Loading...
Minutes 03-02-15PRESENT MINUTES OF THE REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING HELD IN COMMISSION CHAMBERS, CITY HALL, 100 EAST BOYNTON BEACH BOULEVARD, BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA ON MONDAY, MARCH 2, 2015 AT 6:30 P.M. Jerry Taylor, Mayor Joseph Casello, Vice Mayor David T. Merker, Commissioner Mack McCray, Commissioner Michael M. Fitzpatrick, Commissioner 1. OPENINGS A. Call to Order - Mayor Jerry Taylor Invocation Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag led by Commissioner Mack McCray Mayor Taylor called the meeting to order at 6:31 p.m. Commissioner McCray gave the invocation and led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. Roll call revealed all members were present. Agenda Approval: 1. Additions, Deletions, Corrections Mayor Taylor called for a vote on tabling the Casa Del Mar items. 1 Lori LaVerriere, City Manager James Cherof, City Attorney Janet M. Prainito, City Clerk Mayor Taylor noted there was a request to table Items 13. A, B and L. Staff recommended tabling Item13. A to March 17 Item 13.B was previously tabled to March 17 Item L has to be removed from the agenda pending other litigation. Vice Mayor Casello pulled Item 6.A for discussion. He requested that Items 9. A through E be delayed for one more meeting. There has been progress made, but more time would be helpful. Mayor Taylor felt the Casa Del Mar items should move forward. Commissioner McCray was in favor of delaying the items as requested. Commissioner Fitzpatrick had discussion with the developer and wanted to know what areas need further discussion. Commissioner Merker had met on several occasions with both sides and saw no cause for further delay because it would be a plus for the City of Boynton Beach. Mayor Taylor had met with members of the Casa Del Mar team and there were no further negotiable areas. MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Motion Vote The motion passed unanimously. 2. OTHER 2 March 2, 2015 Vote The motion failed 2 -3 (Mayor Taylor, Commissioners Merker and Fitzpatrick dissenting). 2. Adoption Commissioner McCray moved to approve the agenda as amended. Commissioner Merker seconded the motion. A. Informational items by Members of the City Commission Commissioner Fitzpatrick had gone to the South Central Regional Waste Water Board meeting; however, the meeting was cancelled for lack of a quorum. He had gone to the East Boynton Little League opening with Mayor Taylor and attended the Delray Beach Commission meeting and Firefighters Pension Board meeting. Commissioner Fitzpatrick attended the Fire Rescue Award Ceremony and a Condo Board meeting. He disclosed he met with Tony Mauro and his lawyer about Casa Del Mar. The Schoolhouse Children's Museum reunion was another event he attended. Vice Mayor Casello had also attended the Fire Department Pension Board meeting and Mayor's Ball held at the Palm Beach County Convention Center, a gala to raise money to stamp out hunger and homelessness. He disclosed he had met with representative of Casa Del Mar and the residents of Lakeside Gardens. Commissioner Merker was honored to attend the Fire Rescue Award Ceremony. The risk taken and care given by the firefighters for the benefit of the residents is unappreciated and should be applauded. Commissioner McCray received phone calls from citizens of the Casa Del Mar area and representatives of the developers; however, he declined to speak to any of them. Mayor Taylor did attend the Sewer Board meeting, Little League opening and League of Cities meeting. He reported that the population of Boynton Beach has risen to 71,668 and remains the third largest City in Palm Beach County. He had gone to the Firefighters Award Banquet, the Kiwanis scholarship luncheon and Schoolhouse Children's Reunion Blast. MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 3. ANNOUNCEMENTS, COMMUNITY & SPECIAL EVENTS & PRESENTATIONS A. Announcement of the change to free chlorination of the water supply from March 6, 2015 through March 20, 2015. Colin Groff, Director of Utilities, explained for two weeks the amount of chlorine in the system would be increased to ensure high quality water is provided to the residents. Public notice is given. It is required yearly. Vice Mayor Casello mentioned fluoride that is put into the water. Mr. Groff reported it is not required, but it is added to the water. There were some equipment issues that temporarily took the equipment offline. Those repairs are temporary in nature and articles have been published that has helped to clarify the issue. B. Boynton Beach Police Department will host the 2015 South Florida K9 Competition on Saturday, March 7, 2015 at the Boynton Beach High School, 4975 Park Ridge Blvd. The event runs from 2:OOpm - 8:OOpm. Mayor Taylor read the announcement for the free Police K -9 competition on March 7, 2015. It is a great show and he encouraged others to attend. C. Announcement by Recreation & Parks Director Wally Majors regarding the "Spring Into Summer" event, which will be held at Intracoastal Park on Saturday, March 14 from 10 a.m. to 12 noon. Wally Majors, Director of Recreation and Parks, was proud to announce the beginning of the "Play Unplugged Series" with monthly family- oriented special events at various parks. On March 14 from 10 a.m. to 12 noon would be the "Spring Into Summer" event to be held at Intracoastal Park. There would be the opportunity to register for summer camps with a discount for early registration. Commissioner McCray asked for the cost for a resident. Mr. Majors advised the cost of the eight -week summer camp is $500. D. Proclaim March 2015 as "Florida Bicycle Month ". Mayor Taylor proclaimed the month of March, 2015 as Bicycle Month. He presented the Proclamation to Mr. Majors. E. Proclaim March 2015 as "City of Boynton Beach Firefighter Appreciation Month" The Proclamation for Firefighter Appreciation Month was read by Mayor Taylor and presented to Chief Ray Carter. Chief Carter announced the annual boot drive campaign would be held the last three weekends of March to collect money to fight muscular dystrophy with a goal to raise $37,000. He thanked the citizens for their donations. 3 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 4. PUBLIC AUDIENCE March 2, 2015 F. To accept the report on the International Kinetic Art Exhibit and Symposium February 6 -8, 2015 and view video. Debby Coles - Dobay, Public Arts Manager, gave an overview of the Kinetic Art Symposium that met its goal of 5,000 in attendance. Local jobs were created to install the art work, produce marketing materials and event set up and break down. Area hotels and restaurants were full. Positive media coverage reached 2.5 million viewers and readers. A short video that captures the experience was shown. She thanked the Commission, Arts Commission members and all the volunteers for their support. Commissioner Merker commented he truly enjoyed the events. Mayor Taylor was at the grand opening and enjoyed watching the children experiencing the art. INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO 3 MINUTE PRESENTATIONS (at the discretion of the Chair, this 3 minute allowance may need to be adjusted depending on the level of business coming before the City Commission) Harry Woodworth, 685 SE 18 Street, President of INCA, gave a status update. The goals of the organization were the same as the City's Strategic Plan. There was progress with the removal of old poles along Federal Highway being taken down. He submitted to the Commission a list of issues along Federal Highway that needed attention. He was sure the new owner of the Plaza would be helpful in solving issues in his development. Financial assistance may be needed to maximize his efforts. Their goal was to find things with high visual appeal to improve Federal Highway. The sidewalks are a safety issue and have to be improved and cleaned. Lulu DeCamara, Secretary of INCA, had viewed the area along Federal Highway and commented the amount of garbage along the way creates a negative image for the entire City. The Great American Cleanup is scheduled for April 25, 2015 and she hoped it would garner many volunteers to help. Minister Bernard Wright, 713 NW 2 Street, commended Commissioner McCray, the Historic Resource Preservation Board and Warren Adams with the attempts made to establish the history of the Heart of Boynton. Chief Katz had started to develop a dialogue with the community members. The connection to the history of the community has to be maintained for the City to grow. Suzanne Ross, Director of the Schoolhouse Children's Museum, participated in the Kinetic Art Symposium and hosted the JCC and Legal Aid Society event at the Museum. The Reunion Blast was a success, in spite of the rain, and resulted in significant public relations appearing on Channels 5 and 12. She thanked everyone who participated and sponsored the event. March and April would include several new programs too. 4 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA James DeVoursney, 2625 Lake Drive North, introduced himself as a candidate for the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) Board. He had a background as a physician, business owner and lived in the CRA corridor. He was very interested in participating and volunteering to serve. Ray Whitely, 5503 Wishing Star Lane, Greenacres, works with the Boynton Beach Coalition of Clergy. He thanked the Commission, especially Commissioner McCray for all he does for District II. Commissioner McCray indicated he was humbled by the praise. No one else coming forward, Mayor Taylor closed Public Audience. 5. ADMINISTRATIVE A. Appoint eligible members of the community to serve in vacant positions on City advisory boards. The following Regular (Reg) and Alternate (Alt) Student (Stu) and Nonvoting Stu (NN Stu) openings exist: Arts Commission: 2 Alts Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals: 2 Alts Cemetery Board: 1 Reg and 1 Alt. Education and Youth Advisory Board: 1 NN Stu Employees' Pension Trustees: 1 Reg. Golf Course Advisory Committee: 1 Alt Historic Resource Preservation Board: 2 Alts Library Board: 1 Reg and 1 Alt Recreation and Parks Board: 1 Alt Senior Advisory Board: 1 Reg and 2 Alts Veterans Advisory Commission: 1 Alt Motion Vice Mayor Casello moved to appoint Steven Anton as an alternate member of the Veterans Advisory Commission. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Vote The motion passed unanimously. 6. CONSENT AGENDA Matters in this section of the Agenda are proposed and recommended by the City Manager for "Consent Agenda" approval of the action indicated in each item, with 5 March 2, 2015 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 all of the accompanying material to become a part of the Public Record and subject to staff comments A. Authorize the Finance Department to reduce the Allowance for Uncollectible Accounts and the Accounts Receivable Accounts by $286,721.82. This amount reflects unpaid ALS Transportation billings that have been in collections for 12 months or longer. Vice Mayor Casello argued the loss of revenue did have a financial impact on the City. The money could be used for much needed equipment for public safety. He felt there needed to be a better system in place to get more bills paid and place liens on those that do not pay. Commissioner McCray asked if comparisons could be provided to assess how other municipalities handle the issue and Mr. Howard agreed to provide the information. He further explained the bills are sent out, collection is attempted and if unsuccessful, the bill is turned over to the credit bureaus. Liens are not implemented. Commissioner Fitzpatrick asked what percentage of the total revenue is uncollectible and Chief Carter replied it represents approximately 20% of what was billed for the year. Commissioner Merker inquired if the amount has remained consistent over the years and Chief Carter noted it rises slightly because the call volume increases yearly. The collection percentage has not changed much over the years. Commissioner Merker commented there is the variable of the human side and financial history of the users. The procedure is understandable and there are many reasons why money is not collected. Commissioner Fitzpatrick asked if there was any State or Federal programs that helped with the expense of transporting the homeless. Chief Carter indicated there were programs through the Health Care District that paid 20% of the billing amount. The amount reflects billings that were uncollected for a period of time and pushed through collection. For many of the accounts the individuals are deceased or uninsured. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve item A. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Vote The motion passed unanimously. B. Approve the addition of the following job classifications in the City's Pay Plan: Special Projects Coordinator and Executive Assistant. 6 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 7. BIDS AND PURCHASES OVER $100,000 March 2, 2015 C. Accept the Fiscal Year 2014 -2015 Budget Status Report of the General Fund and the Utilities Fund for the four (4) month period ending January 31, 2015. A. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R15 -021 - Approve and authorize the City Manager to execute an amendment to the currently approved Progressive Design Build Contract with CDM Constructors Inc. to reflect a change in the total contract price and duration. The new Guaranteed Maximum Price for the contract is $30,803,124 and the project duration is 16 months from notice to proceed. Mayor Taylor explained the project connects the East and West Water Treatment Plants. Commissioner McCray wanted a presentation if $30 million was being spent. Mr. Groff stressed the project would improve the water quality and move the water from the West to the East, retreat the water and pump it back to the residences. The work includes the ion exchange system, upgrade of the East Water Treatment Plant, upgrade the pump buildings at the East Plant and build a brand new storage tank and transfer pump station that would provide three million gallons of storage in the east grid. It is a guaranteed maximum price of $30,803,124 and all savings go back to the City as components of the project are bid. The completion schedule is approximately 16 months from the notice to proceed that should occur within two weeks. There have been many budget line items that have been budgeted to complete the project. The price is $56,000 Tess than budget. Most of the project would be competitively bid on the open market with additional savings. The ion exchange plant has been moved to the East Plant. Some of the existing buildings and piping will be re -used for savings. It meets the Water Supply Plan through 2030 and maximizes what has already been purchased. It would preserve the value of the real estate at the West Plant. As growth continues the West Plant will need more space. Site security and aesthetics at the East Plant are being improved. The plan meets the environmental objectives of using the water from the west to prevent salt water intrusion into the east wells. There is no contingency on the project because the team spent time to develop a risk register to help avoid any problems and additional expense. If efficiencies can be realized there could be greater savings. There is a website for the project including news about the project, information on the project, call for artist for the public art aspect and a list of job opportunities. The City has other ways to get the information to the public as well. 7 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Vote Commissioner McCray thanked Mr. Groff for informing the public. He inquired if the monies were available and Tim Howard, Director of Finance, replied the financing would be phased in and a bond issued for part of it. The majority of the cost would be financed with the bond and paid for out of utility revenues. It was always the plan, but could not be developed until the guaranteed maximum price was established. There is annual maintenance on all the tanks and they are inspected every five years to avoid any accidental spills or releases. Commissioner McCray recalled the project and plans have been talked about for many years and it was good to see the project come to fruition as it was promised to the citizens. He thanked Mr. Groff for his leadership. Commissioner Fitzpatrick asked when the drilling under 1 -95 would take place. Mr. Groff advised that was a different project. It would go to bid in the next couple weeks. It was an interesting project and people would be invited to watch the drilling. Motion March 2, 2015 Commissioner Merker moved to approve Item 7.A. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. B. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R15 -022 - Approve Agreement piggy- backing the City of Punta Gorda Agreement No. 201010 /Chem - Sulfcont with Evoqua Water Technologies for the purchase of Hydrogen Peroxide through August 21, 2016. The estimated annual expenditure for this chemical is $200,000. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve. Vice Mayor Casello seconded the motion. Vice Mayor Casello inquired how a contract from the west coast was found to be utilized. Mr. Groff indicated the City uses piggybacking for odor control chemicals. The larger utiiities can get better pricing. This contract is 20% Tess than the previous piggyback contract with Manatee County. It will eventually be bid. Vote The motion passed unanimously. C. Approve Change Order #3 for Man Con, Inc for the Central Seacrest Corridor Neighborhood Utility Improvement project in the amount of $182,245.00 for additional sewer main replacement. 8 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Motion 9 March 2, 2015 Commissioner Merker moved for approval. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Commissioner McCray sought information on the location of the project. Mr. Groff displayed a map showing it in the central Seacrest corridor neighborhood improvement project, phase one. It is not sewer replacement that had been addressed previously. A developer was building homes and roots were found to be in the lines when new connections were attempted. It will be less expensive to replace the lines than clean the roots out. It would connect 17 homes on a sewer system that is starting to fail. This would prevent a future problem. There are two sections totaling approximately 800 feet of sewer line. The contractor selected is close to the site and gave the lowest price. Vice Mayor Casello asked if special assessments were charged and Mr. Groff replied there are capitalization fees charged when homes hookup. Vote The motion passed unanimously. 8. CODE COMPLIANCE and LEGAL SETTLEMENTS - None 9. PUBLIC HEARING 7 P.M. OR AS SOON THEREAFTER AS THE AGENDA PERMITS The City Commission will conduct these public hearings in its dual capacity as Local Planning Agency and City Commission. Attorney Cherof administered an oath to all those intending to testify. A brief review of the procedure to be followed was given. Attorney Cherof pointed out one member of the public had raised an issue regarding the re- notice of the requests in accordance with the Code requirements. The City does have an affidavit, as required by the Code, that notifications were not only mailed, but also posted on the property, with pictures of the signs. The document would be made part of the record. Dodi Glas, Certified Land Planner and Certified LEED Professional, representing the owner, K. Hovnanian, was present with Attorney Marty Perry as well as multiple representatives of the project team and from K. Hovnanian, the Architect, Engineer, Marine Consultants and others. Ms. Glas located the proposed site and reviewed the requests of the developer. MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 The site is just less than five acres and there originally was an application for an IPUD that included 78 townhomes, a reduction from the 80 townhomes initially discussed. There were three and four -story townhomes proposed, parking and open space that exceeded the requirements. The new plans are within the project boundaries with some changes. There had been approval in 2009 for a marina on the complex and before that plans for a residential development that failed with the economic landscape. The marina was not built because the market did not exist and it was not a good plan due to permitting issues and the limitations of the site. The developer reviewed the previous plans and looked at the transition between the marina and new residential plans. There was another proposal that trimmed two units to provide a larger buffer area between the townhomes and the single family homes to the south. There have been four meetings with the residents and a multitude of conversations with residents prior to the last meeting and ongoing conversations with adjacent property owners including the commercial property owner. One more conversation was suggested and many things have transpired. There is a concern with drainage throughout the Lakeside Gardens community, specifically along Potter Road next to a previous project and then with the proposed project being built. The developer has agreed to a separate outfall for drainage and to address the drainage on Dimick to facilitate the capital improvement plans for the area. The water system was changed to bring it further south and include an eight inch line into the community along Dimick. There is a hydrant that has to be replaced to provide appropriate service that was agreed to be done to service both communities. Additional guest parking was added to exceed the requirement by 36 %. The Florida Power and Light lines would be buried. All pedestrian access to the community from Lake Side Gardens was removed as requested with additional landscaping. Vehicular access was also eliminated except for emergency access. Transition and compatibility were addressed in terms of architecture and three - tiered landscaping with fence and wall detail. After the last meeting it was agreed to change the plans to include three single - family homes rather than townhomes on the waterfront lots. It started with 80 townhomes and now there will be 69 townhomes added three single - family homes on 50 -foot lots consistent with the property owners to the south. There would be two -story houses on the three Tots. The overall density is less than 15 dwelling units an acre. There were four applications; one for abandonment, another land use amendment, rezoning to include the parcel in the IPUD and the site plan approval. It was argued the three lots should remain as part of Lakeside Garden; however, Ms. Glas argued the three lots should be within the community to maintain the continuity of development. It 10 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 would square off the site which was a common practice with development. The CRA Plan supports the concept of continuity and unity. The same applies to the zoning. The Comprehensive Plan includes the high density residential designation that permits 20 dwelling units per acre as opposed to the 15 dwelling unit density that is proposed for the project. The existing area along the waterfront requires a new seawall with a unified plan to establish the sea wall, replant mangroves and give opportunity for sea grasses to come back into the area with a single dock providing waterfront for the entire community. The open space is one - quarter more than required by Code and one -third more guest parking spaces. The south property line would have a larger setback and maintain a larger buffer. The delineation between the two parcels and the two communities would be more logical with the three single - family homes as part of the new project. The ingress and egress had been reviewed. The amenities, including the boardwalk and bio -swale design, lead out to the docks with connecting common walkways and a pool and cabana to the north. The architecture has varying roof lines and light colored material selections with earth tone accents and colors to create variation within the community. The developer has compromised on the density, types of units, drainage and an outfall. They agreed to no pedestrian and vehicle access to the south and to bury all Florida Power and Light lines. The Comprehensive Plan requirements have been met and the project exceeds the Code requirements. There are benefits beyond the community. Staff recommended approval on the applications because there needs to be consistency. The height transition was considered and the internal design addressed. Derrick Fenick, Vision President for K. Hovnanian Homes, and Certified Licensed General Contractor, advised K. Hovnanian had been building in South Florida since the early 1960s building over 1,000 homes in the City of Boynton Beach. The offices are located in Boynton Beach with 140 jobs and annual payroll of over $12 million. Communities bring business to an area. There will be 200 trade workers on site almost every day for four or five years and then property management companies with over 20 to 30 people to maintain the property for its lifetime. The homes are well built with environmental and energy awareness exceeding Code requirements. A tremendous amount of compromises have been made to meet the concerns of the residents. It is a $44 million project with $2 million revenue and a tax implication for the City and a lasting value for the City of Boynton Beach. Marty Perry, Attorney for the developer, pointed out there was an additional agreement to provide new power lines to the single - family homes on Dimick adjacent to the single - family lots within the project. The changes to the plans would result in a savings of $200,000 to the City of Boynton Beach that will improve the drainage for the residents. 11 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 A series of letters were sent to the residents and Commission on the issue of a marina at the proposed site. He asked they be made part of the record. The developer has made significant strides to address the concerns of the residents. The three single - family homes will be the same size as the existing two single - family homes to the south. There has to be access to the three homes to circulate the traffic through the development so the community's traffic does not go through Lakeside Gardens as the residents agreed. The development was not encroaching into their neighborhood. He requested approval of all applications. Don Groncheck, 7390 Wisteria Avenue in Parkland, representing Monogram Windows and Doors, a contractor for K. Hovnanian, supported the builder as a quality developer. The City goes a long way to address both growth and the tax base. It is a beautiful community. There is a responsibility to embrace economic recovery with the number of jobs on the project, sale of homes, utilities and maintenance for the life of the community. He urged the Commission to vote in favor of the project. Mike McCleary, 2600 Lake Drive, remarked the three lots in question had homes on them and Lakeside Gardens was not encroaching on the new project. The road does serve a purpose as access for the homes along Dimick Road. The abandonment would in effect give the developer the property. All the property on the north of Dimick was single - family homes that were rezoned. The property on the corner of Dimick and US 1 is a commercial property. There have been issues on Lake Drive and Potter Road and the power lines should be buried throughout the area and the water lines fixed. Norman Silverstein, 1364 Via De Pepi in Renaissance Commons, hoped the City of Boynton Beach would continue to grow. The project is an important part of growth. The growth of young people in the community is vital to life of the City. The proposed project will bring those people in. The project is beautiful and the surrounding communities will be very satisfied with it when complete. His main concern is to make sure the City continues its growth with young, vibrant people. Monica DeVoursney, 2625 Lake Drive North, contended smart growth was the objective with a quality project next door. There are only 20 homes in Lakeside Gardens. She questioned why the single - family homes had to be rezoned from R -1 -AA to IPUD. The rezoning of the lots would lower the value of the adjacent homes. Ms. DeVoursney suggested the developer was bullying the City and a decision would be made based on fear. Mayor Taylor remarked he was not afraid of anyone and he would base his decision on what was right for the City of Boynton Beach. Vice Mayor Casello added his decision was never based on fear. It is based on what is best for the City of Boynton Beach and he would not be bullied. He found the remark made about bullying was offensive. 12 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 Commissioner Merker made his decisions on intellect and what is best for the City. The developer had bent over backwards to make it right for everybody and not self - serving. It is a high scale development. The citizens have to realize that compromise is needed. Dan Cling, President of Financial Services for Hovnanian, advised they employ over 100 associates with a payroll over $8 million, having visitors throughout the 20 different states they service. They would be signing a new lease to keep their offices in Boynton Beach. Over 800 rooms have been occupied over the years. They fully support the project and ask the Commission do the same. John Trach, 2623 Lake Drive North, quoted the Charter that ordinances were the law of the City. The rights -of -way should be 50 feet wide. Dimick Road has a 40 foot right -of- way. Ordinances require setbacks should resemble the adjacent development setbacks based on orientation of structures. Dimick has a 25 foot setback and the proposed setback is 18 feet. With the building heights there should be a 32 foot setback. The proposal does not meet the legal standards set by ordinances. Nichole Bueller, 2623 Lake Side North, was concerned about the height of the buildings along Dimick. The developer indicated they would consider two -story buildings. She requested the matter be tabled to continue conversations. Other projects were modified to two -story to be compatible with adjacent neighborhoods. Steve Cohen, with A &N Management, had managed many of K. Hovnanain's properties. The impact of this type of project on a community include the 35 people in full or part time positions that would be necessary to provide service to the property for landscaping, hanging holiday lights, janitorial services and other support personnel for the property. Parking enforcement has been addressed and there are procedures and policies to ensure the property is appropriately managed and parking is not an issue. The interaction of the homeowners and service providers will have a tremendous impact on the economy and the City of Boynton Beach. Mike Mrotek, 2624 Lake Drive North, recalled the original owners had dedicated as public highways to the perpetual use of the public, the roads, avenues and drives as shown on the plat. The roads of the subdivision should remain and be a single - family resident zoned district. Mr. Rotech argued the de facto government was now changing things around. Chris Ciasilli, owner of Gateway Marina, stressed the property being vacant was not a positive thing and leaves unlimited access along the seawall 24 hours a day, seven days a week. He supported the project because it would make his marina safer and 200 customers' property safe. Brian Smith, with Heritage Flooring, employs 90 people, 500 subcontractors and works for K. Hovnanian Homes, one of the finest home builders in South Florida. They have stringent regard for safety on the job site and is a very high - quality builder. Mr. Smith 13 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 would benefit from the project obviously, but he still had to bid for the work. He hoped the project would pass and come to fruition in the future. Josh Evans, Attorney representing Lakeside Gardens residents, indicated there had been many meetings between the residents and developer. The gates were not a compromise of the developer, rather the direction of City staff. Both sides agreed the gate should be removed and it was removed. Several of the other changes are really not compromises. Everyone agrees K. Hovnanian is a quality builder; however, the proposed project is not good for the City of Boynton Beach. There will be too much building on too little space. There are less units but they are now all three and four bedroom units. There is no more space for parking. If approved, the project will cost the residents. The application has not been fully examined. There is a criteria that has to be met, to demonstrate the need to change the proposed land use. Data and analysis has not been provided showing the property values would increase. There has to be a pattern to the zoning and not an isolated zoning district or land use classification not related to adjacent properties or constitute a special privilege to an individual property owner in contrast to the good of public welfare. The project will