The URL can be used to link to this page

CORRESPONDENCE " , , ""..0,.. .." '. ~"II "-" LAKE WORTH DRAINAGE DISTRICT ~>,--^-^-.AJ Board of Supervisors C, Stanley Weaver John I. Whitworth III Murray R. Kalish C, David Goodlett James M. Alderman Secretary/Manager William G. Winters 13081 MILITARY TRAIL DELRAY BEACH, FLORIDA 33484-1105 Assistanf Manager Ronald L. Crone Anorney Perry & Kern. P.A, January 18, 2006 Russell Morrison Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 4431 Embarcadaro Drive West Palm Beach, FL 33407 Re: LWDD Permit #04-7482D.02; Boynton Town CenterNillage, Sembler Company, f1kJa KlattIWoolbright Property Re: Chancery Review, 20/45/43, NE Quad Old Boynton Road and Congress, Lots 68-76 and Lots 77-93, PB/Miami Land Dev Co Plat, LWDD E-4 and Boynton Canals Dear Mr. Morrison: Attached is the original permit for the above referenced project. This permit is being issued in duplicate. Please have the owner of the referenced project (Owner Permittee). print or type and sign his/her name on both of the attached copies of the permit and return both signed copies to LWDD for final execution. A copy of the final executed permit will be returned to you. Please be advised, the permit is not valid until both copies have been signed by both the owner (Owner Permittee) and the Lake Worth Drainage District (Permitter). Construction within the Lake Worth Drainage District rights-of-way prior to receiving the final executed permit is not allowed. Do not hesitate to call this office if you have any questions. Sincerely. ISTRICT ~ RECEIVED JAN 3 1 2006 LWDD JGW:kjr Attachments Delray Beach & Boca Raton (561) 498-5363. Boynton Beach & West Palm Beach (561) 737-3835. Fax (561) 495,9694 Websile: www.LWDD.nel '.. .' '", '-' ~'" """ LAKE WORTH DRAINAGE DISTRICT ~,~^,,-,,^,--/ Boald of Supervisors C. Stanley Weaver John I. Whitworth III Murray R. Kalish C. David Goodlett James M. Alderman Secretary/Manager William G. Winters 13081 MILITARY TRAIL DELRAY BEACH. FLORIDA 33484-1105 Assistant Manager Ronald L. Crone AtlornfOY Perry & Kern, P.A. January 18, 2006 1950 Congress Ave., LLC c/o Jeffrey S. Fuqua, V.P. 1450 S. Johnson Ferry Rd., #100 Atlanta, GA 30319 Re: LWOO Permit #04-74820.02; Boynton Town CenterNillage, Sembler Company, f1kJa KlattIWoolbright Property Re: Chancery Review, 20/45/43, NE Quad Old Boynton Road and Congress, Lots 68-76 and Lots 77-93, PB/Miami Land Dev Co Plat, LWDD E-4 and Boynton Canals Dear Mr. Fuqua: We have reviewed the drainage plans for the above referenced project and do hereby approve of them for connection to our facilities, subject to the following conditions: (X) Permittee shall reconstruct canal(s) to approved design section along and adjacent to the project's limits, including clearing and proper sloping of the maintenance berms. The cleared canal berms and side slopes shall be stabilized. Type of stabilization shall be approved by LWDD. This construction shall be completed prior to any building activity adjacent to LWDD rights-of-way. Please be advised that any fill material scheduled to be removed from the canal may not be relied on for site work. (X) The emergency control type structure(s) shall remain closed at all times unless specific written approval is granted by the Lake Worth Drainage District for its operation. At no time, shall the structure(s) be operated to bypass the water quality detention requirements for the project or to lower the lake levels below the permitted control elevation for the project. If for whatever reason, it is determined that the permittee is not complying with the directives of the LWDD, and/or is operating the structure(s) contrary to their intended purpose as an emergency outflow, the structure(s) shall be modified by LWDD to render the emergency structure(s) inoperable. In addition, the emergency structure(s) shall be equipped with a lock mechanism to prevent its unauthorized use, and a staff gage shall be installed upstream of the structure(s) so that lake levels within the project can be quickly determined. By accepting this permit, the permittee and/or assigns agrees to allow LWDD to ingress/egress and render the emergency portion of the structure(s) inoperable for non-compliance. (X) The Permittee is to construct any sidewalk or pathway that is proposed within LWDD right-of- way with six inch thick concrete, or to meet LWDD approved alternate loading and material(s). The LWDD will not be held responsible or be held liable for any damage to the sidewalk or pathway resulting from LWDD operations and maintenance procedures, or any property damage or personal injury caused by any sidewalk or pathway damage within LWDD right-of- way. All repairs are to be the responsibility of the Permittee. Oelray Beach & Boca Raton (56 t) 498-5363. Boynton Beac~ & West Palm Beach (561) 737-3835 . Fax (561) 495-9694 Website: www.LWDD.net " I LAKE'OVvORTH DRAIN;GE DISTRICT ",",,, ~ January 18, 2006 LWOO Permit #04-74820.02 (X) Permittee or Permittee's representative shall notify the LWDD Inspection Department 48 hours prior to any work within District rights-of-way to coordinate the extent of work to be completed. All facilities needing inspection must be observed prior to backfilling (X) Permittee shall restore LWDD's rights-of-way to its original or better conditions where disturbed by construction activity. (X) The Lake Worth Drainage District cannot accept any water from dewatering either on or off-site until written notification of approval from SFWMD has been submitted to this office. (X) It shall be the responsibility of the permittee to locate and protect any underground facilities within LWDD's rights-of-way prior to construction. (X) Permittee shall take all reasonable precautions necessary to prevent turbidity or silting upstream or downstream during construction. (X) At the time of installation, a permanent benchmark shall be established on top of the control structure(s) with the elevation c1earlv defined. (X) Where improvements are erected on lots or parcels contiguous to LWDO canals, the developer shall install gutters and downspouts eliminating surplus water overland flow, assuring the route of said water into the on-site drainage facility and/or storm sewer system. (X) Permittee shall submit "record drawings" within sixty (60) days of project completion. Drawings should show perimeter grading at or above the design storm and control structure dimensions and elevations. Failure on the Developer/Owner/Permittee's part to provide these drawings within the time specified, will result in LWOD requesting that all permits involved within this project be put on hold until they are received. (X) Permittee shall obtain any and all permits required by EPA, FDEP, USACE, FOOT, SFWMD, Palm Beach County, and/or any municipality that may be involved, prior to the commencement of any construction. (X) Permittee agrees that the stormwater discharge authorized by this permit shall comply with all applicable provisions of Part IV of Chapter 373, Florida Statutes, as well as applicable management and storage of surface water rules, including but not limited to, 40E-4.301, 40E- 400.215, and 40E-400.315, Florida Administrative Code, and Section 5.2 of the SFWMD Basis of Review. All costs of correcting any violations of SFWMD law and rules shall be the exclusive obligation of permittee. (X) All unpermitted drainage facilities installed before or during construction shall be removed prior to the project's final acceptance. () Permittee has provided a bond in favor of LWDD in the amount of 110% of the cost of the pipe and its installation. Bond can be released upon issuance of final inspection by LWDD and developer's submittal of "record drawings" to LWOO. 2 ,. - . , . LNI.~ WORTH DRAINAGE DISTRICT "~' .'" h' ",,.; ""'" January 18, 2006 lWDD Permit #04-74820.02 (X) Permittee agrees that significant construction must start within one year to the date of permit issuance or this permit is void and a new permit must be applied for prior to any construction activity on site. The new application must meet current operating policies. (X) The Permittee, assigns, or successors in title agree to operate and maintain the drainage system in perpetuity. Permittee acknowledges that Lake Worth Drainage District is exempt from liability for personal injury and damages that may arise as a result of the issuance of this Permit by virtue of Florida Statute, Chapter No. 2003-344. In consideration of and by acceptance of the permit issued by the LWDD, the undersigned agrees to perform the above; and further agrees to indemnify and hold harmless LWDD for any damages or injuries emanating out of, or resulting from the permit herein granted. That any non-compliance by permittee of the above conditions will result in the cancellation of this permit and the withholding of Certificates of Occupancy. Further, undersigned represents that permittee is the owner of the project. LAKE WORTH DRAINAGE DISTF~_ By ~.~~ William G. Winters PERMITTER This permit is issued in duplicate. Please sign both copies and return both copies to LWDD for signature. The permit is valid only after both the permitter and permittee have signed. Construction in District rights-of-way prior to receiving the executed permit is not allowed. Owner. SEMBLER F AM1L Y P ARTNERSH1P # 35 LTD. a Florida limited partnership gualified 10 do bus'iness In the State of Georgia as Sembler Family Partnership # 35, Ltd. (L.P.) . By Sembler Retail lnc.. a FJonda C01poldlion, lis sole general panner 3 ,.,....."..,"" -"., ''-"' -......; tL. ~6 ?~ February l, 2006 Mr. Carl Klepper Compson Associates, Inc. 980 North Federal Highway Suite 200 Boca Raton, Florida 33432 RE: Portions of Boynton Village and Boynton Town Center L-wOO ,.1..(: ,')/-"')\/0 '1"<'-'-" \+ Dear Mr. Klepper, Please find attached a copy of the Lake Worth Drainage District Irrigation Connection Permit. This is provided as a courtesy copy for your reference. Please call with any questions. ~'~ Sara Holt The Sembler Company cc: John Quesnell cc: Steve Liller cc: Richard Foreman cc: File l. L _yC Vf' The Sembler Company Shopping Center Development & Management 1450 South Johnson Ferry Road, Suite 100. Atlanta, Georgia 30319.404-847-1800. Fax 404-847-1818 "" ,........, ......., """'" IRRIGATION CONNECTION PERMIT ICP #05-7482E.03 l WDO E-4 Canal January 12, 2006 ISSUED TO: 1950 Congress Ave., HC Clo Jeffrey S. Fuqua PERMITTEE 1450 S. Johnson Ferry Road, #100 Atlanta, GA 30319 ADDRESS This permit is issued by L WOO as a temporary license to use or occupy l WOO works or lands to locate irrigation facilities, as further described on Exhibit" A" (description of location) and Exhibit "B" (drawing). This permit does not create any right or entitlement, either legal or equitable, to the continued use of lWDD works or lands by permittee. By acceptance of this permit, the permittee expressly acknowledges that the permittee bears all risks of loss that may result from issuance and/or revocation of this permit. Permittee agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Lake Worth Drainage District (lWDD) and its successors and/or assigns from any and all damages, injuries, claims or liabilities which may arise by reason of the construction, maintenance or use of the work or structure involved in this permit. The permittee, by acceptance of this permit, hereby agrees to promptly comply with all orders of LWDD and shall alter, repair or remove its use solely at its expense within thirty (30) days of notification from LWDD. Permittee shall comply with all laws, rules and policies administered by lWDD. This permit does not convey to permittee any property rights or any rights, privileges, or interest other than those specified herein, nor relieves the permittee from complying with any law, regulation, or requirement affecting the rights of other governmental entities or agencies. All structures and works installed by permittee hereunder shall remain the property of the permittee. l WOO makes no representations or warranties as to the continued availability, quantity or quality of any water being withdrawn from its canal system. Permittee assumes all responsibility and liability for any water withdrawn from lWOD canals. Permittee holds lWDD harmless and releases lWDO from any damages or injuries that may arise with withdrawal of any water from LWDD's canal system in conjunction with the Consumptive Use Permit being issued by SFWMD. l WOO retains the right to object to or otherwise challenge the issuance of any application for water use permit with SFWMD. This permit is not valid until lWDD receives written confirmation from SFWMD that the Consumptive Water Use Permit associated with this Irrigation Connection Permit has been issued by SFWMD. Any violation of the SFWMD Consumptive Water Use Permit shall be considered a violation of this permit. Af/ existing and future fees associated with this permit will be borne by the permittee. All rights transferred herein to permittee shall be inferior to the rights of lWDD. Permittee acknowledges that lake Worth Drainage District is exempt from liability for personal injury and damages that may arise as a result of the issuance of this Permit by virtue of Florida Statute, Chapter No. 2003-344. WORK PROPOSED, WilL BE COMPLETED ON OR BEFORE ,20 otherwise, this permit is void and all rights hereunder are automatically canceled unless an extension to the construction period is applied for and granted. l WOO inspector shall have the right to field adjust any part of the installation within l WDD's right-of-way. LIMITING CONDITIONS attached hereto are made a part hereof by this reference. 1 Revised 11/04/03 ,""..,,,,- "1"","'0 """'" '-" ICP #05-7482E.03 L WOO E-4 Canal January 12,2006 A duplicate copy of this permit shall be on site at all times during the constru<Jion and installment phase of this permit. PERMITIER: LAKE WOR1H DRAINAGE OIS1RICl, PERMITTEE: By ~~t. /' iliamG.Wi rs Manager Owne r: SEMBLER F:\;'\1J1 Y PARTNERSHIP i; 35.1 TO. o FJondo LmJ1td panmr;rup qualifIed 10 do busme;s m the 5"" 01 CeoTb'J '" Sflnbln Farmh Partntr,;rup = ;S, (LP) Bv Semblfl Rnul Jne . J FlondJ e ~rpora"on, II> sole general p,rtn /' Je LIMITING CONOIlIONS: lts: Vce e em/AssisTanT Secrel;JI}' DaTe i I 20 I ~ ' l WDD's authorization to utilize lands and other works constitutes a temporary revocable permit. In consideration for receipt of the subject temporary revocable permit, permittee agrees to be bound by the following standard limiting conditions; unless expressly waived or modified by the Board of l WDD, as being not in furtherance of the objectives of Chapter 298, F.5., and/or special acts creating l WOO: By: 1. No open channel connections are allowed to l WOO's facilities. All conne<.1ions shall be made by pipe. culverts, etc., constructed of suitable material, as approved by L WOO authorized per'>Onnel. 2 No power poles and electrical lines are allowed in l WOO right-of-way. 3. Cover over facilities installed within l WDD maintenance areas shall be sufficient to withstand L WDO maintenance operations. A minimum of thirty,six inches (36") of cover is required_ [Soil conditions may affect the minimum cover required,) 4, All facilities on L WOO works or lands constructed by permittee shall remain the property of permittee, who shall be solely responsible for ensuring that such facilities and other uses remain in good and safe conditions and comply with all applicable federal, state, and local safety standards. L WDO assumes no obligation with regard to ensuring that such uS€s are '>0 maintained and assumes no liability with regard to injuries caused to other<, by any failure of the facilities. L WOD further assumes no duty to ensure that the permitted use complies with the safety standards of other governmental entities. 5. Perm;t1ee agrees to abide by all of the terms and conditions of this permit, including any representations made on the permit application and related documents. Permit1ee agrees to pay all investigative costs, cour1 costs and reasonable at1orney's fees resulting from any successful action taken by L WDO to obtain compliance with the conditions of the permit or removal of the permit1ed use. 6 1his permit does not create any vested rights, and is revocable at the sole discretion of LWOO within thirty (30) days written notin' Permit1ee bears all risk of loss as to monies expended regiJrding the permitted use Upon revocation, the permit1ee <.hall promptly modify, relocate or remove the permitted use, as required by L WOO. In the event of failure to so comply within the specified lime, l WOO may remov€' th€' p€'rmitted u<.e and permittee shall be responsible for all removal (ost<., ., " Rt>vl~ed 11104/03 ....'- ,,'''' ~ """ ICP #05-7482E.03 L WDD E-4 Canal January 12, 2006 LIMITING CONDITIONS Cont'd: 7. This permit does not convey any property rights nor any rights or privileges other than those specified herein. LWDD approves the permitted use only to the extent of its interest in the works of lWDD. The permittee shall obtain all other necessary federal, state, local, special District and private authorizations prior to the start of any construction or alteration authorized by the permit. LWDD, however, assumes no duty to ensure that any such authorizations have been obtained or are required. 8. Permittee agrees to hold harmless and indemnify lWDD from any and all damages, injuries, liabilities or claims which arise from the ownership, construction, maintenance or operation of the pennitted use of facilities, whether caused by the injured person or permittee, and whether occurring within the area of the permitted use or outside such area, provided the activity originated from the permitted use. This obligation expressly includes any alleged or actual negligence by LWDD as to all permitting activities regarding the subject use, including enforcement of pennit conditions. 