The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 08-07-23 The City of Boynton Beachj y Historic Resources Preservation Board Agenda Monday, August 7, 2023, 6:30 PM City Commission Chambers 100 E. Ocean Avenue Boynton Beach, FL 33435 Boynton Beach Historic Resources Preservation Board Daniel Dugger, City Manager David Tolces, Interim City Attorney Maylee De Jesus, City Clerk *Mission* To create a sustainable community by providing exceptional municipal services, in a financially responsible manner. �` ,, � ��,�`� �ate' a ' , ,' � � �,° � - . �• www.boynton-beach.org ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 1. Call to Order 2. Agenda Approval 1 3. Approval of Minutes A. Approval of Minutes Approve the minutes from the April 10, 2023 Historic Resources Preservation Board meeting 4. Communications and Announcements A. Naming a City Park (Parcel # 08434521210000220) Provide email responses from the Departments of the subject park to the Board B. 306 SE 1 Avenue aka Edith Andrews House Discussion of the draft historic designation report regarding the Edith Andrews House located at 306 SE 1st Avenue, Boynton Beach. 5. Old Business 6. New Business 7. Other 8. Comments by Board Members 9. Public Comments Relative to Historic Preservation 10. Announce Date of Next Meeting 11. Adjournment Notice If a person decides to appeal to any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, He/She will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, He/She may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. (F.S. 286.0105) The City shall furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to afford an individual with a disability an equal opportunity to participate in and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity conducted by the City. Please contact the City Clerk's office, (561)742-6060 or(TTY) 1-800-955-8771, at least 48 hours prior to the program or activity in order for the City to reasonably accommodate your request. Additional agenda items may be added subsequent to the publication of the agenda on the City's web site. Information regarding items added to the agenda after it is published on the City's web site can be obtained from the office of the City Clerk. 2 3.A Approval of Minutes 08/ 7/2023 City of Boynton Beach "• Agenda Item Request Form Commission Meeting Date: 08/7/2023 Approval of Minutes Requested Action by Commission: Approve the minutes from the April 10, 2023 Historic Resources Preservation Board meeting Attachments: HRPB Minutes 04-10-23.pdf 3 Minutes of the Historic Resources Preservation Board Meeting Held on April 10, 2023, at 6:30 p.m. in City Hall Commission Chambers 100 E. Ocean Avenue, Boynton Beach, Florida Present: Barbara Ready, Chair Amanda Radigan, Director Planning and Zoning Dr. Ben Lowe Jae Eun Kim, Principal Planner Michael Wilson Craig Pinder, Planner 11 Thomas Ramiccio Mike Rumpf, HRPB Consultant Victor Norfus, Alternate Absent: Alexander Ranbom Bernard Wright Rhonda Sexton 1. Call to Order Chair Ready called the meeting to order at 6:30 P.M. 2. Agenda Approval Motion Mr. Ramiccio moved to approve the agenda. Mr. Wilson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 3. Approval of Minutes 3.A. Approve board minutes from March 7, 2023 Historic Resources Preservation Board meeting. Motion Mr. Ramiccio moved to approve the minutes. Dr. Lowe seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 4. Communications and Announcements 4.A. Advisory Board update from Planning & Zoning Director, Amanda Radigan - Updates regarding Advisory Boards, including the new Peak Agenda Management System, Advisory Board Annual Reports, and Volunteers for the new Visitor Center. 4 Meeting Minutes Historic Resource Preservation Board Boynton Beach, Florida April 10, 2023 Amanda Radigan, Planning and Zoning Director, introduced herself. She stated that the City currently uses NOVUS Agenda software to publish agendas and that they are changing to PEAK Agenda software City-wide. She advised that Board Members will receive an email regarding training, which will occur in the near future. Ms. Radigan also announced that the Visitors Center is planned to go live in six months and if anyone is interested in volunteering, they should contact her or Assistant City Manager Kathryn Matos. She said that the Board will discuss this further in the future, and that the Board's activities will be included in the Visitors Center. 4.B. Website Migration - Staff will provide an update on the City's progress in merging the existing components of the original historic preservation site with the City's upgraded website, and its expansion to represent a more user-friendly and informative site. Craig Pinder, Planner II, stated that they have a working draft of the website that is live. He demonstrated how to access the site, reviewed the site's features and content, and requested feedback. Chair Ready commented that she will provide links to the Boynton Beach Historical Society and their YouTube videos. Sh—e inquired why the page is found under Business and not Residents. Jae Eun Kim, Principal Planner, stated that this is the way ITS set it up and that eventually when the City migrates to its new platform, it will be moved on the website and in other locations. Ms. Radigan noted that all of Development's Services are listed under the Business Tab. Ms. Kim said that if they share images and photos, it would be nice to have them on the website. Dr. Lowe inquired about the map and the historically significant, but not registered properties, and asked about the definition. He asked who decided if the properties were historically significant and if the Board could make suggestions. Ms. Radigan replied that on the next agenda, they will discuss developing an annual work plan and an updated survey, that they would have to budget for. She said that everything that could be historically significant could be added to the survey and then added to the website. Dr. Lowe said that he knows of some properties that are now historic and can be on the map. Dr. Lowe requested that in the future, they add links to Boynton Beach history, such as books. Ms. Radigan stated that suggestions are welcome and the members can send them to 2 5 Meeting Minutes Historic Resource Preservation Board Boynton Beach, Florida April 10, 2023 her and they will review and add them. 4.C. Andrew's house at 306 SE 1st Avenue - The Board, at the March 71h meeting, moved to initiate the review of the historic Andrew's House for addition to the City's Local Registry of Historic Sites. Staff will report on this initiative to include coordination with the property owner and Historica LLC. Ms. Radigan stated that staff wanted to inform the Board that they have a contract with Warren Adams of Historica, to do the designation report for the site and that he is in touch with the owner. Bradley Miller, from Urban Design Studio, representing the property owner, stated that staff reached out to them about the idea of a designation. He stated that the same owner owns the both the north and south side properties and that they are currently working on getting the north side under construction. He said that the south parcel still has the house designated on the plan and a designation is still planned. Chair Ready stated that Dr. Lowe shared a grant opportunity through the State Historic Preservation Department, which was a matching grant of $500K and that one category was acquisition. She thought that maybe they can apply for the funds and use the funds to move the Andrews home somewhere else. Ms. Radigan agreed and stated that they should consider properties in the CRA Cottage District and that they have a few properties in the HOB. Chair Ready stated that she did not know who owns the Gables property next to the Magnuson House, and commented that it would be a great place to situate other historic properties and that it could make a nice Visitors Center. Mr. Miller stated that overall, the home was in pretty good condition. He stated that the owner may be open to having the home designated, as the owner was unsure what to do with the home. He said that he thought that a very small percentage of people even know the home is there and he pointed out the railroad is next to it, and he surmised that the vibrations do not help the home. Mr. Norfus recalled that they wanted cottages down Ocean Avenue, but when they talk about moving them, he asked where would they be relocated, or if they would be put in a central location or in a historic row. Chair Ready stated they would have to move the home to a City owned property. 5. Old Business 5.A. Local Designation of 413 NE 12th Avenue - Request for designation of 413 NE 12th Avenue, and the addition of this c.1941, Wood-frame Vernacular, 3 6 Meeting Minutes Historic Resource Preservation Board Boynton Beach, Florida April 10, 2023 one-story single-family house to the City's Local Registry of Historic Sites. Applicant: Dr. Martha Meeks-Light, property owner. Motion Dr. Lowe moved to remove the item from the table. Mr. Ramiccio seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Rumpf referred back to the March 7th meeting and said that great contributions were made at the meeting, which was helpful and that the staff report contained highlights of the designation report. He stated that this home was different from other designations and it helped point to a period of events. He advised that the family owned this property since the Iate1800's and it was significant in times of segregation. He announced that staff recommends it be designated. He read into the record that this Ordinance will go before the City Commission, for official adoption, resulting in it being added to the Local Registry. He pointed out that the First Reading of the Ordinance will be on the May 15th City Commission Agenda and the Second Reading on June 5th Mr. Ramiccio asked if there was any consideration of when a homeowner proposes a designation, the Board leverage dollars to help the homeowner landscape it and improve its curb appeal or other improvements, while maintaining the overall integrity of the historic attributes. Ms. Radigan explained that as they develop the Board's work plans, which an updated will be provided at the next meeting, that these are the types of items they would like to see. She noted that funding-based requests should be added to the annual City Commission report they will provide to the City Commission, as they will have to decide on funding for certain items. Mr. Ramiccio clarified that when someone comes to the Board to designate, they should encourage improvements, and that in this instance, the property is in the CRA District. Ms. Radigan commented that the City has a small fund to help fund improvements, which she will research, as it would further the properties historical value. Mr. Rumpf explained that it was similar to the Paint Up Fix Up program. Motion Dr. Lowe moved to approve. Mr. Ramiccio seconded the motion. The motion passed 4- 0 (Mr. Norfus abstaining.) 