hurt their home values much more than the benefit to the applicant. Staff perceived no negative impact on property values without necessary research. The application has to be examined and criteria met. The application before the Planning and Zoning Board that included the townhomes where the 50 -foot lot homes are now planned, was voted down 6 -1. In another instance it was voted down 5 -2. The Planning and Zoning Board listened to the residents about parking, a major issue. There are 16 parking spaces to service 69 townhomes and they are all three - bedroom and four - bedroom homes. Ms. Glas responded there are two and three bedrooms, no four bedrooms. Mr. Evans argued the parking issue had been disregarded. Mr. Evans was not sure of the reason for the reconsideration. The application failed at Planning and Zoning and initially before the Commission and should have been brought back to the Planning and Zoning Board. He asserted the parties should meet again. He was not invited to a meeting held after the last Commission meeting. His notice of the hearing was from one of the residents. The notice to the residents of a meeting was not properly given. It was understood the status quo has to change and Commissioners are elected to steer the change. The Lakeside Gardens residents want their arguments to be heard. They are not totally against the project, rather willing to compromise, but they want the land deeded as Lakeside Gardens and stay as single - family homes. The Commission has the power to protect the City and residents of Lakeside Gardens. Jim Goldasetch, President of Goldasetch and Associates, and a consultant for the project, wanted to mention the instructions they were given to make the design work for 14 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 the project the most environmentally sensitive project possible, locate the grasses and avoid any impact. The slips and docks are further out and there is no dredging through sea grasses. The goal was for the maximum for the project. It was an enlightened position for a developer. Dan Goldberg, USI Construction Services, 832 East View Avenue, Delray, is a structural contractor for K. Hovnanian and employs 100 people out of their Boynton Beach location with several hundrede sub - contractors on a daily basis. He has had a positive work experience with the developer and compromises have been made by both sides. Mery MacDonald, one of the four original partners to buy the property in 2006, had sought and received financing to develop the property. Without the zoning and the price paid, the bank called the loan. There were two appraisals at $5.4 million and the other was $16,210,000 in 2009. We had to pay off the loan or pay down the loan or go after a marina. More money was needed for a marina venture and no one supported the marina concept including staff. The concept was too large and too tall. They attempted to market the property as a marina to no avail, nationally or world -wide. A marina on the site would devalue all the adjoining properties. Ken Depew, Ridgeway Plumbing, 640 Industrial Avenue, works for K. Hovnanian and other national and local builders. The project is seen as an opportunity to get the economic downturn turned around and moving forward. It will make the whole City a better place. Robert L. Moore, with Attorney Jason Evans, a consultant for the residents and Planning Director for the town of Palm Beach, made two observations. He recommended the subdivision stay in place and keep the single - family residences part of the subdivision. There is a good builder and developer and planner involved. He did question the number of bedrooms in the units. Denise Ciasulli, thought the avenue for compromise and listening was open and the height questions and roadways could be further discussed. Ms. Glas clarified there are 48 owners who were provided first -class mail and public notice throughout the process for the one -on -one resident meetings and for the notice of the public hearing as required. There was also discussion on the two -story issue and homes built on the lots would be two story. The roadway as originally dedicated was for use of the subdivision as platted. It would no longer be platted in that way. Originally there were a multitude of lots within the subdivision and the parcel would change. The consistency of land use pattern was noted for the record. There had been a four - bedroom issue and looking at four -story units which is no longer on the table. One of the conditions of approval would be that the plans be updated accordingly. 15 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 The regulations of the IPUD allow a height of 45 feet and the proposed plans are within that limit. The IPUD does allow for design considerations which there are some and other things done for public benefit. Due diligence was done to make the project consistent with the CRA direction and Comprehensive Plan. There is a demonstration of need created in the strategies with the plans to have more high -end residential in the community. There were comments on the parking that have been addressed. The developer has tried to compromise and address the larger picture with a project that is consistent with the existing strategies. Mr. Perry stressed the problems with drainage have been long standing. The drainage has to be retained on site and all current requirements have to be met. The grade elevation would be six feet higher than the existing sites requiring the wall to be built. Any new home would require a first floor elevation of seven or eight feet resulting in a height of 35 to 38 feet. Current requirements dictate a higher elevation for the floor level. Mr. Perry contended there has been little or no give or take by the residents. Along the waterfront there are some expensive homes. The starting prices in the new development will be higher than the existing values of those homes in Lakeside Gardens, not on the waterfront. Mr. Perry pointed out the three 50 -foot lots were originally six 25 -foot lots so the area has already changed. Single- family homes would be built on the lots and they would be limited to two -story that could be a condition of approval, unless further approval of the Commission is sought. Mr. Perry again requested the Commission's favorable consideration. Mayor Taylor had heard from the residents on several occasions, the developer and driven through the area. The project does conform to the Comprehensive Plan, CRA Plan along Federal Highway and complies with all Code requirements. The drainage issue is being addressed and the outfall would help the neighborhood as would the new hydrant and underground Florida Power & Light lines. There was agreement to eliminate the gates and landscaping would be more than required and the sidewalk eliminated. Parking and density were addressed and the request for single - family homes was agreed upon. The road that serviced the three homes on the end were not part of the neighborhood when the lots were sold. It was not part of Lakeside Gardens. Whoever owns it has the right to build on the site. There would be no reason to keep the extension of the street. As far as property values, the houses inside Lakeside Gardens are generally valued at around $200,000 away from the waterfront. One house is valued at only $68,000. The new development is starting at $300,000. Staff determined that the required setbacks were met. 16 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 Every time a demand was met by the developer another concern was voiced. The development is extremely valuable to the City and a tremendous asset. Several realtors had expressed how important the project was to the community. Job creation is another plus. Some residents will be disappointed. The developer has worked hard to accommodate the adjacent property owners and he would support the project. Commissioner Merker concurred with Mayor Taylor. Compromises have been made and home values will only increase. It is a positive with a high -level development. Commissioner McCray thanked everyone for all the input. He was concerned about the lobbyist for the City being on the team for the developer. He wondered if documentation of the notice had been filed with the City. He represented the citizens and his vote would be for the citizens. Commissioner Fitzpatrick recalled there had been a motion to table. He asked if there was a specific list of outstanding issues from the residents to be discussed in the next two weeks. Mr. Evans replied there could be a list asking the developer to build more single - family homes. He thought all the possibilities had not been vetted. Commissioner Fitzpatrick summarized the issues were rezoning, setbacks and heights. Mike Rumpf, Planning and Zoning Director, referred to the footnotes to explain the setbacks. It is a planned district with flexibility. Land patterns in the coastal areas vary significantly. One regulation on setbacks would not fit all situations. The intent is a border -on- border circumstance with different setbacks along roadways. The buildings are required to be front in appearance so the neighborhood did not look at the back of the buildings or balconies. Staff has pushed for greater setbacks in that area where the projects are in closer proximity. Mr. Rumpf stressed the setbacks are not in violation of the Code. On the issue of height, Mr. Rumpf responded the buildings could be four story. With regard to the platting of roadways, Attorney Cherof advised the rights had expired and do not revert to anybody. If the same property owner owns both sides, the rights merge together. Commissioner Fitzpatrick questioned if the plans for single - family homes could be changed. Mr. Rumpf responded the challenge would be with the development order being changed by motion. The applicant would have to come back to the Commission and ask to amend any variation from the development order. Vice Mayor Casello asked if R -1 -AA zoning could be incorporated into an IPUD. Mr. Rumpf replied it could be allowed under the non - conforming provisions or the current standards would have to be met and that would not allow the three homes to be built. Both single- family homes and townhomes are allowed in the IPUD. Attorney Cherof asked if the applicant would agree, as a condition of approval, that the homes would be built as homes built in R -1 -AA. Ms. Glas advised the developer had agreed and addressed it with staff. Post approval and before second reading they 17 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 would submit plans accordingly that would identify the issues. Mr. Perry interjected the developer would be willing to record a deed restriction on the three lots indicating they can only be built as single - family homes and the only release of the deed restriction would be through City Commission approval. Attorney Cherof advised the restriction was characterized as more than a condition of approval. Commissioner Fitzpatrick asked if the lots could be 50 feet as previously required in R- 1-AA or would they be 60 feet in accordance with the current regulations. Mr. Rumpf advised it would be 50 feet. Commissioner Fitzpatrick had decided having the road cutoff would be the best compromise because to swing around there would have to be a second road and create a waste of space. He believed property owners on Dimick Road should have access to Dimick Road. He agreed the road only be an emergency exit and incorporating the three lots. Vice Mayor Casello sought clarification that with setbacks, each project is viewed on an individual basis. Attorney Cherof clarified that applied only to certain zoning districts. Vice Mayor Casello referred to the Comprehensive Plan relating to changes in high density. Mr. Rumpf explained the decision could not be based on that little square brought into the project to square up the boundaries. Staff had previously been accused of not doing their job of reviewing the criteria in the Code. The greater percentage of the project already has the zoning and land use for the project. The criteria is being used that is written for significantly larger projects potentially having greater impact on adjoining properties, both positive and negative. The property values for the entire area had to be assessed and not the small area of those three lots. Other properties were evaluated since the situation is very common. Vice Mayor Casello felt confident staff would not be accused of not doing their job. Vice Mayor Casello had previously mentioned the Commission should think outside the box and build a marina. There is a host of reasons why a marina would not be viable. He requested the reconsideration and he heard the concerns and felt the quality of life and neighborhoods should be kept intact. He supported smart development. If the lots remain as single - family homes he would agree to abandon the road that would serve no purpose to the neighborhood. The project would add value to the area. Adding a few parking spaces will not solve the problems and it will remain an issue. He would support the project as it is best for the entire City with the best possible compromise. As far as the lobbyist issue, he played no part in the development. The developer did not bully anyone. Commissioner Merker heard Mr. Perry change an oral contract to a written contract. It is a done deal. Mayor Taylor agreed it would be part of the conditions of approval. Mr. Perry was authorized to deed restrict the three lots. 18 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA A. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 14 -031 - FIRST READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve abandonment of a portion of North Lake Drive bounded on the south by Dimick Road and Lot 1 of the Hulls Subdivision to the north. The subject right - of -way to be abandoned is 40 feet wide and extends a distance of 135 feet; containing 5,402 square feet (0.1240 acres). Applicant: Dodi Buckmaster Glas of Gentile Glas Halloway O'Mahoney & Associates, Inc., agent for the property owner, K. Hovnanian T & C Homes at Florida, LLC Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 14 -031 by title only on first reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 14 -031. Commissioner Fitzpatrick seconded the motion. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the role. The vote was 4 -1 (Commissioner McCray dissenting). B. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 14 -032 - FIRST READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve Casa Del Mar Future Land Use Map amendment (LUAR 14 -001) from Low Density Residential (LDR) to Special High Density Residential (SHDR). Applicant: Dodi Buckmaster Glas, Gentile Glas Holloway O'Mahoney and Associates, Inc. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 14 -032 by title only on first reading. Motion Vice Mayor Casello moved to approve Ordinance No. 14 -032. Commissioner Fitzpatrick seconded the motion with the stipulations noted earlier. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the role. The vote was 4 -1 (Commissioner McCray dissenting). C. Approve a New Master Plan /Site Plan (NWSP 14 -004) to allow construction of 80 fee - simple townhome units (Casa del Mar on the Intracoastal IPUD) at a density of 16.65 dwelling units per acre, a waterfront amenity area, and related site improvements on 4.8 acres located on the east side of Federal Highway, north of Dimick Road and south of the Peninsula IPUD. Agent: Dodi Buckmaster Glas with Gentile Glas Holloway O'Mahoney & Associates, Inc (2GHO) on behalf of Applicant/Owner K. Hovnanian T & C Homes at Florida LLC. 19 March 2, 2015 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA (This item was addressed after Item E.) Attorney Cherof read the request changing it to construction of 69 fee - simple townhome units and three single - family units. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve the new site plan. Vice Mayor Casello seconded the motion. Vote The motion passed 4 -1 (Commissioner McCray dissenting). D. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 14 -033 - FIRST READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve Casa Del Mar rezoning (LUAR 14 -001) from R -1 -AA (Single - Family Residential District to an IPUD (Infill Planned Unit Development) with a Master Plan for a townhouse development. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 14 -033 by title only on first reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 14 -033. Commissioner Fitzpatrick seconded the motion. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the role. The vote was 4 -1 (Commissioner McCray dissenting). E. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 14 -034 - FIRST READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve Casa Del Mar rezoning (REZN 14 -005) from an IPUD (Infill Planned Unit Development) with a Master Plan for a marina use to an IPUD with a Master Plan for a townhouse development. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 14 -034 by title only on first reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 14 -034. Commissioner Fitzpatrick seconded the motion. 20 March 2, 2015 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA March 2, 2015 Commissioner Fitzpatrick heard the Ordinance was for 80 units. Attorney Cherof explained the body of the Ordinance would reflect the change on second reading. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the role. The vote was 4 -1 (Commissioner McCray dissenting). 10. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT - None 11. UNFINISHED BUSINESS A. Reconsideration requested by Commissioner Fitzpatrick - PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R15 -019 - Approve acceptance of Lake Ida Deed from Palm Beach County. Motion Commissioner Fitzpatrick moved to reconsider Proposed Resolution No. R15 -019. Vice Mayor Casello seconded the motion. Vote The motion filed 2 -3 (Mayor Taylor and Commissioners Merker and McCray dissenting). 12. NEW BUSINESS A. Discuss process by which upcoming vacancy on the CRA Board shall be filled. Commissioner Merker recalled Mark Karageorge had to resign from the position and it was filled by Woodrow Hay for the remainder of the time. Two new applicants have filed applications. Commissioner Merker contended a timeline should be set to accept applications. One candidate already spoke, James DeVoursney, and Linda Cross applied. Commissioner Merker suggested the deadline be March 10 with a decision to be made on March 17th. Vice Mayor Casello asked if there were required time periods to fill the vacancy. Attorney Cherof advised there was flexibility. There is no specific deadline. All vacancies should be filled as soon as you can fill them on any board. The term expires the end of the March. Vice Mayor Casello opined it was not a pressing issue and more time should be allotted and not rush it through. Commissioner Merker disagreed, it was urgent. Vice Mayor Casello did not feel a week or two would be a problem. Mayor Taylor said two weeks would be the 14 and a decision could be made on the 17 21 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 13. LEGAL March 2, 2015 A. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15- 002 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve amendments to the Land Development Regulations, including amendments to the Definitions, Zoning Use Matrix, and corresponding Use Matrix Notes to establish a new use titled Medical Care or Testing (In- Patient) to allow medical uses that provide 24 -hour services or treatment. (TABLED ON 2/17/15) B. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -003 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve amendments to the Mobile Vending Unit regulations of the Land Development Regulations, Part III - Chapter 1, Article 11; Chapter 2, Article II; Chapter 3, Article V; Table 2 -1 Applications by City Departments; and Table 3 -28 Use Matrix (STAFF RECOMMENDS TABLING UNTIL MARCH 17,2015) C. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -004 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve amendments to the Land Development Regulations to decrease parking standards for hotels to more closely match actual demand, which minimizes construction of unnecessary parking areas, reduces impervious surfaces, and lowers project costs. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15 -004 by title only, on second reading. Motion Commissioner McCray moved to approve Ordinance 15 -004. Vice Mayor Casello seconded the motion. Vice Mayor Casello inquired if there were any pending projects that would be affected by the changes. Mr. Rumpf indicated the Marriot project would be eligible for the new standard and was being reviewed. The parking standards are being tailored to a specific project to eliminate a surplus of parking spaces. It would benefit the project. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the role. The vote was 5 -0. D. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -005 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve amendments to the Land Development Regulations to allow sign standards to be based on the commercial use within the M -1 Zoning District, and to increase flexibility for modifying a nonconforming sign at a shopping center to promote economic development and aesthetics. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15.005 by title only, on second reading. 22 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Motion March 2, 2015 Commissioner McCray moved to approve Ordinance No. 15 -005. Vice Mayor Casello seconded the motion. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the roll. The vote was 5 -0. E. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -006 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve amendments to the Land Development Regulations to support the continued implementation of the Downtown Transit Oriented Development (TOD) overlay standards, including provisions for a 25% density bonus for selected future land use classifications. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15.006 by title only, on second reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 15 -006. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Vice Mayor Casello asked if there was a plan to conform to evacuation times and routes. Hanna Matras, Senior Planner, advised the City did not have a model nor did anyone else. The plans are submitted to the County and they have no objection. The City gives the residents east of 1 -95 16 hours to go to shelters. An analysis had been done and it was determined 16 hours was enough time. The State found it met the statutory requirements. The Department of Transportation did not comment. Mayor Taylor inquired if anyone wanted to comment on any of the Ordinances read and no one came forward. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the roll. The vote was 5 -0. F. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -007 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING - Approve Ordinance creating Boynton Beach's Civil Rights Act. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15 -007 by title only, on second reading. 23 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Motion Vote March 2, 2015 Commissioner McCray moved to approve the Ordinance. Commissioner Merker seconded the motion. Commissioner Fitzpatrick recalled an email questioning the language in the Ordinance. Attorney Cherof explained the revised agenda cover sheet was carried over to this meeting. The corrected cover sheet is now online and explains the purpose of the Ordinance. The Ordinance was amended to delete one word from the name of the Organization. Mayor Taylor opened the issue for public comment and no one came forward. Mayor Taylor commented he had voted in favor of the Ordinance on first reading based on an explanation of the changes by Attorney Cherof. Mr. Hoch then emailed everyone claiming my intelligence was biased and discriminatory. Mayor Taylor would now vote no. City Clerk Prainito called the roll. The vote was 4 -1 (Mayor Taylor dissenting). G. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -008 - SECOND READING - PUBLIC HEARING: 1) Amend Section 18 -55 - Definition of Annual Earnings to clarify the exclusions of pay per Florida Statutes 112.66(11); and 2) Amend Section 18 -82 - Re- Employment to allow for the purchase of prior city service on a full actuarial basis after one year of reemployment by the City. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15 -008 by title only, on second reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 15 -008. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Mayor Taylor opened the issue for Public Hearing. No one came forward. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the roll. The vote was 5 -0. H. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -009 - FIRST READING - Approve amendments to Part II, Chapter 2, Article XII, Section 2- 136(b) of the Code of 24 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Ordinances entitled "Establishment of Public Art Fee" to include an additional exemption for normal routine maintenance items. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15 -009 by title only, on first reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 15 -009. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the roll. The vote was 5 -0. March 2, 2015 I. PROPOSED ORDINANCE NO. 15 -010 - FIRST READING - Approve Amendment to the Boynton Beach Code of Ordinances deleting Chapter 2, Article XVIII abolishing the Financial Advisory Committee. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Ordinance No. 15 -010 by title only, on second reading. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Ordinance No. 15 -010. Vice Mayor Casello seconded the motion. Vote City Clerk Prainito called the roll. The vote was 5 -0. J. PROPOSED RESOLUTION NO. R15 -023 - Authorize the City Manager to sign a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with Pelican Point at Boynton Beach Condominium Association, Inc. for the payment of delinquent utility charges owed to the City by the Association and provide for a payment plan. Attorney Cherof read Proposed Resolution No. R15 -023 and asked it be approved with the additional condition that the City Manager not sign the Memorandum of Understanding until the appropriate lien would be recorded if there were a default. Motion Commissioner Merker moved to approve Resolution R15 -023. Commissioner McCray seconded the motion. 25 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Vice Mayor Casello recalled there had been a prior agreement that Pelican Point did not uphold. Ms. LaVerriere explained in 2013 a payment plan was approved and it was not upheld. Ira Libanoff, 150 S. Pine Island Road, Plantation, counsel for Pelican Point Condominium Association, was not involved in the previous agreement. In relation to this agreement, there are additional provisions in the MOU that was negotiated and agreement was reached with staff. The City will have a lien to secure its position with respect to the agreed amounts and will be paid by the association along with other conditions. Vote The motion passed unanimously. March 2, 2015 K. Pursuant to Section 286.011(8), Florida Statutes, Attorney Cherof is requesting a private attorney client session of the City Commission to discuss pending litigation in the following case: 1. William Patterson, Plaintiff vs. The City of Boynton Beach, a Florida Municipal Corporation, Defendant - In the Circuit Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, In and For Palm Beach County, Florida Case No. 50 2014CA005149XXXXMB AF Attorney Cherof advised Items K and M could be held back -to -back taking about 45 minutes for one and 30 for the other. There was agreement to meet at 5:30 p.m. on March 17 for the closed -door sessions. L. Consider options for future administration and maintenance of the Quantum Park Overlay Dependent District including the following: 1. Continue current operations whereby future administrative actions and vision of the District are overseen by the existing Board of Supervisors and their elected successors. 2. Remove and reappoint the Board of Supervisors thus injecting new leadership and vision. 3. Dissolve the Quantum Park Overlay Dependent District and assume all debt and common ground maintenance. (STAFF REQUESTS ITEM TO BE TABLED UNTIL MARCH 2, 2015) M. Pursuant to Section 286.011(8), Florida Statutes, Attorney Cherof is requesting a private attorney /client session of the City Commission to discuss pending litigation in the following case: 1. C.M., Plaintiff vs. CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH and STEPHEN JAMES MAIORINO, Defendants — Case No. 2014CA013942 Division AN 14. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS A. Appoint members of the City Commission to serve on the Palm Beach County League of Cities, Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO), Coalition of 26 MEETING MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA Boynton West Residents Association (COBWRA) and the Countywide Intergovernmental Coordination Program - April 7, 2015 B. Discussion of appointment of Vice -Mayor - 3/17/15 15. ADJOURNMENT There being nothing further to bring before the Commission, Mayor Taylor properly adjourned the meeting at 9:57 p.m. ATTEST: y n. Pkri, et M. Prainito, MMC City Clerk 2 /dith A. Pyle, CM,( eputy City CIerWN /1 David 27 March 2, 2015 CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH Casello, Vice Mayor -11\ sioner ack McCray, Commissioner c ; Commissioner Michael M. Fitzpat PROJECT NAME: Casa del Mar on the Intracoastal (NWSP 14 -004) AGENT: Dodi Buckmaster Glas, Gentile Glas Holloway O'Mahoney AGENT'S ADDRESS: 1907 Commerce Lane, Suite 101, Jupiter, FL 33458 DATE OF HEARING RATIFICATION BEFORE CITY COMMISSION: March 2, 2015 APPROVAL SOUGHT: DEVELOPM ORDER OF THE CITY COMMISCIN OF THE CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORID New Master Plan /New Site Plan for 69 townhomes and 3 single family lots at the southeast corner of the property, and related site improvements on 4.8 acres zoned IPUD. LOCATION OF PROPERTY: 2632 N Federal Highway, 2626 and 2637 N Lake Drive Development Building Engineering Deputy City C lerk • s s DRAWING(S): SEE EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHED HERETO. THIS MATTER was presented to the City Commission of the City of Boynton Beach, Florida on the date of hearing stated above. The City Commission having considered the approval sought by the applicant and heard testimony from the applicant, members of city administrative staff and the public finds as follows: 1. Application for the approval sought was made by the Applicant in a manner consistent with the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations. 2. The Applica VAS HAS NOT established by substantial competent evidence a basis for the approval requested. 3. The conditions for development requested by the Applicant, administrative staff, or suggested by the public and supported by substantial competent evidence are as set forth on Exhibit "C" with notation "Included." 4. The Applicas request is hereby GRANTED subject to the conditions referenced in paragraph 3 above. DENIED 5. This Order shall take effect immediately upon issuance by the City Clerk. 6. All further development on the property shall be made in accordance with the terms and conditions of this order. 7 Other: DATED: .3 - c90 - O City Clerk S: \Planning \SHARED \WP \PROJECTS \Casa del Mar \Casa Del Mar 2014 \NWSP 14 -004 \Final Development Order 3- 2- 15.doc EXHIBIT "A" CASA DEL MAR SITE LOCATION MAP FINAL MASTER PLAN/SITE PLAN Casa Del Mar on the Intracoastal CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA jjjjfiiH CCLCCFGE= Lil 0 Lu - . m -OJ1fl - Cij C.INNNN,,n,MMEn Q Q 4 . Q Q. 4 .1 Q . 7 t l (II W 11 I II IV III N 01 1 011 TvINIMIFIA, • 11 \ 11 S. Illf N SII S'INIMII III SiW011 NVINVA011 )1 tl,I 1 S IVIla I —1 < H . n ` .-1-/ 7. F--< Ce Lil 0 Lu - . m -OJ1fl - Cij C.INNNN,,n,MMEn Q Q 4 . Q Q. 4 .1 Q . 7 t l "1914 w , ..0101rH)VAINOINA.1 , 51 aC°Od JO ♦u5I34 NHJN Ol dOOl3 15IN.i WOC3 C S: 1491314ON11,Og ,,- A A IILDING CAL 0 , & it-IDraj 114.4oN GENERAL NOTE w , ..0101rH)VAINOINA.1 , 51 B110, , :lisns,3#0 , T".mIlmi SIIA1011 NVINVA011 . )1 1101.;1liCHN101 it-IDraj 114.4oN GENERAL NOTE 1 b (J121011 'FI TV NO1 \ 1k'51 I\ F' I ICI N 1. 1 �;I1NI1S 9a�sa 1 \IUIII141 51WOH NYINVAOH 'N bJ I ;1LYJ11 \.NOI sw� 1€101 60161 wow Num mom nwnnnni iiflll nmu LL _ HID II II MUM z 1- F z H z a cc 0 0 LL 0 0 0 0_ 0 0 U- 0 Cs! U.1 0 1 11 Covered Deck Covered Deck . Covered Deck Covered Deck Covered Deck I 1 ,__, Great Room Great Room Great Room Great Room ,____, Great Room mil 1.1111111 a% III .1111111 Amu= 0 ___ Ammo g4 ,-,-,. numil UM 1 immill i m t Emma i ;I ', 1), 1111111M •"" 11111111111 MI =nom 1 1 mum I Emma \et mmuun • xi Fl rE re • slums I IP 111111E! IIIII IIIIIIMIN i I-11 111 dilli Kitchen _ II 4 1, - i ii te f : _---_, .. - NIL 1 110 ,..,•-,11m- .... . .., ,.., L - J M.t. aii ii . I — --- 4 . 