and percenta~es. 194. Landscaping at project entrances shall contain a signature tree at both sides of the entrance (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.N.). A signature tree is a tree with blossoms or natural color other than green intended to beautify project entrances and contribute to the city's image with this element of aesthetic conformity. Signatures trees include Yellow Elder, Tibouchina Granulosa, and Bougainvillea. Note that signature trees do not contribute toward the total number of required perimeter trees. Signature trees must have 6 feet of clear trunk if placed within the safe-sight triangle (Chapter 7.5, Article 2, Section 5.N.). Si~nature trees have been added. 195. Depict paver sidewalks along Federal Highway on the site plan and landscape plan. Also note on plans that sidewalks shall be Hollandstone pavers, red / charcoal color mix by Paver Systems Inc. or equal, laid in a 45 herringbone pattern to continue the design elements in place along Federal Highway (Chapter 2, Section 5.F.8.d.(2). Pavers have been designated and specified as requested. 196. Provide a typical drawing that includes the height and color / material of all proposed freestanding outdoor lighting poles. The design, style, and illumination level shall be compatible with the building design (height) and shall consider safety, function, and aesthetic value (Chapter 9, Section 1O.F.1.). See detail sheet AI.05. 197. Show proposed freestanding site lighting locations on the site plan and landscape plan (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.4.). Lighting depicted. Li~htin~ is NOT shown since we did not receive photometrics in time. 198. Staff recommends incorporating an upgraded Palm Tran bus stop shelter into the design of the project along Federal Highway. Coordinate with Palm Tran and provide a written response at the TART meeting. In addition, please include an architectural detail of proposed bus shelter on plans. See note AI.OI WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 38 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 199. Staffrecommends the submittal of a master sign program as part of this site plan process to encourage continuity for signage, while allowing for flexibility with respect to type, color, and design of signs. A complete signage Criteria Package shall be submitted at a later date. 200. On the building elevations indicate the cumulative area of wall signage to ensure that it complies with Chapter 21, Article 4, Section C.). In addition, indicate the sign type, letter colors and sign material (per the proposed Master Sign Program). Signage will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 201. Be advised that a Publix sign may not be allowed on the parking structure as depicted in the elevations (Ph lA East). A Publix wall sign is allowed on the building wall of Publix store, and shall not extend above the parapet of the building or beyond the building corners. The maximum sign area for Publix is 1.5 sf of area for each one (I) foot of linear frontage. There may be some flexibility with the Master Sign Program details to allow a Publix sign as shown on Ph 1A East, but not at the height depicted on the west elevation. Si~na~e will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 202. On site plan, the size of the two (2) proposed freestanding monument signs differs, yet the typical sign detail provided on sheet A1.04 appears to apply to both signs. Then there is a separate detail of an entry monument sign on H7 of 7. Please clarify by providing all signage details in one location on plans, and by noting which sign detail applies to which right-of-way. Si~na~e will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 203. Revise sign elevations to clearly identify the proposed sign area with new name of development and show the site address at the top of the monument sign (Chapter 21, Article 4, Section 5.B.). Also provide materials and colors of sign structure, sign face, and font on sign details. Si~na~e will be submitted as a separate, subsequent approval. 204. Show the locations of fire hydrants and utility poles on all plans. Water and sewer utilities are on landscape plans. Fire hydrants are depicted on the plans. 205. Revise building elevations (Ph IIA West) to provide architectural enhancements (faux features) or artistic components (mural, etc.) to west side of Publix building, and provide varying levels of landscaping up to a minimum of 12 the building height. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. fT. LAUDERDALE . MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH Page 39 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT Acknowledged. 206. Revise massing plan to match other plans. Clarify if plan is showing upper building levels, building footprints, etc. by labeling. Corrected. 207. Recreational amenities for 576 dwelling units are located solely in Ph m on fourth level of parking garage. There will be no recreational amenities available for the 126 units in Ph IA (until completion of next Ph m). Revise plans to provide recreation throughout the development that is more available to units in other phases. Staff recommends revising the other two parking garages to provide similar recreational amenities for units wrapped around those garages. The recreational facilities is sized for the entire project and be provided as part of Phase 1. 208. Ph IA grade level parking has a parallel parking space designated as a handicap space. Revise location of this space Corrected. 209. Clarify lines for parking spaces in garages, and draw all spaces to scale. All spaces are drawn to scale and are 9' x 18' min clear, HC spaces are 12' x 18' wi 5' access aisle clear. 210. Check parking counts for each floor plan of each garage in each phase and ensure that parking provided breakdown and totals on tabular (sheet A1.01) match. Acknowledged. 211. Provide a plan which shows pedestrian connections and pedestrian circulation, walkway widths, and plazas. See sheet AI.04. 212. Provide typical parking garage structure details which indicate architectural treatment and decorative features for all proposed parking structures. The parking structures are within the bldg footprints, all the exposed wall areas are depicted in the elevation sheets. 213. Include details on plans of fountains proposed in north and south commons. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TAllAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH .. Page 40 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT Fountain details not yet provided. eRA STAFF Comments: 214. Add shared parking calculations to site plan. Calculations noted. 215. Application for height exception needed. A requestfor a height exception is enclosed with this resubmittal. WPB:271610:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. CARACAS. FT. LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST.LUClE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH 1 st REVIEW COMMENTS New Site Plan Project name: Sunshine Square Pile number: NWSP 06-021 Reference: 1 streview plans identified as a New Site Plan with an August 4. 2006 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT PUBLIC WORKS - Solid Waste Comments: 1. Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742- 6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10-26 (a). 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is ten (10) feet (inside dimension including gates). (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.J. and Article III, section 9.A.9.a.) 3. A minimum overhead clearance of 14 feet is noted on the Site Plan for the dumpster/compactor areas in Phases IA, ill, and lIB. No clearance is noted for Phase IIA. Fourteen (14) feet of clearance will allow Solid Waste and FirelRescue to use the ground level of the three noted buildings. It is not sufficient for the overhead pick-up required for dumpsters or "raised bed" conventional pick-up of compactors. Indicate exact method of trash pick-up that does use these methods. 4. Provide a minimum turning radius of 60 feet to approach dumpsters. Provide a minimum backing clearance of 60 feet (measured from the front edge of the dumpster pad.) (LDR, Chapter 2, Section I1.J.2.b.) PUBLIC WORKS - Traffic Comments: 5. Provide a traffic analysis and notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic study shall include an evaluation of the need for an additional right turn lane (eastbound to southbound) on Woolbright Road using proposed generation rates (pre- and post-development.) 6. Dedicate right-of-way as necessary should a right turn lane be warranted in the future. Consider growth in background traffic for the year 2020. Also, coordinate the design and construction of all traffic improvements necessary to support this development with the developer of the Las Ventanas site on the northwest corner of Federal Highway. and Woolbright Road. Provide written proof of this cooperation to the City. 7. Show loading areas on the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans; include a pavement message in yellow indicating "No Parking - Loading Zone". See City Standard Drawings "K" Series for striping details. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 2 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 8. Provide Fire Lanes in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section B.2 and Section M. 9. Sheet C6 of 12 of the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans incorrectly references Broward County standards. Please correct to specify City of Boynton Beach and Palm Beach County standards. PUBLIC WORKS-Forestry Comments: 10. The Landscape plan included with this submittal is incomplete. A complete review cannot be made at this time. 11. Show sight triangles on the Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.H.) Reference FDOT Standard Index 546 for the sight triangles along both Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. Sight triangles in the interior of the development shall be 15-feet. 12. The medians on Federal Highway have existing irrigation and plant material belonging to the City of Boynton Beach. Any damage to the irrigation system and/or plant material as a result of the contractor's operations shall be repaired or replaced to the equivalent or better grade, as approved by the City of Boynton Beach, and shall be the sole responsibility of the developer. The contractor shall notify and coordinate with the City of Boynton Beach Forestry & Grounds Division of Public Works a minimum of six (6) weeks in advance of any underground activities. Please acknowledge this notice in your comments response and add a note to the appropriate plan sheets with the above stated information. 13. Per the LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2. Ficus species are not permitted. UTILITIES Comments: 14. Please provide a time line that clearly illustrates when water and sewer services will be required to serve the proposed project. Your starting date for the time line should be the date of City Commission approval. Also provide milestone dates for permit application, the start of construction, and the setting of the first water meter. This timeline will be used to determine the adequacy of water and wastewater treatment capacity for your project upon the project's completion, so please be as accurate as possible. 15. All utility easements shall be shown on the Site plan, Landscape and Hardscape plans (as well as the Water and Sewer Plans) so that we may determine which appurtenances, trees or shrubbery may interfere with 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 3 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT utilities. In general, palm trees will be the only tree species allowed within utility easements. 16. Canopy trees may be planted outside of the easement so that roots and branches will not impact those utilities within the easement in the foreseeable future. The LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article I, Section 18.1 gives public utilities the authority to remove any trees that interfere with utility services, either in utility easements or public rights-of-way. 17. Palm Beach County Health Department permits will be required for the water and sewer systems serving this project (CODE, Section 26-12). 18. Fire flow calculations will be required demonstrating the City Code requirement of 1,500 g.p.m. (500 g.p.m. some residential developments) with 20 p.s.i. residual pressure as stated in the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16, or the requirement imposed by Insurance underwriters, whichever is greater (CODE, Section 26-16(b)). 19. The LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16 requires that all points on each building will be within 200 feet of an existing or proposed fire hydrant. Please demonstrate that the plan meets this condition, by showing all hydrants. The northernmost eastern building, the easternmost northern building, the middle of the northernmost western building, a small portion of the Public supermarket, and the easternmost southern building lack sufficient coverage. Please correct. 20. The CODE, Section 26-34(E) requires that a capacity reservation fee be paid for this project either upon the request for the Department's signature on the Health Department application forms or within seven (7) days of site plan approval, whichever occurs first. This fee will be determined based upon final meter size, or expected demand. 21. Comprehensive Plan Policy 3.C.3.4. requires' the conservation of potable water. As other sources are readily available City water shall not be allowed for irrigation. 22. Water and sewer lines to be owned and operated by the City shall be included within utility easements. Please show all proposed easements on the engineering drawings, using a minimum width of 12 feet. The easements shall be dedicated via separate instrument to the City as stated in CODE Sec. 26-33(a). 23. This office will not require surety for installation of the water and sewer utilities, on condition that the systems be fully completed, and given to the City Utilities Department before the first permanent meter is set. Note that setting of a permanent water meter is a prerequisite to obtaining the Certificate of Occupancy. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 4 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 24. A building permit for this project shall not be issued until this Department has approved the plans for the water and/or sewer improvements required to service this project, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-15. 25. PVC material not permitted on the City's water system. All lines shall be DIP. 26. The Water & Sanitary Sewer plans reflect numerous 450 bends; please revise to read 22-1/20 bends as no 450 deflections are shown. Check all call- outs to assure they have been correctly identified. 27. Appropriate backflow preventer(s) will be required on the domestic water ~ _ service to the building, and the fire sprinkler line if there is one, in " ~/ccordance with the CODE, Section 26-207. 28 29. Provide a minimum of ten (10) feet separation between water main, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer lines. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. 30. The waste stream from any food preparation area processes must meet the City's pretreatment requirements. A sampling point must be provided to allow monitoring of this waste stream (refer to CODE Section 26-143 and Section 26-147.) 31. All retail buildings are indicated as being fully sprinklered, yet nothing is indicated for the live-work townhomes. Are they to be sprinklered also? 32. All multi-level parking structures (garages); are they to be sprinklered? Spacing of the fire hydrants (see Comment #35) reflects several coverage gaps. 33. There is an eXlstmg six (6) inch DIP water main running east to west immediately north of the existing Public supermarket, which IS not addressed as to be either removed or relocated. In addition, the proposed eight (8) inch water main run in the middle of the property running north- south direction is shown as connecting to an existing six (6) inch line along the north side of SE 18th A venue. This is not acceptable. This project will be required to develop a Hardy-Cross analysis of the project site and the surrounding area to determine which extemallinks will need to be upgraded to support this development. 