6 New Business: 4 7 Meeting Minutes Historic Resource Preservation Board Boynton Beach, Florida April 10, 2023 Dr. Lowe recalled that this item was previously discussed by the Board, and said that the person who conducted the survey in 1996 at FAU, Dr. Sandra Norman, asked him about student internships with the City, as there are a few FAU students living in Boynton Beach that would like an intern in the fall. He advised that if the City can use them, they are available and that they need minimal supervision, a project, and someone to oversee. He advised that the interns are not paid, but they get collage credit. Ms. Radigan requested that they contact her. There was Board consensus to support internship opportunities. Mr. Norfus passed out information, which he reviewed and is attached to the minutes. He announced that he would like to have a park named Missionary Hope Park based on resident outreach to the homeless and downtrodden in the past He said that he thought this could be a possible future project and advised that there is a lot more history in that part of town, but unless they present it, no one will know about it. Discussion followed that this is a passive park owned by the City, but the park is fenced, locked and is likely being used by Utilities as an easement. The fence was added in the last year to keep the homeless out. Mr. Norfus also stated that the Murph house should also be designated. Ms. Radigan said that there were complaints about the park, but said she would research it further. She suggested that they could look at different options. Chair Ready advised that she would not object to naming the easement and they can make a recommendation. Mr. Ramiccio noted that when looking at the City's Parks Plan, this park is not on there. He said that it likely was an easement and then residents used it and a walkway was added, but in unused alleyways cities have to deal with undesirables, and it becomes a burden for residents and the City, especially if it is not designated. He expressed that it starts with the City reviewing it. 7. Other None. 8. Comments by members Chair Ready announced that the next Boynton Beach Historical Society program about Key West hand printed fabric is on April 27th. She stated that the meeting will be held 5 8 Meeting Minutes Historic Resource Preservation Board Boynton Beach, Florida April 10, 2023 via Zoom and is free to the public. 9. Public comments regarding historic preservation None. 10. Announce date of next meeting -July 10, 2023 11. Adjournment There being no further business to discuss, Chair Ready adjourned the meeting at 7:35 P.M. Catherine Cherry Minutes Specialist 6 9 4.A Communications and Announcements 08/ 7/2023 City of Boynton Beach "• Agenda Item Request Form Commission Meeting Date: 08/7/2023 Naming a City Park (Parcel # 08434521210000220) Requested Action by Commission: Provide email responses from the Departments of the subject park to the Board Attachments: Fence & Gate_ Email Response_PCN 08434521210000220.pdf Rec& Park Dept_Email Response_ PCN 08434521210000220.pdf Utilities Dept_Email Response_ PCN 08434521210000220.pdf 10 Kim, Jae Eun From: Lazo, Franky Sent: Tuesday, April 25, 2023 11:46 AM To: Radigan,Amanda; Roschek,Christopher; Kim, Jae Eun;Young, Kacy;Guzman, Mario; Kalkat, Poonam Cc: Pinder,Craig Subject: RE: Parcel No.08434521210000220 - city owned land Yes,we were receiving complaints on a weekly basis. Recreation worked with PW and PD to develop a plan of action.We have done multiple cleanups in the past to remove homeless encampments that were set up. We continue to monitor that property,the linear trail and the park near the railroad tracks on a daily basis and are in constant communications with PW and PD. Franky Lazo Assistant Director, Recreation &Parks Recreation arid Parks Departr-nent City of Boynton Beach Mailing Addre ` ; PO Box 3101 1 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 X .,. Physical r2r`swo 100 E Ocean Ave. Boynton Brach, Florida 22ttr25 561—.742-6255 LazoF@bbfl.Lisbeach.org/;;//V V V 1 lriC.0 ri-I;?E�I�h.org America's Gateway to the Gulfstream Please be advised that. Florida has a broad public records law and all corre pon e rice to r-n is ernail r-nay be subject to disclosure.l!rider Florida records law, e r~grail addresses rare public records.Therefore, your e-r-grail corny-n anication arid our e- r-grail address r-nay be subject to public disclosure. From: Radigan,Amanda <RadiganA@bbfl.us> Sent:Tuesday,April 25, 2023 11:39 AM To: Lazo, Franky<LazoF@bbfl.us>; Roschek,Christopher<roschekc@bbfl.us>; Kim,Jae Eun<KimJ@bbfl.us>;Young, Kacy <YoungK@bbfl.us>;Guzman, Mario<GuzmanM@bbfl.us>; Kalkat, Poonam<KalkatP@bbfl.us> Cc: Pinder, Craig<PinderC@bbfl.us> Subject: RE: Parcel No.08434521210000220-city owned land Franky, Were their complaints from the public or police about homelessness and illegal activity? I agree about renaming. Right now we are gathering information for the Board. i 11 Best regards, Amanda B. Radi0an 4mandaRadigan, 4|CP, LEED4P Director, Planning &Zoning Deve|opmentPlanning&Zoning K4ai|ing4ddress� P.O. Box 310'- | Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical 4ddress� 1OO [ Ocean Ave. | Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 � 561-742-6256 RadiganA@bbfl.us boynton-beach.oro/ � Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law arid all corresponde rice to r-ne via ernail r-nay be subject to disdoyure.UnderF|orida records law, email addresses are public records.Therefore, your e-mai| communication arid your e- mai| address maybesubject topublic disclosure. From: Lazo, Franky Sent:Tuesday,April ZS, ZUZ311:36AM To: Radi0an,Amanda< »; Roschek,Christopher< »; Kim,]aeEun <Kimd(@bbdl4s»;Youn0, Kacy< »; Guznnan, Mario< »; Ka|kat, Poonam < » Cc: Pinder, Craig<Pind US> Subject: RE: Parcel No.UO434SZ1Z1UUUUZZU city owned land Amanda, Fence/gates were installed in January 2023 to eliminate homeless and illegal activity on the property. It allows the Park Rangers to secure the property at night and PID to trespass anyone that is staying overnight. We should be cautious of renaming,this is a bigger conversation with City Management and Commission. Franky Lazo Assistant Director, Recreation &Parks Recreation arid Parks Department City of Boynton Beach Mailing 4ddress� POBox 31O | Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical 4ddress� 1OOEOcean Ave. | Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 �— 5617426255 �� LazoF��bbf|.us | http�//www.boyntonbeach.org/ / 12 America's Gateway tothe Gulfstream Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law and all correspondence to me via email may be subject to disc|oyure.UnderF|orida records law, email addresses are public records.Therefore, your e mail communication arid your e mail address may be subject to public disclosure. From: Radi0an,Amanda < » Sent:Tuesday,April ZS, ZUZ311:Z4AM To: Roschek,Christopher< »; Lazo, Franky< »; Kim,]aeEun<Kimd@ldbfl.us»;Youn0, Kacy <YoungK us>;Guznnan, Mario< »; Ka|kat, Poonam<KalkatP US> Cc: Pinder, Craig<P ind US> Subject: RE: Parcel No.08434521210000220 city owned land Thank you both. Mario—Can you tells why and when the fence/gate was installed? |tlooks tohave been installed within the last year. Best regards, Amanda B. Radi0an Amanda Radigan, 4|CP, LEED4P Director, Planning &Zoning Deve|opmentPlanning&Zoning K4ai|ing4ddress� P.O. Box 310'- | Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical 4ddress� 1OOE. Ocean Ave. | Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 � 5617426256 �, RadiganA��bbf|.us | boynton beach�or�/ �� [�]� � �| �� U:Um��w �� m� �=�. � Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law and all correspondence to me via email may be subject to disdoyure.UnderF|orida records law, email addresses are public records.Therefore, your e-mai| communication arid your e- mai| address maybesubject topublic disclosure. From: Roschek,Christopher Sent:Tuesday,April ZS, ZUZ311:14AM To: Lazo, Franky ; Kim,Jae Eun ;Young, Kacy ;Guzman, Mario ; Ka|hat, Poonam Cc: Radi0an,Amanda ; Pinder,Craig Subject: RE: Parcel No.UO434SZ1Z1UUUUZZU city owned land Hello all, 13 Thank you, Franky. Utilities also did some research, and we have no objections to the proposed named park. We would like to retain a 12 ft. utilities easement/access running north-south along the eastern property line for a future stormwater outfall pipe to the C-16 Canal. Since the land is owned by the City, an easement may not be necessary. There are no other underground utilities within the parcel. Existing water and sewer mains are located within the public right-of-way of NE 13th Avenue. Thanks, Chris Christopher I#o4.ch k, P.E. Deputy Director, Ultilities Operations Boynton Peach Ultilities City of Boynton Peach v� .... ,... 124 E. Woolbright Rd. Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 561-742-6413 1 $,j 561-742-6298 YCi4;c1iE'kc@bb l.Lis http//www.boyritori-beach.org/ America's Gateway to the Gulfstream Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law and all correa pon derice to rne is E`!"€nail !"€nay be bx14I,ject to 'isclo`iure.U'ri er Florida records law, E`!"€nail addresses are public records. [liE`k"E`tore,your e-!"€nail co!""?!"