4 4 6E.,: UNIT A-1 END UNIT A UNIT A UNIT A-1 UNIT A-1 END VCIITA.)1-1 NOI NI kOSI WV TI(] VV 1 [NHS 9# N 5# C' A1(111141 SIJO/OH NVINVAOH •1 SI- PL SUB 10/7/ . lo_i C101011N.NC I 0_ 0 0 U- 0 Cs! U.1 0 1 11 Covered Deck Covered Deck . Covered Deck Covered Deck Covered Deck I 1 ,__, Great Room Great Room Great Room Great Room ,____, Great Room mil 1.1111111 a% III .1111111 Amu= 0 ___ Ammo g4 ,-,-,. numil UM 1 immill i m t Emma i ;I ', 1), 1111111M •"" 11111111111 MI =nom 1 1 mum I Emma \et mmuun • xi Fl rE re • slums I IP 111111E! IIIII IIIIIIMIN i I-11 111 dilli Kitchen _ II 4 1, - i ii te f : _---_, .. - NIL 1 110 ,..,•-,11m- .... . .., ,.., L - J M.t. aii ii . I — --- 4 . 4 4 6E.,: UNIT A-1 END UNIT A UNIT A UNIT A-1 UNIT A-1 END V(11110 li 19 NO IN11011 I \1\ 11(1 tibr 11115 ,/# 5# 0101 I NVINV VOI 1 )1 1101 IL \I L1J LU ommoun.,, 44 01:11X 1 4 . 01111111 01 NM 101 1111111111■1■1■111111111111111 i Jj . I ill, 1011 . IIMM :JEN -,- M1 =IIM SEM 'LW' I =MIME ! =SE MEM Erg MM 0 1 S [ II .-: igam =MN= Mall imi• m 5 '. Z 0 CD NM — --- I ' I 1 -z• . ,... ___, __,J -11 m• - • ... o W11411*. 1.11.102 11 III , , r2 , W4IM =Zip CO _ ....._ _ , -1M.LIMIW__ 1 ' nrnnn-1 1 4 II 1 111111 1 I: i 2 7IFR „, III II 1111 1 I 0 - = 111 *g 0 I-- II 1 111111 1 II > a 111;11111011 8 uuuuu, I a 1 . ...— ._ 1 , it [ f ' ', ,,,, r .= MN .■ Ca ° %W . 4 t ( 1 NI ) r . ___, 1 .. 0 ll En ti rip m 7 0 ...... - .... pr 0 0 0 LUIJUJIM 0 O 1 0 0 0 0 / 2 1 11111111111101111■1111111111111111.1111111111111111111.11/11111111111.11.11111 r:1 0 4 4 11 0 0 ( \r(11110 I] 1, b II Nij Llsi TIVIN 110 INF1 S# )N10111'113 S1W011 NVIKV1011'>1 NCH CJINOHN2A01 z 0 1- (r) z z z w z 0 co re 0 0 LL 0 0 uJ z z z 0 z z 0 z 0 0 u_ -J z orIC cc u.) 0 1i 0 0 lL 0 a Z " 0 zt- 0 w co 8 b1_11110 U 1 - 1 1135.01 5.lit1 11 bib 11CIb5'b ■11 \115 V #\ 5# )VIC] 111111 gWOH NVINVAOH �{ NO 1 C'1lVJH 5-510 L11- -- PEI 0 ` EMINFEll MAO N k _ 1.�1 t......,. iHiHHH#ItH • _- \ II • t-' N. EE Es p CO ;Nom mmil EP= Mom O _ [O a mm MIMI MN :: o.: m:....: o.:. re ..::1...:.H..:....m..:..m.: cmin.m..:r.:.:lmtm: 1numin:1. :1 :...: m .::: uve:....m:..: _+. .m ce 0 0 J LL 0 0 U Z .tt )pen Patio Trellis I . um .. t ....1 . a o 2 7, , ow L' :541::: — - iti 11 till it it( 114 mr) 11 LI U U 1 M ttlungim H in Inemaimmn=lanunimi: a is oCEI a MB Xllet3 jle: infl EEC= EWEN EINEM = mimmil MN MI MI 11 NE nu anum#30 a nacm#######::::::#####mt######=1111 #1#1= i mg.. MEI 4j— I Imo I LIU U , WWI MIMI 111■74! `1, Alb■ arTINiumminvimmanimmainann #:#############:num (1121011 11 ia NO I 1 110 NI s'S Ill 'S• S# AIC1 11119 IMOH NVINVAOH . )1 cj ce 0 1— 0 CC 0 LJ I— CC 0 U- •— < 1— Z BUILDING 5 AND 6 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS UNIT A1 FOURTH FLOOR LOFT =GM= . :ii :•• ---=-- imumi:::=11::ii=1::ZO ff: i: :Ilan Di niminnialimi: maiRE:imITF:11a1—. . ii 11 , SAWOH NVINVAOH '>I ral.,,,,,,: sr 1 am= In= NM= =EN hmil f mim min ........ — II . , —_, ,,,, a . . 4) rellaill . 2.). 8 -:5 g EZ 0 0 „ • . . ‘-, 1 , .. 1 ......E.....,......t. 1. ......................o m...,....................: 0 0 u_ Z o cr) 71: th. „grze F T11111 ZS 401 2 iffielr IIIIIIIIIII 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 mommuiliiis% i 1 1111111111 1 . 1 11 . ___,, ....,, ..,, ._ .,- .,, .._ ..., r' -- uIIIIIIlIIJuIIIIIIII Unnumnin ii,,, .■'. ,.. ! r _ *, do ., .. tom ., 1 1 s s rlp !I , ti c ;,..J1 AL ' - ,S - f . . d • . C 1 0 CL i ,...,,, I� Ii fa.' il — 1 Arnaswilmmi ..' . -0, il .' - limi'li4.1111MMIENtill=111111Mi ,.. ::::::::::::::::::::::::,,,:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::,,:::::::::::::::::::;;;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.:::::::, 0 0 CIRLIII 'H A Al NO I 1 IlVls: 11(1 VW , 5# , '),N11(1 MIN SAWOH NVINVAOH '>I 0 0 u_ Z o cr) 71: th. „grze F T11111 ZS 401 2 iffielr IIIIIIIIIII 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 mommuiliiis% i 1 1111111111 1 . 1 11 . ___,, ....,, ..,, ._ .,- .,, .._ ..., r' -- uIIIIIIlIIJuIIIIIIII Unnumnin ii,,, .■'. ,.. ! r _ *, do ., .. tom ., 1 1 s s rlp !I , ti c ;,..J1 AL ' - ,S - f . . d • . C 1 0 CL i ,...,,, I� Ii fa.' il — 1 Arnaswilmmi ..' . -0, il .' - limi'li4.1111MMIENtill=111111Mi ,.. ::::::::::::::::::::::::,,,:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::,,:::::::::::::::::::;;;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.:::::::, 0 0 I t IlIIIl III n { { { r=r W V no ,-. \,. 1 `I Inn SAWN NVINVIOH'1 mol jp _-'I N0A L �� �� III ::: x: a::: i ,,, f^ wa III i::: r.::: c: a::: a::: n::: c; x:: a::: r::: c: a::: a::: e:: a:: a::: a::: r. ::a:a':::e:x:::c:::::::es::a: Y�I 'O O N m O J I - 1 W V no ,-. \,. 1 ;I1NI1 s, air s; sa ci.I(1 Inn SAWN NVINVIOH'1 mol jp _-'I N0A L ::: x: a::: i ,,, , LL ir ti �d� J h wa III i::: r.::: c: a::: a::: n::: c; x:: a::: r::: c: a::: a::: e:: a:: a::: a::: r. ::a:a':::e:x:::c:::::::es::a: Y�I :110111111 IIIILII! *: 1 z LO >- ct 0 U) 0 CO 0 LO Z CD Z 0 m k'CI1110 li'11 l\ ill Nk. 1x1 ll W V no ,-. \,. 1 ;I1NI1 s, air s; sa ci.I(1 SAWN NVINVIOH'1 mol jp _-'I N0A L :110111111 IIIILII! *: 1 z LO >- ct 0 U) 0 CO 0 LO Z CD Z 0 m X1:::::7::11:. s........I::IlIP:1111 111:111111: 1111:: .:$:1::::: V III : Iut:::.:::::: :17NII::Itll_::::::::::::::111' *p Q 11111111°. i t MS I. I i Ma LL MINI c d _ 111111 aa os EIN :::::::::::111:::111:: U """"" " tti III:It:::I:NI:IINIII:• P1 0 0 Z = 0 0 r 0 o - S u N 0 0 0 0) 0 co Z 0 S 0 ze 11 -, 11 .. \ ��J IVIV 1U V Y i'`A SIt ,1\l(1 1 NVINVAOH')I et 0 0 7t" C Q =1E,711 mem mem Main • co 'Imam mom C as § ao ,. 0 . - - o "fir illiMill �C�' L4111P= mil : I::::....NI: II:... 7,:: II: I: I::::: 1:::: II:: 1:::: I::: I::: I:I II I:::I:::I::::tl::::::l:::l::::l NI::R :: 1:::: 1::: I:::: I:::I::::I::III:::I:::l::::l::: III ::1:::1::::1:::1::1:1:::1::::1: II ::I:'. b C112101111 W {y NO NN.I 2Ibl• 11(1 b N - ) l \I1 5 ■ of \ S# )NIU 111111 SJWOH NVINV \CH 'N 110i' 1 BUILDING 5 AND 6 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR BEDROOM OPTION UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR LOFT I �, l�u111II III nnnn III II II III II 43e8 li� _ = =� I:II_� _ Afl 11111111111111111m1111 IIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I' - � r .�on= =1= = = mum= 111111111111111111 IIIIIIIIIIII1101111111111111IIIIIIIIi? nnnn Ili i! m= .= 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111lii J III I IIIIIIIIIII-3 b C112101111 W {y NO NN.I 2Ibl• 11(1 b N - ) l \I1 5 ■ of \ S# )NIU 111111 SJWOH NVINV \CH 'N 110i' 1 BUILDING 5 AND 6 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR BEDROOM OPTION UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR LOFT -- III �'� I:II_� If111111I1II1II 11111111111111111m1111 IIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I' - � ` `` nnnn II III _111111111iIII 14. Open Patio Trellis - _ =__ -� ,1111 II II 111 II II 111111 III 11 11 11 11 III 4II41 C 8 '- 0 L __ ����.. � 2 te: � ;� II uuuuuu III ill _m b C112101111 W {y NO NN.I 2Ibl• 11(1 b N - ) l \I1 5 ■ of \ S# )NIU 111111 SJWOH NVINV \CH 'N 110i' 1 BUILDING 5 AND 6 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR BEDROOM OPTION UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR LOFT k(111011 NNNN'll V Ot/ 1(1111111 SlIA/OH NVINVAOH )10 I IN '1\01 1- Z 0 CC 7 0 I \ UNO II 'i I Wig NOIN iN AIN - O kW', (TIV\1011 NVINVA011 *>1 AO 1 , MOHN MO I ' L l . l Ati RESLIBMITAL - 10/7/2014 . g 2 1 111 1 ; .,. Ai 1 IiiillP A 1 i Ili I ; 1 1 1 1) 1 li A 11A BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS LEFT SIDE ELEVATION: RIGHT SIDE ELEVATION: SCALE 3/1C -- KEYED ELEVATION NOTES 51 0 0 2130,12 0 512215■ 3110151svo ros 0 1r1e22,23511.1,41,21300.2/1,2120.1.12 1.1.22 321201213151:1000 ssno wars annsmooNim C) 2,51 t3xovne C10022.1 1,20,,,110,121Y.175 21N VS0.201,0, 311 200.911W. 1 0 0 180103 2248 11552/2 TIAIS 112015 waool t•to amni 1.o.04/1.00 SN2 1, 23511M.V. worn 3.1■2100. e mows 27,18 srem. .nna..12211.1.1 SONO. 0 12. 33511 had. nuvnoo isru e 210100 kmoDoHyr■ inHsno,.■ swerrun N■22123125 ooxas ® 0 no ron 2 ronnans 02210.1,,no.onv 5.31.1.5 2 11 wer 23.11231.1 e 00 Irerram An snap. snooa 150.131%3 2 0 ILI-VS thgaoM1Oo 0 22112 22i13112021 531,1 /11122111/ACK171,01010 a cnorus Q g35 3Airagy,. 0 .311,1.3401,19.113411010339 .1 1xave3.slonva iKs.e.a . g 2 1 111 1 i tr.2 1 i t 1 l i 1 1 ii .,. Ai 1 IiiillP A 1 i Ili I ; 1 1 1 1) 1 li A 11A il tt ! ; 1 111 1 . ,..- 111 1 1 I t i l j 1 1 ti 11 IA i 11 li I 1 1 6 ! 8 1 ill BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS LEFT SIDE ELEVATION: RIGHT SIDE ELEVATION: SCALE 3/1C -- \ oTlolI'I w Not \loU Lb1V 11(1 Fs'b NI)s ' cd 1111f1 S`14\1011 NVINV1011' 1 Lo 1'+IWO11N \ \ol 1— z 1-- z 0 ce w I CL b ( 1110U 11 )b 14111N 4041 lib 1N 11(1 N, / 8# N 5# ..;' 8IC1 um TE An SMITAL 2014 53W01 I NVINVA011 )i 11,... ' INI.1A01 i i ; i 0 ' :I sr t g In 1 g g N li Lt i i F r■ I i i ; i 0 THEME 0 1 g" gi , h ' zi! g' gi 1 e ' 0 i4 ;i -.,'.. M I 1, g L'A g 000000000000 1111 000000000000 • g < BUILDING 5 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS KEYED ELEVATION NOTES 1 a 0 0 3 Z 0 z 0 0 OUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS V(111101111 3 141 N, I M •:11N.11 S iqR N Sk" NN.K1111151 TE AN MIT 20M � i __A1011 NVINV;IOI 1 )I s�� �s s 3 1. ..§ ra ,, n �. pan, . s I. 1 IIIIIIII II II II III H11 II 11 1 1 • 7 a -, =ice 4 - - - l- uuuu i �iut us L . a ;-ale II I I I IINNIIII IIIIIII i u n n 11 II II II II 1111111 II III : u u u u � � A ` , ::� N M r � 1� 0 . l , 1 a 0 0 3 Z 0 z 0 0 OUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS V(111101111 3 141 N, I •:11N.11 S iqR N Sk" NN.K1111151 TE AN MIT 20M � i __A1011 NVINV;IOI 1 )I I i."IWJI1N,NJ1 1 a 0 0 3 Z 0 z 0 0 OUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS � i ra ,, n �. pan, . s I. J 7 a Mg 0 =ice 4 , - l- -�. �� I i �iut [. , . v ,1 Rg �.�. -i " ';nit in; = NITS NE - IM II, <. : s ° is I 7-2 ` 1 e; I '' r VA ,..,........... 1 a 0 0 3 Z 0 z 0 0 OUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS z 0 ct 0 ,NMxt —NM,r, —NMI", —NM —N 7 0 z - FOUR & THREE STORY, 5 UNITS 4 STORY BUILDINGS #5 + #6 YRA DESIGN, INC. b(11110 li I I 14 N 1 WV11(1 IC1 „I1„ S.: t■ NN cd , )N NI 1 g ')Ii NV)NVAOWN S1‘AI L- 1101•C „NOV IN MOL .. SI EE PLAN RESEIBMITAL 10/7/2014 z 0 ct 0 ,NMxt —NM,r, —NMI", —NM —N 7 0 z - FOUR & THREE STORY, 5 UNITS 4 STORY BUILDINGS #5 + #6 YRA DESIGN, INC. WK If 1i A NO IN Lbk110\s'b , INHS.Q#VSO , AMMW 51W01i NVINVA011 1101;h4OHNN\01 70 = n o i 1111111 111111 1111111 111$11 ,111 1 11 1 1 1 ird • ... hulIun ' z H Z \71.11110 11 '11 - A , IU NO 11N1011 ININ 111(1 \w' '111 N115 , 911 N Sk , )NKI 0119 S7IWOH NNINVAOH 'i N,A1 ti'II1'0I IN.1 \.'I 1 ird • ... hulIun ' z H Z At n 11 VCII210 NN NACM 'AIN "11(1 N , 11N11 qtt ,N1(1 111141 SAINOH NVINV 'OH *)1 KN.:11%011NA \ OM Inin ME MON ME IMiM MIN OEM In I lia (1111.: 91 - A , 19 NO1 Nvo,, 11(1 , IINI1 5) 9# N NI(1 9119 SV1011 NVINVAOI I )1 90 1 , 11%,1110k0 I 41 4$MMIZI/1] 1111 I 4N10 1:1[4 11 31111 B4 g 101 NUM 10 401 „,t umi 1111111 t. CC 0 balk) ll'll 41]I INIOI NI1 51 11S1V . 110 b ib NIWIl s 9158 S# INK4 Dllil S]WOE 1 NVINVA0E 1 )I N,_i 1 CI1N 011.\,100I 1- 2 z w z 0 CO 0 0 c 0 1- Z z z 3 STORY, UNIT A-1 END - -- - - _ „R Covered Patio i t Pull I A_—_—, _ YOB _-U - L LP IV NI l + ° r i, . ❑ 01 - °� _� .. .fir Open Balcony Trellis Covered Patio rr MI _I . oJ ❑ J C r1 , , _r _� m V m Open Balcony Trellis Covered Patio 1I 11 11 11' 1I 1I1 � ® Z 21 111111 III III 1 Ill 1111 III 1 11111111111 1 11 111111 I � ` 1111 III t i if 'JIl a d I t (J ._..IN. a f l r - Il ls. I - r�l ^ m y '. / ' ` l •04 Open Balcony Trellis Covered Pato O ❑ I II ' ,I _, ,, 1 t 11 _ _ �J m 1 f A. _ __ j ' Covered Patio ,- 11 ;:r /_ .�i -IN ow OII L co MI balk) ll'll 41]I INIOI NI1 51 11S1V . 110 b ib NIWIl s 9158 S# INK4 Dllil S]WOE 1 NVINVA0E 1 )I N,_i 1 CI1N 011.\,100I 1- 2 z w z 0 CO 0 0 c 0 1- Z z z 3 STORY, UNIT A-1 END A_—_—, IPTFT 11 _� m V m 1I 11 11 11' 1I 1I1 � ® Z 21 111111 III III 1 Ill 1111 III 1 11111111111 1 11 111111 I � ` 1111 III t i if 'JIl a d I t (J ._..IN. a f l V� Open E Trel Covers 6 t - -?�_ Covered Patio II ❑ DI 1 f I , bop- _ ;:r 1 4 balk) ll'll 41]I INIOI NI1 51 11S1V . 110 b ib NIWIl s 9158 S# INK4 Dllil S]WOE 1 NVINVA0E 1 )I N,_i 1 CI1N 011.\,100I 1- 2 z w z 0 CO 0 0 c 0 1- Z z z 3 STORY, UNIT A-1 END 1 0 0 o 0 W Y 0 W O-1 co H w II 21011 'RA 111 N01 N4011 NFlti 11(1 F b 1 III \I15 V 54 '1' IN10111111 S3WOH NVWVAOH 121 ti lPC'I INA I 11 I _Irk 11 111 :::1: 1171::.1::::11111:17::7:1711:1::::: 17111:4411: 11441: :1:1:::::::1111:1:::::11: 1719::: 1771::;:IIII:II: ::::41:1:::7:::7147::::::11:1:: 111:: 1711::::1:11:17:7:.::: 1111:::::91:719:1:11:1::1177 =' 1 O� 9 a E .....,. . 10 1 EMME11' Y lt riiM,/�11'� L ....... ..... .. �w N, L ., I /If =111 m I� ° �. 111111111 Il hs „ ,� mr3� / m Man MEI „ I :::7..9.1....:;1111,. ... :1 :111.....9..,.....::1,......... :::::717:1111: 119: 991:... .:1.i1:::::;A'ii::{:7:AA'::fi�_ ° � • IIU Lu C Og ,. L ., 1719,..::: 991.,,,,::1`:1::..91199:::::.1 I iJ = k _ 7 Yi;f.::Y.NL L i , me� rl 1911:11 a All, s .1. 91:::::::199::::::1:1 :1171: :II I 1 0 0 o 0 W Y 0 W O-1 co H w II 21011 'RA 111 N01 N4011 NFlti 11(1 F b 1 III \I15 V 54 '1' IN10111111 S3WOH NVWVAOH 121 ti lPC'I INA I 11 I _Irk 11 111 :::1: 1171::.1::::11111:17::7:1711:1::::: 17111:4411: 11441: :1:1:::::::1111:1:::::11: 1719::: 1771::;:IIII:II: ::::41:1:::7:::7147::::::11:1:: 111:: 1711::::1:11:17:7:.::: 1111:::::91:719:1:11:1::1177 =' 1 O� 9 a E .....,. . 10 1 EMME11' Y lt riiM,/�11'� L ....... ..... .. �w N, L ., I /If =111 m I� ° �. 111111111 Il hs „ ,� mr3� / m Man MEI • • ■ )pen Patio Trellis - - -- "j _ = It = ____ Covered Patio 1 =NI . , , , AIM= 0 , MiliMMi IV:WM& — .aik — , • I = 0 -J ,11,1,1...,,,,„„:„,„,„:„:::„,„„,„,„„:„„,„,„:„„ ,111 e _____ ME Mii.ii' =MO MI* II", Emmi - EMPME a INIIM ii=.1. MOI=1 rda nCO F —... MEN 0 , 4 ,ah — >pen Patio Trellis It — — — , — .aik — , • I = 0 -J e E . Emmi - um ItektIk=ArAMM-1-= rda nCO F 1 gm's. ..= ..m..11.1. .1....i.. .- .... I _ _ .. _ .. _ am MIIINMIIIIMI..M.11...1...I1•1111 0 . jr80 li 11 W pd N1INFN /IVAN LIC1 \." N c' Nft N NI(.11)1111 )H NIVINVNOH 1101 INAV. I L Z < e- BUILDING 5 AND 6 - FOUR STORY. 5 UNITS UNIT A1 FOURTH FLOOR LOFT BEDROOM OPTION UNIT A1 FOURTH FLOOR LOFT 0 0 z O 0 w (n WINO 11 lb"n1 \ � ii\ 1�i41 1141% 11(1 b'\ INI1 S'91t ' ` , ` 1 1 1 S.TWOH NVINVAOH '>1 11.1 city `I IN.N 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 11111 M11IIIII 111111111 1 1 1 1 ■11 111 VIII 'Wart co MO' RIIIIMEEER inl'i ll.III!�In_ lnlnl• 1111nnlnlnlanlnla111111� nlntnn1111M1rtl- a111II111111111111111 IUL CD MON MIN MM. ;. -, :::1:::11: 711::: 11:: :1:::11::::::::::t:::::::::::::: :::::::::::::...•...::::::.........: n::::::.....,::::::......:::::.....,.::::::............::::::......:::: =:: : :.....,:: : : : :......=..._ 0 0 0 1— (n LL 0 W Q H ,6..7C::It::l1— .,,u....� ��i: i.:: 1 .II:II::R::�::11::'I:::II:::Ii .If.:::::In::n::ln::n: .-I { C.D d' j c o ❑te in : nt l: 1 :1=1111=1MIlltat::11 =111 %1:11:: 11:19:::n 0 0 z O 0 w (n WINO 11 lb"n1 \ � ii\ 1�i41 1141% 11(1 b'\ INI1 S'91t ' ` , ` 1 1 1 S.TWOH NVINVAOH '>1 11.1 city `I IN.N 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 11111 M11IIIII 111111111 1 1 1 1 ■11 111 VIII 'Wart co MO' RIIIIMEEER inl'i ll.III!�In_ lnlnl• 1111nnlnlnlanlnla111111� nlntnn1111M1rtl- a111II111111111111111 IUL CD MON MIN MM. ;. -, :::1:::11: 711::: 11:: :1:::11::::::::::t:::::::::::::: :::::::::::::...•...::::::.........: n::::::.....,::::::......:::::.....,.::::::............::::::......:::: =:: : :.....,:: : : : :......=..._ 0 0 0 1— (n LL 0 W Q H • .. L == == 0 it nl:Iltl13tl11In Alb 11111 llllllllllllllllllli_ -- - ........ - -I■MO O J 3• .1•- IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII111111ii 1 , M L „r 46 x=911= 1111111111111111111110 311111 111111111111111111111111 I ■3 Y. 3 nl:Iltl13tl11In Alb 11111 llllllllllllllllllli_ 1 3• , M L „r 46 a ` O5 J^ (IITIO II t V II l^L {dl ININ IRA bib dlt �1 Vd V 53 v I\I(l 31141 SiNOH NVINV,IOH'>1 NO 1 ltN01 MO I CO 4= CV Q cc 0 0 LL o o . 0 0 O 0 O 0 (n co 0 C7 z " 0 = co s coa 11, 1NJH N. . C 1 NMN11(I bb ,I1 c)9# VS #:'i'1(1 81141 SANOH NVINVAOH '>1 NO 1• IINIMOI mai EN Mani ;I:litr - - 1: ::::,.::::1111:;7111:: 0 4 mom° SI#IIII::IIII::::::R:::::: #:1111:; II:::::: ::::::::.111 :1,111::: :::::111::1111 : ...,,::::III' I _ � I U_ . 1 MIMI U N 111■ 1 ::uC.^.ut::T.Ctg::::C9- J ,11 1E Pita ............ . IIII:: u::mu 1Willit . tu... u16u :1:::;^.::;;:^::A 3:::;:::a::NIL'ul::::• = cc 0 0 LL o o . 0 0 O 0 O 0 (n co 0 C7 z " 0 = co s coa 11, 1NJH N. . C 1 NMN11(I bb ,I1 c)9# VS #:'i'1(1 81141 SANOH NVINVAOH '>1 NO 1• IINIMOI mai EN Mani ;I:litr m 1 • , , Il 1 n n n n 0 , II !I i 11 HI 1 i ' 1 • v ILM= . ,, • ■■■••• • Ernim E.. EMMEN= Mau 1 leg Ira MIIIM al att .. _.. MIMI NM IIII. �e = = �Ik = = == L ' Mania. ,... ■ .. j . 0 . . --I .. , 4 E . 