34. Upsize the water main in Woolbright Road to meet the requirements of the Utility Master Plan. The main shall be upsized from the west side of the FECRR east to the point of connection (west driveway) for the project. 35. Coordinate with Boynton Beach Fire-Rescue to determine flow requirements for multi-story buildings over four stories. 36. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3(0) requires Master Plans to 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 5 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT show all utilities on or adjacent to the proposed tract. The plan must therefore show the point of service for water and sewer, and the proposed off-site utilities construction needed in order to service this project. 37. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3(P) requires a statement be included that utilities are available and will be provided by all other appropriate agencies. This statement is lacking on the submitted plans. 38. Utility construction details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All utility construction details shall be in accordance with the Utilities Department's "Utilities Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" manual (including any updates) and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. ENGINEERING DIVISION Comments: 39. Add a note to the Site Plan stating "All plans submitted for specific permits shall meet the City's Code requirements at time of application. These permits include, but are not limited to, the following: paving, drainage, curbing, site lighting, landscaping and irrigation. Permits required from other permitting agencies such as Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), Lake Worth Drainage District (LWDD), Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), Palm Beach County Health Department (PBCHD), Palm Beach County Engineering Department (PBCED), Palm Beach County Department of Environmental Resource Management (PBCDERM) and any others, shall be included with the permit request." 40. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. 41. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. 42. Upon satisfactory Commission approval of the site plan, the applicant shall enter the plat process through the City's Engineering Division. A preliminary plat application may be initiated during the site plan review to expedite issuance of the Land Development Permit. A plat will be required for this development. 43. Provide written and graphic scales on all sheets. The scale shall match between all sheets depicting the site (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.1, 7.C.1, and 7.F.1. If desired a "master" sheet may be provided for each section with enlargements provided for additional detail on subsequent sheets. 1ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 6 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 44. Show proposed site lighting on the Site, all Civil and Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA.) The lighting design shall provide a minimum average light level of one foot-candle. On the Lighting Plan, specify that the light poles shall withstand a 140 MPH wind load (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section Al.a and Florida Building Code). Provide a note that the fixtures shall be operated by photoelectrical control and are to remain on until 2:00 a.ill. (LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section ALa.) Include pole wind loading, and pole details in conformance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article N, Section 11, Chapter 23, Article I, Section 5.B.7 and Chapter 23, Article II, Section A on the Lighting Plan. Lighting shall not be used as a form of advertising in a manner that draws more attention to the building or grounds at night than in the day (LDR, Chapter 9, Section 1O.F.5). Provide hotometrics as art of our TART Ian submittals. 45. The minimum size for a 900 parking stall is 9 feet x 18 feet and for 00 (parallel) parking is 9 feet x 25 feet. (Engineering Design Standard Drawing K-2.) Please correct the detail shown on Sheet C3 of 12 and on the plans. 46. Provide a minimum ten (10) feet clearance between water, sanitary sewer and/or storm sewer. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. 47. The minimum diameter for a storm sewer is 15 inches (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A2.a.) Please correct plans accordingly. 48. Lengths of perforated and non-perforated pipe do not appear to have been called out correctly on the Paving, Grading & Drainage plans (Sheets C2 and C3.) Please correct. 49. Provide an engineer's certification on the Drainage Plan as specified in LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2. 50. Indicate by note that catch basin and manhole covers shall be bicycle proof (LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A2.g). 51. Specify storm sewer diameters, inlets types, etc. on drainage plan. Indicate grate, rim and invert elevations for all structures. Indicate grade of storm sewer segments. Indicate material specifications for storm sewer. 52. Full drainage plans, including drainage calculations, in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article N, Section 5 will be required at the time of permitting. 53. The Site Tabulat~on.?the Site PJPn'1S4eet A1.01) indicates t t there will \ be 18 1Ve-W--?~ownlili~yet I cOb t 2 u's. P ase e . 0 \, t the discrepancy. 54. Pavin, draina e and site details will not be reviewed for construction 1ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 7 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT acceptability at this time. All engineering construction details shall be in accordance with the applicable City of Boynton Beach Standard Drawings and the "Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. FIRE Comments: 55. All entrance gates to construction area shall have a Knox lock system that will also open in case of electrical power failure. All gates shall be a minimum of 20 feet wide if two lanes, and 12 feet wide if single lane. Fire Department apparatus shall be able to turn into the construction site in one turn. Fire Department entry through locked gates shall be by Knox Locks. 56. The construction site access roads shall be maintained free of obstructions at all times. 57. All required fire hydrants, standpipes or sprinkler systems shall be in place before going vertical. Vertical construction shall be protected by standpipes and the sprinkler system to one level below the highest level of construction throughout the building. 58. Any cost of damage to Fire Department vehicles because of improperly stabilized roads or any towing fees if a vehicle becomes stuck will be the responsibility of the contractor. A minimum of 32 tons is required for ground stabilization. The pouring of the foundation pad is considered vertical construction. The roads must be acceptable before construction begins. 59. Adequate Fire Department vehicle turn around space shall be provided in the construction area. 60. Provide the fire hydrant layout for this project with the hydrants clearly shown on one sheet. Show all water supply lines for fire protection and hydraulic calculations using data from a flow test conducted within the past six months. This test will be conducted by the Boynton Beach Fire Department. 61. Sprinkler systems installed in commercial businesses shall be in accordance with NFP A 13. All residential systems shall conform to NFP A 13R. 62. Buildings that exceed 75 feet in height, measured from the point of lowest entry to the bottom of the highest floor that can be occupied, shall be equipped with a Rescue Air Breathing system. POLICE 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 8 DEPARTMENTS Comments: 63. Construction Site Approval: The Staff recommends that prior to issuance of the first building permit, the applicant shall prepare a construction site security and management plan for approval by the City's Police Department CPTED Official. a. The developer/project manager after site clearing and placement of construction trailers shall institute security measures to reduce or eliminate opportunities for theft. The management plan shall include, but not be limited to, temporary lighting, security personnel, vehicle barriers, construction/visitor pass, reduce/minimize entry/exit points, encourage sub contractors to secure machinery, tools at end of work day and/or any other measure deemed appropriate to provide a safe and secure working environment. The security management plan shall be maintained throughout the construction phase of the project. 64. Parkine: Garae:e Parking garages are high priority security areas. Parking garages comprise a large area with relatively low levels of activity; the vulnerability to potential activity can be high risk. With this in mind the Police Department makes the following recommendations: b. Should adhere to the IESNA (Illuminating Engineering Society of North America) standards for garages. c. Design should incorporate both vertical and horizontal luminance. d. Lighting should extend into parking stalls and over vehicles rather than just into driving aisles. e. The exterior of garage should be well lighted on all sides. f. Metal Halide lighting shall be used. g. Position light fixtures to minimize glare to drivers and enhance depth perception. ~ng-gttrage-shotlld bfJ desigRed..to-minimi:ffl-5elffi-wa.Hs-wh' , assist in improvin natural surveillance. Wroughriron Ie . solid's wo be i ea an prererable. LY.il:et arki gar uld . cted access from exterior common groun area~-' tion will-l'rr'(;:ve;-t~e5S1o'the first floor byunw ed ons. exterior walls surrounding the first floor rking shou e at l~ast three to four Ig with / ive screening in p. ce ween the t~pofthe-walL~!!~Jhef1oorifigofthe se parking ~.{~~l1eScr_~.~nteringihe.faci ~t,..y.et--maintaiR-openness1l1i'Obat . j. Any ground level pedestrian exits that open into non-secure areas should be emergency exits only and fitted with panic bar hardware. k. The two ingress and egress points to the parking garage should have raised crossed walks, subject to review by the Fire Department and City INCLUDE REJECT 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 9 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT Engineering. 1. Ceilings should be painted or stained white to significantly enhance the illumination and aid in reducing shadows within the facility. m. Careful placement of signs and graphics indicating exits, stairs, and elevators should be painted or placed on walls to help orient patrons and allow for quick movement in and out of parking garage. n. The parking garage elevator should be designed to permit any individual in the elevator to have a clear and unobstructed view of the immediate surroundings and be seen from outside the elevator. The doors and two sides of the elevator shall have glass walls. The elevator should be equipped with emergency communication and not be equipped with stop button. o. The stairwell towers should be of an open design with open metal handrails and steps. p. For potential criminal activity detection, install a high resolution color digital video system consisting of low lux cameras, with monitoring and photo processing picture or video printout capabilities, shall be installed. q. Surveillance should be strategically placed at locations like ingress/egress points, elevators, and stairwells and on each floor of the facility. The monitoring and control of surveillance system should be at a central monitoring office or other designated location. It should be posted at all access points (pedestrian/vehicular) that the facility is under video surveillance. r. Install convex mirrors in stairwell and elevator areas. 65. Residential: The Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: s. Landscaping should not obstruct view of windows, building address numbers, and walkways. t. Numerical Address: . Needs to be illuminated for nighttime visibility. . Must have bi-directional visibility from the roadway. . Building numbers for multi-unit buildings need to be a minimum of 12" and placed on the front and rear of the building in a conspicuous location away from landscaping. u. Mail boxes for multi-units should be placed in a high activity and conspicuous location for enhanced safety and natural surveillance of users. v. Stairways (to include riser/banister) and balconies shall provide open views. w. Sales center, clubhouse and recreational facilities should be pre-wired for alarm systems. x. Restrict access to recreation buildings and pools through the use of key card or key y. When placing the order for a front door that will have a side pane window it should be placed on the opposite side of the door handle and lock making them unreachable. This would not apply to customized doors. z. If front door has zero visibility to front entryway area, equip it with a 180- degree peephole. aa. Equip all exterior doors with security hinges. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 10 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 66. Commercial: The Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: Landscaping should not obstruct view from doors, windows or walkways. a. All perimeter doors should be equipped with reinforced, case hardened strike plate. b. Rear door shall have 180- degree peephole or security window. c. Delivery doors/bays should be secured with locks and alarm system. d. Directories shall be placed at the ingress points and strategically place directories with arrow indicators for buildings throughout the property at vehicle driver slight level. e. Bicycle Racks shall be installed near building entrances or in close proximity to buildings. Not in parking lots. 67. Li2htin2: The Staff recommends the following as a condition of approval: a. Landscaping shall not conflict with lighting (to include long-term tree canopy growth). b. Building lighting (non- glare) should be around perimeter of all sides and on pedestrian sidewalk. c. Provide timer clock or photocell sensor engaged lighting for above or near entryways to residences and commercial buildings and all pedestrian sidewalks. BUILDING DIVISION Comments: 68. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the TART (Technical Advisory Review Team) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the commission and at permit review. 69. Indicate within the site data the occupancy type of each building as defined in 2004 FBC, Chapter 3. Indicate all occupancies in mixed occupancy buildings. 70. The height and area for buildings or structures of the different types of construction shall be governed by the intended use or occupancy of the building, and shall not exceed the limits set forth in Table 503 of the 2004 FBC. 71. Place a note on the elevation view drawings indicating that the exterior wall openings and exterior wall construction comply with 2004 FBC, Table 704.8. Submit calculations that clearly reflect the percentage of protected and unprotected wall openings permitted per 2004 FBC, Table 704.8. 72. General area modifications to buildings shall be in accordance with 2004 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 11 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT FBC, Section 506. Provide calculations verifying compliance with the above code sections and the 2004 FBC, Table 503. 73. Buildings, structures and parts thereof shall be designed to withstand the minimum wind loads of 140 mph. Wind forces on every building or structure shall be determined by the provisions of ASCE 7, Chapter 6, and the provisions of 2004 FBC, Section 1609 (Wind Loads). Calculations that are signed and sealed by a design professional registered in the state of Florida shall be submitted for review at the time of permit application. 74. Every building and structure shall be of sufficient strength to support the loads and forces encountered per the 2004 FBC, Section 1607 and Table 1607.1. Indicate the live load (pst) on the plans for the building design. 75. Buildings three-stories or higher shall be equipped with an automatic sprinkler system per F.S. 553.895. Fire protection plans and hydraulic calculations shall be included with the building plans at the time of permit application. 76. Add to all plan view drawings of the site a labeled symbol that represents the location and perimeter of the limits of construction proposed with the subject request. 77. At time of permit review, submit signed and sealed working drawings of the proposed construction. 78. On the site plan and floor plan, indicate the number of stories that are in each building. Indicate the overall height of each building. 79. Add to each building that is depicted on the drawing titled site plan and floor plan a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap- accessible entrance doors to each building. 2004 FBC, Sections 11-4.1.2, 11-4.1.3, and 11-4.3. 80. As required by LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7, submit a floor plan drawing. The building plans are not being reviewed for compliance with the applicable building codes. Therefore, add the words "Floor plan layout is conceptual" below the drawing titled Floor Plan found on sheet/s _' However, add to the floor space drawing a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building. The location of the door shall match the location of the accessible entrance doors that are depicted on the site plan drawing. 8!. Compliance with regulations specified III the FFHA, Design and Construction Requirements, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.205, is required. 82. At the time of permit review, submit details of reinforcement of walls for the future installation of grab bars as required by the FFHA, Title 24 CFR, 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 12 DEPARTMENTS Part 100.205, Section 3, Requirement #6. All bathrooms within the covered dwelling unit shall comply. 83. Bathrooms and kitchens in the covered dwelling units shall comply with the FFHA, Title 24 CFR 100.205. Indicate on the plans which design specification ("A" or "B") of the FFHA is being used. The clear floor space at fixtures and appliances and turning diameters shall be clearly shown on the plans. 84. If an accessible route has less than 60 inches clear width, then passing spaces at least 60 inches by 60 inches shall be located at reasonable intervals not to exceed 200 feet. A "T" -intersection of two corridors or walks is an acceptable passing place. 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.3.4. 85. Identify within the site data the finish floor elevation (lowest floor elevation) that is proposed for the building. Verify that the proposed elevation is in compliance with regulations of the code by adding specifications to the site data that address the following issues: a. The design professional-of-record for the project shall add the following text to the site data. "The proposed finish floor elevation _' _ NGVD is above the highest 100-year base flood elevation applicable to the building site, as determined by the SFWMD's surface water management construction development regulations." b. From the FIRM map, identify in the site data the title of the flood zone that the building is located within. Where applicable, specify the base flood elevation. If there is no base flood elevation, indicate that on the plans. c. Identify the floor elevation that the design professional has established for the building within the footprint of the building that is shown on the drawings titled site plan, floor plan and paving/drainage (civil plans). 86. As required by the CBBCO, Part III titled "Land Development Regulations", submit a site plan that clearly depicts the setback dimensions from each property line to the leading edge of the buildings. The leading edge of the buildings begins at the closest point of the overhang or canopy to the property line. In addition, show the distance between all the buildings on all sides. 87. CBBCPP 3.C.3.4 requires the conservation of potable water. City water may not, therefore, be used for landscape irrigation where other sources are readily available. 88. A water-use permit from SFWMD is required for an irrigation system that utilizes water from a well or body of water as its source. A copy of the permit shall be submitted at the time of permit application, F.S. 373.216. 89. If capital facility fees (water and sewer) are paid in advance to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department, the following information shall be provided at the time of building permit application: INCLUDE REJECT 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 13 DEPARTMENTS d. The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. e. If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. f. The number of dwelling units in each building. g. The number of bedrooms in each dwelling unit. h. The total amount paid and itemized into how much is for water and how much is for sewer. (CBBCO, Chapter 26, Article II, Sections 26-34) 90. At time of permit review, submit separate surveys of each lot, parcel, or tract. For purposes of setting up property and ownership in the City computer, provide a copy of the recorded deed for each lot, parcel, or tract. The recorded deed shall be submitted at time of permit review. 91. At time of building permit application, submit verification that the City of Boynton Beach Parks and Recreation Impact Fee requirements have been satisfied by a paid fee or conveyance of property. The following information shall be provided: 1. A legal description of the land. J. The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. k. If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. 1. The number of dwelling units in each building. ill. The total amount being paid. (CBBCO, Chapter 1, Article V, Section 3(t)) 92. Add a general note to the site pIan that all plans submitted for permitting shall meet the City's codes and the applicable building codes in effect at the time of permit application. 93. Pursuant to approval by the City Commission and all other outside agencies, the plans for this project must be submitted to the Building Division for review at the time of permit application submittal. The plans must incorporate all the conditions of approval as listed in the development order and approved by the City Commission. 94. The full address of the project shall be submitted with the construction documents at the time of permit application submittal. The addressing plan shall be approved by the United States Post Office, the City of Boynton Beach Fire Department, the City's GIS Division, and the Palm Beach County Emergency 911. n. Palm Beach County Planning, Zoning & Building Division, 100 Australian Avenue, West Palm Beach, Florida (Sean McDonald - 561-233-5013) o. United States Post Office, Boynton Beach (Michelle Bullard - 561-734- 0872) INCLUDE REJECT 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 14 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 95. Show the proposed site lighting on the site and landscape plans. (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA) If possible, provide photo metrics as part of your TART plan submittals. 96. Add to the floor plan drawings of the individual units a breakdown of the area within the unit. The area breakdowns for each unit shall specify the total area of the unit, area of the balcony, total area that is air-conditioned and, where applicable, total area of storage and garage space. If the garage and storage areas are not part of a specific unit, the area shall be included and identified within the area of the building. Indicate how many of each type of unit will be on each floor and within the building. 97. Add to the site data the total area under roof of each residential building. Provide tabular area data for each floor of each building. The breakdown shall include the following areas and each area shall be labeled on the applicable floor plan drawing: p. Common area covered walkways; q. Covered stairways; r. Common area balconies; s. Entrance area outside of a unit; t. Storage areas (not part of a unit); u. Garages (not part of a unit); v. Elevator room; w. Electrical room; x. Mechanical room; y. Trash room; z. Mailbox pickup and delivery area; and aa. Any other area under roof. (Chapter 4 - Site Plan Review, Section 7.E.2 and 3) 98. This structure meets the definition of a threshold building per F.S. 553.71(7) and shall comply with the requirements ofF.S. 553.79 and the CBBA to the 2004 FBC, Sections 109.3.6.1 through 109.3.6.6. The following information must be submitted at the time of permit application: bb. The structural inspection plan must be submitted to the enforcing agency prior to the issuance of a building permit for the construction of a threshold building. cc. All shoring and re-shoring procedures, plans and details shall be submitted. dd. All plans for the building that are required to be signed and sealed by the architect or engineers of record shall contain a statement that, to the best of the architect's or engineer's knowledge, the plans and specifications comply with the applicable fire safety standards as determined by the local authority in accordance with this section and F.S. Section 633. 99. If this project is located within the Downtown Stormwater Improvement Watershed, appropriate fees must be paid to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department prior to the issuance of a building permit per the 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 15 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT CBBCO, Chapter 26, Section 26-406. Proof of payment shall be submitted to the Building Division at the time of permit application submittal. 100. Indicate on the plans the square footage per floor of the parking garages. Comply with the area and height requirements of 2004 FBC, Table 503. 101. A mechanical ventilation system is required in the parking garages per the 2004 FBC, Section 406.4.2. 102. The passenger loading zone for the CRA trolley shall comply with the handicap accessibility requirements of the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.1.2( c). 103. Sheet A2.01 IIB - Phase 1m Parking Garage - Relocate one of the handicap parking spaces to the north side of the garage. Handicap parking spaces shall be located per the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.6.2. 104. Van accessible parking spaces shall be provided in the parking structures per the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.1.2(5)(6). Identify on the plans. 105. Location of exits in residential buildings shall comply with 2004 FBC, Section 1015.1 and Table 1015.1 for exit access travel distance. 106. Indicate the overall height of the buildings on the elevation plans. 107. The buildings shall comply with 2004 FBC, Section 403 for high-rise buildings. 108. Indicate the occupancy type and type of construction for the residential buildings. 109. Sheet A2.04 IE - The floor plan does not depict all rooms, corridors, stair enclosures, etc. PARKS AND RECREATION Comments: 110. The landscape plan is incomplete. Quantities and species are not indicated on the call outs on the plan. Quantities are not shown on the plant list. 111. Native specifes should be identified on the plant list 112. The Ficus family can not be used in Boynton Beach. 113. Irrigation should have 110% coverage, be from a non-potable water source, have separate bubblers for each tree, and have separate zones for sod and bed areas. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 16 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT FORESTER/ENVIRONMENTALIST Comments: Boundarv Survey Existin2 Trees Mana2ement Plan Sheet 1 of 1 114. The Landscape Architect should tabulate the total diameter inches of existing trees on the site. The tabular data should show the individual species of trees proposed to be preserved in place, relocated or removed and replaced on site. The replacement trees should be shown by a separate symbol on the landscape plan sheet LND5 of 5. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article I Sec. 7.D.p. 2.] Plant Palette Le2end Sheet LND5 of 5 115. All shade and palm trees must be listed in the description as a minimum of 12'-14' height, 3" DBH (4.5' off the ground) not caliper, and Florida #1 (Florida Grades and Standards manual). The height of the trees may be larger than 12' -14' to meet the 3" diameter requirement; or any clear trunk (c.t.) specifications. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C. 2.] 116. The landscape design does not include the City signature trees (Tibochina granulosa) at the ingress / egress areas to the site. These trees must meet the mInImUm SIze specifications for trees. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C.3.N.] 117. All trees proposed under any existing overhead electric power lines must meet the FP & L Right tree in the Right Place manual selection for small trees only. 118. The landscape sheet shade tree planting detail should including a line indicating where the diameter and height of all of the trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. 119. The landscape sheet palm tree planting detail should include a line indicating where the height of all of the palm trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. 120. The landscape sheet shrub and groundcover planting detail should include a line indicating where the height and spread of the shrubs and groundcover plants will be measured at time of planting and inspection. 121. The applicant should add a note that all utility boxes or structures (not currently known or shown on the plan) should be screened with Coco plum hedge plants on three sides. The landscape sheet details indicating use of soil amendments for each of the plantings should indicate structural soil for all planting areas on the site. The total quantity of required structural soil should be added to the plant palette legend. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 17 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 122. The applicant should show an elevation cross-section detail of the actual heights of the proposed landscape trees and vegetation at the time of planting to (proper scale) visually buffer the proposed buildings and parking lot from the Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and S.E. 18th Avenue road rights-of-ways. 123. Many of the landscape symbols are 1lllssmg the speCIes number or identification letters on the landscape sheets. 124. The total quantities of each of the plant materials are not shown in the legend. Irri2ation Plan 125. Turf and landscape (bedding plants) areas should be designed on separate zones and time duration for water conservation. 126. Trees should have separate irrigation bubblers to provide water directly to the root ball. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5. C.2.] PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: 127. At the technical advisory review team (TART) meeting, provide written responses to all staffs comments and questions. Submit 12 sets of revised plans. Each set should be folded and stapled. 128. At the technical advisory review team meeting, also provide a full set of reduced drawings, sized 8Yz inches by 11 inches of each pIan. Save each plan to a compact disk and submit that to staff as well. 129. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. 130. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. 131. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon the approval of the corresponding request (LUAR 06-016) to amend the future land use designation from Local Retail Commercial (LRC) to Mixed Use (MX) and to rezone from Community Commercial (C-3) to Mixed Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3). 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 18 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT . 132. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon submittal and approval of a corresponding request for a height exception of 10 feet (max height in MU-L3 is 75 feet). 133. A drainage statement is required prior to the Technical Application Review Team (TART) meeting (Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2.). 134. All proposed uses and their respective building areas must match between the traffic study and the site plan. In addition, the letter from PBC Traffic dated June 21, 2006 requires a revised traffic study. The revised traffic study will be required prior to the CRA meeting (Chapter 4. Section 8.F.). Staff would prefer to have the revised traffic study by the TART meeting tentatively scheduled for October 3, 2006. 135. Provide a notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic impact analysis must be approved by the Palm Beach County Traffic Division for concurrency purposes prior to the issuance of any building permits. 136. Revise site plan application: (page 1, Section 1.1.) to include new project name; (page 2, Section 11.1.) to revise to MX land use; (page 2, Section II.2.) to revise to MU-L3 zoning district; (page 2, Section II.3.) to switch site area to 14.43 acres and square feet to 628,727 sf. 137. Revise site plan application (page 3, Section 5.e.) to include pervious area of 3.44 acres or 23.83% of site (5.h. should be total of 5.e.-5.g.) 138. The site plan application (page 3, Section 11.6.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) for floor area breakdown do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed square footage for each use and to make application and plans consistent. 139. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.7.c.3-4) total 404 2- and 3+- bedrooms, and site plan tabular (A1.01) bedroom count info for required parking does not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number for each unit type / size and to make application and plans consistent. 140. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.8.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) density is 39.9168 dulac, this should be rounded to 39.92 du/ac. 141. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.9.) should also include maximum number of stories proposed. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 19 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 142. The site plan application (page 4, Section II.lO.a.) should clarify requirement of 14 spaces per 200 sf and what code provision this is based upon. Also each live/work unit requires 2.5 spaces per unit. 143. The site plan application (page 4, Section ILlO.b.) requires a calculation for required number of handicap parking spaces. 144. Submit two (2) copies of the shared parking analysis (signed and sealed by a licensed traffic engineer). 145. Provide details of shared parking analysis on site plan application (page 4, Section II.lO.) and site plan (A 1.0 1). 146. The site plan application (page 4, Section II. 1 O.a.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) parking counts do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number of spaces required and number of spaces provided and to make application and plans consistent. 147. Clarify that site will be developed as one parcel under a Unity of Title, or if there will be separately owned parcels under a Unity of Control. If separate parcels, provide parcel boundaries, lot dimensions, and setbacks from the lot lines. A recorded Unity of Title or Unity of Control will be required prior to the issuance of a building permit. 148. Indicate bolder phase lines on all plans. Provide phasing information, including building square footage per use, total square footage, and parking required/provided per phase in site tabular on sheet A1.01. 149. Submit LLC corporate papers which name principal authorized to sign on behalf of Sunshine Square CRP, LLC. II II M"j.'~ 150. Submit Japge colored renderings (clipped not glued to foamboard) of project at the TART meeting. These will be displayed at the public hearings. 151. Submit color chips of proposed building colors noted on elevations. 152. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the new site plan is publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04-007. 153. The applicant is responsible for compliance with Ordinance 05-060, the "Art in Public Places" program, and must demonstrate their participation. Update and complete the Public Art Information Form submitted May 19, 2006. 154. Correct zoning district (not category) in tabular site data on cover sheet A1.01 to MU-L3 (Mixed Use Low Intensity 3) and Land Use Designation is 1ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 20 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT Mixed Use (MX). 155. Revise parcels labeled as "NIC" to "Not Included". NIC is used by this office as "NOT IN CITY". 156. On site plan and landscape plan, show as-built conditions of adjacent parcels which are not included in the project. Demonstrate how proposed structures with minimal or no setbacks and required landscaping will be maintained (including the side of Publix adjacent to the RR tracks). Foundation landscaping is required in these areas, but not provided. 157. The review of applications for MU-L3 shall emphasize aesthetics and design quality, and physical compatibility with adjacent land uses. Demonstrate how the proposed development will tie in with gas station on corner and parcel on SE 18th Ave. through fac;ade and landscaping upgrades and connectivity. 158. Perimeter landscaping is required along the common property lines adjacent to the gas station and adjacent to properties fronting SE 18th Ave. Revise landscape plan to provide required perimeter/foundation landscaping in these locations. A landscape easement on adjacent property may be considered if parties agree to all terms. 159. Submit a perspective view from Federal and Woolbright of Ph IA North and East elevations which includes the existing gas station to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing gas station. 160. Submit a perspective view from Federal and SE 18th Ave of Ph IE South and East elevations which includes the existing development on parcel not included to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing development offsite. 161. Prior to TART meeting, submit draft cross-access easements for future cross access to gas station, and a letter from gas station owner that he is willing to enter into the recorded cross access easement agreements prior to the first CO. 162. Submit a phasing plan and construction timeline which details what will be completed in each phase before starting next phase (road improvements, parking, traffic circulation, landscaping) and how existing tenants are to be relocated. 1ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 21 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 163. On the site plan tabular data (A1.01 and .02), indicate the maXImum allowable FAR in MU-L3 district and the proposed FAR. 164. Provide tabular parking space breakdown for residential versus nonresidential uses and number of spaces for each type. 165. Clarify within tabular information on plans if multifamily units will be rentals or condominium. 166. Provide graphic and written scales on all plans. 167. Provide legible floor plans for each proposed building. . 168. The area west of Publix is shown as pervious (sod) on landscape and hardscape plans, yet the site plan shows a walkway along side of building. Please revise plans to match. . 169. Provide details of where residential parking spaces are located, and how the spaces for residential will be differentiated from the spaces for nonresidential. 170. Clearly label all bearings and distances for all property lines on plans. 171. The property legal description on sheet A1.01 is not consistent with legal on survey (typos noted). 172. Revise legal description to include acreage to the nearest 1/100th of an acre and total square footage of property (at end of legal). Submit a copy of revised legal with acreage/sf in Word format on a CD for file. 173. Clarify actual acreage of property (legal description is 14.42, application and tabular is 14.43). 174. Dimension ultimate R/W and D.E. widths and depict / label centerlines of all rights-of-way. 175. Indicate all existing easements to remain and those to be abandoned or relocated. Indicate location, purpose, and width of all proposed easements on site and adjacent to subject property. 176. Include a typical floor plan for each residential unit model which notes exterior dimensions, number of bedrooms, AlC area sf, total unit size, etc. (Chapter 4, Section 7.D.1.). . 177. Indicate additional detail on the building elevations regarding the MU-L3 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 22 . DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT locational requirements for arterials to clarify how much of a stepback is provided between the residential units and retail uses. For structures greater than 45 feet in height the frontage on any street is required to provide a 10 foot setback at 35 feet plus 10 for each additional 50 feet in height. For heights greater that 75 feet this shall be provided in two 10-foot stepbacks. 178. Provide building elevations (of all buildings sides) of each building and provide the floor area of each building (Chapter 4, Section 7.E.2.). 179. Provide a graphic depicting view of the garage from the courtyard of the building in Ph lIB. Supplemental landscaping especially around foundation of building and parking structure, decorative features, and benches are needed in this location (add to landscape plan). 180. Label each building on the site plan with the number of floors and building height. 181. Also, please provide an additional unstapled set of separate building elevations for each building that IS subject to the height exception (exceeding 75 feet). These elevations will be used separately as part of the height exception presentation to the Board. 182. Revise all plans to demonstrate that front setbacks are measured from arcades along Federal and Woolbright in compliance with the MU-L3 front setback of 0-1 0 feet. 183. Specify if proposed development will include a bank. If so, provide details in tabular for bank use, floor location, square footage, and specify with or without drive-thru teller facilities. A bank with drive up teller facilities requires conditional use approval (separate application). 184. All proposed uses must be consistent with the MU-L3 zoning district identified in Chapter 2 of the Land Development Regulations. 185. Please submit a list of permissible uses for the Live/W ork units that will be included into the bylaws for the development (refer to Ch, 2, Section 6.H.15. Live/Work Permissible Uses in SMU District for uses). 186. All proposed outdoor dining areas must JH\ve. Ii ~id", n lllk ellifh ~81 mit and comply with an fill\ linlR~tf] f~r B\l8ft. . 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 23 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 187. The trash enclosures shall resemble with respect to the color and materials, the design of the principal buildings and shall be integrated with other site elements (Chapter 9, Section lO.E.3.). On the site plan, place a note indicating this requirement. 188. Equipment placed on the walls of the buildings shall be painted to match the building color (Chapter 9, Section 10.CA.). Place a note on the elevations indicating this requirement. 189. The removal/relocation of trees is subject to review and approval of the City Forester / Environmentalist. 190. Trees are required to be at least 12 feet overall height at the time of installation (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2.) and with multi-story developments trees placed around the buildings must be a minimum of 12 the height of the building. 191. The Royal Palm specifications appear incorrect, indicating only a 6 foot to 8 foot height. 192. All required shrubs are to be at minimum 24 inches in height, 24 inches in spread, and planted with tip-to-tip spacing measured immediately after planting to adequately cover the planted areas on the site (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.CA.). 193. A minimum of fifty percent (50%) of site landscape materials in each category (palms, canopy trees, shrubs, groundcovers) must be native species. Indicate amount of each species proposed and if native material, and indicate a total % native provided for each category in the plant list of the landscape plan (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.P). 194. Landscaping at project entrances shall contain a signature tree at both sides of the entrance (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.N.). A signature tree is a tree with blossoms or natural color other than green intended to beautify project entrances and contribute to the city's image with this element of aesthetic conformity. Signatures trees include Yellow Elder, Tibouchina Granulosa, and Bougainvillea. Note that signature trees do not contribute toward the total number of required perimeter trees. Signature trees must have 6 feet of clear trunk if placed within the safe-sight triangle (Chapter 7.5, Article 2, Section 5.N.). 195. Depict paver sidewalks along Federal Highway on the site plan and landscape plan. Also note on plans that sidewalks shall be Hollandstone pavers, red / charcoal color mix by Paver Systems Inc. or equal, laid in a 45 herringbone pattern to continue the design elements in place along Federal Highway (Chapter 2, Section 5.F.8.d.(2). 196. Provide a typical drawing that includes the height and color / material of all proposed freestanding outdoor lighting poles. The design, style, and illumination level shall be compatible with the building design (height) and shall consider safety, function, and aesthetic value (Chapter 9, Section lO.F.1.). 197. Show proposed freestanding site lighting locations on the site plan and 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 24 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT landscape plan (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA.). 198. Staff recommends incorporating an upgraded Palm Tran bus stop shelter into the design of the project along Federal Highway. Coordinate with Palm Tran and provide a written response at the TART meeting. In addition, please include an architectural detail of proposed bus shelter on plans. 199. Staff recommends the submittal of a master sign program as part of this site plan process to encourage continuity for signage, while allowing for flexibility with respect to type, color, and design of signs. 200. On the building elevations indicate the cumulative area of wall signage to ensure that it complies with Chapter 21, Article 4, Section C.). In addition, indicate the sign type, letter colors and sign material (per the proposed Master Sign Program). 201. Be advised that a Publix sign will not be allowed on the parking structure as depicted in the elevations (Ph lA East). A Publix wall sign is allowed on the building wall of Publix store, and shall not extend above the parapet of the building or beyond the building corners. The maximum sign area for Publix is 1.5 sf of area for each one (1) foot of linear frontage. 202. On site plan, the size of the two (2) proposed freestanding monument signs differs, yet the typical sign detail provided on sheet A1.04 appears to apply to both signs. Then there is a separate detail of an entry monument sign on H7 of 7. Please clarify by providing all signage details in one location on plans, and by noting which sign detail applies to which right-of-way. 203. Revise sign elevations to clearly identify the proposed sign area with new name of development and show the site address at the top of the monument sign (Chapter 21, Article 4, Section 5.B.). Also provide materials and colors of sign structure, sign face, and font on sign details. 204. Show the locations of fire hydrants and utility poles on all plans. 205. Revise building elevations (Ph IIA West) to provide architectural enhancements to west side ofPublix building, and provide varying levels of landscaping up to a minimum of 12 the building height. 206. Recreational amenities for 576 dwelling units are located solely in Ph IE on fourth level of parking garage. There will be no recreational amenities available for the 126 units in Ph IA (until completion of next Ph m). Revise plans to provide recreation throughout the development that is more available to units in other phases. Staff recommends revising the other two parking garages to provide similar recreational amenities for units wrapped around those garages. 207. Ph IA grade level parking has a parallel parking space designated as a handicap space. Revise location of this space 208. Clarify lines for parking spaces in garages, and draw all spaces to scale. 209. Check parking counts for each floor plan of each garage in each phase and ensure that parking provided breakdown and totals on tabular (sheet AI. 01) match. 210. Provide a plan which shows pedestrian connections and pedestrian circulation, walkway widths, and plazas. 1 ST REVIEW COMMENTS 09/08/06 25 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 211. Include details on plans of fountains proposed in north and south commons. eRA STAFF Comments: 212. Add shared parking calculations to site plan. 213. Application for height exception needed. MWR/sc S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Sunshine Square\NWSP 06-021\1ST REVIEW COMMENTS.doc www.bbfrd.org FIRE & LIFE SAFETY DIVISION TO: Ed Breese, Principal Planner FROM: Rodger W. Kemmer, Deputy Chief/Fire Marshal DATE: August 17,2006 SUBJECT: Ellipse (Sunshine Square) Although this project will substantially increase commercial space to be inspected and residents that require emergency services, we anticipate that no impact to our ability to provide services will occur in accordance with our staffing and operations plans. " CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Ed Breese, Principal Planner DATE: August 24, 2006 FILE: NWSP 06-021 FROM: Off. John Huntington Police Department CPTED Practitioner SUBJECT: Ellipse REFERENCES: Impacts of Proposed Plan Upon Department Services ENCLOSURES: I have reviewed the impact for services for the proposed site plan to be located on the South West comer of S Federal Highway and Woolbright Road. (formally Sunshine Square) For the purpose of this study, a statistical analysis was completed to show the percentage of increase of police calls for service for the selected project area. A crime analysis for 2005 shows that there have been 14,971 calls for service for zone 4 & 5 and represents 13.3% of all total calls for service. There are no other existing developments to use as a comparison for this assessment. It must be noted that this project is one of six mixed- use projects planned for completion. This project calls for 576 multi-family units, retail/office space and new Publix. One 6-level parking garage and two 3-level parking garages are also planned as part of this project. The need for additional officers in Zone 4 and 5 is evident by the high percentage of calls for service that officers are currently handling. This future project along with Boynton Lofts, the Marina project and future plans for the development ofE. Ocean Ave. south to SE 5 Avenue, will have a direct impact on providing an adequate level of public service to this area. Additional officers and equipment will be needed to support this increase in department services. City wide, an increase of 8 % of total calls for service can be expected due to proposed growth. Future projects along the waterfront will increase local retail and office space and increase public traffic. These new developments will have a direct impact on future public safety issues, to include calls for service. Service requirements for the police department will be impacted greatly and the demand for more police personnel and equipment will be needed to balance the increase in population and non residential traffic into our city. The City of Boynton Beach DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISON 100 E. Boynton Beach Boulevard P.O. Box 310 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 TEL: 561-742-6260 FAX: 561-742-6259 To: Cc: From: Date: Re: www.boynton-beach.org Peter Mazzella, Assistant Director, Utilities Kofi Boatang, Director of Utilities Matthew Immler, Police Chief Rodger Kemmer, Deputy Chief / Fire Marshal Jody Rivers, Parks Superintendent William Bingham, Fire Chief Wally Majors, Parks Director Laurinda Logan, Civil Engineer Rick Lee, Fire Protection Analyst John Huntington, Police Officer y Ed Breese, Principal Planne~ 8/7/06 Impacts of proposed site plan upon City facilities and services Project: Ellipse (Sunshine Square) MEMORANDUM As part of the City's concurrency requirements, the City Commission directed the Planning & Zoning Division to report whether or not the City could maintain an adequate level of service with current infrastructure and / or staffing levels in order to support the proposed development. Plans for the above-mentioned project have been forwarded to your department's representative for their technical review and comment. We are requesting that you review the proposed project for anticipated impacts to your department's level of service (as requested by the City Commission) and provide us with your comments for direct insertion into our staff report. In the past, you have sent us something that indicates your current staff / infrastructure would either be able to support the proposed project or what would be required to meet the adopted level of service. Please respond no later than 2 weeks from today. Also, any recommendations that you believe that would enhance the project are certainly welcomed. I thank you for your assistance in this matter. Should you have any questions regarding the requested information, please do not hesitate to call me at 742-6260. S:\Planning\SHARED\WP\PROJECTS\Sunshine Square\NWSP 06-021\Impact Analysis.doc Page 1 of 1 - Rivers, Jody To: Breese, Ed; Coale, Sherie Subject: Site Plan Review - Ellipse Project: Ellipse File No.: NWSP 06-021 1. The landscape plan is incomplete. Quantities and species are not indicated on the call outs on the plan. Quantities are not shown on the plant list. 2. Native specifes should be identified on the plant list 3. The Ficus family can not be used in Boynton Beach. 4. Irrigation should have 110% coverage, be from a non-potable water source, have separate bubblers for each tree, and have separate zones for sod and bed areas. JoGttj Rivers Parks Superintendent City of Boynton Beach 100 E. Boynton Beach Blvd. Boynton Beach. FL 33425 (561) 742-6226 (561) 742-6233 (fax) A sense of COMMUNITY...lt Starts in Parks What transforms a crowd into a community? Parks provide that chance. Boynton Beach's parks are where lifetime friendships are formed, where generations can come together, where people discover what they have in common. It starts in parks. 8/1 0/2006 / TRC COMMENTS PROJECT: The Ellipse LOCATION: Southwest Side of Woolbright and Federal Highway FILE#: COUS 06-021 TYPE OF PROJECT: Mixed Residential/Mercantile and Business AREA: 628,717sqft COMMENTS 1. All entrance gates to construction area shall have a Knox lock system that will also open in case of electrical power failure. All gates shall be a minimum of 20' wide if two lanes, and 12' wide if single lane. Fire Department apparatus shall be able to turn into the construction site in one turn. Fire Department entry through locked gates shall be by Knox Locks. 2. The construction site access roads shall be maintained free of obstructions at all times. 3. All required fire hydrants, standpipes or sprinkler systems shall be in place before going vertical. Vertical construction shall be protected by standpipes and the sprinkler system to one level below the highest level of construction throughout the building. 4. Any cost of damage to Fire Department vehicles because of improperly stabilized roads or any towing fees if a vehicle becomes stuck will be the responsibility of the contractor. A minimum of 32 tons is required for ground stabilization. The pouring of the foundation pad is considered vertical construction. The roads must be acceptable before construction begins. 5. Adequate Fire Department vehicle turn around space shall be provided in the construction area. 6. Provide the fire hydrant layout for this project with the hydrants clearly shown on one sheet. Show all water supply lines for fire protection and hydraulic calculations using data from a flow test conducted within the past six months. This test will be conducted by the Boynton Beach Fire Department. 7. Sprinkler systems installed in commercial businesses shall be in accordance with NFPA 13. All residential systems shall conform to NFPA 13R. 8. Buildings that exceed 75 feet in height, measured from the point of lowest entry to the bottom of the highest floor that can be occupied, shall be equipped with a Rescue Air Breathing system. CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Ed Breese, Principal Planner DATE: August 24, 2006 FILE: NWSP 06-021 FROM: Off. John Huntington Police Department CPTED Practitioner SUBJECT: Ellipse REFERENCES: Site Plan ENCLOSURES: I have viewed the above building plans and have the following comments: Construction Site Approval: 1. The Staff recommends that prior to issuance of the first building permit, the applicant shall prepare a construction site security and management plan for approval by the City's Police Department CPTED Official. a. The developer/project manager after site clearing and placement of construction trailers shall institute security measures to reduce or eliminate opportunities for theft. The management plan shall include, but not be limited to, temporary lighting, security personnel, vehicle barriers, construction/visitor pass, reduce/minimize entry/exit points, encourage sub contractors to secure machinery, tools at end of work day and/or any other measure deemed appropriate to provide a safe and secure working environment. The security management plan shall be maintained throughout the construction phase of the project. 2. Parkina Garaae Parking garages are high priority security areas. Parking garages comprise a large area with relatively low levels of activity; the vulnerability to potential activity can be high risk. With this in mind the Police Department makes the following recommendations: a) Should adhere to the IESNA (Illuminating Engineering Society of North America) standards for garages. b) Design should incorporate both vertical and horizontal luminance. c) Lighting should extend into parking stalls and over vehicles rather than just into driving aisles. d) The exterior of garage should be well lighted on all sides. e) Metal Halide lighting shall be used. f) Position light fixtures to minimize glare to drivers and enhance depth perception. g) The Parking garage should be designed to minimize solid walls which will assist in improving natural surveillance. Wrought iron fencing instead of solid walls would be ideal and preferable. h) First level of parking garage should have restricted access from exterior common ground area. A barrier protection will prevent open access to the first floor by unwanted persons. The exterior walls surrounding the first floor parking should be at least three to four feet high with decorative screening in place between the top of the wall and the flooring of the second parking level. The screening would discourage anyone from entering the facility on foot, yet maintain openness and natural surveillance. i) Any ground level pedestrian exits that open into non-secure areas should be emergency exits only and fitted with panic bar hardware. j) The two ingress and egress points to the parking garage should have raised crossed walks, subject to review by the Fire Department and City Engineering. k) Ceilings should be painted or stained white to significantly enhance the illumination and aid in reducing shadows within the facility. I) Careful placement of signs and graphics indicating exits, stairs, and elevators should be painted or placed on walls to help orient patrons and allow for quick movement in and out of parking garage. m) The parking garage elevator should be designed to permit any individual in the elevator to have a clear and unobstructed view of the immediate surroundings and be seen from outside the elevator. The doors and two sides of the elevator shall have glass walls. The elevator should be equipped with emergency communication and not be equipped with stop button. n) The stairwell towers should be of an open design with open metal handrails and steps. 0) For potential criminal activity detection, install a high resolution color digital video system consisting of low lux cameras, with monitoring and photo processing picture or video printout capabilities, shall be installed. p) Surveillance should be strategically placed at locations like ingress/egress points, elevators, and stairwells and on each floor of the facility. The monitoring and control of surveillance system should be at a central monitoring office or other designated location. It should be posted at all access points (pedestrian/vehicular) that the facility is under video surveillance. q) Install convex mirrors in stairwell and elevator areas. 3. Residential: The Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: 1. Landscaping should not obstruct view of windows, building address numbers, and walkways. 2. Numerical Address: . Needs to be illuminated for nighttime visibility. . Must have bi-directional visibility from the roadway. . Building numbers for multi-unit buildings need to be a minimum of 12" and placed on the front and rear of the building in a conspicuous location away from landscaping. 3. Mail boxes for multi-units should be placed in a high activity and conspicuous location for enhanced safety and natural surveillance of users. 4. Stairways (to include riser/banister) and balconies shall provide open views. 5. Sales center, clubhouse and recreational facilities should be pre-wired for alarm systems. 6. Restrict access to recreation buildings and pools through the use of key card or key 7. When placing the order for a front door that will have a side pane window it should be placed on the opposite side of the door handle and lock making them unreachable. This would not apply to customized doors. 8. If front door has zero visibility to front entryway area, equip it with a 180-degree peephole. 9. Equip all exterior doors with security hinges. 4. Commercial: The Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: a) Landscaping should not obstruct view from doors, windows or walkways. b) All perimeter doors should be equipped with reinforced, case hardened strike plate. c) Rear door shall have 180- degree peephole or security window. d) Delivery doors/bays should be secured with locks and alarm system. e) Directories shall be placed at the ingress points and strategically place directories with arrow indicators for buildings throughout the property at vehicle driver slight level. f) Bicycle Racks shall be installed near building entrances or in close proximity to buildings. Not in parking lots. 5. Liahtina: The Staff recommends the following as a condition of approval: 1. Landscaping shall not conflict with lighting (to include long-term tree canopy growth). 2. Building lighting (non- glare) should be around perimeter of all sides and on pedestrian sidewalk. 3. Provide timer clock or photocell sensor engaged lighting for above or near entryways to residences and commercial buildings and all pedestrian sidewalks. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS ENGINEERING DIVISION MEMORANDUM NO. 06-101 TO: FROM: Michael W. Rumpf, Director, Planning and Zoning . ". Laurinda Logan, P.E., Senior Engineer-tt;'\ DATE: September 5, 2006 RE: Review Comments New Site Plan - 1 st Review Ellipse (aka Sunshine Square) File No. NWSP 06-021 The above referenced Site Plans, received on August 7, 2006, was reviewed for Public Works, Engineering, and Utilities against the requirements outlined in the City of Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances. Following are our comments with the appropriate Code and Land Development Regulations (LOR) referenced. PUBLIC WORKS - SOLID WASTE 1. Prior to permit application contact the Public Works Department (561-742-6200) regarding the storage and handling of refuse per the CODE, Section 10-26 (a). 2. The minimum opening for dumpster or compactor pick up is 10-f1. (inside dimension including gates). (LOR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.J. and Article III, section 9.A.9.a.) 3. A minimum overhead clearance of 14-f1. is noted on the Site Plan for the dumpster/compactor areas in Phases lA, IB, and liB. No clearance is noted for Phase IIA. 14-f1. clearance will allow Solid Waste and Fire/Rescue to use the ground level of the three noted buildings. It is not sufficient for the overhead pick-up required for dumpsters or "raised bed" conventional pick-up of compactors. Indicate exact method of trash pick-up that does use these methods. 4. Provide a minimum turning radius of 60 f1. to approach dumpsters. Provide a minimum backing clearance of 60 f1. (measured from the front edge of the dumpster pad.) (LOR, Chapter 2, Section 11.J.2.b.) PUBLIC WORKS - FORESTRY & GROUNDS 5. The Landscape plan included with this submittal is incomplete. A complete review cannot be made at this time. 6. Show sight triangles on the Landscape plans (LOR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.H.) Reference FOOT Standard Index 546 for the sight triangles along both Federal Highway and Woolbright Rd. Sight triangles in the interior of the development shall be 15-f1. 7. The medians on Federal Highway have existing irrigation and plant material belonging to the City of Boynton Beach. Any damage to the irrigation system and/or plant material as a result of the contractor's operations shall be repaired or replaced to the equivalent or better grade, as approved by the City of Boynton Beach, and shall be the sole responsibility of the developer. The contractor shall notify and coordinate with the City of Boynton Beach Forestry & Grounds Division of Public Dept. of Public Works, Engineering Division Memo No. 06-101 RE: Ellipse, New Site Plan - 1 st Review, NWSP 06-021 September 6, 2006 Page 2 Works a minimum of six (6) weeks in advance of any underground activities. Please acknowledge this notice in your comments response and add a note to the appropriate plan sheets with the above stated information. 8. Per the LDR, Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2. Ficus species are not permitted. PUBLIC WORKS - TRAFFIC 9. Provide a traffic analysis and notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic study shall include an evaluation of the need for an additional right turn lane (eastbound to southbound) on Woolbright Rd. using proposed generation rates (pre- and post-development.) 10. Dedicate right-of-way as necessary should a right turn lane be warranted in the future. Consider growth in background traffic for the year 2020. Also, coordinate the design and construction of all traffic improvements necessary to support this development with the developer of the Las Ventanas site on the northwest corner of Federal Hwy. and Woolbright Rd. Provide written proof of this cooperation to the City. 11. Show loading areas on the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans; include a pavement message in yellow indicating "No Parking - Loading Zone". See City Standard Drawings "K" Series for striping details. 12. Provide Fire Lanes in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section B.2 and Section M. 13. Sheet C6 of 12 of the Traffic Marking & Signage Plans incorrectly references Broward County standards. Please correct to specify City of Boynton Beach and Palm Beach County standards. ENGINEERING 14. Add a note to the Site Plan stating "All plans submitted for specific permits shall meet the City's Code requirements at time of application. These permits include, but are not limited to, the following: paving, drainage, curbing, site lighting, landscaping and irrigation. Permits required from other permitting agencies such as Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), Lake Worth Drainage District (LWDD), Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), Palm Beach County Health Department (PBCHD), Palm Beach County Engineering Department (PBCED), Palm Beach County Department of Environmental Resource Management (PBCDERM) and any others, shall be included with the permit request." 15. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. 16. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. 17. Upon satisfactory Commission approval of the site plan, the applicant shall enter the plat process through the City's Engineering Division. A preliminary plat application may be initiated during the site plan review to expedite issuance of the Land Development Permit. A plat will be required for this development. Dept. of Public Works, Engineering Division Memo No. 06-101 RE: Ellipse, New Site Plan - 1 st Review, NWSP 06-021 September 6, 2006 Page 3 18. Provide written and graphic scales on all sheets. The scale shall match between all sheets depicting the site (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.1, 7.C.1, and 7.F.1. If desired a "master" sheet may be provided for each section with enlargements provided for additional detail on subsequent sheets. 19. Show proposed site lighting on the Site, all Civil and Landscape plans (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.4.) The lighting design shall provide a minimum average light level of one foot-candle. On the Lighting Plan, specify that the light poles shall withstand a 140 MPH wind load (LOR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.1.a and Florida Building Code). Provide a note that the fixtures shall be operated by photoelectrical control and are to remain on until 2:00 a.m. (LOR, Chapter 23, Article II, Section A.1.a.) Include pole wind loading, and pole details in conformance with the LOR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 11, Chapter 23, Article I, Section 5.B.7 and Chapter 23, Article II, Section A on the Lighting Plan. Lighting shall not be used as a form of advertising in a manner that draws more attention to the building or grounds at night than in the day (LDR, Chapter 9, Section 10. F .5). If possible please provide photometries as part of your TRC plan submittals - it is much easier to identify and correct any deficiencies now than while you are waiting on a permit! 20. The minimum size for a 900 parking stall is 9-ft. x 18-ft. and for 00 (parallel) parking is 9-ft. x 25-ft. (Engineering Design Standard Drawing K-2.) Please correct the detail shown on Sheet C3 of 12 and on the plans. 21. Provide a minimum 10-ft. clearance between water, sanitary sewer and/or storm sewer. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. 22. The minimum diameter for storm sewer is 15-in. (LOR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A.2.a.) Please correct plans accordingly. 23. Lengths of perforated and non-perforated pipe do not appear to have been called out correctly on the Paving, Grading & Drainage plans (Sheets C2 and C3.) Please correct. 24. Provide an engineer's certification on the Drainage Plan as specified in LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2. 25. Indicate by note that catch basin and manhole covers shall be bicycle proof (LOR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5.A.2.g). 26. Specify storm sewer diameters, inlets types, etc. on drainage plan. Indicate grate, rim and invert elevations for all structures. Indicate grade of storm sewer segments. Indicate material specifications for storm sewer. 27. Full drainage plans, including drainage calculations, in accordance with the LDR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 5 will be required at the time of permitting. 28. The Site Tabulation on the Site Plan (Sheet A 1.01) indicates that there will be 18 Live-Work Townhomes, yet I count 27 units. Please explain or correct the discrepancy. 29. Paving, drainage and site details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All engineering construction details shall be in accordance with the applicable City of Boynton Beach Standard Drawings and the "Engineering Design Handbook and Construction Standards" and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. Dept. of Public Works, Engineering Division Memo No. 06-101 RE: Ellipse, New Site Plan - 1 st Review, NWSP 06-021 September 6, 2006 Page 4 UTILITIES 30. Please provide a timeline that clearly illustrates when water and sewer services will be required to serve the proposed project. Your starting date for the timeline should be the date of City Commission approval. Also provide milestone dates for permit application, the start of construction, and the setting of the first water meter. This timeline will be used to determine the adequacy of water and wastewater treatment capacity for your project upon the project's completion, so please be as accurate as possible. 31. All utility easements shall be shown on the Site plan, Landscape and Hardscape plans (as well as the Water and Sewer Plans) so that we may determine which appurtenances, trees or shrubbery may interfere with utilities. In general, palm trees will be the only tree species allowed within utility easements. 32. Canopy trees may be planted outside of the easement so that roots and branches will not impact those utilities within the easement in the foreseeable future. The LOR, Chapter 7.5, Article I, Section 18.1 gives public utilities the authority to remove any trees that interfere with utility services, either in utility easements or public rights-of-way. 33. Palm Beach County Health Department permits will be required for the water and sewer systems serving this project (CODE, Section 26-12). 34. Fire flow calculations will be required demonstrating the City Code requirement of 1,500 g.p.m. (500 g.p.m. some residential developments) with 20 p.s.i. residual pressure as stated in the LOR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16, or the requirement imposed by insurance underwriters, whichever is greater (CODE, Section 26-16(b)). 35. The LOR, Chapter 6, Article IV, Section 16 requires that all points on each building will be within 200 feet of an existing or proposed fire hydrant. Please demonstrate that the plan meets this condition, by showing all hydrants. The northernmost eastern building, the easternmost northern building, the middle of the northernmost western building, a small portion of the Public supermarket, and the easternmost southern building lack sufficient coverage. Please correct. 36. The CODE, Section 26-34(E) requires that a capacity reservation fee be paid for this project either upon the request for the Department's signature on the Health Department application forms or within seven (7) days of site plan approval, whichever occurs first. This fee will be determined based upon final meter size, or expected demand. 37. Comprehensive Plan Policy 3.C.3.4. requires' the conservation of potable water. As other sources are readily available City water shall not be allowed for irrigation. 38. Water and sewer lines to be owned and operated by the City shall be included within utility easements. Please show all proposed easements on the engineering drawings, using a minimum width of 12 feet. The easements shall be dedicated via separate instrument to the City as stated in CODE Sec. 26-33(a). 39. This office will not require surety for installation of the water and sewer utilities, on condition that the systems be fully completed, and given to the City Utilities Department before the first permanent meter is set. Note that setting of a permanent water meter is a prerequisite to obtaining the Certificate of Occupancy. Dept. of Public Works, Engineering Division Memo No. 06-101 RE: Ellipse, New Site Plan - 1 st Review, NWSP 06-021 September 6, 2006 Page 5 40. A building permit for this project shall not be issued until this Department has approved the plans for the water and/or sewer improvements required to service this project, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-15. 41. PVC material not permitted on the City's water system. All lines shall be DIP. 42. The Water & Sanitary Sewer plans reflect numerous 450 bends; please revise to read 22-1/20 bends as no 450 deflections are shown. Check all call-outs to assure they have been correctly identified. 43. Appropriate backflow preventer(s) will be required on the domestic water service to the building, and the fire sprinkler line if there is one, in accordance with the CODE, Section 26-207. 44. Provide a minimum of 10-ft. separation between water main, sanitary sewer, and storm sewer lines. Please note that City of Boynton Beach separation standards are more stringent that FDEP standards. 45. The waste stream from any food preparation area processes must meet the City's pretreatment requirements. A sampling point must be provided to allow monitoring of this waste stream (refer to CODE Section 26-143 and Section 26-147.) 46. All retail buildings are indicated as being fully sprinklered, yet nothing is indicated for the live-work townhomes. Are they to be sprinklered also? 47. All multi-level parking structures (garages); are they to be sprinklered? Spacing of the fire hydrants (see Comment #35) reflects several coverage gaps. 48. There is an existing 6-in. DIP water main running east to west immediately north of the existing Public supermarket, which is not addressed as to be either removed or relocated. In addition, the proposed 8-in. water main run in the middle of the property runnin~ north-south direction is shown as connecting to an existing 6-in. line along the north side of SE 18t Avenue. This is not acceptable. This project will be required to develop a Hardy-Cross analysis of the project site and the surrounding area to determine which external links will need to be upgraded to support this development. 49. Upsize the water main in Woolbright Rd. to meet the requirements of the Utility Master Plan. The main shall be upsized from the west side of the FECRR east to the point of connection (west driveway) for the project. 50. Coordinate with Boynton Beach Fire-Rescue to determine flow requirements for multi-story buildings over four stories. 51. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3(0) requires Master Plans to show all utilities on or adjacent to the proposed tract. The plan must therefore show the point of service for water and sewer, and the proposed off-site utilities construction needed in order to service this project. 52. The LDR, Chapter 3, Article IV, Section 3(P) requires a statement be included that utilities are available and will be provided by all other appropriate agencies. This statement is lacking on the submitted plans. 53. Utility construction details will not be reviewed for construction acceptability at this time. All utility construction details shall be in accordance with the Utilities Department's "Utilities Engineering Dept. of Public Works, Engineering Division Memo No. 06-101 RE: Ellipse, New Site Plan - 1 st Review, NWSP 06-021 September 6, 2006 Page 6 Design Handbook and Construction Standards" manual (including any updates) and will be reviewed at the time of construction permit application. Cc: Jeffrey R. Livergood, P.E., Director, Public Works Peter V. Mazzella, Deputy Utility Director, Utilities H. David Kelley, Jr., P.E.! P.S.M., City Engineer, Public Works/Engineering Glenda Hall, Forestry & Grounds Manager, Public Works/Forestry & Grounds Division Larry Quinn, Solid Waste Manager, Public Works/Solid Waste File S:\Engineering\ Memorandums\Memorandums 2006\06-101 LOGAN-Ellipse (aka Sunshine Square) 090506.doc DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT BUILDING DIVISION MEMORANDUM NO. 06-120 List of Acronvms/Abbreviations: ANSI - American National Standards Institute ASCE - American Society of Civil Engineers CBB - City of Boynton Beach CBBA - Boynton Beach Amendments CBBCO - City of Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances CBBCPP - City of Boynton Beach Comprehensive Plan Policy CFR - Code of Federal Regulations EPA - Environment Protection Agency FBC - Florida Building Code FFHA - Federal Fair Housing Act FFPC - Florida Fire Prevention Code FIRM - Flood Insurance Rate Map F.S. - Florida Statutes LDR - Land Development Regulations NEC - National Electric Code NFPA - National Fire Prevention Assn NGVD - National Geodetic Vertical Datum of 1929 SFWMD - South Florida Water Management District TO: Ed Breese Principal Planner FROM: Timothy K. Large~ TART Member/Building Division DATE: August 22, 2006 SUBJECT: Project - Ellipse File No. - NWSP 06-021 - 1 st review Building Division (Site Specific and Permit Comments) - Timothy K. Large (561) 742-6352 1 Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the TART (Technical Advisory Review Team) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the commission and at permit review. 2 Indicate within the site data the occupancy type of each building as defined in 2004 FBC, Chapter 3. Indicate all occupancies in mixed occupancy buildings. 3 The height and area for buildings or structures of the different types of construction shall be governed by the intended use or occupancy of the building, and shall not exceed the limits set forth in Table 503 of the 2004 FBC. 4 Place a note on the elevation view drawings indicating that the exterior wall openings and exterior wall construction comply with 2004 FBC, Table 704.8. Submit calculations that clearly reflect the percentage of protected and unprotected wall openings permitted per 2004 FBC, Table 704.8. 5 General area modifications to buildings shall be in accordance with 2004 FBC, Section 506. Provide calculations verifying compliance with the above code sections and the 2004 FBC, Table 503. 6 Buildings, structures and parts thereof shall be designed to withstand the minimum wind loads of 140 mph. Wind forces on every building or structure shall be determined by the provisions of ASCE 7, Chapter 6, and the provisions of 2004 FBC, Section 1609 (Wind Loads). Calculations that are signed and sealed by a design professional registered in the state of Florida shall be submitted for review at the time of permit application. 7 Every building and structure shall be of sufficient strength to support the loads and forces encountered per the 2004 FBC, Section 1607 and Table 1607.1. Indicate the live load (pst) on the plans for the building design. S\Development\Building\ T ART\ TART 2006\ Ellipse Page 1 of 5 /~ 8 Buildings three-stories or higher shall be equipped with an automatic sprinkler system per F.S. 553.895. Fire protection plans and hydraulic calculations shall be included with the building plans at the time of permit application. 9 Add to all plan view drawings of the site a labeled symbol that represents the location and perimeter of the limits of construction proposed with the subject request. 10 At time of permit review, submit signed and sealed working drawings of the proposed construction. 11 On the site plan and floor plan, indicate the number of stories that are in each building. Indicate the overall height of each building. 12 Add to each building that is depicted on the drawing titled site plan and floor plan a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building. 2004 FBC, Sections 11-4.1.2, 11-4.1.3, and 11-4.3. 13 As required by LOR, Chapter 4, Section 7, submit a floor plan drawing. The building plans are not being reviewed for compliance with the applicable building codes. Therefore, add the words "Floor plan layout is conceptual" below the drawing titled Floor Plan found on sheetls However, add to the floor space drawing a labeled symbol that identifies the location of the handicap-accessible entrance doors to each building. The location of the door shall match the location of the accessible entrance doors that are depicted on the site plan drawing. 14 Compliance with regulations specified in the FFHA, Design and Construction Requirements, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.205, is required. 15 At the time of permit review, submit details of reinforcement of walls for the future installation of grab bars as required by the FFHA, Title 24 CFR, Part 100.205, Section 3, Requirement #6. All bathrooms within the covered dwelling unit shall comply. 16 Bathrooms and kitchens in the covered dwelling units shall comply with the FFHA, Title 24 CFR 100.205. Indicate on the plans which design specification ("A" or "B") of the FFHA is being used. The clear floor space at fixtures and appliances and turning diameters shall be clearly shown on the plans. 17 If an accessible route has less than 60 inches clear width, then passing spaces at least 60 inches by 60 inches shall be located at reasonable intervals not to exceed 200 feet. A 'T'- intersection of two corridors or walks is an acceptable passing place. 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.3.4. 18 Identify within the site data the finish floor elevation (lowest floor elevation) that is proposed for the building. Verify that the proposed elevation is in compliance with regulations of the code by adding specifications to the site data that address the following issues: A The design professional-of-record for the project shall add the following text to the site data. "The proposed finish floor elevation _' _ NGVD is above the highest 100-year base flood elevation applicable to the building site, as determined by the SFWMD's surface water management construction development regulations." S\Oevelopment\Building\ T ART\ TART 2006\ Ellipse Page 2 of 5 B From the FIRM map, identify in the site data the title of the flood zone that the building is located within. Where applicable, specify the base flood elevation. If there is no base flood elevation, indicate that on the plans. C Identify the floor elevation that the design professional has established for the building within the footprint of the building that is shown on the drawings titled site plan, floor plan and paving/drainage (civil plans). 19 As required by the CBBCO, Part III titled "Land Development Regulations", submit a site plan that clearly depicts the setback dimensions from each property line to the leading edge of the buildings. The leading edge of the buildings begins at the closest point of the overhang or canopy to the property line. In addition, show the distance between all the buildings on all sides. 20 CBBCPP 3.C.3.4 requires the conservation of potable water. City water may not, therefore, be used for landscape irrigation where other sources are readily available. 21 A water-use permit from SFWMD is required for an irrigation system that utilizes water from a well or body of water as its source. A copy of the permit shall be submitted at the time of permit application, F.S. 373.216. 22 If capital facility fees (water and sewer) are paid in advance to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department, the following information shall be provided at the time of building permit application: A The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. B If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. C The number of dwelling units in each building. D The number of bedrooms in each dwelling unit. E The total amount paid and itemized into how much is for water and how much is for sewer. (CBBCO, Chapter 26, Article II, Sections 26-34) 23 At time of permit review, submit separate surveys of each lot, parcel, or tract. For purposes of setting up property and ownership in the City computer, provide a copy of the recorded deed for each lot, parcel, or tract. The recorded deed shall be submitted at time of permit review. 24 At time of building permit application, submit verification that the City of Boynton Beach Parks and Recreation Impact Fee requirements have been satisfied by a paid fee or conveyance of property. The following information shall be provided: A A legal description of the land. B The full name of the project as it appears on the Development Order and the Commission-approved site plan. C If the project is a multi-family project, the building number/s must be provided. The building numbers must be the same as noted on the Commission-approved site plans. D The number of dwelling units in each building. E The total amount being paid. (CBBCO, Chapter 1, Article V, Section 3(f)) S\Development\Building\ T ART\ TART 2006\ Ellipse Page 3 of 5 25 Add a general note to the site plan that all plans submitted for permitting shall meet the City's codes and the applicable building codes in effect at the time of permit application. 26 Pursuant to approval by the City Commission and all other outside agencies, the plans for this project must be submitted to the Building Division for review at the time of permit application submittal. The plans must incorporate all the conditions of approval as listed in the development order and approved by the City Commission. 27 The full address of the project shall be submitted with the construction documents at the time of permit application submittal. The addressing plan shall be approved by the United States Post Office, the City of Boynton Beach Fire Department, the City's GIS Division, and the Palm Beach County Emergency 911. A Palm Beach County Planning, Zoning & Building Division, 100 Australian Avenue, West Palm Beach, Florida (Sean McDonald - 561-233-5013) B United States Post Office, Boynton Beach (Michelle Bullard - 561-734-0872) 28 Show the proposed site lighting on the site and landscape plans. (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.B.4) If possible, provide photo metrics as part of your TART plan submittals. 29 Add to the floor plan drawings of the individual units a breakdown of the area within the unit. The area breakdowns for each unit shall specify the total area of the unit, area of the balcony, total area that is air-conditioned and, where applicable, total area of storage and garage space. If the garage and storage areas are not part of a specific unit, the area shall be included and identified within the area of the building. Indicate how many of each type of unit will be on each floor and within the building. 30 Add to the site data the total area under roof of each residential building. Provide tabular area data for each floor of each building. The breakdown shall include the following areas and each area shall be labeled on the applicable floor plan drawing: A Common area covered walkways; B Covered stairways; C Common area balconies; D Entrance area outside of a unit; E Storage areas (not part of a unit); F Garages (not part of a unit); G Elevator room; H Electrical room; I Mechanical room; J Trash room; K Mailbox pickup and delivery area; and L Any other area under roof. (Chapter 4 - Site Plan Review, Section 7.E.2 and 3) 31 This structure meets the definition of a threshold building per F.S. 553.71 (7) and shall comply with the requirements of F.S. 553.79 and the CBBA to the 2004 FBC, Sections 109.3.6.1 through 109.3.6.6. The following information must be submitted at the time of permit application: A The structural inspection plan must be submitted to the enforcing agency prior to the issuance of a building permit for the construction of a threshold building. B All shoring and re-shoring procedures, plans and details shall be submitted. S\Development\Building\ TARn TART 2006\ Ellipse Page 4 of 5 C All plans for the building that are required to be signed and sealed by the architect or engineers of record shall contain a statement that, to the best of the architect's or engineer's knowledge, the plans and specifications comply with the applicable fire safety standards as determined by the local authority in accordance with this section and F.S. Section 633. 32 If this project is located within the Downtown Stormwater Improvement Watershed, appropriate fees must be paid to the City of Boynton Beach Utilities Department prior to the issuance of a building permit per the CBBCa, Chapter 26, Section 26-406. Proof of payment shall be submitted to the Building Division at the time of permit application submittal. 33 Indicate on the plans the square footage per floor of the parking garages. Comply with the area and height requirements of 2004 FBC, Table 503. 34 A mechanical ventilation system is required in the parking garages per the 2004 FBC, Section 406.4.2. 35 The passenger loading zone for the CRA trolley shall comply with the handicap accessibility requirements of the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.1.2(c). 36 Sheet A2.01 lIB - Phase lIB Parking Garage - Relocate one of the handicap parking spaces to the north side of the garage. Handicap parking spaces shall be located per the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.6.2. 37 Van accessible parking spaces shall be provided in the parking structures per the 2004 FBC, Section 11-4.1.2(5)(6). Identify on the plans. 38 Location of exits in residential buildings shall comply with 2004 FBC, Section 1015.1 and Table 1015.1 for exit access travel distance. 39 Indicate the overall height of the buildings on the elevation plans. 40 The buildings shall comply with 2004 FBC, Section 403 for high-rise buildings. 41 Indicate the occupancy type and type of construction for the residential buildings. 42 Sheet A2.04 IB - The floor plan does not depict all rooms, corridors, stair enclosures, etc. bf S\Development\Building\ T ART\ TART 2006\ Ellipse Page 5 of 5 TRC Memorandum Page 1 of2 ." Coale, Sherie From: Hallahan, Kevin Sent: Friday, August 25, 2006 2:54 PM To: Coale, Sherie Cc: Breese, Ed Subject: Ellipse- TART comments Planning Memorandum: Forester / Environmentalist To: Ed Breese, Principal Planner From: Kevin J. Hallahan, Forester / Environmentalist Subject: Ellipse New Site Plan - 1st Review NWSP 06-021 Date: August 25, 2006 Boundary Survey Existing Trees Management Plan Sheet 1 of 1 The Landscape Architect should tabulate the total diameter inches of existing trees on the site. The tabular data should show the individual species of trees proposed to be preserved in place, relocated or removed and replaced on site. The replacement trees should be shown by a separate symbol on the landscape plan sheet LND5 of 5. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article I Sec. 7.D.p. 2.] Plant Palette Legend Sheet LND5 of 5 1. All shade and palm trees must be listed in the description as a minimum of 12'-14' height, 3" DBH (4.5' offthe ground) not caliper, and Florida #1 (Florida Grades and Standards manual). The height of the trees may be larger than 12'-14' to meet the 3" diameter requirement; or any clear trunk (c.t.) specifications. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C. 2.] 2. The landscape design does not include the City signature trees (Tibochina granulosa) at the ingress / egress areas to the site. These trees must meet the minimum size specifications for trees. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5.C.3.N.] 3. All trees proposed under any existing overhead electric power lines must meet the FP & L Right tree in the Right Place manual selection for small trees only. 4. The landscape sheet shade tree planting detail should including a line indicating where the diameter and height of all of the trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. 5. The landscape sheet palm tree planting detail should include a line indicating where the height of all of the palm trees will be measured at time of planting and inspection. 6. The landscape sheet shrub and groundcover planting detail should include a line indicating where the height and spread of the shrubs and groundcover plants will be measured at time of planting 8/2512006 TRC Memorandum Page 2 of2 and inspection. 7. The applicant should add a note that all utility boxes or structures (not currently known or shown on the plan) should be screened with Coco plum hedge plants on three sides. The landscape sheet details indicating use of soil amendments for each of the plantings should indicate structural soil for all planting areas on the site. The total quantity of required structural soil should be added to the plant palette legend. 8. The applicant should show an elevation cross-section detail of the actual heights of the proposed landscape trees and vegetation at the time of planting to (proper scale) visually buffer the proposed buildings and parking lot from the Woolbright Road, Federal Highway and S.E. 18th Avenue road rights-of-ways. 9. Many of the landscape symbols are missing the species number or identification letters on the landscape sheets. 10. The total quantities of each of the plant materials are not shown in the legend. .Irrigation Plan 11. Turf and landscape (bedding plants) areas should be designed on separate zones and time duration for water conservation. 12. Trees should have separate irrigation bubblers to provide water directly to the root ball. [Environmental Regulations, Chapter 7.5, Article II Sec. 5. C.2.] Kjh 8/25/2006 Boynton Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Project Review Report Date: Project No: Name: Location: Type of Project: Size of Site: Number of Units: DUlAC: Sq. Ft. of Bldgs: FAR: Sq. Ft. Retail: Sq. Ft. of Office: Existing Land Use: Proposed Land Use: Existing Zoning: Proposed Zoning: Annexation: Abandonment: Parking Required: Parking Provided: Height: Developer: Contact: Phone: Architect: Phone: eRA Comments: August 28, 2006 NWSP 06-021 - 1 st Review Ellipse SW Comer of Woolbright /Federal (Sunshine Square) Mixed-Use 14.43 acres 576 39.92 dulac 1,698,425 sq. ft. 1.71 147,756 10,946 LRC MUL C3 MUL3 No No 154-1 bd.@ 1.5 = 231 422 - 2 bd. @ 2.0 = 844 Retail- 1 per 200 sq. ft. = 739 Office - 1 per 200 sq. ft. = 55 ULI Shared Parking Calculations - 1,684 77' RAM Development Hugo Pacanins 954-981-4116 Marc Weiner 561-750-4111 1. Add shared parking calculations to site plan. 2. Application for height exception needed. 3. Please follow CRA Presentation Guidelines for CRA Public Hearing (attached). SUNSHINE SQUARE / ELLIPSE PROJECT LUAR 06-016 & NWSP 06-021 Planning 1st Review Comments 9/7/06 At the technical advisory review team (TART) meeting, provide written responses to all staffs comments and questions. Submit 12 sets of revised plans. Each set should be folded and stapled. At the technical advisory review team meeting, also provide a full set of reduced drawings, sized 8Y2 inches by 11 inches of each plan. Save each plan to a compact disk and submit that to staff as well. All comments requiring changes and/or corrections to the plans shall be reflected on all appropriate sheets. Please note that changes or revisions to these plans may generate additional comments. Acceptance of these plans during the Technical Advisory Review Team (TART) process does not ensure that additional comments may not be generated by the Commission and at permit review. Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon the approval of the corresponding request (LUAR 06- 016) to amend the future land use designation from Local Retail Commercial (LRC) to Mixed Use (MX) and to rezone from Community Commercial (C-3) to Mixed Use Low Intensity 3 (MU-L3). Site plan approval of this project is contingent upon submittal and approval of a corresponding request for a height exception of 10 feet (max height in MU-L3 is 75 feet). A drainage statement is required prior to the Technical Application Review Team (TART) meeting (Chapter 4, Section 7.F.2.). All proposed uses and their respective building areas must match between the traffic study and the site plan. In addition, the letter from PBC Traffic dated June 21, 2006 requires a revised traffic study. The revised traffic study will be required prior to the CRA meeting (Chapter 4. Section 8.F.). Staff would prefer to have the revised traffic study by the TART meeting tentatively scheduled for October 3, 2006. Provide a notice of concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards Review) from Palm Beach County Traffic Engineering. The traffic impact analysis must be approved by the Palm Beach County Traffic Division for concurrency purposes prior to the issuance of any building permits. Revise site plan application: (page 1, Section 1.1.) to include new project name; (page 2, Section 11.1.) to revise to MX land use; (page 2, Section 11.2.) to revise to MU-L3 zoning district; (page 2, Section 11.3.) to switch site area to 14.43 acres and square feet to 628,727 sf. Revise site plan application (page 3, Section 5.e.) to include pervious area of 3.44 acres or 23.83% of site (5.h. should be total of5.e.-5.g.) The site plan application (page 3, Section 11.6.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) for floor area breakdown do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed square footage for each use and to make application and plans consistent. The site plan application (page 4, Section 1I.7.c.3-4) total 404 2- and 3+-bedrooms, and site plan tabular (A1.0I) bedroom count info for required parking does not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number for each unit type / size and to make application and plans consistent. The site plan application (page 4, Section 11.8.) and site plan tabular (Al.0l) density is 39.9168 dulac, this should be rounded to 39.92 du/ac. The site plan application (page 4, Section 11.9.) should also include maximum number of stories proposed. The site plan application (page 4, Section 1I.10.a.) should clarify requirement of 14 spaces per 200 sf and what code provision this is based upon. Also each live/work unit requires 2.5 spaces per unit. The site plan application (page 4, Section 11.1 O.b.) requires a calculation for required number of handicap parking spaces. Submit two (2) copies of the shared parking analysis (signed and sealed by a licensed traffic engineer). Provide details of shared parking analysis on site plan application (page 4, Section 11.10.) and site plan (A1.01). The site plan application (page 4, Section II.10.a.) and site plan tabular (A1.01) parking counts do not match. Revise to reflect the accurate proposed number of spaces required and number of spaces provided and to make application and plans consistent. Clarify that site will be developed as one parcel under a Unity of Title, or if there will be separately owned parcels under a Unity of Control. If separate parcels, provide parcel boundaries, lot dimensions, and setbacks from the lot lines. A recorded Unity of Title or Unity of Control will be required prior to the issuance of a building permit. Indicate bolder phase lines on all plans. Provide phasing information, including building square footage per use, total square footage, and parking required/provided per phase in site tabular on sheet A 1.0 1. Submit LLC corporate papers which name principal authorized to sign on behalf of Sunshine Square CRP, LLC. Submit large colored renderings (clipped not glued to foamboard) of project at the TART meeting. These will be displayed at the public hearings. Submit color chips of proposed building colors noted on elevations. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure that the new site plan is publicly advertised in accordance with Ordinance 04-007. The applicant is responsible for compliance with Ordinance 05-060, the "Art in Public Places" program, and must demonstrate their participation. Update and complete the Public Art Information Form submitted May 19,2006. Correct zoning district (not category) in tabular site data on cover sheet A1.01 to MU-L3 (Mixed Use Low Intensity 3) and Land Use Designation is Mixed Use (MX). Revise parcels labeled as "NIC" to "Not Included". NIC is used by this office as "NOT IN CITY". On site plan and landscape plan, show as-built conditions of adjacent parcels which are not included in the project. Demonstrate how proposed structures with minimal or no setbacks and required landscaping will be maintained (including the side of Publix adjacent to the RR tracks). Foundation landscaping is required in these areas, but not provided. The review of applications for MU-L3 shall emphasize aesthetics and design quality, and physical compatibility with adjacent land uses. Demonstrate how the proposed development will tie in with gas station on comer and parcel on SE 18th Ave. through fa9ade and landscaping upgrades and connectivity. Perimeter landscaping is required along the common property lines adjacent to the gas station and adjacent to properties fronting SE 18th Ave. Revise landscape plan to provide required perimeter/foundation landscaping in these locations. A landscape easement on adjacent property may be considered if parties agree to all terms. Submit a perspective view from Federal and Woolbright of Ph IA North and East elevations which includes the existing gas station to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing gas station. Submit a perspective view from Federal and SE 18th Ave of Ph ill South and East elevations which includes the existing development on parcel not included to demonstrate how the designs/facades of buildings and parking structure and landscaping will visually connect with the existing development offsite. Prior to TART meeting, submit draft cross-access easements for future cross access to gas station, and a letter from gas station owner that he is willing to enter into the recorded cross access easement agreements prior to the first CO. Submit a phasing plan and construction time line which details what will be completed in each phase before starting next phase (road improvements, parking, traffic circulation, landscaping) and how existing tenants are to be relocated. On the site plan tabular data (A1.01 and .02), indicate the maximum allowable FAR in MU-L3 district and the proposed FAR. Provide tabular parking space breakdown for residential versus nonresidential uses and number of spaces for each type. Clarify within tabular information on plans if multifamily units will be rentals or condominium. Provide graphic and written scales on all plans. Provide legible floor plans for each proposed building. The area west of Publix is shown as pervious (sod) on landscape and hardscape plans, yet the site plan shows a walkway along side of building. Please revise plans to match. Provide details of where residential parking spaces are located, and how the spaces for residential will be differentiated from the spaces for nonresidential. Clearly label all bearings and distances for all property lines on plans. The property legal description on sheet Al.0 1 is not consistent with legal on survey (typos noted). Revise legal description to include acreage to the nearest 1/l00th of an acre and total square footage of property (at end of legal). Submit a copy of revised legal with acreage/sf in Word format on a CD for file. Clarify actual acreage of property (legal description is 14.42, application and tabular is 14.43). Dimension ultimate R/W and U.E. widths and depict / label centerlines of all rights-of-way. Indicate all existing easements to remain and those to be abandoned or relocated. Indicate location, purpose, and width of all proposed easements on site and adjacent to subject property. Include a typical floor plan for each residential unit model which notes exterior dimensions, number of bedrooms, AlC area sf, total unit size, etc. (Chapter 4, Section 7.D.l.). Indicate additional detail on the building elevations regarding the MU-L3 locational requirements for arterials to clarify how much of a stepback is provided between the residential units and retail uses. For structures greater than 45 feet in height the frontage on any street is required to provide a 10 foot setback at 35 feet plus 10 for each additional 50 feet in height. For heights greater that 75 feet this shall be provided in two 10-foot stepbacks. Provide building elevations (of all buildings sides) of each building and provide the floor area of each building (Chapter 4, Section 7.E.2.). Provide a graphic depicting view of the garage from the courtyard of the building in Ph 1m. Supplemental landscaping especially around foundation of building and parking structure, decorative features, and benches are needed in this location (add to landscape plan). Label each building on the site plan with the number of floors and building height. Also, please provide an additional unstapled set of separate building elevations for each building that is subject to the height exception (exceeding 75 feet). These elevations will be used separately as part of the height exception presentation to the Board. Revise all plans to demonstrate that front setbacks are measured from arcades along Federal and Woolbright in compliance with the MU-L3 front setback of 0-10 feet. Specify if proposed development will include a bank. If so, provide details in tabular for bank use, floor location, square footage, and specify with or without drive-thru teller facilities. A bank with drive up teller facilities requires conditional use approval (separate application). All proposed uses must be consistent with the MU -L3 zoning district identified in Chapter 2 of the Land Development Regulations. Please submit a list of permissible uses for the Live/W ork units that will be included into the bylaws for the development (refer to Ch. 2, Section 6.H.15. Live/Work Permissible Uses in SMU District for uses). All proposed outdoor dining areas must have a sidewalk cafe permit and comply with all requirements for such. The trash enclosures shall resemble with respect to the color and materials, the design of the principal buildings and shall be integrated with other site elements (Chapter 9, Section 10.E.3.). On the site plan, place a note indicating this requirement. Equipment placed on the walls of the buildings shall be painted to match the building color (Chapter 9, Section 10.CA.). Place a note on the elevations indicating this requirement. The removal/relocation of trees is subject to review and approval of the City Forester / Environmentalist. Trees are required to be at least 12 feet overall height at the time of installation (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.C.2.) and with multi-story developments trees placed around the buildings must be a minimum of Y2 the height of the building. The Royal Palm specifications appear incorrect, indicating only a 6 foot to 8 foot height. All required shrubs are to be at minimum 24 inches in height, 24 inches in spread, and planted with tip-to- tip spacing measured immediately after planting to adequately cover the planted areas on the site (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.CA.). A minimum of fifty percent (50%) of site landscape materials in each category (palms, canopy trees, shrubs, groundcovers) must be native species. Indicate amount of each species proposed and if native material, and indicate a total % native provided for each category in the plant list of the landscape plan (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.P). Landscaping at project entrances shall contain a signature tree at both sides of the entrance (Chapter 7.5, Article II, Section 5.N.). A signature tree is a tree with blossoms or natural color other than green intended to beautify project entrances and contribute to the city's image with this element of aesthetic conformity. Signatures trees include Yellow Elder, Tibouchina Granulosa, and Bougainvillea. Note that signature trees do not contribute toward the total number of required perimeter trees. Signature trees must have 6 feet of clear trunk if placed within the safe-sight triangle (Chapter 7.5, Article 2, Section 5.N.). Depict paver sidewalks along Federal Highway on the site plan and landscape plan. Also note on plans that sidewalks shall be Hollandstone pavers, red / charcoal color mix by Paver Systems Inc. or equal, laid in a 45 herringbone pattern to continue the design elements in place along Federal Highway (Chapter 2, Section 5.F.8.d.(2). Provide a typical drawing that includes the height and color / material of all proposed freestanding outdoor lighting poles. The design, style, and illumination level shall be compatible with the building design (height) and shall consider safety, function, and aesthetic value (Chapter 9, Section 10.F.1.). Show proposed freestanding site lighting locations on the site plan and landscape plan (LDR, Chapter 4, Section 7.BA.). Staff recommends incorporating an upgraded Palm Tran bus stop shelter into the design of the project along Federal Highway. Coordinate with Palm Tran and provide a written response at the TART meeting. In addition, please include an architectural detail of proposed bus shelter on plans. Staff recommends the submittal of a master sign program as part of this site plan process to encourage continuity for signage, while allowing for flexibility with respect to type, color, and design of signs. On the building elevations indicate the cumulative area of wall signage to ensure that it complies with Chapter 21, Article 4, Section C.). In addition, indicate the sign type, letter colors and sign material (per the proposed Master Sign Program). Be advised that a Publix sign will not be allowed on the parking structure as depicted in the elevations (Ph lA East). A Publix wall sign is allowed on the building wall of Publix store, and shall not extend above the parapet of the building or beyond the building comers. The maximum sign area for Publix is 1.5 sf of area for each one (1) foot oflinear frontage. On site plan, the size of the two (2) proposed freestanding monument signs differs, yet the typical sign detail provided on sheet Al.04 appears to apply to both signs. Then there is a separate detail of an entry monument sign on H7 of 7. Please clarify by providing all signage details in one location on plans, and by noting which sign detail applies to which right-of-way. Revise sign elevations to clearly identify the proposed sign area with new name of development and show the site address at the top of the monument sign (Chapter 21, Article 4, Section 5.B.). Also provide materials and colors of sign structure, sign face, and font on sign details. Show the locations of fire hydrants and utility poles on all plans. Revise building elevations (Ph IIA West) to provide architectural enhancements to west side of Publix building, and provide varying levels oflandscaping up to a minimum of Y2 the building height. Recreational amenities for 576 dwelling units are located solely in Ph m on fourth level of parking garage. There will be no recreational amenities available for the 126 units in Ph IA (until completion of next Ph m). Revise plans to provide recreation throughout the development that is more available to units in other phases. Staff recommends revising the other two parking garages to provide similar recreational amenities for units wrapped around those garages. Ph IA grade level parking has a parallel parking space designated as a handicap space. Revise location of this space. Clarify lines for parking spaces in garages, and draw all spaces to scale. Check parking counts for each floor plan of each garage in each phase and ensure that parking provided breakdown and totals on tabular (sheet A1.01) match. Provide a plan which shows pedestrian connections and pedestrian circulation, walkway widths, and plazas. Include details on plans of fountains proposed in north and south commons. S:\Planning\Shared\Wp\Projects\Sunshine Square\NWSP 06-021 \Planning 1st Review Comments.doc