€"?lf!'kation grid your e- r€nail address !"€nay be bilfl;ject to public disclosure. From: Lazo, Franky<LazoF@bbfl.us> Sent:Tuesday,April 25, 2023 10:56 AM To: Kim,Jae Eun<KimJ@bbfl.us>;Young, Kacy<YoungK@bbfl.us>;Guzman, Mario<GuzmanM@bbfl.us>; Roschek, Christopher<roschekc@bbfl.us>; Kalkat, Poonam <KalkatP@bbfl.us> Cc: Radigan,Amanda<RadiganA@bbfl.us>; Pinder,Craig<PinderC@bbfl.us> Subject: RE: Parcel No. 08434521210000220-city owned land Jae Eun, I have limited information on that land but can do more research. It is owned, operated and maintained by the City.The Public Works department maintains it using one of our landscape vendors.The Recreation and Parks department opens, closes and enforces City policies via our Park Rangers. The property connects to the Palmetto Greens Linear trail and has been used by community members as a passive park. However, it is not included in our park inventory and does not have a name dedicated to it. Hope this information is helpful. Team, Any other information is welcomed! 4 4 Franky Lazo Assistant Director, Recreation &Parks Recreation arid Parks Department City of Boynton Beach Mailing 4ddress� POBox 31O | Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical 4ddress� 1OOEOcean Ave. | Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 � 561-742-6255 ��LazoF��bbf|.us | n�r http�//www.boynton-beach.org/ / �� ^ �� America's Gateway tothe Gulfstream Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law arid all corresponde rice to r-ne via ernail r-nay be subject to disc|oyure.UnderF|orida records law, email addresses are public records.Therefore, your e mail communication arid your e mail address may be subject to public disclosure. From: Kim,Jae Eun< » Sent: Friday,April Z1, ZUZ34:ZZPM To:Young, Kacy< »;Guznnan, Mario< »; Lazo, Franky< »; Roschek, Christopher< »; Ka|kat, Poonam < » Cc: Radi0an,Amanda< »; Pinder,Crai0<Pin US> Subject: Parcel No.UO434SZ1Z1UUUUZZU city owned land Good afternoon, One ofthe Historical Resource and Preservation Board members is interested in renaming this city owned land below. Attached is the historical information that the Board member prepared. Please let us know the following: * Are there any underground utilities? * What are the purposes ofthe land? * Dovxehave aplan for the land? * Anything that the PZ team should know? Please feel free tocall mefor any questions. Thank you for your time! s � Ones 4. r3 � t Sales Information � '4k--t Om, hk* 41 Jae Eun Kim, PLA Principal Planner Developr-nent, Planning Zoning Mailing Address� P.O. Box 31C) 1 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical Address� 100 E. Ocean Ave. I Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 561-742-6378 Iain J@bbfl.Ljs boyritori-brach.org/ [�]. t LJi Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law and all corresponderice to r-ne is Crnail rnay be subject to disclosurr.l!rider Florida records law, ernail addresses are public records.Therefore, your e-rnail corny-n unication and our e- r-nail address r-nay be subject to public disclosure. 6 6 Kim, Jae Eun From: Lazo, Franky Sent: Tuesday, April 25, 2023 10:56 AM To: Kim, Jae Eun;Young, Kacy; Guzman, Mario; Roschek, Christopher; Kalkat, Poonam Cc: Radigan,Amanda; Pinder,Craig Subject: RE: Parcel No.08434521210000220 - city owned land Jae Eun, I have limited information on that land but can do more research. It is owned, operated and maintained by the City.The Public Works department maintains it using one of our landscape vendors.The Recreation and Parks department opens, closes and enforces City policies via our Park Rangers. The property connects to the Palmetto Greens Linear trail and has been used by community members as a passive park. However, it is not included in our park inventory and does not have a name dedicated to it. Hope this information is helpful. Team, Any other information is welcomed! Franky Lazo Assistant Director, Recreation &Parks Recreation arid Parks Departr-nent City of Boynton Beach Mailing Addre ` ; PO Box 3101 1 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 X .,. Phys.crl r2r`swo 1l ; �Ocean Ave. Boynton BCach, Florida 22ttr25 561-742-6255 LaZoF@1;?b l.Lis http//www.boyritori-beach.org/ ach.org .J :A America's Gateway to the Gulfstream Please be advised that. Florida has a broad public records law and all corre pon e rice to r-n is ernail r-nay be subject to disclosure.l!rider Florida records law, e r~grail addresses rare public records.Therefore, your e-r-grail corny-n anication arid our e- r-grail address r-nay be subject to public disclosure. From: Kim,Jae Eun<KimJ@bbfl.us> Sent: Friday,April 21, 2023 4:22 PM To:Young, Kacy<YoungK@bbfl.us>;Guzman, Mario<GuzmanM@bbfl.us>; Lazo, Franky<LazoF@bbfl.us>; Roschek, Christopher<roschekc@bbfl.us>; Kalkat, Poonam <KalkatP@bbfl.us> Cc: Radigan,Amanda<RadiganA@bbfl.us>; Pinder,Craig<PinderC@bbfl.us> Subject: Parcel No. 08434521210000220-city owned land 1 17 Good afternoon, One of the Historical Resource and Preservation Board members is interested in renaming this city owned land below. Attached is the historical information that the Board member prepared. Please let us know the following: • Are there any underground utilities? • What are the purposes of the land? • Do we have a plan for the land? • Anything that the PZ team should know? Please feel free to call me for any questions. Thank you for your time! https://m ap.gridics.cam/us/fl/boynton-beach?fol io=08434521210000220#18/26.538354/-80.061387 owners A plrt 41 ! � l � UK Yen 2M. Jae Mfr: Kim, PLA Principal Planner Developr-nent, Planning Zoning Mailing AddressP.O. prix 31%f 1 Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical Address 100 E. Ocean Ave. I Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 J 561-742-6378 [�] U In &� 19 Please be advised treat. Florida has abroad public records law and all corms poode rice to r-n is ernail r-nay be subject to disclosure.l!rider Florida records law, e r~grail addresses rare public records.Therefore, your e-r~mail cornanunication arid our e- r~mail address r~pray be subject to public disclosure. 2 18 Kim, Jae Eun From: Roschek,Christopher Sent: Tuesday, April 25, 2023 11:14 AM To: Lazo, Franky; Kim, Jae Eun;Young, Kacy;Guzman, Mario; Kalkat, Poonam Cc: Radigan,Amanda; Pinder,Craig Subject: RE: Parcel No.08434521210000220 - city owned land Hello all, Thank you, Franky. Utilities also did some research, and we have no objections to the proposed named park. We would like to retain a 12 ft. utilities easement/access running north-south along the eastern property line for a future stormwater outfall pipe to the C-16 Canal. Since the land is owned by the City, an easement may not be necessary. There are no other underground utilities within the parcel. Existing water and sewer mains are located within the public right-of-way of NE 13th Avenue. Thanks, Chris Christopher Roschek, P.L. Deputy Director, U.ltilitie.Operations Boynton Beach Ultilitie. City of Boynton Beach .... ,... 124 E. Woolbright Rd. Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 561-142-6413 361-742-629 ro4icliE'kc@bb l.Lis http//www.boyritori-beach.org/ America's Gateway to the Gulfstream Please be advised treat. Florida has abroad public records law and all corre pon e rice to rne is ernail rn ay be subject to disclosure.U!rider Florida records law, e rn ail addresses are public records.Therefore, your e-r-n ail cornynunication arid our e- rn ail address rn ay be subject to public disclosure. From: Lazo, Franky<LazoF@bbfl.us> Sent:Tuesday,April 25, 2023 10:56 AM To: Kim,Jae Eun<KimJ@bbfl.us>;Young, Kacy<YoungK@bbfl.us>;Guzman, Mario<GuzmanM@bbfl.us>; Roschek, Christopher<roschekc@bbfl.us>; Kalkat, Poonam <KalkatP@bbfl.us> Cc: Radigan,Amanda<RadiganA@bbfl.us>; Pinder,Craig<PinderC@bbfl.us> Subject: RE: Parcel No. 08434521210000220-city owned land Jae Eun, I have limited information on that land but can do more research. It is owned, operated and maintained by the City.The Public Works department maintains it using one of our landscape vendors.The Recreation and Parks department opens, closes and enforces City policies via our Park Rangers. i 19 The property connectsto the Palmetto Greens Linear trail and has been used by community members as a passive park. However, it is not included in our park inventory and does not have a name dedicated to it. Hope this information ishelpful. Team, Any other information is welcomed! Franky Lazo Assistant Director, Recreation &Parks Recreation arid Parks Department City of Boynton Beach Mailing 4ddress� POBox 31O | Boynton Beach, Florida 33425 Physical 4ddress� 1OOEOcean Ave. | Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 � 561-742-6255 �A11) LazoF��bbf|.us | �� http�//www.boynton-beach�or�/ �� | N�� | ==� �� / America's Gateway tothe Gulfstream Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law arid all corresponde rice to r-ne via ernail r-nay be subject to disc|oyure.UnderF|orida records law, email addresses are public records.Therefore, your e mail communication arid your e mail address may be subject to public disclosure. From: Kim,Jae Eun< » Sent: Friday,April Z1, ZUZ34:ZZPM To:Young, Kacy< »;Guznnan, Mario< »; Lazo, Franky< »; Roschek, Christopher< »; Ka|kat, Poonam < » Cc: Radi0an,Amanda< »; Pinder,Crai0<Pin US> Subject: Parcel No.UO434SZ1Z1UUUUZZU city owned land Good afternoon, One ofthe Historical Resource and Preservation Board members is interested in renaming this city owned land below. Attached is the historical information that the Board member prepared. Please let us know the following: * Are there any underground utilities? * What are the purposes ofthe land? * Dovxehave aplan for the land? * Anything that the PZ team should know? Please feel free tocall mefor any questions. Thank you for your time! z 20 Owners A pert MMI!` Ism Jae Eun Kir~ r PLA Principal Planner Developr-nent, Planning Zoning Mailing Address; P.O. Box 1C.'- 1 Boynton Beach, Florida 3 425 Physical Address� 100 E. Ocean Ave. I Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 561-742-6378 5 Iain J(��.�bfl.Ljs oyritori-�.�rach.org/ tu Please be advised that Florida has a broad public records law and all corresponderice to r-ne is Crnail rnay be subject to disclosurr.l!rider Florida records law, ernail addresses are public records.Therefore, your e-rnail corny-n unication and your e- r-nail address r-nay be subject to public disclosure. 3 21 4.B Communications and Announcements 08/ 7/2023 City of Boynton Beach "• Agenda Item Request Form Commission Meeting Date: 08/7/2023 306 SE 1 Avenue aka Edith Andrews House Requested Action by Commission: Discussion of the draft historic designation report regarding the Edith Andrews House located at 306 SE 1st Avenue, Boynton Beach. Attachments: DRAFT - 306 SE 1st Ave (Edith Andrews House) 22 Edith Andrews House 306 SE Ist Avenue, Boynton Beach Local Historic Designation Final Report July 12, 2023 Prepared by Warren Adams Histo' rica, LLC 1 CIT 1) 23 List of Illustrations Figure 1: Boynton Railroad Station, c.1898 Figure 2: Seaboard Airline Depot c.1950s Figure 3: Hurricane Damage to High School, 1928 Figure 4: Town of Boynton Plat Title Block Figure 5: Town of Boynton Subdivision Plat, 1898 Figure 6: Lake Worth, Fla., USGS, 1945 Figure 7: Partial Town of Boynton Subdivision Aerial Figure 8: 306 SE 1st Avenue Looking East Figure 9: 306 SE 1st Avenue Looking West Figure 10: 306 SE 1st Avenue Looking North Figure 11: Miami News,August 3, 1907 Figure 12: Miami News,August 10, 1909 Figure 13: North Elevation Figure 14: North Elevation (no date) Figure 15: West Elevation Figure 16: South and East Elevations Figure 17: East Elevation Figure 18: Boynton Sanborn Map, 1924 Figure 19: Boynton Sanborn Map, 1940 Figure 20: 1998 Surveys Showing Relocation of Structure Figure 21: 1986 Figure 22: 1996 Figure 23: North Elevation Figure 24: West Elevation Figure 25: Byrd Spilman Dewey& Fred Dewey Figure 26: Albert &Anna Parker Figure 27: Mrs. Katie Andrews Figure 28: Charles Lee Andrews 1 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation 24 Edith Andrews House Local Historic Designation Property Address: 306 SE 11t Avenue, Boynton Beach, Florida 33435 Parcel Control Number: 08-43-45-28-03-011-0040 Legal Description: Lots 4, 5, and 6, Block 11, Town of Boynton, Lot 17, according to the Plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 1, Page 23, of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida. Construction Date: 1907 Architect/Builder: Architect not known. Builder not known. Building Type: Single-Family Residence Architectural Style: Wood Frame Vernacular Location and Site: The property is located on the southeast corner of Se 11t Avenue and SE 3rd Street.The corner site, consisting of three lots, measures approximately 147 feet wide by 137 feet deep. The two-story structure faces north. Florida Master Site File No.: PB00513 Statement of Significance The property at 306 SE 1st Avenue is the earliest surviving residential structure in the City and is a rare remaining example of the wood frame vernacular style. Although altered and relocated thirty-seven feet to the east on the original site, the structure was built during the Pioneer Era and retains sufficient integrity and characteristics to convey its architectural significance. The property, which is located within the first subdivision platted in the City, is associated with the early development of the City,and significantly contributes to the historic fabric of the downtown area. The property is associated with several pioneer families who contributed to the early development of the City. Based on the above, 306 SE 1st Avenue is eligible for individual historic designation and inclusion on the Boynton Beach Register of Historic Places. 2 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Criteria for Significance Chapter 4, Article IX, Section 6.B.1 of the City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations "Designation of Historic Properties and Districts"1 states: "To qualify as a Property or a District, individual properties must have significance in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture and possess integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship,feeling, and association. For Districts, eligibility is based on the establishment of historic contexts or themes which describe the historical relationship of the Properties within the district. Individual Buildings shall normally be at least 50 years old and, in the case of a District at least 50%of the Buildings shall normally be at least fifty years old. Buildings shall also be significant in one or more of the following areas: a. Association with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of the City's history, or b. Association with the lives of persons significant in the City's past,or c. Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction, or represents the work of a master, or possesses high artistic values, or represents a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction; d. Has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history, or e. Is listed in the National Register of Historic Places." As indicated in the report, 306 SE 1st Avenue is eligible for local historic designation under the following criteria: a. Association with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of the City's history. b. Association with the lives of persons significant in the City's past. c. Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction, or represents the work of a master, or possesses high artistic values, or represents a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction. 1 City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations. 3 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Historic Context The development of the City of Boynton Beach has taken place over four broad eras: • Pioneer Era (c.1875 to c.1919) • Boom Time Era (c.1920 to c.1928) • Depression/New Deal/War Time Era (c.1929 to c.1945) • Modern Era (c.1946 to c.1967) 306 SE 15t Avenue was built in 1907 during the Pioneer Era in the Wood Frame Vernacular style. Pioneer Era The earliest recorded property owner in the Boynton Beach area was Captain James A. Armour, the head lighthouse keeper in Jupiter, who, in 1875, filed a claim for beachfront land which encompassed the present Boynton Municipal Beach. Some of the earliest settlers included black families who farmed in the area. It was believed that the Town of Boynton was founded by Major Nathan Smith Boynton who owned all the land in the area and the hotel; however, recent research has shown this is not entirely accurate. In 1892, Byrd Spilman Dewey (Birdie Dewey), a prominent author of the time and wife of Fred Dewey,a Civil Warveteran from Indiana, purchased 160 acres of land at the southern end of Lake Worth. In 1895, she sold 120 acres of this land to William Seelye Linton, a new speculator from Michigan who made a small down payment of$100. In 1897, Linton sold 40 acres of this land to Major Boynton, former editor and publisher of the Port Huron Press and owner of the recently built Boynton Hotel. However, the sale was not completed as Linton, who had not paid the Dewey's in full forthe land, had no deed.This left the area known as Boynton in turmoil especially as Major Boynton had formed the Southern Florida Land Company and sold town lots on his land for$50. In September 1897, the Deweys filed a foreclosure lawsuit against Linton and Boynton for nonpayment which resulted in them regaining their land. Neither Boynton nor Linton ever filed a plat for the Town of Boynton. In 1898, the Deweys filed plats for the town of Boynton and for Dewey's Subdivision. As the Deweys were friends with Major Boynton, they named the town in his honor. Fred Dewey sold lots with genuine deeds to settlers and, as a consequence, served as land agent for several interests in the area including Henry M. Flagler's Florida East Coast (F.E.C.) Railway which had been granted property for building the railroad through to Mia mi2. Flagler's first passenger train traveled through Boynton in 18963. z Pedersen,G.L.and DeVries,J.M.Pioneering Palm Beach, the Deweys and the South Florida Frontier.Charleston, SC:The History Press,2012, p.96-100. s Farace,V.K.et.al.Boynton Beach, The First 100 Years. Boynton Beach: Boynton Beach Historical Society& Friends of the Boynton Beach City Library, 1995, p.38. 4 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation 4 gl�pr ,�i �IIPp,I�s„. est° 161, t5 ts}. { 77M f l3 } fit ti ir Figure 1:Baynton Railroad Station, c.1898(Baynton Beach City Library). During the late 1890s, residences and commercial buildings sprang up along Ocean Avenue. By 1900, Boynton had become a major supplier of tomatoes and pineapples to northern markets'. The rich soil from the farms also quickly produced beans, peppers, and bananas. Dairy farming also developed on the ocean ridge east of the Florida East Coast Canal. The success of the Boynton Hotel and local farm production prompted the designation of Boynton as a regular stop for the F.E.C. Railroad. The successes from the farms and dairies triggered more expansion to the area throughout the early 1900s. In 1907,the black community petitioned the School Board for a teacher.The Superintendent was ordered to employ a teacher, but the residents were to provide a building. A one-room wooden schoolhouse was constructed on Federal Highway north of Boynton Beach Boulevard. In 1909, when Palm Beach County separated from Dade County,the school became known as the Boynton Negro Schools. In 1908, a group of civic-minded women banded together to improve the quality of life for residents. The group was formally organized into the Boynton Woman's Club in 1909. The club quickly succeeded in its main purpose: to provide a venue for local social affairs and to house a lending library. Boom Time Era The Florida "Boom Time Era” was at its peak during the early 1920s. In 1920 Boynton Beach became an incorporated town and in November of this year, a $10,000 bond was passed which financed the $6,000 purchase of an ocean front park. Other early projects included the construction of a jail and, in 1920, doubling the F.E.C. railroad tracks which serviced Boynton. 4 Ibid. p.7. s Boynton Beach Historical Society Website"Boynton Beach's Poinciana School History". 5 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Within the next three years the town proceeded with paving streets and installing a water treatment system and, in 1924,a volunteer fire department was organized. In 1925 the Seaboard Coastline Railroad served the Boynton area. Figure 2:Seaboard Airline Depot c.1950s(Boynton Beach City Library). On February 20, 1924,the Commissioners of the Town of Boynton adopted and passed Ordinance No. 37 which established segregation and set apart "separate residential limits or districts for white and negro residents"'.The Ordinance set the boundaries for what was to be known as"The Negro District within the Town of Boynton, Florida" while the remaining land or parcels of land within the Town would be known as "The White District within the Town of Boynton, Florida". The Ordinance made it illegal for black residents to reside "within the territorial limits of said Town so set apart and established for the residence of white persons" and for white residents to reside "within the territorial limits of said Town so set apart and established for the residence of negroes." The penalty for violating this Ordnance was a fine of no more than $500, or imprisonment for not more than 60 days, or both. The black community, who primarily lived on Federal Highway to the north of Boynton Beach Boulevard, was forced to move west. Many buildings were also moved including homes, businesses,and the Boynton Elementary School which was moved to Wells Avenue and renamed Boynton Colored Elementary. On November 18, 1924, the Town Commission adopted and passed Ordinance No. 47 amending Ordinance 37 by "extending and defining the boundaries of the separate residential limits or districts for negro residents'17. Enterprising men were developing large tracts of land throughout Boynton. James Hartley and the Palm Beach-Boynton Development Company with K.D. Purdy began Lake Boynton Estates, a a Ordinance No.37,Town of Boynton.City of Boynton Beach Public Records, 1924. Ordinance No.47,Town of Boynton.City of Boynton Beach Public Records, 1924. 6 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation subdivision at the west end of Ocean Avenue. Two additional platted areas increased the size of Lake Boynton Estates. Stile Hall, C.F. Knuth and C.O. Miller organized the Boynton Finance Corporation to cover all aspects of real estate from construction to finance. The firm purchased tracts of land for both residential and commercial development throughout the community. Two developments by Knuth and Miller were found in Beverly Hills and Bower's Park. Hall with K.D Purdy developed Lakeside Gardens and Boynton Heights, L.E. Perkins purchased 30 acres of the Carrie Knapp tract west of town for redevelopment, and the Blake Company, owned by George H. Blake, developed Boynton Hills which was originally the Hardee pineapple fields. The Blake Company's extensive plans called for a "Grand Boulevard", which would accommodate 350 lots and the Blake Hotel. During the height of the boom Frank J. Nutting of the Nutting and Perkins Real Estate Firm confirmed a land sale exceeding $10,000 an acre. The newly named EI Dorado Park became the costliest parcel in the area according to Nutting. In 1925, Robert E. Wells, a Bahamian landowner and businessman, platted his property as the Robert E. Wells Subdivision. The street, originally named Wells Avenue and now East Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, became a thriving main street serving the black community$. Also in 1925, a new Rosenwald School was built for the black community on the corner of Seacrest Blvd. and NW 12th Ave. Rosenwald Schools were built primarily for the education of African American children in the South in the early 20th century. The project was the product of a partnership between Julius Rosenwald, CEO of Sears, Roebuck and Company and the African American leader Booker T. Washington. From the 1910s to the early 1930s, over 5,000 Rosenwald Schools were built in the southern states9. In the second half of the 1920s, a series of unfortunate events began to unfold in Boynton. In early 1925, citrus canker was discovered in the orange groves forcing the destruction of all citrus groves in Boynton. Financial problems began to plague the town, tax assessments continued to rise, recall elections and failed resolutions were topics of discussion, and resignations became commonplace with municipal officers. While salaries for municipal workers were slashed and bonds were burned, the voters of Boynton voted unanimously for the construction of a beach front casino that cost nearly$12,000.The Florida Land Boom was coming to an end and Boynton was deeply in debt. s City of Boynton Beach Black History Website. 9 Ibid. 7 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation In 1927, the Boynton Beach High School, designed by William Manley King in the Mediterranean Revival style, was completed. However, the building was badly damaged along with many others during the 1928 hurricane. Many people took refuge in the new building only to be injured when the auditorium gave way10 S{ Figure 3:Hurricane Damage to Nigh School, 1928(City of Baynton Beach). Depression/New Deal/War Time Era State legislative assistance alleviated some of Boynton's financial problems; however, concerns regarding indebtedness from municipal projects reached a peak when residents on the east side of the Intracoastal Waterway, which was earlier known as the East Coast Canal, served notice to the town of their wish to separate from Boynton and start a new municipality. Boynton and the eastside residents reached an agreement whereby the new municipality would assume indebtedness in excess of$350,000. The agreement was finalized in 1931 with the formation of two separate municipalities, Boynton and Boynton Beach. On November 7, 1933, the Board of Town Commissioners passed and adopted Ordinance No. 13611. This racial "sunset law" stated that after December 1, 1933, white people over 18 years of age could not be in the black section of town, and blacks could not be in the white section after 9 p.m. from October through May or 10 p.m. from June through September. By 1935 the Town of Boynton began construction of a replacement for the old wooden bridge on Ocean Avenue. The new bridge was financed with Depression Era funds supplied by the federal government. By 1939 the Town of Boynton Beach changed its name to Ocean Ridge. Within two years the Town of Boynton also adopted a new name and became the Town of Boynton Beach. The war years brought a different kind of living to Boynton residents as nighttime activities ceased, blackouts were ordered along the shoreline, and patrols kept watch on the beaches which were off-limits at night and partially limited in the day. Allied ships became the target of German U-boats. During one four-month period, sixteen ships were torpedoed between Cape Canaveral and Boca Raton. In 1945, the Club Continental opened at 150 NE 10th Avenue. The first floor contained a bar area and the second floor was used for dances and concerts. The club was a hub for black to Farace,V.K.et.al. Boynton Beach,The First 100 Years. Boynton Beach: Boynton Beach Historical Society& Friends of the Boynton Beach City Library, 1995, p.22. 11 Ordinance No. 136,Town of Boynton.City of Boynton Beach Public Records, 1933. 8 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation entertainment from the 1950s to the 1960s and was part of the Chitlin' Circuit which was a network of clubs, theaters, and other venues where black entertainers were allowed to perform during the segregation era. Many artists that performed here for$400 a night would eventually become household names such as James Brown, B.B. King, Fats Waller, and Guitar Slim12. Modern Era In 1951, the Palm Beach Post reported a meeting between the Boynton Negro Civic League and the City Commission.The Civic League requested expansion of the black residential section of the town, playgrounds for children, and beach bathing facilities for the black community. The meeting was noted as being the first time the black community had taken part in a local Commission meeting13 By the 1950s Boynton Beach was developing along the lines of other small South Florida cities. A new city hall was built on the corner of Seacrest Boulevard and Boynton Beach Boulevard in 1958, additional beach front property was purchased to extend recreational facilities, and Bethesda Memorial Hospital was opened in 1959. Further improvements included construction of a new civic center (1960), a new water treatment plant (1962), and a bridge over the Intracoastal at SE 15th Avenue (1967). From 1950 to 1960, Boynton's population grew from 2,543 to 10,400. Private developers once again returned to the community. In the mid-1960s three large residential projects began at Hampshire Gardens, Sterling Village, and the 415-acre "Leisureville"14 In 2016, plans for the Town Square, major redevelopment project, were introduced. Located between Boynton Beach Boulevard to the north, SE 211 Avenue to the south, Seacrest Boulevard to the west, and SE/NE 11t Street to the east,the project included the demolition of almost every structure except the vacant Boynton High School and the Elementary School (Schoolhouse Children's Museum), both of which are historically designated. To date, a new City Hall, library, town square park, children's playground, and amphitheater have been constructed,and the High School has been rehabilitated for use as a cultural center. 12 City of Boynton Beach Black History Website. 13 Palm Beach Post,"Negroes Present 3-Point Program",May 22, 1951, p.7(Newspapers.com). 14 Historic District Design Guidelines,City of Boynton Beach,2013. p.25-31. 