0 11 E 0 , ■-=.111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111ifi L9Ei .1!lik, IIIIIMEMMIE1 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ill11111111111111111111r .litilinni ---.111111101* Ina nagommummiummumut wanu=omuommini..- =NM Iti&I MENEM EMI= .. a MIN MOM MIN WM N 1 L4 112 1:11111111;111# 111111111:111111111111111111:111111111111:11111111111111:111111::111:1111:1111;111:111111 :111111111111:111:1111111111111 k1112I011 'I I A ISA LNI (03 11( 1 .•1I 9# S# "11(1 111111 5JWOH NVINVAOH *)i 211.) I silV01-11 (2 IMUU21*. BUILDING 5 AND 6 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR BEDROOM OPTION UNIT A FOURTH FLOOR LOFT Fi11T1��11'll III N I M1I��VI <I Nil qr, 9r :')N1(11111‘1 S1VVOH NVINVAOH 1101, IWoI \\ seso-s uoi • 1. ■us in. \ 0111011'41 A iti \01. \ 1011 TIM '11(1 , /NH c' qft V p S1N01 I NVIN . )I lioi 1 SIVE MAN RESUBMIT AL 10/7/2014 C' la - .' = . 2 1 1 1 1 1 , - t g li 1g KEYED ELEVATION NOTES 0 CEMENT PAVERS {TRENRON HERITAGE COLOR HERRINGBONE 90 PATTERNI 0 DECORATIVE WOOD BRACKET I.E.. A-C21 srucco F4•1151, IOLD WORLD KNOCKDOWN I MTN SHER,. WILIAM MONTEREY vairrE G oEcoRAT,E woo, KET ,py 0 °PAY EXTERIOR DOORS MO GARAGE DOORS WI WAL NOT FINISH COLOR 0 e WCORATL F SHUTTERS 6 nw.. PAINTER SNFPWIN .1. LAMS 91 ACK W.*: ,ON OR 0 „, , „ 0 FLAT MUCCO rurrED SHERWIN WILLIAMS POUSHED MAHOGANY .LOR 0 CAM STONE COLUMN ON PER ,sEE I.A■ 0 RAILINGS PAINTED SHERWIN WO.LIAMS BUCK MAGIC COLOR 0 DECORATIVE WOOD BRACKET ISEE LA-121 0 OWENS CORNING STONE CUL TURCO STONE (CORAL STONE S I 'ILL ANU FOSSIL RELF COLOR, 0 0 EAGLE ROOFING ROOF TILE ■voNocuosA sryLE AND SIERRA MADRE COLOR, 0 OE LORAN, KRACKE I ,SEE 0 WINDOWS AND SLIDING GLASS DOORS (BRONZE MAME, 0 OECORATIW WOOD BRACKET (SEE 9,42 0 CAST STONE SILL 0 CAST STONE PLASTERS 0 FAUX WOOD MEADER 0 0 CA S TS '''. 0 WOOOEN MELLIS i 1 I 1 1 Ai ti t § 5 v _ i , 1 $if 1 I, 1 ) t 1 1 1 I it 1 li 81 81 8i I a g ; Ill i i I ii' lejp 1 1 it 11 it i gi ti 0 ii 1 I 1 . li Hi j f i $ 0 BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS LEFT SIDE ELEVATION: RIGHT SIDE ELEVATION: SCALE 3/16' = 4CI11IC 1111 341 NCIN 011 11V1V"111\ti\ INI1 5 `ft \ Sp;'l \ICI 111141 S1WOf I NVINVA011 ')1 UC1 VW:111a\\CI 1-- z 1— z 1— z J ,..-', ,... 1 I i i ; ) ; ; § t ' P ul ,i t g ' v L, / 'e , 6 ! c 4 90. i :ff: ., = Ei 11. i P.6 n.: bi ,1' 4 i i . ' I 31 tA P p$ t 0 .. Li 1 W V hi \ isk0F1 FINIFd94$11011111 S NVINV A011 )1 NO1 MH\ANO1 6 6 BUILDING 5 - FOUR STORY, 5 UNITS LEFT SIDE ELEVATION:BUILDING 5 KEYED ELEVATION NOTES 4. • • 441 1— z _ 0 0 cc ROOF PLAN BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS \,(1j11,1 111 { '1 \ , I1 \. miememeRemerm" - ''' ' 11\11' Lill V.N. 1 ,„ c OZ •fl.INIII C ' ga N' Ct{ , ',N.1(1 I11111 rE An MI 201 . - - .- 510101 1 NIVINV,101 1 )1 l • • 1101 q1A'01-IN.W. I 110 ,„ 1 — 4. • • 441 1— z _ 0 0 cc ROOF PLAN BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS miememeRemerm" - ''' ' I 14 ' s '' ■' ' ■ ‘ 5 \ a■ ,„ c 47 „ ‘' Na■■■ '. 4V ‘‘‘ . - - .- l • • willii,,144 110 ,„ 1 — , ; t‘I*4 6 ;;F:P / I ..... x ....... EN . Imi■ DE ".1''' kgggggggg:4„ ; ,,ir 1 rilloir Imre r 111111111 ,Tfl iirril 'EN() L • ..,..1 ----1[. ... 4agigg4iggglalir 1`301 at IIII ., , ...?: • . ' 4g-4,gg " !gig:kw ., • 4011, Eirihr ' . • I 111111111 II IIIIIII • 46! ' u u U U II II i; :',, , §, ,■411R31 mnssal-t. , Mg 1101 EVAIA" tilatt„ 1 )kgtt , . s.1 .■.. ,..::::::::: e;;;;',;;V r"'' . 1 111111111 11111111111 • tO u u u u FJ t —,,; I 4 ,,,,,, glaffg mermillo• . wa, -- ■ - Eftg‘gA„•,:; 1. . 0 , ,, „ . . , _ A:tititiglir • fi i ! a 1 I a , ±ir - m on s.■ 1 a : 4. • • 441 1— z _ 0 0 cc ROOF PLAN BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS miememeRemerm" - ''' ' I 14 ' s '' ■' ' ■ ‘ 5 \ a■ ,„ c 47 „ ‘' Na■■■ '. 4V ‘‘‘ . - - .- eatAkkkk*IkkAW • ;;:!& rag t‘I*4 6 ;;F:P / I . . Imi■ DE ".1''' kgggggggg:4„ ii , FA 0 0 ' . '''',-, ..,..1 ----1[. ... 5E2 at IIII ., , ...?: • . ' 4g-4,gg " !gig:kw ., • gs#„,,gmt‘g;ft:#3•„::.- . . -,--.• ... -- 11117 IMMO r IIIIMIN•=111. NOM tOR 1 OW, kti ItnE t ‘:W...:‘:,n: ' I • 1111111111 It 11 11111111H nn n IR till 1111111 . '' om..• / , ' • 7 i mi, M 0 . 0 , ,, .... r■ • 1141.411 fi IIMMIM MEM UMW 1 0.1.= NW •W MOM, IIM( , 4. • • 441 1— z _ 0 0 cc ROOF PLAN BUILDING 6 - FOUR/THREE STORY, 5 UNITS VA01,1 '1.1V al NOINA0Et AO A,LID itlstoDului (4o lad tst) NV'ld adVOSCENVI DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT ENGINEERING / PUBLIC WORKS / FORESTRY / UTILITIES Comments: 1. Relocation of drainage outfall for Federal Highway and construction of improvements for boardwalk is contingent on FDOT approval. 4 2. The proposed design for the onsite water mains and fire lines is congested and future maintenance will be very difficult. Reduce the amount of water main piping onsite and ensure that all City owned utilities are located with open easements with easy access for maintenance. 3. Reconfigure water main layout onsite and replace existing 4" water main along Dimick Road with new 8" C -900 PVC water main. Connect to existing 8" water main at Federal Highway and loop onsite water main to the new main. Provide a stub for future connection south on Lake Drive. 4 4. The stormwater design along Dimick Road and the outfall details shall be worked out during final design. J 5. At time of permitting, revise landscape plan to indicate the total diameter inches of existing trees on the site proposed to be preserved in place, relocated, or removed and replaced [diameter inches] on site. The replacement trees shall be shown by a separate symbol on the formal landscape plan sheet. (Environmental Protection, Chapter 4, Article I, Section 3.C.1 -6). 4 FIRE Comments: 6. At time of permitting, revise plans to include the following: (1) fire flow for each building in accordance with the 2009 edition of NFPA 1 Chapter 18, Table 18.4.5.1.2.; (2) the number of hydrants, location, and distribution in accordance with Annex 1, Table 1.3, and 1.3 of the 2009 Edition of NFPA 1; and (3) an additional fire hydrant located midway on the north side of the project. J EXHIBIT "C" Conditions of Approval Project Name: Casa del Mar on the Intracoastal File number: NWSP 14 -004 Reference: 3rd review plans identified as a Master Plan / New Site Plan with an October 7, 2014 Planning and Zoning Department date stamp marking DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 7. Prior to permitting, a flow test shall be scheduled with the Boynton Beach Fire Rescue Department (561- 742 - 6600). The flow test will be compared to the required fire flow. Keep in mind that automatic fire sprinkler systems will reduce fire flow in accordance with the 2009 edition of NFPA 1 18.4.5 fire flow requirements for buildings. 8. At time of permitting, revise site plan and civil plans to indicate all underground fire sprinkler piping sizes and dimensions including backflows and FDC(s). NI POLICE Comments: None. BUILDING DIVISION Comments: None (all previous comments have been addressed). RECREATION & PARKS Comments: 9. The project involves six (6) 4 -unit buildings for a total of 24 dwellings. The impact fee for buildings containing 2 -4 units is $678 per dwelling x 24 dwellings = $16,272. The project also involves nine (9) buildings containing 5 or more units, for a total of 56 dwellings. The impact fee for buildings containing 5 or more units is $595 per dwelling x 56 dwellings = $33,320. The total impact fee for this project is $49,592 ($16,272 + $33,320). PLANNING AND ZONING Comments: 10. Approval of this project is contingent upon the approval of the accompanying requests for land use amendment (LUAR 14 -001), rezoning (REZN 14 -005), and abandonment (ABAN 14 -001). 11. At time of permitting, include plan revisions on all applicable plan sheets so plans are consistent and match. NI 12. A Unity of Title for the subject property is required to be submitted with completed City form at the time of building permit application. The Unity of Title is required to be recorded prior to the issuance of a building permit for this project. 4 Casa del Mar (NWSP 14 -004) Conditions of Approval Pa 2 of 4 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 13. All 12 private boat slips shall be restricted for the use of only Casa del Mar residents, and the 2 public boat slips shall be for daily turn -over only, not to be leased. The Casa del Mar Homeowner's Association shall incorporate these boat slip restrictions into their bylaws. J 14. Two (2) parking spaces are required for each townhouse unit, and a 2 -car garage is provided for each unit. To ensure sufficient parking remains, each garage shall be used only for parking, not storage or other purposes. The Casa del Mar Homeowner's Associations shall incorporate this restriction into their bylaws. 15. At time of permitting, revise plans to include a detail of the proposed gate for emergency access. The gate, as viewed from Dimick Road shall be decorative and opaque since this area in front of it will not be landscaped. 16. At time of permitting, revise plans to include a detail of decorative wall along Dimick Road, including columns with caps, rail on top, total height, and proposed materials, finish and colors. Ni 17. The Casa del Mar Homeowner's Association shall include a deed restriction requiring that any marina or dockage built will not exceed in width the boundaries of the project's actual frontage on the water, regardless of what any other governing or permitting entity may allow or permit. 4 18. At time of permitting, revise landscape plan to eliminate any small sod areas to reduce irrigation demand. Substitute hardy groundcovers and shrubs in place of the sod, except where used for play areas or otherwise where residents have access for recreational purposes. Label these areas and update plant list accordingly. J 19. At time of permitting, revise landscape plan plant lists to include the following requirements: a minimum of 4 -inch tree caliper for all required trees (except for signature trees); a minimum of 6 different canopy tree species; clusters of 3 Sabal Palms count as one (1) canopy tree; shrubs to be a minimum of 24" in height and spread. 20. At time of permitting, revise landscape plan to include square footage and percent of site that is pervious and impervious. Ai 21. An irrigation plan is required to be submitted and approved prior to the issuance of a permit for this project. Ni 22. At time of permitting, revise landscape plan to indicate locations of all freestanding light poles consistent with locations on photometric plan, and ensure that poles are not located too close to landscaping when it becomes mature. NI Casa del Mar (NWSP 14 -004) Conditions of Approval Paae 3 of 4 DEPARTMENTS INCLUDE REJECT 23. The monument sign proposed in the entrance median is subject to Engineering review and approval for safe sight distance. The sign is limited by the Land Development Regulations to a maximum height of five (5) feet with a maximum of 32 square feet of sign face area, and a minimum setback of ten (10) feet from any property line. 4 24. At time of permitting, revise plans to provide benches in passive open space /recreation areas, and near the public artwork and waterfront. 4 25. The Casa del Mar Homeowner's Association shall schedule and coordinate bulk trash pickup times with the City's Sanitation Department, and incorporate this information into their bylaws. 4 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Comments: None (Previous comments have been addressed). PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT BOARD CONDITIONS Comments: None ADDITIONAL CITY COMMISSION CONDITIONS Comments: 26. Project approved with changes to plan as presented on March 2, 2015 including, in part, changes in unit counts to equal 69 townhomes and 3 single family lots at the southeast corner of the property. All revisions to be shown on all respective pages of the rectified version of the site plan and filed at time of permit application. 4 Casa del Mar (NWSP 14 -004) Conditions of Approval Page 4 of 4 S: \Planning \SHARED \WP \PROJECTS \Casa del Mar \Casa Del Mar 2014 \NWSP 14- 004\Final Conditions of Approval 3- 2- 15.doc N AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, ,2G4yc4 eL .Gly l�!1 , residing at, 2624 ZAP—'as, Ne ,cf9,�� , who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application • P d development. • 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple p • , rty own, 's Affidavit's as submitted. /�/'r SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS 3 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared M:c_hae_k MA-0\ F, , , h0 is aercnnally own to mne or w ie- or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. 42e-pelLitk Not Signature (SEAL) K;CAo>\Q. eh\ec Printed Notary Name NICHOLE BUEHLER NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF FLORIDA 144. Comm#EE129230 .ig Expires 9/11/2015 AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, NO‘0 \.e__. \.e ,residing at, -7_c„,7,- _ t3 Ar,/-0.U�ch, ,who, being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted theproperty..owners_of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and_ granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. Sir2414_,_ SIG ATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS day of January, 2615, before me, appeared I 1 C.hd/2. . a U E i--L€VZ , who ' rson y�c iOWr to me or why has produced a Florida Drivers License No. as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. eti,i) f"-)11/4„.9s2k. Notary Signature (SEAL t� s'TA MY COOMMMIIS ON#EE 856973 A1►I /71 ft_d 14. ki EXPIRES:April 7,2017 Printed Notary Name 4411„ ' Bonded Thor Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, LQ.o 0 ka La✓'4jLf ,residing at, .5 I Lcxk-be.N }Q�Ol.�Y1t bo„iv-L_'sw,5, who,//being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their i Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multipl- aro.erty . •• - ' ffidavit' submi -d. 44 i i w,"Iff _,......i(..c...,_, S 1 I•GN 4 7 1- 41 I 1 w- STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWOR11 TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of January, 2015, before me, appeared 'eop r LO L41c.O ltiy , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. 1,11 ' as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. / )%JiY Notary Signature " �� // (SEAL) / -411nC��r"I ISI/Z d ` l� ,,.„ • ted Notary Name '�� RAMONA MROTEK €,m � MY COM :•e 1�i i MISSION#EE 856973 TA,::,,,.- .24..; EXPIRES:April 7,2017 ' ••• " Banded Piro Notary PublicUndemilers Af,E�� AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, M (A< i.e' L—Ok na •,residing at,a5 U LictY,o_)r. N ib®ki nlb n 13611C L '33435,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C.Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within .the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. f Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with themultiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. (YYd/v )rl SIGNATUTetYCIA/1/ STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS '/ day of January, 2015, before me, appeared /h/r/W'e L.4 i 4 i€ , who i ersonally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers Lice a No.., or- as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. 4017140k,"-- Notary Signature (SE ,.,, ilk - ynn-dTel , + RAMONA MROTEI( ..4 MYCOMMISSION YEE856973 Printed Notary Name EXPIRES:April 7,2017 %,t14:0Bonded Thu Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorizedtoadminister oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, �J�( "F.VYI \4bUi.c11,4 •,residing at, acs?. L4\c-e bh r v ,who,beingfirs d y cautioned 'Mn and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 1 haus 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tetae3 c where single family homes are zoned,1 nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. t Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property •wner's Affidavit's as submitted. i 4\ i CPIGNA IP1 ` 6 -- STATE OF FLORIDA _ COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUpSCRIBED THIS ! day of January, 2015, before me, appeared .1-7e 12 elft De_ o O/1S Fly , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature . " -:--' RAMONAMROTEK /�-�" � Y1\ r�0��`/� _*: ! :*: MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 Printed Notary Name EXPIRES: Pf : Bonded ThruNotary April c'u denvriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, A/t4o"/4 /11_2:07EK. ,residing at, Qc24 4I4 --'v- ✓PG:35" ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. /2697)(•&114--- ---1\' /I''`C1-"LD--- SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS ? day of January, 2015, before me, appeared —Zn un tk c- , o is person. y s own to m- - ::- . :: . __! _ , •,.. I � " I - . . or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. UL&QLAL LELA-A- Not Signature (SEAL) �:r, e., 6Aer— Printed Notary Name NICHOLE BUEHLER ibilNOTARYPUBLIC F `` _STATE OF FLORIDA . CommitEE129230 199 Expires 9/11/2015 AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments,personally ap.13eared, . r - 1 RR residing at, b 4-© r vie ck o- . ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn,deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions,adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic,social,environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat, dated 1/21/1922, thereof as • recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners,Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C.Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4 The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property;lots-8-thru--- - — — 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall.The separation would therefore be a" taking" from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. g The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements.This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium(The Peninsula) are 21%, owned and 79% • rental.The'mathematics'prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. g The City of Boynton Beach,a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple prop owner' Affidavit's as submitted. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWO' ► TO t . BSCRIBED THIS 3 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared who is pgmonall.y_knomttamS or who has.produced a Florida Driver�rr'''nse No. /tel #©4/©(-6 2"1 '71br as identification,and attests t.h ee aforementioned. (-) 71/14441-- �o jic�Jty ' "�r,,''a RAMONAMROTEK • 14‘.. MY COMMISSION EE 85697 Notary Signature • o i EXPIRES:April 7,2017 Rf�Rh I A-inA-1� 0.127- C haps://mail•attachment.googleusercontent.coni/attachmenthi/O/s/?view=att...oy33r64&sadet=1420225476944&sads=phiWIDJbPpiAm-uBxcIEWBMIrAM 1/2/15,2:07 PM Page 1 of 2 AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personallyapwl, ,,) wq,\ \ ,residing at, CIi<6. b ‘\‘i\N ,who, being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and -- ____ granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and de -lopment. 9. The undersigned concurs with the m.1 '.le pr-, /erty . - r'/Affi•. ' s as submitted. Ali-ridILS 11 S - N, ' STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS ' day of January, 2015, before me, appeared toed Col well_ , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or NY576o p7a et,E53 as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. / � i -ate-).1 A�, Notary Signature I v (SEAL) Mint.441 r "It/C ,,,,,n�gl�.vl?dile. ILA._ RAMONA MR0TEK fir ,, 4 MY COMMISSION N EE 856973 -,':.^-,i e 1 EXPIRES:April 7,2017 'II i Bonded Thio Notary Public Undk:milers AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, c III mo4 I l ;VII�l ,residing at, 6' g I Wit ,who,beingduly first cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The'resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C.Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and — granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a." taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens I animous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and develop s . . 9. The undersigned concurs with the , fl tiple prop,mL- Ir Affidavit's .. :. I miffed. 4iiiianlikidg , SIGNA '.,4! STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS I day of January, 2015, before me, appeared 'Hii/2 )ATI e /71 L reit.I , who is personally known to me or who , has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or _ as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. / /2,;(2/2&-,-).— '--) d Notary Signature - / (SEAL) 06110 Vk-ii i1/zd //4 k Printed Notary Name LRAMONAMROTEK , , .4. MY COMMISSION 8 EE 856973 -�..... EXPIRES:April 7,2017 """" ` Bonded TM Notary PubYC Unde+writela AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, C personally appeared, J 9% , .j, �a 7- / , residing at,6. k �t d �y� £ ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and wanted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. . The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property o AAP: ' =i w • ' as submitted. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of January, 2015, before me, appeared au(N l). fI CCityuk.i , who is pally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature (SEAL) c11�-1 �z �C Printed Notary Name `,Uu,q 4 MY most 7441,10B°n�yli(PIR r 2017 Undenwin AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, n 1((k ( Y/1�.(I` v ,residing at, 61\ DI r'Yl t C,� a o! Q,,€ Fc , ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn,deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C.Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and _ granted by Purdy and Hall. --- -- -- -- --_.. ._ _— — — - 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with th, multipl- property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. S GNATURE • STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH swopT To AND SUBSCRIBED THIS tfr'da , , before me, --- - — appeared N 1/101-e WI A,05- , wh. is personally kno o me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification,and attests to the aforem- o . Signature (SEAL) Laji:S5A rWir•-eSCO Pled Notary Name 46,74k, MEUSSA NERME£3AN MY COMMISSION#FF 045160 EXPIRES:August 28,2017 V,Rf„tiV Bonded Thfu Nalary Public Umienwilers .e r. AFFIDAVIT STA FE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, .r it i' n f MA UQ tS ,residing at, •& 1/ P/i"is k Roo./ Z. 6 C . ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy-and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. , ..., • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental.The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and . development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SW I yoNIMIMRD3ED THIS ( h day,..,_. ;,.,.6.., 2015, before me, ell-- appeared F tit , , w e is .erso. . ii own to me or who has produce. a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. Ill "Ada& 4 0'-; ignature (SEAL) )14-(014.c3A- VavrnesAl.-. Printed Notary Name 0% MELISSA NERMESAN 4 MY COMMISSION 0 FF 045168 ti EXPIRES:August 28,2017 'Whii:ei• Bonded Thru Nobly Pu!ob Underernicre AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, c"h,� .�k 1 ,residing at, aL ,-� - airsCb eA who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a "taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens •f►• •ii ous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application id develop as •nt. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple propoa • - • .t avit's as submitted. ____tty SIGNA STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS �/ day of January, 2015, before me, appearedH-/l) TM-CH{ -L-L , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. , -/i'i97ic_ )9244_0i-_____ Notary Signature °,, RAMONA MROTEK ��/�/IlUyt� /" `C (SEAL) ,zv�'�"P' '=_ _*. �- ;*_ (ul`f COMMISSION N EE 856973 p' Printed Notary Name �"%thril a? EXPIRES;y nt 7,2017 ��Pf��''�`, Bonded firu Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, 17414-e q L(. ,residing at, LizAG br YJ ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the_property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1 AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. � •��-u Qom, SIGNA 1 .RE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS ` day of January, 2015, before me, appeared Z) 'J F 1—MC¢-1 , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. �r as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. '16 Notary Signature (SEAL)„ ... -�l d v1L(c-i 'r;'�,,,,, RAMONAMROTEK Printed Notary Name .:. MY COMMISSION N EE 856973 jam Bonded Tbru Notary Publ c Under/niters J AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, �\611-C6(,Ald ,residing at,1_0 3 Lae, t c ��,,A R3,e4 3;traS ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property. owners_of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and...-:. granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. r Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multipl- p o .- o.i °•davit's as submitted. i 7g ' ► . r • STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH QQ SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS da of Jan . 2015, before me, appearedj�h„�`�-enc \— , who is personally known to me ',a • e I . Florida D - _ _- - - or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned 4. 1 ,, No Signature (SEAL) i\Th \-e_ Printed Notary Name t.. NICHOLE BUEHLER NOTARY PUBLIC F -+STATE OF FLORIDA Comm#EE129230 N e 1 Expires 9/1.1/2015 AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, 1 ��� �V►Y'S 1(1 ,residing at, 01(Q2 5 L c,\LQ 1 )e)t ,who,being st d y cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets. and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density t -ents EA where single family homes are zoned, arxcnonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple prop-rty owner's Affidavit's as submitted. SIG /TURF 4 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS 14 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared/h o N i CA. D e..V()kik$ftfe y , who is personally own to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Nor Signature °k-,. RAMONAMROTEK 1 �T/11 6v1-1 y'�l� i . a / t4 t•_ MY COMMISSION N EE 856973 Printed Notary Name EXPIRES:April 7,2017 %;pF ;Q Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters I� AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, ,koovl2,s V3bkAgNcYl ,residing at, ate t5 La 1 Y I IN? N oy' who,be' first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changingthe zoning of property,3, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. VYNATal 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density where single family homes are zoned,�*nonconforming with the subdivision R- r 1AA zoning requirements. ThiOncludes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. I. • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. \\) SeTURE bjdj(2.1) STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of January, 2015, before me, appeared t7174-die S be.. Uo V AR , who is person known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License . of as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature - ppMOrIpMROTEK Agin�r� Yr1C --4,„t-T,,,,,,--- ''• MISSION 6 EE 856973 Printed Notary Name IS- My COMMISSION 7,2017 74 ` 147 6wwledxThtu NotaryPIRES: PPubhc Undervaiteis i AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, Ettrar ,residing at, "lot. ay/den 044Lcst, ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. •. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple roperty owner's Affidavit's as submitted. SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH THIS da _.. _ SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED y of i , .- S e, appeared 5,1 "R 1144 Pis AAA s/C( , who is personally known to me or wh has produced a Florida Drivers License No. u,l as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. A-7)-(6'74— Notary Signature 7— (S �.� RAMONA MROTEK �/i'L /td' l :Ai MY COMMISSION7E Printed Notary Name EXPIRES:April pfit 117,2017017 - ;:incp Bonded liner Notary Public tinderwnters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, V4 i C k 0 . / ( ►V �et,(4.a 01,residing at, 2 .4.6 d Lai k� �r�1�es aab6� ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; F L. 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and.Hal 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. GNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SW T6-AND SUBSCRIBER- THIS -day of-ianuary, 2015, before me, appeared m l}-/ 1 . /11 C c/ehit,� , who is pe or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature n (SEAL) /n. 2-d r rL ,+;; n-... .• a Name (.'•• 1 Mi ON °�°, --._...._'I'yTh Nola A;iil%2016?3 Pub*end er rilerg AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, c_k - p. Mc_c_l eav^ ,residing K- at, 2 00 La e. a)rr'v.e a,f4t,�8�K�`�`- FL– ,who,being firt duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C.Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by-Purdy-and-Hall — 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. r , Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. / %beau SIGNATURE .- STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SW 4 T0-AND -SUBSCRIBED THIS da of January, 2015, before me P appeared t/kg_ H'l c l eotti� , who is per§^naiiy>nowr to ^,P ^r,uho has produced a Florida Drivers License 14o. as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notail (SEAL) e01 02 cri- Printed NotaryName ti"*" RAMONA MROTEK ?.: �� :r MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 EXPIRES:April 7,2017 RAO" Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, dul. authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally p.ppeared, ti h ,residing at, - /O A -- ,�2�,yi %�, ca„Zs_ ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall, 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse, Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental.The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multi.le pro.: •er's Affidavit's as submitted. y �.I. ; SI hr ATURE r STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND, THIS SCRIBED TS 'Y day of January, 2015, before me, d 4appeare14-144.11-71-up- , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. er as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. /2-av/e-AA-- '')-?1,1"--94..k Notary Signature y�� M / : 1;.-• RAMONA MROTEK A all ov`-'#1 f f r k.-677-- 6 -: 4t :+n MY COMMISSION tr EE 856973 Printed'NotaryName V. 6 EXPIRES:April 7,2017 tP7 tr Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, /' g � �/� in f� rZ° �7 ,residing at, a5/4 / 14- �( 'O' 3o y i i t-04 l(' -who, being first duly cautioned and sworn,deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners, 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-IAA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. r • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental.The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. SI ATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS ' 7 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared 57 A -A- P IL) ke/L7 , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. (` 71b-/!-4971.._. x-2 Notary Signature RAL"q MROTEK /11 (�VV9) vi I L (5 .^ ' Q0.` d EXPIgsgpll 7,2017 73 P.,. rnN row Public Underwriters Printed Notary Name 1 • AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH• BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly au rized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, Atm) r / IUKC,JD/J ,residing at, _2 5/D L- 4--Ie fJ,e A. a 1i ✓ Gte , who,being first duly cautioned and sworn,deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the paint being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation,acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multi 4e property o is vit's as submitted. S NATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO 4UBS ,�RIBED THIS day of January, 2015, before me, appeared SOI�N r �- " , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. - or-- as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. /2a,roi Notary Signature (SEAL) 6v641 P1(LOI7 IC Printed Notary Name .4-0144k RAMONA MROTEK � MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 i -•.-��.:a EXPIRES:Apn77,2017 ?"pfd ' Bonded Tha Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized, to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, Do m-e n t q e)a 1,C1<I , residing at, (02(D PHO' i� 3o ki vim-)) &CtCh FL .33'0who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and - --- ----------- -------- -- --- - - - -- --- --------- - -- ---- ---- -- ---- granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the. Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multi e property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. bakc c! , SIGNATURE 4( STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRID THIS y day of January, 2015, before me, appeared Jbrn ,ate/G e� , who is pe or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. /31/�d /�7 9/80 9-0 or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. • a.MROTEK Notary Signature • "'=EE 856973 2017 (SEAL) " u6hcUndenvriler: 61A (/ A/Ldrk Printed Notary Name ` ,„eik RAMONA MROTEK 1r, :t MY COMMISSION II EE 856973 . . 