9. Prior to construction, a copy of the Consumptive Use Permit from SFWMD shall be submitted to L WOD. 10. The permittee shall not engage in any activity regarding the permitted use, which interferes with the construction, alteration, maintenance or operation of the works of lWDD, including, but not limited to: A. Discharge of debris or aquatic weeds into the works of l WDD. B. Causing erosion or shoaling within the works of lWDD. C. Planting trees or shrubs or erecting structures which limit or prohibit access by lWDD equipment and vehicles, except as may be authorized by the permit. Permittee shall be responsible for any costs incurred by lWDD resulting from any such interference. 11. Permittee shall allow LWDD to inspect the permitted use at any time. 12. LWDD has the right to change, regulate, limit, schedule, or suspend discharges into, or withdrawals from, works of LWDD, in accordance with criteria established by LWDD and other regulatory agencies. Reasonable prior written notice shall be given to permittee. 13. No encroachments shall be located within LWDD right-of-way, other than what is permitted on the design plans. Existing facilities located within L WDD right-of-way shall be relocated within sixty (60) days of written l WDD notification to relocate. 14. Permittee shall comply with any and all Limiting Conditions contained in lake Worth Drainage District's South Florida Water Management District Consumptive Use Permit Number 50-00793-W. 15. Permittee releases and holds harmless L WDO for any damages caused by Permittee to the permitted facilities. 16. Permittee will restore right-of-way to its original or better condition where disturbed by construction activity. 17. Prior to commencement of construction, the Permitter will contact the proper authorities to locate all existing utilities that may be located in the lWOO right-of-way 3 Revised 11/04/03 .""""".~." ....... '-"" -- -, -l LAKE WORTI-I DRAINAGE DISTRICT IRRIGATION CONNECTION PERMIT ~ LOCATION MAP NAMEdlQxnh!n T!""l1 !?'nhur.~tryn~n Vt/l'tJe ADDRESS: Co(jr[(!SS Ave cvnd old 8~nlo~ Road. SHOW NORTH I . SU6D1VISION: . I J I I I L_____ LOCATION SKETCH SHOW ROUTE TO PROJECT SITE: INqUOE NEAREST MAIN ROAD AND CROSSROAO_ I~I L w Ol w '- "<( r- 41' a:: w r- Z ~OINTON ROAO '<t" L\ BOtNTON BEACH BOULEVARD .-- PROFILE VIE)V I ~ 0:: 01 o ~I 36~J..IINIMUN i i \\ ~ WATER lEVEl (f!' 50' /lJ6,v D) - -- - - - -,- - - - - - - - -- ~~ 1; ___ 6'SO/(N6lVD) \. N '\ r--i "'- STRAINER 2 'IJAX. DIMENSION or IRRIGATION LINE /1 IN INCHES___,6 ,\ - 1-:; lti.",." 3Nn AVo!{ J.SY3 ooooc)oooo ~~~~Q:jlQ~c'4~ 15_ .. , I l r j , ; II j II I, I . , . , II j ill i c +'+--!,",'i''''''-r- ~ I f I ' ~ , : l ; ~ ! ; : l rll il~ ~ LLLlLL ~ I! ! I i . I. I I l! 0 :!: 0 0 N J~ .., 8 0 'OJ- in 0 ui j I 'I \1 , : ( c '-r'h~ ~ , , , ! ' r~' "'.; ... 9l ~ in b ~ h- e:: 0 QJ 0> 0 < 0 a) s: u 0 '" ~ Ul 0 ~ ~ e:! l- e z ~ b ~ ~ , : I C) ;'"11"'1<) I I ~ I ' ; : ' ! .!{3J.lfM .:10 3903 · j ! >lNVTJ .:10 dOJ. : i ;,-jl--t ~ Ill, i i I fil'l ! t I I , ;: i >IN'18 .:10 dOl. -/~f'T 1:+;- ~ z i! " o! e ',!; G ++ H--. ~ jilw I! ! ~ . D.. . r I .1 coD: i' 1 ~ 88 N 0 I') 'OJ- 3Nn AVo!{ J.53M 1 I I C)C)C)C)C)C)C)C)C) lQ':c'4~Q:jlQ':c'4~ ..."""'-,-... C) - o ::i ~ ~ z ~~ Oq <e:: 00 ~~ oZ ~~ ~~ Clo ~~ Ou ~ ~9 e Ow Z ZlD '" " ....... .....; SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT 3301 Gun Club Road, West Palm BeclCh, Florida 33406 . (561) b~j6.S8()U . FL WArS 1-8UU-432-2045 . TOO (561) 697-2574 Mailing Address: 1',0. Box 24680, West Palm Beach, FL 33416-468U . \\'\V\\'.stwmd,gm' CON 24-06 Application No.: 051121-24 January 19, 2006 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.L.C. 1450 SOUTH JOHNSON FERRY ROAD, STE. 100 ATLANTA, GA 30319 Dear Permittee: SUBJECT: Permit No.: Project: Location: Permittee: 50-07079-W BOYNTON TOWN CENTER AND BOYNTON VILLAGE PALM BEACH COUNTY S20rr 45S/R43E 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.L.C. District staff has reviewed the information submitted in support of the referenced application for permit modification(s) and determined that the proposed activities are in compliance with the previous permit and the appropriate provisions of Rule 40E-20.331 (3)(a), Florida Administrative Code. The permit modification(s) include the following: The dewatering plan of the existing permit (Permit Number 50-07079-W) has been revised to include an additional recharge trench/hydraulic barrier to completely surround an on-site contamination area and to extend a recharge trench at the south side of the project to provide a hydraulic barrier between dewatering activities and a potential off-site contamination site. The revised site plan is shown in Exhibit 4. Hydraulic Barrier B will encompass the east end of the dairy barn where groundwater Impacts were identified in an environmental site assessment (Application Number 050201-7). Water recovered during construction and dewatering activities within Hydraulic Barrier B will be properly characterized, tested and disposed. Hydraulic Barrier A will be extended to provide buffering between dewatering activities and an off-site dry cleaner (Oakwood Cleaners). The water level in each trench will be maintained at 1.0 foot above the existing water table elevation. Please understand that your permit remains subject to the 25 Limiting Conditions and all other terms of the permit authorization as previously issued. Sincere~ rcHarmon. P.G. Sr Supv Hydrogeologist Water Use Regulation Division JH /cb GOVERNiNG BOARD EXECUTl\'E OITICE Kevin McCarty, Chair Irela /vI. Bague, Vice-Chair Pamela Brooks-Thomas Alice J. Carlson Michael Collins Nicolas J. Gutierrez, Jr.. Esq, Lennart E, Lindahl. PE Harkley R. Thornton Malcolm 5, Wade, Jr. Carol Ann \Nehle. ExeCLllIi'" Dlrecto" ,,' """",,, "..,.,;' Limiting Conditions This permit shall expire on September 19, 2006. 2 Application for a permit modification may be made at any time. 3 Water use classification: Dewatering water supply 4 Source classification is: Surface Water from: Water Table aquifer 5 Permittee shall not withdraw more than 1800 million gallons in the duration of this permit, nor more than 10 million gallons per day. 6 Pursuant to Rule 40E-1.61 05, FAC., Notification of Transfer of Interest in Real Property, within 30 days of any transfer of interest or control of the real property at which any permitted facility, system, consumptive use, or activity is located, the permittee must notify the District, in writing, of the transfer giving the name and address of the new owner or person in control and providing a copy of the instrument effectuating the transfer, as set forth in Rule 40E-1.61 07, FAC. Pursuant to Rule 40E-1.61 07 (4), until transfer is approved by the District, the permittee shall be liable for compliance with the permit. The permittee transferring the permit shall remain liable for all actions that are required as well as all violations of the permit which occurred prior to the transfer of the permit. Failure to comply with this or any other condition of this permit constitutes a violation and pursuant to Rule 40E-1.609, Suspension, Revocation and Modification of Permits, the District may suspend or revoke the permit. This Permit is issued to: 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.L.C. 1450 SOUTH JOHNSON FERRY ROAD, STE. 100 ATLANTA, GA - 30319 7 Withdrawal facilities: Surface Water - Proposed: 1 - 4" x 2 HP X 75 GPM1 centrifugal Pump 8 Permittee shall mitigate interference with existing legal uses that was caused in whole or in part by the permittee's withdrawals, consistent with the approved mitigation plan. As necessary to offset the interference, mitigation will include pumpage reduction, replacement of the impacted individual's equipment, relocation of wells, change in withdrawal source, or other means. Interference to an existing legal use is defined as an impact that occurs under hydrologic conditions equal to or less severe than a 1 in 10 year drought event that results in the: ~"",, ........, (1) Inability to withdraw water consistent with provisions of the permit, such as when remedial structural or operational actions not materially authorized by existing permits must be taken to address the interference; or (2) Change in the quality of water pursuant to primary State Drinking Water Standards to the extent that the water can no longer be used for its authorized purpose, or such change is imminent. 9 Permittee shall mitigate harm to existing off-site land uses caused by the permittee's withdrawals, as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance. When harm occurs, or is imminent, the District will require the permittee to modify withdrawal rates or mitigate the harm. Harm as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance, includes: (1) Significant reduction in water levels on the property to the extent that the designed function of the water body and related surface water management improvements are damaged, not including aesthetic values. The designed function of a water body is identified in the original permit or other governmental authorization issued for the construction of the water body. In cases where a permit was not required, the designed function shall be determined based on the purpose for the original construction of the water body (e.g. fill for construction, mining, drainage canal, etc.) (2) Damage to agriculture, including damage resulting from reduction in soil moisture resulting from consumptive use; or (3) Land collapse or subsidence caused by reduction in water levels associated with consumptive use. 10 Permittee shall mitigate harm to the natural resources caused by the permittee's withdrawals, as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance. When harm occurs, or is imminent, the District will require the permittee to modify withdrawal rates or mitigate the harm. Harm, as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance includes: (1) Reduction in ground or surface water levels that results in harmful lateral movement of the fresh water/salt water interface, (2) Reduction in water levels that harm the hydroperiod of wetlands, (3) Significant reduction in water levels or hydroperiod in a naturally occurring water body such as a lake or pond, (4) Harmful movement of contaminants in violation of state water quality standards, or (5) Harm to the natural system including damage to habitat for rare or endangered species. 11 If any condition of the permit is violated, the permit shall be subject to review and possible modification, enforcement action, or revocation. 12 Authorized representatives of the District shall be permitted to enter, inspect, and observe the permitted system to determine compliance with special conditions. 13 The Permittee is advised that this permit does not relieve any person from the requirement to obtain all necessary federal, state, local and special district authorizations. ,",,/ """ 14 The permit does not convey any property right to the Permittee, nor any rights and privileges other than those specified in the Permit and Chapter 40E-2, Florida Administrative Code. 15 Permittee shall submit all data as required by the implementation schedule for each of the limiting conditions to: S.F.W.M.D., Supervising Hydrogeologist - Post-Permit Compliance, Water Use Regulation Dept. (4320), P.O. Box 24680, West Palm Beach, FL 33416-4680. 16 The Permittee is advised that this Permit does not relieve the Permittee of complying with all county, state, and federal regulations governing these operations, maintenance, and reclamation of the borrow pit. 17 All dewatering water shall be retained on the Permittee's land. Off-site discharge of dewatering effluent shall not be made. 18 The excavation shall be constructed using sound engineering practice. If the excavation endangers the properties of adjacent owners through erosion, side wall collapse, etc., the Permittee shall cease operation upon notification by the District until a method to prevent such occurrences is found and instituted. 19 Permittee shall immediately cease dewatering when continued dewatering would create a condition hazardous to the health, safety, and general welfare of the people of the District. 20 Permittee shall be responsible for clearing shoaling if the Permittee's dewatering operation creates shoaling in adjacent water bodies. 21 Permittee shall comply with turbidity and general water quality standards for surface discharge into receiving streams, as established by Chapter 62-302, Florida Administrative Code. 22 Permittee shall not lower the water table below the following depths: -11.5 feet NGVD (approximately 22.5 feet below land surface). 23 A copy of the permit, its limiting conditions, and dewatering plan is required to be kept on site at all times during dewatering operations by the lead contractor or site manager. 24 In the event of a declared water shortage, water withdrawal reductions will be ordered by the District in accordance with the Water Shortage Plan, Chapter 40E-21, FAC. The Permittee is advised that during a water shortage, pumpage reports shall be submitted as required by Chapter 40E-21, FAC. 25 The Permittee shall construct the proposed recharge trenches prior to dewatering and maintain water levels during active dewatering operations within one foot below land surface. Obstructions and sediments within the recharge trenches shall be removed to maintain the effectiveness of the recharge trenches. ~._.._.- r, Vi{~~{~" "\.:>,:....'..--. - ._--------" t'.,' i,\ .\..;, __--,...___ \" i I ! \tf\ ~~~::n- ;;;,,-:>?,) ,.\) ";;;;"1U:~"\ ;, \\'1 ,~:--:~ ....,/ t /~-"t ", i ! , ........, i [t '\ N A ) t ~ \ ... \ , -, "-\ """\, I -j'--"-j i I . '. r"-.-'~. __J ,:~:\}-( i I ,., ,.. ---,- - "I I I I I I I .. - -.-----4--.----.---.- I l ,,,-,-,-- I I '-'~t: L______. ! \ -'1 \ I \,y;;\~;;r ~\". d ~ -::-'v SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT ~ Okeechobee Service Area o t 10 20 30 40 50 Miles , ~.w'\ 'Jr- OCJ) 0:: Cl. .,... i! ...-"';"., ,"" ," -- - ~ i! ~J: J J :hl- / ' 1/ II ; / I,,: ~ N~ / ~'- ~ v ~ ""' "':t a:: <::) ~ 0) \"') a:: co \"') a:: r-... C") a:: 10 \"') a:: Ii') C") a:: I' , , "',, ,;" ",- ; .. .....,'" ","".,f "':t LO 10 "'- ~ i! ~ ~ .......... -.....:.. ----- ~ ., "- J- "-.,) , ~ , \"') ~ l"-- :",/' ). 1/ ./ T ~ / ~~;- s ~ V I - I \.. oOl"....... -c= """J '-- L ~r: , n ~~ d cn~ Q: ~O ~ -JU ~ <U f -, '\ ~' 1:/, ' II : ,- -- , . z< I ' '/ w (9 ::s -.J :> z 0 I- Z >- 0 II) 0 z <( 0:: w I- Z W 0 Z ~ 0 ~ I- Z cr, 0 "- I- 0 "- z 0 >- 6 0 lO II) ~ ~ .. 0 E Cl) ~ '0 Ql ~ 0.. a.. en .!!! :1: co ~ a) o ~.)~ --<"'1 (] /V\ .-J~' ~ t.::::r iT ~ ' r: J'i\ I ~r:Y U ~ /2:: /) ~ -J :? Exhibit 2 \,.,,Y """'" '''"'''' w c.9 :) ...J :> z 0 f- Z <.0, r r- 0 I ro U 0 z <x: 0::: w f- Z W l) Z ~ 0 ~ f- Z en 0 r-- f- a Z r-- 0 >- 6 0 '" ro \ It: .... .'!:: U , \ E Q.) ~ "0 Q) ~ \ a.. a.. z~ :r.: o U5 ~ d cn~ Ci :E 0 3lL """0 Q5 OJ u- o o o N o o o ~ o Exhibit 3 [-' ;l.:.....' ,~-.. ~ --.:.....1-. r-o;'""" n. .. "-" .1 I i ! ':: "~.'I':':~'~S",:'.: P~"" .... )' ~~_'~ ...:~: ",,-~,,-_ , ~'_' ,L~~ - . . ,.,.,'. ~'- ......... .~,-"-. ,. ..., ........,.,",.~ .... . ." ' -~- . , .."..... H_ '" -.. ...-.. -' '0' '1 \ 'u,_ -. I I I I i I I I ""~~"'i;,;,: . r I ---5":- =" - -.,... 7,'.-:-- - ,-' ~ : i ._-f- I I ~ I '. , !~,----- ~------~=-= -1:i, '-\1 -- ~'~,,~ ~:.~'-',i ~/~HI '.\.~::f i ~,,~~ L-J 'r: --'~ I' ~ -- I--t- f" ~; ~'.~ i~ i _ '~F . .. / ~; .I _,._1.- .. -- E~" i~< -~ c~ 5 :~~~ \ ' ; l ~ \ , . i , \\ ~.:l::::t -~ \\\ '.-_.l.~4 ~JS 1 \ ~ ':; f; 1: ~~_, ' ", 'I " \ \ "~ 'Ii:, , ' r ~, ~~ \ i\\ : \, \ \ . ~- \:i 'i i ' \ \ ~, !!~ : 1\ ',~ \ \:',~ I ~ \ ',1\ \ \' I i\l\ ", \ i; \\' I II.. I ' a IT : \ l h \ \ \\ "'\ \ \, . I' 'roo \ \ \ \ , \\'" \ ' : I 1'1' i \..", \ I i \\ ,\ 0 \ \<r" ' I \ ,\\ ." \, ,'\..: I ~ \:\'\'\ \ >~6~ "\ ! ~\ il~/~' \~~<'~~.\~. . \ ! i Ir-:u~ \:. \0\ '.~\, ~ \: I ./:~ ~~ \ ~\\ \ ,\'\ \\ ' I ~~ ~,ili\\ '\'.., \\ ; II' ~! \~\' ~ \ " '\. '\ \\ ' ~. \\ '\\~\\\ "\\ \\: I ~- \\ \~,~~~ \.. '\.\\ \~ II \\ :\\\\ \ ,', \~ '\ ~~\\\\.\ \ I ,'~~ \\ i, ~ \\\\\, ,'I 'j I ..}~;.90\\ \\ III \ i' i ! ',\ \ ,': ~ i,\, : I' . I" Ill' '\ J I 5B i ! ~ t f I: I:~ i ! ~ i ~=--::::-~~; -~ll :Ii I; , "I' U ; '. - I~ i ' II!! i ~ i i iC~lI ;~ ~< ~ i!l J <'.11 :i; iil 1 I: ,;. i ill : ! , ) ~ !?; · I , ! i ! /' E3 i~ i! q j ti; I' ; !I" q !' i. rii II' i~ I' :. ~ ~:I J~ ~ ! ! 'I ~\~! 1~ !i ! i ill -, i~ I! ~ I! I in-- il ii' ! \ \ ~ ) I ~ \~ - 01 ~ .~ II '\ I:I}: ,j! t!i..,: llt~ 11 L~l ;! , II 11 ~l i6 ,Il~ ~~j~ff c , ,\1" I"J'.~ I "(,1 I~,~ I,l l~l'J!l: ' , "kl"" '", , ,;; , ;':Fd~?;:";@, 'cr.'" ~i:l '~ J'~ t:.i 4;:<: H 1';':1 r~j \t t';j '~~\ !; H l., : ;,: ; r ~:' !.!t~ I:, I; : I" : I:" " :1 ";1 ~< f ~~ j', , <, :'!i' lif ~.f~ Hi; lid i l~ i:~i wi .~ ~;~~ ~I ~~ im L G,; .....q ~i6 ~ I! . Ii- / !I . ~o ~' (~'; I : i~ ~ 'I 111 !S~ J~ ~g~ ~~~ ~ ~~~ = >:" " . ~I ~i ~'?flg'ie ~: _lIE ~~ ~l ~~~ .~ ~IJ ~ijl t rr I j \ l \ f~l \ !. , I " i L. J '~;~; .i d i I :\ ~: li:\ D' 1 J I,{ ! \ ~ ,\ ;1 ti-~ ". '-' 1- ~ ~-';1 :.. i! :'~=",:~;~c~j~q~;'~J,t{i'~,~~2;C,"~"'if=1<i!::! I , I, II , il ' . 1. I! ~I-'u ""_u_u -. if -. - . i . c! I' !i ~; Ii:" I I ';j 1 j.o I ;~r:::r'?:V ;:~~~;;...:.., .~~~~ '~. " , :. I. : .~l;Ff~+!C .~,.~~i;,~;'~;,~;: t~{~;~;4.~-..~~ ~"": . -" - -, --~""~...,.. "V. _. .,.~-.:'l>....; ~:::;;:: ::';';.~ ':.:..:..,~:!'~~$: ~. - '.: ..~ j 1 f:'i ;:; 'i . : :i () ~i "",I """I 1; <;" i BOYNTON ViLLAGE ~ihi DEVELOPER: i::" 1950 CONGRESS AVE, L.L.C. DEWATERING AND F~,:;~:;;;~~ ~~g,;;:+""'r u_~=;; ~ EROSION CONTROL PLAN ; ""~: j ;'fhi.-'I ~"'-"<:":':';~~':'~-:'''~' ' '" n"." Exh,Ob,"t ! ,"O~."" ~" ; ~41:'; 1 ....v~~~~._~~~ ~~-;n.~;."'~ d--""'''''':'~~';~'~'':-''''''~ 4 '. Y', .:-- .;_ ';'J> ..:::0:.. r" , "", ........, ~ c: Div of Recreation and Park - District 7 Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission Kimley-Horn And Associates, Inc. Mr. Ed Dailey, Chairman Patrick Martin, Director of Engineering Solid Waste Authority Town of Jupiter Utilities '! \" -' ......, I~ SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT 3301 Gun Club Road, WI's! Palm Beach, Florida 33406 . (56J) b8b-S800 . FL WATS 1-800-432-2045 . TOO (561) 697-2574 Mailing Addr('ss: r.o. Box 2'*1>80, W~:;I Palm Bt!'i\ch. FL 3J.J16-4680 . www.l'fwmd.go" CON 24-06 Application No.: 050721-9 General Permit No.: 5D-07079-W September 19,2005 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.L.C. 1450 SOUTH JOHNSON FERRY ROAD, SUITE 100 ATLANTA, GA 30319 ("See Attached Sheet for Other Permittees.) Dear Permittee: SUBJECT: General Water Use Permit No.: SO-07079-W Project: BOYNTON TOWN CENTER AND BOYNTON VILLAGE Location: PALM BEACH COUNTY, S20/T45S1R43E Permittee: 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.LC. This letter is to notify you of the District's agency action concerning your Notice of Intent to Use Water. This action is taken pursuant to Chapter 40E-20, Florida Administrative Code (FAC.). Based on the information provided, District rules have been adhered to and a General Water Use Permit is in effect for this project subject to: 1. Not receiving a filed request for Chapter 120, Florida Statutes, administrative hearing and 2. The attached limiting Conditions. The purpose of this application is to obtain a Dewatering General Water Use Permit for short-term dewatering for the safe excavation and installation of underground utilities, storm drainage facifities, and on-site wet detention areas for the proposed project known as Boynton Town Center and Boynton Village. The project is located in Section 20 of Township 45S, and Range 43E in Palm Beach County, east of. Congress Avenue and between the SFWMD C-16 Canal and New Boynton Road West. Please see Exhibits 1-3 for project location maps. Actual dewatering activities are expected to require less than 145 days, with a maximum daily pumpage of less than .108 million gallons and a total project pumpage not expected to exceed 15.66 million gallons. All dewatering water shalf be retained on the Permittee's land. Off-site discharge of dewatering effluent shall not be made. The dewatering water shalf be retained on-site in the proposed recharge trenches. If off-site discharge becomes a necessity, the Permittee shalf apply for a modification of this permit prior to discharging off-site. A copy of the permit, its limiting conditions, and dewatering plan is required to be kept on site at all times during dewatering operations by the lead contractor or site manager. The Permittee is advised that this permit does not relieve any person from the requirement to obtain all necessary federal, state, locaf and special district authorizations. Gm 'f1(....we; BOARD fXIC1 'T'1~E OmCE J<t!'\-in McCarty" O,lti" .-----.--,. .__ ,Alice..J.Carlson- lrl'la 1\1, Sagu!?, ~'"...C1"'JT MichaE'J Collins Pamela Brooks.Thomas Nicolas J. Gulierr('4, Jr., hq, ,--Leno~rl E. lindahl, P,E. _ HnrklE'~' R. Thornton Malcolm S. WailE', Jr. CaloLt.nTtyvl'hJl'....b.'.!'S!!,!!'.....,Pj!~~rh.__..._ ,.,,__" _ " Application Number: 050721-9 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE. L.L.C. September 19, 2005 Page 2 Date Of Issuance: September 19. 2005 Expiration Date: September 19. 2006 Water Use Classification: Dewatering Water Use Permit Status: Proposed Environmental Resource Permit Status: Permitted (No. 50-o6808-P). Right Of Way Permit Status: Not Applicable. Surface Water From: Water Table aquifer Permitted AJlocation(s): Annual Allocation: Maximum Daily Allocation: 15,660.000 Gallons 108.000 Gallons Proposed Withdrawal Facilities - Surface Water Source: Water Table aquifer 1 - 4n X 2 HP X 75 GPM centrifugal Pump Rated Capacity Source(s) Water Table aquifer Totals: Status Code P GPM 75 75 ~ MGD 0.11 0.11 MGM 3_3 3.3 MGY 39 39 ,", J ""''' Application Number: 050721-9 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, LLC. September 19, 2005 Page 3 Should you object to the Umiting Conditions, please refer to the attached Notice of Rights which addresses the procedures to be followed if you desire a public hearing or other review of the proposed agency action. Please contact this office if you have questions concerning this matter. If we do not hear from you prior to the time frame specified in the Notice of Rights, we will assume that you concur with the District's recommendations. Certificate Of Service I HEREBY CERTIFY that a Notice of Rights has been mailed to the addressee not later than 5:00 p.m. this 19th day ot September, 2005, in accordance with Section 120.60(3), Florida Statutes. Sincerely, ;~ Sr Supv Hydrogeologist Water Use Regulation Division JH I cb Certified Mail No.: 7005 0390 0005 9812 6025 Enclosure c: Divof Recreation and Park - District 7 Engineer, City of Boynton Beach Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission Kimley-Hom & Assoc. Inc.. Kim ley-Horn & Assoc., Inc. Lake Worth Drainage District Mr. Ed Dailey, Chairman Patrick Martin, -Director of Engineering Solid Waste Authority Town of Jupiter Utilities \a;. ,.-J ,","; Application Number: 050721-9 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.L.C. September 19,2005 Page 4 limiting Conditions 1. This permit shall expire on September 19, 2006_ 2. Application for a permit modification may be made at any time. 3. Water use classification: Dewatering water supply 4. Source classification is: Surface Water from: Water Table aquifer 5. Permittee shall not withdraw more than 1800 million gallons in the duration of this permit, nor more than 10 million gallons per day. 6. Pursuant to Rule 40E-l.6105, FA.C., Notification of Transfer of Interest in Real Property, within 30 days of any transfer of interest or control of the real property at which any permitted facility, system. consumptive use, or activity is located, the permittee must notify the District, in writing, of the transfer giving the name and address of the new owner or person in control and providing a copy of the instrument effectuating the transfer. as set forth in Rule 40E-l.6107. F.A.C. Pursuant to Rule 40E-l.6107 (4), until transfer is approved by the District, the permittee shall be liable for compliance with the permit. The permittee transferring the permit shall remain liable for all actions that are required as well as all violations of the permit which occurred prior to the transfer of the permit. Failure to comply with this or any other condition of this permit constitutes a violation and pursuant to Rule 40E-1.609, Suspension, Revocation and Modification of Permits, the District may suspend or revoke the permit. This Permit is issued to: 1950 Congress Avenue, l.L.C. c/o Jeffery S. Fuqua 1450 South Johnson Ferry RD, Suite 100 Atlanta, GA 30319 7. Withdrawal Facilities: Surface Water - Proposed: 1 - 4" x 2 HP X 75 GPM centrifugal Pump ~, J" ~""'" Application Number: 050721-9 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, L.L.C. September 19, 2005 Page 5 Limiting Conditions 8. Permittee shall mitigate interference with existing legal uses that was caused in whole or in part by the permittee's withdrawals, consistent with the approved mitigation plan. As necessary to offset the interference, mitigation will include pumpage reduction, replacement of the impacted individual's equipment, relocation of wells, change in withdrawal source, or other means. Interference to an existing legal use is defined as an impact that occurs under hydrologic conditions equal to or less severe than a 1 in 10 year drought event that results in the: (1) Inability to withdraw water consistent with provisions of the permit, such as when remedial structural or operational actions not materially authorized by existing permits must be taken to address the interference; or (2) Change in the quality of water pursuant to primary State Drinking Water Standards to the extent that the water can no longer be used for its authorized purpose, or such change is imminent 9. Permittee shall mitigate harm to existing off-site land uses caused by the permittee's withdrawals, as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance. When harm occurs, or is imminent, the District will require the permittee to modify withdrawal rates or mitigate the harm. Harm as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance, includes: (1) Significant reduction in water levels on the property to the extent that the designed function of the water body and related surface water management improvements are damaged, not including aesthetic values. The designed function of a water body is identified in the original permit or other governmental authorization issued for the construction of the water body. In cases where a permit was not required, the designed function shall be determined based on the purpose for the original construction of the water body (e.g. fill for construction, mining, drainage canal, etc.) (2) Damage to agriculture, including damage resulting from reduction in soil moisture resulting from consumptive use; or (3) Land collapse or subsidence caused by reduction in water levels associated with consumptive use. .... \0, ,"'" Application Number: 050721-9 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, l.L.C. September 19, 2005 Page 6 Limiting Conditions 10. Permittee shall mitigate harm to the natural resources caused by the permittee's withdrawals, as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance. When harm occurs, or is imminent, the District will require the permittee to modify withdrawal rates or mitigate the harm. Harm, as determined through reference to the conditions for permit issuance includes: (1) Reduction in ground or surface water levels that results in harmful lateral movement of the fresh water/salt water interface, (2) Reduction in water levels that harm the hydroperiod of wetlands, (3) Significant reduction in water levels or hydroperiod in a naturally occurring water body such as a lake or pond, (4) Harmful movement of contaminants in violation of state water quality standards, or (5) Harm to the natural system including damage to habitat for rare or endangered species. 11. If any condition of the permit is violated, the permit shall be subject to review and possible modification, enforcement action, or revocation. 12. Authorized representatives of the District shall be permitted to enter, inspect. and observe the permitted system to determine compliance with special conditions. 13. The Permittee is advised that this permit does not relieve any person from the requirement to obtain all necessary federal. state, local and special district authorizations. 14. The permit does not convey any property right to the Permittee, nor any rights and privileges other than those specified in the Permit and Chapter 40E-2, Florida Administrative Code. 15. Permittee shall submit all data as required by the implementation schedule for each of the limiting conditions to: S.F.W.M.D., Supervising Hydrogeologist - Post.Permit Compliance, Water Use Regulation Dept. (4320), P.O. Box 24680, West Palm Beach, FL 33416-4680. 16. The Permittee is advised that this Permit does not relieve the Permittee of complying with all county, state, and federal regulations governing these operations, maintenance, and reclamation of the borrow pit ~ 17. All dewatering water shall be retained on the Permittee's land. Off-site discharge of dewatering effluent shall not be made. 18. The excavation shall be constructed using sound engineering practice. If the excavation endangers the properties of adjacent owners through erosion, side wall collapse, etc., the Permittee shall cease operation upon notification by the District until a method to prevent such occurrences is found and instituted. 19. Permittee shall immediately cease dewatering when continued dewatering would create a condition hazardous to the health, safety, and general wenare of the people of the District 20. Permittee shall be responsible for clearing shoaling if the Permittee's dewatering operation creates shoaling in adjacent water bodies. " '" ' """*" Application Number: 050721-9 1950 CONGRESS AVENUE, l.l.C. September 19, 2005 Page 7 Limiting Conditions 21. Permittee shall comply with turbidity and general water quality standards for surface discharge into receiving streams, as established by Chapter 62-302, Florida Administrative Code. 22. Permittee shall not lower the water table below the following depths:-11.5 feet NGVD (approximately 22.5 feet below land surface). 23. A copy of the permit, its limiting conditions, and dewatering plan is required to be kept on site at all times during dewatering operations by the lead contractor or site manager. 24. In the event of a declared water shortage, water withdrawal reductions will be ordered by the District in accordance with the Water Shortage Plan, Chapter 40E-21, F AC. The Permittee is advised that during a water shortage, pumpage reports shall be submitted as required by Chapter 40E-21, F.A.C. 25_ The Permittee shall construct the proposed recharge trenches prior to dewatering and maintain water levels during active dewatering operations within one foot below land surface. Obstructions and sediments within the recharge trenches shall be removed to maintain the effectiveness of the recharge trenches. '0. " "," ,.'" NOTICE OF RlGHTS Seclion 120.5691 I), Aa. Sial. (1997), requires lhat "each notice shaD inform the recipienl of any admiuismbve hearing or judicial review tbal is available uDder this section, s. 120.57. or 5. 120.68: shall indicale the procedure whicb must be followed looblain Ihe hearing or judicial review. and shall slate the time limits which apply.M Please note that this Notice of Rigbts is nOI intended 10 provide legal advice. NOI aD Ibe legal proceedings detailed below may be an applicable or appropriale remedy. You may wish to consull an anomey reguding your legal rights. PETmON FOR ADMINlSTRA TIVE PROCEEDINGS I. A person w1Jose substantial iutClesls arc affecled by the South Florida WalCf Management Districl's ISFWMD) action has the right to requesl an adminisuative hearing llIIthat action. The affecled pcrsoo may request eilber a fonnal or an infonnal hearing. as set fOMb below. A poinl of enlry inlo admiuisuabve proceedings is governed by Rules 28-106.111 and 4OE-l.5l1. Fla. Admin. Code, (also published as an exception to the Unifonn Rules of Procedure as Rule 4OE-O.l09). as set forth below. Pl:utions arc decmed filed upon receipl of the original documenls by the SFWMD Cled,. a. Formal AcIminislJative Hearlnl!: If a genuine issue(s) of malerial fact is in dispute. the affected person seeking a formal bearing on a SFWMD decision which docs or may dctmnine, their substaDtiaJ interests shaJI file a petition for hearing pwsuanllO Scclions 120569 md 12051(1). Fla. Sial or for mediation pursuant to Scct:im 120573. F1a. SiaL within 21 days. except as provided in subseclions c. and II. below, of either written notice through mail or posting or publication of notice Ihat the SFWMD has or intends to talte final agCIICY actioo. Petitions must substanlially comply wilh the requitements of Rule 28- ] 06.20J (2), Fla. Admin. Code. a copy of tbe whicb is attached to lhis Notice of Rights. b. Informal AdminiSlJative Hcarine: If thae an: no issues of material fact in dispule, the affecte:d penon sccJcjng m infomral hearing on a SFWMD dccisioo which docs or may delmnine their substantial interests shaD file a petition for hearing pwsuanl to Sections 120.569 md 120.57(2), Fla. StaL or for mediatiOll pursuant to Section 120.573. Fla. SiaL within 21 days. execpl as provided in subsections c. and d. below. of either written DOIice lluoogb mail or posting or publicauOll of notice !bar lhe SFWMD has or intends to tale final agency action. Petitions must substantiaDy comply with the requirements of Rule 28- I 06.301 (2). Aa. Admin. Code. a eopy of the which is attacbed 10 this Noiice of Rights. c. Adminis1nllivc COIIlDIainl and Order: If a Respondent(s) objects to a SFWMD Administrative Complaint and 0nIcr. pwsuantto SecliOll ID.Jl9. Fla. Stat (1997), the person named in the Adminisrrative Complaint and Order may file a petitiar for a hearing no later than 14 days after the date such order is served. Petitions must substantially comply with the requirements of either subsec1ion a. or b. above. d Swc: lands Environmental Rcsoun:e Pmnit: Pursuant 10 Section m.4I1. Fla. Stat. and Rule 4OE-J.511(3). Aa. Admin. Code (also published as an cxceptiOll to the UDifonn Rules of Pmcedun: as Rule 4OE- O.109(2)(c)). a pelitioo objecting 10 the SFWMD's agency actiOD regarding consolidated applications for Environmental Resowce Permits and Use of Sovereign Submerged Unds (SLERPs). must be filed within 14 days of the notice of consolidated inlmlto gratlt or deny the SLERP. PetitiODS must substantiaDy comply with the requimncuts of either subsedioo a. or b.. above. e. Emc:n!encv AuthorizauOD and Order: A person wllo5e substantial interests an: affected by a SFWMD Emergency Authorization and Order. bas a right to file a pctitioo under Sections l20.S69, 120.57(1). and 12051(2), FJa. Stal. as provided in subscc1ions a. and b.. above. However, the pelSoo. or the agent of the pcrsm responsible for causing or conDibuting 10 lhe cmergeucy conditions shall lake whatever actiar necessary 10 cause immediate compliance with the ICJJDS of the Emerge:ucy AutborizatiOD and Order. f. Order for EmcrmIcv Action: A pClSon whose substantial intcn:s!S an: affected by a SFWMD Order for Emagency Action has a right 10 file a petilioD ptUSIWlt to Rules 28-107.005 md 4OE-l .61 I. FIa. Admin. Code. copies of which are anachcd 10 Ibis Notice of RigblS, and Section 373.119(3), FJa. Slat., for a bearing on the Order. Any subsequent ageucy action or proposed agency action loinitialc a formal revocatioa pr-oaeding shaD be separately noticed pulSWllltlO section g. below. g. Permit SusIlcnsion. Revocation. Amu1mcnt. and Withdrawal: If the SFWMD issues an adminislJative complailll to suspend. rcvolcc. annul, or witbdlaw a permit, lhe permittcc may request a hearing to be conducted in accordance with Sections 120.569 and 120.57. FJa. Sial., \\itbin 21 days of either wriuen notice through mail or posting or publication of notice thai the SFWMD has or intends to talte fll\8l agency action, Petitions must subslaDtiaDy comply with the requirements ofRuJe 28-107.004(3). FJa. Admin. Code. a copy ofllle which is altached to this Notice of RigblS. 2. Because: \be administrative hearing process is designed 10 formulaic final agency action. \be filing of a petition means that the SFWMD's final acuOD may be different from the position taken by it previously. Persons whose substanlial inlerests may be affected by auy such final decision of the SFWMD shall have. pursuant to Rule 40E.J.SJJ(2). Fla. Admin. Code (also publisbed as an exception to the Uniform Rules of Procedure as Rule 4OE-O.J09(2Xc)), an additional 21 days from the dale of receipt of nOlice: of said decision to request an adminisU8tive hearing. However, the scope of the adminisuative bearing shall be limited 10 the substmtial deviation. 3. Pursuanlro Rille 40E.t.51 1(4). Fla. Admin. Code. subslaDliaIly affecled persons entitled 10 a bearing p\llSuaDlto Section 120.57(1), Aa. SiaL. may waive lheir right to such a bearing and request an infonnal hearing before Ihe Goveruing Board pursuant 10 Section 120.57(2). All. 5tal., which may be grmted allhe option of the Governing B~d. 4. Pursuant to Rule 28.106.111(3), AlL Admin. Code, persons may file: with the SFWMD a request for exleosillll of lime for filing a petition. The SFWMD. for good cause shoWII. II\8Y grant tbe C.1<ICIlsion. The request for exlension must contain a certificate that tbe pc:litioner has cODSulled with all other . panies. if any. concerning lhe eXlension aDd thatlhe SFWMD and aD other panies agree to the exlensioo. CIRCUIT COURT 5. Pursuanl to Scctioo373.617. Aa. Sial.. my substantiaUy affected pasOD who claims thaI final agency action of the SFWMD relating 10 permit decisions constitutes an unconstitutional rating of prapcrty wilhoul just compensation may seek judicial review of the action in circuit CDWt by liIing a civil action in the circuit court in the judicial circuit in which \be affected pl'q)CJ1y is located wilhiD 90 days of the retldering of the SFWMD's final agency action. 6. Pursuant 10 SccliOD 403.412. Fla. Sial, any cilizcn of Florida may bring aJI action for injunctive relief againsl the SFWMD 10 eompcl tbc SFWMD to enforce lhe laws of Olapler 373. All. Sial., and ntle 4OE. Fla. Admin. Code. The complaining party must file with the SFWMD C1crt a verified complaint se:tting forth the facts upon which the Complainl is based and \be manner in which the complaining party is affecled. If lbe SFWMD docs not lake appropriale action 01\ the eomplaint within 30 days ofrc=ipl. the complaining party may then file a civil suit for injunctive relief in the ISoh Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach COlOny or cin:uil cOlD1 in the county where the cause: of action allegedJy occwyed. 7. Pwsuantto Section 373.433, Aa. Sial, a private citizen of Florida may file: suil in oranl cOlD1to require the abatemenl of any stOJmwalcr tDlIDagcmCRt system. dam. impoundment, resnvoir, appurtenant work or works that violale lhe provisions of Chapler 373, FIa.. SiaL " " ......, DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL 8. Pursuanllo Section 120.68, Aa. Sial.. a pari)' ....00 is adversely affecled by final SFWMD action may seek judicial review of tbr SFWMD's final decision by filing a nolice of appral pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.110 in Ihe Founh District Court of Appeal 01 in the appellale dismcl where a party resides and filing a second copy of the nolice with the SFWMD Oed: within 30 days of rendering of the final SFWMD action. LAND AND WATER ADJUDICATORY COMMISSION 9. A pari)' 10 a ''proceeding beJoww may seek moiew by the Land and Waler Adjudicalory Commission (LAWAC) of SFWMD's final ageucy acticnto delc11nine if such actioo is coosislenl with \be provisions and pmposcs ofChaprer 373. FIa. Stat Plusuant 10 Section 373.1 14. Aa. Slat, and Rules 42-2.013 and 42-2.0132, Fla. Admin. Code. a request fa review of (a) an order or rule of the SFWMD mUSI be filed with LAW AC within 20 days after rendition of the order OJ adoptioo of the rule sOUgbt 10 be reviewed; (b) an order of the DepanmenI of Enviromncnlal PrOleclion (DEP) requiring amendment OJ TCpQI of a SFWMD role must be filed with LAW AC within 30 days of reridition of the DEP's order, and (e) a SFWMD order cntemJ pursuant 10 a formal administrative bearing UDder Section 12057(1). Fla. Slat, 1J1lJSt be filed no 1aler than 20 days after rmditicm of the SFWMD's fiaal order. Simullaneous with filing. a copy of the request fOJ review must be served 00 the DEP Secretary, any persoo named iil the SFWMD or DEP final order, and all panies 10 the proceeding below. A copy of Rule 42.2.013. Aa. Admin. Code is a!tached to this Notice of Rights. PRN ATE PROPERTY RIGHTS PROTECDON ACT to. A property owner who alIcga a specific action of the SFWMD has inordinately bmdened an existing use of the real prq>CJl)', or a vested right 10 a specific use of the real propertY. may file a claim in the circuit court where the real property is located within 1 year of the SFWMD lU:tion pursuant to the procedures set forth in Subscc1ion 7O.00l(4)(a). Fla. Stat. LAND USE AND ENVlRONMENTAL DISPUTE RESOUmON 11. A property owner who alleges that a SFWMD developmenl order (as that tcnn is defmed in Section 7051 (2)(a). Aa. SIaL to include pamilS) a SFWMD en!orcl:lI1ellt actioo is umc:asonabJe, a DDfairly bUJdens tbr use of the real property, may file a request fOJ relief with the SFWMD within 30 days of receipt of the SFWMD's onIer or notice of ageucy actioo pursuant to the procedurcs set forth in SubsCClions 7051 (4) and (6). Aa. Sial. MEDIATION 12.. A person whose SlIbstantiaJ irllereslS are, or may be, affected by the SFWMD's lIttion may choose mediation as an alternative remedy UDder Section 120573. FIa. SIal Purswmtto Rule 28-]06.11](2), Aa. Admin.. Code. Ihc petition for rm:diation shall be filed within 21 days of either wrinen DOtice through mail a posting a publica1iaI of notice that the SFWMD has or inlends to talte fmal agency actiOlL Choosing mediation wiD not adversely affcct the right to an adrnirIbtralive hearing if mediation dDcs nOl result in senlemeDt . Pursuant to Rule 28-106.402, FIa.. Admin. Code, the COIItenlS of the petition far medialillD shall emlain the following information: (I) the name. address, and lelephone number of the person requesling mediatiOll and that person's rqmseutalive. if any; (2) a slatement of the pre1iminary agency actioo; (3) an explanation oebow the pc1son's subslantial interests will be affccled by the agency delermination; and (4) a slatement of relief sought. As provided in Scctioo 120573. Aa. SiaL (1997), the timely agreement of all the parties 10 mediate wiD toD the time limilations imposed by Sections 120.569 and J2057. AI. SiaL. for Rq1lCS1ing and holding an adminisbalive bearing. Unless otherwise agreed by the panies. the mcdiaticm must be concluded within 60 days of the cxCCDtiIlll of the agreement. If mediation resullS in seq!c:mcnt of the dispute. tbe SFWMD must enter a fmal order incOlpOOlting the agrccmeut of the parties. PeIsons whose substantial interest will be alfe.cted by such a modified agent)' decisiDD have a rigln to pc1itillll fm hearing within 2J days of receipt of the fiDaJ order in accordance wilb the requiremcDls of SCClims J20.569 and 120.57. FJa. SIaL. and SFWMD Rule 28-106.201 (2). Aa. Admin. Code. If mediauDD terminales withoul senJemeut of the dispute, the SFWMD shaD nOlify aD panies in writiDg that the adminiSbalive beariDg process under Sections J2O.569 and 120.57, Aa. Slat. remain awilable for disposiliDD of the dispute. and the nlllice wiD specify the deadlines that then win apply far cbaDenging the agency action. V ARJANCES AND WANERS J3. A pc:rsm woo is subject to regulation pursuant to a SFWMD rule and betic:vcs the application of thaI rule wilt create a substanlial hardship or wiD violate principles or fairness (as those terms are defined in Subsectioo J2O.542(2), Aa. Slat} and can dcmorIsbale that the purpose or the lDJdc:rIying statule wiD be or has been achieved by other means. may file a petiliDD with the SFWMD C1crIt requestiDg a variance from or waiver of the SFWMD role. Applying for a variance ar waiver does DOl substilDle a cxu:nd the time for filing a petition far an admiuistrative hearing a aen:ising any other right that a pctSOIl may have concerning the SFWMD's actillD. PI1rsuanl to Rule 28.IOU)02(2), Aa. Admin. Code., the peliliDD D1IISt inclnde the following informatioo: (a) the caption sbaJI mad: Pctilillll far (Variance from) or (Waiver 01) Rule (Cilatioo) (b) The nart1C, address. tdepbone number and any facsimile number of the pctiuooer; (c) The nart1C. address 1elcpbone Dwnber and any facsimile number of the attorney or qualified represc:ulative of the peliliooer.; (d) the applicablensle or portim of the NJe; (e) the cilation 10 the S13tuc the rule is imp1emeDting; (I) Ibe type of action requested; (g) the specific facts thai dcmoostrale a subslantiaJ hardship or viOlatillll of principals of fairness thai would juslify a waiver ar variance for, the petitioner, (b) the reason why !be variance or the waiver requested would serve the pwposc:s of the underlying SlalUlc: and (i) a SIaIm1ml or wbetber the varillDCe or waiver is permanent a temporary. If the variance m waiver is temporary. the petitioo shall incIudc the dates indicatiDg the duratillll of the requested variance or waiver. A person re1J1ICSling an emergmcy variance from OJ waiver of a SFWMD role must clearly SO state in the caption of the petition. In addition to Ihc requirements of Sectioo ) 20.542(5). Aa. SIaL pDlSD8I1t to Rule 28- J 04.004(2), FIa.. Admin. Code., the petition must also include:: a} the specific facts that make the situation lllI emageDCY; and b) the specific fac1s to show that the petitiOller will suffer immediate adverse effect unless the variance or waiver is issued by the SFWMD more expeditiously than the applicable timeframes sri forth in Sec1iOD 120.542, Aa. SiaL WANER OF RIGHTS 14. Failure to obsCl'Ve Ibe relevant time frames prescribed above will constilUle a waiver of such right 28-106.201 INJ11A nON OF PROCEEDINGS (INVOLVING DtSPUlED JSSlJES OF MAn:RlAL FACT) (2) All petitions filed lDlOO Ihese rules shaD cOlltain: (a) The name am:! address of eacb agency affected and eacb agency's file or identification number, if known: "',,- ,e" ......, (b) The name, address. and telephone number of the petitioner. the name. address. and telephone number of the petitioner's representative. if any. whicb shaU be the address for service purposes during the course of the proceeding. and an aplanation of bow the petitioner's subslantial interests wiD be affected by the agency detc:rmioation; (c) A statement of when aDd how the petitioner received notice of the agency decision; (d) A statemenl of aD disputed issues of marerial fact. If there are none. the petition must 50 indicate; (e) A concise statement of the ultimate fadS alleged. as well as the rules and stlItutes which entitle the: pelitiooer to relief; and (f) A demand for relief. 28-106.301.1 lNITlATION OF PROCEEDINGS (NOT INVOL vINe DISPUTED JSSIJES OF MATERJAL FACT) (2) AU petitions filed Wlder these rules shaD coorain: (a) The name and ad~ of each agency affected and each agency's file or idenlificatioo number. if known; (b) The 1IlIme. addn:ss. and telephone number of rbe petitioner. rbe name. address. and tdepbcne nwnber of the petitioner's representative. if any. which shaD be the address for service purposes during the course of the proceeding. and an expJanatiOJl ofhow the petirion/:J's 5ubslaDtial iIIt/:Jesrs wiD be affected by the agency determilllltioD; (c) A statement of wben and bow the petitioner received notice of the agency decision; (d) A CODCise statement of the ultimate facts alleged. as weII as the rules and statules which entitle thepctitioo/:J 10 relief; and (e) A demand for Jelief. 28-107.1104 SUSPENSION, REVOCA TION,ANNULMENT, OR WITJIDRA WAL (3) Requests for bearing fiJcd in accordance wirb this rule shall iDclude: (a) The name and address of the paJty mWng the request. for purposes of service; (b) A statement thai the party is requesting a hearing involving dispured issues of malerial fact, or a bearing DOl invohing disputed issues of material fact; and (c) A reference to the notice. order to show cause, admioistrative complaint. or other communication thai the party has received from the agency. (2) REQUEST FOR REVIEW PURSUANT TO SECTION 373.1]4 OR 373.217 In any proceeding uisiDg rmder OIlIpIeJ 373. F.S.. review by the Aoricla Land and Water Adjudicalory Commission may be initialed by !he Departmalt or a party by filiDg a request for sucb review wish the SUJetary of the Commissioo8Dd serving a copy 011 any peISOII uamed in tile rule or order. and on an parties to she proceeding which ~uJlcd in !be order sougbllo be reviewed. A certificate of service showing completion of service as required by Ibis subsection shan be a requiJemeor for a determiDation of sufficieDcy under Rule 42-2.0132. Failure to file the request with \be Commission within the time period provided iD Rule 42-2.0132 shaD ~1i1l in dismissal of the RqlIest for review. The JeqUest for review shaD ide:Drify \be rule or ord/:J requested 10 be revicwed. the proceeding in whicb the ru1e OJ order was entered aDd the IIlIlDre of the rule tI' order. A copy of !be JUle or ordCJ sought 10 be reviewed shaD be anacbed. The requesl fOl review shall Slate with panicuIariry: (a) How the order or rule caaflicrs with the n:quimnents. provisillllS and pUlpOSes of OIapler 373. F.S.. or rules duly adopled thereunder. (b) How the rule or ord/:J sought 10 be Jeviewed afftttS the inlCJeSlS of the paJty sedcing review; 42-2.013 (I) (c) The orallll' written statement, sworn or WJSWOlD. which was submined 10 the ageucy cooccmiDg lbe mailer 10 be reviewed and !be date aDd location of the statement. if the individual m entity requesring the review bas nol participaled in a proceeding previonsly iDStihlted plUSll8llt to Chapter 120. F.S~ 00 the order for whicb review is SOUgbl; (d) If review of an order is being sought, wbelber and bow the activity authorized by the order wwld substantially affect natuJal resources of statewide or regional significance. or wberber the order mises issues of policy. statulory interpretation. or rule inlerpretalioD thai have regional or statewide signifiCllDCe from a standpoint of agency precedent. and all the factual bases in the record whicb the petitioner claims support snch determinatiOD(s); and (e) The action requested 10 be taken by the Commissiou as a rC5uh of the review, wberber to rescind or modify rbe order. or Jemand lIIe proceeding 10 tbe water maoagement distriel for funha aebon. or 10 require the walCJ management disbict to initiate ruJcmaldng 10 adopt. ameud 01 repeal a rule. 28-107.005 EMERGENCY ACTION (I) If the agency finds that immediate serious danger to !he public health. safety. or welfare requires emergency actiou. the agency shall summan1y suspeud. limit. or ICSbict a license. (2) The 14-(jay DOtice requin:menl of Scaion 120.569(2)(b). F. S., does nol apply and shaD Dol be conslJUed to preveDt a bearing al the earliest time pracricablt upoa request of an aggrieved party. (3) Unless odterwise provided by law. witllin 20 days afler emergency action taken pu~uantlo paragraph (I) of Ibis ruJe. the agency shall initiate a fc:nnal suspension or revocatilllJ proceeding ill compliance with Seclions 120.569. 120.57. and 120.60. F.s. 40&-1.6)] EMERGENCY ACI10N (I) AD emergency exists wheD immediate acriOD is necessary to protecl public health. safery or welfare; tbe health of animals. fisb or aquatic life; the works of the District; a public: water supply. or recreational. commercial, industrial, agricoItuml or olbcr reasonable uses of land and water resources. (2) The Executive Director may employ the JCS~es of the District 10 take wbalCVcr remedial actioo necessary to aJJeviate tbe emcrgeucy cOJldilion withoul the issuance of aD emergency order. or in the event aD emergency order bas been issued. after rbe expiration of the requisile rime for compliance widt thai order. i!il~ '~" ......., t... '10 N A -_.~ '-.- ~..~: h J:~ \"'- :,~"., '.._~ ~ ':.1 .. ..' . .". . 'I '. \:~., .~ \~::... ....L_. _ __ ..' - -"--- -.._- : " . ~l . : .. -.-. '. SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT 1L22 Okeechobee Service Area o , 10 20 30 40 50 Miles . Permit Expiration Basins Exhibit 1 l~-~ I WW -,1- 0- ~(I) a. C"') "t It) (0 ..... ~ i! i! i! i! ..... - ) "'- be: r-... - ,- ~ r- "- "- ~ '---- "- "" i! i! - -- .- ....-1~ ........ N~ / ~ ~/ /u J / / J """ / ~ 0 V "t a:: J 0) / C"') a:: c:o // ~ -'\ . ' / / ..... """'- C"') 1:::"""- a:: , , .,~ ~ I\. ~~ 1 L-=.:. - I (0 ~(, ~ It) f C"') ~ a:: ~ l3 i:: ~ IQ~ ~ :SOLt ...JO ~ ."", ......." / ?F m ,... 0 CD ,... . 0 N 0 ,.. II) 0 II) 0 ~ - :BI: E D. I- ~ at n.. w C) ::5 ....J ;> Z o I- Z >- o aJ o Z ~ lr W I- Z W o z ~ I- Z o I- Z ~ aJ .:.; U at 0- l- n.. rI> .9! :E <0 -- co o - 'i_I~ ~I/~ r-~ t~ -.: I IV-' 'I ;.t:l h.n lso.cr . ~~ . .;'Y z~ Exhibit 2 ... "-" ~"1, w t!) :5 oJ 5 z to g Z ..-- >- t 0 () ED 0 Z c( lr ~ w u z ~ ~ I- Z (l) Q) g . .... - 0 N .... ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 II) ED =Jt .0.: - u =Jt E lD a. ... 0' ~ lD ... a.. a.. z< ~ ~~ 9 CO;:j a:: ~O 0 ....J 0 Lt ~ CD CD U. C o o N o o o .... o Exhibit 3 '..~ : ('1'(.:- '::-.>t 1 1"','. (-:_..... ~,_.o., C':: . .; . L . " ~ .1 1,.- ,'. l~"'" :, :'c<y . .. -, €. ~ J.i'F) ,~-" ::i...... L,. ,"""", SEE~IAL CO~nITIONS ;: r n. 1. " :'.. .l.t .~ :.:.~' sr. ::....~ 1_.;'. ~~.~. :: .H,;. ,.'f~.r": i': ".1.:03 t. nit', 1 : _ L ,; :> .~ ," "r ;:0'- ~ .::1 u ~ti,:";t il . !-.. ~ " r ': r, ::: t(:'1 E .. "j t:: .'. .. '. ,~ . .-~. ,,,- e() ..:'.... ~... : I: . ~.. . c : J:' ~ ..' <r 17'}' . "",J I' .C" a :. '..... '."{ .:. I :~.'.. . ~ .;,'~!' . :;: . ~... .., .;,.;.... I ~:..:.,: . :...;0: ),)'-:,C-' ._') -, I ~r."~ ~.- . t'. i..':' ~ .: :. ':~:""i.~: .' -.;: i~ ,,' E:r? }, C:"i:,: 1 :.t,. - , . ~ r.': : :;~"l/""; . l .~ i . '" 4" :..~ c. .: . :1 , ,~ " !:: c-: .... ......- . .... ,4,' .._.'_ ( -, '~ .. c-r S..~: :- t .ere i':. (;:f: ( ~' ,'~ \.r r'~l:R , ( .J:. ..,.. 1. .: c....:. 'I, , . r'~:': '~, r t; :~ r. ii t ':'"' \. .i.:.. ~ ~, ....)..- , t L" l"~' r. L 0.'"' ': j('" ...n. t". k ;~. /~=::-t ., ...,..' .', .;'. : ,;:r' :". ~A;'(', u: :: '~.~'nc \, ~!l ") ~', I.. '1. ',' ! ..I: . () <: ')t ,'oj ','1 :.: ,:Cl.1 ':! :1..' 'r "1 .. . t. .......,:. U,e ::(]o ,-;:; r:.''' ': :': i ~ r' (.. :In, \I,':' :_ en t. \~ ~:- r ,,( . "::.,', . ~ r<'- . .- .&..~. .' t : }.-: ,-' ," . ,', ..... , . .'. .(.! r~i. . : t '~ I .. :- " ~ - ~ .; ':.:0 ~;(: n',::.::' . C"-: iJ)!'. i '.... ,', ,) C' \"'~' ',: : . .. .''=' :c 'e: ': r ,'O c t :. : 'O,~' , , " ..<::~ c.- 1'::( r t r....: 1 .. "I, it" t'l ;' t "::. i'! ': :t,j": l: , (~ l;. ~ T: 1:: ~ ~ .: . :l.:, :1.. .' .'. '''r. -::, t. i ~ ',: r " :.'/::;': . . f)' ~'{ ,:_.(j). s sr .~i:..... ~),- t'i :: :u: .f ,'it C '1. 'ij', .!,... '. ,,'C i;' '., ~.;VCI':.:.cn ; I Sl.. ':f: .) ': ::= ~,03':' ir":: t. r .... 1.'" t-:-- -;: ," ': "t:_:._ ,',,-' .... . '" -... ,.' ~ ,-A. r . 11 I ' -:-( )", " , ~.f - ,-" : i.-I to;::~ F-.E;. :E!.1 V' .r.'1 .t'.: fl', "~ ( ~ ' ~v .-', . :"" r ':' T " ,": ",:,' :' i." 1. '.' " ::: , \ . ,-~: .r ~ r )~.>l.-: ':' "': 1'" ". '"..:,j .:4,t:lr ~e ,J '" t.. :r ':'1>.:.' ,:" "n;,': -:: t ~ ~..~r(:t:E:.:~ ql.l;: :.:H-.. F "t y.,;3::~ ... I""t. i ""1; :1:: .< ~ I>... r.;':--' ~1.'.a~.:'" t .l:~::: ::i.:~ Y V:..t:', ,~". '1':1' t ;. ,i b'? :. ~:... ,,! :): ": .: ;. .,... .;~ s~..':-;~ .c: ...::icr: i'.':.r-. ..~ ( ~ f'.. ..:. :~. . \ : d.. :\, () - I'.rt ."~ ,Lx:,' ":.-;::i::f! C!n~']:' :. ,;.:. t: ~ .).~.~ ',.,: (' ;,'.-' 7 ~f' : .ll':_7:'I.'jJ .roJa LJ .,.. . "1 La -:1: . w: : I;" ~i ~1 .: :) _rE. t.r :r . ,',,: ( ,1"f" .t:." <: ..". .. ~. .~ , ~.. t. '.~ ',f.>~:'" '. .::- l~' :: ..- ... _ .l.. .~. .! . .c~~ 1.: ': ': .' ~~f', :C d. j.'. ~:)::: O"~ c":"":;l-,:,~d ',:::~:,J\-1':" j" . ~:~ :~:"i':H'''"1 ',j.... ...... J.:";' " , ., : .;:1 , , f r );" .'. ';.?~: :. t:.._ V -; )t- ," '..1: :(.d :.;i '':'.1: a~J :~ (. ... ':' -:: ~ :n ., \, "., t.. : :3~. ~.l~ . .~'llE-'d 0: ,: r 'Ii d '( \. .:. r;.; <1 J !E " ~~ t:1" 1. : .; E' r :r:" 9 ~ -:.: i:' , t ~. ~ \.. ~.' i':': ;'i lm ; d ::(! . .... J.':-i 1. '.: ': '. t:' \"i ,,:\ . .;., ~',r. .r~.;..!:~=':':(:'r ,...(::. ,', H.:..: 1.':.~ _ ' " ,,,:, :l:~ " . ':" .. - .. .. ,. (cr.};)! I~-: '~~~ ( f ': - (" S~!:..] ':'::C... . to; .r 1';'.-:::' .- ,-:~. :;:I;d ~ .:; I ~. ..,:;.~ ':'h.;: ' r:":.: ':e,;, (,~ rf ,,,-:-, "f-/.i.l':';".- . ,l._ ,...::. f' i .,3:' r t . ':'.: r. .'~ , , ...".r'€ ... - '-\.~ :: c,,JP( ~. ~.1... .s !: ,.... ':"r:Cl"hl1: _ ,: : t l _'/.: L " -, :,,1' ;-ei;':f "',,~ J c' . i; :oIL;';' ~i )1r' (,rm" ;-: ~ " ::t . .,:;, 1':'~:': ,. ',;, _'O y;i .r 't:' (',-: l" 0: ,', ::;' Ci:=. .,J:'". ~'.:: t.:: ,.... : ~ '..~ r. . ...... ..:- _I../.. . r, ' :, J:. ; " ': :H'~ _.It;. . ~,: '": l'rJ "f;,:.' ::-.t -/, ~ ": ,i "(.- I f' '1 : ':.~ ' . , ,- ".V: :! i> ::11.1 i,i.;j",~ S'l,:. , .' ,~ ,.f' 'v:' ;, r. ''''-' ~. :: c ~: .: - ,t ,;( : r."" ;::c l",-, '~ " ': .<_1 ~. (.~ '1.: lr... _ ..... -1:.. j~! }"O..i:; .......... r, '~4 . : l' l 1 -:: :"1d _ ~:". f1 r. ~:t .. ;. -,,': i( 1. , r:,.,,~c I.L( I.>., Tt :f: ~ ...."" Dewaterinq Activities Dewatering is needed for the safe excavation and install.ation of underground utilities, storm drainage facilities, and on-site wet detention areas. Facilities'for dewatering include a portable 4-inch centrifugal pump and wellpoints discharging on-site to proposed recharge trenches. Specific pump information is provided in Exhibit 5. All Dewatering effluent will be retained on the Permittee's land. There are several locations to be dewatered for this project, including underground utilities, stormwater piping, and the proposed on-site wet detention areas. The dewatering site plan is provided in Exhibit 48. Instillation of the lift station will require the maximum dewatering and excavation depths, which will occur at a maximum depth of -11.5 feet NGVD (approximately 22.5 feet below land surface). The anticipated duration for actual dewatering activities is 145 days with a maximum daily use limited to the maximum pump capacity, which is approximately 75 gallons per minute (less than 0.108 million gallons per day). Contamination: The nearest potential source of contamination is the Oakwood Cleaners, located approximately 700 feet south of the project. The Permittee has proposed recharge trenches on the dewatering plans (Exhibit 48) and pursuant to Limiting Condition Number 25, the Permittee shall construct the proposed recharge trenches prior to dewatering and maintain water levels during active dewatering operations within one foot below land surface. Obstructions and sediments within the recharge trenches shall be removed to maintain the effectiveness of the recharge trenches. Additional drawdown buffering is expected to be provided by the maintained Lake Worth Drainage District canals which surround at least half of the project site. Due to the small magnitude of the proposed dewatering activities, the depth of the proposed dewatering, and on-site recharge. the potential for harm due to the movement of contaminants is considered to be minimal. Saline Water/Salt Water: The site is more than 1,000 teet from the nearest source of surface saline water and discharge of fresh water to saline or salt water is not proposed. Wetlands: Wetlands on site are to be developed; therefore, no significant drawdown impacts to associated wetlands are anticipated. Stormwater: Dewatering water will be stored on-site in proposed recharge trenches; therefore, the proposed activities should have no impact on the storage capacities of any off-site stormwater management facilities. Exl1ffiil4A !J"'...'''' r" D-~..,..- "'.I'o.,"~'.a.," ..~-.~~..u:~"".:':'..:'!~~"'::' ~~. ~'.r :,: ..aI'):'Ift ="1._ I, ....... .r.__ ....- _...._~---;....,.... ....-.--... .'- ~...-'''~-' ..-....-....-...... --... ..-..----.....-....--...-....-..........-- -- ...---....-.-- .--- -....--.-....--... ! ;1 '1 i :1' , 'I i i " j, " .. .. ~_. " I .:1 :1 'I :J , ., :1 t ~~ .J " ... .!. '. " : I~ :1: r- - ~ II I~ ~ I B III~! j .. . i I! U '.! (I 1; ~ I: : j! II illl ~ , :r lit i JI!i. i It;! ) !2 -~ 'IL-! ': r . \'~ . '1~~:.~.~""'" ~- ~'~-~~ ':~_-I' ~~-_ :.......~.._~~.-:.;2_,~=~: i _~~~~.= ~~~~i:;;;.<:~: ':...:~,~~~:~~t '_i......_..~:-,..,..,',~~'~-=.,...~~"..I..'::;;.=..;:.~~'-'----,.. i' ,-.'-'. '.' ,,~-!~"-...J'----p-----r (' '''. c~;..~:.~, '." '- (~_____r'~:'~:-- ..;. "l.f~r I . i . !. ~. ! . I:~f . rJ I .. \...1 \,:\..~:;)'IU(':t. , I: . I ...--.--.-..1...------ f~ . ~. : "j j I . ~ - 1 f i - f tl'l i"i~ ~ "'" .! .....'''1 U:~'lI'~. .... , JII"':-n~ .. ""''''' ....._U 1Ild.-.-.... -~ ."!)~._"__-"'o" I)I.~' .::.,.....-..r___....-n_ ,. t\ ...-,...:-.:- ..........-- -~-- .-... n ~~h BOYNT::~~':E~~-SMU ... t;,r; 1950CONGRESSAVENUE,LlC, ~ot',.,":.. JL .;;:r - l:C- r .. Exhibit 48 I .f DEWATERING AND EROSION CONTROL PlAN 2:... ! , i I i i i I I I i , \ I I I I :/ II 1:\ i': .:' 'i I I I I , I ., '.1 i ".i ! ,; i '" ""''''' .....,1 S :oN l!q~4x3 en :E c :J> 'T1'T1en -0 m -t -0 -0 2 -om "TIS:Z -0 :J> e SD tit n CD CD 0 iii" CD :: e c SD e )( III III III e 'n ~ - CD n ClICDe :J < 0 3 3 3 3 iii' 2.'U 3 3 '!!. III ClI en 0 ...... SD III :E'U 'n 'U= ::;011>> 'U n .. - c zm n .. .. CD -f:J n ClI c DI :J CD 0' DI :J: 0 - '< CD SD CII - .. o III r- '< 0 III ell ,<IE!. Q!!. 0 .. :E c :; ~~ 0 :J .. o' CD (jJ 'n - 'U '1J en :r n -0 :; ..co III co - III CD .. o :J :J -i DJ ? .. - c CD C1 n 0 C III CD '< s: 0' 3 '1J ::; :r 'U Z .. 'n CD Z 0 'U.. C m CD :J :0 o '< CD 0 .. G') ::C3 ~ CII ... 3 0 :r ..,) CD a.. 0 < CD -0 Q. 0- Q. 0 CD '< - .. s: :-! - 1\I~ os: -0 :J 0)(0 :D . ZN ...., ~ n -0 Z ~ ..... 0 -" .gDJ CD - .... 0 001 m -" U1 (I) -- Q) UI -.-+ :: 2. ~r :l -"~ :5 0, ::t )>!!!. N 0 -CD (I) (,J~ co ...., (I)... DJ:l DJ ::!. -0-0 ...~ -co -< mOl m 2' o 0 Q) II.) ~-- -"0) :E co ..... DJ :0 ;il.:J . c:T :r m !!!. IU -+ co CD co :D cr Ul (i) 0 CD CII n :!. .. 0' :J 0 -f - en :J> C m -0 ~ r- III m CD n co CD CD :E m ...... 2- OJ .. CD ...... .. -0 e CII -0 1\I co (I) ..... .;. ~""". ~~ "', ' "-" ~,..-l",",",'" o SOUTH FI..ORIDA WATER MP-..NAGE...MENT ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCE PERMIT NO. DATE ISSUED: DISTHICT 50-06808-P JUNE 8, 2005 fORM fIC)14S Fil'\f.D.~f05 PERMITTEE: '::':5: C ,)t !GR,E:;S i\,;e:N,.,;= :_e lacy \TCN TOW"; cnn:R i.,',:' 8C'y:\r: O'~ VIL...A,GE) 1450 .s, ,'CH!\S'JI\ Ff.P.!~:~ R)AJ,~.) TE 'j,j{' .L.TUvrA. G.4 :'031f< PROJECT DESCRIPTION: CO' :CEPTi;A.. /IF-PRC \'J'L ':.= A Si. ::tFACE WATER 'y1.~\~iA'::;Er~Elr SYSE1\: T :3::F:"l= A 1 ';(1.48 ACRE ;\:jiXEC> :..r\N,:'; JS= DEVE!..C:JMEl\iT ,.,:~[;W'4 AS 2(IY[liT\ B~ACH TOW~~ C:='JTi:.R .~N) BOy;,,~c'r\ v ....AG::. Af\D CO"~3"'RL;CTfON AND ,)PERATiOrl 0= ::>-lASE 1 ;591 A:::~:tS} V\'l~:CH !,;CUDES T"IE VA~-E:R S';P;=AC:: \,\,4Ti:.;:': MANAGEMENT SYSTEM Allie: P~OPC:S=D C.:M\1EQCA_ C'EVELOPMF\ I,; PROJECT lOCATION: PERMIT DURATION: PALM 3S\,,::li CCV-.;;Y . SEn;CN (0 ""\Iv!' 453 ':<(;1: 4:,E Se;:! St;~!C!ai:;ol1dlt;)n ~o,~, SE~:: clt:a:;'18C !=lute ~(IE-4.3i". Fo:iaa Ajnr:.s:ra: ,,'e ': 00;: ' ThIs Penni1 is i:i!'lll'rj i)'USt' lUJ! 1.(, ,1\!)pli,;ary,'" :~o. (l.:} I! j ';.18 , .1fll'C., nrTllI)('r :15, .200 L Pllwiltl I: r::1."tu, 1,0 ho)l! and saw the Suuth Flori(!:. ',\!Htt'r :\o1anngl,m,':U i),strkt and Its SllrCI:;:;S[)">{ hllInlle$s fr'(lIn un)' and all damn.g~s, daif_1s..1 hlb,MH'S wh.ich may arts(' oy fI'ason 01 tIll' .'oustru('t1on, ,)pn:,uj('ln, nUI~:r,Il'naJl('e fir us(' of flCC;vitics autllorize.1 by this l'tnmt, 'nUl'; I'Ulnit is IS!.l:ed und(:r tht' provlsi()ll~ of ChHpter J~'3 , Part!V I~io:rka Sltltut('!, tl'.S,), fWG 1["" Operating Agr(Tmf'j',t C'oncI'mir:f:; R"gllla1il)!1l),',dcr Part lV, ('h:3j)ler 3,'.3 F .S., bl;.twer-:n SOli t!' F!!Irid~. WIll a Man>I(;I:mt'nl I)istrkt and Uw Dr partmt'nt cd' '2:nvi.fomnt'I:: ill PrOH'c.!:ioll. Issuant(. \If thls !'(:rn1l1 /'nn,tttutes c.'rt,if"Ub()tl of COmpHf:ll'" '.vidl ~,Inn~ \V,tlf'r l'jualll.)I f.t6nd"rd~ Wht:11 11l:l'('t~s';;,ry PUl'.,l.l;l1it to S~.('tiO~l 401. l'libhr Law 9J-300, ~'j 3 l.'SC S('I'!um 134! ,uT:!e S~, i1i:~ PIT)::'! If, iSikll'd pl.lrSllfdlt 1(1 Ih., net !Inprc'vul1el,l l)n)\l:~;;on5 Of ~;Uhsecti(,ns :l73.414!1Hhl. I".S.. or as otlU'fwise staled 1wn in. This Pu:Uil may b(' tJMsi'enTd PUi ~;Uclm hl Ib~ "H,rc.p:ialt' p: ')",5;0:lS .,e C !l:qJter 37.1, F.S, alld f:1~C(:l)t;'i~OE-: (0 l,07, l} a,d ~2:. an.j 401':-4.351 (l), i2), and ;-Ii. l'lorid,\ ,\drmnistra'-'H Cone (FJ\.I,'.j This l'"nnil rna:. hI' f('\'okc'd. suspend"li, or moc1iflC([ ai, a1'1Y time pursuallt to the ~,pproprial(~ pro\'ll.ions..{ ('ilflpl,,':' 373. F.R. anu ~,~\ clion,,> '~OE-4.::\5.1 ('). (2). Elml ;,1;. F,'\,C, This P(,lmlt !;l1all be sllbJfCI tn 1.'1t> G";>I(nt' Condi.tlolls Sl~t f(,rth In 1'!\lJe 405:-4,'381, F,A.C., u::'e38 w;;.ivc-d or mod1l1('d by tIlt' Goveming 1'3oard. The Applicl'ltioll, lmd 1 h(' F.rvirOlmlel' :011 F:~sour':(' Penn:t Slldl j~~I'\'!eW f3ummn:)' of :he Applkatlon, mcluding aU c<Jndnolls, and all plRn'l ar;~ SP,,'(;!fl,~"'ljt;o'_'i u:.c()I'Por!'\'~d by r(':'('r'~11rC. Rrf' .1 pro' p! Ihi.. PtT!l,j~, -\!! ani"iric,; aur.h::lfi:~<:d by t11is Pt'nnit :o;l;al' he implr.,'nu:'lllcd us set "1.;1'1'11 W 'li<' !~,Iil.n:~. 1>l"'t'C!llCRI b'l;~~, ;ene' p,'rt'lln1'IiUl<7t. c,.,t('nii ,<t; s<t "('Ith ann m<:orpOl ated in r!,,(' 1'~n\'it'l)l1n1t'ntal R('SOU!I'I' Pn'rl1lt '\T:!lff ~~c'1';fW Summa'')', WI! hill :W (h'iYs aft(.; COII::plf",H.,rl (' f I ()11~"J'lclicm (If Ltll' permittee! ,,,-dl"lty, rlu: PenrllttN: :->ll~';; ,,;;hm,t a wn',7.('11 sh.II(":!lL~l1t ,)r(:O!;,,]>I~tlvf; and ceni:lc'lli\Jn by 11 r"r.,,>~"r,"! p"o'.e:-.si'lIlal''1'J.gint:eror other appropristf: mdiv:dl.lr,J, 1".11 s,'anr. iO ':he ;lpprOl'rj, Te' !"llNbtClLS d C!.l~pter ::\';'.1, F, S. a!ld St clon:-; .IOr;'.l.~I;) 1 a"c -, OE-'!.,3S1. j,'.A,(, fn l.ht, ev<,'nt the pl'o!"'rt3 is sdd or otlll:T\\.'isl: conwyni, tile Pamjtll~(' wiLl Tf'mllln ;ial)~e fr..r r(laJp~;,'J.;C( ""ne' 1':llS "emit until tnu;sfer is appro\elllJy tl-t{' j)i~;t:''kll'urbuaal to j::lll. 40L- i .1,10';', l~.A.C, S?EClAL AND GENERAL CONDITIONS ARE AS FOllOWS: 3EE F'AGES 2 3 CF'3 (i6 P~C A:_ C:)N,) TiC'\S), s:::;: f1AGE~ ,t " CF': -1g GE".:ERP,L GCi<D:-iCNS:. SG:.. T-l F..oR!DA WATER '.'A\iACF:iv'EN" 01f,.,-rtG'T' 8':' JTS G':I\.'t;R~., '\:3 f:CAIO )", _ ~::~i.!' J':' .-.:!:~ ,~ :0;1-[... ~;~ _ ~-.~_._._.__._ -.. , '-6)'; ~ ~,'~':;: ":~<~:::''=.:''':'~::. ,- _,-:.': -_ :" ,~ .,' ~~:.~:- .., rE.H TiC..!: c;,( .- PAGE " C= 6 I) . ~;. .... ;. "::-~. t- r " -' ". 1. , ::; " 'I,: ~ r. ~:~ . ..(j '..;'. .'. t'"' l;' ~ .~. 'b " e t : ~~ t.. f~ . ':. ~,,,. .' . . L: i _, ::':]~" s _ (-:1n~'::~::!j i ;:;. ....., 'I -. ",."","- ~ :,::: c '::. '. :; ,. _J n C' , ] ",'8~, -_tt':~- 4 _I:: . J " .~ ... l.i. " 1 " - - ;" . v. - :(;': '.:1. ';r', -.1-'," .:c ': .le c :nn )". ';;.' ; ,". J ~~.~: '.. f. ':: '~-= !'1'!\ . .. --, t. :cr.;: h' J. Dr )~. ~. c.:,; ::, . ~: I .~ .,v . ; '. _~ r :lC' V...y r',.. . r ,DC ";'.. '[11 ,':. ;-:'.. ~ ~.:::-; 1= . .... ;',-' .\ J'; .:: ~ . C'c ,,; :...l. :. t: ':"1 r . -' , , .j . ;_... -,.. .' \~ , n:d t t" ;~f. ';'1 _ ,J. r . c , r:' ,r::::c -1.(: \.::,1:....3::; c r)::~l (ri(:(~ ca ...~:. '!.F '.01 :~..: J.o,n,:' ~:- r:~3'1~1 :r<;",f."t. ::-,1 ,,:c': ',' v~:. ~> : ~';r :'.". ..; _ t'. :1\r 1 :: . ~ 'I' rer:1. r s1:a~. 'vi '.:.' .'; \ r. ~ '~L l, \. r. ,0 ~: !1e )'1.: .: .~ "" "r.... ..:': '::; " ,,!' ': :1. .1', ".n, .~ ~ :~ t . <.' 1':" ~:!' t: .; I. ,:;:t :. ~ . ,\., ~-? :_ ~J.:." y SLC~:'.i("!f," ..~..~. COrl3tll..cL', ... ....,., GENER?J~ cmm:TIONS f,q :::" r .: ' r ,c. "P"'::' c. ~) ; , .. " c... .C ,,, 'j' v ',F' ,,~ ,. .. ..... .t". 'r, .... ( ':( t, \. ..-.:....-1 ':.: 1 t ~ h:":':'.r :.' 1 ,,::;; i',: t " (. ~:' ': ( ~,' b...i' ::-r :( -;: .E.'i ~. , :. ",",l~',: tt. 1:. '. ,~. (:,):1"" d ,:,:t.,.V~':"'/ ~.~::'.. r} >:-c; .:-~.y tr_i }t;,.. i' , ,~; .~. .'L bE-: ~'.:>r cue t c'( ~ ~:tar,c,-:r ~:~. '0 f" r ~ .: '. " 111 \: i c ,: r..c;; " .!:" i. ': C ,,_ ~.. ') ~.~. ( T .. " :~' ::-c~ ry '~r'J>~ i Ci (').1 '_ J70 ~:' _J'-:-. .i ~::-, j,.. .... )E :_' ~!'.:,'~ '1.:C l"'.. t r " . =t.. :i .::- ~,. .' ". , ,'1': :::::; ~','li) '';0" '". t .X "1 ::, n: \..:'..: _ .\:'"~. '.::. ~". ..t.,._ :1..-: l I' ", ( ", _ ~,::", ',"' -: y .'. :h. '!~! i. r;..' . ~: :~ ~~ ,-:;'. .",1."::":::;'j r .-,': :( - ~ '. ;!; ~ '..:. .~. ~ " l~ . \':. : I l,d ,c. , ,(' ..1. ..; , ;1'...",1 n. " .~;. _ '. " .;.l:..-' .~: r :) , e ,', -: ':, , , r;:. : r:j'. "", ~M .:' ;1D.. J._ j.3~~'!~ ':1. .'1 ~r" ..... .... . , -.. ..- . :. V: ~- JL 1.1'. : ..r; 3 ': . .' ~~.:!:' ;:. t: ~[: . .... ~~t.:.r ~:-::.,':-l :::~_::.. ":"1 '"'_ 1: :: ~ " ~'~ ':a ~ ..1. lJ. 1.)0; " "" f ~:"'.:., s, "c' "~r V._:: )T "c. --::.: :~.~ C ':.::.:';;;, oJ ~'r:,;')r f'.. . I. (-. . - .. ~; ': :. \ i ," .?r :';:::J',' : ... .. l' ,l(' , C.:,!' ':; c,c'~ y !:- J ::. ~~ . (; na:- -:: ..'i ::cc 't',' , ; .... r a' '1., ~ .. - ,.:. ... .;:. 'r;.. '..- t; ~ r: ',. .:::1':7, ~. L,': .::' ".'\0 '. ..~. .' r ':I:j. ( 'I. 1 :: ~:'. .::' 1:',c ':',. L t ::- : .~ ::'i .j' -::! r:!-: ':'C-: ~: ~"r't . : :.. =,' t .' T' :r.' '1;. 1.:' '~'" '_:'"'''' ,. .; ;; -:; I' ,. "jl4: . ;.~.. . . . .-- .. ~. .. " tt l-~~' (' '~'.: ',: " (. :0:":: '11-:,: . :. .,'. (:. ~~j . . L :> ....1: '!,~.~ ;.', '._' Zl + :: .,", .~: .(' t;~,s.~ _.rE E; , ' .". d\:. ~: r i .'..r ~ ~.: ;. !'!I ..": ': ~'.::: j.o.l~: ": ~.: .r:.~ -cru:'_.. ::r. ,,'. _-,,;'!.. d. :~ r. l .:;. :. ~ '. : '. .: -:.::. .~. .:. ( :. ..; j(,s::-r .b d . "r ~': '1 '" : ~. :. c .: P { i ... :,- 7 .- C'l':" '( ',':~: ( l.~ Y V'~;.; r~=' r" . ~ ": : ., -::~':'n C)~.:. .; :~ ;;e t ,". D(" .!..... 5:'1 .~ ~ :-C~... -';;'::.. a'" y . :. ( j 7' ,_ ( , ')r c:' .... .. : j~ '.' :'. ~ . C _ oS -~ :: ~. .':: .: .~. b'.,' '~:jis ;(:'::1 'j ,c .. ::' :: j .. :; . r ~ -: -:. ..l ::'_ . ~')! '.:: ".' :,:~,,:..:,;. pi;p:'r t: .. \..;,.:: t:' ", :r: . . ~.. Y' ",r::..;:,.._ :,~f" -; " ,~ E .~ ":"" , }... 1'. }.: }' - ..; -', ~ p:;" r ''of., c. .~' 1...... 1 r., ,~... : i ';r. : ::.r .';, (.... " . :.l" tr- ,.:: ':: c: "'r .. :'_ ~ '-':,. 1 ~~; r I :' :.. 1':.1 C'.; " ....: t)~~ ~-rrl._ .'. - ~ ~ .l~ " .... .... ::'( n ! ..: _C" ."r::: E :-q.)~': ~ . :x: ' ~:€. L.r I ~;;:Iric:'- c: r c..J, -l., .~ ~'i : . a ; . t ',.' ~ ':,;H:,' r" 1\,.;: a. :ri: _y \:--. .... r:. c ~ :t . 3. ~ ~ t r .. ,.4 ~, -;-. ....,. ~ t i. or . ' , - . ..! r ": I ):-j 1-: .:, ':: h ". '-... . ....: ...... .::.L ::? 'l', , : f ,-,: .:.1... : VI; )::, r:: ...:...t. i ci l' r, '\.. ,J ... ,: t '(: :. f:';.'V!' ~ 1 ,. ~~7i~:-~ .'. C '1 .~ r :'. ~ :'";, ;~~-:.'" .1 ':.v it -: .). ~ \ :. 1_ ,: ~_l .:- .: pl ,. "J,: ::J" ~',-'T "'yt 'C. '} ~(, :: : r f~ ::= : :) , (. i . f VI I ;.. ;-:f;-P T:', '; ;".3"::.1' ::r ", '.', ;')t, . . ... '-'. .::. I :":,1. " .. .. '. , ... ": y. l'E ; ~. ,'; ',', r_ 'of ...?:' .....:.'1' . '\.: . ....il~ -r.... ('::: I~ p' , ~~ ~..: t. :'~ i "!~~:;"'. ::i.r.r:'3 nc.: I' p":.(~j;H.:nt: tlt!-.t ~ 1 '. tic .r. c f :~:: .1 -. t: 'f r-. e:..t:e:-c ;:'ri.l C i_C '1'" C ,;f ::(-''f: .; .._ :.. ',~: ~ \.....1, ~~ ," i "1 ... L~ y::; "': " _ j , ,',' I', .:-:d, t ".:" " ': '1 ; j :' c, "is ~ r t -';'-.. , .' ~.. .t: d r r :~. .1 r~. s t. ~..: ." ~ :> ~ i (: <. "le: :10.1.., .:) ar~" ~.>l ,11 f~icc~.Jr:j .~.. (~( ~ ;'] .'. (:,f L-'':''cr.:Lda La 1.:1 . (~ := ~Jc: .r-t: r: ~,-; ,.. !. .: i. ~; t: 4 ~ :;: - ,: . ( ~ 1 1 ? . :~. :. . ::-:: r,' r.il :~-: -.... \ :1:: ;I 5 "~E"l ': '.'i\:, ':1". .: l' '. ~= :~. .~ ~~ : ~ S ~(.:\j;~' ,~s.. -. ~nt ::~~:a""i:t (I.,t." l). '.;:0' .t; .i:J;:-~. };!2...C~: : ,'r '; ; ~.~ (,1" -- :) Netic': :"it: F',:1r' )Y ,:'C,:)" It () ::> .;;. d_._. ~:'J. ::.'r:~i t '.. _to I' . : 1., 1 ~ 1 ., ",:n,ld .J J'" (. f . 'J to .. OW.i.. ..~ ~ \.. .0;."_ c:ct._ "..:' ".:; I "<; ": .i -''"J'" .:; n ::/) ", r ',r ~ ",p:: 1" ," _ f:;: tr.l.,:"",C1 :-t ,fl. C. ~: I :..' . .: : -' I ~ ~ .~ : :: : r:",::. -~ ': ,~ ( ::- ~. . :5,r; ('. , 'C :::is :c 0:,.-; ;' f' ': pl.:1.'p< S. .: ~;.a!".: ar: 'Tl t " ' , - , t ~ . r.: ~ '/S t t. ! .:. s :r(;..w:.'" ;:\ C. -f- L~: 1,.1.: '.' l: ,I,;.' :::q: n 'c by 0,..... ~ ~'::"t ,: r c. ,_" , {::-i ~ r. ::>e ': e 1: 1 :, ' . 1. (~~ ' .~~ x _':.j'- ,)r,.:1: I' -. ~:.. 1".1 ~ e.~: ::> . .:' :.~ ;:;.c :.: ~, . I ~ -' ....... :'., (p""r;: . ,[ ';. ( ;..,.rr 1 t :"1;~7 ... ~ ;-:<1 t ~. '-: : ~, . l I ~.. :0 ; . f:, :",;: a ..1..... ,'C~,! ~f.::: I, I.. .f~ 1"'),: r'":,, t 1:.1 t.e.:" or J)E- C :I':::; , ,,1-.. (. t,. ..j. ':.... U€' :-1';'f ~: . -.., :< .::~.'!; : : '1 Y'. :c' :'(:, - , .' ;"1 '1" ",: ,i" I:' . "., i': >: :1,::, it :' .,,::)~ ".. ': '11 "rl '; "i'~ ; ", -. ::-E: '<:>.:. ....'.1-:. ,,(:: ~ :,,"':(':0 [', y, ;~ -~, ., ':i liY d t :f' h: : '.") -;. p ~ ,. T' ....:' :i. " :"":'\,1 'J :.. i ;::: .::"("'. " 'cr. .. t~,,: ...n'" '''',"' ~.. r..~:: .,.1 ":::, ~ 'j.: c.t: ' ~'r ' , 2.. ~).;;.' :-r 1::. ::. '. 't'. 'r .- t "C. ;,',:V,;::..,. ;'1 :r .l~' - ", .-.,.' .: i, ';, ,I , .: -;E .n.. l;' :'i- i.', _.:.. 3. w ]. ~r n~.. t'&:' .. ., In:. ::c .1'... ') ,').' ~ " :','!'"; 'f "',' lIo., .). - .: _ 1.11: ;. .'-.. , ~.L.'.' ;') S ~:' " "l-~..~ -: '/ t't< " C L, :'11 :.. I.'i -... '" )0' : J:~'t~ (,:: '-,,j/I' ':j;: . :<:\ .. I r i ,'. < ~ ....; [".." ': r'.c ..: ,:C: "; )-" ," 01' ,.. : ) ( r' ~U :i-. :~, ': . :" ~. !. .'':' . ; .;, r.C ."f. '.1 ;~; r, i '::'..< .. ':~~: r~!:i', ::-n ot" , - f yo:: , c a ~ " ,v t:. !' ::-:'!. ',,", ;~ . ..c. " ;,;....,: ;~', 1 i ;.r c' ":.. '::': , - - ~~ ~ \ :J i -:.. ':. r .. c : '~I t: 'J q:":~ :r:";:..! )' .. \,' -;~. f~' d '::~ t..;.. C ;- t,.l i t. .-:' ":: J" :-~ ....1 E . \rJ ;.,:.nj' :::-n:. - ~ i .:c.::, c.~. ~: 7~1'. :t?r r 'F ,: r' i :Je .: :~l. ;~. Er~'::itv t.:. 'l\. ..1 .sys1. ,,:: ~ le,'T~(:.r,- !~,\.i.~trici:, ':'1 E [:.cr".:.t :,;;-:.1.1 n t ,., t ~l .~ ':"'1:' ,'. __ j " t;.C:~. r'" L._ c;,-~. ,"., . () 'J '.:";. ~' ."1._~. ':.{ c - ".:, - ~ ' "(1 - ~ . d'.:f~ ~?:;:: f. '( .; ( r "j ~,"" . ~ _:::~,.: (;:::~ 1 .:! r,!':'.:.i a9~:r'Y:.:,..;..L ". r ,3,.' :,' t. :~ r ,: f 1: ' ,"!""",:" dE. C"'C: ---::" '.~ r Ie ,~:'k! ~ ....~:..., ", ~,'~i,v :(;~' '!:' "": ~~. :) (' . _r :- :) : ~:) -:+ ';':.. '1... t (.; I",,, b :.1 , . ~ 7 ". , ' .-'f (:' F'...~rr.~:} :- ~ ,~~-; . ::),;.~ l' - :~ 1:": c- == t 1 ~,.....~:r 1:1. :'I{" ..: ~. j. ""! -. - ..; ..;... -, -,"':'.~ J _ :.~ ty '. :'l;~ .. I.. " _ .; .C: >. r.t ,[ .'" ...1 t1 '")1 'I. 1. '~ I ~ r' '.:"1''::.rc' t! l ':-:. ...::;:~ rl' : t c " L, (. r:f' .: C'-:.':~ .:.. f;.~ (' ~ '11'.:. ->: :):" ; J.~ .:. "" r:L:, .~. L '. , .:::.. t;- ,)', ..: '~r -:- ,.. " ..' I ~ " : t ", .:"'; .,.. .... ,~ t" ~ . ", "! . ~ ..... I" "'\":. "!'=Jr .r ~ ~ ~ .0: .: , ; J~.:A !I". ... .::-- ;~,; d by -: :~. a': ': )(', ::::,':3t'.l'1 T .,st '", ;:'r ..:)r' '.0 )J- : .(t: ',< ..' c:~ :-.1_.. '::>, ::.'~l': :' : ~ ... .. >-~ .. - ... - : r'.: ..~::: :' ~. ,1-' "'I. ! ;:. is )' '~: :l~': " i:L , 1"': =,: ".' r-~= -~j r :: r.:. \\ .~ .") r,' -, ,.. -- r ,::; , )1 :: ,- ~..:..:. . 1'. ,'J :: i' ,. r.; ::.... , i!,!'"I'::'l..1n T'J::( '::.:;~3 "" n::c:.':-j e .~ '1 .i :.l" ': r r t" ! . :-l.~i'.: r: .: ;f. 3::-: .Jr.-::; ::. :, ~ .~ ,~~ .~ ': : , ;'):: ~~. r '., !., :':' ",.. .1 - :; ~ ~ ~ 1'.:. ' : I. i ,),"\ ," : 3: ;)'? "" ':r. dr":.' :r i: r: c ~. ~ . .~) 07 pI:. ':T r, ':',e-'~t;-, .:.~ '..,I' v,: r: ."~ I ,. S . r, '.' - ~,,:: ~,~1! 1 t a. '_1 :r~ -::. ,) . :')Y ,f' ,,: ! t J : t ':';1' ;'.' , L -)~ ::,J .~ :11. ~ ':,~ ~ '. J .Po j, ,c .l.< 1 (":j. r .' ~ .. C;", r. ': , , . . ~ .. rr ( t: / cf: (':)\; '; EO;:; t:"; .... l ...: ~. ... ~... ::. ., :')';''',. - -.:\ ';,1 ...; .::: '::c .... :f.)!~r :...r~; ) .....'., t!'.,". E;',crei c.r}' ci c :Vl' ~:n:~" !i !' .~r, ':i t.:, s:: .~~. ct \fJ" E \J( ~/' ,-.':', 10 ~ . l' .:....Y. .. ':':.r".t.:: .' ,~ l _ a :::[" . . , " -,.;:: " ':f:.~;. l:lZ". >: ~ " \" :r ,;; r":. . .1."::' j ,', " ., r ~''iS~~;' :? n, "J: .. ,',.0 ;:;v::::o:~ i ,. I; .- '/~ 'jl; Pf-'..::"I ;p..:."::..a.t.~ '. ..,~ ..0( c.:U': ;'t.:.i:Ttt ni;:.C'~ "'f: ".\, . =~) . 'l~. r ;':c :'(...: -:. d S~.1tl t.,'=;ITt, /-' 1- '.-,:. j ~J. h -: ".C t_ '\: .!:~. ,-: . E~" '."'1: ':' t.., c ~: ""',' .- '. .. \1t , .~ t. ~ rn. t / \ i l: ,:'r ::: ,: :.1 , .. (- .~ (" c' !.-t.,.:: _1_ ::--?'j. "...l: : d f ~:f'.~-~.t~1 5!~'':'1'~':-' __;. ";' .,-~J .'l.:'~:;;.( 't"'3:r~ .t- r.r .r .- +. 'J :- r:'.. ..':' : r .' .' :' 4 ,-:i I':;". I., ..',-.: . ..-, C',~ C.:~.I':.;: ~~I . .i.'1 ,- l'. ~~ )' n.o .. (i "..f; ::: c. ::'~,"';"!:cll;.!;:;d Sf'f::C:" '::'-1- j :. ,~ ;.~ ...-':l ; I" ., ~c~~j c:' " "OJ :)'1 ./ Cl1<::: ,:, .. : jL ':. J, i: S': :.. ':t" , ~~ :. r :~'.: 'J 'p ;'t'. '1 ~':i. .. ':,l'. :,t 3- ,r,',r-; ,,";'.,r.;: ,;', '-,J '_ ";.' IiCln:~ a,:: ,:1-': :: i;...r.:.- :>r. 1:'..aJ , 1- '.: J:. '-': ~ j' l' i r r. ,:1,' ' _ 1 I': ',1 ~): \'. :,;:'~ ( (, :r .....l..~ ~,' :"Jrd f tH rc r :: lCE .1i.r~'CI .":.lr.,se( ..~ I il"': "3: f :: : ~ , ~1 ,~. .: l' (;:n '1' .:1 ," .' - 1..... 1.... -," _ rif.: ,-:. .,,"e- :: r. ;.., ~v.:E.:':'( ... ...::i , , ! :', ~: . : ~ . :: ~ ! r ' ' 'i(...{~a:j s, 'i . .~. ':. ': ::;: -: :. : .1 t ", .;....: : ... .. :', .~ -, '_: y .. . - t:: .J. ;i .J -....... - t ,I' . ;"' '~,+ i " ... :~. ... .. I ~ ,'1' ~ "" . . '"'; ~:."' ~ ii" " 'd' ", 'j , : -;~,,~:C (.,_, . :-<>-1 t :;.-::! . j"'E,"".q. :;..r~. .. ." '. -3. t.: -~. . . - '::-1.....,,:,. ~ .;::n:.' '=,1 ,d 1: ,,>\~t 'j(} ,: P' .L -I ,':. ~1' '/: .-:.' .~. .:0. ,~: . , " .(. .~. :', E':. r :' i' ,(, t: ':,,'" . .1. t ':. ~ :. .~ -! \. ,()~. I ~ 'ld. ::'\ I.: . )T' ;.; i ~', . !::3 :. .' . ':::: i, "'J!- f (; r -~.....::: ::"" ;),.!- ':'.r: " \.-:J 'I ::,t r::~..r :t.. ':.1 ~ S./:"tE:~:' : :r;;r .:.: ~rr~ ..' L ~ ':1':, ,; '" .11: ~p' ::t, 3 '..l'':'~' < . r, :i:': 1....l;... :: 11L: :., ~ ..I' (";' ! .; ...... t...., :-,..,.. t " - " 1. 7. :.I~'(' I ::-:;.:: E. (:.. ... ,~a t i (::-: ~ Cl~) 1='.. r c 'V " , , _',~:. i\.. d. . .: - ~01 '.'. . r j:: ,'n'f ...!:~.:; 1. ,'':: b . . ''''t" ;.1. ::r :. "' . ) .~ t'= n:. ,-: }.:: r" ~:: ':', (' 1': l:_=- ,:1: '" ~;.' z..r.t' ~i:':':'; r: -(: ,", ...,c:.":.-~r(-:J. I. y :1.:I~ '."): :.h ~:j ,. 'r'; s;~.. e, ::C " ':' _".' i:! ... -,r' :: :; " , 'i" ~it:p, .:... t:: ~ /. ".,. .J," '.1" :;" .:' ~ ... _ () r~ t :-i.' .:..~ ( 'ni i. r;~ :": ';'C) 'T- b.', ..-,'. ,',- r~n:.;.;:r:~ !.')vfl:'~ r:.;'. ,..J> ~: -d~, ,.. , ... r ::: i":. fr ,"t;" . ,'..,("- ?,J. , , ,', -, "'c l' ".\p t f~; -1 ( ~~-' ., ,j a:'ld ~. .BiL L'E- ::?r C<: :".: ~ c -: I:', ... () . ~;" r t' r = " ~.. t':: " 1:.' _. (.; ....; !1 ::'. ~- a .:;,; I ',7, , J: (.I ':.:: :'~ ~.~ ::;) ~ .:~. (:". '1:j ~ .:f '."11.1.1:1" propi";'r " ~f t" t '1f': :y~ tf':n :t:: ',(.:,.-'''i~::.:.,,'~''''~'')'l'' :..lp~~.~, .3 .., r .', -;,; ~ ~- (:I " n . . ,'; : :...: 1 C r... ,: , ':1'! ( ; ? ~.i J.l' 'n..:!- r:y -;,,' fErni";.. ~ .,.:" J . :;IV (!': -: to-": ;:-r (l" _c'c'~ 'f' i~:'V' t.., . t . f . t" t~.:,' ..J:.t' :'f'Y ':.r:,\'.;.,:,cl:, :,y "",,,,,., ....., == :..L'iRor', ~/: = 1',1,-\1.. R E,s C J ~~::: ?::.I; '.-IIT Ch .~\PTEF~ l-C:E..~ :~ ': :::a~. jl'~ D'Jia:ti!);"1 .:~; Ferm~ts L'.~' <;~"'5 I'ev .:':~ ed cr Qtna '\v:s.; m~d. ;n;.:! :h:: .:: ..1' at:c .. ~~.: .~ 1 ~:n ..I,(.:r '" :;i" ~a rCS;Q'....\::.:;.:~. -:". '::.51.. ~',: . id:-r :~ <.-3 .:. '~':-_: ~rE' C'" .:I,apt3f 4C E.4tJ, i=.A.C. i:; as ;.:: 1:)voiS . l' F~'~ ,; =:~rCE:~'~l ~i e~::":'rava: t.y(> ) ::-!:S f O:'} tn~ da~c c: :..;'"Ja:1Cf~ ;:,;"tt..; C3''3 5pt':;:~'~?1 3~;:' :.::",(l.:.Jt1 cft19 p-.;"'l'1.t ... ~ eS5\VJ~h,rl ~'''a:' ret.::~i E": a~:i~':dtcn fot 3''', jl- :;'"'.!,juci Ot S1.31da'-;j g~ne"a r~"-::i :, f.eJ for a-,y p)1i~'f1 of tlE: p-Cject If an app ca~'Ol fo' a~ 12-,'/ rC'iTer:a' :eS;)J;':e per'''1, is fi'cc : is:1 the CO:i:61: :~a ap;::rcva reTla:";s ....fl j U'lt! f I" 3' a:t ::lrs :a~:e" 00 :'I~ ~m"r::'r rrerlal ~esc Tee:: S "',i :,:~: :~1',IO('l, "l":; a~'p i-;;at 0:' S ~',~I':;j ~;"en P'e c.::"::;:p:.la: 61=prC;,.;3 is vaiid for ar :wd tiona: I.v,:;. ',:.00'5 :',::11 '-:(- C:?'e Of '55 ):;:' :;S 0' t-',~ pnn:: C .;;".:=p:ua' :~;r:'( .:,vais wh :::11 r:E1', e r =' 'n:jl\l iell,.1i cr sta "'cer'j :e,.,e.'~l e-,' ",:::1'ner,t3! resc.Jrce rer,..,it a~ piica::0J15 r IE::, fOi a eer ad of 1'.\0 feai.::' sl1a:1 ex~\i"e r.. ':' -' :~:~!C~l" a' !:e e1d ::1 1;',? :'N(l yeElr peria::;, _' :::c- ace '"l::E-P:,,3' 2o~roval fll.::o .:;;:::,...ctneI1H) wit.'1 a 'ja ,:!!op"nei't .,; reg,,)1ai l'Ti;JE:ct :C:i-;,' ;, j:; ic:r ':;- :)j (~:;ve op-ne'1( ap~: "ova, (AC'A.) and a loca; g,,:r>iernnH:1C ':O"1;ye,,:;:r !';,'ip' plan c, ,r.endr1,:nt. ' '-:' : .,",,'iO':: :b; c~::"f:~,:)!:',3 sPPic'V3Isr:rl be t',\,':) y€:a;s fiC1'1 \'j"';,'::i":eVei ~:r:e c' (i-:e fc !.)wij~ C::,(U"s at tr.-: :;~:c;t): :ate t~:e e'TE!cti'...e dat;; of the :~'cal ;overnr:lellL s CO,T,pre'€;,l~-:;1Vt' rla:- a:" ;;;'d '1"'3, l 2 the effeci ve date o~ the local gO'lef:1lT ent d;;ve!ocme!'1 t 0,-<1:' .. t!l~ datE.: C:1 'Nh;ch tre C1istnC! i.5SJCS trie c(J:11;ep~\Jai a:p."o\a:, :;." 4 ll": l;'if~3t ;:1a:e cf :'"l€' resolut:t)i} of a;IY C"as:::er 120 ::7. FA C ,a'!"','E,f.ra'\'Ic proc:€'ed (}~i .t' ':' 't,;'" :~,~,a 2~~e;'l!s ,J' Fo' 8r, :i1l"V,':C3i : r Stcl:1::J.3({1 ge"er?!! e:w,rcr:msnt:3 :-eso,..-ce p.3,'''11, f'.'::: yeE',rs f'Jm :r:E c:,'e c C SS":;;,1ce C' SL;C~: .~!,"l)U'lt c,f t;(.;e ciS ,',ade a CC'l,:n;rJ"! c,1' :'1e p'3,.".;f, '.d Fer a "creed (;~"I::r;:l: pe:'T:: '5SL:eO Ql."'SiJsr,t tc. ch~',iJtf;~ 4~-E-4,=,:, r ~\,~.. f;'ve ',~3rs i.~lr:' '.'<, ,j::: .0:. ',',,," ,',.',-", ,.,: :r,te'" '(' -I"';:' j"e "e-'T,t 1'5 P"U'\ :,i~.: ~'... I,"~ i';';'nr' . . ..... _... ~.....' ......""'....... .. . ..1............. r'" ". ,. I 'II "~"""'_..,,,,, J..... - ""'.... .....\. ~'2".a) l,h~'3S c,re5U tee tv Sp~C!8' O'2p"t C;Jlid.tl::n DenT1its exp:'e C!u~'=rTati::al:~/,3CCO'-C;'-:g to ~ :- ',"i2<:'cll~'(:5 i:':d:ated if' to'. S rU!~ if ;1p,::iic3'cn fe:' extel1S,Q,l is made :', lJF t,tig 1>.,"~',1(1t te' S~,b32,::tiJ' -!'l t"E: :e;"r-~it 5-:t?~! fer!'~ain in fu" f)~:~ a!1j e;fe~ct Ufiti:: P'iS GoveT!flg 8:el,,:l IBh:sac:c:'l lYi;;,n ~ppi :atiu f;:' 2,:';;"5;;:)', of a" ind:'JdJe p~rr1i:" 0: s~.arrtckes ~:cto"" Ci en aq~~!::a~io'1 f(~'e'ttt!(lsic: r~fCi s:~r~.?~j n.~\l-'e'~a~ perri- ~ , ::J; irr: ta, :;)',::;r ,A tr,= p,,:), eel !)Jtf ai: S:"U :;'v:€. S~',al' 'i':)! c:Jf'st'L:te c 'H.1'A:ng :)~ t~12 per'l':' 3 The PSrrT'i: e).:i.e~5io" ~h3ii te iSSlj~C ~:"'Jvided [~,c:l;:Ii p-err.',:tf.-::: ; e::. a .\:,~:e') ree; ;65: w:-, .,,;; .~, .<"': ~ ':0'." ;'c qoed ::a:.,5;'> ::: ':0: to the e~{t.."~a:lcr '..of ~;,e, I);,;.-':-"t i=u [:. :.' Gl" .J(::..: ()r t ii" :. ...<~ ::):;C:, ".., '.~ :,',,;;,. ,',""",r ; ~:., ,..r OXI''''',' :Oi'~C' -,..-J....."ts.".;>"',' JISI'j,:, "r t' '" cr":~j' ,,,,: ..',,~ I c,-",'!'..,., Re:"'-';::oc:+", ~-". _ .....,. .. _.... ~ '_ .\_ .~'. ' ~ J.,.... il'... :....__.... .... t.' .... .; .... ,. ~ ,. .~- \......~,. ..l~'-"''''_. E" ...:ts M.S.: 15 /!, hie,., sha' ~'.C 'J::-: a j JCL. "'r~7;;rtatlcn n~ t~e G x le.;t"l':-i t.r.:~ .:l:'C:J~"'" .,;r,~1'''' .:.:;.'~ ~! ~,ti I-':) I; ti~l ~:Y' ," 3\:;:? ~':!;;;""3j llis p~C'ject. IN: ~), 0': a::e;:W:d more t~,an '18J ;j3'15 pr1o' to t~e ':?XO,!'.l'.:C;\ :::a~=. ~: Sl,~5tar'::8 n'(:oif:':31iolS to C..Jn,:::epbal App~ov<Jls N':I e:(te"'l,j the dvat,:)- of ,'18 C(::C8~':..a, ApprOVed for tw':) yea~s fron', the cc!te of is';d3.1ce of thai1odif,,:;atlon Fo!' ti":e plllposes of It s s~ctlOtl. the term "substantial modiflcat:o'1" ,hail rnean a modificatl~n \'\h:ch is rcaso!'1ab11 expected to i~:3;: ~c Sl!t'stant aly differer:t wa;er reS00rce or environmental [",pacts which :eq'J;,'e a jetal!ed rev;ey.!. (5) SUOSWiI!:Cl: rrodifi~atio;1s to indIVidual or sta'1dard (Jer<eral ei!vlr\:mm~nlal resou~ce ~:E:T':,:S ::;-5~l-:::j p.Jrsuan: to c! perm;! apr:,c-3tio': e:'(t~r.d tre du"atlf)r' 0" tho? ~le"rr:'l fc,r t(rel.~ years rrnlT! \(;: :h:.:: (;~ :3S:.lSnCe ~f ti1-: :i10dlf:("at,or. InO'V'CLCli c: ~)ta:-1cj"lj ~el' era envlrr:'ire",,,'! r""~,(;drCe perm t "oj7ical': -:5 ();;; no! e:<:;e,-d the d.!;a~lcr: o' a cClcer.'tu<11 a:J;)rov~,. ('3:: Perr',:1 :~1C.i:hfiC3t:ors ,s~.JI:::~ p.J:"SiJ,1t,: tJ !3~,;~ser:icr! 4':E-4 331 ~2<b.;, F i~ C. Jetter TIO::;'icatl: ":"J .:;'J r,ot e,(t:nd t:- e CUia',Oi'; of a iC'~;'l1:t (7) Fa;IJre ~o cQmp!'::~~~ cct5~"uctlor or a!tera:iClr; cf ti""'e 5l.lrra-::; ,^,at~f ~':a'lac~:i;e;'it 5'isterr: ,31C1 C,J:B:~: oce-aticn ph3~le apprev.:J' r'-(lii' VIe D'str":t 'Nllr ", :~1::: p_~':r" : d~.-at<;n sha:: .eqlJir>3 a re~'l perrn: dc>:r:zalrl1 r. :n~ar t:' ~::';': '1',:"3 cor'stfl.:U:1 V1'E':.S a perT::t e,<:Oi"ls:::: 's g'ant"::c. ::::e,i~Cal.i:tc:~.i~la'3044 :,":i ~?I;:;-;. r"/~y:i-:'T2rtec:T~~"3.3:.:.t\.:).::'734',~ ~7'3J2~-F 5 '-:ls~c-.,-'::",,9-3"1~1. A "e~j3: 1.2,.....:.;. 1::......::!. ;::~.~i1~r !.;..:..~.'j.l(r..~'r~!::',"C€C' :-..l..3r. 4.2~i9~, P-.t":f:'"',:ej :;:.~..:';'. 4t'2J/;~ ,!... :...:~. 02/81/2085 13:25 561434~~# i -- T- '~'", PINDER TROUTMAN '-' PAGE: 02 NO.604S P.2 i , D ...._.,~t._~ I ....... ,.. PA ...._ -.r........... .L SM1"1 . =l: I . .... .....~ =..-:.= ,.,....~. AdIIaI..~_ ICAIWt To J... J--+ .....+en *'Y~ 1lIft~ 0...., MI......... I I ,....... I ..."..,--L,.,. ..............~~ O,.....~PlM r P"bN,ry 1. 2008 . .. l RIS: a.tGI-G310 ,.,....,- (1..10.. TOWI CtItIIr &"toft VII....) l! ITANDAMI R!VIIW Our Mr. Rumpf: tII. fie"" .... ~ for... .- '- TrIfIIo ~1"ntC Tr'Iflfc DIvIIfon .. ,....,..,lhetraftlo ~.. _pan.... ~ ... ,projHt antIIIed; WIMftIeW ,........,. c:omprIIeCI or Lwa I ... 80rnt0n,.... CtntIrA __"...... pu,.... . ....... In Ari;Ia 12 or the ""m IacIt COuntr L..nd : T1tII ~ II 'l.IInmIfIIIcI. roIIawI: ; or COnsJraa AV8., North or Old loynton Read. ... La""": .....,.11tJI ........ u..: ..__.... u.. .". M' Rwldentllll unltl (Co~",,",). ae8,QQO 6" a.mol t 10.000 8' _11'11 0ftI0e. Nfw ..., TttIM: I,..... r N", PH TttpI: 3 Am .,.Si.IST flU ' ~ .......lIty~ . ': ~ ; . ..... an our . . the TnlftIc 0iYIEcn tin ~lnld 111\ the ~ mlxea-UN I f =:-- -- ramc ~_ 8ttnd" of'PIIm each Cou~, under... , . · 110..... """*' lOr.... .... 1110 _ _ PM peok hour lItpo until : I aonnucl n t)1IIn~ Iddllion of ttWd WI and E8 ~ .. Gf\ tIoU1 : I IPProe of Cht..~f' Bo.ant Ilk the interucitican CJf CGrispwtI AVlnue. : t " No lJuNn perrnftI ftjrmen U1an 411 ftew axtemll PM _ hour IrfPt until CIOIIItN _lne!CftlClcfillan ofNllijIIl Je1l.tum IanIIWIIt pr....reoeIvIng ..... or OptIOn ottppraprttte CftAU.8. rat' ItlllntlfMdiOn of Old 8oynton PtOId 1M o~ rue, 1 ~ pem;te .. mort ....n 183 nWl MImI! PM ~ hour.. until ; i Mllnl 1M' addition of ....1VI . du.l tdetum .... \filth ' , .pprap fIGIlYlng~ 111"1., cr IdoPllon of .~ CAALL8 It the ) IritirUctla or Old 8CiJrdOn ROGel IInd ~ Avenua. '\.' . ) · No buQltln plrmltl fcif more "In I'B oew extIrntI PM P"~ hour btpe untQ 09" ....tn, -fir _en or In MIIUt1vo E8 l1Qht-\um .. .. the · I"..... of G_wit 8o~Je".~ and COtlQC'MI Avenue. ,~~ :l J( : I PACE 214 t RCVD AT 211120051:22:44 PM ~astem Standard Time] t SVR:FTLWEB1/4 * D~3442 * CSlD:5614341663 * DURATION (mm.ss):02.36 bLI01/2005 13:25 I I ~ r, ~< ~~~ , . ',), ' I I I I I I - I I I I I 56"143 ,",' t PINDER TROUTMAN '~', PAGE 03 : I """'~. 64ir"""-P. 3 . ... . I *... """ I" 'lo. ,,/ ~ { ! ~ .. f ! , ~ I c c '*"* far men thin _ heW"mII PM ~ hoqr _ until : -- fOr ...... fA Old ~ ..- 1cNIwIrd. tam ~ "...... to ~ IIeIIoh 1ktutMnI. or ....... of ~".. J ' .. ar aome lnka... thellttrf8ll11f1'!tnt :: Plrmlflfarmen .. '~f' ,.. '*"* PM... htlurtrlr>> unal i 1..111 "lddIIon of.....,.,... ~""ar8dclPaon r:I 1 cMlU, 1Itthe........, "'~ JlGuI8Vlrd ancr eanar- . pImI!!. fwmcn thin 1,1" nWl __ PM... haur ttfpt until I ~- fOr IGdftIan of ~ I. ct. WHama ..,... lit: 1M ~ of 011( Ioynton RaId W __ Iuah 1ou1aVlrd. ~ !*mila formate thM 1_ ,., ~... PM ~k hour _ until { I ....,.,. for 8-I1ft1n1 or eonar- Awnue. rrotn LIntIn8 Itoa '" . · No bUIld ptfmIta fOr ma,. 11l1li1.$41 new... PM PM hour ttrp.. : aa .... for Mtnln, f1P ear.,... Avenu'. _ ,... ....d tD Met. LInt. I ; , · &xClIaMIw ,.,. "1'IqU1IId the folTDwlrlg proJIct IClC:IllloQIdonl, \VIWt : nat MIll II ; o -net NBR 111m ,.. llong Ca~ MnW It the"ont'WnOIt ; ICCIII d~r : o turn ... ... COne..... ~wt'I~. It .,. m*re PraJeot.... i oR"'" ItnI .... eon.,.. Avenul If .. lfMtI-mott p'" I .... i .; hm-.... ofmun_J'~tord". "ecl.wlop.,.must i ~("A)WIth~"'ch~tofunQ__1D " InpovIiMntI that.. .. 'AwUrIf COnItruaIIGnw ..the term" : ~ ...... ORIlnMGCL ltle PFA mUll: be In . farm :=-. 1M mu~. IhatI nat .. IllY IXI_ II. unreu .. unll Ita PJrA hit bten Ippruyed by'" m...... to be a..u.d byth. CfW. afterttte bufld-outci.te ~ .1MNe. rrerq lPPftMlI"IU~. ttut PrajlCtaltlreo-tton Rut" lit not ItIncIlWCII ORllnlll1Cl. . 'I I I I PAGE 314 * RCVD AT ~1120051 :22:44 PM ~astern standard TIme] * SVR:FTLWEB1/4 * DNlS:3442 * CSlD:5614341663 * DURATION Imm-ss):02.36 31/2005 13:25 I ..(. r- , .. ~, .~~~ . , ,\...' . I I 56143 ,? PINDER TROUTMt}N PAGE 04 NO.648 -':'.4' " ..... ...~ ~"-" ! 4 ......, .....,,; . ...... = RClIId. thl hlah 10,.._' valUlQU for GnaWIY I!tauIewanl, anc;t th. ; I_a n~ fOrtillPPRMt~ It,....., for &he Clrto ~ Of GltIwIv Boulevard. from ConI,. AWIn.. to M. RJq. i . I · Due ID '" fJWt farr1tId JMHIk hoUr VOIu",_ JtRMlfan of ~. toIrowin. ' ! In tJ.m.MItt.. 'UQOtat". Wh.. f'08*lble: : I o S lit ItIe ...... of eq... Avenu.1ftCI OM Iovntan RoM. : e .... IIICIDnd WlR .... .. tIte InIIrHaIon of 1DM*n..." ! Iftcl 0Id~,,~. : o N Ith "'l'IKIan at ~ BouIMRt .net HIgh RIcIga Acted. : i ..bjIct to the concIiIfOM Ht forth in "....... ".. aondtIah. .' ~Otd... iIeued.".,.~. TNt DilWIDramnOnler ! I'I'Md .,., PRWIcht fIlIurt to nwM."" r:I u.. oaMIoIII ... gIVe the cauntv I I!nIfntwtN~),t IIIdnd or imMel the ~.rantId In tltll TI'IfItc PIIr1bml... i . -.... RevMw ... If t'O&f hew or If """'''I tN. deterrn.." pt.... aonttGt rM It ".~030. SfnQe,.tJ, , I i , ~ICI 0," THE hr). I I . I i 1 I ! ~ q ~ [ ~ I j I : ( ! ~ PAGE 414 t RCVD AT 211120051 :22:44 PM IEastem standard Time] t SYR:FTLWEB114 t DNIS:3442 t CSlD:5614341663 t DURATION lmm-ss):02-36 ,-.... , ' ~ ~~ ~ ""'" January 30,2006 Mr. Carl Klepper Compson Associates, Inc. 980 North Federal Highway Suite 200 Boca Raton, FL 33432 Re: Boynton Village/ Boynton Town Center CRALLS Amendment Dear Carl: The City of Boynton Beach has received a Notice of Intent that Comprehensive Plan Amendments 2005-049 thru 2005-60 for Palm Beach County have been found by OCA to be in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan. A portion of these Amendments relate to the CRALLS benefiting the Winchester Development. This Notice was issued January 24th, with copy of same distributed to both you and me by Ms. Kim Glas-Castro of Ruden McClosky on January 25th, 2006. Please find a hard copy of this Notice attached to this letter, as well as the Staff Report from the second hearing of the Pahn Beach County Commission. This took place on November 28' 2005, and it was at this time that the Amendments were adopted by the County for DCA final action. This will become final action from DCA on the CRALLS after a twenty-one (21) day appeal period, or February 14, 2006. Richard Foreman Senior Development Manager Cc: file Joe Filippelli lC Sc v~ The Sembler Company Shopping Center Development & Management 1450 South Johnson Ferry Road, Suite 100. Atlanta, Georgia 30319.404-847-1800. Fax 404-847-1818 /; .., "" ~ PUBLISHED IN THE PALM BEACH POST ON 1/24/06 ST A TE OF FLORIDA DEP ARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS NOTICE OF INTENT TO FIND PALM BEACH COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT IN COMPLIANCE DOCKET NO. 05-2-NOI-500 I-(A)-(l) The Department gives notice of its intent to find the Amendment to the Comprehensive Plan for Palm Beach County, adopted by Ordinance Nos. 2005-049 thru 2005-060, on November 28, 2005, IN COMPLIANCE, pursuant to Sections] 63.3184. 163.3187 and 163.3] 89, F.S. The adopted Palm Beach County Comprehensive Plan Amendment and the Department's Objec- tions, Recommendations and Comments Report, (if any), are available for public inspection Monday through Friday, except for legal holidays, during nonnal business hours, at the Palm Beach County Planning, Zoning and Bui]ding Department. 100 Australian Avenue. West Palm Beach, Florida 33406. Any affected person, as defined in Section] 63.3] 84, F.S., has a right to petition for an admin- istrative hearing to challenge the proposed agency detennination that the Amendment to the Palm Beach County Comprehensive Plan is In Compliance, as defined in Subsection 163.3] 84(1), F.S. The petition must be filed within twenty-one (21) days after publication of this notice, and must include all of the infonnation and contents described in Unifonn Ru]e 28-] 06.20], F.A.C. The petition must be filed with the Agency Clerk, Department of Community Affairs, 2555 Shumard Oak Bou]evard, Tallahassee, F]orida 32399-2] 00, and a copy mailed or delivered to the loca] government. Fai]ure to timely file a petition shall constitute a waiver of any right to request an administrative proceeding as a petitioner under Sections ]20.569 and 120.57, F.S. If a petition is filed, the purpose of the administrative hearing will be to present evidence and testimony and forward a recommended order to the Department. If no petition is filed, this Notice of Intent shall become final agency action. If a petition is filed, other affected persons may petition for leave to intervene in the proceeding. A petition for intervention must be filed at least twenty (20) days before the final hearing and must include all of the infonnation and contents described in Unifonn Ru]e 28-106.205, F.A.C. A petition for leave to intervene shall be filed at the Division of Administrative Hearings, Department of Management Services, 1230 Apa]achee Parkway, Tallahassee, F]orida 32399-3060. Fai]ure to petition to intervene within the allowed time frame constitutes a waiver of any right such a person has to request a hearing under Sections ]20.569 and ]20.57, F.S., or to participate in the administrative hearing. After an administrative hearing petition is timely filed, mediation is available pursuant to Sub- section 163.3189(3)(a), F.S., to any affected person who is made a party to the proceeding by filing that request with the administrative law judge assigned by the Division of Administrative Hearings. The choice of mediation shall not affect a party's right to an administrative hearing. -s-K. Marlene Conaway Chief of Comprehensive Planning Division of Community Planning Department of Community Affairs 2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee. F]orida 32399-2100 I. CALL TO ORDER """". ... " '''''''''' FINAL AGENDA PALM BEACH COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ADOPTION PUBLIC HEARING FOR ROUND 05-2 Monday, November 28,2005 A. Roll Call - 9:30 a.m. B. Opening Prayer and Pledge of Allegiance C. Remarks of the Chair: D. Proof of Publication MOTION: To receive and file proof of publication. E. Comments By the Planning Director 1.E.1. MOTION: 1.E.2. MOTION: 1.E.3. MOTION: 1.E.4. MOTION: 1.E.5. MOTION: Land Use Advisory Board 2005 Annual Report Motion to receive and file Annexation 2005 Annual Report Motion to receive and file Comprehensive Plan Implementation 2005 Annual Report Motion to receive and file PBIA 2005 Annual Report Motion to receive and file Initiation of Amendment Round 06-1 Motion to initiate the items in Round 06-1 as recommended by staff BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda """......... ... ' ......., 2. OPEN PUBLIC HEARING 2.A. PROPOSED TRANSPORTATION AMENDMENTS - which did not receive objection or comment from DCA . ITEM DESCRIPTION RECOMMENDA TIONI ACTION 2.&1 This proposed amendment will amend Policy 1.1-n Planning: Approval Corridor Master time frame associated with the development of the LPA: Approval (9-0). Plans Time Corridor Master Plans. BCC: Transmit with a modification (6-0, Frame Update with Commissioner Koons absent). At the Initiated at the request of the County Engineering hearing, Board discussion focused on the Department. modification which included language that added prioritization of five specific corridors to be completed within 2 years of adoption of this amendment and an additional 2 years for the next four prioritized corridor plans to be completed. There was no public comment on this item. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Transportation Element pursuant to the proposed Corridor Master Plans Time Frame Update amendment. 2.B. PROPOSED TRANSPORTATION AMENDMENTS - which did receive objection or comment from DCA 2.B.1 Congress/Old Boynton .QB~Jd~~ RECOMMENDATIONI ACTION Planning: Approval LPA: Approval with a modification (10-0). The modification incorporated part of the City's proposed alternative language allowing for a fee in-lieu of providing affordable units. BCC: Transmit with a modification (6-0, with Commissioner Koons absent). At the hearing, Board discussion focused on the linkage between CRALLS and affordable housing conditions. The modification incorporated part of the City's proposed alternative language allowing for a fee in-lieu of providing affordable units. Michael Rumph, the City of Boynton Beach's Planning and Zoning Director and a representative of the Winchester Property spoke and indicated support for the modification. DCA OBJECTIONS: The Department is objecting on the basis that the CRALLS designations are internally inconsistent with Policy 1.2-q in that they don't improve mobility in the corridor and identify specific mitigation measures related to traffic, evaluate measures to encourage the use of alternatives to the Florida Interstate Highway System, determine the timing and responsibility of the implementation of mitigation measures, identify methodology related to the anticipated impacts of development to the mitigation measures, and demonstrate coordination with appropriate agencies. Recommendation: Demonstrate consistency with Policy 1.2-q, through appropriate data and analysis. Initiated at the request of the City of Boynton Beach. ITEM DESCRIPTION This proposed amendment will amend the Transportation Element and Map Series by designating several segments and intersections in the vicinity of Boynton Beach Mall as Constrained Roadway at Lower Level of Service (CRALLS) facilities. STAFF RESPONSE: Mitigation measures have already been identified in the policy language (see Exhibit 1 of the Staff Report). Additional Considerations (Policy TE 1.2-q) section of Exhibit 2 of the Staff Report clearly demonstrates, in detail, the consistency with the Policv 1.2-0. A DCA reoresentative has indicated a favorable review of this response in our phone conversations. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Transportation Element and Map Series pursuant to the proposed Conaress/Old Boynton CRALLS amendment. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 2 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda DESCRIPTION This proposed amendment will amend the Transportation Element and Map Series by designating several segments on Atlantic Avenue as a Constrained Roadway at Lower Level of Service (CRALLS) facilities exclusively for purposes of concurrency for certain project located in that aeneral area. DCA COMMENTS: The Department is objecting on the basis that the CRALLS designations are internally inconsistent with TE Policy 1.2-q in that they don't improve mobility in the corridor and identify specific mitigation measures related to traffic, evaluate measures to encourage the use of alternatives to the Florida Interstate Highway System, determine the timing and responsibility of the implementation of mitigation measures, identify methodology related to the anticipated impacts of development to the mitigation measures, and demonstrate coordination with appropriate agencies. Recommendation: Demonstrate consistency with TE Policy 1.2-q, through appropriate data and analysis. "" ~ ITEM 2.B.2 Atlantic Avenue CRALLS ..., ......, RECOMMENDA TIONI ACTION Planning: Approval LPA: Approval (11-0). BCC: Transmit (6-0, with Commissioner Koons absent). At the hearing, there was minimal Board discussion and no public comment on this item. STAFF RESPONSE: This is a temporary CRALLS which will expire after West Atlantic Avenue is widened to six lanes from Turnpike to Jog Road and to four lanes from SR-7 to Lyons Road. The widening of the road has to be done before December 31st 2008 or no building permits will be issued to the developers. Once after the widening of West Atlantic Avenue is completed there will be no necessity for this CRALLS since the roadway will function well within its capacity. Generally for temporary CRALLS when mitigation opportunities are limited the County does not insist on mitigation measures since the roadway is anyway not going to be constrained permanently. However the major mitigation measure of this project is that it will be relieving traffic on State Road 7 which is projected to carry heavy traffic on the long term. This mitigation measure is an important land use/site planning technique (shown in Policy 1.2-q) that will balance land use/traffic regionally. Also we are modifying this CRALLS to include additional properties which will contribute towards widening of West Atlantic Avenue. Hence taking into consideration the temporary nature of this CRALLS and the fact that it includes an important mitiqation technique of balancinq land use/traffic in a reqional scale, this CRALLS is consistent with TE Policy 1.2-0. To adopt an ordinance amending the Transportation Element and Map Series pursuant to the proposed Atlantic Avenue CRALLS amendment. This proposed amendment will amend the Transportation Element and Map Series by revising and expanding the existing Okeechobee Blvd CRALLS. MOTION: Planning: Approval LPA: Approval (7-3). BCC: Transmit (4-2, Commissioners Marcus and McCarty dissenting and Commisisoner Koons absent). At the hearing, Board discussion focused on the potential premature timing of this amendment since the point system is yet to be adopted in the ULDC and the status of the Roebuck Road extension from Jog Road to SR-7. There was no public comment on this item. DCA COMMENTS: The Department is objecting on the basis that the CRALLS designations are internally inconsistent with TE Policy 1.2-q in that they don't improve mobility in the corridor and identify specific mitigation measures related to traffic, evaluate measures to encourage the use of alternatives to the Florida Interstate Highway System, determine the timing and responsibility of the implementation of mitigation measures, identify methodology related to the anticipated impacts of development to the mitigation measures, and demonstrate coordination with appropriate agencies. Additionally, Okeechobee CRALLS capacity is being increased without addressing how the increased capacity ensures adequate facility capacity to serve the existing and future land uses or how mobility will be enhanced. Recommendation: Demonstrate consistency with TE Policy 1.2-q, through appropriate data and analysis. Apply appropriate mitigation measures to the Okeechobee CRALLS to mitigate the increased capacity being assigned. ~J?3 Okeechobee g RA l;J..::~ STAFF RESPONSE: This CRALLS will not take effect until the point system is adopted in the Unified Land Development Code. The point system was a combined effort of the County and FDOT. The point system consists of fourteen mitigation strategies. Each mitigation strategy has a certain amount of points attached to it. Applicants meeting the minimum required point totals will receive approval. Seven of the fourteen mitigation strategies available in the point system are also available in TE Policy 1.2-q. County believes that the point system has sufficient mitigation measures to improve mobilitv in the corridor and that it is consistent with TE Policv 1.2-q. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Transportation Element and Map Series pursuant to the proposed Okeechobee CRALLS amendment. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 3 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda ",,", . .~., ......, 2.C. PROPOSED TEXT AND MAP SERIES AMENDMENTS - which did not receive objection or comment from DCA ITEM 2.C.1 TOR Density Ca!culations in the Urb"!!l Suburban Tier {Glades Areal 2.C.2 Tier BOlll1dary Redesignation gIil!;lrL~ .?&d Revitalization. Redevelopment and lnfil! (R~ Sub-O..!2J.gctivf!: MOTION: Lg.4 E.!-.lturQ...b.?_od .!d.~ Element and ~J!as Re.'{~j.2!1~ MOTION: DESCRIPTION This proposed amendment will amend the Future Land Use Element by adding language under Objective 2.6 specifying that the TDR density calculation for a property in the Glades Tier is 3 units per acre or 4 units per acre for a property in a RRO. This proposed amendment will amend the Future Land Use and Introduction and Administration Elements by revising the criteria/ including additional criteria to justify movement of a tier boundary (i.e. must be contiguous to the Urban/Suburban Tier). This proposed amendment will amend the Future Land Use Element by: . revising Sub-Objective 1.2.3 and its associated policies to include revitalization, redevelopment and infill considerations and to reflect current conditions; and . deleting Policies 1.2.3-f and 1.2.3-g. This proposed amendment is a result of a recommendation of the EAR. RECOMMENDATIONI ACTION Planning: Approval LPA: Approval (13-0). BCC: Transmit (6-0, with Commissioner Koons absent). At the hearing, there was minimal Board discussion and no public comment on this item. Planning: Approval LPA: Approval (11-0). BCC: Transmit with a modification (5-1, with Commissioner Marcus dissenting and Commissioner Koons absent). At the hearing, Board discussion focused on whether private applicants should be permitted to request tier changes. The modification was to remove language proposed by staff that would have disallowed private applicants to request tier changes. Three members of the public spoke; one in support of staff's recommendation, one in support of the modification, and one stating that no land use changes in the western area of the county should be allowed after Scripps. Planning: Approval LPA: Approval (11-0). BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Aaronson and Koons absent). At the hearing, there was minimal Board discussion and no public comment on this item. To adopt an ordinance amending the Introduction and Administration Element and Future Land Use Element pursuant to the proposed Agenda Items 2.C.1 throuah 2.C.3. This proposed amendment will amend the Future Planning: Approval Land Use Element and Future Land Use Atlas to LPA: Approval (8-0). maintain consistency with the technical aspects of BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners the digital FLUA by: Aaronson and Koons absent). At the . deleting any reference in the text to hearing, there was minimal Board overlays on the FLUA; discussion and no public comment on this . deleting overlays from the FLUA; and item. reclassifying the FLUA 'Notes' as Administrative. To adopt an ordinance amending the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Atlas pursuant to the proposed Future Land Use Element and Atlas Revisions amendment. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 4 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda ."'~""""" \!b",J ......, ITEM DESCRIPTION RECOMMENDATIONI ACTION ~.C.5 The proposed amendment to the Housing Element Planning: Approval Workforce will update Policy 1.5-h revising the timeframe that LPA: Denial (11-0). HOllsinq Policy allows BCC evaluation of the effectiveness of the BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Update program from 3 years to 1 year, consistent with Aaronson and Koons absent). At the recent BCC direction. hearing, there was minimal Boa rd discussion and no public comment on this item. 2.C.6 This proposed amendment will amend portions of Planning: Approval Health and the Heath and Human Services Element by adding LPA: Approval (9-0). Human Services language that encourages physical activity and BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Y..n d a JQ healthy lifestyles through utilization of specific Aaronson and Koons absent). At the community design strategies. hearing, there was minimal Board discussion and no public comment on this Initiated at the request of the County Health item. Department. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Housing Element and Health and Human Services Element pursuant to the proposed AQenda Items 2.C.5 throuqh 2.C.6. 2.C.Z This proposed amendment will amend the Capital Planning: Approval Capital Improvement Element by updating Tables 1-17. LPA: Approval (10-0). Improv~.meDj BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Element (CI~ Aaronson and Koons absent). At the Tabl~ l!Q.dal~ hearing, there was minimal Board discussion and no public comment on this item. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Capital Improvement Element pursuant to the proposed amendment. 2.C.8 This proposed amendment will amend the Planning: Approval p.Ql.L.QLPa 1m Transportation Element and Coastal Management LPA: Approval (10-0). Beach Master Element by updating policies to include the new Port BCC: Transmit (6-0, with Commissioner Pl? n _Ulli! ate of Palm Beach Master Plan. Koons absent). At the hearing, Board discussion included the reference made to Initiated at the request of the Port of Palm Beach. Peanut Island in the Master Plan. There was no public comment on this item. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Transportation Element and Coastal Management Element pursuant to the proposed Port of Palm Beach Master Plan Update amendment. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 5 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda ,"",.,# ..-..... ........, 2.0. PRIVATELY INITIATED SITE SPECIFIC AMENDMENTS - To the Future land Use Atlas, which did receive objection or comment from DCA ITEM 2.0.1 Yamatoi SR 7 US 441 - SE (LGA 2005-00031) District: 5 Request: DESCRIPTION UIT (7.40 ac.) & HR-8 (9.61 ac.) to CU8 (7.42 ac.) & INST/8 (9.59 ac.) 17.01 acres Southeast corner of Yamato Road and SRl7 - US 441. RECOMMENDAT10NI ACTION Planning: Approval w/Conditions LPA: Approval of Staff's recommendation (8- 3). BCC: Transmit (6-0, with Commissioner Koons absent). At the hearing, the Board discussion focused on concerns regarding the size of usable open space and thus gave direction to staff that additional lands be provided in order to have park space that included between 2.4 and 5 acres on non-submerged usable open space. Nineteen members of the public spoke raising concerns regarding the need for additional commercial, and the remaining park size. Conditions: . Non-residential development on the CL/8 portion of the site shall be limited to a maximum of 50,000 square feet. . Development on INST/8 portion of the site shall be limited to school uses with a maximum of 72,000 square feet and a Congregate Living Facility (CLF) with a maximum of 94 beds. If the site develops alternatively with residential uses (other than a CLF), the site shall be governed by the density allowed under the HR-8 land use designation. . At the time a rezoning application is submitted for this site, the application must include the entire property subject to this amendment. DCA COMMENTS: The Department is objecting on the basis that the data and analysis presented with the amendment demonstrates the Level of Service Standard for State Road 7 will not be maintained through the 5-year and long range planning periods. The provided analysis confirms that the amendment will degrade the LOS below the adopted level of service both at the maximum use permitted by the amendment and the conditioned level of development. Recommendation: Do not adopt or revise the amendment accordingly to demonstrate how the adopted Level of Service Standard for State Road 7 and the surrounding roadways will be maintained. Agent: land Design South of Florida, Inc. Size: Location: STAFF RESPONSE: The traffic study was reviewed based on our Comprehensive Plan, specifically Future Land Use Elemment (FLUE) Policy 3.5-d, which requires that all long term traffic impacts from new developments be reviewed for both significant and negative traffic impacts. An impact is considered negative when the total traffic exceeds LOS D. An impact is considered significant when the project traffic is above 3% of the roadway capacity. A project fails only if the long term traffic impacts are both significant and negative. This project at the maximum intensity, significantly and negatively impacted State Road 7 and Lyons Road, hence it did not pass at the maximum intensity. By limiting the project to 80,803 sf of commercial and 108.000 sf of Institutional, State Road 7 and Lyons Road were negatively impacted but the project traffic was not significant (the impact was de minimis). The proposed conditions further limit the project below the above figures; hence this project at the conditioned intensity meets the traffic requirements for plan amendments as set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. The short-term roadway failures are dealt with a very comprehensive concurrency system in place in Palm Beach County. The backbone of the Concurrency System is mandated in detail within the adopted policies of the Transportation Element (TE) of the Comprehensive Plan. While all of the policies can be reviewed, of particular note are TE Policies 1 .1-a and 1.1-g. All projects coming in for development approvals must meet Palm Beach County Traffic Performance Standards (TPS) to show that necessary roadway infrastructure is in place concurrent with the impacts of the development. Based on our discussion with DCA we are submitting a short-term peak hour analysis for informational purposes only_ The short-term peak hour directional analysis and the consultant's covering letter are attached with this report and it doesn't show any failures of the impacted roadways. Since the long-term impacts and the short-term impacts of the proposed land use amendment meet the LOS standard as explained above, the County believes that the amendment is consistent with the Comorehensive Plan. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Future Land Use Atlas pursuant to the proposed Yamato/SR 7 - US 441 - SE amendment, with conditions. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 6 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda "., ,,".... ......., 2.E. PROPOSED COUNTY INITIATED CORRECTIVE SITE SPECIFIC AMENDMENTS - To the Future Land Use Atlas, which did not receive objection or comment from DCA n ITEM DESCRIPTION RECOMMENDA TIONI ACTION 2.E.1 Request: HR-12 to IND Planning: Approval Canal Point Size: 5.17 acres (multiple properties) LPA: Approval (10-0). Industrial Location: Between Okeechobee Avenue and BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Properties Lakewood Street to the north and Aaronson and Koons absent). At the hearing, jLGA 2005-00050l south and either between there was minimal Board discussion and no Everglades Street and Lakeshore public comment on this item. Drive or Lake shore Drive and the District: 6 FEC RR to the east and west. 2.E.2 Request: HR-8 to HR-12 Planning: Approval Haverhill Commons Size: 19.09 acres LPA: Approval (10-0). Property Location: East side of Haverhill Road, BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners i!:::.QA 2005-00051j approximately % mile north of Aaronson and Koons absent). At the hearing, Belvedere Road. there was minimal Board discussion and no District: 2 public comment on this item. 2.E.3 Request: RR-10 to RR-2.5 and Exurban Tier Planning: Approval Stonewal PUD (LGA 2005-00052l Adjustment LPA: Approval (11-0). Size: 983 acres BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Location: South side of Northlake Boulevard Aaronson and Koons absent). At the hearing, District: 6 approximately 4 miles west of the there was minimal Board discussion. Several Beeline Highway. members of the public spoke in opposition to this amendment citing concerns with drainage in the area. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Future Land Use Atlas and Map Series pursuant to the proposed AQenda Items 2.E.1 throuQh 2.E.3. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 7 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda ... ",", .., ""'" 2.F. PROPOSED COUNTY INITIATED SITE SPECIFIC AMENDMENTS - To the Future land Use Atlas, which did not receive objection or comment from DCA II ITEM DESCRIPTION RECOMMENDATIONI ACTION 2.F.1 Request: C/8 to CH/8 Planning: Approval COI1!:lress Size: 25.70 acres LPA: Approval (11-0). Avenue/Lake Location: Northeast corner of Lake Worth Road and BCC: Transmit (5-0, with Commissioners Worth Road Congress Avenue. Aaronson and Koons absent). At the Properties hearing, there was minimal Boa rd (LGA 2005-00049) discussion and no public comment on this item. District: 3 2.F.2 Request: AGR with a preserve note to U/T Planning: Approval Solid Waste Size: 40.88 acres LPA: Approval (10-0). Authority! Ag Location: East side of State Road 7/US 441, BCC: Transmit (4-1, with Commissioner Re~~rve II approximately .25 mile south of the L-30 Marcus dissenting and with Commissioners (LGA 2005-000351 Canal and 1.5 miles north of West Atlantic Aaronson and Koons absent). At the Avenue. hearing, there was minimal Board District: 5 discussion. A representative from COBWRA spoke in support of the amendment and 2 members of the public spoke in opposition to the amendment. MOTION: To adopt an ordinance amending the Future Land Use Atlas pursuant to the proposed Agenda Items 2.F.1 and 2.F.2. 3. CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING 4. ADJOURNMENT Be advised that anyone choosing to appeal any action with respect to any matter discussed by the Board of County Commissioners will need a record of the proceedings, and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. BCC Adoption Public Hearing November 28, 2005 8 Amendment Round 05-2 Final Agenda "",., "" /" The City of Boyn'rOn Beach DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT PLANNING AND ZONING DIVISON 100 E. Boynton Beach Boulevard P.O. Box 310 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425-0310 TEL: 561-742-6260 FAX: 561-742-6259 -....,.; www.boynton-beach.org Lorenzo Aghemo, Planning Director Palm Beach County Planning Division 100 Australian Way West Palm Beach, FL 33406 Re: Application by the City of Boynton Beach for a CRALLS designation Dear Mr. Aghemo: Please accept this letter as a request by the City of Boynton Beach to initiate a Comprehensive Plan amendment to accomplish a CRALLS designation for the following locations: . Intersection of Old Boynton Road and Congress A venue . A segment of Old Boynton Road between Congress A venue and Boynton Beach Boulevard . Intersection of Gateway Boulevard and Congress A venue The City is currently evaluating traffic impact from the proposed Boynton Town Center and Boynton Village Developments located on the east side of Congress A venue and north of Old Boynton Road to the Boynton C- 16 Canal. The property is more commonly known as the Winchester parcel. The Developer has received a concurrency letter from Palm Beach County Traffic Staff dated February 1, 2005 that details a number of off- site roadway improvements that, according to the Traffic Performance Standards in Article 12 of the Palm Beach County Land Development Code, are required to support the proposed development. Unfortunately, many of the required improvements will be exceedingly difficult to construct because of the lack of sufficient right-of-way. The construction would require the acquisition of additional right-of-way from a number of private properties near the proposed development. Furthermore, the acquisition of property, and construction of the proposed improvements, would have a negative impact on the remaining properties by reducing building setbacks, potentially reducing available parking, and by degrading the overall appearance of the property when viewed from the public roadway. Because of these issues, alternative solutions such as CRALLS designation must be explored to allow for the aforementioned development to proceed, if approved on February 15, 2005. We appreciate your cooperation and assistance in working with the City in processing this application. We will prepare data analysis within the time schedule specified by the Palm Beach County Land Development Code. Please call me at 561-742-6260 in you have any questions concerning this request. Sincerely, Michael W. Rumpf Director of Planning & Zoning G:\CRALLS.nf r...... ........ ......" Kim Glas-Castro, AICP Certified Land Planner Ruden McClosky 222 Lakeview Avenue #800 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 telephone: (561) 838-4542 in Broward: (954) 761-2926 fax: (561) 514-3442 kim.glascastro@ruden.com NOTICE: This e-mail message and any attachment to this e-mail message contains confidential information that may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not review, retransmit, convert to hard copy, copy, use or disseminate this e-mail or any attachments to it. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify us immediately by return e-mail or by telephone at 954-764-6660 and delete this message. Please note that if this e-mail message contains a forwarded message or is a reply to a prior message, some or all of the contents of this message or any attachments may not have been produced by the sender. NOTICE: This e-mail message and any attachment to this e-mail message contains confidential information that may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not review, retransmit, convert to hard copy, copy, use or disseminate this e-mail or any attachments to it. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify us immediately by return e-mail or by telephone at 954-764-6660 and delete this message. Please note that if this e-mail message contains a forwarded message or is a reply to a prior message, some or all of the contents of this message or any attachments may not have been produced by the sender. NOTICE: This e-mail message and any attachment to this e-mail message contains confidential information that may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not review, retransmit, convert to hard copy, copy, use or disseminate this e-mail or any attachments to it. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify us immediately by return e-mail or by telephone at 727-384-6000 and delete this message. Please note that if this e-mail message contains a forwarded message or is a reply to a prior message, some or all of the contents of this message or any attachments may not have been produced by the sender. 2 r'"",, -...,.,.. "-" CJrl E. K1ee'per Jr. Subject: Joe Filippelli [Joe. Filippelli @sembler.com] Thursday, March 03, 2005 3:11 PM Richard Foreman; Glas-Castro, Kimberly; Miskel, Bonnie; jcomparato@compson.com; cklepper@compson.com; Heather Duffy; Andrea Troutman RE: CRALLS From: Sent: To: When and where would this pre-app take place -----Original Message----- From: Richard Foreman Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2005 2:47 PM To: 'Glas-Castro, Kimberly'; Miskel, Bonnie; Joe Filippelli; jcomparato@compson.com; cklepper@compson.com; Heather Duffy; Andrea Troutman Subject: RE: CRALLS I agree - we absolutely must be prepared to propose mitigation at the pre-app. I have Kimley-Horn undertaking preliminary design for widening of Gateway and determining if the other mitigation measures suggested within the concurrency letter from Masoud can be accommodated within existing public ROW. Other measures, if those cannot be performed, need to be then determined and suggested. The broader network traffic study Masoud wanted has just been completed by Kimley Horn and he is sending me a draft copy. He has other suggestions within that report. I'll update the team shortly. Richard Foreman Senior Development Manager The Sembler Company (404)-847-1801, ext. 205 (404)-847-1818 - Fax -----Original Message----- From: Glas-Castro, Kimberly [mailto:Kimberly.Glas-Castro@ruden.com] Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2005 2:09 PM To: Richard Foreman; Miskel, Bonnie; Joe Filippelli; jcomparato@compson.com; cklepper@compson.com; Heather Duffy; Andrea Troutman Subject: FW: CRALLS Hanna is faxing this to the County today ..... Also, she spoke to the County and they think we should come to the pre-App meeting with Mitigation Measures in mind -----Original Message----- From: Matras, Hanna [mailto:MatrasH@ci.boynton-beach.f1.us] Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2005 2:05 PM To: Glas-Castro, Kimberly Subject: RE: CRALLS Kim, Here is the letter. Hanna -----Original Message----- From: Glas-Castro, Kimberly [mailto:Kimberly.Glas-Castro@ruden.com] Sent: Thursday, March 03, 2005 11:34 AM To: Matras, Hanna Subject: CRALLS Please forward a copy of the City's letter to the County when it is sent out (I can forward to all on our team) 1 THE SCHOOL DISTRIC 0;; PALM BEACH COUNl .'. JA '-'" PLANNINGDEPARlMENT 3320 FOREST HILL BLVD., C-331 WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406-5813 (561) 434-8020 FAX: (561) 434-8187 ARTHUR C. JOHNSON, Ph.D. SUPERINTENDENT . '."",, May 18, 2004 Mr. Dick Hudson, Senior Planner City of Boynton Beach 100 E. Boynton Beach. Blvd. Boynton Beach, FL 33435 RE: CONCURRENCY DETERMINATION - CASE NUMBER #04043001C --BOYNTON VILLAGE Dear Mr. Hudson: The Palm Beach County School District has reviewed the request for a Concurrency Determination on the above reference~ project for 1 ,120 multi-family units. Attached please find the approved Palm Beach County School District Concurrency Application and Service Provider Form for Boynton Village. This Concurrency Determination is valid for one (1) year from the date of issuance. Once a Development Order has been issued for the project, the concurrency determination will be valid for the life of the Development Order. If Y04 have any questions regarding this determination, please feel free to contact me at (561) 434-7343. David L. DeYoun Planner cc: Kim Glas-Castro, Ruden McClosky enc. S:\Planning\Public\(NTERGOV\Concllrrency\Concurrenc~ Determination r .etters\Concurrency\C404300 i.doc AN l:.QUAL OPPORTUNITY l:.MPLOYER