9 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Significance Analysis Town of Boynton Subdivision In 1892, Byrd Spilman Dewey (Birdie Dewey), a prominent author of the time and wife of Fred Dewey,a Civil Warveteran from Indiana, purchased 160 acres of land at the southern end of Lake Worth. In 1895, she sold 120 acres of this land to William Seelye Linton, a new speculator from Michigan who made a small down payment of$100. In 1897, Linton sold 40 acres of this land to Major Boynton, former editor and publisher of the Port Huron Press and owner of the recently built Boynton Hotel. However, the sale was not completed as Linton, who had not paid the Deweys in full forthe land, had no deed.This left the area known as Boynton in turmoil especially as Major Boynton had formed the Southern Florida Land Company and sold town lots on his land for$50. In September 1897, the Deweys filed a foreclosure lawsuit against Linton and Boynton for nonpayment which resulted in them regaining their land. Neither Boynton nor Linton ever filed a plat for the Town of Boynton. In 1898, the Deweys filed plats for the town of Boynton (Attachment A) and for Deweys Subdivision. As the Deweys were friends with Major Boynton, they named the town in his honor. Fred Dewey sold lots with genuine deeds to settlers and, consequently, served as land agent for several interests in the area including Henry M. Flagler's Florida East Coast (F.E.C.) Railway which had been granted property for building the railroad through to MiaMi15 Krtgw [i�1 mega� ky3 F S.e Pr ss e-nYS 'i}aai WC }h{ kn�er3a�av<J am. aw .r,a3e N, '�>LA®"°�1*+ 4k.act,t err.a'p aye a 5xbdvis3tl+ e} lei W�'�4 w} 4ht �4��A s� iia 2.45, � 455'�1C3� tmt ke ic�awaa a§ Mae }nwn. •!q 43ev4n�'trq anal a5 tlatft, b� dcd�ca�'t Fr k: Asa e� #°tac 'aOm lr%, Si�re.t?s and al9.er{s Shawr vkc.e®n reseed n`i. +a. tanx 5tl.tes — htcrl •s4+q 5 Hw. s+t*t— ar .eY<rgienc lhcrt e�'.W h'O—sr a N%r.T%In1'.t d ky l aw t"' W3ktet55 WW�xre.}l # h.avt \Ae'(0u.rs-.sty p,av w."A5 G.d sea\-, '�'"5 tult.wty-7.� �s data�S Yze.w«rA37r C1 _ Sa )k'r.I� 5'.rSmnolr.t ap�C'xr•d 1tRICera*3+e°\Ssra.x S,C]twL k A,nd `rre:d 51ewt�j St 3nt.rs Gnd 5e'lLC '144 a ktarteyoin 'tn So ra Y'V—°C—6 C3 Gl4nfipr t.l+c ,�rYst SnNrkt !'06t'CM[a roe oalY€s.+s d+.e.4 ,r Figure 4: Town of Baynton Plat Title Black(City of Baynton Beach). The subdivision is associated with the development of the City of Boynton Beach in the Pioneer Era and with the life of early pioneers Byrd Spilman Dewey (Birdie Dewey) and Fred Dewey. is Pedersen,G.L.and DeVries,J.M. Pioneering Palm Beach,the Deweys and the South Florida Frontier.Charleston, SC:The History Press,2012, p.96-100. 10 306 SE 1"Ave.—Local Historic Designation The subdivision originally consisted of twelve blocks located between E. Boynton Beach Boulevard to the north, SE 211 Avenue to the south, SE 1st Street to the west, and S. Federal Highway to the east.The Florida East Coast Railway passes through the subdivision in a southwest to northeast direction. The majority of the lots were rectangular in shape and similarly sized although the lots adjacent to the railway were trapezoidal, and the lots on the east side of SE 1st Street were larger. All the roads were originally forty feet wide apart from Ocean Avenue which was fifty feet wide to signify its significance as the main east to west thoroughfare. As can be seen below, the streets originally had names as opposed to the current numbers with subject property located on Jessamine Street. AW Y w ci'. r t � � ___"_____._—. ��. _.p._ � � .metro_ ` •„Y f � +....' s F -p $; #'. .$ .ia}..S F ID .'0 * , l "L •:' % fF `a § S I J' Q $ m f Figure 5: Town of Boynton Subdivision Plat 1898. When the subject property was built, it would have been one of only a few houses in the subdivision. As the map below indicates, by 1945, most development had taken place to the north along Boynton Beach Boulevard and Ocean Avenue and to the east along South Federal Highway.The development of the downtown area is exhibited along these streets which included sites such as the Boynton High School,the Elementary School,the F.E.C. Railroad Station,the first Boynton Woman's Club building, and a number of commercial structures along Ocean Avenue. Very little development had taken place in the southwest of the subdivision. 10 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation AI AM i, �i A. .. .... D,-,,,111,,,, AV, i�. IF Figure 6:Lake Worth, Fla, UIGI1945/UIGIgov/ Over time the subdivision hes continued to develop with e wide variety of uses and building styles,sizes,and heights.The predominant land uses are commercial, industrial,and multi-family residential Single-family residential units are mostly located in the southwest section of the subdivision. The Andrews House is located beside other single-family homes in the subdivision to the north, west, and south. Also tothe north are one-story storage units. Tothe east, on the opposite side of the railroad tracks are oonnnneroie| properties and e seven-story apartment and perking structure.The apartment structure has somewhat impacted the setting of the historic structure. The partial aerial image below shows the residential structures are similar in size tothe Andrews House and the setbacks are consistent although the Andrews House sits on three lots. The oonnnnercie| and multi-family developments on C>oeen Avenue to the north and across the railroad tracks to the east mostly have larger footprints and are located on larger sites. The quality of landscaping and associated features such as fences, driveways, boundary walls, vegetation, and level ofmaintenance varies from property to property along SE 11t Avenue and SE3ru Street. The roadways are surfaced with asphalt and there are no sidewalks. Records indicate the property operated as a guest house from as early as 1913 until at least 1925 and ese pioneer museum c.200016. z«City ofBoynton Beach Library Archives Manuscript Collection—AOO2J—Andrews House Collection. 12 306SE1°`Ave.—Local Historic Designation 35 t pry . . ......... "IT 4 . LU uj 41 Figure 7:Partial Town of Boynton Subdivision Aerial(Palm Beach Property Appraiser Website). M, Figure 8:306 SE 1"Avenue Looking East Figure 9:3065E1"Avenue Looking West (W.Adams,April 11, 2023). (W.Adams,April 11, 2023). Figure 10:306 SE 1"Avenue Looking North (W.Adams,April 11, 2023). 13 306 SE 1"Ave.—Local Historic Designation 36 316 SE 151 Avenue is an early residence located in the Town of Boynton Subdivision which was the first subdivision platted in the City by early pioneers Byrd Spilman Dewey and Fred Dewey. The house is one of the earliest structures built in the City and is the oldest structure remaining within the subdivision which developed into the downtown area. Based on the above, 316 SE 1st Avenue is eligible for historic designation under criterion "a", "association with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of the City's history" as it is associated with the early development of the City of Boynton Beach. 14 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation 306 SE 15t Avenue Description The single-family residence at 306 SE 1st Avenue, built 1907, sits on a corner lot on the southeast corner of SE 1st Avenue and SE 3rd Street. The north facing lot measures approximately 147 feet wide by 137 feet deep. The residence is setback approximately twenty-five feet from the front property line and is approached by a concrete paver walkway.There is no driveway or delineated parking on the property. There are no fences or walls on the north, west, or east property lines although there is a wooden fence on the south property line. The property is adjacent to the Florida East Coast Railway tracks which lie just to the east. The property was originally constructed as a single-family home but is currently vacant. As shown in Figure 11 below, the structure was built by Mr. B. L. Kapp in 1907. Surveys show the property was originally located on Lot 5, Block 11 of the Town of Boynton Subdivision (it was later moved to Lot 4). As shown in Figure 12 below, he purchased Lots 4 and 6 for$35 in 1909. '1 Q. Mld8ucle ot Mr. B. L. Kapp. Serdit 'S, " v , fast ueaftc com letion. , . finlahv It Vill be ove of the pret-, ", toAsIderation 034. best, homps tu Boynton. 'COX to rn ' p ton lot It. block- 6" ,< Figure 11:Miami News,August 3, 1907. coustdoration 01 _ KOPP. IOU I and 2. blocU In Itown of, 80YInt,01411 (,"Ololslilillellrl4tioll, '. Figure 12:Miami News,August 10, 1909. The property is noted as being Boynton's oldest residence17. The structure, which comprises the two-story main body of the house and two single-story attachments, is irregular in plan and has a total floor area of 1,600 square feet, 1,404 square feet of which is under air18. The single-story attachment to the south elevation appears to be original and the single-story attachment to the east elevation appears to be a later addition. Construction is of a concrete block stem wall foundation supporting a wood frame structure with exterior novelty wood siding. The two-story and one-story sections have pitched gable roofs surfaced with wood shakes. The north and south roof slopes of the two-story section contain a projecting dormer window. The entire structure is surrounded by a wooden deck supported by concrete piers. The north (front) elevation of the two-story structure is of novelty drop siding. The covered entrance porch structure comprises a pitched gable roof surfaced with wood shakes supported by two simple square wooden columns and simple wood brackets. Two simple wood railings comprising square top and bottom rails with square spindles are attached between the porch columns and house wall. The porch eaves contain exposed rafters, and the gable contains 17 Boynton Beach Historical Society Website,"Boynton's Oldest House". 18 Palm Beach County Property Appraiser Website. 15 306 SE 1"Ave.—Local Historic Designation decorative fish scale shingles. A porch light with globe fitting hangs in the center of the porch roof. The top half of the central wooden front door is glazed with a single-light and the bottom half contains three rectangular recessed panels. Above the front door, projecting from the roof slope is a dormer window with a pitched, wood shake roof, exposed rafters, and decorative fish scale shingles in the gable.There are two single-windows at first floor level and a double-window in the dormer. All are covered with louvered metal shutters; however, Figure 14 below indicates the windows are wood frame, double-hung with a two-over-two lighting configuration. There is decorative wood trim around the door and windows and at the structure corners.Two decorative exterior lights with globe fittings are attached to the top corners of the fagade. The north elevation of the one-story section attached to the east elevation is of similar construction to the two-story section. The windows are covered with louvered metal shutters; however, Figure 14 below, shows them to be either fixed or casement, with a two-over-two lighting configuration. � w Yw„ Mknir P' Figure 13:North Elevation (W.Adams,April 11,2023). Figure 14:North Elevation (no date). 16 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation The west elevation of the two-story section contains novelty drop siding, decorative wood trim, and decorative fish scale shingles in the roof gable. At first-floor level there are a single- and double window although both are covered with metal louvered shutters. There are two single- windows at the second-floor level. Both are covered with metal louvered shutters; however, one of the shutters was open to reveal a wood frame double-hung window with a two-over-two lighting configuration. A staircase of wooden supports, wooden top rails, and wooden spindles leads to a central second-floor landing providing access to a central door. The door is covered with plywood. The west elevation of the one-story attachment to the south elevation is of novelty siding.There are no doors or windows. r-. Y m„ �! T 3 ) F Figure 15: West Elevation(W.Adams,April 11,2023). The south (rear) elevation of the two-story section is of novelty drop siding and decorative wood trim. There are exposed rafters at the eaves. A central dormer with decorative fish scale shingles in the gable projects from the southern roof slope. There are two single-windows at first floor level, a single-window at second-floor level, and a double-window in the dormer; however, all are obscured by louvered metal panels. There is a wall-light with a decorative globe fitting at second-floor level. The one-story attachment to this elevation contains decorative fish scale shingles in the roof gable and a door which is obscured by plywood. A wooden lattice fence with gate is used to screen the AC equipment on this elevation. The one-story attachment to the east elevation is of similar construction. It appears to contain three windows,all of which are obscured by louvered metal shutters. There is also an access door covered with plywood. 17 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Figure 16:South and East Elevations/N/Adams,April 11,2023/ The east elevation of the two-story section is of novelty drop siding. The roof gable contains decorative fish scale shingles. There is one single-window at first-floor level, and two single- windows at second-floor level, all of which are obscured by louvered metal shutters. The single- story attachment to this elevation contains decorative fish scale shingles and e light with decorative globe fitting in the gable. The windows are obscured by louvered metal shutters. Figure 17:East Elevation(KKAdams,April 11,203). There was noaccess tothe interior ofthe structure etthe time ofsurvey. 18 306SE1°`Ave.—Local Historic Designation 36 Additions and Alterations Very few records exist on this property; therefore, most of the following was determined from an exterior survey, photographs from the survey, historic photographs, plats and surveys, and information found online. As can be seen from the 1924 and 1940 Sanborn Maps and the surveys below, the structure was moved thirty-seven feet to the east in 1998. The relocation of a structure can have a significant adverse effect on integrity of location and setting. However, as the distance moved was small, the structure is still on the same site, and the structure is still oriented in the same direction, the negative impact is minimal. JESSAMINEa f JC �; JESSAMINE n z k f F3 Figure 18:Baynton Sanborn Map, 1924. Figure 19:Baynton Sanborn Map, 1940. Wr EYlSrru4a tl5".4-?* I.T t Ez�strut6.t.8-45T1► tT n + 4e4■E rS6.49[.,' i s , EwtrE 166.4r�' w 1, P y a4r � i. # q _I BtCK' 10F -&&fast It - I Z '10 'dLLE Y( frXIPIY 1 '114CGY{trNSAM1PItO: D Figure20:1998 Surveys Showing Relocation of Structure(FMSF#:PB00513) 19 306 SE 1"Ave.—Local Historic Designation i tY p - r - Figure 21:1986(Florida Master Site File P800513). Figure 22:1996(Florida Master Site File PB00513) (g � t �f z S� I Figure 23:North Elevation(W.Adams,April 11, 2023). Figure 24: West Elevation (W.Adams,April 11,2023). As can be seen when comparing the 1986 and 1996 photographs, very few changes appear to have occurred during this period apart from a new roof covering. As no original construction details exist, the original roof covering cannot be determined. The fenestration pattern on the north and west elevations of the two-story element appears to be unaltered from the original design apart from the addition of an exterior staircase and second floor entry door on the west elevation. The photographs indicate this alteration was undertaken prior to 1986. The north, east, and possibly the south elevations of the one-story section have been altered to incorporate a series of windows on all three elevations. Other alterations include replacement siding, construction of a new foundation when the house was moved in 1998,the installation of a wood shake roof, and the addition of a wood deck around the structure. Access to the interior was not possible during the survey; however, it does appear to have been altered per the City of Boynton Beach Library archive which states "Contractors John Dority and 20 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation O'Shea stripped the walls to the framing,sandblasted the paint off, used salvaged Dade Pine(now extinct) when necessary."19 This work was undertaken when the structure was moved. Integrity Chapter 4, Article IX, Section 6.13.1 of the City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations "Designation of Historic Properties and Districts" states: "Guidelines for Historic Designation. To qualify as a Property or a District, individual properties must have significance in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture and possess integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship,feeling, and association." As noted above the structure is not in its original location; however, as it was moved only thirty- seven feet, remains on the same site, and is oriented in the same direction, the negative impact on the integrity of location is minimal. The subdivision has developed over time with the introduction of multi-family structures and commercial structures of varying architectural styles and sizes. These newer, larger structures are most apparent to the east and do have some negative impact on the setting. However,these structures are on the opposite side of the railroad tracks to the east. The properties near the subject are mainly one- and two-story residential structures. The property, therefore, retains sufficient integrity of location and setting to convey its significance. The property has been altered; however, the alterations are consistent with the architectural style of the house. The addition, exterior staircase, inserted second floor door on the west elevation, and the deck ae reversible. The essential exterior form, structure, and style have been retained. The property retains much of its integrity of design. It is unclear how much of the original exterior material has been retained; however, apart from the windows, it appears most have been replaced. It is unknown if fish scale shingles or a wood shake roof were part of the original design. The integrity of material has been adversely impacted. A loss of original exterior materials also impacts the workmanship of the house on the exterior. However, if the original framework has been retained,this will exhibit a high degree of traditional workmanship associated with the early construction techniques required to build a house of this type, likely without the aid of a set of plans. The integrity of workmanship has been partially impacted. Feeling is how a property conveys a particular period of time through physical features. The materials and workmanship have been compromised; however, the addition and replacement materials are compatible with and appropriate for the style. The structure relates to the feeling 19 City of Boynton Beach Library Archives Manuscript Collection—A0023—Andrews House Collection. 20 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation of residential life during the Pioneer Era in Boynton Beach. The property, therefore, retains sufficient integrity of feeling. Wood Frame Vernacular structures are the earliest form of construction within the City of Boynton Beach and the subject is the oldest surviving example of this style in the City. The structure is sufficiently intact to convey the property's relationship to the Pioneer Era and the early development of the City. The property retains its integrity of association. Based on the above, 306 SE 1st Avenue is eligible for historic designation under criterion "c" "embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction" as this is a rare and the oldest surviving example of a Wood Frame Vernacular residence in the City. The structure retains sufficient integrity to convey its significance and contributes to the historic fabric of the downtown area. 22 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Ownership History 1892 - Pre-1907 Byrd Spilman Dewey(Birdie Dewey) and Fred Dewey20 Pre-1907 - 1915 Bert L. Kapp2122 1915 - 1924 A. E. Parker23 1924- 1971 Alice Fields24 1925 - 1971 Katie Gager Andrews(1887-1971)25 1971 - 1972 Charles Lee AndrewS26 1972 - 1993 George Kermit AndrewS27 1993 - 1998 Edith Burns AndrewS28 1998 - 2000 Robert F. Katz29 2000- 2015 Bobkatz Properties, Inc.30 2015 - 2022 East Ocean Avenue, LLC31 2022 - present BB South, LLC32 Byrd Spilman Dewey and Fred Dewey Byrd Spilman Dewey was born Julia Bird Spilman in Covington, Kentucky to Jonathan Edwards Spilman and Eliza Sarah Taylor. Her maternal great-grandfather was Colonel Richard Taylor, father of President Zachary Taylor. In 1877, she moved to Salem, Illinois where her father, a Presbyterian Minister, received a pastorate. It was there she met Frederick Sidney Dewey. They were married on September 25, 1877. The Deweys moved to Jacksonville, Florida in 1881 where they purchased 20 acres of land in Zellwood to grow vegetables and raise an orange grove. However, as the land was unsuitable for their plans, they sold the land and moved to Eustis where Fred became a bookkeeper. As life in 20 Pedersen,G.L.and DeVries,J.M. Pioneering Palm Beach,the Deweys and the South Florida Frontier.Charleston, SC:The History Press,2012, p.96-100. 21 Miami News,August 3, 1907. 22 Palm Beach Post, "Bert L. Kapp",April 18, 1927,p.5. 23 Boynton Beach Historical Society Website,"Boynton's Oldest House". 24 City of Boynton Beach Library Archives Manuscript Collection—A0023—Andrews House Collection. 2s_Ibid. 261bid. 27 Ibid. 281bid. 29 Palm Beach Property Appraiser Website. 301bid. 311bid. 321bid. 23 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Eustis was unsatisfying for them,they moved back to Jacksonville where, in 1885, Byrd gave birth to Elizabeth Dewey who died in infancy. In 1887, the Deweys heard of a new frontier opening in Lake Worth County and purchased 76 acres of land west of Lake Worth. They cultivated approximately two acres of the land. During this time, Fred worked as a bookkeeper and carpenter in Palm Beach33 In 1892, the Deweys purchased 160 acres of land at the southern end of Lake Worth. In 1895, she sold 120 acres of this land to William Seelye Linton, a new speculator from Michigan who made a small down payment of$100. In 1897, Linton sold 40 acres of this land to Major Boynton, former editor and publisher of the Port Huron Press and owner of the recently built Boynton Hotel. However, the sale was not completed as Linton, who had not paid the Dewey's in full for the land, had no deed.This left the area known as Boynton in turmoil especially as Major Boynton had formed the Southern Florida Land Company and sold town lots on his land for$50. In September 1897, the Deweys filed a foreclosure lawsuit against Linton and Boynton for nonpayment which resulted in them regaining their land. Neither Boynton nor Linton ever filed a plat for the Town of Boynton. In 1898, the Deweys filed plats for the town of Boynton and for Dewey's Subdivision. As the Deweys were friends with Major Boynton, they named the town in his honor. Fred Dewey sold lots with genuine deeds to settlers and, as a consequence, served as land agent for several interests in the area including Henry M. Flagler's Florida East Coast (F.E.C.) Railway which had been granted property for building the railroad through to Miami34 Byrd Spilman Dewey was also an accomplished author with her first known work appearing in the Florida Farmer and Fruit Grower newspaper in 1887. Also in that year, was her first article published in a national magazine, the Christian Union. In 1891, she became the first columnist in the Tropical Sun newspaper. In 1896, she was published in the Lake Worth Historian, which was produced by the pioneer women of Lake Worth as a fund raiser for the Royal Poinciana Chapel. In 1899, Little Brown & Company, published her first book Bruno, which sold more than 10,000 copies throughout the country in the first year. Her second book, The Blessed Isle and its Happy Families was published in 1907, and her third book, From Pine Woods to Palm Groves, was published in 1909 in serialized form in The Florida Review. Her last published work in 1927 was an article in the Florida Naturalist titled "Some Bird Notes". After her husband's death in 1919, Byrd worked with the Audubon Society where, in 1920, she was named the field secretary. She moved to Jacksonville in 1928 where she died in 194235 33 Byrd Spilman Dewey—Florida's Pioneer Author Website. 34 Pedersen,G.L.and DeVries,J.M.Pioneering Palm Beach, the Deweys and the South Florida Frontier.Charleston, SC:The History Press,2012, p.96-100. 3s Byrd Spilman Dewey—Florida's Pioneer Author Website. 24 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation 47 Figure 25:Byrd Ip8monDewey& Fred Dewey(Byrd Ip8monDewey — Florida's Pioneer Author Nebsite). Bert L. Kapp Bert L. Kapp arrived in the United States from Holland during his childhood. He lived in Muskegon, Michigan until 1896 when he moved to Boynton where he was one of the first settlers. In 1915, he and his wife moved to West Palm Beach. He died in his residence at 620 0 Street in 1927 aged so 69� A. E. Parker Albert Edward Parker was born in England in 1873 and emigrated to the United States in 1886. Hewas the first naturalized citizen in Pe|nn Beach County as hewas sworn in onthe day Pe|nn Beach County becameofficial onJuly 1, 1909. Parkerwas married toAnna Boynton,the daughter of Major Nathan S. Boynton. He managed the Boynton Hotel until the early 1920s and had the first dairy in Boynton, the Bertana Farm, the name of which was a combination of his and Anna's first names. Albert became the City Manager of West Pe|nn Beach and sold real estate in Pe|nn Beach. He lived on F|eg|erOrive in e Mediterranean Revival style house which he built. Albert sr pessedevveyin1935 Figure 26:Albert&Anna Parker (Boynton Beach Historical Society Website"No hurly-burly hrBoynton/ 3«Palm Beach Post,"Bert LKopp'',April 18, 19Z7,p.5. nBoynton Beach Historical Society Website,"No hudy'burly/n8oynton" ZS 306SE1°`Ave.—Local Historic Designation 48 Katie Gager&Charles Lee Andrews c t� t i I 4 da3��.t'1h1�fYYb��+N\ �NA� Y yyyY Figure 27:Mrs. Katie Andrews Figure 28: Charles Lee Andrews (Palm Beach Post October 25, (Boynton Beach Historical Society 1864)• Website"Boynton's Oldest Nouse"). Katie Andrews was married in 1910 to Major Charles Lee Andrews when "...she was not quite 18 years old..." in Gulfport, Mississippi. They moved to the downtown section of Boynton in 1915. She operated a general store until her husband died in 1922. Katie sold out and bought 306 SE 15t Avenue which she ran as a guest house. Major Andrews was the son of a family of plantation owners in Louisiana. Mrs. Andrews' grandparents bought and sold slaves. Her grandfather was one of a family of four boys who, at first, lived in New York. Her grandfather and a brother moved south where they bought slaves from their brothers in the north. During the Civil War, two brothers fought for the North and two for the South. When they were not fighting, they would visit each other's camps as many of the soldiers did. All brothers survived the war. During World War II, Mrs. Andrews served as an aircraft spotter. In 1964, she was the only known living widow of a Civil War veteran in Palm Beach County38. Based on the above, 316 NE 15t Avenue is eligible for historic designation under criterion "b" "association with the lives of persons significant in the City's past" as the property is associated with several pioneer families who contributed to the settlement and development of the City of Boynton Beach. ss Palm Beach Post,"Widow Living Tie to American Civil War",October 25, 1964,p.41,(Newspapers.com). 26 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Bibliography Publications City of Boynton Beach Land Development Regulations. Farace, V.K. et. al. Boynton Beach, The First 100 Years. Boynton Beach: Boynton Beach Historical Society & Friends of the Boynton Beach City Library, 1995. Historic District Design Guidelines, City of Boynton Beach, 2013. Pedersen, G.L. and DeVries, J.M. Pioneering Palm Beach, the Deweys and the South Florida Frontier. Charleston, SC: The History Press, 2012. Documents Ordinance No. 37,Town of Boynton. City of Boynton Beach Public Records, 1924. https://Ifpub.bbfl.us/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=13126&dbid=0 Ordinance No.47,Town of Boynton. City of Boynton Beach Public Records, 1924. https://Ifpub.bbfl.us/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=13116&dbid=0 Ordinance No. 136,Town of Boynton. City of Boynton Beach Public Records, 1933. https://Ifpub.bbfl.us/WebLink/DocView.aspx?id=12366&dbid=0&repo=CityClerk Newspapers Miami News,August 3, 1907. Miami News,August 10, 1909. Palm Beach Post, "Bert L. Kapp", April 18, 1927, p.5 (Newspapers.com). Palm Beach Post, "Negroes Present 3-Point Program", May 22, 1951, p.7 (Newspapers.com). Palm Beach Post, "Widow Living Tie to American Civil War", October 25, 1964, p.41, (Newspapers.com). Maps and Plats Boynton Sanborn Map, 1924. Boynton Sanborn Map, 1940. Lake Worth, Fla., USGS, 1945 (USGS.gov) Town of Boynton Subdivision Plat, 1898. Surveys Florida Master Site File PB00513 27 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation Websites Boynton Beach Historical Society Website "Boynton Beach's Poinciana School History". Page consulted October 9, 2O22. http://www.boyntonhistory.org/category/bl v/ Boynton Beach Historical Society Website, "Boynton's Oldest House". Page consulted June 5, 2023. Boynton Beach Historical Society Website, "No hurly-burly inBoynton" Page consulted June 11, 2023. Byrd Spilman Dewey—Florida's PioneerAuthor Website. Page consulted on various dates. City ofBoynton Beach website, page consulted onvarious dates. EZ City of Boynton Beach Black History Website, page consulted October 1, 2022. City of Boynton Beach Library Archives Manuscript Collection — AOO23 — Andnevvs House Collection. Page consulted onvarious dates. Google Street View, page consulted onvarious dates. Nevvspepenszonn, page consulted onvarious dates. Palm Beach County Property Appraiser Website, page consulted on various dates. USGS.gov, page consulted onvarious dates. ZO 306SE1°`Ave.—Local Historic Designation 50 Attachment A Town of Boynton Subdivision i ,,7>/W7 ." Y 4 Na .. ,ty < « 3 1 Y 1 , e.s ...._ txr r��✓7wr t k $ LL it .w ��►yy .Yryy. wF �� ,. � � w ti r, Y w h 1 ,., . .......... y�"y1 .. ... ..._ f i � 4 r � n 5� gg gyp, .. p�. x ap c� ,P �� Pk p 29 306 SE 1St Ave.—Local Historic Designation