41 EXPIRES;April 7,2017 w,iiegip Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, 4 ir , Sp 140 ,residing at, GZ 4,1-ef 14toy/rl , who,being first duly cautioned .3_34 and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7, The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. Ai 1 SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN T9 AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of January, 2015, before me, appeared fr? ii J e U i , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No./ - [jt i- e/L S_ kiceitge..or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. g 5-)0 -5 - Notary Signature (SEAL) / vyA4C1 ad it--( RaMONnMaotEK Printed Notary Name .=q. ,P . MY COMMISSION p EE 856973 Apl 7,2017 moi-. ,, Bonded ThruRNotary Public Unndervmters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, t cLkc( f l o o d ,residing at, (,qL pdr'Cr iZ c( , who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. a' Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. 1441/ Wird SIGNATU STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORNO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of January, 2015, before me, appeared i lie. P/ueD , who is ers 1 known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. r or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. )01.A4g./Notary Signature ( R: :.-.,, RAMONAMRO1EK /44ifl -�4 in no7 2Z •, MY COMMISSION N EE 856973 Printed NotaryName EXPIRES:April 7,2017 ALS Bonded Thio Notary Public Unde writers • AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appered, SIAAIDA e..'g101\\ ,residing ataSb g "De_ No 2- 14 ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and ranted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru. 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- , IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics,prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development: 9. The undersigned concurs with the multi,lei rope owner' 'davit's as submitted. ./ IGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of J na 2015, before 'me, appeared Si iMA O Ueit,-r v , wh 's_personally known . e or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned.Notary Signature �•/ (SEY'�''' RAMONA MROTEK q-((1 d r-rT IDYL YE C ''"7' .4 MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 o 20 JZEX72Oi7JPrinted Notary Name fah• Bonded AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, r' Thp-). a ,residing ato�f0who,bfirst� 1 ��'. dl. � `JC� '� g my cautioned and.sworn, deposes and states as following; 33 cr- 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted. the property__owners of_Lakeside Gardens.Subdivision by the-provisions set down-and --- granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1 AA property in the • subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned,:alonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. SIGNATURE tit/ STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWqRN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS Y day of January, 2015, before me, appeared R-4-"-o a A.) Ifl onal l -m ,S /4 j eA , who is persy-kn who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. - or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. )77144'0- Notary Signature (SEAL) 2i4M d 17 /( Printed Notary Name •i rift. RAMONA MROTEK e#- MY COMMISSION#EE 85 7973 =q.���:b`r EXPIRES:April 7,2017 'l;pf�y;�^� Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters f AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personall appeared, 1 D4' � � PP � - � � � �r'fesidmg at, 6 • e, Aka A who ing first i my cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; `j/ 5 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down.and __ granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, a'nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the mu le prope owner's A 'davit's as submitted. SIGNA ' STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWO RN TO AND SUBSCRIBE}) THIS 7 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared en i /Aj eSSfn 3 , who is personally known to me or_who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. L441/Cat/cam Notary Signature Rogit4A144319( �}—/nor /t o1 /� (SE I '�'i'+..y ISSION#EE 856973 i'1 - my VEXPIA$:ppn17.u°aewiters Printed Notary Name ARtre AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, 1--%.1 ,residing at, 219 D ] 1-A.- 1-C h D 1I+ .I -]n, 14�FL.,who, being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; ,_35‘11.3 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. r ' Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of ' (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. k SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / ' day of January, 2015, before me, appeared beM's-e_ /11.esshvi Sl G-/ - , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers"License No. - or as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. '--)/22,i &lam— ) ? - - Notary Signature (SEAL) nONAMRo x. , /affil d'L-� AiL6FEk- "''y''' Printed Notary Name :ia1"` '�`�,''''= MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 *9 ;1' a PIRES:April 7,2017 �` " Public Underwriters d' Bonded"(btu Notary • AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally a pear d, _. i 4 i A) I - r t .41- ,residing I�, f-pi .t at, V 87'1. j� •,.. ., ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with theatiple prop: r, owner's A • •.vit's as submitted. 1 NA AP" , 0 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCWBED THIS V day of January, 2015, before me, appeared 1ZUti' /3etNDe , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers . or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Add iy46-76- 1 1444(74 Notary Signature (SEAL) RA-01-(1 Printed Notary Name , r •,,, RAMONAMROTEK e') MY COMMISSION H EE 856973 l%`— EXPIRES:Apn17,2017 ' i4 x Bonded'Mu Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, S , residing at, 1.0k4 yo#4(31_, ••?..4av,,oi.,,,a,,(:),r_9, 14o...being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 334.3% 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and _ granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. 1M ( SIGNA STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN T4 AND SVOSCRMED THIS day of January, 2015, before me, appeared S"u zi l)i A- 4/ , who is personally lmown to ie or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. — or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature �-, (SEAL) iet Ea ' Ito /C Printed Notary Name ;t: MROTE( zN. :a A M a.a MOO 973 °) E ORES: : V. Vika 4'' Bonded Thm Notary Public AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,1_ duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, G\a" l7 cJWt,,L Z, , residing at, G 76 f G fit f PA. fx.$14,kin d / EL Of 3S,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and - ---- granted by Purdy and Hall. - — - --- -- - - --�- - 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8, The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multi e )rape �• !' er'• Affidavit's as submitted. a►•r SIGNA friW717 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AN SUBSCRIBED THIS <I day of January, 2015, before me, appeared 148GA �`'zA-fe , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature (SEAL) - 124 n U�d`� yid oT '( 11 PYa RAMONA MROTEK r Printed Notary Name *d �! MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 ?oi?:= EXPIRES:April 7,2017 Bonded Thai Notary PuN!c Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, SEefani QJ ( üci //e5 e5 , residing at, C(5jCp ? tt' 1 Naiai Bead PL 53?Swho,being first duly cautioned and swornde oses and states as owin p g; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and. values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. • • Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the m ltiple prope o gir's Affidavit's as submitted. SI A. ' STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND UBSC 7 ED THIS day of January, 2015, before me, appeared .S71€4-0i-k;(� (d�1 Q 1f( , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. 41--r: >/ ) Y Notary/Signature (SEAL) ¢?„lye` ti1YCRAMONAMR07EK nj (J4-1 EXPIRES:COMMISSION k EE 858973 April 7,2017 • ted Notary Name ,h. Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters i AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, (,(,S /}q/ /9D#9-m S ,residing at, as 6.5 l_rn-i - OR/ g, j pro h aen-QJ,FL ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Pahn Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property_owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by_the_provisions set down and -- ' granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- IAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. l Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. LtCL€4e,nto SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS '/ day of January, 2015, before me, appeared ,5 S ii✓� /�-,)/ /} , who is r Dersonally kno t&me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature (S =R-,,. J� � /LTE/( i''eN PA OviM SSA MFOTEK Printed Notary Name r!"°. haY COmmISSION fF 656973 ;�� c •� EXPIRES:;j, 7,2017 .°:;,i Bonded ihni Votary Rivc u nderwritera AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, /l-eec , A-I) [WY) S ,residing at, 13yl./,r-9.—NAyit/i1N 1- 4F /who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; a3 S 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners_of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and - - granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a "taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned)Udlionconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics: Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula) are 21% owned and 79% renta'. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. _7///4., SIG A K4' STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN ;TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS 'y.. day of January, 2015, before me, appeared Nei / 40/)-/Y1.s , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Vrivers License No. - or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature SEAL).. ... ... (L4.4-/YL(*A 77:1( /( PAPAW MROTEK Printed Notary Name MY COMMIS iON N EE 856973 * ,:,• 6i XPItkE;4..,pril 7,2017 .....r bt;.ueu'r'iw Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, 0-11( ALLAr0 ,residing at, ado R ka4 `, C l*? + 44"g ti,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 33`I 1J r 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and -- -- granted by Purdy 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values,marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental.The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and dev- opment. 9. The undersigned concurs with the mu!' ; erty o er's Affidavit's as submitted. I LF SI NA —Cr' STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS 7 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared C X// IS-79 4-"/ 44 Auk Ca , who is personally known to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. as identification,and attests to the aforementioned. Notary Signature Signature (SEAL) /fr/?Z6)L11 in d T • RAMONA MROTEK Printed Notary Name 4in*, 17 nu MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 EXPIRES:April 7,2017 • Bonded Tbru Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, ,4 -tiit7 ,residing at, 2.6// N. j ,34 ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted __._ ____________ the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set_down and__ granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- 1 AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote •of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multip a property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. SIGNATURE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH Y_ ------ --—--- --- - ---------- ---------- SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS / day of January, 2015, before me, appearedi(}/Le h—dri 0 (who is person known to me or who2 has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. /iewte9771-t.,- // Notary Signature (SEAL) 12-4/4 a ik n) fief Printed Notary Name ,, �:s'i : RAMONA MROTEK *: ':,r MY COMMISSION NEE 656973 *.-�7-: EXPIRES:April 7,2017 % AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,_ duly authorized to administer oaths and take p acknowledgments, personally appeared, /11 /10mA talo ,residing at, Z-(01I tAiet-' t)r_ N . 'Oort.,A -5-e6.4% ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted the property owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bounds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a" taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density housing where single family homes are zoned, and nonconforming with the subdivision R- lAA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the mul • le property owner's Affidavit's as submitted. •SI A STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORNTO SUBSCRIBED THIS 6 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared /�TC��e� /1-t) yL0 , who is pe-sorMlyknown to me or who has produced a Florida Drivers License No. or _ as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. )1111-11"Xl Notary Signature (SEAL) I21 i' 1[Eit/ Printed Notary Name esV t, RAMONA MROTEK Vii`.41 MYOOAdMISSION9EE856973 . ,• EXPIRES:April 7,2017 Notary Public Underwriters AFFIDAVIT STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority, duly authorized to administer oaths and take acknowledgments, personally appeared, AIVThbIVff J Att ,residing at, 2 6/f t.-'l//'5 Dr: /�l• � ,who,being first duly cautioned and sworn, deposes and states as following; 1. We, the people of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, united in our resolve and convictions, adamantly oppose the proposed Casa Del Mar high density development project. The resulting severe impacts to our economic, social, environment and life style will cause all of us to experience everlasting hardships as property owners. 2. Lakeside Gardens Subdivision, according to the Plat dated 1/21/1922, thereof as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 57 of the Public Records of Palm Beach County, Florida is an entity unto itself set forth by the original owners, Kelsey D. Purdy and Stiles C. Hall. 3. No forum has the lawful authority to remove/transfer the rights and privileges granted =_the property_owners of Lakeside Gardens Subdivision by the provisions set down._and granted by Purdy and Hall. 4. The proposed development would require changing the zoning of property, lots 8 thru 24, within the meets and bonds of the Lakeside Gardens Subdivision as plated, making that rezoned property inconsistent with the rest of the R-1AA property in the subdivision. The rezoning would be a division of the plated subdivision as an entity set forth by Purdy and Hall. The separation would therefore be a " taking " from the property owners interests and values of the subdivision as they perceived and purchased. 5. The massive intrusion of our development which proposes high density tenements where single family homes are zoned, nt nconforming with the subdivision R- 1AA zoning requirements. This includes but is not limited to: resulting effects of the density issue, elevations, setbacks, population, relevant location, traffic, property values, marketability and demographics. p Affidavit Page Two 6. Supportive data indicates this development would be inclined to manifest into investment rental property or worse. Vacant properties are excessive in the area and current studies verify rental demands are on a ten year decline cycle. Neighboring townhouses and high-rise condominium ( The Peninsula ) are 21% owned and 79% rental. The mathematics prove the point being made. 7. The Planning and Zoning Board acting as the advisory board to the Mayor and Commissioners of Boynton Beach has and did veto the Casa Del Mar land use and development proposal application. 8. The City of Boynton Beach, a municipal corporation, acting as a defacto government by the acquisence of the citizens, hereby directs their elected representatives, their Mayor and Commissioners, to repeat the undersigned citizens unanimous vote of (NO)to the proposed Casa Del Mar application and development. 9. The undersigned concurs with the multiple p .p, /o Aff•avit's as submitted. AfAlgfAtalitAM/A7— SIG,, • STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED THIS '7 day of January, 2015, before me, appeared f;?- -kcf S , r)1 Jq-uI/IX , who is personally known to me llo. has produced a Florida Drivers License-No or as identification, and attests to the aforementioned. me'w- / / Notary Signature (SEAL) !2A-I1 CJ A 1 V}"1 fZ dT/ „�}P9"Pit;; RAMONA MROTEK Printed Notary Name * '� MY COMMISSION#EE 856973 7-� g EXPIRES:A 2017 Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters